Từ Điển Thiền & Thuật Ngữ Phật Giáo Việt-Anh & Anh-Việt (Thiện Phúc)
Từ Điển Thiền & Thuật Ngữ Phật Giáo Việt-Anh [Dictionary of Zen & Buddhist Terms] Vol 2 (C)
Nguồn: kho Dân tộc KING — Giảng Sư (văn bản trích từ PDF)

THIEÄN PHUÙC

TÖØ ÑIEÅN THIEÀN & THUAÄT NGÖÕ PHAÄT GIAÙO

DICTIONARY OF ZEN & BUDDHIST TERMS

VIEÄT-ANH VIETNAMESE-ENGLISH

TAÄP HAI (C) VOLUME TWO (C)

Copyright © 2016 by Ngoc Tran. All rights reserved.

No part of this work may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying and recording, or by any information storage or retrieval system without the prior written permission of the author, except for the inclusion of brief quotations. However, staff members of Vietnamese temples who want to reprint this work for the benefit of teaching of the Buddhadharma, please contact Ngoc Tran at (714) 778-2832.

LÔØI GIÔÙI THIEÄU Ñaïo höõu Traàn Ngoïc phaùp danh Thieän Phuùc khoâng chæ laø moät hoïc giaû nghieân cöùu khaù saâu saéc veà Phaät phaùp, maø coøn laø moät Phaät töû thuaàn thaønh luoân gaéng coâng tu taäp ñeå ñaït ñeán con ñöôøng giaùc ngoä vaø giaûi thoaùt. Thieän Phuùc ñaõ bieân soaïn boä töï ñieå n Phaät Hoïc Vieät-Ngöõ vaø Anh Ngöõ raát kyõ löôõng. Ñoàng thôøi, ñaïo-höõu cuõng ñaõ bieân soaïn boä Phaät Phaùp Caên Baûn vaø möôøi taäp saùch giaùo lyù phoå thoâng baèng tieáng vieät ñeå giuùp caùc baïn treû muoán tìm hieåu Phaät phaùp. Sau khi ñoïc xong nhöõng boä saùch treân, toâi thaønh thaät taùn thaùn coâng ñöùc cuûa ñaïo höõu, ñaõ daønh ra hai möôi maáy naêm trôøi ñeå nghieân cöùu vaø saùng taùc, trong luùc ñôøi soáng ôû Myõ raát baän roän. Hoâm nay ñaïo höõu Thieän -Phuùc laïi ñem baûn thaûo boä Töø Ñieån Thieàn vaø Thuaät Ngöõ Phaät Giaùo nhôø toâi vieát lôøi giôùi thieäu. Taùc phaåm "Töø Ñieån Thieàn vaø Thuaät Ngöõ Phaät Giaùo" ñöôïc vieát baèng hai ngoân ngöõ Vieät-Anh raát deã hieåu. Sau khi ñoïc xong, toâi nhaän thaáy boä saùch vôùi gaàn 7.000 trang giaáy khoå lôùn toaøn boä vieát veà nhöõng thuaät ngöõ Thieàn, nhöõng lôøi daïy cuûa Phaät Toå Thích Ca Maâu Ni vaø chö Toå veà phöông phaùp Thieàn ñònh, cuõng nhö haønh traïng cuûa caùc Thieàn Sö Trung Hoa, Ñaïi Haøn, Nhaät Baûn vaø Vieät Nam. Maëc daàu caùc Thieàn sö daïy raèng haønh giaû tu Thieàn khoâng neân leä thuoäc vaøo vaên töï ñeå daïy hay ñeå naém baét giaùo phaùp nhaø Thieàn bôûi vì ñoïc vaø giaûi thích kinh ñieån khoâng daãn ñeán giaùc ngoä, nhöng haønh giaû tu Thieàn ñöøng bao giôø queân raèng kinh ñieån luoân ñoùng moät vai troø quan troïng nhaát trong vieäc tu haønh: kinh ñieån gioáng nhö baûn ñoà chæ ñöôøng - trong khi baûn ñoà coù theå chæ cho baïn choã naøo baïn neân ñi vaø ñöa ra moät loä trình ngaén nhaát, baïn vaãn phaûi töï mình ñi treân con ñöôøng aáy. Vaø khoâng leä thuoäc vaøo vaên töï ñoøi hoûi haønh giaû hoïc hoûi qua thöïc taäp vaø kinh nghieäm. Noùi toùm laïi, maëc daàu Thieàn Phaät giaùo nhaán maïnh vaøo thöïc taäp, haønh giaû tu Thieàn phaûi tu taäp môùi mong ñaït ñöôïc caùi thaáy ñuùng ñaén veà giaùo phaùp nhaø Thieàn, nhöng nhöõng höôùng daãn baèng vaên töï vaãn luoân caàn thieát cho ngöôøi môùi baét ñaàu tu taäp Thieàn ñònh. Töôûng cuõng neân nhaéc laïi laø Thieàn ñöôïc Toå Boà Ñeà Ñaït Ma chính thöùc ñöa vaøo Trung Hoa vaøo khoaûng naêm 520 sau Taây lòch, maëc daàu noù ñaõ ñeán ñoù tröôùc ñaây vaø ñaõ phaùt trieån trong toâng Thieân Thai. Nhöng vaøo khoaûng theá kyû thöù hai thì taïi mieàn Baéc Vieät Nam ñaõ coù nhöõng vò Taêng noåi tieáng, ñieån hình laø ngaøi Khöông Taêng Hoäi. Ngöôøi ta tin raèng trong ba trung taâm Phaät giaùo coå ñaïi ôû Ñoâng AÙ laø Laïc Döông, Baønh Thaønh vaø Luy Laâu thì trung taâm Luy Laâu ôû Giao Chæ laø trung taâm Phaät giaùo ñaàu tieân ñöôïc thaønh laäp döôùi trieàu Haùn vaø o khoaûng theá kyû thöù nhaát sau Taây lòch. Thôøi ñoù Luy Laâu laø thuû phuû cuûa Giao Chæ, luùc baáy giôø laø thuoäc ñòa cuûa Trung Hoa. Vì Luy Laâu naèm giöõa con ñöôøng giao thöông AÁn Hoa, neân thôøi ñoù caùc nhaø sö tieàn phong AÁn Ñoä tröôùc khi ñeá n Trung Hoa hoï ñeàu gheù laïi Luy Laâu. Vì theá maø Luy Laâu ñaõ trôû thaønh moät ñieåm thuaän tieän vaø höng thònh cho caùc ñoaøn truyeàn giaùo tieân phong töø AÁn Ñoä ñeán löu truù, truyeàn baù giaùo lyù nhaø Phaät tröôùc khi caùc vò tieáp tuïc cuoäc haønh trình ñi veà phöông Baéc. Cuõng chính vì theá maø Taêng Ñoaøn Luy Laâu ñöôïc thaønh laäp tröôùc caû Laïc Döông vaø Baønh Thaønh. Vaøo thôøi ñoù trung taâm Luy Laâu coù treân 20 ngoâi chuøa vaø 500 Taêng só. Chính ra Khöông Taêng Hoäi laø vò Thieàn sö Vieät Nam ñaàu tieân; tuy nhieân, thieàn phaùi Vieät Nam chæ baét ñaàu ñöôïc thaønh laäp töø thôøi Thieàn sö Tyø Ni Ña Löu Chi vaøo theá kyû thöù VI maø thoâi. Kyø thaät, Phaät giaùo Thieàn toâng Vieät Nam chöa ñöôïc phaùt trieån maïnh cho maõi ñeán naêm 580 khi Thieàn sö Tyø Ni Ña Löu Chi, moät vò sö AÁn Ñoä, laø ñeä töû cuûa Tam Toå Taêng Xaùn, tröôùc khi doøng Thieàn Trung Hoa bò chia laøm hai, Baéc vaø Nam toâng, ñaõ ñeán Vieät Nam vaø saùng laäp doøng Thieàn Tyø Ni Ña Löu Chi. Toå truyeàn cuûa doøng Thieàn ñaàu tieân naày chaám döùt sau khi toå thöù 28 cuûa noù thò tòch vaøo naêm 1216. Tuy nhieân, aûnh höôûng cuûa noù coøn raát maïnh ôû phía Baéc. Doøng Thieàn thöù hai taïi Vieät Nam ñöôïc phaùt khôûi vaøo cuoái theá kyû thöù VIII bôûi moät nhaø sö Trung Hoa teân laø Voâ Ngoân Thoâng (?-826), moät ñeä töû cuûa Thieàn sö Baùch Tröôïng Hoaøi Haûi. Toå truyeàn cuûa doøng Thieàn naày chaám döùt vaøo theá kyû thöù 13, duø doøng Thieàn naày vaãn toàn taïi. Maëc duø hai doøng Thieàn naày khoâng coøn toàn taïi nhö nhöõng doøng truyeàn thöøa, nhöng chính hai doøng Thieàn naày ñaõ ñaët neàn moùng vöõng chaéc cho Phaät giaùo Vieät Nam. Naêm 1069, vua Lyù Thaùnh Toân phaùt ñoäng chieán dòch Nam tieán choáng laïi Chieâm Thaønh, trong chieán dòch naày trong soá haøng traêm ngaøn tuø binh baét ñöôïc, coù moät tuø binh raát ñaëc bieät ñöôïc ñöa veà

kinh ñoâ Thaêng Long, moät nhaø sö Trung Hoa teân Thaûo Ñöôøng. Vôùi söï hoå trôï maïnh meõ cuûa vua Lyù Thaùnh Toân, doøng Thieàn Thaûo Ñöôøng ñaõ ñöôïc khai saùng vaøo theá kyû thöù XI. Sau ñoù doøng Thieàn Truùc Laâm ñöôïc sô Toå Traàn Nhaân Toâng (1258-1308) khai saùng vaøo cuoái theá kyû thöù XIII. Trong khi Laâm Teá toâng ñöôïc Thieàn sö Vinh Taây Minh truyeàn sang Nhaät Baûn vaøo theá kyû thöù XII vaø Taøo Ñoäng ñöôïc truyeàn sang Nhaät Baûn vaøo theá kyû thöù XIII bôûi thieàn sö Ñaïo Nguyeân thì ôû Vieät Nam maõi ñeán theá kyû thöù 17, moät soá nhaø sö Trung Hoa môùi sang Vieät Nam vaø saùng laäp nhöõng doøng Thieàn Laâm Teá vaø Taøo Ñoäng. Hoï ñöôïc caùc chuùa Trònh ôû Ñaøng Ngoaøi cuõng nhö caùc chuùa Nguyeãn ôû Ñaøng Trong tieáp ñaõi noàng haäu. Cuøng thôøi ñoù, Thieàn phaùi Truùc Laâm cuûa Vieät Nam cuõng ñöôïc phuïc hoài. Taát caû nhöõng ñieàu naøy cho chuùng ta thaáy raèng Thieàn ñaõ trôû thaønh moät phaàn cuûa ñôøi soáng vaø cuûa neàn vaên hoùa Vieät Nam chuùng ta trong gaàn hai ngaøn naêm nay. Ñieàu naøy coù nghóa laø khi noùi veà moät ñôøi soáng an laïc trong Phaät giaùo ngöôøi ta nghó ngay ñeán Thieàn. Toâi raát ñoàng yù vôùi ñaïo höõu Thieän Phuùc veà vieäc bieân soaïn boä “Töø Ñieån Thieàn & Thuaät Ngöõ Phaät Giaùo” vì muïc ñích cuûa ngöôøi tu Phaät laø “Giaùc Ngoä vaø Giaûi Thoaùt” vaø muïc ñích cuûa Thieàn cuõng laø nhö vaäy, cuõng laø giaùc ngoä ñeå ñi ñeán choã voâ öu, khoâng buoàn phieàn, khoâng lo aâu. Noùi caùch khaùc, thieàn laø khoâng coù phieàn naõo laøm naùo loaïn thaân taâm. Haønh giaû haønh thieàn ñeå ñaït ñöôïc traïng thaùi haïnh phuùc vaø an laïc nhaát trong ñôøi soáng haèng ngaøy. Ñaïo höõu Thieän Phuùc ñaõ nhieät tình xem xeùt veà taát caû nhöõng gì bao goàm trong boä saùch naøy, vì thaät deã daøng laïc loái trong moät phaïm truø noùi vaø laøm haàu nhö khoâng coù giôùi haïn cuûa caùc Thieàn Sö vaø caùc Thaày Thieàn Trung Hoa, Nhaät Baûn vaø Vieät Nam. Ñeå laøm ñöôïc ñieàu naøy, ñaïo höõu Thieän Phuùc ñaõ coá gaéng laøm sao cho moãi töø trong boä “Töø Ñieån Thieàn & Thuaät Ngöõ Phaät Giaùo” naøy laø moät böôùc tieán ñi gaàn tôùi giaùc ngoä vaø giaûi thoaùt maø Ñöùc Phaät ñaõ noùi ñeán hôn 2.600 naêm tröôùc. Toâi nghó raèng vò naøo coù duyeân laønh tham khaûo nhöõng thuaät ngöõ trong boä “Töø Ñieån Thieàn & Thuaät Ngöõ Phaät Giaùo” naày vaø tinh chuyeân tu taäp thì chaéc chaén seõ töøng böôùc gaët haùi ñöôïc söï giaùc ngoä vaø giaûi thoaùt moïi khoå ñau phieàn naõo ñeå ñi ñeán nieàm an laïc nhaát ñôøi. Vôùi tinh thaàn quaûng baù phaùp thí, ñaïo höõu Thieän Phuùc hy voïng raèng oâng ñaõ trình baøy moät caùch roõ raøng nhöõng yù nghóa cuûa Thieàn vaø ñaày ñuû lòch söû cuõng nhö tieåu söû nhaèm ñöa ra moät böùc tranh khaù roõ raøng veà söï phaùt trieå n cuûa Thieàn taïi caùc xöù Trung Hoa, Nhaät Baûn vaø Vieät Nam. Sau khi tham khaûo xong taùc phaåm, toâi thaønh thaät caûm ôn ñaïo höõu Thieän Phuùc ñaõ boû ra raát nhieàu thì giôø vaø coâng söùc trong ñôøi soáng beà boän ôû Hoa Kyø ñeå soaïn thaûo vaø vieát boä “Töø Ñieån Thieàn & Thuaät Ngöõ Phaät Giaùo” ñeå coáng hieán cho caùc ñoïc giaû höõu duyeân vôùi Phaät Phaùp seõ ñöôïc nieàm haïnh phuùc vaø an laïc voâ bieân. Ñaây laø moät coâng ñöùc phaùp thí khoù nghó baøn. Toâi raát hoan hyû taùn thaùn coâng ñöùc phaùp thí trong vieäc hoaøn taát moät taùc phaåm toân giaùo vaø vaên hoùa hieám hoi naøy. Nhöõng taäp saùch naøy coøn laø söï ñoùng goùp quyù baùu trong vieäc truyeàn baù Chaùnh Phaùp. Toâi cuõng muoán nhaân ñaây chaân thaønh ca ngôïi tinh thaàn vò tha cuûa ñaïo höõu Thieän Phuùc, ñaõ vì söï an laïc vaø haïnh phuùc voâ bieân cuûa chuùng sanh maø boû ra nhieàu thì giôø vaø coá gaéng khoâng meät moûi ñeå hoaøn thaønh taùc phaåm “Töø Ñieån Thieàn & Thuaät Ngöõ Phaät Giaùo” naày. Hoâm nay nhaân muøa Phaät Ñaûn Phaät lòch 2559 taây lòch 2015, toâi raát hoan hyû giôùi thieäu taùc phaåm “Töø Ñieån Thieàn & Thuaät Ngöõ Phaät Giaùo” do ñaïo höõu Thieän Phuùc bieân soaïn ñeán vôùi taát caû chö Taêng Ni vaø Phaät töû cuøng ñoäc giaû boán phöông. Ñaây chaúng nhöõng laø moät moùn aên tinh thaàn raát quyù baùu vaø thaät caàn thieát chaúng nhöõng cho chö Taêng Ni trong caùc töï vieän maø coøn cho taát caû moïi ngöôøi. Hy voïng moïi ngöôøi ñeàu coù trong tay boä “Töø Ñieån Thieàn & Thuaät Ngöõ Phaät Giaùo” vaø söû duïng noù nhö Kim Chæ Nam trôï giuùp mình tieán saâu hôn trong vieäc tu taäp haàu coù ñöôïc cuoäc soáng an laïc vaø haïnh phuùc ngay trong luùc naøy. Thaät vaäy, moät khi chuùng ta hieåu ñöôïc coát loûi cuûa Phaät Phaùp, ñaëc bieät laø yù nghóa vaø phöông phaùp haønh Thieàn, chuùng ta coù theå aùp duïng chuùng trong ñôøi soáng nhaèm caûi thieän thaân taâm vaø cuoái cuøng ñaït ñeán Ñaïo Quaû.

Caån Buùt Sa-moân Thích Chôn Thaønh

INTRODUCTION Mr. Ngoc Tran, his Buddha Name Thien Phuc, is not only a Buddhist scholar, but he is also a devout practitioner who always tries his best to cultivate to achieve enlightenment and emancipation. He has an extensive knowledge of Buddhism. Thien Phuc is also the author of Vietnamese-English Buddhist Dictionary, English-Vietnamese Buddhist Dictionary, the Basic Buddhist Doctrines, and ten volumes of Buddhism in Daily Life. These books help Buddhists understand the application of Buddhist theory in their daily activities. After reading these volumes, I sincerely commend Thien Phuc, who has spent more than two decades studying and composing these books, regardless of his busy and hurried life in the United States. Today, Mr. Thien Phuc Ngoc Tran brought me a draft of his work called “Dictionary of Zen & Buddhist Terms” which comprises of nine volumes, and asked me to write an introduction for this work. The work is written in Vietnamese and English and is very easy to understand. After reading the draft of “Dictionary of Zen & Buddhist Terms”, I found that this work with almost 7,000 large-sized pages were written about all Zen terms, the Buddha’s and Patriarches’ teachings on methods of resettlement of mind, as well as actions from Ancient Zen Masters from China, Korea, Japan, and Vietnam. Even though Zen Masters say that Zen practitioners do not depend on written words to teach or grasp the Zen teachings because reading and intepreting the Buddhist scriptures will not lead to enlightenment, but Zen practitioners should never forget the fact that scriptures always play one of the most important roles in cultivation: the scriptures are like a road map - while the map can show you where you would like to go and even set out the quickest route, you still must travel the road for yourself. And not depending on written words requires that practitioners learn through practice and experience. In short, even though Zen Buddhism places great emphasis on practices, a practitioner must perform to gain proper insight into Zen teachings, but written guidelines are still necessary for any Zen beginners. It should be noted that official introduction of Zen to China in around 520 is attributed to Bodhidharma, though it came earlier, and its extension to T’ien-T’ai. But by the second century, Tongkin (North Vietnam) already had several famous monks, especially Sanghapala. It is believed that among the three ancient Buddhist centers in East Asia, Lo-Yang, Peng-Ch’eng, and Luy-Lau, Luy Lau center in Giao Chi (Tongkin) was then the first to be founded under the Han Dynasty, around the early first century A.D. Luy Lau at that time was the capital of Giao Chi, which was then a Chinese colony, was on the main trade route between India and China, so before landing in China, most pioneer Indian monks landed in Tongkin. Therefore, Luy Lau became a favorable and prosperous resort for Indian pioneer missionaries to stay and preach the Buddha’s Teachings before continuing their journey to the North. And therefore, the Order Buddhism of Luy Lau was founded even before the ones in Lo-Yang and Peng-Ch’eng. According to the document recorded in an Anthology of the Most Talented Figures in Ch’an Park, our most ancient Buddhist literary collection, Master K’ang Seng Hui, a monk of Sogdian origin, was the first Buddhist Master at Luy Lau Center. He was born in Tongkin, where he was received into the Order of monks afterwards. He became the most famous monk who translated a large number of Buddhist Canonical books into Chinese and later he visited Nan-King, where he built the first temple and preached the Dharma. At that time, Luy Lau had more than 20 temples and 500 monks. Hjiang-Jing-Hui was the first Vietnamese Zen master; however, Vietnamese Zen sects only developed at the time of Zen master Vinitaruci in the sixth century. As a matter of fact, Vietnamese Zen Buddhism had not developed until 580 when Vinitaruci, an Indian monk, a disciple of the Third Patriarch Seng-Ts’an, long before its split into northern and southern schools. The first lineage of Vietnamese Zen Masters ended with the death of its twenty-eighth patriarch in 1216, however, its influence continued to be prominent in the north (see Tyø Ni Ña Löu Chi). The second Zen lineage in

Vietnam was initiated in the end of the eighth century by the Chinese monk named Wu-Yun-T’ung, a disciple of Pai-Zhang. This lineage of Zen Masters also died out in the thirteenth century, though the school itself survives. Although the first two lineages of Zen did not survive as lineages, they did lay the solid foundations for future Vietnamese Buddhism. In 1069, the Ly dynasty’s campaign of southward expansion against Champa reached its farthest extent, the seventeenth parallel. In the course of this campaign, a very significant prisoner of war was brought to Thang Long Capital from captured Champa territory. This prisoner was the Chinese monk Ts’ao-Tang. With the strong support of king Lyù Thaùnh Toân (1054-1072), Ts’ao-Tang established the Ts’ao-Tang Zen lineage in the eleventh century. Later, Truùc Laâm Zen sect was founded by the first patriarch Traàn Nhaân Toâng in the end of the thirteenth century. While in the twelfth century, the tradition of Lin-Chi school was brought from China by Zen master Eisai Zenji (1141-1215); and in the first half of the 13th century, the tradition of Soto school was brought to Japan from China by the Japanese master Dogen Zenji (1200-1253). In Vietnam, until the 17th century, a number of Chinese monks came to Vietnam and founded such Ch’an Sects as the Lin-Chi Sect and the T’ao Tung Sect. They were warmlly received by both Trinh Lords in the North and Nguyen Lords in the South. The Ch’an Sect of Truc Lam was also restored. All these show us that Zen has become a part of our life and our Vietnamese culture for almost two thousand years. It is to say, when talking about a peaceful life in Buddhism, people think right away of meditation. I totally agree with Thien Phuc about the subject of “Dictionary of Zen & Buddhist Terms” for the purpose of any Buddhist practitioner is “Enlightenment and Emancipation” and the purpose of Zen is also the same, also reaching the state of mind that is without sorrow or without worry. In other words, Zen means something that does not disturb the body and mind. Zen practitioners practice zen in order to obtain the most peaceful state of mind in daily life. Thien Phuc has given the most earnest consideration as to what to include in this series, as it would be easy to stray into the almost unlimited field of sayings and doings of the many Chinese, Japanese and Vietnamese Zen Masters and Teachers. In order to be able to do this, Thien Phuc has tried to make each term in the “Dictionary of Zen & Buddhist Terms” a step that helps us to approach the enlightenment and emancipation that the Buddha mentioned twenty six hundred years ago. I think whoever has the opportunity to make a reference to the “Dictionary of Zen & Buddhist Terms” and dilifently practice will achieve the most peaceful states of mind. With the spirit of broad Dharma offering, Mr. Thien Phuc Ngoc Tran hopes that he has presented the Zen ideas clearly and sufficient history and biography to give a pretty clear picture of the growth of Zen in China, Japan and Vietnam. After reading these volumes, I sincerely thank Mr. Thien Phuc Ngoc Tran, who has sacrificed so much time and efforts in his busy life in the United States in order to be able to complete this work and contribute to our unlimited happiness and peace for all of us. This work is the unthinkable merit of giving of the Buddhadharma. I am very please to praise the author’s merits for his accomplishment of this rare religious and cultural work. These books are also a genuine contribution to the propagation of the Dharma. I also want to take this opportunity to send my appreciation to Mr. Thien Phuc Ngoc Tran for his altruism. For the sake of all beings’ unlimited happiness and peace, he has spent so much time and untiring efforts to complete this work. By the commemoration festival of the Vesak (Buddha’s Birth Day) in the year of 2559 (2015), I am glad to introduce this great work to all Monks, Nuns, lay-people and all other readers. This is precious spiritual nourishment not only for Monks and Nuns in temples but also for everybody. With the hope that each and everyone of you will possess and to utilize the “Dictionary of Zen & Buddhist Terms” as a guide to aid in your deeper study of Buddha-Dharma so that we can all have peaceful and happy lives at the present moment. In fact, when we understand the core meanings of the Buddhadharma, especially the exact meanings and methods of Zen practices, we can put them into practice in our life to improve our body and mind and, eventually to attain the Way. Respectfully Most Ven. Thich Chon Thanh

LÔØI TÖÏA Ñaây khoâng phaûi laø boä Töï Ñieån Anh-Vieät Vieät-Anh bình thöôøng, ñaây cuõng khoâng phaûi laø Toaøn Taäp Thuaät Ngöõ Thieàn. Ñaây chæ laø moät boä saùch nhoû goàm nhöõng töø ngöõ Thieàn vaø Phaät giaùo caên baûn, hay nhöõng töø thöôøng hay gaëp trong nhöõng baøi thuyeát giaûng veà Thieàn, vôùi hy voïng giuùp nhöõng Phaät töû vaø haønh giaû tu Thieàn naøo mong muoán tìm hieåu theâm veà nhöõng baøi giaûng veà Thieàn baèng Anh ngöõ. Ñöùc Phaät ñaõ baét ñaàu thuyeát giaûng Phaät phaùp 26 theá kyû veà tröôùc maø giaùo lyù thaät laø thaäm thaâm raát khoù cho baát cöù ai trong chuùng ta thaáu trieät, duø baèng chính ngoân ngöõ cuûa chuùng ta. Ngoaøi ra, khoâng coù töø ngöõ töông ñöông Vieät hay Anh naøo coù theå loät traàn ñöôïc heát yù nghóa cuûa nhieàu töø ngöõ Phaïn Pali vaø Sanskrit. Laïi caøng khoù hôn cho ngöôøi Vieät chuùng ta traùnh nhöõng dieãn dòch sai laàm khi chuùng ta ñoïc nhöõng kinh ñieån ñöôïc Vieät dòch töø nhöõng kinh ñieån Ñaïi thöøa cuûa Trung quoác. Trong boä saùch naøy toâi ñaõ maïo muoäi boû taát caû nhöõng daáu cuûa chöõ Hoa vaø Sanskrit cuõng nhö Pali ñöôïc vieát theo maãu töï La Tinh vì toâi thieát nghó chuùng chæ laøm cho nhöõng ñoäc giaû thoâng thöôøng boái roái theâm maø thoâi. Rieâng ñoái vôùi caùc baäc hoïc giaû uyeân thaâm chöõ Hoa vaø chöõ Baéc Phaïn cuõng nhö Nam Phaïn, thì nhöõng daáu naøy thaät söï khoâng caàn thieát, vì hoï seõ nhaän ra ñöôïc ngay nguyeân ngöõ chöõ Hoa vaø chöõ Phaïn. Theo truyeàn thoáng Thieàn, ngöôøi ta noùi giaùo thuyeát Thieàn ñaõ coù töø thôøi ñöùc Phaät lòch söû Thích Ca Maâu Ni, ngöôøi ñaõ truyeàn laïi khoâng baèng ngoân ngöõ cho moät trong nhöõng ngöôøi ñeä töû taøi gioûi cuûa Ngaøi laø Ma Ha Ca Dieáp. Truyeàn thoáng naøy ñeà caäp ñeán teân cuûa hai möôi taùm vò Toå AÁn Ñoä, nhöõng ngöôøi ñaõ truyeàn laïi giaùo phaùp Thieàn baét ñaàu töø thôøi ñöùc Phaät vaø Ñaïi Ca Dieáp, roài keát thuùc taïi AÁn Ñoä vôùi toå Boà Ñeà Ñaït Ma. Vaøo theá kyû thöù naêm, Boà Ñeà Ñaït Ma du haønh sang Trung Hoa, nôi oâng ñaõ coù nhöõng ñeä töû ngöôøi Hoa. Trong soá nhöõng ngöôøi naøy, ngöôøi ta noùi ngaøi ñaõ choïn Hueä Khaû laø ngöôøi keá thöøa chính thöùc cuûa mình. Sau ñoù truyeàn thoáng naøy theo ñoù maø phaùt trieån qua saùu doøng truyeàn thöøa cuûa caùc Toå sö Trung Hoa, keát thuùc vôùi Luïc Toå Hueä Naêng. Chính vì vaäy chuùng ta coù theå caû quyeát raèng taát caû nhöõng hình thöùc cuûa Thieàn Phaät giaùo coøn toàn taïi ñeán ngaøy nay ñeàu coù nguoàn goác töø Luïc Toå, Boà Ñeà Ñaït Ma, vaø ñöùc Phaät lòch söû Thích Ca Maâu Ni. Rieâng ñoái vôùi ngöôøi Vieät Nam, nhö quyù vò ñaõ bieát, giaùo lyù vaø truyeàn thoáng Phaät giaùo ñaõ aên saâu vaøo xaõ hoäi Vieät Nam chuùng ta töø 20 theá kyû nay, vaø ña phaàn ngöôøi Vieät chuùng ta trong quoác noäi cuõng nhö taïi haûi ngoaïi ñeàu tröïc tieáp hay giaùn tieáp thöïc haønh Thieàn Phaät giaùo. Thaät tình maø noùi, ngaøy nay Phaät töû hay khoâng Phaät töû ñeàu ñang tìm toøi hoïc hoûi giaùo lyù naày nhöõng mong môû mang vaø caûi thieän cuoäc soáng cho chính mình. Nhöõng ai nhieät thaønh nghieân cöùu Thieàn thöôøng thaáy raèng sau khi caùi quyeán ruõ ban ñaàu cuûa noù moøn moûi, nhöõng böôùc keá tieáp ñoøi hoûi phaûi theo ñuoåi noù moät caùch ñuùng ñaén ñaõ trôû thaønh chaùn naûn vaø khoâng coù keát quaû. Caùi kinh nghieäm ngoä Thieàn quaû thaät laø tuyeät vôøi, nhöng vaán ñeà thieát yeáu ôû ñaây laø laøm sao ngöôøi ta coù theå theå nhaäp vaøo kinh nghieäm naøy? Phaûi thaønh thaät maø noùi raèng vaán ñeà naém baét ñöôïc caùi ngoä Thieàn tuyeät dieäu naøy maõi cho ñeán ngaøy nay vaãn coøn laø moät aån soá chöa giaûi ñaùp ñöôïc cho nhieàu ngöôøi haâm moä Thieàn treân theá giôùi. Coù phaûi vì lyù do ña soá hoï chöa ñaït ñeán möùc chín chaén trong vieäc nghieân cöùu ñeå coù theå thöïc söï tu taäp Thieàn hay khoâng? Raát coù theå laø nhö vaäy, vì ña soá haønh giaû muoán tu thieàn thöôøng nghe ñaâu ñoù caùi caâu 'giaùo phaùp naøy baát laäp vaên töï'. Ñaây quaû laø moät loái suy nghó sai laàm veà Thieàn. Ñoàng yù tu taäp Thieàn khoâng phaûi laø moät vaán ñeà maø caùc hoïc giaû khoâng ñöôïc truyeàn thuï coù theå ñöông ñaàu chæ baèng trí thöùc hoaëc baùc hoïc thuaàn tuùy. Vaø cuõng ñoàng yù chæ coù nhöõng ngöôøi ñaõ coù kinh nghieäm töï thaân môùi coù theå baøn luaän veà chuû ñeà naøy moät caùch maät thieát vaø ñaùng tin caäy ñöôïc. Bôûi vì Thieàn, töï baûn tính cuûa noù khoâng phaûi laø moät trieát hoïc, maø laø moä t kinh nghieäm tröïc tieáp maø ngöôøi ta phaûi thaâm nhaäp baèng caû con ngöôøi mình, nghóa laø baèng taát caû thaân vaø taâm mình. Trong Phaät giaùo moät ngöôøi phaûi traûi qua vieäc tu taäp coù nghóa laø moät ngöôøi 'höõu hoïc'. Haønh giaû tu thieàn neân luoân nhôù raèng phaøm phu, neáu khoâng hoïc thì khoâng bieát ñaâu laø ñuùng ñaâu laø sai ñeå tu taäp. Vì theá, neáu khoâng hoïc theo lôøi chæ daãn cuûa caùc Thieàn sö ñaõ ñaït ñaïo, khoâng suy nghieäm veà nhöõng kinh nghieäm veà cuoäc ñôøi tu haønh cuûa hoï vôùi ñaày nhöõng töôøng thuaät veà kinh nghieäm maø hoï thöïc söï ñaït ñöôïc trong suoát nhöõng cuoäc tranh ñaáu trong Thieàn cuûa hoï, quaû thaät laø khoâng theå naøo tu taäp Thieàn ñuùng caùch ñöôïc. Caùc phaùp ngöõ vaø töï

truyeän cuûa nhöõng thieàn sö ñaõ chöùng toû, trong suoát nhöõng theá kyû ñaõ qua, laø nhöõng taøi lieäu voâ giaù cho ngöôøi hoïc Thieàn, vaø nhöõng taøi lieäu ñoù ñaõ ñöôïc chaáp nhaän vaø quí troïng bôûi taát caû nhöõng ngöôøi tìm kieám Thieàn khaép nôi treân theá giôùi nhö laø caùc höôùng ñaïo vaø baïn löõ voâ song treân cuoäc haønh trình tieán ñeán giaùc ngoä. Vôùi hy voïng giuùp taêng tieán kieán thöùc veà Thieàn vaø giuùp cho nhöõng ai vaãn haèng tìm kieám nhöõng lôøi chæ daãn veà Thieàn ñeå cho vieäc coâng phu tu taäp Thieàn ñöôïc deã daøng hôn, toâi maïo muoäi bieân soaïn boä Töø Ñieån Thieàn vaø Thuaät Ngöõ Phaät Giaùo nhoû nhoi naøy. Nhöõng taäp saùch naøy khoâng nhöõng chæ bao goàm nhöõng thuaät ngöõ, maø coøn coù moät soá caâu chuyeän veà cuoäc ñôøi cuûa caùc thieàn sö vaø phaùp ngöõ cuûa hoï. Hy voïng raèng töø noäi dung cuûa nhöõng taøi lieäu naøy chuùng ta coù theå coù ñöôïc moät hình aûnh veà ñôøi soáng vaø haønh traïng cuûa caùc thieàn sö, nhôø vaäy maø chuùng ta coù theå hieåu roõ hôn Thieàn ñaõ ñöôïc thöïc söï tu taäp nhö theá naøo. Vì khoâng ai coù ñuû tö caùch hôn chính nhöõng baäc thieàn sö ñaõ ñaéc phaùp naøy ñeå ñoái trò vôùi vaán ñeà tu taäp Thieàn. Do vaäy, theo thieån yù, tu taäp theo göông haïnh vaø nhöõng lôøi chæ daïy cuûa nhöõng thieàn sö ñaõ ñaéc phaùp trong quaù khöù laø phöông caùch ñuùng ñaén vaø an toaøn nhaát ñeå tu taäp Thieàn. Vì nhöõng lyù do ñoù, cho ñeán khi naøo coù ñöôïc moät boä Töø Ñieån Thuaät Ngöõ Thieàn hoaøn chænh, toâi ñaõ maïo muoäi bieân soaïn nhöõng töø ngöõ thöôøng duøng cuûa Thieàn Phaät giaùo cuõng nhö nhöõng töø ngöõ lieân heä vôùi Thieàn Phaät giaùo trong suoát hôn hai möôi laêm naêm qua. Ñoàng yù laø coù raát nhieàu loãi laàm vaø sai soùt trong nhöõng taäp saùch nhoû naày vaø coøn laâu laém nhöõng quyeån saùch naày môùi ñöôïc xem laø hoaøn chænh, tuy nhieân, vôùi öôùc mong chia xeû chaân lyù, chuùng toâi ñaõ khoâng ngaàn ngaïi cho xuaát baûn vaø truyeàn baù nhöõng quyeån saùch naày ñeán tay moïi ngöôøi. Hôn nöõa, chính Ñöùc Töø Phuï ñaõ töøng daïy: “Trong phaùp Boá Thí, boá thí Phaùp hay boá thí moùn quaø chaân lyù Phaät phaùp laø caùch cuùng döôøng cao tuyeät nhöùt treân ñôøi naày.” Moät laàn nöõa, Hy voïng nhöõng quyeån saùch nhoû naày seõ thaät söï giuùp ích cho nhöõng ai muoán tìm bieát theâm veà chaân lyù thöïc taùnh vaïn höõu. Nhö ñaõ noùi treân, ñaây khoâng phaûi laø moät tuyeät taùc hoaøn chænh, vì theá chuùng toâi chaân thaønh caûm taï söï chæ daïy cuûa chö hoïc giaû vaø caùc baäc cao minh. Toâi cuõng xin ñöôïc thaâm taï thaày boån sö laø Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Giaùc Nhieân, Phaùp Chuû Giaùo Hoäi Phaät Giaùo Taêng Giaø Khaát Só Theá Giôùi, chö Taêng Ni ñaõ töøng giuùp ñôû toâi trong tieán trình bieân soaïn taäp saùch naøy, cuõng nhö nhöõng ngöôøi trong gia ñình ñaõ trôï giuùp toâi raát nhieàu. Vaø treân heá t, taùc giaû xin tröôùc cung kính cuùng döôøng leân ngoâi Tam Baûo, sau thaønh kính hoài höôùng taát caû coâng ñöùc naày ñeán chuùng sanh muoân loaøi trong quaù khöù, hieän taïi vaø vò lai. Nhöõng mong ai naáy ñeàu thaáy ñöôïc söï lôïi laïc cuûa Phaät phaùp, ñeå moät ngaøy khoâng xa naøo ñoù, phaùp giôùi chuùng sanh ñoàng sanh veà coõi Nieát Baøn mieân vieãn.

Anaheim, California Thieän Phuùc

PREFACE This work is not an ordinary English-Vietnamese or Vietnamese-English Dictionary, nor is this a Total Zen and Buddhist Terminology. This is only a small work that compiles of some basic Zen and Buddhist terms, and related terms that are often seen in Zen and Buddhist texts in English with the hope to help Vietnamese Buddhists and Zen practitioners understand more Zen teachings and Buddhist essays written in English or Buddhist Three Baskets translated into English from either Pali or Sanscrit. Buddha teachings taught by the Buddha 26 centuries ago were so deep and so broad that it’s difficult for any one to understand thoroughly, even in their own languages. Beside, there are no absolute English or Vietnamese equivalents for numerous Pali and Sanskrit words. It’s even more difficult for Vietnamese people who have tried to read Vietnamese texts partly translated from the Chinese Mahayana without making a fallacious interpretation. In this work, all the diacritical marks in Romanized Chinese, Sanskrit and Pali words have been left out, since, in my poor opinion, they would only be causing more confusing to the general readers. For Chinese, Sanskrit, and Pali scholars, these marks may not be necessary for they will at once recognize the original characters. According to Zen tradition, the teachings of Zen are said to date back to the historical Buddha, Sakyamuni, who wordlessly transmitted them to Mahakasyapa, one of his most talented disciples. The tradition names a series of twenty-eight Indian Patriarchs who passed the teachings on, beginning with the historical Buddha and Mahakasyapa, then culminating in India with Patriarch Bodhidharma. In the fifth century, Bodhidharma traveled to China, where he took on Chinese disciples. From among them, Bodhidharma is said to have selected Hui-k'o to be his official successor. The tradition then traces its lineage through six generations of Chinese Patriarchs, concluding with Sixth Patriarch Hui-neng. Therefore, we can be determined that all forms of Zen Buddhism existing today trace their origins back to the Sixth Patriarch, Bodhidharma, and the historical Buddha, Sakyamuni. Especially for Vietnamese people, as you know, Buddhist teaching and tradition have deeply rooted in Vietnamese society for at least 20 centuries, and the majority of Vietnamese, in the country or abroad, directly or indirectly practice Buddha teachings. Truly speaking, nowadays Buddhist or Non-Buddhist are searching for Buddhist text books with the hope of expanding their knowledge and improving their life. Those who take up the study of Zen Buddhism enthusiastically often discover, after initial fascination has worn off, that the consecutive steps required for its serious pursuit turn out to be disappointing and fruitless. The experience of enlightenment is indeed wonderful, but the crucial question here is, how can one get into it? Trully speaking, to this very day the problem of catching this wonderful enlightenment remains an unknown matter for most of the Zen enthusiasts in the world. Is this because most of them have not yet come to a point of maturity in their studies at which they can actually practice Zen? May be very so, because most of people who want to practice Zen often hear this phrase 'this teaching does not establish words and letters'. This is really a mistaken way of thinking about Zen. It is agreeable that the practice of religion through the mystic trance. Zen practice is not a subject that uninitiated scholars can deal with competently through intellection or formal pedantry. And it is also agreeable that only those who have had the self-experience can discuss this topic with authoritative intimacy. Since Zen is not, in its essence, a philosophy but a direct experience that one must enter into with one's whole being, it is to say with both one's body and mind. In Buddhism those who still undergo religious exercises means those are still learning. Zen practitioners should always remember that for ordinary men, if they do not learn, will never know what is right and wrong for their cultivation. Therefore, it would be impossible to practice correct methods of Zen if one would not learn to follow the advice of the accomplished Zen Masters, not to reflect on their life-stories; stories that abound with accounts of the actual experience gained during their struggles in Zen. The discourses and autobiographies of these Masters have proved, in past centuries, to be invaluable documents for Zen

students, and they are accepted and cherished by all Zen seekers from all over the world as infallible guides and companions on the journey towards Enlightenment. In the hope of helping beginning Zen practitioners further an understanding of Zen and making things easier for them to search for practical instructions from the past Zen Masters, I venture to compose this little Dictionary of Zen and Buddhist Terms. These volumes not only include Zen and Buddhist terms, but they also include a number of short stories of lives of the past Zen Masters and their teachings. In the hope that from these documents we may obtain a picture of the lives and works of the Zen Masters, thus getting a clearer idea of how Zen work is actually done. For none is better qualified than these accomplished Masters to deal with the subject of Zen practice. Therefore, in my poor opinion, to follow the past Zen masters' examples and instructions is the best and safest way to practice Zen. For these reasons, until an adequate and complete Dictionary of Zen and Buddhist Terms is in existence, I have temerariously tried to compile some most useful Zen and Buddhist terms, and related terms which I have collected from reading Zen and Buddhist texts in English during the last twenty- five years. I agree that there are surely a lot of deficiencies and errors in these booklets and I am far from considering this attempt as final and perfect; however, with a wish of sharing the gift of truth, I am not reluctant to publish and spread these booklets to everyone. Besides, the Buddha taught: “Among Dana, the Dharma Dana or the gift of truth of Buddha’s teachings is the highest of all donations on earth.” Once again, I hope that these booklets are really helpful for those who want to know more about the truth of all nature and universe. As I mentioned above, this is not a completely perfect work, so I would very much appreciate and open for any comments and suggestions from the learned as well as from our elderly. I wish to express my deep gratitude to my original teacher, Most Venerable Thich Giac Nhieân, President of the International Sangha Bhikshu Buddhist Association. I also wish to appreciate all monks and nuns, as well as everybody in my family who have been helping me a lot in the process of composing this work. And above all, the author would like first to respectfully offer this work to the Triratna, and secondly to demit the good produced by composing these books to all other sentient beings, universally, past, present and future. Hoping everyone can see the real benefit of the Buddha’s teachings, and hoping that some day every sentient being will be able to enter the Eternal Nirvana.

Anaheim, California Thieän Phuùc

CAÛM TAÏ Tröôùc nhaát, taùc giaû xin chaân thaønh caûm taï Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Giaùc Nhieân ñaõ khuyeán khích taùc giaû töø nhöõng ngaøy ñaàu khoù khaên cuûa coâng vieäc bieân soaïn. Hoøa Thöôïng ñaõ cung caáp Anh Taïng cuõng nhö nhöõng saùch giaùo lyù Phaät giaùo khaùc. Ngoaøi ra, Ngaøi coøn daønh nhieàu thì giôø quí baùu coi laïi baûn thaûo vaø giaûng nghóa nhöõng töø ngöõ khoù hieåu. Keá thöù, taùc giaû cuõng xin chaân thaønh caûm taï Hoøa Thöôïng Tieán Só Thích Quaûng Lieân, Thieàn sö Thích Thanh Töø, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Taâm Chaâu, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Chôn Thaønh, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Giaùc Löôïng, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Nguyeân Ñaït, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Giaùc Toaøn, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Giaùc Tueä, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Giaùc Ngoä, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Taâm Vaân, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Chaân Toân, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Giaùc Só, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Phaùp Taùnh, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thích Quaûng Thanh, Thöôïng Toïa G.S. Thích Chôn Minh ñaõ khuyeán taán trong nhöõng luùc khoù khaên, Thöôïng Toïa Thích Minh Maãn, Thích Nguyeân Trí, Thích Minh Ñaït, Thích Voâ Ñaït, Thích Taâm Thaønh, Thích Haûi Tín, chö Ñaïi Ñöùc Thích Minh AÅn, Thích Minh Ñònh, Thích Minh Thoâng, Thích Minh Nhaân, Thích Minh Nghò, caùc Sö Coâ Thích Nöõ Dung Lieân, Thích Nöõ Maãn Lieân, Thích Nöõ Phuïng Lieân, Thích Nöõ Taùnh Lieân, Thích Nöõ Hieån Lieân, Thích Nöõ Dieäu Laïc, Thích Nöõ Dieäu Nguyeät, Thích Nöõ Dieäu Hoùa, Thích Nöõ Tònh Hieàn, Thích Nöõ Dieä u Minh, Thích Nöõ Dieäu Ñaïo, Thích Nöõ Chaân Thieàn, Thích Nöõ Vieät Lieân vaø Thích Nöõ Nhö Haïnh ñaõ khuyeán khích taùc giaû vöôït qua nhöõng khoù khaên trôû ngaïi. Moät soá ñaõ khoâng ngaïi thì giôø quí baùu duyeät ñoïc phaàn Vieät ngöõ nhö Giaùo Sö Löu Khoân, Giaùo Sö Nghieâm Phuù Phaùt, Giaùo Sö Andrew J. Williams, Sonia Brousseau, Giaùo Sö Ñaøo Khaùnh Thoï, Giaùo Sö Voõ thò Ngoïc Dung, Sheila Tröông, Nguyeãn thò Kim Ngaân, Nguyeãn Minh Laân, Nguyeãn thò Ngoïc Vaân, Maät Nghieâm, Minh Haïnh, Thieän Vinh, Minh Taøi Taêng Nhieàu, Töø Bi Phuù Phöông Lan, Töø Bi Quí Phöông Dung, Thieän Taøi, Thieän Minh, Nhieàu Phan, Hoàng Vaân Leâ, Lyù Ngoïc Hieàn, Taêng Nhôn Trí, Hueä Ñöùc, Minh Chaùnh vaø Dieäu Haûo. Taùc giaû cuõng xin chaân thaønh caûm taï ñaëc bieät ñeán quí ñaïo höõu Quaûng Taâm, Minh Chính, Minh Haïnh, Khaùnh Ly, Yeán Tuyeát Ngoâ, Hoa, Laønh, vaø Quaân ñaõ giuùp ñôû taùc giaû thaät nhieàu trong nhöõng luùc khoù khaên. Xin thaønh kính cuùng döôøng taùc phaàm naày leân ngoâi Tam Baûo, keá thöù cuùng döôøng leân Thaày Boån Sö, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Giaùc Nhieân, Phaùp Chuû Giaùo Hoäi Phaät Giaùo Taêng Giaø Khaát Só Theá Giôùi, keá thöù laø cuùng döôøng ñeán cha meï quaù vaõng laø oâng Leâ Vaên Thuaän vaø baø Traàn Thò Söûu, nhaïc phuï Taân Ngoïc Phieâu vaø nhaïc maãu Traàn thò Phaøn. Toâi cuõng xin kính taëng taùc phaåm naày ñeán hieàn phuï Töông Thuïc, vaø caùc con Thanh Phuù, Thanh Myõ, Thieän Phuù ñaõ heát mình yeãm trôï cho taùc giaû hoaøn taát taùc phaåm naày . Toâi cuõng voâ cuøng bieát ôn vaø caàu an laïc luoân ñeán vôùi taát caû anh chò em cuûa toâi, nhaát laø chò Nguyeãn Hoàng Leä, nhöõng ngöôøi ñaõ heát loøng hoã trôï toâi hoaøn taát taùc phaåm naøy. Keá ñeán taùc giaû xin thaønh thaät caûm ôn söï coá gaéng taän tuïy cuûa ban duyeät ñoïc, ñaëc bieät laø nhöõng coá gaéng vöôït böïc cuûa Öu Baø Di Tònh Myõ Nguyeãn Thò Ngoïc Vaân trong coâng vieäc cöïc kyø khoù khaên naày. Cuoái cuøng, taùc giaû xin thaønh kính hoài höôùng coâng ñöùc naày ñeán chuùng sanh trong saùu ñöôøng phaùp giôùi seõ ñöôïc sanh veà coõi Nieát Baøn mieân vieãn. Taùc giaû cuõng xin töôûng nieäm ñaëc bieät ñeán Thaày Boån Sö, Coá Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Giaùc Nhieân. Tröôùc khi boä saùch naày ñöôïc xuaát baûn thì vò Boån Sö ñaùng kính cuûa toâi laø Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Giaùc Nhieân ñaõ vieân tòch vaøo ngaøy 3 thaùng 8 naêm 2015. Caàu mong möôøi phöông chö Phaät hoä trì cho Ngaøi cao ñaêng Phaät quoác.

Anaheim, California Thieän Phuùc

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS First, I would like to take this opportunity to thank Most Venerable Thich Giac Nhien for encouraging me to start this project, providing me with Tripitaka in English version and other books of Buddhist doctrines, and reviewing my work. Beside, Most Venerable Thích Giaùc Nhieân also takes his time to sit down and explain to me Buddhist terms which I don’t know. Secondly, I want to take this opportunity to thank Most Venerable Dr. Thich Quang Lien, Zen Master Thich Thanh Tu, Most Venerable Thich Tam Chau, Most Venerable Thich Chon Thanh, Most Venerable Thich Giac Luong, Most Venerable Thich Nguyeân Ñaït, Most Thich Giac Toan, Most Ven. Thich Giac Tue, Most Ven. Thich Giac Ngo, Most Venerable Thich Tam Van, Most Venerable Thich Chan Ton, Most Ven. Thich Giac Si, Most Ven. Thich Phap Tanh, Most Ven. Thich Quang Thanh, Ven. Prof. Thich Chôn Minh, Ven. Thich Minh Man, Ven. Thich Nguyen Tri, Ven. Thich Minh Ñat, Ven. Thich Vo Ñat, Thich Tam Thanh, Thich Hai Tin, Ven. Thich Minh An, Ven. Thich Minh Ñinh, Ven. Thich Minh Thong, Ven. Thich Minh Nhan, Ven. Thich Minh Nghi, Bhikhunis Thich Nu Dung Lien, Thich Nu Man Lien, Thich Nu Phung Lien, Thich Nu Tanh Lien, Thich Nu Hien Lien, Thich Nu Dieu Lac, Thich Nu Dieu Nguyet, Thich Nu Dieu Hoa, and Thich Nu Tinh Hien, Thich Nu Dieu Ñao, Thich Nu Dieu Minh, Thich Nu Chan Thien, Thich Nu Viet Lien, Thich Nu Nhu Hanh, Prof. Nghiem Phu Phat, Prof. Löu Khon, Prof. Andrew J. Williams, Ms. Sonia Brousseau, Prof. Ñao Khanh Tho, Prof. Vo thi Ngoc Dung, Ms. Sheila Truong, Ms. Nguyen Thi Kim Ngan, Mr. Nguyen Minh Lan, Nguyen thi Ngoc Van, Mat Nghiem, Minh Hanh, Thien Vinh, Minh Tai Tang Nhieu, Tu Bi Phu Phuong Lan, Tu Bi Qui Phuong Dung, Thien Tai, Thien Minh, Nhieu Phan, Hong Van Le, Ly Ngoc Hien, Tang Nhon Tri, Hue Duc, Minh Chanh and Dieu Hao. I also would like to take this chance to send my special thanks to all my good spiritual advisors and friends, especially Quang Tam and Minh Chinh, Minh Hanh, Khanh Ly, Yen Tuyet Ngo, Hoa, Lanh and Quan, who have provided me with lots of supports in difficult times. This work is respectfully dedicated to the Three Jewels, to my Original Master, Most Venerable Thích Giaùc Nhieân, to my deceased parents Mr. Leâ Vaên Thuaän and Mrs. Traàn Thò Söûu, and to my in- laws Mr. Taân Ngoïc Phieâu and Mrs Traàn Thò Phaøn. This work is also dedicated to my wife Töông Thuïc and children Thanh Phuù, Thanh Myõ and Thieän Phuù, who have been supporting me with extraordinary efforts to complete this extremely difficult assignment. I am enormously grateful to my brothers and sisters, especially my elder sister Le Hong Nguyen, who have greatly supported me in completion of this work. May they always live in peace and joy! Next, I would like to take this opportunity to thank the proof-reading committee for their hard work, especially Upasika Tinh My Nguyen Thi Ngoc Van for her extraordinary efforts to complete this extremely difficult assignment. Last but not least, I would respectfully like to dedicate all merits and virtues derived from this work to all sentient beings throughout the six paths in the Dharma Realms to rebirth in the Eternal Nirvana. This work is especially in commemoration of my Late Original Master, Most Venerables Thich Giac Nhien. Before the printing of this work, my Original Master, Most Venerable Thich Giac Nhien passed away on August 3, 2015. May the Buddhas in the ten directions support him to advance into the Buddha-land to attain the Buddhahood there.

Anaheim, California Thieän Phuùc

Note on Language and Abbreviations (A) Languages:                                   (B) Abreviations

Chi : Chinese                         A.D. : Anno Domini
Jap : Japanese                                (sau Taây Lòch)
Kor : Korean                          B.C. : Before Christ
P : Pali                                      (tröôùc Taây Lòch)
Skt : Sanskrit                                i.e. : For example
Tib : Tibetan                         e.g. : For example
Viet: Vietnamese                              a      : Adjective
n      : Noun
n.pl : Noun Plural
v     : Verb

Words or Phrases that are used interchangeably Nhaân = Nhôn (nghóa laø ngöôøi) Nhaát = Nhöùt (nghóa laø moät)                   Naày= Naøy Nhaät = Nhöït (nghóa laø ngaøy)                  Dharma (skt)=Dhamma (p) Yeát = Kieát                                     Karma (skt)=Kamma (p) Xaûy = Xaåy                                      Sutra (skt)=Sutta (p)

Note To Our Readers Lôøi ghi chuù ñeán chö ñoäc giaû This booklet is a collection of Zen and Buddhist-related terms, and terms that are often seen in Buddhist Zen texts, written in both Vietnamese and English. Like I said in the Preface, this is not a Total and Complete Dictionary of Zen and Buddhist Terms; however, with a wish of share, I hope that all of you will find this a useful and helpful booklet for you to broaden knowledge on Zen Buddhism— Quyeån saùch nhoû naày chæ laø moät taäp hôïp caùc töø ngöõ Thieàn vaø caùc töø ngöõ coù lieân quan ñeán Phaät giaùo, vaø caùc töø ngöõ thöôøng ñöôïc tìm thaáy trong caùc saùch baùo veà Thieàn ñöôïc vieát baèng caû tieáng Vieät laãn tieáng Anh. Nhö treân ñaõ noùi, ñaây khoâng phaûi laø boä töø ñieån hoaøn haûo; tuy nhieân, vôùi taâm nguyeän seû chia, toâi mong raèng quí vò seõ tìm thaáy nôi boä saùch naày nhöõng ñieàu boå ích cho vieäc môû roäng kieán thöùc veà Thieàn trong Phaät giaùo cuûa mình.

Thieän Phuùc

REFERENCES FOR BUDDHIST TERMS 1)    AÂn Ñöùc Phaät, Cö Só Huyønh Thanh Long, 1962. 2)    Ba Vaán Ñeà Troïng Ñaïi Trong Ñôøi Tu, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thanh Töø, 1997. 3)    Baùch Duï Kinh, Vieät dòch Thích Nöõ Nhö Huyeàn, 1957. 4)    Baûn Ñoà Tu Phaät, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thieän Hoa, 1958. 5)    Baùt Quan Trai Thaäp Giaûng, Dieãn Boài Ñaïi Sö, Vieät dòch Thích Thieän Hueä, 1992. 6)    The Beginnings of Buddhism, Kogen Mizuno, 1980. 7)    Bodh Gaya, Shanti Swaroop Bauddh, New Delhi, 2005. 8)    Bodhinyana, Ajahn Chah, 1999. 9)    Bodhisattva Avadanakalpalata: A Critical Study, Jayanti Chattopadhyay, Calcutta, India, 1994. 10)   The books of The Discipline (Vinaya Pitaka), translated by I.B. Horner: 1997. 11)   Buddha, Dr. Hermann Oldenberg, New Delhi, 1997. 12)   The Buddha’s Ancient Path, Piyadassi Thera, 1964. 13)   The Buddha Eye, Frederick Franck, 1982. 14)   Buddha and Gospel of Buddhism, Ananda K. Coomaraswamy, 1974. 15)   The Buddha and His Dharma, Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, 1997. 16)   The Buddha and His Teachings, Ernest K.S. Hunt, 1962. 17)   The Buddha and His Teachings, Narada: 1973. 18)   Buddha's Words, Bhikkhu Bodhi, Somerville, MA, U.S.A., 2005. 19)   Buddhism, Clive Erricker, 1995. 20)   Buddhism, Ed. Manan Sharma, New Delhi, 2002. 21)   Buddhism, William R. LaFleur, New Jersey, U.S.A., 1988. 22)   Buddhism A to Z, Ronald B. Epstein, Ph.D., 2003. 23)   Buddhism Explained, Bhikkhu Khantipalo, 1973. 24)   Buddhism: Its Essence and Development, Edward Conze, 1951. 25)   Buddhism In The Eyes Of Intellectuals, Ven. Dr. K Sri Dhammananda, Malaysia, 1994. 26)   Buddhism And Present Life, Ven. Dr. K. Sri Dhammananda, Malaysia, 1995. 27)   Buddhism For Today, Nikkyo Niwano, 1976. 28)   Buddhism: A Very Short Introduction, Damien Keown, NY, U.S.A., 1996. 29)   The Buddhist Catechism, Henry S. Olcott, 1903. 30)   The Dhammapada, Narada, 1963. 31)   Buddhist Dictionary, Nyanatiloka and Nyanaponika: Revised 1980. 32)   Buddhist Ethics, Hammalawa Saddhatissa, 1970. 33)   The Buddhist Handbook, John Snelling, 1991. 34)   Buddhist Images of Human Perfection, Nathan Katz, India 1982. 35)   Buddhist Logic, 2 vols., Th. Stcherbatsky, 1962. 36)   The Buddhist Outlook, 2 vols., Francis Story, Sri Lanka 1973. 37)   Buddhist Parables, Eugene Watson Burlingame, New Delhi, India, 1991. 38)   A Buddhist Philosophy of Religion, Bhikkhu Nanajivako, 1992. 39)   Buddhist Sects In India, Nalinaksha Dutt, 1978. 40)   Buddhist Shrines in India, D.C. Ahir, New Delhi, 1986. 41)   Buddhist Thought in India, Edward Conze, 1962. 42)   Caùc Boä Phaùi Phaät Giaùo Tieåu Thöøa, Andreù Bareau, dòch giaû Phaùp Hieàn, NXB Toân Giaùo Haø Noäi, 2003. 43)   Caùc Toâng Phaùi Ñaïo Phaät, Ñoaøn Trung Coøn, Phaät Hoïc Vieän Quoác Teá, North Hills, CA, U.S.A., 1987. 44)   The Chinese Madhyama Agama and The Pali Majjhima Nikaya, Bhikkhu Thích Minh Chaâu, India 1991. 45)   Chôn Lyù, Toân Sö Minh Ñaêng Quang, 1946. 46)   Chö Kinh Taäp Yeáu, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Duy Löïc, 1994. 47)   Chöõ Nho Vaø Ñôøi Soáng Môùi: Thaønh Ngöõ Vieät Haùn Thoâng Duïng, Nguyeãn Ngoïc Phaùch, Melbourne, Australia, 2004. 48)   A Compendium of Chief Kagyu Master, Dr. C.T. Dorji, New Dehli, 2005. 49)   A Comprehensive Manual Of Abhidharma, Bhikkhu Bodhi, Sri Lanka, 1993. 50)   Con Döôøng Coå Xöa, Piyadassi Thera, dòch giaû Tyø Kheo Phaùp Thoâng, NXB Toân Giaùo, 2006. 51)   Con Ñöôøng Thoaùt Khoå, W. Rahula, dòch giaû Thích Nöõ Trí Haûi, 1958. 52)   The Concept of Personality Revealed Through The Pancanikaya, Thích Chôn Thieän, New Delhi, 1996. 53)   A Concise History of Buddhism, Andrew Skilton, 1994. 54)   The Connected Discourses of the Buddha, translated from Pali by Bhikkhu Bodhi, 2000. 55)   The Conquest of Suffering, P.J. Saher, Delhi 1977. 56)   Danh Töø Phaät Hoïc Thöïc Duïng, Taâm Tueä Hyû, NXB Toân Giaùo, 2005. 57)   A Dictionary of Chinese Buddhist Terms, William Edward Soothill & Lewis Hodous: 1934.

58) Dictionary of Philosophy, Dagobert D. Runes: 1981. 59) Dictionary Of World Religions, Keith Crim, NY, U.S.A., 1981. 60) Du Taêng Caàu Phaùp, Thích Haèng Ñaït, San Jose, U.S.A., 1998. 61) Duy Thöùc Hoïc, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thieän Hoa, 1958. 62) Döôïc Sö Kinh, Haùn dòch Huyeàn Trang, Vieät dòch Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Huyeàn Dung, 1949. 63) Döôïc Sö Boån Nguyeän Coâng Ñöùc Kinh, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Huyeàn Dung, 1949. 64) Ñaïi Baùt Nieát Baøn, dòch giaû Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Trí Tònh: 1990. 65) Ñaïi Taïng Kinh Nhaäp Moân, Haùn dòch Thích Haûi AÁn vaø Thích Nguyeän Quyûnh, Vieät dòch Thích Vieân Lyù, 1999. 66) Ñaïo Phaät An Laïc vaø Tænh Thöùc, Thieän Phuùc, USA, 1996. 67) Ñaïo Phaät Trong Ñôøi Soáng, 10 volumes, Thieän Phuùc, USA, 1994. 68) Ñaïo Phaät Vôùi Con Ngöôøi, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Taâm Chaâu, 1953. 69) Ñòa Taïng Kinh, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Trí Thuû. 70) Ñöôøng Vaøo AÙnh Saùng Ñaïo Phaät, Tònh Maëc, 1959. 71) Early Madhyamika In India and China, Richard H. Robinson, 1967. 72) The Encyclopedia of Eastern Philosophy and Religion, Ingrid Fisher-Schreiber: 1994. 73) English-Vietnamese Buddhist Dictionary, 10 volumes, Thieän Phuùc, USA, 2007. 74) The Essence of Buddhism, Daisetz Teitaro Suzuki, 1947. 75) Essential of Buddhism, Gnanarama, Singapore, 2000. 76) Essentials of Buddhism, Kogen Mizuno, Tokyo, 1972. 77) The Essence of Buddhism, P. Lakshmi Narasu, Colombo 1907. 78) The Essentials of Buddhist Philosophy, Junjiro Takakusu, 1947. 79) Essential Tibetan Buddhism, Robert A.F. Thurman, 1995. 80) The Flower Ornament Scripture, Shambhala: 1987. 81) The Four Noble Truths, Dalai Lama XIV, translated into English Geshe Thupten Jina, Dhramsala, India, 2008. 82) Gems of Buddhist Wisdom, many authors, Kular Lumpur, 1983. 83) Gems Of Buddhism Wisdom, Most Venerable Dr. K. Sri Dhammananda, 1983. 84) Giôùi Ñaøn Ni, T.T. Thích Minh Phaùt: 1988. 85) Giôùi Ñaøn Taêng, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thieän Hoøa: 1968. 86) A Glossary of Buddhist Terms, A.C. March, 1937. 87) Good Question Good Answer, Ven. Shravasti Dhammika, Singapore, 1991. 88) The Gospel Of Buddha, Paul Carus, 1961. 89) The Great Buddhist Emperor of Asia, Ven. Dr. Medhankar, Nagpur, India, 2000. 90) The Great Religions by which Men Live, Floyd H. Ross & Tynette Hills, 2000. 91) Göông Saùng Ngöôøi Xöa, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Huyeàn Vi, 1974. 92) Hai Ngaøn Naêm Vieät Nam & Phaät Giaùo, Lyù Khoâi Vieät, CA, U.S.A., 1981. 93) Haùn Hoïc Töù Töï Thaønh Ngöõ, Hoà Ñaéc Haøm, NXB Vaên Höõu AÙ Chaâu, 1961. 94) The Heart of Wisdom, Dr. C.T. Dorji, New Dehli, 2005. 95) Hinayana and Mahayana, R. Kimura, 1927. 96) History of Theravada Buddhism in South East Asia, Kanai Lal Hazra, New Dehli, 1981. 97) How To Get From Where You Are To Where You Want To Be, Cheri Huber, 2000. 98) How to Overcome Your Difficulties: Worry and Fear, Dhammananda, Ven. Nhuan Chau translated in 2005. 99) Hueä Quang Phaät Hoïc Ñaïi Töø Ñieån, Ven. Thích Minh Caûnh Chuû Bieân, 1994. 100) Human Life and Problems, Dr. K. Sri Dhammananda, 1960. 101) Huyeàn Thoaïi Duy Ma Caät, Tueä Syõ, VN, 2007. 102) In The Hope of Nibbana, Winston L. King, 1964. 103) Introducing Buddhism, Kodo Matsunami, Tokyo 1965. 104) Introduction To Tantra, Lama Thubten Yeshe, 1935. 105) Jataka (Stories Of The Buddha’s Former Births), Prof. E.B. Cowell: Delhi 1990. 106) Khaûo Nghieäm Duy Thöùc Hoïc, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thaéng Hoan, 1987. 107) Kim Cang Giaûng Giaûi, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thanh Töø, 1992. 108) Laù Thö Tònh Ñoä, Ñaïi Sö AÁn Quang, dòch giaû Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thieàn Taâm, 1956. 109) Laøm Theá Naøo Toâi Thöïc Haønh Phaät Giaùo Taïi Nhaân Gian?, Ñaïi Sö Tinh Vaân, dòch giaû Thích Nguyeân Haûi, Los Angeles, CA, U.S.A., 2010. 110) The Land of Bliss, Luis O. Gomez, 1996. 111) Liberation In The Palm Of Your Hand, Pabongka Rinpoche, 1991. 112) Lòch Söû Ñöùc Phaät Toå, Thoâng Kham Medivongs. 113) Lieân Toâng Thaäp Tam Toå, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thieàn Taâm, 1956. 114) The Life of Buddha, Edward J. Thomas, 1952. 115) Life & Teachings Of Tsong Khapa, Prof. R. Thurman, New Delhi, India, 1982. 116) The Light Of Asia, Sir Edwin Arnold, New Delhi, 1996.

117) Linguistic Approach to Buddhism Thought, Genjun H. Sasaki, Delhi 1986. 118) The Literature of The Personalists of Early Buddhism, Bhikkhu Thích Thieän Chaâu, English translator Sara Boin-Webb, 1996. 119) The Long Discourses of the Buddha, translated from the Pali by Maurice Walshe, 1987. 120) Loving and Dying, Bhiksu Visuddhacara, 1960. 121) Luaän Baûo Vöông Tam Muoäi, Sa Moân Dieäu Hieäp, Vieät dòch Minh Chaùnh. 122) Luaän Ñaïi Trí Ñoä, dòch giaû Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Trung Quaùn: 1990. 123) Luaän Thaønh Duy Thöùc, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thieän Sieâu, 1995. 124) Luaät Nghi Khaát Só, Toå Sö Minh Ñaêng Quang: 1950. 125) Luaät Sa Di Thöôøng Haøng (Luaät Caên Baûn Cuûa Ngöôøi Xuaát Gia), dòch giaû Thích Thieän Thoâng, Thích Ñoàng Boån, Thích Nhöït Chieâu: 1995. 126) Luaät Töù Phaàn Giôùi Boån Nhö Thích, dòch giaû Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Haønh Truï: 1950. 127) Luaät Töù Phaàn Tyø Kheo Ni Giôùi Boån Löôïc Kyù, dòch giaû Tyø Kheo Ni Huyeàn Hueä: 1996. 128) Löôïc Söû Phaät Giaùo AÁn Ñoä, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thanh Kieåm, 1963. 129) Mahayana Buddhism, Beatrice Lane Suzuki, 1969. 130) A Manual of Abhidharma, Most Venerable Narada, Kuala Lumpur, 1956. 131) A Manual of Buddhism, Most Venerable Narada, Kuala Lumpur, 1992. 132) Mi Tieân Vaán Ñaùp Kinh, Hoøa Thöôïng Giôùi Nghieâm Vieät dòch, 2005. 133) The Middle Length Discourses of the Buddha, translated from the Pali by Bhikkhu Nanamoli, edited and revised by Bhikkhu Bodhi, 1995. 134) Milinda Vaán Ñaïo vaø Kinh Na Tieân Tyø Kheo, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Minh Chaâu, 1964. 135) Modern Buddhism, Alan & Jacqui James, 1987. 136) Möôøi Vò Ñeä Töû Lôùn Cuûa Phaät, Tinh Vaân Phaùp Sö, Vieät dòch Haïnh Cô, 1994 137) Na Tieân Tyø Kheo, Cao Höõu Ñính, 1970. 138) Nagarjuna’s Philosophy, K. Venkata Ramanan, Delhi 1975. 139) Neàn Taûng Phaät Hoïc Thieân Thai Toâng, Paul L. Swanson, dòch giaû Töø Hoa Nhaát Tueä Taâm, NXB Phöông Ñoâng, 2010. 140) Nhaät Lieân Toâng Nhaät Baûn, Watanabe Hooyoo & Ootani Gyokoo, dòch giaû Thích Nhö Ñieån, Hannover, Germany, 2008. 141) Nhôn Quaû, Nghieäp vaø Luaân Hoài, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thieän Hoa, 1960. 142) Nhöõng Toân Giaùo Lôùn Trong Ñôøi Soáng Nhaân Loaïi, Floyd H. Ross & Tynette Hills, dòch giaû Thích Taâm Quang, Fresno, U.S.A., 2004. 143) Nieäm Phaät Thaäp Yeáu, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thieàn Taâm, 1950. 144) Numerical Discourses Of The Buddha, translated by Nyanaponika Thera & Bhikkhu Bodhi, New York, U.S.A., 1999. 145) Pagodas, Gods and Spirits of Vietnam, Ann Helen Unger and Walter Unger, 1997. 146) The Path of Purification, Pali Text by Bhadantacariya Buddhaghosa, translated by Bhikkhu Nanamoli: 1956. 147) Pen Portraits Ninety Three Eminent Disciples of the Buddha, C. de Saram, Singapore, 1966. 148) Phaùp Moân Tònh Ñoä Thuø Thaéng, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Haân Hieàn, 1991. 149) Phaùt Boà Ñeà Taâm Löôïc Giaûng, Thích Kieán Chôn, Oakland, CA, U.S.A., 2008. 150) Phaät Baûn Haïnh Taäp Kinh, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Trung Quaùn. 151) Phaät Ñaûnh Toân Thaéng Ñaø La Ni, dòch giaû Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thieàn Taâm: 1950. 152) Phaät Giaùo Nhìn Toaøn Dieän, Mahathera Piyadassi, Phaïm Kim Khaùnh Dòch, Seattle, WA, U.S.A., 1995. 153) Phaät Giaùo, Tueä Quang Nguyeãn Ñaêng Long, 1964. 154) Phaät Giaùo Cöông Yeáu, Vieät dòch Sa Moân Hieån Chôn, 1929 155) Phaät Giaùo Thaùnh Ñieån, Cö Só Thaùi Ñaïm Lö, Taiwan 1953. 156) Phaät Giaùo Thaùnh Kinh, Cö Só Döông Tuù Haïc, Taiwan 1962, Vieät dòch Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Trí Nghieâm, 1963. 157) Phaät Giaùo Theà Giôùi, Thích Nguyeân Taïng, Australia, 2001. 158) Phaät Giaùo vaø Trieát Hoïc Taây Phöông, H.T. Thích Quaûng Lieân, 1996. 159) Phaät Giaùo Vieät Nam, Mai Thoï Truyeàn, Saøi Goøn, VN, 1964. 160) Phaät Hoïc Phoå Thoâng, Thích Thieän Hoa: 1958 (3 volumes). 161) Phaät Hoïc Tinh Hoa, Nguyeãn Duy Caàn, 1964. 162) Phaät Hoïc Tinh Yeáu, 3 vols., Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thieàn Taâm, 1965. 162) Phaät Hoïc Töø Ñieån, Ñoaøn Trung Coøn: 1963 (2 volumes). 164) Phaät Lyù Caên Baûn, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Huyeàn Vi, 1973. 165) Phaät Phaùp, Hoøa Thöôïng Minh Chaâu, Hoøa Thöôïng Thieân AÂn, Hoøa Thöôïng Chôn Trí, Hoøa Thöôïng Ñöùc Taâm, 1964. 166) Phaät Phaùp Caên Baûn (Vieät-Anh)—Basic Buddhist Doctrines, 08 volumes, Thieän Phuùc, USA, 2009. 167) Phaät Vaø Thaùnh Chuùng, Cao Höõu Ñính, 1936. 168) Phaät Thuyeát A Di Ñaø Kinh, Haùn dòch Cöu Ma La Thaäp, Vieät dòch Cö Só Tueä Nhuaän, 1951. 169) Philosophy and Psychology in The Abhidharma, Herbert V. Guenther, 1957. 170) Phoå Hieàn Haïnh Nguyeän Löôïc Giaûng, Thích Kieán Chôn, Oakland, CA, U.S.A., 2009. 171) Phoå Hieàn Haïnh Nguyeän Kinh, Vieät dòch Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Trí Tònh, 1956. 172) The Pioneers of Buddhist Revival in India, D.C. Ahir, New Delhi 1989.

173) A Popular Dictionary of Buddhism, Christmas Humphreys: London 1984. 174) Prayers to the Medicine Buddha, composed by Geshe Norbu Phunsok, translated into Vietnamese by Sonam Nyima Chaân Giaùc Buøi Xuaân Lyù in 2005. 175) The Questions of King Milinda, T.W. Rhys Davis, 1963. 176) Qui Nguyeân Tröïc Chæ, Ñoã Thieáu Laêng, Saigon 1961. 177) Rebirth as Doctrine and Experience, Francis Story, 1975. 178) Rebirth and The Western Buddhist, Martin Wilson, Ven. Thich Nguyeân Taïng Vieät dòch 2006. 179) A Record of Buddhist Kingdoms, Fa-Hsien, English translator James Legge, 1965. 180) Religions In Asian America: Building Faith Communities, Pyong Gap Min & Ha Kim, NY, U.S.A., 2002. 181) Religions of The Wolrd, Lewis M. Hopfe: 1983. 182) Sa Di Luaät Giaûi, dòch giaû Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Haønh Truï: 1950. 183) The Sacred East, Scott Littleton, 1996. 184) Sakyamuni’s One Hundred Fables, Tetcheng Lioa, 1981. 185) Sarnath, Shanti Swaroop Bauddh, New Delhi, 2003. 186) The Seeker’s Glossary: Buddhism: 1998. 187) A Sense Of Asia, Sol Sanders, U.S.A. and Canada, 1969. 188) Seven Works of Vasubandhu, Stefan Anacker, Delhi 1984. 189) The Shambhala Dictionary of Buddhism and Zen: 1991. 190) Skillful Means, Tarthang Tulku, 1978. 191) The Spectrum of Buddhism, Mahathera Piyadassi, Sri Lanka, 1991. 192) The Story of Buddha, Jonathan Landaw: 1978. 193) The Spectrum of Buddhism, Mahathera Piyadassi, Sri Lanka, 1991. 194) Suramgama Sutra, Minh Taâm Leâ Ñình Thaùm: 1961. 195) Söï Tích Phaät A Di Ñaø, 7 Vò Boà Taùt vaø 33 Vò Toå Sö, Traàn Nguyeân Chaån, 1950. 196) Symbols Of Tibetan Buddhism, Claude B. Levenson & Laziz Hamani, NY, U.S.A., 2000. 197) Taøi Lieäu Nghieân Cöùu Vaø Dieãn Giaûng, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thieän Hoa, 1957. 198) Talks on Dharma, Volumes I to IX, Venerable Master Hsuan Hua, from 1958 to 1980. 199) Tam Baûo Kinh, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Trí Tònh, 1970. 200) Tam Kinh Tònh Ñoä, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Trí Thuû. 201) Taùm Quyeån Saùch Quí, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thieän Hoa, 1954. 202) Taïp A Haøm Kinh, Vieän Nghieân Cöùu Phaät Hoïc Vieät Nam: 1993. 203) Taêng Chi Boä Kinh, Vieän Nghieân Cöùu Phaât Hoïc Vieät Nam: 1996. 204) Taêng Giaø Vieät Nam, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Trí Quang, Phaät Lòch 2515. 205) Taâm Ñòa Quaùn Kinh, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Taâm Chaâu, 1959. 206) Thaéng Phaùp Taäp Yeáu Luaän, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Minh Chaâu. 207) Thaäp Ñoä, Tyø Kheo Hoä Toâng. 208) Thieân Truùc Tieåu Du Kyù, Thieän Phuùc, USA, 2006. 209) Three Teachings, Tenzin Palmo, Singapore, 2005. 210) Thuû Laêng Nghieâm Kinh, Hoøa Thöôïng Bích Lieân, Hoøa Thöôïng Nhö Phöôùc, Hoøa Thöôïng Töø Quang, 1957. 211) Thuû Laêng Nghieâm Kinh, Taâm Minh Leâ Ñình Thaùm, 1961. 212) Thuû Laêng Nghieâm Kinh, Vieät dòch Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Phöôùc Haûo, 1990. 213) Thuû Laêng Nghieâm Kinh, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Töø Quang, 1948. 214) Thuû Laêng Nghieâm Kinh, Trí Ñoä vaø Tueä Quang, 1964. 215) Thuyeát Luaân Hoài & Phaät Giaùo Taây Phöông, Martin Willson, dòch giaû Thích Nguyeân Taïng, Melbourne, Australia, 2006. 216) Thö Göûi Ngöôøi Hoïc Phaät, Thöôïng Toïa Thích Haûi Quang, 1998. 217) The Tibetan Book Of The Dead, Guru Rinpoche according to Karma Lingpa, 1975. 218) The Tibetan Book of Living and Dying, Sogyal Rinpoche, 1992. 219) Tinh Hoa Bí Yeáu, Ni Sö Huyønh Lieân, VN, 1995. 220) Tònh Ñoä Thaäp Nghi Luaän, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thieàn Taâm, 1962. 221) Tònh Ñoä Toâng Nhaät Baûn, Kakehashi Jitsuen, dòch giaû Thích Nhö Ñieån, Hannover, Germany, 2007. 222) Tranh Töôïng Phaät Giaùo Taây Taïng, NXB Toân Giaùo, 2009. 223) Trao Cho Thôøi Ñaïi Moät Noäi Dung Phaät Chaát, Phaät Hoïc Vieän Quoác Teá, U.S.A., 1990. 224) Tri Thöùc Toân Giaùo Qua Caùc Vaán Naïn Vaø Giaûi Ñaùp, John Renard, dòch giaû Löu Vaên Hy, NXB Toân Giaùo, 2005. 225) Trung A Haøm Kinh, Vieän Nghieân Cöùu Phaät Hoïc Vieät Nam: 1992. 226) Trung Boä Kinh, Vieän Nghieân Cöùu Phaät Hoïc Vieät Nam: 1992. 227) Tröôøng A Haøm Kinh, Vieän Nghieân Cöùu Phaät Hoïc Vieät Nam: 1991. 228) Tröôøng Boä Kinh, Vieän Nghieân Cöùu Phaät Hoïc Vieät Nam: 1991. 229) Tröôûng Laõo Ni Keä, Vieät dòch Tyø Kheo Sieâu Minh, NXB Toång Hôïp TPHCM, 2008. 230) Tu Laø Chuyeån Nghieäp, H.T. Thích Thanh Töø, Vieät Nam, 1993. 231) Tö Töôûng Phaät Giaùo AÁn Ñoä, Edward Conze, dòch giaû Haïnh Vieân, NXB Phöông Ñoâng, VN, 2007.

232) Töù Thaäp Nhò Chöông Kinh, Cö Só Nguyeãn Vaên Höông, 1951. 233) Töø Ñieån Phaùp Soá Tam Taïng, Thích Nhaát Nhö, dòch giaû Leâ Hoàng Sôn, NXB Phöông Ñoâng, 2011. 234) Töø Ñieån Phaät Hoïc Haùn Vieät, GHPGVN, Phaân Vieän Nghieân Cöùu, NXB Khoa Hoïc Xaõ Hoäi, 1992, 235) Töø Ñieån Phaät Hoïc, Nguyeãn Töôøng Baùch & Thích Nhuaän Chaâu, NXB Thôøi Ñaïi, 2011. 236) Töø Ñieån Phaät Hoïc Vieät Nam, Thích Minh Chaâu: 1991. 237) Töø Vöïng Phaät Hoïc Thöôøng Duøng, Traàn Nghóa Hieáu, Vieät dòch Giaûi Minh, NXB Phöông Ñoâng, 2007. 238) Töông Öng Boä Kinh, Vieän Nghieân Cöùu Phaät Hoïc Vieät Nam: 1993. 239) Twenty-Five Hundred Years of Buddhism, P.V. Bapat, 1959 240) Tyø Ni Höông Nhuõ, dòch giaû Thích Thieän Chôn: 1997. 241) Öu Baø Taéc Giôùi Kinh, Sa Moân Thích Quaûng Minh, 1957. 242) Vi Dieäu Phaùp Toaùt Yeáu, Narada Maha Thera, 1972, Vieät dòch Phaïm Kim Khaùnh. 243) Vì Sao Tin Phaät, K. Sri Dhammananda, dòch giaû Thích Taâm Quang, 1998. 244) Vieân Giaùc Kinh, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thieän Hoa, Saigon 1958. 245) Vieät Nam Phaät Giaùo Söû Luaän, Nguyeãn Lang: 1977. 246) Vieät Nam Phaät Giaùo Söû Löôïc, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Maät Theå, 1943. 247) Vietnamese-English Buddhist Dictionary, 6 volumes, Thieän Phuùc, USA, 2005. 248) Walking with the Buddha, India Dept. of Tourism, New Delhi, 2004. 249) What The Buddha Taught, Walpola Rahula: 1959. 250) What Buddhists Believe, Most Venerable Dr. K. Sri Dhammananda: 1987. 251) World Religions, Lewis M. Hopfe: 1982. 252) You & Your Problems, Ven. Dr. K Sri Dhammananda, Kuala Lampur, Malaysia, 2004.

REFERENCES FOR ZEN TERMS 1)    An Annotated Bibliography Of Selected Chinese Reference Works, Ssu-yu Teng & Knight Biggerstaff, London, UK, 1950. 2)    An Truù Trong Hieän Taïi, Thích Nhaát Haïnh, Tu Vieän Kim Sôn, U.S.A., 1987. 3)    The Art Of Chinese Poetry, James J. Y. Liu, London, 1962. 4)    The Art of Zen, Stephen Addiss, NY, U.S.A., 1989. 5)    At The Zen Gate: Vaøo Coång Nhaø Thieàn, Thích Thanh Töø, translated into English by Toaøn Kieân Phaïm Ngoïc Thaïch & Leâ Thuøy Lan, San Diego, CA, USA, 2000. 6)    Ba Möôi Ngaøy Thieàn Quaùn, Joseph Goldstein, dòch giaû Nguyeãn Duy Nhieân, 1992. 7)    Ba Truï Thieàn, Roshi Philip Kapleau, Vieät dòch Ñoã Ñình Ñoàng, U.S.A., 1962. 8)    Baù Tröôïng Ngöõ Luïc, dòch giaû Döông Thanh Khaûi, Vinhlong, VN, 2012. 9)    Beat Stress With Meditation, Naomi Ozaniec, London, UK, 1997. 10)   Being Peace, Thich Nhat Hanh, Berkeley, CA, U.S.A., 1987. 11)   The Benefits Of Walking Meditation, Sayadaw U. Silananda, Sri Lanka, 1995. 12)   Bích Nham Luïc, Thieàn Sö Vieân Ngoä, dòch giaû, Thích Thanh Töø, 1995. 13)   Bieån Trí Hueä, Tenzin Gyatso, The Fourteenth Dalai Lama, dòch giaû Ñaøo Chính & Ñoan Nghieâm, NXB Phuï Nöõ, 2007. 14)   Bieän Chöùng Giaûi Thoaùt Trong Giaùo Lyù Trung Hoa, Nghieâm Xuaân Hoàng, NXB Xuaân Thu, 1967. 15)   The Blooming Of A Lotus, Thich Nhat Hanh, Boston, U.S.A., 1993. 16)   The Blue Cliff Record, translated into English by Thomas Cleary & J.C. Cleary, Boston Massachusetts, U.S.A., 1977. 17)   Book Of Serenity, Thomas Cleary, Boston, Massachusetts, U.S.A., 1988. 18)   The Book of Tea, Kakuzo Okakura, NY, U.S.A., 1964. 19)   Boà Ñeà Ñaït Ma Quaùn Taâm Phaùp, Vieät dòch Minh Thieàn, 1972. 20)   The Brightened Mind, Ajahn Sumano Bhikkhu, India, 2011. 21)   The Buddha’s Ancient Path, Piyadassi Thera, 1964. 22)   The Buddha And His Teaching, Ernest K.S. Hunt, 1992. 23)   In the Buddha's Words, Bhikkhu Bodhi, Somerville, MA, U.S.A., 2005. 24)   Buddhism In China, Kenneth K. S. Ch'en, Princeton, New Jersey, U.S.A., 1964. 25)   Buddhism Is Not What You Think, Steve Hagen, New York, U.S.A., 1999. 26)   A Buddhist Bible, Rebert Aitken, Boston, Massachusetts, U.S.A., 1938. 27)   Buddhist Meditation, Edward Conze, 1956. 28)   The Buddhist Teaching Of Totality, Garma C.C. Chang, New Delhi, 1992. 29)   Calm and Insight, Bhikkhu Khantipalo, 1981. 30)   Calming The Mind, Gen Lamrimpa, 1992. 31)   Calming The Mind and Discerning The Real, Tsong-Kha-Pa, English Translator Alex Wayman, 1978. 32)   Cao Taêng Trieàu Tieân, Giaùc Huaán, Vieät dòch Thích Nguyeân Loäc, NXB Phöông Ñoâng, VN, 2012. 33)   The Central Philosophy of Buddhism, T.R.V. Murti, London, England, 1960.

34)   The Chan Handbook, Ven. Master Hua, Ukiah, CA, U.S.A., 2004. 35)   Chaân Ngoân Toâng Nhaät Baûn, Satoo Ryoosei & Komine Ichiin, Vieät dòch Thích Nhö Ñieån, Hannover, Germany, 2010. 36)   Chuyeån Hoùa Taâm, Shamar Rinpoche, dòch giaû Luïc Thaïch, NXB Toân Giaùo, 2004. 37)   Chöùng Ñaïo Ca, thieàn sö Huyeàn Giaùc, dòch giaû Truùc Thieân, 1970. 38)   A Concise Dictionary Of Buddhism & Zen, Ingrid Fischer-Schreiber & Michael Diener, translated by Michael H. Kohn, Boston, U.S.A., 1991. 39)   The Connected Discourses of the Buddha, translated from Pali by Bhikkhu Bodhi, 2000. 40)   Coâng AÙn Cuûa Phaät Thích Ca Vaø Toå Ñaït Ma, Thích Duy Löïc, Santa Ana, CA, U.S.A., 1986. 41)   Cuoäc Ñôøi Laø Moät Haønh trình Taâm Linh, Sayadaw U Jotika, dòch giaû Tyø Kheo Taâm Phaùp, NXB Toân Giaùo, 2006. 42)   Daily Wisdom, Tenzin Gyatso, The Fourteenth Dalai Lama, edited by Josh Bartok, Boston, U.S.A., 2003. 43)   Danh Töø Thieàn Hoïc Chuù Giaûi, Thích Duy Löïc, Thaønh Hoäi PG TPHCM, 1995. 44)   Duy Ma Caät Sôû Thuyeát Kinh, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Hueä Höng, 1951. 45)   Duy Thöùc Hoïc, Thích Thaéng Hoan, San Jose, CA, U.S.A., 1998. 46)   Ñaïo Phaät Trong Ñôøi Soáng, 10 volumes, Thieän Phuùc, USA, 1994. 47)   Ñaïo Phaät An Laïc vaø Tænh Thöùc, Thieän Phuùc, USA, 1996. 48)   The Diamond Sutra and The Sutra Of Hui-Neng, A.F. Price and Wong Mou-Lam, 1947. 49)   The Diary Of A Meditation Practitioner, Dr. Jane Hamilton Merrit, U.S.A., 1960. 50)   The Dictionary of Zen , Ernest Wood, NY, U.S.A., 1962. 51)   Directing To Self Penetration, Tan Acharn Kor Khao-suan-luang, Bangkok, 1984. 52)   Ñoaïn Tröø Laäu Hoaëc, Acharya Buddharakkhita, dòch giaû Tyø Kheo Phaùp Thoâng, 2002. 53)   Dropping Ashes on the Buddha, Seung Sahn, translated by Stephen Mitchell, NY, U.S.A., 1976. 54)   Ñöôøng Veà Beán Giaùc, Thích Thanh Caùt, Palo Alto, CA, 1987. 55)   Ñöôøng Veà Thöïc Taïi, Chu Tö Phu-Caùt Tö Ñính, dòch giaû Töø Nhaân, NXB Phöông Ñoâng, 2007. 56)   The Elements of Zen, David Scott and Tony Doubleday, 1992. 57)   The English-Chinese Dictionary, Lu Gusun, Shangai, China, 1994. 58)   Essays In Zen Buddhism, First Series, Daisetz Teitaro Suzuki, London, England, 1927. 59)   Essays In Zen Buddhism, Second Series, Daisetz Teitaro Suzuki, London, England, 1933. 60)   Essays In Zen Buddhism, Third Series, Daisetz Teitaro Suzuki, London, England, 1934. 61)   The Essence of Zen Practice, Taizan Maezumi Roshi, Shambhala, Boston, MA, U.S.A., 2001. 62)   Essentials Of Insight Meditation, Ven. Sujiva, Malaysia, 2000. 63)   Everyday Zen, Charlotte Joko Beck, edited by Steve Smith, NY, U.S.A., 1998. 64)   The Experience of Insight, Joseph Goldstein, Santa Cruz, CA, U.S.A., 1976. 65)   The Flower Ornament Scripture, Shambhala: 1987. 66)   Food For The Thinking Mind, Ven. K. Sri Dhammananda, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, 1999. 67)   Foundations of T'ien-T'ai Philosophy, Paul L. Swanson, U.S.A., 1951. 68)   The Gateless Barrier, Robert Aitken, San Francisco, CA, U.S.A., 1990. 69)   Generating The Mind Of Enlightenment, The Dalai Lama XIV, 1992. 70)   The Gift Of Well-Being, Ajahn Munido, UK, 1997. 71)   Goõ Cöûa Thieàn, Zen Master Muju, dòch giaû Nguyeân Minh, NXB Vaên Hoùa Thoâng Tin, 2008. 72)   A Guide To Walking Meditation, Thich Nhat Hanh, 1985. 73)   A Heart As Wide As The World, Sharon Salzberg, Boston, Massachusetts, U.S.A., 1997. 74)   Hieåu Veà Traùi Tim, Thích Minh Nieäm, NXB Treû, V.N., 2010. 75)   The Holy Teaching Of Vimalakirti, Robert A.F. Thurman: 1976. 76)   How To Get From Where You Are To Where You Want To Be, Cheri Huber, 2000. 77)   Hua-Yen Buddhism: The Jewel Net of Indra, Francis H. Cook, NY, U.S.A., 1977. 78)   Höông Thieàn, Thích Nhaät Quang, NXB TPHCM, 2001. 79)   The Illustrated Encyclopedia Of Zen Buddhism, Helen J. Baroni, Ph.D., NY, U.S.A., 2002. 80)   Im Laëng Laø Tieáng Ñoäng Khoâng Ngöøng, Thích Giaùc Nhieäm, VN, 2004. 81)   An Index To The Lankavatara Sutra, D.T. Suzuki, New Delhi, India, 2000. 82)   In This Very Life, Sayadaw U. Pandita, 1921. 83)   In This Very Moment, James Ishmael Ford, Boston, U.S.A., 1996. 84)   An Index to the Lankavatara Sutra, Daisetz Teitaro Suzuki, London, 1934. 85)   Insights, Ven. Master Hsuan Hua, Ukiah, CA, U.S.A., 2007. 86)   Insight Meditation, Joseph Goldstein, 1993. 87)   The Intention Of Patriarch Bodhidharma Coming From The West, Ven. Master Hsuan Hua, Burlingame, CA, U.S.A., 1983. 88)   An Introduction To Zen Buddhism, D.T. Suzuki, 1934. 89)   In the Light of Meditation, Mike George, NY, U.S.A., 2004. 90)   It’s Easier Than You Think, Sylvia Boorstein, 1995. 91)   Journey Without Goal, Chogyam Trungpa, 1981. 92)   Just Add Buddha!, Franz Metcalf, Berkeley, CA, U.S.A., 2004.

93) Khai Môû Ñaïo Taâm, Ñaïo Sö Duy Tueä, U.S.A., 2008. 94) Khi Naøo Chim Saét Bay, Ayya Khema, Vieät dòch Dieäu Lieân Lyù Thu Linh, 2004. 95) Kim Cang Giaûng Giaûi, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thanh Töø, 1992. 96) Kinh Nghieäm Thieàn Quaùn, Joseph Goldstein, dòch giaû Nguyeãn Duy Nhieân, NXB Ñaø Naúng, 2007. 97) Kinh Phaùp Baûo Ñaøn, Döông Thanh Khaûi, Vinhlong, VN, 2007. 98) Lòch Söû Thieàn Hoïc, Ibuki Atsushi, dòch giaû Taøn Moäng Töû, NXB Phöông Ñoâng, VN, 2001. 99) The Lion Roar, David Maurice, NY, U.S.A, 1962. 100) Living Buddhist Masters, Jack Kornfield, Santa Cruz, CA, U.S.A., 1977. 101) Living In The State Of Stuck, Marcia J. Scherer, Santa Cruz, CA, U.S.A., 1996. 102) The Long Discourses of the Buddha, translated from the Pali by Maurice Walshe, 1987. 103) Luminous Mind, Joel and Michelle Levey, CA, U.S.A., 1999. 104) Maõ Toå Ngöõ Luïc, dòch giaû Döông Thanh Khaûi, Vinhlong, VN, 2012. 105) Meditating With Mandalas, David Fontana, London, UK, 2005. 106) Meditation, Eknath Easwaran, Petaluma, CA, U.S.A., 1978. 107) Meditation Now: Inner Peace Through Inner Wisdom, S.N. Goenka, Seattle, WA, U.S.A., 2002. 108) The Method of Zen, Eugen Herrigel, 1960. 109) The Middle Length Discourses of the Buddha, translated from the Pali by Bhikkhu Nanamoli, edited and revised by Bhikkhu Bodhi, 1995. 110) The Mind In Early Buddhism, Ven. Thich Minh Thanh, NXB Toång Hôïp TPHCM, 2001. 111) Mindfulness, Bliss, And Beyond, Ajahn Brahm, U.S.A., 1951. 112) Minh Saùt Thöïc Tieãn, Mahasi Sayadaw, dòch giaû Tyø Kheo Phaùp Thoâng, NXB Toân Giaùo, VN, 2007. 113) Minh Trieát Thieàn, Ñaïo Sö Duy Tueä, NXB Vaên Hoùa-Thoâng Tin, Haø Noäi, VN, 2008. 114) More Daily Wisdom, Tenzin Gyatso, The Fourteenth Dalai Lama, edited by Josh Bartok, Boston, U.S.A., 2006. 115) Môû Roäng Taâm, Ñaïo Sö Duy Tueä, U.S.A., 2003. 116) Neûo Vaøo Thieàn Hoïc, Thích Nhaát Haïnh, NXB Laù Boái, 1970. 117) Neáp Thieàn, Thích Nhaät Quang, NXB TPHCM, 2002. 118) Ngay Trong Kieáp Soáng Naøy, U Pandita, dòch giaû Tyø Kheo Khaùnh Hyû, San Jose, CA, U.S.A., 1996. 119) Nghieân Cöùu Kinh Laêng Giaø, D.T. Suzuki, Vieät dòch Thích Chôn Thieän & Traàn Tuaán Maãn, GHPGVN Ban Giaùo Duïc Taêng Ni, 1992. 120) Nguoàn Soáng An Laïc, Thích Töø Giang & Thích Phong Hoäi, NXB Toân Giaùo Haø Noäi, VN, 2001. 121) Nhöõng Vò Thieàn Sö Ñöông Thôøi, Jack Kornfield, dòch giaû Tyø Kheo Minh Thieän, NXB TPHCM, 1999. 122) Nieäm Phaät Thaäp Yeáu, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thieàn Taâm, 1950. 123) The Nine Essential Factors Which Strengthen The Indriya Of A Vipassana Meditating Yogi, Ven. Sayadaw U Kundalabhivamsa, Singapore, 1994. 124) Nirvana In A Nutshell, Scott Shaw, New York, 2002. 125) Nôi AÁy Cuõng Laø Baây Giôø Vaø ÔÛ Ñaây, Jon Kabat-Zinn, dòch giaû Nguyeãn Duy Nhieân, NY, U.S.A., 1996. 126) An Open Heart, The Dalai Lama XIV, 2012. 127) Open Heart, Clear Mind, Thubten Chodron, 1990. 128) Opening The Hand Of Thought, Kosho Uchiyama, U.S.A., 2004. 129) Original Teachings Of Ch'an Buddhism: Selected from Transmission Of The Lamp, Chang Chung Yuan, 1969. 130) OÁc Ñaûo Töï Thaân, Ayya Khema, dòch giaû Dieäu Ñaïo, U.S.A., 2002. 131) Pagodas, Gods and Spirits of Vietnam, Ann Helen Unger & Walter Unger, NY, U.S.A., 1997. 132) Phaùp Baûo Ñaøn Kinh, Cö Só Toâ Queá, 1946. 133) Phaùp Baûo Ñaøn Kinh, Mai Haïnh Ñöùc, 1956. 134) Phaùp Baûo Ñaøn Kinh, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Maõn Giaùc, 1985. 135) Phaùp Baûo Ñaøn Kinh, Hoøa Thöôïng Minh Tröïc, 1944. 136) Phaùp Baûo Ñaøn Kinh, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thanh Töø, 1992. 137) Phaùp Böûu Ñaøn Kinh, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Töø Quang, 1942. 138) Phaùp Haønh Thieàn Tueä, Tyø Kheo Hoä Phaùp, NXB Toân Giaùo, 2000. 139) Phaùp Moân Toïa Thieàn, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Giaùc Nhieân, 1960. 140) Phaät Daïy Luyeän Taâm Nhö Chaên Traâu, Taâm Minh Ngoâ Taèng Giao, NXB Phöông Ñoâng, VN, 2010. 141) Phaät Giaùo Thieàn Toâng, Muso, dòch giaû Huyønh Kim Quang, 1996. 142) Phaät Phaùp Caên Baûn (Vieät-Anh)—Basic Buddhist Doctrines, 08 volumes, Thieän Phuùc, USA, 2009. 143) Pheùp Laï Cuûa Söï Tænh Thöùc, Zen Master Thích Nhaát Haïnh, 1975. 144) Phöông Phaùp Toïa Thieàn, Thích Thanh Töø, NXB TPHCM, 2004. 145) Poems of the T'ang Dynasty Robert Payne, NY, U.S.A., 1947. 146) Pointing The Way, Bhagwan shree Rajneesh, India, 2006. 147) The Practice of Tranquility and Insight, Khenchen Thrangu, New York, 1993. 148) The Practice of Zen, Chang Chen Chi, London, UK, 1959. 149) Practicing The Dhamma With A View To Nibbana, Radhika Abeysekera, Sri Lanka, 2008.

150) Present Moment Wonderful Moment, Thich Nhat Hanh, 1990. 151) Pure Land Zen-Zen Pure Land, Letters From Patriarch Yin Kuang, translated by Master Thich Thien Tam, 1993. 152) The Pursuit Of Happiness, David Pond, Woodbury, MN, 2008. 153) Quy Sôn Caûnh Saùch, Quy Sôn Linh Höïu, dòch giaû Nguyeãn Minh Tieán, NXB Toân Giaùo, 2008. 154) Quy Sôn Ngöõ Luïc, dòch giaû Döông Thanh Khaûi, Vinhlong, VN, 2012. 155) The Requisites Of Enlightenment, Ven. Ledi Sayadaw, Sri Lanka, 1971. 156) Roar of the Tigress, Western Woman Zen Master Jiyu Kenneth, Mt. Shasta, CA, U.S.A., 2000. 157) Sayings Of Buddha, The Peter Pauper Press, New York, U.S.A., 1957. 158) The Shambhala Dictionary Of Buddhism & Zen, Ingrid Fischer-Schreiber & Michael Diener, translated by Michael H. Kohn, Boston, U.S.A., 1991. 159) Shobogenzo: book 1, book 2, book 3, and book 4, Zen Master Dogen, translated into English by Gudo Nishijima & Chodo Cross, London, UK, 1994. 160) A Short History Of Buddhism, Edward Conze, London, UK, 1980. 161) Sixth Patriarch’s Sutra, Tripitaka Master Hua, 1971. 162) Soi Göông Ngöõ Haïnh Thieàn Moân, Thích Quaûng Hieån, NXB Toân Giaùo Haø Noäi, VN, 2006. 163) Soáng Thieàn, Eugen Herrigel, Vieät dòch Thích Nöõ Trí Haûi, VN, 1989. 164) A Still Forest Pool, Achaan Chah, compiled and edited by Jack Kornfield & Paul Breiter, Wheaton, Illinois, U.S.A., 1985. 165) Studies in Ch’an and Hua-Yen, Robert M. Gimello and Peter N. Gregory, Honolulu, 1983. 166) Studies in The Lankavatara Sutra, Daisetz Teitaro Suzuki, London, 1930. 167) The Supreme Science Of The Buddha, Egerton C. Baptist, San Diego, CA, U.S.A., 1955. 168) Suramgama Sutra, Minh Taâm Leâ Ñình Thaùm: 1961. 169) Söû 33 Vò Toå Thieàn Toâng AÁn-Hoa, Thích Thanh Töø, NXB Toân Giaùo, VN, 2010. 170) Söï Thöïc Haønh Veà Thieàn Chæ Vaø Thieàn Quaùn, Khenchen Thrangu, dòch giaû Nguyeân Höông, 2004. 171) Taùc Duïng Cuûa Thieàn Ñoái Vôùi Ñôøi Soáng Con Ngöôøi, Thoâng Trieät, U.S.A., 2000. 172) Tam Giaùo Vieät Nam Tieàn Ñeà Tö Töôûng Môû Ñaïo Cao Ñaøi, Hueä Khaûi, NXB Tam Giaùo Ñoàng Nguyeân, CA, USA, 2010. 173) Taming The Monkey Mind, Thubten Chodron, Singapore, 1990. 174) Tao Te Ching, Lao-tsu, Random House, NY, U.S.A., 1972. 175) Taâm Baát Sinh, Zen master Bankei, dòch giaû Thích Nöõ Trí Haûi, Hoa Dam Publisher 2005. 176) Taâm Vaø Ta, Thích Trí Sieâu, NXB Ñoâng Phöông 2010. 177) Teachings From The Silent Mind, Ajahn Sumedho, Hertfordshire, UK, 1984. 178) Temple Dusk, Mitsu Suzuki, translated into English by Kazuaki Tanahashi & Gregory A. Wood, Berkeley, CA, U.S.A., 1992. 179) That Which You Are Seeking Is Causing You To Seek, Cheri Huber, 1990. 180) Thieân Truùc Tieåu Du Kyù, Thieän Phuùc, USA, 2006. 181) Thieàn Caên Baûn, Trí Giaû Ñaïi Sö, Trí Giaû Ñaïi Sö, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thanh Töø dòch, Dalat, VN, 1981. 182) Thieàn Döôùi AÙnh Saùng Khoa Hoïc, Thích Thoâng Trieät, Perris, CA, U.S.A., 2010. 183) Thieàn Ñaïo Tu Taäp, Chang Chen Chi, Vieät dòch Nhö Haïnh, North Hills, CA, U.S.A., 1998. 184) Thieàn Ñònh Thöïc Haønh, Thuaàn Taâm, Nhaø Saùch Leâ Lai, Saigon, VN, 1970. 185) Thieàn Ñoán Ngoä, Thích Thanh Töø, Tu Vieän Chôn Khoâng, VN, 1974. 186) Thieàn & Giaûi Thoaùt, H.T. Tinh Vaân, dòch giaû Thuaän Huøng, NXB Thôøi Ñaïi, 2010. 187) Thieàn Laø Gì?, Thích Thoâng Hueä, U.S.A., 2001. 188) Thieàn Laâm Baûo Huaán, Dieäu Hyû & Truùc Am, dòch giaû Thích Thanh Kieåm, NXB Toân Giaùo, 2001. 189) Thieàn Luaän, 3 vols, D.T. Suzuki, dòch giaû Truùc Thieân, 1926. 190) Thieàn Phaùi Laâm Teá Chuùc Thaùnh, Thích Nhö Tònh, Illinois, U.S.A., 2006. 191) Thieàn Quaùn: Tieáng Chuoâng Vöôït Thôøi Gian, Sayagyi U Ba Khin, dòch giaû Tyø Kheo Thieän Minh, NXB TPHCM, 2002. 192) Thieàn Sö, Thieän Phuùc, USA, 2007. 193) Thieàn Sö Trung Hoa, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thanh Töø: 1995. 194) Thieàn Sö Vieät Nam, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thanh Töø: 1972. 195) Thieàn Taøo Ñoäng Nhaät Baûn, Amazu Ryuushin, Vieät dòch Thích Nhö Ñieån, Hannover, Germany, 2008. 196) Thieàn Taâm Töø, Sharon Salzberg, dòch giaû Tyø Kheo Thieän Minh Traàn Vaên Huaân, NXB Toân Giaùo, 2002. 197) Thieàn Thö Taây Taïng, Lama Christie McNally, Vieät dòch Ñaïi Khaû Hueä, NXB Phöông Ñoâng, 2010. 198) Thieàn Toâng Tröïc Chæ, Thieàn sö Thieân Cô, dòch giaû Thích Thanh Töø, 2002. 199) Thieàn Toâng Vieät Nam Cuoái Theá Kyû 20, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thanh Töø, 1991. 200) Thieàn Töù Nieäm Xöù Minh Saùt Tueä, H.T. Giôùi Nghieâm, NXB Toân Giaùo 2009. 201) Thieàn Uyeån Taäp Anh, Leâ Maïnh Thaùt, NXB TPHCM, 1999. 202) Thuû Laêng Nghieâm Kinh, Hoøa Thöôïng Bích Lieân, Hoøa Thöôïng Nhö Phöôùc, Hoøa Thöôïng Töø Quang, 1957. 203) Thuû Laêng Nghieâm Kinh, Taâm Minh Leâ Ñình Thaùm, 1961. 204) Thuû Laêng Nghieâm Kinh, Trí Ñoä vaø Tueä Quang, 1964. 205) Thuaàn Hoùa Taâm Hoàn, Ven. Thubten Chodron, dòch giaû Thích Minh Thaønh, NXB Toång Hôïp TPHCM, 2003. 206) The Three Pillars of Zen, Roshi Philip Kapleau, 1912.

207) Thuaät Ngöõ Duy Thöùc Hoïc, Giaûi Minh, NXB Phöông Ñoâng, 2011. 208) To Be Seen Here And Now, Ayya Khema, Sri Lanka, 1987. 209) Three Hundred Sixty-Five Zen Daily Readings, Jean Smith, NY, U.S.A., 1999. 210) Three Pilars Of Zen, Roshi Philip Kapleau, U.S.A., 1962. 211) Three Principal Aspects Of The Path, The Dalai Lama XIV, 1992. 212) Three Zen Masters, John Steven, Kodansha America, Inc., NY, U.S.A., 1993. 213) The Tibetan Book Of Meditation, Lama Christie McNally, NY, U.S.A., 2009. 214) Toå Sö Boà Ñeà Ñaït Ma, H.T. Tuyeân Hoùa, Burlingame, CA, U.S.A., 1983. 215) Traùi Tim Thieàn Taäp, Sharon Salzberg, dòch giaû Nguyeãn Duy Nhieân, NXB Vaên Hoùa Thoâng Tin, 2008. 216) The Training of the Zen Buddhist Monk, Daisetz Teitaro Suzuki, Tokyo, Japan, 1934. 217) Transforming The Mind, His Holiness The Dalai Lama, London, 2000. 218) Trung A Haøm Kinh, Vieän Nghieân Cöùu Phaät Hoïc Vieät Nam: 1992. 219) Trung Boä Kinh, Vieän Nghieân Cöùu Phaät Hoïc Vieät Nam: 1992. 220) Tröôøng A Haøm Kinh, Vieän Nghieân Cöùu Phaät Hoïc Vieät Nam: 1991. 221) Tröôøng Boä Kinh, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Minh Chaâu: 1991. 222) Tröôøng Boä Kinh, Vieän Nghieân Cöùu Phaät Hoïc Vieät Nam: 1991. 223) Tu Taäp Chæ Quaùn Toïa Thieàn Phaùp Yeáu, Thieân Thai trí Giaû Ñaïi Sö, Vieät dòch Thích Giaûi Naêng, NXB Toân Giaùo, 2005. 224) Tueä Trung Thöôïng Só Ngöõ Luïc, Thích Thanh Töø, Thieàn Vieän Thöôøng Chieáu, VN, 1996. 225) Tuyeát Giöõa Muøa Heø, Sayadaw U Jotika, dòch giaû Tyø Kheo Taâm Phaùp, Riverside, CA, U.S.A., 2012. 226) Töông Öng Boä Kinh, Vieän Nghieân Cöùu Phaät Hoïc Vieät Nam: 1993. 227) Töø Ñieån Phaät Hoïc Anh-Vieät—English-Vietnamese Buddhist Dictionary, 10 volumes, Thieän Phuùc, USA, 2007. 228) Töø Ñieån Phaät Hoïc Vieät-Anh—Vietnamese-English Buddhist Dictionary, 6 volumes, Thieän Phuùc, USA, 2005. 229) Töø Ñieån Thieàn Toâng Haùn Ngöõ, Hoà Baéc Nhaân Daân Xuaát Baûn Xaõ, Trung Quoác, 1994. 230) Töø Ñieån Thieàn Toâng Haùn Vieät, Haân Maãn & Thoâng Thieàn, NXB TPHCM, 2002. 231) Töø Ñieån Thuaät Ngöõ Thieàn Toâng, Thoâng Thieàn, NXB Toång Hôïp TPHCM, 2008. 232) The Unborn, Bankei Yotaku, translated by Norman Waddell, NY, U.S.A., 1984. 233) Understanding The Heart, Thich Minh Niem, U.S.A., Authorhouse published in 2012. 234) Vaøi Chuù Giaûi Veà Thieàn Ñoán Ngoä, Nguyeân Giaùc Phan Taán Haûi, CA, U.S.A., 1990. 235) Vaøo Coång Nhaø Thieàn, Thích Thanh Töø, Ñaø Laït, VN, 1980. 236) Kinh Vieân Giaùc, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thieän Hoa, Saigon 1958. 237) The Vimalakirti Nirdesa Sutra, Charles Luk, 1972. 238) Vipassana Meditation, Sayadaw U Janakabhivamsa, Yangon, Myanmar, 1985. 239) Voâ Moân Quan, Thieàn Sö Voâ Moân Hueä Khai, dòch giaû Traàn Tuaán Maãn, VN, 1995. 240) Voâ Ngaõ Voâ Öu, Ayya Khema, translated by Dieäu Ñaïo, U.S.A., 2000. 241) Walking with the Buddha, India Dept. of Tourism, New Delhi, 2004. 242) What Is Buddhism?, Frank Tullius, 2001. 243) What Is Zen?, Alan Watts, Novato, CA, U.S.A., 1973. 244) When the Iron Eagle Flies, Ayya Khema, NY, U.S.A., 1991. 245) Wherever You Go, There You Are, Jon Kabat Zinn, NY, U.S.A., 1994. 246) Zen Antics, Thomas Cleary, Boston, MA, U.S.A., 1949. 247) Zen Art For Meditation, Stewart W. Holmes & Chimyo Horioka, Tokyo, 1973. 248) Zen Buddhism and Psychoanalysis, D.T. Suzuki and Richard De Martino, 1960. 249) Zen’s Chinese Heritage, Andy Ferguson: 2000. 250) Zen Dictionary, Ernest Wood, NY, U.S.A., 1957. 251) The Zen Doctrine of No Mind, D.T. Suzuki, 1949. 252) Zen In The Art Of Archery, Eugen Herrigel, 1953. 253) Zen And The Art Of Making A Living, Laurence G. Boldt, Auckland, New Zealand, 1992. 254) The Zen Art Book: The Art of Enlightenment, Stephen Addiss & John Daido Loori, Shambhala, Boston, MA, U.S.A., 2007. 255) Zen Buddhism, The Peter Pauper Press, NY, U.S.A., 1959. 256) Zen Dictionary, Ernest Wood, NY, U.S.A., 1957. 257) Zen and Japanese Culture, Daisetz Teitaro Suzuki, Bollingen Foundation Inc., NY, U.S.A., 1959. 258) Zen In The Light Of Science, Thích Thoâng Trieät, Perris, CA, U.S.A., 2010. 259) Zen Mind, Beginner's Mind, Shunryu Suzuki, Tokyo, Japan, 1970. 260) Zen Philosophy, Zen Practice, Hoøa Thöôïng Thích Thieân AÂn, 1975. 261) Zen In Plain English, Stephan Schuhmacher, New York, NY, U.S.A., 1988. 262) The Zen & Pure Land Meditation, Thich Huyen Dung, Chatsworth, CA, U.S.A., 2006. 263) The Zen Teaching of Bodhidharma, translated by Red Pine 1987. 264) Zen: Tradition and Transition, Kenneth Kraft, Gorve Press, NY, U.S.A., 1988.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Volume One: Vieät-Anh töø A ñeán B—Vietnamese-English from A to B

Volume Two: Vieät-Anh Maãu Töï C—Vietnamese-English Letter C

Volume Three: Vieät-Anh töø D ñeán G—Vietnamese-English from D to G

Volume Four: Vieät-Anh töø H ñeán K—Vietnamese-English from H to K

Volume Five: Vieät-Anh töø L ñeán M—Vietnamese-English from L to M

Volume Six: Vieät-Anh töø N ñeán P—Vietnamese-English from N to P

Volume Seven: Vieät-Anh töø Q ñeán T—Vietnamese-English from Q to T

Volume Eight: Vieät-Anh töø TH ñeán TO—Vietnamese-English from TH to TO

Volume Nine: Vieät-Anh töø TR ñeán Y—Vietnamese-English from TR to Y

Volume Ten: Anh-Vieät töø A ñeán I—English-Vietnamese from A to I

Volume Eleven: Anh-Vieät töø J ñeán R—English-Vietnamese from J to R

Volume Twelve: Anh-Vieät töø S ñeán Z—English-Vietnamese from S to Z

About The Author Thieän Phuùc Traàn Ngoïc was born in 1949 in Vónh Long Province, a small town about 136 kilometers southwest of Saigon. AKA Ngoïc-Em Traàn. He was born to a very poor family; however, his parents had tried their best to raise their all children with a minimum of high school education. He obtained his Bachelor in English in 1973, and Bachelor in Vietnamese-Chinese in 1974 at Cantho University. He was brought up in a Buddhist-tradition family. His grandparents and parents were devoted lay disciples of Honarable Venerable Master Minh Ñaêng Quang. He came to the United States in 1985 and became a disciple of Most Venerable Thích Giaùc Nhieân in the same year. He has been working for California State Department of Rehabilitation as a Rehabilitation Supervisor since 1988. His main responsibility is to supervise a unit of ten counselors who counsel people with problems, especially people with disabilities. He was very much impressed by the life and teachings of the Buddha. He realizes that Buddhism has been an important part of the cultural heritage, not only of Vietnam, but also of Southeast Asian countries and most parts of Asia. While working as a volunteer teacher of Vietnamese language programs in Southern California, around 1985 and 1986, a lot of young Vietnamese students came to him to ask for the meanings of some Zen and Buddhist terms. Some terms he was able to provide the meaning, but a lot of them he could not. He talked to Most Venerable Thích Giaùc Nhieân and was encouraged by the Most Venerable to start his work on The Basic Buddhist Terms, which later turned out to be a set of dictionary of six volumes. With the encouragement from Most Venerable Thích Giaùc Nhieân, he continued to composed a Dictionary of Zen and Buddhist Terms in 1986 and completed the first draft in 2014. He is also the author of a series of books written in Vietnamese and English, titled "English-Vietnamese Buddhist Dictionary," 10 volumes, "Basic Buddhist Doctrines," 8 volumes, "The Sorrowless Flowers," 3 volumes, "Zen in Life," one volume, “Buddhism in Life,” ten volumes, “Buddhism, a religion of Peace, Joy, and Mindfulness,” and “Intimate Sharings with Parents and Children.” Books will be published in a near future: 1) Zen in Buddhism, 2) Famous Zen Virtues in Vietnamese and English.

Ca Ca Na: Gagana (skt)—Baàu trôøi hay khoâng trung—The firmament—Space. C                                                              Ca Chaù: Kaca (skt)—Pha leâ—Crystal—Glass. Ca Chieân Dieân: See Ca Chieân Dieân Töû. Ca: 1) Anh trai: Elder brother; 2) Baûn nhaïc: A               Ca Chieân Dieân Töû: Katyayana, Katyayaniputra song; 3) Ca haùt: To sing.                                     or Mahakatyayana, or Mahakatyayaniputra (skt). Ca Boá Ñöùc Ca: Kapotaka (skt)—Chim boà caâu—A                 1) Vaên Söùc Toân Giaû: Moät trong möôøi ñaïi ñeä töû dove—Pigeon.                                                         cuûa Ñöùc Phaät—One of the ten noted disciples Ca Boá Ñöùc Ca Giaø Lam: Kapotaka-samgharama                         of Sakyamuni. (skt)—Teân cuûa moät töï vieän noåi tieáng trong vuøng         2) Boä Luaän Vi Dieäu Phaùp ñöôïc ngöôøi ta gaùn cho Kashmir, phía nam xöù Ma Kieät Ñaø, trung AÁn Ñoä.                   oâng laø taùc giaû, kyø thaät boä luaän naày ñöôïc vieát Chuøa Ca Boá Ñöùc Ca (thôøi nhaø Ñöôøng goïi laø chuøa               bôûi moät ngöôøi cuøng teân, nhöng sanh sau oâng chim Boà Caâu). Chuøa ñöôïc mang teân naày laø vì                    töø 300 ñeán 500 naêm—The foundation work of trong moät thôøi xa xöa, Ñöùc Phaät töøng thuyeát phaùp              the Abhidharma philosophy (Abhidharma- cho ñaïi chuùng trong moät khu röøng. Khi Ñöùc Phaät                 jnana-prasthana-sastra) has been attributed to ñang thuyeát phaùp, coù ngöôøi thôï saên giaêng baãy baét            him, but it is by an author of the same name chim trong khu röøng, nhöng suoát ngaøy chaúng ñöôïc                 300 to 500 years later. con naøo. Anh ta beøn tôùi choã Phaät, noùi to raèng:          Ca Chieân Laân Ñaø: Kacilindika (skt)— “Hoâm nay Nhö Lai thuyeát phaùp ôû ñaây, laøm toâi             Kacalindikaka (skt)—Ca Giaø Laân Ñòa Ñieåu—See khoâng baãy ñöôïc con chim naøo, vôï con toâi ñeán cheá t      Ca Giaø Laân Ñòa. ñoùi maát.” Phaät baûo anh ta haõy ñoát löûa leân roài Ngaøi   Ca Da: Kaya (skt)—Thaân—Body—Assemblage. seõ ban cho thöïc phaåm. Khi aáy Ñöùc Phaät lieàn thò          Ca Di: Kasi (p & skt)—Old name of Benares— hieän laøm thaân chim boà caâu roài lao mình vaøo löûa ñeå     Moät ñòa danh veà phía baéc cuûa Kosala, mang ñòa laøm thöïc phaåm cho ngöôøi thôï saên vaø vôï con anh ta.      danh nhö vaäy vì coù nhieàu loaïi truùc toát ñöôïc duøng Laàn sau anh laïi ñeán choã Ñöùc Phaät ñang thuyeát            laøm teân—A place said to be so called because its phaùp, ñöùng nghe Phaät giaûng vaø thaáy hoái haän, töø ñoù    bamboos were good for arrows, north of Kosala— phaùt taâm xuaát gia tu haønh giaùc ngoä—Name of a             See Benares. famous monastery said to be in Kashmir, south of               Ca Di Ni: Kamini (skt)—Teân cuûa moät trong thaäp Magadha, central India. A monastery of the                     nguõ quyû thöôøng naõo loaïn treû con—Name of one of Sarvastivadah school, so called because the                    fifty departed spirits (devils) who always disturb Buddha in a previous incarnation is said to have               children. changed himself into a pigeon and to have thrown               Ca Dieáp: Kasyapa (skt)—Ca Nhieáp—Ca Dieáp himself into the fire in order to provide food for a           Ba—Ca Nhieáp Ba—Theo Eitel trong Trung Anh hunter who was prevented from catching game                    Phaät Hoïc Töø Ñieån, Ma Ha Ca Dieáp laø moät vò Baø because of Buddha’s teaching. When the hunter                  La Moân cuûa xöù Ma Kieät Ñaø, trôû thaønh moät trong learned of Buddha’s power, he repented and                     nhöõng ñaïi ñeä töû cuûa Phaät Thích Ca. Sau khi Phaät asked the Buddha to allow him to join the order.               nhaäp dieät, oâng ñaõ trôû thaønh tröôûng chuù ng Tyø Kheo, He later attained enlightenment.                               vaø trieäu taäp vaø chuû trì hoäi nghò kieát taäp kinh ñieån Ca Ca: Kaka or Kakala (skt)—Ca Ca Ca—Ca Ca                     ñaàu tieân, chöùc vò thöôïng toïa cuûa oâng coù töø ñaáy — La—Con quaï—A crow.                                            According to Eitel in The Dictionary of Chinese- Ca Ca Baø CaTaàn Ñoà La: Kapinjala (skt)—Moät                  English Buddhist terms, Mahakasyapa, a brahman loaïi chim tró—A patridge or pheasant.                         of Magadha, who became one of the principal Ca Ca Ca: Kaka (skt)—See Ca Ca.                                disciples of sakyamuni, and after his death Ca Ca La: Kakala (skt)—See Ca Ca.                              became leader of the disciples, convoked and Ca Ca La Truøng: Kakala (skt)—Moät loaïi saâu ñen              presided (directed) the first synod,whence his title (loaøi saâu caén cheát saâu meï)—A black insect or             chairman (Arya-Sthavira) is derived. worm.                                                          Ca Dieáp Di: Kasyapiya (skt)—Ca Dieáp Duy—Ca Dieáp Tyø—Ca Dieáp Ba—Sau khi Ñöùc Phaät nhaäp

dieät, tröôøng phaùi Tieåu Thöøa Nguyeân Thuûy ñöôïc           the flagpole in the front yard—See Ca Dieáp Saùt chia laøm naêm nhaùnh, tröôøng phaùi Ca Dieáp Di laø           Can. moät, giaùo thuyeát caên baûn döïa vaøo boä Luaän Ca           Ca Dieáp Ma Ñaèng: Kassapa-Matanga (p)— Dieáp Di—A school formed on a division of the                  Kasyapa-Matanga (skt)—Nhieáp Ma Ñaèng—Truùc Mahasanghikah into five schools a century after                Nhieáp Ma Ñaèng—Moät vò sö ngöôøi mieàn Trung AÁn the Nirvana. Kasyapiya was one of which teaching               Ñoä. Thôøi Haùn Minh Ñeá, vua sai moät phaùi ñoaøn based on the Kayapiya Sastra.                                  sang AÁn Ñoä caàu phaùp ñaõ gaëp sö. Sö cuøng vôùi ngaøi Ca Dieáp Di Boä: Kasyapiya (skt)—Mahakasyapiya                 Truùc Phaùp Lan mang töôïng Phaät vaø kinh ñieån veà (skt)—The Kasyapiya school—Ca Dieáp Di hay                     Laïc Döông khoaûng naêm 67 sau Taây Lòch. Theo Giaûi Thoaùt Giôùi Kinh—Ca Dieáp Duy—Ca Dieáp                  truyeàn thoáng hoaèng hoùa, ñaây laø vò Taêng AÁn Ñoä Tyø—Ca Dieáp Ba—Kha Thi Bi Döõ—AÁm Quang                       ñaàu tieân cuøng vôùi Gobharana ñeán Trung quoác. Taïi Boä—Sau khi Ñöùc Phaät nhaäp dieät, tröôøng phaùi Tieåu        ñaây hoï ñaõ cuøng dòch boä kinh Töù Thaäp Nhò Chöông Thöøa Nguyeân Thuûy ñöôïc chia laøm naêm nhaùnh,               vaøo khoaûng naêm 67 sau Taây Lòch—The monk who tröôøng phaùi Ca Dieáp Di laø moät, giaùo thuyeát caên         with Gobharana, of Central India, or baûn döïa vaøo boä Luaän Ca Dieáp Di. Boä phaùi naày           Dharmaraksa, i.e. Chu-Fa-Lan, according to khaùc vôùi Nhaát Thieát Höõu Boä vaø Phaùp Taïng Boä ñoâi      Buddhist statements, brought images and chuùt nhöng raát gaàn vôùi Thöôïng Toïa Boä, neân coøn         scriptures to China with the commissioners sent by ñöôïc goïi laø Sthavariya. AÁm Quang Boä tin raèng quaù        Ming-Ti, arriving in Lo-Yang in around 67 A.D. khöù ñaõ sinh quaû thì khoâng coøn toàn taïi nöõa, coøn quaù   According to tradition the first official Indian khöù chöa sinh quaû thì tieáp tuïc toàn taïi; do ñoù, hoï      monk, along with Gobharana, to arrive in China laøm rung chuyeån phaàn naøo ñòa vò cuûa phaùi Höõu Boä        around 67 A.D. They translated the Sutra of the voán cho raèng quaù khöù cuõng toàn taïi nhö hieän taïi        Forty-Two Sections. vaäy. Ñoâi khi AÁm Quang Boä ñöôïc xem nhö laø                 Ca Dieáp Nhö Lai: Kasyapa-buddha (skt)— tröôøng phaùi thoûa hieäp giöõa Höõu Boä (Sarvastivadin)       Kassapa-buddha (p)—Phaät Ca Dieáp laø vò Phaät thöù vaø Phaân Tích Boä (Vibhajyavadin). Phaùi naày cuõng           ba trong naêm vò Phaät hieàn kieáp, laø vò Phaät thöù saùu ñoøi coù boä Tam Taïng cuûa rieâng hoï—A school                trong baûy vò Phaät thôøi coå. Ñeå cho phuø hôïp vôùi formed on a division of the Mahasanghikah into                 quan ñieåm Thieàn 'giaùo ngoaïi bieät truyeàn', caùc söû five schools a century after the Nirvana.                      gia Thieàn ñaõ keùo daøi cuoäc truyeàn thöøa tröôùc caû Kasyapiya was one of which teaching based on                   thôøi ñöùc Phaät Thích Ca; vì theo truyeàn thuyeát löu the Kayapiya Sastra. The Mahakasyapiyas                        haønh trong soá nhöõng Phaät töû ngay töø luùc ban sô thì differed on minor poits from the Sarvastivadins                ñaõ coù ít nhaát saùu vò coå Phaät tröôùc thôøi ñöùc Phaät and the Dharmaguptikas, and were closer to the                 Thích Ca Maâu Ni cuûa hieän kieáp; vaø moãi vò ñeàu coù Sthaviravadins. Hence, they are also called the                löu laïi moät baøi keä phoù phaùp. Sau ñaây laø baøi keä cuûa Sthavariyas. The Mahakasyapiyas believed that                  ñöùc Phaät Ca Dieáp: the past which has borne fruit ceases to exist, but                  "Taùnh cuûa chuùng sanh toaøn thanh tònh that which has not yet ripened continues to exist,                    Xöa ñaõ khoâng sanh nay chaúng dieät thus partially modifying the position of the                          Chæ thaân taâm naøy môùi huyeãn sanh Sarvastivadins, for whom the past also exists like                    Trong huyeãn hoùa vaãn khoâng toäi phöôùc." the present. The Mahakasyapiyas are sometimes                  Kasyapa Buddha, the third of the five Buddhas of represented as having effected a compromise                    the present kalpa, the sixth of the seven ancient between         the      Sarvastivadins       and       the    Buddhas. To be consistent with the view that Zen Vibhajyavadins, and also claim a tripitaka of their            was a 'special transmission from the Buddha own.                                                           outside of his doctrinal teaching', Zen historians Ca Dieáp Duy Boä: Ca Dieáp Tyø—See Ca Dieáp Di                 have extended this transmission even beyond Boä.                                                           Sakyamuni; for, according to tradition prevalent Ca Dieáp Ñaûo Khöôùc Saùt Can: Ca Dieáp xoâ ngaõ               already among primitive Buddhas, there were at caây coät côø tröôùc saân—Mahakasyapa pushes down              least six Buddhas prior to the Buddha of the present kalpa who was the Muni of the Sakya; and

these several Buddhas had each to leave a gatha               ñoà chuùng cuûa hoï. Sau baøi thuyeát giaûng veà “Löûa” of 'Dharma transmission'. The following is the                cuûa Ñöùc Phaät, nhöõng vò taân Tyø Kheo naøy ñeàu ñaéc gatha from Kasyapa Buddha:                                    quaû A La Haùn—All three are said to be disciples "Pure and immaculate is the nature of all                 of the Buddha (Uruvilva Kasyapa, Gaya Kasyapa, sentient beings;                                         and Nadi Kasyapa). However, before becoming From the very beginning there is no birth,               Buddhist followers they were ascetic fire no death;                                                worshippers, each of them lived separately with a This body, this mind, a phantom creation it is;         great assembly. According to the Buddhist And in phantom transformation;                           tradition, the Buddha first tamed the eldest There are neither sins nor merits."                      brother, Uruvella Kasyapa, in his fire chamber, Ca Dieáp Phaät: Kassapa-buddha (p)—See Ca                     and then his brothers, following his example, Dieáp Nhö Lai.                                                asked the Buddha for ordination together with Ca Dieáp Saùt Can: Caây coät côø cuûa Ca Dieáp, thí duï       their followers. After the Buddha’s expounding on thöù 22 cuûa Voâ Moân Quan. Moät hoâm ngaøi A Nan             the “Discourse on Fire,” all of the newly ordained hoûi ngaøi Ca Dieáp: "Ngoaøi boä y vaøng, Theá Toân coøn      monks attained Arahantship. truyeàn gì cho ngaøi nöõa?" Ca Dieáp goïi: "A Nan!" A         Ca Dieáp Tyø: Ca Dieáp Duy—See Ca Dieáp Di Boä. Nan traû lôøi: "Daï." Ca Dieáp noùi: "Haõy laät ngöôïc        Ca      Dieáp    Tyø    Boä:     Kasyapiya      (skt)— caây coät côø ngoaøi cöûa." Theo Voâ Moân Hueä Khai           Mahakasyapiya (skt)—The Kasyapiya school—Ca trong Voâ Moân Quan, neáu ôû ñaây maø haï ñöôïc moät          Dieáp Di hay Giaûi Thoaùt Giôùi Kinh—Ca Dieáp caâu chuyeån ngöõ cho xaùc thieát thì thaáy ñöôïc phaùp       Duy—Ca Dieáp Tyø—See Ca Dieáp Di Boä. hoäi Linh Sôn nhö ñang coøn tieáp dieãn. Coøn neáu nhö        Ca Ña Dieãn Ni Töû: Katyayiniputra (skt)— chöa, thì quaû laø Phaät Tyø Baø Thi ñaõ sôùm lo toan,        Katyayana          or       Mahakatyayana,           or maõi ñeán giôø vaãn chöa xong—Mahakasyapa's                   Mahakatyayaniputra (skt)—Ca Chieân Dieân—See Flagpole, example 22 of the Wu-Men-Kuan. One                  Ca Chieân Dieân Töû. day, Ananda asked Mahakasyapa, "The World                     Ca Ñaïi: See Skandha. Honored One transmitted the robe of gold brocade              Ca Ñaøm Ba: Kadamba (skt)—Moät loaïi caây coù hoa to you. What else did he transmit to you?"                    thôm—A tree or plant with fragrant flowers. Mahakasyapa said, "Ananda!" Ananda answered,                  Ca Ñaïo: Thi ca coå ñieån cuûa Nhaät Baûn—Japanese "Yes!" Mahakasyapa said, "Knock down the                      classical poetry and songs. flagpole at the gate." According to Wu Men Hui-               Ca Giaø Laân Ñòa: Kacalindikaka or Kacilindika Kai in the Wu-Men-Kuan, if you can give a                     (skt)—Ca Laân Ñaø—Ca Laân Ñeà—Ca Chæ Laät Na— turning word that is intimate to this case, then you          Ca Giaø Laân Ñeå Ca—Moät loaøi chim maø loâng cuûa will see that the Meeting at Mount Grdhrakuta is              noù duøng ñeå ñan aùo—A sea bird, from whose still vigorously in session. If you cannot, then              feathers robes are made. Vipasyin Buddha, who has been striving from                   Ca Giaø Laân Ñòa Ñieåu: Kacalindikaka or earliest times, has not yet attained true subtlety.           Kacilindika (skt)—See Ca Giaø Laân Ñòa. Ca Dieáp Tam Huynh Ñeä: Three brothers of the                 Ca Giaø Maït Ni: Kacamani (skt)—Ca Thaùc Maït Kasyapa—Ba anh em Ca Dieáp—Ngöôøi ta noùi caû                 Ni—Teân moïi loaøi ngoïc löu ly—Crystal—Quartz. ba anh em ñeàu laø ñeä töû cuûa Phaät (Öu laâu taàn loa       Ca Hy Na: Kathina (skt)—Ca Ñeà—Yeát Hy Na. Ca Dieáp, Giaø da Ca Dieáp, vaø Na ñeà Ca Dieáp). Tuy         1) Cöùng—Khoâng uyeån chuyeån—Khoâng töông nhieân, tröôùc khi trôû thaønh ñeä töû cuûa Phaät, caû ba          nhöôïng: Hard—Inflexible—Unyielding. anh em Ca Dieáp ñeàu laø nhöõng ñaïo só khoå haïnh thôø       2) Teân cuûa moät loaïi aùo cuûa chö Taêng Ni, nhaän Thaàn Löûa, moãi vò ñeàu soáng rieâng vôùi moät hoäi               sau muøa an cö kieát haï: Name of a monk’s or chuùng lôùn. Theo truyeàn thuyeát Phaät giaùo thì tröôùc           nun’s robe, received after the summer retreat. tieân Ñöùc Phaät caûm hoaù ngöôøi anh caû laø Öu Laâu         3) Ca Hy Na Nguyeät—Thaùng ôû giöõa thaùng möôøi Taàn Loa Ca Dieáp trong ñeàn thôø thaàn löûa cuûa vò               vaø thaùng möôøi moät, sau khi xong an cö kieát naøy, sau ñoù hai ngöôì em theo göông ngöôøi anh caû,              haï, khi chö Taêng Ni nhaän aùo Ca Hy Na (Haï thænh caàu ñöôïc thoï giôùi vôùi Ñöùc Phaät moät löôït vôùi        Laïp): Kathina-masa, the month in October-

November, interpreted as the month after the               Ca La Cöu Toân Ñaø Phaät: Krakucchanda or summer retreat, when monks and nuns                        Kakuda-Katyayana (skt)—See Caâu Löu Toân Phaät. received the “kathina” robe of merit.                      Ca La Cöu Xan Ñaø: Krakucchanda or Kakuda- Ca Keä: Verses for singing—To sing verses.                      Katyayana (skt)—See Caâu Löu Toân Phaät. Ca Khuùc: Sama-veda (skt)—Samhita (skt)—Sa                      Ca La La: Kalala (skt)—Phoâi thai—An embryo— Ma—Ca Vònh Veä Ñaø—Tam Ma Bì Ñeà—Ta Ma                          The womb—An embryo shortly after conception. Veä Ñaø—The third of four books of Veda,                        Ca La Sa Daõ: Kasaya (skt)—Ca La Sa Dò—AÙo containing the hymns—Quyeån kinh thöù ba trong                  nhuoäm cuûa chö Taêng Ni, ñoái laïi vôùi aùo traéng cuûa boán quyeån kinh Veä Ñaø, goàm nhöõng baøi ca trong             Phaät töû taïi gia—A monk’s dyed robe, in contrast khi haønh leã.                                                  with white lay garb. Ca La: Kala (skt)—1) Moät phaàn cöïc nhoû: A minute part; 2) Moät nguyeân töû: An atom; 3) Moät              Ca La Sa Dò: Kasaya (skt)—See Ca La sa Daõ. phaàn traêm cuûa ñöôøng kính sôïi toùc cuûa con ngöôøi:         Ca La Sai Ma Thích: Kalaksemakasya-skysaya- The hundredth part lengthwise of a human hair; 4)               Vihara (skt)—Tònh xaù Ca La Sai Ma Thích— Moät phaàn möôøi saùu: A sixteenth part of anything;            Name of a monastery in northern India. 5) Moät khoaûng thôøi gian xaùc ñònh: A definite time,          Ca La Taàn Ca: Kalavinka (skt)—See Ca Laêng a division of time; 6) Thôøi gian laøm vieäc hay                Taàn Giaø. nghieân cöùu, ñoái laïi vôùi thôøi gian nhaøn roãi: The         Ca La Thôøi: Kala (skt)—Thöïc thôøi hay laø thôøi time of work, or study, as opposed to leisure time;             gian coá ñònh cho caùc böõa aên—Fixed hour for 7) Maøu ñen: Black; 8) Teân cuûa moät trong moät traêm          meals or regular hour for meals, one of the two vò ñoäc giaùc Phaät soáng thaät laâu treân nuùi Isigili: Kala   times or periods. (p)—Name of one of one hundred pratyeka-                        Ca La Toân Ñaïi Phaät: Krakucchanda or Kakuda- buddhas who lived a long period of time on Mount                Katyayana (skt)—See Caâu Löu Toân Phaät. Isigili.                                                        Ca La Traán Ñaàu: Kalaka and Tinduka (skt). Ca La Ca: 1) Moät loaøi haéc long (roàng ñen):                  1) Ca La: Kalaka (skt). Kaliyaka (skt)—A naga or a black dragon                         a) Traùi caây coù chaát ñoäc: A poisonous fruit. inhabiting the Yamuna (Jumna), slain by Krsna; 2)               b) Vò Taêng phaù giôùi: A bad monk. Loaïi aùo ca leâ ca coù maøu loám ñoám (deät baèng hoa          2) Traán Ñaàu: Tinduka (skt). caùt boái): Kalika (skt)—A garment of diverse                   a) Traùi caây khoâng coù chaát ñoäc: A non-poisonous colours; 3) Taùc Nhaân: Karaka (skt)—One who dos,                    fruit. or causes, or an agent.                                         b) Moät vò Taêng tinh chuyeân tu haønh: A good Ca La Cö Ñaø Ca Chieân Dieân: See Ca La Cöu Ñaø                      monk. Ca Chieân Dieân.                                                Ca La Tyù Naõ Ca: Kalapinaka (skt)—Theo Eitel Ca La Cöu Ñaø Ca Chieân Dieân: Kakuda-                          trong Trung Anh Phaät Hoïc Töø Ñieån, Ca La Tyù Naõ Katyayana (skt)—Baø Phuø Ñaø Ca Chieân Neâ—Moät                 Ca (Kalapinaka) laø thaønh phoá Ma Kieät Ñaø, khoaûng trong saùu ngöôøi laõnh ñaïo ngoaïi ñaïo, ngöôøi chuû           20 daäm ñoâng nam Kulika, phía nam cuûa thaønh phoá tröông theo vaät chaát, khoâng coù ngöôøi gieát, cuõng          Behar baây giôø—According to Eitel in The khoâng coù keû bò gieát, maø chæ coù söï chuyeån hoùa cuûa      Dictionary of Chinese-English Buddhist Terms, nhöõng yeáu toá vaät chaát maø thoâi (cho raèng phaùp vöøa      Kalapinaka was the city of Magadha, 20 miles höõu töôùng vöøa voâ töôùng. Neáu ai hoûi höõu thì ñaùp         southeast of Kulika, south of the present city voâ, maø ai hoûi voâ thì ñaùp höõu)—Kakuda-                     Behar. Katyayana, one of the six famous heretical                      Ca La Tyø Ca: Kapilavastu (skt)—See Ca Tyø La leaders, who taught a materialism in which there                Veä. was no such things as killer or killed, but only                Ca La Tyø La: Karavira (skt)—Moät loaïi truùc ñaøo transformations of elements—See Luïc Sö Ngoaïi                  coù boâng thôm—A fragrant oleander. Ñaïo.

Ca La Vieät: Kulapati (skt)—Ngöôøi ñöùng ñaàu boä              chim coù gioïng hoùt thaûnh thoùt. Ngöôøi ta noùi loaøi toäc: The head of a clan, or family—Ñaøn Vieät hay             chim naày coù theå hoùt töø trong tröùng, tröôùc khi ñöôïc cö só: Lay people.                                             nôû ra—A kind of sparrow in Indian, mentioned in Ca Lam: Kalama (p)—Moät boä toäc ôû vuøng Ñoâng                the Amitabha Sutra, described as having a Baéc AÁn Ñoä vaøo thôøi Ñöùc Phaät coøn taïi theá, theo        melodious voice, found in the valley of Himalaya. lòch söû thì boä toäc naøy laø nhöõng ngöôøi ñaõ chaáp nhaän   It is said to sing in the shell before hatching. lôøi khuyeân cuûa ñöùc Phaät veà vieäc nhöõng nhaø laõnh       Ca Laêng Taàn Giaø Ñieåu: See Ca Laêng Taàn Giaø. ñaïo taàm caàu chôn lyù trong vieäc trò quoác —A tribe         Ca Laêng Taàn Giaø Vöông: Kapinjalaraja (skt)— in north-east India in the time of the Buddha                  Tieàn thaân cuûa Ñöùc Phaät laø moät con chim tró—A known to history as the recipients of the Buddha’s             previous incarnation of Sakyamuni as a pheasant. famous advice on the subject of authority in the               Ca Laêng Tính AÂm: Teân cuûa moät vò danh Taêng search for Truth.                                              Trung Hoa vaøo thôøi nhaø Thanh (1644-1912)— Ca Lan Ñaø: Kalanda, Karanda or Karandaka                      Name of a Chinese famous monk who lived in the (skt)—1) Moät loaøi chim bay thaønh ñoaøn vaø coù              Ch'ing Dynasty in China. gioïng hoùt hay: A bird which flies in flocks and has          Ca Laät Ñeå Ca: Karttika (skt)—Thaùng ôû giöõa a pleasant note; 2) Moät loaøi soùc ñaõ ñaùnh thöùc vua        thaùng möôøi vaø thaùng möôøi moät—The month Bình Sa Vöông ñeå baùo cho ngaøi bieát veà moät con            between October and November—See Thaäp Nhò raén: A squirrel which awakened Bimbisara to                   Nguyeät. warn him against a snake.                                      Ca Laâu Ñaø Di: See Kaludayin. Ca Lan Ñaø Truùc Laâm: Karanda-Venuvana                        Ca Laâu La: Garuda (skt)—Khyung (tib)—See (skt)—See Ca Lan Ñaø-Truùc Laâm Tònh Xaù.                      Kim Xí Ñieåu. Ca Lan Ñaø Truùc Laâm Tònh Xaù: Karanda-                       Ca Laâu La Vöông: Garuda-raja (skt)—See Kim Venuvana (skt)—Ca Lan Ñaø-Truùc Laâm Tònh Xaù,                 Xí Ñieåu Vöông. thuoäc moät vò tröôûng giaû teân Ca Lan Ñaø, tröôùc ñoù        Ca Laâu Na Vöông Thaàn Chuù: Mahapurna (skt)— nhoùm Ni Kieàn Töû cö nguï, veà sau vua Bình Sa                Ñaïi Vieân Maõn Ñaø La Ni—Great perfection Vöông hieán cho Phaät Thích Ca Maâu Ni (ñaây laø               dharani. Taêng Vieän sôùm nhaát ôû AÁn Ñoä)—The Karanda-                Ca Leâ Ca: Kaliyaka (skt)—Se Ca La Ca. Venuvana, a garden belonging to an elder called                Ca Leâ Sa Xaù Ni: Karsaniya (skt)—Söï tha thöù— Karanda, used by Nirgrantha sect, then presented               Forgiveness. by King Bimbisara to Sakyamuni.                                Ca Lôïi: Kali (skt)—Ca Leâ—Caùt Lôïi—Ca Lam Ca Lan Ñaø Tröôûng Giaû: Kalanda (skt)—An elder                Phuø—Ca La Phuù—Striver—Ill-born. named Karanda who owned the Karanda-                           1) Ñaáu Traùnh AÙc Sanh: Striver—Ill-born. Venuvana—Moät vò tröôûng giaû teân Ca Lan Ñaø—                 2) Ñaáu Traùnh Vöông—AÙc Theá Voâ Ñaïo Vöông: See Ca Lan Ñaø-Truùc Laâm Tònh Xaù.                                  Kaliraja or Kalingaraja (skt)—Theo Kinh Ca Lan Ñaø Vieân: Venuvana (skt)—See Truùc Laâm                      Nieát Baøn, Ca Lôïi hay vua Ca Lam Phuø hay Tònh Xaù.                                                            Ñaáu Traùnh Vöông laø vua cuûa xöù Ma Kieät Ñaø, Ca Laêng Giaø Quoác: Kalinga (skt)—Teân cuûa moät                    noåi tieáng veà söï baïo ñoäng cuûa oâng ta. Ngöôøi ta trong nhöõng vöông quoác coå ôû AÁn Ñoä—Name of                      noùi raèng trong tieàn kieáp, oâng ñaõ töøng caét tai, one of the ancient kingdoms in India.                                xeûo muõi, hay chaët tay chaân cuûa Ñöùc Phaät— Ca Laêng Giaø Vöông: Kaliraja or Kalingaraja                         According to the Nirvana Sutra, Kaliraja was (skt)—Vua cuûa xöù Ma Kieät Ñaø, noåi tieáng veà söï                 a king of Magadha noted for his violence; it is baïo ñoäng cuûa oâng ta—King of Magadha noted for                    said that in a former incarnation he cut off the his violence.                                                        ears, nose, and hands of the Buddha, who Ca Laêng Taàn Giaø: Kalavinkas (skt)—Ca Lan                          bore it all unmoved. Giaø—Ca Lan Taàn Giaø—Yeát La Taàn Ca—Ca Laêng                   Ca Lôïi Sa: Karsa or Karsana (skt)—Moät ñôn vò Tyø Giaø—Ca Tyø Giaø La—Caùp Tyø Giaø La—Yeát Tyø              ño löôøng troïng löôïng cuûa ngöôøi AÁn, töông ñöông Giaø La—Ca Tyø Giaø—Ca Vó La—Moät loaïi chim seû               vôùi nöûa löôïng cuûa ngöôøi Trung Hoa—An Indian ôû AÁn Ñoä, ñöôïc ñeà caäp trong Kinh A Di Ñaø, loaïi

measure of weight, equivalent to half a Chinese                ancient country in India, probably part of the ounce.                                                         present Chittagong, opposite the mouth of the Ca Lôïi Sa Ba Naõ: Karsapana (skt)—Moät ñôn vò                 Ganges. tieàn teä cuûa AÁn Ñoä, töông ñöông vôùi 400 tieàn             Ca Ma Luõ Ba: Kamarupa (skt)—Theo Eitel trong vaøng—An Indian monetary unit, equivalent to 400               trung Anh Phaät Hoïc Töø Ñieån, Ca Ma Luõ Ba, baây candereens.                                                    giôø laø Kamrup, laø moät vöông quoác coå ñöôïc thaønh Ca Lôïi Vöông: Kaliraja or Kalingaraja (skt)—                  laäp bôûi moät phaàn ñaát taây boä cuûa Assam (theo Taây Vua cuûa xöù Ma Kieät Ñaø, noåi tieáng veà söï baïo ñoäng      Vöïc Kyù cuûa Huyeàn Trang, thì xöù naày roäng treân cuûa oâng ta—King of Magadha noted for his                     vaïn daäm, gioáng ngöôøi nhoû beù, noùi tieáng khaùc vôùi violence.                                                      AÁn Ñoä, thôø phuïng thieân thaàn, khoâng tin Phaät Phaùp. Ca Loâ Naõ: Karuna (skt)—Bi (thöông xoùt)—Pity—                Ñeán ñôøi nhaø Ñöôøng vaãn chöa thaáy döïng chuøa thôø Pitying.                                                       Phaät. Ngöôøi daân chæ leùn luùt nieäm Phaät. Ñeán ñôøi Ca Löu Ñaø Di: Kalodaka (skt)—Kalodayin                        vua Caâu Ma La, nghe tin Huyeàn Trang ñi ngang, (skt)—Kaludayin (skt)—Thôøi Thuûy—Vò Tyø Kheo                  beøn thænh ngaøi ñeán thuyeát phaùp)—According to da ñen boùng; ngöôøi ta noùi oâng laø thaày daïy hoïc cuûa     Eitel in The Dictionary of Chinese-English Phaät Thích Ca luùc Ngaøi coøn laø thaùi töû, veà sau naày     Buddhist Terms, Kamarupa, now Kamrup, an oâng trôû thaønh moät trong nhöõng ñeä töû ñaàu tieân cuûa     ancient kingdom formed by the western portion of Phaät—Udayin or Black Udayin, said to have been                Assam. Until the T’ang dynasty, no temples were schoolmaster to Sakyamuni when young and one                   ever built there. When King Kamala heard that of the early disciples.                                        Hsuan-Tsang crossed by the country, he invited Ca Löu Ñaø Giaø: Kalodaka (skt)—See Ca Löu Ñaø                 Hsuan-tsang to stop by to preach Buddha’s Di.                                                            teaching. Ca Löu La: Garuda (skt)—Khyung (tib)—Ca Laâu                   Ca Ma Sa Ba Ñaø: Kajmasapada (skt)—Loäc Tuùc La—See Kim Xí Ñieåu.                                           Vöông—Moät trong nhöõng vò ñaïi ñeä töû cuûa ñöùc Ca Lyù Ca: Kalika (skt)—Teân cuûa moät trong 16 vò             Phaät—One of the great disciples of the Buddha. La Haùn ñaõ vaâng lôøi Phaät daïy tieáp tuïc truï theá ñeå     Ca Ma Sa Ñaø Vöông: Kamamsapada (p)— giöõ gìn chaùnh phaùp—Name of one of the sixteen               Kalmasapada (skt)—Ca Ma Sa Ba Ñaø—See Ban arhats who obeyed the Buddha's instruction to stay             Tuùc Vöông. in the samsara to maintain correct dharma.                     Ca Na Ñeà Baø: Kanadeva (skt)—Thaùnh Thieân— Ca Ma: Kama (skt)—Tham duïc: Desire—Luyeán                     Ca Na GiaøMaâu Ni (Kanakamuni)—Ñeä töû cuûa ngaøi aùi: Love—Mong caàu: Wish—Ngaï quyû: A hungry                  Long Thoï vaø laø toå thöù 15, ngöôøi mieàn Nam AÁn, ghost.                                                         doøng doõi quyù toäc. Ngöôøi ta noùi oâng chæ coù moät maét Ca Ma Ñaø Ñoâ: Kamadhatu (skt)—Duïc Giôùi goàm                 neân mang teân “Kuna.” OÂng coøn coù teân laø Ñeà Baø theá giôùi naày vaø saùu coõi trôøi—Baát cöù theá giôùi naøo   Boà Taùt—A disciple of Nagarjuna and fifteenth maø nhöõng yeáu toá tham duïc chöa ñöôïc khaéc phuïc —         patriarch, a native of South India, of the Vaisya The realm of desire, of sensuous gratification; this           caste; said to have only one eye, hence Kana his world and the six devalokas; any world in which                name; known also as Deva-Bodhisattva. the elements of desire have not ben suppressed.                Ca Na Giaø Maâu Ni: Kanakamuni (skt)—Caâu Na Ca Ma La Thaäp La: Kamalashila (700-750)—An                    Haøm Mau Ni—Caùt Naëc Giaø Maâu Ni. Indian Buddhist master, one of the most important              1) See Ca Na Ñeà Baø. representatives of the Madhyamika school in the                2) Vò Phaät thöù hai trong naêm vò Phaä t Hieàn kieáp, 8th century—See Lieân Hoa Giôùi.                                     vò Phaät thöù naêm trong baûy vò Phaät quaù khöù: Ca Ma Laõng Ca: Kamalanka (skt)—Theo Eitel                           the second Buddha in the five Buddhas of the trong Trung Anh Phaät Hoïc Töø Ñieån, Kamalanka laø                  Bhadrakalpa, and the fifth of the seven moät vöông quoác coå beân AÁn Ñoä, coù leõ laø moät phaàn            ancient Buddhas—See Nguõ Phaät and Thaát cuûa Chittagong baây giôø, ñoái dieän vôùi cöûa soâng                Phaät. Haèng—According to The Dictionary of Chinese-                  Ca Na Maâu Ni: See Ca Na Giaø Maâu Ni. English Buddhist Terms, Kamalanka was an

Ca Naëc Ca Baït Lî Ñoïa Xaø: Kanakabharadvaja               Sindh, North West India, Kashmir, and part of (s)—Teân cuûa moät trong soá 16 vò La Haùn ñöôïc ñöùc       Madhyadesa. He became a patron of Buddhism, Phaät chæ thò cho ra nöôùc ngoaøi hoaèng phaùp—One          the greatest after Asoka and Milinda. of the sixteen Arhats that the Buddha instructed to         Ca Phaïm Ba Ñeà: Gavampati (skt)—See Kieâu go abroad to spread the dharma.                             Phaïm Ba Ñeà. Ca Naëc Ca Phaït Sa: Kanakavatsa (skt)—                     Ca Phaïm Ñaït Ma: Bhagavaddharma (skt)—Daø Kanakavata (skt)—Teân cuûa moät trong soá 16 vò La          Phaïm Ñaït Ma—See Giaø Phaïn Ñaït Ma. Haùn ñöôïc ñöùc Phaät chæ thò cho ra nöôùc ngoaøi           Ca Sa Bieán Baïch: Hình thöùc thay ñoåi cuûa aùo caø sa hoaèng phaùp—One of the sixteen Arhats that the             töø hoaïi saéc thaønh maøu traéng—The alteration form Buddha instructed to go abroad to spread the                of the monk’s robe or cassock from broken colour dharma.                                                     to white—See Caø Sa. Ca Ngaâm: To sing poems.                                    Ca Sa Traøng Nhö Lai: Kashaya Banner Thus Ca Nhaï Ca Baït Lî Hoa Xaø: See Ca Naëc Ca Baït             Come One—Theo Kinh Ñòa Taïng Boà Taùt, phaåm Lî Ñoïa Xaø.                                                thöù chín,voâ löôïng voâ soá kieáp veà thuôû quaù khöù coù Ca Nhaï Ca Phaït Ta: See Ca Naëc Ca Phaït Sa.               ñöùc Phaät ra ñôøi hieäu laø Ca Saø Traøng Nhö Lai. Nhö Ca Nhó Cö Phaùi: Kagyu (tib)—Moät trong boán                coù ngöôøi nam ngöôøi nöõ naøo nghe ñöôïc danh hieäu tröôøng phaùi chính cuûa Phaät giaùo Taây Taïng. Ba         cuûa ñöùc Phaät ñaây, thôøi ngöôøi naày seõ sieâu thoaùt toäi tröôøng phaùi khaùc laø phaùi Coå Maät (Ninh Maõ), Thích    sanh töû trong moät traêm ñaïi kieáp—According to the Ca (Ñaát Xaùm), vaø Hoaøng Maïo Giaùo—One of the            Earth Store Bodhisattva Sutra, Chapter 9, limitless four major schools of Buddhism in Tibet. It was             asamkheyas of aeons ago, a Buddha named founded by Marpa and is headed by His Holiness              Kashaya Banner Thus Come One appeared in the Kamapa. The other three are the Nyinggma, the               world. If a man or woman hears this Buddha’s Sakya, and the Gelukpa schools.                             name, that person will overcome the offenses of Ca Nhó Maõ Baït Hy (1206-1283 C.E.): Karma-                 birth and death for one hundred great aeons. pakshi (tib)—See Phaät Haïnh Giaû Ñeä Nhò.                  Ca Saám: Lokaraksa (skt)—Theá Hoä—Chi Caâu La Ca Nhó Maõ Phaùi: Karmapa (tib)—Phaät Haïnh                 Saám—Name of an Indian monk. Giaû—Man of Buddha-activity—See Kieát Maõ Ba.               Ca Taøi: Master Ka-Ts'ai—Teân cuûa moät vò Taêng Ca Nhò Saéc Giaø: Kaniska (skt)—See Ca Ni Saéc              Trung Hoa vaøo thôøi nhaø Ñöôøng (618-907)—Name Ca.                                                         of a Chinese monk during the T'ang dynasty. Ca Ni Ca: Kanaka or Kanika (skt)—Moät loaïi caây,           Ca Taùt Phaùi: Sakyapa (skt)—Teân cuûa moät tröôøng coù leõ laø caây chieân ñaøn—A tree or plant, probably      phaùi thuoäc Phaät giaùo Taây Taïng, ñöôïc ñaët theo teân a kind of sandal-wood.                                      cuûa moät töï vieän ôû mieàn Nam Taây Taïng. Tröôøng Ca Ni Saéc Ca: Kniska (skt)—Kanishka (skt)—                 phaùi Ñaát Xaùm, moät trong ba tröôøng phaùi môùi cuûa Kanishka (first-second century A.D.)—Vua thöù ba            Phaät giaùo Taây Taïng—Name of a school of Tibetan cuûa trieàu ñaïi Kusana, nöôùc Nguyeät Chi (toäc            Buddhism named after the Sakya Monastery in Nguyeät Thò, toå tieân xuaát phaùt töø Trung AÙ), cai trò   southern Tibet. One of the three “new orders” of xöù Kieän Ñaø La, phía baéc Punjab baây giôø, oâng ñaõ      Tibetan Buddhism. thoáng trò moät vuøng roäng lôùn maø phía taây giaùp ñeán   Ca Taàn Xaø La: Kapijala (skt)—Partridge—Chim Ñaïi Haï, vuøng laõnh thoå roäng lôùn töø Kabul,            tró. Gandhara, Sindh, Taây baéc AÁn Ñoä, Kashmir vaø moät        Ca Taát Thí: Kapisa (skt)—Theo Giaùo Sö Soothill phaàn cuûa Madhyadesa veà sau ñôøi vua A Duïc. OÂng         trong Trung Anh Phaät Hoïc Töø Ñieån, Ca Taát Thí laø laø moät oâng vua ñaày quyeàn uy thuoäc doøng doõi Saka     teân nöôùc Kanaka coù chu vi 4000 daäm, thuû ñoâ cuõng hoaëc Turuska. OÂng laø vò hoä phaùp lôùn cuûa Phaät        cuøng teân nöôùc, vôùi chu vi 10 daäm. Ñaây laø nôi an cö giaùo, chæ sau coù vua A Duïc vaø Di Lan Ñaø—The            kieát haï cuûa Ñöùc Phaät döôùi trieàu vua Ca Nhò Saéc third king of the Kusana dynasty of Yueh-Chih,              Giaø (Kaniska)—According to Professor Soothill in i.e. of Tukhara and the Indo-Scythians, ruler of            The Dictionary of Chinese-English Buddhist Gandhara in northern Punjab, who conquered                  Terms, Kapisa was an ancient kingdom, south of northern India and as far as Batria from Kabul,             Hindukush, said to be 4,000 miles around, with a

capital of the same name 10 miles in                          and cry out in pain and agony. They also cause a circumference; formerly a summer resort of                    lot of danger to humans. Kaniska                                                       Ca Tuïng Coå Ñöùc: Praise of the ancients. Ca Thanh: Tieáng haùt cuûa loaøi khaån na la—The              Ca Tyø La: 1) Taùc giaû cuûa boä Taêng Khö Luaän (noùi sound of singing of Kinnaras.                                 veà nghóa cuûa 25 ñeá): Kapila (skt)—Author of the Ca Thaáp Ba: Kashmir (skt)—Keá Taân—Vöông                     Sankhya philosophy; 2) Kapilavastu: See Ca Tyø quoác coå Keá Taân, baây giôø laø Kashmir, naèm veà phía      La Veä; 3) Hoaøng Xích Saéc Tieân Nhaân, teân cuûa taây baéc AÁn Ñoä. Vuøng ñaát maø vua A Duïc ñaõ saùp         giaùo chuû ngoaïi ñaïo phaùi Soá luaän: Kapila (skt)— nhaäp vaøo vöông quoác cuûa mình ngay sau khi oâng            Name of a leader of the heretic sect. leân ngoâi. Ñaây laø moät trung taâm Phaïn ngöõ quan          Ca Tyø La Baø Toâ Ñoâ: See Kapilavastu. troïng, cuõng laø moät tröôøng hoïc Phaät giaùo coù uy theá   Ca Tyø La Veä: Kapilavastu (skt)—Kapilavatthu thôøi ñoù. Ngoaøi ra, Kashmir giöõ moät vai troø quan         (p)—Ca Tyø La Veä—Kieáp Tyø La Phaït Thoát Ñoå— troïng trong vieäc truyeàn baù Phaät giaùo sang Trung         Thaønh Ca tyø la veä, kinh ñoâ cuûa doøng toäc Thích Ca, Quoác. Theo Taây Vöïc Kyù, Ca Thaáp Di La laø teân            nôi trò vì cuûa Vua Tònh Phaïn vaø Hoaøng Haäu Ma goïi cuûa nöôùc Keá Taân hoài xöa, baây giôø laø Kabul, ôû    da, kinh thaønh naøy toïa laïc döôùi chaân nuùi Hy Maõ veà phía Baéc AÁn Ñoä. Ca Thaáp Di La laø nôi kieát taäp      Laïp Sôn—Kapilavastu was one time the capital of kinh ñieån laàn cuoái döôùi trieàu vua Ca Nhò Saéc Giaø       Sakya Kingdom where dwelt King Suddhodana (Kaniska)—Ancient Kashmir kingdom, situated in                and his wife Maya, located in the foothills of the the north-east of India. A region which Asoka                 Himalayas. added to his empire right after he enthroned.                 Ca Tyø La Veä Pheá Tích: Pheá tích thaønh Ca Tyø La Kashmir was one of the most important centers of              Veä, nay laø laøng Tilaurakot, chöøng 70 daäm veà phía Buddhist Sanskrit learning and the center of the              baéc Ba La Naïi, kinh ñoâ cuûa boä toäc Thích Ca do most powerful Buddhist school. Besides, Kashmir               vua Tònh Phaïn cai trò ngaøy xöa. Taïi ñaây caùc nhaø played an important role in the transmission of               khaûo coå AÁn Ñoä cuõng tìm thaáy pheá tích coång hoaøng Buddhism to China. According to the Records of                cung cuûa vua Tònh Phaïn, nôi maø Thaùi Töû Só Ñaït Western Lands, Kasmira formerly known as Chi-                 Ña ñaõ ra ñi xuaát gia tu haønh khoå haïnh—The ruins Pin, the modern Kabul, north of India. Kasmira                at Kapilavastu, modern village Tilaurakot in was the seat of the final synod for determining the           Nepal, about 70 miles north of Benares, the Canon under King Kaniska.                                     capital of the Sakya’s tribe of whom king Ca Thaáp Di La: Kasmira or Kashmir (skt)—Yeát                 Suddhodana was               a ruler. Here, Indian Thaáp Nhó La—Ca Dieáp Di La—See Ca Thaáp Ba.                  archaelogists also found ruins of thegate of Ca Thi: Kasi (skt)—1) Teân cuûa moät loaïi truùc:             Suddhodana’s palace by which Prince Siddhartha Name of a kind of bamboo; 2) Moät ñòa danh veà                went out to become an ascetic. phía baéc cuûa Kosala, mang ñòa danh nhö vaäy vì coù          Ca Tyø Ma La: Kapimala (skt)—Moät vò Taêng ôû nhieàu loaïi truùc toát ñöôïc duøng laøm teân: A place        Ma Kieät Ñaø baây giôø laø Patna, vaøo khoaûng theá kyû said to be so called because its bamboos were                 thöù hai sau Taây Lòch. Tröôùc ngaøi theo ngoaïi ñaïo, good for arrows, north of Kosala.                             sau ñöôïc ngaøi Maõ Minh khuaát phuïc neân xin laøm Ca Thieân: Gitadevata (skt)—Name of a deity—                  ñeä töû Phaät. Ngaøi laø Toå thöù 13 ôû AÁn Ñoä. Ngöôøi ta Teân cuûa moät vò trôøi.                                      noùi ngaøi chính laø ngöôøi ñaõ khuaát phuïc vaø truyeàn Ca Tì La: See Ca Tyø La Veä.                                  phaùp cho ngaøi Long Thoï—A monk of Magadha Ca-Tra Phuù Ñôn Na: Pataphutana or Kataputana                 (Patna), around the second century A.D., (skt)—Kyø Xuù Quyû—Caø Tra Boá Ñôn Na—Moät loaøi              converted by Asvaghosa. He was the thirteenth quyû cöïc kyø xaáu xí vôùi thaân hình hoâi haùm, khi baét     Patriarch and he himself is said to have converted ngöôøi thì khieán cho hoï keâu khoùc moät caùch thoáng        Nagarjuna. khoå. Loaøi quyû naày cuõng gaây nhieàu nguy hieåm cho        Ca Tyû La: Kapila (skt)—See Ca Tyø La. loaøi ngöôøi—A kind of extremely ugly demons                  Ca Vaên: Goïi ñuû laø Thích Ca Vaên Phaät—See (pretas of remarkably evil odour) whose bodies                Thích Ca. expel the foulest odors, who makes people scream              Ca Vònh: See Ca Vònh Veä Ñaø.

Ca Vònh Veä Ñaø: Sama-veda (skt)—Samhita                 Caù Theå: Individuality. (skt)—Sa Ma—Ca Vònh Veä Ñaø—Tam Ma Bì                    Caù Theå Hoùa: Individualization. Ñeà—Ta Ma Veä Ñaø—Quyeån kinh thöù ba trong boán         Caù Trung: Caù Lyù—Choã naøy—This place. quyeån kinh Veä Ñaø, goàm nhöõng baøi ca trong khi       Caù Vò Nhôn Taát Ñaøn: The individual treatment or haønh leã—The third of four books of Veda,               adapting the teaching to the capacity of his containing the hymns.                                    hearers—See Töù Taát Ñaøn. Ca Xa: Kasa (skt).                                       Caø Sa: Kasaya (skt)—Kesa (jap)—Y aùo cuûa nhaø 1) Moät naém coû duøng laøm chieáu, ñöôïc nhaân caùch    sö. Maûnh vaûi vuoâng goàm nhöõng maãu nhoû vaù laïi hoùa nhö laø thò giaû cuûa Dieâm Ma Vöông—A         vôùi nhau. Ngöôøi ta khoaùc noù quanh coå baèng moät piece of grass, used for mats, thatch, etc.;        daõy daây. Thöù vaûi naày töôïng tröng cho aùo caø sa vaù personified as one of Yama’s attendants.            cuûa Phaät Thích Ca ngaøy tröôùc—The monk’s robe 2) Theo Eitel trong Trung Anh Phaät Hoïc Töø             or cassock. A rectangular piece of fabric Ñieån, kasa laø naém coû duøng ñeå laøm choåi cho   composed of 'patches' which is worn on a cord Ñöùc Phaät, vaãn coøn laø moät vaät thôø phöôïng:   around the neck. It symbolizes the patchwork robe According to Eitel in The Dictionary of             of Sakyamuni Buddha. Chinese-English Buddhist terms, kasa is a           1) Phöôùc ñieàn y: Garment of the field of piece of grass, of which a broom was made,                blessing. and used by Sakyamuni. It is still an object of     2) Tieâu Saáu Phuïc: Teân khaùc goïi aùo caø sa laø tieâu worship.                                                  tröø phieàn naõo—The monk’s robe as putting an Ca Xa Boá La: Kasapura (skt)—Theo Eitel trong                  end to illusion. Trung Anh Phaät Hoïc Töø Ñieån, Kasapura laø teân        3) Phöông Phuïc: Phaùp phuïc cuûa Taêng Ni, heát thaønh cuûa nöôùc Baùt La Da Giaø—According to                 thaûy ñeàu ñöôïc raùp noái baèng hình vuoân g—A Eitel in The Dictionary of Chinese-English                     monk’s robe (Caø Sa), to be so called because Buddhist Terms, Kasapura used to be a city                     its square appearance. between Lucknow and Oudh.                                4) Tröïc Chuyeát: AÙo cuûa chö Taêng chaáp vaù hay Ca Xöôùng: See Ca.                                             noái lieàn aùo loùt vaø quaàn, treân döôùi thaønh moät — Caù: Moãi—Each—Every.                                          A monk’s garment, upper and lower in one. Caù Ban: Nhö vaäy—Like that—So—Thus.                     Caø Sa Nguõ Ñieàu: Nguõ Ñieàu Caø Sa—See Nguõ Caù Bieät: Visista (skt)—Ñieåm ñaëc bieät cuûa moãi      Ñieàu Y. phaùp—Individual difference in each dharma.              Caø Sa Thaäp Ñöùc: Ten virtues of the robes—Möôøi Caù Bieät Taùnh: Prthak (skt)—Söï khaùc bieät—           ñöùc khi maëc vaøo ngöôøi chieác aùo caø sa: chieác aùo Different—Unlike—Separate—Diverse—                       bieåu toû loøng bieát saùm hoái vaø taøm quyù; chieác aùo giöõ Diversity—Not the same—Diversity—Change—                 cho thaân theå khoâng noùng khoâng laïnh, traùnh ñöôïc Strange—Heterodox.                                       muoãi moøng vaø ñoäc truøng; chieác aùo bieåu toû chaùnh Caù Caù Vieân Thöôøng Ñaïo: Moãi moãi laø moät ñaïo      haïnh cuûa nhaø sö; chö thieân nhaân toû loøng toân kính troøn ñaày vónh cöûu—Every single thing is the           chieác aùo nhö toân kính chuøa thaùp; chieác aùo bieåu toû complete eternal Tao.                                    söï ly aùi duïc; chieác aùo töông hôïp vôùi con ñöôøng taän Caù Ñaûo Ñoaïn: Caùi loän ngöôïc, yù chæ choã chöùng     dieät aùc duïc; nhöõng haønh ñoäng xaáu aùc deã daøng bò ngoä trong nhaø Thieàn—Something upside down,            khaùm phaù khi chieác aùo ñöôïc maëc vaøo; nhöõng ai this implies an experience of enlightenment in           maëc caø sa khoâng caàn baát cöù moùn trang söùc naøo Zen.                                                     khaùc; ngöôøi maëc aùo caø sa luoân saün saøng tu taäp baùt Caù Lyù: Caù Trung—Choã naøy—This place.                 chaùnh ñaïo; nhöõng ngöôøi maëc aùo caø sa luoân chuyeân Caù Nhaân: Individual—Personal.                          caàn tu taäp con ñöôøng vôùi taâm voâ caáu nhieãm—Ten Caù Nhaân Chuû Nghóa: Individualism.                     advantages of wearing the robes: the robes exhibit Caù Nhaân Hoùa: To individualize.                        one's feeling of repentance and shame; they keep Caù Nhaân Thaønh Töïu Coâng Ñöùc Löïc: personal          the body from heat and cold and keep away achievement of merit.                                    mosquitoes, gadflies and poisonous insects; they show the proper manner of a monk; devas and

humans pay respect to them as they worship                    Caùch Phaân Tích Cuûa Phaät Giaùo: Buddhist stupas and temples; they show the mind of                     analysis—Caøng hieåu roõ veà caùch phaân tích cuûa detachment; they are in accord with the way of                Phaät giaùo veà caùc yeáu toá khaùc nhau nhö saéc, thoï, extinction of evil passions; any evil acts can be             töôûng, haønh vaø thöùc, caùc nhaø khoa hoïc caøng thaáy easily discovered when robes are worn; those                  roõ caùch phaân tích naøy raát gaàn guûi vôùi caùch phaân wearing the robes do not required any other                   tích theo khoa hoïc hieän ñaïi. Töø hôn 25 theá kyû veà ornaments; those wearing the robes readily                    tröôùc maø Ñöùc Phaät ñaõ tieân lieäu ñöôïc chaúng nhöõng practice the Eightfold Noble Path; and those                  phöông phaùp caên baûn cuûa khoa hoïc nhö quan saùt, wearing the robes diligently practice the Way                 thöû nghieäm vaø phaân tích, maø coøn ôû moät soá keát luaän without the impure minds.                                     ñaëc tröng veà baûn chaát con ngöôøi vaø vuõ truï. Treân Caø Tra Boá Ñôn Na: Kataputana (skt)—See Ca                   nhieàu laõnh vöïc, Phaät giaùo vaø khoa hoïc thaät söï raát Tra Phuù Ñôn Na.                                              gaàn guûi vôùi nhau—The more the modern scientists Caùc Caên Suy Yeáu: Declined (deminished or                   understand about Buddhist analysis of various disintegrated) faculties.                                     factors of form, feeling, perception, volition and Caùc Chuû: Vò Taêng quaûn lyù taát caû caùc ñieän ñöôøng      consciousness, the more they can see the trong tu vieän (thaát ñöôøng giaø lam). Vò naày döôùi söï     similarities of Buddhist analysis with that of giaùm saùt cuûa Duy Na—A monk who is responsible              modern science. From more than 25 centuries ago, for all halls in a monastery. He is under the                 not only the Buddha anticipated the primary supervision of the duty-distributor.                          methods of science such as observation, Caùc Chuûng: See Caùc Loaïi.                                  experimentation, and analysis, but he also had Caùc Loaïi: Each kind—Every sort.                             some conclusions about the nature of man and the Caùch: 1) Caét ra: To cut off, to strip; 2) Da soáng          universe. Buddhism and science are really very (chöa thuoäc): Hides; 3) Ñöôøng thaúng: A line; 4)            close in many areas. Ngaên ra: To divide off, to separate, to part.                Caùch Sinh: Khi taùi sanh laø maát heát taát caû söï hieåu Caùch Lòch: Separate—Distinct.                                bieát cuûa tieàn kieáp—Divided by birth; on rebirth to Caùch Lòch Tam Ñeá: Bieän bieät hieåu bieát veà tam           be parted from all knowledge of a previous life. quaùn: khoâng, giaû, trung (khoâng laø ñaûn khoâng, ñeå       Caùch Song Khaùn Maõ Kî: Xem ngöïa chaïy qua phaù caùi hoaëc kieán tö; giaû laø ñaûn giaû, ñeå phaù caùi   song cöûa, yù noùi thôøi gian nhö boùng caâu qua cöûa soå hoaëc traàn sa; trung laø ñaûn trung, ñeå phaù caùi hoaëc     nhanh nhö nhöõng con ngöïa chaïy ngoaøi kia vaäy— voâ minh)—To differentiate and apprehend the                  To see horses run through a window. This implies three       distinctive     principles        noumenon,       the time is flashing by a window as fast as the phenomenon, and the mean—See Khoâng Giaû                      horses run out there. Trung.                                                        Caùch Soáng: Way of living. Caùch Löôïng: Quy caùch vaø soá löôïng hay khuoân             Caùch Thaân Cuù: Caùch Thöû Cuù—Chæ caâu noùi ñaëc maãu saün coù—Mode or procedure.                              bieät duøng ñeå chæ yù nghóa cuûa cöùu caùnh cuûa nhaø Caùch Maïng: Revolution.                                      Thieàn maø lôøi noùi bình thöôøng khoâng theå bieåu ñaït Caùch Maïng Xaõ Hoäi: Social revolution.                      ñöôïc—Only a special expression can express the Caùch Ngoa Traûo Daïng: Chaân ngöùa maø ñi gaõi               meaning of an end of Zen, not an ordinary one. chieác giaøy, yù noùi khoâng thaät söï thaáu roõ nghóa lyù    Caùch Thieân Sôn: Caùch nhau raát xa—To be far cuûa Phaät phaùp—One has an itching leg but                   away—Long intermittent. scratches on the shoes. This implies one does not             Caùch Thöû Cuù: See Caùch Thaân Cuù. really understand the Buddha-dharma.                          Caùch Tuùc: Caùch moät ñeâm, thí duï nhö laø noùi ñeán Caùch Ngoaïi: Phong caùch phi phaøm—                          ngaøy hoâm qua—Separated by a night, i.e. the Extraordinary.                                                previous day. Caùch Ngoaïi Ñaøm: Caâu noùi coù phong caùch phi              Caùch Töû Moân: Cöûa caùi cuûa thaát vò truï trì töï vieän phaøm—Extraordinary speech.                                   ñeàu höôùng ra ngoaøi saân tröôùc—Main doors of all Caùch Ngoân: Maxim—Proverb.                                   seven monks face the front yard of a temple.

Caùch Vaät, Trí Tri, Thaønh YÙ, Chaùnh Taâm: Tìm               qua giaùc quan nhaän thöùc, nhöng trong caùi ñeïp, hieåu söï vaät ñeán cuøng, bieát gì thì phaûi bieát cho ñeán   ngöôì Phaät töû luoân thaáy tính bieán hoaïi cuûa noù maø nôi ñeán choán, yù phaûi chaân thaønh, taâm phaûi ngay         khoâng sanh luyeán chaáp. Ngöôøi aáy luoân nhôù lôøi daïy thaúng, ñoù laø boán ñieàu maø ngöôøi quaân töû phaûi theo.    cuûa Ñöùc Phaät veà moïi phaùp höõu hình: “Chuùng coù Ngöôøi Phaät töû cuõng neân hoïc theo boán ñieàu naày, vì      sinh khôûi, thì chuùng phaûi chòu hoaïi dieät.” Nhö vaäy chuùng giuùp chuùng ta thaáy roõ ñöôïc baûn maët thaät cuûa    ngöôøi Phaät töû chaân thuaàn chieâm ngöôõng caùi ñeïp söï vieäc trong moïi tình huoáng)—Investigate                  maø khoâng pha laãn loøng tham muoán chieám höõu. Vôùi everything thoroughly, to extend one’s knowledge               ngöôøi Phaät töû, daùng daáp hay nhan saéc beân ngoaøi to the utmost, to be sincere, and to be upright.               khoâng heà gì vì noù chæ taïm bôï vôùi thôøi gian. Moät Caùch Xích: Chuaån möïc—Standard.                              göông maët treû ñeïp hoâm nay, coù theå moät ngaøy naøo Cai La: See Cai Nhieáp.                                        ñoù noù trôû neân giaø nua xaáu xí vôùi nhöõng veát nhaên Cai Nhieáp: 1) Nhaát Thöøa thaâu nhieáp Tam Thöøa:             vaø nhöõng ñoám ñoài moài ñaày maët. Vôùi ngöôøi Phaät töû, The one vehicle containing the three; 2) Thaâu                 baát luaän göông maët hoï ñeïp xaáu theá naøo, hoï luoân toùm, toaøn theå, khoâng phaân caùch: Containing,              tröôûng döôõng loøng yeâu thöông, vì chính loøng yeâu inclusive, undivided, whole.                                   thöông aáy seõ mang ñeán cho hoï moät neùt ñeïp vónh Cai Nhieáp Moân: Giaùo lyù thuyeát minh tam thöøa laø          haèng, ñoù môùi chính laø caùi ñeïp chaân thaät cuûa ngöôøi nhaát thöøa, ñoái laïi vôùi “phaân töôùng moân” hay giaùo      con Phaät—Many people, especially people from thuyeát giaûi thích söï khaùc bieät giöõa nhöùt thöøa vaø      the western world, have a misconception of tam thöøa—The doctrine which maintains the three               Buddhism. They suggest that Buddhism is a vehicles to be the one vehicle, in contrast with the           religion of pessimism. They suggest that doctrine which differentiates the one vehicle from             Buddhism stresses on impermanence, suffering the three.                                                     and egolessness so there is no so-called “Beauty” Caùi: 1) Che ñaäy: To cover, anything that screens,            in Buddhism. In fact, the Buddha never criticized hides, or hinders; 2) Duø che: An umbrella, or a hat,          “Beauty” in any of his lectures. A Buddhist never or any cover; 3) Chöôùng ngaïi bôûi duïc voïng, duïc           avoids objects of beauty, nor does he run away voïng laøm ñieân ñaûo meâ môø chaân taâm, laøm cho chaân       from these things. He only refrains from making taâm khoâng phaùt trieån ñöôïc: Obstruction of the             them the basis for strong and individual likes and passions, the passions which delude the real mind              dislikes. He always keeps in mind the Buddha’s so that it does not develop; 4) Teân khaùc cuûa phieàn         Teaching: “Whatever there is in the world, naõo: Another name for afflictions.                            pleasant and lovable, we have a tendency to Caùi Cheát Khoâng Thieân Vò Ngöôøi Sang Keû Giaøu:             attach to them, and we develop a dislike towards Death is blind to the noble and the rich.                      their opposites.” Keep this in mind, the Buddhist Caùi Cheát Laø Chaéc Chaén: Death is certain.                  recognizes beauty where the senses can perceive Caùi Ñeïp Vaø Phaät Giaùo: Beauty and Buddhism—                it. But in beauty he also sees its own change and Nhieàu ngöôøi, ñaëc bieät laø nhöõng ngöôøi töø theá giôùi     destruction. He always remember what the Taây phöông, coù moät quan nieäm sai laàm veà Phaät            Buddha said with regard to all component things, giaùo. Hoï cho raèng Phaät giaùo bi quan yeám theá. Hoï        that they come into being, undergo change and cho raèng vôùi ñaïo Phaät moïi thöù ñeàu laø voâ thöôøng,      aredestroyed. Therefore the wise man acquires a khoå vaø voâ ngaõ, neân khoâng coù caùi goïi laø “Ñeïp”        great depth of vision. His admiration for the trong ñaïo Phaät. Kyø thaät, Ñöùc Phaät chöa bao giôø ñaû      beauty is not coloured by a greed for acquisition kích veà “Veû Ñeïp” trong caùc baøi thuyeát giaûng cuûa        and possession. To Buddhists, the shape or color ngaøi. Vaø ngöôøi Phaät töû cuõng khoâng laõng traùnh caùi     of the face doesn’t matter because it’s only ñeïp, cuõng khoâng töø boû noù. Ngöôøi aáy chæ coá laøm sao    temporary with time. A young, beautiful face of cho noù khoâng trôû thaønh ñoái töôïng cuûa yeâu vaø gheùt     today may someday become an old ugly face with cuûa rieâng mình, vì Ñöùc Phaät ñaõ daïy: “Baát cöù thöù gì    wrinkles and dots all over. To Buddhists, no matter khaû laïc, khaû aùi treân ñôøi naøy ñeàu laøm cho chuùng       how beautiful or ugly their face may be, they sanh tham luyeán, roài sinh loøng yeâu thích hay gheùt         focus on cultivating love, that love will give them boû.” Nhôù nhö vaäy ngöôøi Phaät töû nhìn nhaän caùi ñeïp      an inward eternal charm, a real beauty to all

Buddhists.                                                  Caûi Toâng: Boû toâng phaùi naày theo toâng phaùi kia, boû Caùi Laâu Tuyeân: Avalokitesvara (skt)—The                  tö töôûng cuûa tröôøng phaùi naày theo tö töôûng cuûa Bodhisattva Avalokitesvara—See Quaùn Theá AÂm               tröôøng phaùi khaùc, boû toân giaùo naày theo toân giaùo Boà Taùt.                                                   khaùc—To change one’s cult, school of thought, or Caùi Ta Thöôøng Coøn: Permanent self.                       religion. Caùi Theá Anh Huøng: A hero over the world.                 Cam: Kansu (skt)—1) Ngoït: Sweet; 2) Chòu (cam Caùi Thieân Caùi Ñòa: Gaiten-Gaichi (jap)—Taän              chòu): Willing; 3) Ñoàng YÙ: Agreeable. thaäp phöông theá giôùi, aùm chæ Phaät phaùp xöa nay        Cam Boà: Kamboja (skt)—Quaû Cam Boà ñöôïc dieãn nhö thò, bao truøm taát caû. Thuaät ngöõ chæ cho traïng     taû laø maøu ñoû, troøn, coù ba ngaán ngang. Nôi coå cuûa thaùi cuûa ngöôøi tu thieàn sau khi trieät ngoä ñi khaép    Ñöùc Phaät cuõng coù hình töôùng naày, moät trong 32 nôi giaùo hoùa chuùng sanh—All the worlds of the            töôùng haûo cuûa Ñöùc Phaät—Described as a round ten directions. The term implies the state of a Zen         reddish fruit, the Buddha having something practitioner who goes to all worlds of the ten              resembling it on his neck, one of his characteristic directions to teach and to convert sentient beings          marks—See Tam Thaäp Nhò Haûo Töôùng. after attaining enlightenment.                              Cam Boà Quoác: Kamboja (skt)—Moät trong 16 Caùi Thöïc Thuaàn Y: AÊn xin vaø maëc ñoà cuõ raùch,        vöông quoác thuoäc AÁn Ñoä thôøi coå, noåi tieáng vôùi aùm chæ ñôøi soáng thanh baàn cuûa chö Taêng—To beg         nhöõng ngöôøi ñaøn baø ñeïp—One of the sixteen for foods and to wear patchy robes, this implies            countries in ancient India, noted for its beautiful the poor but unsullied life of monks.                       women. Caùi Trieàn: Nguõ trieàn caùi vaø thaäp trieàn—Covers       Cam Chaâu (1914-1978): Master Kan-Chou—Teân and bonds, i.e. the passions which stunt growth             cuûa moät vò Taêng Trung Hoa ôû Thanh Haûi vaøo theá and hold in bondage, such as five covers and ten            kyû thöù XX—Name of a Chinese monk in Ching- entanglements or bonds.                                     Hai Province in the twentieth century. Caûi: Thay ñoåi hay söõa ñoåi—To change—To                  Cam Chaâu Nhó: Kanjur (tib)—Moät trong hai phaân correct.                                                    boä cuûa Taïng Kinh Taây Taïng, goàm 160 quyeån, moãi Caûi AÙc Tuøng Thieän: To leave the evil and follow         quyeån 1.000 trang—One of the two divisions of the good—To correct oneself                                 the Tibetan canon, consisting of 160 books Caûi Bieán Vaän Meänh: To change our destiny.               (chuan), each book 1,000 leaves. Caûi Dung: To change one’s countenance.                     Cam Chí: Zen Master Kan-Chi—Teân cuûa moät vò Caûi Ñaùn: Ngaøy moät moät cuûa thaùng aâm lòch—The         cö só Thieàn sö Trung Hoa ôû An Huy vaøo thôøi nhaø first day of the lunar calendar month.                      Ñöôøng. Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån Caûi Ñaïo: See Caûi Toâng.                                  X, oâng laø ngöôøi noái phaùp cuûa Thieàn sö Nam Tuyeàn Caûi Hình Bieán Maïo: Transfiguration.                      Phoå Nguyeän—Name of a layman Zen master in Caûi Hoùa: To convert.                                      An-Hui Province in the T'ang dynasty (618-907). Caûi Hoái: To repent—To repent and reform.                  The Records of the Transmission of the Lamp Caûi Laõo Hoaøn Ñoàng: Rejuvenation—Laøm cho                (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), Volume X, he was the Dharma giaø thaønh treû, ñieàu naøy ñi ngöôïc laïi quy luaät voâ   heir of Zen master Nan-chuan Pu-yuan. thöôøng taát yeáu trong ñaïo Phaät.                         Cam Ñan: Dgahldan (tib)—Töï vieän baûn sôn cuûa Caûi Phuïc: Thay ñoåi y aùo—To change robes.                phaùi Hoaøng Giaùo, khoaûng 30 daäm ñoâng baéc cuûa Caûi Taø Quy Chaùnh: To give up wrong deeds and             thuû ñoâ La Sa, ñöôïc ngaøi sô toå Toâng Khaùch Ba xaây return to the right ones—To mend one's way.                 döïng—The monastery of Yellow sect, 30 miles northeast of Lhasa, built by Tson-Kha-Pa. Caûi Taïo Nhaân Quaû: Amelioration of cause and effect.                                                     Cam Ñan Phaùi: Blah-gdamspa (tib)—Tröôøng phaùi Cam Ñan (Taây Taïng)—The school of Blah- Caûi Thieän: To improve—To reform. gdamspa—Yellow sect. Caûi Tieán: To change for better prospects. Cam Giaù: Caûi Tính: To change (alter) one’s character. 1) Mía—Sugar-cane.

2) Iksvaku (skt): Moät trong caùc hoï cuûa doøng          Cam Loä Moân: Nirvana. Thích Ca, theo truyeàn thuyeát laø moät trong        Cam Loä Phaïn: Amrtodana (skt)—Amitodana nhöõng oâng toå cuûa Ngaøi ñaõ ñöôïc sanh ra töø     (p)—A Di Ñoâ Ñaøn Na—Vò vua coù teân laø “Cam Loä trong moät caây mía—One of the surnames of           Phaïn,” laø cha ñeû cuûa A Naäu Laâu Ñaø vaø Bhadrika, Sakyamuni, from a legend that one of his             vaø laø chuù cuûa Phaät Thích Ca—The king whose ancestors was born from a sugar cane.                name was “Ambrosia-Rice,” a prince of Magadha, Cam Giaù Thò: Isaku (skt)—Suryavamsa (skt)—               father of Anurudha and Bhadrika, and paternal Nhaát Xoa Cöu Vöông—See Nhaät Chuûng Thieän               uncle of Sakyamuni. Sanh.                                                     Cam Loä Phaùp: Giaùo phaùp cuûa Ñöùc Phaät ví nhö Cam Giaù Vöông: Iksvaku-Virudhaka (skt)—Vua               nöôùc cam loä (trong Kinh Phaùp Hoa, phaåm Döôïc Mía, maø ngöôøi ta noùi laø moät trong nhöõng oâng toå    Thaûo Duï, Ñöùc Theá Toân ñaõ khaúng ñònh vì muoán cuûa doøng Thích Ca, nhöng nhöõng ngöôøi khaùc cuõng      cho chuùng sanh ñöôïc yeân oån maø Ngaøi xuaát hieän cho ñaây laø toå cuûa doøng hoï mình—King of the          nôi ñôøi, vì ñaïi chuùng maø Ngaøi thuyeát Cam Loä sugar-cane, said to be one of the ancestors of            Phaùp, phaùp chæ thuaàn moät vò giaûi thoaùt)—The Sakyamuni, but the name is claimed by others.             ambrosial truth or rain, the Buddha truth. Cam Loà: See Cam Loä.                                     Cam Loä Phaùp Moân: Phaùp moân giaûi thoaùt (nieát Cam Loà Thuûy: Healing nectar.                            baøn)—The method of the ambrosial truth. Cam Loä: Amrta (skt)—Duttsi (tib)—Kanro                   Cam Loä Quang Nhö Lai: See Voâ Löôïng Quang (jap)—Toâ Ñaø—Holy water—Wine of gods—                    Phaät. Thaùnh Thuûy—Toâ Ma (soma)—The nectar from                Cam Loä Thaønh: Thaønh cam loä ñöôïc ví vôùi Nieát heaven.                                                   Baøn—The nectar city or nirvana. 1) Söông Ngoït: Sweet dew.                                Cam Loä Thuûy: Healing nectar. 2) Phaán Ong (phaán hoa do ong tích tuï trong toå ñeå     Cam Loä Thuûy Chaân Ngoân: Sweet Dew True aên): Ambrosia.                                      Words. 3) Thaàn Töûu: Wine of gods—Moät loaïi thöùc uoáng        Cam Loä Vuõ: The ambrosial rain—See Cam Loä coù röôïu laøm töø moät loaïi caây maø tröôùc ñaây   Phaùp. ñöôïc duøng ñeå teá leã Phaïm Thieân—The             Cam Loä Vöông: Amrtaraja (skt). alcoholic drink made from the plant named            1) AÙm chæ baát töû laø teân cuûa Ñöùc A Di Ñaø Nhö “Soma” and formerly offered to the                        Lai (thöôøng ñi chung vôùi Cam Loä Chuù, Cam Brahminical gods.                                         Loä Ñaø La Ni Chuù, Thaäp Cam Loä Chuù hay 4) Nöôùc (maät) Baát Töû: The nectar (water) of                Thaäp Cam Loä Minh, Cam Loät Kinh): Amrta immortality—The nectar from heaven.                       (skt)—In its implication of immortality is a 5) Boán loaïi Thieân Töûu (röôïu trôøi): Thanh Cam             name of Amitabha (connected with him are Loä, Hoaøng Cam Loä, Hoàng (Xích) Cam Loä, vaø            the Mantra of Ambrosia, the Mantra of Baïch Cam Loä—There are four kinds of Deva-               Ambrosial Dharani, Ten Mantras of wine (nectar of gods): Green Ambrosia,                    Ambrosia, Sutra of Ambrosia). Yellow Ambrosia, Red Ambrosia, and White             2) Cha cuûa A Naäu Laâu Ñaø: Amrtodana (skt)— Ambrosia.                                                 Father of Anuruddha. Cam Loä Coå: Troáng Cam Loä hay Phaät Phaùp —The          Cam Loä Vöông Nhö Lai: Amitabha and his ambrosial drum, the Buddha-truth.                         implication of immortality—See Cam Loä Vöông Cam Loä Dieät: Cam loä ñöôïc ví vôùi nieát baøn tòch      (1). tònh—The nectar of nirvana, the entrance is the           Cam Loä Vöông Toân: Amrtakundalin (skt)—Moät Nirvana.                                                  trong naêm vò Minh Vöông, vò luoân hieän döôùi ba Cam Loä Giôùi: Amrta-dhatu (skt)—Cam loä giôùi            hình thöùc khaùc nhau—One of the five Ming- ñöôïc ví vôùi Nieát Baøn—The nectar region or             Wang, who has three different forms: nirvana.                                                  1) Kim Cang Cam Loä Minh Vöông: Vajra- Cam Loä Huyeàn Moân: The method of the                         Amrtakundalin. ambrosial truth.

2) Lieân Hoa Cam Loä Minh Vöông: Lotus-                          nguyeân lyù cuûa yù thöùc, trong khi ñoù, chöùng ngoä laø Amrtakundalin.                                              theå hieän caùi voâ thöùc vöôït ngoaøi ñoái ñaõi. Vì vaäy, ñeå 3) Cam Loä Minh Vöông: Nectar-Amrtakundalin.                     giaûi phoùng khoûi tình traïng ñoái laäp aáy, ngöôøi ta phaûi Cam Myõ: Ngoït ngaøo—Sweetness—Sweet.                            taïo ra moät caûm giaùc vöôït leân treân taát caû. Moät tay Cam Phaùt: Coøn goïi laø Cam Ñænh, loâng toùc cuûa               lang baït, soáng ngoaøi voøng phaùp luaät, ñeán ñaâu cuõng Ñöùc Phaät coù maøu cam löu ly (xanh pha laãn ñoû                bò baïc ñaõi, khoâng phaûi chæ bôûi nhöõng keû khaùc maø tía)—The purplish colour of the Buddha’s hair.                   coøn bôûi chính mình, noù thaáy raèng mình laø sôû höõu Cam Phöôøng: Teân cuûa moät töï vieän—Name for a                 chuû cuûa taát caû taøi saûn, vaø uy quyeàn maø moät sinh Buddhist monastery.                                              vaät coù theå ñaït ñöôïc trong coõi ñôøi naày, sao laïi coù Cam Thuø: Kangyur (tib)—Kanjur (tib)—Cam                         theå theá, neáu khoâng caûm giaùc ñöôïc kyø cuøng veû töï Chaâu Nhó—Moät trong hai phaân boä cuûa Taïng Kinh               toân töï ñaïi cuûa mình? Moät Thieàn sö noùi: “Luùc Taây Taïng, goàm 160 quyeån, moãi quyeån 1.000 trang.            chöùng ngoä laø luùc thaáy ra moät laâu ñaøi traùng leä xaây Trong soá naày coù 104 quyeån laø lôøi cuûa ñöùc Phaät, vaø      baèng pha leâ treân moät tô haøo ñoäc nhaát; nhöng khi phaàn coøn laïi laø phaàn söu taäp nhöõng boä luaän —One         khoâng chöùng ngoä, laâu ñaøi traùng leä aáy khuaát laáp sau of the two divisions of the Tibetan canon,                       moät tô haøo maø thoâi.” Moät Thieàn sö khaùc ñaõ daãn duï consisting of 160 books (chuan), each book 1,000                 Kinh Hoa Nghieâm: “Naày caùc thaày haõy xem kìa! leaves. Among these 104 volumes of the words of                  AÙnh saùng röïc rôõ ñang toûa khaép caû ñaïi thieân theá the Buddha, and the rest is the great collection of              giôùi, cuøng luùc hieån hieän taát caû nhöõng nuùi Tu Di, commentaries.                                                    nhöõng maët trôøi, nhöõng maët traêng, nhöõng baàu trôøi Cam Tieäp: Loâng maøy cuûa Ñöùc Phaät maøu cam löu               vaø coõi ñaát, nhieàu ñeán haèng traêm nghìn öùc soá. Naøy ly—The Budha’s violet or red-blue eyebrows.                      caùc Thaày, caùc Thaày coù thaáy aùnh saùng aáy chaêng?” Cam Tuùc: Kan-Su—Name of a city in China.                        Theá nhöng, caûm giaùc sieâu thoaùt cuûa Thieàn ñuùng ra Caùm: Maøu tím thaúm, söï pha troän giöõa maøu xanh              laø moät caûm giaùc traàm laëng cuûa coõi loøng tri tuùc; noù da trôøi vaø maøu ñoû—A violet or purplish colour, a             chaúng coù chuùt gì loà loä, khi giaây phuùt xaùn laïn ñaàu blend of blue and red.                                           tieân ñaõ ñi qua. Caùi voâ thöùc aáy khoâng boäc loä oàn aøo Caùm Boà: Kamboja (skt)—See Cam Boà.                             ôû Thieàn—The feeling of exaltation inevitably Caùm Vieân: Töï Vieän—Monastery ground and                       accompanies enlightenment is due to the fact that buildings—A monastery.                                           it is the breaking-upof the restriction imposed on Caûm: 1) Caûm ñoäng: To be moved, affected; 2)                   one as an individual being, and this breaking-up is Daùm: To dare, to venture.                                       not a mere negative incident but quite a positive one fraught with signification because it means an Caûm Giaùc: feeling—Senses—Sensation—To infinite expansion of the individual. The general feel—To experience. feeling, though we are not always conscious of it, Caûm Giaùc Hyû Laïc: Somanassa (p)—Happiness— which charaterizes all our                   functions of Happy feeling—Haïnh phuùc. consciousness, is that of restriction and Caûm Giaùc Sieâu Thoaùt: Feeling of exaltation— dependence, because consciousness itself is the Theo Thieàn Sö D.T. Suzuki trong Thieàn Luaän Taäp outcome of two forces conditioning or restricting II, caûm giaùc sieâu thoaùt keøm theo söï chöùng ngoä, laø each other. Enlightenment, on the contrary, vì noù beû gaõy giôùi haïn phaân bieät caù theå; vaø ñaây essentially consists in doing away with the khoâng phaûi chæ laø moät bieán coá tieâu cöïc maø hoaøn opposition of two terms in whatsoever sense, and toaøn tích cöïc, chöùa ñaày yù nghóa, bôûi vì noù chính laø this opposition is the principle of consciousness, moät söï trieån khai caù theå ñeán voâ cuøng. Maëc duø while enlightenment is to realize the Unconscious chuùng ta khoâng luoân luoân ñeå yù, nhöng caûm giaùc which goes beyond the opposition. To be released thoâng thöôøng noùi leân taát caû nhöõng nhieäm vuï yù of this, must make one feel above all things thöùc cuûa chuùng ta laø caûm giaùc höõu haïn vaø leä thuoäc, intensely exalted. A wandering outcast maltreated bôûi vì chính yù thöùc laø haäu quaû cuûa hai theá löïc everywhere not only by others but by himself töông duyeân hay giôùi haïn laãn nhau. Traùi laïi, chöùng finds that he is the possessor of all the wealth and ngoä chính laø xoùa boû söï ñoái laäp cuûa hai ñaàu moái, power that is ever attainable in this world by a trong baát cöù chieàu höôùng naøo , vaø söï ñoái laäp naày laø

mortal being, if it does not give him a high feeling           Caûm Thaønh: Thieàn Sö Caûm Thaønh (?-860)—See of self-glorification, what could? Says a Zen                  Caûm Thaønh Thieàn Sö. Master, “When you have enlightenment you are                   Caûm Thaønh Thieàn Sö: Thieàn Sö Caûm Thaønh (?- able to reveal a palatial mansion made of precious             860)—Zen Master Caûm Thaønh (?-860)—Sö queâ ôû stones on a single blade of grass; but when you                huyeän Tieân Du, tröôùc tu ôû chuøa Phaät Tích. Thieàn have no enlightenment, a palatial mansion itself is            Sö Caûm Thaønh, ñôøi thöù nhaát cuûa doøng Voâ Ngoân concealed        behind     a     simple      blade      of    Thoâng. Khi môùi xuaát gia, sö laáy hieäu laø Laäp Ñöùc, grass."”Another Zen master alluding to the                     chuyeân trì tuïng kinh ñieån—Zen Master Caûm Avatamsaka, declares: “O monks, look and                       Thaønh, a Vietnamese monk from Tieân Du, North behold! A most auspicious light is shining with the            Vietnam. He previously practiced Buddhism at utmost brilliancy all over the great chiliocosm,               Phaät Tích Temple. He was the first lineage of the simultaneously revealing all the countries, all the            Wu-Yun-T’ung Sect. When he left home to oceans, all the Sumerus, all the suns and moons,               become a monk, he focused in reciting sutras. all the heavens, all the lands, each of which                   Luùc aáy coù ngöôøi hoï Nguyeãn ôû höông Phuø number as many as hundreds of thousands of kotis.                   Ñoång hieán ñaát laäp chuøa. Thoaït tieân, oâng e O monks, do you not see the light? But the Zen                      ngaïi khoâng nhaän vì oâng khoâng muoán vöôùng feeling of exaltation is rather a quiet feeling of                  maéc vaøo baát cöù thöù gì; tuy nhieân, sau ñoù oâng self-contentment; it is not at all demonstrative,                   naèm moäng coù ngöôøi maùch baûo neân nhaä n vì lôïi when the first glow of it passes away. The                          ích cuûa nhieàu ngöôøi khaùc. Quaû thaät, sau khi Unconscious does not proclaim itself so                             xaây chuøa Kieán Sô chaúng bao laâu, vaøo naêm boisterously in the Zen consciousness.                              820, döôùi thôøi nhaø Ñöôøng, coù Thieàn Sö Voâ Caûm Giaùc Toäi Loãi: Feeling of guilt—Guilt-                       Ngoân Thoâng, nguyeân truï trì chuøa Hoøa An töø feelings—Ngöôøi Phaät töû sanh ra khoâng coù caûm                   beân Taøu qua, gheù laïi chuøa vaø thieàn dieän bích giaùc toäi loãi vôùi yù nghóa sôï moät ñaáng thöôïng ñeá            taïi ñaây trong nhieàu naêm. Sö Caûm Thaønh raát tröøng phaït nhöõng ñieàu sai traùi cuûa mình. Tuy                  kính moä vaø toân Thieàn Sö laøm Thaày. Sau khi nhieân, ngöôøi Phaät töû caûm thaáy coù toäi theo luaä t            Thieàn Sö Voâ Ngoân Thoâng thò tòch thì Sö Caûm nhaân quaû. Khi baïn laøm ñieàu gì sai traùi, baïn seõ              Thaønh trôû thaønh nhò toå cuûa Thieàn phaùi Voâ nhaän laáy haäu quaû cho vieäc laøm sai traùi cuûa baïn, vaø        Ngoân Thoâng. Vaøo naêm 860, Sö an nhieân thò theo caùch naày baïn phaûi chòu ñöïng cho haäu quaû cuûa            tòch—There was a patron of Buddhism, whose toäi loãi cuûa chính mình—Buddhist born has no                      last name was Nguyeãn, a rich landlord from feeling of guilt in the sense of fear of a God who                  Phuø Ñoång hamlet, donated his land for him to will punish him for his wrong-doing. However, he                    build a temple. First, he was reluctant to feels guilty by the law of Karma. When you do                       accept it because he did not want to be some wrong-doing, you will receive the effects of                   attached to anything; however, later in his his wrong doing and in this way suffer the effect                   dream, he met someone who recommended of your sin.                                                        him to accept the land to build a temple for Caûm Haø: Caûm taï vaø tieáp nhaän trong nieàm caûm                 the benefits of other people. In fact, not long phuïc—Appreciation and acception with great                         after the Kieán Sô Temple was built, in 820, admiration.                                                         under the T’ang dynasty in China, Zen Master Caûm Hoùa: Rehabilitate (v).                                        Voâ Ngoân Thoâng, used to be Head of Hoøa An Caûm Hoaøi: Moving remembrance.                                     Temple in China, arrived in Vietnam and Caûm Höùng Ngöõ: Udana (skt)—Verses of Uplift—                      stayed at Kieán Sô to practice “face-to-a-wall” See Voâ Vaán Töï Thuyeát.                                           meditation for several years. Later he Caûm Quaû: Quaû tìm thaáy hay quaû do nghieäp nhaân                 founded the Wu-Yun-T’ung (Voâ Ngoân Thoâng) taïo taùc maø coù—The result that is sought.                        Zen Sect right at the Kieán Sô Temple and Caûm Quan: Giaùc quan—Organs of sense.                              became the First Patriarch, and Caûm Thaøn h Caûm Taán: Inspire to progress—To move to                           became his disciple. When he passed away, zeal—Gôïi nguoàn caûm höùng cho tieán boä.                          Zen Master Caûm Thaønh became the second

Patriarch. In 860, Zen master Caûm Thaønh                kinh qua nhôø caûm giaùc, Phaät giaùo goïi ñoù laø “thoï” passed away quietly.                                     vaø Phaät khaúng ñònh trong Thaäp Nhò Nhaân Duyeân  Moät hoâm, coù moät vò Taêng ñeán gaëp Thieàn sö             raèng “thoï” taïo nghieäp luaân hoài sanh töû —Feeling is Caûm Thaønh, phaùi Voâ Ngoân Thoâng ñeå hoûi Sö:         knowledge obtained by the senses, feeling "Phaät laø gì?" Thieàn sö Caûm Thaønh ñaùp: "Moïi        sensation. It is defined as mental reaction to the thöù." Vò Taêng hoûi tieáp: "Phaät Taâm laø gì?"         object, but in general it means receptivity, or Thieàn sö Caûm Thaønh ñaùp: "Khoâng coù gì che           sensation. Feeling is also a mind which daáu." Vò Taêng hoûi tieáp: "Ñeä töû khoâng hieåu gì     experiences either pleasure, unpleasure or caû." Thieàn sö Caûm Thaønh noùi: "OÂng ñaõ lôõ cô       indifference (pleasant, unpleasant, neither hoäi. Moãi khi ngöôøi ta ñöa ra cho chuùng ta caây       pleasant nor unpleasant). When we meet gaäy, hoaëc chuùng ta naém ñöôïc hoaëc chuùng ta         attractive objects, we develop pleasurable ñeå vuoät maát. Khoâng theå khaùc hôn ñöôïc. Do döï      feelings and attachment which create karma for us chöùng toû raèng chuùng ta chöa ñaït ñeán ñoä chín       to be reborn in samsara. In the contrary, when we muoài. Nhöng moãi laàn thaát baïi, chuùng ta khoâng      meet undesirable objects, we develop painful or neân nuoái tieác. Chuùng ta coù theå quay veà vôùi       unpleasurable feelings which also create karma sinh hoaït haèng ngaøy, ñi laáy nöôùc, naáu aên vaø      for us to be reborn in samsara. When we meet troàng troït, vaø khi chuùng ta caøng ra söùc noå löïc   objects that are neither attractive nor unattractive, môùi, chaùnh nieäm caøng lôùn hôn."—A monk               we develop indifferent feelings which develop came to Zen master Cam Thanh, a ninth-                   ignorant self-grasping, also create karma for us to century monk of the Vo Ngon Thong Sect,                  be reborn in samsara. All actions performed by and asked, 'What is Buddha?' Cam Thanh                   our body, speech and mind are felt and said, 'Everything.' The monk continued, 'What            experienced, Buddhism calls this “Feeling” and is the mind of Buddha?' Cam Thanh replied,               the Buddha confirmed in the Twelve Nidanas that 'Nothing has been hidden.' The monk said, 'I             “Feeling” creates karma, either positive or don't understand.' Cam Thanh responded,                  negative, which causes rebirths in samsara. 'You missed!' Each time a staff is held out to           Caûm Thoï Kinh: Vedana sutta (p)—Kinh Caûm us, we either grab it or miss it. There is no            Thoï, Töông Öng Boä XXVII.5—Sutra on Feeling, alternative. Hesitation shows that we are not            Samyutta Nikaya XXVII.5. yet ripe. But each time we fail, we must not             Caûm Thöông: Touched to pity—Ñöùc Phaät caûm regret. We can only go back to our daily work            thöông noåi khoå cuûa chuùng sanh—The Buddha was of carrying water, cooking, and cultivating the          touched by the suffering of the human condition. earth, striving anew with increased                      Caûm Thöông Noãi Khoå Cuûa Kieáp Ngöôøi: To be mindfulness."                                            touched by the suffering of the human life. Caûm Thaáy An Nhieân Thanh Tònh: To feel calm                  Caûm Tieán: To move to zeal, or inspire to (at peace) and pure.                                           progress. Caûm Thoï: Vedana (skt)—Sensation—Thoï uaån—                   Caûm Töû: Fearless before death. To         bear—Contact—Feeling—Perceiving—To                  Caûm Töôûng: Impression. receive—Receiving—Thoï laø phaùp taâm sôû nhaän                Caûm ÖÙng: Chuùng sanh coù cô duyeân thieän caên laøm laõnh dung naïp caùi caûnh maø mình tieáp xuùc. Thoï           caûm ñoäng ñeán chö Phaät, chö Phaät cuõng duøng söï cuõng laø caùi taâm neám qua nhöõng vui, khoå hay döûng        caûm öùng kyø dieäu cuûa mình ñeå ñaùp laïi thì goïi laø döng (vöøa yù, khoâng vöøa yù, khoâng vöøa yù maø cuõng        caûm öùng (thí duï nhö nöôùc khoâng daâng cao, traêng khoâng khoâng vöøa yù). Khi chuùng ta gaëp nhöõng ñoái         khoâng xuoáng thaáp, nhöng traêng vaãn luoân baøng baïc töôïng haáp daãn, chuùng ta lieàn phaùt khôûi nhöõn g caûm     khaép nôi treân maët nöôùc)—Respond to appeal or giaùc vui söôùng vaø luyeán aùi. Khi gaëp phaûi nhöõng         need; Buddha moved to respond. ñoái töôïng khoâng haáp daãn, thì chuùng ta sinh ra caûm       Caûm ÖÙng Ñaïo Giao: Kanno-Doko (jap)—Söï giaùc khoù chòu; neáu ñoái töôïng khoâng ñeïp khoâng xaáu      truyeàn thoâng bí maät giöõa chö Phaät vaø chuùng sanh thì chuùng ta caûm thaáy döûng döng. Taát caû moïi taïo        hay giöõa vuõ truï vaø chuùng sanh—Mystical taùc cuûa chuùng ta töø thaân, khaåu vaø yù cuõng ñeàu ñöôïc   communication between Buddhas and living

beings, or between the Universe and living                    Can Ñoà Na: Kancana (skt)—Kieän Chieát Na— beings—See Tình Caûm Hoã Töông.                               Golden—A shrub of trees, with golden hue, Caûm Xuùc: Feeling—Strongly affected—Very                     described as the leguminous order. much impressed—Very much moved by one’s                       Can Hoaøi: Quaáy roái—To harass—To disturb. compassion.                                                   Can Laät Ñaø: Hrdaya (skt)—Can Laät Thaùi—Caøn Can: Mieáng che: A shield—Caây choáng ñôõ: A                  Laät Ñaø—Caït Lôïi Ña—Traùi tim—The physical stem, a pole.                                                 heart. Can AÙn: To be condemned (convicted).                         Can Moäc: Moäc Thöôïng Toïa—Caây gaäy maø caùc vò Can Baùc Baùc: Khoâ khan, khoâng coù nöôùc—Dry                Thieàn sö thöôøng duøng luùc thöôïng ñöôøng—The and without water.                                            staff that Zen masters usually use when entering Can Baùn: Vöôùng maéc—Attachment.                             the hall. Can Boäc Boäc: Thieàn Taêng ít noùi —Close-mouthed            Can Saùch Saùch: Khoâ khoâng khoác—Extremely Zen monk.                                                     dry—Withered. Can Chöùng: Witness.                                          Can Thieäp: To interfere—To intervene—To Can Döï: To take part.                                        meddle. Can Ñaûm: Brave—Courageous—Fearless—                          Can Truùc Giaûo Chaáp: Vaét tre khoâ tìm nöôùc, yù noùi Dauntless.                                                    keá hoaïch hoaøi coâng voâ ích—A project that is Can Ñaû Hoáng: Phí coâng daïy doã—Wasteful                    wasteful and without result. instructions.                                                 Can Tröôøng: Courage—Bravery. Can Ñaàu Tieán Boä: Shih-shuang: "Step from the               Caùn: To run over. Top of the Pole"—Treân ñaàu saøo traêm thöôùc laïi            Caùn Nhieäm Ñaïi Söï: Gaùnh vaùc vieäc lôùn, duï cho tieán theâm moät böôùc, yù noùi nhöõng haønh ñoäng duõng      vieäc tu haønh giaùc ngoä—To manage important caûm vaø khoâng sôï haõi cuûa ngöôøi tham thieàn vöôït        matters, i.e., To cultivate to attain enlightenment. qua moïi trôû ngaïi ñeå ñi ñeán ñaïi ngoä . Trong thí duï     Caøn: 1) Caøn khoân (Trôøi): Heaven; 2) Chòu ñöïng: 46 cuûa Voâ Moân Quan: "Hoøa Thöôïng Thaïch Söông             Enduring; 3) Gioáng ñöïc: Masculine; 4) Khoâ raùo: noùi: 'Ñaàu saøo traêm thöôùc laøm sao tieán theâm?' Coù vò   Dry, dried up; 5) Saïch seõ: Clean; 6) Tieáp tuïc: coå ñöùc laïi noùi: 'Ñaàu saøo traêm thöôùc ñaõ ngoài leân,   Continual. thaáy ñaïo maø chöa thaät nhaäp chaân. Traêm thöôùc ñaàu      Caøn Ñaø: 1) AÙo caø sa cuûa chö Taêng, maøu nhuoäm saøo caàn böôùc nöõa, möôøi phöông theá giôùi hieän toaøn     giöõa vaøng vaø ñoû thaúm: Kasaya (skt)—A coloured thaân.'" Theo Voâ Moân Hueä Khai trong Voâ Moân               composed of red and yellow, the monk’s robe; 2) Quan, böôùc tôùi ñöôïc, quay lui ñöôïc, coøn ngaïi choã       Nguõ uaån: the five skandhas; 3) Voøng nuùi ñaàu tieân naøo maø khoâng xöng toân? Tuy nhö vaäy, thöû hoûi ñaàu       boïc quanh nuùi Tu Di: Yugamdhara (skt)—The first saøo traêm thöôùc laøm sao tieán theâm? Höø! —                of the concentric mountains around Mount Meru. Courageous and fearless acts of Zen practitioners             Caøn Ñaø Ha Ñeà Boà Taùt: Gandhahastin (skt)—Baát to overcome all obstructions in order to achieve              HöuTöùc Boà Taùt—Coøn goïi laø Caøn Ña Ha Chuù, teân great enlightenment. In example 46 of the Wu-                 moät vò Boà Taùt, dòch laø Höông Töôïng. Vò Boà Taùt Men-Kuan: "Zen master Shih-shuang said, 'How                  naøy tu haønh trong nhieàu kieáp, khoâng ngöøng nghæ, do you step from the top of a hundred-foot pole?'             tieán boä ñeàu ñaën ñeå laøm lôïi mình vaø lôïi ngöôøi Another ancient virtue said, 'You who sit on the              khoâng bao giôø moûi meät—Name of Gandhahastin top of a hundred-foot pole, although you have                 bodhisattva, also called fragrant elephant. This entered the Way, it is not yet genuine. Take a step           Bodhisattva has cultivated for eons without ever from the top of the pole, and worlds of the Ten               stopping, making constant progress, tirelessly Directions are yours total body.'" According to Wu            benefitting self and others. Men Hui-Kai in the Wu-Men-Kuan, stepping                      Caøn Ñaø La: Gandhara (skt)—Kieän Ñaø La—Xöù forward, turning back, is there anything to reject            Kieàn Ñaø Veä—Coøn goïi laø Caøn Ñaø, Höông Bieán, as ignoble or unworthy? be that as it may, how do             Höông Haønh, Höông Khieát, Höông Tònh, vaø Kieän you step from the top of a hundred-foot pole? Sah!            Ñaø La, Kieän Ñaø La, teân moät vöông quoác coå ôû vuøng baéc AÁn Ñoä. Nôi ñaây ñaõ töøng laø vöông quoác

cuûa Dharmavardhana, con trai cuûa vua A Duïc.               Caøn Phong Ñình Chæ Ñaïi Vuõ: Kan-feâng's Vuøng ñaát naèm veà phía taây baéc mieàn Punjab cuûa         stopping pouring rain (rain cats and dogs or raining AÁn vaø Ñoâng Baéc cuûa Kashmir, nay goàm caùc mieàn         very hard)—Hoøa Thöôïng Caøn Phong, teân cuûa moät A phuù haõn vaø moät phaàn cuûa Hoài quoác, naèm doïc        vò Thieàn sö Trung Hoa vaøo thôøi nhaø Ñöôøng (618- theo soâng Kabul giöõa khoaûng Kunar vaø soâng AÁn           907). Hieän nay chuùng ta khoâng coù nhieàu taøi lieäu haø, goàm khu Peshawar vaø Rawalpindi, taây baéc             chi tieát veà Thieàn sö Can Phong; tuy nhieân, coù moät vuøng Punjab. Ñaây laø moät trong nhöõng trung taâm          chi tieát lyù thuù veà lôøi daïy cuûa oâng trong trong Nguõ lôùn cuûa vaên hoùa Phaät giaùo vaøo theá kyû thöù hai sau   Ñaêng Hoäi Nguyeân, quyeån XIII: Moät hoâm, Thieàn Taây lòch—Name of an ancient kingdom, north of               sö Can Phong thöôïng ñöôøng thò chuùng: "Möa nhö India. This was a former kingdom of                          truùt ñoå; laøm sao maáy oâng laøm cho möa taïnh ñaây?" Dharmavardhana, son of king Asoka. The region                Noùi xong, Sö xuoáng gheá vaø rôøi khoûi saûnh ñöôøng. in the extreme north-west of Punjab of India and             Kyø thaät, coù nhieàu tuyeân boá mang tính phi lyù trong northeast of Kashmir, today including southern               Thieàn. Vaøi ngöôøi coøn cho raèng Thieàn voâ lyù cöùng Afghanistan and parts of Pakistan, lies along the            nhaét vaø ñieân roà. Qua nhöõng caâu hoûi roõ raøng laø vôù Kabul river between the Kunar (Khoaspes) and                 vaån vaø khoâng hôïp lyù, Thieàn muoán chuùng ta coù the Indus rivers, comprising the district of                 ñöôïc moät quan ñieåm hoaøn toaøn môùi, ñeå deã daøng Peshawar and Rawalpindi in the northwestern                  nhìn thaáu vaøo nhöõng huyeàn dieäu cuûa ñôøi soáng vaø Punjab. Its old capital was Puskaravati. This was            bí maät cuûa thieân nhieân. Vieäc naøy laø vì Thieàn ñaõ ñi one of the greatest centers of Buddhist art and              ñeán keát luaän raèng tieán trình lyù luaän thoâng thöôøng culture during the 2nd century A.D.                          roát cuoäc khoâng coù söùc maïnh cho chuùng ta caùi thoûa Caøn Ñaø La Ñoäc Giaùc Phaät: Gandhara-Pratyeka-             maõn sau cuøng veà nhöõng nhu caàu saâu thaúm cuûa taâm Buddha (skt)—Teân cuûa moät trong moät traêm vò              linh—Most Venerable Kan-feâng, name of a Phaät ñoäc giaùc ñaõ soáng moät thôøi gian daøi treân nuùi   Chinese Zen master in the T'ang dynasty. We do Isigili—Name of one of one hundred Pratyeka-                 not have detailed documents on this Zen Master; buddhas who lived a long time on Mount Isigili.              however, there is an interesting detail on his Caøn Ñaø Leâ: Kieän Ñaø Leâ—Loaïi maät chuù cho ta           teaching on Zen in The Wudeng Huiyuan, Volume khaû naêng bay ñöôïc—A spell that gives power to             XIII: One day, Zen master Kan-feâng entered the fly.                                                         hall and addressed the monks, saying, "It is Caøn Ñaø Leâ Thaûo: Teân cuûa moät loaïi caây coù muøi       pouring now; how would you stop it?" He then got thôm, thaân maøu vaøng—Name of a fragrant tree,              off the seat and left the hall. In fact, there are and of a yellow colour.                                      many irrational statements in Zen. Some may Caøn Ñaø Ma Ñaø Ma La: Gandhamadanamala                      declare Zen irrevocably insane or silly. Through (skt)—The hill of intoxicating perfumes.                     these apparent trivialities and irrationalities, Zen Caøn Hueä: Khoâng coù trí hueä—Without wisdom.               wants us to acquire an entirely new point of view Caøn Hueä Ñòa: Sudha-vidarsana-bhumi (skt)—Giai              whereby to look into the mysteries of life and the ñoaïn ñaàu trong Thaäp Ñòa Boà Taùt Tam Thöøa, giai          secrets of nature. This is because Zen has come to ñoaïn maø trí tueä chöa ñöôïc tö nhuaän—The dry or           the definite conclusion that the ordinary logical unfertilized stage of wisdom, the first of the ten           process of reasoning is powerless to give final stages—See Thaäp Ñòa Boà Taùt Tam Thöøa.                     satisfaction to our deepest spiritual needs—See Caøn Khoân Ñoäc Boä: Ñaát trôøi rieâng böôùc, yù noùi        Kieàn Phong Vieät Chaâu Thieàn Sö. Thieàn Taêng toû ngoä khoâng coøn maûy may chaáp tröôùc      Caøn Phong Nhaát Loä: Kan-feng's One Road— nöông töïa, maø vaän duïng töï taïi voâ ngaïi —After         Moät ñöôøng cuûa Caøn Phong, thí duï thöù 41 cuûa Voâ achieving realization, Zen monks pass by                     Moân Quan. Moät oâng Taêng hoûi Hoøa Thöôïng Caøn everything in an easy manner and without any                 Phong: "Chö Baïc giaø phaïm möôøi phöông cuõng chæ obstructions.                                                moät ñöôøng nieát baøn, khoâng bieát ñaàu ñöôøng ôû ñaâu?" Caøn Laät Ñaø: See Caøn Laät Ñaø Da.                         Caøn Phong caàm gaäy vaïch moät ñöôøng noùi: "Ñaây!" Caøn Laät Ñaø Da: Hrdaya (skt)—Kieân thöïc taâm              Sau coù oâng Taêng ñem chuyeän naày hoûi ngaøi Vaân hay traùi tim beàn chaéc—Heart, soul, mind, core.            Moân. Vaân Moân caàm quaït giô leân baûo: "Quaït nhaûy

moät caùi leân taän taàng trôøi thöù ba möôi ba, goõ loã muõi        perceived or apprehended, and that which Ñeá Thích. Con lyù ngö ngoaøi bieån Ñoâng ñaùnh moät                 perceives or apprehends). heøo, trôøi möa nhö truùt." Theo Voâ Moân Hueä Khai             (B) Tam Bònh: The three ailments—Three trong Voâ Moân Quan, moät ngöôøi ñi döôùi bieån saâu,                diseases—Ba loaïi beänh: buïi bay muø mòt; moät ngöôøi ñöùng treân ñænh cao,             1) Tham: Lust—Craving—Greed—For which soùng traéng ngaát trôøi. naém ñöùng, buoâng ñi, moãi beân           the meditation on uncleanness (Quaùn thaân baát ñeàu troû ngoùn maø neâu roõ toâng phong, thaät gioáng hai           tònh) is the remedy. con ngöïa chaïy ñuïng vaøo nhau. treân ñôøi e chaúng ai         2) Saân: Anger—Hate—Ire—For which the roõñöôïc leõ ñoù. Xeùt laïi cho kyõ, caû hai oâng laõo ñeàu          meditation on kindness (töø) and pity (bi) is the khoâng bieát ñaàu ñöôøng ôû ñaâu—Kan-feng's One                      remedy. Road, example 41 of the Wu-Men-Kuan. A monk                     3) Si: Stupidity—Ignorance—Unwilling to learn asked Zen master Kan-feng, "Bhagavats in the                         the truth—For which the meditation on Ten Directions, one straight road to nirvana. I                      causality (Nhôn duyeân) is the remedy. wonder where that road is?" Kan-feng lifted up his              Caøn Phong Vieät Chaâu Thieàn Sö: Zen Master staff, drew a line in the air, and said, "Here, it is."         Qianfeng Yuezhou—See Kieàn Phong Vieät Chaâu Later a monk asked Yun-men about this. Yun-men                  Thieàn Sö. held up his fan and said, "This fan jumps up to                 Caøn Thaønh: Coøn goïi laø Caøn Thaùt Baø Thaønh, Kieän Heaven of the Thirty-three and strikes the nose of              Thaùt Baø Thaønh, Kieän Thaùt Phöôïc Thaønh, hay the deity Sakradevendra. Give a carp of the                     Nguïc Thaùt Phöôïc Thaønh (do vò nhaïc thaàn bieán hoùa Eastern sea one blow, and the rain comes down in                ra laàu gaùc cho moïi ngöôøi nhìn thaáy)—Gandharva torrents." According to Wu Men Hui-Kai in the                   city, i.e. a mirage city. Wu-Men-Kuan, one goes deep, deep to the                         Caøn Thaùt: Gandharva or Gandharva Kayikas bottom of the sea, and winnows the mud and pump                 (skt)—Teân goïi taét cuûa Caøn Thaùt Baø—See Caøn up the sand. The other goes high, high to the top of            Thaùt Baø. the mountain, and raises foaming waves that                     Caøn Thaùt Baø: Gandharva (skt)—Driza (tib)— spread over the entire sky. Maintaining, releasing,             Being who comes into the scene of conception— each using but one hand, they safeguard the                     Kieän Ñaït—1) Caøn Thaùt Baø khoâng aên thòt uoáng vehicle of the Tao. They are like two children,                 röôïu maø chæ tìm muøi thôm ñeå haáp thuï, vaø cuõng toûa running from different directions, who collide with             ra muøi thôm: Fragrance-devouring celestial each other. In this world, there is almost no one               musicians. They do not drink wine or eat meat, but who can touch the true essence. In the view of the              feed on inscense or fragrance and give off fragrant true eye, even these two ancient worthies do not                odours; 2) Nhöõng nhaïc thaàn cuûa Trôøi Ñeá Thích know the road.                                                  trong Töù Thieân Vöông: Musician Angels for the Caøn Phong Nhò Quang Tam Beänh: Lôøi thöôïng                    Cakra Heaven Kings in the Four Heaven Kings; 3) ñöôøng khai thò cuûa Thieàn sö Caøn Phong laø khi ñeán          Moät trong taùm chuùng sanh sieâu nhaân trong Kinh caûnh giôùi ngoä caàn phaûi tröø boû, thoaùt khoûi nhò          Lieân Hoa: Gandharva, one of the eight classes of quang vaø tam beänh—Zen master Kan-Feng's                       supernatural beings in the Lotus Sutra or eight instructions on realization of Zen:                             Vajra Deities—See Baùt Chuùng; 4) Moät trong taùm (A) Nhò Quang Naêng Thuû Sôû Thuû: Cognizing                    boä quyû chuùng: Gandharvas, one of the eight subject and cognized object—Muoán ñaït ñeán                groups of demon-followers of the four giaùc ngoä, Thieàn sinh phaûi baèng moïi caùch loaïi       maharajas—See Thieân Long Baùt Boä. tröø chuû theå nhaän bieát vaø ñoái töôïng ñöôïc nhaän     Caøn Thaùt Baø Thaønh: Gandharva-upama (skt)— bieát—In order to achieve realization, Zen                 Gandharva city—Mirage city—Caøn thaùt baø practitioners, by all means, must eliminate                thaønh—Coøn goïi laø Caøn Thaùt Baø Thaønh, Kieän Thaùt both cognizing subject and cognized object                 Baø Thaønh, Kieän Thaùt Phöôïc Thaønh, hay Nguïc (caùi ñöôïc nhaän thöùc hay ñöôïc hieåu, vaø caùi          Thaùt Phöôïc Thaønh (do vò nhaïc thaàn bieán hoùa ra laàu nhaän thöùc hay caùi hieåu—That which is                   gaùc cho moïi ngöôøi nhìn thaáy).

Caøn Thaùt Baø Thaønh Duï: Gandharva-upama                   Medicines that should be taken between dawn and (skt)—Syllogism on Gandharva city.                           the first watch, of which eight are name. Caøn Thaùt Baø ÖÙng Thaân: The body of                       Canh Giöõ: To guard—To watch Gandharvas—Theo Kinh Thuû Laêng Nghieâm,                     Canh Haäu Nieân: Naêm thöù tö tính töø naêm nay— quyeån Saùu, Ñöùc Quaùn Theá AÂm Boà Taùt ñaõ baïch          The fourth year counting from this year. tröôùc Phaät veà vieäc öùng thaân laøm Caøn Thaùt Baø noùi   Canh Nhaân Ñieàn Baát Chuûng, Hoøa Thuïc Baát phaùp, khieán cho chuùng sanh ñöôïc thaønh töïu—             Laâm Tröôøng: Ngöôøi caøy khoâng caáy luùa, luùa chín According to The Surangama Sutra, book Six,                  khoâng ñem phôi. Töø naày chæ cho Thieàn nhaân queân Avalokitesvara Bodhisattva vowed in front of the             ñi coäi reã nhaø mình, khoâng thaáy ñöôïc Phaät taùnh cuûa Buddha about his appearance as a gandharva                   chính mình—Farmer does not grow rice seedlings, before sentient beings and speak Dharma for                  and does not dry out the rippen rice. This term them, enabling them to accomplish their wish—                indicates Zen practitioners who forget their own See Tam Thaäp Nhò ÖÙng Thaân.                                Buddha-nature. Caøn Thaùt Baø Vöông: Vua cuûa caùc vò nhaïc Thaàn           Canh Taân: To innovate—To reform. cuûa vua trôøi Ñeá Thích—The king of Gandharvas,             Canh Thaân Hoäi: Keng-Sheng Assembly—Hoäi named Citraratha, but translated as Druma, a tree.           cuùng döôøng vaøo ñeâm Canh Thaân caàu cho quoác thaùi Caøn Thæ Quyeát: Shiketsu (jap)—Caây duøng trong             daân an, laáy Kim Cöông maët xanh döôùi hình con caùc nhaø caàu AÁn Ñoä thay cho giaáy veä sinh. Beân         khæ laøm boån toân. Ñaây laø moät nghi thöùc Laõo Giaùo, Trung Quoác ngöôøi ta duøng giaáy, rôm hay truùc—A           ñöôïc Phaät Giaùo Trung Hoa coâng nhaän nhö moät stick used in India as “toilet paper.” In China              nghi thöùc Phaät giaùo taïi ñòa phöông (môû ñaàu hoäi thì people use paper, straw, or bamboo.                          ñaùnh chuoâng khua thanh la, ca haùt xöng tuïng Phaät, Caøn Tra Baø Ni: Kanthapanini (skt)—Teân cuûa moät           chuùng hoäi vöøa ñi vöøa nieäm Phaät, moät soá thì ñaùnh loaøi quyû, thöôøng hay naõo loaïn treû con—Name of a        ñaøn thoåi saùo, suoát ñeâm khoâng nguû) —An assembly demon, usually disturbs children.                            for offerings on the night of Keâng-Sheân to an Caøn Tueä: Bare insight—Chæ coù trí tueä maø thoâi.          image in the form of a monkey, which is the Sheân Caøn Tueä Vò: Bare insight stage—Giai ñoaïn tu taäp          symbolical animal. This is a Taoist rite adopted by trong ñoù haønh giaû chæ ñeå yù tôùi trí tueä maø thoâi .    Chinese Buddhism as a local Buddhist rite. Caøng Töø Boû Chaáp Tröôùc, Ñöôøng Tu Caøng                  Canh Thieät Ñòa Nguïc: Hell of Plowing Tongues. Thaønh Coâng; Caøng Tònh Taâm, Caøng Tieán Gaàn              Canh Y: Thay ñoåi y aùo—To change robes. Ñeán Ñaïo: The more successful their cultivation is,         Caùnh Hoaït Ñòa Nguïc: Ñòa nguïc thöù nhaát trong the more detachment they achieve; the calmer                 taùm ñòa nguïc noùng—The first of the eight hot their mind becomes and the closer they are to the            hells. Way.                                                         Caùnh Nhaät: Suoát ngaøy—All day long. Canh: 1) Laàn nöõa: Again, the more; 2) Ngoâi thöù           Caùnh Phuùc Nhaät Dö Thieàn Sö: Zen master baûy trong Thaäp Thieân Can (Giaùp, AÁt, Bính, Ñinh,         Ching-fu Jih-yu—See Caûnh Phuùc Nhaät Dö Thieàn Maäu, Kyû, Canh, Taân, Nhaâm, Quyù): The seven of            Sö. the ten celestial stems; 3) Tuoåi taùc: Age; 4) Phía         Caùnh Thaønh: To succeed in finishing. taây: West; 5) Thöôûng: To reward; 6) Teân cuûa vì           Caûnh: Visaya, artha, or gocara (skt)—Nôi taâm vin sao Canh, moät trong hai möôi taùm choøm sao:                vaøo ñoù maø chaïy theo goïi laø caûnh, nhö phaùp laø nôi Punarvasu (skt): Name of one of the twenty eight             yù thöùc vin vaøo goïi laø phaùp caûnh, saéc laø nhaõn thöùc constellations.                                              vin vaøo ñoù goïi laø saéc caûnh, thanh laø nôi nhó thöùc Canh Döôïc: Phi Thôøi Döôïc—Moät trong taùm loaïi            vin vaøo goïi laø thanh caûnh, vaân vaân—A prospect, thuoác uoáng cho chö Taêng Ni, chæ uoáng töø raïng           region,        territory,      surroundings,        views, ñoâng ñeán ñaàu hoâm (nöôùc reã mai, nöôùc chuoái chín,      circumstances, environment, area, field, sphere, nöôùc taùo chua, nöôùc haït quaû Boà Ñeà, nöôùc moät loaïi   environments and conditions, i.e. the sphere of quaû ôû AÁn Ñoä gioáng nhö quaû maän, nöôùc nho, nöôùc       mind, the sphere of form for the eye, of sound for moät loaïi quaû ôû AÁn Ñoä gioáng nhö quaû taùo nhoû) —      the ear, etc.

Caûnh A-Tu-La: The host of Asuras—See A-Tu-                  soaïn naêm 1004. Taùc phaåm goàm nhöõng tieåu söû La.                                                          ngaén vaø nhöõng giai thoaïi veà cuoäc ñôøi cuûa caùc Caûnh Baát Sinh: An object has not yet arisen—               thieàn sö töø tröôùc thôøi sô toå phaùi Phaùp Nhaõn laø Trong Phaät giaùo, chöõ "caûnh" coù nhieàu nghóa, nhö        Thieàn Sö Phaùp Nhaõn Vaên Ích, bao goàm nhöõng chi quang caûnh, moâi tröôøng, laõnh vöïc, phaïm vi, ñoái        tieát veà tieåu söû cuõng nhö nhöõng lôøi giaùo huaán, vaø noù töôïng, hay kieán thöùc, vaân vaân. Thieàn Phaät giaùo       cuõng töôøng thuaät laïi moät soá coâng aùn coù aûnh höôûng döôøng nhö coù caùch duøng chöõ "caûnh" raát ñaëc bieät;     trong truyeàn thoáng. Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc thí duï nhö "caûnh baát sinh" coù nghóa laø moät kinh        goàm ba taäp, ghi laïi yù kieán cuûa hôn 600 thieàn sö vaø nghieäm ñaëc bieät cuûa Thieàn chöa ñöôïc khôûi daäy         noùi ñeán haøng ngaøn thieàn sö khaùc. Nhieàu coâng aùn trong ngöôøi ñeä töû. Nhö vaäy, "caûnh" coù nghóa laø caùi   ñöôïc tìm thaáy trong taùc phaåm naày. “Truyeàn Ñaêng kinh nghieäm hay kieán giaûi ñaëc bieät trong taâm, maø,     Luïc,” keå laïi chi tieát veà söï truyeàn coâng aùn vaø nhöõng dó nhieân coù theå ñöôïc xem nhö laø moät "ñoái töôïng"      giaûi ñaùp cuûa 52 vò toå trong truyeàn thoáng Kasyapa ñöôïc taâm quaùn töôûng hay laõnh hoäi—In Buddhism,          (doøng ñeä töû cuûa Ñöùc Phaät Thích Ca Maâu Ni) the word "object" has many meanings, such as                 truyeàn tôùi Ñaïo Nguyeân, sô toå toâng Taøo Ñoäng taïi scene, environment, domain, sphere, object,                  Nhaät Baûn. Nhöõng kinh vaên naøy giöõ vai troø chuû yeáu understanding, etc. Zen Buddhists seemed to have             trong truyeàn thoáng nhaø Thieàn, maø giaùo thuyeát vaø a special usage of this word; for instance, a realm          thöïc haønh ñeàu khaùc vôùi kinh vaên Phaät giaùo taïi AÁn has not yet arisen (ching pu sheng) means a                  Ñoä. Truyeàn thoáng Thieàn thì laïi cho raèng giaùo certain specific experience of Zen which has not             thuyeát vaø thöïc haønh cuûa hoï môùi ñích thöïc laø coát loõi yet arisen in the disciple. Thus "realm" means the           giaùo phaùp cuûa Ñöùc Phaät, ñöôïc truyeàn tröïc tieáp töø specific experience or understanding within one's            taâm qua taâm töø doøng truyeàn thöøa Kasyapa tôùi Ñaïo mind, which, of course, can be referentially                 Nguyeân, qua moät daõy caùc vò thaày. Kyø thaät, khoâng treated as an "object" visualized or comprehended            coù söï thaät veà chuyeän truyeàn thöøa naày; tuy nhieân, by the mind.                                                 moät vò thaày coù theå aán chöùng veà söï thaønh töïu giaùc Caûnh Dieäu: The subtlety of objects.                        ngoä baèng chöùng nghieäm khaû naêng cuûa ñeä töû mình. Caûnh Duy Thöùc: Caên cöù vaøo caûnh maø thuyeát veà         Taâm truyeàn taâm töø moät vò Thaày Thieàn qua söï tieáp Duy Thöùc, moät trong naêm loaïi Duy Thöùc —                 xuùc caù nhaân, chöù khoâng qua vaên töï, nhö caùch Wisdom or insight in objective conditions, one of            truyeàn Phaät Taâm trong nhaø Thieàn—Record the five kinds of wisdom or insight or idealistic            Concerning the Passing On the Lamp, composed representation in the sutras and sastras (the first          in the Ching-Te period. This is the earliest four are objective and the fifth is subjective)—See          historical work of Ch’an literature, compiled by Nguõ Chuûng Duy thöùc.                                       the Chinese monk named T'ao-Hsuan in the year Caûnh Duyeân: Arammanapaccayo (p)—Object                     1004. It consists of short biographies and condition—Ngoaïi         caûnh—Environments          and     numerous anecdotes from the lives of the early conditions.                                                  masters of Ch’an up to Fa-Yen-Wen-I, the founder Caûnh Duyeân Giaû Taïm Hôïp Roài Tan Nhö AÙnh                of the Fa-Yen school, including biographical Chôùp, Nhö AÛo Töôûng, Nhö Ma: All things come               details and teachings, and it reports a number of together and disintegrate like a lightning, an               kung an (koan) that have been influential in the illusion or a phantom.                                       tradition. This thirty-volume work, in which the Caûnh Duyeân Thaéng Dieäu: Supremely wonderful               deeds and sayings of over 600 masters are environments and conditions.                                 recorded and more than 1000 masters are Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc: Keitoku-Dento-                mentioned, is one of the most important source Roku (jap)—The Records of the Transmission of                works of Ch’an literature; many of the koans that the      Lamp—Ching-Te-Ch’uan-Teng-Lu—Caûnh                  are found in later Zen literature were fixed in Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc coù nghóa laø Bieân Nieân Söû        writing here for the first time. The Zen Records of ñöôïc truyeàn döôùi aùnh ñeøn, soaïn döôùi thôøi Caûnh       the Transmission of the Lamp,” which recounts Ñöùc. Taùc phaåm xöa nhaát trong lòch söû vaên hoï c         the transmission of the Koan and solutions of the thieàn, do nhaø sö Trung Quoác teân Ñaïo Nguyeân             fifty-two patriarchs of the tradition from Kasyapa

(a disciple of Sakyamuni Buddha) to Dogen Zenji                       of mind, the sphere of form for the eye, of (1200-1253), the founder of the Japanese Soto                         sound for the ear, etc.: Visaya, artha, or order. Such texts play a key role in the Zen                          gocara (skt). tradition, which has teachings and practices that              (II) Coù naêm caûnh giôùi—There are five realms: are at variance with what is described in Indian               1) Duïc Giôùi: Kamadhatu (skt)—The sensual Buddhist texts. The tradition claims that its                         realm or the realm of desire: Theá giôùi cuûa caùc doctrines and practices are the true core teachings                   loaøi sinh ñoäng—The world of living beings— of the Buddha, which were passed directly by                          See Duïc Giôùi. mind-to-mind transmission to Kasyapa and from                  2) Saéc Giôùi: Sô thieàn thieân, Nhò thieàn thieân, Tam him through a succession of masters. In reality,                      thieàn thieân, vaø Töù thieàn thieân—Heaven with there is no truth to transmit (transmission of the                    form (Rupadhatu (skt): First Dhyana Heaven, Heart-Seal of the Buddha Seal of mind); however,                      Second Dhyana Heaven, Third Dhyana a master can seal his pupil’s achievement of                          Heaven, and Fourth Dhyana Heaven. enlightenment by testing and approving it as true.             3) Voâ Saéc Giôùi: Khoâng voâ bieân xöù, Thöùc voâ bieân Mind-to-mind transmission, mental transmission,                       xöù, Voâ sôû höõu xöù, vaø Phi töôûng phi phi töôûng or to pass from mind to mind, from a Zen master to                    xöù—Heaven without form (Arupadhatu (skt): his disciples by personal contact without using the                   The endlessness of space, the endlessness of words. To transmit the mind of Buddha as in the                       mind, the heaven of nothingness, and Neither Intuitional school.                                                   conscious nor unconscious state of heaven. Caûnh Ñöôøng Giaùc Vieân (1244-1306): Teân cuûa                4) Tòch Dieät Ñòa: Nirodha-samapatti (skt)— moät vò Thieàn sö Trung Hoa vaøo theá kyû thöù XIII,                  Extinction—Boà Taùt hay A La Haùn— thuoäc toâng Laâm Teá, queâ ôû tænh Töù Xuyeân, Trung                 Bodhisattva or Arhat. Hoa. Vaøo naêm 1279, Sö thaùp tuøng Thieàn sö Voâ              5) Phaät ñòa hay Phaùp giôùi ñòa: Dharmadhatu- Hoïc Toå Nguyeân du haønh ñeán Nhaät Baûn ñeå tuyeân                  samapatti (skt)—Thieàn quaùn veà nguyeân lyù löu Thieàn phaùp—Name of a Chinese Zen master,                        phoå bieán, töù theá giôùi—Abstract-meditation on belonged to the Lin-chi sect. He came from Si-                        the universal principle, i.e., world. Chuan, China. In 1279, he accompanied Zen                      Caûnh Giôùi A-Tu-La: Realm of angry spirits— master Mugaku-Sogen to travel to Japan to spread               Realm of asuras (titans). Zen teachings.                                                 Caûnh Giôùi Baùt Nhaõ: Taát caû chö phaùp ñeàu laø caûnh Caûnh Giaùc: Uttras or Santras (skt)—Alertness—                giôùi cuûa Baùt Nhaõ; Baùt Nhaõ laø trí naêng duyeân, chö Introspect—Warned—Alarm.                                       phaùp laø caûnh sôû duyeân—External world prajna, or Caûnh Giaùo: Nhö tröôøng phaùi Nestor cuûa Cô Ñoác             wisdom of all things; prajna is subjective all things Giaùo—The Luminous Religion, i.e. Nestorian                    are its objective. Christianity.                                                  Caûnh Giôùi Chöùng Ngoä: Realization realm. Caûnh Giaùo Lyù Haïnh Quaû: Fivefold                           Caûnh Giôùi Cuûa Nhöõng Chuùng Sanh Giaùc Ngoä: consciousness-only—Five kinds of consciousness-                The realm of enlightened beings. only—See Nguõ Chuûng Duy thöùc.                                Caûnh Giôùi Cöïc Laïc: Chuùng sanh sanh vaøo caûnh Caûnh Giôùi: Dhatu (skt)—Laukka (skt)—Visisya                  giôùi Tònh Ñoä laø nhöõng baäc Boà Taùt thöôïng thieän, ñaõ (skt)—Realm—Sphere—Region.                                     döùt tröø taát caû chöôùng ngaïi aùc duyeân. Hôn nöõa, (I) Nghóa cuûa caûnh giôùi—The meanings of                     khoâng coù ngoaïi ñaïo taø ma neân taâm hoï thöôøng an realms: Nôi taâm vin vaøo ñoù maø chaïy theo goïi         tònh—The extreme joys in the Pure Land. Those laø caûnh, nhö phaùp laø nôi yù thöùc vin vaøo goïi laø   who are reborn in the Pure Land have the highest phaùp caûnh, saéc laø nhaõn thöùc vin vaøo ñoù goïi laø   level Bodhisattvas as their companions, and are saéc caûnh, thanh laø nôi nhó thöùc vin vaøo goïi laø     free from all obstacles, calamities and evil thanh caûnh, vaân vaân—A prospect, region,                conditions. Moreover, there are no externalists or territory, surroundings, views, circumstances,            evil demons, so their minds are always calm and environment,          area,       field,     sphere,      still. environments and conditions, i.e. the sphere

Caûnh Giôùi Cöïc Thaønh: Prasiddha (skt)—Söï thaønh              Caûnh Giôùi Ngaï Quyû: Peta-loka (p)—Realm of töïu toät cuøng—Ultimate accomplishment.                         hungry ghosts—Theá giôùi cuûa loaøi ngaï quyû, moät Caûnh Giôùi Ñôøi Soáng: Realm of life.                           trong thaäp giôùi. Trong coõi naày chuùng sanh thaân theå Caûnh Giôùi Giaùc Ngoä: The realm of                             hoâi haùm, xaáu xa, buïng to nhö caùi troáng, coå nhoû nhö enlightenment.                                                   caây kim, mieäng luoân phöïc ra löûa, khoâng aên uoáng gì Caûnh Giôùi Haønh Ñoäng Voâ Ngaïi: To be                         ñöôïc neân phaûi chòu ñoùi khaùt trong muoân ngaøn unhindered in one’s sphere of action.                            kieáp—The realm of hungry ghosts, one of the ten Caûnh Giôùi Hoan Laïc: Sugati (skt)—Bliss—                       realms or states of existence. In the realm of Blissful         realm—Blissing              world—Happy         hungry ghosts, beings have ugly and smelly bodies destinations—Happy fate—Thieän ñaïo.                             with bellies as big as drums, while their throats are Caûnh Giôùi Huyeãn: Mayavisaya (skt)—World of                    as small as needles and flames always shoot out of delusion—The realm of maya.                                      their mouth, therefore, they cannot eat or drink Caûnh Giôùi Huyeãn AÛo: Mayavisaya (skt)—World                   and       are subject to hunger and thirst for of delusion.                                                     incalculable eons. Caûnh Giôùi Höõu Dö Nieát Baøn: Saupadisesa-                     Caûnh Giôùi Nhö Lai: The realm of Tathagata. nibbanadhatu (p)—Nieát Baøn Giôùi Höõu Dö Y—Baäc                 Caûnh Giôùi Nieäm Xöù: Chaùnh nieäm treân caùc hieän A La Haùn ñaõ ñoaïn taän caùc laäu hoaëc, ñaõ thaønh töïu        töôïng—Mindfulness of the objective realm. caùc phaïm haïnh, ñaõ ñaït ñöôïc A La Haùn quaû, ñaõ ñaët        Caûnh Giôùi Nieát Baøn: Nirvana-dhatu (skt)— xong gaùnh naëng xuoáng, ñaõ ñoaïn dieät caùc höõu kieát         Abode of Nirvana—Nirvana-world—Realm of söû, baäc aáy ñaõ giaûi thoaùt nhôø hieåu bieát chaân chaùnh.    nirvana—Caûnh Giôùi Nieát Baøn—Nieát Baøn Giôùi Chính caùc caên cuûa vò aáy chöa bò huûy hoaïi neân vò           (theá giôùi Nieát Baøn)—Nieát Baøn coù theå taøng giöõ aáy caûm thoï caùc ñieàu khaû yù vaø khoâng khaû yù, vò aáy      muoân ñöùc voâ vi, nôi sanh ra caùc vieäc lôïi laïc theá caûm thoï laïc vaø khoå. Nguõ uaån vaãn coøn, chính söï taän     gian vaø xuaát theá gian, moät trong tam phaùp voâ vi. dieät tham, saân, si cuûa vò aáy ñöôïc goïi laø Nieát Baøn       Coù hai Nieát Baøn Giôùi: Dö Y vaø Höõu Dö Y—The Giôùi Höõu Dö Y. Nguõ uaån cuûa vò aáy laø do tham saân          realm of nirvana (the abode of Nirvana), or bliss, si trong quaù khöù voâ ñònh cuûa vò aáy taïo thaønh. Vò aáy      where all virtues are stored and whence all good vaãn coøn soáng neân caùc uaån cuûa vò aáy phaûi vaän            comes, one of the three dharmas of inaction. haønh. Do ñoù, vò aáy vaãn caûm thoï nhöõng thoï laïc            There are two Nibbana elements: Nibbana cuõng nhö thoï khoå maø caùc caên cuûa vò aáy löu giöõ do        element with a basis remaining, and Nibbana söï xuùc chaïm vôùi caùc traàn caûnh. Nhöng vì vò aáy ñaõ        element without a basis remaining. thoaùt khoûi söï chaáp thuû, phaân bieät vaø yù nieäm veà ngaõ   Caûnh Giôùi Phi Saéc: Arupa-bhava (skt)—Formless theå neân vò aáy khoâng bò taùc ñoäng bôûi nhöõng caûm thoï      realm—Immaterial realm. naày nöõa—An Arhat whose taints are destroyed,                   Caûnh Giôùi Phong: Caûnh giôùi cuûa coõi vaät theå höõu who has lived the life, done what was to be done,                hình—Wind of the objective realms. laid down the burden, attained Arahatship by                     Caûnh Giôùi Sôû Haønh Nhieáp: Laáy taát caû caùc caûnh stages, destroyed completely the bond of                         giôùi trôøi, ngöôøi, ma, phaïm, sa moân, baø la moân, a- becoming, one who is free through knowing                        tu-la laøm choã sôû haønh—Taking in all celestials, rightly. As his faculties have not been demolished               humans, demons, monks, priests, titans. he experiences what is agreeable and                             Caûnh Giôùi Suùc Sanh: Tirracchana (p)— disagreeable, he experiences pleasure and pain.                  Tiryagyoni (skt)—Animal realm—Thuù Ñaïo— The five aggregates remain. It is his extinction of              Caûnh thuù—Suùc Sanh—Suùc Sanh Caûnh—Phaät giaùo lust, hate and delusion, that is called the Nibbana              ñoà tin raèng caûnh thuù laø caûnh baát haïnh vaø chuùng element with a basis remaining (saupadisesa-                     sanh bò sanh vaøo caûnh thuù vì taïo nghieäp baát thieän nibbanadhatu).                                                   trong quaù khöù. Duø caûnh thuù khoâng khoå nhö ñòa Caûnh Giôùi Laïc: The joys in the Pure Land.                     nguïc, nhöng noù cuõng ñöôïc xeáp vaøo caûnh baát haïnh Caûnh Giôùi Löïc Trì: Support by the power of the                vì nôi naày khoå ñau nhieàu hôn haïnh phuùc, vaø nôi environment.                                                     naày chuùng sanh khoâng coù ñieàu kieän thuaän tieän ñeå taïo taùc coâng ñöùc thieän nghieäp—Buddhists believe

that animal realm is a woeful plane into which                xuoáng, ñaõ ñaït ñöôïc A La Haùn Quaû, ñaõ taän dieät beings may be reborn as a result of their past evil           hoaøn toaøn caùc höõu kieát söû, baäc ñaõ giaûi thoaùt nhôø kammas. Although the animal realm does not                    hieåu bieát chaân chaùnh. Moïi caûm thoï cuûa vò aáy involve as much misery as the hells, it is included           khoâng coøn öa thích, khoâng coøn thích thuù, ñaõ trôû in the woeful planes because the suffering there              neân laéng dòu. Vò aáy ñaõ chöùng ñöôïc Nieát Baøn Voâ greatly exceeds the amount of happiness, and it               Dö Y. Khi vò aáy nhaäp dieät, caùc uaån cuûa vò aáy cuõng does not provide suitable conditions for the                  ngöng vaän haønh, chuùng seõ tieâu hoaïi vaøo luùc cheát; performance of meritorious deeds.                             caùc thoï cuûa vò aáy khoâng coøn nöõa, vaø do söï taåy tröø Caûnh Giôùi Thanh Tònh: Purity of perspective.                tham saân si maø vò aáy khoâng coøn taùi sanh, ñöông Caûnh Giôùi Thieàn: The world of Zen—See Thieàn               nhieân luùc aáy söï aáp uû caùc caûm thoï cuõng khoâng coøn. Caûnh Giôùi.                                                  Vaø do ñoù, thoï cuûa vò aáy seõ trôû neân nguoäi laïnh Caûnh Giôùi Troáng Roãng: Empty space—Trong                   (sitibhavissanti)—An Arhat whose taints are Kinh Phaät Ñaûnh Toân Thaéng Ñaø La Ni, Ñöùc Phaät            destroyed, who has lived the life, done what was ñaõ daïy raèng nhöõng ai ñem chuù naày ñi vaøo nhöõng         to be done, laid down the burden, attained caûnh giôùi ñòa nguïc vaø ngaï quyû maø tuyeân löu thì laäp   Arahatship by stages, destroyed completely the töùc nhöõng nôi aáy seõ bieán thaønh nhöõng caûnh giôùi       bond of becoming, one who is free through khoâng coøn toäi nhôn, khoâng coøn ngöôøi ñeå thoï khoå—      knowing rightly. All his feelings not being In The Unisha-Vijaja- Dharani-Sutra, the Buddha               welcome, not being delighted in, will here and reminded that those who recite this dharani, when             now become cool; it is thus, that is called the entering the realms of hell and hungry ghost, read            Nibbana element without a basis remaining. or chant it, the result is all the dwellers of such           Caûnh Giôùi Voâ Ngaïi Duïng: Unimpeded function places will be liberated, and the place will                  relating to realms. immediately become completely empty.                          Caûnh Haïnh Quaû: Teân goïi chung cho ba thöù: Caûnh Giôùi Tuyeät Ñoái: Absolute realm.                      Caûnh, Haïnh vaø Quaû—A general name for views Caûnh Giôùi Töôùng: Bahyubhava (skt)—External                 (circumstances, environment), behavior (conduct world—The object perceived, or empirical world,               or manner of action), and reward. associated with function—Outside objects—                     Caûnh Huyeàn (943-1027): Taiyo Kyogen (jap)— Phenomenal world—Ngoaïi vaät (caûnh vaät beân                 Ta-yang Ching-hsuan (Wade-Giles Chinese)— ngoaøi) hay theá giôùi beân ngoaøi, coøn goïi laø Hieän       Dayang Jingxuan (Pinyin Chinese)—See Ñaïi Töôùng hay Hieän Thöùc, moät trong tam teá ñeà caäp           Döông Kænh Huyeàn Thieàn Sö. trong Ñaïi Thöøa Khôûi Tín Luaän, nghóa laø theá giôùi        Caûnh        Huoáng:         Circumstance—Situation— hieän töôïng beân ngoaøi—The external, or                     Condition. phenomenal world: The object perceived, or                    Caûnh Höng: Master Ching-Hsing—Teân cuûa moät empirical world, associated with function, the third          vò danh Taêng Trieàu Tieân vaøo theá kyû thöù VII— aspect referred to in the Awakening of Faith—See              Name of a famous Korean monk in the seventh Tam Teá.                                                      century. Caûnh Giôùi Töôûng Töôïng: Realm of                           Caûnh Khoái Töû: See Caûnh. imagination—Phaät töû khoâng bao gôø coù höùng thuù           Caûnh Luùc Nguû: Scenes dreamed during vôùi nhöõng caûnh giôùi töôûng töôïng—Buddhists are           sleeping—Dreaming scenes. never interested in the realms of imagination.                Caûnh Luùc Thöùc: Waking scenes. Caûnh Giôùi Voâ Dö Nieát Baøn: Anupadisesa (p)—               Caûnh Lyù Caàu Hình: Tìm vaät sau göông (xem thaáy Anupadisesa-nibbana-dhatu (p)—Anupadhisesa-                   boùng daùng söï vaät trong göông roài ñöa tay ra phía nirvana-dhatu (skt)—Nirvana element without a                 sau göông ñeå naém baét vaät ñoù), yù noùi laáy giaû laøm basis remaining—The realm of final nirvana                    thaät (loäng giaû thaønh chôn), chæ uoång coâng voâ ích without remainder of reincarnation.                           maø thoâi—To find things behind the mirror, this Nieát Baøn Giôùi khoâng coù Dö Y—Baäc A La Haùn ñaõ           indicates someone who fulfils what was promised ñoaïn taän caùc laäu hoaëc, ñaõ thaønh töïu caùc phaïm        in jest, only wastes the time without any result. haïnh, vieäc caàn laøm ñaõ laøm xong, ñaõ ñaët gaùnh naëng

Caûnh Meänh Nhaät: Day of king’s accession—Gaàn                thuû laø moät vieäc môùi." "Laõo Taêng thuoäc vaøo moät ñeán ngaøy nhaäm chöùc hay ñaêng quang cuûa moät vò            trong nhöõng giai caáp bò khinh bæ, coù traùn roäng." vua, nghi leã caàu nguyeän ñöôïc toå chöùc haèng thaùng        "Laõo Taêng laø tieâu chuaån cuûa caû theá giôùi." "Moät ñeå caàu phuùc lôïi cho taân vöông—The day of the              böõa aên ñaïm baïc chæ coù canh vaø côm." "Moät bao king’s accession, when services were conducted                 baïc chöùa nöôùc thôm ñaøng sau maøn theâu khieán caû monthly on that day for his welfare.                           con ñöôøng ñeàu coù muøi thôm khi noù thoåi." "Vôùi moät Caûnh Ngoä: See Caûnh Huoáng.                                  bình baùt vaø moät caây gaäy, choã naøo laõo Taêng ñeán laø Caûnh Ngöôøi: The Human Realm—See Nhôn                         nhaø cuûa laõo Taêng." "Gaët haùi vaøo muøa thu vaø gom Ñaïo.                                                          chöùa vaøo muøa ñoâng." "Moät lôøi thoát ra khoûi mieäng, Caûnh Nhai: Kyogai (jap)—Household air—House                   moät nhoùm boán ngöïa ñuoåi khoâng kòp." "Moät caây atmosphere—Gia phongTaùc phong rieâng cuûa moãi                khoâng reã treân ñænh nuùi, khoâng coù gioù thoåi, nhöng vò toå. Trong vaên hoïc Thieàn coù moät thuaä t ngöõ yù vò     haõy xem laù xaøo xaïc." "Ngay caû moät caùi naém tay laø "caûnh nhai" hay "gia phong" nghóa laø khoâng khí          giaän döõ ñöa leân cuõng khoâng ñaùnh moät ñöùa beù ñang trong nhaø, hay truyeàn thoáng gia ñình. Hai thuaät            cöôøi." "Caùi thaân naøy töø ñaàu ñeán chaân khoâng ñaùng ngöõ Nhaät Baûn "Kyogai" (Caûnh nhai) vaø "Kafu"               naêm xu." "Thaân naèm treân vuõng soùng meânh moâng; (gia phong) haàu nhö noùi leân cuøng moät yù nieäm:            nhìn ngöôøi caàm ñuoác giöõa ban ngaøy." "Dóa chaùo caûnh nhai coù moät haøm yù chuû quan vaø taâm lyù hôn,        buoåi saùng vaø baùt côm buoåi tröa." "Trong beáp trong khi gia phong coù tính caùch lòch söû vaø coù theå       khoâng coøn côm dö cho ngöôøi khaùch." "Con gaø laøm ñöôïc quan nieäm nhö laø moät thöù khoâng khí hieän            baèng buøn, con choù laøm baèng gaïch." "Hoa quyù caùch haønh trong moät coäng ñoàng. Trong lòch söû nhaø              maáy roài cuõng heùo, coû daïi daàu bò khinh khi chaø ñaïp Thieàn, caùc caâu hoûi thöôøng laø veà caùi "khoâng khí        ñeán ñaâu roài cuõng luoân moïc leân laïi." "Tay aùo ngaén taâm linh" trong ñoù vò Thieàn sö ñang di chuyeån, hay         quaù, loä ra caùnh tay traàn truïi." "Nhaøo loän voøng voøng thaùi ñoä hay phaûn öùng taâm lyù chung tieâu bieåu cho vò     maõi." "Con coùc ba chaân coõng con voi khoång loà treân thieàn sö ñuùng nghóa. Nhöõng caâu hoûi naøy hoûi veà          löng." Nhöõng caâu trích daãn naøy ñuû cho chuùng ta giaùo lyù caên baûn cuûa Thieàn, bôûi vì khi chuùng ta bieát   thaáy nôi choán cuûa thieàn sö, nghóa laø vò thieàn sö nôi choán cuûa Thieàn sö, chuùng ta cuõng bieát ñöôïc          soáng trong gia phong naøo. Daàu nhöõng ñoaïn vaên cuoái cuøng Thieàn muoán ñöa chuùng ta ñeán ñaâu.              naøy coù veû bí hieåm ñeán ñaâu ñi nöõa, ñieåm chính yeáu Trong kinh ñieån nhöõng töø ngöõ nhö caûnh giôùi               cuûa chuùng ñöôïc goïi trong töø ngöõ chuyeân moân laø (gocara, kyogai), tinh xaù (vihara, shoâja), hay               "nhöõng haønh ñoäng phi muïc ñích" hay "moät ñôøi sthana ñöôïc duøng ñeå chæ “phaïm vi cho suùc vaät”            soáng phi noã löïc," hay trong Phaïn ngöõ laø hay “ñoàng coû cho suùc vaät,” laø moät phaïm vi cho           "Anabhoga-carya." Taát caû caùc kinh ñieån Ñaïi thöøa haønh ñoäng vaø ñoái töôïng cuûa giaùc quan. Trong Kinh        ñeàu coi vieäc ñaït ñeán "moät ñôøi soáng phi noã löïc" naøy Laêng Giaø, Gocara coù nghóa laø moät thaùi ñoä taâm linh      coù taàm quan troïng lôùn lao nhaát. Nhöõng ñoùa hoa chung maø ngöôøi ta coù ñoái vôùi theá giôùi beân ngoaøi,      hueä ngoaøi ñoàng soáng vôùi lyù töôûng naø y, cuõng nhö hay ñuùng hôn laø moät khung caûnh taâm linh maø söï           caùc nhaø laõnh ñaïo tinh thaàn vó ñaïi nhaát cuûa theá giôùi hieän höõu cuûa con ngöôøi ñöôïc bao boïc trong ñoù.           naøy. Vaø taát caû caùc "Ñaïi Nguyeän" cuûa chö Boà Taùt Trong Thieàn, nhöõng töø naøy ñeàu coù chung moät khaùi        ñeàu phaùt sinh töø ñoù; nguyeän cuûa Boà Taùt khoâng nieäm. Theo Thieàn sö D.T. Suzuki trong quyeån "Söï            phaûi laø nguyeän trong yù nghó thoâng thöôøng cuûa töø Huaán Luyeän cuûa moät Thieàn Taêng Phaät Giaùo,"              naøy—Individual style of each patriarch. In Zen nhöõng caâu traû lôøi sau ñaây cuûa nhieàu vò thieàn sö        literature there is an expressive term called trích ra moät caùch ngaãu nhieân töø caùc nieân giaùm cuûa     "household air," or "house atmosphere," or Thieàn seõ giuùp chuùng ta ñoaùn ra muïc tieâu cuoái cuøng     "family tradition." Two Japanese terms of cuûa ñôøi soáng Thieàn ñöôøng vaø cuûa pheùp tu taäp coâng     "Kyogai" and "Kafu" express practically the same aùn: "Vöôøn khoâ quaù, haõy töôùi rau deàn ñi." "Traêng        idea: "Kyogai" has a more subjective and moïc leân töø bieån, aùnh saùng chieáu roäng xa." "Trôøi       psychological connotation, while "Kafu" is xanh vaø aùnh saùng ban ngaøy." "Gioù xuaân vaãn coøn          historical and may be conceived as a kind of thoåi laïnh vaøo maët laõo Taêng; laõo Taêng khoâng hieåu      atmosphere prevailing in a given community. In aùnh traêng saùng röïc kia ñeå cho ai." "Moãi laàn ñoäng       the history of Zen, questions frequently concern

this "spiritual atmosphere" in which the master is     flowers soon wither away; however, despised and moving, or the general psychological attitude or       down-trodden weeds never cease to grow." "The reaction characterizing a Zen master as such.          sleeves being too short, the arms are bare." These questions amount to asking about the             "Tumbling over again and again." "The three- fundamental teaching of Zen, for when we know          legged toad carries an enormous elephant on its where the master's abode is, we know also where        back." According to Zen master Daisetz Teitaro Zen finally purports to lead us. In the sutras, such   Suzuki in "The Training of the Zen Buddhist Monk words as "gocara," "vihara," or "sthana" are used      (p.118)," these quotations are enough to show to denote experience, mental attitude. Gocara          where is the abode of the Zen master, that is, in literally means “a range for cattle,” or “a            what "household air" he is living. However pasturage,” is a field for action and an object of     enigmatically these passages may appear, their sense. In the Lankavatara Sutra, it means a            fundamental keynote is what is technically called general attitude one assumes toward the external       "deeds of no purpose" or "a life of effortlessness," world, or a better spiritual atmosphere in which       or in Sanskrit "Anabhoga." All the Mahayana one’s being is enveloped. In Zen, these terms          sutras give the greatest significance to the denote the same conception. According to Zen           attainment of this "life of no-purposiveness." The master Daisetz Teitaro Suzuki in "The Training of      lilies of the field are living it, so are all the the Zen Buddhist Monk (p.118)," the following          greatest spiritual leaders of the world. And all the answers given by various masters as culled at          "Great Vows" of the Bodhisattva grow out of it; random from the annals of Zen will help us to          his vows a re no vows in the ordinary sense of the surmise where is the final destination of the Zendo    word. life and of the koan exercise: "The garden is          Caûnh Nhaøn (1298-1374): Master Ching-Hsien— terribly dry; have the spinach well water." "The       Teân cuûa moät vò danh Taêng Trieàu Tieân vaøo theá kyû moon is rising from the ocean and its rays reach       thöù XIV—Name of a famous Korean monk in the far and wide." "The blue sky and the broad             fourteenth century. daylight." "The spring breeze is still blowing cold    Caûnh Nuùi Non Vaéng Veû: Mountaineous against my face; I wonder for whom is this             wilderness. brightly shining moonlight." "Each time it is held     Caûnh Phong: Caûnh nhö gioù hay laøm taâm ñoäng. up it is a new thing." "I belong to one of the         Tuy nhieân, trong nhaø Thieàn thì Phöôùn Ñoäng, Gioù despised classes, whose forehead is broad." "I am      Ñoäng Hay Taâm Ñoäng? Luïc toå Hueä Naêng ñaõ khaúng the standard of all the world." "A simple meal of      ñònh vôùi caùc vò sö ñang caûi coï tröôùc tu vieän Phaùp rice and soup." "A silver bag of perfume behind        Taâm raèng: “Chaúng phaûi phöôùn ñoäng, cuõng chaúng the brocade screen makes the whole avenue              phaûi gioù ñoäng, maø laø taâm cuûa maáy oâng ñoäng.”— odorous as it blows." "With one bowl and one           The wind moving usually causes our minds staff, I make my home wherever I go."                  moving. However, in Zen, the question for Zen "Harvesting in autumn and garnering in winter."        practitioners is that the flag moving, the wind "One word out of the mouth and even a team of          moving, or our minds moving? Several monks was four horses cannot overtake it." "A rootless plant     arguing back and forth about the flag and the at the top of the mountain; no wind is blowing, but    wind without reaching the truth in front of the Fa see how the leaves sway." "Even a fist angrily         Hsin monastery in Kuang Chou. The sixth lifted would not strike the smiling baby." "This       patriarch, Hui-Neng, said to them: “It is not the body from head to toe is not worth five cents."        wind moving, neither the flag moving. It is your "The body is lying on the vast expanse of waves;       own minds that are moving." see the man carrying a torch in the broad              Caûnh Phuùc Nhaät Dö Thieàn Sö: Zen master daylight." "A dish of gruel in the morning and rice    Ching-fu Jih-yu—Coù moät vò taêng hoûi thieàn sö for noon." "There is in the kitchen no extra meal      Caùnh Phuùc Nhaät Dö: "Theá naøo laø yù Toå sö töø Taây for a visitor." "The cock made of mud, the dog         sang?" Caùnh Phuùc Nhaät Dö ñaùp: "Traûi qua chín made of brick." "However lovingly cherished            naêm dieän bích maø khoâng ai nhaän bieát ngaøi, nhöng

khi ngaøi xaùch deùp trôû veà Taây Truùc thì ñaâu ñaâu         This is the case in which answers are indicated cuõng nghe bieát." Khi ñöôïc yeâu caàu noùi theâm ñeå          more or less directly concerned with the person of laøm saùng toû yù nghóa cuûa caâu traû lôøi, Sö noùi: "Neáu    the Patriarch himself with assertions which are coù ai muoán bieát veà vieäc xaûy ra trong nieân ñaïi Phoå     made about his doings. However, the answers still thoâng xa xöa, khoâng caàn phaûi naém ñöôïc tin töùc veà       do not touch the central point of the question; that daõy nuùi Thoâng Lónh." Ñaây laø tröôøng hôïp trong ñoù        is, "the meaning of the patriarchal visit to China" caâu traû lôøi ñöôïc nhaém ngay vaøo haønh traïng cuûa         is not explained in any way that we of plain minds chính Toå sö, vôùi nhöõng ñoan quyeát troû vaøo caùc           would like, for Ching-fu Jih-yu's further haønh vi cuûa ngaøi. Tuy nhieân, caâu traû lôøi naøy vaãn      explanation is simply a narration of the deeds of khoâng ñuïng tôùi taâm ñieåm cuûa caâu hoûi; ñoù laø "yù       Bodhidharma on his way back to India. This is nghóa Ñoâng du cuûa Toå" ñöôïc caét nghóa ñeå laøm             where Zen is difficult to understand by the thoûa maõn taâm trí bình thöôøng cuûa chuùng ta, vì söï        ordinary way of thinking. Mere words are giaûi thích theâm cuûa thieàn sö Caùnh Phuùc Nhaät Dö          insufficient to convey the meaning, but as rational chæ laø söï töôøng thuaät veà haønh traïng cuûa Boà Ñeà Ñaït   beings we cannot avoid making statements. And Ma treân ñöôøng trôû veà Taây Truùc maø thoâi. Töôûng          these statements are at once puzzling and cuõng nhaán maïnh ôû ñaây, Thoâng Lónh laø teân cuûa moät      illuminating according to our own insight. daõy nuùi phaân chia Trung Hoa vôùi vuøng Trung AÙ             Caûnh Quaùn Baát Nhò: Caûnh sôû quaùn vaø taâm naêng maø truyeàn thuyeát noùi Toå Boà Ñeà Ñaït Ma ñaõ ñi            quaùn dung hôïp khoâng hai—Object of ngang qua ñaây treân ñöôøng trôû veà AÁn Ñoä. Ngaøi ñaõ        contemplation and the mind that is contemplating ñi baèng chaân khoâng, vì tay ngaøi xaùch moät chieác          are not two. deùp. Coøn chieác kia; khi tin ngaøi trôû veà qua nuùi         Caûnh Quaùn Töông Tö: Three insights in one Thoâng Lónh ñöôïc loan truyeàn roäng raõi giöõa caùc           thought—Khoâng, Trung vaø Giaû chæ do caùi nhìn cuûa moân ñeä cuûa ngaøi taïi trung Hoa, ngöôøi ta quaät moà        taâm maø thoâi—The simultaneous vision of past, ngaøi leân, thaáy noù vaãn coøn ñoù. Ñaây chính laø choã       present and future—The void, the “mean,” and the khoù hieåu cuûa Thieàn ñoái vôùi leà loái suy nghó thoâng      seeming, are all aspects of the one mind. thöôøng. Chæ baèng danh töï khoâng ñuû chuyeån taûi yù         Caûnh Saùch: See Caûnh Saùch Boång. nghóa, nhöng ñaõ laø sinh vaät coù lyù trí, chuùng ta          Caûnh Saùch Boång: Keisaku (jap)—Staff of khoâng laøm sao traùnh khoâng phaùt bieåu baèng danh           admonition—Roi duøng ngaên chaän côn buoàn nguû töï. Vaø nhöõng phaùt bieåu naøy mô hoà hay saùng suûa,        cuûa chö Taêng Ni trong luùc ngoài thieàn trong thieàn coøn tuøy theo sôû kieán cuûa rieâng chuùng ta—A monk          ñöôøng (roi daøi 4 thöôùc 2 taác, coù ñaàu meàm, keû bò asked Ching-fu Jih-yu, "What is the meaning of                 ñaùnh phaûi cuùi ñaàu taï toäi). Neáu tu taäp thieàn ñònh the Patriarch's coming from the West?" Ching-fu                lieân heä ñeán pheùp tu taäp coâng aùn thì khoâng gioáng Jih-yu said, "Nobody knew him when he spent                    vôùi caùch ñaøo luyeän taâm linh thoâng thöôøng, bôûi vì nine years gazing at the wall, but he was heard all            haønh giaû phaûi taäp trung quaù nhieàu naêng löïc taâm over when he returned west with one shoe in his                linh trong vieäc giaûi quyeát coâng aùn, phöông dieän hand." When the master was asked to say                        theå chaát cuûa ñôøi soáng chuùng ta cuõng traûi qua moät something further about the answer, he said, "If               aùp löïc raát lôùn; vaø keát quaû laø caùc baép thòt bò co ruùt one wants to know about the event in the remote                vaø thaàn kinh bò caêng thaúng quaù ñoä. Ñeå giuùp thieàn era of P'u-tung, it is not necessary to get an                 sinh vöôït qua söï ueå oaûi naøy, ngöôøi ta ñaùnh leân vai intelligence on the T'sung-ling range." It should be           cuûa hoï baèng moät caùi gaäy goïi laø "Caûnh Saùch Boång," emphasized here that the T'sung-ling is a range of             coù nghóa laø caây gaäy caûnh tænh. Chieác gaäy naøy cuõng mountains dividing China from central Asia, which              ñöôïc duøng ñeå giuùp cho vò Taêng khoûi nguû guïc trong Bodhidharma is reported to have crossed on his                 luùc ngoài thieàn. Trong nhöõng giôø toïa thieàn dieãn ra, way back to India. He was then bare-footed and                 moät vò Taêng vôùi chieác gaäy caûnh tænh ñöùng ôû cuoái carried one of his shoes in his hand while the other           moãi ñaøn, canh chöøng kyõ caøng caùc sö huynh ñeä cuûa was found in his grave, which was opened when                  mình—A staff or cane to awaken sleepers during the report of his return over the T'sung-ling range            an assembly for meditation. If the meditation got widely known among his Chinese followers.                  practice is in connection with the koan exercise, it

is not the same ordinary mental training, because            T’ai Chih-I tried to invite him so many times to so much psychic energy is concentrated on the                come to teach the Dharma for his disciples, but he "lifting up" of the koan, the physical side of our           kindly refused all the invitations. existence also undergoes great pressure; and the             Caûnh Thuù: The Animal Realm—See Thuù Ñaïo. result is that the muscles become cramped and the            Caûnh Tænh: To disilussion. nerves too taut. To relieve the monk of this kind of         Caûnh Traïng: See Caûnh huoáng. discomfort, his shoulders are frequently slapped             Caûnh Trí: Landscape—Sight—View—Caûnh hay with a stick called "Staff of admonition"                    coøn goïi laø lyù sôû quaùn; trí hay coøn goïi laø taâm naêng (Keisaku). This staff is also used to prevent a              quaùn—The objective world and the subjective monk from falling asleep while sitting in                    mind, or knowledge of the objective sphere. meditation. While the zazen hours are on, a monk             Caûnh Trong Chieâm Bao: See Caûnh Luùc Nguû. with the "staff of admonition" stands at the end of          Caûnh Trung Höõu Thuûy: In the reality of either meditation platform, keeping a close watch            circumstances there is water, and in the reality of on his brother-monks.                                        water there are circumstances—Trong caûnh coù Caûnh Saàm Thieàn Sö: Ching Chen (chi)—Chosha                nöôùc—See Kyochusui. Keijin (jap)—Chosa Shin (jap)—Zen master                     Caûnh Trung Töôïng Duï: Pratibhasa-upama Ching Chen Chang Sha (Jincen Changsha)—See                   (skt)—AÛnh Duï—Thí duï chæ chö phaùp gioáng nhö Tröôøng Sa Caûnh Saàm Thieàn Sö.                             hình boùng—Simile on Image, that all dharmas Caûnh Sôû Duyeân: Rasarammana (skt)—Object of                bear a resemblance to a shadow or a reflection. flavor.                                                      Caûnh Töôøng (1062-1132): Zen Master Ching- Caûnh Sôn Quoác Nhaát Thieàn Sö: Zen master                  Hsiang—Teân cuûa moät vò Thieàn sö Trung Hoa vaøo Kuo-i Ching-shan—See Quoác Nhaát Caûnh Sôn                   theá kyû thöù möôøi hai. Hieän nay chuùng ta khoâng coù Thieàn Sö.                                                   nhieàu taøi lieäu chi tieát veà Thieàn sö Caûnh Töôøng; tuy Caûnh Tam Muoäi: See Ñònh.                                   nhieân, theo Nguõ Ñaêng Hoäi Nguyeân, quyeån III thì Caûnh Thanh Ñaïo Phoù: Ching-ch'ing Tao-fu—See               Sö ñeán töø Giang Taây, xuaát gia vôùi toâng Laâm Teá. Kính Thanh Ñaïo Phoù Thieàn Sö.                              Luùc ñaàu Sö aån cö ôû Laâm Xuyeân hôn 10 naêm. Ñeán Caûnh Thanh Thoát Traùc Cô: Ching-ch'ing's Man               naêm 1116, sö truï ôû nuùi Baûo Phong vaø taïi ñaây coù in the Weeds—See Kính Thanh Ñaïo Phoù.                       treân 5.000 ngöôøi theo hoïc Thieàn vôùi Sö—Zen Caûnh Thieàu (508-583): Master Ching-Shao—Teân               Master Ching-Hsiang, name of a Chinese Zen cuûa moät vò Taêng Trung Hoa vaøo theá kyû thöù saùu.        monk in the twelfth century. We do not have Hieän nay chuùng ta khoâng coù nhieàu taøi lieäu chi tieát   detailed documents on this Zen Master; however, veà Sö Caûnh Thieàu; tuy nhieân, theo boä Tuøy Thieân        according to Wudeng Huiyuan, volume III, he was Thai Trí Giaû Ñaïi Sö Bieät Truyeän, Sö ñeán töø Chieát      from Jiang-Hsi Province and joined the Lin-Chi Giang, naêm 15 tuoåi xuaát gia. Naêm 23 tuoåi Sö baét        sect. First, he lived in seclusion for more than ten ñaàu giaûng Kinh Ñaïi Phaåm Baùt Nhaõ. Naêm 563, Sö          years. In 1116, he came to live on Mount Pao- ñöôïc thænh veà truï trì chuøa Baïch Maõ ôû Döông Ñoâ.       Feâng, where there were over five thousand Nhieàu laàn Thieân Thai Trí Giaû Ñaïi Sö thænh Sö            disciples studied Zen under him. giaûng kinh luaän cho ñoà chuùng toâng Thieân Thai,          Caûnh Töôïng: Sight—Occurrence. nhöng Sö ñeàu nhaõ nhaën töø choái taát caû nhöõng lôøi      Caûnh Töôïng Kyø Laï: Wondrous sights. thænh caàu—Master Ching-Shao, name of a                      Caïnh: Caïnh tranh hay kình choáng nhau—To Chinese monk in the sixth century. We do not                 wrangle—To emulate. have detailed documents on this Master; however,             Caïnh Ñaàu: Nhoän nhòp—Bustling. according to Great Master T’ien-T’ai Chih-I's                Caïnh Giaø: Ganga (skt)—Haèng Haø—The Ganges. Special Stories, master Ching-Shao was from Che-             Caïnh Giaø Haø Moân: Gangadvara (skt)—Cöûa soâng Jiang Province and joined the Sangha at the age of           Haèng. Theo Eitel trong Trung Anh Phaät Hoïc Töø fifteen. He started to preach the Mahaprajna-                Ñieån thì ñaây laø moät nôi haønh höông noåi tieáng, baây Paramita Sutra. In 563, he was invited to dwell at           giôø laø Hurdwar hay Haridwar—The gate of the Pai-Ma Temple in Yang-tu. Great Master T’ien-                Ganges. According to Eitel in The Dictionary of

Chinese-English Buddhist Terms, this is a famous              Cao Löông Myõ Vò: Rich and tasty foods—Gaïo devalaya, the object of pilgrimages, the                      traéng thôm ngon vaø nhöõng ñoà aên ngon boå. present Hurdwar, or Haridwar.                                 Cao Löu: Haøng só phu cao thöôïng—Noble feudal Caïnh Toàn: Struggle for existence.                           intellectuals. Caïnh Tranh: To compete—To contend.                           Cao Ly Taïng: Korean canon of Buddhism—Cao Cao: Cao vuùt: Eminent—Lofty; Chieàu cao:                     Ly Taïng (taïng kinh ñieån cuûa Cao Ly)—Boä ñaïi High—Tall; Môõ loaõng: Fat—Oil—Unguent.                       taïng Cao Ly, moät trong ba taïng sö taäp hieän vaãn Cao An Ñaïi Ngu Thieàn Sö: Koan Daigu (jap)—                  coøn ñaày ñuû taïi chuøa Haûi AÁn vôùi 1.521 boä vaø 6.589 Kao-an Ta-yu (Wade-Giles Chinese)—Gaoan                       quyeån—One of the three collections which still Dayu (Pinyin Chinese)—Teân cuûa moät vò sö truï trì           exists in the “Ocean Seal” Temple with 1,521 sets töï vieän Ñaïi Ngu mang danh hieäu cuûa Maõ Toå cuûa          and 6,589 volumes. Thieàn phaùi Qui Toâng, ngöôøi cuõng ñaõ töøng truï trì ôû    Cao Minh: Lofty and intelligent. ñoù—Name of a monk who resided at Ta-Yu                       Cao Moân: 1) Phaùp moân cao tuyeät: A noble monastery. The monastery was named after of its               dharma door; 2) Tröôøng phaùi cao tuyeät: A noble patriarch Ma-Tsu of the Zen or Intuitive school.              sect. Cao Bieän (1173-1232): Koben (jap)—Vò sö Nhaät                Cao Nam Thuaän Thöù Lang (1866-1945): Junjiro Baûn chuyeân tu theo toâng Hoa Nghieâm —A                     Takakusu—Hoïc giaû Phaät giaùo ngöôøi Nhaät—Moät Japanese monk who purely practiced Kegon.                     trong nhöõng hoïc giaû Phaät giaùo ngöôøi Nhaät raát noåi Cao Cöôøng: Superior.                                         tieáng. OÂng keá nghieäp Nanjio taïi tröôøng Ñaïi Hoïc Cao Danh: Great reputation.                                   Ñoâng Kinh. OÂng cuõng theo hoïc vôùi giaùo sö Max Cao Daät: Vò aån só cao thöôïng—A noble recluse.              Muller taïi Oxford. Khi trôû veà Nhaät, oâng daïy veà Cao Ñaøi: Caodaism.                                           Vaên Hoïc Phaïn vaø Trieát Hoïc AÁn Ñoä taïi Ñaïi Hoïc Cao Ñaøm Huøng Bieän: Ready-wit—To speak                      Ñoâng Kinh. OÂng vieát nhieàu baøi baèng tieáng Anh vaø eloquently—Thuyeát noùi khoâng ngaên ngaïi hay                caùc thöù tieáng khaùc, do ñoù trôû thaønh noåi tieáng ôû haûi ngaèn meù—Power of unhindered discourse (perfect              ngoaïi. OÂng ñaõ cho xuaát baûn caùc boä saùch quan freedom of speech or debate).                                 troïng sau ñaây: Quaùn Voâ Löôïng Thoï Kinh, baûn dòch Cao Ñaúng: Higher.                                            tieáng Anh 1894; Ghi Nhaän Veà Phaät Giaùo taïi AÁn Cao Ñeá: Kunti (skt)—Who is associated with                   Ñoä vaø Quaàn Ñaûo Maõ Lai (671-695) nguyeân taùc Avalokitesvara (Quaùn AÂm)—See Cao Ñeá La Saùt                cuûa Nghóa Tònh, baûn dòch tieáng Anh naêm 1896; Nöõ.                                                          Cuoäc Ñôøi Ngaøi Theá Thaân, do Chaân Ñeá vieát, baûn Cao Ñeá La Saùt Nöõ: Kunti (skt)—Haø Sôû La Saùt              dòch tieáng Anh 1904; Kieän Thieän Luaät, hôïp taùc vôùi Nöõ—Teân cuûa moät trong möôøi loaøi la saùt nöõ ñöôïc        M. Nagai vieát töø naêm 1924 ñeán naêm 1938; vaø Tinh noùi ñeán trong kinh Phaùp Hoa, vò coù lieân heä tôùi ngaøi   Yeáu Trieát Hoïc Phaät Giaùo, nhöõng baøi giaûng taïi Ñaïi Quaùn Theá AÂm Boà Taùt—Name of one of ten                    Hoïc Ñöôøng Hawaii, Myõ quoác naêm 1947. OÂng coøn Raksasi (female demon) mentioned in the Lotus                 laø chuû bieân boä Ñaïi Chính Taân Tu Ñaïi Taïng Kinh, sutra, who is associated with Avalokitesvara.                 aán baûn Taisho cuûa Tam Taïng. OÂng vöøa laø moät Cao Ñeä: An able student—Ngöôøi hoïc troø xuaát saéc          giaùo sö gioûi, vöøa laø moät hoïc giaû uyeân baùc. Trong ñöôïc Thaày öng yù nhaát—An outstanding student               soá caùc nhaø nghieân cöùu veà AÁn Ñoä laøm vieäc döôùi söï who pleases the master the most.                              höôùng daãn cuûa oâng taïi tröôøng Ñaïi Hoïc Ñoâng Kinh Cao Ñoà: See Cao Ñeä.                                         coù Tieán Só H. Ui vaø giaùo sö E. Kanakura, chuyeân Cao Giaû Baát Thuyeát, Thuyeát Giaû Baát Cao:                 veà trieát hoïc AÁn Ñoä; coá giaùo sö T. Kimura, Tieán Só Ngöôøi taøi cao hôn ngöôøi thì ít noùi. Ngöôïc laïi,          S. Miyamoto vaø giaùo sö Hanayama chuyeân veà ngöôøi keùm coûi thöôøng hay noùi—Talented people             Phaät giaùo; Tieán Só M. nagai nghieân cöùu chuû yeáu are not boastful. Who know speak not, who speak               veà vaên hoïc Pali vaø giaùo sö N. Tsuji nghieân cöùu veà know naught.                                                  vaên hoïc Veä Ñaø vaø Phaïn. Takakusu cuõng laäp ra moät tröôøng Cao Ñaúng Nöõ taïi Ñoâng Kinh, taïi ñaây Cao Khieát: Incorruptible. vieäc daïy veà ñaïo Phaät chieám moät vò trí quan Cao Kieán: Kieán thöùc roäng—Great knowledge. troïng—One of the famous Japanese Buddhist

scholars. He succeeded B. Nanjio at Tokyo               theá kyû thöù XIII, thuoäc toâng Laâm Teá. Sö sanh naêm University. He also studied at Oxford under Max         1241 vaø thò tòch naêm 1316. Nhöng theo vaøi nguoàn Muller. On his return to Japan, he became               khaùc thì noùi Sö sanh naêm 1235 vaø thò tòch naêm professor of Sanskrit literature and Indian             1308. Sö xuaát gia naêm 16 tuoåi. Sö laø thaày cuûa philosophy at Tokyo University. He wrote many           Thieàn sö Moäng Sôn Sô Thaïch—Name of a articles in English and other languages which           Japanese Zen master in the thirteenth century, made him famous abroad. He published the                belonged to the Rinzai School. He was born in following important works: The Amitayurdhyana-          1241 and passed away in 1316. But according to sutra (1894); A Record of the Buddhist Religion as      some other sources, he was born in 1235 and died Practiced in India and the Malay Archipelago by I-      in 1308. He left home at the age sixteen. He was Tsing (English translation in 1896); The Life of        the master of Zen master Muso-Kokushi—See Vasubandhu by Paramartha (English translation in        Moäng Sôn Sô Thaïch Thieàn Sö. 1904); the Samanata-pasadika (edition in                Cao Phong Nguyeân Dieäu Thieàn Sö (1238-1295): collaboration with M. Nagai 1924-1938); anf The         Kao-Feng-Yuan-Miao—Thieàn sö Cao Phong Essentials of Buddhist Philosophy (Lectures at          Nguyeân Dieäu, coøn goïi laø Cao Phong Dieäu Toå— Hawaii University, U.S.A. in 1947). He was also         Zen Master Kao-Feng-Yuan-Miao, also called the chief editor of Taisho-Shin-Shu Daizokyo (the       Kao-Feng Miao-Tsu—Theo Thieàn Sö D.T. Suzuki Taisho edition of the Tripitaka). He was both a         trong Thieàn Luaän, Taäp II, Thieàn Sö Trung Hoa, great teacher and a great scholar. Among the            thuoäc toâng Laâm Teá, soáng vaøo thôøi Nam Toáng beân many Indologists who worked under his guidance          Trung Hoa (1127-1279)—According to Zen master at Tokyo University were Dr. H. Ui and professor        D.T. Suzuki in the Essays in Buddhism, Book II, E. Kanakura who specialized in Indian                   Kao-Feng-Yuan-Miao, a Chinese Zen Master in philosophy; the late professor Kimura, Dr. S.           the thirteenth century, who lived during the South Miyamoto and Prof. S. Hanayama who worked on            Sung Dynasty in China. Buddhism; Dr. M. Nagai who was primarily                 Cao Phong Dieäu Toå laø moät ñaïi sö cuoái ñôøi nhaø interested in Pali literature and Prof. N. Tsuji who         Toáng. Khi sö phuï ngaøi laàn ñaàu trao cho ngaøi studied Vedic and Sanskrit literature. Takakusu              coâng aùn chöõ “Voâ” cuûa Trieäu Chaâu ñeå tham also founded a Women’s College in Tokyo, where               quaùn, ngaøi chuyeån heát khí löïc bình sanh vaøo the study of Buddhism occupied a prominent                   ñeà aùn. Ngaøy kia, baát thaàn sö phuï hoûi: “Ai place.                                                       mang cho oâng caùi thaân voâ tri giaùc aáy?” Ngaøi Cao Ngoân Ñaïi Trí: Söï aên noùi thoâng suoát vaø trí        khöïng, khoâng bieát sao maø thöa thoát, maø thaày hueä cao thaâm—Great eloquence and much                      ngaøi thì khaéc nghieät, thöôøng laø hoûi ñaâu thì wisdom.                                                      ñaùnh ñoù. Sau ñoù, luùc nöûa ñeâm khi ñang nguû, Cao Nhaøn: Master Kao-Hsien—Teân cuûa moät vò                Sö söïc nhôù tröôùc kia thaày cuõ coù giao cho sö Taêng Trung Hoa vaøo thôøi nhaø Ñöôøng (618-907)—            tìm ra dieäu nghóa caâu noùi ‘Muoân vaät trôû veà Name of a Chinese monk during the T'ang                      moät.’ Theá laø suoát ñeâm aáy vaø maáy ñeâm sau, Sö dynasty.                                                     khoâng sao ngoài yeân hay chôïp maét ñöôïc, trong Cao Phaåm: Phaåm caùch cao quí—Noble character.              taâm thaàn caêng thaúng cöïc ñoä aáy. Ngaøy kia sö Cao Phaät Ñaûnh: Usnisavyaya (skt)—Vijaya                    baát chôït thaáy mình ñang ñoïc baøi thô cuûa Nguõ (skt)—Phaùt Sanh Phaät Ñaûnh—Quaûng Sanh Phaät               Toå Phaùp Dieãn vieát treân chaân dung cuûa Toå, Ñaûnh—Toái Thaéng Kim Luaân Phaät Ñaûnh—See Toái             trong ñoù coù caâu: Thaéng Phaät Ñaûnh.                                                "Traêm naêm, ba vaïn saùu ngaøn ngaøy Cao Phong: Phong thaùi cao quí—Noble behavior.                      Laõo haùn aáy luoân luoân cöû ñoäng." Cao Phong Dieäu Toå: See Cao Phong Nguyeân                   Theá laø nhöõng thaéc maéc cuûa sö veà caâu hoûi ‘Ai Dieäu Thieàn Sö.                                             mang cho oâng caùi thaân voâ tri giaùc aáy?’ phuùt Cao Phong Hieån Nhaät Thieàn Sö (1241-1316):                 choác ñöôïc giaûi tröø ngay. Ngaøi ñöôïc aán chöùng Koho Kennichi (jap)—Zen master Kao-Feng                      vaø trôû thaønh moät ngöôøi hoaøn toaøn môùi. Trong Hsien-Ju—Teân cuûa moät vò Thieàn sö Nhaät Baûn vaøo         boä Cao Phong Ngöõ Luïc, sö coù vieát: “Tröôùc

kia, khi coøn ôû Tröôøng Khaùnh, tröôùc khi vaøo              was usually folowed by a hard knocking Thieàn ñöôøng moät thaùng, ñeâm kia trong giaác               down. Later, in the midst of his sleep one nguû say toâi baát chôït thaáy toâi ñeå heát taâm trí         night, he recalled the fact that once when he vaøo caâu hoûi ‘Muoân vaät trôû veà moät, moät trôû veà       was under another master he was told to find gì?’ Toâi chieáu coá ñeán ñeà aùn chuyeân nhaát ñeán          out the ultimate significance of the statement noãi queân maát nguû nghæ aên uoáng, khoâng coøn              ‘All things return to one,’ and this kept him up phaân bieät phöông höôùng ngaøy ñeâm gì heát. Khi             the rest of that night and through the several traûi khaên baøn, hay saép cheùn dóa, hay ñi tieåu            days and nights that succeeded. While in this tieän, daàu ñoäng hay tònh, daàu noùi hay im, toaø n          state of an extreme mental tension he found theå cuoäc soáng cuûa toâi nhö goùi troïn trong nghi          himself one day looking at Fa-Yen’s verse on nieäm ‘Caùi moät trôû veà gì?’ khoâng xen loän maûy           his portrait, which partly read: may nieäm naøo khaùc; vaû laïi daàu muoán, toâi vaãn          “One hundred years, khoâng theå nghó gì leäch ngoaøi trung taâm ñieåm               thirty-six thousand morns. aáy, daàu chæ nghó thoaùng qua thoâi. Töôûng chöøng             This same old fellow moved on forever.” nhö toâi bò ñoùng cöùng hoaëc choân chaân taïi choã;          This at once made him dissolve his eternal daàu toâi coá vuøng vaãy maáy noù vaãn khoâng buoâng          doubt as to ‘Who carying around this lifeless tha; daàu giöõa ñaùm ñoâng, giöõa Taêng chuùng, toâi          body of yours?’ He was baptized and became vaãn caûm thaáy nhö hoaøn toaøn chæ coù moät mình             an altogether new man. He leaves us in his toâi töø saùng ñeán toái, töø toái ñeán saùng, tinh khieát    Saying Records: “On olden days when I was laøm sao, thanh tònh laøm sao, tö töôûng cuûa toâi            at Shuang-Ching, and before one month was trang nghieâm, löôùt treân muoân vaät. Moät nieäm             over after my return to the Meditation Hall thanh khieát laøm sao, khoâng gôïn maûy buïi! Moät            there, one night while deep in sleep, I sudenly nieäm bao truøm muoân thuôû! Theá giôùi beân ngoaøi           found myself fixing my attention on the vaéng laëng laøm sao, toâi khoâng coøn bieát coù ai           question ‘All things return to the One, but khaùc nöõa. Nhö moät keû ngoác, nhö moät teân ngu             where does this One return?’ My attention daïi, traûi qua saùu ngaøy saùu ñeâm nhö vaäy, keá toâi       was so rigidly fixed on this that I neglected vaøo chaùnh ñieän vôùi chö Taêng khaùc, vaø khi               sleeping, forgot to eat, and did not distinguish ñang ñoïc kinh, maét toâi chôït ñaët treân caâu thô           east from west, nor morning from night. While cuûa Nguõ Toå Phaùp Dieãn. Theá laø ñoät nhieân toâi          spreading the napkin, producing the bowls, or thöùc tænh côn meâ, vaø yù nghóa caâu hoûi ‘Ai mang           attending to my natural wants, whether I cho oâng caùi thaân voâ tri giaùc aáy’ vuït saùng trong       moved or rested, whether I talked or kept toâi, caâu hoûi maø thaày toâi trao cho toâi ngaøy            silent, my whole existence was wrapped up tröôùc. Toâi caûm nhö caû khoâng gian voâ bieân naày          with the question ‘Where does this one vôõ tan töøng maûnh vaø ñaïi ñòa suïp ñaâu maát. Toâi         return?’ No other thoughts ever disturbed my queân toâi, toâi queân theá gian; ñoù nhö moät taám           consciousness; even if I wanted to stir up the göông phaûn chieáu moät taám göông, toâi thöû                 least bit of thought irrelevant to the central tham quaùn vaøi coâng aùn khaùc, sao maø coâng aùn            one, I could not do so. It was like being naøo cuõng saùng rôõ ñeán vaäy! Töø nay toâi khoâng           screwed up or glued; however, much I tried to coøn nghi hoaëc dieäu duïng cuûa trí Baùt Nhaõ                shakemyself off, it refused to move. Though I nöõa.”—Kao-Feng was one of the great                          was in the midst of a crowd or congregation, I masters in the end of the the Sung dynasty.                   felt as if I were all by myself. From morning When his first let him attend to the Chao-                    till evening, from evening till morning, so Chou’s Wu, he exerted himself hard on the                     transparent, so tranquil, so majestically above problem. One day his master, Hsueh-Yen,                       all things were my feelings! Absolutely pure suddenly asked him: “Who is it that carries for               and not a particle of dust! My one thought you this lifeless corpse of yours?” The poor                  covered eternity; so calm was the outside fellow did not know what to make of the                       world, so oblivious of the existence of other question, for the master was merciless and it                 people I was. Like an idiot, like an imbecile,

six days and nights thus elapsed when I                      ngöôi böøng nôû trong moät töông lai gaàn. Tuy entered the Shrine with the rest, reciting the               nhieân, caùc ngöôi phaûi naém tôùi, phaûi baét ñöôïc, Sutras, and happened to raise my head and                    chæ coøn ñôïi thôøi cô ñeán maø thoâi. Khoâng ñöôïc looked at the verse by Fa-Yen. This made me                  nghe noùi nhö vaäy maø khôûi moät nieäm taâm tinh all of a sudden awake from the spell, and the                taán caàu noù, cuõng khoâng ñöôïc ñem taâm ñôïi noù, meaning of ‘Who carries this lifeless corpse                 cuõng khoâng ñöôïc buoâng thaû, boû rôi. Maø phaûi of yours?’ burst upon me, the question once                  giöõ vöõng chaùnh nieäm laáy ngoä laøm pheùp taéc. given by my old master. I felt as if this                    Luùc aáy coù taùm vaïn boán ngaøn quaân ma rình raäp boundless space itself were broken into                      tröôùc cöûa luïc caên cuûa caùc oâng. Taát caû caùc söï pieces, and the great earth were altogether                  kyø dò thieän aùc tuøy theo taâm caùc oâng maø hieän. levelled away. I forgot myself, I forgot the                 Caùc oâng vöøa maûy may taâm nhieãm tröôùc laø rôi world, it was like one mirror reflecting                     ngay vaøo baãy raäp cuûa chuùng, bò chuùng ñieàu another. I tried several koans in my mind and                khieån, chæ huy; luùc aáy mieäng noùi lôøi ma, thaân found them so transparently clear! I was no                  laøm vieäc ma, chính nhaân Baùt Nhaõ töø ñoù maõi more deceived as to wonderful working of                     döùt, haït gioáng Boà Ñeà thoâi khoâng naåy maàm. Prajna (transcendental wisdom).                              Luùc aáy chæ khoâng ñöôïc moáng khôûi taâm, nhö    Cao Phong laø ngöôøi chuû tröông tu taäp coâng aùn           con quæ giöõ thaây ma, maø giöõ ñi giöõ laïi, khoái nhö vaày: “Coâng aùn toâi thöôøng ñaët cho caùc moân         nghi boãng noå moät tieáng lôùn, luùc ñoù maáy oâng nhaân laø ‘Vaïn phaùp qui Nhaát, Nhaát qui haø xöù?’         ñaït ñeán traïng thaùi kinh thieân ñoäng ñòa.” Thaät Toâi khuyeân hoï haõy tham cöùu caâu naày. Tham              vaäy, chuùng ta khoâng ñeà khôûi coâng aùn hieän cöùu caâu aáy töùc laø ñaùnh thöùc moät moái nghi tình       tieàn, maø phaûi ñaët noù vaøo trong taâm baèng taát caû lôùn ñoái vôùi yù nghóa cöùu caùnh cuûa coâng aùn.           söùc maïnh cuûa nghi tình. Moät khi coâng aùn ñöôïc Vaïn phaùp thieân sai vaïn bieät ñöôïc qui veà Moät,         chi trì bôûi moät tinh thaàn nhö theá, thì noù gioáng nhöng roài Moät trôû veà ñaâu? Toâi baûo hoï, haõy           nhö moät ngoïn löûa chaùy lôùn ñoát chaùy taát caû ñem heát söùc maïnh bình sinh maø ñeo moãi moái              nhöõng con saâu hyù luaän ñang xaêm tôùi. Vaø cuõng nghi tình naày, ñöøng luùc naøo xao laõng. Duø ñi,           chính vì vaäy maø taát caû caùc Thieàn sö ñeàu ñoàng ñöùng, naèm, ngoài, hay laøm caùc coâng vieäc, ñöøng         yù raèng ‘Trong söï tham Thieàn, ñieàu troïng yeáu ñeå thôøi giôø luoáng troâi qua. Roài ra caùi Moät trôû      nhaát laø giöõ vöõng nghi tình; nghi tình caøng veà ñaâu? Haõy coá maø ñi tìm moät caâu traû lôøi            maïnh, ngoä caøng lôùn. Quaû thöïc chaúng bao giôø chính xaùc cho caâu hoûi naày. Ñöøng buoâng troâi            coù ngoä neáu khoâng coù nghi—Zen master Kao- mình trong caùi voâ söï; ñöøng luyeän taäp töôûng            Feng-Yuan-Miao talked about the koans as töôïng phieâu du, maø haõy coá thöïc hieän cho ñöôïc         follows: “The koan I ordinarily give to my caùi traïng thaùi toaøn nhaát vieân maõn baèng caùch         pupils is ‘All things return to One; where does ñaåy nghi tình löôùt tôùi, beàn bó vaø khoâng hôû. Ñoù       the One return?’ I make them search after laø luùc nghi tình ñaõ ñöôïc ñuùc thaønh moät khoái,         this. To search after it means to awaken a lay cuõng khoâng ñoäng, ñuoåi cuõng khoâng ñi,               great inquiring spirit for the ultimate meaning saùng toû linh dieäu, thöôøng hieän ôû tröôùc maët. Ñoù      of the koan. The multitudiness of things is laø luùc coù theå tieán trieån. Ñeán traïng thaùi naøy       reducible to the One, but where does the One phaûi giöõ vöõng chaùnh nieäm cuûa mình, coi                 finally return? I say to them: ‘Make this chöøng khoâng ñöôïc khôûi nhò taâm. Cho ñeán khi             inquiry with all the strength that lies in your ñi khoâng bieát mình ñi, ngoài khoâng bieát mình             personality, giving yourself no time to relax in ngoài, laïnh, noùng, ñoùi, khaùt, thaûy ñeàu khoâng          this effort. In whatever physical position you bieát. Roài caùc ngöôi seõ thaáy mình nhö moät keû           are, and in whatever business you are bònh ngaët, chaúng coøn muoán aên uoáng gì nöõa.             employed, never pass your time idly. Where Laïi nhö moät thaèng khôø, khoâng hieåu caùi gì ra           does the One finally return? Try to get a caùi gì heát. Caùi caûnh giôùi naøy hieän tieàn, töùc laø    definite answer to this query. Do not give coù ñieàm saép ñeán nhaø (giaùc ngoä). Nghóa laø khi         yourself up to a state of doing nothing; do not coâng phu ñeán ñaây, giôø laø luùc taâm hoa cuûa caùc        exercise your fantastic imagination, but try to

bring about a state of identification by                state which will frighten the heaven and pressing your spirit of inquiry forward,                shake the earth.” In fact, we can’t just hold steadily and uninterruptedly. It is the time            up a koan before the mind, we must make it when the inquiring spirit becomes one whole,            occupy the very center of attention by the continuous piece which will not be dislodged,           sheer strength of an inquiring spirit. When a no matter how hard you attempt to shake it.             koan is cultivated with such a spirit, it is like a Even though you try to push it away, it will            great consuming fire which burns up every persist in sticking to you. At all times it is          insect of idle speculation that approaches it. clearly before you. Now this is when you can            Therefore, it is almost a common sense saying progress. On reaching this stage you should             among Zen masters to declare that, ‘In the keep your mind straight and refrain from                mastery of Zen the most important thing is to having secondary thoughts. When you find                keep up a spirit of inquiry; the stronger the yourself not knowing that you are walking               spirit the greater will be the enlightenment while walking or sitting while sitting, and             that follows; there is, indeed, no unconscious of cold, heat, hunger. You will be          enlightenment when there is no spirit of then like a person who is critically ill, having        inquiry. no appetite for what you eat or drink. Again       Cao Phong Giaùc Minh: Koho-Kakumyo (jap)— you will be like an idiot, with no knowledge       Name of a monk. of what is what, then you are about to reach       Cao Phong Hieån Nhaät: Koho-Kennichi (jap)— home (enlightenment). It is to say when your       Name of a monk. searching spirit comes to this stage, the time     Cao Phong Hueä Vöông: Kumbanda king of High has come for your mental flower to burst out       Peak Intellect—Moät trong möôøi Cöu Baøn Traø in a near future. However, you should be able      Vöông. to to catch up and hold on. You do not have to     Cao Phong Quaùn Tam Muoäi: Moät loaïi tam muoäi do anything but wait until the time comes. But     maø ñöùc Phaät chöùng ñöôïc treân ñænh nuùi cao—A do not let this remark influence you to wait       samadhi that the Buddha realized on a high idly, nor excite you to exert yourself, striving   mountain. for such a stage with anxious mind. Nor            Cao Quaùn Nhö (?-1979): Kao-Kuan-Ru—Teân cuûa should you just let go and give up. Rather,        moät hoïc giaû Phaät giaùo ngöôøi Trung Hoa vaøo theá kyû you should perceive your mindfulness,              thöù XX—Name of a Chinese Buddhist scholar in keeping it steady until you reach                  the twentieth century. Enlightenment. At times you will encounter         Cao Quyù: Distinguished—Noble. eighty-four thousand demons waiting for their      Cao Só: chance to enter the gate of your six organs.       1) Boà Taùt: Bodhisattva. The projections of your mind will appear           2) Hoïc giaû noåi tieáng: Eminent scholar. before you in the guise of good or bad,            Cao Taùt La: Kosala (skt)—Kieàu Taùt La—See pleasant or unpleasant, strange or astonishing     Kosala. visions. The slightest clinging to these things    Cao Taêng: will entrap you into enslavement to their          1) Vò Taêng cao tuoåi haï: Eminent monk— commands and directions. You will then talk             Venerable Buddhist—Elder monk or master. and act as a devil. Thenceforth the right cause    2) Vò Taêng ñaïo cao ñöùc troïng: Veteran bonze of of Prajna will die away forever, and the seed           high virtues. of Bodhi will never sprout. At such time you       Cao Taêng Truyeän: Gao Seng Zhuan— should refrain from stirring up your mind, and     Biographies of Eminent Monks—Stories of should make yourself like a living corpse.         Eminent monks—Theo Nguõ Ñaêng Hoäi Nguyeân, Then, as you hold on and on, suddenly and          Thieàn sö Ñöùc Hoàng Thanh Löông (1071-1128) laø abruptly you will feel as though you were          moät trong nhöõng thieàn sö noåi tieáng cuûa phaùi Hoaøng being crushed to pieces. You will then reach a     Long, moät trong nhöõng nhaùnh thieàn quan troïng

trong tröôøng phaùi Laâm Teá vaøo thôøi nhaø Toáng. Ngaøi       Mu-Ying Hsing-t'ao. ñaõ tröôùc taùc vaø bieân soaïn moät soá lôùn taùc phaåm pheâ   Cao Vónh Tieâu (1924- ?): Kao-Yung-Tsiao—Teân bình Thieàn coå ñieån vaø töï truyeän, bao goàm boä Cao         cuûa moät hoïc giaû Phaät giaùo ngöôøi Trung Hoa vaøo Taêng Truyeän (12 quyeån)—According to Wudeng                   theá kyû thöù XX—Name of a Chinese Buddhist Huiyuan, Zen master Dehong Qingliang, one of                    scholar in the twentieth century. the famous Zen masters of Huang-lung branch,                    Cao Voïng: Great ambition. one of the most important branches from Lin-Chi                 Cao Xuaát Tam Muoäi: Samudgata-samashi (skt)— school in China during the Sung dynasty. He                     Eminent exiting concentration—Tam muoäi giuùp authored and compiled a large number of classic                 haønh giaû ñi ra khoûi theá giôùi Ta baø moät caùch roõ Zen commentaries and biographies, including the                 neùt—Samadhi that helps practitioners eminently work of Biographies of Eminent Monks (Gao Seng                  exiting the samsara. Zhuan), 12 volumes.                                             Cao Xöù Cao Bình: Taát caû nhöõng choã cao ñeàu cao Cao Taâm: Töï cao töï ñaïi—Proud—Haughty.                       baèng nhau—All high places have the same high Cao Thaâm: Cao saâu—Lofty and deep.                             level. Cao Thinh Hieän Oai: Noùi phaùch nhöõng lôøi maïnh              Cao Xöông: Khalcha (skt)—Karakhojo (skt)— döõ hoaëc noùi hueânh hoang ñeå caàu lôïi döôõng—               Teân moät vöông quoác coå ôû Taây Vöïc coù coå thaønh Hectoring and bullying.                                         Cao Xöông, khoaûng 30 daäm veà phía ñoâng cuûa Cao Thöøa Döông Ñaïi Sö: Dogen-Eihei Zenji                      Turfan thuoäc Turkestan, xöa kia laø moät trung taâm (jap)—Ñaïo Nguyeân Thieàn Sö—See Ñaïo Nguyeân                   Phaät giaùo quan troïng, töø nôi ñoù nhieàu vò cao Taêng Hy Huyeàn Thieàn Sö.                                            ñaõ mang kinh ñieån ñeán Trung quoác ñeå hoaèng hoùa. Cao       Thöôïng:        High-minded—Magnanimous               Vaøo tröôùc theá kyû thöù baûy ngöôøi ta ñaõ nghe noùi taïi behavior.                                                       ñaây coù daân toäc Turks sinh soáng trong khu vöïc Cao Tieâu: Vöôït möùc taàm thöôøng—Extraordinary.               Orkhon ñeán khoaûng naêm 840 sau Taây Lòch, hoï bò Cao Tænh Quaùn Haûi (1884-1953): Takai Kankai                   ngöôøi Kirghiz ñaùnh ñuoåi neân chia laøm hai nhoùm; (jap)—Teân cuûa moät vò Taêng Nhaät Baûn vaøo theá kyû          moät nhoùm ñi ñeán Kansu vaø sinh toàn ñeán khoaûng XX, thuoäc Chaân Ngoân toâng—Name of a Japanese                 naêm 1020; coøn nhoùm kia toàn taïi ñeán thôøi kyø ñeá Shingon monk in the twentieth century.                          quoác Moâng Coå. Hoï coù maãu töï laáy töø maãu töï Cao Toøa: Koza (jap)—Discoursing—Lecturing—                     Soghdian maø veà sau naày Thaønh Caùt Tö Haõn ñaõ See Ñeà Xöôùng.                                                 cho duøng nhö chöõ vieát chính thöùc cuûa ngöôøi Moâng Cao Toå: Koso (jap)—Vò sô toå saùng laäp ra toâng               Coå. Vaøo naêm 1294 thì toaøn boä giaùo ñieån Phaät giaùo phaùi—The founder of a sect or school—Great                     ñaõ ñöôïc phieân dòch ra chöõ Uighur (theo söû lieäu great grandfather.                                              Trung Hoa, Haùn Thö vaø Taân Cöïu Ñöôøng Thö, thì Cao Traøng Phoå Chieáu Thaàn: Lofty Banner                      ñaây laø ñaát cuõ cuûa Hieäu UÙy Maäu Kyû ñôøi Haäu Haùn Shinning Everywhere Deity (Spirit).                             vaø Tieàn Boä Xa Sö ñôøi Haùn, nay laø vuøng phuï caän Cao Tuùc: Ñaïi ñeä töû—Superior pupils or disciples.            Thoå Loå Phoàn, vaø Caùp Thích Hoøa Traùc, ñoâng baéc Cao Tuyeàn Tính Ñoân (1633-1695): Zen master                    sa maïc Goâ Bi, thuoäc tænh Taân Cöông. Thôøi xöa Kao-Chuan Hsin Tuan—Teân cuûa moät vò Thieàn sö                 Phaät giaùo raát thònh haønh ôû ñaây. Nhöõng kinh ñieån Nhaät Baûn, thuoäc phaùi Thieàn Hoaøng Baù vaøo theá kyû        baèng chöõ Phaïn vaø chöõ Haùn ñeàu ñöôïc xöû duïng. thöù XVII. Sö laø nguõ toå cuûa phaùi Hoaøng Baù ôû Nhaät       Thôøi Baéc Löông xuaát hieän nhöõng thaày Phaùp Thònh, Baûn, ngöôøi ñaõ bieân soaïn boä Hoaøng Baù Thanh Quy,          Phaùp Chuùng; thôøi Baéc Nguïy xuaát hieän caùc thaày vôùi söï duyeät xeùt vaø chuaån thuaän tröôùc ñoù cuûa nhò      Ñaøm Loäc vaø Uy Ñöùc dòch Kinh Hieàn Ngu; thôøi toå Moäc Anh Tính Thao Thieàn Sö—Name of a                      Ñoâng Taán nhöõng thaày Trí Nghieâm, Trí Giaûn sang Japanese Zen master of the Huang-Po Sect                        Taây Truùc, treân ñöôøng sang Taây Truùc coù gheù qua (Obaku) in the seventeenth century. He was the                  vuøng naày tìm löông thöïc ñi ñöôøng. Veà sau ngaøi fifth patriarch of the Obaku Sect in Japan, who                 Huyeàn Trang cuõng döøng laïi ñaây moät thaùng, ñöôïc composed all Huang-po Hsi-yun 's regulations for                vua Cuùc Vaên Thaùi raát kính troïng). Theo ngaøi Phaùp monks in a Zen monastery with previous review                   Hieån trong caùc vöông quoác trong vuøng Taây Vöïc, and approval of the second patriarch, Zen master                "Cao Xöông laø teân cuûa moät xöù toaøn laø nuùi non

trong vuøng Baéc AÁn. Xöù naøy toïa laïc veà phía Ñoâng         Caùp Lôïi Quaùn AÂm: Moät trong 33 Quaùn AÂm, ngoài cuûa daõy Thoáng Lónh. Xöù naøy thôøi tieát raát laïnh,         treân voû soø—One of the thirty-three forms of Kuan- khoâng troàng ñöôïc nguõ coác ngoaïi tröø luùa maïch, thôøi     Yin, seated on a shell. tieát trôû laïnh giaù buoát raát baát thöôøng. ÔÛ giöõa raëng   Caùp Noâ Man: Hanumana (skt)—Ñaïi Laõnh Thaàn nuùi Tuyeát cuûa xöù naøy trôû ñi, ngoaïi tröø tre, löïu, vaø   Haàu—Teân cuûa moät nhaân vaät trong La Ma Dieãn Na mía, coøn thì nhöõng loaïi caây traùi khaùc ñeàu khaùc bieät    Ma hay Ma Du Kyù, moät boä ñaïi töï söï thi cuûa AÁn vôùi Trung quoác. Cö daân trong vöông quoác naøy maëc           giaùo vaøo theá kyû thöù III vaø thöù IV tröôùc taây lòch— moät thöù vaûi thoâ nhö ôû beân Trung quoác, nhöng næ vaø       Name of a character in Ramayana, a Hinduism daï cuûa hoï thì khaùc."—The ancient town of Kao-               Records of relating something from the beginning Ch’ang, 30 miles east of Turfan in Turkestan,                   to the end, written in the third or fourth century formerly an important Buddhist centre, whence                   B.C. came scriptures and monks to China. The Turks in                Caùp Vieân: Kapotakasamgharama (skt)—Ca Boá Karakhojo were first heard of in the seventh                    Ñöùc Ca—Moät töï vieän noåi tieáng trong vuøng century in the Orkhon district where they                       Kashmir, phía nam xöù Ma Kieät Ñaø, trung AÁn Ñoä remained until          840 A.D. when they were                 (Ñöùc Phaät vaøo thôøi quaù khöù, laø moät con chim boà defeated and driven out by the Kirghiz; one group               caâu to daãn ngöôøi ñi saên vaøo chaùnh ñaïo, khi bay tôùi went to Kansu, where they remained until about                  ñaây ñaõ lao vaøo löûa maø cheát)—A famous 1020 A.D.; another group founded a kingdom in                   monastery said to be in Kashmir, south of the Turfan country which survived until Mongol                  Magadha, central India. times. They had an alphabet which was copied                    Caùt: 1) Caét: To cut; 2) Daây leo hay daây saén: The from the Soghdian. Chingis Khan adopted it for                  rambling, or creeping bean. writing Mongolian. In 1294 A.D. the whole                       Caùt Ca Daï: Moät vò Taêng noåi tieáng vaøo ñôøi Buddhist canon was translated into Uighur. Fa-                  Toáng—A noted monk of the Sung dynasty. Hsien reported in The Records of Western                        Caùt Daï Ca: Kinkara (skt)—Khaån Yeát La Boà Kingdoms: "Khalcha, name of a mountainous                       Taùt—Caên Yeát La—Teân cuûa moät vò Boà Taùt— country in North India. It located in the East of the           Name of a Bodhisattva. Pamirs. “It’s so cold in the area that no cereals can           Caùt Ñaèng: Katto (jap). grow here except wheat. The weather often turns                 1) Daây leo, saén daây, ví vôùi phieàn naõo: Arrowroot frosty. The country is in the middle of the Pamir                     and wisteria, creepers, trailers, clinging vines, ranges. From the Pamirs onwards, except                               etc, i.e. the entanglement, afflicting passions. bamboos, pomegranate and sugarcane, plants,                     2) Nhöõng ngöôøi hay gaây söï: Troublesome trees and fruits are different from those in China.                   people. People in this kingdom wear the same coarse cloth               3) Nhöõng töø duøng trong nhaø Thieàn: Talk (words as in China, but their felt and serge cloths differ."                 so use by the Intuitional School). Caùo: To inform—To accuse—To plead.                             4) Daây leo laø töø ngöõ nhaø thieàn duøng ñeå chæ Caùo Baùo: To tell, to relate, to report.                             nhöõng bình giaûi raát daøi doøng veà Phaùp cuûa Caùo Höông: Thoâng baùo hay cung thænh baèng                          Phaät. Ngöôøi ta duøng thuaät ngöõ naày ñeå chæ moät caùch daâng höông—To inform or to respectfully                        söï gaén boù quaù naëng neà vaøo vaên töï vaø nghóa invite by offering incense.                                           ñen cuûa chuùng. Ñaây laø loaïi thieàn chæ döøng laïi Caùo Toäi: To recognize one’s fault.                                  ôû vaên baûn kinh thay cho vieäc tröïc tieáp naém Caùo Vaõng Tri Lai: Bieát chuyeän vò lai, yù noùi lanh                ñöôïc yù nghóa saâu saéc cuûa noù: The term "the lôïi maãn tieäp—To know future occurences                             thicket of creeping vines" is used in Zen, (incidents), i.e., clever, intelligent, quick-minded,                 refers to oververbose explanations of the etc.                                                                  Buddha-dharma. It is also used to refer to Caïo Toùc: To shave one’s hair.                                       hanging on words and their literal meaning. Caùp: 1) Chim boà caâu: Paravata or Kapotaka                          The creeping-vines Zen (Katto Zen) is also (skt)—A dove, a pigeon; 2) Soø heán: Clams.                           meant a Zen that hangs on the words of the

scriptures rather than directly grasping their        thaáy ngaøy khoâng ñuû roäng, thaùng khoâng ñuû daøi ñeå deeper meaning.                                       mình tieáp tuïc laøm thieän, nhöng ngöôøi aùc laïi cuõng 5) Koteng (jap): Name of a monk.                           nghó nhö theá, töùc laø sao maø thôøi gian troâi qua mau Caùt Ñaèng Quaät: Hang daây leo, saén daây, ví vôùi lôøi   quaù neân y khoâng coù ñuû ngaøy giôø ñeå laøm chuyeän noùi daøi doøng khoâng döùt—Cave of creepers,              aùc—Good man doing good finds the day trailers, clinging vines, etc, i.e. non-stop long and      insufficient; the evil man doing evil likewise finds tedious talking or chattering.                             the day insufficient. Caùt Ñaèng Saøng Töû: Giöôøng daây leo, saén daây, ví      Caùt Quaû: The auspicious fruit. vôùi thieàn sö nhieàu lôøi—Bed of creepers, trailers,      Caùt Sôn Minh Trieäu (1252-1433): Kichizan clinging vines, etc, i.e. a criticism on talkative Zen     (jap)—Teân cuûa moät vò Thieàn sö Nhaät Baûn doøng masters.                                                   Laâm Teá, queâ ôû Binh Khoá—Name of a Japanese Caùt Ñaèng Thieàn: Thieàn nhieàu lôøi—Talkative            Zen master, of the Lin-chi lineage. He came from meditation.                                                Awaji, Central Japan. Caùt Ñoaïn: Caét ñöùt ñoaïn—To cut off.                    Caùt Taïng: Ji-Zang (549-623 A.D.)—Teân cuûa moät Caùt Haø: Taø ñaïo cho raèng nöôùc soâng Haèng coù theå    Phaùp sö noåi tieáng cuûa tröôøng phaùi Trung Luaän vaøo röûa saïch moïi toäi loãi—Auspicious river—The             theá kyû thöù baûy, ngöôøi ñaõ vieát naêm boä luaän veà kinh Ganges for the heretics say they can wash away             Phaùp Hoa, trong ñoù Sö uûng hoä söï kieän cho raèng their sins.                                                tam giôùi naøy laø nôi truù nguï qua ñeâm daøi. Taâm thöùc Caùt Hoä: Srgupta (p)—Thaéng Maät—See Ñöùc Hoä.            laø chuû theå cuûa ñaïi moäng. Neáu con ngöôøi tænh thöùc Caùt Hung: Fortune and misfortune—Good and                 bieát ñöôïc raèng tam giôùi naøy voán laø khoâng thì voïng bad—Toát vaø xaáu.                                         thöùc seõ chaám döùt. Kyø thaät taát caû nhöõng chuoãi hieän Caùt Khaùnh: Auspicious—Lucky—Fortunate.                   höõu ñöôïc tieáp nhaän vaøo luùc naøy chæ nhö trong moät Caùt Laït Saét Noa: Krsna (skt)—Mahakala (skt)—            giaác mô neáu haønh giaû tænh giaác luùc trôøi raïng ñoâng See Haéc Thieân.                                           thì nhöõng aûo giaùc seõ maát daáu, voïng thöùc seõ tan Caùt Lôïi Ña Vöông: Vua Caùt Lôïi Ña, maø con chaùu        bieán, tam giôùi hieän töôùng Khoâng döôùi maét haønh cuûa oâng sau naày choáng ñoái Phaät giaùo, bò Ca Nhò      giaû. Vaøo luùc ñoù, khoâng coù choã cho baát cöù thöù gì Saéc Giaø (Kaniska) laät ñoå ñeå hoài phuïc Phaät giaùo    sinh khôûi, cuõng khoâng coù choã cho baát cöù thöù gì trong vöông quoác, nhöng veà sau naày thì con chaùu        hoaïi dieät—Name of a famous Dharma master of cuûa doøng Caùt Lôïi Ña khoâi phuïc ngai vaøng vaø ñuoåi   Madhyamikas, who wrote five books regarding chö Taêng ñi—King Krta of Kashmere, whose                  the Lotus Sutra in which he supported the fact descendants were opposed to Buddhism; they                 that this triple world is a dwelling for a long night. were dethroned by Kaniska, who restored                    Mental consciousness is the subject of a great Buddhism; but later the royal regained the throne          dream. In fact, if one awakens to the fundamental and drove out the Buddhist monks.                          emptiness of this triple world, deluded Caùt Lyù Ma: Karma (skt)—See Nghieäp.                      consciousness will be expended. The assembly of Caùt Lyù Saét Naõ: 1) Maøu ñen hay xanh ñaäm: Krsna        existents which is perceived now are all (skt)—Black, dark, or dark blue; 2) Teân moät vò           perceptions in a dream. If one awakens from the Thaàn anh huøng cuûa AÁn Ñoä: Krishna (skt)—The            great dream after dawn brightens this long night, hero-god of India; 3) Ñoái vôùi Phaät giaùo, Caùt Lyù      then delusions are overturned, the deluded Saét Naõ laø teân moät loaøi chuùa cuûa “Haéc Quyû,” keû   consciousness is extinguished, and the triple world thuø ñòch vôùi Ñöùc Phaät vaø Baïch quyû: Krishna          is seen to be empty. At that time there is no place (skt)—With Buddhists he is chief of the black              from which anything arises, yet no place which demons, who are enemies of Buddha and the                  has no arising. white demons.                                              Caùt Thaûo: The auspicious grass used at a Caùt Nhaân: A good man.                                    religious ceremony. Caùt Nhaân Vi Thieän Duy Nhaät Baát Tuùc: Caùt nhaân       Caùt Tieät Hö Khoâng: Caét ñöùt hö khoâng, chuyeän vi thieän duy nhaät baát tuùc, hung nhaân vi baát thieän   khoâng theå xaûy ra ñöôïc, yù noùi haønh giaû muoán duøng dieäc duy nhaät baát tuùc—Ngöôøi toát laøm vieäc thieän    voïng töôûng ñeå taùch rôøi hay chia caét söï vaät voán

khoâng theå taùch rôøi hay chia caét ñöôïc—To separate          Caùt Töôøng Haûi Vaân: 1) Ñieàm laønh cuûa maây vaø space, an impossibility. The term means                         bieån: The auspicious sea-cloud; 2) Daáu treân ngöïc practitioners who want to use their deluded                     cuûa thaàn Visnu: Sri-vatsa (skt)—The breast mark thoughts to separate or divide inseparable things.              of Visnu; 3) Phaät Taâm AÁn: Svastika (skt)—Symbol Caùt Tín: Good news.                                            on a Buddha’s breast. Caùt Trieäu: Fortunate omen.                                    Caùt Töôøng Hyû Kim Cang Teá Sôù Chaâu Chaâu Caùt Töôøng: Kosa (skt)—Srivadlaksana (skt)—                    Man:           Sri-hevajra-panjika-muktikavalimana Swastika (skt)—Svastika (skt)—Ueá Khö A Taát Ñeå                (skt)—Teân cuûa moät boä chuù sôù—An explanation of Ca—Kieát töôøng—The revolving cross—Toát                        the sastra on Diamond Auspicious Joy. laønh—Phaït Xa La—Hung Töï—Kim Cöông                            Caùt Töôøng Mao Quoác: Kusagrapura (skt)—Theo Chaáp—Phaït Xa La—Phöôïc Baïch La—Phaït Trieát                  Eitel trong Trung Anh Phaät Hoïc Töï Ñieån cuûa Giaùo Ña—Ba Phaùt Xa La—Phaït Trieát Xa La—                           Sö Soothill, ñaây laø nôi truù nguï cuûa caùc vua taïi xöù Auspicious—Diamond club—Good luck—Great-                        Ma Kieät Ñaø, bao boïc bôûi nuùi non, khoaûng 14 daäm fortune—Prosperity—Propitious—Thunderbolt—                      veà phía nam cuûa Behar. Noù bò boû pheá töø khi vua Caùt töôøng (chöõ Vaïn)—Daáu kieát töôøng treân ngöïc           Bình Sa Vöông xaây thaønh Vöông Xaù môùi, khoaûng cuûa Phaät, moät trong 32 töôùng haûo. Daáu hieäu cuûa          6 daäm xa hôn veà phía taây—According to Eitel, this söùc maïnh coù khaû naêng cheá ngöï taát caû cuûa Phaät. Töø    is an ancient residence of the kings of Magadha, “Swastika” laø Phaïn ngöõ laáy töø tieáp ñaàu ngöõ “Sw”         surrounded by mountains, about 14 miles south of coù nghóa laø toát laønh, vaø ñoäng töø “asti” coù nghóa “laø   Behar. It was deserted under King Bimbisara, who nhö vaäy.” Teân chöõ Vaïn, töôïng tröng cho söï vaän            built new Radjagriha, about 6 miles farther to the chuyeån (sinh hoaït) khoâng ngöøng cuûa ñôøi soáng vaø          west. vuõ truï. Ñaây laø daáu hieäu maët trôøi thôøi coå töôïng       Caùt Töôøng Phaät Ñaûnh Caùi Thaønh Töïu Phaùp: tröng cho giaøu coù vaø may maén. Noù cuõng töôïng              Sri-buddha-kalpala-sadhana             (skt)—Auspicious tröng cho phaùp luaân trong Phaät giaùo, vaø trong nhaø         Buddha Crown accomplishment of dharma. Thieàn noù coù nghóa laø “Phaät taâm aán.” Daáu hieäu naøy      Caùt Töôøng Quaû: Quaû Caùt Töôøng, quaû löïu, caàm thöôøng ñöôïc thaáy treân caùc tònh xaù hay chuøa               treân tay cuûa Quyû Töû Maãu, nhö söï ban boá treû con— chieàn—The svastika on Buddha’s breast, one of                  The auspicious fruit, a pomegranate, held by the thirty-two marks. The symbol of the all-                    Hariti as a bestower of children. conquering power of Buddha. The term                            Caùt Töôøng Quaùn Töï Taïi Boà Taùt: Sri-mahavid “Swastika” is Sanskrit term derives from prefix                 (skt)—See Ñaïi Caùt Töôøng Minh Boà Taùt. “Sw,” meaning good or well, and the verb “asti,”                Caùt Töôøng Thaûo: Dabbha (p)—Kusa (skt)— means “to be.” It symbolizes the ceaseless activity             Kusa grass—Thöôïng Mao—Coû Caùt Töôøng, tieáng of the universal life principle evolving the cosmos.            Phaïn goïi laø Coâ-Sa, tieáng Haùn laø Thöôïng Mao, This is an ancient solar symbol of well-being and               ñöôïc duøng trong caùc buoåi leã hay nghi thöùc toân good fortune. The ancient sign of the Swastika is               giaùo—Auspicious grass used at religious interpreted in Buddhism as a symbol of the wheel                ceremonials. of Buddhist teaching, and in Zen it symbolizes the              Caùt Töôøng Thaàn: Auspicious Deity (Spirit). “seal of the Buddha-mind.” It is often found on                 Caùt Töôøng Thieân: See Caùt Töôøng Thieân Nöõ. Buddhist monasteries and temples.                               Caùt Töôøng Thieân Hoái Saùm Phaùp: Nghi thöùc phaùt Caùt Töôøng Boà Taùt: Sri-mahavid (skt)—See Ñaïi                loà saùm hoái toäi loãi ñeå caàu phöôùc cuûa Maät giaùo — Caùt Töôøng Minh Boà Taùt.                                      Auspicious devas' Tantric rules for repentance and Caùt Töôøng Böûu Nguyeät Thaàn: Auspicious Jewel                confession. The aim of the repentance is to seek Moon Deity (Spirit).                                            blessings. Caùt Töôøng Duyeät YÙ: Auspiciously Joyful                      Caùt Töôøng Thieân Nöõ: Laksmi (skt)—Sri-maha- mentality.                                                      deva (skt)—Baûo Taïng Thieân Nöõ—Coâng Ñöùc Caùt Töôøng Giaø Ña: Manjugatha (skt)—Manjusri                  Thieân—Caùt Töôøng Thieân Nöõ, vò nöõ thaàn cuûa söï (skt)—Ña Maïn Thuø Thaát Lôïi—See Vaên Thuø Sö                  may maén vaø saéc ñeïp. Vò naày troài leân töø bieån vôùi Lôïi.                                                           hoa sen treân tay. Coù söï hieåu laàm giöõa Caùt Töôøng

Thieân Nöõ vaø Quaùn Theá AÂm, coù leõ töø yù töôûng           trong quyeån 'Thaïch Tuyeàn Thieàn Ñöôøng' Laksmi cuûa AÁn Giaùo—The goddess of fortune and               (Sebastopol, California): "Giaùo huaán cuûa Boà Ñeà beauty. She sprang from the ocean with a lotus in              Ñaït Ma, Sô Toå huyeàn thoaïi cuûa Thieàn toâng, baét her hand. There is some confusion between this                 ñaàu vaø chaám döùt vôùi caùi taâm ñöôïc xem nhö laø goddess and Kuan-Yin, possibly through the                     caùnh cöûa cuûa giaûi thoaùt, khoâng coù Phaät naøo ngoaøi attribution of Hindu ideas of Laksmi to Kuan-Yin.              caùi taâm voán laø chaân taùnh tuyeät vôøi cuûa chuùng ta, Caùt Töôøng Trí: A Ñeå Sa—Dipankara-Srijnana                   vaø vôùi kieán taùnh ñöôïc xem nhö laø chìa khoùa cuûa (skt)—Auspicious wisdom—Ngöôøi xuaát chuùng.                   caùnh cöûa naøy. Tu taäp chính yeáu maø Sô Toå ñaõ daïy Caùt Töôøng Tònh Dieäp Thaàn: Auspicious Pure                  laø toïa thieàn, ñöôïc dòch laø 'bích quaùn,' ngoài nhö moät Leaves Deity (Spirit).                                         böùc töôøng, vöõng vaøng vaø baát ñoäng. Ngaøi noùi raèng Caùt Töôøng Vaân: Megha-sri (skt)—Coâng Ñöùc Vaân              ñaây laø caùch ñeå thanh tònh taâm vaø do ñoù thanh tònh Tyø Kheo—Name of a monk.                                       caû thaân vaø theá giôùi cuûa baïn. Taäp trung, vöùt boû moïi Caên: Buddhindriya (skt)—Indriya (skt)—Mula                    voïng nieäm, quay veà vôùi chaân thöïc töôùng, vaø qua (skt)—Faculty—Khaû naêng taâm lyù vaø theå chaát.              ñoù töø boû chuû nghóa nhò nguyeân giöõa ta vaø ngöôøi ñeå 1) Caên baûn: Mula (skt)—Basis—Origin.                         truï vaøo chaân taùnh tónh laëng cuûa vaïn höõu. Ngoân ngöõ 2) Giaùc quan: Indriya (p & skt)—Senses—                       cuûa Sô Toå thöôøng mang taùnh töôïng tröng vaø tröõ Faculty of sense—Organs of sense.                         tình khi ngaøi luoân chæ vaøo caùi maø ngaøi goïi laø caùi a) Naêng löïc cuûa giaùc quan: Faculty of sense—               taâm thanh tònh caên baûn, coá höõu, maø chuùng phaûi laáy Sense—Organ of sense.                                     laøm goác. Caùi taâm naøy khoâng phaûi chæ laø yù nghó vaø b) Naêng löïc cuûa thaân vaø taâm: Bodily and mental           söï nhaän thöùc cuûa baïn, maø noù laø caùi ñöôïc ngöôøi ta power.                                                    goïi laø Phaät, Phaät taùnh, chaân nhö, khoâng moät töø ngöõ c) Naêng löïc cuûa taâm linh: Spiritual faculties or           naøo coù theå haøm chöùa heát ñöôïc noù, khoâng moät caùi power of the spirituality.                                ngaõ naøo coù theå naém baét ñöôïc noù."—Jisho Warner Caên Baïi: Söï hö hoaïi cuûa nguõ caên (laø khoâng theå        wrote in Stone Creek Zendo (Sebastopol, traùnh ñöôïc vì chuùng chæ laø söï keát hôïp cuûa töù ñaïi)—   California): "The legendary First Ancestor of Zen The decay of the powers, or senses.                            Bodhidharma's teaching begins and ends with the Caên Baûn: 1) Cô baûn: Basic, fundamental, radical,            mind as the gateway to liberation, there is no basal, elemental, original; 2) Nguyeân Thuûy, khi              Buddha beyond the mind that is our marvelously noùi ñeán baøi kinh, hay mulagrantha, thì caên baûn coù        aware true nature, and with beholding the mind as yù noùi ñeán kinh chöùa ñöïng nhöõng lôøi noùi nguyeân         the key to the gate. The central pratice he taught thuûy cuûa Ñöùc Phaät: When referring to a                     was seated meditation, translated as 'wall gazing,' fundamental text, or mulagrantha, it indicates a               sitting like a wall, stable and immovable. He said sutra supposed to contain the original words of the            this is the way to clarify the mind and thus your Buddha.                                                        life and your world. Concentrate, relinquish all Caên Baûn A Tyø Ñaït Ma Luaän: Mulabhidharma-                  false ideas, return to true reality, and with that sastra (skt)—Treatise on fundamental teachings of              abandon all dualism of self and other, settling into Abhidharma.                                                    the still true nature of things. His language is often Caên Baûn Baát Tònh: The ultimate impurity of the              symbolic and lyrical as he points over and over to body—Sau khi cheát, cô theå chuùng ta sình leân, trôû          what he calls the fundamental pure inherent mind maøu xanh vôùi ñaày doøi boï raát ö laø baát tònh—After        on which we should ground ourselves. This mind death our bodies swell up, turn green, and breed               is not just your or my thinking and perception; it is worms, all of which is impure.                                 what is also called Buddha, Buddha-nature, Caên Baûn Chaùnh Haïnh Luaän: Mulacara (skt)—                  suchness, no word can contain it, no self can grasp Treatise on fundamental teachings of right                     it." conducts.                                                      Caên Baûn Coâng Ñöùc Chaùnh Haïnh: Mulaguna Caên Baûn Coá Höõu Thanh Tònh Taâm:                            (skt)—Moät trong 28 coâng ñöùc caên baûn—One of Fundamental pure inherent mind—Caùi taâm voán laø              twenty-eight kinds of fundamental morality. chaân taùnh thanh tònh tuyeät vôøi. Jisho Warner vieát

Caên Baûn Ñaúng Trí: See Caên Baûn Ñònh and Caên                 saùt na ñaàu tieân—The manifested activities and Baûn Trí.                                                        unmanifested activities (of the body, mouth, and Caên Baûn Ñònh: Dhyana-mula (skt)—Coøn goïi laø                  mind; or invisible power conferred at ordination) Caên Baûn Ñaúng Trí hay Caên Baûn Thieàn, nghóa laø              are formed in the first ksana (the shortest period or giôùi ñònh ñoaïn lìa phieàn naõo trong coõi thieàn voâ           measure of time). saéc—The stages of dhyana in the formless or                     Caên Baûn Nhöùt Thieát Höõu Boä Tyø Naïi Da: See immaterial realm.                                                Caên Baûn Thuyeát Nhöùt Thieát Höõu Boä Tyø Naïi Da. Caên Baûn Giôùi: Parajika (skt)—Ba La Di—Taùm söï                Caên Baûn Nhöùt Thieát Höõu Boä Tyø Naïi Da Taïp Söï: cö xöû xaáu—Taùm söï cö xöû xaáu—Baùt Ba La Di Baùt              See Caên Baûn Thuyeát Nhöùt Thieát Höõu Boä Tyø Naïi Ba La Di, moät trong saùu chöông cuûa Luaät Taïng—               Da Taïp Söï. Eight misbehaviors, one of the six chapters of the               Caên Baûn Phaùp Luaân: The root wheel is the Vinaya-Pitaka.                                                   Avatamsaka (Wreath)—Caên baûn Phaùp Luaân laø Caên Baûn Hoaëc: Mulaklesa (skt)—Coøn goïi laø Caên              Hoa Nghieâm. Baûn Phieàn Naõo—Fundamental illusions—See Boån                  Caên Baûn Phieàn Naõo: Mulaklesa (skt)—Coøn goïi laø Hoaëc and Caên Baûn Phieàn Naõo.                                 Boån Hoaëc, hay Boån Phieàn Naõo—Fundamental Caên Baûn Hoäi: See Thaønh Thaân Hoäi and Yeát Ma                illusions, passions, or afflictions, including: Hoäi.                                                            1) Ñoän Söû: The envoys of stupidity caused by Caên Baûn Höõu Boä: Mulasarvastivadah (skt)—                          illusion of the body or self. Nhaát Thieát Höõu Caên Boån—Moät nhaùnh cuûa tröôøng             2) Lôïi Söû: The higher wholesome deeds. phaùi Nhaát Thieát Höõu Boä cho raèng vaïn höõu ñeàu coù         3) Nhöõng phieàn naõo chính nhö tham, saân, si, thöïc höõu—A branch of the Sarvastivadin Sect                         maïn, nghi, vaân vaân: Main afflictions such as which asserted the reality of things.                                 lust, anger, ignorance, pride, doubt, etc. Caên Baûn Kieán Hoaëc: Basic deluded views—                      Caên Baûn Taâm: Taâm caên baûn—Root or Nhöõng kieán hoaëc caên baûn—Kieán hoaëc laø nhöõng aûo          fundamental mind. töôûng ñöa ñeán taø kieán. Coù möôøi kieán hoaëc caên baûn       Caên Baûn Thieàn: See Caên Baûn Ñònh. töï chuùng hieän ra lieân heä tôùi vieäc tu taäp Töù Dieäu Ñeá   Caên Baûn Thuyeát Nhöùt Thieát Höõu Boä: trong tam giôùi: duïc giôùi, saéc giôùi vaø voâ saéc giôùi.      Mulasarvastivadah           (skt)—Mula-sarvastivada Möôøi kieán hoaëc naøy laø tham, saân, si, maïn, nghi,           (skt)—Sarvastivada (skt)—Taùt Baø Ña boä—See ngaõ kieán, bieân kieán, taø kieán, kieán thuû, vaø giôùi caám   Nhaát Thieát Höõu Caên Boån. thuû kieán—Deluded views are illusory or                         Caên Baûn Thuyeát Nhaát Thieát Höõu Boä Baùch Nhaát misleading views and thoughts. There are ten                     Keä: Hundred and One Customs of the Mula- basic deluded views which manifest themselves in                 Sarvastivadin School. relation to the Four Noble Truths in each of the                 Caên Baûn Thuyeát Nhöùt Thieát Höõu Boä Ni Ñaø Na three worlds: desire, form, and formless. The ten                Muïc Ñaéc Ca: Nidana-matrka (skt)—Kinh Nhaân are greed, anger, delusion, arrogance, doubt,                    Duyeân Baûn Söï cuûa tröôøng phaùi Nhaát Thieát Höõu wrong view of self, one-sided view, deviant                      Boä, hai trong möôøi hai boä Kinh Phaät—Sutra views, the view of being attached to views, view                 dealing with nidanas, two of the twelve divisions of grasping prohibitive precepts.                                of the sutras—See Thaäp Nhò Ñaïi Thöøa Kinh. Caên Baûn Maïn: Maïn Caên Baûn hay goác cuûa söï kieâu           Caên Baûn Thuyeát Nhöùt Thieát Höõu Boä Tyø Naïi maïn—Root of pride.                                              Da:         Mula-sarvastivada-vinaya            (skt)— Caên Baûn Nghieäp Baát Töông Öng Nhieãm: Giai                    Mulastivadin-vinaya (skt)—Boä luaät cuûa tröôøng ñoaïn cao nhaát cuûa Boà Taùt, böôùc vaøo Phaät quaû —           phaùi Caên Baûn Thuyeát Nhaát Thieát Höõu Boä , goàm 50 The highest Bodhisattva stage, entering the                      quyeån. Buddhahood—See Caên Boån Nghieäp Baát Töông                      Caên Baûn Thuyeát Nhöùt Thieát Höõu Boä Tyø Naïi Da Öng Nhieãm.                                                      Taïp Söï: Mula-sarvastivada-vinaya-ksudrakavastu Caên Baûn Nghieäp Ñaïo: Bieåu nghieäp vaø voâ bieåu              (skt)—Teân moät boä luaät cuûa tröôøng phaùi Caên Baûn nghieäp (khoâng bieåu hieän cuûa thaân, khaåu, yù, ñoái laïi     Thuyeát Nhaát Thieát Höõu Boä, goàm 40 quyeån. vôùi nghieäp bieåu hieän) ñöôïc hình thaønh trong khoaûn

Caên Baûn Thöùc: Mula-vijnana (skt)—Root                           empty of inherent existence (svabhava), come into consciousness—Caên Baûn Thöùc laø teân khaùc cuûa A                being in dependence upon causes and conditions, Laïi Da Thöùc (goác cuûa taát caû caùc phaùp)—Basic or             and are thus impermanent (anitya). Fundamental consciousness or vijnana, another                      Caên Baûn Trung Quaùn Luaän Thích: Mula- name for Alaya-vijnana.                                            madhyamika-vrtti-akutobhaya                        (skt)— Caên Baûn Trí: Mulajnana (skt)—Fundamental                         Interpretation of the fundamental ideas in the wisdom—Original wisdom—Primal wisdom—Coøn                          Madhyamika-sastra. goïi laø Chaân Trí, Chaùnh Trí, Nhö Lyù Trí, Voâ Phaân             Caên Baûn Trung Quaùn Luaän Thích Voâ UÙy Chuù : Bieät Trí, nghóa laø hieåu bieát roõ chaân lyù maø khoâng coù      Mula-madhyamikavttiakutobhaya                      (skt)— söï phaân bieät naêng duyeân hay sôû duyeân, ñaây laø trí          Interpretation of the fundamental ideas of mantras sanh ra nhaát thieát chaân lyù vaø coâng ñöùc, ñoái laïi vôùi      of fearlessness in the Madhyamika-sastra. “haäu ñaéc trí.” Cuõng ñöôïc goïi laø Caên Baûn Ñaúng Trí          Caên Baûn Trung Quaùn Luaän Tuïng: Mula- hay Caên Baûn Thieàn, nghóa laø giôùi ñònh ñoaïn lìa               madhyamika-karika (skt)—Trung Quaùn Luaän phieàn naõo trong coõi thieàn voâ saéc—Source of all               Tuïng—Ñöôïc ngaøi Long Thoï vieát vaøo theá kyû thöù truth and virtue; knowledge of fundamental                         ba—Verses of Madhyamika-sastra, written by principles; intuitive knowledge or wisdom, in                      Nagarjuna in the 3rd century. contrast with acquired wisdom. Also called the                     Caên Baûn Uaån: Mula-tikaskandha (skt)—Uaån stages of dhyana in the formless or immaterial                     goác—Root aggregate. realm.                                                             Caên Baûn Voâ Minh: Mulavidya (skt)—Basic Caên Baûn Trung Quaùn Keä: Mulamadhyamika-                         ignorance—Innate ignorance—Voâ minh coá höõu— karika (skt)—Moät trong ba boä luaän chính cuûa Tam                Coøn goïi laø Voâ Thuûy Voâ Minh, hay caùi voâ minh töø Toâng Luaän. Boä Caên Baûn Trung Quaùn Keä do Ngaøi                tröôùc khi naûy ra yù nghó bieän bieät, ñoái laïi vôùi Maït Long Thoï bieân soaïn, may maén nguyeân baûn tieáng                chi Voâ minh (caên baûn voâ minh döïa vaøo taïi trieàn Phaïn vaãn coøn toàn taïi. Baûn Haùn vaên do Ngaøi Cöu             chaân nhö maø taïo ra duyeân khôûi, roài töø ñoù maït chi Ma La Thaäp dòch. Taùc phaåm naày goàm hai möôi                    voâ minh laïi töïa vaøo caên baûn voâ minh maø caùc phaùp baûy phaàn, trong ñoù Ngaøi Long Thoï ñaõ baùc boû moät            tieáp tuïc noåi daäy)—The radical, primal,              or soá nhöõng kieán giaûi sai laàm cuûa phaùi Tieåu Thöøa hay         fundamental ignorance, the condition before cuûa caùc trieát gia thôøi baáy giôø, töø ñoù oâng baùc boû taát   discernment and differentiation, in contrast with caû nhöõng quan nieäm duy thöùc vaø ña nguyeân ñeå                 ignorance in detail (chi maït voâ minh)—Original giaùn tieáp thieát laäp hoïc thuyeát “Nhaát Nguyeân” cuûa          darkness or ignorance. mình. Boä Keä Caên Baûn Trung Quaùn trôû thaønh giaùo              Caên Baûn Voâ Phaân Bieät Trí: Mulajnana (skt)— ñieån caên baûn cuûa tröôøng phaùi Trung Quaùn, noù                Fundamental wisdom—Original wisdom—Primal nhaán maïnh ñeán “taùnh khoâng,” theo ñoù vaïn höõu                wisdom—See Caên Baûn Trí. khoâng coù thöïc taùnh, maø chæ hieän höõu nhôø nhaân              Caên Bieân Uaån: Ekarasa-skandha (skt)—Nhaát Vò duyeân vaø khoâng hieän höõu cuõng vì nhaân duyeân —               Uaån—Taâm thöùc coù töø luùc voâ thæ—The One of the three main works of the Middle                          beginningless consciousness. School, composed by Nagarjuna. Fortunately the                     Caên Bònh Chung Cuûa Ngöôøi Tu: Common Sanskrit text of it has been preserved. It was                     disease of practitioners. translated into Chinese by Kumarajiva. It is a                     Caên Boån Nghieäp Baát Töông Öng Nhieãm Taâm: treatise of verses written in 27 sections in which                 Giai ñoaïn cao nhaát cuûa Boà Taùt khi tieán vaøo Phaät Nagarjuna refutes certain wrong views of                           quaû, moät trong saùu thöù nhieãm taâm trong Khôûi Tín Mahayana or of general philosophers, thereby                       Luaän—The non-interrelated or primary taint of rejecting all realistic and pluralistic ideas, and                 accepting the idea of primal action or activity in indirectly establishing his monistic doctrine.                     the absolute. This is the highest bodhisattva stage, Mulamadhyamaka-karika became the central text                      entering the Buddhahood, one of the six mental of the Madhyamaka tradition. it focuses on the                     taints of the Awakening of Faith—See Luïc Nhieãm doctrine of emptiness (sunyata), according to                      Taâm. which all conditioned phenomena (samskrta) are

Caên Boån Trí: Voâ phaân bieät trí—Chính theå trí—           Caên Löïc Giaùc Ñaïo: Roots, powers, limbs of truth, Chaân trí—See Nhö Lyù Trí and Caên Baûn Trí.                 and path—See Nguõ Caên, Nguõ Löïc, Thaát Giaùc Chi, Caên Caûnh: Coøn goïi laø Caên Traàn, töù c laø phaïm vi     and Baùt Chaùnh Ñaïo. hoaït ñoäng cuûa caên, hay caûnh maø saéc töôùng döïa        Caên Moân: Sense door—Luïc caên chính laø nhöõng vaøo ñeå thu laáy (moät khi caên traàn ñoái nhau thì taâm    cöûa ngoõ cho phieàn naõo xaâm nhaäp —The senses as laäp töùc khôûi leân)—The field of any organ, its field      doors through which illusion enters. of operation.                                                Caên Phaåm: Indriyanirdesa (skt)—Caùi duïng cuûa Caên Cô: Ky Tính—Tö chaát (caên cô, phaåm taùnh töï          phaùp—The function of the dharmas. nhieân)—Fundamenal               ability—Fundamental         Caên Tan Raõ: Faculties are disintegrated. quality—Level—Motive                   power—Natural         Caên Taùnh: See Caên Tính. ability—Original endowment and nature.                       Caên Thöôïng Haï Trí Löïc: Moät trong Thaäp Ñaïi Caên Cô Thaáp: Low (dull) capacity.                          Löïc cuûa Phaät, bieát ñöôïc heát thaûy taùnh vaø nghieäp Caên Cô Trung Haï: From moderate to low                      cuûa chuùng sanh—One of a Buddha’s great ten capacities.                                                  powers, to know the capacities of all beings, their Caên Duyeân: Indriyapaccayo (p)—Traàn Duyeân—                nature and karma—See Thaäp Löïc (2). Faculty condition—Caên tính cuûa con ngöôøi vaø              Caên Taùnh: See Caên Tính. nhaân duyeân cuûa hoaøn caûnh nöông töïa vaøo nhau,          Caên Taùnh Duyeân: Cause-nature-environment— hay söï nöông töïa giöõa luïc caên vaø luïc traàn, maø söï   Caên tính cuûa con ngöôøi vaø nhaân duyeân cuûa hoaøn taùc ñoäng lôùn laø ôû luïc caên—Cause, nature and           caûnh nöông töïa vaøo nhau, hay söï nöông töïa giöõa environment; natural powers and conditioning                 luïc caên vaø luïc traàn, maø söï taùc ñoäng lôùn laø ôû luïc environment.                                                 caên. Caûnh cuûa luïc traàn (saéc, thanh, höông, vò, xuùc, Caên Ñeá Trung Quaùn Luaän Thích: Mula-                      phaùp) laø nhöõng sôû duyeân laøm nhô baån taâm tính; madhyamakakarika (skt)—Fundamental Verses                    hay söï phoái hôïp giöõa luïc caên vaø luïc traàn, maø luïc on the Middle Way—Boä luaän giaûi thích nhöõng               traàn laø yeáu toá chính—Cause, nature and ñieåm caên baûn trong Trung Quaùn Luaän cuûa Ngaøi           environment; natural powers and conditioning Long Thoï—Explanations of fundamental verses                 environment. The circumstances or conditions on the Madhyamaka Sastra.                                    environing the mind created by the six gunas. Caên Ñoän: Dull powers.                                      Conditioning environment and natural powers in Caên Hieän Löôïng: Pratyaksha (skt)—Abhisamaya               which environment plays a main role. (skt)—Abhisamaya           (skt)—The          immediate      Caên Thöùc: Caên khí cuøng taøi naêng vaø kieán thöùc realization of enlightenment or nirvana—See                  cuûa chuùng sanh—Natural capacity, talent and Hieän Chöùng.                                                knowledge of beings. Caên Höông: Putchuk (skt)—Moäc Höông.                        Caên Tính: Natural capacity—1) Baûn tính cuûa Caên Khí: Khaû naêng töï nhieân cuûa caên, hay cuûa          naêng löïc cuûa caùc giaùc quan: Natural disposition, chuùng sanh (thieân tö cuûa chuùng sanh coù theå ñaûm        nature and character, the nature of the power of nhaän Phaät phaùp)—Natural capacity, capacity of             any sense; 2) Caên khí: Capacity of any organ; 3) any organ, or of beings.                                     Tính ñöùc töï nhieân toát hay xaáu, ñoái laïi vôùi tu ñöùc Caên Khuyeát: Moät trong nguõ caên bò khieám khuyeát,        ñaït ñöôïc qua tu taäp: Natural capacity for good or nhö muø hay ñieác—Defective in any organ of                  evil, in contrast with powers of goodness obtained sense, e.g. blind or deaf.                                   by practice. Caên Lôïi: Caên tính thoâng minh lanh lôïi, ñoái laïi vôùi   Caên Tònh: Söï thanh tònh cuûa luïc caên—The purity caên ñoän—Of penetrative powers, intelligent, in             of the six organs of sense. contrast with dull powers.                                   Caên Traàn: Caên Caûnh: The object or sensation of Caên Löïc: Caên vaø löïc: Organs and their powers—           any organ of sense—Khaû naêng nhaän bieát vaø caùc Nguõ Caên Nguõ Löïc: The five organs of sense and            ñoái töôïng cuûa chuùng: Cognitive faculties and their five powers—See Nguõ Caên, and Nguõ Löïc.              objects. Caên Tö: Caên khí vaø ngoä taùnh—Khaû naêng töï nhieân cuûa caên vaø taùnh giaùc ngoä cuûa chuùng sanh—Natural

capacity (capacity of any organ) and the nature of           especially the Vinaya as containing in the laws awakening of beings,.                                        and regulations of Buddhism. Caên Yeát La: Kinkara (skt)—Khaån Yeát La Boà                Caám Haï Baát Caám Ñoâng: Haï an cö, töø raèm thaùng Taùt—Teân cuûa moät vò Boà Taùt—Name of a                    tö ñeán raèm thaùng baûy—Summer retreat, from the Bodhisattva.                                                 fifteenth day of the fourth month till the fifteenth Caên Yeát La Ñoàng Töû: See Caên Yeát La.                    day of the seventh month (lunar calendar)—See Caêng Giaø: Soâng Haèng Haø—The river Ganges—                An Cö Kieát Haï. See Haèng Haø.                                               Caám Phoøng: To go into retreat—See An Cö Kieát Caêng thaúng: Tension.                                       Haï. Caêng Thöùc: Khuoân pheùp—Rule of conduct—Rule               Caám Saùt Sanh: Not to kill. of behavior.                                                 Caám Saùt Sanh Ñeå Cuùng Döôøng Hay Ñaõi Khaùch: Caêng Yeát La: Kimkara (skt)—Kim Giaø La—1)                  No animals should be slaughtered for offerings or Ngöôøi noâ leä: A slave; 2) Thò giaû: A server, an           entertain guests. attendant; 3) See Kim Cang La Ñoàng Töû; 4) Khaån            Caám Tuùc: Chuyeân ôû moät nôi ñeå tham thieàn, chöù Yeát La Boà Taùt hay Caên Yeát La, teân cuûa moät vò Boà     khoâng ra ngoaøi haønh cöôùc du phöông—To confine Taùt: Kinkara (skt)—Name of a Bodhisattva.                   oneself in a place for practicing meditation, not to Caét Ñöùt Luyeán AÙi Nhò Bieân: To sever                     wander or travel about. dualistic attachments (attachments to either                 Caàm Thuù: Birds and beasts. pleasure, not pleasure or indifference).                     Caàm Tuø: To detain—To imprison—To keep Caét Ñöùt Nghi Laàm: To cut off all doubts.                  someone in prison. Caâm vaø Ñieác: Edamuka (skt)—Deaf and dumb,                 Caåm Bao Ñaëc Thaïch: Duøng taám gaám ñeå bao boïc unable to express oneself.                                   taûng ñaù, yù noùi cô phaùp cuûa vaøi vò thieàn sö tuy beân Caám: Caám caûn hay ngaên caûn—To forbid—To                  ngoaøi meàm moûng nhöng beân trong cöùng raén vaø prohibit—To interdict—To ban—To                      bar--   nghieâm khaéc—To cover a stone with a velvet Prohibitions.                                                cloth. In Zen, the term means methods of some Caám Cheá: Nisedha (skt)—Prohibition—Söï caám                masters seem gentle outward (outward cheá (trong nghi leã cuùng kieán).                           gentleness), but tough and strict inside. Caám Chæ: See Caám.                                          Caåm Tuù: Very beautiful. Caám Chuù Taïng: Taïng chuù bí maät cuûa Maät giaùo,         Caân: Caùi rìu: An adze—Moät caân Taøu: One and môùi ñöôïc theâm vaøo Tam Taïng Kinh Ñieån cuûa              one-third pounds. Phaät—The Vidyadharapitaka, or Dharanipitaka,                Caân Bình: 1) Thò giaû cho sö truï trì: The abbot's the canon of dharanis, a later addition to the               attendant; 2) Khaên vaø bình: Kinbyo (jap)—Towel Tripitaka.                                                   and flask. Caám Duïc Chuû Nghóa: Asceticism—Chuû nghóa                  Caân Ñaåu: Nhaøo loän. Trong thieàn, töø naày chæ traïng Khoå haïnh—Cuoäc soáng khoå haïnh—Life of                    thaùi ngoä cuûa haønh giaû—To make loops or ascetisism.                                                  somersaults. In Zen, the term indicates a state of Caám Ñoâng Baát Caám Haï: Ñoâng an cö, töø raèm              enlightenment. thaùng möôøi ñeán raèm thaùng gieâng naêm sau—               Caân Nhaéc: To consider carefully—To deliberate. Winter retreat, from the fifteenth day of the tenth          Caân Nhaéc Lôïi Haïi: To weigh the pros and cons. month till the fifteenth day of the first month of           Caân Thò: Thò giaû cho sö truï trì—The abbot's the following year (lunar calendar).                         attendant. Caám Giôùi: Sila or Pratimoksa (skt)—Phieân aâm              Caàn: Virya (skt)—Teân cuûa taâm sôû, nghóa laø theo tieáng Phaïn laø Thi La Hay Ba La Ñeà Moäc              chuyeân caàn, hay tinh taán—Energy—Zeal— Xoa, nghóa laø giôùi luaät do Phaät cheá ñònh ñeå ngaên      Fortitude—Virility—See Tinh Taán. chaën söï sai traùi nôi thaân khaåu yù cuûa caùc ñeä töû—    Caàn Ba Töû: Engo-kokugon (jap)—Vieân Ngoä Abstention, or prohibitions, commandments,                   Khaéc Caàn Thieàn Sö—Yuan-Wu-Ko-Chin—See Khaéc Caàn Phaät Quaû Thieàn Sö.

Caàn Caàu: Tìm caàu nhöõng vieäc toát—To seek                  Caän Duyeân: Moät trong ba moái duyeân noái keát khi diligently after the good.                                     chuùng ta caàu nieäm Phaät. Ñöùc Phaät A Di Ñaø hieån Caàn Chuyeån: See Khuyeán Chuyeån.                             hieän ngay tröôùc nhöõng ngöôøi mong moûi ñöôïc thaáy Caàn Cöïu: Nhöõng vò Taêng lôùn tuoåi vaø ñaõ nghæ höu         Ngaøi—One of the three nidanas or links with the trong töï vieän. Öu tieân chính cuûa hoï laø tu taäp vaø       Buddha resulting from calling upon him. Amitabha tham thieàn nhaäp ñònh cho ñeán cuoái ñôøi —Elderly            Buddha shows himself to those who desire to see monks who have already retired from any posts in               him—See Tam Duyeân (III). a monastery. Their main priority is to cultivate and           Caän Ñaïi: Modern times. meditate for the rest of their life.                           Caän Ñaïo Baát Tri: To be unaware that we are Caàn Haønh: Tinh caàn laøm vieäc thieän. Caàn haønh            near the truth—"Ñaïo gaàn beân maø chaúng bieát," quaû coøn coù nghóa laø sieâng naêng tu taäp—Diligently             laø nhö vaäy! Moãi ngöôøi chuùng ta töø saùng cho ñeán going forward to pursue the good. Zealous conduct              toái, laø moät doøng hieåu bieát khoâng ngöøng tuoân chaûy, also means devoted to service, worship, etc.                   moät baûn giao höôûng baát taän goàm voâ soá giai ñieäu Caàn Ích: Useful—Serviceable.                                  traàm boång cuûa naêng löïc tri giaùc. Chuùng ta chaúng Caàn Saùch: See Caàn Saùch Luaät Nghi.                         bao giôø taùch rôøi khoûi doøng chaûy hieåu bieát aáy; moïi Caàn Saùch Luaät Nghi: Sramanerasamvara (skt)—                 thôøi ñeàu laø hieän taïi. Cuoäc soáng laø moät bí aån lôùn, Luaät nghi cho ngöôøi môùi tu caàn cuø coá gaéng tuaân         maø cuõng chaúng chuùt bí aån naøo caû. Nieàm an laïc ñeán theo lôøi chæ daïy cuûa caùc baäc ñaïi Taêng—Precepts          töø vieäc thaáy raèng khoâng coù an laïc maø khoâng maâu for a new practitioner to follow the instructions of           thuaãn, nhöng nieàm an laïc khi nhaän thaáy raèng maâu great monks—See Sa Di Giôùi.                                   thuaãn cuõng xuaát phaùt tri kieán thöïc taïi. Chim bay Caàn Thaùo (758-827): Teân cuûa moät vò Taêng Nhaät            treân trôøi, caù loäi döôùi nöôùc, con ngöôøi soáng trong Baûn Tam Luaän toâng, queâ ôû Yamato—Name of a                 naêng löïc hieåu bieát. Haønh giaû tu Thieàn haõy töï mình Japanese master, of the San Lun sect. He came                  thöùc ngoä. Taát caû nhöõng gì ngöôøi khaùc tìm thaáy voán from Yamato, Japan.                                            khoâng thuoäc veà mình. Haõy töï mình tìm kieám vaø Caàn Thaàn Tuùc: Tinh Taán Nhö YÙ Thaàn Tuùc hay               naém baét. Khi mình toïa thieàn vaø hít vaøo, caùi gì ñang tinh taán thöïc chöùng thaàn thoâng. ÔÛ ñaây vò Tyø Kheo       hieän höõu? Khi mình thôû ra, caùi gì ñang hieän höõu? tu taäp caàn thaàn tuùc caâu höõu vôùi tinh taán thöïc hieän   Taát caû nhöõng gì ngöôøi khaùc thuyeát giaûng laø kinh Tinh Taán Thieàn Ñònh. Ñaây laø moät trong Töù Thaàn           nghieäm nhaän thöùc cuûa hoï, chaúng coù quan heä gì ñeán Tuùc (boán ñieàu neân bieát ñuû)—Effort to realize             mình. Haõy thaønh taâm töï vaán: Caùi gì ñang hieän höõu magic (virya-rddhi-pada) or vigor or exertion or               ñaây?—How near the truth indeed! Each one of us, sufficience of energy or intensified effort. Here a            from morning till night, is a continuous flow of monk develops concentration of energy                          knowing, and unending symphony of knowing, a accompanied by strenuous efforts. This is one of               rising and falling of knowing. We are never out of the four steps to rddhi or supernatural powers or              knowing; it is always present. It is a great mystery, four sufficiences—See Töù Nhö YÙ Tuùc.                         and yet there is no mystery to it. The peace that Caàn        Thieát:         Indispensable—Essential—           comes from seeing this is not a peace without Necessary.                                                     conflict, but a peace that sees that conflict too is Caàn Töùc: Sramana (skt)—Haùn dòch laø Sa Moân,                knowing. Birds fly in the air, fish swim in the nghóa laø ngöôøi chaêm laøm caùc vieäc thieän, vaø ngaên       water, human beings live in knowing. Zen ngöøa caùc vieäc aùc—One who diligently pursues the            practitioners should always look for yourself. good, and ceases from evil.                                    Never mind about all those people who have got Caàn Yeáu: Essential—Important.                                this or that. Find for yourself. When you sit in Caån Baïch: To inform respectfully.                            zazen and breathe out, what is it? When you breathe in, what is it? Never mind what others Caån Chính: Cautious and decent. have to say. What is it? Caån Kính: Respectful. Caän Ñònh: Upacara samadhi (p)—Partial Caån Troïng: Prudent—Cautious—Careful. concentration—Ñònh ñöôïc moät phaàn naøo ñoù. Caän: Gaàn: Near (close)—Thaân maät: Intimate.

Caän Ñoàng: Upasaka (skt)—Vò tuïc Sa Di hoïc Phaät          Caän Truï Vieân: Teân khaùc cuûa Nieát Baøn—Another Phaùp hay teân khaùc cuûa Öu Baø Taéc—A devotee,            name for Nirvana. or disciple, or another name for Upasaka.                   Caän Töû Nghieäp: Asanna-kamma (p)—Death Caän Giaùc Thöôøng Quan (1870-1941): Teân cuûa              proximate kamma—Near-death karma—See moät vò Taêng Nhaät Baûn Tònh Ñoä Chaân Toâng, queâ ôû      Nghieäp Caän Töû. Shiga—Name of a Japanese master, of the True                Caän Vieân: Near perfection. Pure Land Sect (Jodo Shinshu (jap). He came from            Caän Vieân Giôùi: See Vieân Cuï, and Cuï Tuùc Giôùi. Shiga, Japan.                                               Caáp: 1) Ban cho: To give; 2) Caëp ñöïng saùch: Caän Keà Töû Thaàn: On the verge of death.                  Book-box; 3) Caáp baùch: Urgent, haste, promptly; Caän Lai: Recently.                                         4) Keùo nöôùc töø gieáng leân: To draw water (out of a Caän Nhaân: Immediate cause—Direct cause—                   well). Chính nhaân—Nhaân chính, so vôùi nhaân phuï—                Caáp Chö Coâ Laõo: See Caáp Coâ Ñoäc. Correct cause (Buddha nature of all beings). Main           Caáp Coâ Ñoäc: Anathapindika (skt)—A Na Tha Taân cause—True cause, as compared to a contributory             Ñoà Ñaø—A Na Ñaø Taân Ñoà Ñaø—Teân thaät laø Tu cause.                                                      Ñaït (Sadatta), ngöôøi cho ngöôøi ngheøo baùnh vaø ñoà Caän Phaàn Ñònh: Samantaka-samadhi (skt)—Gia                aên, ngöôøi nuoâi naáng nhöõng keû coâ ñoäc, soáng vaøo Haïnh Ñònh—Phöông Tieän Ñònh—Concentration                  thôøi cuûa Ñöùc Phaät Thích Ca vaø laø moät trong nhöõng of expedient means.                                         ñeä töû taïi gia noåi tieáng cuûa Phaät. OÂng ñaõ mua Truùc Caän Quaû: Quaû baùo tieáp caän vôùi nhaân—See              Laâm Tònh Xaù cho Phaät vaø giaùo ñoaøn an cö kieát haï Chaùnh Quaû.                                                trong ba thaùng muøa möa gaàn thaønh Vöông Xaù. Söï Caän Söï: Those who attend on and serve the                 boá thí cuûa oâng lôùn ñeán noãi laøm cho cuoái cuøng oâng Triratna.                                                   phaûi trôû neân ngheøo khoå, nhöng laïi ñöôïc quaû taùi Caän Söï Nam: Upasaka (skt)—Gonji-Nan (jap)—                sanh vaøo cung trôøi Ñaâu Suaát—His real name is OÂ Ba Saéc Ca—Öu Baø Taéc—Ngöôøi nam taïi gia thoï          Sadatta, the giver of cakes or food to the poor, the trì nguõ giôùi, laáy nghóa gaàn guõi Tam Baûo ñeå phuïng    feeder of forlorn, who lived at the time of the söï Nhö Lai—Male servant or disciple (Layman—               Sakyamuni Buddha, was one of the Buddha’s most Servant—Follower) i,e, laymen or woman who                  renowned lay folowers. He purchased Jetavana so undertake to oney the five commandments.                    that the Buddha and Sangha could pass the rains Caän Söï Nam Nöõ: Upasaka-Upasika (skt)—Gonji-              retreat near Sravasti. His generosity was so great Nannyo (jap)—Laypeople.                                     that he was finally reduced to poverty, but he was Caän Söï Nöõ: Upasika (skt)—Gonji-Nyo (jap)—                rewarded with rebirth in Tusita heaven. Female servant or disciple—Laywoman.                        Caáp Coâ Ñoäc vieân: Garden of the Benefactor of Caän Thaân: Close (near) relation.                          Orphans         and       the     Solitary—Garden          of Caän Truï: Caän söï nam hay nöõ giöõ taùm giôùi tu taïi     Anathapindika. gia—Laymen or women who remain home and                     Caáp Ña: Upagupta (skt)—Cuùc Ña—Quaät Ña— observe the eight commandments—See Cö Só.                   Teân cuûa moät trong Hai Möôi Taùm Toå AÁn Ñoä — Caän Truï Luaät Nghi: Taùm giôùi maø nam nöõ taïi gia       Name of one of twenty-eight Indian patriarchs— thoï trì—The eight commandments which received              See Hai Möôi Taùm Toå AÁn Ñoä. by laymen and women.                                        Caáp Ña Vöông Trieàu: Gupta (skt)—Moät trieàu ñaïi Caän Truï Nam: See Caän Truï.                               taïi AÁn Ñoä, toàn taïi vaøo theá kyû thöù III vaø thöù IV—A Caän Truï Nöõ: Upasika (skt)—Laywomen—Nöõ                   dynasty in India in the third and fourth centuries. Phaät töû taïi gia phuïng söï Phaät giaùo maø khoâng trôû   Caáp Phoøng Baùt Ñeå: Gavampati (skt)—Kieâu thaønh ni coâ—A lay woman who devotes herself to            Phaïm Ba Ñeà. Buddhism at home without becoming a nun. A                  Caáp Thí: Boá thí khaån caáp—Urgent almsgiving— woman who remains at home and observe the                   Alms made under stress of urgency. eight commandments.                                         Caáp Thí Nhö Luaät Leänh: Caâu thaàn chuù ñöôïc caùc thaày phuø thuûy nieäm—“Swiftly as Lu-Ling runs,” used by sorcerer in their incantation.

Caáp Thò:                                                     Caâu Caâu La Boä: Cöu Cöu La Boä hay Keâ Daän Boä, 1) Haàu haï: To attend on.                                    moät trong 18 boä cuûa phaùi Tieåu Thöøa —Kukkutikah 2) Thò giaû: Attendant.                                       (skt) is described as one of the eighteen schools of Caáp Thieát Caàu Sanh: Urgently seeking rebirth.              Hinayana—See Keâ Daãn Boä. Caáp Thôøi: Immediately—At once.                              Caâu Chaáp: Vöôùng maéc vaøo—To be attached to— Caáp Tænh Luaân: Voøng sanh töû luaân hoài voâ cuøng          To entangle oneself in—Entanglement of. voâ cöïc nhö guoàng xe muùc nöôùc gieáng leân xuoáng          Caâu Chi Nhaát Chæ: Chu-chih Raises One khoâng ngöøng—The round of reincarnation (cycle)              Finger—See Caâu Chi Thuï Chæ. is like the waterwheel at the well ever revolving             Caâu Chi Thieàn Sö: Koti (skt)—Gutei (jap)—Koti up and down.                                                  (skt)—Chu-chih (Wade-Giles Chinese)—Thieàn sö Caáp Trí: Quick witted.                                       Caâu Chi, khoaûng theá kyû thöù IX, ñeä töû vaø truyeàn Caäp Moân Ñeä Töû: Hoïc troø chính thöùc—Registered           nhaân noái phaùp cuûa Haøng Chaâu Thieân Long—A students.                                                     Chinese Zen master of about the 9th century; a Caäp Thôøi: On time—Timely.                                   student and dharma successor of Zen Caát Gaùnh: To put down a burden.                             master Hang-chou T'ien-lung. Caát Gaùnh Lo AÂu: To put down a burden of                     Thieàn sö Caâu Chi ít ñöôïc bieát ñeán, teân cuûa anxiety.                                                           oâng chæ xuaát hieän trong moät coâng aùn noåi tieáng Caät Luaän: Baøn luaän—To debate.                                  thöù 3 cuûa Voâ Moân Quan—Master Chu-chih, Caät Löïc: To labor.                                               about whom hardly any thing else is known, Caät Vaán: To raise questions—To question in                       appears in a famous koan number 3 of Wu- detail to try to find some weaknesses.                             Men-Kuan. Caâu: 1) Caùi moùc: A hook, a barb; 2) Baét bôù: To            Khi Caâu Chi saép thò tòch, oâng noùi vôùi ñeä töû cuûa seize, to arrest, to take; 3) Moïi: Every.                         mình: 'Ta nhaän ñöôïc Thieàn töø ngoùn tay giô leân Caâu Baát Cöïc Thaønh: Taát caû ñeàu khoâng troïn                  cuûa Thieân Long vaø ta ñaõ aùp duïng noù suoát caû veïn—All incomplete; a fallacy in the comparison,                  moät ñôøi khoâng heát.' Noùi xong oâng thò tòch." or example, which leaves syllogism incomplete.                     Theo Voâ Moân Hueä Khai trong Voâ Moân Quan, haønh giaû tu thieàn neân luoân nhôù raèng choã ngoä Caâu Baát Khieån: Moät yù nghó sai laàm trong lyù luaän cuûa Caâu Chi cuõng nhö cuûa vò ñeä töû khoâng phaûi gaây ra bôûi lôøi daãn duï giôùi thieäu khoâng roõ raøng—A ôû ngoùn tay. Neáu thaáy ñöôïc choã naày thì haønh fallacy in a syllogism caused by introducing an giaû coù theå xaâu ñöôïc Thieân Long. Caâu Chi, vò irrelevant example, one of the thirty-three ñeä töû vaø caû mình nöõa vaøo chung moät moái —As fallacies. Chu-chih was getting ready to depart from the Caâu Boà Taùt: The bodhisattva guardian with the world, he spoke to his students and said, 'I trident, one of the four with barb, noose, chain, or received the one-finger Zen from T'ien-ling, I bell. used it my whole life long and never used it Caâu Ca Lôïi: Kokalika (skt)—Teân cuûa ñeä töû cuûa up.' According to Wu Men Hui-Kai in the Wu- Ñeà Baø Ñaït Ña, ngöôøi ñaõ caùo gian Xaù Lôïi Phaát vaø Men-Kuan, Zen practitioners should always Muïc Kieàn Lieân coù söï daâm duïc vôùi moät ngöôøi ñaøn remember that the enlightenment of Chu-Chih baø. Keát quaû laø oâng bò ñoïa vaøo ñaïi nguïc hoàng lieân and his disciple has nothing to do with the end ngay khi coøn soáng—Name of Devadatta's disciple, of the finger. If you can realize this, then who made a false accusation that Sariputra and T'ien-Lung, Chu-chih, the disciple, and you Maugalyayana had a sexual intercourse with a yourself are all run through with a single woman. As a result, he fell into great lotus hell skewer. while alive. Caâu Chi Thuï Chæ: Chu-chih Raises One Finger— Caâu Caâu La: Kukkuta (skt)—Cöu Cöu La—1) Buoåi ñaàu Thieàn sö Caâu Chi ôû am ôû Kim Hoa Vuï Con gaø troáng: A cock; 2) Tieáng gaø: The clucking Chaâu, coù moät vò Ni teân laø Thaät Teá ñeán am, ñi of fowls. thaúng vaøo chaúng loät noùn, caàm tích tröôïng ñi nhieãu giöôøng thieàn ba voøng noùi: "Noùi ñöôïc thì loät noùn."

Hoûi nhö theá ñeán ba laàn maø Caâu Chi khoâng ñaùp             gì thì mình noùi theo nhö vaäy, maø phaûi giöõ vöõng ñöôïc. Vò Ni lieàn ñi. Caâu Chi noùi: "Trôøi ñaõ chieàu,        tinh thaàn cuûa mình. Söï khaúng ñòng cao hôn naèm coâ haõy ôû laïi nghæ." Vò Ni noùi: "Noùi ñöôïc thì ôû laïi."   nôi tinh thaàn. Theo Thieàn thì tinh thaàn naèm ngay Caâu Chi cuõng khoâng ñaùp ñöôïc. Vò Ni lieàn ñi. Caâu          trong nhöõng vieäc nhö laø ñi, ñöùng, naèm, ngoài haèng Chi than: "Ta tuy mang hình tröôïng phu maø khoâng              ngaøy vaø chuùng seõ laøm taát caû nhöõng nhu caàu cuûa coù khí tröôïng phu. Lieàn phaùt phaãn quyeát roõ ñöôïc         chuùng ta trong ñoù. Vì vaäy haønh giaû tu thieàn caàn vieäc naày." Caâu Chi toan boû am ra ñi caùc nôi ñeå            phaûi thaáu coát thaáu tuûy, phaûi thaáy thaáu môùi ñöôïc — tham thænh, laøm ngöôøi haønh cöôùc toâi luyeä n. Ñeâm          During the time when Zen Master Chu-chih first aáy, Sôn thaàn ñeán maùch: "Chaúng caàn rôøi choã naày,         dwelt in a hermitage in Chin Hua Wu Chou, there ngaøy mai coù nhuïc thaân Boà Taùt ñeán, vì Hoøa Thöôïng        was a nun named Shih Chi (Reality) who came to noùi phaùp." Quaû thaät ngaøy hoâm sau coù Hoøa Thöôïng         his hut. When she got there she went straight in; Thieân Long ñeán am, Caâu Chi tieáp ñoùn thöa roõ vieäc         without taking off her rain hat, she walked around qua. Thieân Long lieàn ñöa ngoùn tay leân chæ ñoù. Caâu         his meditation seat three times holding her staff. Chi boãng nhieân ñaïi ngoä. Bôûi Caâu Chi hieän thôøi           "If you can speak," she said, "I'll take off my rain trònh troïng chuyeân chuù, neân thuøng thoâng deã luûng         hat." She questioned him like this three times; ñaùy. Sau naày coù ai hoûi, Sö lieàn ñöa moät ngoùn tay         Chu-chih had no reply. Then as she was leaving leân chöù khoâng theå hieän ñieàu gì khaùc. Sau ñoù oâng        Chu-chih said, "It's rather late, would you stay coù moät ngöôøi ñeä töû laøm thò giaû cho oâng. Moät hoâm,      over here during the night?" The nun said, "If you coù ngöôøi hoûi vò ñeä töû naày: 'Thaày maøy daïy thöù phaùp    can speak, I'll stay over." Again Chu-chih had no naøo vaäy?' Ñeä töû cuõng chæ ñöa moät ngoùn tay leân.          reply. The nun then walked out. Chu-chih sighed Caâu Chi nghe thaáy chuyeän naày, beøn laáy dao chaët           sorrowfully and said, "Although I inhabit the body ñöùt ngoùn tay cuûa ñöùa ñeä töû aáy ñi. Vò ñeä töû vöøa        of a man, still I lack a man's spirit." After this he chaïy vöøa la vì quaù ñau ñôùn. Caâu Chi goïi caäu ta tôùi      arouse d his zeal to clarify this matter. He meant beân mình. Caäu hoïc troø quay ñaàu veà phía thaày. Caâu        to abandon his hermitage and travel to various Chi laïi ñöa moät ngoùn tay chæ leân trôøi. Ngöôøi thò giaû     places to call on teachers to ask for instruction, coá baét chöôùc Thaày nhö thöôøng leä, ñöa ngoùn tay            and had wrapped up his things for foot-travelling. leân, nhöng khoâng thaáy ngoùn tay nöõa, ñoät nhieân yù         But that night the spirit of the mountain told him, nghóa naøy böøng saùng trong oâng. Vò ñeä töû hoát nhieân       "You don't have to leave this place. Tomorrow a ñaïi ngoä. Theo Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc, thí            flesh and blood Bodhisattva will come and duï thöù 19, neáu nhaèm treân ñaàu ngoùn tay hieåu thì coâ      expound the truth for you, Master. You don't have phuï Caâu Chi. Neáu chaúng nhaèm treân ñaàu ngoùn tay           to go." As it turned out, the following day, Master hieåu thì gioáng nhö reøn saét laøm ñoà duøng. Hieåu cuõng      T'ien Lung actually came to the hermitage. Chu- theá aáy, maø chaúng hieåu cuõng theá aáy; cao cuõng theá       chih welcomed him ceremoniously and gave a full aáy, maø thaáp cuõng theá aáy; phaûi cuõng theá aáy, maø        account of the previous events. T'ien Lung just quaáy cuõng theá aáy. Do ñoù noùi: "Moät haït buïi vöøa dôû     lifted up one finger to show him; suddenly Chu- leân thì caû quaû ñaát toaøn thaâu, moät ñoùa hoa chôùm nôû     chih was greatly enlightened. At the time Chu- thì toaøn theá giôùi rung ñoäng; moät sôïi loâng sö töû hieän   chih was most earnest and singleminded, so the thì traêm öùc sôïi loâng hieän." Vieân Minh noùi: "Laïnh        bottom of his bucket fell out easily. Later, thì khaép trôøi ñaát ñeàu laïnh; noùng thì khaép trôøi ñaát     whenever anything was asked, Chu-chih just ñeàu noùng; nuùi soâng quaû ñaát thaáu toät huyønh tuyeàn;      raised one finger. Later, he had one disciple, an vaïn töôïng sum la thoâng taän hö khoâng." Haõy noùi laø        attendant. Once outsider asked the attendant, vaät gì maø kyø quaùi theá aáy. Neáu bieát ñöôïc thì chaúng     'What kind of dharma does the master teach?' The tieâu moät caùi aán tay. Neáu bieát chaúng ñöôïc thì            attendant also just held up a finger. Chu-chih chöôùng ngaïi daãy ñaày. Loaïi thieàn naày thaät laø deã        heard about it, immediately grabbed a kitchen tham maø khoù hoäi. Nhö ngöôøi ñôøi nay, coù ai hoûi ñeán       knife, and cut the attendant's finger off. The lieàn ñöa ngoùn tay hay ñöa naém tay leân, ñaây thaät           attendant overwhelmed with pain, ran away khoâng hôn gì söï baét chöôùc trô treõn. Baét chöôùc laø        screaming. Then Chu-chih shouted to him to come noâ leä. Chuùng ta khoâng theå cöù baét chöôùc heã ai noùi      back. The attendant turned his head around. Then

Chu-chih once more held his finger up. The             hay moät thaønh phoá coå ôû Trung AÁn Ñoä (töøng do vua attendant tried to imitate the master as usual, but    Öu Ñieàn cai trò), baây giôø laø laøng Kosam taïi Jumna, the finger was no more there, and then suddenly        khoaûng 30 daäm beân treân Allahabad—A country or the significance of its all dawned upon him. All of    an ancient city in Central India, identified with the a sudden, the attendant attained enlightenment."       village of Kosam on Jumna, 30 miles above According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, example         Allahabad. 19, if you understand at the finger, then you turn     Caâu Duyeân Quaû: Bijapura or Bijapuraka (skt)— your back on Chu-chih; if you don't go to the          Teân moät loaïi quaû, ñöôïc dieãn taû nhö laø quaû chanh, finger to understand, then it's like cast iron.        maø Ñöùc Chuaån Ñeà Quan AÂm caàm trong tay—A Whether you understand ot not, Chu-chih still goes     fruit, described as a citron, held in one of the on this way; whether you're high or low, he still      hands of Kunti Kuan-Yin. goes on this way; whether you're right or wrong,       Caâu Ñaøm Di: Kausambi (skt)—Kosambi (skt)— he still goes on this way. Thus, it's said, "As soon   Vatsapattana (p)—Caâu La Cuø Quoác—Caâu Dieâm as a speck of dust arises, the great earth is          Di Quoác—Caâu Thieâm Di—Cöï Thöôûng Di—Name contained therein; when a single flower is about to    of a city in ancient India—Kieàu Thöông Di, teân open, the world immediately comes into being.          cuûa moät ñoâ thò thôøi coå AÁn Ñoä, moät xöù hay moät The lion on the tip of a single hair appears on the    thaønh phoá coå ôû Trung AÁn Ñoä (töøng do vua Öu tips of ten billion hairs." Yuan Ming said, "When      Ñieàn cai trò), baây giôø laø laøng Kosam taïi Jumna, it's cold, all throughout heaven and earth are cold;   khoaûng 30 daäm beân treân Allahabad. Vöông quoác when it's warm, all throughout heaven and earth        cuûa vua Udayana vôùi kinh ñoâ noåi tieáng ñöôïc ghi are warm." The mountains and rivers and the great      laïi trong Taây Vöïc Kyù. Nôi coù moät hình töôïng Phaät earth reach down through the Yellow Springs            thaät lôùn. Ñaây laø moät trong nhöõng thaønh phoá coå (Hades); the myriad images and multitude of            nhöùt cuûa AÁn Ñoä—A country or an ancient city in forms penetrate upward through the heavens. Tell       Central India, identified with the village of Kosam me, what is so extraordinary? For those who            on Jumna, 30 miles above Allahabad (western part know, it's not worth taking hold of; for those who     of southern Allahabad). The country of King don't know, it blocks them off utterly. This kind of   Udayana in “Central India” with a famous capital Ch'an is easy to approach but hard to understand.      mentioned in the Vogage to the West. There was People these days who just hold up a finger or a       a great image of the Buddha. It was one of the fist as soon as they're questioned; this is no more    most ancient cities of India. than a shameless imitation. Copying is slavery.        Caâu Ñöông: The letter must never be followed, only the spirit     1) Giaûi quyeát: To resolve. is to be grasped. Higher affirmations live in the      2) Nhaân vieân laøm vieäc trong töï vieän: An spirit. In Zen, you can seek the spirit in your               employee in a monastery. everyday experience such as going, standing,           Caâu Giaûi Thoaùt: Simultaneous emancipation— lying down, and sitting, and therein lies abundance    Giaûi thoaùt cuøng luùc—Simultaneous liberation—Trí of proof for all we need. Therefore, it is still       nhaõn hoaøn toaøn giaûi thoaùt, cuøng luùc lìa boû caû hai necessary for Zen practitioners to pierce the bone,    chöôùng phieàn naõo vaø thieàn ñònh. Baäc A La Haùn ñaõ penetrate to the marrow, and see all the way           hoaøn toaøn giaûi thoaùt, baäc ñaõ lìa boû caû tueä vaø ñònh through in order to get it.                            giaûi thoaùt—Complete deliverance in regard to Caâu Chæ: Koti (skt)—Caâu Lôïi.                        both wisdom and meditative or vision hindrances. Caâu Daï La: Nhöõng vaät ñi keøm vôùi baùt nhö         Complete release, i.e. the freedom of the arhat muoãng, ñuõa, vaân vaân—Things that go with the        from moral and meditative hindrances. almsbowl, i.e. spoon, chopsticks, etc.                 Caâu Hoäi Nhaát Xöù: Soáng chung moät choã vôùi caùc Caâu Dieâm Di: Kausambi (skt)—See Caâu Dieâm Di        baäc thöôïng nhaân—To live together with superior Quoác.                                                 people at the same place. Caâu Dieâm Di Quoác: Kausambi, or Vatsapattana         Caâu Höõu: Sahabhu (skt)—Baûn lai—Coá höõu, töï (skt)—Caâu Thieâm Di—Caâu La Cuø Quoác, moät xöù       nhieân—Cuøng song song toàn taïi (hieän höõu)—Ñoàng

thôøi hieän höõu—Existing together—All beings—                ñeä töû noåi tieáng cuûa Ñöùc Phaät—An arhat, maternal Co-existent—Existing—Having—Inherent (a).                     uncle of Sariputra, who became an eminent Caâu Höõu Caên: Caâu Höõu Y—Chö phaùp hay nhöõng              disciple of Sakyamuni. ñieàu kieän maø chuùng ta tuøy thuoäc vaøo (taâm vaø taâm     Caâu Khaùch: To try to attract customers. sôû ñoàng thôøi toàn taïi vaø ñeàu döïa vaøo nhau)—Things     Caâu Khoâng: Moät trong Tam Khoâng. Ngaõ vaø phaùp or conditions on which one relies,                            ñeàu khoâng thöïc—One of the three voids or or from which things spring, i.e. knowledge.                  immaterialities. Both or all empty, or unreal, i.e. Caâu Höõu Nhaân: Sahabhuheta (skt)—Co-existent                both ego and things have no reality—See Tam cause—Corresponding                     causation—Mutual      Khoâng. causation—Simultaneous               causes—Caâu      Höõu    Caâu La: Kula (skt)—1) UÏ ñaát: A Mound; 2) Trieàn Nhaân—Caâu höõu nhaân laø loaïi nhaân maø treân hai yeáu      doác: A slope; 3) Thaùp ñöïng coát cuûa cö só: A small toá luoân luoân cuøng haønh söï vôùi nhau. Moät trong luïc    stupa in which ashes of a layman are kept. nhaân, töù ñaïi cuøng thay phieân nhau laøm nhaân             Caâu La Baùt Ñeå: Kulapati (skt)—Gia chuû—The duyeân. Taâm vöông laø nhaân maø khôûi leân taâm sôû, coi     head of a family—A householder. taâm sôû laø nhaân maø khôûi leân taâm vöông (ví bæ thöû      Caâu La Cuø Quoác: Kausambi (skt)—Kosambi töông öùng neân goïi laø töông öùng nhaân). Caâu höõu         (skt)—Vatsapattana (p)—Caâu Dieâm Di Quoác— nhaân sanh ra quaû ñoàng thôøi, coù nghóa laø töù ñaïi ñeàu   Caâu Thieâm Di—Cöï Thöôûng Di—See Caâu Ñaøm laø nhaân caâu höõu vôùi nhau, khoâng coù caùi gì bò loaïi    Di. boû. Töù ñaïi cuøng thay phieân nhau laøm nhaân duyeân .      Caâu Laâu Baø Vöông: Koravya (skt)—Kuru (skt)— Luaät hoã töông, töùc laø tình traïng hoã töông aûnh          Caâu Löu Sa—See Caâu Löu Baø Vöông. höôûng laøm ñieàu kieän cho nhau. Ñaây laø moät trong         Caâu Lôïi: Koti (skt)—Moät trieäu (coù nôi giaûi thích saùu nhaân sanh ra caùc phaùp höõu vi. Phaùp höõu vi          laø 100, 100.000 hay 10 trieäu)—A million (Also sanh ra ñeàu do söï hoøa hôïp cuûa nhaân vaø duyeân —         explained by 100, or 100,000, or 10 million). The co-existent cause, more than two factors                  Caâu Lôïi Giaø La: Caâu Lôïi Ca La—Caâu Lyù Ca— always working together. Mutual causation, one of             Gia La Ca—Gia Leâ Ca—Coå Löïc Ca—Moät loaïi the six causes, the simultaneous causal interaction           roàng ñen—A kind of black dragon. of a number of things, e.g. earth, water, fire, and           Caâu Lôïi Giaø La Baát Ñoäng Minh Vöông: Duøng air. Corresponding or mutual causation, i.e. mind,            hình töôïng thanh kieám coù roàng ñen bao boïc laøm or mental conditions causing mentation. Mutual                boån toân. Ñaây laø hình Tam Muoäi da cuûa Ñöùc Baát causation or sahabhu-hetus or the co-operative                Ñoäng Minh Vöông—A black dragon with its sword causes produce simultaneous effect, as the four               as a symbol of Arya-Acalanatha-Raja. elements in nature, not one of which can be                   Caâu Lôïi Thaùi Töû: Kolita (skt)—Ngöôøi con tröôûng omitted. The simultaneous causal interaction of a             cuûa Ñaáu Phaïm Vöông, moät ngöôøi chuù cuûa Phaät number of things, e.g. earth, water, fire, and air.           Thích Ca; coù ngöôøi noùi laø Ma-Ha-Na-Ma, nhöng The law of mutuality, that is, the state of being             coù ngöôøi laïi noùi laø Ma Ha Muïc Kieán Lieâ n—The mutually conditioned. This is one of the six causes           eldest son of Dronodana, uncle of Sakyamuni; of all conditioned things. Every phenomenon                   said to be Mahanama, but others say depends upon the union of the primary cause and               Mahamaudgalyayana. conditional or environmental cause—See Luïc                   Caâu Loâ Xaù: Krosa (skt)—Caâu Laâu Xaù—Caâu Loâ Nhaân (A).                                                    Xa—1) Khoaûng xa nhaát coù theå nghe tieáng boø roáng Caâu Höõu Phaùp: Chö phaùp (töù ñaïi ñòa, thuûy, hoûa,        hay tieáng troáng ñaùnh: The distance a bull’s bellow phong) cuøng hieän höõu vaø cuøng laø taùc nhaân trong        or the sound of a drum can be heard; 2) Moät phaàn moïi ñieàu kieän hay hoaøn caûnh—Co-existent, co-             taùm cuûa Duï Thieân Na hay 5 daäm: The eighth part operative things, conditions, or circumstances.               of a yojana or 5 miles. Caâu Höõu Sôû Y: Neàn taûng chung—Shared basis.               Caâu Lö Chaâu: Kurudvipa or Uttarakuru (skt)— Caâu Hy La: Kausthila (skt)—Caâu Saét Sæ La—Caâu              Teân goïi cuûa Baéc Ñaïi Chaâu hay Baéc Cu Loâ Chaâu— Saét Chæ La—Teân cuûa moät vò A La Haùn, moät ngöôøi          The northern of the four continents of a world— caäu cuûa ngaøi Xaù Lôïi Phaát, ngöôøi ñaõ trôû thaønh moät   See Baéc Caâu Lö Chaâu.

Caâu Lö Xaù: Krosa (skt)—See Caâu Loâ Xaù.                    phía taây nam cuûa Nalanda trong xöù Ma Kieät Ñaø — Caâu Löu: To arrest—To confine.                               According to Eitel in The Dictionary of Chinese- Caâu Löu Baø Vöông: Koravya (skt)—Kuru (skt)—                 English Buddhist Terms composed by Professor Caâu Löu Sa—Teân cuûa vua xöù Caâu Löu Sa. Xöù maø            Soothill in 1937, Kulika, used to be a big city ngöôøi noùi chính taïi ñaây Ñöùc Phaät ñaõ thuyeát giaûng     about 9 miles south-west of Nalanda University in Kinh Tröôøng A Haøm—Name of the king of Kuru.                 Magadha. The country where Buddha is said to have                      Caâu Ma La: Kumara (skt)—1) Ñoàng Töû: A child; delivered the sutra the Long Discourses.                      2) Thieáu Nieân: A youth; 3) Thaùi Töû: A prince; 4) Caâu Löu Sa: Kuru (skt)—Xöù maø ngöôøi noùi chính             Phaùp vöông töû: Son of the Dharma-king taïi ñaây Ñöùc Phaät ñaõ thuyeát giaûng Kinh Tröôøng A        (Bodhisattva). Haøm—The country where Buddha is said to have                 Caâu Ma La Ña: Kumaralabdha (skt)—Caâu Ma La delivered the sutra the Long Discourses.                      Laù Ña—Cöu Ma La Ña—Coøn goïi laø Caâu Ma La Caâu Löu Taàn Phaät: Krakucchanda or Kakuda-                  La Ña, Cuû Ma La Ña, Cöu Ma La Ñaø, Cöu Ma La Katyayana (skt)—See Caâu Löu Toân Phaät.                      Ñaït, Haùn dòch laø Ñoàng Haøo, Ñoàng Thuû, Ñoàng Thuï, Caâu Löu Toân: Krakucchanda (skt)—See Caâu Löu                Ñoàng Töû. Teân cuûa hai vò sö noåi tieáng, moät laø Cöu Toân Phaät.                                                   Ma La Ña soáng thôøi vua A Duïc (theo Duy Thöùc Caâu Löu Toân Maâu Ni: Krakucchanda or Kakuda-                Thuaät Kyù, sau khi Ñöùc Phaät nhaäp dieät khoaûng 100 Katyayana (skt)—Caâu Löu Toân Phaät.                          naêm, ôû nöôùc Ñaùt Xoa Kieàu La, phía baéc Thieân Caâu Löu Toân Phaät: Krakucchanda or Kakuda-                  Truùc, coù ngaøi Cöu Ma La Ña, dòch laø Ñoàng Thuû ñaõ Katyayana (skt)—Cöu Laâu Toân Phaät—Caâu Löu                  laøm ra “Cöûu Baùch Luaän.” Roài 400 naêm sau môùi ra Taàn Phaät—Ca La Cöu Xan Ñaø—Ca La Cöu Thoân                  ñôøi moät vò khaùc cuõng teân Cöu Ma La Ña laøm toå Ñaø—Yeát Laïc Ca Toân Ñaø—Yeát La Ca oân Ñaø—                 ñôøi thöù 19 ôû AÁn Ñoä—Names of two noted monks, Yeát La Ca Thoán Ñòa—Yeát Caâu Thoân Na.                      one during the period of Asoka, founder of the 1) Vò Phaät thöù nhaát trong caùc vò Phaät trong (1000        Sautrantika sect; the other Kumaralabdha, or vò Phaät) Hieàn kieáp, vò Phaät thöù tö trong baûy vò   Kumarata, the nineteenth patriarch—See Hai coå Phaät: The first of the Buddhas of the              Möôi Taùm Toå AÁn Ñoä.. present Bhadrakalpa, the fourth of the seven            Caâu Ma La Laù Ña: Kumaralabdha (skt)—Cöu ancient Buddhas.                                        Ma La Ña—See Caâu Ma La Ña. 2) Theo Kinh Ñòa Taïng Boà Taùt, phaåm thöù chín,             Caâu Ma La Thieân: Kumarakadeva (skt)—Cöu veà thuôû quaù khöù, coù ñöùc Phaät ra ñôøi hieäu laø   Ma La Thieân—Cöu Ma La Giaø Thieân—Vò Ñeá Caâu Löu Toân Nhö Lai. Nhö coù ngöôøi nam               Thích hay Phaïm Thieân ôû sô thieàn, maët troâng nhö ngöôøi nöõ naøo nghe danh hieäu cuûa ñöùc Phaät         treû con, ngoài treân löng coâng, moät tay caàm kích, ñaây, chí taâm chieâm ngöôõng leã baùi, hoaëc taùn      moät tay caàm chuoâng vaø côø —A youthful deva, an thaùn, ngöôøi naày nôi phaùp hoäi cuûa moät ngaøn       Indra of the first dhyana heaven whose face is like ñöùc Phaät trong Hieàn Kieáp laøm vò Ñaïi Phaïm         that of a youth, sitting on a peacock, holding a Vöông, ñaëng Phaät thoï kyù ñaïo Voâ thöôïng cho:       cock, a bell, and a flag. According to the Earth Store Bodhisattva                Caâu Ma La Vöông: Kumara (skt)— Sutra, Chapter 9, in the past, a Buddha named           Kumarabhuta-raja (skt)—Cöu Ma La Phuø Ña— Krakucchanda appeared in the world. If a man            Cöu Ma La Phuø—Phaùp Vöông töû hay Boà Taùt, or woman hears this Buddha’s name and                   ngöôøi keá thöøa ngoâi vò cuûa Phaät ñeå noái truyeàn sincerely beholds, worships, or praises him,            Chaùnh Phaùp—Son of the Dharma-king— that person will become the king of the Greay           Bodhisattva—Dharma prince. Brahma Heaven in the assemblies of the one              Caâu Ma Lôïi Thieân: Kumari-deva (skt)—Teân cuûa thousand Buddhas of the Worthy Aeon, and                moät vò trôøi—Name of a deity. will there receive a superior prediction.               Caâu Meâ Ñaø: Kumidha (skt)—Theo Eitel trong Caâu Lyù Ca: Kulika (skt)—Theo Eitel trong Trung              Trung Anh Phaät Hoïc Töø Ñieån cuûa Giaùo Sö Anh Phaät Hoïc Töø Ñieån cuûa Giaùo Sö Soothill, nôi          Soothill, ñaây töøng laø moät vöông quoác coå naèm treân ñaây töøng laø moät thaønh phoá lôùn, khoaûng 9 daäm veà      Beloortagh, veà phía baéc cuûa Badakhshan—

According to Eitel in The Dictionary of Chinese-                 seven persons worthy of offerings—See Baûy Loaïi English Buddhist Terms composed by Professor                     Ngöôøi Ñaùng Kính Troïng. Soothill, this used to be an ancient kingdom on the              Caâu Pheä La: Kuvera or Kubera (skt)—1) Moät vò Beloortagh to the north of Badakhshan.                           Thieân Vöông ôû phöông Baéc, Tyø Sa Moân Thieân Caâu Na Haøm Maâu Ni: Kanakamuni (skt)—                          Vöông, coù ba chaân taùm raêng: The god of riches, Konagamana (p)—Caâu Na Haøm—Caâu Na Maâu                         Vaisravana, regent of the north, having three legs Ni—Ca Naëc Ca Maâu Ni—Vò Phaät thöù nhì trong 5                  and eight teeth; 2) Vua xöù Baéc Cu Loâ Chaâu: King vò Phaät Hieàn Kieáp, cuõng laø vò Phaät thöù naêm trong         of Uttarakuru. baûy vò coå Phaät—The second of the five Budhas of               Caâu Phæ La Thieân: Kuvera or Kubera (skt)—See the present Bhadrakalpa, the fifth of the seven                  Caâu Pheä La. ancient Buddhas.                                                 Caâu Sa La: Kausala (skt)—Kosala (skt)—Coøn goïi Caâu Na Haøm Phaät: See Caâu Na Haøm Maâu Ni.                    laø Caâu Taùt La, hay Cö Taùt La—See Kieàu Taùt La. Caâu Na La: Kunala (skt)—Cöu Na La—1) Teân                       Caâu Sanh Trí Hueä: See Caâu Sinh Trí Hueä. moät loaøi chim maét ñeïp: Name of a bird which has              Caâu Saét Sæ La: Kausthila (skt)—Kosthaka (skt)— beautiful eyes, or a bird with beautiful eyes; 2)                Caâu Saét Chæ La—Teân cuûa moät vò A La Haùn, moät Theo Eitel trong Trung Anh Phaät Hoïc Töø Ñieån cuûa             ngöôøi caäu cuûa ngaøi Xaù Lôïi Phaát, ngöôøi ñaõ trôû Giaùo Sö Soothill, Kunala coøn coù nghóa laø moät aùc            thaønh moät ñeä töû noåi tieáng cuûa Ñöùc Phaät —An nhaân hay aùc nhaõn: According to Eitel in The                   arhat, maternal uncle of Sariputra, who became an Dictionary of Chinese-English Buddhist Terms,                    eminent disciple of Sakyamuni. Kunala is also translated as an evil man, or an evil             Caâu Saét Tha Ca: See Caâu Saét Sæ La. eye; 3) See Phaùp Taêng.                                         Caâu Sanh Duyeân: See Caâu Sinh Duyeân. Caâu Na La Ñaø: Gunarata (skt)—Caâu Na La                        Caâu Sinh: Ñoàng thôøi sanh ra, ñoái laïi vôùi do huaân Tha—Tam Taïng Phaùp Sö Chaân Ñeá, töø Ujjain Taây                taäp maø coù—Natural, spontaneous, inborn as AÁn ñeán Trung Quoác vaøo khoaûng naêm 546 sau Taây              opposed to acquire. Lòch. Ngaøi ñaõ dòch nhieàu kinh saùch, ñaëc bieät laø boä       Caâu Sinh Khôûi Meâ Hoaëc: Meâ hoaëc khôûi leân do luaän cuûa ngaøi Theá Thaân Boà Taùt—Name of                     huaân taäp töø voâ thuûy ñeán nay, sinh ra cuøng vôùi thaân, Paramartha, who was known as Kulanatha, came                     töï nhieân maø coù—Delusions or errors that arise to Chine around 546 A.D. from Ujjain in Western                  naturally among people. India. He translated many books, especially the                  Caâu Sinh Khôûi Phieàn Naõo: Phieàn naõo do huaân treatises of Vasubandhu.                                         taäp töø voâ thuûy ñeán nay—Klesa that which is Caâu Nöõu: Coøn goïi laø Huyeàn Nöõu, treo aùo caø sa            natural to all. maø kheùp kín hai vaït laïi goïi laø caâu, boû thoûng hai        Caâu Sinh Ngaõ Chaáp: Ngaõ chaáp baåm sinh, luùc môùi daûi xuoáng goïi laø nöõu (thaét nuùt treân aùo caø sa sau khi   sanh ra ñaõ coù—The natural or intinctive cleaving maëc aùo vaøo)—To knot, to tie, to button, e.g. a                (clinging) to the idea of self or soul. girdle.                                                          Caâu Sinh Duyeân: Concurrent conditions—Caùc Caâu Phaàn: Baèng caû hai caùch—Both ways.                       ñieàu kieän xaûy ra ñoàng thôøi. Caâu Phaàn Cuù Nghóa: Sadrsya padarthah (skt)—                   Caâu Sinh Hoaëc: Innate delusions—Nhöõng meâ Moái quan heä baèng caû hai caùch vöøa ñoàng vöøa                chaáp baåm sinh—Caùc moái nghi hoaëc cuøng sinh khôûi khaùc—The relationship of all dharmas in both                    (ngaõ chaáp caâu sinh, phaùp chaáp caâu sinh, phieàn naõo ways, sameness and difference.                                   chöôùng caâu sinh, sôû tri chöôùng caâu sinh), ñoái laïi Caâu Phaàn Giaûi Thoaùt: The Both-Ways-                          vôùi nhöõng nghi hoaëc huaân taäp hay ñöôïc daïy doã — Liberated—Caû thaân vaø taâm ñeàu giaûi thoaùt. Theo             Natural doubt, inborn illusion, in contrast to doubt Kinh Töï Hoan Hyû vaø Kinh Phuùng Tuïng trong                    or illusion acquired, e.g. being taught. Tröôøng Boä Kinh, ñaây laø moät trong baûy loaïi ngöôøi          Caâu Sinh Hueä: Sahajajnana (skt)—Coemergent ñaùng       kính      troïng—According              to     the   wisdom—Söï chöùng ñaéc thieàn ñònh ôû möùc ñoä cao Sampasadaniya Sutta and Sangiti Sutta in the                     veà söï khoâng theå taùch rôøi ta baø khoûi nieát baøn vaø Long Discourses of the Buddha, this is one of the                laøm theá naøo hai söï kieän naày cuøng khôûi leân moät luùc—The        advanced         realization    of      the

inseparability of samsara and nirvana and how                  Caâu Sinh Nhaân Ngaõ Chaáp: Innate grasping of these arise simultaneously and together.                       self and person—Caùi chaáp baåm sinh vaøo caùi toâi vaø Caâu Sinh Khôûi: Sahaja (skt)—Nhöõng sai laàm töï              tha nhaân. khôûi töø luùc môùi sanh hay phieàn naõo khôûi leân töï        Caâu Sinh Phaùp: 1) Caùc phaùp ñoàng thôøi sinh ra vaø nhieân, ñoái laïi vôùi Phaân Bieät Khôûi. Caâu sinh khôûi      khoâng taùch lìa nhau: Spontaneous ideas or things; lieân heä maät thieát vôùi Chaân Ngoân thöøa —Errors that      2) Hieän töôïng töï sinh: Spontaneous phenomena. arise naturally among people (arising and born                 Caâu Sinh Phaùp Chaáp: Söï chaáp baåm sinh vaøo caùc with one; spontaneous), errors or delusions that               hieän töôïng. Khuynh höôùng thoâng thöôøng coi moïi arise naturally among people, in contrast with                 söï laø coù thaät, phaûi qua quaù trình tu taäp maø ñoaïn delusions arising from reasoning and teaching                  tröø—Innate attachment to phenomena. The (Phaân bieät khôûi). “To be born together” or ‘sahaja’         common or natural tendency to consider things as is closely related to Mantrayana.                              real. Caâu Sinh Khôûi Meâ Hoaëc: Meâ hoaëc khôûi leân do             Caâu Sinh Phaùp Ngaõ Chaáp: Innate grasping at the huaân taäp töø voâ thuûy ñeán nay, sinh ra cuøng vôùi thaân,   self of a phenomenon—Chaáp vaøo baûn chaát cuûa töï nhieân maø coù—Delusions that arise naturally              hieän töôïng. among people or errors that arise naturally among              Caâu Sinh Thaønh Töïu Phaùp: Sahaja-siddhi (skt)— people.                                                        Phaùp thaønh töïu ñoàng thôøi sanh ra, ñoái laïi vôùi thaønh Caâu Sinh Khôûi Thöøa: Sahajayana (skt)—Caâu                   töïu phaùp do huaân taäp maø coù—Natural, Sinh Khôûi Thöøa lieân heä maät thieát vôùi Chaân Ngoân        spontaneous, or inborn accomplishment of dharma Thöøa. Hai thöøa naøy ñaõ coù aûnh höôûng raát lôùn treân      (fulfilment of dharma, or completion of dharma), Phaät Giaùo Taây Taïng. Caâu Sinh Khôûi thöøa vôùi pheùp       as opposed to acquired perfection of dharma. haønh thieàn saâu laéng. Caû Chaân Ngoân thöøa vaø Caâ u       Caâu Sinh Thaàn: Sahadeva (skt)—1) Vò Thaàn cuøng Sinh Khôûi thöøa ñeàu quan taâm tôùi khía caïnh thöïc          sanh ra vôùi taát caû moïi ngöôøi vaø ghi cheùp taát caû haønh cuûa Phaät giaùo vôùi boán ñænh cao. Thöù nhaát laø      nhöõng thieän aùc cuûa con ngöôøi ñeå baùo caùo cuøng Kieán hay caùi nhìn döïa treân kinh nghieäm thöïc teá.         Dieâm Vöông: The spirit born at the same time as Thöù nhì laø Tu hay khai trieån nhöõng gì maø caùi nhìn        the individual, which records his deeds(one’s good ñoù cho thaáy. Thöù ba laø Haønh hay soáng vaø laøm phuø       and evil)and reports to Yama; 2) Coù ngöôøi noùi Caâu hôïp theo ñoù. Thöù tö laø Quaû hay söï hôïp nhaát cuûa caù    Sinh Thaàn chính laø A Laïi Da Thöùc: Another says it theå (giaùc ngoä, Phaät quaû, hay söï thaønh thuïc veà taâm    is the Alaya-vijnana. linh)—Sahajayana is closely related to                         Caâu Sinh Trí Hueä: Sahajajnana (skt)— Mantrayana. These two yanas have had the                       Coemergent wisdom—Söï chöùng ñaéc thieàn ñònh ôû greatest influence on Tibetan Buddhism. Both                   möùc ñoä cao veà söï khoâng theå taùch rôøi ta baø khoûi Mantrayana and Sahajayana are concerned with                   nieát baøn vaø laøm theá naøo hai söï kieän naày cuøng khôûi the practical aspect of Buddhism which culminates              leân moät luùc—The advanced realization of the in the four peaks of view. First, view based on                inseparability of samsara and nirvana and how experience. Second, cultivation or development of              these arise simultaneously and together. what this view offers. Third, practice or to live and          Caâu Sinh YÙ Laïc: Innate aspiration—Khaùt voïng to act accordingly. Fourth, the integration of the             baåm sinh. individual (enlightenment, Buddhahood, or                      Caâu Taùt La: Kausala (skt)—Kosala (skt)—Coøn spiritual maturity).                                           goïi laø Caâu Sa La, Cö Taùt La—See Kieàu Taùt La. Caâu Sinh Ngaõ Chaáp: Natural cleaving (clinging)              Caâu Thi Na: Kusinagara (skt)—Kusinara (p)— to the idea of self or soul—Ngaõ chaáp baåm sinh, luùc         Coøn goïi laø Caâu Di Na Kieät, Cöùu Thi, Caâu Thi Na môùi sanh ra ñaõ coù—Intinctive cleaving (clinging)            Kieät, Caâu Thu Yeát La, Giaùc Thaønh, kinh ñoâ cuûa to the idea of self or soul.                                   vöông quoác Maït La naèm veà phía baéc AÁn Ñoä, moät Caâu Sinh Ngaõ Kieán: Innate view of self—Quan                 trong 16 vöông quoác lôùn taïi AÁn Ñoä thôøi Ñöùc Phaät. ñieåm baåm sinh veà caùi ‘ngaõ’.                               Baây giôø laø tænh Kasia, khoaûng 35 daäm veà phía Ñoâng thaønh phoá Gorakhupur thuoäc bang Uttar Pradesh vuøng Baéc AÁn. Nôi Ñöùc Phaät nhaäp Nieát

baøn trong vöôøn Ta La (Ñöùc Phaät nhaäp dieät trong            Dictionary of Chinese-English Buddhist Terms, an nhieân vaøo tuoåi 80 taïi röøng Ta La phía baéc thaønh       this is the name of a white China aster. caâu Thi Na, vaøo khoaûng 543 naêm tröôùc Thieân                Caâu Toâ Ma Baït Ñeâ: Kusumavati (skt)—Teân cuûa Chuùa)—The capital of the kingdom of Mallas,                    Phaät giôùi—Name of a Buddha-realm. located in northern India, one of the sixteen major             Caâu Toâ Ma Boå La: Kusumapura (skt)—Cuø Toâ countries in India during the Buddha’s lifetime. It             Ma Boå La—Thaønh Hoa Cung, coù hai nôi: 1) Moät ôû is now Kasia, about 35 miles to the east of the city            thaønh Ba Tra Ly Töû thuoäc nöôùc Ma Kieät Ñaø, nay of Gorakhpur in Uttar Pradesh State of northern                 laø Patna; 2) Moät khaùc ôû thaønh Khuùc Nöõ, nöôùc Yeát India. This is the place where the Buddha entered               Nhaõ Cuùc Xaø, nay laø thaønh phoá noåi tieáng veà phía Nirvana in the Sala Grove (the Buddha passed                    baéc cuûa Hindustan—City of flower palaces; two away without any sorrow at 80 years of age in a                 names in two places: 1) Pataliputra, ancient grove of sala trees north of Kusinara, about 543                capital of Magadha, the modern Patna; 2) Another years before Christ).                                           one in Kanauj (classical Canogyza) in Caâu Thi Na Thaønh: See Caâu Thi Na.                            Kanyakubja, a noted city in northern Hindustan. Caâu Thi Na Thaùp: Kusinagara stupa—Taïi thaønh                 Caâu Toâ Laïc Ca: Kusula (skt)—Kyø Tu La—Coà Tu Caâu Thi Na, nôi Phaät nhaäp Nieát Baøn. Ñaây laø moät          La—Quyeát Tu La—Quyeát Toâ Laïc Ca—Quaàn maëc trong taùm ngoâi thaùp thieâng lôùn cuûa Phaät giaùo—           cuûa Tyø Kheo Ni (quaàn thuùng do hai oáng khaâu goäp Kusinagara, where the Buddha entered nirvana.                   laïi, nhö hình chieác thuùng nhoû, daøi 4 caùnh tay, roäng This is one of the eight Great Spiritual or Sacred              2 caùnh tay, treân che kín roán, döôùi caùch maét caù Stupas of Buddhism.                                             chaân khoaûng 4 ngoùn tay)—A skirt worn by nuns. Caâu Thi Na Yeát La: Kusinagara (skt)—Kusinara                  Caâu Toâ Ma La: Kusumamala (skt)—Voøng hoa, (p)—See Caâu Thi Na.                                            chuoãi hoa hay xaâu hoa—A wreath—A garland. Caâu Thi Veä Ñaø: Rgveda (skt)—Caâu Veä Ñaø hay                 Caâu Toân Haø: Kakuttha (skt)—Teân cuûa con soâng Ñoäc Tuïng Veä Ñaø (goàm nhöõng baøi ca tuïng thaàn             nôi ñöùc Theá Toân taém laàn sau choùt tröôùc khi Ngaøi thaùnh)—Collection of the song texts of Veda.                   nhaäp dieät—Name of a river where the Buddha Caâu Thieâm Di Quoác: Kausambi (skt)—Kosambi                    bathed for the last time before He passed away. (skt)—Vatsapattana (p)—Caâu Dieâm Di Quoác—                     Caâu Toán Baø: Kusumbha (skt)—Loaïi boâng maøu Caâu La Cuø Quoác—See Caâu Ñaøm Di.                             tím—Safflower—Saffron. Caâu Thuùc: Bhanda or Samyoga (skt)—Keát—                       Caâu Trieäu Phaùp: Akarsana (skt)—Akarsani Bond—Fetter—To constrain—To bind—Knot—                          (skt)—Vasikarana (skt)—Kuyo (jap)—Moät trong Tie.                                                            nguõ chuûng ñaøn phaùp, pheùp tu trieäu taäp chö toân cuûa Caâu Thöôøng: Thöôøng Cuù—Ngoaïi ñaïo chaáp caùi                Maät giaùo—One of the five kinds of esoteric ‘ngaõ’ trong quaù khöù töùc laø caùi ‘ngaõ’ trong hieän taïi,   ceremonial, the method in esoteric practice of töông tuïc chaúng giaùn ñoaïn, neân goïi laø thöôøng kieán      summoning and influencing               the beneficent hay thöôøng cuù—The permanence of ego, i.e. that                powers—See Nguõ Chuûng Tu Phaùp. the ego of past lives is the ego of the present.                Caâu Tyø Ñaø La: Kovidara (skt)—Caâu Beä Ñaø La— Caâu Thöôøng Di: Kausambi (skt)—See Caâu Ñaøm                   Teân moät loaøi caây nôi coõi Cöïc Laïc. Ngöôøi ta noùi Di.                                                             ñaây laø loaïi caây trong vöôøn chôi cuûa Phaät Thích Ca Caâu Toâ La: Kusulaka (skt)—Moät trong naêm y cuûa              Maâu Ni luùc ngaøi coøn nhoû —Name of a tree of Tyø Kheo Ni (goàm ba y cuûa Tyø Kheo theâm hai y                Paradise. Said to be the tree of the great Trì Chi, loaïi che khaép chaâu thaân, vaø Phuù Kieân,           playground where the child Sakyamuni played. loaïi che vai)—One of the five garments worn by a               Caâu Tyø La: 1) Giao Long, caù saáu: Kumbhira nun are the three worn by a monk with two                       (skt)—A crocodile; 2) Kuvera or Kubera: See Caâu others—See Nguõ Y.                                              Pheä La and Tyø Sa Moân Thieân Vöông; 3) Giao Caâu Toâ Ma: Kusuma (skt)—Theo Eitel trong                      Long Tyø Kheo: A monk named Kumbhira; 4) Trung Anh Phaät Hoïc Töø Ñieån cuûa Giaùo Sö                    Kumbhira (skt): See Kim Tyø La. Soothill, ñaây laø teân cuûa moät loaøi hoa traéng coù xuaát    Caâu Tyø Löu Ba Xoa: Virupaksa (skt)—Tyø Löu xöù töø beân Trung Quoác—According to Eitel in the              Baùt Xoa, coøn goïi laø Quaûng Muïc hay Tam Muïc

Thieân Vöông, teân cuûa vò Thieân Vöông phía taây              trong vieäc taùi laäp baûn vaên thaát laïc vaø ñöôïc kieän trong Töù Thieân Vöông—The three-eyed Siva; the                toaøn bôûi Rahula Sankrityayana ngöôøi Tích Lan. guardian ruler of the West.                                    Moãi yeáu toá trong vuõ truï ñöôïc Theá Thaân giaûi nghóa Caâu Vaät Ñaàu: Kumuda (skt)—Cuù Vaên La—Caâu                  chi li trong Luaän Caâu Xaù cuûa oâng. Danh töø quan Vaät Ñaø—Caâu Maãu Ñaø—Caâu Maâu Ñaàu—Caâu                     troïng cuûa toâng naøy laø ‘hoïc thuyeát veà taát caû ñeàu Maäu Ñaàu—Sen nôû, ñaëc bieät laø sen traéng—An                hieän höõu,’ khaúng ñònh moïi hieän höõu, caû taâm vaø opening lotus, especially the yellow or white                  vaät, cuõng nhö khoâng phaûi taâm vaø khoâng phaûi vaät. lotus.                                                         Tuy nhieân, ñieàu naày khoâng phaûi ñeå thöøa nhaän hieän Caâu Voâ Thöôøng: Present ego is of independent                höõu cuûa ngaõ (atman), moät baûn ngaõ caù bieät hay moät birth, not the result from the past causes—See Voâ             linh hoàn hay nguyeân lyù phoå quaùt hay nguyeân nhaân Thöôøng Cuù.                                                   ñaàu tieân. Chuùng ta khoâng bieát Theá Thaân coù tieân Caâu Xaù: Kosa (skt)—Taïng—Treasury—Store.                     ñoaùn moïi nguy hieåm do söï thöøa nhaän coù ‘Ngaõ,’ seõ Caâu Xaù Baø Ñeà Thaønh: Kusavati (skt)—Caâu Xaù               xaõy ra hay khoâng maø oâng ñaõ boû ra toaøn chöông Baït Ñeà Thaønh, teân cuûa moät ñoâ thò coå ôû vuøng Baéc      chín ñeå baùc boû thuyeát Höõu Ngaõ. Caâu Xaù toâng duø AÁn—Name of an ancient city in North India.                    chuû tröông raèng taát caû caùc phaùp ñeàu thöïc höõu, Caâu Xaù Baït Ñeà Thaønh: See Caâu Xaù Baø Ñeà                 hoaøn toaøn khaùc vôùi duy thöïc luaän ngaây thô thöôøng Thaønh.                                                        tình, bôûi vì theo lyù thuyeát cuûa toâng naày, vaïn höõu laø Caâu Xaù Luaän: Kosa-sastra (skt)—A Tyø Ñaït Ma                nhöõng phaùp bao goàm caû taâm vaø vaät, taát caû cuøng ôû Caâu Xaù Luaän, boä Luaän “Kho Taøng Phaùp Baûo”               treân cöôùc ñòa nhö nhau. Toâng naøy thöøa nhaän thöïc ñöôïc Ngaøi Theá Thaân soaïn vaøo theá kyû thöù naêm sau       taïi tính cuûa moïi phaùp nhöng laïi chaáp nhaän thuyeát Taây Lòch. Ñaây laø boä luaän quan troïng nhaát, giaûi         khoâng coù toàn theå, khoâng coù thöôøng haèng, khoâng coù thích ñaày ñuû veà toâng phaùi Nhaát Thieát Höõu Boä cuûa      phuùc laïc ngoaïi tröø Nieát Baøn. Haàu heát nhöõng tröôøng Phaät giaùo Tieåu Thöøa, ñöôïc ngaøi Paramartha vaø            phaùi A Tyø Ñaøm coù leõ ñaõ phaùt khôûi sau cuoäc keát Huyeàn Trang ñôøi nhaø Ñöôøng dòch sang Hoa ngöõ —             taäp cuûa Vua A Duïc (khoaûng naêm 240 tröôùc Taây Abhidharma-kosa-sastra, the sastra of “Treasure                Lòch), bôûi vì vaên hoïc A Tyø Ñaøm goàm taát caû 7 boä Chamber of the Abhidharma” composed by                         luaän, laàn ñaàu tieân ñöôïc chaáp nhaän laø moät trong Vasubandhu in the fifth century AD. This is the                Tam taïng Kinh Ñieån (Tripitaka) trong cuoäc keát taäp most important compilation of the Sarvastivada                 naøy. Trong cuoäc keát taäp laàn ñaàu vaø laàn thöù hai chæ (Hinayana) teaching. It was translated into                    coù hai taïng (Kinh vaø Luaät)—Name of the school is Chinese by Paramartha and Hsuan-Tsang during                   an abbreviation of Abhidharma-kosa, which is the the T’ang dynasty.                                             title of Vasubandhu’s work on realism and may be Caâu Xaù Toâng: Kosa Sect—Toâng Caâu Xaù cuûa                  translated “The Story of the Higher Dharma.” The Ngaøi Theá Thaân—Abhidharma-kosa or Pitaka                     great philosopher Vasubandhu was born in school of Vasubandhu—Teân goïi cuûa toâng phaùi laø            Purusapura (Peshawar) in Gandhara and received moät danh töø giaûn löôïc cuûa Phaïn ngöõ A Tyø Ñaït Ma        his ordination in the Sarvastivada School. He went Caâu Xaù, laø nhan ñeà cuûa moät taùc phaåm cuûa Theá          to Kashmir incognito to learn the Abhidharma Thaân vieát veà chuû thuyeát duy thöïc vaø coù theå dòch laø   philosophy. On his return home he wrote the “Caâu chuyeän cuûa Phaùp Toái Thöôïng.” Ñaïi trieát gia        Abhidharma-kosa-sastra which is preserved in Theá Thaân sanh taïi Baïch Sa Ngoõa, thuoäc xöù Kieän          sixty volumes of Chinese translation. The Sanskrit Ñaø La, xuaát gia theo Höõu Boä. OÂng aâm thaàm ñeán           text is lost, but fortunately we have a commentary Ca Thaáp Di La ñeå hoïc trieát hoïc A Tyø Ñaøm. Khi trôû       written by Yasomitra called the Abhidharma-kosa- veà coá höông, oâng vieát A Tyø Ñaït Ma Caâu Xaù Luaän         vyakhya which has facilitated the restoration of (Abhidharma-kosa-sastra) hieän vaãn coøn 60 quyeån             the lost text undertaken by the late Professor Haùn dòch. Baûn vaên Phaïn ngöõ ñaõ thaát laïc, nhöng          Louis De La Valleùe Poussin of belgium and may maén chuùng ta vaãn coøn moät baûn chuù giaûi do           completed by Rahula Sankrityayana of Ceylon. Yasomitra vieát vôùi nhan ñeà laø A Tyø Ñaït Ma Caâu           All elements of the universe were minutely Xaù Thích Luaän. Nhôø baûn chuù giaûi naøy maø coá Giaùo       explained by Vasubandhu in his Abhidharma- Sö Louis De La Valleùe-Poussin ôû Bæ ñaõ deã daøng             kosa. The significant name of the School ‘all-

things-exist-doctrine’ (sarva-asti-vada) affirms all        Tsang. It was brought in once again by Gembo (in existences, both material and mental, as well as            735 A.D.) who was a pupil of Chih-Chou, the third that which is neither matter nor mind. This,                generation pupil of Kuy-Ji, a direct disciple of however, does not mean to admit the existence of            Hsuan-Tsang. In an official document of 793 A.D. Self (atman), an individual ego or soul or the              the realistic Kusha School was registered as a sect universal principle or First Cause. Whether or not          appended to the idealistic Dharmalaksana (Hosso) he anticipated the danger of being involved in the          School, no separate position being given to it, admission of Self, Vasubandhu devoted the whole             because it had no adherents belonging exclusively ninth chapter of his Abhidharma-kosa sastra to the          to it. Japanese Kosa School has three branches: refutation of the atman theory (see Baûy Möôi Laêm          1) Hoïc phaùi Duy Thöïc hay Nhaát Thieát Höõu Boä — Phaùp Caâu Xaù Toâng). The Kosa School, though it                 The Realistic School or Sarvastivadins: Hoïc states that all things exist, is quite different from             phaùi naày laáy hai taùc phaåm Baùt Kieàn Ñoä Luaän general naïve materialism, because, according to                  hay Phaùt Trí Luaän cuûa Ca Ña Dieãn Ni Töû vaø its theory, all things are elements (dharmas) which               Luïc Tuùc Luaän laøm vaên baûn chính yeáu—This include mind as well as matter, all on an equal                   school considered Katyayaniputra’s The footing. It asserts the reality of all dharmas and                Source of Knowledge (Jnana-prasthana) and yet it admits the theory of no substance, no                      the Six Padas as its main texts. duration and no bliss except Nirvana. Most of the           a) Tyø Ñaøm toâng Kieän Ñaø La: Gandhara- Abhidharma schools probably arose after the                       Abhidharmikas. Council of Asoka (240 B.C.), because the                    b) Tyø       Ñaøm       Toâng     Kashmir:      Kashmir- Abhidharma literature, seven texts in all, was for                Abhidharmikas. the first time recognized as one of the Tripitaka           2) Hoïc phaùi Coå Tyø Baø Sa—Vaibhasikas: Hoïc (three baskets or collections) in this council. At the            phaùi naày laáy taùc phaåm Ñaïi Tyø Baø Sa laøm vaên time of the first and the second councils there                   baûn chính yeáu—This school considered were only two Pitakas (Sutras and Vinaya).                        Puarsva’s Mahavibhasa as its main text. Caâu Xaù Toâng Nhaät Baûn: Japanese Kosa                    3) Hoïc phaùi Taân Phaân Bieät Thuyeát—Neo- School—Theo Giaùo Sö Junjiro Takakusu trong                       Vaibhasikas: Cöông Yeáu Trieát Hoïc Phaät Giaùo, ôû Nhaät toâng phaùi    a) Theá Thaân (420-500 sau Taây Lòch)— naày ñöôïc goïi laø Kusha, thöôøng ñöôïc coi nhö laø do           Vasubandhu (420-500 A.D.): Hoïc phaùi naày Trí Thoâng vaø Trí Ñaït truyeàn vaøo Nhaät Baûn vaøo              laáy hai taùc phaåm Luaän Tuïng vaø Luaän Thích naêm 658; ñoù laø hai nhaø sö Nhaät theo hoïc vôùi                laøm caên baûn—This school considered these Huyeàn Trang moät thôøi gian. Veà sau naày toâng phaùi            two texts as its basic texts: Verses naày laïi ñöôïc truyeàn vaøo Nhaät laàn nöõa vôùi Huyeàn          (Abhidharma-kosa-karika) and Commentary Phöông (735 sau Taây Lòch), ñoà ñeä cuûa Trí Chaâu;               (Abhidharma-kosa-sastra). Trí Chaâu laïi laø ñoà ñeä cuûa ñôøi thöù ba cuûa Khuy Cô   b) Chuùng Hieàn—Samghabhadra: Hoïc phaùi naày vaø Khuy Cô voán laø ñoà ñeä tröïc tieáp cuûa Huyeàn              laáy hai taùc phaåm Chính Lyù Luaän vaø Hieån Trang. Trong moät taøi lieäu chaùnh thöùc naêm 793,               Toâng Luaän laøm vaên baûn chính yeáu—This phaùi Caâu Xaù Duy Thöïc ñöôïc ghi cheùp nhö laø moät             school considered Nyayanusara and Samaya- toâng phaùi phuï thuoäc toâng Phaùp Töôùng Duy Thöùc,             pradipika as its main texts. khoâng coù vò trí rieâng naøo daønh cho noù, bôûi vì        Caâu Xí La: Kokika (skt)—Kokila (skt)—Cöu Di khoâng coù nhöõng ñoà ñeä chuyeân nhöùt vôùi noù. Caâu      La—Teân moät loaøi chim cu—A kind of cuckoo. Xaù Toâng Nhaät Baûn coù ba tröôøng phaùi—According         Caáu: Mala (skt). to Prof. Junjiro Takakusu in the Essentials of              1) Baát tònh (tinh thaàn vaø ñaïo ñöùc): Mala (skt)— Buddhist Philosophy, The Kosa School, or the                      Impurity—Voïng hoaëc hay baát cöù thöù gì laøm Kusha School as it is called in Japan, is generally               cho taâm bò oâ ueá nhö phieàn naõo ueá tröôïc — understood to have been brought into Japan in 658                 Impurity (moral and mental). Whatever A.D. by Chitsu and Chitatsu, two Japanese monks                   misleads or deludes the minds; illusions, who studied some time under the famous Hsuan-                     defilement.

2) Thaáu suoát: To understand thoroughly.                  however, life is not easy as we think. We cannot Caáu Chöôùng: Unclean hindrance.                           fulfill what we wish. So we suffer when those Caáu Keát: Hoaëc ñoäc hay söï caáu keát cuûa vaät chaát    wishes are denied or cannot be fulfilled—See Baùt ueá tröôïc vaø söï taùi sanh (laøm nhô baån tònh taâm)—    Khoå. The bond of the defiling of the material and of            Caàu Chaùnh Phaùp: Caàu tìm ñöôïc chaùnh phaùp— reincarnation.                                             Seek the true teaching. Caáu Nhieãm: Tainted—Ñem caùi nhô baån nhieãm              Caàu Chaâu: To seek for a mani pearl—YÙ noùi Phaät vaøo mình ñeå ví vôùi loøng phieàn naõo—Taint of           phaùp quyù baùu nhö vieân ngoïc "Nhö YÙ" coù khaû naêng earthly things or illusion.                                ban phaùt taát caû taøi vaät hay ñoà duøng maø chuùng sanh Caáu OÂ: OÂ ueá—Defilement (of the physical as type        mong muoán, nhöng laïi bò queân laõng trong cheùo aùo; of mental illusion).                                       vaø roài ngöôøi ta laïi ñi tìm kieám noù töø beân ngoaøi — Caáu Taäp: Söï huaân taäp cuûa ueá nhieãm—Habituation      The term implies Buddhism as a Mani pearl, to defilement.; the influence of its practice.             which has the power to grant any wish or desire, Caáu Thöùc: Defiling knowledge—Taâm thöùc cuûa             with regard to material possession, to all sentient ngöôøi bình thöôøng hay tri thöùc traàn theá, bò caùo      beings, but left forgotten in the corner of a coat; hoaëc laøm nhô baån, khoâng phaân bieät thaät giaû —The    and then people try to seek it from outside. common worldly knowledge that does not                     Caàu Chi: Chu-Chih (Juzhi)—Caâu Chi, teân cuûa moät discriminate the seeming from the real.                    vò Thieàn sö Trung Quoác vaøo theá kyû thöù 9, ñeä töû vaø Caáu Truùc Tö Duy: Thought construction.                   phaùp töû cuûa Thieàn sö Haøng Chaâu Thieân Long— Caáu Ueá: Stains—See Tam Ueá.                              Name of a Chinese Zen master in the ninth Caàu: To seek—To beseech—To pray—Quest—                    century, a disciple and dharma-successor of Zen Tìm kieám.                                                 master Hang-Chou T’ien-Lung. Caàu An:                                                   Caàu Chôn Lyù: To seek to get the truth. 1) Tìm kieám söï an laïc: To seek for peace.               Caàu Chöùng Ñaéc: To seek enlightenment. 2) Caàu nguyeän hoøa bình: To wish for peace.              Caàu Danh: To seek after honours (reputation)— 3) Caàu an cho ngöôøi coøn soáng: To pray for the          For the sake of renown. peace of living people.                               Caàu Danh Boà Taùt: Yasaskama (skt)—Theo Kinh Caàu Baùo Thí: Seeking-reward giving or                    Dieäu Phaùp Lieân Hoa, ñaây laø vò Boà Taùt tieàn thaân anticipating gifts in return—Caàu baùo thí hay boá thí     cuûa Phaät Di Laëc, ñeä töû cuûa Ngaøi Dieäu Quang Boà vôùi yù mong caàu ñöôïc baùo ñaùp veà sau naày. Ñaây laø   Taùt, noåi tieáng veà tham voïng vaø ham muoán veà trí moät trong taùm loaïi boá thí theo Caâu Xaù Luaän—One      nhôù—According to the Lotus Sutra, Ch’iu-Ming is gives, thinking: “I give him something now, he             the name of Maitreya in a previous life, a will give me back something in the future.” This is        bodhisattva, a disciple of Varaprabha, noted for one of the eight causes of dana or giving                  his boundless ambition and utter want of memory. according to the Kosa Sastra—See Baùt Chuûng Boá           Caàu Danh Caàu Lôïi: Seek for fame and benefit— Thí.                                                       Ngöôøi Phaät töû tu taäp maø khoâng coù caùi taâm caàu Caàu Baát Ñaéc Khoå: Suffering of frustrated               danh caàu lôïi, ñaõ dieät tröø ñöôïc naêm goác reã cuûa ñòa desire—Suffering due to unfulfilled wishes                 nguïc, töùc laø tieàn taøi, saéc duïc, danh tieáng, aên vaø (unattained aims or denial of one’s desires)—              nguû, khoâng coù taâm luyeán aùi vaøo nhöõng thöù aáy Nhöõng mong caàu khoâng toaïi nguyeän gaây neân ñau        trong moïi hoaøn caûnh, trong moïi luùc, aáy ñích thöïc khoå. Chuùng ta coù nhieàu öôùc muoán trong ñôøi soáng     laø haønh giaû tu theo Phaät. Chuùng ta phaûi coá gaéng tu vaø raát muoán ñöôïc thoûa nguyeän; tuy nhieân, ñôøi       taäp baèng coâng phu cuûa chính mình. Chôù ham danh soáng khoâng deã daøng nhö ta töôûng. Chuùng ta luoân      tieáng, lôïi loäc, vaân vaân. Phaûi tu taäp theo tinh thaàn khoâng theå hoaøn thaønh nhöõng öôùc nguyeän naày. Vì      cuûa chö Boà Taùt Vaên Thuø, Phoå Hieàn, Quaùn AÂm, theá maø chuùng ta luoân khoå ñau moãi khi chuùng ta       Ñòa Taïng, cuøng caùc Boà Taùt khaùc vì caùc vò Boà Taùt khoâng ñöôïc thoûa nguyeän—The pain which results          thöôøng laáy söï thaønh töïu cuûa chuùng sanh laøm söï from not receiving what one seeks. We have many            thaønh töïu cuûa chính mình. Caùc ngaøi khoâng phaân wishes in our life and want to fulfill them;               bieät ngöôøi vôùi ta. Boà Taùt thöôøng nghe thaáy roài tuøy

hyû taùn thaùn coâng ñöùc cuûa moïi ngöôøi—Buddhists            kinh, hai trong soá ñoù ñaõ bò thaát truyeàn naêm 730 sau cultivate without thoughts of seeking fame and                  Taây Lòch. OÂng sanh naêm 367, thò tòch taïi Nam benefit, for they have already eradicated the five              Kinh naêm 431 sau Taây Lòch. OÂng giaûng phaùp beân roots of the hell: wealth, sex, fame, food, and                 trong, chöù khoâng phaûi beân ngoaøi; phaùp töø chính sleep in all circumstances. We should cultivate the             mình chöù khoâng phaûi töø nôi ngöôøi khaùc. Trung taâm Way with our own effort. Do not crave fame and                  hoaèng hoùa cuûa oâng ñaët taïi Döông Chaâu. Ngöôøi ta profits. We should follow the spirit of the                     noùi chính oâng laø ngöôøi ñaàu tieân saùng laäp ra giaùo Bodhisattvas            Manjusri,         Samantabhadra,        ñoaøn Ni taïi Trung Quoác—Gunavarman, a prince Avalokitesvara,           Ksitigarbha,       and      other     of Kubha (Cashmere), who refused the throne, Bodhisattvas for they feel that living beings’                  wandered alone, reached China, translated ten accomplishments are the same as their own                       works, two of which were lost by 730 A.D. He was accomplishment. They do not make dictinctions                   born in 367 and died in 431 A.D. He taught that between self and others. Bodhisattvas joyfully                  truth is within, not without; and that the truth or support the merit and virtue they see and hear                  dharma is of oneself, not of another. The centre of others doing.                                                   his work is placed in Yang-Chou. It is said that he Caàu Ña Vaên: Caàu ñöôïc nghe nhieàu bieát nhieàu —             started the order of nuns in China. Seek broad learning.                                            Caàu Na La Ñaø: Gunarata (skt)—See Caâu Na La Caàu Ñaûo: To pray for rain.                                    Ñaø. Caàu Ñaïo: Seek enlightenment—Practice for                      Caàu Na Ma Ñeá: Gunamati (skt)—Sa moân Ñöùc enlightenment—strive for enlightenment.                         Tueä—Teân cuûa moät vò luaän sö noåi tieáng cuûa tröôøng Caàu Hoøa: To seek for peace—To sue for peace.                  phaùi Du Giaø—Name of a famous sastra master of Caàu Hoàn: To call up a spirit.                                 the Yogacara. Caàu Kinh: To say one’s prayers.                                Caàu Na Tyø Ñòa: Gunavrddhi (skt)—Tyø Kheo Ñöùc Caàu Kinh Toáng Gioù: Hoài xöa ngöôøi Vieät Nam tin             Tieán (An Tieán), ngöôøi Thieân Truùc, ñeán Trung raèng caàu kinh toáng gioù coù theå traùnh ñöôïc nhöõng tai     Quoác vaøo khoaûng nhöõng naêm 492-495, dòch ba boä hoïa (coù leõ ñaây cuõng laø moät truyeàn thoáng cuûa ngöôø i   kinh naêm 502—An Indian monk who came to Trung Hoa)—To pray to avert calamities, an old                  China around 492-495 A.D., translated three belief of the Vietnamese people (this may also be               works in 502. a tradition of Chinese).                                        Caàu Nguyeän: To pray. Caàu Lôïi: To seek profits—To aim at interests.                 Caàu Nguyeän Tha Thieát: A fervent prayer. Caàu Na: Guna (skt)—Thöïc theå cuûa ñaát nöôùc löûa             Caàu Nhaát Thieát Trí Quaûng Ñaïi Nguyeän Löïc: gioù laø ñöùc cuûa saéc thanh höông vò xuùc—A quality,          Adhyasayasarva-jnana-pranidhana-prasthana characteristic, or virtue, e.g. sound, taste, etc.              (skt)—Naêng löïc khieán nhieät thaønh höôùng tôùi nhaát Caàu Na Baït Ñaø La: Gunabhadra (skt)—Ñöùc                      thieát trí vaø caùc ñaïi nguyeän—The power of Hieàn.                                                          earnestly walking towards all-knowledge and 1) Teân moät vò Tyø Kheo noåi tieáng ngöôøi Trung               original vows. AÁn, ñeán Trung Quoác khoaûng nhöõng naêm 435-            Caàu Nhöùt Thieát Trí Thanh Tònh: Purity of the 443, dòch 78 boä kinh sang Hoa ngöõ: Name of a            quest for omniscience. famous monk from Central India, came to                   Caàu Nieát Baøn: Seek nirvana—Caàu Tòch—Sa China around 435-443 A.D., a translator of                Di—Thaát La Maït Ni La—Ngöôøi mong caàu ñaït Buddhist sutras into Chinese.                             ñöôïc caûnh giôùi nieát baøn (ngöôøi xuaát gia thoï thaäp 2) Name of a follower of the Mahisasaka in                      giôùi Sa Di)—To seek nirvana (any disciple who Kapisa: Teân cuûa moät ñoà ñeä cuûa phaùi Tieåu           accepts the ten commandments). Thöøa taïi Kapisa.                                        Caàu Phaùp: To seek to learn and practice Dharma. Caàu Na Baït Ma: Gunavarman (skt)—Coâng Ñöùc                    Caàu Phaùp Haønh Giaû: Practitioner who searches Khaûi, teân moät vò Tyø Kheo noåi tieáng ngöôøi Thieân          for the Dharma—See Haønh Giaû Caàu Phaùp. Truùc, thaùi töû xöù Cashmere, töø boû ngai vaøng, laøm         Caàu Phaät: Seek (v) Buddha—Haønh giaû tu Thieàn du Taêng Khaát Só, ñeán Trung Quoác vaø dòch möôøi boä          neân luoân nhôù ñöøng caàu Phaät baèng saéc töôùng hay

aâm thanh, vì nhöõng thöù naày khoâng phaûi laø Phaät.       concerning her own practice in order to receive Nhöõng ai mong caàu Phaät baèng saéc töôùng aâm thanh        Shining Light from the Bhiksus, commits an laø ñang theo taø ñaïo. Phaät chính laø söï giaùc ngoä Boà   Expression of Regret Offence. Ñeà vaø con ñöôøng taàm Phaät phaûi laø söï chöùng ngoä      Caàu Vaõng Sanh: To seek rebirth in the Pure ñaïo quaû Boà Ñeà—Zen practitioner should always             Land. remember not to seek a Buddha by his form or his             Caàu Vaên Trì Phaùp: See Vaên Trì Phaùp. sound because neither the form nor the sound is              Caàu Xa: Tìm xe—To seek for carts—See Tam the real Buddha. Those who seek Buddha by form               Giôùi Nhö Hoûa Traïch. and sound are on the wrong path. The true Buddha             Caåu Giôùi: Ngoaïi Ñaïo mong caàu cöùu ñoä theo kieåu is Enlightenment and the true way to know                    choù, soáng nhö choù, aên ñoà thöøa thaûi nhö choù—Dog- Buddha is to realize Enlightenment.                          rule or dog-morals, i.e. heretics who sought Caàu Phöôùc: Yacna (skt)—Kyø—To pray—Caàu                    salvation by living like dogs, eating garbage, etc. phöôùc khoâng ñöôïc noùi ñeán trong giaùo lyù Tieåu          Caåu Kyû: Coû gai—A spinous shrub. Thöøa, maø chæ ñöôïc bieát ñeán qua giaùo lyù Ñaïi Thöøa,    Caåu Laâm Tænh Pheä: Choù suûa boùng cuûa chính ñaëc bieät laø trong Maät giaùo—Prayer is spoken of as       mình döôùi ñaùy gieáng—Like the dog barking at its absent from Hinayan, and only known in                       own reflection in the well. Mahayana, especially in the esoteric sect.                   Caåu Lö Xaù: Krosa (skt)—Khoaûng caùch maø tieáng Caàu Sieâu: Leã caàu sieâu thoaùt cho vong linh ngöôøi       roáng cuûa moät con boø coù theå nghe ñöôïc, khoaûng cheát—A celebration of praying for the liberation            moät phaàn taùm do tuaàn—The distance the lowing of dead people.                                              of an ox can be heard, the eighth part of a Caàu Sinh: Teân khaùc cuûa thaân trung aám—Another           yojana—See Do Tuaàn. name for Intermediate Existence Body—See                     Caåu Ngoân: Careless speech. Thaân Trung Höõu.                                            Caåu Phaùp: Pheùp cuûa loaøi choù, baûn taùnh cuûa aùc Caàu Taùi Sanh Laøm Ngöôøi: To pray to obtain a              Taêng trong nhöõng ngaøy choùt cuûa cuoäc ñôøi—Dog- human rebirth.                                               law, fighting and hating, characteristics of the evil Caàu Taøi: To wish for wealth.                               monks in the last days of the world. Caàu Theá Gian Ly Duïc Phaùp: Mong caàu theá gian            Caåu Taâm: Taâm choù, khoâng bao giôø chaáp nhaän xa lìa duïc voïng—Seek mundane indifference to               Phaät phaùp—A dog’s heart, satisfied with trifles, objects of desire.                                           unreceptive of Buddha’s truth. Caàu Thænh: To invite respectfully.                          Caåu Toâ Ma: Kusuma (skt)—Loaïi hoa baïch cuùc Caàu Thoï: To seek long life.                                cuûa Trung Quoác—A flower, especially the white Caàu Thöïc: To earn one’s living.                            China-aster. Caàu Tòch: Sa Di—Thaát La Maït Ni La—Ngöôøi                  Caåu Toâ Ma Boå La: Kusamapura (skt)—Thaønh mong caàu ñaït ñöôïc caûnh giôùi nieát baøn (ngöôøi xuaát    phoá ñaày hoa, nhö khu Patna cuûa thaønh gia thoï thaäp giôùi Sa Di)—To seek nirvana (any             Pataliputra—The city of flowers, Pataliputra, i.e. disciple who accepts the ten commandments).                  Patna. Caàu Toaøn: To wish for perfection.                          Caåu Tröôùc Sö Töû Bì: Choù döôùi loáp da sö töû. Caàu Tu Chö Phaùp Haïnh: Haïnh caàu tu taát caû caùc         Nhöõng con choù khaùc thaáy noù ñeàu sôï cho ñeán khi phaùp, vì nhôø ñoù maø tu hoïc taát caû—Practice             noù caát tieáng suûa vang môùi heát sôï (vì bieát noù cuõng seeking all truths, to learn them all.                       laø choù nhö mình)—The dog in the lion’s skin. All Caàu Töï Töù: Receive Shining Light—Vò Tyø Kheo              the dogs fear him till he barks. Ni naøo, sau khi an cö kieát haï maø khoâng chòu ñeán        Caåu Töû Phaät Tính: Chao-Chou's Dog—Does a giaùo ñoaøn Taêng ñeå noùi nhöõng vieäc ñaõ thaáy, ñaõ       dog have Buddha-nature?—See Trieäu Chaâu Caåu nghe, hay nhöõng choã nghi ñeå caàu Töï Töù, vò aáy          Töû. phaïm giôùi Ba Daät Ñeà, phaûi phaùt loà saùm hoái—A         Caây Baùch Tröôùc Saân: The cypress tree at the Bhiksuni who at the end of the Rains retreat                 front of the courtyard—See Tieàn Ñình Baùch Thuï refuses to go to the Bhiksu Sangha to express                Töû. what she has seen, heard, or has doubts about

Caây       Boà       Ñeà:       Bodhi-tree—Tree           of   Coù Töôùng Maø Lìa Töôùng: Ñoái vôùi Boà Taùt, coù enlightenment—Voâ Toäi Thuï (goïi laø caây voâ toäi vì         töôùng maø lìa töôùng; nhöng vôùi taâm meâ môø cuûa baát cöù ai ñi quanh noù ba voøng seõ hoaøn toaøn ruõ boû      chuùng sanh thì khoâng phaûi vaäy—With moïi toäi loãi—No-sin tree, because whoever goes               Bodhisattvas, marks exist but they have been left around it three times is rid of sin).                          behind; however, it it is not the case for the Caây Ñuoác Long Ñaøm: Lung-t'an: Renowned Far                  sentient beings’ deluded minds. and Wide—Lung-t'an's paper candle, example 28                  Coõi: of the Wu-Men-Kuan—Thí duï thöù 28 cuûa Voâ Moân               1) Dhatu (skt)—Space—Sphere. Quan—See Long Ñaøm Cöûu Höôûng.                                2) Gati (skt)—Abode—Realm. Caây Gaäy Vaø Tieáng Heùt: Bokatsu (jap)—“Caây                 Coõi A-Tu-La: Asuras Realm—Titanic Demons— gaäy vaø tieáng heùt,” ñaây laø loái daïy phoå bieán trong     A-tu-la laø nhöõng sinh vaät ngoã nghòch öa thích moät vaøi tröôøng phaùi Thieàn, maø ngöôøi ta noùi noù         chieán ñaáu. Teân cuûa chuùng coù nghóa laø “Xaáu teä.” A- ñöôïc truyeàn töø hai vò Thieàn sö ngöôøi Trung Hoa laø        tu-la coøn coù nghóa laø “khoâng Thaùnh Thieän” vì maëc Ñöùc Sôn Tuyeân Giaùm vaø Laâm Teá Nghóa Huyeàn.               duø coù vaøi loaïi A-tu-la cuõng höôûng phöôùc trôøi, Loái daïy naøy lieân heä tôùi vieäc vò Thieàn sö duøng caùch   nhöng khoâng coù quyeàn löïc nhaø trôøi. Kyø thaät, A-tu- ñaùnh phöông tieän vôùi moät chieác gaäy vaø moät tieáng       la laø nhöõng ngöôøi haâm moä Phaät phaùp vaø öa cuùng heùt, maø ngöôøi ta tin raèng neáu laøm ñuùng phöông           döôøng, nhöng taùnh khí noùng naõy, hay ngaïo baùng caùch noù coù coâng naêng ñöa caùc vò thieàn sinh ñeán         neân sanh ra trong ñöôøng naày. Trong Tam Giôùi coù choã tröïc ngoä chaân lyù—“A stick and shout,” this is         boán loaïi A-tu-la—Asuras are unruly beings that the training style common in some Zen traditions,              love to fight. Their name means “ugly.” It also which is said to have been derived from two                    means “ungodly” because, although some Asuras Chinese Ch’an masters, Te-Shan Hsuan-Chien                     enjoy heavenly blessings, nonetheless, they lack (jap. Tokusan Senkan 781- 867), and Lin-Chi I-                 authority in the heavens. In fact, Asuras are those Hsuan (jap. Rinzai Gigen- 866). It involves skillful           who like to Dharmas and prefer performing use of blows with a stick and shouting by a Zen                offerings; however, they are hot-tempered, perfer master, which is believed to bring students to                 to ridicule other people; thus born in this realm. immediate and direct realization of truth if done              There are four categories of Asuras in the Three properly.                                                      realms of Existence: Caây Hoàng Taùo: A rose-apple tree.                            1) A-Tu-La Quyû Ñaïo: Asuras in the path of Caây Ta La: Döôùi haøng Ta La, beân ngoaøi thaønh                   ghosts—Loaïi quyû A-tu-la, sanh baèng tröùng Caâu Thi Na, Phaät ñaõ nhaäp dieät—Sala tree—                       trong loaøi quyû, duøng söùc maïnh cuûa mình ñeå hoä Buddha Sakyamuni passed away in a grove of sala                     trì Chaùnh Phaùp vaø nhôø thaàn löïc chuùng coù theå trees on the outskirts of Kushinagar.                               du haønh voâ ngaïi trong khoâng gian—Asuras in Caäy: To rely on—To lean on.                                        the path of ghosts, born from eggs and belong Coù, Khoâng, Coù Vaø Khoâng, Chaúng Coù Chaúng                      to the destiny of ghosts, who use their strength Khoâng: Existence, non-existence, both existence                    to protect Dharma and can with spiritual and non-existence, neither existence nor non-                       penetrations travel through space. existence.                                                     2) A-Tu-La Suùc Sanh Ñaïo: Loaïi quyû A-tu-la Coù Nieäm Laø Voâ Nieäm: Thought is the same as                     sanh trong ñöôøng suùc sanh—Asuras in the no-thought—Coù nieäm laø voâ nieäm ñoái vôùi Boà Taùt,              realm of Animals. They are Asuras who nhöng khoâng phaûi vaäy ñoái vôùi taâm meâ môø cuûa                 belong to the destiny of animal. chuùng sanh—Thought is the same as no-thought                  3) A-Tu-La Nhôn Ñaïo: Loaïi quyû A-tu-la sanh for a bodhisattva, but it is not the case for sentient              trong nhôn ñaïo—Asuras in the realm of beings’ deluded minds.                                              humans. They are Asuras born from wombs Coù Thaân Laø Coù Bònh: To possess a body is to                     and belong to the destiny of humans. open to disease.                                               4) Thaàn A-Tu-La Vöông: Loaïi naày do hoùa sanh Coù Theå Döùt Ñöôïc: Be able to remove.                             maø thaønh trong ñöôøng Thieân ñaïo, chuùng hoå trôï Phaät phaùp baèng söùc thaàn thoâng vaø voâ uùy.

Chuùng ñaáu tranh ñeå ñaït ñeán ñòa vò Phaïm            always shoot out of their mouth, therefore, they Chuû—Asuras in the realm of gods. They are              cannot eat or drink and are subject to hunger and Asura Kings who come into being by                      thirst for incalculable eons. transformation and belong to the destiny of             Coõi Ngöôøi: Manusaloka (p)—The human realm— gods. They support Dharma with a penetrating            See Duïc Giôùi. power and fearlessness. They struggle for               Coõi Nöôùc Voâ Öu: The Land of No-Concerns. position with the Brahma Lord.                          Coõi Phaøm Thaùnh Ñoàng Cö: The land of common Coõi AÙc: Evil world                                          residence of ordinary beings and saints. Coõi AÙc Tröôïc: Evil or defiled world.                       Coõi Phaät: Buddha-ksetra (skt)—Buddha-land— Coõi Cöïc Laïc Baûy Baùu Trang Nghieâm: The                   See Phaät Ñoä. Western Pure Land is adorned with seven                       Coõi Phöông Tieän Höõu Dö: The land of treasures.                                                    expediency. Coõi Dieäu Hyû: Laïc Thoå—Land of Nirvanic Bliss—             Coõi Sô Thieàn: See Sô Thieàn Thieân. Chæ coõi Tònh Ñoä cuûa ñöùc Phaät A Di Ñaø—Refers to          Coõi Suùc Sanh: Tiryagyoni (skt)—Ñeå Laät Xa— Amitabha's Pure Land.                                         Baøng Sinh—Domestic animals—Animals—The Coõi Duïc Giôùi: The realm of desire—The Human                realm of animals—Animality—See Suùc Sanh Thuù. realm.                                                        Coõi Ta Baø: Human world—Saha world. Coõi Ñòa Nguïc: Mayo (p)—Hells—Hell                           Coõi Thaät Baùo Voâ Chöôùng Ngaïi: The land of true dwellers—Realm of hells.                                      reward. Coõi Ñoàng Cö Tònh ñoä: The common residence                  Coõi Thöôøng Tòch Quang: The land of eternally Pure Land.                                                    tranquil light. Coõi Ñoàng Cö Ueá Ñoä: The common residence                   Coõi Thöôøng Tòch Quang Tònh Ñoä: The realm of impure land.                                                  the “Ever-Silent Illuminating Pure Land.” Coõi Giôùi: Realm—See Giôùi.                                  Coõi Tieân: Fairyland. Coõi Giôùi Thanh Tònh: Dag-zhing (tib)—Pure                   Coõi Tònh: Pure Abode—Pure Land. realm—Caûnh giôùi thanh tònh.                                 Coõi Tònh Ñoä: See Tònh Ñoä. Coõi Hoa Taïng Theá Giôùi: Hoa Taïng theá giôùi laø           Coõi Tònh Löu Ly Cuûa Ñöùc Phaät Döôïc Sö: The toaøn theå vuõ truï, ñöôïc dieãn taû trong Kinh Hoa           Pure Lapis Lazuli. Nghieâm. Ñaây laø coõi ngöï trò cuûa Phaät Tyø Loâ Giaù       Coõi Traàn: This world. Na, moät hình aûnh sieâu vieät cuûa Phaät Thích Ca vaø        Coõi Trôøi: Devaloka (p)—Heavenly world— chö Phaät. Theá giôùi Ta Baø, Taây phöông Tònh ñoä vaø        Celestial realms—Realms of the devas—Realms taát caû caùc coõi nöôùc khaùc ñeàu ôû trong coõi Hoa Taïng   of heaven. naày—The Flower-store world, the entire cosmos                Coõi Trôøi Coøn Nguõ Töôùng Suy Nghó Vaø Nhöõng as described in the Avatamsaka Sutra. It is the               Ñieàu Baát Nhö YÙ: The heavenly realms are still land of Vairocana Buddha, the transcendental                  marked by the five types of decay and the things aspect of Buddha Sakyamuni and of all Buddhas.                that go agaisnt our wishes. The saha world, the Western Pure Land, and all                Coõi Trôøi Duïc Giôùi: Desire realm. other lands are realms within the Flower-store                Coõi Trôøi Ñao Lôïi: Cung Trôøi Ñao Lôïi— world.                                                        Trayastrimsha Heaven—Coõi trôøi thöù hai trong saùu Coõi Naày: See Coõi Traàn.                                    coõi trôøi Duïc giôùi—The second level heaven of six Coõi Ngaï Quyû: Petaloka (p)—Pettivisaya (p)—                 heavens of Desire, or heavens of the thirty-three Trong coõi naày chuùng sanh thaân theå hoâi haùm, xaáu        devas. xa, buïng to nhö caùi troáng, coå nhoû nhö caây kim,          Coõi Trôøi Ñaâu Suaát: Tushita Heaven. mieäng luoân phöïc ra löûa, khoâng aên uoáng gì ñöôïc         Coõi Trôøi Quaûng Quaû: Abundant Fruit Heaven. neân phaûi chòu ñoùi khaùt trong muoân ngaøn kieáp —In Coõi Trôøi Saéc Giôùi: Taát caû chö thieân trong coõi trôøi the realm of hungry ghosts, beings have ugly and saéc giôùi khoâng coù khöùu giaùc vaø vò giaùc; hoï khoâng smelly bodies with bellies as big as drums, while aên uoáng, nguû nghæ hay duïc voïng. Tuy nhieân, nhöõng their throats are as small as needles and flames

ham muoán vaãn coøn aâm æ saâu kín beân trong, neân khi         vieät—The “path of preparation” is the second of thoï meänh nôi coõi trôøi vöøa döùt laø hoï phaûi trôû veà      the five paths to Buddhahood, which begins when caûnh giôùi thaáp tuøy theo nghieäp löïc (chö thieân trong      a meditator attains the levels of “union of calming caûnh trôøi voâ saéc cuõng coøn nhöõng duïc voïng saâu kín      and      higher    insight.”    (samatha-vipasyana- naày)—The realms of form. All the gods in the                   yuganaddha). It is prefatory (giai ñoaïn giaùo ñaàu) form realm heavens are without the senses of                    because the meditator is preparing for the first smell and taste; they do not eat food, sleep or                 supramundane path, the “path of seeing” (darsana- have sexual desire. However, the desires for these              marga), which begins with direct perception of things are still latent, and once their heavenly life           emptiness (sunyata). There are four levels of the comes to an end, they can return to any lower                   path of preparation: Heat (usma-gata); in the first realms of existence, in accordance with their                   stage the meditator has a direct, non-conceptual karma (these desires are also latent in the gods in             awareness of suchness (Tathata), which said to the formless heavens).                                          burn away false conceptuality. The second stage Coõi Trôøi Tha Hoùa: Coõi trôøi luïc duïc—The sixth             is the peak (murdhan). Peak” marks a point at heaven in the realm of desire.                                  which the “virtuous roots” (kusala-mula) that one Coõi Trôøi Voâ Saéc: Taát caû chö thieân trong coõi trôøi       previously cultivated will not decrease or be lost, naày khoâng coù thaân theå, chæ coøn “Thöùc” maø thoâi —        and one progresses in understanding of suchness. The realm of formlessness. All the gods in this                 The third stage is Patience (ksanti). “At the level realm have no bodies, they only have                            of “patience” the meditator becomes increasingly consciousness.                                                  familiar with the concept of emptiness and Con Ñöôøng: Path.                                               overcomes fear with respect to it. From this point Con Ñöôøng Chuaån Bò: Prayoga-marga (skt)—                      onward one will never again be reborn in the “Con ñöôøng chuaån bò” laø con ñöôøng thöù hai trong            lower destinies (gati) of hell beings, hungry naêm ñöôøng ñi ñeán quaû vò Phaät, baét ñaàu khi haønh          ghosts, or animals due to the force of afflicted giaû ñaït ñöôïc trình ñoä “noái keát chæ vaø tueä.” Ñaây laø    actions and attitudes. The last stage is the supreme giai ñoaïn giaùo ñaàu vì haønh giaû ñang chuaån bò cho          mundane qualities (laukikagra-dharma). Supreme con ñöôøng sieâu vieät thöù nhaát, “kieán ñaïo,” baét ñaàu      mundane qualities refer to the fact that the baèng tröïc nhaän veà “khoâng taùnh. Coù boán trình ñoä         meditator actualizes the highest qualities that are treân con ñöôøng tu taäp chuaån bò. Giai ñoaïn thöù nhaát       possible within cyclic existence, and at the same laø söùc noùng. Trong giai ñoaïn naøy, haønh giaû coù           time prepares for direct realization of emptiness, ñöôïc söï nhaän bieát tröïc tieáp, khoâng qua khaùi nieäm       which is a supramundane attainment. veà “Nhö Lai,” maø ngöôøi ta noùi ñoù laø söùc noùng ñoát       Con Ñöôøng Deã: Easy path of practice (The Pure chaùy taát caû nhöõng khaùi nieäm giaû taïo. Giai ñoaïn thöù    Land Dharma Door)—Recitation of Amitabha nhì laø cao ñoä. Cao ñieåm ñaùnh daáu caùi ñieåm cuûa           Buddha’s name. nhöõng caên laønh tu taäp töø tröôùc seõ khoâng suy giaûm       Con Ñöôøng Ñaïo Ñöùc: Ethical path. hay maát maùt, vaø ôû giai ñoaïn naøy haønh giaû tieán tôùi     Con Ñöôøng Haïnh Phuùc: The path to happiness. söï hieåu bieát chaân chaùnh veà chaân nhö. Nhaãn nhuïc         Con Ñöôøng Khoù: Difficult path of practice—The trong giai ñoaïn thöù ba, haønh giaû trôû neân gia taêng        path of practicing Paramita and meditation. quen thuoäc vôùi khaùi nieäm veà “khoâng taùnh” vaø vöôït       Con Ñöôøng Trí Tueä: atisambhida-magga (p)— qua söï sôï haõi. Töø luùc naøy trôû ñi haønh giaû seõ khoâng   Voâ Ngaïi Giaûi Ñaïo—The path of unhindered coøn sôï phaûi taùi sanh vaøo caùc ñöôøng döõ nhö ñòa           discrimination—See Voâ Ngaïi Ñaïo Giaûi Thoaùt. nguïc, ngaï quyû, hay suùc sanh vì nhöõng thaùi ñoä hay         Con Ñöôøng Trôû Veà Tònh Ñoä: The way back to haønh ñoäng phieàn naõo nöõa. Giai ñoaïn cuoái cuøng laø        the Pure Land. nhöõng phaåm chaát sieâu vieät toái thöôïng. chæ caùc söï       Con Ñöôøng Trung Ñaïo: The Middle Path. kieän maø haønh giaû thöïc chöùng nhöõng phaåm chaát cao        Con Ñöôøng Tu Taäp: Tu haønh theo phaùp moân cuûa hôn, coù theå coøn trong voøng luaân hoài sanh töû, vaø         toân giaùo—To practice the way—To cultivate the ñoàng thôøi chuaån bò cho vieäc chöùng nghieäm tröïc            way of religion—See Tu Ñaïo. tieáp veà taùnh khoâng, ñaây laø söï chöùng ñaéc sieâu          Con Ngöôøi: human being.

Coõng: To carry on the back.                                 Coâ Sôn: Coâ: Mua baùn röôïu—To deal in alcoholic liquor.             1) Ngoïn nuùi naèm cheo leo moät mình: An isolated Coâ Ñòa Nguïc: See Coâ Ñoäc Ñòa Nguïc.                             hill. Coâ Ñieäu Giaûi Thoaùt: A self-benefiting person—A           2) Coâ Sôn Töï vaø teân cuûa moät trong nhöõng vò self-profit person—See Töï Lieãu Haùn.                             Taêng truï trì taïi ñaây (Sö Thích Trì Vieân 975- Coâ Ñoäc: Solitary—Lonely.                                         1021, ñeä töû cuûa Phuïng Tieân Nguyeân Thanh, töï Coâ Ñoäc Ñòa Nguïc: Pratyeka-naraka (skt)—Bieân                    laø Voâ Ngaïi Trung Dung Töû. Coøn goïi laø Theá Ñòa Nguïc—Hell of solitude—Solitary hells—                         Phu hay Beänh Phu. Sö theo hoïc yeáu chæ cuûa Solitary hells.                                                    toâng Thieân Thai Tam Quaùn vôùi ngaøi Phuïng Coâ Ñoäc Vieân: Jetavana (skt)—Kodoku-On (jap)—                    Tieân Nguyeân Thanh, tu haønh taïi nuùi Coâ Sôn ôû Theo Eitel trong Trung Anh Phaät Hoïc Töø Ñieån cuûa               Taây Hoà, soaïn vieát nhieàu tröôùc taùc. Sö thò tòch Giaùo Sö Soothill, ñaây laø tònh xaù baûy töøng cuøng vôùi         naêm 1021. Sö ñaõ töøng soaïn boä sôù chuù Kinh coâng vieân maø ngaøi Caáp Coâ Ñoäc ñaõ mua töø Thaùi Töû          Laêng Nghieâm)—A monastery in Kiang-Su Kyø Ñaø ñeå hieán cho Phaät. Ñaây laø nôi an cö maø Ñöùc           and name of one of its monks. Phaät raát thích, cuõng laø nôi maø nhieàu boä kinh ñaõ      Coâ Taïng: Ku-Tsang—Teân moät quaän phuû, nay ñöôïc Phaät thuyeát giaûng—According to Eitel from           thuoäc Löông Chaâu, tænh Cam Tuùc, laø trung taâm löu The Dictionary of Chinese-English Buddhist                   thoâng quan troïng sang Taây Taïng—Formerly a city Terms, this is the seven-storey abode and park               in Liang-Chou, Kan-Su, and an important center presented to Sakyamuni by Anathapindaka, who                 for communication with Tibet. bought it from the prince Jeta. It was a favourite           Coâ Thi Thaûo: Kusa (skt)—Cöï Xaù—Moät loaïi coû resort of the Buddha, and most of the sutras date            kieát töôøng—Grass of good omen for divination. from this spot.                                              Coâ Thieàm Thöøa Thieân Hoøa Thöôïng: Most Coâ Hoàn: Forsake spirits.                                   Venerable Ku-Ch’an Ch’eng-T’ien—Teân cuûa moät Coâ Khôûi: Gatha (skt)—Giaø Ñaø—Phuùng Tuïng—                vò Thieàn sö Trung Hoa vaøo theá kyû thöù 12. Hieän Nhöõng caâu phuùng vònh, taùn thaùn nghóa lyù thaâm          nay chuùng ta khoâng coù nhieàu taøi lieäu chi tieát veà dieäu vaø ca tuïng coâng ñöùc cuûa Phaät vaø Tam Baûo —      Hoøa Thöôïng Coâ Thieàm; tuy nhieân, coù moät chi tieát To intone—To sing.                                           nhoû veà vò Thieàn sö naøy trong Moâng Sôn Töï Coâ Khôûi Tuïng: See Coâ Khôûi.                              Truyeän: "Cuoái naêm 1065, toâi ñeán chuøa Thöøa Coâ Laäp: To isolate.                                        Thieân, nôi ñaây Coâ Thieàm Hoøa Thöôïng ñang truï trì, Coâ Lieâu: Isolation—ÔÛ nôi coâ lieâu (ôû nôi coâ lieâu      vaø taïm thôøi döøng chaân ôû ñoù. Toâi töï theä seõ khoâng ñeå thaønh töïu thieàn ñoä)—Lonely and unfrequented.         rôøi khoûi nôi naày cho ñeán khi naøo laõnh hoäi ñöôïc Coâ Minh: Voøng saùng leû loi, chæ cho Phaät taùnh hay       ñaïo Thieàn. Hôn moät thaùng sau, toâi laáy laïi coâng phu chaân ngaõ—Lonely (solitary) halo—Lonely                     ñaõ maát. Baáy giôø khaép mình gheû lôõ; nhöng vaãn (solitary) circle of light, i.e., Buddha-nature or true      quyeát taâm giöõ vöõng coâng phu duø coù ñaùnh ñoåi caû self (the real or nirvana ego).                              cuoäc ñôøi. Nhôø ñoù maø taâm löïc ñöôïc maï nh meõ theâm Coâ Ngaïnh: Ngöôøi coù moät phong caùch cöùng coõi—A         nhieàu, vaø bieát giöõ vöõng coâng phu cuûa mình ngay person with a firm manner.                                   caû luùc beänh hoaïn. Moät hoâm ñöôïc môøi ñi thoï trai, suoát treân ñöôøng ñeán nhaø trai chuû, vöøa ñi vöøa ñeo Coâ Phong Giaùc Minh (1271-1361): Koho- ñuoåi coâng aùn, maõi mieát trong coâng phu tu taäp cho Kakumyo (jap)—Cao Phong Giaùc Minh laø teân cuûa tôùi ngang qua nhaø maø vaãn khoâng hay mình ñang ôû moät vò Thieàn Taêng Nhaät Baûn, thuoäc toâng Laâm Teá. ñaâu. Nhôø vaäy maø toâi hieåu ra theá naøo goïi laø thöïc Naêm 1311, Sö sang Trung Hoa, noái phaùp cuûa haønh coâng phu ngay trong moïi ñoäng duïng. Ñeán Thieàn sö Trung Phong Minh Boån—Name of a ñaây thì taâm cô cuûa toâi nhö maët traêng phaûn chieáu töø Japanese Lin-chi Zen monk. In 1311, he traveled loøng saâu cuûa doøng nöôùc ñang chaûy; maët nöôùc tuy to China, studied and became the Dharma heir of chaûy xieát, nhöng maët traêng vaãn y nhieân baát Zen master Chung-feng Ming-pen. ñoäng."—Most Venerable Ku-Ch’an, name of a Coâ Quaû: Orphan and widow. Chinese Zen Master in the thirteenth century. We Coâ Quaïnh: See Coâ ñoäc. do not have detailed documents on this Zen

Master; however, in Mung-Shan's autobiography,                   Moät nhaø sö hoûi Thuû Sôn: Theo kinh noùi heát thaûy there is a brief detail on him: "Around the end of               chuùng sanh ñeàu coù Phaät tính; vaäy sao chuùng sanh 1065, I left this monastery and travelled to Cheâ -              khoâng bieát?” Thuû Sôn ñaùp: “Bieát chöù.”—Historical Chiang. On the way I experienced many hardships                  references—Words from the sutras (see Ñieån Coá). and my Zen exercise suffered accordingly. I came                 In Zen, this is a question containing words from to the Ch’eng-T’ien monastery which I was                        the sutras. A monk asked Shou-Shan: “According presided over by the Master Ku-Ch’an, and there                  to the sutra, all beings are endowed with the took up my temporal habitation. I vowed to myself                Buddha-nature; how is it then that they know it that I would not leave this place until I realized               not?” Shou-Shan replied: “They know” (see Phaàn the truth of Zen. In a little over a month I regained            Döông Thaäp Baùt Vaán). what I had lost in the exercise. It was then that my             Coá Chaáp: Thambha (p)—Obduracy—Obstinate— whole body was covered with boils; but I was                     Persistent—Stubborn. determined to keep the discipline even at the cost               Coá Chí: Determined—Decided to do something— of my life. This helped a great deal to strengthen               Resolved mind. my spiritual powers, and I knew how to keep up                   Coá Chæ: Giaáy cuõ—Old or waste paper. my seeking and striving even in illness. One day,                Coá Chæ Trung Hôïp Döôïc: Toa thuoác ñöôïc vieát being invited out to dinner I walked on with my                  treân giaáy cuõ, chæ cho söï phuû ñònh nôi vieäc chaáp koan all the way to the devotee’s house, but I was               tröôùc ngoân ngöõ vaên töï—A prescription on old or so absorbed in my exercise that I passed by the                  waste paper, i.e., a denial of attachments to words house without even recognizing where I was. This                 and speeches. made me realized what was meant by carrying on                   Coá Coâng: To endeavour—To strive. the exercise even while engaged in active work.                  Coá Coát: Xöông coát trong tieàn kieáp, hay cuûa nhieàu My mental condition then was like the reflection                 theá heä—Old bones, bones of former incarnation or of the moon penetrating the depths of a running                  generation. stream the surface of which was in rapid motion,                 Coá Coát Nhö Sôn: Chæ söï soáng cheát troâi daït, neân while the moon itself retained its perfect shape                 xöông coát cuûa nhieàu ñôøi nhieàu kieáp chaát choàng leân and serenity in spite of the commotion of the                    cao nhö nuùi—Old bones, or bones of former water."—See Moâng Sôn Ñöùc Dò Thieàn Sö.                         incarnation or generation piled up as high as a Coâ Töùc: Phong caùch cuûa keû tieåu nhaân laø caåu thaû         mountain. ñeå ñöôïc yeân oån—The manner of mean people is                  Coá Gaéng: To try—To strive—To endeavor— to be careless so they can be left alone.                        Effort—Exertion. Coâ Töûu Giôùi: Giôùi caám baùn röôïu—The                        Coá Khoå: 1) Noåi khoå sôû xöa kia: Old suffering; 2) commandment which is against the selling of                      Noãi khoå do haäu quaû cuûa hoaït ñoäng keùo daøi, nhö alcoholic liquor.                                                naèm nhieàu, ñöùng nhieàu, ñi nhieàu, thoaït tieân thaáy Coâ Vaân Hoaøi Trang Thieàn Sö (1198-1280):                      thích thuù, nhöng sau ñoù trôû neân meät moûi raû rôøi: Koun-Ejo (jap)—Teân cuûa moät thieàn sö Nhaät Baûn               The suffering resulting from prolongation, e.g. too vaøo theá kyû thöù 13, ñeä töû noåi tieáng cuûa thieàn sö Ñaïi   much lying, standing, walking, at first a joy, Nhaät Naêng Nhaãn cuûa phaùi Ñaït Ma toâng Nhaät Baûn.           become wearying. Veà sau naày oâng trôû thaønh nhò toå cuûa Taøo Ñoäng            Coá Laøm Ra Veû Beà Ngoaøi: For appearance sake. toâng Nhaät Baûn—Name of a Japanese Zen master,                  Coá Nhò: Purva-dvitiya (skt)—Ngöôøi vôï cuûa moät vò one of the most prominent students of Zen master                 Taêng hoài chöa xuaát gia—The former mate or wife Dainichi Nonin. He later became the second                       of a monk. patriarch of the Soto Zen school of Japan.                       Coá Söï Thoáng Hoái: Kathasantsagara (skt)—Teân Coâ Xöôùng: Ñaùnh giaù tröôùc khi keâu baùn vaät gì (cuûa        cuûa moät boä Tröôøng Thi vaøo theá kyû thöù XI, coù treân taêng chuùng)—To estimate the price before selling               21.500 caâu tuïng—Name of a Long Poetry something (from the Sangha).                                     Collection in the eleventh century with more than Coá: Lôøi daïy trong kinh ñieån. Trong Thieàn, ñaây laø          21,000 verses. caâu hoûi coù chöùa ñöïng nhöõng lôøi noùi trong kinh.           Coá Taùc Nghieäp: See Coá Tö Nghieäp.

Coá Taát: Pheùp taéc coá ñònh khoâng thay ñoåi—Fixed          Coå AÂm Phaät: Divya-dundubhi-meghanirghosa and unchangeable regulations.                                 (skt)—The rolling of drums Buddha—See Thieân Coá Taät: Chronic disease.                                    Coå Loâi AÂm Phaät. Coá Tri: Old acquaintance.                                    Coå AÂm Thanh Vöông: Amita-dundubhi- Coá Traùnh: To try to evade.                                  svararaja-dharani (skt)—Rolling of drums Buddha. Coá Tö Nghieäp: Coøn goïi laø Coá Taùc Nghieäp, Coá Tö        Coå AÂm Thanh Vöông Kinh: Amita-dundubhi- Taïo Nghieäp, hay Coá Taùc Nghieäp, laø caùi nghieäp          svararaja-dharani-sutra (skt)—Sutra on Rolling of thaân vaø mieäng do coá yù taïo ra (neáu khoâng coá yù taïo   drums Buddha. ra thì goïi laø Baát Coá Tö Nghieäp. Quaû baùo caûm thoï      Coå AÂm Tònh Caàm Thieàn Sö: Ku-Yin-Ching-Ch'in khoå laïc chæ giôùi haïn ôû Coá Tö Nghieäp maø thoâi)—        (chi)—Teân cuûa moät thieàn sö Trung Hoa vaøo cuoái The karma produced by former intention.                       theá kyû thöù XV. Ngaøi thöôøng daïy caùc moân nhaân: Coá Tö Taïo Nghieäp: See Coá Tö Nghieäp.                      "Coâng phu coù theå thöïc haønh toát ñeïp nhaát laø ôû nôi Coá Vaán: Advisor.                                            khoâng coù tieáng ñoäng vaø taïp loaïn, Haõy döùt boû taát caû Coá Vò: To cling to one’s position.                           nhöõng ñieàu kieän quaáy nhieãu, haõy döøn g laïi suy tö Coá YÙ: Adhyasayati (skt)—Coù chuû yù—                        vaø nghó töôûng, ñeå heát taâm trí vaøo vieäc tieán haønh Intentionally—Purposeful intention—Purposely.                 coâng aùn, ñöøng bao giôø buoâng thaû noù ra khoûi trung Coá YÙ Phöông Haønh Laäp: Töø ñòa thöù ba ñeán ñòa            taâm cuûa thöùc, duø khi ñi, ñöùng hay naèm ngoài vaãn thöù baûy trong Thaäp Ñòa Boà Taùt—The third to the           vaäy. Ñöøng bao giôø quan taâm ñeán vieäc mình ñang ôû seventh of the ten Bodhisattva stages of                      trong caûnh ngoä naøo, duø khi vöøa loøng hay khoâng development—See Thaäp Ñòa Phaät Thöøa.                        vöøa loøng, maø luoân luoân haõy coá giöõ laáy coâng aùn Coà Da Ni Da: Godaniya or Apara-godaniya                      trong loøng, phaûn quan töï chieáu, vaø töï hoûi ai laø keû (skt)—Coà Da Ni Da Chaâu—See Taây Ngöu Hoùa                   ñang theo ñuoåi coâng aùn chaúng bieát meät theá, vaø Chaâu.                                                        tieáp tuïc töï hoûi nhö vaäy khoâng ngöøng. Cöù tieáp tuïc Coà Di: Gopika (skt)—Minh Nöõ—Name of                         tieán haønh nhö theá, heát söùc haêng haùi, nghi chính keû Siddhartha-gautama's second royal concubine—                  ñang nghi, chaéc chaén seõ ñeán luùc khoâng coøn nghi Teân cuûa baø phi thöù hai cuûa thaùi töû Taát Ñaït Ña.       vaøo ñaâu ñöôïc nöõa, gioáng nhö caùc oâng ñaõ ñi ñeán Coà Ñaøm: Gotamo (p)—Gotama (skt)—See Thích                   chính taän nguoàn cuûa doøng suoái vaø thaáy mình ñang Ca Maâu Ni Phaät.                                             bò nhöõng ngoïn nuùi vaây haõm chung quanh. Ñaây laø Coà Ñaøm Di: Gotami (skt)—Mahaprajapati (skt)—                luùc goác caây cuøng vôùi saén bìm chaèng chòt gaõy ñoå, Gautami (skt)—See Ma Ha Ba Xaø Ba Ñeà.                        töùc laø khi söï phaân bieät chuû khaùch hoaøn toaøn bò xaùo troän, khi keû bò nghi vaø caùi bò nghi hoøa hôïp thaønh Coà Ñaøm Taát Ñaït Ña: Gotamo-Siddhattha (p)— moät khoái duy nhaát. Moät khi tænh thöùc töø söï hôïp Gotama-Siddhartha (skt)—See Thích Ca Maâu Ni nhaát naøy, caùi ngoä lôùn hieän ñeán, mang söï thanh Phaät. bình cho nghi tình vaø tham cöùu cuûa caùc oâng"—Ku- Coà Ñaøm Toân Giaû: Gotamo (p)—Gotama (skt)— Yin-Ching-Ch'in, name of a Chinese Zen master in See Thích Ca Maâu Ni Phaät. the end of the fifteenth century. He used to teach Coà Na Maït Ñeà: Gaunamati (skt)—Ñöùc Hueä La his disciples: "Searching and contriving may best Haùn, ñeä töû cuûa ñöùc Phaät—Name of a disciple of be practiced where noise and confusion do not Sakyamuni Buddha. reach;        cut      yourself       off     from         all Coà Sa: Ghosha (skt)—Noùi Moät Lôøi—Uttering a disturbingconditions; put a stop to speculation and word. imagination; and apply yourself wholeheartedly to Coà Tyø Gia: Gopika (skt)—See Coà Di. the task of holding on to your koan, never letting it Coå: 1) Caùi troáng: A drum; 2) Coå xöa: Ancient, go off the centre of consciousness, whether you antique. are sitting or lying, walking or standing still. Never Coå AÂm: The rolling of drums. mind in what condition you are placed, whether Coå AÂm Nhö Lai: See Coå AÂm Phaät.                           pleasing or displeasing, but try all the time to keep the koan in mind, and reflect within yourself who it is that is pursuing the koan so untiringly and

asking you this question so unremittingly. As you           loaøi Quyû Coå Ñoäc—If it was greed for hatred that thus go on, intensely in earnest, inquiring after the       made the person commit offenses, then, after he inquirer himself, the time will most assuredly              has finished paying for his crimes, then, after he come to you when it is absolutely impossible for            has finished paying for his crimes, he takes shape you to go on with your inquiry, as if you had come          when he encounters worms, and he is called a Ku- to the very fountain of a stream and were blocked           Poison Ghost. by the mountains all around. This is the time when          Coå Ñöùc: Pubbacariya (p). the tree together with entwining wistaria breaks            1) Baäc Thaùnh, baäc hoïc giaû, baäc thaày, hay baäc coù down, that is, when the distinction of subject and                nhieàu coâng ñöùc vaøo thôøi xöa: Ñöùc haïnh thôøi object is utterly obliterated, when the inquiring                 xöa—Nhöõng baäc ñöùc haïnh thôøi xöa—Ancient and the inquired are fused into one perfect                       sages—Ancient scholars—Master of the identity. Awakening from this identification, there               past—Meritorious person of ancient times— takes place a great enlightenment (satori) that                   Virtuous ancients. brings peace to all your inquiries and searchings."         2) Coâng ñöùc cuûa ngöôøi xöa—Ancient merit. Coå Caùch: See Coå Taéc.                                    Coå Ñöùc Hoûa Sao: Coâng aùn ñoå naêm thöù löûa ñoát Coå Chuøy: Caùi duøi xöa, chæ cho cô phong thieàn hay       löng—The koan of "placing five hot jabs on the khía caïnh vi dieäu thaâm aùo cuûa thieàn, hay tính caùch   Old Virtue's back"—Theo Nguõ Ñaêng Hoäi Nguyeân, saéc beùn cuûa moät vò thieàn sö—An old stick (staff),      quyeån III, moãi khi Thieàn sö Loã Toå Baûo Vaân thaáy i.e., the wonderful and profoundly aspects of Zen,          moät vò Taêng ñeán laø oâng xoay maët vaøo töôøng. Nam or sharp characters of a Zen master.                        Tuyeàn nghe vaäy noùi: "Ta thöôøng noùi vôùi chö Taêng, Coå Chuyeát Vi Tieáu: Nuï cöôøi haøm tieáu coù phong        'Höôùng veà luùc Phaät chöa xuaát theá maø hoäi thuû coøn caùch ñaëc bieät treân caùc töôïng Phaät—An archaic         chöa ñöôïc moät ngöôøi, thaäm chí laø nöûa ngöôøi.' OÂng smile with a special manner in any statue of                ta maø nhö theá thì ñeán naêm con löøa coøn chöa ñöôïc." Buddha.                                                     Huyeàn Giaùc noùi: "Nam Tuyeàn coù ñoàng loøng vôùi Coå Chöôûng: Voã tay—To clap one's hands.                   Loã Toå hay khoâng?" Baûo Phöôùc hoûi Thöôøng Thanh: Coå Coân (?-1892): Master Ku-Kun—Teân cuûa moät             "Neáu maø moïi thöù ñeàu nhö Loã Toå, thì laøm gì coøn coù vò Taêng Trung Hoa ôû Giang Taây vaøo theá kyû thöù         kyù luïc Thieàn giaùo! Coù phaûi ñieàu naøy laø caùi maø XIX—Name of a Chinese monk in Jiang-Hsi                     Nam Tuyeàn ñaõ noùi khoâng?" Tröôøng Thanh noùi: Province in the nineteenth century.                         "Ñoàng yù vôùi ngöôøi baèng caùch naøy! Thì trong möôøi Coå Daãn: Ñöa ñöôøng daãn loái—To guide and lead            ngaøn ngöôøi oâng khoâng theå tìm ñöôïc laáy moät!" La the way.                                                    Sôn noùi: "Neáu tieân sö Muïc Chaâu Traàn Ñaïo Minh Coå Ñaïi Toân Giaùo: Toân giaùo xuaát hieän hoài thôøi      maø thaáy Loã Toå kieåu naøy seõ cho oâng ta naêm thoi coå ñaïi—Religions of the ancient times.                    noùng hoåi treân löng! Taïi sao? Vì oâng ta chæ cho ra Coå Ñieàn Chöùc Boä: Furuta Oribe (jap)—Teân cuûa           maø khoâng laáy voâ." Huyeàn Sa noùi: "Neáu maø toâi coù moät vò Thieàn Taêng Nhaät Baûn—Name of a                   ôû ñoù, toâi cuõng seõ cho oâng ta naêm thoi noùng hoåi treân Japanese Zen monk.                                          löng thoâi!" Vaân Cö Tích (?) noùi: "La Sôn vaø Coå Ñieàn Thieäu Khaâm (1911- ?): Furuta Shokin             Huyeàn Sa noùi nhö vaäy, ai ñuùng? Neáu maø maáy oâng (jap)—Teân cuûa moät vò hoïc giaû Phaät giaùo Nhaät Baûn    coù theå tuyeån löïa ñöôïc, thì laõo Taêng seõ ñoàng yù raèng vaøo theá kyû thöù XX—Name of a Japanese Buddhist           kyû xaûo Phaùp cuûa maáy oâng löu loaùt." Huyeàn Giaùc scholar in the twentieth century.                           noùi: "Nhöng noùi veà naêm thoi noùng hoåi cuûa Huyeàn Coå Ñieån: Kinh Phaät vaø nhöõng lôøi daïy doã cuûa chö     Sa, coù ñeán ñöôïc Loã Toå hay khoâng?"—According Toå sö thôøi xöa—Buddhist scriptures and ancient            to Wudeng Huiyuan, volume III, whenever Zen Patriarchs' teachings.                                      master Luzu Baoyun would see a monk coming he Coå Ñình Thieän Kieân Thieàn Sö: Teân cuûa moät vò          would face the wall. When Nanquan heard this he Thieàn sö Nhaät Baûn vaøo theá kyû thöù XVII—Name of        said, "I usually say to the monks, 'You must a Japanese Zen master in the seventeenth century.           comprehend what is before the Buddha appears in Coå Ñoäc Quyû: Neck-Poisoned Ghost—Tham saân                the world.' But until now there hasn't been a single haän, gaây toäi, gaëp loaøi truøng thaønh hình, laøm caùc   one, or even a half one, who understands. If he

acts like this he'll keep on going right through the           strings to your stomach and go traveling to other year of the ass!" Xuanjue said, "Is Nanquan going              mountains.” Yueh-Shan said: “Who am I to speak along with Luzu or not?" Baofu asked Changqing,                of being head of a Zen mountain?” Ma-Tsu said: "If everything was like Luzu, then there'd be no               “That’s not what I mean. Those who haven’t gone records at all! Isn't this what Nanquan was                    on a long pilgrimage can’t reside as an abbot. saying?" Changqing said, "Acceding to people in                There’s no advantage to seeking advantage. this way! You can't find one in ten thousand like              Nothing is accomplished by seeking something. this!" Luoshan said, "If old teacher Chen Muzhou               You should go on a journey and not remain in this Daoming had seen him he would have given him                   place.” Yueh-Shan then left Ma-Tsu and returned five hot jabs on the back! Why? Because he lets it             to Shih-T’ou. out but doesn't take it in." Xuansha said, "If I'd             Coå Giaûn Haøn Tuyeàn: Khe suoái xöa nöôùc laïnh— been there, I would have given him five hot jabs               The cold fountain and the ancient stream—Ñaây on the back too!" Yunju Ci said, "Luoshan and                  cuõng laø moät trong nhöõng coâng aùn noåi tieáng cuûa Xuansha talking like this, which one is right? If              Thieàn sö Trieäu Chaâu Toøng Thaåm (778-897). Ñaây you can sort it out, then I'll agree that your                 laø moät trong nhöõng coâng aùn thuoäc loaïi giaûi minh Dharma skills are proficient." Xuanjue said, "But              chaân lyù Thieàn baèng nhöõng phaùn ngoân giaûn dò vaø about these five jabs by Xuansha, can they reach               tröïc chæ, nghóa laø loaïi "minh nhieân xaùc nhaän." Caâu Luzu?"                                                         noùi naøy chaúng coù yù nghóa gì vôùi moät ngöôøi tri thöùc, Coå Ñöùc Laïn Haïnh: Coâng aùn quaû haïnh thoái cuûa           kyø thaät, noù cuõng nghe thaät laø bình thöôøng ngay ñoái Thieàn sö Chí Vieân, moät Thieàn sö Trung Hoa vaøo             vôùi moät ngöôøi bình thöôøng. Coù chuyeän gì lôùn lao thôøi nhaø Toáng—The koan of Zen master Ji-yuan's              vôùi caùi goïi laø "Khe suoái xöa nöôùc laïnh!" Nhöng rotten apricot. Zen master Ji-yuan was from China              neáu chuùng ta suy nghó kyõ caøng, caâu noùi taàm thöôøng during the Sung dynasty (960-1279).                            naøy bieåu toû moät caùch soáng ñoäng nhöõng giôùi haïn Coå Ñöùc Tam Mieät: Coâng aùn coät ba laït tre vaøo            cuûa tö töôûng con ngöôøi, bò ñoùng khuoân chaët cheõ buïng—The koan of binding three bamboo strings                 trong caùc khuoân maãu bieán chuyeån lieân tuïc. Noù ñeà to one's stomach—Theo Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån               nghò raèng chuùng ta phaûi vöôït qua tö löông phaân XIV, Döôïc Sôn haàu Maõ Toå ba naêm. Moät hoâm Maõ             bieän ñeå hieåu ñöôïc caâu noùi taàm thöôøng naøy. Trieäu Toå hoûi Döôïc Sôn: “Ngaøy gaàn ñaây choã thaáy cuûa           Chaâu quaû thaät laø moät vò thaày phi thöôøng, nhöng ngöôi theá naøo?” Döôïc Sôn thöa: “Da moûng da daày            ñoâi khi Sö quaù thaâm traàm khoâng hieå u noåi. Ngay ñeàu rôùt saïch, chæ coù moät chôn thaät.” Maõ Toå baûo:       Thieàn sö Hoaøng Baù cuõng khoâng theo kòp Sö, trong “Sôû ñaéc cuûa ngöôi ñaõ hôïp vôùi taâm theå, khaép heát töù   khi Thieàn sö Tuyeát Phong goïi Sö laø coå Phaät vaø cuùi chi. Ñaõ ñöôïc nhö theá, neân ñem ba caät tre coät da          laïy Sö töø xa khi ngöôøi ta yeâu caàu Tuyeát Phong pheâ buïng, tuøy choã ôû nuùi ñi.” Döôïc Sôn thöa: “Con laø         bình Sö—This is also one of Zen master Chao- ngöôøi gì daùm noùi ôû nuùi?” Maõ Toå baûo: “Chaúng phaûi      chou's famous koans. This is one of the koans that vaäy, chöa coù thöôøng ñi maø chaúng ñöùng, chöa coù           illustrates Zen-truth through plain and direct thöôøng ñöùng maø chaúng ñi, muoán lôïi ích khoâng choã        statement, i.e., the explicit-affirmative type. This lôïi ích, muoán laøm khoâng choã laøm, neân taïo thuyeàn       statement makes no sense whatsoever to an beø, khoâng neân ôû ñaây laâu.” Döôïc Sôn töø giaû Maõ Toå     intellectual, as a matter of fact, it sounds very trôû veà Thaïch Ñaàu—According to The Records of               ordinary even to the most ordinary man. There is the Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu),                 no big deal with a so-called "The cold fountain Volume XIV, Yueh-Shan served as Ma-Tsu’s                       and the ancient stream!" But if we think about it attendant for three years. One day Ma-Tsu asked                carefully, this down-to earth, seemingly ordinary Yueh-Shan: “What have you seen lately?” Yueh-                  statement demonstrate vividly the limitations of Shan said: “Shedding the skin completely, leaving              human thought solidly moulded in derivative and only the true body.” Ma-Tsu said: “Your                        sequential patterns. It suggests that we shouldgo attainment can be said to be in accord with the                beyond conceptualization to understand this very mind-body, spreading through its four limbs. Since             ordianry statement. Chao-chou was indeed a it’s like this, you should bind these three bamboo             remarkable Master, but sometimes he was too

profound to be understood. Even Huang-po (?-                  linh thaùnh chuùt naøo." Vò Thaày quay ñaàu laïi nhìn 850) failed to follow him, while Hsueh-feng (822-             Sö. Sö noùi: "Phaät tuy khoâng linh thaùnh, nhöng coù 908) called him the ancient Buddha and bowed to               theå       phoùng        quang!"—After             attaining him at a distance when he was asked to comment                enlightenment, Ku-ling bid farewell to Master on him.                                                       Bai-Zhang and returned to the monastery in which Coå Giaùo: Lôøi daïy cuûa caùc baäc coå ñöùc—Virtuous         he had been ordained by his "first teacher", the ancients' teachings.                                          monk who had brought him up from childhood and Coå Hôïp: Coå ñoäng—To launch a propaganda.                   who, at that time, was a very old man. However, Coå Kim: Kokon (jap)—Xöa nay, thuaät ngöõ khoâng              his original teacher had not entirely understood chæ coù nghóa laø xöa nay hay quaù khöù vaø hieän taïi,       the Truth, but he was too proud to take advice maø coøn coù nghóa laø moïi thôøi ñaïi hay vónh cöûu—         from his student, as he thought disciples would Ancient-present, the term means not only "past                never surpass their teacher. So Shen-tsan would and present" or "ancient and modern times," but               like to help his teacher to get awakened. One day, also "all ages" or eternity.                                  Shen-tsan was helping his old teacher to bathe. Coå Kim Ñoäc Loä AÅn Hieån Voâ Phöông: Chaân lyù              While washing the old man's back, he clapped on Phaät giaùo khoâng giôùi haïn töï coå chí kim—The truth       his back and said to him, "This is such a fine of Buddhism is not limited from ancient times up              temple, but the Buddha in it is not at all holy!" His to now.                                                       old teacher then turned round and looked at him, Coå Kính: Kokyo (jap)—Göông xöa, tieâu bieåu cho              whereupon Shen-tsan commended, "Though the taâm. Trong Thieàn, göông xöa duï cho chaân nhö               Buddha is not holy, he can still radiate the light!" Phaät taùnh, tuy noù soi chieáu khaép khoâng gian thôøi       Coå Linh Thaàn Taùn Thieàn Sö: Zen master Ku-ling gian töï coå chí kim, nhöng töï noù khoâng coù yù nieäm       Tsan—See Thaàn Taùn Thieàn Sö. chieáu soi—Ancient mirror, symbolizes the mind.               Coå Luaän: Kinh luaän xöa—Old treatise. In Zen, ancient mirror implies Bhutatathata or                Coå Maät Phaùi: Nyingmapa (tib)—Ninh Maõ Phaùi— Buddha-nature, though it has the ability to light up          Tröôøng phaùi laâu ñôøi nhaát trong boán tröôøng phaùi from the ancient times up to now, but it contains             cuûa Taây Taïng. Tröôøng phaùi naøy cho raèng noù coù töø no concept of shining.                                        thôøi cuûa ngaøi Lieân Hoa Sanh, nhaø du giaø maø theo Coå Lai: From ancient times.                                  truyeàn thoáng Taây Taïng ñaõ giuùp thaønh laäp Phaät Coå Lai Thöïc Höõu Toâng: Belief in the reality of            giaùo Taây Taïng vaøo theá kyû thöù 8. teân cuûa tröôøng both past and future—Khöù Lai Thöïc Höõu Toâng—               phaùi naøy döïa treân söï kieän laø tröôøng phaùi döïa vaøo Moät trong möôøi saùu toâng phaùi ngoaïi ñaïo chaáp raèng     nhöõng baûn cöïu dòch coù töø thôøi cuoäc truyeàn baù Phaät quaù khöù vò lai vaø hieän ñeàu laø thöïc höõu —One of        giaùo Taây Taïng laàn thöù nhaát. Tu taäp thieàn cao nhaát the sixteen heretical sects, which believed in the            cuûa tröôøng phaùi laø “Dzogchen” hay laø “Ñaïi Ba La reality of past and future as well as present.                Maät,” vaø tröôøng phaùi coù lieân heä thaät maät thieát vôùi Coå Leã: Ancient rites.                                       tröôøng phaùi “AÅn Taïng.” Nyingmapa tin raèng nhöõng Coå Leä: Ancient customs.                                     kinh vaên cuûa tröôøng phaùi “AÅn Taïng” ñaõ ñöôïc daáu Coå Linh Khai Boái: Coâng aùn veà Coå Linh Voã                ñi bôûi ngaøi Lieân Hoa Sanh vaø nhöõng ñeä töû cuûa Löng—The koan on Ku-ling's clapping on the                    ngaøi, hoï ñaõ caát giaáu nhöõng phaùp chuù vaøo nôi maø back—Sau khi ngoä ñaïo vôùi Toå Baùch Tröôïng,                hoï tin raèng ñuùng thôøi seõ coù ngöôøi tìm ra. Nguoàn Thieàn sö Coå Linh beøn trôû veà boån töï, nôi Sö thí         chính khaùc cuûa tröôøng phaùi Nyingmapa laø giaùo phaùt vôùi vò "thuï nghieäp sö", vò thaày ñaõ daïy Sö töø     phaùp vaø söï tu taäp cuûa hoï laø giaùo phaùp truyeàn thöøa, hoài nhoû vaø khi ñoù ñaõ giaø laém roài. Tuy nhieân, vò      maø ngöôøi ta tin raèng noù tieâu bieåu cho söï truyeàn boån sö naøy chöa thaáu ñaïo, nhöng laïi raát kieâu ngaïo     thöøa khoâng ñöùt ñoaïn töø thôøi Phaät toå. Khoâng gioáng vaø khoâng muoán nghe lôøi khuyeân cuûa ñeä töû, vì nghó      nhö nhöõng tröôøng phaùi khaùc ôû Taây Taïng, tröôøng raèng ñeä töû laøm sao hôn thaày ñöôïc. Vì theá ngaøi         phaùi Nyingmapa khoâng phaùt trieån laõnh ñaïo trung muoán tìm caùch caûnh tænh boån sö. Moät hoâm, Sö kyø         öông hay toå chöùc ñaúng caáp, vaø thöôøng traùnh quan coï cho thaày khi taém. Sö beøn voã löng thaày noùi:          heä ñeán chính trò—The oldest of the four orders of "Thaät laø moät ñieän Phaät ñeïp, maø trong ñoù laïi chaúng   Tibetan Buddhism. It traces itself back to

Padmasambhava, the yogin who according to                   vöôøn sau." Ñoái nhöõng ngöôøi tu taäp Thieàn thì lôøi Tibetan tradition helped to establish Buddhism in           tuyeân boá cuûa Thieàn sö Nham Ñaàu mang ñaày yù Tibet in the eighth century. Its name is based upon         nghóa. Neáu chuùng ta thaät söï thöïc chöùng ñöôïc traïng the fact that its adherents rely on the “old                thaùi taâm cuûa Nham Ñaàu luùc ngaøi traû lôøi caâu hoûi, laø translations,” made during the period of the “first         chuùng ñaõ böôùc ñöôïc vaøo caùnh cöûa ñaàu tieân trong dissemination” of Buddhism to Tibet. Its highest            caûnh giôùi Thieàn. Vaøo luùc ñoù, haønh giaû tu Thieàn seõ meditative practice is “Dzogchen” or “great                 thaáy raèng khoâng caàn phaûi hoûi veà caùnh buoàm xöa perfection,” and it is the order most closely               chöa treo maø cuõng coù theå laø baát kyø moät vaät gì associated with the “hidden treasure” (Gter Ma)             trong theá giôùi sai bieät muoân hình vaïn traïng naøy. tradition. The texts of the “hidden treasure”               Beân trong caùnh buoàm xöa chöa treo, chuùng ta nhìn tradition are believed by Nyingmapa to have been            thaáy ñöôïc taát caû khaû naêng toàn taïi, cuõng nhìn thaáy hidden by Padmasambhava and his disciples, who              ñöôïc taát caû khaû naêng kinh nghieäm. Ñuùng nhö trieát placed spells on them to ensure that they would             hoïc Hoa Nghieâm daïy: "Moät dung nhieáp taát caû, taát only be discovered at the proper time and by the            caû dung nhieáp moät. Moät laø taát caû, taá caû laø moät. proper “treasure discoverer” (Gter-ston). The               Moät thaâu nhieáp taát caû, taát caû thaâu nhaäp laøm moät. other main source of Nyingmapa doctrines and                Ñieàu naøy cuõng ñuùng vôùi moïi vaät theå, vôùi moïi söï practices is the “teaching lineage,” believed to            toàn taïi." Thaät vaäy, töø tröôùc ñeán nay chuùng ta chöa represent an unbroken line of transmission of the           töøng nghó raèng mình coù theå thoaùt ra khoûi söï giôùi dharma from the Buddha. Unlike the other orders             haïn cuûa trí tueä do töï mình aùp ñaët cho mình. Thaät of Tibetan Buddhism, it never developed a                   vaäy, tröø khi chuùng ta phaù vôõ söï ñoái laäp "ñuùng" vaø centralized leadership or organized hierarchy               "sai", neáu khoâng chuùng ta seõ khoâng hy voïng gì (ñaúng caáp), and generally avoided political               soáng ñöôïc cuoäc soáng töï do thaät söï. Vaø taâm hoàn involvements.                                               chuùng ta nhö cöù ñang gaøo theùt ñeán ñieàu naøy, queân Coå Ngaïn: Old proverb.                                     ñi raèng roát roài cuõng khoâng khoù khaên laém ñeå ñaït Coå Nghi: See Coå Taéc.                                     ñeán söï khaúng ñònh cao hôn, maø khoâng coù söï maâu Coå Nguyeät (1843-1919): Master Ku-Yue—Teân                 thuaãn phaân bieät giöõa phuû ñònh vaø khaúng ñònh. Nhôø cuûa moät vò Thieàn sö toâng Taøo Ñoäng Trung Hoa ôû        Thieàn maø söï khaúng ñònh cao hôn naøy cuoái cuøng Phuùc Kieán vaøo theá kyû thöù XIX—Name of a                ñöôïc ñaït ñeán qua phöông tieän laø "caùnh buoàm xöa Chinese Ts'ao-tung Zen master in Fu-jian                    chöa treo" trong tay cuûa moät vò Thieàn sö— Province in the nineteenth century.                         According to Wudeng Huiyuan, volume VII, one Coå Ngöõ: Ancient language.                                 day a monks asked Zen master Yen T'ou, "What Coå Nhaïc Huyeàn Ca: Troáng nhaïc vaø ca vôùi ñaøn          happens when an old sail has not yet been daây—Drum music and singing with stringed                   hoisted?" Yen T'ou said, "Big fishes eat small instruments.                                                fishes." Another monk also asked the same Coå Nhaân: The ancients.                                    question. Yen T'ou said, "A donkey is gnawing Coå Nieäm (1842-1916): Master Ku-Nien—Teân cuûa             grass in the back yard." To Zen practitioners this moät vò Thieàn sö toâng Laâm Teá Trung Hoa ôû Hoà Baéc      declaration by Zen master Yen T'ou is vaøo theá kyû thöù XIX—Name of a Chinese Lin-chi            meaningful. Let us really realize the state of his Zen master in Hu-bei Province in the nineteenth             mind in which he proposed his answers, and we century.                                                    have attained our first entrance into the realm of Coå Phaøm Vò Quaûi: Coâng aùn veà Caùnh Buoàm Xöa           Zen. At that time, Zen practitioners will see that it Chöa Treo Leân—The koan of "an old sail not yet             goes without saying that this old sail not yet been been hoisted"—Theo Nguõ Ñaêng Hoäi Nguyeân,                 hoisted thus brought forward can be any one of quyeån VII, moät hoâm coù moät vò Taêng hoûi Thieàn sö      myriads of things existing in this world of Nham Ñaàu: "Khi caùnh buoàm xöa chöa tröông leân            particulars. In this old sail we find all possible thì caùi gì xaûy ra?" Nham Ñaàu noùi: "Caù lôùn nuoát caù   existences and also all our possible experiences beù." Moät vò Taêng khaùc cuõng hoûi caâu hoûi ñoù thì      concentrated. As the Avatamsaka philosophy Thieàn sö Nham Ñaàu laïi traû lôøi: "Löøa ñang gaëm coû     teaches: "The One embraces All, and All is

merged in the One. The One is All, and All is the              nguoàn töø truyeàn thoáng Trung Ñaïo beân AÁn Ñoä— One. The One pervades All, and All is in the One.              Madhyamika school of Nagarjuna, or the This is so with every object, with every                       Mahayanistic Negativism, called Madhyamika in existence." In fact, it has never occured to us that           Sanskrit. The doctrine of the Middle Path, or it is possible for us to escape this self-imposed              Sunyatavada, the “Theory of Negativity” or intellectual limitation. Indeed, unless we break               “Relativity.” The school was based on the three through the antithesis of "yes" and "no" we can                main sastras, Madhyamika-Sastra or Middle Path, never hope to live a real life of freedom. And the             Dvadasa-dvara-Sastra or the Twelve Gates, and soul has always been crying for it, forgetting that it         the Sata-Sastra or the One Hundred Verse is not after all so very difficult to reach a higher           Treatise. In China, Kumarajiva is also credited form of affirmation, where no contradicting                    with establishing the San Lun school, which is distinctions obtain between negation and                       derived from the Indian Madhyamaka tradition. assertion. It is due to Zen that this higher form of           Coå Taéc: Lôøi daïy cuûa caùc baäc coå ñöùc, bao goàm affirmation has finally been reached by means of               nhöõng lôøi daïy cuûa chö Phaät vaø chö toå cuõng nhö caùc "an old sail that has not yet hoisted" in the hand of          coâng aùn ngoä ñaïo cuûa caùc thieàn sö—Virtuous a Zen master.                                                  ancients' teachings, including the teachings of Coå Phaät: Kobutsu (jap)—Phaät quaù khöù—Ancient               Buddhas, patriarchs, and other masters' Buddhas—Phaät quaù khöù; trong thieàn töø naày ñöôïc           enlightened koans. duøng ñeå chæ taâm cuûa moät vò thieàn sö ñaõ ñaït ñöôïc       Coå Taéc Coâng AÙn: See Coå Taéc. ñaïi giaùc saâu—An ancient Buddha or a Buddha of               Coå Thanh Quy: 1) Töï taùnh: Self-nature; 2) See an earlier world age. In Zen, the term is used for             Baùch Tröôïng Thanh Quy. the mind of a profoundly enlightened Zen master.               Coå Thi: Ancient poetry. Coå Phaät Kim Phaät: Kobutsu-Konbutsu (jap)—                   Coå Thieân: Troáng trôøi hay tieáng seùt—The drum- Phaät quaù khöù vaø Phaät hieän taïi—Ancient Buddhas           deva, thunder. and present Buddhas.                                           Coå Thoaïi: Coâng aùn thôøi coå ñaïi—Ancient koans— Coå Phaät Taâm: Kobusshin (jap)—"Taâm cuûa moät vò             See Coâng AÙn. coå Phaät" laø thuaät ngöõ toân troïng duøng ñeå chæ taâm      Coå Thö: Ancient book. cuûa moät vò thieàn sö ñaõ ñaït ñöôïc ñaïi giaùc saâu—         Coå Tieân AÁn Nguyeân (1295-1374): Teân cuûa moät vò "Old Buddha's mind"; deferential term for the                  Thieàn sö Nhaät Baûn doøng Laâm Teá, queâ ôû Satsuma mind of a profoundly enlightened Zen master.                   (Kagoshima)—Name of a Japanese Zen master, Coå Quy: See Coå Thanh Quy.                                    of the Lin-chi lineage. He came from Satsuma Coå Sô: Ancient times.                                         (Kagoshima), Japan. Coå Sôn Nguyeân Hieàn: Ku-Shan-Yuan-Hsien                      Coå Toân Tuùc Ngöõ Luïc: Records of Teachings of (chi)—Teân cuûa moät thieàn sö Trung Hoa vaøo thôøi            Ancient Honoured Monks nhaø Thanh (1644-1912)—Name of a Chinese Zen                   Coác Chaán Tích: Ma-Ku's carrying his ring-staff, master during the Ch'ing dynasty.                              circling the meditation seat three times—See Ma Coå Tam Luaän: Ku San Lun (chi)—Old                            Coác Thuû Tröôïng Nhieãu Thieàn Saøng. Madhyamika School—Tam Luaän Toâng chuû tröông                  Coác Ñaàu: See Khaùn Löông. “Ñaïi Thöøa Phuû Ñònh Luaän.” Tieáng Phaïn goïi laø            Coác Tuyeàn Thieàn Sö: Zen master Ku-Chuan— Madhyamika, chuû tröông hoïc thuyeát Trung Ñaïo,               Teân cuûa moät vò Thieàn sö Trung Hoa doøng Laâm Teá Khoâng Luaän, hay Töông Ñoái Luaän. Tam Luaän                  vaøo thôøi nhaø Ñöôøng—Name of a Chinese Zen Toâng döïa vaøo ba boä luaän ñöôïc Ngaøi Long Thoï vaø         master, of the Lin-chi lineage, in the T'ang ñeä töû cuûa ngaøi laø Ñeà Baø bieân soaïn. Ba boä luaän aáy   dynasty (618-907). laø Trung Quaùn Luaän, Thaäp Nhò Moân Luaän, vaø               Coäi Goác Sanh Töû: Sources of birth and death—Sö Baùch Luaän (see Trung Quaùn Luaän, Thaäp Nhò Moân             Goshu ñeán gaëp thieàn sö Yui-e vaø noùi: "Toâi ñaõ hoïc Luaän, and Baùch Luaän). Taïi Trung Hoa, ngöôøi ta             thieàn nhieàu naêm, nhöng khoâng coù keát quaû. Xin cuõng cho raèng Cöu Ma La Thaäp chính laø ngöôøi               ngaøi chæ daïy." Thieàn sö Yui-e noùi: "Ñaïo thieàn voán saùng laäp ra Tam Luaän Toâng, moät toâng phaùi baét           khoâng coù gì bí maät caû. Chæ laø vaán ñeà thoaùt ly sanh

töû maø thoâi." Goshu hoûi: "Laøm caùch naøo thoaùt ly         savage man chews raw iron, i.e., a state of no sanh töû?" Thieàn sö Yiu-e cao gioïng ñaùp: "Moãi              discriminations from deluded thoughts. Zen nieäm sanh dieät cuûa oâng laø coäi goác sanh töû." Vôùi       practice at K'un-Lun Mountain repeatedly nhöõng lôøi naøy, Goshu ñi vaøo thaâm ñònh, caûm thaáy         appealed to the strict Zen of the great Chinese nhö mình vöøa truùt moät gaùnh naëng vaäy—Goshu                master, Hsu-T'ang. Zen practitioners at K’un-Lun came to Zen master Yui-e and said, "I have been                either practiced hard or chewed the whole iron studying Zen for many years, but have not yet                  bar. One day, a monk asked Zen master Hsu-t'ang, succeeded. Please give me some guidance." Yui-e                "Does secret transmission here on this sacred said, "There is no secret trick to Zen study. It's just        mountain allow students to ask for clarification?" a matter of freedom from birth and death." Goshu               Zen master Hsu-T'ang replied, "Chew the whole asked, "How does one pass through birth and                    iron bar." Zen practitioners should always death to freedom?" Raising his voice, Yui-e said,              remember that meaningless argument means "Your every passing thought is birth and death!"               frivolous or unreal discourse or talking vainly or At these words Goshu went into ecstasy, feeling                idly. In Buddhism, meaningless arguments are as if he had put down a heavy burden.                          hindrances on spiritual progress. Coân: Coân truøng—Insects—Creeping things.                     Coân Sôn: Coân Loân: Dvipatala (skt)—Ñaûo Coân Loân trong                1) Teân khaùc cuûa chuøa Thieân Tö Phuùc, chuøa toïa bieån Nam Haûi—Condre island in the South China                     laïc taïi thoân Chí Ngaïi, huyeän Chí Linh, tænh Sea.                                                                Haûi Höng, Baéc Vieät Nam—Another name Coân Loân Quoác: Dvipatala (skt)—Ñöôïc dieãn taû                    Thieân Tö Phuùc Temple, located in Chí Ngaïi nhö laø teân nöôùc cuûa moät nhoùm ngöôøi da ñen treân              village, Chí Linh district, Haûi Höng province, ñaûo Gia Va vaø Su Ma Tra (baây giôø thuoäc Nam                     North Vietnam. Döông)—A native of those islands of black colour,              2) See Coân Loân Sôn. and is described as Java, Sumatra, etc.                        Coân Truøng Taùc Phaät: Theo Ñaïi Trí Ñoä Luaän, Coân Loân Sôn: Nuùi Coân Luaân hay Höông Sôn,                  ngay caû coân truøng cuõng coù theå laøm Phaät ñöôïc — naèm veà phía baéc nuùi Tuyeát Sôn cuûa Taây Taïng—            Accoding to the Maha-Prajna-Paramita Sastra, The K’un-Lun mountain range north of Tibet, the                even insects may attain Buddhahood. Gandhamadana.                                                  Coâng: 1) Coâng Coäng: General, public; 2) Chính Coân Luaân:                                                    Thöùc: Official; 3) OÂng (ngoaïi hay noäi): 1) Teân nöôùc thôøi coå: Dvipatala (skt)—Name of               Grandfather; 4) OÂng (caùch goïi toân quyù): Ko an ancient country—See Coân Loân Quoác.                  (jap)—Gentlemen, an honorific used for both 2) Traïng thaùi hoån ñoän: Hoàn Loân—Confused                  monks and laymen. state—Chaotic state.                                     Coâng AÙn: Koan (jap)—Kung-an (chi). Coân Luaân Töôùc Sinh Thieát: To swallow the                   (I) Toång quan veà coâng aùn—An overview of whole hot bar—Thaèng moïi nhai saét soáng, chæ cho                  Koans: Coâng aùn Thieàn cuõng coøn goïi laø "Caùt traïng thaùi khoâng coøn phaân bieät töø voïng töôûng nöõa.         ñaèng", theo nghóa ñen laø "giaây saén giaây bìm, Thieàn taäp taïi nuùi Coân Luaân döïa vaøo tính nghieâm             giaây mô reã maù" moïc quaán quít vaøo nhau ngaët cuûa thöù thieàn do ñaïi thieàn sö Trung Hoa naày             khoâng gôõ noåi, vì vaäy caùc thieàn sö noåi tieáng thöïc haønh. Haønh giaû tu Thieàn treân nuùi Coân Luaân             cho raèng ngay trong baûn chaát Thieàn khoâng coù hoaëc laø tu taäp nghieâm nhaët, hoaëc laø muoát troïn thoûi        gì laø coâng aùn heát; ñoù chæ laø troø baøy ñaët laøm roái saét. Moät hoâm, coù moät vò Taêng hoûi Thieàn sö Hö                theâm söï vaät töï noù raát ñôn giaûn, vaø chaân lyù Ñöôøng: "Nhö söï trao truyeàn bí maät ôû Linh Sôn, coù              thieàn chaúng caàn ñeán coâng aùn. Ñoù laø veà phaàn cho ngöôøi hoïc thöa hoûi hay khoâng?" Thieàn sö Hö                 caùc thieàn sö noåi tieáng; tuy nhieân, ñoái vôùi Ñöôøng ñaùp: "Nhai nguyeân thoûi saét." Haønh giaû tu               ngöôøi tu thieàn cuõng caàn phaûi bieát veà coâng aùn Thieàn neân luoân nhôù raèng ngoân luaän phi lyù voâ nghóa          treân ñöôøng tu taäp. Coâng aùn laø moät ñeà taøi cho hay noùi chuyeän voâ boå khoâng ñaâu vaøo ñaâu. Trong               caùc ñeä töû suy nghó vaø quaùn chieáu trong thieàn ñaïo Phaät, hyù luaän laø nhöõng phieàn naõo chöôùng hay            quaùn trong caùc thieàn ñöôøng phaùi Laâm Teá. Luùc nhöõng chöôùng ngaïi treân tieán trình taâm thöùc —A                ñaàu, coâng aùn laø moät “yeát thò coâng khai,” coù

nghóa laø “coù tröôùc veà maët coâng lyù.” Veà sau        “public notice,” means a legal case naày coâng aùn ñöôïc nhaø Thieàn söû duïng moät           constituting a precedent. Later, koans have caùch coù heä thoáng nhö nhöõng phöông tieän ñaøo         been used in Zen as a systematic means of taïo töø khoaûng giöõa theá kyû thöù möôøi baèng caùch    training since around the middle of the tenth traùnh taát caû nhöõng lôøi giaûi thích duy lyù. Coâng    century. Since the koan eludes solutions by aùn cho pheùp ñeä töû thaáy roõ nhöõng giôùi haïn cuûa    means of discursive understanding, it makes trí tueä vaø buoäc phaûi vöôït leân nhöõng giôùi haïn     clear to the student the limitations of thought aáy baèng tröïc giaùc chöù khoâng baèng duy lyù, laø      and eventually forces him to transcend it in an thöù ñöa anh ta vaøo moät vuõ truï naèm beân ngoaøi       intuitive leap (not by speaking or discussion), moïi maâu thuaãn vaø moïi tö töôûng nhò nguyeân.          which takes him into a world beyond logical Söï phaùt khôûi naày cho pheùp ngöôøi ñeä töû trình       contradictions and dualistic modes of thought. baøy vôùi thaày moät caùch töï phaùt vaø khoâng caàn      On the basis of this experience, the student tôùi söï giuùp ñôû töø beân ngoaøi. Haønh giaû tu Thieàn  can demonstrate his own solution of the koan neân luoân nhôù raèng ñoái töôïng cuûa toïa thieàn        to the master in a spontaneous and without trong ñôøi soáng cuûa haønh giaû laø ñeå khai môû maét    recourse to preconceived notions. Zen trí hueä. Nhö chuùng ta ñoïc trong kinh Baùt Nhaõ         practitioners should always remember that the Ba La Maät Ña, khoâng coù trí hueä thì taát caû caùc      object of meditation in the life of Zen ñöùc haïnh kia ñeàu khoâng thaønh töïu ñöôïc gì caû,      practitioners is to open the wisdom eye. As bôûi vì chuùng thieáu con maét ñeå nhìn vaøo yù           we read in the Prajna-paramita Sutra, without nghóa cuûa söï vaät moät caùch phoå quaùt. Do ñoù,        the wisdom all the other virtues are incapable moät haønh giaû phaûi baèng moïi caùch goät röûa taát     of accomplishing anything, for they lack the caû nhöõng caùu baån baèng coâng aùn, töùc laø moät       eye which sees into the meaning of things vaán ñeà ñeå giaûi ñaùp. Moät khi ngöôøi ta giaûi ñaùp    generally. Therefore, a Zen practitioner must ñöôïc coâng aùn cuûa mình, moät coâng aùn nöõa laïi       by all means have the scale cleared off by ñöôïc giao cho maõi ñeán khi naøo vò thaày hoaøn          means of the koan, which is a kind of question toaøn thoûa maõn vôùi söï laõnh hoäi cuûa ngöôøi ñeä töû. given him for solution. When one koan is Coù nhieàu caâu hoûi nhö vaäy ñeå söû duïng trong         successfully solved, another is given until the muïc ñích naøy. Kyø thaät, khi ngöôøi ta hieåu ñöôïc      master is thoroughly satisfied with the moät coâng aùn moät caùch saâu saéc, taát caû nhöõng      understanding of his student. There is a large coâng aùn coøn laïi khoâng laø nhöõng trôû ngaïi lôùn     number of such questions available for the lao gì trong söï thaønh töïu thieàn toái haäu—Koans       purpose. But in fact when one koan is grasped are sometimes called 'complications', literally           in a most penetrating manner, all the meaning 'vines and wistarias' which are                   remaining ones present no substantial entwining and entangling, for according to the            hindrances to the final Zen realization. masters there ought not to be any such thing (II) Nguoàn goác cuûa töø "Coâng AÙn"—The origin of as a koan in the very nature of Zen, it was an            the term "Koan": Coâng aùn voán chæ cho vieäc unnecessary invention making things more                  xeùt xöû ôû phuû quan, moät böùc coâng vaên ñaët leân entangled and complicated than ever before,               treân aùn thö, moät hoà sô ôû coâng ñöôøng, hay moät and the truth of Zen has no need for koans.               tröôøng hôïp thieát laäp moät tieàn leä hôïp phaùp, moät These are famous Zen masters' considerations              thuaät ngöõ coù töø ñôøi nhaø Ñöôøng. Nhöng thuaät on koans; however, Zen practitioners still                ngöõ naøy ñöôïc caùc Thieàn gia söû duïng moät caùch need to know about koans on their path of                 hoâi khaùc ôû choã noù chæ moät cuoäc ñoái thoaïi hoaëc cultivation. Something to be pondered on                  moät bieán coá naøo ñoù xaûy ra giöõa Thieàn sö vaø during meditation by novices in Zen                       ñeä töû cuûa ngaøi. Ngaøy nay, coâng aùn chæ nhöõng monasteries of the Lin-Chi school. Problems               giai thoaïi cuûa moät baäc coå ñöùc naøo ñoù, hoaëc set by Zen masters, upon which thought is                 moät cuoäc ñoái thoaïi giöõa moät baäc Thaày vôùi concentrated as a means to attain inner unity             Taêng chuùng, hoaëc lôøi noùi hay caâu hoûi cuûa moät and illumination. Originally, koan means                  baäc Thaày khi thöôïng ñöôøng thuyeát phaùp, taát

caû ñeàu ñöôïc duøng nhö phöông tieän khai môû            1) Moät tröôøng hôïp thieát laäp moät tieàn leä hôïp phaùp: cho taâm trí cuûa haønh giaû ñeán vôùi chaân lyù             A case which established a legal precedent. Thieàn. Toùm laïi, coâng aùn laø moät caâu chuyeän        2) Söï theå hieän cuûa Phaùp, ñoù laø hieän thöïc cuûa vuõ Thieàn, moät hoaøn caûnh veà Thieàn, hay moät vaán           truï: The concrete manifestation of Dharma, ñeà veà Thieàn. Dó nhieân, luùc ñaàu hoaøn toaøn             that is reality or the Universe itself. khoâng coù coâng aùn nhö chuùng ta bieát ngaøy nay;       3) Moät caâu chuyeän theå hieän nhöõng nguyeân taéc noù chæ laø moät loaïi coâng cuï nhaân taïo cuûa nhöõng      caên baûn cuûa Phaät Phaùp: A story which vò Thieàn sö sau naøy nhaèm ñeå laïi toaøn boä               manifests the universal principles of the nhöõng ñieàu quan troïng cuûa toâng moân, ñeå soi            Buddha-Dharma. saùng cho nhöõng ñeä töû keùm coõi cuûa mình—             4) Trong nhaø Thieàn, coâng aùn laø moät ñònh thöùc, Koan is a public document, a document of an                  baèng ngoân ngöõ ñaùnh löøa, chæ thaúng chaân lyù toái official transaction on the desk, an                         haäu. Coâng aùn khoâng theå ñöôïc giaûi ñaùp baèng authoritative statue, or a case which                        caùch söû duïng lyù luaän hôïp lyù, maø chæ baèng caùch established a legal precedenta term coming                   laøm taâm giaùc ngoä ñeán moät möùc saâu hôn, cuõng from the T'ang dynasty. But the term is used                 nhö vöôït qua lyù trí bieän bieät: In Zen a koan is by Zen Buddhism in a slightly different                      a formulation, in baffling language, pointing manner in that it denotes a certain dialogue or              to the ultimate truth. Koans cannot be solved event that has taken place between a Zen                     by recourse to logical reasoning, but only by Master and his student. It now denotes some                  awakening a deeper level of the mind beyond anecdote of a certain ancient master, or a                   the discursive intellect. dialogue between a master and monks, or a                 5) Coâng aùn laø moät ñeà muïc trieát lyù do moät vò statement or question put forward by a                       Thieàn sö ñöa cho moät vò Thieàn sinh môùi nhaäp teacher, all of which are used as the means                  moân ñeå quaùn töôûng. Ñaây laø moät phöông phaùp for opening one's mind to the truth of Zen. In               thoâng thöôøng trong nhaø Thieàn nhaèm giuùp caùc short, koan means a Zen story, or a Zen                      Thieàn sinh môùi giaûm bôùt söï chaáp tröôùc: Koan situation, or a Zen problem. In the beginning,               is a philosophical topic given to a Zen student of course, there was no koan as we                           for contemplation by the Zen master. This is a understand it now; it is a kind of artificial                common method in Zen which helps the instrument devised out of the fullness of heart              novice Zen students lessen his attachments. by later Zen masters, who by this means                   6) Coâng aùn laø moät töø ngöõ Nhaät Baûn chæ “nhöõng would force the evolution of Zen                             tröôøng hôïp aån ngöõ,” maø chuû yù khoâng theå nhaän consciousness in the minds of their less                     bieát baèng khaùi nieäm hay phaân tích baèng suy endowed disciples.                                           nghó ñöôïc. Coâng aùn ñöôïc ñeà ra cho ngöôøi hoïc (III) Ñònh nghóa veà coâng aùn—Definition of Koans:                laø ñeå daãn tôùi taâm traïng caêng thaúng cöïc ñoä, vaø Coâng aùn ñöôïc hình thaønh töø caùc cuoäc vaán ñaùp         giaûi ñaùp cuûa noù ñoøi hoûi haønh giaû phaûi tröïc giöõa thaày troø ngaøy xöa, töø nhöõng ñoaïn vaên            nhaän thöïc chaát cuûa vaïn höõu. Coâng aùn ñöôïc trong caùc baøi thuyeát phaùp hay caùc baøi giaûng           duøng trong Thieàn, ñaëc bieät laø trong caùc Thieàn cuûa caùc vò thaày, hoaëc töø nhöõng caâu kinh vaø           phaùi Laâm Teá. “Koan” laø thuaät ngöõ Nhaät Baûn, caùc lôøi daïy khaùc. Coâng aùn cuõng coù nghóa laø          coù nghóa laø moät thöù vaán ñeà maø vò thaày ñeà ra "chuyeän" hay "bieán coá". Beân caïnh ñoù, coâng aùn         cho ngöôøi ñeä töû giaûi quyeát. Tuy nhieân, “vaán aùn vaãn coøn moät vaøi nghóa khaùc nöõa —Koans              ñeà” khoâng phaûi laø chöõ ñuùng vì khoâng coù töø are constructed from the questions of disciples              Anh ngöõ naøo töông ñöông vôùi töø naøy. Theo töø together with responses from their masters,                  ngöõ Nhaät Baûn, “Ko” nguyeân nghóa laø “coâng,” from portions of the masters’ sermons or                     vaø “an” laø “moät vaên kieän.” Nhöng “moät vaên discourses, from lines of the sutras, and from               kieän” thì khoâng aên nhaäp gì vôùi Thieàn caû. Caùi other teachings. Koan also means "story" or                  “vaên kieän” Thieàn laø caùi “vaên kieän” maø moãi "event". Besides, koan still have some other                 ngöôøi chuùng ta ñem theo ñeán theá giôùi naøy khi meanings:                                                    mình sanh ra vaø coá ñoïc ra tröôùc khi mình cheát

ñi. Theo truyeàn thuyeát Ñaïi Thöøa, ngöôøi ta baûo      read, and those who read it successfully are Ñöùc Phaät ñaõ thoát ra moät caâu sau ñaây khi Ngaøi     the followers of Zen. There is, however, no ra khoûi thaân theå cuûa baø meï: “Thieân thöôïng        secrecy in this, as it is all open or “public” to thieân haï, duy ngaõ ñoäc toân.” Ñoù laø vaên kieän      us, to everyone of us; and to those who have cuûa Ñöùc Phaät ñeå laïi cho chuùng ta ñoïc, vaø         an eye to see the utterance it presents no nhöõng ai ñoïc ñöôïc noù töùc laø nhöõng ñeä töû nhaø    difficulty. If there is any hidden meaning in it Thieàn vaäy. Tuy nhieân, khoâng coù gì bí aån trong      at all, it is our side and not in “the document.” caâu noùi naøy, vì taát caû noù khai môû hay “coâng      The koan is within ourselves, and what the khai” tröôùc chuùng ta, tröôùc moãi ngöôøi chuùng        Zen master does is no more than to point it ta; vaø ñoái vôùi nhöõng ai coù maét ñeå thaáy lôøi thoá out for us so that we can see it more plainly loä aáy chaúng ñeà ra khoù khaên naøo caû. Neáu coù      than before. When the koan is brought out of moät yù nghóa aån daáu naøo trong noù, laø ôû phía       the unconscious to the field of consciousness, chuùng ta chöù khoâng phaûi töø “vaên kieän.” Coâng      it is said to have been understood by us. To aùn ôû trong chuùng ta, vaø Thieàn sö chaúng laøm gì     effect this awakening, the koan sometimes khaùc hôn laø chæ noù ra cho chuùng ta thaáy roõ hôn     takes a dialectical form but frequently tröôùc. Khi coâng aùn ñöôïc ñem ra khoûi voâ thöùc       assumes, superficially at least, an entirely vaøo phaïm vi cuûa yù thöùc, thì chuùng ta noùi laø      nonsensical form. chuùng ta hieåu noù. Ñeå thöïc hieän söï thöùc tænh (IV) Muïc ñích cuûa tu taäp Thieàn theo coâng aùn—The naøy, coâng aùn ñoâi khi mang hình thöùc bieän           aim of the koan in practicing Zen: Caùc coâng chöùng nhöng thöôøng thì, ít ra laø moät caùch bieåu     aùn laø caùch dieãn ñaït tröïc tieáp söï theå nghieäm hieän beân ngoaøi, noù mang moät hình thöùc hoaøn        cuûa caùc thieàn sö ngaøy xöa, moät söï theå nghieäm toaøn phi lyù—A Japanese term "Koan" or                  khoâng theå nhaän ra, khoâng theå hieåu ñöôïc theo "Koungan" for enigmatic or problem cases                 loái duy lyù. Baûn chaát cuûa coâng aùn laø döïa vaøo whose purport cannot be discerned by                     nghòch lyù, nghóa laø döïa vaøo nhöõng gì vöôït ra conceptual and analytical thinking. The koan             ngoaøi khaùi nieäm (hay ôû beân kia caùi coù theå is given to the student first of all to bring            nhaän ra ñöôïc). Vì vaäy, caùc vaên baûn coâng aùn about a highly wrought-up state of                       thuoäc veà nhöõng vaên baûn khoù dòch nhaát trong consciousness, and its solution requires that            toaøn boä vaên hoïc theá giôùi. Ngay caû nhöõng ai ñaõ practitioners directly and intuitively perceive          ñaït ñöôïc möùc ñoä thoâng thaïo naøo ñoù veà Hoa the true nature of reality. They are commonly            ngöõ hay Nhaät ngöõ vaãn chöa theå cung caáp moät used in Zen, especially in Lin-Chi Zen sects.            baûn dòch thích hôïp cuûa caùc coâng aùn, nghóa laø “Koan” is originated from Japanese language,             moät baûn vaên coù theå ñöôïc duøng trong vieäc tu which means a kind of problem, which is                  taäp thieàn neáu mình khoâng coù söï theå nghieäm given the master to his disciples to solve.              thieàn saâu saéc. Trong nhaø Thieàn coâng aùn laø moät “Problem” is not a good term, however, for               ñònh thöùc, baèng ngoân ngöõ ñaùnh löøa, chæ thaúng there is no other equivalent term for such               chaân lyù toái haäu. Coâng aùn khoâng theå ñöôïc giaûi term in English. According to Japanese term,             ñaùp baèng caùch söû duïng lyù luaän hôïp lyù, maø chæ “Ko” literally means “public” and “an” is “a             baèng caùch laøm taâm giaùc ngoä ñeán moät möùc saâu document.” But “a public document” has                   hôn, cuõng nhö vöôït qua lyù trí bieän bieät. Moät vò nothing to do with Zen. The Zen “document”               Thieàn sinh neân luoân chuyeân chuù vaøo coâng aùn is the one each one of us brings along to this           vaø coá gaéng naém ñöôïc chaân lyù trong ñoù neáu coù. world at his birth and tries to decipher before          Muïc ñích cuûa coâng aùn chính laø laøm cho moät vò he passes away. According to Mahayana                    Thieàn sinh tham cöùu moät caùch caån thaän. Moät legend, the Buddha is said to have made the              vò Thieàn sinh phaûi duøng thaùi ñoä tham cöùu naøy following utterance when he came out of his              laøm cho tinh thaàn haêng haùi vaø phaán chaán theâm mother’s body: “Heaven above, earth below, I             tôùi choã khoâng coøn söï löïa choïn naøo khaùc hôn laø alone am the most honored one.” This was                 phaûi nhaûy qua khoûi noù. Söï töø boû caùi chaáp Buddha’s “document” bequeathed to us to                  tröôùc cuoái cuøng naøy seõ mang vò Thieàn sinh

ñeán vôùi toaøn caûnh cuûa caùi goïi laø "baûn lai dieän ngaøi Phaät Quang Quoác Sö ôû Trung Hoa vaø muïc cuûa chính mình"—Koans originated as an             Baïch AÅn ôû Nhaät Baûn cho nhöõng haønh giaû Loái immediate expression of the Zen realization              nhaän thöùc Thieàn bôûi nhöõng ngöôøi thuoäc heä of the ancient masters, realization that is not          thoáng khoâng duøng coâng aùn ñöôïc ñaïi dieän, conceptually graspable, not understandable.              theo taøi lieäu maø chuùng ta coù ñöôïc bôûi Laâm Teá Its nature is paradoxical, i.e., beyond concept.         ôû Trung Hoa vaø bôûi Baøn Khueâ Vónh Traùc ôû Thus, Zen texts are among the most difficult             Nhaät Baûn—The koan method of studying Zen to translate in world literature. Even for               started in China in the twelfth century with someone who has achieved perfect mastery                 the Sung masters, such as Goso Hoyen (died of Chinese or Japanese, it is just about                 in 1104), Yengo Kokugon (1063-1135), and impossible for one who does not have a                   Daiye       Soko       (1089-1163).        But     its profound realization of Zen to come up with              systematization took place in Japan soon after an appropriate translation, i.e., one usable for         the introduction of Zen in the thirteenth Zen training of a koan. In Zen a koan is a               century. In the beginning the koan was formulation, in baffling language, pointing to           classified under three headings: prajna- the ultimate truth. Koans cannot be solved by            intuitional (richi), actional (kikwan), and the recourse to logical reasoning, but only by               ultimate (kojo). Later, in the seventeenth awakening a deeper level of the mind beyond              century, Hakuin and his followers amplified the discursive intellect. A Zen student should           them into five or six, but in essence the older always dwell on the koan itself and endevour             three still hold good. Since, however, the to get at its truth if it has any. To force a Zen        schema was completed, all the Zen students student to assume this inquiring attitude is the         belonging to the Rinzai school nowadays aim of the koan. A Zen student must then go              study Zen after it, and the study is more or on with his inquiring attitude until he comes to         less stereotyped and to that extent shows the edge of a mental precipice, as it were,              signs of deterioration. The typical and where there are no other alternatives but to             classical examples of the koan students are leap over. This giving up his last hold on life          supplied by Bukko Kokushi (1226-1286) in will bring the student to a full view of a so-           China and by Hakuin (1685-1768) in Japan. called "his own original face".                          The approach to Zen by those of non-koan (V) Phöông phaùp nghieân cöùu Thieàn theo coâng              system is exemplified, as far as we have the aùn—The koan method of studying Zen:                     record, by Rinzai (died in 867) in China and Phöông phaùp nghieân cöùu Thieàn theo coâng aùn          by Bankei (1622-1693) in Japan. ôû Trung Hoa vaøo theá kyû thöù 12 vôùi caùc Thieàn (VI) Nhöõng ñaëc ñieåm cuûa coâng aùn— sö ñôøi nhaø Toáng, nhö ngaøi Nguõ toå Phaùp Dieãn,      Characteristics of koans: Vieân Ngoä Khaéc Caàn, vaø Ñaïi Hueä Toâng Caûo. 1) Nhieàu coâng aùn, ñoái töôïng cuûa nhöõng cuoäc vaán Nhöng söï heä thoáng hoùa cuûa noù xaûy ra ôû Nhaät      ñaùp giöõa thaày vaø troø, vaïch laïi nhöõng söï bieán Baûn ngay sau söï du nhaäp cuûa Thieàn vaøo theá         cuûa laàn 'ñoäc tham' trong quaù khöù. Theo truyeàn kyû thöù 13. Luùc ñaàu coâng aùn ñöôïc phaân loaïi vôùi  thoáng thieàn, vieäc duøng loái giaûng rieâng cho 3 tieâu ñeà: tröïc giaùc Baùt Nhaõ, hoaït ñoäng, vaø     töøng ngöôøi coù töø nhöõng baøi hoïc bí truyeàn cuûa cöùu caùnh. Sau naøy, vaøo theá kyû thöù 17 thì Baïch    chính ñöùc Phaät Thích Ca Maâu Ni; caùch naày AÅn vaø caùc ñoà ñeä laøm lôùn theâm thaønh naêm hay     hieän vaãn coøn ñöôïc giöõ trong caùc phaùi Thieàn, saùu tieâu ñeà, nhöng coát loõi ba tieâu ñeà cuõ vaãn    caùch laøm naày ñaõ bieán maát trong phaùi Taøo coøn coù giaù trò. Tuy nhieân, töø khi bieåu thöùc       Ñoäng, nhöng vaãn coøn trong phaùi Laâm Teá— hoaøn thaønh, taát caû haønh giaû thuoäc toâng Laâm      Many koans have as their content, mondo Teá ngaøy nay ñeàu nghieân cöùu Thieàn theo noù,         (questions and answers) between master and vaø vieäc nghieân cöùu khoâng nhieàu thì ít bò ñoùng     student and thus give us information about khuoân ñeán möùc ñaõ coù daáu hieäu suy ñoài.            dokusans in the past. The practice of giving Nhöõng thí duï tieâu bieåu vaø coå ñieån ñaõ ñöôïc       indicidual instruction in this manner began,

according to Zen tradition, with the secret            thöïc. Vaø vì ñoù khoâng phaûi laø moät taâm thaùi giaû teachings of Sakyamuni Buddha and has been             taïo, chuùng ta goïi noù laø "chaân thaønh." Trong tu preserved in this school of the Buddha-mind            taäp Thieàn, neáu khoâng coù caùi taâm chaân thaønh ever since. Although it was formerly                   ñoù, khoâng theå naøo thaáu nhaäp vaø hieåu ñöôïc — customary in all Zen lineages, the practice has        The Third Patriarch Seng-Ts’an (Sosan) nearly died out today in the Soto school and is        entered the hall to preach the assembly: basically still only cultivated by the Rinzai          "Whenever one is studying a particular kung- school.                                                an, then if one does one's work with sincerity 2) Ngöôøi ñoïc caùc vaên baûn veà coâng aùn veà nhöõng    of mind, like a hen brooding on her eggs, like coâng aùn ñaùnh laïc höôùng ñöøng bao giôø queân       a cat watching a mouse, like a hungry person raèng nhöõng vaên baûn naøy, theo ñònh nghóa cuûa      thinking of food, like a thirsty person thinking chuùng, laø khoù hieåu, khoâng theå duøng trí tueä     of water, like a child longing for its mother, phaøm tuïc ñeå hieåu ñöôïc. Muïc ñích cuûa chuùng      then surely there will be a time when one will laø kích thích haønh giaû vöôït qua nhöõng giôùi haïn  penetrate and understand." In fact, the koan of cuûa lyù luaän vaø tö duy duy lyù. Haønh giaû neân     the patriarch consist of 1,700 cases, such as luoân nhôù raèng nhöõng lôøi giaûi veà coâng aùn ngay  "The dog has no Buddha-nature," "The pine caû nhöõng giaûi thích töï noù chieáu saùng, roõ raøng tree in front of the courtyard," "Three pounds laø sai laàm theo quan ñieåm Thieàn neáu chuùng        of flax," and "A dry shit-stick." When a hen ñöôïc tìm ra baèng caùch laäp luaän vaø dieãn dòch     broods on her eggs, the warmth continues maø baát cöù moät baäc thaày chaân chaùnh naøo ñeàu    without interruption. When a cat watches a deã daøng nhaän ra—The reader of Zen texts             mouse, its mind and eyes are fixed on their who finds koans strange or alienating, must            object. As for a hungry person thinking of always keep in mind that koans are by                  food, a thirsty person thinking of water, a definition ununderstandable, inaccessible to           child longing for its mother, all are done out the reasoning mind precisely because they              of genuineness of mind. Since this is not an are challenges to transcend logical-conceptual         artificially constructed state of mind, it is mind. Zen practitioners should always                  called "sincere." In studying Zen, without this remember that even in cases where                      sincerity of mind there is no such thing as illuminating interpretations of koans present          being able to break through and understand. themselves, from the standpoint of Zen they 4) Theo Thieàn Sö Linh Moäc Ñaïi Chuyeát Trinh are false if they are thought out and will be          Thaùi Lang trong boä Thieàn Phaät Giaùo: "Coâng quickly exposed as such by any Zen masters.            aùn khoâng phaûi ñöôïc ñeà ra ñeå giaûi moät caùch deã 3) Tam Toå Taêng Xaùn thöôïng ñöôøng daïy chuùng:         daøng. Nhöng moät khi ñaõ giaûi xong, coâng aùn coù "Khi quaùn moät coâng aùn ñaëc bieät, vaø neáu chuùng  theå ñöôïc ví nhö vieân gaïch vôõ duøng ñeå goõ cöûa. ta laøm vieäc ñoù moät caùch thaønh taâm, nhö moät     Khi cöûa ñaõ môû, ngöôøi ta neùm boû vieân gaïch ñi. con gaø maùi aáp tröùng, con meøo rình chuoät,         Coâng aùn coøn höõu duïng khi caùnh cöûa taâm linh gioáng nhö ngöôøi ñoùi mô ñeán thöùc aên, ngöôøi       coøn ñoùng chaët, vaø khi cöûa ñaõ môû ra, ngöôøi ta khaùt mong chôø ly nöôùc, treû con chôø meï, chaéc     coù theå queân noù ñi. Ñieàu maø ngöôøi ta thaáy chaén seõ coù luùc chuùng ta thaám nhaäp vaø thaáu     ñöôïc sau khi cöûa môû ra laø moät ñieàu gì hoaøn hieåu." Kyø thaät, con soá coâng aùn cuûa chö Toå leân toaøn baát ngôø, ñieàu gì ñoù tröôùc ñaây chöa bao ñeán 1.700 tröôøng hôïp, chaúng haïn nhö "Con          giôø xuaát hieän, ngay caû trong trí töôûng töôïng choù khoâng coù Phaät taùnh," "Caây tuøng ngoaøi       cuûa chuùng ta, moät ñieàu baát khaû tö nghì. Vaø khi saân," "Ba caân gai," "Caây gaäy choïc phaân." Khi     coâng aùn laïi ñöôïc quaùn töôûng theo quan ñieåm gaø aáp tröùng, hôi aám phaû ra lieân tuïc. Khi meøo   chuùng ta vöøa môùi thuû ñaéc ñoù, noù trôû neân haøm rình chuoät, taâm trí cuõng nhö ñoâi maét gaén chaët   xuùc tuyeät vôøi, caáu truùc hoaøn haûo vaø khoâng coù vaøo con moài. Veà chuyeän ngöôøi ñoùi nghó ñeán       chuùt gì giaû taïo!"—According to Zen Master mieáng aên, ngöôøi khaùt nghó ñeán nöôùc uoáng, ñöùc   D. T. Suzuki in Zen Buddhism: "The koan beù chôø meï, taát caû xuaát phaùt töø caùi taâm ñích  refuses to be solved under any easy

conditions. But once solved the koan is                     is one that naturally grows out of one's life compared to a piece of brick used to knock at               situation. For example, a Buddhist might be a gate; when the gate is opened the brick is                gripped by the following problem: 'If all thrown a way. The koan is useful as long as                 beings without exception are intrinsically the mental doors are closed, but when they                  perfect, as the Buddha proclaimed, why is are opened it may be forgotten. What one                    there so much pain and suffering in the sees after the opening will be something quite              world?' Or a believer may question intensely: unexpected, something that has never before                 'I am fundamentally a Buddha, why do I act entered even into one's imagination. But                    like anything but one?' Those driven by the when the koan is re-examined from this                      need to dispel a fundamental contradiction newly acquired point of view, how                           between their faith in the truth of the marvelously suggestive, how fittingly                       Buddha's pronouncement and the evidence of constructed, although there is nothing                      their senses have a natural koan." artificial here!"                                        7) Theo Christmas Humphreys trong quyeån 'Phaät 5) Theo Thieàn sö Thích Nhaát Haïnh trong quyeån               Giaùo': "Coâng aùn gioáng nhö moät vieân soûi ngöôøi 'Chìa Khoùa Tu Thieàn': "Coâng aùn khoâng phaûi laø         ñi qua sa maïc ngaäm trong mieäng. Daàu khoâng nghieân cöùu hoaëc tìm toøi chaát lieäu. Moãi coâng         giaûi ñöôïc côn khaùt, noù kích thích caùc phöông aùn phaûi ñöôïc xem nhö ngoùn tay chæ cho chuùng            tieän laøm giaûi côn khaùt."—According to ta thaáy thöïc taïi cuûa chaân baûn theå cuûa chính         Christmas Humphreys in Buddhism: "The mình, cuõng nhö thöïc taïi cuûa theá giôùi. Ngoùn tay       koan is like the pebble in the mouth of a man ñoù chæ laøm ñöôïc neân chuyeän neáu baïn yù thöùc          who walks in the desert. It does not quench ñöôïc raèng noù chæ thaúng tröïc tieáp vaøo baïn—           existing thirst, but it stimulates the means of According to Zen Master Thich Nhat Hanh in                  quenching it." Zen Keys: "Kung-ans (koans) are not to study 8) Maurine Stuart vieát trong quyeån 'AÂm Thanh or research material. Each kung-an must be                  Vi Teá': "Taát caû caùc caâu chuyeän Thieàn ñeàu considered a finger pointing to the realityof               luaän chung veà moät chuû ñeà. Caûnh trí khaùc our own true nature as well as the reality of               nhau, nhaân vaät khaùc nhau, nhöng taát caû caùc the world. This finger can only fulfill its role            caâu chuyeän ñeàu giuùp chuùng ta thaáy roõ hôn vaøo as pointer if you are aware that it is pointing             caùi chaân taùnh cuûa mình, Phaät taùnh, hay coäi reã directly at you."                                           baûn theå cuûa chuùng ta, döôùi baát kyø teân goïi naøo 6) Theo Thieàn sö Philip Kapleau trong quyeån                  do chuùng ta ñaët ra. Caùc coâng aùn vaø nghi thöùc 'Thieàn: Truyeàn Thoáng & Söï Chuyeån Tieáp':               khoâng chæ thuoäc veà quaù khöù, vaø chuùng ta "Coâng aùn hay nhaát chaéc chaén laø coâng aùn xuaát        khoâng neân ñeå chuùng trôû thaønh nhöõng hình thöùc xöù töø tình huoáng cuoäc soáng cuûa töøng ngöôøi.          troáng roãng. Chuùng ta phaûi caån thaän khoâng ñeå Chaúng haïn, moät Phaät töû coù theå bò daèn vaët bôûi      cho caùi cuõ bieán thaønh caën baõ cuûa quaù khöù, vaø vaán naïn sau ñaây: 'Neáu taát caû moïi chuùng sanh         xem nhöõng caùi môùi nhö nhöõng baûn moâ phoûng. theo baûn chaát ñeàu hoaøn haûo nhö lôøi Phaät daïy,        Khi ngöôøi ta thöïc söï söû duïng nhöõng coâng aùn taïi sao vaãn coøn bao nhieâu laø phieàn naõo vaø ñau       naøy, hoï trôû neân sinh ñoäng ngay trong hieän taïi; khoå treân coõi ñôøi?' Moät tín ñoà cuõng coù theå töï      nhöõng phaân bieät giöõa caùi cuõ vaø caùi môùi khoâng vaán: 'Cô baûn toâi laø moät vò Phaät, vaäy thì taïi sao    coøn nöõa. Moãi coâng aùn ñeàu laø coâng aùn cuûa haønh ñoäng cuûa toâi chaúng khaùc gì haønh ñoäng           chuùng ta. Chuùng ta phaûi tieán tôùi trong söï töï do cuûa phaøm nhaân?' Nhöõng ngöôøi coù nhu caàu               ñôn ñoäc. Söï laøm saùng toû töï ngaõ khoâng gì khaùc thuùc baùch phaûi giaûi quyeát maâu thuaãn caên baûn        hôn ngoaøi chuyeän chuyeân taâm tu taäp. Khoâng giöõa loøng tin theo chaân lyù cuûa Phaät vaø nhöõng        ai daïy cho chuùng ta ñöôïc, khoâng ai cho chuùng caûm xuùc cuûa giaùc quan xem nhö phaûi ñöông               ta ñöôïc. Roõ raøng chuùng ta phaûi töï tìm ra moät ñaàu vôùi moät coâng aùn töï nhieân."—According to          caùch ñoäc laäp."—Maurine Stuart wrote in The Zen Master Philip Kapleau in 'Zen: Tradition                Subtle Sound: "All Zen stories are about the and Transition,': "Undoubtedly the best koan                same thing. There are different scenes,

different characters, but they all help us see           phaûi tuaân theo. Haønh giaû tu thieàn töø moät coâng more clearly into our true nature, our Buddha-           aùn tuyeät nhieân khoâng tìm caùch ñeå bieát xem nature, the ground of our being, whatever we             moät thieàn sö naøo ñoù ñaõ soáng nhö theá naøo trong want to call it. Koans and rituals do not just           quaù khöù, hay coù theå noùi ra nhöõng lôøi gì; ñieàu pertain to ancient times; we must not let them           maø haønh giaû quan taâm laø chính baûn thaân mình become more forms. We must be careful not                hieåu vaø thöïc hieän chaân lyù soáng trong coâng aùn to treat the old like dregs from the past, and           ngay ôû ñaây vaø baây giôø. Haønh giaû tu thieàn cuõng not to see the new as imitations. When truly             neân nhôù raèng nhieàu coâng aùn chæ hieän leân alive people make use of these koans, they               nhöõng giai thoaïi noâng caïn vaø vui ñuøa töø söï haøi become vividly present; distinctions between             höôùc saâu saéc cuûa caùc thieàn sö ngaøy xöa. Tuy old and new are gone. Each koan is our koan.             nhieân, noùi gì thì noùi, chuùng ta phaûi ñoàng yù We must come forth in solitary freedom,                  raèng nhöõng coâng aùn naày coù coâng naêng giuùp independently. The clarification of the true             caùc thieàn sö ngaøy xöa ñaït ñöôïc ñaïi giaùc —Zen self is none other than this practice we are             practitioners should always remember that engaged in. No one can teach us about it, no             texts of koans are aids in Zen training and one can give it to us. We must find out for              they should not be considered as a model that ourselves, clearly independently."                       practitioners must strictly followed. For Zen 9) Nancy Wilson Ross vieát trong quyeån 'Theá                practitioners with a koan, it is absolutely not Giôùi Thieàn': "Quaùn töôûng moät coâng aùn ñoøi hoûi    the point to be informed about what a certain moät nhieät tình chaân thaät vaø kieân trì giaûi quyeát  Zen master experienced or said in the past; noù, vaø moät trong voâ soá nghòch lyù trong Thieàn      but rather to realize themselves right here and laø baïn phaûi ñoái ñaàu vôùi coâng aùn maø khoâng       right now the living truth toward which the nghó ñeán noù. Ñieåm naøy ñöôïc nhaán maïnh moät         koan points. Zen practitioners should also caùch quyeát lieät ñeå buoäc thieàn sinh noå löïc vöôït  remember that many of the koans only appear quaù caùi coâng thöùc muoân ñôøi cuûa nhò nguyeân        superficially as amusing anecdotes, not rarely vaø bieän chöùng tö duy bình thöôøng. Ngöôøi ta          ancient Zen masters have a profound sense of khoâng ngöøng nhaán maïnh raèng khoâng theå naøo         humor. However, no matter what we say, we naém ñöôïc chaân lyù baèng caùch chæ ñôn thuaàn töø      must agree that the power of these koans can boû caùi sai traùi, cuõng nhö khoâng theå naøo ñaït      help       ancient      Zen       masters       attain ñöôïc caùi taâm bình an hay tìm ñöôïc giaûi ñaùp toái    enlightenment. haäu baèng tranh bieän hay lyù luaän."—Nancy 11) Theo Robert Atken trong Voâ Moân Quan: "Toâi Wilson Ross wrote in The World Of Zen: "To               ñaõ hoïc ñöôïc moät ñieàu veà tu taäp coâng aùn vaøo work on a koan necessitates a sincere and                moät buoåi toái khi cuøng taém chung vôùi Laõo sö enduring eagerness to solve it, but also, and            Soen Nakagawa trong phoøng taém cuûa töï vieän here comes the twist, and one of the many                Ryutaku. Laõo sö ñaõ keå laïi cho toâi moät caâu noùi paradoxes in which Zen abounds; you must                 ñöôïc cho laø Yamaoka Tesshu, moät chính face it without thinking about it. This point is         khaùch vaø voõ sö noåi tieáng hoài cuoái theá kyû thöù stressed in the unbending effort to force the            XIX. Vaøo thôøi Tesshu, caùc vaät duïng ñöôïc student beyond the eternally dualistic and               nhaäp caûng töø phöông Taây nhö xaø boâng baét ñaàu dialetic pattern of ordinary thinking. Again             thay theá cho caùc vaät duïng truyeàn thoáng cuûa and again it is emphasized that one cannot               ngöôøi Nhaät nhö vieân ñaù boït. Ngaøi baûo toâi: take hold of the true merely by abandoning               'Thieàn cuõng gioáng nhö cuïc xaø boâng. Tröôùc the false, nor can one reach peace of mind or            heát, oâng duøng xaø boâng ñeå goät röûa, sau ñoù, oâng any final answer by argument or logic."                  xaû saïch heát xaø boâng ñi'."—According to 10) Haønh giaû tu thieàn neân luoân nhôù raèng nhöõng        Robert Atken in the Gateless Barrier, "I got baûn vaên veà coâng aùn laø nhöõng thöù boå trôï cho söï instruction in the koan practice aspect one ñaøo taïo thieàn vaø ñöøng bao giôø xem chuùng nhö       evening when I was in the bathhouse of khuoân vaøng thöôùc ngoïc maø haønh giaû tu thieàn       Ryutaku Monastery with Nikagawa Soen

Roshi. He told me about a remark attributed                vieân maõn cuûa Nhö Lai cuõng nhö ñem löûa ñom to the great nineteenth-century statesman and              ñoùm maø ñoát nuùi Tu Di, roát cuoäc chaúng bao giôø swordman Yamaoka Tesshu. In Tesshu's time,                 ñöôïc). Sau khi coâng aùn deïp saïch taát caû chöôùng new Western imports like soap were                         ngaïi ñöa ñeán chaân lyù cöùu caùnh, roát cuoäc chuùng beginning to replace traditionally Japanese                ta seõ bieát raèng hoaøn toaøn khoâng coù "caûnh giôùi things like pumice. He said, 'Zen is like soap.            bí maät taâm linh," cuõng khoâng coù caùi goïi laø First you wash with it, and then you wash off              chaân lyù Thieàn laëng leõ vi dieäu. Coâng aùn khoâng the soap.'"                                                phaûi laø caâu ñoá cuõng khoâng phaûi laø lôøi noùi khoâi (VII)Khi naøo vò Taêng môùi nhaäp moân ñöôïc giao cho          haøi. Coâng aùn coù moät muïc tieâu raát roõ raøng, khôûi coâng aùn?—When will a novice monk be                      leân nghi tình vaø khaùm phaù ra chaân töôùng cuûa assigned with a koan?: Thöôøng thöôøng, sau                söï vaät. Moät caâu noùi laáy lyù luaän laøm neàn taûng khi ñöôïc thaâu nhaän vaøo thieàn vieän, vò Taêng          coù theå tieán ñeán gaàn ñöôïc khi döïa theo tính môùi ñeán seõ khoâng ñöôïc giao cho moät coâng aùn         hôïp lyù ñeå bieän bieät; coù gì nghi ngôø hay khoù cho ñeán khi naøo anh ta coù cuoäc ñoái thoaïi ñaàu        khaên chuùng ta ñeàu coù theå giaûi quyeát ñöôïc tieân vôùi vò Thieàn sö vaø toái thieåu phaûi hieåu        baèng caùch quay veà vôùi nguoàn goác cuûa quan ñöôïc cuoäc ñoái thoaïi vôùi thaày naøy. Sau cuoäc         nieäm. Moïi doøng soâng ñeàu chaûy veà bieån caû, ñaøm thoaïi vôùi thaày, vaøo luùc tham thieàn buoåi        nhöng coâng aùn laø moät böùc töôøng saét cho neân toái, vò Taêng ñöôïc goïi leân cuøng vôùi taát caû         baát cöù tri kieán naøo cuõng khoâng theå xuyeân qua nhöõng ngöôøi khaùc ñeå gaëp Thaày, roài anh ta seõ        ñöôïc. Moät hoâm khi böùc töôøng coâng aùn bò phaù ñöôïc giao cho moät coâng aùn, ñoù coù nghóa laø söï       saäp thì chöôùng ngaïi tri kieán seõ bò queùt saïch, khôûi ñaàu cuûa ñôøi soáng thieàn ñöôøng cuûa anh          baïn seõ trôû veà vôùi yù thöùc hoaøn chænh ñöôïc caáu ta—Usually, after being admitted to a Zen                  keát bình thöôøng. Tröø phi coù moät baøn tay voã monastery, a novice monk will not be                       vaøo moät baøn tay khaùc, neáu khoâng seõ khoâng assigned with a koan until after his first                 phaùt ra aâm thanh. Caây baùch ñöùng tröôùc saân, conversation with the Zen master of the                    muõi ai cuõng naèm doïc, maét ai cuõng naèm ngang. monastery. After the first conversation with               Ngaøy nay, Thieàn laø thöù bình thöôøng nhaát treân the master, the novice monk must wait until                theá giôùi. Tröôùc ñaây noù gioáng nhö moät phaïm he has solved and at least be able to                      truø raát xa laï, giôø ñaây laïi phaùt hieän ra raèng moãi understand the dialogue with the master.                   ngaøy chuùng ta ñeàu daïo chôi trong Thieàn. Noùi After the first conversation with the master, at           toùm laïi, khi haønh giaû hoaøn toaøn thaáu trieät moät the time of the evening sanzen, he is told to              coâng aùn, caùc coâng aùn coøn laïi seõ khoâng coøn caàn come to see the master with the rest, and then             thieát nöõa. Thaät vaäy, theo Thieàn sö D.T. Suzuki he will have his koan, which means the real                trong quyeån "Thieàn Hoïc Nhaäp Moân," treân beginning of his Zendo life.                               phöông dieän truyeàn thoáng thì coù ñeán 1.700 (VIII)Haønh giaû seõ phaûi tu taäp bao nhieâu coâng            coâng aùn, ñoù chæ laø caùch tính roäng raõi veà nhöõng aùn?—How many koans will Zen practitioners                 coâng aùn maø thoâi. Vôùi nhöõng muïc ñích thöïc practice?: Khi tu taäp coâng aùn, haønh giaû chæ           tieãn, chæ caàn khoâng quaù 10, hay 5 coâng aùn, neân duïng taâm vaøo moät coâng aùn, chöù khoâng coá       thaäm chí chæ caàn moät coâng aùn cuõng ñuû cho hieåu vaø giaûi thích taát caû caùc coâng aùn. Daàu coù    haønh giaû môû taâm ñeán chaân lyù Thieàn. Tuy giaûi thích ñöôïc ñi nöõa, roát cuoäc laø kieán giaûi      nhieân, ñeå ñaït ñöôïc moät söï chöùng ngoä trieät ñeå chöù ñaâu phaûi laø ngoä. Kinh Phaùp Hoa daïy: "Thò        haønh giaû chæ caàn buoâng boû taát caû vôùi nieàm tin phaùp phi tö löông phaân bieät chi sôû naêng ñaùo."        khoâng lay chuyeån vaøo muïc ñích cöùu caùnh cuûa (Phaùp naøy khoâng phaûi laø choã maø suy töôûng           Thieàn. Seõ khoâng ñaït ñöôïc keát quaû gì neáu chæ phaân bieät coù theå hieåu ñöôïc). Kinh Vieân Giaùc        leo leân theo söï saép xeáp coâng aùn heát caùi naøy tuyeân boá: "Dó tö duy taâm traéc ñaïc Nhö Lai             ñeán caùi kia nhö thöôøng ñöôïc tu taäp cuûa caùc ñoà Vieân Giaùc caûnh giôùi nhö dó huyønh hoûa nhieät          ñeä cuûa toâng Laâm Teá. Con soá coâng aùn thöïc söï Tu Di Sôn, chung baát naêng ñaéc." (laáy caùi taâm         khoâng quan heä gì ñeán vieäc tu taäp, nhöõng ñoøi suy töôûng maø ño löôøng caûnh giôùi giaùc ngoä            hoûi caàn thieát laø nieàn tin vaø coâng phu caù nhaân,

neáu khoâng ñöôïc nhö vaäy thì Thieàn chæ laø moät       vertically set and the eyes horizontally caùi bong boùng. Nhöõng ai xem Thieàn laø söï tö         arranged. Zen is now the most ordinary thing bieän vaø suy ngaãm tröøu töôïng seõ khoâng bao giôø     in the world. A field that we formerly ñaït ñöôïc nhöõng caùi thaâm saâu cuûa noù, Thieàn       supposed to lie far beyond is now found to be chæ vang voïng vôùi nhöõng ai coù taâm löïc cao toät     the very field in which we walk, day in, day maø thoâi. Coù theå coù haøng traêm coâng aùn, hay coù   out. In short, if we completely break through theå coù voâ soá coâng aùn vì coù voâ soá vaät theå laáp one koan, the rest of the koans will be ñaày vuõ truï, nhöng ñieàu ñoù chaúng lieân quan gì      unnecessary. As a matter of fact, according to ñeán chuùng ta. Chæ caàn haønh giaû ñaït ñöôïc caùi      Zen master Daisetz Teitaro Suzuki in "An thaáy chaân thöïc töôùng cuûa vaïn vaät trong doøng      Introduction to Zen Buddhism (p.85)," the sinh sinh baát tuyeät cuûa vaïn höõu thì coâng aùn töï   number of koans is traditionally estimated at chuùng hoaøn thaønh söù meänh cuûa mình—When             1,700, which, however, is a very generous working at Zen, one should concentrate on                way of counting them. For all practical one koan only, and not try to understand or              purposes, less than ten, or even less than five, explain them all. Even one were able to do               or just one may be sufficient to open one's so, this would be merely intellectual                    mind to the ultimate truth of Zen. A thorough- understanding and not true realization. The              going enlightenment, however, is attained Lotus Sutra says: "This Dharma is not                    only through the most self-sacrificing understood through thinking and intellection."           application of the mind, supported by an The Total Enlightenment Sutra declares: "To              inflexible faith in the finality of Zen. It is not perceive the Realm of Enlightenment of the               to be attained by merely climbing up the Tathagata with the thinking mind is like                 gradation of the koans one after another, as is attempting to burn Mount Sumeru with the                 usually practiced by followers of the Rinzai light of a firefly; never will one succeed."             school. The number really has nothing to do When the koan breaks down all the                        with it; the necessary requirements are faith hindrances to the ultimate truth, we all realize         and personal effort, without which Zen is a that there are , after all, no such things as            mere bubble. Those who regard Zen as "hidden recesses of mind" or even the Truth              speculation and abstraction will never obtain of Zen appearing all the time so mysterious.             the depths of it, which can be sounded only The koan is neither a riddle nor a witty                 through the highest will-power. There may be remark. It has most definite objective, the              hundreds of koans, or there may be an infinite arousing of doubt and pushing it to its furthest         number of them as there are infinite numbers limits. A statement built upon a logical basis           of objects filling up the universe, but it does is approachable through its rationality;                 not necessarily concern us. Only let one gain whatever doubt or difficulty we may have had             an all-viewing and entirely satisfying insight about it dissolves itself by pursuing the                into the living actuality of things and the natural current of ideas. All rivers are sure to         koans will take care of themselves. pour into the ocean; but the koan is an iron (IX) Soá löôïng coâng aùn—Numbers of koans: Ngöôøi wall standing in the way and threatening to              ta noùi toaøn boä coù khoaûng chöøng 1.700 coâng overcome one's every intellectual effort to              aùn. Trong soá naày coù 500 coâng aùn chính yeáu, vì pass. One day when the wall of koan broken               coù nhieàu coâng aùn truøng laäp nhau, cuõng nhö coù through and the intellectual obstructions well           nhöõng coâng aùn coù giaù trò thaáp cho vieäc thöïc cleared off, you come back, so to speak, to              haønh. Caùc vò sö ñeàu coù nhöõng sôû thích rieâng your      everyday        relatively      constructed    veà coâng aùn, nhöng thöôøng thöôøng hoï duøng Voâ consciousness. The one hand does not give                Moân Quan vaø Bích Nham Luïc laø hai bieân taäp out a sound until it is clapped by the other.            coâng aùn chính—It is said that altogether there The cypress-tree stands straight before the              are about 1,700 koans. Of these, about 500 window; all human beings have the nose                   are usually used, since many are repetitive

and others are less valuable for practice.                  cuûa ñôøi soáng naøy? Ai laø caùi keû ñoät nhieân yù Masters have their own for references, but                  thöùc ñöôïc caùi töø ñaâu ñeán vaø ñi veà ñaâu cuûa ñôøi they prefer to use the Wu-Meân-Kuan and Pi-                 soáng? Laïi nöõa ai laø caùi keû ñoái maët vôùi coâng aùn Yen-Lu.                                                     naøy, khoâng theå giöõ ñoâi maét mình ñònh, vaø vì (X) Coâng aùn ñöôïc Thieàn sö Laâm Teá söû duïng:               haén khoâng laõnh hoäi noåi noù, thaáy caû ruoät gan “Koans” used by Zen master Lin-Chi—Coâng                    mình ñaûo loän nhö nuoát phaûi moät hoøn löûa aùn laø moät caùi gì ñoù cho caùc ñeä töû suy nghó vaø      khoâng deã daøng phun ra ñöôïc. neáu oâng muoán quaùn chieáu trong thieàn quaùn trong caùc thieàn           bieát caùi keû naøy laø ai, laõnh hoäi haén ôû caùi choã ñöôøng phaùi Laâm Teá. Luùc ñaàu, coâng aùn laø moät        maø mình khoâng theå ñem haén vaøo khuoân khoå “yeát thò coâng khai,” coù nghóa laø “coù tröôùc veà        cuûa lyù trí. Khi oâng ñaõ laõnh hoäi ñöôïc haén nhö maët coâng lyù.” Veà sau naày coâng aùn ñöôïc nhaø          theá, oâng haún bieát raèng roát cuoäc haén laø keû vöôït Thieàn xöû duïng moät caùch coù heä thoáng nhö              qua söï can thieäp cuûa sanh töû.” Muïc tieâu toái nhöõng phöông tieän ñaøo taïo töø khoaûng giöõa theá        haäu vaãn giöõ nguyeân nhö vaäy: bieát vaø laõnh hoäi kyû thöù möôøi baèng caùch traùnh taát caû nhöõng lôøi      xem ta laø ai beân kia caùi “khuoân khoå cuûa lyù giaûi thích duy lyù. Coâng aùn cho pheùp ñeä töû thaáy      trí,” nghóa laø beân kia caùi cô caáu chuû theå -khaùch roõ nhöõng giôùi haïn cuûa trí tueä vaø buoäc phaûi         theå cuûa trí naêng. Höôùng veà cöùu caùnh naøy cuûa vöôït leân nhöõng giôùi haïn aáy baèng tröïc giaùc chöù     coâng aùn, moät thöù caâu hoûi, vaán ñeà, thaùch thöùc, khoâng baèng duy lyù, laø thöù ñöa anh ta vaøo moät         hay ñoøi hoûi ñeà ra bôûi vaø do saùng kieán cuûa vò vuõ truï naèm beân ngoaøi moïi maâu thuaãn vaø moïi         thaày, coù yù ñònh thoûa maõn hai taùc duïng: thöù tö töôûng nhò nguyeân. Söï phaùt khôûi naày cho             nhaát laø thaâm nhaäp vaøo nhöõng mieàn saâu vaø pheùp ngöôøi ñeä töû trình baøy vôùi thaày moät caùch       kích thích taän caên nguoàn noù moái öu taâm neàn töï phaùt vaø khoâng caàn tôùi söï giuùp ñôû töø beân       taûng choân saâu hay giaû doái che ñaäy cuûa baûn ngoaøi. Nhaèm giuùp cho caùi ngaõ tænh thöùc vaø            ngaõ trong ngaõ thöùc. Thöù hai laø trong khi khích chöùng nghieäm “Phaät taùnh,” maø ngaøi Laâm Teá            ñoäng moái hoaøi mong caên baûn naøy vaø cuoäc tìm goïi laø “Voâ vò chaân nhaân,” nghóa laø troïn veïn laø     kieám noù, giöõ cho chuùng ñöôïc beùn reã vaø chæ mình vaø chaân thöïc bieát mình, trong caùc Thieàn          ñaïo moät caùch thích ñaùng. Vì chæ khôûi daäy sö, nhaát laø caùc Thieàn sö thuoäc phaùi Laâm Teá,         chuùng thoâi cuõng khoâng ñuû. Maø coøn phaûi chæ môùi coù söï söû duïng caùi maø tieáng Nhaät goïi laø       ñaïo vaø hôn nöõa nuoâi döôõng chuùng moät caùch “koan.” Ñoù laø moät phaùt trieån ñaëc bieät cuûa caùc      caån maät ngoõ haàu traùnh nhieàu caïm baãy giaû doái theá kyû 11 vaø 12, khi Thieàn ñöôïc heát söùc öa           vaø aûo töôûng trong aáy chuùng coù theå bò giaûm chuoäng vaø phoå bieán roäng raõi khaép Trung Hoa,          thieåu hay ñi laïc höôùng. Trong giai ñoaïn tieàn thu huùt caû nhieàu ngöôøi khoâng coøn tìm ñeán vì          coâng aùn cuûa Thieàn, keû caàu ñaïo thöôøng ñeán vì moät nhu caàu hieän sinh thuùc baùch naøo caû.              söï thuùc ñaåy cuûa kinh nghieäm soáng cuûa chính Nhöõng vò thaày thôøi tröôùc coù leõ haún ñaõ phaûn         mình, ñaõ roái loaïn bôûi moät moái hoang mang öùng vôùi caùi laõnh ñaïm vaø lô laø beà ngoaøi nhö Boà     daèn neùn naøo ñoù cuûa ñôøi soáng. Tuy nhieân, bình Ñeà Ñaït Ma. Tuy nhieân, nhöõng vò thaày sau                thöôøng “caâu hoûi” hay moái öu taâm chöa ñöôïc naøy, thaønh thaät vaø bi maãn muoán giuùp taát caû         thaêm doø tôùi mieàn saâu toái haäu cuûa noù. Maëc duø nhöõng keû tìm kieám, giôø ñaây baét ñaàu chính hoï         ñöôïc nhen nhuùm moät caùch töï nhieân, ngöôøi ta thieát laäp moái lieân heä vôùi nhöõng ngöôøi ñeán tìm      cuõng khoâng bieát caùi caên nguoàn hay chaân tính baèng moät coâng aùn. Vò thieàn sö ñôøi Toáng ñaàu          cuûa noù, do ñoù khoâng coù moät hình thöùc thích tieân söû duïng coâng aùn coù phaàn heä thoáng laø          ñaùng, noù deã trôû thaønh mô hoà hay leäch laïc. Baát Toâng Caûo Ñaïi Hueä (theá kyû thöù 12), trong moät         chaáp moät söï caêng thaúng hay nghieâm troïng dòp, ñaõ noùi nhö sau: “Chuùng ta sinh ra töø ñaâu?         thöïc söï, do ñoù moái hoaøi mong vaø tìm kieám chuùng ta ñi veà ñaâu? Keû naøo bieát caùi töø ñaâu         naøy thöôøng muø quaùng, baát thöôøng vaø hoãn ñoän, ñeán vaø ñi veà ñaâu naøy laø keû maø chuùng ta coù theå    ñoøi hoûi moät neàn taûng vaø taâm ñieåm chính xaùc. thöïc söï goïi laø moät Phaät töû. Nhö ai laø caùi keû      Khi, trong thôøi kyø naøy, trong moät cuoäc gaëp gôõ traûi qua sinh töû naøy? Laïi nöõa, ai laø caùi keû         vôùi vò thaày, haønh giaû nhaän ñöôïc moät thaùch chaúng bieát gì veà caùi töø ñaâu ñeán vaø ñi veà ñaâu      thöùc hay ñoøi saéc beùn, thí duï nhö “Ñem taâm

oâng ra ñaây!” “Caùi gì ñeán nhö theá vaäy?” “Theá             monasteries of the Lin-Chi school. Problems naøo laø baûn lai dieän muïc cuûa oâng tröôùc khi oâng         set by Zen masters, upon which thought is ñöôïc sanh ra?” “Khi cheát, hoûa thieâu, vaø tro taøn          concentrated as a means to attain inner unity ruïi thì oâng ôû ñaâu?” Hay, giaûn dò “Noùi! Noùi!”            and illumination. Originally, koan means Thöôøng thöôøng hieäu quaû cuûa noù cung caáp caùi             “public notice,” means a legal case ñònh höôùng vaø chæ daãn caàn thieát. Duø nhö vaäy,            constituting a precedent. Later, koans have nhöõng thaùch thöùc , nhöõng caâu hoûi, hay nhöõng             been used in Zen as a systematic means of ñoøi hoûi khoâng ñöôïc goïi laø coâng aùn. Thay vaøo           training since around the middle of the tenth ñoù ngöôøi ta laïi goïi nhöõng trao ñoåi nhaát thôøi vaø       century. Since the koan eludes solutions by khoâng coù caáu truùc, khoâng coù toå chöùc giöõa thaày        means of discursive understanding, it makes vaø troø laø “Vaán Ñaùp,” nghóa ñen laø hoûi vaø traû          clear to the student the limitations of thought lôøi. Nhöng vì nhöõng trao ñoåi, hay vaán ñaùp naøy            and eventually forces him to transcend it in an gôïi yù, ñaët neàn taûng vaø ñieàu khieån moái öu taâm         intuitive leap (not by speaking or discussion), caên baûn vaø cöùu caùnh cuûa baûn ngaõ, do ñoù, treân         which takes him into a world beyond logical thöïc teá nhieàu vaán ñaùp ñöôïc söû duïng nhö laø             contradictions and dualistic modes of thought. coâng aùn, hay nhö laø neàn taûng cho coâng aùn. Do            On the basis of this experience, the student ñoù chuùng ta coù theå xem coâng aùn vôùi taùc duïng           can demonstrate his own solution of the koan hai maët cuûa noù laø moät noã löïc coá yù vaø coù truø        to the master in a spontaneous and without tính ñeå baûo ñaûm moät keát quaû tröôùc ñaây ñaõ              recourse to preconceived notions. To help the ñöôïc moät caùch töï nhieân khoâng möu tính. Traùi             ego awaken to and realize the “Buddha- laïi, coù leõ ta coù theå noùi, baát chaáp caùi thuaät ngöõ    nature,” which Lin-Chi called “true man kyõ thuaät vaø nhöõng sai bieät cuûa Thieàn, raèng             without a title,” that is, to fully be and truly ngöôøi ñeä töû tröôùc kia coù coâng aùn töï nhieân cuûa        know itself, there arose among certain Zen mình, töï nhieân ôû caùi chaát theå noàng chaùy, maëc          masters, notably those of the Lin-Chi school, duø vaãn phaûi theå hieän noù döôùi moät hình thöùc            the use of what is known, in Japan, as the hay taâm ñieåm thích öùng, trong khi ôû giai ñoaïn             koan. This is a development especially of the sau naøy, khi ngöôøi ta vaãn chöa ñöôïc vôùi moät              eleventh and twelfth centuries, when Zen hình thöùc thích hôïp cuûa caâu hoûi cuõng chöa loät           Buddhism having acquired great esteem and taû ñöôïc heát caùi noäi dung soáng ñoäng cuûa noù,            wide renown throughout China, attracted chính vò thaày phaûi coá tìm caùch tröôûng döôõng              many who no longer came out of any caû hình thöùc laãn noäi dung baèng caùch ngay töø             compelling existential need. Earlier masters ñaàu ñeà ra moät “caâu hoûi” naøo ñoù, töø beân ngoaøi.        would probably have reacted with the same Trong tröôøng hôïp naøy, coâng aùn ñöôïc hoaøn                 outward indifference and disregard as did toaøn ñeà ra thay vì coù phaàn naøo töï nhieân.                Bodhidharma. These later teachers, however, Nhöng laàn nöõa, chuùng ta phaûi nhaán maïnh                   in the sincere and compassionate desire to ngay töùc khaéc raèng khi naøo maø caùi “caâu hoûi”            help all inquirers, began, now themselves to hay “coâng aùn” vaãn tieáp tuïc laø “caùi töø phía beân        initiate their relation to the caller by means of ngoaøi” hay “ñöôïc ñeà ra” moïi noã löïc cuûa chuùng           a koan. The Chinese Sung master first to ta ñeàu voâ ích, vaø roát cuoäc laïi, chaúng coù Thieàn        employ the koan somewhat systematically, gì caû. Tuy nhieân, trong ñaëc taùnh veà cô caáu naøy          Ta-Hui (12th century), on one occasion spoke cuõng nhö trong theå caùch aùp duïng vaø söû duïng             as follows: “Whence are we born? Whither do noù, coâng aùn ñöôïc tính toaùn moät caùch caån thaän          we go? He who knows this whence and ñeå choáng laïi ñuùng caùi nguy hieåm naøy. Vì ngay            whither is the one to be truly called a töï baûn taùnh cuûa noù coâng aùn khoâng töï cho mình          Buddhist. But who is this one who goes thích öùng vaøo baát cöù khuoân khoå nhò nguyeân               through this birth-and-death? Again, who is chuû theå-khaùch theå naøo cuûa baûn ngaõ trong ngaõ           the one who knows not anything of the thöùc—Koan is something to be pondered on                      whence and whither of life? Who is the one during meditation by novices in Zen                            who suddenly becomes aware of the whence

and whither of life? Who is the one, again,             original face prior to your birth?” “When you who, facing this koan, cannot keep his eyes             are dead, cremated, and ashes scattered, fixed, and as he is not able to comprehend it,          where are you?” Or, simply, “Speak! Speak!” feels his internals altogether put out of order         The effect, often, was to provide just the as if a fiery ball swallowed down could not             needed orientation and guidance. Even so, readily be ejected. If you wish to know who             such challenges, questions, or demands were this one is, apprehend him where he cannot              not called koans. These spontaneous, be brought within the fold of reason. When              unstructured exchanges between master and you thus apprehend him, you will know that              student were instead termed “mondo,” or in he is after all above the interference of birth-        Chinese “Wen-ta,” literally, question and and-death. The ultimate objective remains the           answer. But since the “mondo-exchanges” did same: to know and apprehend who one is                  not prompt, ground, and direct the radical and beyond “the fold of reason,” that is, beyond            ultimate concern of the ego, many of them the subject-object structure of intellection.           were actually used, subsequently, either as Toward this end the koan, a kind of question,           koans, or as the basis of koans. The koan in its problem, challenge, or demand presented by              double function may therefore be considered and upon the initiative of the master, is               a deliberate and calculated attempt to secure intended to serve a twofold function: The first         a result previously obtained naturally and is to penetrate to the depths and quicken at its        without contrivance (saùng kieán). Conversely, source the deeply buried or deceptively                 it can perhaps be said, regardless of the concealed basic underlying concern of the               technical terminology and distinctions of Zen ego in ego-consciousness. The second is,                Buddhism itself, that the earlier student had while stirring this fundamental longing and its         his own natural koan, natural as to the burning quest, to keep them properly rooted and                 substance, although still to be given a proper directed. For it is not sufficient that they            form or focus, whereas, in the later period, simply be aroused. They must, in order to               when the inquirer approached neither with a avoid the many deceptive and delusive                   suitable form of the quesiton nor yet pitfalls in which they may become attenuated            existentially fired to its all-consuming content, or go astray, also be careful guided even               the master himself sought to foster both by fostered. In the earlier or pre-koan phase of           intially presenting such a “question,” as it Zen Buddhism, the caller generally came out             were, from the outside. In this instance, the of the provocation of his own life experience,          koan, rather than being partially natural, was already bestirred by some existentially                 totally given. But again, it must be oppressing perplexity. Normally, however,               emphasized immediately that as long as the the “question” or concern had not yet been              “question,” or koan continues to be “on the plumbed to its ultimate depth. Although                 outside” or “given,” the effort is futile, and kindled naturally, known neither in its root-           there is, finally, no Zen Buddhism. In its source nor in its true nature, and hence                character and structure, however, as well as in without adequate form, it could easily become           the mode of its application and usage, the veiled or deflected. Despite a genuine                  koan is carefully designed as a safeguard intensity and seriousness, the longing and              against precisely this danger. For by its very quest were thus usually blind, amorphous, and           nature the koan does not permit itself to be confused, requiring a correct grounding and             fitted into any dualistic subject-object scheme focus. When, in this period, the student,               of the ego-consciousness. during an encounter with the master, would         Coâng AÙn AÅn Phong Ñaûo Hoùa: The koan of Zen receive a piercing challenge or demand, for        master Teng-Yin-Feng who passed away standing instance, “Bring forth your heart-mind!”           on his head—Coâng aùn Thieàn sö Ñaëng AÅn Phong “What is it which thus comes?” “What is your       loän ngöôïc ñeå thò tòch—See AÅn Phong Ñaûo Hoùa.

Coâng AÙn AÅn Phong Phi Tích: The koan of Teng-        Coâng AÙn Baïch Maõ Phaùp Thaân: Pai-ma's Yin-Feng Zen master who threw his staff up into        Dharmakaya—See Baïch Maõ Phaùp Thaân. the sky and, riding upon it—See AÅn Phong Phi          Coâng AÙn Baïch Vaân Laàu Quyønh Ñieän Ngoïc: Pai- Tích.                                                  Yun: A jade palace—See Baïch Vaân Laàu Quyønh Coâng AÙn AÅn Phong Thoâi Xa: The koan of Teng-        Ñieän Ngoïc. Yin-Feng Zen master who was pushing a cart, he         Coâng AÙn Baïch Vaân Thieát Bích: Pai-Yun: An iron happened to see his master Ma-Tsu stretching his       wall—See Baïch Vaân Thieát Bích. legs a little too far out in the roadway—See AÅn       Coâng AÙn Baøn Sôn Tam Giôùi Voâ Phaùp: P'an Phong Thoâi Xa.                                        Shan's There Is Nothing in the World—See Baøn Coâng AÙn Ba Caân Gai: Three pounds of hemp—           Sôn Tam Giôùi Voâ Phaùp. See Ba Caân Gai.                                       Coâng AÙn Baøn Sôn Tinh Ñeå Nhuïc: Coâng aùn Baøn Coâng AÙn Ba Laêng Kieám Saéc: Pa Ling's Blown         Sôn thaáy baùn thòt maø tænh ngoä—The koan of P'an- Hair Sword, example 100 of the Pi-Yen-Lu—See           shan's overhearing a customer of pork meat—See Kieám Thoåi Loâng.                                     Baøn Sôn Tinh Ñeå Nhuïc. Coâng AÙn Ba Laêng Ngaân Oaûn Lyù Thaïnh Tuyeát:       Coâng AÙn Baûn Khoâng Traø Lam: Phaät Nhaät Baûn Pa-ling's Snow in a Silver Bowl—See Ba Laêng           Khoâng: gioû traø—Fo Ru Pen K'ung's tea basket— Ngaân Oaûn Lyù Thaïnh Tuyeát.                          See Baûn Khoâng Traø Lam. Coâng AÙn Ba Laêng Ngaân Uyeån Lyù Thaïnh Tuyeát:      Coâng AÙn Baøng Cö Só Haûo Tuyeát Phieán Phieán: Pa-ling's Snow in a Silver Bowl—See Ba Laêng           Coâng aùn Baøng Cö Só töøng maûnh tuyeát rôi ñeïp — Ngaân Oaûn Lyù Thaïnh Tuyeát.                          The koan of P'ang Yun's statement: "Good Coâng AÙn Ba Laêng Tam Chuyeån Ngöõ: The koan          Snowflakes; they don't fall in any other place"— of Pa-ling Hao-chien's three turning phrases—See       See Baøng Cö Só Haûo Tuyeát Phieán Phieán. Ba Laêng Tam Chuyeån Ngöõ.                             Coâng AÙn Baøng Cö Só Tuyeát Ñoaøn Ñaû Tuyeát Coâng AÙn Ba Laêng Tuyeát Trung Baïc Oaûn: Pa-         Ñoaøn Ñaû: Coâng aùn Baøng Cö Só töøng maûnh tuyeát ling's Snow in a Silver Bowl—See Ba Laêng Ngaân        rôi ñeïp—The koan of P'ang Yun's statement: Oaûn Lyù Thaïnh Tuyeát.                                "Good Snowflakes; they don't fall in any other Coâng AÙn Ba Laêng Xuy Mao Kieám: Pa Ling's            place"—See Baøng Cö Só Haûo Tuyeát Phieán Phieán. Blown Hair Sword, example 100 of the Pi-Yen-           Coâng AÙn Baûo Trieät Ma Coác Caàm Gaäy Nhieãu Lu—See Ba Laêng Kieám Saéc.                            Giöôøng: Ma Ku Carrying his Ring Staff—See Ma Coâng AÙn Ba Tieâu Truï Tröôïng: Pa-chiao's            Coác Truï Tröôïng. Staff—See Ba Tieâu Truï Tröôïng.                       Coâng AÙn Baûo Trieät Ma Coác Truï Tröôïng: Baûo Coâng AÙn Baø Töû Taùc Trai: The koan of an old        Trieät Ma Coác Caàm Gaäy Nhieãu Giöôøng—Ma Ku woman treats a lunch meal to the monks—See Baø         Carrying his Ring Staff, example 31 of the Pi- Töû Taùc Trai.                                         Yen-Lu—See Ma Coác Truï Tröôïng. Coâng AÙn Baø Töû Thaâu Duaãn: The koan of an old      Coâng AÙn Baùt Phong Suy Baát Ñoäng, Nhaát Thi woman's stealing bamboo shoots from Chao-              Ñaû Quaù Giang: Eight winds can hardly move a chou—See Baø Töû Thaâu Duaãn.                          person (Su-Tung-Po) an inch, but a single puff of Coâng AÙn Baø Töû Thieâu Am: Coâng aùn cuûa baø laõo   wind from the anus (of Zen master Fo-ying) can ñoát am—The koan of an old woman who burns a           carry him away—See Baùt Phong Suy Baát Ñoäng, hermit's hut—See Baø Töû Thieâu Am.                    Nhaát Thi Ñaû Quaù Giang. Coâng AÙn Baùch Tröôïng Daõ Hoà: Pai-Chang and         Coâng AÙn Baát Khaû Kieán Laêng Nghieâm: The the fox—See Baùch Tröôïng Daõ Hoà.                     Surangama Scripture's Not Seeing—See Baát Khaû Coâng AÙn Baùch Tröôïng Daõ Ngan: Pai Chang's          Kieán Laêng Nghieâm. Wild Ducks—See Baùch Tröôïng Daõ Ngan.                 Coâng AÙn Baát Tö Thieän Baát Tö AÙc: Fushizen- Coâng AÙn Baùch Tröôïng Vaán Vaân Nham: Pai            fushiaku (jap)—Neither Good Nor Evil—See Chang Questions Yun Yen—See Baùch Tröôïng              Khoâng Nghó Thieän Khoâng Nghó AÙc. Vaán Vaân Nham.

Coâng AÙn Baát Tö Thieän Baát Tö AÙc. Thaäp Ma                  sanh" chæ mang taùnh giôùi ñieàu, moät daïng meänh Thò Baûn Lai Dieän Muïc?: With no thoughts of                   leänh hay huaán thò, coù leõ khoâng caàn thieát ñeå ñöa good and with no thoughts of evil, at just this                 ñeán thaùi ñoä giaùc ngoä, thì thöïc chöùng "khoâng theå saùt moment, what is your original face?—See Khoâng                  sanh" chuyeån bieán töï nhieân aên saâu vaøo yù nieäm xaùc Nghó Thieän, Khoâng Nghó AÙc, Chính Khi AÁy Caùi Gì             quyeát "Ta seõ khoâng saùt sanh." Tuy vaäy, ñöôøng Laø Baûn Lai Dieän Muïc?                                        ranh chia caét giöõa "khoâng saùt sanh" (meänh leänh Coâng AÙn Bieät Phong Töông Kieán: To meet on a                 giôùi ñieàu) vaø "khoâng theå saùt sanh" (nhaän thöùc) separate peak—Gaëp nhau taïi ñænh Bieät Phong—                  döôøng nhö tan bieán khi chuùng ta thaáy raèng chuùng See Bieät Phong Töông Kieán.                                    ta luoân huûy hoaïi caùi gì ñoù. Chuùng ta coù theå quyeát Coâng AÙn Bình Thöôøng Taâm Thò Ñaïo: Heijoshin-                ñònh khoâng saùt haïi ñoäng vaät ñeå laøm thöùc aên, nhöng kore-do (jap)—The normal mind is the Way—See                    caùc loaïi rau coû thì sao? Vaân vaân vaø vaân vaân, vôùi Bình Thöôøng Taâm Thò Ñaïo.                                     moïi thöù khaùc maø chuùng ta huûy hoaïi vaø lieäng boû. Coâng AÙn Caøn Phong Ñình Chæ Ñaïi Vuõ: Kan-                    Neáu chuùng ta tuaân thuû meänh leänh giôùi ñieàu "khoâng feâng's stopping pouring rain—See Caøn Phong                    saùt sanh," chuùng ta khoâng ñöôïc pheùp aên uoáng, Ñình Chæ Ñaïi Vuõ.                                              chuùng ta seõ phaûi nhòn ñoùi nhòn khaùt ñeán cheát, keát Coâng AÙn Caøn Phong Nhaát Loä: Kan-feng's One                  quaû laø chính sinh maïng cuûa chuùng ta bò huûy hoaïi. Road—See Caøn Phong Nhaát Loä.                                  Laøm sao ñeå vöôït qua tình traïng khoù xöû naøy? Khi Coâng AÙn "Caám Giôùi": The koan of precepts—                   nhu caàu thuùc baùch phaûi laáy ñi sinh maïng hay söï Haønh giaû tu Thieàn neân laáy "caám giôùi" laøm coâng aùn      soáng, daàu laø cuûa sinh vaät hay caây coû, hay vaät voâ tri trong tu taäp. Thaät vaäy, trong tu taäp Thieàn, haønh giaû     giaùc, haønh giaû neân heát loøng an truï taâm mình ôû tham cöùu "Thaäp troïng caám giôùi" nhö moät ñeà taøi           caûnh giôùi "Voâ". Theo ñoù, cöù moãi khoaûnh khaéc maø coâng aùn. Giôùi luaät Phaät giaùo coù theå ñöôïc nhìn töø      chuùng ta laáy ñi cuoäc soáng töø moät hình thaùi sinh toàn hai höôùng. Thí duï, giôùi thöù nhaát "Khoâng saùt sinh"        khaùc coù theå laø moät cô hoäi ñeå cho chuùng ta nhaän thöôøng ñöôïc hieåu nhö laø moät lôøi khuyeán caùo coù          thöùc saâu saéc taùnh nhaát theå giöõa con ngöôøi vaø toaøn lieân quan tröïc tieáp ñeán thaùi ñoä haønh xöû ñuùng ñaén      boä vuõ truï trong caûnh giôùi "Voâ". Duy trì thaùi ñoä naøy hay phuø hôïp vôùi ñaïo ñöùc. Trong khi lôøi giaùo huaán        laø ñieåm then choát cuûa vieäc thoï trì Nguõ Giôùi, Thaäp nhö vaäy laø caàn thieát, nhöõng haønh giaû tieáp tuïc          Troïng Caám Giôùi, cho ñeán 250 giôùi hay 348 giôùi. Thieàn taäp vaø môû roäng söï xaùc chöùng veà thöùc ngoä        Nhöõng giôùi luaät naøy khoâng nhaèm troùi buoäc hay noâ cuûa hoï khi nhaäp caûnh giôùi hö khoâng bieát raèng,           dòch con ngöôøi. Ñöôïc aùp duïng vôùi kinh nghieäm noäi trong caûnh giôùi aáy, thaät söï khoâng coù ai laøm chuyeän     kieán veà "Voâ," caùc giôùi luaät aáy trôû thaønh phöông saùt sanh maø cuõng khoâng coù ai bò saùt sanh. Töø quan        tieän giaûi thoaùt cuûa con ngöôøi. Thaäp Troïng Caám ñieåm toái haäu aáy, "khoâng saùt sinh" cuõng caûnh baùo        Giôùi ñöôïc söû duïng nhö moät coâng aùn khoâng chæ coù chuùng ta ñöøng rôi vaøo quan ñieåm nhò nguyeân saùt            giaù trò ñôn thuaàn nhö nhöõng giôùi caám, maø chuùng sanh vaø khoâng saùt sanh. Tuy nhieân, seõ laø sai laàm         coøn taïo neân moät böôùc tieán xa hôn treân con ñöôøng khi lyù giaûi giôùi luaät treân phöông dieän quan nieäm         thöïc chöùng hoaøn toaøn toaøn caûnh giôùi cuûa taùnh nhaát toái haäu ñeå bieän minh cho nhöõng haønh vi toäi loãi.         theå trong moïi hoaït ñoäng cuûa cuoäc soáng haøng ngaøy. Ñoái laïi vôùi thoùi quen thoâng thöôøng veà nhaän thöùc söï    Söï chöùng ngoä nhö vaäy khoâng heà phuû ñònh hieäu löïc vaät döïa treân quan ñieåm toát xaáu, ngöôøi Phaät töû thaáy    cuûa caùc giaù trò töông ñoái; noù chæ ñôn thuaàn khoâng theá giôùi vôùi toaøn boä caùc maët thieän aùc nhö moät thöïc   cho pheùp nhöõng giaù trò töông ñoái naøy laøm môø ñi taïi nhaát nhö, ñuùng nhö baûn chaát voán coù cuûa noù. Veà     Phaät taùnh cuûa chuùng ta, hay ngaên trôû söï töï taïi boån cô baûn maø noùi, theá giôùi voán khoâng toát cuõng khoâng      lai cuûa con ngöôøi. Khi ñaõ hoaøn taát myõ maõn coâng xaáu. Thieáu moät caùi nhìn chaân thaät, caùi goïi laø haønh    aùn "Thaäp Troïng Caám Giôùi," vò thaày laïi cho thieàn vi hoaøn thieän veà maët ñaïo ñöùc cuûa con ngöôøi ñeàu         sinh caùi ñöôïc bieát nhö laø "Quan AÛi Cuoái Cuøng." leäch laïc vaø hôøi hôït. Chaùnh kieán (nhaän thöùc chaân       Coâng aùn ñaëc bieät naøy ñöôïc duøng tuøy thuoäc vaøo söï chaùnh) khoâng nhöõng chæ ñöa ñeán thöïc chöùng raèng           höôùng daãn cuûa vò thaày, nhöng muïc ñích luoân gioáng khoâng coù keû gieát vaø ngöôøi bò gieát, maø noù coøn ñöa      nhau: loaïi tröø söï kieâu ngaïo vi teá cho raèng "Ta ñaõ ñeán söï thöïc chöùng raèng ngöôøi ta khoâng theå gieát         ñaït ngoä caùi gì ñoù." Tröø phi haønh giaû coù theå queân ñi moät ai hay moät caùi gì caû. Trong khi "khoâng saùt            thaønh töïu thöùc ngoä cuûa mình, vieäc hoaøn taát heä

thoáng coâng aùn cuûa hai thaày troø Baïch AÅn vaø Ñoâng         necessarily lead to enlightened behavior, the Laõnh chaúng coù gì khaùc hôn laø moät loaïi tín chæ             "cannot" realization naturally evolves into the trong chöông trình ñaïi hoïc. Do vaäy "Quan AÛi Cuoái            deeply rooted stance of "I won't kill." Yet the line Cuøng" laø daïng coâng aùn coù coâng naêng heát söùc quan        separating "do not" (injunction) and "cannot" troïng trong quaù trình taåy xoùa ñi taát caû nhöõng daáu        (realization) seems to dissolve when we see that veà cuûa caùi ngaõ. Haàu heát caùc thieàn sö khoâng deã          we are always killing something. We may decide daøng thöøa nhaän vieäc hoaøn taát ñeà taøi coâng aùn naøy,      not to kill animals for food, but what about thoâng thöôøng hoï giöõ laïi söï aán chöùng naøy ñeán naêm       vegetables? And so on with everything else we baûy naêm trong thöû thaùch. Thôøi nay chuùng ta muoán           destroy and discard. If we obeyed the injunction bieát vaø laøm moïi thöù caøng nhanh caøng toát. Höôùng ñi       "do not kill" literally, we could not eat, we would tôùi cuûa Thieàn taäp thì khaùc haún: noù daïy chuùng ta         starve to death, thus ending up by taking life laøm sao kieân nhaãn, laøm sao naém baét söï vaät baèng          anyway. How can we overcome this dilemma? tröïc giaùc, vaø laøm sao thöøa nhaän raèng coù nhöõng           When the need arises to take life or destroy, vieäc baát khaû tri ñoái vôùi chuùng ta. Nhieàu Thieàn sinh      whether it be animal, vegetable, or inanimate coù theå choáng ñoái: "Cuoäc soáng ngaén nguûi nhö vaäy .        object, one should just dwell on "Mu" with all Taïi sao phaûi maát quaù nhieàu naêm thaùng ñeå tu taäp,         one's heart. Thus each moment we are taking life haï thaáp mình trong söï voâ minh cuûa chuùng ta, tröôùc         from some form of existence can be an occasion khi chuùng ta coù theå daãn daét ngöôøi khaùc?" Quan             to be deeply aware of our oneness with the ñieåm töông ñoái naøy thaáy ñôøi soáng nhö moät quaõng           universe in "Mu." Maintaining this attitude is the thôøi gian haïn ñònh. Vôùi moät nhaän thöùc vieân maõn           key point of the Five, Ten, Two Hundred Fifty or veà Töï Taùnh (baûn chaát toái haäu cuûa töï ngaõ), haønh giaû   Three hundred forty-eight moral precepts. These bieát raèng ñôøi soáng khoâng heà chaám döùt. Noù chæ bieán      precepts are not meant to bind or enslave us. ñoåi maø thoâi—Zen practitioners should take                     Applied with "Mu" insight, they can be a means to "Precepts" as their koan practice. In fact, in Zen               emancipation. The Ten Precepts as koan study are training, Zen practitioners see the Ten Cardinal                 no longer just moral injunctions, but constitute a Precepts as koan practice. These Buddhist                        further step on the road toward the complete precepts can be seen from two perspectives. For                  realization of oneness in our everyday actions. example, the first precepts, "Do not kill," gives the            Such realization does not negate the validity of impression that it just concerns right behavior or               relative values; it simply does not allow relative morality. While such teaching is needed, those                   values to obscure our original freedom, our who continue Zen practice and further clarity their              Buddha-nature. When the koans of Ten Precepts insight into emptiness know that, actually, there is             are well integrated, the master gives the student no one to do the killing and no one to be killed.                what is known as the "Last Barrier." The specific From the ultimate standpoint, "Do not kill" also                 koan used depends on the master, but the purpose warns us not to fall into the dualistic view of                  is always the same: to eliminate the subtle pride killing versus not killing. However, it would be a               that came with the idea "I have attained misinterpretation to use this view of the precepts               something." Unless one can forget one's as a pretext for immoral transgression or excess.                "attainment," having passed through the koan In contrast to the conventional habit of viewing                 system of Hakuin and Torei is nothing more than a things from the standpoint of good and bad, the                  kind of college credit. So this "Last Barrier" has Buddhist sees the world, with all its good and evil,             the important function of erasing all traces of ego. just as it is. Fundamentally, the world is neither               Most masters do not easily acknowledge that the good nor bad. Without genuine insight, so-called                 final koan has been passed, often withholding moral perfection is uninformed and hollow. True                  approval for several years. These days we want to insight not only leads to the realization that there             know and do everything as quickly as possible. is no killers and no one to be killed, it also results           Zen's approach is different: it teaches us how to be in the realization that one simply cannot "kill."                patient, how to know things intuitively, and how to Whereas "do not" is an injunction, which may not                 acknowledge that there are things we do not

know. Students may object, "Life is so short. Why               caùc thieàn sö ngaøy xöa. Tuy nhieân, noùi gì thì noùi, spend so many years in training, humbled by our                 chuùng ta phaûi ñoàng yù raèng nhöõng coâng aùn naày coù ignorance, before we can even begin to guide                    coâng naêng giuùp caùc thieàn sö ngaøy xöa ñaït ñöôïc ñaïi others?" This relative viewpoint sees life only as a            giaùc. Coøn ñoái vôùi haønh giaû tu taäp "Chæ quaùn ñaû single span of time. With genuine insight into the              toïa" cuõng neân nhôù raèng "Chæ quaùn ñaû toïa" laø moät fundamental nature of Self, one knows that life                 loaïi coâng phu khoù khaên nhaát trong tu taäp Thieàn never ends. It simply changes.                                  ñònh. Haønh giaû nhaát ñònh phaûi queân chính mình thì Coâng AÙn Chí Ñaïo Voâ Nan, Duy Hieàm Giaûn                     môùi coù theå "Chæ quaùn ñaû toïa" ñöôïc. Trong "Chæ Traïch: The Ultimate Path is Without Difficulty—                quaùn ñaû toïa," khoâng coù yù töôûng vì khoâng coù ngöôøi See Chí Ñaïo Voâ Nan, Duy Hieàm Giaûn Traïch.                   suy töôûng. Thay vaøo ñoù, haønh giaû tu Thieàn chính Coâng AÙn Vaø Chæ Quaùn Ñaû Toïa: Practicing koans              laø nhöõng yù töôûng lôûn vôûn aáy. Khoâng coù tieáng chim and practicing just-sitting—Coâng aùn ñöôïc duøng               hoùt vì khoâng coù khaùi nieäm chim hoùt. Thay vaøo ñoù, nhö laø ñeà muïc cuûa thieàn taäp trong truyeàn thoáng          haønh giaû laø nhöõng aâm thanh ñoù. Cuõng vaäy, haønh Thieàn. Ngöôøi ta nghó coù theå laáy ra ngay caùi coát loõi     giaû tu Thieàn laø nhöõng gioït möa, tieáng saám vaø tia cuûa chaân lyù vaø boïc noù vaøo trong voû ngay luùc lôøi       chôùp. Chæ caàn ngoài xuoáng laø caû vuõ truï lieàn hieån noùi töï noù chaám döùt, ñöa ñeán khoâng coøn khaùi nieäm       baøy ra tröôùc maét—“Kung-an” (koan) are used as a vaø tröïc chöùng chaân töôùng. Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc coù           topic of meditation in the Zen tradition. The ghi con soá moät ngaøn baûy traêm Thieàn sö, moãi vò            stories are thought to get to the very essence of Thieàn sö ñeàu coù nhöõng coâng aùn cuûa mình. Vì theá          truth and to encapsulate the moment at which coâng aùn coù voâ soá khoâng theå noùi heát ñöôïc. Baát cöù     speech exhausts itself, leading to non-conceptual, vieäc gì cuõng ñeàu coù theå xem laø moät coâng aùn. Vaäy       direct realization of reality. The Record of the thì laøm sao môùi hieåu roõ ñöôïc coâng aùn? Tham cöùu          Transmission of the Lamp numbers seventeen coâng aùn coù theå xem laø phöông aùn, laø phöông tieän         hundred Zen masters, each with his own koans. So maø töø ñoù chuùng ta mong ñôïi coù theå ñaït ñöôïc keát        koans are literally numberless. Anything could be quaû naøo ñoù. Nhöng ñieåm quan troïng ôû ñaây khoâng           a koan. How to really appreciate it? We can look phaûi laø soá coâng aùn maø baïn giaûi quyeát hay tu taäp       at koan practice as a kind of a scheme or nhö laø caùi khaùch theå naøo ñoù ngoaøi baïn. Neáu baïn        expediency, where we expect a result. But the khoâng nhaän ra ñôøi soáng cuûa baïn nhö laø söï hieån          point is not the number of koans you solve or hieän cuûa coâng aùn, thì baïn seõ taêng vieän cho moät         practicing koans as something apart from yourself. loaïi "ngaõ" khaùc, moät caùi "ngaõ" khoâng toát.               If you are not realizing your life as the "ngaõ"Ñieåm quan troïng laø laøm sao baïn coù theå hieåu        manifestation of koan, then you are reinforcing ñöôïc taùnh tuyeät ñoái vaø töông ñoái trong ñôøi soáng         another kind of ego, which is not good. The cuûa mình? Chæ quaùn ñaû toïa laïi cuõng nhö vaäy.              important point is how do you realize the absolute Chuùng ta bieát coù ngöôøi cho raèng chæ quaùn ñaû toïa         and the relative in your life? The same can be said öu vieät hôn tham cöùu coâng aùn. Thaäm chí hoï coøn            of "Nothing but precisely sitting" (Shikan-taza). noùi xaáu veà tu taäp coâng aùn. Ñieàu coát yeáu laø phaûi tu   We know there are people who believe that "Chæ quaùn ñaû toïa" nhö theá naøo? Chuùng ta ñaõ theå          "Nothing but precisely sitting" is superior to koan chöùng bao nhieâu veà giaù trò chaân thaät vaø söï phong        practice. They even speak badly about the phuù caùi coâng ñöùc voâ giaù ñöôïc chöùa ñöïng trong           practice of koan Zen. The point is how are we phaùp tu "Chæ quaùn ñaû toïa"? Vôùi haønh giaû tu thieàn        practicing "Nothing but precisely sitting"? How töø moät coâng aùn tuyeät nhieân khoâng tìm caùch ñeå bieát     much are we manifesting or realizing the real xem moät thieàn sö naøo ñoù ñaõ soáng nhö theá naøo             value, the richness and boundless merit contained trong quaù khöù, hay coù theå noùi ra nhöõng lôøi gì; ñieàu     in the practice of "Nothing but precisely sitting"? maø haønh giaû quan taâm laø chính baûn thaân mình hieåu        For Zen practitioners with a koan, it is absolutely vaø thöïc hieän chaân lyù soáng trong coâng aù n ngay ôû        not the point to be informed about what a certain ñaây vaø baây giôø. Haønh giaû tu thieàn cuõng neân nhôù        Zen master experienced or said in the past; but raèng nhieàu coâng aùn chæ hieän leân nhöõng giai thoaïi        rather to realize themselves right here and right noâng caïn vaø vui ñuøa töø söï haøi höôùc saâu saéc cuûa       now the living truth toward which the koan points.

Zen practitioners should also remember that many          needle into a bowl of water—Theo Ñaïi Ñöôøng of the koans only appear superficially as amusing         Taây Vöïc Kyù, quyeån X, vaø Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng anecdotes, not rarely ancient Zen masters have a          Luïc, quyeån II, Ñeà Baø Boà Taùt, Ñoäc Nhaõn Ñeà Baø profound sense of humor. However, no matter               (chæ coù moät maét vì ngaøi ñaõ boá thí cho Thieân Thaàn what we say, we must agree that the power of              con maét kia), sanh tröôûng taïi vuøng Pataliputra, ñeä these koans can help ancient Zen masters attain           töû cuûa ngaøi Long Thoï. Luùc ñaàu Ñeà baø laø ngoaïi enlightenment. And for Zen practitioners who              ñaïo, moät hoâm töø nöôùc Chaáp Sö Töû (Tích Lan) ñeán practice "Just sitting" should always remember            nöôùc Kieàu Taùt La (moät vöông quoác naèm veà phía that "Just sitting" is perhaps the most difficult thing   baéc soâng Haèng) ñeå gaëp ngaøi Long Thoï. Long Thoï to do in cultivation (Zen practice). For in order to      beøn sai moät trong nhöõng ñeä töû laáy moät caùi baùt just sit, Zen practitioners have to forget the self. In   ñöïng ñaày nöôùc ñem ñeå tröôùc maët Ñeà Baø. Ngay laäp "Just-sitting," there are no thoughts because there       töùc Ñeà Baø beøn neùm moät caây kim vaøo ñoù. Long is no thinker. Instead, Zen practitioners are the         Thoï heát söùc khen ngôïi. Veà sau Ñeà Baø trôû thaønh vò thoughts that come up. There are no bird songs            toå thöù 15 taïi AÁn Ñoä. Ñeà Baø Boà Taùt ñaõ cuøng vôùi because there are no concepts of bird songs.              Ngaøi Long Thoï laäp ra Tam Luaän Toâng— Instead, Zen practitioners are those sounds. In the       According to the Great T’ang Chronicles of the same way Zen practitioners are the rain-drops, are        Western World, volume X, and the Records of the the thunder and the lightning. In sitting, the whole      Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), universe is revealed and manifested.                      Volume II, the one-eyed deva (Aryadeva or Coâng AÙn Chích Thuû: The clap of just one hand—          Kanadeva), a monk of Pataliputra, a disciple of Tieáng Voã Cuûa Moät Baøn Tay—See Chích Thuû.             Nagarjuna. First, he was a disciple of a heretical Coâng AÙn Chích Thuû Chi Thanh: The clap of just          sect, one day he came from Simhala to Kausala to one hand—Tieáng Voã Cuûa Moät Baøn Tay—See                meet with Nagarjuna. Nagarjuna told one of his Chích Thuû.                                               disciples to bring a bowl full of water and placed Coâng AÙn Coå Ñöùc Hoûa Sao: Coâng aùn ñoå naêm thöù      in front of Deva. Deva immediately threw a löûa ñoát löng—The koan of "placing five hot jabs         needle into the bowl. Nagarjuna praised for his on the Old Virtue's back"—See Coå Ñöùc Hoûa Sao.          wisdom. Later, he became the fifteenth patriarch; Coâng AÙn Coå Ñöùc Tam Mieät: Coâng aùn coät ba laït      and along with his master, Nagarjuna, he is tre vaøo buïng—The koan of binding three bamboo           counted as one of the founders of the strings to one's stomach—See Coå Ñöùc Tam Mieät.          Madhyamika School. Coâng AÙn Coå Giaûn Haøn Tuyeàn: Khe suoái xöa            Coâng AÙn Dieâm Quan Teâ Ngöu Phieán Töû: Dieâm nöôùc laïnh—The cold fountain and the ancient             Quan Caây Quaït Teâ Ngöu—Yen Kuan's stream—See Coå Giaûn Haøn Tuyeàn.                         Rhinoceros Fan, example 91 of the Pi-Yen-Lu— Coâng AÙn Coå Linh Khai Boái: Coâng aùn veà Coå Linh      See Dieâm Quan Teâ Ngöu Phieán Töû. Voã Löng—The koan on Ku-ling's clapping on the            Coâng AÙn Duy Nghieãm Baát Vi: The Zen koan of back—See Coå Linh Khai Boái.                              Wei-yen's doing something—Coâng aùn Thieàn "Duy Coâng AÙn Coå Phaøm Vò Quaûi: Coâng aùn veà Caùnh         Nghieãm Baát Vi". Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Buoàm Xöa Chöa Treo Leân—The koan of "an old              Luïc, quyeån XIV, moät hoâm sö ngoài treân taûng ñaù, sail not yet been hoisted"—See Coå Phaøm Vò Quaûi.        Thaïch Ñaàu troâng thaáy beøn hoûi: “Ngöôi ôû ñaây laøm Coâng AÙn Cô Lai Khieát Phaïn, Khoán Lai Ñaû              gì?” Sö thöa: “Taát caû chaúng laøm.” Thaïch Ñaàu laïi Mieân: Ñoùi thì aên, meät thì nguû—To eat when we         hoûi: “Taïi sao ngoài nhaøn ôû ñaây?” Sö thöa: “Ngoài are hungry and to sleep when we are tired—See             nhaøn roãi töùc laøm.” Thaïch Ñaàu laïi hoûi: “Ngöôi noùi Cô Lai Khieát Phaïn, Khoán Lai Ñaû Mieân.                 chaúng laøm, laø chaúng laøm caùi gì?” Sö thöa: “Ngaøn Coâng AÙn Cöôùc Baû: Bò daäp chaân—Vaân Moân bò           Thaùnh cuõng khoâng bieát.” Thaïch Ñaàu duøng keä daäp chaân—Yun Men: The leg broke—See Cöôùc               khen: Baû.                                                               Tuøng lai coäng truï baát tri danh Coâng AÙn Dó Chaâm Ñaàu Baùt: Coâng aùn Thieàn neùm                Nhaäm vaän töông töông chæ ma haønh kim vaøo baùt nöôùc—The koan of Zen, to throw a                    Töï coå thöôïng hieàn du baát thöùc

Taïo thöù phaøm löu khôûi khaû minh                  Voâ Moân Hueä Khai trong Voâ Moân Quan, Quy Sôn (Chung ôû töø laâu chaúng bieát chi                  moät phen haêng haùi, ngaët raèng vaãn khoâng vöôït qua Laëng leõ theo nhau chæ theá ñi                      ñöôïc caùi baãy cuûa Baùch Tröôïng. Xeùt laïi cho kyõ, teù Thöôïng hieàn töø tröôùc coøn chaúng bieát           ra boû nheï löïa naëng. Taïi sao vaäy? Traùnh khoûi böng Huoáng boïn phaøm phu ñaâu deã tri).                 maâm, laïi bò mang goâng saét—Kuei-shan Kicks Veà sau Thaïch Ñaàu daïy: “Noùi naêng ñoäng duïng chôù       Over the Water Bottle, example 40 of the Wu- giao thieäp.” Sö thöa: “Chaúng noùi naêng ñoäng duïng        Men-Kuan. When Kuei-shan was with Pai-chang's cuõng chôù giao thieäp.” Thaïch Ñaàu noùi: “Ta trong aáy     assembly, he was a cook of the monastery. Pai- muõi kim maûnh buïi chaúng loït vaøo.” Sö thöa: “Con         chang wanted to choose a founding teacher for trong aáy nhö troàng hoa treân ñaù.” Thaïch Ñaàu aán         Mount ta-kuei. He invited all his monk to make a khaû—The Zen koan of Wei-yen's doing                         presentation, saying, "The outstanding one will be something. According to The Records of the                   sent." The he took a water bottle and set it on the Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu),                   floor, and said, "Don't call this a water bottle. Volume XIV, one day, as Yueh-Shan was sitting,               What would you call it?" The head monk said, "It Shih-T’ou asked him: “What are you doing here?”              can't be called a wooden clog." Pai-chang then Yueh-Shan said: “I am not doing a thing.” Shih-              asked Kuei-shan his opinion. Kuei-shan kicked T’ou said: “Then you’re just sitting leisurely.”             over the water bottle and walked out. Pai-chang Yueh-Shan said: “If I were sitting leisurely, I’d be         laughed and said, "The head monk loses." Then doing something.” Shih-T’ou said: “You say                   Pai-chang assigned the assignment to Kuei-shan. you’re not doing anything. What is it that you’re            Kuei-shan thereupon was made the founding not doing?” Yueh-Shan said: “A thousand sages                teacher at Mount Ta-kuei. According to Wu Men don’t know.” Shih-T’ou then wrote a verse of                 Hui-Kai in the Wu-Men-Kuan, though Kuei-shan praise that said:                                            was altogether valiant, he could not leap out of "Long abiding together, not knowing its name,             Pai-chang's trap. if you scrutinize what happened Just going on, practicing like this,                     next, you'll see that he accepted the heavy and Since ancient times the sages don’t know.                rejected the light. How? Look! Removing his Will searching everywhere now make it                    sweatband, he shouldered an iron yoke. known."                                                  Coâng AÙn Döôïc Sôn Chuû Trung Chuû: Yao Shan's Later Shih-T’ou offered an instruction, saying,              Shooting the Elk of Elks, example 81 of the Pi- “Words do not encroach upon it.” Yueh-Shan said,             Yen-Lu—Thí duï thöù 81 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Moät “No words does not encroach upon it.” Shih-T’ou              vò Taêng hoûi Döôïc Sôn: "Khoûa ruoäng coû caïn, nai said, “Here, I can stick a needle to it.” Yueh-Shan          höôu thaønh baày, theá naøo baén ñöôïc höôu trong said, “Here, is like I am growing flowers on a bare          höôu?" Döôïc Sôn noùi: "Xem teân!" Vò Taêng phoùng rock.” Shih-T’ou approved Yueh-Shan’s answer.                thaân lieàn nhaøo. Döôïc Sôn sai thò giaû loâi gaõ cheát Coâng AÙn Döôïc Ñaûo Tònh Bình: Kuei-shan Kicks              naøy ra ngoaøi. Vò Taêng lieàn chaïy. Döôïc Sôn noùi: Over the Water Bottle—Quy Sôn ñaù ñoå tònh bình,             "Keû chôi ñaát coù bao nhieâu haïng?" Tuyeát Ñaäu thí duï thöù 40 cuûa Voâ Moân Quan. Hoøa Thöôïng Quy         nieâm: "Ba böôùc tuy soáng, naêm böôùc phaûi cheát." Sôn tröôùc ôû vôùi ngaøi Baùch Tröôïng, giöõ chöùc ñieån     Theo Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc, coâng aùn toøa. Baùch tröôïng saép choïn ngöôøi ñeán nuùi Ñaïi Quy     naøy Toâng Taøo Ñoäng goïi laø "Taù söï vaán", cuõng goïi laøm chuû trì, beøn daïy sö cuøng oâng thuû toøa ra ñoái     laø "Bieän chuû vaán" duøng ñeå roõ ñöông cô. Nai höôu ñaùp tröôùc chuùng, xem ai ñoái ñaùp gioûi seõ ñöôïc phaùi   taàm thöôøng thì deã baén, chæ coù höôu trong höôu laø ñi. Baùch tröôïng caàm tònh bình ñaët xuoáng ñaát hoûi:      vua trong loaøi nai raát laø khoù baén. Loaïi höôu nai "Khoâng ñöôïc goïi laø tònh bình thì goïi laø gì?" OÂng      naøy thöôøng ñeán treân bôø ñaù maøi gaïc gioáng nhö muõi thuû toøa ñaùp: "Khoâng theå goïi laø khuùc caây." Baùch     nhoïn raát beùn, ñem thaân giöõ gìn baày nai, coïp cuõng Tröôïng quay sang hoûi Quy Sôn, Quy Sôn beøn ñaù             chaúng daùm ñeán gaàn. Vò Taêng naøy cuõng gioáng tænh ñoå tònh bình maø ñi. Baùch Tröôïng cöôøi noùi: "OÂng ñeä    tænh, daãn laïi hoûi Döôïc Sôn ñeå roõ cô thöù nhaát. Döôïc nhaát toøa thua maát hoøn nuùi roài vaäy" Noùi xong beøn     Sôn noùi: "Xem teân!" Haøng toâng sö taùc gia quaû phaùi Quy Sôn ñi laøm Toå khai sôn Ñaïi Quy. Theo            nhieân kyø ñaëc nhö choïi ñaù nhaùng löûa, tôï laøn ñieån

chôùp. Ñaâu chaúng thaáy Tam Bình ban ñaàu ñeán                thaân nhaøo. Döôïc Sôn baûo: "Thò giaû loâi gaõ cheát naøy tham vaán Thaïch Cuûng. Thaïch Cuûng vöøa thaáy ñeán           ra." Vò Taêng lieàn chaïy. Tuyeát Ñaäu noùi: "Chæ e lieàn laøm theá keùo cung, noùi: "Xem teân!" Tam Bình          ngoaì ba böôùc chaúng soáng." Khi aáy neáu nhaûy ra vaïch ngöïc noùi: "Ñaây laø teân gieát ngöôøi hay teân         ngoaøi naêm böôùc, ngöôøi trong thieân haï chaúng laøm soáng ngöôøi?" Thaïch Cuûng khaûy daây cung ba caùi.           gì ñöôïc y. Haøng taùc gia gaëp nhau, phaûi laø chuû Tam Bình leã baùi. Thaïch Cuûng noùi: "Ba möôi naêm            khaùch tröôùc sau laãn ñoái khoâng cho giaùn ñoaïn, môùi moät tröông cung hai muõi teân, ngaøy nay chæ baén             coù phaàn töï do töï taïi. Khi aáy vò Taêng naøy ñaõ khoâng ñöôïc nöûa ngöôøi thaùnh." Noùi xong lieàn beû gaõy cung       theå tröôùc sau, neân bò Tuyeát Ñaäu kieåm ñieåm —A teân. Veà sau Tam Bình thuaät laïi cho Ñaïi Ñieân              monk asked Yao Shan, "On a level field, in the nghe. Ñaïi Ñieân noùi: "Ñaõ laø teân soáng vì ngöôøi vì        shallow grass, the elk and deer form a herd: how sao nhaèm treân daây cung maø bieän?" Tam Bình                 can one shoot the elk of elks?" Yao Shan said, khoâng ñaùp ñöôïc. Ñaïi Ñieân noùi: "Ba möôi naêm sau          "Look, an arrow!" The monk let himself fall down. caàn ngöôøi cöû lôøi naøy cuõng khoù ñöôïc." Phaùp Ñaêng       Yao Shan said, "Attendant, drag this dead fellow coù laøm baøi tuïng: "Xöa coù thaày Thaïch Cuûng, gaùc         out." The monk then ran out. Yao Shan said, "This cung teân maø ngoài, nhö theá ba möôi naêm, tri aâm            fellow playing with a mud ball; what end will khoâng moät gaõ. Tam Bình truùng ñích laïi, cha con            there be to it?" Hsueh Tou commented saying, hôïp nhau hoøa, chín chaén suy nghó kyõ, nguyeân laø y         "Though he lived for three steps, after five steps baén ñaát." Taùc löôïc Thaïch Cuûng cuøng Döôïc Sôn laø        he had to die." According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi- moät loaïi, Tam Bình treân ñaûnh moân ñuû maét, nhaèm          Yen-Lu, in the Ts'ao Tung tradition this case is döôùi moät muõi teân lieàn truùng ñích. Gioáng nhö Döôïc       called "a question that uses things." It's also called Sôn noùi: "Xem teân!" Vò Taêng kia lieàn laøm con              "a question testing the host," used in order to höôu phoùng thaân nhaøo. Vò Taêng kia gioáng taùc gia,         illustrate his present state of mind. Ordinarily deer chæ laø coù ñaàu khoâng ñuoâi, ñaõ taïo loàng baãy coát gaøy   and elk are easy to shoot. Only the elk of elks, Döôïc Sôn. Ñaâu ngôø Döôïc Sôn laø taùc gia moät beà eùp       that is, the king among deer, is very difficult to ngaët phaûi ñi, noùi: "Thò giaû, loâi gaõ cheát naøy ra."      shoot. This king elk always sharpens his horns on Gioáng nhö baøy traän laïi tröôùc. Vò Taêng kia lieàn          the rocks of the cliffs where it lives, so that they chaïy. Cuõng toát, phaûi thì phaûi vaãn laø khoâng thaûnh      become sharp as sword blades. He defends the thôi, dính chaân dính tay. Vì theá Döôïc Sôn noùi: "Keû        herd of deer with his own body so that even tigers chôi ñaát coù bao nhieâu haïng?" Khi aáy neáu Döôïc            cannot come near. Likewise, this monk seems Sôn khoâng coù lôøi noùi sau, seõ muoân ñôøi bò ngöôøi         intelligent and alert as he draws on this to question kieåm ñieåm. Döôïc Sôn noùi xem teân, vò Taêng naøy            Yao Shan to reveal what he would do first. Yao lieàn nhaøo, haõy noùi laø hieåu hay chaúng hieåu? Neáu laø    Shan said, "Look, an arrow!" An expert Teaching hieåu, taïi sao Döôïc Sôn laïi noùi keû chôi ñaát? Caùi        Master, he is undeniably marvellous, like sparks naøy raát aùc. Gioáng nhö vò Taêng hoûi Ñöùc Sôn: "Hoïc        struck from stone, like a flash of lightning. Haven't nhôn nöông kieám Maïc Da muoán laáy ñaàu thaày thì             you heard about what happened when San P'ing theá naøo?" Ñöùc Sôn ñöa coå ra noùi: "Heø!" Vò Taêng          first called on Shih Kung? As soon as Kung saw noùi: "Ñaàu thaày ruïng." Ñöùc Sôn cuùi ñaàu ñi veà            him coming, he immediately went through the phöông tröôïng. Laïi Nham Ñaàu hoûi moät vò Taêng:             motion of bending a bow and said, "Look, an "ÔÛ ñaâu ñeán?" Vò Taêng thöa: "Taây Kinh ñeán."               arrow!" San P'ing opened his breast to the "arrow" Nham Ñaàu hoûi: "Sau traän giaëc Hoaøng Saøo töøng             and said, "This is the arrow that kills the man; löôïm ñöôïc kieám chaêng?" Vò Taêng thöa: "Löôïm               what is the arrow that brings the man life?" Shih ñöôïc." Nham Ñaàu ñöa coå ra noùi: "Heø!" Vò Taêng             Kung plucked the bowstring three times, noùi: "Ñaàu thaày ruïng." Nham Ñaàu cöôøi ha haû! Loaïi        whereupon San P'ing bowed in homage. SHih coâng aùn naøy troïn laø maùy gaøi coïp. Chính so vôùi choã    Kung said, "After thirty years with a single bow naøy gioáng nhau. Döôïc Sôn chaúng quaûn y, chæ vì             and two arrows, today I've finally managed to bieát ñöôïc phaù, neân eùp y phaûi ñi. Tuyeát Ñaäu noùi:       shoot half a sage." Then he broke his bow and "Vò Taêng naøy ba böôùc tuy soáng, naêm böôùc phaûi            arrows. Later San P'ing took this up with Ta Tien. cheát." Vò Taêng naøy tuy raát gioûi xem teân, phoùng          Ta Tien said, "Since it is the arrow that brings

people life, why draw it on a bowstring?" San          steps, after five steps he had to die." Although this P'ing was speechless. Ta Tien said, "Thirty years      monk knew very well how to look at the arrow, he hence it will still be hard to find someone to raise   immediately let himself fall down; when Yao these words." Fa Teng had a verse saying: "On the      Shan said, "Attendant, drag this dead fellow out," old days we had Master Shih Kung; setting his          he immediately ran out. Hsueh Tou says, "I'm bow and arrows, he sat. He went on like this for       afraid he won't live beyond three steps." If the thirty years; not a single one understood until San    monk had leaped beyond five steps at that time, P'ing came and hit the target, and father and son      no one in the world would have been able to reach harmony. Thinking back carefully, I see that     handle him. In a meeting of adepts, from from the beginning, they were shooting the mound       beginning to end there must be an uninterrupted instead of the target on it." Shih Kung's strategy     interchange of guest and host; only then is there a was the same as Yao Shan's. San P'ing had an eye       share of freedom and independence. Since at that on his forehead, so he hit the target immediately      time the monk wasn't able to continue from given a single phrase. It was just like Yao Shan       beginning to end, consequently he meets with saying, "Look, an arrow!" and this monk then           Hsueh Tou's censure. letting himself fall down, playing the elk. This       Coâng AÙn Döôïc Sôn Thaêng Toøa: Coâng aùn Thieàn monk seemed to be an adept too, but it's just that     sö Döôïc Sôn Duy Nghieãm Thaêng Toøa —The koan he had a head but no tail. Once he had set his trap,   of Zen master Yao-shan Wei-yen's ascending the he wanted to make Yao Shan fall in. But what           seat—Theo Thong Dong Luïc, moät hoâm vò Sö could he do? Yao Shan was an adept and kept on         Giaùm Vieän ñeán baùo caùo vôùi Thieàn sö Döôïc Sôn pressing relentlessly. When Yao Shan said,             Duy Nghieãm raèng: "Baïch Thaày, cuõng ñaõ laâu Thaày "Attendant, drag this dead fellow out," it was as if   khoâng thöôïng ñöôøng thò chuùng." Döôïc Sôn beøn he was extending his battle lines forward. This        thöôïng ñöôïng, thaêng toøa, vaø noùi: "Naøo, baây giôø monk then ran out: he may have been right, but         haõy rung chuoâng trieäu taäp ñaïi chuùng ñeán saûnh nonetheless he wasn't free and clean, his hands        ñöôøng." Khi moïi ngöôøi ñaõ vaân taäp veà saûnh ñöôøng, and feet were stuck. That's why Yao Shan said,         vò Sö Giaùm Vieän nhaéc Thaày laø moïi ngöôøi ñang ñôïi "This fellow playing with a mud ball; what end         thaày chæ daïy. Döôïc Sôn vaãn ngoài im moät luùc, roài will there be to it?" If Yao Shan hadn't had the       thình lình xuoáng toøa vaø rôøi khoûi saûnh ñöôøng. Vò Sö final word at that time, he would have been            Giaùm Vieän beøn ñi theo sau vaøo phoøng cuûa Thaày criticized by others down through the ages. Yao        vaø hoûi: "Thaày ñaõ höùa ban cho chuùng con baøi phaùp, Shan said, "Look, an arrow!" Whereupon this            maø taïi sao Thaày khoâng noùi moät lôøi naøo heát vaäy?" monk fell down. Tell me, was this understanding        Döôïc Sôn noùi: "Kinh thì coù Kinh sö; Luaät thì coù or not? If you say it was understanding, why then      Luaät sö; Luaän thì coù Luaän sö, vaäy thì maáy oâng coøn did Yao Shan speak of him this way, as a fellow        troâng mong gì ôû laõo Taêng?"—According to the playing with a mud ball? This was extremely evil,      Ts’ung-Jung-Lu (Shoyo roku (jap), one day the just like the following: A monk asked Te Shan,         warden monk of the monastery came to report to "How is it when a student holding a sharp sword        the master, saying, "Master, it has been sometime tries to take the Master's head?" Te Shan              that you have not entered the hall and addressed extended his neck forward toward him and               the assembly." Yao-shan entered the hall, shouted. The monk said, "The Master's head has         ascended the seat, and said, "All right, let's ring fallen. Yen T'ou extended his neck forward             the bell to assemble everybody to the hall." When toward him and shouted. The monk said, "The            everybody was there, the warden monk reminded Master's head has fallen." Yen T'ou laughed            the master that the assembly was waiting for his loudly. Cases of this kind are all traps to fell       instructions. Yao-shan remained silent for a while, tigers, just like the present main case. Fortunately   and then, all of a sudden, he descended the seat Yao Shan wasn't taken in by this monk; since he        and left the hall without saying a word. The saw through him, he just kept on passing. Hsueh        warden monk of the monastery followed Yao-shan Tou says, "Although this monk lived for three          to his room and asked, "Master, you just promised

to give us a lecture, why didn't you say a word?"           family customs and habits (family tradition)— Yao-shan said, "For sutras, we have Sutra-                  Theo Nguõ Ñaêng Hoäi Nguyeân, quyeån XIV, moät masters; for Vinaya, we have Vinaya-masters; for            hoâm, coù moät vò Taêng hoûi Ñaïi Döông Kænh Huyeàn: Sastras, we have Sastra-masters, what do you                “Theá naøo laø gia phong Ñaïi Döông?” Ñaïi Döông expect this old monk to say?"                               Kænh Huyeàn ñaùp: “Bình ñaày nghieâng chaúng ñoå, Coâng AÙn Ñaïi Chöùng Chæ Thaïch Sö Töû: Coâng aùn          khaép nôi chaúng ngöôøi ñoùi.”—According to veà Hueä Trung chæ con sö töû ñaù—The koan of Hui-          Wudeng Huiyuan, volume XIV, one day, a monk chung's pointing at the stone lion—Theo Truyeàn             asked T’a-Yang: “What is the master’s family Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån V, moät hoâm, vua Ñöôøng Tuùc            style?” T’a-Yang said: “A full pitcher that can’t be Toâng vaø Hueä Trung ñang ñi daïo tröôùc cung ñieän,        emptied. Across the great earth, no one hungry.” Hueä Trung chæ con sö töû ñaù vaø thænh nhaø vua cho        Coâng AÙn Ñaïi Ñieân Löông Cöûu Cô Duyeân: Coâng moät chuyeån ngöõ. Tuùc Toâng baûo: "Traãm khoâng noùi      aùn Ñaïi Ñieân yeân laëng—The koan of Ta-Tien-Pao- ñöôïc, vaäy thænh Quoác Sö noùi." Hueä Trung noùi:          Tung's remaining silent—Theo Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, "Sôn Taêng ñaéc toäi vaäy." Veà sau naøy Ñam Nguyeân        quyeån XVI, sau khi lui veà aån cö ôû Linh Sôn, moät ÖÙng Chaân hoûi Hueä Trung: "Vaäy Hoaøng ñeá Tuùc           hoâm, coù moät vò quan vieân ñeán hoûi sö: "Hoøa Toâng coù hieåu vaán ñeà hay khoâng?" Hueä Trung noùi:      Thöôïng, thænh Thaày noùi cho chuùng con bieát moät lôøi "Vieäc aáy haõy gaùc laïi, coøn oâng hieåu theá naøo?"—     veà yeáu nghóa cuûa gia phong cuûa Thaày." Ñaïi Ñieân According to The Records of the Transmission of             ngoài yeân. Thò giaû cuûa Sö laø Tam Bình Nghóa Trung the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), Volume V, one day,               goõ vaøo saøng thieàn ba caùi. Sö beøn hoûi: "Caùi gì Emperor Su Tsung and Hui-Chung were walking                 vaäy?" Nghóa Trung thöa: "Tröôùc do ñònh cheá ñoäng, in the front of the royal palace. Hui-Chung pointed         sau duøng trí nhoå" Vò quan vieân laøm leã noùi: "Moân at a stone lion and asked Emperor Su Tsung to               phong cuûa Hoøa Thöôïng cao vuùt, ñeä töû töø nôi Thaày give a turning word. Emperor Su Tsung said, "I              thò giaû môùi coù theå vaøo ñöôïc."—According to The can't, invite Kuo-Shih to give one." Hui-Chung              Records of the Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan- said, "This mountain monk is guilty." Later, Tan-           Teng-Lu), Volume XVI, even after his retirement yuan-Ying-cheân asked Hui-Chung, "Did Emperor               in Ling-chou, one day, a local mandarin came and Su Tsung understand the matter?" Hui-Chung said,            asked Ta-Tien, "Master, would you please teach "Let's not talk about that, now I want to know how          us just one words of the essence of your family do you understand this matter?"                             tradition." Ta-Tien remained silent. His attendant, Coâng AÙn Ñaïi Döông Caûnh: Coâng aùn veà Caûnh             San-ping struck on his meditation seat three times. Ñaïi Döông—The koan on T’a-Yang’s state of                  Ta-Tien asked, "What's that?" San-ping said, being—Theo Nguõ Ñaêng Hoäi Nguyeân, quyeån XIV,             "First, utilization of a motion determination; then, moät hoâm, coù moät vò Taêng hoûi Ñaïi Döông Kænh           utilzation wisdom to uproot it." The local Huyeàn: “Theá naøo laø caûnh Ñaïi Döông?” Sö ñaùp:          mandarin said, "Master, your family tradition is so “Haïc coâi vöôïn laõo keâu hang doäi, tuøng gaày truùc      lofty, your disciple must rely on the attendant to laïnh toûa khoùi xanh.” Vò sö hoûi: “Theá naøo laø ngöôøi   be able to get into it."—See Trieàu Chaâu Ñaïi Ñieân trong caûnh?” Ñaïi Döông Kænh Huyeàn hoûi: “Laøm            Thieàn Sö. gì? Laøm gì?”—According to Wudeng Huiyuan,                  Coâng AÙn Ñaïi Ñieân Minh Lieãu Chaân Taâm: The volume XIV, one day, a monk asked T’a-Yang:                 koan of Ta-Tien-Pao-Tung's realization of own “What is T’a-Yang’s state of being?” T’a-Yang               true Mind—Coâng aùn Ñaïi Ñieân bieát chaân taâm cuûa said: “A gaunt crane and an old ape call across the         chính mình. Theo Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån XVI, valley in harmony. A slender pine and the cold              sau khi lui veà aån cö ôû Linh Sôn, Taêng ñoà tuï taäp bamboo are enveloped in blue mist.” The monk                ñoâng. Moät hoâm, Thieàn sö Ñaïi Ñieân thöôïng ñöôøng said: “What about the person in that state?” T’a-           thò chuùng: "Ngöôøi muoán hoïc Ñaïo tröôùc heát phaûi Yang said: “What are you doing? What are you                bieát baûn Taâm cuûa chính mình. Ñem taâm ra maø baøy doing?”                                                     toû cho thaáy, môùi laø thaáy ñaïo. Nhöng nay laém keû vì Coâng AÙn Ñaïi Döông Gia Phong: Coâng aùn veà Gia           khoâng theå thaâm nhaäp taùnh theå cuûa vaïn vaät neân bò Phong Ñaïi Döông—The koan on T’a-Yang’s                     meâ hoaëc coi moät caùi nhöôùng maøy, moät caùi chôùp

maét, moät noùi, moät laëng, laø taâm yeáu cuûa Thieàn. Kyø   Ñaïi Long: "Saéc thaân baïi hoaïi, theá naøo laø Phaùp thaät, chöa phaûi laø troïn veïn. Ta nay vì maáy oâng maø     thaân kieân coá?" Ñaïi Long ñaùp: "Hoa nuùi nôû döôøng phaân minh noùi roõ ra. Ai naáy haõy laéng nghe. Chæ          gaám, nöôùc khe trong tôï chaøm." Theo Vieân Ngoä caàn tröø boû nhöõng voïng töôûng, voïng nieäm, kieán         trong Bích Nham Luïc, vieäc naøy neáu nhaèm treân löôïng, töùc laø Chaân Taâm cuûa maáy oâng. Taâm aáy          ngoân ngöõ maø tìm, gioáng nhö ñöa gaäy ñaäp maët cuøng vôùi traàn caûnh hoaøn toaøn khoâng giao thieäp, khi    traêng, chaúng dính daùng chuùt naøo. Coå nhaân phaân maáy oâng caâm laëng, giöõ gìn tòch tónh. Töùc Taâm laø       minh, noùi: "Muoán ñöôïc thaân thieát chôù ñem hoûi ñeán Phaät, khoâng ñôïi tu taäp ñoái trò. Côù sao vaäy? ÖÙng       hoûi. Vì sao? Vì hoûi taïi choã ñaùp, ñaùp taïi choã hoûi." theo cô, tuøy vaät chieáu, laïnh luøng hoaït duïng, töï       Vò Taêng naøy gaùnh moät gaùnh loã maõng, ñoåi moät khôûi. Coäi nguoàn thaêm thaúm cuûa taát caû nhöõ ng hoaït    gaùnh hoà ñoà, ñaët caâu hoûi hö dôû chaúng ít. Neáu chaúng duïng naøy vöôït ngoaøi khaùi nieäm tìm thaáy trong kinh      phaûi laø Ñaïi Long ñaâu ñöôïc che trôøi che ñaát. Kia luaän. Caùi dieäu duïng aáy ta goïi laø Baûn Taâm. Naøy,      hoûi theá aáy, Ñaïi Long ñaùp theá aáy, moät hôïp töôùng, haõy neân giöõ gìn, ñöøng ñeå dong ruoåi."—The koan           laïi chaúng dôøi ñoåi moät maûy tô. Gioáng nhö thaáy thoû of Ta-Tien-Pao-Tung's realization of own true                 thaû chim öng, xem loã ñaët choát. Ba thöøa möôøi hai Mind. According to The Records of the                         phaàn giaùo laïi coù thôøi tieát naøy chaêng? Quaû thöïc kyø Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu),                    ñaëc, chæ laø ngoân ngöõ voâ vò bít laáp mieäng ngöôøi. Volume XVI, even after his retirement in Ling-                Theá neân noùi: "Moät maûnh maây traéng mieäng hang chou he was besieged by monks. One day, Zen                   khuaát, chim veà queân toå bieát laø bao?" Coù ngöôøi noùi master Ta-Tien entered the hall and addressed the             chæ laø tuøy tieän ñaùp suoâng maø thoâi. Neáu hieåu theá aáy monks, saying, "Those who wish to master the                  troïn laø keû dieät doøng hoï Thích. Ñaâu chaúng bieát coå truth must know first what is their own original              nhaân moät cô moät caûnh phaù goâng ñaäp xieàng, moät Mind. This is attained when it is pointed out by              caâu moät lôøi oâm vaøng chöùa ngoïc. Neáu laø maét laõo means of its forms and manifestations. But most               thieàn Taêng coù khi naém ñöùng, coù khi buoâng ñi, people nowadays, being unable to penetrate into               chieáu duïng ñoàng thôøi, nhôn caûnh ñeàu ñoaït, song the very essence of things, are falsely led to take           phoùng song thaâu, gaëp thôøi thoâng bieán. Neáu khoâng a mere raising of the eyebrows, glancing this way             ñaïi duïng ñaïi cô, ñaâu hieåu phuû trôøi che ñaát nhö theá. and that way, remaining silent, or uttering a word,           Gioáng nhö göông saùng treân ñaøi Hoà ñeán hieä n Hoà, for the finality of Zen truth. In point of fact, this is      Haùn ñeán hieän Haùn. Coâng aùn naøy cuøng "Thöôïc Lan far from being satisfactory. I will tell you now              Hoa" moät loaïi, song yù laïi chaúng ñoàng. Choã hoûi cuûa most plainly how to proceed in this matter, and               vò Taêng chaúng roõ, choã ñaùp cuûa Ñaïi Long raát hay. you will listen attentively. Only when all your               Moät vò Taêng hoûi Vaân Moân: "Khi laù ruïng caønh khoâ erroneous imaginations, thought-constructions, and            thì theá naøo?" Vaân Moân ñaùp: "Thaân baøy gioù thu." experiences are put aside, will you come to the               Ñaây goïi laø hai muõi teân choáng nhau. Vò Taêng hoûi realization of your true Mind. This Mind has                  Ñaïi Long: "Saéc thaân baïi hoaïi, theá naøo laø Phaùp nothing to do with a world of defilements, with               thaân kieân coá?" Ñaïi Long ñaùp: "Hoa nuùi nôû döôøng your being silent, with your holding on to                    gaám, nöôùc khe trong tôï chaøm." Döôøng theå anh ñeán quietude. Mind is no other than Buddha, and there             Taây Taàn, toâi ôû Ñoâng Loã. Kia ñaõ ñi theá aáy, toâi is in it no artifice, no elaboration. Why? It                 chaúng ñi theá aáy, cuøng vôùi Vaân Moân moät khoái traùi responds to calls, it illuminates objects as they             nhau. Gaõ kia ñi theá aáy laø deã thaáy, gaõ naøy chaúng ñi come, and its functions are cool and self-                    theá aáy laïi khoù thaáy. Quaû thöïc ba taác löôõi cuûa Ñaïi originating. The mysterious source of all these               Long raát vi teá—According to example 82 of the activities is beyond conception found in the sutras           Pi-Yen-Lu, a monk asked Ta Lung, "The physical and sastras. And we call this mystery our own                 body rots away: what is the hard and fast body of original Mind. Take heed, monks, not to let it                reality?" Ta Lung said, "The mountain flowers wander away from your hold."                                  bloom like brocade, the valley streams are Coâng AÙn Ñaïi Long Kieân Coá Phaùp Thaân: Ta                 brimming blue as indigo." According to Yuan-Wu Lung's Hard and Fast Body of Reality—Theo thí                 in the Pi-Yen-Lu, if you go to the words to search duï thöù 82 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Coù moät vò Taêng hoûi       for this thing, it's like trying to hit the moon by

waving a stick; you won't make any connection.        streams are brimming blue as indigo." This is just An Ancient clearly stated, "If you want to attain     like "you go west to Ch'in, I go east to Lu": since Intimacy, don't ask with questions. Why? Because      he acts this way, I don't act this way. Matching Ta the question is in the answer and the answer is in    Lung's answer with Yun Men's, they're opposites. the question." This monk picked up a load of          It's easy to see Yun Men acting thus, but it's hard crudeness and exchanged it for a load of              to see Ta Lung acting otherwise. Nevertheless, Ta confusion: in posing this question, his defeat was    Lung's tongue is very subtle—See Voâ Khoång not slight. How could anyone other than Ta Lung       Ñòch. manage to cover heaven and cover earth? The           Coâng AÙn Ñaïi Ngu Tam Quyeàn: The koan of Lin- monk asking this way and Ta Lung answering this       Chi's Lin-Chi hitting T’a-Wu on the side three way is a single whole. Ta Lung didn't move a          times—Coâng aùn Laâm Teá ñaám Ñaïi Ngu ba ñaám. hair's breadth: it was like seeing a rabbit and       Theo Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån XII, Laâm Teá töø giaû releasing a falcon, like seeing a hole and putting    Hoaøng Baù ñeå ñi ñeán choã Ñaïi Ngu. Ñaïi Ngu hoûi: in a plug. Is this time a season in the twelve-part   “ÔÛ choã naøo ñeán?” Sö thöa: “ÔÛ Hoaøng Baù ñeán.” canon of the Triple Vehicle? Undeniably his           Ñaïi Ngu hoûi: “Hoaøng Baù coù daïy gì khoâng?” Sö answer was extraordinary, it's just that his words    thöa: “Con ba phen hoûi ñaïi yù Phaät phaùp, ba laàn bò have no flavor and he blocks up people's mouths.      ñaùnh. Chaúng bieát con coù loãi hay khoâng loãi?” Ñaïi Thus it is said, "When white clouds lie across the    Ngu noùi: “Baø giaø Hoaøng Baù ñaõ vì ngöôi chæ choã toät valley mouth, many birds returning by night can't     khoå, laïi ñeán trong aáy hoûi coù loãi khoâng loãi?” Ngay find their nests." Some say that this was just        caâu noùi aáy, sö ñaïi ngoä, thöa: “Xöa nay Phaät phaùp answering glibly. Those who understand in this        cuûa Hoaøng Baù khoâng nhieàu.” Ñaïi Ngu naém ñöùng fashion are nothing but exterminators of the          laïi, baûo: “Con quyû ñaùi döôùi saøng, vöøa noùi coù loãi Buddha's race. They are far from knowing that         khoâng loãi, giôø laïi noùi Phaät phaùp cuûa Hoaøng Baù with one device and one objective, the Ancients       khoâng nhieàu. Ngöôi thaáy ñaïo lyù gì, noùi mau! Noùi broke fetters and smashed chains, that every word     mau!” Sö lieàn cho vaøo hoâng Ñaïi Ngu ba thoi. Ñaïi and phrase were pure gold and raw gems. If one        Ngu buoâng ra, noùi: “Thaày cuûa ngöôi laø Hoaøng Baù, has the eye and brain of a patchrobed monk,           chaúng can heä gì vieäc cuûa ta.” Sau ñoù Sö töø taï Ñaïi sometimes he holds fast and sometimes he lets go.     Ngu trôû veà Hoaøng Baù—The koan of Lin-Chi's Lin- Shining and functioning at the same time, with        Chi hitting T’a-Wu on the side three times. both persons and objects taken away, both sides       According to The Records of the Transmission of let go and both sides gather in. Facing the           the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), Volume XII, when situation, he changes accordingly. Without the        Lin-Chi reached T’a-Wu, T’a-Wu said: “Where great function and great capacity, how could he be    have you come from?” Lin-Chi said: “From able to enclose heaven and earth like this? Much      Huang-Po.” T’a-Wu said: “What did Huang-Po as a bright mirror on its stand: when a foreigner     say?” Lin-Chi said: “Three times I asked him comes, a foreigner appears, and when a native         about the essential doctrine and three times I got comes, a native appears. This case is the same as     hit. I don’t know if I made some error or not.” T’a- the story of the Flower Hedge, though the             Wu said: “Huang-Po has old grandmotherly meaning is not the same. Here the monk's              affection and endures all the difficulty for your question was ignorant, so Ta Lung's answer was        sake, and here you are asking whether you’ve exactly appropriate. Haven't you heard this story?    made some error or not!” Upon hearing these A monk asked Yun Men, "How is it when the tree        words Lin-Chi was awakened. Lin-Chi then said: withers and the leaves fall?" Yun Men said, "The      “Actually, Huang-Po’s Dharma is not so great.” body exposed in the golden wind." This is called      T’a-Wu grabbed him and said: “Why you little "Arrowpoints meeting." Here the monk asked Ta         bed-wetter! You just came and said: you don’t Lung, "The physical body rots away: what is the       understand. But now you say there’s not so much hard and fast body of reality?" Ta Lung said, "The    to Huang-Po’s teaching. What do you see? Speak! mountain flowers bloom like brocade, the valley       Speak!” Lin-Chi then hit T’a-Wu on his side three

times. T’a-Wu let go of him, saying: “Your                Coâng AÙn Ñaïo Ngoâ Nhaát Gia Ñieáu UÛy: Ñaïo Ngoâ teacher is Huang-Po. I’ve got nothing to do with          Baát Ñaïo Baát Ñaïo—The koan of T’ao-Wu's it.” Lin-Chi then left T’a-Wu and returned to             offering ritual objects to a deceased person—See Huang-Po.                                                 Ñaïo Ngoâ Nhaát Gia Ñieáu UÛy. Coâng AÙn Ñaïi Quang Daõ Hoà Tinh: Ta Kuang               Coâng AÙn Ñaïo Phoù Suùc Thuû: Coâng aùn Ñaïo Phoù Does a Dance—See Ñaïi Quang Daõ Hoà Tinh.                 ruùt tay—The koan of Tao-fu's withdrawing of his Coâng AÙn Ñaïi Quang Giaù Caù Thò Daõ Hoà Tinh:           hand—See Ñaïo Phoù Suùc Thuû. Ta Kuang Does a Dance—See Ñaïi Quang Daõ Hoà              Coâng AÙn Ñaït Ma Khueách Nhieân: Coâng aùn Boà Tinh.                                                     Ñeà Ñaït Ma Roãng Khoâng—The koan of Coâng AÙn Ñaïi Tuøy Hoûa Kieáp: Ta Sui's It Goes          Bodhidharma's vast emptiness—See Ñaït Ma Along With It—See Ñaïi Tuøy Hoûa Kieáp.                   Khueách Nhieân. Coâng AÙn Ñaïi Tuøy OÂ Qui: Coâng aùn con ruøa Ñaïi       Coâng AÙn Ñaâu Suaát Tam Quan: Ba cöûa aûi cuûa Tuøy—The koan of Ta-sui's black tortoise—See              Ñaâu Suaát—Tou-shuai's Three Barriers—See Ñaâu Ñaïi Tuøy OÂ Qui.                                         Suaát Tam Quan. Coâng AÙn Ñan Haø Khieát Phaïn Daõ Vò: The koan           Coâng AÙn Ñaàu Töû Ngöu Taïi: The koan of T'ou- of Tan Hsia's questioning a monk: Have you eaten          tzu's "cow is still here"—See Ñaàu Töû Ngöu Taïi. yet or not?—See Khieát Phaïn Daõ Vò.                      Coâng AÙn Ñaàu Töû Nhaát Thieát Phaät AÂm: T'ou Coâng AÙn Ñan Haø Thieân Nhieân: Coâng AÙn Ñan            Tzu's All Sounds are Sounds of Buddha—See Ñaàu Haø Töï Nhieân—The koan of Tan Hsia's being               Töû Nhaát Thieát Phaät AÂm. natural—See Ñan Haø Thieân Nhieân.                        Coâng AÙn Ñaàu Töû Nhaát Thieát Phaät Thanh: Coâng Coâng AÙn Ñan Haø Thieâu Phaät: Coâng aùn Ñan Haø         aùn cuûa Ñaàu Töû: "Taát caû aâm thanh ñeàu laø aâm thanh Ñoát Töôïng Phaät—The koan of Tan Hsia's burning          cuûa ñöùc Nhö Lai"—T'ou-tzu's all the sounds are a wooden buddha statue—See Ñan Haø Thieâu                 the Buddha’s sound (voice of the Buddha)—See Phaät.                                                    Ñaàu Töû Nhaát Thieát Phaät AÂm. Coâng AÙn Ñaïo Ñaéc Töùc Moân Khai: Say the right         Coâng AÙn Ñaàu Töû Thaäp Thaân Ñieàu Ngöï: Tou word and I will open the door—See Ñaïo Ñaéc Töùc          Tzu: Ten Buddha-bodies—See Ñaàu Töû Thaäp Thaân Moân Khai.                                                Ñieàu Ngöï. Coâng AÙn Ñaïo Ngoâ Khaùn Beänh: T’ao-Wu: To see          Coâng AÙn Ñaäu Ñoäc: Phaät Nhaät: Haït ñaäu ñang noå a doctor—Theo Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån XIV,             laùch taùch—Fo-Ru: A pea is decrepitating—See moät hoâm, Qui Sôn Linh Höïu hoûi Ñaïo Ngoâ: “ÔÛ ñaâu     Ñaäu Ñoäc. ñeán?” Sö ñaùp: “Khaùn beänh ñeán.” Qui Sôn Linh          Coâng AÙn Ñeä Nhöùt Nghóa Ñeá: Bodhidharma's Höïu hoûi: “Coù bao nhieâu ngöôøi beänh?” Sö ñaùp: “Coù   koan of the Highest Meaning of the Holy Truth— ngöôøi beänh, coù ngöôøi chaúng beänh.” Qui Sôn Linh      See Ñeä Nhöùt Nghóa Ñeá (2). Höïu noùi: “Coù ngöôøi khoâng beä nh ñaâu khoâng phaûi    Coâng AÙn Ñòa Taïng Chuûng Ñieàn: The koan about Trí ñaàu ñaø?” Sö ñaùp: “beänh cuøng chaúng beänh ñeàu    ploughing the soil and eating meals—See Ñòa khoâng can heä vieäc ñoù, noùi mau! Noùi mau!”—           Taïng Chuûng Ñieàn. According to The Records of the Transmission of           Coâng AÙn Ñình Tieàn Baùch Thuï: The Oak Tree in the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), Volume XIV, one                the Courtyard—See Ñình Tieàn Baùch Thuï. day, Kui-Shan asked T’ao-Wu: “Where did you               Coâng AÙn Ñoâng Qua AÁn Töû: The winter melon go?” T’ao-Wu said: “To see a doctor.” Kui-Shan            seals—See Ñoâng Qua AÁn Töû. asked: “How many people are sick?” T’ao-Wu                Coâng AÙn Ñoâng Sôn Haønh Taïi Thuûy Ba Thöôïng: said: “Some are sick, some are not.” Kui-Shan             The Eastern Mountains move over the waves— said: “Is the one who is not sick Ascetic Chih?”          See Ñoâng Sôn Haønh Taïi Thuûy Ba Thöôïng. T’ao-Wu said: “Is one who is not sick has nothing         Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Dung Döông Coå Loä, Baát Ñoïa to do with it, say quickly! Say quickly!”                 Tieáu Nhaân Cô: Shou-shan: In deportment, uphold Coâng AÙn Ñaïo Ngoâ Nguõ Phong: The koan of               the ancient road, not letting silent function fall— T’ao-Wu and Wu-feâng Ch'ang-kuan—See Ñaïo Ngoâ Nguõ Phong.

See Ñoäng Dung Döông Coå Loä, Baát Ñoïa Tieáu        Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Sôn Thuøy Ngöõ: T’ung-Shan's Nhaân Cô.                                            instructions—See Ñoäng Sôn Thuøy Ngöõ. Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Sôn Baát An: T’ung-Shan's            Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Sôn Thuûy Thaâm Thieån: T’ung- unease—See Ñoäng Sôn Baát An.                        Shan's "Is the water deep or shallow?"—See Ñoäng Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Sôn Cuùng Chaân: T’ung-Shan's        Sôn Thuûy Thaâm Thieån. celebrating an offering to Yun-yen's image—See       Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Sôn Thuyeát Taâm Thuyeát Tính: Ñoäng Sôn Cuùng Chaân.                               T’ung-Shan's talking about mind and nature—See Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Sôn Ñaïi Söï: T’ung-Shan's great     Ñoäng Sôn Thuyeát Taâm Thuyeát Tính. matter—See Ñoäng Sôn Ñaïi Söï.                       Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Sôn Thöôøng Thieát: T’ung-Shan's Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Sôn Ñaùo Ñænh Ma?: Ñoäng Sôn         talking about mind and nature—See Ñoäng Sôn ñeán ñænh hay khoâng?—T’ung-Shan's questioning a     Thöôøng Thieát. monk "Have you reached the peak?"—See Ñoäng          Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Sôn Tröø Danh: T’ung-Shan's Sôn Ñaùo Ñænh Ma?                                    elimination of fame—See Ñoäng Sôn Tröø Danh. Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Sôn Ñaøo Meã Thoaïi: T’ung-Shan's    Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Sôn Voâ Haøn Thöû: Tung Shan's straining the rice—See Ñoäng Sôn Ñaøo Meã Thoaïi.    No Cold or Heat—See Ñoäng Sôn Haøn Thöû. Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Sôn Ñòa Thaàn: T’ung-Shan's          Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Sôn Voâ Haøn Voâ Thöû: Tung Land Deity (Earth Spirit who controls the earth)—    Shan's No Cold nor Heat—See Ñoäng Sôn Haøn See Ñoäng Sôn Ñòa Thaàn.                             Thöû. Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Sôn Ñieåu Ñaïo: The path of          Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Sôn Voâ Thoán Thaûo: T’ung-Shan's birds—See Ñoäng Sôn Ñieåu Ñaïo.                      there's not an inch of grass—See Ñoäng Sôn Voâ Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Sôn Ñoäc Nhaõn: T’ung-Shan's         Thoán Thaûo. One Eye—See Ñoäng Sôn Ñoäc Nhaõn.                    Coâng AÙn Ñôn Haø AÊn Côm Roài Chöa?: Ñôn Haø Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Sôn Haøn Thöû: Tung Shan's No        Thöïc Phaïn Lieãu Moät Höõu?—See Ñan Haø Khieát Cold or Heat, example 43 of the Pi-Yen-Lu—See        Phaïn Daõ Vi. Ñoäng Sôn Haøn Thöû.                                 Coâng AÙn Ñôn Haø Thöïc Phaïn Lieãu Moät Höõu?: Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Sôn Ma Tam Caân: Tung-shan's         Ñôn Haø AÊn Côm Roài Chöa?—See Ñan Haø Khieát Three Pounds of Flax (Hemp), example 18 of the       Phaïn Daõ Vi. Wu-Men-Kuan—See Ma Tam Caân.                         Coâng AÙn Ñöùc Sôn Hieäp Phöùc Vaán Ñaùp: Te-Shan Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Sôn Phaát Tuï Xuaát Khöù: T’ung-     carrying His Bundle, example 4 of the Pi-Yen- Shan's moving his sleeves and leaving the            Lu—See Ñöùc Sôn Hieäp Phöùc Vaán Ñaùp. hall—See Löông Giôùi Phaát Tuï Xuaát Khöù.           Coâng AÙn Ñöùc Sôn Tam Thaäp Boång: Ba möôi Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Sôn Phaät Höôùng Thöôïng Söï:        heøo cuûa Ñöùc Sôn—Te-Shan's Thirty Blows—See T’ung-Shan's awakening that enlightenment is the     Ñöùc Sôn Tam Thaäp Boång. path of the inclination to the good—See Ñoäng Sôn    Coâng AÙn Ñöùc Sôn Tam Theá Baát Khaû Ñaéc: Te- Phaät Höôùng Thöôïng Söï.                            Shan's "Mind of the three times (past, present and Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Sôn Quaù Thuûy: T’ung-Shan's         future) cannot be attained ", example 4 of the Pi- crossing the river—See Ñoäng Sôn Quaù Thuûy Ngoä     Yen-Lu—See Ñöùc Sôn Tam Theá Baát Khaû Ñaéc. Ñaïo.                                                Coâng AÙn Ñöùc Sôn Thaùc Baùt: Te-Shan-Bowls in Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Sôn Quaù Thuûy Ngoä Ñaïo: T’ung-     Hand—See Ñöùc Sôn Thaùc Baùt. Shan's enlightenment when wading a river and         Coâng AÙn Giaùp Sôn Huy Kieám: Chia-shan's glimpsed his reflection in the water—See Ñoäng       throwing out his sword—See Giaùp Sôn Huy Kieám. Sôn Quaù Thuûy Ngoä Ñaïo.                            Coâng AÙn Gioù Ñoäng, Phöôùn Ñoäng: Gioù lay ñoäng Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Sôn Quaû Töû : T’ung-Shan's eating   hay phöôùn lay ñoäng—The wind is moving or the fruits—See Ñoäng Sôn Quaû Töû.                       flag is moving? —See Gioù Ñoäng, Phöôùn Ñoäng. Coâng AÙn Ñoäng Sôn Tam Ñoán: Tung-shan's Three      Coâng AÙn Haø Dieäp Ñoaøn Ñoaøn: Troøn nhö laù Cudgels (blows)—See Ñoäng Sôn Tam Ñoán.              sen—Chia-shan's "a lotus leaf is roundish"—As round as a lotus leaf—See Haø Dieäp Ñoaøn Ñoaøn.

Coâng AÙn Haø Tính: Tính gì?—What nature?—See                  had two wheels and an axle. The koâan asks, what Haø Tính.                                                      happens if you take off the two wheels and the Coâng AÙn Haø Xöù Lai? Haø Xöù Ñaùo?: Where do                 axle? The two wheels refer to the world of you come from? Where will you go?—See Haø Xöù                  dualism: one wheel is the absolute and the other Lai? Haø Xöù Ñaùo?                                             the relative. When you take off the two wheels, Coâng AÙn Haø Xöù Lai? Haø Xöù Khöù?: Where do                 you're left with the axle, the state of oneness, but you come from? Where will you go?—See Haø Xöù                  take away the axle too (the state of oneness as a Lai? Haø Xöù Ñaùo?                                             concept is still in the realm of dualism) and what is Coâng AÙn Haøi Töû Thöùc: Chao Chou's Newborn                  left? In Zen, when all notions have dropped away Baby—See Haøi Töû Thöùc.                                       is just the functioning of everything as it is, Coâng AÙn Haûo Söï Baát Nhö Voâ Söï: A good thing is           independent of our ideas of what they are or not better than nothing—It is better to go without             should be, now functioning freely because we are even a laudable thing—See Haûo Söï Baát Nhö Voâ                no longer bound by notions. In a sense it's Söï.                                                           confusing even to say that the axle and wheels Coâng AÙn Heà Troïng Taïo Xa: Hsi-Chung Builds                 remain, because they don't go anywhere! In Carts—Heà Troïng ñöôïc cho laø laøm ra moä t coã xe,           returning to their true nature, their boundlessly maø ngaøy ñoù coù hai baùnh xe vaø moät truïc. Coâng aùn       free functioning is vividly manifesting right here, hoûi, neáu boû ñi hai baùnh xe vaø moät truïc thì coøn laïi    right now. In our daily lives we function in the gì? Hai baùnh xe noùi veà theá giôùi cuûa nhò nguyeân:         world of dualism without any self-conscious moät baùnh laø caùi tuyeät ñoái vaø baùnh kia laø caùi töông   awareness that we are in the world of dualism. ñoái. Khi baïn boû ñi caû hai baùnh, baïn coøn laïi caùi       The very notion of dualism is just a notion; it truïc, traïng thaùi duy nhaát seõ coøn laïi gì (traïng thaùi   doesn't naturally come up. When self-conscious duy nhaát nhö laø moät khaùi nieäm thì vaãn coøn trong         awareness drops away altogether, we call this caûnh giôùi nhò nguyeân)? Trong Thieàn, khi moïi yù            functioning ordinary, pointing to the fact that it's nieäm rôi rôùt seõ chæ laø söï hoaït duïng cuûa moïi thöù      completely free of notions, including such exotic nhö chuùng ñang laø, khoâng phuï thuoäc vaøo yù töôûng         ones as absolute, relative, self, , and even the term cuûa chuùng ta vaø vieäc chuùng laø gì hay neân nhö theá       notion,, and even the term notion, etc. Zen naøo, giôø ñaây hoaït duïng töï do bôûi vì chuùng ta khoâng    practitioners should always remember that until coøn bò caâu thuùc bôûi caùc yù nieäm. Theo moät yù nghóa      we truly forget all these things (absolute, relative, naøo ñoù, thaäm chí noùi raèng caû truïc vaø baùnh xe ñeàu     self, and even the term notion), we are really coøn laïi cuõng laø laãn loän, vì chuùng khoâng ñi ñaâu caû!   treading on the Path of Enlightenment—See Heà Vôùi vieäc quy veà baûn chaát cuûa chuùng, söï hoaït duïng     Troïng Taïo Xa. töï do phi giôùi haïn cuûa chuùng seõ bieåu hieän soáng        Coâng AÙn Hoøa Sôn Nguõ AÂm: Ho-Shan's Knowing ñoäng ngay taïi ñaây, ngay luùc naøy. Trong cuoäc soáng        How to Beat the Drum—See Hoøa Sôn Nguõ AÂm. haèng ngaøy, chuùng ta hoaït duïng trong theá giôùi cuûa       Coâng AÙn Hoøa Thöôïng Daõ Tònh Khöôùc: Hoøa nhò nguyeân maø khoâng coù baát kyø nhaän thöùc naøo           Thöôïng Cuõng Phaûi Deïp Heát—You too, Most raèng chuùng ta ôû trong theá giôùi cuûa nhò nguyeân.          Venerable, should shut up—See Hoøa Thöôïng Daõ Chính yù nieäm veà nhò nguyeân cuõng chæ laø moät yù           Tònh Khöôùc. nieäm; noù khoâng töï nhieân xaûy ñeán. Khi nhaän thöùc        Coâng AÙn Hoûa Phong Vò Taùn: Phong Hoûa Vò hoaøn toaøn rôi rôùt, thieàn goïi caùch hoaït duïng naøy laø   Taùn—Wind and fire that have not yet dispersed— bình thöôøng, nhaèm chæ ñeán thöïc teá raèng noù hoaøn         See Hoûa Phong Vò Taùn. toaøn thoaùt khoûi yù nieäm, keå caû nhöõng yù nieäm nhö laø   Coâng AÙn Hoaøng Baù Chö Phaät Döõ Chuùng Sanh tuyeät ñoái, töông ñoái, caùi ngaõ, vaø ngay caû töø ngöõ yù   Thò Giaù Taâm: Chö Phaät vaø chuùng sanh chæ laø caùi nieäm, vaân vaân. Haønh giaû tu Thieàn neân luoân nhôù         taâm naøy—Huang-Po's all the Buddhas and raèng cho tôùi khi naøo chuùng ta thaät söï buoâng boû taát    sentient beings are nothing but one's mind—See caû nhöõng thöù aáy thì chuùng ta môùi thaät söï daãm böôùc    Hoaøng Baù Chö Phaät Döõ Chuùng Sanh Thò Giaù Taâm. treân con ñöôøng ñi ñeán giaùc ngoä—Hsi-chung                  Coâng AÙn Hoaøng Baù Traøng Töûu: Huang-Po's supposedly invented the cart, which in those days              Gobblers of Dregs—See Hoaøng Baù Traøng Töûu.

Coâng AÙn Hoaøng Baù Traøng Töûu Tao Haùn:                      words as an expression of apporval in Zen Huang-Po's Gobblers of Dregs—See Hoaøng Baù                     ostensible condemnation often indicates praise. Traøng Töûu.                                                    Unfortunately there is no way to tell how Daio Coâng AÙn Hoái Ñöôøng Moäc Teâ Höông: Hui-                      Kokushi himself interpreted the koan. According T’ang's fragrance of wild laurel—See Moäc Teâ                   to Wu Men Hui-Kai in the Wu-Men-Kuan, Kuo- Höông.                                                          shih called three times and his tongue fell out. His Coâng AÙn Hueä Sieâu Vaán Phaät: Hui-chao Asks                  attendant answered three times, and his responses about Buddha—See Hueä Sieâu Vaán Phaät.                         were brillant. Kuo-shih was old and feeling lonely. Coâng AÙn Hueä Trung Tam Hoaùn: Hui-Zhung                       He held the cow's head to make it eat grass. The Kuo-shih's Three Calls, example 17 of the Wu-                   attendant would have none of it. Delicious food Men-Kuan—Quoác Sö Tam Hoaùn, thí duï thöù 17                    does not attract a person who is full. Zen cuûa Voâ Moân Quan. Moät trong nhöõng coâng aùn noåi            practitioners, at what point was there any tieáng nhaát cuûa Hueä Trung laø “Ba laàn Quoác Sö goïi”        ingratitude to the other? cuûa Voâ Moân Quan 17. Ba laàn Quoác Sö goïi thò giaû           Coâng AÙn Hueä Trung Thaäp Thaân Ñieàu Ngöï: Hui cuûa mình vaø ba laàn ngöôøi naày ñaùp laïi. Quoác sö           Chung's Ten-Body Controller—See Hueä Trung noùi: “Cho ñeán baây giôø ta nghó raèng chính ta quay           Thaäp Thaân Ñieàu Ngöï. löng laïi phía con. Baây giôø ta môùi bieát raèng chính         Coâng AÙn Hueä Tö Hoùa Ñoä: Hui-Ssu: teaching and con quay löng laïi phía ta.” Coâng aùn naøy ñöôïc lyù           saving—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô duyeân vaán ñaùp giöõa giaûi theo nhieàu caùch khaùc nhau. Moät soá nhaø bình          Toân giaû Nam Nhaïc Hueä Tö vò toå thöù ba cuûa toâng luaän Thieàn tin raèng lôøi noùi cuûa Quoác Sö, neáu chæ        Thieân Thai vaø Baûo Chí. Theo Nguõ Ñaêng Hoäi ñöôïc naém baét baèng giaù trò ngoaøi maët thì thaáy Quoác      Nguyeân, quyeån II, moät hoâm, ngaøi Baûo Chí sai thò Sö hoaøn toaøn thaát voïng vì vò thò giaû khoâng naém baét      giaû ñeán hoûi Toân giaû Nam Nhaïc Hueä Tö taïi sao ñöôïc yù chæ cuûa Sö qua ba laàn goïi lieân tieáp. Nhöõng       ngaøi khoâng xuoáng nuùi giaùo hoùa chuùng sanh. Toân ngöôøi khaùc thì cho raèng Quoác Sö ñaõ ngaàm aán               giaû Nam Nhaïc Hueä Tö ñaùp: "Ba ñôøi chö Phaät bò ta chöùng cho vò thò giaû, raèng trong ngoân ngöõ Thieàn,          nuoát moät caùch heát saïch thì choã naøo coøn coù chuùng nhöõng lôøi noùi coù veû nhö cheâ traùch laïi thöôøng coù       sanh ñeå hoùa ñoä?"—The koan about the haøm yù khen ngôïi. Thaät khoâng may, khoâng coù caùch          potentiality and conditions of questions and gì ñeå cho chuùng ta bieát Quoác Sö dieãn giaûi coâng aùn       answers between Hui-Ssu, the third patriarch of naøy nhö theá naøo. Theo Voâ Moân Hueä Khai trong               the T’ien-T’ai school (if counted from Nagarjuna) Voâ Moân Quan, Quoác sö ba laàn laàn goïi, löôõi ruïng          and Pao-Chih. According to Wudeng Huiyuan, xuoáng ñaát. Ngöôøi thò giaû ba laàn daï, tuøy duyeân tuøy      volume II, one day, Zen master Pao-Chi instructed thuaän moät caùch saùng suoát. Quoác sö giaø nua vaø caûm       his attendant to come to ask Hui-Ssu the reason thaáy coâ ñoäc, ñeø ñaàu traâu xuoáng baét traâu aên coû. Thò   why he has not descended the mountain to teach giaû khoâng chòu. Cuûa ngon khoâng ñaùng cho ngöôøi             Zen doctrines to people. Hui-Ssu said, "I already ñaõ aên no. Haønh giaû tu thieàn, thöû hoûi ngöôøi thò giaû     swallowed Buddhas of the three generations (past, naày phuï loøng quoác sö choã naøo?—One of the most             present and future), where is there any beings left famous koans in which National Teacher appears                  for me to teach and save?" is “The National Teacher called three times.”                   Coâng AÙn Huyeàn Sa Nhaân Höõu Tam Beänh: (Wu-Men-Kuan 17): “Three times the National                     Hsuan Sha's Guiding and Aiding Living Beings— Teacher called his monastic servant and three                   See Huyeàn Sa Nhaân Höõu Tam Beänh. times the servant answered. The National Teacher                Coâng AÙn Huyeàn Sa Tam Chuûng Beänh Nhaân: said, ‘Until now I thought I was turning my back                Hsuan Sha's Guiding and Aiding Living Beings— on you. But it’s really you who are turning your                See Huyeàn Sa Nhaân Höõu Tam Beänh. back on me.’” Interpretations of this koan differ.              Coâng AÙn Huyeàn Sa Tòch Tònh Voâ Ngoân: Hsuan- Some commentators believe that the National                     Sha's sense of remaining quiet and without any Teacher's words are to be taken at face value and               words—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô duyeân khieán Thieàn sö that he was genuinely disappointed at the lack of               Huyeàn Sa Sö Bò khai thò ñaïi chuùng veà söï tòch tònh vitality in his attendant's response. Others see his            khoâng lôøi. Theo Nguõ Ñaêng Hoäi Nguyeân, quyeån

VII, moät hoâm, Huyeàn Sa thöôïng ñöôøng, ngoài treân           guiding and aiding living beings—See Huyeàn Sa thieàn saøng hoài laâu roài noùi: "Ta luoân luoân saün saøng    Nhaân Höõu Tam Beänh. vì maáy oâng, nhöng maáy oâng coù hieåu khoâng?" Moät           Coâng AÙn Huyeàn Sa Vaên Yeán Töû Thanh: Hsuan- vò Taêng hoûi: "Tòch tònh khoâng lôøi aáy laø yù gì?" Sö        Sha's listening to the sound of the swallows— noùi: "Caùi oâng noùi trong giaác nguû kìa!" Vò Taêng laïi      Coâng aùn noùi veà cô duyeân khieán Thieàn sö Huyeàn noùi: "Con mong thaày giaûng ñaïo Thieàn." Sö noùi:             Sa Sö Bò khai thò ñaïi chuùng khi Sö nghe tieáng chim "Taïi sao phaûi ngaùy?" Vò Taêng noùi: "Coù leõ con             yeán hoùt. Theo Nguõ Ñaêng Hoäi Nguyeân, quyeån VII, ngaùy, coøn Hoøa Thöôïng thì sao?" Sö baûo: "Sao laïi           moät hoâm, Huyeàn Sa thöôïng ñöôøng, roài ngoài treân khoâng bieát ngöùa nhæ?" Thieàn sö Huyeàn Sa soáng              thieàn saøng hoài laâu khoâng noùi moät lôøi. Sö chæ ngoài vaøo khoaûng cuoái nhaø Ñöôøng ñaàu nhaø Toáng. Luùc ñoù        laëng yeân nghe tieáng chim yeán ñang hoùt. Ñaïi chuùng thieân höôùng phaùt trieån cuûa giaùo phaùp Thieàn toâng        nghó raèng thaày seõ khoâng thuyeát phaùp neân nhaát teà laàn hoài thay theá caùc toâng phaùi khaùc ôû Trung Hoa.        ruùt lui. Sö quôû: "Xem ra, maáy oâng caù meø moät löùa. Nghóa laø thaùi ñoä Thieàn ñoái vôùi truyeàn thoáng, vaø        Chaúng coù laáy moät ngöôøi coù trí hueä. Khi thaáy ta môû trieát lyù ñaïo Phaät, coù khuynh höôùng coi nheï vieäc         mieäng ra, ai naáy keùo ñeán tìm lôøi, cho raèng ñoù laø hoïc hoûi theo thöù lôùp cuûa noù, lô laø kinh ñieån vaø caùc   chaân lyù toái thöôïng. Thaät ñaùng thöông, chaúng moät thöù sieâu hình trong kinh. Vaø vaøo thôøi ñoù, vieäc giöõ      ai hieåu caùi gì laø caùi gì caû. Thaät laø moät tai öông im laëng khoâng noùi moät lôøi trong moät thôøi khi             chöøng naøo maø maáy oâng vaãn cöù nhö theá naøy!"— thöôïng ñöôøng cuõng laø moät phöông caùch ñöôïc                The koan about the potentiality and conditions that nhieàu thieàn sö öa thích duøng ñeå daïy chuùng—The             caused Zen master Hsuan-Sha addressed the koan about the potentiality and conditions that                 assembly when he listened to the sound of the caused Zen master Hsuan-Sha addressed the                       swallows. According to wudeng Huiyuan, volume assembly about quietness and speechlessness.                    VII, one day, Hsuan-Sha entered the hall, then sat According to wudeng Huiyuan, volume VII, one                    quietly in his pulpit for some time without saying a day, Hsuan-Sha entered the hall, then sat quietly               word. He just remained silent and listened to the in his pulpit for some time and then said, "I have              sound of the swallows. The monks thought he was been thoroughly kind to you, but do you                         not going to give them a sermon and began to understand?" A monk asked, "What is the sense of                retire all at once. He then scolded them: "As I remaining quiet without uttering a word?" Hsuan-                observe, you are all of one pattern; not one of you Sha said, "How you talk in your sleep!" The monk                has sagacity enough to see things properly. You then said, "I wish you to tell me about the truth of            have come here to see me open my mouth, and, Zen." Hsuan-Sha said, "What is the use of                       taking hold of my words, imagine they are snoring?" The monk said, "I may snore, but how                  ultimate truths. It is a pity that you all fail to know about you?" Hsuan-Sha said, "How is it possible to              what's what. As long as you remain like this, what be so insensitive as not ro know where it itches?"              a calamity!" Zen master Hsuan-sha, who lived between late                    Coâng AÙn Höng Hoùa Ñaû Trung: Höng Hoùa ñaùnh T'ang and early Sung when the trend of                          ôû giöõa—Hsing-hua's striking in the middle—Coâng development of Zen teaching gradually                           aùn noùi veà cô duyeân vaán ñaùp giöõa Thieàn sö Höng superseded the other Buddhist schools in China. It              Hoùa Toàn Töông vaø moät vò Taêng. Theo Nguõ Ñaêng is to say, Zen attitude towards Buddhist lore and               Hoäi Nguyeân XI, moät hoâm, coù moät vò Taêng hoûi philosophy tended to slight its study in an orderly             Thieàn sö Höng Hoùa: "Khi töù phöông taùm höôùng manner, to neglect the sutras and what                          ñeán thì theá naøo?" Sö ñaùp: "Ñaùnh ôû khoaûng giöõa." metaphysics there is in them. And during that                   Vò Taêng beøn leã baùi roài lui ra. Nhöng coù gì can heä period of time, the keeping quiet in silence for                giöõa caâu traû lôøi cuûa thieàn sö Höng Hoùa vaø töù some time in the pulpit was a favorite method that              phöông taùm höôùng khoâng? Ñieàu naøy cho thaáy caùc many masters used to instruct their disciples.                  thieàn sö khoâng phaûi laø trieát gia maø laø nhöõng baäc Coâng AÙn Huyeàn Sa Tieáp Vaät Lôïi Sinh: Hsuan                 thöïc tu, neân hoï vieän daãn kinh nghieäm thay vì vieän Sha: The old adepts everywhere all speak of                     daãn baèng lôøi; moät kinh nghieäm voán laø caên baûn hoùa giaûi nhöõng nghi hoaëc thaønh moät nhaát theå hoøa ñieäu.

Taát caû caùc leõ ñöông nhieân cuõng nhö leõ baát khaû nôi      Nghieâm ñoaùn moäng—Hsiang-Yen's interpreting of nhöõng phaùt bieåu cuûa caùc thieàn sö phaûi ñöôïc coi laø      master Kuei-shan's dream—See Höông Nghieâm xuaát phaùt tröïc tieáp töø kinh nghieäm baát nhò saâu          Nguyeân Moäng. thaúm cuûa hoï. Vaø chuùng ta chæ coù theå hieåu chöøng         Coâng AÙn Höông Nghieâm: Nhö Nhaân Thuï naøo chuùng ta nhaûy vaøo moät caûnh giôùi vöôït leân kinh      Thöôïng, Khaåu Haøm Thuï Chi, Ñaùp Baát Ñaùp Tha nghieäm ñoái ñaõi cuûa mình. Haønh giaû chuùng ta cuõng         Sôû Vaán?: Man's hanging from a branch by his neân nhôù raèng caùc thieàn sö gheâ tôûm moïi thöù tröøu        teeth; respond or not respond to a question?—See töôïng vaø thuyeát lyù, neân ñoâi khi caùc caâu noùi cuûa hoï   Höông Nghieâm: Nhö Nhaân Thuï Thöôïng, Khaåu quaù ö loän xoän vaø voâ nghóa; ñoàng thôøi nhöõng caâu         Haøm Thuï Chi, Ñaùp Baát Ñaùp Tha Sôû Vaán? traû lôøi cuûa hoï luoân coù caùi loái ñoäc ñieäu cuûa chuû     Coâng AÙn Höông Nghieâm Thöôïng Thuï: Höông tröông sieâu nghieäm—The koan about the                         Nghieâm Leo Caây—Hsiang-Yen's Up a Tree—See potentiality and conditions of questions and                    Höông Nghieâm Thöôïng Thuï. answers between Zen master Hsing-hua and a                      Coâng AÙn Khaû Chaân Ñieåm Hung: Khaû Chaân chæ monk. According to Wudeng Huiyuan, volume XI,                   ngöïc—K'e-chen's pointing at the chest—See Khaû one day, a monk asked, "What happens when the                   Chaân Ñieåm Hung. four regions and eight directions arrive?" Zen                  Coâng AÙn Khai Môû Ñeä Tam Nhaõn: To open the master Hsing-hua answered, "Strike in the                       third eye—See Khai Môû Ñeä Tam Nhaõn. middle." The monk bowed and withdrew. But, is                   Coâng AÙn Khai Só Nhaäp Duïc: Bhadrapala and there any connection between master Hsing-hua's                 Sixteen Bodhisattvas Go In to Bathe—See Baït Ñaø answer and the four regions and eight directions?               Baø La Döõ Thaäp Luïc Boà Taùt Nhaäp Duïc. This proves that Zen masters are not philosophers               Coâng AÙn Khai Só Vaøo Taém: See Baït Ñaø Baø La but pragmatists, they appeal to an experience and               Döõ Thaäp Luïc Boà Taùt Nhaäp Duïc. not to verbalism; an experience which is so                     Coâng AÙn Khaéc Taân Xuaát Vieän: K'e-Hsin's fundamental as to dissolve all doubts into                      expulsion of the monastery—See Khaéc Taân Xuaát harmonious unfication. All the matter-of-fact-ness              Vieän. as well as the impossibility of the master's                    Coâng AÙn Khaâm Sôn Moät Muõi Teân Phaù Ba statements must thus be regarded as issuing Coång: Ch'in-shan-wen-sui's one Arrowpoint directly from their inmost unified experience. And Smashes Three Barriers—See Coâng AÙn Nhaát the above impossible condition so long as space- Phoác Phaù Tam Quan. time relations remain what they are to our final Coâng AÙn Khoaùi Tieän Nan Phuøng: An opportunity consciousness; they will only be intelligible when in a thousand years—Good opportunities that are we are ushered into a realm beyond our relative difficult to encounter in thousands of years—See experience. We, Zen practitioners, should Khoaùi Tieän Nan Phuøng. remember that Zen masters abhor all abstractions Coâng AÙn Veà “Khoâng”: Koan of Emptiness. and theorizations, so their propositions sound (I) Nhaän thöùc ñöôïc caùi “Khoâng” trong Thieàn— outrageously incoherent and nonsensical; at the Realization of “Emptiness” in Zen: Töø same time, their answers too, harp on the same “Khoâng” hay “Hö khoâng” ñaõ trôû neân noåi tieáng string of transcendentalism. laø moät coâng aùn cuûa Thieàn phaùi Laâm Teá, caùi Coâng AÙn Höông Laâm Toïa Cöûu Thaønh Lao: “Khoâng” cuûa Trieäu Chaâu Toøng Thaåm, vaø Ngoài laâu sanh meät nhöng maø thaønh töïu nhö Ngaøi chuùng ta coù theå noùi toaøn boä muïc ñích cuûa caùc Boà Ñeà Ñaït Ma—To accomplish one’s labour by tröôøng phaùi Thieàn laø nhaän thöùc cho ñöôïc caùi prolonged sitting, as did Bodhidharma—See “Khoâng.” Tuy nhieân, nguoàn goác cuûa khaùi Höông Laâm Toïa Cöûu Thaønh Lao. nieäm naøy khôûi söï ngay töø giaùo lyù caên baûn cuûa Coâng AÙn Höông Nghieâm Kích Truùc: Höông Ñöùc Phaät. Ñöùc Phaät ñaõ daïy raèng moïi hieän Nghieâm neùm gaïch chaïm buïi tre—Hsiang-Yen's töôïng ñeàu bò ñoùng bôûi boán daáu aán: voâ thöôøng, throwing a small piece of the tile and it struck a khoå, voâ ngaõ vaø khoâng. Taïi sao Ñöùc Phaät laïi stalk of bamboo—See Höông Nghieâm Kích Truùc. noùi veà söï troáng roãng cuûa taát caû caùc hieän Coâng AÙn Höông Nghieâm Nguyeân Moäng: Höông                         töôïng? Theo ñaïo Phaät, moïi hieän töôïng noåi

leân vaø toàn taïi qua söï taäp hôïp cuûa nhieàu thaønh      vaät maø chuùng ta goïi laø “ta” khi ñöôïc phaân tích phaàn khaùc bieät. Moïi vaät toàn taïi ñöôïc cuõng nhôø      cuõng tan bieán thaønh moät hình töôùng thieáu caùc vaät khaùc cho söï toàn taïi cuûa noù, maø khoâng       vaéng thöïc taïi toái haäu. Muïc ñích ñaàu tieân vaø coù ñöôïc coát tuûy baát bieán hieän thöïc ñoäc laäp, vaø    cuoái cuøng cuûa Thieàn laø nhaän thöùc ñöôïc raèng do ñoù, töï noù voán laø “khoâng”. Caùc hieän töôïng         moïi vaät laø “troáng roãng,” Nhöng söï nhaän thöùc ñeàu coù moät veû beà ngoaøi toàn taïi, nghóa laø            naøy phaûi do thöïc nghieäm, chöù khoâng phaûi do chuùng coù theå thaáy ñöôïc, nghe ñöôïc, sôø ñöôïc,          tri thöùc. Chæ khaúng ñònh raèng moïi vaät ñeàu song ngoaøi caùi veû beà ngoaøi naøy chuùng khoâng           troáng roãng vaãn chöa ñuû, chuùng ta coøn phaûi coù moät thöïc chaát beàn vöõng. Caùi thieáu thöïc           thaáy ñöôïc söï troáng roãng trong haønh ñoäng haèng chaát beàn vöõng naøy laø yù nghóa cuûa “Khoâng.”            ngaøy cuûa chuùng ta. Söï troáng roãng phaûi ñöôïc Theo Thieàn Sö Thích Thieân AÂn trong “Trieát                naém vöõng trong töøng luùc, khoâng moät thoaùng Lyù Thieàn-Thöïc Taäp Thieàn,” coù leõ khaùi nieäm           chaàn chöø. Ngaøy xöa coù moät thieàn sinh ñöôïc khoù hieåu veà “Khoâng” khoâng theå ñöôïc laøm               Thaày trao cho coâng aùn “Khoâng” ñeå tham cöùu. saùng toû baèng moät hay hai thí duï. Trong moät             Suoát nhieàu naêm trôøi oâng cöù nghieàn ngaãm coâng caên phoøng toái, neáu moät que nhang chaùy ñoû              aùn cho ñeán moät buoåi chieàu ngoài thieàn oâng ñöôïc quay voøng thaät nhanh, chuùng ta seõ thaáy            nghó laø mình ñaõ ngoä ñöôïc. OÂng lieàn chaïy ñi moät voøng saùng. Nhöng khi que nhang vöøa                   tìm thaày ñeå baùo caùo kinh nghieäm cuûa oâng, ngöøng quay thì voøng troøn löûa bieán maát. Daàu            nhöng oâng thaày laïi khoâng voäi khen taëng. Ngay voøng troøn coù hieån hieän vaø moïi ngöôøi ñeàu thaáy       khi vò thieàn sinh vöøa böôùc chaân vaøo phoøng roõ nhö vaäy, noù thaät ra chæ laø moät aûo giaùc do         thaày vaø gaàm leân moät tieáng “Khoâng” thaät lôùn, taâm taïo ra, Cuõng vì noù khoâng heà hieän höõu thaät       oâng thaày beøn caàm caây quaït ñaäp cho y moät caùi. söï, neân ngay khi voøng troøn löûa aáy coù maët, noù        Laäp töùc, vò thieàn sinh ñoû maët tía tai vì giaän. vaãn laø troáng roãng, noù vaãn laø “khoâng.” Cuõng          Thaáy theá vò thaày lieàn baûo: “Neáu quaû thaät con nhö vaäy, moïi hieän töôïng ñeàu laø “troáng roãng”          hieåu raèng moïi söï ñeàu laø khoâng, taïi sao con vì chuùng noåi leân ñöôïc nhôø nhöõng nguyeân nhaân          coøn giaän?” Vò thieàn sinh ngoä ngay trong caâu vaø ñieàu kieän. Töï chuùng, chuùng voán troáng roãng        noùi cuûa thaày. “Khoâng” phaûi ñöôïc soáng trong vaø khoâng coù thöïc chaát, gioáng nhö voøng troøn           doøng ñôøi cuûa chuùng ta töøng giaây töøng phuùt, löûa do que nhang quay nhanh taïo neân. Maët                 chöù khoâng phaûi chæ saép xeáp thaønh moät khaùi khaùc, caùc hieän töôïng laø troáng roãng vì chuùng          nieäm tröøu töôïng baèng kieán thöùc. Khi “Khoâng” phuø du. Caùc vaät ñeàu hoaïi dieät khi chuùng môùi          ñöôïc xem nhö moät khaùi nieäm chöù khoâng phaûi thaønh, vaø vì theá khoâng coù moät thöïc theå coá ñònh      laø moät thöïc theå soáng ñoäng, thì noù ñaõ maát. Chæ ñaèng sau nhöõng veû beà ngoaøi caûm xuùc ñöôïc              chôùp maét moät caùi laø chuùng ta ñaõ khoâng thaáy nhö chuùng ta thaáy chuùng. Vuõ truï hieän töôïng            ñöôïc. Moät ngöôøi coù theå hieåu thaáu ñaùo kieán nhö laø moät cuoán phim chieáu treân maøn aûnh               thöùc giaùo lyù veà “Khoâng,” nhöng neáu ngöôøi aáy traéng. Cuoán phim laø moät chuoãi lieân tuïc caùc           noåi giaän khi bò thoùa maï, lôùn tieáng khoe böùc aûnh luoân thay ñoåi. Vì voâ minh chuùng ta coù         khoang khi ñöôïc ca tuïng hay danh voïng, vaø theå chaáp vaøo nhöõng nhaân vaät treân maøn aûnh.           thaáy böïc boäi khi khoâng ñöôïc vöøa yù, thì khoâng Chuùng ta coù theå hoaëc khoùc theo hoï, töï haøo            theå noùi ngöôøi aáy ñaõ nhaän thöùc ñöôïc caùi hay caêng thaúng böùc xuùc theo hoaøn caûnh,                 “Khoâng”. “Khoâng” laø moät loái soáng nhieàu hôn nhöng nhö theá cuõng khoâng laøm cho hoï coù thaät           laø moät yù nghó. Moät ngöôøi soáng vôùi caùi ñöôïc, vaø moät khi maùy chieáu phim ngöng                   “Khoâng” coù theå khoâng giaûi thích ñöôïc noù, chieáu, thì taát caû nhöõng nhaân vaät maø chuùng ta         nhöng neáu ngöôì aáy thaät söï chöùng toû ñöôïc caùi ñaõ quyeán luyeán seõ tan bieán vaøo hö khoâng,              “Khoâng” naøy trong moïi luùc cuûa ñôøi soáng haèng ñem theo taát caû nhöõng vui buoàn, thöông, gheùt,           ngaøy thì ngöôøi aáy ñaõ thaønh töïu con ñöôøng tu nhöõng phieâu löu, uaån khuùc. Theá giôùi maø                ñaïo—The term “Emptiness” or “Nothingness” chuùng ta ñang soáng cuõng gioáng nhö moät cuoán             has become best known as a koan in Lin-Chi phim ñang chieáu treân maøn aûnh: phuø du, khoâng            Zen, Zhao-Chou-T’sung-Shen’s “Emptiness” thöïc chaát vaø troáng roãng. Ngay caû ñeán caùi sinh        (Mu), and it can indeed be said that the whole

aim of all school of Zen is to bring about the        pride or grow tense with excitement, but this realization of “Emptiness.” However, the              does not make them real, and once the origin of this concept goes back to the basic         projector stops, all these figures with whom teaching of the Buddha. The Buddha taught             we have been so deeply involved will vanish that all phenomena are branded with four              into nothingness, together with all their loves marks: impermanence, suffering, selflessness,         and hates, their joys and sorrows, and their and emptiness. Why does the Buddha say                ventures and intrigues. The world we are about the ‘emptiness’ of all phenomena?               living in is just like a movie on the screen: According to Buddhism, all phenomena arise            evanescent, insubstantial and void. Even this and exist through the combination of many             very being we call our “self” dissolves upon different elements. Since whatever exists             analysis into a mere appearance destitute of depends upon other things for its existence, it       final actuality. The first and final goal of Zen lacks an immutable core of independent                is to realize that everything is emptiness. But actuality and is therefore, considered in itself,     this realization must be experiential, not void. Phenomena possess a kind of apparent            merely intellectual. It is not enough to assert existence, in that they can be seen, heard,           that everything is empty; one must see into touched, etc., but beyond their status as             the fact of emptiness in all one’s daily appearances they have no substantial reality.         activities. Emptiness is to be grasped from the This lack of substantial reality is what              inside at each moment, without hesitation. signified by the word “Emptiness.” According          Once there was a Zen student who was to Zen Master Thich Thien An in “Zen                  studying the koan of “Emptiness” under a Philosophy-Zen Practice,” perhaps the                 master. He worked very hard on the koan for concept of “emptiness” is difficult to be             several years until, one evening in meditation, clarified by one or two illustrations. If in a        he believed that he had realized “Satori”. He dark room, a stick of burning incense is              ran to the master to report his experience, but twirled very rapidly, a circle of light is seen.      the master was not in a hurry to offer his But as soon as we stop the stick of burning           congratulations. As soon as the student incense, the circle of light disappears. Though       entered the master’s room and burst out with the circle was visible and everybody saw it as        a loud bellowing “Emptiness”, the master such, it was actually an illusion created by the      swatted him with his fan. Immediately the mind. Since it has no real existence, the circle      student’s face turned red with anger. Seeing even when present and visible is empty. In            this, the master added with a gentle smile: “If the same way, all phenomena are empty                 you really understand that everything is because they arise in dependence upon                 empty, why are you angry?” The student causes and conditions. In themselves they are         suddenly attained “satori” after hearing this. vacuous and insubstantial         as the circle       Emptiness must be lived in the stream of daily created by the twirling stick of burning              life flowing by us all the time and not forming incense. Again, phenomena are empty                   into an abstract concept by understanding. because they are evanescent. Things perish            When “emptiness” is grasped as a concept the moment they arise, and thus there is no           and not a living reality, it has been lost. With abiding     entity    behind     the    sensible      a blink of the eyes we have missed seeing. A appearances that present themselves to us.            man may have a thorough intellectual The phenomenal universe is like a film                understanding of the doctrine of emptiness, projected upon a blank screen. The film is a          but if he gets angry when insulted, clamors for continuous series of ever changing pictures.          praise and fame, and feels upset when he Through our ignorance we may become                   does not get his way, he cannot be said to attached to the figures on the screen. We may         have realized emptiness. Emptiness is not so laugh with them or cry with them, swell with          much an idea as it is a state of being. The man

who lives in “emptiness” may not be able to                       follows: "A monk asked master Chao-chou explain it, but if he can really demonstrate                      respectfully, 'Does a dog really have Buddha- “Empiness” in every phase of his day to day                       nature or not?' Chao-chou said, 'Mu!'" The life, he is an accomplished man of the Way.                       task of the student, while practicing sitting (II) Coâng AÙn "Khoâng" cuûa ngaøi Trieäu Chaâu—                       meditation (zazen) with this 'Mu', is to come Chao-Chou's Mu koan: "Voâ" laø moät tieáp ñaàu                    to an immediate experience, beyond any ngöõ coù nghóa phuû ñònh, töông ñöông vôùi                        intellectual signification, of its very profound 'khoâng' maø thieàn sö Trieäu Chaâu ñaõ duøng ñeå traû            content. Since this koan is extraordinarily apt lôøi cho coâng aùn 'con choù coù Phaät taùnh hay                  as a 'dharmakaya or dharma-body' (hosshin khoâng?' 'Mu' cuõng ñöôïc duøng vôùi nghóa laø                    koan), it is often the first koan received by a khoâng coù gì heát. Sau ñaây laø coâng aùn trong thí              Zen student from his master. When the duï thöù nhaát cuûa Voâ Moân Quan: "Moät vò Taêng                 student has mastered it, it is said that he has hoûi Trieäu Chaâu: 'Con choù thaät coù Phaät tính hay             become acquainted with 'the world of mu'. In khoâng?' Trieäu Chaâu noùi: 'Khoâng!'" Nhieäm vuï                 the course of Zen training this 'mu' is to be cuûa moät thieàn sinh laø tröïc tieáp ñi saâu vaøo yù             experienced and demonstrated on ever nghóa saâu saéc cuûa coâng aùn naày, maø khoâng caàn              deeper levels. Often the first Koan presented tôùi söï can döï cuûa trí tueä, baèng caùch toïa thieàn           to a new student of Zen Buddhism. Here töø tieáng 'Voâ' aáy. Coâng aùn naày hoaøn toaøn ñaùp             "Wu" literally means “nothing” or “not,” but öùng vôùi chöùc naêng cuûa moät coâng aùn phaùp                   in this context indicates a refusal to provide thaân, vaø thöôøng ñöôïc vò thaày ñöa ra cho hoïc                 an answer that is based on conceptual thought troø tröôùc. Khi hoïc troø giaûi ñöôïc, ngöôøi ta noùi            or ordinary language. The problem of the ngöôøi ñoù hieåu ñöôïc 'Theá giôùi Voâ'. Trong suoát              koan is that according to Ch’an tradition all thôøi gian ñaøo taïo thieàn, ñieàu quan troïng laø                beings have the buddha-nature, and so dogs khaùm phaù vaø bieåu hieän nhöõng möùc ñoä theå                   would naturally be included. But if Chao- nghieäm ngaøy caøng saâu. Thöôøng thì ñaây laø                    Chou responds to the question affirmatively, coâng aùn ñöôïc trao cho moät thieàn sinh môùi                    he falls to the trap of duality. On the other trong Phaät giaùo. “Khoâng!” Khoâng coù nghóa laø                 hand, if he responds negatively, he puts “khoâng coù gì heát,” nhöng trong baøi naøy noù chæ               himself at odds with the received wisdom of söï töø choái cung caáp moät caâu traû lôøi baèng tö              the patriarchs of tradition. Thus his response töôûng khaùi nieäm hay ngoân ngöõ phaøm phu. Vaán                 indicates that the answer to the question lies ñeà coâng aùn, theo Thieàn toâng, taát caû chuùng                 beyond words and doctrines and must be sanh ñeàu coù Phaät taùnh, vaø vì vaäy con choù cuõng             grasped directly and intuitively. When a phaûi coù Phaät taùnh. Nhöng neáu Trieäu Chaâu traû               student understands the purport of Chao- lôøi caâu hoûi laø “coù,” thì hoùa ra oâng ta bò maéc             Chou’s answer, it is said that a spontaneous keït vaøo nhò nguyeân. Ngöôïc laïi, neáu oâng traû lôøi           flash of insight dawns. “khoâng,” hoùa ra oâng töï ñaët mình taùch rôøi khoûi        Coâng AÙn Khoâng Nghó Thieän, Khoâng Nghó AÙc : trí tueä cuûa caùc vò toå trong truyeàn thoáng. Vì vaäy      Fushizen-fushiaku (jap)—Neither Good Nor maø caâu traû lôøi cuûa oâng chæ raèng traû lôøi caâu hoûi   Evil—See Baát Tö Thieän Baát Tö AÙc. naøy vöôït ra ngoaøi ngoân ngöõ vaø giaùo phaùp vaø          Coâng AÙn Khoâng Nghó Thieän, Khoâng Nghó AÙc, phaûi ñöôïc naém baét baèng tröïc giaùc. Khi thieàn          Chính Khi AÁy Caùi Gì Laø Baûn Lai Dieän Muïc?: sinh hieåu ñöôïc yù ñònh cuûa caâu traû lôøi cuûa            With no thoughts of good and with no thoughts of Trieäu Chaâu, ngöôøi ta noùi ñoù laø moät tia loeù töùc      evil, at just this moment, what is your original thôøi cuûa trí tueä—"Mu" ia a negative prefix,               face?—See Khoâng Nghó Thieän, Khoâng Nghó AÙc, somewhat equivalent to 'non' which Zen                       Chính Khi AÁy Caùi Gì Laø Baûn Lai Dieän Muïc? master Chao-Chou used to response to the                     Coâng AÙn Khueách Nhieân Voâ Thaùnh: Coâng AÙn koan 'does the dog have Buddha nature?' 'Mu'                 Roãng theânh khoâng Thaùnh cuûa Toå Boà Ñeà Ñaït Ma— is also used with the meaning of 'nothing'. The              Bodhidharma's koan of the Vast emptiness without first example in the Wu-Men-Kuan is as                       holiness—See Khueách Nhieân Voâ Thaùnh.

Coâng AÙn Kieán Thaønh: Hieän Thaønh Coâng AÙn—       Coâng AÙn Long Sinh Long Töû, Phöôïng Sinh All things themselves reveal Buddha-nature—See        Phöôïng Nhi: Dragons give birth to dragons. A Kieán Thaønh Coâng AÙn.                               phoenix gives birth to a phoenix—See Long Sinh Coâng AÙn Kieán Thoá Phoùng Öng: Seeing the           Long Töû, Phöôïng Sinh Phöôïng Nhi. rabbit one looses the falcon—See Kieán Thoá           Coâng AÙn Loâ Laêng Meã Giaù: Ch'ing Yuan “What is Phoùng Öng.                                           the price of rice in Lu-Ling?”—See Loâ Laêng Meã Coâng AÙn Kính Sôn Nhaát Thoác Phaù Tam Quan:         Giaù. Ch'in Shan "A single arrowhead smashing three         Coâng AÙn Loã Toå Dieän Bích: Lu-tsu Pao-yun barriers"—See Nhaát Phoác Phaù Tam Quan.              "Facing the wall"—See Loã Toå Dieän Bích. Coâng AÙn Laïc Phoå Ñaàu Sö: Luopu acquiesced to      Coâng AÙn Loã Toå Gia Phong: Thoùi quen vaø leà loái Zen master Jiashan—See Laïc Phoå Ñaàu Sö.             cuûa töï vieän Loã Toå—Lu-tsu's customs and Coâng AÙn Laïc Phoå Hoaøn Höông: Luopu's              tradition—See Loã Toå Dieän Bích. returning home—See Laïc Phoå Hoaøn Höông.             Coâng AÙn Loä Phuøng Ñaït Ñaïo: Meeting Someone Coâng AÙn Laïc Phoå Laâm Chung: Luopu's final         Attained in the Tao—See Loä Phuøng Ñaït Ñaïo. time of death—See Laïc Phoå Laâm Chung.               Coâng AÙn Loäng Quang AÛnh Haùn: One who plays Coâng AÙn Laõng Thöôïng Toïa Laät Ngöôïc AÁm Traø     with his own swining shadow—See Loäng Quang Taïi Chieâu Khaùnh: Turning Over the Tea Kettle       AÛnh Haùn. at Chao Ch'ing—See Laõng Thöôïng Toïa Laät            Coâng AÙn Löông Giôùi Phaát Tuï Xuaát Khöù: Liang- Ngöôïc AÁm Traø Taïi Chieâu Khaùnh.                   chieh's moving his sleeves and leaving the hall— Coâng AÙn Laõo Thaåm Töù Moân: Koan of Chao-          See Löông Giôùi Phaát Tuï Xuaát Khöù. chou's Four Gates—See Laõo Thaåm Töù Moân.            Coâng AÙn Löông Sôn Ngoâ Xöû Só Hoïa: Liang- Coâng AÙn Laâm Teá Chaân Nhaân: Lin-Chi's True        Shan's “This was painted by Wu-Chu”—See Man—See Laâm Teá Chaân Nhaân.                         Löông Sôn Ngoâ Xöû Só Hoïa. Coâng AÙn Laâm Teá Haït Lö: Lin-Chi's blind ass—      Coâng AÙn Löôõng Beänh Haønh Giaû: Vaân Moân: See Laâm Teá Haït Lö.                                 haønh giaû hai loaïi beänh—Yun Men: Practitioners Coâng AÙn Laâm Teá Phaät Phaùp Ñaïi YÙ: Lin-Chi's     with two kinds of illness—See Löôõng Beänh Haønh ultimate principle of Buddhism—See Laâm Teá           Giaû. Phaät Phaùp Ñaïi YÙ.                                  Coâng AÙn Löôõng Cöôùc Sao Khoâng: Two legs Coâng AÙn Laâm Teá Taøi Tuøng: Lin-Chi's growing      don't touch the ground—See Löôõng Cöôùc Sao pine trees—See Laâm Teá Taøi Tuøng.                   Khoâng. Coâng AÙn Lieân Hoa Phong Truï Tröôïng: The           Coâng AÙn Löôõng Truøng: Koans that are Hermit of Lotus Flower Peak Holds up His Staff—       interpreted twice—See Löôõng Truøng Coâng AÙn. See Lieân Hoa Phong Truï Tröôïng.                     Coâng AÙn Löu Thieát Ma Laõo Ngöu: Löu Thieát Coâng AÙn Long Ñaøm Cöûu Höôûng: Lung-t'an:           Ma, Traâu Caùi Giaø—Iron Grindstone Liu, an Old Renowned Far and Wide—Lung-t'an's paper               Cow—See Löu Thieát Ma Laõo Ngöu. candle—See Long Ñaøm Cöûu Höôûng.                     Coâng AÙn Ly Khöôùc Ngöõ Ngoân: Lìa khoûi noùi Coâng AÙn Long Ñaøm Dieät Chuùc: Lung-t'an's          naêng—Equality and Differentiation—See Ly paper candle—See Long Ñaøm Cöûu Höôûng.               Khöôùc Ngöõ Ngoân. Coâng AÙn Long Nha Quaù Baûng: Lung-ya "Would         Coâng AÙn Lyù Boät Hoaøi Nghi: Li-Bo's doubt—See you kindly pass me the meditation plank"—See          Lyù Boät Hoaøi Nghi. Long Nha Quaù Baûng.                                  Coâng AÙn Lyù Cao Vaán Ñaïo: Li-Kao's questioning Coâng AÙn Long Nha Taây Lai YÙ: See Long Nha          Buddha-dharma—See Lyù Cao Vaán Ñaïo. Quaù Baûng.                                           Coâng AÙn Ma Coác Chaán Tích Nhieãu Saøng: Ma- Coâng AÙn Long Nha Thaïch Qui Khôûi Thuyeát:          Ku's carrying his ring-staff, circling the meditation Long Nha Ñôïi bao giôø con ruøa ñen baèng ñaù bieát   seat three times—See Ma Coác Thuû Tröôïng Nhieãu noùi—Wait until the dark stone turtle begins to       Thieàn Saøng. talk—See Long Nha Thaïch Qui Khôûi Thuyeát.           Coâng AÙn Ma Coác Löôõng Xöù Chaán Tích: Ma-

Ku's carrying his ring-staff, circling the meditation   Haùn. seat three times—See Ma Coác Thuû Tröôïng Nhieãu        Coâng AÙn Muïc Chaâu Löôïc Khoâng Haùn: Mu- Thieàn Saøng.                                           chou's Thieving Phoney—See Muïc Chaâu Löôïc Coâng AÙn Ma Coác Thuû Tröôïng Nhieãu Thieàn            Khoâng Haùn. Saøng: Ma-Ku's carrying his ring-staff, circling the    Coâng AÙn Na Bieân Cuù Giaù Bieân Cuù: Beân kia vaø meditation seat three times—See Ma Coác Thuû            beân naøy—That side and this side—Coâng aùn noùi veà Tröôïng Nhieãu Thieàn Saøng.                            cô duyeân vaán ñaùp veà vieäc Thieàn sö Ñoäng Sôn khai Coâng AÙn Ma Coác Trì Tích: Ma-Ku's carrying his        ngoä cho Sô Sôn Quang Nhaân. Theo Caûnh Ñöùc ring-staff, circling the meditation seat three          Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån XV, vaøo moät dòp Ñoäng times—See Ma Coác Thuû Tröôïng Nhieãu Thieàn            Sôn thöôïng ñöôøng vaø noùi: "Laõo Taêng muoán maáy Saøng.                                                  oâng phaûi laõnh hoäi söï vieäc naøy. Maáy oâng phaûi gioáng Coâng AÙn Maõ Toå: Thaùi Coâ Nguy Sanh: Thaät cao       nhö moät caùi caây khoâ troå hoa. Theá laø maáy oâng hoøa ngaát laøm sao!—How lofty!—See Maõ Toå: Thaùi Coâ       nhaäp ñöôïc vôùi noù." Sô Sôn hoûi: "Coøn veà caùc nôi Nguy Sanh.                                              ñeàu baïi hoaïi thì sao?" Ñoäng Sôn noùi: "Ñaïi Ñöùc! Coâng AÙn Maõ Toå Töù Cuù Baùch Phi: Ma Tsu's           OÂng ñang noùi veà tu taäp haïnh. May maén laø coù moät Permutations of Assertion and Denial—See Maõ            caûnh giôùi tu taäp voâ haønh haïnh. Taïi sao oâng khoâng Toå Töù Cuù Baùch Phi.                                  hoûi veà caûnh giôùi ñoù?" Sô Sôn noùi: "Tu taäp voâ haønh Coâng AÙn Maïc Gia Kieám: Mo-Jia sword—See              haïnh? Coù theå coù moät ngöôøi nhö vaäy khoâng?" Ñoäng Maïc Gia Kieám.                                         Sôn noùi: "Nhieàu ngöôøi seõ cöôøi oâng khi oâng hoûi moät Coâng AÙn Mai Töû Thuïc Daõ: T'a Mei, the Plum is       caâu nhö vaäy." Sô Sôn noùi: "Trong tröôøng hôïp ñoù, ripe—See Mai Töû Thuïc Daõ.                             con ñaõ ñi leäch." Ñoäng Sôn noùi: "Leäch laø khoâng Coâng AÙn Maïi Phieán Laõo Baø Thuû Giaø Nhaät: An      leäch, cuõng khoâng khoâng leäch." Sô Sôn noùi: "Theá old lady who sells paper folding fans—See               naøo laø leäch?" Ñoäng Sôn noùi: "Neáu oâng noùi 'moät Maïi Phieán Laõo Baø Thuû Giaø Nhaät.                   ngöôøi nhö vaäy,' laø oâng vaãn chöa laõnh hoäi." Sô Sôn Coâng AÙn Maëc Nhieân Phuû Nhaän: The implicit-         noùi: "Caùi gì laø khoâng leäch?" Ñoäng Sôn noùi: "Moät negative type of koans—See Maëc Nhieân Phuû             nôi khoâng coù söï khaùc bieät hay khoâng coù beân kia Nhaän Coâng AÙn.                                        beân naøy."—The koan about the potentiality and Coâng AÙn Maëc Nhö Loâi: Söï im laëng saám seùt—        conditions of questions and answers regarding Zen Thunder of silence—Deafening like thunder—See           master Tung-shan (807-869) opened up the Maëc Nhö Loâi.                                          intelligence and brought enlightenment to Shu- Coâng AÙn Meâ Lyù Ma La: Lôø môø khoâng roõ—To be       shan K'uang-jeân. According to the Records of the not clear (dim or vague) with a subject—Not             Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), clear with something—See Meâ Lyù Ma La.                 Volume XV, on one occasion Tung-shan entered Coâng AÙn Minh Chieâu Tònh Bình: Mingzhao's             the hall and said, "I want you to understand this pure water pitcher—See Minh Chieâu Tònh Bình.           matter. You must be like a dead tree that blossoms flowers. Then you will merge with it." Shushan Coâng AÙn Minh Nhieân Xaùc Nhaän: The explicit- asked, "What about when every place is affirmative type of koans—See Minh Nhieân Xaùc corrupted?" Tung-shan said, "Your Reverence! Nhaän Coâng AÙn. You're talking about practicing a practice (a Coâng AÙn Moâng Ñoång Tam Baùch Ñaûm: Lacking habitual action). Fortunately there is a realm of comprehension of theories and practice is a nonpracticing practice. Why don't you ask about burden for practitioners—See Moâng Ñoång Tam that?" Shushan said, "Practicing a nonpracticing Baùch Ñaûm. practice? Can there be such a person?" Tung-shan Coâng AÙn Moät Baøn Tay: Sekishu (jap)—One said, "Many people will laughed at you for asking hand—See Moät Baøn Tay. such a question." Shushan said, "In that case, my Coâng AÙn Mu: A koan named "Mu"—See Mu. thinking has gone astray." Tung-shan said, "Astray Coâng AÙn Muïc Chaâu Löôïc Hö Haùn: Mu-chou's is not astray, nor not astray." Shushan said, "What Thieving Phoney—See Muïc Chaâu Löôïc Khoâng is 'astray'?" Tung-shan said, "If you say, 'such a

person,' then you still don't understand." Shushan           töùc laø gieát Phaät, neáu chaáp töôùng ngoài, chaúng ñaït yù said, "What is not 'astray'?" Tung-shan said, "A             kia.” Ñaïo Nhaát nghe sö chæ daïy nhö uoáng ñeà hoà, leã place of no differentiation or place without that            baùi hoûi: “Duïng taâm theá naøo môùi hôïp vôùi voâ töôùng side and this side."                                         tam muoäi?” Sö baûo: “Ngöôi hoïc phaùp moân taâm ñòa Coâng AÙn Nam Döông Tònh Bình: Nan-Yang's                    nhö gieo gioáng, ta noùi phaùp yeáu nhö möa moùc, neáu Vase of pure water—Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn                   duyeân ngöôi hôïp seõ thaáy ñaïo naày.” Ñaïo Nhaát laïi Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån V, moät hoâm, coù vò Taêng ñeán hoûi      hoûi: “Ñaïo khoâng phaûi saéc töôùng laøm sao thaáy Thieàn sö Nam Döông Hueä Trung: “Theá naøo laø boån          ñöôïc?” Sö noùi: “Con maét phaùp taâm ñòa hay thaáy thaân Phaät Tyø Loâ Giaù Na?” Thieàn sö Nam Döông            ñöôïc ñaïo. Voâ töôùng tam muoäi cuõng laïi nhö vaäy.” baûo: “Ñem caùi bình ñoàng kia ñeán cho ta.” Vò Taêng        Ñaïo Nhaát hoûi: “Coù thaønh hoaïi chaêng?” Sö noùi: lieàn laáy tònh bình ñem laïi. Thieàn sö Nam Döông           “Neáu laáy caùi thaønh hoaïi tuï taùn, thieän aùc maø thaáy baûo: “Ñem ñeå laïi choã cuõ.” Vò Taêng ñem bình ñeå         ñaïo, laø khoâng theå thaáy ñaïo. Nghe ta noùi keä: laïi choã cuõ xong, beøn hoûi laïi caâu tröôùc. Thieàn sö               Taâm ñòa haøm chö chuûng, Nam Döông baûo: Phaät xöa ñaõ quaù khöù laâu roài.”—                    Ngoä traïch töùc giai manh According to the Records of the Transmission of                         Tam muoäi hoa voâ töôùng the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), Volume V, one day,                           Haø hoaïi phuïc haø thaønh? a monk came and asked Zen master Nan-yang                               (Ñaát taâm chöùa caùc gioáng Hui-chung (675-775): “What is the true body of                           Gaëp öôùt lieàn naåy maàm Vairocan Buddha?” Nan-yang said: “Bring me that                          Hoa tam muoäi khoâng töôùng pitcher of pure water.” The monk brought him the                         Naøo hoaïi laïi naøo thaønh?) pitcher. Nan-yang then said: “Now put it back                Nhôø nhöõng lôøi naày maø Ñaïo Nhaát khai ngoä taâm yù where it was before.” The monk returned the                  sieâu nhieân—The koan about the potentiality and bottle to its former position. Then the monk asked           conditions of questions and answers regarding Zen his previous question again. Nan-yang said: "The             master Nan Yueh (677-744) opened up the ancient Buddhas are long gone.”                              intelligence and brought enlightenment to Ma-tsu Coâng AÙn Nam Nhaïc Ma Chuyeân: Nan Yueh                     Tao-i (709-788). According to the Records of the "Grinding a piece of tile on a rock"—Coâng aùn noùi          Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), veà cô duyeân vaán ñaùp veà vieäc Thieàn sö Nam Nhaïc        Volume V, during the Kai-Yuan era of the T’ang Hoaøi Nhöôïng khai ngoä cho Maõ Toå Ñaïo Nhaát.              dynasty (713-741) there was a novice monk called Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån V, thôøi          Ma-Tsu T’ao-Yi who constantly practice Zen nhaø Ñöôøng, nieân hieäu Khai Nguyeân, coù vò Sa Moân        meditation upon Mount Heng. Nan-Yueh knew ôû huyeän Truyeàn Phaùp hieäu Ñaïo Nhaát, haèng ngaøy        that T’ao-Yi was a great vessel for the Dharma, ngoài thieàn. Sö bieát ñoù laø phaùp khí (ngöôøi höõu ích    and once walked up to him and said: “ What does trong Phaät phaùp) beøn ñi ñeán hoûi: “Ñaïi ñöùc ngoài       your Worthiness intend to do by sitting in thieàn ñeå laøm gì?” Ñaïo Nhaát thöa: “Ñeå laøm Phaät.”      meditation?” Ma-Tsu said: “I intend to become a Sau ñoù sö laáy moät cuïc gaïch ñeán treân hoøn ñaù ôû       Buddha.” Nan-Yueh then picked up a piece of tile tröôùc am Ñaïo Nhaát ngoài maøi. Ñaïo Nhaát thaáy laï        from the ground and began grinding on a rock. hoûi: “Thaày maøi gaïch ñeå laøm gì?” Sö ñaùp: “Maøi ñeå     T’ao-Yi then asked: “What are you trying to make laøm göông.” Ñaïo Nhaát noùi: “Maøi gaïch ñaâu coù theå      by grinding that?” Nan-Yueh said: “I’m grinding it thaønh göông ñöôïc?” Sö hoûi laïi: “Ngoài thieàn ñaâu coù    to make a mirror.” T’ao-Yi said: “How can you theå thaønh Phaät ñöôïc?” Ñaïo Nhaát hoûi: “Vaäy laøm        make a irror by grinding a tile on a rock?” Nan- theá naøo môùi phaûi?” Sö noùi: “Nhö traâu keùo xe, neáu     Yueh said: “If you can’t make a mirror by grinding xe khoâng ñi, thì ñaùnh xe laø phaûi hay ñaùnh traâu laø     a tile on a rock, how can you become a Buddha by phaûi?” Ñaïo Nhaát laëng thinh, sö noùi tieáp: “Ngöôi        sitting in meditation?” T’ao-Yi said: “What is the hoïc ngoài thieàn hay hoïc ngoài Phaät? Neáu hoïc ngoài      correct way?” Nan-Yueh said: “It can be thieàn, thieàn khoâng phaûi ngoài naèm. Neáu hoïc ngoài      compared to an ox pulling a cart. If the cart Phaät, Phaät khoâng coù töôùng nhaát ñònh, ñoái phaùp        doesn’t move, do you strike the cart or strike the khoâng truï, chaúng neân thuû xaû. Ngöôi neáu ngoài Phaät,   ox?” T’ao-Yi didn’t answer. Nan-Yueh then said:

“Are you sitting in order to practice Zen, or are              According to the Records of the Transmission of you sitting to be a Buddha? If you’re sitting to               the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), Volume V, a great practice Zen, then know that Zen is not found in               worthy one asked Nan-Yueh: “If an image is sitting or lying down. If you’re sitting to become a           reflected in a mirror, where does the light of the Buddha, then know that Buddha has no fixed form.               image go when it’s no longer observed?” Nan- With respect to the constantly changing world, you             Yueh said: “It’s similar to remembering when should neither grasp it nor reject it. If you sit to           Your Worthiness was a child. Where has your become a Buddha, you kill Buddha. If you grasp                 childlike appearance gone now? The worthy one sitting form then you have not yet reached the                 asked: “But afterward, why does the image not meaning.” When T’ao-Yi heard this instruction it               remain?” Nan-Yueh said: “Although it is no longer was as though he had drunk sweet nectar. He                    reflected, it can be reproved even slightly.” bowed and asked: “How can one cultivate mind to                Coâng AÙn Nam Nhaïc Thuyeát Töï Nhaát Vaät: Nan be in accord with formless samadhi?” Nan-Yueh                  Yueh “To say it’s a thing misses the mark.”— said: “You’re studying the Dharma gate of mind-                Coâng aùn noùi veà cô duyeân vaán ñaùp giöõa Luïc Toå ground, and this activity is like planting seeds               Hueä Naêng vaø Thieàn sö Nam Nhaïc Hoaøi Nhöôïng. there. The essential Dharma of which I speak may               Theo Kinh Phaùp Baûo Ñaøn, chöông baûy, vaø Caûnh be likened to the rain that falls upon the seeded              Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån V, Sö ñeán Taøo Kheâ ground. In this same manner your auspicious                    tham vaán Luïc Toå Hueä Naêng. Toå hoûi: “ÔÛ ñaâu karmic conditions will allow you to perceive the               ñeán?” Sö thöa: “ÔÛ Tung Sôn ñeán.” Toå hoûi: “Maø Way.” T’ao-Yi then asked: “The Way is without                  vaät gì ñeán?” Sö thöa: “Noùi in tuoàng moät vaät töùc color or form. How can one perceive it?” Nan-                  khoâng truùng.” Toå hoûi: “Laïi coù theå tu chöùng Yueh said: “The Dharma eye of mind-ground can                  chaêng?” Sö thöa: “Tu chöùng töùc chaúng khoâng, perceive the true way. The formless samadhi is                 nhieãm oâ töùc chaúng ñöôïc.” Toå noùi: “Chính caùi likewise perceived.” T’ao-Yi then asked: “Does it              khoâng nhieãm oâ naày laø choã hoä nieäm cuûa chö Phaät, have good and bad, or not?” Nan-Yueh said: “If                 ngöôøi ñaõ nhö theá, ta cuõng nhö theá. Toå Baùt Nhaõ Ña the Way is seen in the aggregation and                         La ôû Taây Thieân coù lôøi saám raèng: ‘Döôùi chaân ngöôi disintegration of good and bad, then it is not the             seõ xuaát hieän NHAÁT MAÕ CAÂU (con ngöïa tô) ñaïp way. Listen to this verse:                                     cheát ngöôøi trong thieân haï. ÖÙng taïi taâm ngöôi “The mind-ground fully sown,                           chaúng caàn noùi sôùm.’” Nghe xong Hoaøi Nhöôïng When moisture comes, all seeds sprout                 hoaùt nhieân kheá ngoä, lieàn haàu haï Toå möôøi laêm naêm, The formless flower of samadhi,                       moãi ngaøy caøng thaâm ñöôïc söï huyeàn aùo. Sau ñoù Sö How can it be bad or good?”                           ñi ñeán nuùi Nam Nhaïc, xieån döông Thieàn toâng— At these words T’ao-Yi experienced great                       The koan about the potentiality and conditions of enlightenment and unsurpassed realization.                     questions and answers between the Sixth Coâng AÙn Nam Nhaïc Nhö Caûnh Chuù Töôïng: Nan                 Patriarch, Hui Neng, and Zen master Nan Yueh Yueh "An image is reflected in a mirror"—Coâng                 (677-744). According to the Flatform Sutra, aùn noùi veà cô duyeân vaán ñaùp giöõa Thieàn sö Nam           Chapter Seven, and the Records of the Nhaïc Hoaøi Nhöôïng vaø moät vò Taêng. Theo Caûnh              Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån V, coù vò Ñaïi ñöùc            Volume V, Nan-Yueh came to Tsao-Xi to study ñeán hoûi sö: “Nhö göông ñuùc töôïng, sau khi töôïng           with Hui-Neng. Hui-Neng said to Nan-Yueh: thaønh khoâng bieát caùi saùng cuûa göông ñi veà choã          “Where did you come from?” Nan-Yueh said: naøo?” Sö baûo: “Nhö Ñaïi ñöùc töôùng maïo luùc treû thô       “From Mount Song.” Hui-Neng said: “What is it hieän thôøi ôû ñaâu?” Ñaïi ñöùc laïi hoûi: “Taïi sao sau khi   that thus come?” Nan-Yueh couldn’t answer. After thaønh töôïng khoâng chieáu soi?” Sö baûo: “Tuy                eight years, Nan-Yueh suddenly attained khoâng chieáu soi, nhöng ñoái y moät ñieåm cuõng               enlightenment. He informed the Sixth Patriarch of chaúng ñöôïc.”—The koan about the potentiality                 this, saying: “I have an understanding.” The Sixth and conditions of questions and answers between                Patriarch said: “What is it?” Nan-Yueh said: “To Zen master Nan Yueh (677-744) and a monk.                      say it’s a thing misses the mark.” The Sixth

Patriarch said: “Then can it be made evident or             vaäy bò ngöôøi cheâ cöôøi. Ba laõo naøy muoán ñi leã baùi not?” Nan-Yueh said: “I don’t say it can’t be made          Quoác Sö, ñeán giöõa ñöôøng taïo ra moät tröôøng baïi evident, but it can’t be defiled.” The Sixth                quyeát naøy. Nam Tuyeàn noùi: "Theá aáy thì chaúng ñi." Patriarch said: “Just this that is undefiled is what is     Ñaõ laø moãi ngöôøi ñeàu noùi ñöôïc, taïi sao noùi chaúng upheld and sustained all Buddhas. You are thus. I           ñi? Haõy noùi yù coå nhaân theá naøo? Ñöông thôøi ñôïi Sö am also thus. “Prajnadhara has foretold that from           noùi theá aáy thì chaúng ñi, nhaèm loã tai lieàn taùt, xem beneath your feet will come a horse which will              Sö suy tính theá naøo? Vaïn coå chaán höng cöông toâng trample to death everyone in the world. Bear this           chæ laø cô yeáu nhoû beù naøy. Vì theá, Töø Minh noùi: in mind but don’t soon repeat it.” Huai-Jang                "Caàn loâi chæ ôû taïi ñaàu daây, vaïch ñöôïc naém ñöôïc suddenly       understood        (experienced     Great     lieàn xoay, nhö ñaåy quaû baàu treân maët nöôùc." Nhieàu Enlightenment). Accordingly he waited upon the              ngöôøi baûo laø lôøi khoâng thöøa nhaän nhau. Ñaâu chaúng Master for fifteen years, daily penetrating more            bieát vieäc naøy ñeán choã toät cuøng phaûi lìa buøn lìa deeply into the profound and mysterious. He later           nöôùc, thaùo choát nhoå ñinh. Neáu oâng khôûi hieåu taâm went to Nan-Yao where he spread the Dhyana                  haïnh laø khoâng giao thieäp. Coå nhaân chuyeån bieán raát School.                                                     kheùo, ñeán trong ñaây khoâng ñöôïc chaúng theá aáy, Coâng AÙn Nam Tuyeàn Baïch Coå: Nam Tuyeàn traâu            phaûi laø coù cheát coù soáng. Xem kia moät ngöôøi vaøo traéng (Li Noâ Baïch Coå)—Nan Ch'uan's domestic             trong voøng troøn ngoài, moät ngöôøi giaû ngöôøi nöõ leã cat and white buffalo—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô duyeân          baùi, thaät taøi tình. Nam Tuyeàn baûo: "Theá aáy thì veà nhöõng lôøi daïy cuûa Thieàn sö Nam Tuyeàn Phoå         chaúng ñi." Qui Toâng baûo: "Laø taâm haïnh gì?" Keû Nguyeän. Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc,                taàm thöôøng laïi theá aáy ñi. Qui Toâng noùi theá aáy, coát quyeån VIII, moät hoâm Thieàn sö Nam Tuyeàn thöôïng         nghieäm Nam Tuyeàn. Nam Tuyeàn bình thöôøng noùi: ñöôøng daïy chuùng, noùi: "Chö Phaät ba ñôøi khoâng         "Goïi laø nhö nhö, sôùm ñaõ bieán roài." Nam Tuyeàn, bieát maø ly noâ baïch coå (meøo nhaø traâu traéng) laïi    Qui Toâng, Ma Coác laïi laø ngöôøi ôû trong moät nhaø, bieát."—The koan about the potentiality and                 moät baét moät thaû, moät cheát moät soáng, quaû thaät kyø conditions of lectures from Zen master Nan Chuan            ñaëc—According to example 69 of the Pi-Yen-Lu, Pu Yuan. According to the Records of the                    Nan Ch'uan, Kuei Tsung, and Ma Tsu went Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu),                  together to pay respects to National Teacher Volume VIII, one day, Zen master Nan Chuan                  Chung. When they got halfway there, Nan Ch'uan entered the hall and addressed the assembly,                drew a circle on the ground and said, "If you can saying, "Buddhas of the three generations (past,            speak, then let's go on." Kuei Tsung sat down present and future) do not know; but the domestic           inside the circle; Ma Ku curtseyed. Nan Ch'uan cat and the white buffalo know."                            said, "Then let's not go on." Kuei Tsung said, Coâng AÙn Nam Tuyeàn Baùi Trung Quoác Sö: Nan               "What's going on in your mind?" According to Ch'uan Pays Respects to National Teacher Chung              Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, at the time Ma Tsu's (Nan Ch'uan's Circle)—Theo thí duï thöù 69 cuûa             teaching was flourishing in Kiangsi, Shih T'ou's Bích Nham Luïc. Nam Tuyeàn, Qui Toâng, Ma Coác              Way was current in Hu-Hsiang (Hunan), and ñoàng ñi leã baùi Quoác Sö Hueä Trung. Ñeán giöõa           National Teacher Chung's Way was influencing ñöôøng, Nam Tuyeàn veõ moät voøng troøn treân ñaát, noùi:   Ch'ang An. The latter had personally seen the "Noùi ñöôïc thì ñi." Qui Toâng vaøo giöõa voøng troøn       Sixth Patriarch; at the time, of those in the South ngoài. Ma Coác giaû laøm ngöôøi nöõ laïy. Nam Tuyeàn        who held up their heads and wore horns, there was noùi: "Theá aáy thì chaúng ñi." Qui Toâng noùi: "Laø taâm   none who did not want to ascend his hall and enter haïnh gì?" Theo Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc,            his room; otherwise, they would be shamed by ñöông thôøi Maõ Toå giaùo hoùa höng thaïnh ôû Giang         others. These three old fellows wanted to go pay Taây, Thaïch Ñaàu höng thaïnh ôû Hoà Töông, Quoác Sö        respects to National Teacher Chung; when they Hueä Trung ñaïo hoùa ôû Tröôøng An. Quoác Sö ñích           got halfway, they enacted this scenario to defeat. thaân gaëp Luïc Toå roài veà ñaây. Khi aáy phöông Nam       Nan Ch'uan said, "Then let's not go." Since they nhöõng ngöôøi naâng ñaàu moïc söøng, khoâng ai chaúng       had each been able to speak, why did he instead muoán ñeán nhaø kia, vaøo thaát kia. Neáu chaúng ñöôï c     say he wouldn't go? Tell me, what was the

intention of that man of old? At that time, when he           Chuan's road?" Zen master Nan Chuan raised the said, "Then let's not go," I would have slapped him           sickle up and said, "My sickle cost me 30 right on the ear, to see what trick he would pull;            piasters." The monk said, "I do not ask about the what eternally upholds the all-embracing source is            sickle, I only ask about what direction leads to just this little bit of active essence. That is why           Nan Chuan's road?" Zen master Nan Chuan said, Tz'u Ming said, "If you want to restrain him, just            "This old monk handles this sickle very well." grab the rein and yank." Hit and he turns, like               Coâng AÙn Nam Tuyeàn Ngoaïn Nguyeät: Nan pushing down a gourd on the water. Many people                Ch'uan “Enjoying the moonlight”—Coâng aùn noùi say that Nan Ch'uan's words are words of                      veà cô duyeân vaán ñaùp giöõa Thieàn sö Nam Tuyeàn disagreement, but they are far from knowing that              Phoå Nguyeän vaø Trieäu Chaâu Toøng Thaåm. Theo in this matter, when you get to the ultimate point,           Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån VIII, moät toái it is necessary to leave the mud, get out of the              Thieàn sö Nam Tuyeàn ñang ngaém traêng, Trieäu water, draw out the wedges, and pull out the nails.           Chaâu hoûi Sö khi naøo ngöôøi ta coù theå ñöôïc gioáng If you make an intellectual interpretation, then              nhö aùnh traêng. Sö noùi: "Thì hai möôi naêm tröôùc laõo you've missed it. The Ancients could turn and shift           Taêng cuõng töøng nhö theá." Trieäu Chaâu laïi tieáp tuïc: well; at this point they could not be otherwise;              "Coøn baây giôø thì sao?" Nam Tuyeàn laäp töùc ñi veà there must be killing and giving life: see how one            phöông tröôïng—The koan about the potentiality of them sat inside the circle, and one curtseyed.             and conditions of questions and answers between That toowas very good. Nan Ch'uan said, "Then                 Zen Master Nan Ch'uan and Chao Chou. let's not go." Kuei Tsung said, "What is going on             According to the Records of the Transmission of in your mind?" Brash fellow! He too goes on like              the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), Volume VIII, one this. His whole idea was that he wanted to test               evening when Master Nan Ch'uan was enjoying Nan Ch'uan. Nan Ch'uan always said, "Call it                  the moonlight, Chao chou asked him when one thusness, and already it has changed." Nan                    could be equal to the moonlight. The master said, Ch'uan, Kuei Tsung, and Ma Ku, after all they                 "Twenty years ago I attained that state." Chao- were people of one house. One holds, one                      chou continued, "What about right now?" The releases; one kills, one enlivens: undeniably they            Master went immediately to his room. are exceptional.                                              Coâng AÙn Nam Tuyeàn Nhö Moäng: Nan Ch'uan's Coâng AÙn Nam Tuyeàn Lieâm Töû: Nam Tuyeàn: Caùi              It's like a Dream, example 40 of the Pi-Yen-Lu— Lieàm—Nan Ch'uan's sickle—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô               Thí duï thöù 40 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Luïc Hoaøn Ñaïi duyeân vaán ñaùp giöõa Thieàn sö Nam Tuyeàn Phoå              Phu cuøng noùi chuyeän vôùi Nam Tuyeàn. Luïc Hoaøn Nguyeän vaø moät vò Taêng. Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn            hoûi: "Trieäu Phaùp Sö noùi 'Trôøi ñaát cuøng ta ñoàng Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån VIII, moät hoâm, Thieàn sö Nam             goác, vaïn vaät cuøng ta moät theå' thaät laø kyø quaùi?" Tuyeàn ñang caét coû treân nuùi, coù moät vò Taêng haønh      Nam Tuyeàn chæ hoa tröôùc saân keâu ñaïi phu, noùi: cöôùc ñeán hoûi ngaøi raèng: "Höôùng naøo ñi veà con          "Thôøi nhôn thaáy goác hoa naøy gioáng heät nhö ñöôøng Nam Tuyeàn?" Thieàn sö Nam Tuyeàn giô caùi             moäng." Theo Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc, Luïc löôõi lieàm leân noùi: "Caùi lieàm caét coû cuûa laõo Taêng   Hoaøn Ñaïi Phu tham kieán Nam Tuyeàn ñaõ laâu, bình mua 30 tieàn." Vò Taêng thöa: "Khoâng hoûi caùi lieàm         thöôøng löu taâm trong lyù taùnh, taàm khaûo Trieäu caét coû, chæ hoûi con ñöôøng Nam Tuyeàn ñi veà höôùng        Luaän. Moät hoâm, ngoài baøn luaän ñem hai caâu cho laø naøo?" Thieàn sö Nam Tuyeàn noùi: "Laõo Taêng söû             kyø ñaëc, hoûi: "Trieäu Phaùp Sö noùi 'Trôøi ñaát cuøng ta duïng caùi naøy raát taøi tình."—The koan about the           ñoàng goác, vaïn vaät cuøng ta moät theå' thaät laø kyø potentiality and conditions of questions and                  quaùi?" Trieäu Phaùp Sö laø vò cao Taêng ñôøi Taán cuøng answers Zen master Nan Chuan Pu Yuan and a                    Ñaïo Sinh, Taêng Dueä, Ñaïo Dung ñoàng döôùi tay cuûa monk. According to the Records of the                         Cöu Ma La Thaäp, goïi laø Töù Trieát. Phaùp sö Taêng Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu),                    Trieäu thuôû nhoû thích ñoïc Laõo Trang, sau nhôn vieát Volume VIII, one day, when Zen master was                     kinh Duy Ma Caät coù choã ngoä, môùi bieát Laõo Trang cutting grass in the mountain, a wandering monk               vaãn chöa taän thieän. Sö chuyeån hôïp caùc kinh laøm came and asked, "What direction leads to Nan                  thaønh boán quyeån luaän (Baùt Nhaõ Voâ Tri Luaän, Baát

Chaân Khoâng Luaän, Vaät Baát Thieân Luaän, vaø Nieát              nghe noùi: "Moät con ñöôøng höôùng thöôïng ngaøn Baøn Voâ Danh Luaän). YÙ chæ Laõo Trang noùi trôøi ñaát            thaùnh chaúng truyeàn, hoïc giaû nhoïc hình nhö khæ baét hình lôùn, hình ta cuõng vaäy, ñoàng sanh trong hö voâ.            boùng."—As the officer Lu Hsuan was talking with Trang Sanh ñaïi yù chæ luaän teà vaät. Ñaïi Coâng ñaïi yù          Nan Ch'uan, he said, "Master of the Teachings luaän taùnh ñeàu qui veà chính mình. Nhö trong luaän,              Chao sai, 'Heaven, earth, and I have the same Sö noùi: "Phaøm baäc chí chôn roãng tueách khoâng hình             root; myriad things and I are one body.' This is töôïng maø vaïn vaät ñeàu do ta taïo, hoâò vaïn vaät veà           quite marvelous." Nan Ch'uan pointed to a flower chính mình chæ laø baäc thaùnh nhaân. Tuy coù thaàn coù            in the garden. He called to the officer and said, ngöôøi, coù hieàn coù thaùnh, moãi loaïi khaùc nhau, song          "People these days see this flower as a dream." ñeàu ñoàng moät taùnh theå." Coå nhaân noùi: "Toät caû caøn        According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, the khoân ñaïi ñòa chæ laø moät caùi chính mình, laïnh thì             officer Lu Hsuan studied for a long time with Nan khaép trôøi khaép ñaát laïnh, noùng thì khaép trôøi khaép          Ch'uan. He always kept his mind on essential ñaát noùng, coù thì khaép trôøi khaép ñaát coù, khoâng thì         nature, and he immersed himself in the Discourses khaép trôøi khaép ñaát khoâng, phaûi thì khaép trôøi khaép         of Chao. One day as they sat, he happened to ñaát phaûi, quaáy thì khaép trôøi khaép ñaát quaáy." Phaùp         bring up these two lines, considering them Nhaõn noùi: "Y y y, ta ta ta, nam baéc ñoâng taây ñeàu             remarkable. He questioned, "Master of the toát toát, chaúng toát toát, chæ coù ta thaûy laø toát." Vì theá   Teachings Chao said, 'Heaven, earth, and I have noùi: "Treân trôøi, döôùi trôøi, chæ ta laø hôn heát." Thaïch      the same root; myriad things and I are one body.' Ñaàu xem Trieäu Luaän ñeán choã "hoäi vaïn vaät veà                This is quite marvelous." Master of the Teachings chính mình," hoaùt nhieân ñaïi ngoä, sau laøm baûn                 Seng Chao was an eminent monk of Chin times Tham Ñoàng Kheá chaúng ngoaøi yù naøy. Xem oâng hoûi               (later 4th, early 5th centuries A.D.); he was theá aáy, haõy noùi ñoàng goác gì? Ñoàng theå naøo? Ñeán           together with Tao Sheng, Tao Jung, and Seng Jui trong ñaây quaû laø kyø ñaëc, haù ñoàng vôùi ngöôøi thöôøng        in the school of Kumarajiva. They were called the chaúng bieát trôøi cao ñaát daøy, ñaâu coù vieäc theá aáy.         Four Stages. When Seng Chao was young, he Luïc Hoaøn Ñaïi Phu hoûi nhö theá, kyø thì raát kyø, chæ laø       enjoyed reading Chuang Tzu and Lao Tzu. Later, chaúng thoaùt ngoaøi yù kinh. Neáu noùi yù kinh laø toät, vì       as he was copying the old translation of the sao Theá Toân laïi nieâm hoa, Toå Sö laïi Taây sang laøm           Vimalakirti Scripture, he had an enlightenment. gì? Choã ñaùp cuûa Nam Tuyeàn laø duøng loã muõi cuûa              Then he knew that Chuang and Lao still were not Thieàn Taêng, vì kia ñöa ra choã ñau, ñeå phaù hang oå             really thoroughgoing. Therefore, he completed all kia. Beøn chæ caây hoa tröôùc saân, keâu Ñaïi Phu noùi:            the scriptures and composed four discourses. What "Thôøi nhôn thaáy moät goác hoa naøy gioáng heät nhö               Chuang and Lao intended to say was that "heaven moäng." Nhö daãn ngöôøi leân ñeán bôø cao muoân                    and earth are greatness of form; my form is also tröôïng roài xoâ moät caùi khieán hoï teù cheát. Neáu oâng xoâ     thus; we are alike born in the midst of empty teù treân ñaát baèng, cho ñeán ñöùc Phaät Di Laëc ra ñôøi          nothingness." Chuang and Lao's overall meaning cuõng chaúng laøm cho ngöôøi cheát. Gioáng heät nhö                just discusses equalizing things; Seng Chao's ngöôøi ñang moäng muoán tænh maø tænh khoâng ñöôïc,                overall meaning says that nature all returns to self. bò ngöôøi goïi lieàn tænh. Neáu Nam Tuyeàn con maét                Have you not seen how his discourse says, "The chaúng chaùnh, quyeát ñònh bò oâng aáy boâi veõ roài. Xem          ultimate man is empty and hollow, without form; Sö noùi thoaïi theá aáy thöïc laø khoù hieåu. Neáu laø ngöôøi      yet none of the myriad things are not his own con maét ñònh ñoäng linh hoaït nghe ñöôïc nhö thöôïng              doing. Who can understand that myriad things are vò ñeà hoà. Neáu laø keû cheát nghe ñöôïc trôû thaønh thuoác       his own self? Only a sage, I wot." Although there ñoäc. Coå nhaân noùi: "Neáu ôû treân söï thaáy thì rôi taïi        are spirits and there are humans, there are the taàm thöôøng; neáu nhaèm döôùi yù caên suy tính doø tìm            wise and the sage, each is distinct, but all alike thì chaúng ñöôïc." Nham Ñaàu noùi: "Ñaây laø keá soáng             have one nature and one substance. An Ancient cuûa ngöôøi höôùng thöôïng, chæ hieän baøy tröôùc maét             said, "Heaven and earth, the whole world, is just choác laùt nhö ñieän chôùp." Ñaïi yù Nam Tuyeàn nhö                one self; when cold, it is cold throughout heaven theá, coù thuû ñoaïn baét con teâ con coïp, ñònh roàng raén.       and earth; when hot, it is hot throughout heaven Ñeán trong aáy phaûi töï hoäi môùi ñöôïc. Ñaâu chaúng              and earth. When it exists, all throughout heaven

and earth exists; when it doesn't exist, heaven and        feelings; if you go to your intellect to figure it out, earth do not exist. When affirmed, all throughout          after all you will seek without finding." Yen T'ou heaven and earth is; when denied, all throughout           said, "This is the livelihood of a transcendent man; heaven and earth is not." Fa Yen said, "He, he, he.        he just reveals the bit before the eyes, just like a I, I, I. South north east west, everything is all right.   flash of lightning." Nan Ch'uan's great meaning All right or not all right, only for me there is           was like this; he has the capability to capture nothing not all right." That is why it was said, "In       rhinos and tigers, to judge dragons and snakes. the heavens and on earth, only I alone am                  When you get here, you must understand on your honorable." As Shih T'ou read the Discourse of             own: have you not heard it said, "The single Chao, when he got to this place, "Understand               transcending road has not been transmitted by a myriad things as oneself," he was vastly and               thousand sages; students toil over forms like greatly enlightened. Later he composed the book            moneys grasping at reflections." Ts'an T'ing Ch'i (Merging of Difference and                Coâng AÙn Nam Tuyeàn Phaùp Voâ Thuyeát: Nan Sameness), which also does not go beyond this              Ch'uan's Truth that's never been spoken, example meaning. See how Lu Hsuan questioned; tell me,             28 of the Pi-Yen-Lu—Thí duï thöù 28 cuûa Bích what root do they share? Which body do they have           Nham Luïc. Nam Tuyeàn ñeán tham vaán Hoøa in common? When he got here, still he was                  Thöôïng Nieát Baøn ôû nuùi Baùch Tröôïng. Baùch undeniably unique: how could this be the same as           Tröôïng hoûi: "Töø tröôùc chö Thaùnh laïi coù phaùp an ordinary man's ignorance of the height of the           chaúng vì ngöôøi noùi chaêng?" Nam Tuyeàn ñaùp: "Coù." sky or the breadth of the earth? How could there           Baùch Tröôïng hoûi: "Theá naøo laø phaùp chaúng vì ngöôøi be such a thing? Lu Hsuan's questioning in this            noùi?" Nam Tuyeàn ñaùp: "Chaúng phaûi taâm, chaúng manner was indeed quite exceptional, but he did            phaûi Phaät, chaúng phaûi vaät." Baùch Tröôïng baûo: not go beyond the meaning of the Teachings. If             "Noùi roài vaäy." Nam Tuyeàn hoûi: "Con chæ theá aáy, you say that the meaning of the Teachings is the           Hoøa Thöôïng theá naøo?" Baùch Tröôïng baûo: "Ta ultimate paradigm, then why did the World                  chaúng phaûi ñaïi thieän tri thöùc, ñaâu bieát coù noùi chaúng Honored One also raise the flower? What did the            noùi." Nam Tuyeàn thöa: "Con chaúng hoäi." Baùch Patriarchal Teacher come from the West for? Nan            tröôïng baûo: "Ta vì oâng maø noùi raát nhieàu roài." Theo Ch'uan's way of answering used the grip of a               Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc, ñeán trong ñaây patchrobed monk to pull out the painful spot for           cuõng chaúng tieâu töùc taâm chaúng töùc taâm, chaúng tieâu the other, and broke up his nest; he pointed at a          phi taâm chaúng phi taâm, thaúng ñoù töø ñaàu ñeán chaân flower in the garden and called to the officer,            moät sôïi loâng maøy cuõng khoâng, vaãn coøn ñoâi chuùt so saying, "People these days see this flower as              saùnh. Töùc taâm phi taâm, Thieàn sö Thoï cho ñoù laø though it were a dream." This is like leading the          'bieåu thuyeân' vaø 'giaù thuyeân'. Hoøa Thöôïng Nieát man to the edge of a ten thousand fathom cliff and         Baøn töùc laø thieàn sö Chaùnh Phaùp, khi xöa ôû choã giving him a push, causing his life to be cut off. If      Baùch Tröôïng laøm Taây ñöôøng, baûo chuùng khai ñieàn you were pushed over on level ground, even till            vì noùi ñaïi nghóa. Khi aáy Nam Tuyeàn ñaõ gaë p Maõ Maitreya Buddha was born in the world, you still           Toå xong, chæ caàn ñeán caùc nôi ñeå quyeát traïch. Baùch would simply be unable to accomplish the cutting           Tröôïng ñaët caâu hoûi raát khoù ñaùp "Töø tröôùc chö off of life. It is also like a man in a dream; though      Thaùnh laïi coù phaùp chaúng vì ngöôøi noùi chaêng?" Neáu he wants to awaken, he cannot wake up; called by           laø sôn Taêng chæ bòt tai ñi ra, xem oâng giaø naày nhö another, he awakens. If Nan Ch'uan's eyes were             moät tröôøng roái loaïn. Neáu laø haøng taùc gia, thaáy not true, he would certainly have been befuddled           Baùch Tröôïng hoûi theá aáy lieàn bieát phaù ñöôïc. Nam by Lu Hsuan. See how he talks; yet undeniably he           Tuyeàn cöù choã thaáy ñaùp: "Coù." Theá laø Maïnh Baùt is difficult to understand. If the action of your eyes     Lan. Baùch Tröôïng beøn ñem laàm naày ñeán laàm kia is alive, you will experience it like the superb           theo sau noùi: "Theá naøo laø phaùp chaúng vì ngöôøi flavor of ghee; if you are dead, you will hear it          noùi?" Nam Tuyeàn ñaùp: "Chaúng phaûi taâm, chaúng and turn it into poison. An Ancient said, "If you          phaûi Phaät, chaúng phaûi vaät." Laõo naày thích xem maët see it in phenomena, you'll fall into ordinary             traêng treân trôøi, rôi maát haït chaâu trong tay. Baùch

Tröôïng baûo: "Noùi roài vaäy." Ñaùng tieác thay! Vì kia          in return he preached the great meaning for them. chuù phaù. Ngay khi aáy chæ nhaèm xöông soáng maø                 At this time Nan Ch'uan had already seen Ma Tsu, ñaùnh, cho kia bieát ñau nhöùc. Tuy nhieân nhö theá,              but he was going around to various places to settle oâng haõy noùi choã naøo laø choã noùi roài? Cöù choã thaáy       what's righ and pick out what wrong. When Pai cuûa Nam Tuyeàn "Chaúng phaûi taâm, chaúng phaûi                  Chang posed this question it was indeed very Phaät, chaúng phaûi vaät" laø chöa töøng noùi ñeán. Thöû          difficult to respond to. He said, "Have all the hoûi caùc oâng, taïi sao laïi baûo "Noùi roài"? Döôùi lôøi cuûa   sages since antiquity had a truth that they haven't Sö khoâng coù daáu veát. Neáu baûo Sö chaúng noùi, vì             spoken for people?" If it had been me, I would sao Baùch Tröôïng laïi noùi theá aáy? Nam Tuyeàn laø              have covered my ears and left. Look at this old ngöôøi bieán thoâng lieàn theo sau moät caùi ñaåy, "Con           fellow's scene of embarrassment. If an adept had chæ theá aáy, Hoøa Thöôïng laïi theá naøo?" Neáu laø ngöôøi       seen him asking this way, he would have been khaùc chöa khoûi boái roái, ngaïi vì Baùch Tröôïng laø            able to see through him immediately. But Nan haøng taùc gia, choã ñaùp quaû thöïc kyø ñaëc, "Ta chaúng         Ch'uan just went by what he had seen, so he said, phaûi laø ñaïi thieän tri thöùc, ñaâu bieát coù noùi khoâng       "They have." This was indeed brash. Pai Chang noùi." Nam Tuyeàn thöa: "Con chaúng hoäi." Theá laø               then added error to error and followed up behind Sö ñaõ hoäi roài maø laïi noùi chaúng hoäi? Chaúng phaûi          saying, "What is the truth that hasn't been spoken thaät khoâng hoäi. Baùch Tröôïng baûo: "Ta raát vì oâng           for people?" Nan Ch'uan said, "It's not mind, it's noùi xong." Haõy noùi choã naøo laø choã Baùch Tröôïng            not Buddha, it's not any thing."Greedily gazing at ñaõ noùi cho Nam Tuyeàn? Neáu laø keû ñuøa hoøn ñaát thì          the moon in the sky, this fellow has lost the pearl hai caùi loän xoän. Neáu caû hai ñeàu laø taùc gia thì nhö        in the palm of his hand. Pai Chang said, "You said göông saùng taïi ñaøi. Kyø thaät phaàn tröôùc caû hai ñeàu        it." Too bad, he explained in full for Nan Ch'uan. laø taùc gia, phaàn sau caû hai ñeàu boû qua. Haønh giaû tu       At the time I would have simply brought my staff thieàn, neáu laø ngöôøi ñuû maét saùng thì nghieäm thaáy roõ      down across his back to get him to know real pain. raøng. Haõy noùi laøm sao nghieäm kia?—Nan Ch'uan                 Although it was like this, you tell me, where did went to see Master Nirvana of Pai Chang. Pai                      he say it? According to Nan Ch'uan's view, it's not Chang asked, "Have all the sages since antiquity                  mind, it's not Buddha, it's not any thing, it's never had a truth that they haven't spoken for people?"                 been spoken. So I ask all of you, why did Pai Nan Ch'uan said, "They have." Pai Chang said,                     Chang nevertheless say, "You said it"? And there "What is the truth that hasn't been spoken for                    aren't any traces in Nan Ch'uan's words. If you say people?" Nan Ch'uan said, "It's not mind, it's not                he didn't say it, then why did Pai Chang talk like Buddha, it's not anything." Pai Chang said, "You                  this? Nan Ch'uan was a man who could shift and said it." Nan Ch'uan said, "I am just thus. What                  get through, so after this he pressed Pai Chang and about you, Teacher?" Pai Chang said, "I am not a                  said, "I am just thus. What about you, Teacher?" If great man of knowledge either: how would I know                   it had been anyone else, he wouldn't have been whether it has been spoken or not?" Nan Ch'uan                    able to explain. But Pai Chang was an adept: his said, "I don't understand." Pai Chang said, "I've                 answer is undeniably extraordinary. Immediately already spoken too much for you." According to                    he said, "I am not a great man of knowledge Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, at this point he doesn't                either: how would I know whether it has been use "it's mind" or "it's not mind," nor does he use               spoken or not?" Nan Ch'uan then said, "I don't "not mind" or "not not mind." Even though from                    understand." He said, "I don't understand" while head to foot he doesn't have one hair of his                      actually he did understand: this is not genuine not eyebrows, still, he's gotten somewhere.                           understanding. Pai Chang said, "I've already Meditation Master Shou calls "it's mind" a                        spoken too much for you." But tell me, where did revealing explanation and "it's not mind" a                       he speak? If they had been two fellows playing concealing explanation. This Master Nirvana is                    with mud balls, both would have been covered Meditation Master Fa Cheng. Formerly he                           with slime. If both were adepts, they were like dwelled as retired abbot in the Western hall at Pai               bright mirrors in their stands. In fact in the Chang: he had the monks clear fields for him and                  beginning both were adepts, in the end both let go.

Zen practitioners, if you're a fellow with eyes,               trình ñoä cao maø tröïc giaùc saâu xa cuûa hoï töông you'll judge them clearly. But say, how will you               xöùng vôùi tröïc giaùc cuûa nhöõng ngöôøi ñeà ra coâng aùn, judge them?                                                    nhö theá hoï môùi coù theå nhaän thöùc ñöôïc tröïc tieáp vaø Coâng AÙn Nam Tuyeàn Thaïch Phaät: Nan Ch'uan                  roõ raøng yù nghóa cuûa coâng aùn maø khoâng caàn phaûi “Can it be carved into the image of a Buddha?”—                nhôø ñeán phoûng ñoaùn hay phaân tích. Neáu haønh giaû Coâng aùn noùi veà cô duyeân vaán ñaùp giöõa Thieàn sö         saün saøng khoâng sôï hieåu laàm thì nhöõng coâng aùn loaïi Nam Tuyeàn Phoå Nguyeän vaø Luïc Hoaøn. Theo                   naøy coù theå khoâng phaûi laø tuyeät ñoái khoâng theå hieåu Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån VIII, moät hoâm          hoaëc khoâng theå giaûi thích ñöôïc, nhöng ñaây khoâng Luïc Hoaøn ñaïi phu, moät trong nhöõng ñeä töû xuaát saéc      phaûi laø ñieàu mong muoán cuûa nhieàu haønh giaû tu nhaát cuûa Thieàn sö Nam Tuyeàn Phoå Nguyeän, hoûi             Thieàn. Theo Voâ Moân Hueä Khai trong Voâ Moân Thaày raèng: "Trong nhaø ñeä töû coù moät phieán ñaù maø       Quan, haønh giaû tu thieàn thöû nghó xem Trieäu Chaâu coù luùc chuùng con ñöùng treân ñoù; coù luùc chuùng con       ñoäi deùp coû nhö vaäy nhaèm yù gì? Neáu ôû ñaây maø haï ngoài treân ñoù. Baây giôø coù theå khaéc phieán ñaù ñoù ñeå   ñöôïc moät caâu chuyeån ngöõ thì söï thaùch thöùc cuûa laøm töôïng Phaät ñöôïc khoâng?" Nam Tuyeàn noùi:              Nam Tuyeàn quaû khoâng phaûi laø voâ traùch nhieäm. "Ñöôïc! Ñöôïc!" Luïc Hoaøn laïi hoûi: "Nhöng laøm nhö          Coøn neáu chöa thì haõy caån troïng! Ñaây cuõng laø thí vaäy laøm sao ñöôïc?" Nam Tuyeàn noùi: "Khoâng                 duï thöù 63 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Theo Vieân Ngoä ñöôïc! Khoâng ñöôïc!"—The koan about the                       trong Bích Nham Luïc, haøng Toâng sö moät ñoäng moät potentiality and conditions of questions and                   tònh, moät ra moät vaøo, haõy noùi yù chæ theá naøo? Caâu answers between Zen Master Nan Ch'uan and Lu                   chuyeän cheùm meøo, trong tuøng laâm khaép nôi baøn Hsuan. According to the Records of the                         taùn xoân xao. Coù ngöôøi noùi: "Choã ñeà khôûi lieàn Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu),                     phaûi." Laïi coù ngöôøi noùi: "ÔÛ choã cheùm." Hoaøn toaøn Volume VIII, one day, Governor Lu Hsuan, one of                khoâng dính daùng. Nam Tuyeàn neáu khi chaúng ñeå the most outstanding dharma-heirs of Zen master                khôûi khaép nôi cuõng taïo taùc ñaïo lyù. Ñaâu chaúng bieát, Nan Ch'uan, asked the Master, "There is a piece                coå nhaân coù con maét ñònh caøn khoân, coù caây kieám of stone in my house. Sometimes we stand up on                 ñònh caøn khoân. OÂng haõy noùi cöùu caùnh laø ai cheùm it; sometimes we lie down on it. Now, can it be                con meøo? Chæ khi Nam Tuyeàn ñeà khôûi: "Noùi ñöôïc carved into the image of a Buddha?" The Master                 töùc chaúng cheùm." Chính khi aáy boãng coù ngöôøi noùi answered, "Yes, it is possible." But Lu Hsuan                  ñöôïc thì Nam Tuyeàn cheùm hay khoâng cheùm? Vì countered, "But is it impossible to do so?" "It is             theá noùi: "Chaùnh leänh ñöông haønh, ngoài ñoaïn möôøi impossible! It is impossible!" exclaimed the                   phöông, thoaùt ra xem ngoaøi trôøi, ai laø ngöôøi trong Master.                                                        aáy?" Kyø thaät ñöông thôøi voán chaúng cheùm, thoaïi Coâng AÙn Nam Tuyeàn Traûm Mieâu: Nan-ch'uan                   naøy cuõng chaúng ôû choã cheùm cuøng chaúng cheùm. Kills the Cat—Nam Tuyeàn ñöôïc nhaéc tôùi trong caùc           Vieäc naøy thaät bieát roõ raøng nhö theá, chaúng ôû treân thí duï 14, 19, 27 vaø 34 cuûa Voâ Moân Quan. Thí duï          tình traàn yù kieán thaûo luaän. Neáu nhaèm treân tình traàn 14 noùi veà Nam Tuyeàn cheùm meøo. Ngaøy noï, Taêng            yù kieán thaûo luaän thì coâ phuï Nam Tuyeàn. Chæ nhaèm chuùng hai chaùi ñoâng taây tranh nhau con meøo. Hoøa          treân muõi nhoïn kieám beùn xem thì coù cuõng ñöôïc, Thöôïng Nam Tuyeàn giô con meøo leân maø noùi: "Caùc           khoâng cuõng ñöôïc, chaúng coù chaúng khoâng cuõng oâng noùi ñöôïc thì tha, khoâng noùi ñöôïc thì cheùm."         ñöôïc. Vì theá coå nhaân noùi: "Cuøng taéc bieán, bieán taéc Chaúng ai bieát noùi sao. Nam Tuyeàn beøn cheùm con            thoâng." Ngöôøi ñôøi nay chaúng hieåu bieán thoâng, chæ meøo. Ñeán toái Trieäu Chaâu veà, Nam Tuyeàn keå               nhaèm treân ngoân cuù maø chaïy. Nam Tuyeàn ñeà khôûi chuyeän laïi cho nghe. Trieäu Chaâu beøn côûi deùp, ñeå        theá aáy, khoâng theå baûo ngöôøi haï ñöôïc lôøi gì? Chæ leân ñaàu maø ñi ra. Nam Tuyeàn noùi: "Neáu luùc aáy coù       caàn baûo ngöôøi töï tieán, moãi moãi töï duïng töï bieát. oâng thì cöùu ñöôïc con meøo roài." Ñaây laø loaïi coâng       Neáu chaúng hieåu theá aáy, chôït doø tìm khoâng ñeán. aùn ôû möùc ñoä naøo ñoù khoù hieåu vaø khoù giaûi thích.      Hôn nöõa, khi khoâng ai ñaùp ñöôïc, vaø Nam Tuyeàn Nhöõng Thieàn Taêng moâ taû loaïi coân g aùn naøy nhö laø      lieàn gieát cheát con meøo voâ phöôùc. Nam Tuyeàn loaïi "baát khaû theå nhaäp," gioáng nhö "nhöõng raëng         döôøng nhö laø moät keû quaù nhaãn taâm, nhöng quan nuùi baïc vaø nhöõng böùc töôøng saét." Noùi ñuùng ra, loaïi   ñieåm cuûa Sö coù theå laø nhö vaày: "Noùi 'coù' laø keït ôû naøy chæ coù theå ñöôïc hieåu bôûi nhöõng haønh giaû coù       caùi theá nhò nguyeân. Noùi 'khoâng' cuõng keït nhö nhau.

Muoán ñaït chaân lyù caàn phaûi traùnh thaùi ñoä nhò          not held it up, then would you still spin out all nguyeân ñoái ñaõi aáy. Laøm sao traùnh? Neáu maáy oâng        sorts of rationalizations? You are far from (ñeä töû cuûa Nam Tuyeàn) khoâng traùnh khoûi ngoõ cuït       knowing that this Ancient had the eye to judge aáy thì khoâng nhöõng con meøo maát maïng, maø caû            heaven and earth, and he had the sword to settle chính maïng cuûa maáy oâng, vaø caû linh hoàn nöõa cuõng      heaven and earth. Now you tell me, after all, who maát luoân." Do ñoù, Nam Tuyeàn môùi duøng ñeán moät          was it that kill the cat? Just when Nan Ch'uan held thuû ñoaïn heát söùc cöïc ñoan ñeå nhaèm caûnh tænh ñeä töû   it up and said, "If you can't speak, then I won't kill cuûa mình—Nan-Ch’uan appears in examples 14,                  it," at this moment, if there were suddenly 19, 27, and 34 of the Wu-Men-Kuan. Example 14                 someone who could speak, tell me, would Nan talks about "Nan-ch'uan Kills the Cat." One day,              Ch'uan have killed it or not? This is why I say, Zen master Nan-ch'uan found monks of the                      "When the true imperative goes into effect, the eastern and western halls arguing about a cat. He             ten directions are subdued." Stick your head out held up the cat and said, "Everyone, if you can say           beyond the heavens and look; who's there? The something, I will spare this cat. If you can't say            fact is that at that time he really did not kill. This anything, I will cut off its head." No one could say          story does not lie in killing or not killing. This a word, so Nan-ch'uan cut the cat into two. That              matter is clearly known; it is so distinctly clear. It evening, Chao-chou returned from outside and                  is not to be found in emotions or opinions; if you Nan-ch'uan told him what happened. Chao-chou                  go searching in emotions and opinions, then you removed a sandal from his foot, put it on his head,           turn against Nan Ch'uan. Just see it right on the and walked out. Nan-ch'uan said, "If you had been             edge of the knife. If it exists, all right; if it does there, the cat would have been spared." This is a             not exist, all right; if it neither exists nor doesn't kind of koan which is somewhat difficult to                   exist, that is all right too. That is why an Ancient understand and explain. Zen monks describe this               said, "When at an impasse, change; when you type of koans as the "impenetrable type," like                change, then you can pass through." People "silver mountains and iron walls." This can, strictly         nowadays do not know how to change and pass speaking, only be understood by advanced                      through; they only go running to the spoken words. practitioners whose profound intuitions match                 When Nan Ch'uan held up the cat in this way, he those of the actors, thus enabling them to discern            could not have been telling people they should be directly and clearly the meaning of the koan                  able to say something; he just wanted people to without resorting to guesses or analysis. If one is           attain on their own, each act on their own, and willing to risk missing the point, these koans may            know for themselves. If you do not understand it not be absolutely unintelligible or unexplainable,            in this way, after all you will grope without finding but this is not the desirability of many Zen                  it. Furthermore, when no one made a response, practitioners. According to Wu Men Hui-Kai in                 and the master slew the poor kitten. Nan-ch'uan the Wu-Men-Kuan, Zen practitioners, what do you               looks like a hard-hearted man, but his point may think about the meaning of Chao-chou putting his              be this: "To say it is involves us in a dilema; to say sandal on his head? If you can give a turning word            it is not puts us in the same predicament. To attain here, you will see that Nan-ch'uan's challenge was            the truth, this dualism must be avoided. How do not irresponsible. But if you cannot yet do this, be          you avoid it? It may not only be the loss of the life careful! This is also example 63 of the Pi-Yen-Lu.            of a kitten, but also the loss of your own life and According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, an                     soul, if you fail to ride over this impasse." accomplished master of our school: see his                    Therefore, Nan-ch'uan utilized a drastic procedure movement, stillness, his going out and entering in.           to open the eye of his disciples. Tell me, what was his inner meaning? This story               Coâng AÙn Nam Tuyeàn Vaán Trieäu Chaâu: Nan- about killing the cat is widely discussed in                  ch'uan Questions Chao Chou—Theo thí duï thöù 64 monasteries everywhere. Some say that the                     cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Ngaøy noï, Taêng chuùng hai holding up is it; some say it lies in the cutting. But        chaùi ñoâng taây tranh nhau con meøo. Hoøa Thöôïng actually these bear no relation to it all. If he had          Nam Tuyeàn giô con meøo leân maø noùi: "Caùc oâng noùi

ñöôïc thì tha, khoâng noùi ñöôïc thì cheùm." Chaúng ai          you had been there, the cat would have been bieát noùi sao. Nam Tuyeàn beøn cheùm con meøo. Ñeán            spared." According to Wu Men Hui-Kai in the toái Trieäu Chaâu veà, Nam Tuyeàn keå chuyeän laïi cho          Wu-Men-Kuan, Zen practitioners, what do you nghe. Trieäu Chaâu beøn côûi deùp, ñeå leân ñaàu maø ñi         think about the meaning of Chao Chou putting his ra. Nam Tuyeàn noùi: "Neáu luùc aáy coù oâng thì cöùu           sandal on his head? If you can give a turning word ñöôïc con meøo roài." Theo Voâ Moân Hueä Khai trong             here, you will see that Nan-ch'uan's challenge was Voâ Moân Quan, haønh giaû tu thieàn thöû nghó xem               not irresponsible. But if you cannot yet do this, be Trieäu Chaâu ñoäi deùp coû nhö vaäy nhaèm yù gì? Neáu ôû        careful! According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, ñaây maø haï ñöôïc moät caâu chuyeån ngöõ thì söï thaùch        Chao Chou was Nan Ch'uan's true heir; when Nan thöùc cuûa Nam Tuyeàn quaû khoâng phaûi laø voâ traùch          Ch'uan spoke of the head, Chao Chou understood nhieäm. Coøn neáu chöa thì haõy caån troïng! Theo               the tail; when it is brought up, he immediately Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc, Trieäu Chaâu laø               knows where it comes down. In the evening Nan ñích töû cuûa Nam Tuyeàn, noùi ñaàu hieåu ñuoâi, cöû ñeán       Ch'uan repeated the preceding story and asked laø bieát choã rôi. Nam Tuyeàn ñeán chieàu thuaät laïi lôøi     Chao Chou about it. Chao Chou was an old adept; khi saùng hoûi Trieäu Chaâu, Trieäu Chaâu laø laõo taùc         he immediately took off his straw sandals, put gia, lieàn côûi giaøy coû ñoäi leân ñaàu maø ñi ra. Thöû noùi   them on his head, and left. Nan Ch'uan said, "If thaät theá aáy, chaúng thaät theá aáy? Nam Tuyeàn noùi:         you had been here, you could have saved the cat." "Noùi ñöôïc thì khoâng cheùm," nhö choïi ñaù nhaùng             But tell me, was it really like this or not? Nan löûa, tôï laøn ñieån chôùp. Trieäu Chaâu lieàn côûi giaøy coû   Ch'uan said, "If you can speak, then I won't kill it." ñoäi leân ñaàu maø ñi ra. Sö tham caâu soáng chaúng             Like a flint-struck spark, like a flash of lightning, tham caâu cheát, ngaøy ngaøy môùi, giôø giôø môùi, ngaøn        Chao Chou immediately took off his sandals, put Thaùnh dôøi ñoåi moät maûy tô cuõng chaúng ñöôïc. Phaûi         them on his head, and left; he studied the living laø vaän duïng ñöôïc cuûa baùu nhaø mình, môùi thaáy toaøn      word, not the dead word; each day renewed, each cô ñaïi duïng cuûa Sö. Sö noùi ta laø vua phaùp, ñoái vôùi      moment renewed; even the thousand sages could phaùp ñöôïc töï taïi. Nhieàu ngöôøi hieåu laàm noùi Trieäu      not stir a hairsbreadth. You must bring forth your Chaâu quyeàn bieán ñem giaøy coû laøm con meøo. Coù             own family treasure; only then will you see the ngöôøi noùi: "Ñôïi kia baûo noùi ñöôïc thì khoâng cheùm,        great function of his total capacity. He is saying, "I lieàn ñoäi giaøy coû ñi ra, töï laø oâng cheùm con meøo,        am King of Dharma, free in all respects." Many chaúng can döï gì ñeán toâi." Vaãn khoâng dính daùng,           people misunderstand and say that Chao Chou chæ laø ñuøa tinh hoàn. Ñaâu chaúng bieát coå nhaân nhö         temporarily made his sandals into the cat. Some trôøi khaép che, nhö ñaát khaép chôû. Thaày troø Sö hôïp        say he meant, "When you say, 'If you can speak, nhau, cô phong kheá nhau, beân naøy ñöa ñaàu beân kia           then I won't kill it,' I would then put my sandals on lieàn hieåu ñuoâi. Hoïc giaû thôøi nay chaúng bieát choã coå    my head and leave. It's just you killing the cat; it's nhaân chuyeån, chaïy roãng treân ñöôøng yù suy tính.            none of my business." But this has nothing to do Neáu caàn thaáy, chæ ñeán choã chuyeån cuûa Nam                 with it; this is just giving play to the spirit. You are Tuyeàn, Trieäu Chaâu lieàn thaáy—According to                   far from knowing that the Ancient's meaning was example 64 of the Pi-Yen-Lu, Nan-ch'uan                         like the universal cover of the sky, like the Questions Chao Chou, example 64 of the Pi-Yen-                  universal support of the earth. That father and son Lu. One day, Zen master Nan-ch'uan found monks                  conformed with each other; the edges of their of the eastern and western halls arguing about a                activity met with each other. When Nan Ch'uan cat. He held up the cat and said, "Everyone, if you             raised the head, Chao Chou immediately can say something, I will spare this cat. If you                understood the tail. Students these days do not can't say anything, I will cut off its head." No one            know the turning point of the Ancients, and vainly could say a word, so Nan-ch'uan cut the cat into                go to the road of ideation to figure them out. If two. That evening, Chao-chou returned from                      you want to see, just go to Nan Ch'uan's and Chao outside and Nan-ch'uan told him what happened.                  Chou's turning point and you will see them well. Chao-chou removed a sandal from his foot, put it                Coâng AÙn Nan Ngoä: Koans that are especially on his head, and walked out. Nan-ch'uan said, "If               hard to penetrate—Moät baø laõo döïng moät tuùp leàu,

cung caáp vaät thöïc cho moät nhaø Sö tu haønh roøng raõ         Hakuin and his disciple Torei Enji categorized the suoát hai möôi naêm. Thöôøng thöôøng baø cho moät coâ            below koan as the one that is especially hard to gaùi treû ñeán daâng thöùc aên cho nhaø sö. Moät hoâm, vôùi      penetrate. The difficulty of nanto is not only a muïc ñích traéc nghieäm möùc ñoä noäi chöùng cuûa nhaø           matter of seeing into the koan, but also of sö, baø laõo baûo coâ gaùi aáy oâm laáy ruõ nhaø sö vaø hoûi     integrating the insight one has attained into one's oâng ta: "Baây giôø thì oâng laøm gì ñaây?" Nhaø sö ñaùp:        everyday activities. One must absorb these koans "Moät thaân caây khoâ moïc giöõa vuøng nuùi ñaù laïnh;           as one's marrow and blood, so to speak. Zen khoâng coù chuùt hôi aám söôûi qua ba thaùng muøa                practice is a continuous process of reducing ñoâng." Coâ gaùi beøn keå laïi söï vieäc cho baø laõo nghe,      egocentricity and developing compassion. The vaø baø laõo noùi: "Theá maø ta ñaõ phí maát coâng cuûa ñeå      difficulty and never-ending nature of these tasks chu caáp thöïc vaät vaø choã ôû cho moät keû nhö theá suoát      can be seen in Hakuin's statement: "I experienced hai möôi naêm trôøi!" Baø laõo beøn ñuoåi vò sö aáy ñi vaø       great enlightenment eighteen times; as for small ñoát truïi tuùp leàu. Thieàn sö Baïch AÅn vaø Ñoâng Laõnh        ones, I am unable to remember." Below is another cuõng xeáp coâng aùn döôùi ñaây vaøo nhoùm nan ngoä. Söï         well-known nanto koan from Zen master Fa-Yen. khoù ñaït ngoä ôû ñaây khoâng phaûi laø chuyeän thaáy ñöôïc      One day, Wu-tsu Fa-yen said, "To give an coâng aùn, maø laø phoái hôïp ñöôïc caùi thaáy maø haønh         example, it is like a buffalo passing through a giaû ñaït ñöôïc trong cuoäc soáng haèng ngaøy. Nhö vaäy          window. Its head, horns, and four legs have all phaûi noùi nan ngoä ôû ñaây laø haønh giaû phaûi thaåm thaáu     passed through. Why is it that its tail cannot?" nhöõng coâng aùn naøy vaøo tuûy vaøo maùu cuûa chính             Here one must thoroughly realize that the mình. Tu taäp Thieàn laø moät tieán trình lieân tuïc nhaèm       buffalo's head or tail are not the obstacles. In fact, laøm giaûm thieåu taùnh töï kyû vaø phaùt trieån loøng töø bi.   there are no obstacles, and there never were any; Baûn chaát khoù khaên vaø khoâng bao giôø ngöøng cuûa            from the beginning the buffalo's head and tail coâng vieäc naøy ñöôïc thaáy trong lôøi tuyeân boá cuûa          have already passed through, and are passing, Thieàn sö Baïch AÅn Hueä Haïc: "Laõo Taêng möôøi taùm            always passing through, moment by moment. laàn ñaït ñaïi ngoä, coøn nhöõng laàn nhoû nhaët thì laõo        Coâng AÙn Ngöôõng Sôn Baát Taèng Du Sôn: Yang Taêng khoâng theå nhôù heát ñöôïc." Döôùi ñaây laø moät          Shan Asks "Where Have You Come From?", coâng aùn nan ngoä khaùc cuûa Thieàn sö Phaùp Dieãn.             example 34 of the Pi-Yen-Lu—Thí duï thöù 34 cuûa Moät hoâm, Thieàn sö Nguõ Toå Phaùp Dieãn noùi: "Ñöa             Bích Nham Luïc. Ngöôõng Sôn hoûi moät vò Taêng: ra moät thí duï cuõng gioáng nhö laø traâu ñi qua cöûa soå.      "Vöøa rôøi choã naøo?" Vò Taêng thöa: "Loâ Sôn." Ñaàu, söøng, töù chi ñeàu qua, maø taïi sao caùi ñuoâi laïi      Ngöôõng Sôn hoûi: "Töøng daïo Nguõ Laõo Phong khoâng loït qua ñöôïc?" ÔÛ ñaây haønh giaû phaûi nhaän           chaêng?" Vò Taêng thöa: "Chaúng töøng ñeán." Ngöôõng thöùc moät caùch toaøn dieän raèng ñaâu hay ñuoâi traâu          Sôn noùi: "Xaø Leâ chaúng töøng daïo nuùi." Veà sau Vaân khoâng laø nhöõng trôû ngaïi. Kyø thaät, chaúng coù trôû         Moân noùi: "Lôøi naøy vì côù töø bi neân noùi rôi trong ngaïi naøo caû, vaø chaúng bao giôø coù baát cöù trôû ngaïi      coû." Theo Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc, naøo; töø khôûi thuûy caû ñaàu vaø ñuoâi traâu ñeàu ñaõ loït     nghieäm ngöôøi ñeán choã ñoan ñích, thoát lôøi lieàn laø tri qua, ñang loït qua vaø luoân ñang loït qua vaøo baát cöù         aâm. Coå nhaân noùi: "Khoâng löôïng ñaïi nhaân nhaèm thôøi khaéc naøo—An enlightened elderly woman                    trong ngöõ maïch chuyeån ñi." Neáu laø ñuû con maét ôû once provided a monk with food and lodging for                   ñaûnh moân, nhaéc ñeán lieàn bieát choã rôi. Xem kia twenty years. Always a young girl served the                     moät hoûi moät ñaùp, roõ raøng phaân minh, vì sao Vaân monk his meal. One day the woman instructed the                  Moân laïi noùi "Lôøi naày vì côù töø bi neân noùi rôi trong girl to embrace the monk and ask him, "What are                  coû"? Coå nhaân ñeán trong aáy nhö göông saùng taïi ñaøi, you going to do now?" The girl did as she was told               minh chaâu trong tay, Hoà ñeán hieän Hoà, Haùn ñeán and the monk responded, "The withered tree leans                 hieän Haùn, môùi neân buoâng naém. Vaân Moân nieâm against the cold precipice; three months of winter               raèng: "Vò Taêng naày chính töø Loâ Sôn ñeán," vì sao without a breath of warmth." The girl reported this              laïi noùi "Xaø Leâ chaúng töøng daïo nuùi"? Moät hoâm Qui to the elderly woman, who said, "I have wasted                   Sôn hoûi Ngöôõng Sôn: "Coù Taêng caùc nôi ñeán, con twenty years of food and lodging." She kicked the                ñem caùi gì nghieäm hoï?" Ngöôõng Sôn thöa: "Con monk out and burned down his hut. Zen masters                    coù choã nghieäm." Qui Sôn baûo: "Con thöû neâu

xem?" Ngöôõng Sôn thöa: "Con bình thöôøng thaáy                compassion? It was nevertheless dangerously Taêng ñeán chæ döïng caây phaát töû leân, nhaèm y noùi         steep; getting to this realm, only this fellow could 'Caùc nôi laïi coù caùi naày chaêng'? Ñôïi y coù noùi, chæ     hold up. This monk had personally come from nhaèm y baûo 'Caùi naày thì gaùc laïi, caùi aáy thì theá       Mount Lu; why did Yang Shan then say, "You naøo'?" Qui Sôn baûo: "Ñaây laø nanh vuoát cuûa ngöôøi         have never visited the mountain"? Kuei Shan one höôùng thöôïng." Haù chaúng thaáy Maõ Toå hoûi Baùch           day asked Yang Shan, "When there are monks Tröôïng: "ÔÛ choã naøo ñeán?" Baùch Tröôïng thöa:              coming from various places, what do you use to "Döôùi nuùi ñeán." Maõ Toå hoûi: "Treân ñöôøng gaëp ñöôïc      test them?" Yang Shan said, "I have a way of moät ngöôøi chaêng?" Baùch Tröôïng thöa: "Chaúng               testing." Kuei Shan said, "Try to show me." Yang töøng gaëp." Maõ Toå hoûi: "Vì sao chaúng töøng gaëp?"         Shan said, "Whenever I see a monk coming, I just Baùch Tröôïng thöa: "Neáu gaëp ñöôïc töùc trình leân           lift up my whisk and say to him, 'Do they have this Hoøa Thöôïng." Maõ Toå hoûi: "ÔÛ ñaâu ñöôïc tin töùc           in other places?' When he has something to say, I naày?" Baùch Tröôïng thöa: "Con toäi loãi." Maõ Toå noùi:      just say to him, 'Leaving this aside for the "Laïi laø laõo Taêng toäi loãi." Ngöôõng Sôn hoûi Taêng        moment, what about That?'" Kuei Shan said, "This chính gioáng loaò naày. Khi aáy ñôïi hoûi: "Töøng ñeán         has been the tooth and nail of our sect since time Nguõ Laõo Phong chaêng?", vò Taêng naày neáu laø ngöôøi        immemorial." Haven't you read how Ma Tsu cuï nhaõn chæ ñaùp "Vieäc hoïa", trôû laïi ñaùp: "Chaúng       asked Pai Chang, "Where do you come from?" Pai töøng ñeán." Vò Taêng naày ñaõ chaúng phaûi laø haøng taùc     Chang said, "From down the mountain." Ma Tsu gia, Ngöôõng Sôn sao chaúng cöù leänh maø haønh, khoûi         said, "Did you meet anyone on the road?" Pai thaáy phaàn sau coù nhieàu saén bìm. Ngöôõng Sôn laïi          Chang said, "Not at all." Ma Tsu said, "Why did noùi: "Xaø leâ chaúng töøng daïo nuùi." Vì theá maø Vaân       you not meet anyone at all?" Pai Chang said, "If I Moân noùi "Lôøi naày vì côù töø bi neân noùi rôi trong coû."   had met anyone, I would mention it to you, Neáu laø lôøi ra khoûi coû thì chaúng theá aáy—Yang Shan       teacher." Ma Tsu said, "How could this have been asked a monk, "Where have you just come from?"                 happening?" Pai Chang said, "I am at fault." Ma The monk said, "Mount Lu." Yang Shan said, "Did                Tsu said, "On the contrary, I am at fault." Yang you visit Five Elders Peak?" The monk said, "I                 Shan's questioning the monk was just like these didn't get there." Yang Shan said, "You never                  examples. At that time, when he said, "Did you visited the mountain at all." Later Yun Men said,              ever get to Five Elders Peak?" If that monk had "These words were all for the sake of compassion;              been a man, he would simply have said, "A thus they had a conversation in the weeds."                    disaster." Instead, he said, "I never got there." According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, the point               Since this monk was not an adept, why did Yang of testing someone is to know him intimately as                Shan not act according to the rule, so as to avoid soon as he opens his mouth. An ancient said,                   the many complications that subsequently "Immeasurably great people are turned about in                 appeared? Instead he said, "You never visited the the stream of speech." If you are one who has the              mountain." That is why Yun Men said, "These eye on your forehead, as soon as it is being                   words were all for the sake of compassion, thus brought up, you immediately know where it comes                they had a conversation in the weeds." If it were a down. See their one question, one answer; each is              talk outside the weeds, then it would not be like distinctly clear. Why did Yun Men then say that                this. these words were all for the sake of compassion,               Coâng AÙn Ngöôõng Sôn Chæ Tuyeát: Yang Shan: so they had a conversation in the weeds? When                  pointing at the snow—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô duyeân veà that man of old gets here, he is like a clear mirror           nhöõng lôøi daïy cuûa Thieàn sö Ngöôõng Sôn Hueä Tòch. on its stand, like a bright jewel in the palm of the           Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån XI, moät hand: when a foreigner comes, a foreigner is                   hoâm tuyeát ñoå traéng, phuû ñaày treân mình con sö töû reflected, and when a native comes, a native is                ñaù tröôùc saân. Thieàn sö Ngöôõng Sôn chæ sö töû roài reflected. Not even a single fly could get past his            hoûi ñaïi chuùng: "Coù thöù gì traéng hôn maøu naøy scrutiny. But tell me, how is it that there was a              khoâng?" Khoâng ai traû lôøi ñöôïc. Veà sau, Thieàn sö conversation in the weeds for the sake of                      Vaân Moân Vaên Yeån bình: "Ngay luùc aáy neân xoâ

ngaõ." Thieàn sö Tuyeát Ñaäu Truøng Hieån laïi bình            thirty blows from me?" Kui-shan said, "You will Vaân Moân raèng: "Chæ bieát xoâ ngaõ, chaúng bieát ñôû         be spared of my thirty blows." daäy."—The koan about the potentiality and                     Coâng AÙn Ngöôõng Sôn Saùp Thaâu: Ngöôõng Sôn conditions of lectures from Zen master Yang                    caém xuoång—Yang Shan: Thrusting his hoe into Shan. According to the Records of the                          the ground—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô duyeân vaán ñaùp Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu),                     giöõa Thieàn sö Qui Sôn vaø ñeä töû cuûa mình laø Volume XI, one day, Yang-shan Hui-chi (807-883                 Ngöôõng Sôn Hueä Tòch. Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn or 814-891) pointed to the stone lion that was                 Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån XI, moät hoâm Thieàn sö Qui Sôn covered all over with snow and said to the                     hoûi Ngöôõng Sôn: "Töø ñaâu veà?" Ngöôõng Sôn ñaùp: assembly, "Is there anything whiter than this?"                "Töø ruoäng veà." Qui Sôn laïi hoûi: "Trong ruoäng coù No-one was able to reply. Later, Zen master Yun-               bao nhieâu ngöôøi?" Ngöôõng Sôn lieàn caém xuoång men commented, "Push it down right at that                     xuoáng ñaát roài khoanh tay ñöùng nhìn. Qui Sôn noùi: moment." Zen master Hsueh Tou criticized Yun                   "Nam Sôn coù nhieàu ngöôøi caét coû." Ngöôõng Sôn laïi men, saying, "Yun men only knows how to push it                nhoå caây xuoång leân roài vaùc ñi—The koan about the down, but doesn't know how to get it up."                      potentiality and conditions of questions and Coâng AÙn Ngöôõng Sôn Ñaéc Theå Thaát Duïng:                   answers between Zen master Kuei-Shan and his Yang-shan "Obtaining the Essence and not the                   disciple Yang Shan. According to the Records of Function"—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô duyeân vaán ñaùp giöõa         the Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), Thieàn sö Qui Sôn Linh Höïu vaø ñeä töû cuûa mình laø          Volume XI, one day Zen master Kuei Shan asked Ngöôõng Sôn Hueä Tòch. Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn                 Yang Shan, "Where have you been?" Yang Shan Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån IX, moät hoâm, Qui Sôn cuøng                said, "I have just come from the fields." Kuei Shan chuùng haùi traø. Sö baûo Ngöôõng Sôn: "Troïn ngaøy haùi       went on, "How many people were there?" Yang traø chæ nghe tieáng con maø khoâng thaáy hình con."           Shan thrust his hoe into the ground and stood Ngöôõng Sôn lieàn rung caây traø. Sö baûo: "Con chæ            there. Kuei Shan said, "Today at the southern ñöôïc caùi duïng cuûa noù, chaúng ñöôïc caùi theå cuûa noù."   mountain there was one who harvested rushes." Ngöôõng Sôn thöa: "Hoøa Thöôïng noùi sao?" Sö im               Yang Shan picked up his hoe and went away. laëng. Ngöôõng Sôn noùi: "Hoøa Thöôïng chæ ñöôïc caùi          Coâng AÙn Ngöôõng Sôn Thôøi Xuaát Chaåm Töû: theå cuûa noù, khoâng ñöôïc caùi duïng cuûa noù." Sö noùi:     Ngöôõng Sôn ñaåy caùi goái—Yang Shan: pushing "Cho con ba chuïc gaäy." Ngöôõng Sôn noùi: "Neáu               forward his pillow—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô duyeân vaán con laõnh ba chuïc gaäy cuûa Hoøa Thöôïng thì ai laõnh         ñaùp giöõa Thieàn sö Ngöôõng Sôn Hueä Tòch vaø moät ba chuïc gaäy cuûa con ñaây?" Qui Sôn noùi: "Vaäy tha          vò Taêng. Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån cho con ba chuïc gaäy."—The koan about the                     XI, moät hoâm, coù moät vò Taêng hoûi Ngöôõng Sôn: potentiality and conditions of questions and                   "Phaùp Thaân coù thuyeát phaùp chaêng?" Ngöôõng Sôn answers between Zen Master Kuei-shan and his                   ñaùp: "Laõo Taêng khoâng thuyeát ñöôïc, nhöng coù moät disciple, Yang-shan. According to The Records of               ngöôøi thuyeát ñöôïc." Vò Taêng laïi hoûi: "Ngöôøi the Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu),                 thuyeát ñöôïc ôû ñaâu?" Ngöôõng Sôn lieàn ñaåy caùi goái Volume IX, one day, while Kui-shan and the                     tôùi. Khi Qui Sôn nghe chuyeän naøy, Sö bình raèng: monks were picking tea leaves, Kui-shan said to                "Hueä Tòch ñang chôi vôùi ñao kieám."—The koan Yang-shan, "All day today I've heard your voice                about the potentiality and conditions of questions but I haven't seen your form." Yang-shan then                  and answers between Zen master Yang Shan and shook the tea tree. Kui-shan said, "You attained               a monk. According to the Records of the its function, but you haven't realized its essence."           Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), Yang-shan said, "What does the master say?" Kui-               Volume XI, one day, a monk asked Zen master shan was silent. Yang-shan said, "The master has               Yang-shan, "Would dharmakaya (the essence of attained its essence but hasn't realized its                   all beings) also know how to expound the teaching function." Kui-shan said, "I give you thirty blows             of Buddhism?" The Master answered, "I cannot with the staff." Yang-shan said, "If I receive thirty          answer you, but somebody else can." The monk blows of the master's staff, who then will receive             asked, "Where is the one who can answer?" The

Master pushed forward his pillow. When Kuei-                  Caûnh Thoâng noùi: "Nhö theá! Nhö theá! 28 vò Toå AÁn shan heard of this, he remarked, "Hui-chi is                  Ñoä cuõng ñeàu nhö theá, 6 vò Toå Trung Hoa cuõng nhö engaging in swordplay."                                       theá, Hoøa Thöôïng laïi cuõng nhö theá, Caûnh Thoâng Coâng AÙn Ngöôõng Sôn Tuøy Phaàn: Ngöôõng Sôn:                cuõng nhö theá." Noùi xong, Caûnh Thoâng xoay sang Tuøy hoûi maø ñaùp—Yang Shan: Replying as                     beân phaûi ñöùng kieãng chaân. Ngöôõng Sôn ñöùng daäy expected—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô duyeâ n vaán ñaùp giöõa        ñaùnh cho Caûnh Thoâng 4 roi maây. Caûnh Thoâng Thieàn sö Qui Ngöôõng Sôn Hueä Tòch vaø moät vò               nhaân ñoù töï xöng Taäp Vaân Phong Haï Töù Ñaèng Taêng. Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån             Ñieàu Thieân Haï Ñaïi Thieàn Phaät—The koan about XI, moät hoâm, coù moät vò Taêng hoûi Thieàn sö ngöôõng       the potentiality and conditions of questions and Sôn: "Bieát chöõ khoâng?" Ngöôõng Sôn ñaùp: "Tuøy             answers between Zen master Yang Shan and his phaàn (tuøy hoûi maø ñaùp)." Vò Taêng ñi nhieãu moät          disciple Ching T'ung. According to the Records of voøng theo chieàu tay phaûi; Ngöôõng Sôn veõ moät chöõ        the Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), thaäp treân maët ñaát. Vò Taêng laïi ñi moät voøng theo       Volume XI, one day, Ching T'ung came to seek höôùng beân traùi; Ngöôõng Sôn boâi chöõ thaäp vaø söõa       instructions from his master Yang Shan, Yang thaønh chöõ vaïn. Vò Taêng laïi veõ moät voøng troøn, duøng   Shan closed his eyes and sat quietly. Ching T'ung hai tay naâng leân, nhö theå Tu La che maët trôøi vaø         said, "Like this! Like this! Twenty eight Indian maët traêng. Ngöôõng Sôn laïi veõ moät voøng troøn bao        Patriarchs were like this, Six Chinese Patriarchs quanh chöõ vaïn. Vò Taêng laïi laøm theo tö theá cuûa         were like this, Master was like this, and Ching Phaät Laâu Chí (vò Phaät thöù 1.000 trong thôøi Hieàn         T'ung was like this too!" After speaking, Ching Kieáp). Ngöôõng Sôn lieàn aán khaû vaø caên daën haõy coá     T'ung turned to his right side and stood on tiptoe. hoä trì Phaät phaùp—The koan about the potentiality           Yang Shan stood up and whipped Ching T'ung and conditions of questions and answers between               four whips. By this opportunity, Ching T'ung gave Zen master Yang Shan and a monk. According to                 himself a title: "Four whips under the the Records of the Transmission of the Lamp                   accumulation of clouds and winds, the world Great (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), Volume XI, one day, a monk                  Meditative Buddha." came and asked Zen master Yang-shan, "Master,                 Coâng AÙn Ngöôõng Sôn Vaán Tam Thaùnh Hueä do you know how to read?" Yang-shan said,                     Nhieân: Yang Shan Questions San Sheng—Theo "Reply as expected." The monk circumumbulated                 thí duï thöù 68 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Ngöôõng Sôn hoûi (went around) clockwise once; Yang-shan drew a                Tam Thaùnh: "OÂng teân gì?" Tam Thaùnh thöa: "Hueä cross on the ground. The monk circumumbulated                 Tòch." Ngöôõng Sôn noùi: "Hueä Tòch laø teân ta." Tam (went around) counterclockwise once; Yang-shan                Thaùnh thöa: "Hueä Nhieân." Ngöôõng Sôn cöôøi ha erased the cross and drew a sauvastika on the                 haû! Theo Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc, Tam ground. The monk drew a circle, and then raised it            Thaùnh laø haøng toân tuùc trong toâng Laâm Teá, thuôû with his both hands as if an Asura wanted to cover            nhoû ñaõ ñuû khaû naêng xuaát quaàn, coù ñaïi cô ñaò duïng, both the Sun and the Moon. Yang-shan then drew                ôû trong chuùng ngang ngang taøng taøng, tieáng vang an circle to encircle the sauvastika. The monk                khaép nôi. Sau töø giaû Laâm Teá, Sö daïo khaép soâng imitated the posture of Rucika Buddha (the last of            bieån, ñeán caùc tuøng laâm ñeàu ñöôïc ñaõi vaøo haønh the 1,000 Buddhas of the present kalpa). Yang-                khaùch quí. Sö töø mieán Baéc ñeán phöông Nam, tröôùc shan immediately approved the monk and advised                ñeán Tuyeát Phong hoûi: "Caù vaøng thoaùt khoûi löôùi, him to do the best to support Buddhism.                       laáy gì laøm thöùc aên?" Tuyeát Phong ñaùp: "Ñôïi oâng ra Coâng AÙn Ngöôõng Sôn Töù Ñaèng Ñieàu: Ngöôõng                khoûi löôùi ñeán, seõ noùi vôùi oâng." Tam Thaùnh noùi: Sôn: ñaùnh boán roi maây—Yang Shan: Whipping                  "Laø thieän tri thöùc cuûa moät ngaøn naêm traêm ngöôøi, Ching T'ung four whips—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô duyeân           maø thoaïi ñaàu cuõng chaúng bieát." Tuyeát Phong noùi: vaán ñaùp giöõa Thieàn sö Qui Ngöôõng Sôn Hueä Tòch           "Laõo Taêng truï trì nhieàu vieäc." Tuyeát Phong cuøng vaø ñeä töû cuûa mình laø Hoaéc Sôn Caûnh Thoâng. Theo        Tam Thaùnh ñi thaêm trang sôû cuûa chuøa, treân ñöôøng Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån XI, moät hoâm           gaëp moät con khæ. Tuyeát Phong noùi: "Con khæ naøy Caûnh Thoâng ñeán tham vaán vôùi thaày mình laø               moãi moãi mang moät maët göông xöa." Tam Thaùnh Ngöôõng Sôn, Ngöôõng Sôn vaãn nhaém maét ngoài yeân.          noùi: "Nhieàu kieáp khoâng teân, do ñaâu baøy laø göông

xöa?" Tuyeát Phong noùi: "Coù tyø vaäy." Tam Thaùnh             toâng." Chæ trong moät caâu ñoàng thôøi tuïng xong. noùi: "Laø thieän tri thöùc cuûa moät ngaøn naêm traêm          Ngöôõng Sôn cöôøi haû! haû!, cuõng coù quyeàn coù thaät, ngöôøi, maø thoaïi ñaàu cuõng chaúng bieát." Tuyeát             coù chieáu coù duïng, vì kia taùm maët linh lung. Theá Phong noùi: "Toäi loãi, laõo Taêng truï trì nhieàu vieäc."      neân choã duøng ñöôïc töï taïi. Caùi cöôøi naøy cuøng caùi Sau Sö ñeán Ngöôõng Sôn, Ngöôõng Sôn raát meán taøi             cöôøi cuûa Nham Ñaàu khoâng ñoàng. Nham Ñaàu cöôøi huøng bieän cuûa Sö neân ñaõi ôû Minh Song. Moät hoâm,          coù thuoác ñoäc. Caùi cöôøi naøy ngaøn xöa muoân xöa gioù coù oâng quan ñeán tham vaán Ngöôõng Sôn, Ngöôõng               maùt laïnh run—According to example 68 of the Pi- Sôn hoûi: "Quan ôû vò naøo?" Quan thöa: "Deïp quan."            Yen-Lu, Yang Shan asked San Sheng, "What is Ngöôõng Sôn döïng caây phaát töû, hoûi: "Laïi deïp ñöôïc        your name?" San Sheng said, "Hui Chi." Yang caùi naøy chaêng?" OÂng quan khoâng ñaùp ñöôïc. Caû             Shan said, "Hui Chi? That's me." San Sheng said, chuùng ñaùp thay cuõng khoâng kheá hôïp yù Ngöôõng              "My name is Hui Jan." Yang Shan laughed aloud. Sôn. Khi aáy Tam Thaùnh naèm beänh taïi nhaø Dieân              According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, San Thoï, Ngöôõng Sôn sai thò giaû ñem lôøi naøy hoûi. Tam          Sheng was a venerable adept in the Lin Chi Thaùnh ñaùp: "Hoøa Thöôïng coù vieäc." Ngöôõng Sôn              succession. Since youth he possessed abilities that laïi sai thò giaû hoûi: "Chöa bieát coù vieäc gì?" Tam          stood out from the crowd: he had great capacity Thaùnh noùi: "Taùi phaïm chaúng tha." Ngöôõng Sôn               and had great function; while still in the thaàm nhaän ñoù. Baùch Tröôïng ñöông thôøi laáy thieàn          community, he was in full vigor, and his name was baûn boà ñoaøn trao cho Hoaøng Baù, laáy caây gaäy phaát        known everywhere. Later he left Lin Chi and töû trao cho Qui Sôn. Sau Qui Sôn trao cho Ngöôõng              travelled throughout Hui Nan and Hai Chou; the Sôn. Ngöôõng Sôn ñaõ thöøa nhaän Tam Thaùnh. Moät               monasteries everywhere he went all treated him hoâm, Tam Thaùnh töø giaõ ra ñi, Ngöôõng Sôn laáy caây          as a distinguished guest. He went from the north to gaäy phaát töû trao cho Tam Thaùnh. Tam Thaùnh thöa:            the south; first he went to Hsueh Feng and asked, "Con ñaõ coù thaày." Ngöôõng Sôn hoûi nguyeân do, môùi          "What does a golden carp who has passed through bieát laø ñích töû cuûa Laâm Teá. Chæ nhö Ngöôõng Sôn           the net take for food?" Hsueh feng said, "Wait till hoûi Tam Thaùnh "OÂng teân gì?" Sö khoâng theå chaúng           you've come out of the net; then I'll tell you." San bieát teân kia, côù sao laïi hoûi theá aáy? Sôû dó haøng taùc   Sheng said, "The teacher of fifteen hundred gia caàn nghieäm ngöôøi bieát cho chín chaén, döôøng            people doesn't even know what to say." Hsueh nhö thong thaû hoûi oâng teân gì? Khoâng suy tính Tam           feng said, "My task as abbot are many." As Hsueh Thaùnh ñaùp laø Hueä Tòch, maø chaúng noùi laø Hueä             Feng was going to the temple manor, on the way Nhieân, laø taïi sao? Xem kia ñuû con maét töï nhieân           he encountered some macaques, whereupon he chaúng ñoàng. Tam Thaùnh theá aáy maø chaúng phaûi              said, "Each of the macaques is wearing an ancient ñieân, moät beà duïng yù cöôùp côø ñoaït troáng ngoaøi lôøi     mirror." San Sheng said, "For aeons it has been cuûa Ngöôõng Sôn. Lôøi naøy chaúng rôi trong thöôøng            nameless; why do you depict it as an ancient tình, khoù beà doø tìm. Nhöõng keû coù thuû ñoaïn naøy laø      mirror?" Hsueh Feng said, "A flaw has been laøm soáng ñöôïc ngöôøi. Vì theá noùi, kia tham caâu            created." San Sheng said, "The teacher of fifteen soáng chaúng tham caâu cheát. Neáu theo thöôøng tình            hundred people does not even know what to say." thì döùt ngöôøi chaúng ñöôïc. Xem coå nhaân kia nghó            Hsueh Feng said, "My fault. My task as abbot are ñaïo theá aáy, duøng heát tinh thaàn môùi ñöôïc ñaïi ngoä,      many." Later he came to Yang Shan. Shan very ñaõ ngoä roài khi duøng cuõng ñoàng chöa ngoä, gioáng heät      much admired his outstanding acuity and seated thôøi nhôn, tuøy phaàn moät lôøi nöûa caâu, chaúng ñöôïc        him under the bright window. One day an official rôi choã thöôøng tình. Tam Thaùnh bieát choã rôi cuûa           came to call on Yang Shan. Shan asked him, Ngöôõng Sôn, lieàn noùi vôùi Sö, con teân Hueä Tòch.            "What is your official position?" He said, "I am a Ngöôõng Sôn coát thaâu Tam Thaùnh, ngöôïc laïi Tam              judge." San Sheng raised his whisk and said, "And Thaùnh thaâu Ngöôõng Sôn. Ngöôõng Sôn chæ ñöôïc                 can you judge this?" The official was speechless. nhaèm treân thaân ñaùnh keû cöôùp, noùi Hueä Tòch laø ta,       All the people of the community made comments, laø choã phoùng haønh. Tam Thaùnh thöa: "Con teân               but none accorded with Yang Shan's idea. At that Hueä Nhieân," cuõng laø phoùng haønh. Vì theá ôû döôùi          time San Sheng was sick and staying in the Life- Tuyeát Ñaäu tuïng: "Hai thaâu, hai phoùng neáu laøm             Prolonging Hall: Yang Shan ordered his attendant

to take these words and ask him about them. San         why Hsueh Tou later says, "Both gather in, both Sheng said, "The Master has a problem." Yang            let go, which is fundamental?" With just one Shan again ordered his attendant to ask, "What is       phrase he has completely versified it all at once. the problem?" San Sheng said, "A second offense         Yang Shan laughed aloud. "Ha, ha!" There was is not permitted." Yang Shan deeply approved of         both the provisional and the real, there was both this. Pai Chang had formerly imparted his               illumination and function. Because he was crystal meditation brace and cushion to Huang Po, and           clear in every respect, therefore he functioned had bequeathed his staff and whisk to Kuei Shan;        with complete freedom. This laugh was not the Kuei Shan later gave them to Yang Shan. Since           same as Yen Tou's; in Yen Tou's laugh there was Yang Shan greatly approved of San Sheng, when           poison, but in this laugh, for all eternity the pure one day Sheng took his leave and departed, Yang         wind blows chill. Shan took his staff and whisk to hand them over to      Coâng AÙn Ngöôõng Sôn Xuaát Tænh: Ngöôõng Sôn ra San Sheng. Sheng said, "I already have a                khoûi gieáng—Yang-shan "Getting someone out of teacher." When Yang Shan inquired into his              the well without using a bit of rope"—Coâng aùn noùi reason for saying this, it was that he was a true       veà cô duyeân vaán ñaùp giöõa Thieàn sö Thaïch Söông heir of Lin Chi. When Yang Shan asked San               Taùnh Khoâng vaø ñeä töû cuûa mình laø Ngöôõng Sôn Sheng, "What is your name?" He could not have           Hueä Tòch. Theo Nguõ Ñaêng Hoäi Nguyeân, quyeån IX, but known his name; why did he then go ahead            khi Ngöôõng Sôn coøn laøm thò giaû cho thieàn sö Taùnh and ask in this way? The reason is that an adept        Khoâng, moät hoâm coù moät vò Taêng ñeán hoûi thieàn sö wants to test people to be able to know them            Taùnh Khoâng Thaïch Söông: "YÙ nghóa cuûa vieäc thoroughly. He just seemed to be casually asking,       Tröôûng laõo ñeán töø phöông Taây laø gì?" Sö baûo: "What is your name?", and spoke no further              "Giaû söû coù moät ngöôøi bò rôi xuoáng taän ñaùy gieáng judgement or comparison. Why did San Sheng not          saâu ngaøn thöôùc, neáu oâng coù theå keùo y leân khoûi maø say "Hui Jan," but instead said, "Hui Chi"? See         khoâng caàn ñeán moät taác daây, ta seõ traû lôøi cho oâng yù how a man who has the eye is naturally not the          chæ cuûa Toå Sö töø Taây ñeán." Vò Taêng döôøng nhö same as others. This manner of San Sheng's was          khoâng laáy ñoù laøm troïng; neân noùi: "Gaàn ñaây, Hoà still not crazy, though; he simply captured the flag    Nam Söôùng Hoøa Thöôïng truï trì taïi moät tu vieän and stole the drum. His meaning was beyond              cuõng coù chæ giaùo naøy noï cho chuùng toâi veà vaán ñeà Yang Shan's words. These words do not fall within       aáy." Sö goïi vò sa di thò giaû vaø ra leänh: "Haõy mang the scope of ordinary feelings; they are difficult to   caùi thaây ma naøy toáng khöù ñi." Thieàn sö Taùnh get a grasp on. The methods of such a fellow can        Khoâng traû lôøi baèng caùch vieän daãn nhöõng vieäc bring people to life; that is why it is said, "He       khoâng theå coù trong theá giôùi nhaân quaû töông ñoái studies the living phrase; he does not study the        naøy. Vaø ñieàu kieän vöøa keå treân laø hi höõu nhö moïi dead phrase." If they followed ordinary feelings,       ñoái ñaõi thôøi khoâng vaãn nguyeân daïng ñoái vôùi taâm then they couldn't set people at rest. See how          thöùc höõu haïn cuûa chuùng ta. Chæ coù theå hieåu chöøng those men of old contemplated the Path like this:       naøo chuùng ta nhaûy vaøo moät caûnh giôùi vöôït leân kinh they exerted their spirits to the utmost, and only      nghieäm ñoái ñaõi cuûa mình. Nhöng vì caùc thieàn sö then were capable of great enlightenment. Once          gheâ tôûm moïi thöù tröøu töôïng vaø thuyeát lyù, neân ñoâi they were completely enlightened, when they             khi caùc caâu noùi cuûa hoï quaù ö loän xoän vaø voâ nghóa; used it, after all they appeared the same as people     ñoàng thôøi nhöõng caâu traû lôøi cuûa hoï luoân coù caùi loái who were not yet enlightened. In any case, their        ñoäc ñieäu cuûa chuû tröông sieâu nghieäm. Vò sa di thò one word or half a phrase could not fall into           giaû ñoù chính laø Ngöôõng Sôn Hueä Tòch, moät trong ordinary feelings. San Sheng knew where Yang            nhöõng tay cöï phaùch cuûa Thieàn. Veà sau Ngöôõng Shan was at, so he said to him, "My name is Hui         Sôn coù ñeán hoûi Ñam Nguyeân laøm sao keùo ngöôøi Chi." Yang Shan wanted to take in San Sheng, but        kia ra khoûi gieáng. Ñam Nguyeân baûo: "Suît! Ñoà San Sheng conversely took in Yang Shan. Yang            ngu, ai ôû döôùi gieáng." Sau nöõa, Ngöôõng Sôn laïi ñi Shan was only able to make a counterattack and          hoûi Qui Sôn laøm caùch naøo ñeå keùo ngöôøi kia ra say, "I am Hui Jan." This too is letting go. This is    khoûi gieáng. Qui Sôn goïi: "Hueä Tòch (teân cuûa

Ngöôõng Sôn)." Ngöôõng Sôn ñaùp: "Daï, baåm Hoøa             Coâng AÙn Nham Ñaàu Thaâu Kieám Hoaøng Saøo: Thöôïng." Qui Sôn noùi: "Kìa, ra roài." Ñeán khi ñuû         Yen T'ou's Getting Huang Ch'ao's Sword—Theo duyeân cuûa Thieàn vaø truï trì taïi Ngöôõng Sôn, luùc aáy   thí duï thöù 66 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc, Nham Ñaàu hoûi Ngöôõng Sôn thöôøng nhaéc ñeán nhöõng cuoäc phieâu           moät vò Taêng: "ÔÛ ñaâu ñeán?" Vò Taêng thöa: "Taây löu naøy vaø baûo: "ÔÛ Ñam Nguyeân ta ñöôïc danh, ôû         Kinh ñeán." Nham Ñaàu hoûi: "Sau khi giaëc Hoaøng Quy Sôn ta ñöôïc theå." Haønh giaû tu Thieàn coù coù theå    Saøo qua roài, laïi thaâu kieám ñöôïc khoâng?" Vò Taêng thay theá 'danh' baèng trieát hoïc vaø 'theå' baèng kinh     thöa: "Thaâu ñöôïc." Nham Ñaàu ñöa coå ra, noùi: nghieäm ñöôïc chaêng?—The koan about the                     "Heø!" Vò Taêng noùi: "Ñaàu thaày ruïng." Nham Ñaàu potentiality and conditions of questions and                 cöôøi ha haû! Sau vò Taêng naøy ñeán Tuyeát Phong. answers between Zen Master Hsing-k'ung and his               Tuyeát Phong hoûi: "ÔÛ ñaâu ñeán?" Vò Taêng thöa: "ÔÛ disciple, Yang-shan. According to Wudeng                     Nham Ñaàu ñeán." Tuyeát Phong hoûi: "Coù ngoân cuù Huiyuan, volume, IX, when Yang-shan was                      gì?" Vò Taêng thuaät laïi vieäc tröôùc, lieàn bò Tuyeát serving as Hsing-k'ung's attendant, one day a                Phong ñaùnh cho ba möôi gaäy roài ñuoåi ra. Theo monk came and asked Zen master Hsing-k'ung,                  Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc, phaøm laø ngöôøi "What is the meaning of the patriarch's coming out           quaûy tuùi mang baùt vaïch coû xem gioù, phaûi ñuû con of the west?" The master said, "Suppose a man is             maét haønh cöôùc môùi ñöôïc. Vò Taêng naøy maét tôï sao down at the bottom of a well one thousand feet               baêng, cuõng bò Nham Ñaàu khaùm phaù xong, xoû xaâu deep; if you could get him out without using a bit           laïi. Ñöông thôøi neáu laø keû kia, hoaëc cheát hoaëc soáng of rope, I would give you the answer as to the               cöû ñeán lieàn duøng. Vò Taêng loâi thoâi naøy laò noùi: meaning of our patriarchal visit here." The monk             "Thaâu ñöôïc." Ñi haønh cöôùc theá aáy, laõo Dieâm did not evidently take this very seriously, for he           Vöông seõ ñoøi tieàn côm oâng. OÂng naøy ñi naùt bao said, "Lately, the venerable Ch'ang of Hu-nan was            nhieâu ñoâi giaøy coû thaúng ñeán Tuyeát Phong. Khi aáy given a monastery to preside over, and he is also            neáu coù ñoâi phaàn maét saùng, lieàn bieát lieác qua haù giving us all kinds of instruction on the subject."          chaúng thích sao? Moät nhôn duyeân naøy coù aâm thanh The master called a boy-attendant and ordered                kyø quaùi. Vieäc aáy tuy nhieân khoâng ñöôïc maát, maø him 'to take this lifeless fellow out.' Zen master           ñöôïc maát raát lôùn; tuy nhieân, khoâng giaûn traïch, maø Hsing-k'ung replied by utilzing cases where things           trong naøy laïi caàn ñuû con maét giaûn traïch. Xem impossible in the relative world of causation are            Long Nha khi coøn ñi haønh cöôùc, ñaët caâu hoûi vôùi referred to. And the above impossible condition so           Ñöùc Sôn: "Hoïc nhôn nöông kieám Maïc Da nghó laáy long as space-time relations remain what they are            ñaàu thaày thì theá naøo?" Ñöùc Sôn ñöa coå ra noùi: to our final consciousness; they will only be                "Heø!" Long Nha noùi: "Ñaàu thaày ruïng." Ñöùc Sôn intelligible when we are ushered into a realm                lieàn trôû veà phöông tröôïng. Sau Long Nha thuaät laïi beyond our relative experience. But as the Zen               vôùi Ñoäng Sôn, Ñoäng Sôn hoûi: "Khi aáy Ñöùc Sôn noùi masters abhor all abstractions and theorizations, so         gì?" Long Nha thöa: "Sö khoâng noùi." Ñoäng Sôn their propositions sound outrageously incoherent             baûo: "Sö khoâng noùi gaùc laïi, cho möôïn ñaàu Ñöùc and nonsensical; at the same time, their answers             Sôn ruïng xem?" Long Nha ngay caâu noùi naøy ñaïi too, harp on the same string of transcendentalism.           ngoä, thaép höông troâng xa veà Ñöùc Sôn leã baùi saùm Later, the boy-attendant for Zen master Hsing-               hoái. Coù vò Taêng truyeàn ñeán Ñöùc Sôn, Ñöùc Sôn noùi: k'ung came to be known as Yang-shan, one of the              "Laõo Ñoäng Sôn chaúng bieát toát xaáu, keû naøy cheát most masterful minds in Zen. Afterwards Yang-                bao laâu roài, cöùu ñöôïc duøng vaøo choã naøo?" Coâng aùn shan came and asked Tan-yuan how to get out the              naøy vôùi Long Nha laø moät loaïi. Ñöùc Sôn trôû veà man in the well, when the master exclaimed,                  phöông tröôïng aét trong toái raát maàu. Nham Ñaàu "Why, this fool, who is in the well?" Still later the        cöôøi to, trong caùi cöôøi coù ñoäc. Neáu coù ngöôøi bieän boy-attendant asked Wei-shan as to the means of              ñöôïc thì ñi doïc ngang trong thieân haï. Vò Taêng naøy getting the man out of the bottom of the well.               khi aáy neáu bieän ñöôïc thì vöôït qua ngaøn xöa, khoûi Wei-shan called out "O Hui-chi!" (as this was the            bò kieåm traùch, maø döôùi cöûa Nham Ñaàu moät tröôøng name of the young monk). Hui-chi repsonded,                  loãi laàm. Xem laoõ nhôn Tuyeát Phong laø baïn ñoàng "Yes, master!" Wei-shan said, "There, he is out!"            tham neân bieát choã rôi, cuõng chaúng vì kia noùi phaù,

chæ ñaùnh ba möôi gaäy roài ñuoåi ra khoûi vieä n, khaû dó      dotard and instead said, "I got it." If you travel on saùng tröôùc baët sau. Caùi naøy laø naém loã muõi haøng taùc   foot like this, the King of Death will question you gia thieàn khaùch, thuû ñoaïn vì ngöôøi maø chaúng vì hoï       and demand you pay your grocery bill. I don't theá naøy hoaëc theá noï, khieán hoï töï ngoä. Baäc boån        know how many straw sandals he wore out until phaän Toâng sö vì ngöôøi, coù khi ñaäy kín khoâng cho           he got to Hsueh Feng. At that time, if he had had a loù ñaàu, coù khi tung ra cho cheát lang thang, laïi caàn       little bit of eye power, then he would have been coù choã xuaát thaân. Caû thaûy Nham Ñaàu, Tuyeát               able to get a glimpse; wouldn't that have felt Phong ngöôïc laïi bò vò Taêng loâi thoâi khaùm phaù. Caâu       good? This story has a knotty complication in it. Nham Ñaàu hoûi: "Giaëc Hoaøng Saøo qua roài, coù thaâu          Although this matter has neither gain nor loss, the ñöôïc kieám chaêng?" Caùc oâng haõy noùi trong ñaây neân        gain and loss are tremendous: although there is no haï lôøi gì ñeå khoûi bò kia cöôøi, laïi khoûi bò Tuyeát        picking and choosing, when you get here, you Phong ñaùnh ñuoåi ra? Trong caùi kyø quaùi naøy, neáu           after all must possess the eyes to pick and choose. chaúng töøng chöùng thaân ngoä, duø cho coù nhanh               So how when Lung Ya was travelling on foot, he mieäng lôïi khaåu, cöùu caùnh thaáu thoaùt sanh töû cuõng       posed this question to Te Shan: "How is it when chaúng ñöôïc. Sôn Taêng bình thöôøng daïy ngöôøi xem            the student wants to take the Master's head with a choã chuyeån cuûa cô quan naøy. Neáu suy nghó, xa ñoù           sharp sword?" Te Shan stretched out his neck, caøng xa. Ñaâu chaúng thaáy Ñaàu Töû hoûi Taêng Dieâm           approached, and said, "Yaa!" Lung Ya said, "The Bình: "Sau khi giaëc Hoaøng Saøo qua roài, laïi thaâu           Master's head has fallen." Te Shan returned to the ñöôïc kieám chaêng?" Vò Taêng laáy tay chæ döôùi ñaát.          abbot's room. Lung Ya later recited this to Tung Ñaàu Töû noùi: "Ba möôi naêm ñuøa côõi ngöïa, ngaøy             Shan. Tung Shan said, "What did Te Shan say at nay laïi bò löøa ñaù." Xem vò Taêng naøy quaû laø baäc taùc     the time?" Lung Ya said, "He said nothing." Tung gia, chaúng noùi thaâu ñöôïc, cuõng chaúng noùi thaâu           Shan said, "His having nothing to say, I leave chaúng ñöôïc, so vôùi vò Taêng ôû Taây Kinh nhö caùch           aside for the moment: just bring Te Shan's fallen trôøi bieån. Chôn Nhö nieâm: "Coå nhaân kia moät ngöôøi         head for me to see." Lung Ya at these words was laøm ñaàu, moät ngöôøi laøm ñuoâi."—According to                greatly awakened; later he burned incense, and example 66 of the Pi-Yen-Lu, Yen T'ou asked a                   gazing far off towards Te Shan, he bowed and monk, "Where do you come from?" The monk                        repented. A monk repeated this to Te Shan. Te said, "From the Western Capital." Yen T'ou said,                Shan said, "Old man Tung Shan does not know "After Huang Ch'ao had gone, did you get his                    good from bad; this fellow has been dead for so sword?" The monk said, "I got it." Yen T'ou                     long, even if you couldn't revive him, what would extended his neck, came near and said, "Yaa!"                   be the use?" This public case is the same as that of The monk said, "Your head has fallen, Master."                  Lung Ya: te Shan returned to the abbot's room; Yen T'ou laughed out loud. Later that monk went                 thus in darkness he was most wonderful. Yen T'ou to Hsueh Feng. Hsueh Feng asked, "Where did                     laughed loudly; in his laugh there is poison: if any you come from?" The monk said, "From Yen                        one could discern it, he could travel freely T'ou." Hsueh Feng said, "What did he have to                    throughout the world. If this monk had been able say?" The monk recounted the preceding story.                   to pick it out at that moment, he would have Hsueh Feng hit him thirty blows with his staff and              escaped critical examination for all time. But at drove him out. According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-                  Yen T'ou's place, he had already missed it. Yen-Lu, whenever you carry your bag and bowl,                   Observe that old man Hsueh Feng; being a fellow pulling out the weeds seeking the Way, you must                 student with Yen T'ou, he immediately knew first possess the foot-travelling eye. This monk's              where he was at. Still, he didn't explain it all for eyes were like comets, yet he was still thoroughly              that monk, but just hit him thirty blows of the staff exposed by Yen T'ou, and pierced all the way                    and drove him out of the monastery. Thereby he through on a single string. At that time, if he had             was "before light and after annihilation." This is been a man, whether it were to kill or to enliven,              the method of holding up the nostrils of an adept he would have made use of it immediately as soon                patchrobed monk to help the person; he doesn't do as it was brought up. But this monk was a rickety               anything else for him, but makes him awaken on

his own. When genuine teachers of our school                  meâ voïng cuûa chuùng sanh hay voâ thuûy voâ minh. help people, sometimes they trap them and do not              Theo Bích Nham Luïc, taéc 19, moät haït buïi vöøa dôû let them come out; sometimes they release them                leân thì caû quaû ñaát toaøn thaâu, moät ñoùa hoa chôùm nôû and let them be slovenly. After all, they must have           thì toaøn theá giôùi rung ñoäng; moät sôïi loâng sö töû hieän a place to appear. Yen T'ou and Hsueh Feng,                   thì traêm öùc sôïi loâng hieän. Cuõng nhö khi baïn cheùm supposedly so great, were on the contrary exposed             moät cuoän tô, cheùm moät moái laø cheùm heát caû cuoän; by this rice-eating Ch'an follower. When Yen T'ou             hay khi baïn nhuoäm moät cuoän tô, chæ caàn nhuoäm said, "After Huang Ch'ao had gone, did you get his            moät cheùo laø nhuoäm taát caû. Thieàn sö Vieân Minh sword?" People, tell me, what could be said here              noùi: "Laïnh thì khaép trôøi ñaát ñeàu laïnh; noùng thì to avoid his laughter, and to avoid Hsueh Feng's              khaép trôøi ñaát ñeàu noùng; nuùi soâng quaû ñaát thaáu toät brandishing his staff and driving him out? Here it            huyønh tuyeàn; vaïn töôïng sum la thoâng taän hö is difficult to understand; if you have never                 khoâng." Haõy noùi laø vaät gì maø kyø quaùi theá aáy. Neáu personally witnessed and personally awakened,                 bieát ñöôïc thì chaúng tieâu moät caùi aán tay. Neáu bieát even if your mouth is swift and sharp to the very             chaúng ñöôïc thì chöôùng ngaïi daãy ñaày. Loaïi thieàn end, you will not be able to pass through and out             naày thaät laø deã tham maø khoù hoäi. Nhö ngöôøi ñôøi of birth and death. I always teach people to                  nay, coù ai hoûi ñeán lieàn ñöa ngoùn tay hay ñöa naém observe the pivot of this action; if you hesitate,            tay leân, ñaây thaät khoâng hôn gì söï baét chöôùc trô you are far, far away from it. Have you not seen              treõn. Baét chöôùc laø noâ leä. Chuùng ta khoâng theå cöù how T'ou Tzu asked a monk from Yen Ping,                      baét chöôùc heã ai noùi gì thì mình noùi theo nhö vaäy, "Have you brought a sword?" The monk pointed at               maø phaûi giöõ vöõng tinh thaàn cuûa mình. Söï khaúng the ground with his hand. T'ou Tzu said, "For thirty          ñòng cao hôn naèm nôi tinh thaàn. Theo Thieàn thì years I have been handling horses, but today I                tinh thaàn naèm ngay trong nhöõng vieäc nhö laø ñi, have been kicked by a mule." Look at that monk;               ñöùng, naèm, ngoài haèng ngaøy vaø chuùng seõ laøm taát caû he too was undeniably an adept; neither did he say            nhöõng nhu caàu cuûa chuùng ta trong ñoù. Vì vaäy haønh he had it, nor did he say he did not have it; he was          giaû tu thieàn caàn phaûi thaáu coát thaáu tuûy, phaûi thaáy like an ocean away from the monk from the                     thaáu môùi ñöôïc—A roll of silk. In Zen, the term is Western Capital. Chen Ju brought this up and said,            used to indicate the source of sentient beings' "Those Ancients; one acted as the head, the other             ignorance or the period of unenlightenment or as the tail, for sure."                                       ignorance without beginning. According to the Pi- Coâng AÙn Nhaát Baû Mao Caùi Ñaàu: To cover the               Yen-Lu, example 19, as soon as a speck of dust head with a bundle of thatch—See Nhaát Baû Mao                arises, the great earth is contained therein; when a Caùi Ñaàu.                                                    single flower is about to open, the world Coâng AÙn Nhaát Caù Quan Taøi Löôõng Caù Töû Haùn:            immediately comes into being. The lion on the tip One coffin for two corpses—See Nhaát Caù Quan                 of a single hair appears on the tips of ten billion Taøi Löôõng Caù Töû Haùn.                                     hairs. Just as when you cut off a roll of silk, if you Coâng AÙn Nhaát Caàm Nhaát Tuùng: Moät beân naém              cut off one thread, the whole roll is cut off; or moät beân buoâng—One side is grasping, the other              when you dye a roll of silk, if you dye one corner side is realeasing—See Nhaát Caàm Nhaát Tuùng.                of the roll the whole roll is dyed. Zen master Yuan Coâng AÙn Nhaát Haùt Vaïn Cô Baõi, Tam Trieâu                 Ming said, "When it's cold, all throughout heaven Löôõng Nhó Lung: A deafening cry causes                       and earth are cold; when it's warm, all throughout everything to stop and the ear cannot hear for                heaven and earth are warm." The mountains and three days—See Nhaát Haùt Vaïn Cô Baõi, Tam Trieâu            rivers and the great earth reach down through the Löôõng Nhó Lung.                                              Yellow Springs (Hades); the myriad images and Coâng AÙn Nhaát Khanh Mai Khöôùc: Everything is               multitude of forms penetrate upward through the buried in one grave—See Nhaát Khanh Mai                       heavens. Tell me, what is so extraordinary? For Khöôùc.                                                       those who know, it's not worth taking hold of; for Coâng AÙn Nhaát Leä Ty: A roll of silk—Moät cuoän             those who don't know, it blocks them off utterly. tô. Trong thieàn, töø naày ñöôïc duøng ñeå chæ coäi nguoà n   This kind of Ch'an is easy to approach but hard to

understand. People these days who just hold up a               ñích." Noùi xong lieàn ra ñi. Khaâm Sôn goïi laïi: "Xaø finger or a fist as soon as they're questioned; this           Leâ laïi ñaây!" Löông Toaïi xoay ñaàu. Khaâm Sôn is no more than a shameless imitation. Copying is              naém ñöùng noùi: "Moät muõi phaù ba coång, haõy gaùc laïi, slavery. The letter must never be followed, only               thöû vì Khaâm Sôn baén teân xem?" Löông Toaïi suy the spirit is to be grasped. Higher affirmations live          nghó, Khaâm Sôn ñaùnh baûy gaäy noùi: "Haõy cho gaõ in the spirit. In Zen, you can seek the spirit in your         naøy nghi ba möôi naêm." Hieän nay moät soá thieàn everyday experience such as going, standing,                   hoøa töû troïn baûo: "Vì sao chaúng ñaùnh taùm gaäy hay lying down, and sitting, and therein lies abundance            saùu gaäy, maø laïi ñaùnh baûy gaäy?" Kia baûo thöû vì of proof for all we need. Therefore, it is still               Khaâm Sôn baén teân xem, lieàn ñaùnh. Theá laø gioáng necessary for Zen practitioners to pierce the bone,            thì cuõng gioáng, phaûi thì chöa phaûi. Coâng aùn naøy penetrate to the marrow, and see all the way                   phaûi trong hoâng ngöïc chaúng chöùa chuùt xíu ñaïo lyù through in order to get it.                                    so saùnh naøo, vöôït ngoaøi ngoân ngöõ, môùi coù moät caâu Coâng AÙn Nhaát Phoác Phaù Tam Quan: Ch'in Shan                phaù ba coång vaø coù choã baén teân. Neáu coøn phaûi quaáy "A single arrowhead smashing three barriers"—                  thì doø tìm chaúng ñöôïc. Vò Taêng khi aáy, neáu laø Coâng aùn noùi veà cô duyeân vaán ñaùp giöõa Thieàn sö         Khaâm Sôn cuõng raát hieåm, kia ñaõ khoâng theå haønh Khaâm Sôn vaø Thieàn khaùch Löông Toaïi. Theo thí              leänh, ñaây chaúng khoûi ñaûo haønh. Haõy noùi oâng chuû duï thöù 56 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Thieàn khaùch Löông           trong coång cöùu caùnh laø ngöôøi naøo? Tuyeát Ñaäu laïi Toaïi hoûi Khaâm Sôn: "Khi moät muõi teân phaù ba              tuïng ra: coång thì theá naøo?" Khaâm Sôn baûo: "Daãn oâng chuû               "Döõ quaân phoùng xuaát quan trung chuû trong ba coång ra xem?" Löông Toaïi noùi: "Theá aáy                   Phoùng tieån chi ñoà maïc maõng loã thì bieát loãi aét caûi." Khaâm Sôn baûo: "Laïi ñôïi khi              Thuû caù nhaõn heà nhó taát lung naøo?" Löông Toaïi noùi: "Teân toát baén chaúng ñeán                  Xaû caù nhó heà muïc song coå. ñích." Noùi xong lieàn ra ñi. Khaâm Sôn goïi laïi: "Xaø               Khaû laân nhaát phoác phaù tam quan Leâ laïi ñaây!" Löông Toaïi xoay ñaàu. Khaâm Sôn                      Ñích ñích phaân minh tieån haäu loâ. naém ñöùng noùi: "Moät muõi phaù ba coång, haõy gaùc laïi,            Quaân baát kieán Huyeàn Sa höõu ngoân heà: thöû vì Khaâm Sôn baén teân xem?" Löông Toaïi suy                     Ñaïi tröôïng phu tieân thieân vi taâm Toå." nghó, Khaâm Sôn ñaùnh baûy gaäy noùi: "Haõy cho gaõ                  (Chuû nhaân trong coång vì anh daãn naøy nghi ba möôi naêm." Theo Vieân Ngoä trong                        Nhöõng keû baén teân chôù sô hôû Bích Nham Luïc, Thieàn khaùch Löông Toaïi cuõng                       Giöõ con maét thì hai tai ñieác thöïc laø moät vieân chieán töôùng, nhaèm trong tay                   Boû loã tai thì hai maét toái. Khaâm Sôn xoay traùi loän phaûi, khieán rôi roi rôùt daây,            Ñaùng thöông moät muõi phaù tam quan roát sau ñaùng tieác cung gaõy teân maát. Tuy vaäy,                   Quaû thöïc ñöôøng sau teân quaù roõ. töôùng quaân hoï Lyù töï coù tieáng khen, chaúng ñöôïc                Anh chaúng thaáy Huyeàn Sa lôøi leõ: phong haàu cuõng laø nhaøn. Coâng aùn naøy moät ra moät               Ñaïi tröôïng phu tieân thieân laø taâm Toå). vaøo, moät baét moät thaû, ñöông cô thaáy maët ñeà, thaáy      Thaät vaäy, Thieàn sö Huyeàn Sa thöôøng laáy caâu "Ñaïi maët ñöôïc cô nhanh, troïn chaúng rôi nôi coù khoâng           tröôïng phu tieân thieân laø taâm Toå" ñeå daïy chuùng. ñöôïc maát, goïi laø huyeàn cô, nhìn qua thaáy coù chuùt ít    Nhöng ñaây laø baøi tuïng cuûa Quy Toâng Trí Thöôøng, löïc löôïng, lieàn coù choã saåy chaân. Vò Taêng naøy cuõng    moät trong nhöõng ñeä töû xuaát saéc cuûa Thieàn Sö Maõ laø haøng thieàn Taêng anh linh, ñaët caâu hoûi quaû laø       Toå Ñaïo Nhaát, Tuyeát Ñaäu laàm duøng cho laø cuûa kinh quaàn. Khaâm Sôn laø baäc Toâng sö taùc gia, lieàn        Huyeàn Sa Sö Bò. Hieän nay ngöôøi tham hoïc cho bieát choã rôi cuûa caâu hoûi. Caâu hoûi "Khi moät muõi teân   taâm naøy laø Toå toâng, daàu coù tham ñeán ñöùc Phaät Di phaù ba coång thì theá naøo?" YÙ Khaâm Sôn traû lôøi, oâng     Laëc ra ñôøi cuõng chöa hoäi. Neáu laø keû ñaïi tröôïng baén ñöôïc haõy gaùc qua, thöû daãn oâng chuû trong ba         phu thì taâm naøy vaãn laø con chaùu. Trôøi ñaát chöa coång ra xem? Löông Toaïi noùi: "Theá aáy thì bieát loãi       phaân ñaõ laø ñaàu thöù hai roài—The koan about the aét caûi," quaû thaät kyø ñaëc. Khaâm Sôn baûo: "Laïi ñôïi     potentiality and conditions of questions and khi naøo?" Xem kia ñoái ñaùp theá aáy, choã hoûi cuûa          answers between Zen Master Ch'in Shan and Khaâm Sôn khoâng coù chuùt ít thieáu troáng. Sau thieàn        Ch'an traveller Liang. According to example 56 of khaùch Löông Toaïi laïi noùi: "Teân toát baén chaúng ñeán      the Pi-Yen-Lu, Ch'an traveller Liang asked Ch'in

Shan, "How is it when a single arrowhead                 held him tight and said, "Leaving aside for the smashes three barriers?" Ch'in Shan said, "Bring         moment a single arrowhead smashing three out the lord within the barriers for me to see."         barriers, let's see you shoot an arrow." When Liang said, "So then knowing my fault I must             Liang hesitated, Ch'in Shan immediately struck change." Ch'in Shan said, "Why wait any longer?"         him seven blows. After this he went on to Liang said, "A well-shot arrow doesn't hit               pronounce a curse on Liang saying, "I'll allow this anywhere," and started to leave. Ch'in Shan said,        fellow will be doubting for thirty more years." "Come here a minute." Liang turned his head;             Followers of Ch'an these days all say, "Why didn't Ch'in Shan held him tight and said, "Leaving aside       he hit him eight times or six times? Why just for the moment a single arrowhead smashing three         seven times? Or else why didn't he hit him barriers, let's see you shoot an arrow." Liang           immediately as he was asking him to try to shoot hesitated, so Ch'in Shan hit him seven times and         an arrow?" Though this seems right, in reality it said, "I'll allow as this fellow will be doubting for    isn't. For this case you must not cherish the least thirty more years." According to Yuan-Wu in the          bit of rational calculation in your heart; you must Pi-Yen-Lu, Ch'an traveller Liang was undeniably          pass beyond the words. Only then will you be able a battle-tested general. In Ch'in Shan's hand he         to have a way to smash the three barriers at a turned to the left and revolved to the right,            single phrase and to shoot an arrow. If you keep bringing down his whip and flashing his stirrups. In     thinking of right and wrong, you will never be able the end, what a pity, his bow is broken, and his         to get a grasp on it. At that time, if this monk had arrows are used up. Even so, "General Li Kuang,          been a real man, Ch'in Shan would have been in though he had a glorious reputation, was never           great danger too. Since Liang could not carry out conferred as a noble, so it was useless." The            the imperative, he couldn't avoid it being carried public case has one exit and one entry, one              out on him. But say, after all, who is the lord capture and one release. "Taking charge of the           within the barriers? Look at Hsueh Tou's verse: situation, he brings it up face to face; face to face,     "I bring out the lord within the barriers for you taking charge of the situation is swift." Throughout         You disciples who would shoot an arrow, there is no falling into existence and nonexistence          Don't be careless! or gain and loss. This is called "mysterious                 Take an eye and the ears go deaf; activity." If one lacks strength, then he will               Let go an ear and the eyes both go blind. stumble. This monk too was a brave and spirited              I can admire a single arrowpoint smashing patchrobed one; he posed a question that really              three barriers startles the crowd. Being an expert of our school,           The trail of the arrow is truly clear. Ch'in Shan immediately knew where his question               You don't see? came down. How is it when a single arrowhead                 Hsuan Sha had words for this: smashes the three barriers? Ch'in Shan really                'A great adept is the primordial ancestor of meant, "For the moment leave aside your shooting             mind.'" through; try to bring out the lord within the            As a matter of fact, "A great adept is the barriers for me to see." Liang's saying, "So then        primordial ancestor of mind." Zen master Hsuan knowing my fault I must change," was undeniably          Sha often taught his community with these words. extraordinary. Ch'in Shan said, "Why wait any            But this is from a verse of Zen master Kuei-tsung longer?" See how he replied, this question of Ch'in      Chih-ch'ang's, one of the most outstanding Shan's had no gaps. Finally Ch'an traveller Liang        disciples of Zen master Ma-tsu Tao-i, which just said, "A well-shot arrow doesn't hit                Hsueh Tou has wrongly attributed to Hsuan Sha. anywhere." He shook out his sleeves to go away.          Practitioners of today who take this mind as the As soon as he saw him talking this way, Ch'in            ancestral source can study until Matreya Buddha Shan immediately called out to him, "Come here a         comes down to be born here and still never minute, Reverend." As it turned out Liang couldn't       understand. For one who is a great adept, even hold fast; he turned his head back then. Ch'in Shan      mind is still just the descendant. Heaven and earth

not yet distinct is already the secondary.                      Hoøa Thöôïng Huyeàn Truï noùi: "Tham Thieàn coát soi Coâng AÙn Nhaät Dieän Phaät, Nguyeät Dieän Phaät:               saùng yù nghóa cuûa soáng vaø cheát, coøn nieäm Phaät daïy "Sun Face Buddha, Moon Face Buddha"—See                         cho thanh toaùn vaán ñeà soáng cheát; haõy choïn moät Nhaät Dieän Phaät, Nguyeät Dieän Phaät.                         trong hai ñöôøng, bôûi vì chaúng coù tranh luaän naøo Coâng AÙn Nhò Taêng Quyeát Lieâm: Two Monks                     noåi leân ôû ñoù. Ñuùng vaäy, chaúng coù tranh luaän naøo ôû Roll Up the Blind, example 26 of the Wu-Men-                    giöõa hai ñöôøng, nhöng ñöøng coù oâm laáy caû hai. Keû Kuan—Hai oâng Taêng cuoán reøm, thí duï thöù 26 cuûa            hoïc Thieàn cöù moät möïc theo Thieàn, ngöôøi nieäm Voâ Moân Quan—See Nhò Taêng Quyeát Lieâm.                       Phaät haõy cöù khaêng khaêng nieäm Phaät. Neáu taâm bò Coâng AÙn Nhö Haø Thò Phaät: What or Who is the                 phaân chia giöõa hai thöù, seõ chaúng thaønh ñöôïc gì caû. Buddha?—Phaät laø ai?—See Nhö Haø Thò Phaät.                    Coå nhaân ñaõ noùi coù thí duï veà tình traïng phaân taâm Coâng AÙn Nhöôïc Phaøm Nhöôïc Thaùnh: Baát keå                  nhö theá vôùi moät ngöôøi coá böôùc vaøo hai con thuyeàn phaøm thaùnh—Irrespective of the ordinary or the                cuøng moät luùc nhöng cuoái cuøng chaúng böôùc vaøo ñaâu sage—Regardless of the ordinary or the sage—                    ñöôïc. Roài ta, coù leõ chaúng coù gì nguy hieåm, nhöng See Nhöôïc Phaøm Nhöôïc Thaùnh.                                 caùi keû böôùc leân hai thuyeàn aáy coù theå laâm vaøo tình Coâng AÙn Nieäm Phaät: Koan of Buddha                           traïng baát lôïi baát cöù luùc naøo, vì y coù theå rôi vaøo recitation—Coâng aùn nieäm Phaät ñöôïc duøng khi                khoaûng giöõa cuûa hai chieác thuyeàn neáu khoâng töï chuùng ta coi nieäm Phaät A Di Ñaø nhö laø moät coâng           caûnh tænh. Toâi chæ coù theå baûo caùc oâng theá naøy aùn. Ngay trong phuùt giaây hoàng danh Phaät ñöôïc              'trong nieäm Phaät chæ ñeà khôûi boán chöõ A Di Ñaø nieäm ra, noù laø ñieåm taäp trung then choát maø moïi          Phaät', voûn veïn chæ coù vaäy, khoâng noùi gì khaùc, ít nghi hoaëc aûo töôûng phaûi ñöôïc ñeå qua moät beân.            nöõa ñoái vôùi Thieàn giaû sô cô. Dó nhieân hoï muø môø, Ñoàng thôøi töï hoûi coi ai laø ngöôøi ñang nieäm Phaät?        khoâng roõ phaûi laøm gì. Nhöng trong vieäc tham cöùu Khi döïa vaøo coâng aùn, moïi meâ môø voïng töôûng ñeàu         coâng aùn, daïy raèng caùc oâng ai cuõng coù caùi 'baûn lai bò böùc vôõ gioáng nhö nhöõng guùt chæ bò caét ñöùt. Khi        dieän muïc' voán ñoàng vôùi chö Phaät, chæ vì chuùng ta maø khoâng coøn gì nöõa ñeå cho nhöõng thöù naày taùi           khoâng nhaän ra ôû trong mình. Haõy coá gaéng töï mình xuaát hieän, cuõng laø luùc aùnh nhaät quang phoå chieáu        soi xeùt, ñöøng nöông töïa vaøo ai khaùc. Ñaây coù theå khaép trôøi. Khi aûo töôûng khoâng khôûi vaø meâ môø bieán      baûo raèng caùc oâng coù ñaàu moái daãn böôùc vaøo maát, luùc ñoù taâm ta tónh laëng vaø trong suoát . Thieàn      Thieàn." Theo thieàn sö D.T. Suzuki trong Thieàn sö Sôû Sôn Thieäu Kyø (1404-1473) vieát cho moät ñoà            Luaän, Taäp II, moät trong nhöõng vò thieàn sö ñaà u tieân ñeä: "Caùi yù cuûa tuïng nieäm laø ñeå bieát raèng Phaät töùc   mang yù töôûng nieäm Phaät vaøo Thieàn toâng laø thieàn taâm; nhöng taâm naøy laø gì? Haõy xeùt xem töø ñaâu coù        sö Vónh Minh Dieân Thoï. Ngaøi raát chuù troïng ñeán tö töôûng khieán cho caùc oâng ñoïc leân danh hieäu             nhöõng haønh giaû tu Thieàn chaêm chæ thöïc haønh pheùp Phaät; noù khôûi leân ôû choã naøo? Nhöng caùc oâng coøn        nieäm Phaät; chuù troïng ñeán ñoä ngaøi baûo raèng nhöõng phaûi tieán xa hôn nöõa vaø haõy nghi 'Ai' laø keû muoán        ngöôøi theo hoïc Thieàn maø khoâng coù nieäm Phaät xeùt xem töø ñaâu coù moät nghó töôûng. Noù laø taâm, laø       trong möôøi ngöôøi heát chín ngöôøi khoâng theå ñaït tôùi Phaät hay laø Vaät? Caùc vò toân tuùc baûo, khoâng, chaúng      ñích, coøn nhöõng ai thöïc haønh nieäm Phaät seõ chöùng phaûi caùi naøo heát. Vaäy thì noù laø caùi gì?" Ñoù laø loái   ñaéc hoaøn toaøn chaúng soùt moät; nhöng toát nhaát laø caùc thieàn sö noùi veà Nieäm Phaät, lieân heä ñeán söï tu      nhöõng ngöôøi vöøa haønh Thieàn vöøa nieäm Phaät vì hoï taäp coâng aùn, neáu coù ai ñoù muoán chöùng Thieàn.            seõ nhö coïp coù theâm caëp söøng. Muoán hieåu roõ Vónh Ngaøy nay coù moät soá haønh giaû mong nhôø nieäm Phaät         Minh noùi gì trong caâu naøy khoâng phaûi laø chuyeän ñeå ñöôïc vaõng sanh veà coõi Tònh Ñoä vaø töï hoûi nieäm       deã; vì ngaøi khoâng noùi cho chuùng ta bieát veà khía Phaät coù khaùc Thieàn hay khoâng. Hoï khoâng heà nhaän         caïnh haønh trì cuûa noù; nghóa laø laøm theá naøo ñeå thöïc ra Thieàn vaø nieäm Phaät khoâng ñoàng maø ñoàng, vì            haønh caû Thieàn vaø nieäm Phaät cuøng luùc. Phaûi chaêng muïc ñích cuûa Thieàn laø thaáu hieåu yù nghóa cuûa söï         ngaøi muoán noùi laø thöïc haønh nieäm Phaät sau khi ñaéc soáng vaø muïc ñích cuûa nieäm Phaät laïi cuõng nhö vaäy.       Thieàn, hay ngöôïc laïi? Vaán ñeà haønh trì naøy maø Thieàn chæ thaúng vaøo taâm ñeå thaáy taùnh thaønh Phaät;       chöa ñöôïc giaûi quyeát thì chuùng ta khoan haõy baøi trong khi ñoù, nieäm Phaät nhaém ñi tôùi coõi Tònh Ñoä          baùc hay beânh vöïc Vónh Minh—The koan of voán dó khoâng khaùc hôn chính laø töï taâm, vaø nhaém          Buddha Recitation uses the invocation of thaáy roõ töï taùnh voán dó chính laø ñöùc Phaät A Di Ñaø .     Amitabha Buddha as a koan. At the very moment

the name is uttered, it must be the focal point in     exclusively to the Buddha-recitation. If the mind is respect to which all doubts and delusions are laid     divided between the two, neither will be attained. aside. At the same time you ask “Who is this           There is a comparision drawn by an old master person reciting the Amitabha’s name?” When you         between such a divided mind and a man who tries rely steadily on the koan, all illusions and           to be in two boats simultaneously and is in neither. confused thoughts will be broken down the way          So far, there is no harm, perhaps, but a worse case knotted threads are cut. When there is no longer       may come to him at any moment, for he may fall any place for them to reappear, it is like the         between the two boats if he does not look out for shinning sun in the sky. When illusion does not        himself. I can only tell you that in the Buddha- arise and delusions disappear, the mind is all calm    recitation just these four syllables are held up: A- and transparent. Ch'u-shan Shao-ch'i writes to one     mi-da-butsu, which indicates no way, at least to of his disciples: "The idea of the invocation is to    Zen beginners, as to how to proceed with it. They know that the Buddha is not other than your own        are naturally at a loss, and fail to know what to do mind; but what is this mind? See into the whence       with the subject. But in the study of the koan you of your thought which makes you utter the name         are told that you are each in possession of 'the of the Buddha; where does it originate? But you        original face' which is the same as it is in all the must go even farther than this and make inquiries      Buddhas, only that in us it is not recognized. Try to as to the 'who' of this person wants to see into the   see into it all by yourself without depending on whence of a thought. Is it mind, or Buddha, or         anyone else. In this it may be said that you have a matter? No, it is none of these, say the masters.      kind of clue whereby to go on with your Zen." What is it, then?" This is the way the masters dealt   According to Zen master D.T. Suzuki in Essays in with the Buddha-recitation (Nembutsu) in               Zen Buddhism, Second Series (p.150), one of the connection with the koan exercise if one wanted        first Zen masters to introduce the idea of Buddha- to master Zen. Nowadays, some practitioners            recitation into Zen was Yang-ming Yen-shou. He desire by means of Buddha-recitation to be born in     laid great importance on Zen Yogins devoting the Land of Purity and wonder if the Buddha-           themselves to the practice of the Buddha- recitation is not to be distinguished from Zen.        recitation to this extent, that he declared that those They fail to recognize that Zen and Buddha-            who follow Zen without Buddha-recitation may recitation are not the same and yet are the same;      fail nine out of ten in their attainment of the final for the object of Zen is to understand what life       goal, whereas those who practice Buddha- means, and the object of Buddha-recitation is also     recitation will all without exception come to the same. Zen directly points to the mind in every     realization; but the best are those who practice one of us , declaring that to see into the nature of   Zen and Buddha-recitation, for they will be like a every being means attaining Buddhahood;                tiger provided with horns. What Yang-ming whereas Buddha-recitation aims at reaching the         exactly means by this statement is not easy to Land of Purity which is no other than one's own        comprehend, for he does not tell us as to its mind, and seeing into the original nature of every     practical side; that is, how to practice both Zen being which is Amitabha himself. Master Huan-          and Buddha-recitation at the same time. Did he chu says: "The study of Zen aims at elucidating        mean to practice the Buddha-recitation after the the meaning of birth and death, whereas the            attainment of Zen, or vice-versa? Until this Buddha-recitation proposes to get settled with the     practical question is definitely settled, we may not question of death and birth; choose either one of      venture either to refute or to defend Yang-ming. the pathways, for there is disputation to be           Coâng AÙn Nieäm Phaät Thò Thuøy?: Who is the one aroused about them. Quite true, there is no            who recites the name of Buddha?—Moät hoâm Hoøa disputation between the two, but do not allow          Thöôïng Hö Vaân thöôïng ñöôøng daïy chuùng: "Ngaøy yourself to keep both with you. Let the Zen            tröôùc ñeä Thaát Toå Thanh Nguyeân Haønh Tö hoûi Luïc devotee keep himself exclusively to Zen, and let       Toå: 'Phaûi tu taäp theá naøo ñeå khoûi rôi vaøo phaân bieät the one who recites the Buddha-recitation keep         giai taàng?' Luïc Toå hoûi: 'Töø tröôùc ñeán giôø oâng laøm

gì?' Haønh Tö ñaùp: 'Thaùnh Ñeá cuõng chaúng laøm!'             Neáu khi chuùng ta môùi duïng coâng, khoâng ñeå khôûi Luïc Toå noùi: 'Nhö vaäy thì oâng coøn rôi vaøo phaân bieät     thoaïi ñaàu ñöôïc, caùc oâng khoâng neân noùng ruoät, chæ giai taàng gì nöõa!' Haønh Tö ñaùp: 'Thaùnh Ñeá coøn            cöù ñöøng moùng khôûi tình caûm gì caû, vaø khoâng ngôùt chaúng laøm, thì coøn coù giai taàng gì nöõa?' Nghe vaäy        quaùn saùt. Neáu voïng töôûng ñeán, cho noù ñeán, mình Luïc Toå bieát ñaây laø moät baäc Phaùp khí (ngöôøi coù caên    chaúng heà chuù yù ñeán noù, voïng töôûng töï nhieân phaûi cô haønh ñöôïc Phaät Ñaïo). Coøn baây giôø, caùc oâng vaø       döùt baët. Voïng töôûng ñeán chuùng ta laáy caùi söùc quaùn toâi caên khí yeáu keùm, caùc ñaïi toå sö chaúng theå chaúng    saùt maø baùm chaët vaøo caâu thoaïi ñaàu. Neáu thoaïi ñaàu möôïn phöông tieän, daïy chuùng ta tham moät caâu               maát, chuùng ta laäp töùc ñeà khôûi laïi. Khi môùi ngoài thoaïi ñaàu. Töø ñôøi Toáng veà sau naøy, ngöôøi nieäm          Thieàn, chuùng ta chaúng ngôùt bò voïng töôûng, nhöng Phaät raát nhieàu, vì theá caùc ñaïi toå sö daïy tham caâu      laâu daàn chuùng ta môùi ñuû söùc ñeà khôûi thoaïi ñaàu leân thoaïi ñaàu: 'Ai laø keû nieäm Phaät?' Hieän taïi khaép nôi     ñöôïc. Ñeán luùc aáy caùc oâng coù theå ñeà khôûi thoaïi ñaàu moïi ngöôøi theo caùch tham thoaïi ñaàu naøy maø tu taäp.       deã daøng, suoát haøng giôø chaúng vuoät maát. Ñoù laø caùc Nhöng coøn raát nhieàu ngöôøi vaãn chöa hieåu roõ, laïi         oâng ñaõ tìm ra choã ñeå naém roài vaäy. Caùc oâng neân ñem thoaïi ñaàu 'Ai laø ngöôøi nieäm Phaät' naøy maø            luoân nhôù raèng nhöõng lôøi toâi noùi vöøa roài chæ laø lôøi nieäm ñi nieäm laïi, hoùa ra laø nieäm thoaïi ñaàu chöù         roãng tueách. Quan troïng laø caùc oâng phaûi coá gaéng ra chaúng phaûi laø tham thoaïi ñaàu. Tham nghóa laø tham          söùc vaäy."—One day, Most Venerable Hsu Yun khaùn, töùc laø nhìn thaáu vaø quan saùt, bôûi vaäy haàu heát   entered the hall to teach the assembly, "Once the caùc Thieàn Ñöôøng ñeàu coù treo boán chöõ 'Chieáu coá          so called Seventh Patriarch, Ching-yuan-hsing- thoaïi ñaàu'. Chieáu laø phaûn chieáu, coá laø troâng ngoùng,   szu, asked the Sixth Patriarch, Hui-neng, 'Through töùc laø töï quay nhìn vaøo töï taùnh. Vaäy quay ngöôïc         what practice should one work that one may not caùi taâm trí quen höôùng ra tìm caàu ngoaïi vaät maø           fall into a category?' The Sixth Patriarch replied, nhìn vaøo mình, môùi goïi laø tham thoaïi ñaàu. Noùi veà        'What have you been doing?' Hsing-szu answered, thoaïi ñaàu thì 'Ai laø ngöôøi nieäm Phaät?' laø moät caâu      'I do not even practice the Holy Truth!' 'In that noùi. Caâu noùi aáy khi chöa ñöôïc noùi ra, goïi laø thoaïi     case, to what category do you belong?' said the ñaàu, ñaõ noùi ra noù trôû thaønh thoaïi vó. Chuùng ta tham     Sixth Patriarch. 'Even the Holy Truth does not thoaïi ñaàu töùc laø tham chöõ 'Ai' naøy, khi chöa khôûi        exist, so how can there by any category?' said leân thì nhö theá naøo? Ví duï nhö toâi ñang ngoài ôû ñaây      Hsing-szu. Hearing this answer, the Sixth nieäm Phaät, boãng coù moät ngöôøi hoûi, 'Ai nieäm Phaät        Patriarch was impressed by Hsing-szu's ñoù vaäy?' Toâi ñaùp, 'Toâi nieäm Phaät'. Laïi hoûi, 'Ngöôøi    understanding. Now you and I, not being as highly nieäm Phaät laø oâng, vaäy thì oâng nieäm Phaät baèng           endowed as the Patriarchs, are obliged to devise mieäng hay baèng taâm. Neáu nieäm baèng mieäng thì              methods such as the 'practicing of the head khi oâng nguû sao laïi chaúng nieäm; neáu nieäm baèng           phrase', which teach us to work on a specifically taâm, thì khi oâng cheát sao laïi khoâng nieäm nöõa.' Neáu      chosen koan problem crystallized into a single chuùng ta ñoái vôùi caâu naøy coù ñieàu nghi ngôø, thì phaûi    sentence or head phrase. After the Sung Dynasty truy cöùu caùi choã nghi ñoù. Xeùt xem caâu noùi aáy roát       the Pure Land School became increasingly cuoäc laø töû ñaâu tôùi, vaø noù nhö theá naøo, quan saùt kyõ   popular, and reciting the name of Buddha löôõng, ñoù cuõng laø phaûn vaên töï tính vaäy. Neáu nhö        Amitabha became a widespread practice among luùc naøo cuõng quaùn ñöôïc thoaïi ñaàu, coâng phu töï          the Buddhists. Under these circumstances, the nhieân thuaàn thuïc deã daøng, caùc taäp khí töï nhieân döùt    great Zen Masters urged people to work on the baët. Ñoái vôùi ngöôøi môùi duïng coâng, khoâng deã gì          head phrase of 'Who is the one who recites the quaùn thoaïi ñaàu cho ñuùng ñöôïc, theá nhöng khoâng            name of Buddha?' This head phrase then became, neân sôï haõi, cuõng khoâng ñöôïc coù yù nieäm giaùc ngoä       and still remains, the most popular of all. But there hoaëc caàu trí hueä gì caû. Neân bieát raèng tu Thieàn laø      are still many people who do not understand how ñeå giaùc ngoä, ñeå caàu trí hueä, neáu nhö caùc oâng laïi      to practice it. Some are foolish enough to recite ñem moät caùi taâm nöõa maø caàu nhöõng thöù aáy coù            repeatedly the sentence itself! This head phrase khaùc gì theâm ñaàu leân ñaàu. Baây giôø chuùng ta ñaõ          practice is not a matter of reciting the sentence or bieát laø chæ caàn ñeå khôûi moät thoaïi ñaàu, khaû dó coù      concentrating on it. It is to 'Tsan' the very nature theå ñaûm ñöông moät caùch ñôn giaûn mau choùng.                of the sentence. 'Tsan' means to look into

penetratingly and to observe. In the meditation          Coâng AÙn OÂ Cöïu Vaán Phaùp Ñaïo: Ukyu (jap)— hall of any monastery we usually find the                Wu-Chiu's Unjust Beating—See OÂ Cöïu Vaán Phaùp following admonition posted on the walls:                Ñaïo. 'Observe and Look into your head phrase'. Here           Coâng AÙn Phaùp Ñaêng Vò Lieãu: Fa-T'eng's "Not 'to observe' means to look at in reverse, that is, to    yet enlightened"—See Phaùp Ñaêng Vò Lieãu. look backward, and 'look into' means to put your         Coâng AÙn Phaùp Thaân: Hosshin Koâan—See Nguõ mind penetratingly into the head phrase (hua-tou).       Chuûng Coâng AÙn. Our minds are used to going outside and sensing          Coâng AÙn Phaàn Döông Linh AÂm Ñieåu Haùt: Fen- the things in the outer world. 'Tsan' is to reverse      Yang "The sound of the bell and the chirp of the this habit and to look inside. 'Who is the one who       sparrow"—See Phaàn Döông Linh AÂm Ñieåu Haùt. recites the name of Buddha?' is the 'hua', the           Coâng AÙn Phaàn Döông Truï Tröôïng: Fen-Yang's sentence. But before the thought of this sentence        staff—See Phaàn Döông Truï Tröôïng. ever arises, we have the head (tou). As soon as it       Coâng AÙn Phi Phong Phi Phan: Not the Wind, Not is uttered we have the sentence's tail or end (hua-      the Flag—See Phi Phong Phi Phan. wei). To 'tsan' this head phrase is to look into the     Coâng AÙn Phoù Ñaïi Só Giaûng Kinh: Mahasattva Fu very idea of 'Who?', to penetrate into the state         Ta Shih Expounds the Scripture—See Phoù Ñaïi Só before the thought ever arises, and to see what          Giaûng Kinh. this state looks like. It is to observe from whence      Coâng AÙn Phong Huyeät Nhaát Vi Traàn: Feng- the very thought of 'Who' comes, to see what it          Hsueh's One Atom of Dust—See Phong Huyeät looks like, and subtly and very gently to penetrate      Nhaát Vi Traàn. into it. If you can always adhere to your 'head          Coâng AÙn Phong Huyeät Thieát Ngöu Cô: Feng phrase', you will naturally and easily master the        Hsueh's Workings of the Iron Ox—See Phong work. Thus, all your habitual thoughts will              Huyeät Toå Sö Tam AÁn. automatically be subdued. It is not easy for             Coâng AÙn Phong Huyeät Toå Sö Tam AÁn: Feng beginners to work well on the 'head phrase', but         Hsueh's Workings of the Iron Ox—See Phong you should never become afraid of discouraged;           Huyeät Toå Sö Tam AÁn. neither should you cling to any thought of Coâng AÙn Phong Tính Thöôøng Truï: The nature of attaining Enlightenment, because you are now the wind is always abiding—See Phong Tính practicing meditation, whose very purpose is to Thöôøng Truï. produce Enlightenment. Therefore any additional Coâng AÙn Phu Coâng Dieâu Ñaàu: Tai-Yuan Fu: thought of attaining Enlightenment is as "Nodding the head"—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô duyeân unnecessary and as foolish as to think of adding a vaán ñaùp giöõa Thieàn sö Tuyeát Phong vaø Thaùi head to one you already have! You should not Nguyeân Phu. Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, worry about it if at first you cannot work well on quyeån XIX, moät hoâm, khi Tuyeát Phong gaëp Thaùi the 'head phrase'; what you should do is just to Nguyeân Phu ngoaøi saân, Tuyeát Phong laáy tay chæ keep remembering and observing it continuously. maët trôøi. Thaùi Nguyeân Phu phuûi tay aùo roài boû ñi. If any distracting thoughts arise, do not follow Tuyeát Phong hoûi: "OÂng khoâng chaáp nhaän laõo them up, but just recognize them for what they Taêng, coù phaûi vaäy khoâng?" Thaùi Nguyeân Phu noùi: are. In the beginning everyone feels the "Hoøa Thöôïng gaät ñaàu coøn con thì vaãy ñuoâi, coøn distraction of continuously arising errant thoughts, choã naøo laø chaúng chaáp nhaän?" Tuyeát Phong noùi: and cannot remember the 'head phrase' very well; "OÂng phaûi thaän troïng baát cöù nôi naøo maø oâng ñeán." but gradually, as time goes on, you will learn to Moät hoâm khaùc, Tuyeát Phong hoûi Thaùi Nguyeân: take up the 'head phrase' more easily. When that "Nghe noùi Laâm Teá coù ba cuù phaûi khoâng?" Thaùi time comes you can take it up with ease and it will Nguyeân noùi: "Phaûi." Tuyeát Phong hoûi: "Theá naøo laø not escape you once during the entire hour. Then ñeä nhaát cuù?" Thaùi Nguyeân giöông maét nhìn, Tuyeát you will find the work is not difficult at all. I have Phong noùi: "Ñoù vaãn coøn laø ñeä nhò cuù, theá naøo laø ñeä talked a lot of nonsense today! Now all of you had nhaát cuù?" Thaùi Nguyeân xoa tay roài lui ra. Töø ñoù better go and work hard on your 'head phrase'." Tuyeát Phong raát xem troïng Thaùi Nguyeân. Thaùi

Nguyeân nhaän söï truyeàn Phaùp töø Tuyeát Phong, vaø          gaëp teân oâng trong thí duï thöù 36 cuûa Bích Nham coù aán giaûi ñaëc bieät giöõa thaày troø. Thaùi Nguyeân ôû    Luïc. ÔÛ ñaây chuùng ta tìm thaáy moät cuoäc vaán ñaùp laïi vôùi Tuyeát Phong moät khoaûn thôøi gian daøi vaø         giöõa Tröôøng Sa vôùi moät trong nhöõng vò ñeä töû cuûa phuï traùch vieäc chaêm soùc nhaø taém cho chö Taêng—          oâng: "Moät hoâm Tröôøng Sa phieâu löu leân nuùi. Roài The koan about the potentiality and conditions of              oâng trôû veà vaø xuaát hieän nôi cöûa. Vò sö lôùn tuoåi questions and answers between Zen Master                       nhaát hoûi oâng: 'Thöa thaày, thaày ñi nhöõng ñaâu? Thaày Xuefeng and Tai-Yuan. According to the Records                 töø ñaâu tôùi?' Tröôøng Sa noùi: 'Ta trôû veà töø moät of the Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-                  chuyeán ñi chôi nuùi.' Nhaø sö lôùn tuoåi kia laïi hoûi: Lu), Volume XIX, one day, Xuefeng met Tai-                     'Thaày ñi tôùi taän ñaâu?' Tröôøng Sa ñaùp: 'Luùc ñaàu ta Yuan in the front yard, Xuefeng pointed at the sun             cöù ñi theo höôùng coû. Roài ta trôû veà theo nhöõng caùnh with his finger, Tai-Yuan dusted off his sleeves               hoa ñang rôi xuoáng.' Nhaø sö laïi noùi: 'Theá laø thaày and left. Xuefeng asked, "You don't accept me, do              caûm thaáy ñöôïc muøa xuaân.' Tröôøng Sa noùi: 'Thaät ra you?" Tai-Yuan said, "Your Venerable nodded the                söï caûm nhaän aáy maïnh hôn söï caûm nhaän söông muøa head and I wagged the tail, where do you say that              thu nhoû gioït töø caùc boâng sen nhieàu.'" Theo Vieân I don't accept you?" Xuefeng said, "You should be              Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc, ñaïi sö Chieâu Hieàn ôû more careful wherever you go!" Another day,                    Loäc Uyeån Tröôøng Sa keá thöøa Nam Tuyeàn, cuøng Xuefeng asked Tai-Yuan, "I understand that Linji               Trieäu Chaâu, Töû Hoà ñoàng baïn. Cô phong cuûa Sö has three phrases. Is that so?" Tai-Yuan said,                 nhanh nheïn, coù ngöôøi hoûi kinh, laáy kinh ñaùp; caàn "Yes." Xuefeng said, "What is the first one?" Tai-             tuïng duøng tuïng ñaùp. Neáu oâng caàn taùc gia thaáy Yuan looked up and stared directly at Xuefeng.                 nhau thì duøng taùc gia thaáy nhau. Ngöôõng Sôn bình Xuefeng said, "That's the second phrase. What's                thöôøng cô phong thaät laø baäc nhaát, moät hoâm cuøng the first?" Tai-Yuan clasped his hands and left.               Tröôøng Sa xem traêng. Ngöôõng Sôn chæ maët traêng After this incident Xuefeng held Tai-Yuan in high              noùi: "Moãi ngöôøi troïn coù caùi naøy, chæ vì duøng chaúng esteem. Tai-Yuan received Dharma transmission                  ñöôïc." Tröôøng Sa baûo: "Vöøa laø tieän vöøa laø ñeïp, and had a special affinity with Xuefeng. He                    oâng duøng xem?" Ngöôõng Sôn noùi: "Sö thuùc duøng remained with Xuefeng for a long period and                    xem?" Tröôøng Sa ñaïp cho Ngöôõng Sôn moät ñaïp teù served as the bath attendant.                                  nhaøo. Ngöôõng Sôn ñöùng daäy noùi: "Sö thuùc gioáng Coâng AÙn Phuø Ly Maïc Bích: Two hand support                  nhö con coïp." Ngöôøi ñôøi sau goïi laø Saàm con coïp. the fence, or touch the wall—See Phuø Ly Maïc                  Moät hoâm nhaân ñi nuùi veà, Thuû toïa cuõng laø ngöôøi Bích.                                                          trong hoäi cuûa Sö, hoûi: "Hoøa Thöôïng ñi ñaâu veà?" Coâng AÙn Phuøng Phaät Saùt Phaät Phuøng Toå Saùt              Tröôøng Sa ñaùp: "Ñi daïo nuùi veà." Thuû toïa hoûi: Toå: Encounter Buddhas kill Buddhas, encounter                 "Ñeán choã naøo ñi veà?" Tröôøng Sa ñaùp: "Tröôùc tuøy Patriarchs kill Patriarchs—See Phuøng Phaät Saùt               coû thôm ñeán, sau theo hoa ruïng veà." Phaûi laø ngöôøi Phaät Phuøng Toå Saùt Toå.                                     ngoài ñoaïn möôøi phöông môùi ñöôïc. Coå nhaân ra vaøo Coâng AÙn Phöôùn Ñoäng, Gioù Ñoäng Hay Taâm                    chöa töøng chaúng laáy vieäc naøy laøm nieäm. Xem kia Ñoäng?: The flag moving, the wind moving, or our               chuû khaùch laãn xoay, ñöông cô chaët thaúng, moãi beân minds moving?—See Phi Phong Phi Phan.                          chaúng dung. Ñaõ laø ñi daïo nuùi, taïi sao laïi hoûi ñeán Coâng AÙn Phöông Thaûo Laïc Hoa: Ch'ang Sha's                  choã naøo ñi veà? Neáu laø thieàn Taêng ñôøi nay, lieàn fragrant grasses and falling flowers (Wandering in             ñaùp Giaùp Sôn ñình veà. Thaáy roõ coå nhaân khoâng coù the Mountains), example 36 of the Pi-Yen-Lu—                   maûy may ñaoï lyù so saùnh, cuõng khoâng coù choã truï Thí duï thöù 36 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Tröôøng Sa laø            tröôùc, vì theá noùi "Tröôùc tuøy coû thôm ñeán, sau theo teân cuûa moät vò thieàn sö Trung Hoa vaøo theá thöù IX,       hoa ruïng veà." Thuû toïa theå theo yù kia noùi: "Raát ñeä töû vaø truyeàn nhaân noái phaùp cuûa thieàn sö Nam        gioáng yù xuaân." Tröôøng Sa baûo: "Cuõng hôn gioït Tuyeàn Phoå Nguyeän. Sau khi nhaän töø Nam Tuyeàn              söông thu treân hoa sen." Tuyeát Ñaäu noùi: "Taï ñaùp daáu aán xaùc nhaän, Tröôøng Sa ñi lang thang khoâng           thoaïi." Ñoù laø theá cho lôøi sau roát, cuõng rôi vaøo hai nôi ôû coá ñònh OÂng ñi khaép Trung Hoa vaø thuyeát            beân, maø cöùu caùnh chaúng ôû hai beân. Thuôû xöa coù tuù phaùp tuøy cô duyeân vaø ngaãu nhieân chöù khoâng coù          taøi Tröông Chuyeát xem kinh Thieân Phaät Danh, hoûi saép ñaët tröôùc. OÂng coù hai ñeä töû noái phaùp. Chuùng ta   Tröôøng Sa: "Traêm ngaøn chö Phaät chæ nghe danh,

chöa bieát ôû quoác ñoä naøo, laïi coù giaùo hoùa hay     Hence, people later called Ch'ang Sha "Ts'en the khoâng?" Tröôøng Sa ñaùp: "Laàu Hoaøng Haïc sau khi       Tiger." One day as Ch'ang Sha returned from a Thoâi Haïo ñeà thi, tuù taøi töøng ñeà thi hay chöa?"     stroll in the mountain, the head monk, who was Tröông Chuyeát ñaùp: "Chöa töøng ñeà." Tröôøng Sa         also a man of Ch'ang Sha's congregation, asked baûo: "Khi naøo raûnh ñeà laáy moät thieân cuõng toát."   him, "Where are you coming from, Master?" Saàm con coïp bình sanh vì ngöôøi thöôøng laø chaâu       Ch'ang Sha said, "I come from a stroll in the hoài ngoïc chuyeån, caàn ngöôøi ñoái dieän lieàn hoäi —   mountains." The head monk asked, "Where did Name of a Chinese Zen master in the ninth                 you go?" Ch'ang Sha said, "First I went following century, disciple and dharma successor of Zen             the fragrant grasses; then I returned pursuing the master Nan-Ch’uan-Pu-Yuan. After receiving the            falling flowers." Only a man who had cut off the seal of confirmation from Nan-chuan, Ch'ang-sha           ten directions could be like this. The Ancients, in wandered homelessly throughout China and                  leaving and entering, never failed to be mindful of expounded the Buddha-dharma according to the              this Matter. See how the host and guest shift circumstances he encountered. He had two                  positions together; confronting the situation dharma successors. We encounter him in example            directly, neither overlaps the other. Since he was 36 of the Pi-Yen-Lu. There we find Ch'ang sha in          wandering in the mountains, why did the monk a 'Question and answer' (mondo) with one of his           ask, "Where did you go?" If he had been one of students: "One day Ch'ang sha was wandering               today's followers of Ch'an, he would have said, "I around in the mountains; then he turned back and          came to the inn on Mount Chia." See how that came to the gate. The eldest of the monks asked           man of old did not have even the slightest hair of him: 'Master, where did you go and where did you          reason or judgment, and that he had no place to come back from?' Ch'ang-sha said: 'I am coming            abide: that is why he said, "First I went following from a walk in the mountains.' The elder monk             the fragrant grasses; then I returned pursuing the said: 'How far did you go?' Ch'ang-sha said: 'First I     falling flowers." The head monk then followed his followed the fragrance of the herbs; then I came          idea and said to him "How very much like the back following falling flower petals.' The elder          sense of springtime!" Ch'ang Sha said, "It even monk said: 'That sounds a lot like spring.' Ch'ang-       surpasses the autumn dew dripping on the sha said: 'It really goes beyond the autumn dew           lotuses." Hsueh Tou says on behalf of the monk, that drips from the lotus blossom.'"According to          "Thanks for your reply," as the final word. This Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, Great Master Chao               too falls on both sides but ultimately does not Hsien of the Deer Park at Ch'ang Sha succeeded            remain on either side. In the past there was a to the Dharma of Nan Ch'uan; he was a                     scholar, Ch'ang Ch'o, who upon reading the Sutra contemporary of Chao Chou and Tzu Hu. The                 of the Thousand Names of Buddhas, asked, "Of point of his wit was sharp and swift. If anyone           the hundreds and thousands of Buddhas, I have asked about the Teachings, he would then give             only heard their names; what lands do they dwell him an explanation of the Teachings; if someone           in, and do they convert beings or not?" Ch'ang Sha wanted a verse, he would then give a verse. If you        said, "Since Ts'ui Hao wrote his poems in the wanted to have a meeting of adepts, then he               Golden Crane Pavillion, have you ever written or would have a meeting of adepts with you. Yang             not?" Ch'ang Ch'o said, "No." Ch'ang Sha said, Shan was usually considered foremost in having a          "When you have some free time, you should write sharp intellect. Once as he was enjoying the moon         one." Ts'en the Tiger's usual way of helping along with Ch'ang Sha, Yang Shan pointed at the           people was like jewels turning, gems revolving; moon and said, "Everyone has this; it's just that         he wanted people to understand immediately on they can't use it." Ch'ang Sha said, "Quite so true.      the face of it. So, shall I have you use it?" Yang Shan said, "Try        Coâng AÙn Quaù Moäc Kieàu: To cross over the single to use it yourself." Ch'ang Sha kicked him over           log bridge, i.e. only one string to the bow—See with one blow. Yang Shan got up and said,                 Quaù Moäc Kieàu. "Respected Uncle, you are just like a tiger."             Coâng AÙn Quan Leä Töû: Then gaøi cöûa—Latch of a

door—See Quan Leä Töû.                                        cultivate until attaining enlightenment. The koan Coâng AÙn Qui Gia OÅn Toïa : Returning home and               about the potentiality and conditions of questions sitting in peace—Veà nhaø ngoài an oån. Trong thieàn,         and answers between the First Patriarch töø naày coù nghóa laø söï xa lìa cuoäc soáng phaân bieät     Bodhidharma and Emperor Wu of Liang. voïng töôûng, chæ vôùi moät nieäm nhaát taâm tu haønh         According to the Pi-Yen-Lu, example 1, shortly giaûi thoaùt. Coâng aùn noùi veà cô duyeân vaán ñaùp giöõa    after arriving in China, in about 520 A.D., he Sô Toå Boà Ñeà Ñaït Ma vaø vua Löông Voõ Ñeá. Theo            visited Emperor Wu of Liang. "What is the Bích Nham Luïc, taéc 1, khoâng laâu sau khi ñeán              meaning of the dharma?" the emperor asked. Trung Hoa (khoaûng naêm 520 sau Taây lòch), ngaøi             "Vast emptiness without holiness," Bodhidharma beä kieán vua Löông Voõ Ñeá. Löông Voõ Ñeá hoûi:              replied. "Who is standing before me now?" The "Theá naøo laø Thaùnh ñeá ñeä nhaát nghóa?" Toå ñaùp:         emperor asked. Bodhidharma replied, "I don't "Roãng theânh khoâng Thaùnh." Löông Voõ Ñeá hoûi:             know." Zen practitioners in the world can leap "Ñoái dieän vôùi traãm laø ai?" Toå ñaùp: "Chaúng bieát."     clear of this. Bodhidharma gives them a single Thieàn giaû khaép nôi nhaûy khoâng qua khoûi choã naøy.       swordblow that cuts off everything. These days Toå Boà Ñeà Ñaït Ma cho hoï moät nhaùc ñao ñöùt saïch         how people misunderstand! They go on giving moïi thöù. Ngaøy nay coù moät soá ngöôøi laàm hieåu! Trôû     play to their spirits, put a glare in their eyes and laïi ñuøa vôùi tinh thaàn cuûa chính mình, trôïn maét noùi:   say, "Empty, without holiness!" Fortunately, this "Roãng theânh khoâng Thaùnh." Thaät may, choã naøy            has nothing to do with it. Zen master Wu Tsu once khoâng dính daùng gì vôùi noù. Thieàn sö Nguõ Toå Phaùp       said, "If only you can penetrate 'empty, without Dieãn coù laàn noùi: "Chæ caâu 'Roãng theânh khoâng           holiness,' then you can return home and sit in Thaùnh' neáu ngöôøi thaáu ñöôïc veà nhaø ngoài an oån         peace." All this amounts to creating complications; (qui gia oån toïa)." Taát caû nhöõng thöù naøy ñang taïo ra   still, it does not stop Bodhidharma from smashing nhieàu phöùc taïp, nhöng cuõng khoâng ngöøng ñöôïc Toå        the lacquer bucket for others. Among all, Boà Ñeà Ñaït Ma vì ngöôøi maø ñaäp naùt thuøng sôn.           Bodhidharma is most extraordinary. So it is said, Trong taát caû thì Toå Boà Ñeà Ñaït Ma thaät laø kyø ñaëc     "If you can penetrate a single phrase, at the same nhaát. Vì vaäy neân ngöôøi ta noùi: "Neáu haønh giaû tham     moment you will penetrate a thousand phrases, thaáu moät caâu thì cuøng luùc ngaøn caâu muoân caâu          ten thousand phrases." Then naturally you can cut ñoàng thaáu." Roài thò töï nhieân naèm ngoài ñeàu yeân        off, you can hols still. An Ancient said, "Crushing ñònh. Ngöôøi xöa noùi: "Tan xöông naùt thòt chöa ñuû          your bones and dismembering your body would ñeàn; khi moät caâu roõ suoát, vöôït qua traêm öùc." Toå      not be sufficient requital; when a single phrase is Boà Ñeà Ñaït Ma ñoái ñaàu thaúng vôùi Vua Löông Vuõ           clearly understood, you leap over hundreds of Ñeá, moät phen muoán chìu cho vua thaáy! Vua chaúng           millions." Bodhidharma confronted Emperor Wu ngoä laïi ñem caùi chaáp nhaân ngaõ maø hoûi laïi: "Ñoái      directly; how he indulged! The Emperor did not dieän traãm laø ai?" Loøng töø bi cuûa Toå Boà Ñeà Ñaït Ma    awaken; instead, because of his notions of self and quaù laém; neân laàn nöõa laïi noùi vôùi nhaø vua: "Chaúng    others, he asked another question, "Who is facing bieát." Ngay luùc ñoù Vuõ Ñeá söûng soát, khoâng hieåu yù     me?" Bodhidharma's compassion was excessive; cuûa Toå. Khi haønh giaû ñeán ñöôïc choã naøy, coù vieäc      again he addressed him, saying, "I don't know." At hay khoâng vieäc laïi ñeàu khoâng kham ñöôïc. Qua thí         this, Emperor Wu was taken aback; he did not duï naày, chuùng ta thaáy vaøo theá kyû thöù saùu, toå Boà    know what Bodhidharma meant. When Zen Ñeà Ñaït Ma thaáy caàn phaûi ñeán Trung Hoa ñeå               practitioners get to this point, as to whether there truyeàn taâm aán cho nhöõng ngöôøi coù caên cô Ñaïi           is something or there isn't anything, pick and you Thöøa. Chuû ñích cuûa chuyeán ñi truyeàn giaùo cuûa           fail. Through this koan, we see that in the sixth ngaøi laø vaïch baøy nhöõng lôùp meâ, chaúng laäp ngoân       century, Bodhidharma saw that he need to go to ngöõ vaên töï, chæ thaúng taâm ngöôøi ñeå thaáy taùnh         China to transmit the Mind seal to people who had thaønh Phaät—To return home and sit down                      the capability of the Great Vehicle. The intent of peacefully. In Zen, the term means to stay away               his mission was to arouse and instruct those mired from a life full of discriminations from deluded              in delusion. Without establishing written words, he thoughts, with only an unconfused mind to                     pointed directly to the human mind for them to see

nature and fulfill Buddhahood.                               if I did, in the future I would be bereft of Coâng AÙn Qui Sôn Thænh Baùch Tröôïng: Kuei                  descendants." According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi- Shan Attends on Pai Chang—Theo thí duï thöù 70               Yen-Lu, although Pai Chang acted like this, his cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Qui Sôn, Nguõ Phong, Vaân               pot had already been carried off by someone else. Nham ñoàng ñöùng haàu Baùch Tröôïng. Baùch Tröôïng           He also asked Wu Feng this same question. Wu hoûi Qui Sôn: "Deïp heát coå hoïng moâi meùp, laøm sao       Feng said, "Teacher, you too should shut up." Pai noùi?" Qui Sôn thöa: "Thænh Hoøa Thöôïng noùi."              Chang said, "Where there's no one, I shade my Baùch Tröôïng baûo: "Ta chaúng töøng noùi vôùi oâng, chæ     eyes with my hand and gaze out towards you." Pai e veà sau maát heát con chaùu." Theo Vieân Ngoä trong        Chang also asked Yun Men the same question. Bích Nham Luïc, tuy Baùch Tröôïng noùi nhö theá, caùi        Yun Men said, "Teacher, do you have any way to noài ñaõ bò ngöôøi keû khaùc cöôùp maát roài. Baùch          speak or not?" Pai Chang said, "I have lost my Tröôïng laïi hoûi Nguõ Phong. Nguõ Phong thöa: "Hoøa         descendants." Each of these three men was a Thöôïng cuõng phaûi deïp heát." Baùch Tröôïng noùi:          Master. An Ancient said, "On the level ground "Choã khoâng ngöôøi vaïch traùn nhìn oâng." Baùch            there are dead people without number. Those who Tröôïng hoûi Vaân Nham. Vaân Nham thöa: "Hoøa                can pass through the forest of brambles are the Thöôïng coù hay chöa?" Baùch Tröôïng noùi: "Maát heát        skillful ones." Therefore teachers of our school con chaùu cuûa ta. Ba ngöôøi moãi vò moät nhaø." Coå         use the forest of brambles to test people. Why? nhaân noùi: "Treân ñaát baèng ngöôøi cheát voâ soá, qua      They couldn't test people if they stuck to phrases ñöôïc röøng gai goùc laø ngöôøi tay kheùo." Vì theá haøng    based on ordinary feelings. Patchrobed monks Toâng sö ñem röøng gai goùc nghieäm ngöôøi. Côù sao?         must be able to display their ability in phrases and Neáu ôû döôùi caâu thöôøng tình nghieäm ngöôøi chaúng        discern the point within words. As for board- ñöôïc. Haøng thieàn khaùch caàn phaûi trong caâu trình       carrying fellows, they often die within the words cô, trong lôøi bieän muïc ñích. Neáu laø keû gaùnh baûn,     and say, "If throat, mouth, and lips are shut, there's phaàn ñoâng nhaèm trong caâu maø cheát, nghe noùi deïp       no longer a way to say anything." As for those heát coå hoïng moâi meùp thì khoâng coù choã môû mieäng.     who can adapt successfully, they have waves Neáu laø ngöôøi bieán thoâng, coù loái soáng ngöôïc nöôùc,   which go against the current, they have a single chæ nhaèm treân caâu hoûi coù loái ñi, tay chaúng bò         road in the question. They don't cut their hands thöông tích. Qui Sôn thöa: "Thænh Hoøa Thöôïng               blundering against its sharp point. Kuei Shan said, noùi." Haõy noùi yù nghó theá naøo? Trong ñaây nhö choïi     "Please, Teacher, you speak instead." Tell me, ñaù nhaùng löûa, tôï laøn ñieån chôùp, nhôn choã hoûi kia    what did he mean? Here he was like sparks struck lieàn ñaùp, töï coù con ñöôøng xuaát thaân, chaúng toán      from stone, like a flash of lightning: pressing back maûy may khí löïc. Vì theá noùi, kia tham caâu soáng         against Pai Chang's question, he answered chaúng tham caâu cheát. Baùch Tröôïng chaúng bieän kia,      immediately. He had his own way to get himself chæ noùi chaúng töøng noùi vôùi oâng, chæ e veà sau maát     out, without wasting the slightest effort. Thus it is heát con chaùu cuûa ta. Ñaïi phaøm baäc Toâng sö vì          said, "He studies the living phrase; he doesn't ngöôøi phaûi nhoå ñinh thaùo choát. Nhö ngöôøi nay noùi:     study the dead phrase." Nevertheless, Pai Chang "Ñaùp naøy chaúng thöøa nhaän, kia thoâng laõnh thoaïi."     did not take him up on it, but just said, "I don't Ñaâu chaúng bieát trong ñaây moät ñöôøng sanh cô, vaùch      refuse to speak to you, but I fear that if I did, in ñöùng ngaøn nhaãn, khaùch chuû laãn keùo, soáng linh         the future I would be bereft of descendants." ñoäng. Tuyeát Ñaäu meán lôøi cuûa Qui Sôn, phong caùch       Whenever teachers of our school help people, uyeån chuyeån töï taïi, laïi hay naém vöõng phong            they pull out nails and extract pegs. As for people cöông—According to example 70 of the Pi-Yen-                 these days who say that this answer doesn't Lu, Kuei Shan, Wu Feng, and Yun Men were                     approve of Kuei Shan and doesn't comprehend his together attending on Pai Chang. Pai Chang asked             words, how far they are from knowing that right Kuei Shan, "With your throat, mouth, and lips                here is the one path of his living potential, shut, how will you speak?" Kuei Shan said,                   towering up like a thousand fathom wall, "Please, Teacher, you speak instead." Pai Chang              interchanging guest and host, leaping with life. said, "I don't refuse to speak to you, but I fear that       Hsueh Tou likes these words of Kuei Shan's, like

his freedom to revolve around and maneuver                       "Neáu chaúng hieåu ñaâu daùm noùi chuù kinh." Quoác Sö elegantly while still being able to hold fast to his             beøn sai thò giaû ñem moät cheùn nöôùc, baûy haït gaïo, territory.                                                       moät chieác ñuõa ñeå treân caùi cheùn, trao cho Cung Coâng AÙn Qui Toâng Traûm Xaø Nhaân Duyeân:                      Phuïng, hoûi: "AÁy laø nghóa gì?" Cung Phuïng ñaùp: Kuei-tsung's cutting a snake with a spade—See                    "Chaúng hieåu." Quoác Sö baûo: "YÙ cuûa laõo Taêng coøn Coâng AÙn Quy Toâng Traûm Xaø Nhaân Duyeân.                      chaúng hieåu, laïi noùi gì yù Phaät?"—The koan about Coâng AÙn Quoác Sö Lö Baát Kham Töôïng Söï:                      the potentiality and conditions of questions and National Teacher Chung's Elephant load can’t be                  answers between National Teacher Chung and the carried by a donkey—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô duyeân                 purple-clad Imperial Attendant Monk. According vaán ñaùp giöõa Hueä Trung Quoác Sö vaø ñaïi chuùng.             to the Pi-Yen-Lu, example 48, one day, National Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån V, moät               Teacher Chung asked the purple-clad Imperial hoâm, Quoác Sö thöôïng ñöôøng daïy chuùng, “Ngöôøi               Attendant Monk, "I hear that you have written a hoïc thieàn toâng neân theo lôøi Phaät, laáy nhaát thöøa lieãu   commentary on scriptures. Is this so or not?" The nghóa kheá hôïp vôùi nguoàn taâm cuûa mình, kinh                 Imperial Attendant said, "It is so." National khoâng lieãu nghóa chaúng neân phoái hôïp. Nhö boïn              Teacher Chung said, "One must first understand truøng trong thaân sö töû, khi vì ngöôøi laøm thaày, neáu        the Buddha's meaning to be fit to explain the dính maéc danh lôïi beøn baøy ñieàu dò ñoan, theá laø            scriptures." The Imperial Attendant said, "If I mình vaø ngöôøi coù lôïi ích gì? Nhö ngöôøi thôï moäc            didn't understand the meaning, how could I dare to gioûi, buùa rìu khoâng ñöùt tay hoï. Söùc con voi lôùn           say I've explained the Scritpures?" The National chôû, con löøa khoâng theå kham ñöôïc”—The koan                  teacher then ordered his attendant to bring a bowl about the potentiality and conditions of questions               of water, seven grains of rice, and a single and answers between National Teacher Chung                       chopstick. Putting them in the bowl, he then and his assembly. According to the Records of the                passed it to the Imperial Attendant and asked, Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu),                       "What meaning is this?" The Imperial Attendant Volume V, one day, the National Teacher entered                  said, "I don't understand." The National teacher the hall and addressed the monks, saying, “Those                 said, "You don't even understand my meaning, who study Zen should venerate the words of                       how can you go on talking of Buddha's meaning?" Buddha. There is but one vehicle for attaining                   Coâng AÙn Quoác Sö Voâ Phuøng Thaùp: National Buddhahood, and that is to understand the great                  Teacher Chung's seamless monument—Thaùp principle that is to connect with the source of                  khoâng coù moái noái, nhaø Thieàn duøng ñeå chæ Thieàn mind. If you haven’t become clear about the great                phaùp kín ñaùo vi dieäu, khoù duøng lôøi bieåu ñaït. Coâng principle then you haven’t embodied the teaching,                aùn noùi veà cô duyeân vaán ñaùp giöõa Hueä Trung Quoác and you are like a lion cub whose body is still                  Sö vaø vua Ñaïi Toâng. Theo Bích Nham Luïc, taéc 18, irritated by fleas. And if you become a teacher of               moät hoâm Hueä Trung Quoác Sö thaáy duyeân hoùa ñoä others, even attaining some worldly renown and                   saép maõn, beøn ñeán töø giaû vua Ñaïi Toâng ñeå trôû veà fortune, but you are still spreading falsehoods,                 nuùi. Vua hoûi: "Sau khi dieät ñoä, ñeä töû naøy phaûi laøm what good does that you do or anyone else? A                     gì ñeå töôûng nhôù thaày?" Sö ñaùp: "Baûo ñaøn vieät xaây skilled axe-man does not harm himself with the                   moät ngoâi thaùp Voâ Phuøng cho ta." Vua noùi: "Xin axe head. What is an elephant load can’t be                      thaày cho con baûn veõ cuûa ngoâi thaùp." Sö laëng thinh carried by a donkey.”                                            giaây laùt roài hoûi laïi vua: "Ngaøi coù hieåu chaêng?" Coâng AÙn Quoác Sö Thuûy Oaûn: National Teacher                  Vua noùi: "Khoâng hieåu." Sö noùi: "Khi baàn ñaïo ñi Chung's bowl of water—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô duyeân               roài coù thò giaû ÖÙng Chôn seõ bieát vieäc naøy. Xin hoûi vaán ñaùp giöõa Hueä Trung Quoác Sö vaø Töû Laân Cung            oâng ta."—Zen methods are wonderful and cannot Phuïng. Theo Bích Nham Luïc, taéc 48, moät hoâm,                 be expressed by words. The koan about the Trung Quoác Sö hoûi Töû Laân Cung Phuïng: "Nghe                  potentiality and conditions of questions and noùi Cung Phuïng chuù giaûi kinh Tö Ích phaûi chaêng?"           answers between National Teacher Chung and Cung Phuïng ñaùp: "Phaûi." Quoác Sö baûo: "Phaøm chuù            Emperor Dai Zong. According to the Pi-Yen-Lu, kinh phaûi hieåu yù Phaät môùi ñöôïc." Cung Phuïng ñaùp:         example 18, one day when Nanyang was near

death, he took leave of the emperor Dai Zong.                    tsung Chih-ch'ang and a monk. According to the The emperor said, "After you have gone, how                      Records of the Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan- should this disciple memorize you?" Nanyang                      Teng-Lu), Volume VII, one day, Kuei-tsung was said, "Please build me a seamless monument."                     weeding in the garden, a Buddhist scholar monk The emperor said, "Please give me the drawing                    versed in the philosohy of Buddhism came to see plan for the stupa." After a long pause, Nanyang                 the master. A snake happened to pass by them, said, "Do you understand?" The emperor said,                     and the master at once killed it with a spade. The "No." Nanyang said, "After I'm gone, my disciple                 philosopher-monk remarked, "How long I have Danyuan will understand about this matter. Please                heard of the name of Kuei-tsung, and how ask him about this."                                             reverently I have thought of it! But what do I see Coâng AÙn Quy Toâng Traûm Xaø Nhaân Duyeân:                      now but a rude-mannered monk?" The master Kuei-tsung's cutting a snake with a spade—Coâng                  said, "O my scholar-monk, you had better go back aùn noùi veà cô duyeân vaán ñaùp giöõa Thieàn sö Quy             to the Hall and have a cup of tea over there." The Toâng Trí Thöôøng vaø moät vò Taêng. Theo Caûnh Ñöùc             monk asked, "Why do I have to go back to the Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån VII, moät hoâm, Quy Toâng             Hall for tea?" The monk asked, "Why do you ask ñang giaãy coû thì coù moät vò Taêng thuoäc daïng giaûng         me to go back to the Hall for tea?" Kuei-tsung sö uyeân baùc ñeán thaêm. Tình côø luùc ñoù coù con raén         said, "If so, let me ask you, who is the rude- boø ngang. Quy Toâng beøn ñöa löôõi xuoång xuoáng                mannered one, you or I?" Then the monk said, xaén ñöùt con raén laøm ñoâi. Vò Taêng noùi: "Baáy laâu          "What is rude-manner?" Kuei-tsung held up the nghe tieáng Quy Toâng, teù ra chæ laø moät oâng sa moân          spade, assumed the attitude as if to kill the snake, xaáu haïnh maø thoâi." Sö noùi: "Toïa chuû, xin oâng ñi          said, "What is refined?" The monk said, "If so, you vaøo saûnh ñöôøng uoáng traø ñi!" Vò Taêng hoûi: "Sao            are behaving according to the law." Kuei-tsung laïi vaøo saûnh ñöôøng uoáng traø?" Quy Toâng noùi:              demanded, "Enough with my lawful or unlawful "Neáu theá thì toâi hoûi oâng, ai haïnh xaáu, oâng hay           behavior, when did you see my killing the snake, toâi?" Vò Taêng laïi hoûi: "Haïnh xaáu laø haïnh theá naøo?"     anyway?" The monk made no answer. According Quy Toâng giô cao caây xuoång, ra boä nhö gieát raén             to Zen master D.T. Suzuki in Essays in Zen hoûi: "Coøn haïnh toát thì sao?" Vò Taêng ñaùp: "Neáu            Buddhism, First Series (p.286), perhaps this is theá, quaû hôïp chaùnh phaùp." Quy Toâng noùi: "Thoâi ñuû        sufficient to show how freely Zen deals with those roài, ñöøng noùi chaùnh hay khoâng chaùnh vôùi toâi, toïa        abstruse philosophical problems which have been chuû coù thaáy toâi cheùm raén hoài naøo khoâng?" Vò Taêng       taxing all human ingenuity ever since the dawn of khoâng noùi gì. Theo thieàn sö D.T. Suzuki trong                 intelligence. According to Plotinus, mind is that Thieàn Luaän, Taäp I, coù leõ baáy nhieâu ñaây cuõng ñuû         which when it turns back, thinks before it thinks minh ñònh Thieàn töï do töï taïi nhö theá naøo trong khi         itself. We do not find it altogether beyond our giaûi quyeát nhöõng vaán ñeà hoùc buùa aáy, töø thuôû bình       understanding to get at their meaning as far as minh cuûa lòch söû trí oùc, khoâng ngôùt thöû thaùch ñuû         ideas are concerned. But when we come to ngoùn tuyeät kyû cuûa trí khoân loaøi ngöôøi. Theo               statements by the Zen masters, we are entirely at Plotinus, taâm laø caùi khi phaûn tænh thì coù tö töôûng         sea how to take them. Their affirmations are so tröôùc khi noù nghó veà chính noù. Chuùng ta khoâng              irrelevant, so inappropriate, so irrational, and so thaáy ñieàu maø Plotinus vöøa noùi naøy vöôït ra ngoaøi          nosensical, at least superficially that those who taàm hieåu bieát cuûa mình, ít ra treân phöông dieän khaùi       have not gained the truth of Zen way of looking at nieäm. Nhöng khi phaûi ñoái ñaàu vôùi nhöõng caâu noùi           things can hardly make, as we say, head or tail of cuûa caùc vò thieàn sö thì thaät khoâng coøn bieát rôø vaøo      them. ñaâu ñöôïc. Nhöõng lôøi noùi caû quyeát hoaëc khaúng ñònh        Coâng AÙn Sanh Thò Tuøng Haø Xöù? Töû Khöù Ñaùo cuûa caùc ngaøi, ít ra treân hình thöùc, thaät laïc loõng, phi   Haø Xöù?: Sanh töø ñaâu ñeán? Cheát ñi veà ñaâu?— lyù vaø voâ nghóa ñeán noãi ngöôøi chöa bieát chaân lyù          Whence is birth? Whither is death?—Where does Thieàn khoâng coøn bieát ñaàu ñuoâi ra sao nöõa —The             the birth come from? Where does death go?—Ñôøi koan about the potentiality and conditions of                    soáng cuûa chuùng ta chính noù laø moät cuoäc haønh cöôùc. questions and answers between Zen master Kuei-                   "Töø ñaâu?" laø teân cuûa traïm khôûi haønh cuûa chuùng ta

vaø "Veà ñaâu?" laø teân cuûa nôi ñeán. Do ñoù maø Thieàn          "Luùc khoâng toân troïng chö Thaùnh vaø baûn lai dieän sö Ñaïi Hueä ñaõ nhaén nhuû vôùi moät ñeä töû cö só cuûa           muïc cuûa chính mình thì theá naøo?" Höông Nghieâm oâng nhö sau: "'Sanh Thò Tuøng Haø Xöù? Töû Khöù                   ñaùp: "Muoân cô thoâi döùt, ngaøn Thaùnh chaúng mang." Ñaùo Haø Xöù?' Ai bieát ñöôïc caùi 'Töø ñaâu vaø Veà ñaâu'         Sô Sôn khi ñoù coù maët taïi ñoù, beøn laøm boä nhö oeï naøy môùi laø moät Phaät töû chaân chaùnh. Nhöng maø ai            moät tieáng vaø cöôøi lôùn. Höông Nghieâm quay laïi laø ngöôøi bieát ñöôïc sinh vaø töû? Ai laø keû chòu khoå          thænh giaùo, Sô Sôn yeâu caàu Höông Nghieâm phaûi sanh vaø töû? Ai laø keû khoâng bieát sanh töø ñaâu ñeán vaø       laøm leã mình nhö thaày. Höông Nghieâm rôøi choã ngoài töû ñi veà ñaâu? Ai laø ngöôøi boãng nhieân laõnh hoäi ñöôïc       ñeán leã baùi Sôn Sôn. Sô Sôn beøn noùi: "Sao chaúng caùi 'Töø ñaâu vaø Veà ñaâu?' Khi ñieàu naøy chöa ñöôïc            noùi daàu raát toân troïng cuõng chaúng ñöôïc gì?" Vì toäi hieåu moät caùch thoâng suoát thì hai maét laùo lieân, tim         aùc kieán naøy, Höông Nghieâm baùo tröôùc veà sau Sô ñaäp thình thòch, gan caøo ruoät thaét in hình nhö coù             Sôn seõ bò tieâu ngöôïc 30 naêm, laïi coøn bò daàu ôû nuùi moät quaû caàu löûa ñang laên leân laên xuoáng trong               cuõng khoâng coù cuûi ñoát, gaàn nöôùc cuõng khoâng coù mình. Vaø moät laàn nöõa, ai laø ngöôøi chòu ñöïng nhöõng          nöôùc uoáng. Sau ñoù Sô Sôn veà truï taïi nuùi Sô Sôn, haønh haï naøy? Neáu oâng muoán bieát ngöôøi ñoù laø ai,           quaû nhö lôøi ñoaùn cuûa Höông Nghieâm. Ñeán 27 naêm haõy laën xuoáng choã saâu nhaát trong noäi taâm cuûa              thì laønh beänh, Sô Sôn lieàn noùi: "Hai möôi baûy naêm mình, nôi trí naêng khoâng theå ñeán ñöôïc, vaø khi oâng           tröôùc, Sö huynh Höông Nghieâm thoï kyù cho laõo ñaõ bieát roài, oâng seõ bieát raèng coù moät nôi 'sanh vaø töû'   Taêng 30 naêm tieâu ngöôïc, nay coøn thieáu ba naêm." khoâng chaïm ñeán ñöôïc."—Our life itself is a form                Chính vì vaäy maø sau moãi böõa aên, Sô Sôn luoân laáy of travelling or pilgrimage or wandering from                      tay moùc cho möûa ra ñeå öùng vôùi vôùi thoï kyù cuûa place to place. "Whence?" is the name of our                       Höông Nghieâm—The koan about the potentiality starting station and "Whither?" is that of the                     and conditions of questions and answers between arrival. Hence this admonition by Zen master Ta-                   Zen master Su Shan and his Dharma elder brother Hui-Zong-Kao given to one of his lay-disciples as                  Hsiang Yen. According to the Records of the follows: "'Whence is birth? Whither is death?' He                  Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), who knows this 'Whence and Whither' is said to be                  Volume XI, one day, a monk came to as Zen the true Buddhist. But who is the one that knows                   master Hsiang Yen (a dharma-heir of Zen master birth and death? Who is the one that suffers birth                 Kuei-shan), "What would happen when you do not and death? Who is the one that does not know                       respect the saints and your own original face?" whence birth is and whither death is? Who is the                   Hsiang Yen said, "You stop hundred thousand one that suddenly comes to the realization of this                 fundamental qualities; and have nothing to do with 'Whence and Whither?' When this is not                             thousand saints." Su Shan was present at the time, thoroughly understood, the eyes rove, the heart                    so he pretended to be vomitting and then he palpitates, the viscera writhe, as if a fire-ball were             laughed loudly. Hsiang Yen turned around to ask rolling up and down inside the body. And who is                    for advice. Su Shan requested that Hsiang Yen the one, again, that undergoes this torture? If you                respectfully bow him as if he were Hsiang Yen's want to know who this one is, dive down into the                   master. Hsiang Yen left his seat and came to bow depths of your being, where no intellection is                     him respectfully. Su Shan said, "Why do you not possible to reach; and when you know it, you                       say you get nothing even though you pay full know that there is a place where neither birth nor                 respect?" For this kind of sin, Hsiang Yen death can touch."                                                  predicted that Su Shan would have been vomitting Coâng AÙn Sô Sôn Ñaûo A: Sô Sôn bò tieâu ngöôïc                    like this for thirty years. Besides, even though he (baèng mieäng)—Su Shan's Su Shan's have been                       dwells in the mountains or near rivers, he would vomitting for thirty years—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô                   have no wood for cooking and no water for duyeân vaán ñaùp giöõa Thieàn sö Sô Sôn vaø sö huynh               drinking. Later, Su Shan dwelt on Mount Su Shan, cuûa ngaøi laø Thieàn sö Höông Nghieâm Trí Nhaøn.                  and Hsiang Yen's prediction was totally correct. Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån XI, moät                However, after twenty-seven years Su Shan hoâm, coù moät vò Taêng hoûi Thieàn sö Höông Nghieâm               recovered from the illness of vomitting. Su Shan (ñeä töû noái phaùp cuûa Thieàn sö Qui Sôn Linh Höïu):             told his assembly, "Twenty-seven years ago, my

Elder brother Hsiang Yen fortold that this old                support" to examine, but he could not finish. Later monk would have been vomitting like this for                  Shushan heard about a teacher named Mingzhao thirty years; now the prediction is totally correct,          Qian who was teaching in Wuzhou. He had only but three years short." For this reason, to match             one eye. Shushan went straight there and paid his with Hsiang Yen's prediction, after each meal, Su             respects to Mingzhao. Mingzhao said to him, Shan always took out the food with his fingers                "Where have you come from?" Shushan said, until he vomitted.                                            "From Minzhong (Fuzhou)." Mingzhao then asked, Coâng AÙn Sô Sôn Höõu Cuù Voâ Cuù: Sô Sôn Coù caâu            "Did you go see T'a-kuei An there?" Shushan said, khoâng caâu—There are phrases that are not                    "Yes." Mingzhao said, "What did he say?" phrases. They are like a creeping plant that relies           Shushan then told Mingzhao what T'a-kuei An on a tree for support—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô duyeân            said. Mingzhao said, "It may be said that from vaán ñaùp giöõa hai Thieàn sö Minh Chieâu Ñöùc Khieâm         beginning to end, T'a-juei An was correct. But you vaø Sô Sôn Quang Nhaân. Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn               haven't encountered his words." Shushan did not Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån XVII, khi Sô Sôn hoïc Thieàn vôùi          yet understand, and he asked Mingzhao, "If Thieàn sö Ñaïi An ôû Phuùc Chaâu, ngaøi chæ giao cho          suddenly the tree collapses and the creeper Sö moät coâng aùn ñeå tham cöùu, ñoù laø "Höõu cuù voâ cuù    withers, to where do the words return?" Mingzhao nhö caây ngaõ bìm khoâ", nhöng Sö khoâng hoaøn taát           said, "You've made T'a-kuei An laugh again!" ñöôïc. Veà sau naày Sô Sôn nghe noùi veà moät vò thaày        When Shushan heard these words, he experienced teân Minh Chieáu Kieàn (Minh Chieâu Ñöùc Khieâm)              great enlightenment. Shushan then said, "Before ñang daïy Thieàn ôû Ngoâ Chaâu. OÂng ta chæ coù moät          T'a-kuei An's laughter contained a knife." He then maét. Sô Sôn lieàn ñi thaúng ñeán ñoù vaø tham baùi           faced in the direction of T'a-kuei An's monastery Minh Chieáu Kieàn. Minh Chieáu Kieàn noùi vôùi Sô             and bowed in belated gratitude. Sôn: "OÂng töø ñaâu ñeán?" Sô Sôn noùi: "Töø Maân             Coâng AÙn Sô Toå Ñoâng Du: First Patriarch's going Trung Phuû Chaâu ñeán." Minh Chieáu Kieàn beøn hoûi:          to the East—Ngaøy noï, Trieäu Chaâu thöôïng ñöôøng, "OÂng coù ñeán ñoù gaëp Ñaïi Qui An khoâng?" Sô Sôn           baûo chuùng Taêng: "Ñaïo lyù cuûa caùi naøy khoù maø naém noùi: "Coù." Minh Chieáu Kieàn noùi: "Ñaïi Qui An daïy        ñöôïc, vaø ngay caû moät nhaân vaät dò thöôøng khoâng bò nhöõng gì?" Sô Sôn beøn noùi vôùi Minh Chieáu Kieàn           raøng buoäc bôûi nhöõng yù töôûng ñoái ñaõi cuõng thaáy nhöõng gì Ñaïi Qui An ñaõ daïy. Minh Chieáu Kieàn             khoù vöôït nhöõng caûn trôû. Khi ta ôû vôùi Toå Quy Sôn, noùi: "Coù leõ töø ñaàu ñeán cuoái, Ñaïi Qui An ñeàu ñuùng.   coù moät vò Taêng hoûi Toå, 'YÙ Sô Toå ñoâng du laø gì?' Nhöng chæ vieäc oâng khoâng chaïm ñöôïc nhöõng lôøi           Toå baûo, 'Ñöa caùi gheá laïi ñaây.' Khi moät chaân sö maø oâng ta ñaõ noùi aáy thoâi." Sô Sôn chöa laõnh hoäi       xuaát hieän, ngaøi ñaùnh thaúng vaøo moïi ngöôøi baèng chæ yù cuûa Minh Chieáu Kieàn, neân hoûi: "Neáu baát          kieán giaûi sieâu vieät cuûa mình" Moät vò Taêng böôùc tôùi thình lình maø caây ngaõ bìm khoâ thì ngoân töï ñi veà        hoûi: "YÙ Toå töø Taây laø gì?" Sö noùi: "Caây baùch tröôùc ñaâu?" Minh Chieáu Kieàn noùi: "OÂng ñaõ laøm cho Ñaïi        saân." Vò Taêng noùi: "Xin thaày ñöøng chæ vaät baèng Qui An cöôøi nöõa roài!" Khi nghe nhöõng lôøi naøy, Sô        moät söï kieän khaùch quan." Sö noùi: "Khoâng, ta ñaâu Sôn lieàn chöùng nghieäm ñaïi giaùc. Sô Sôn beøn noùi:        coù." Vò Taêng laïi hoûi: "YÙ Toå töø Taây laø gì?" Sö laïi "Caùi cöôøi tröôùc ñaây cuûa Ñaïi Qui An chöùa dao."          ñaùp: "Caây baùch tröôùc saân." Ñieàu naøy cuõng ñöôïc Roài Sô Sôn xoay maët veà höôùng töï vieän cuûa Ñaïi          xem nhö laø moät coâng aùn trao cho ngöôøi sô cô hoïc Qui An leã baùi trong söï bieát ôn muoän maøng—The            Thieàn. Moät caùch tröøu töôïng maø noùi thì coâng aùn koan about the potentiality and conditions of                 naøy, cho duø ñöôïc hieåu theo quan ñieåm thoâng questions and answers between two Zen masters                 thöôøng, cuõng khoâng theå noùi laø hoaøn toaøn khoâng Ming-chao Teâ-ch'ien and Shushan. According to                hôïp lyù, vaø vaãn coøn coù choã cho chuùng ta neáu chuùng the Records of the Transmission of the Lamp                   ta muoán baøn luaän veà noù. Chaúng haïn nhö, coù ngöôøi (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), Volume XVII, when Shushan                   cho raèng "caây baùch" cuûa Trieäu Chaâu laø hieån baøy studied Zen under Zen master Kuei-shan T’a-an                 cuï theå ñaïo cao caû, maø coù leõ trong ñoù chuùng ta nhìn (793-883), the master gave him just one koan of               ra ñöôïc khuynh höôùng phieám thaàn luaän cuûa Phaät "There are phrases that are not phrases. They are             giaùo. Nhöng duøng tri kieán ñeå hieåu coâng aùn nhö theá like a creeping plant that relies on a tree for               aáy thì chaúng phaûi laø Thieàn, vaø caùi goïi laø heä thoáng

kyù hieäu sieâu hình hoïc cuõng khoâng coù maët ôû ñaây.        courtyard." The monk said, "Don't try to Theo Thieàn sö D.T. Suzuki trong quyeån "Thieàn                 demonstrate the matter by means of an objective Hoïc Nhaäp Moân", döôùi baát cöù tình huoáng naøo Thieàn        fact." Chao-chou said, "No, I do not." The monk cuõng khoâng ñöôïc laãn loän vôùi trieát hoïc; Thieàn coù lyù   persisted, "What is our Patriarch's idea of coming do rieâng cuûa noù ñeå töï thaønh hình phong caùch rieâng,      from the West?" Chao-chou said again, "The chuùng ta khoâng theå boû qua söï thaät naøy, neáu khoâng       cypress-tree in the courtyard." This is also khoâng thì toaøn boä caáu truùc cuûa Thieàn seõ rôi xuoáng      considered as a koan given to a Zen beginner. thaønh töøng maûnh vuïn. Caây baùch maõi maõi laø caây          Abstractly speaking, this koan cannot be said to be baùch, khoâng lieân quan gì ñeán phieám thaàn luaän hay         nonsensical even from a common-sense point of baát cöù chuû nghóa naøo. Daàu theo yù nghóa ñaïi chuùng        view, and if we want to reason about it, there is hay yù nghóa phoå bieán nhaát ñi nöõa thì Trieäu Chaâu          perhaps room enough to do so. For instance, some khoâng phaûi laø moät nhaø trieát hoïc, maø laø moät Thieàn     may regard Chao-chou's cypress-tree as a sö ñuùng nghóa, vaø ngoân ngöõ cuûa Trieäu Chaâu noùi ra        concrete manifestation of the highest principle, töø ñoâi moâi cuûa oâng ta ñeàu laø kinh nghieäm noäi           through which the pantheistic tendency of chöùng tröïc tieáp töø baûn thaân cuûa ngaøi. Vì vaäy, ngoaøi   Buddhism may be recognized. But to understand thöù raát gioáng vôùi "chuû nghóa chuû theå" naøy, daàu         the koan thus intellectually is not Zen, nor is such raèng Thieàn khoâng theo nhò nguyeân ñoái laäp chuû theå        metaphysical symbolism at all present here. vaø khaùch theå, tö töôûng vaø theá giôùi, thì caây baùch       According to Zen master D.T. Suzuki in "An hoaøn toaøn maát ñi yù nghóa cuûa noù. Neáu coâng aùn laø       Introduction To Zen Buddhism," under no moät lôøi trình baøy tính bieát hay khaùi nieäm, coù leõ        circumstances ought Zen to be confounded with chuùng ta seõ coá hieåu yù nghóa cuûa noù qua moät trình        philosohy; Zen has its own reason for standing for töï suy luaän, vaø coù leõ cuoái cuøng chuùng ta seõ töôûng     itself, and this fact must never be lost sight of; raèng mình ñaõ giaûi quyeát ñöôïc vaán ñeà khoù khaên;          otherwise, the entire structure of Zen falls to nhöng caùc Thieàn sö khaúng quyeát vôùi caùc baïn raèng         pieces. The "cypress-tree" is forever a cypress- daàu laø nhö vaäy ñi nöõa, Thieàn vaãn coøn caùch baïn          tree and has nothing to do with pantheism or any nhöõng ba ngaøn daëm, vaø tinh thaàn cuûa Trieäu Chaâu ôû       other "ism". Chao-chou was not a philosopher sau böùc reøm ñang cheá gieãu baïn, maø roát roài baïn          even in its broadest and most popular sense; he cuõng khoâng veùn leân ñöôïc. Coâng aùn laø thöù phaûi          was a Zen master through and through, and all that ñöôïc nuoâi döôõng ôû nôi saâu thaúm nhaát cuûa taâm hoàn       comes forth from his lips is an utterance directly nôi maø lyù luaän phaân tích khoâng theå ñeán ñöôïc. Khi        ensuing from his spiritual experience. Therefore, taâm thaønh thuïc ñeán ñoä noù coù cuøng moät nhòp ñieäu        apart from this much of "subjectivism", though vôùi caûnh giôùi cuûa Trieäu Chaâu thì yù nghóa "caây           really there are no such dualities in Zen as subject baùch" seõ töï noù hieån baøy, vaø khoâng caàn phaûi gaïn       and object, thought and the world, the "cypress- hoûi gì theâm nöõa baïn seõ töï thuyeát phuïc laáy mình         tree" utterly loses its significance. If it is an raèng trong loøng baïn ñaõ hieåu roõ taát caû —One day,         intellectual or conceptual statement, we may Zen master Chao-Chou entered the hall and said                  endeavor to understand its meaning through the to the monks, "The truth of this matter is difficult            ratiocinative chain of ideas as contained in it, and to grasp; and even an extraordinary personality                 we may come to imagine that we have finally who is free from the ideas of relativity finds it               solved the difficulty; but Zen masters will assure hard to transcend the entanglements. When I was                 you that even then Zen is yet three thousand miles with Kuei-shan, a monk asked him, 'What is our                  away from you, and the spirit of Chao-chou will Patriarch's idea of coming from the West?' The                  be heard laughing at you from behind the screen, master said, 'Pass me the chair over there.' When               which after all you had failed to remove. The a real master comes, he deals with people straight              koan is intended to be nourished in those recesses from his transcendental understanding." At that                 of the mind where no logical analysis can ever time a monk came forward and asked Chao-chou,                   reach. When the mind matures so that it becomes "What is our Patriarch's idea of coming from the                attuned to a similar frame to that of Chao-chou, West?" Chao-chou said, "The cypress-tree in the                 the meaning of the "cypress-tree" will reveal

itself; and without further questioning you will be           "You beast! Now where do you go?" The monk convinced that you now know it all—See Trieäu                 failed to answer. In this case, the monk Chaâu Toøng Thaåm Thieàn Sö.                                  presumptuously called himself "the lion cub", but Coâng AÙn Suøng Thoï Ñaéng Töû: Chong-shou's                  when Te-shan gave him a test by treating him like Chair—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô duyeân vaán ñaùp giöõa hai        a real lion cub when he rode on the monk's neck, Thieàn sö Vaên Ích Phaùp Nhaõn vaø Vaân Moân Vaên             and then asked him a question; the monk failed to Yeån. Theo Nguõ Ñaêng Hoäi Nguyeân, quyeån X, khi             answer. This proved that the monk lacked the Phaùp Nhaõn ñang truï trì chuøa Suøng Thoï, moät hoâm,        genuine understanding he claimed to possess. Sö chæ caùi gheá vaø noùi: “Bieát ñöôïc caùi gheá, chung      Coâng AÙn Tam Thaùnh Thaáu Cöông Kim Ngö: quanh coù thöøa.” Vaân Moân noùi: “Bieát ñöôïc caùi gheá,     San Sheng's Golden Fish Who Has Passed through khaùc nhau nhö trôøi vôùi ñaát.” Lieàn xuoáng toøa—The        the Net—Tam Thaùnh Caù Vaøng Phuûng Löôùi— koan about the potentiality and conditions of                 Trong thí duï thöù 49 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc, Tam questions and answers between two Zen masters                 Thaùnh hoûi Tuyeát Phong: "Caù vaøng voït phuûng löôùi, Fa-yen-Weân-i (885-958) and Yun-men Weân-yen                  chöa bieát laáy gì laøm thöùc aên?" Tuyeát Phong ñaùp: (864-949). According to Wudeng Huiyuan, volume                "Ñôïi oâng ra khoûi löôùi ñeán, vì oâng noùi." Tam Thaùnh X, when Fa-yen-Weân-i (885-958) was the abbot of              noùi: "Laø thieän tri thöùc cuûa moät ngaøn naêm traêm Chong-shou Monastery, one day, he pointed at a                ngöôøi maø thoaïi ñaàu cuõng chaúng bieát." Tuyeát chair and said: “You know this is a chair,                    Phong noùi: "Laõo Taêng truï trì nhieàu vieäc." Theo everything else is superfluous.” Yun Men sai,                 Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc, Tuyeát Phong, “You know this is a chair, it is different as heaven          Tam Thaùnh tuy nhieân moät ra moät vaøo, moät xoâ moät and earth.”                                                   ñaåy, chöa phaân thaéng baïi. Haõy noùi hai vò toân tuùc Coâng AÙn Sö Töû Nhi: Lion cub—Thuaät ngöõ "Sö töû            naøy ñuû con maét gì? Tam Thaùnh töø Laâm Teá nhaän con" ñöôïc caùc Thieàn sö duøng ñeå chæ moät ñeä töû ñuû      aán kyù traûi khaép caùc nôi, ñeàu ñöôïc caùc nôi ñaõi vaøo khaû naêng laõnh hoäi Chaân lyù Thieàn; khi nhöõng Thieàn     haøng cao khaùch. Xem Sö ñaët caâu hoûi bao nhieâu sö khen ngôïi hay thöû thaùch cô trí cuûa moät ñeä töû, hoï   ngöôøi doø tìm chaúng ñöôïc. Vaû laïi chaúng dính lyù thöôøng duøng töø "sö töû nhi". Theo Ñöùc Sôn Ngöõ            taùnh Phaät phaùp. Hoûi con caù vaøng voït phuûng löôùi, Luïc, moät hoâm, coù moät vò Taêng ñeán tham baùi Ñöùc        chöa bieát laáy gì laøm thöùc aên? Thöû noùi yù Sö theá Sôn. Ñöùc Sôn ñoùng chaët cöûa. Vò Taêng goõ cöûa, Ñöùc       naøo? Caù vaøng voït phuûng löôùi bình thöôøng ñaõ Sôn hoûi: "Ai ñoù?" Vò Taêng noùi: "Sö töû nhi". Ñöùc         chaúng aên moài thôm cuûa ngöôøi, chaúng bieát laáy gì Sôn beøn môû cöûa vaø nhaåy leân coå vò Taêng vöøa cöôõi      laøm thöùc aên? Tuyeát Phong laø haøng taùc gia döôøng vöøa heùt: "Suùc sinh! Baây giôø maày ñi ñaâu?" Vò Taêng      nhö nhaøn roãi, chæ laáy moät hai phaàn ñaùp kia, laïi vì khoâng ñaùp ñöôïc. Trong coâng aùn naøy, vò Taêng töï         kia noùi "Ñôïi oâng ra khoûi löôùi ñeán, vì oâng noùi". xöng laø "Sö töû nhi" moät caùch töï ñaéc, nhöng khi          Phaàn Döông goïi laø hoûi "trình giaûi", toâng Taøo Ñoäng Ñöùc Sôn thöû thaùch oâng baèng caùch ñoái xöû vôùi oâng      goïi laø hoûi "möôïn vieäc". Phaûi laø vöôït quaàn thoaùt nhö moät "sö töû con" thaät khi Sö cöôõi coå oâng vaø hoûi    loaïi ñöôïc ñaïi thoï duïng, treân ñaûnh coù con maét, môùi oâng moät caâu hoûi, thì vò Taêng khoâng traû lôøi ñöôïc.     goïi laø caù vaøng voït phuûng löôùi. Naøo ngôø Tuyeát Ñieàu naøy chöùng toû vò Taêng thieáu caùi tri thöùc chaân    Phong laø haøng taùc gia chaúng ngaïi laøm giaûm uy thaät maø oâng khoe laø oâng coù —The term "lion cub"         danh cuûa ngöôøi, neân noùi ñôïi oâng ra khoûi löôùi ñeán, is used by Zen Buddhists to denote a disciple well            vì oâng noùi. Xem hai vò naém vöõng phong cöông, able to understand Zen Truth; when the Masters                vaùch ñöùng muoân tröôïng. Neáu chaúng phaûi Tam praise or prove a disciple's understanding, this              Thaùnh moät caâu naøy lieàn ñi chaúng ñöôïc. Nhöng term is often used. According to the Records of               Tam Thaùnh cuõng laø haøng taùc gia môùi bieát noùi vôùi lectures of Zen Master Te-Shan-Hsuan-Chien, one               kia, laø thieän tri thöùc cuûa moät ngaøn naêm traêm ngöôøi day, a monk went to Te-shan, who closed the door              maø thoaïi ñaàu cuõng chaúng bieát. Tuyeát Phong noùi: in his face. The monk knocked and Te-shan asked,              "Laõo Taêng truï trì nhieàu vieäc." Caâu naøy thöïc cöùng "Who is it?" The monk said, "The lion cub." Te-               raén cao ngaïo. Hai vò taùc gia gaëp nhau, moät baét moät shan then opened the door and jumped on to the                thaû, gaëp maïnh lieàn yeáu, gaëp tieän lieàn quí. Neáu oâng neck of the monk as though riding, and cried,                 khôûi hieåu hôn thua thì chöa moäng thaáy Tuyeát

Phong. Xem hai vò luùc ñaàu nguy hieåm cao voùt, roát          the golden fish who has passed through the net use sau hai ngöôøi ñeàu laø keû cheát. Haõy noùi coù ñöôïc coù     for food?" Hsueh Feng said, "When you come out maát, hôn thua chaêng? Nhöõng vò taùc gia khaùc ñoái           of the net I'll tell you." San Sheng said, "The ñaùp aét chaúng nhö theá. Tam Thaùnh ôû choã Laâm Teá          teacher of fifteen hundred people and you con't laøm Vieän chuû, Laâm Teá saép tòch daïy: "Sau khi ta ñi,      even know what to say!" Hsueh Feng said, "My chaúng ñöôïc dieät chaùnh phaùp nhaõn taïng cuûa ta."          affairs as abbot are many and complicated." Tam Thaùnh ra thöa: "Ñaâu daùm dieät chaùnh phaùp              According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, with nhaõn taïng cuûa Hoøa Thöôïng." Laâm Teá hoûi: "Veà sau        Hsueh Feng and San Sheng, though there is one coù ngöôøi hoûi oâng laøm sao?" Tam Thaùnh lieàn heùt.         exit and one entry, one thrust and one parry, there Laâm Teá noùi: "Ai bieát chaùnh phaùp nhaõn taïng cuûa ta      is no division into victory and defeat. But say, ñeán beân con löøa muø naøy dieät roài." Tam Thaùnh lieàn      what is the eye that these two venerable adepts leã baùi. Sö laø chôn töû cuûa Laâm Teá môùi daùm ñoái ñaùp    possesse? San Sheng received the secret from Lin nhö theá. Thieàn sö Tuyeát Ñaäu tuïng baøi keä:                Chi. He travelled all over and everyone treated "Thaáu cöông kim laân                               him as an eminent guest. Look at him posing a Höu vaán ñôùi thuûy                               question. How many people look but cannot find Dieâu caøng ñaûng khoân                           him! He doesn't touch on inherent nature or the Chaán lieäp baõi vó.                              Buddha Dharma: instead he asked, "What does Thieân xích kình phuùn hoàng laõng phi            the golden fish who has passed through the net use Nhaát thinh loâi chaán thanh tieân khæ            for food?" But say, what was his meaning? Since Thanh tieân khæ                                   the golden fish who has passed through the net Thieân thöôïng nhôn gian tri kyû kyû."            ordinarily does not eat the tasty food of others, (Thuûng löôùi caù vaøng. Thoâi baûo dính nöôùc. Rung           what does he use for food? Hsueh Feng is an caøn ñoäng khoân. Mang chaán ñuoâi quaït. Ngaøn thöôùc         adept: in a casual fashion he replies to San Sheng caù kình phun soùng to. Moät tieáng saám vang gioù             with only ten or twenty percent. He just said to maïnh noåi. Gioù maïnh noåi. Treân trôøi nhôn gian maáy        him, "When you come out of the net, I'll tell you." ngöôøi bieát). Hai caâu "Thuûng löôùi caù vaøng, thoâi baûo    Fen Yang would call this "a question that displays dính nöôùc", Nguõ Toå tieân sö noùi chæ trong moät caâu        one's understanding." In the Ts'ao Tung tradition it naøy tuïng xong vaäy. Ñaõ laø caù vaøng voït thuûng löôùi      would be called "a question that uses things." You haù keït trong nöôùc, aét ôû choã nöôùc noåi meânh moâng       must be beyond categories and classifications, you soùng daäy ngaäp trôøi. Haõy noùi trong moät ngaøy hai         must have obtained the use of the great function, möôi boán giôø laáy caùi gì laøm thöùc aên? Caùc oâng haõy     you must have an eye on your forehead; only then nhaèm döôùi ba caây ñoøn tay, tröôùc caùi ñôn baûy taác,       can you be called a golden fish who has passed thöû ñònh ñuùng xem? Tuyeát Ñaäu noùi vieäc naøy tuøy          through the net. Nevertheless, Hsueh Feng is an phaàn nieâm loäng, nhö loaïi caùc vaøng khi "Mang              adept and can't help but diminish the other man's chaán ñuoâi quaït" thì "Rung caøn ñoäng khoân". Caâu           reputation by saying "When you come out of the "Ngaøn thöôùc caù kình phun soùng to" laø tuïng Tam            net I'll tell you." Observe how the two of them Thaùnh noùi "Laø thieän tri thöùc cuûa moät ngaøn naêm         held fast to their territories, towering up like ten traêm ngöôøi maø thoaïi ñaàu cuõng chaúng bieát", nhö caù      thousand fathom walls. With this one sentence of kình phun soùng to. Caâu "Moät tieáng saám vang gioù           Hsueh Feng's anyone other than San Sheng would maïnh noåi" laø tuïng, Tuyeát Phong noùi "Laõo Taêng truï      have been unable to go on. Yet San Sheng too trì nhieàu vieäc", gioáng nhö moät tieáng saám gioù maïnh      was an adept: thus he knew how to say to him, noåi daäy. Ñaïi cöông tuïng hai vò ñeàu laø haøng taùc gia.    "The teacher of fifteen hundred people and you Hai caâu "Gioù maïnh noåi. Treân trôøi nhôn gian maáy          don't even know what to say!" But Hsueh Feng ngöôøi bieát", haønh giaû tu Thieàn haõy thöû noùi hai caâu    said, "My affairs as abbot are many and tuïng naøy rôi taïi choã naøo? Chöõ tieân laø gioù, khi gioù   complicated." How obstinate this statement is! maïnh thì treân trôøi nhôn gian coù maáy ngöôøi hay            When these adepts met, there was one capture bieát?—In example 49 of the Pi-Yen-Lu, San                     and one release; each acted weak when Sheng asked Hsueh Feng, "I wonder, what does                   encountering strength and acted noble when

encountering meanness. If you form your               does in fact shake heaven and earth. "When a understanding in terms of victory and defeat, you     thousand-foot whale sprouts, vast waves fly." This haven't seen Hsueh Feng even in dreams. Look at       versifies San Sheng saying, "The teacher of these two men: initially both were solitary and       fifteen hundred people and you don't even know dangerous, lofty and steep; in the end both were      what to say!" He was like a whale sprouting out dead and decrepit. But say, was there still gain      giant waves. "At a single thunderclap, the pure and loss, victory and defeat? When these adepts       wind gusts." This versifies Hsueh Feng saying, harmonized with each other, it was necessarily not    "My affairs as abbot are many and complicated." this way. San Sheng was the Temple Keeper at          He was like the pure wind gusting when a Lin Chi. When Lin Chi was about to pass on he         thunderclap sounds. The overall meaning is to directed, "After I'm gone you mustn't destroy the     praise the two of them for both being adepts. " treasure of the eye of my correct teaching." San      The pure wind gusts - Among gods and humans, Sheng came forward and said, "How could we            how many know? How many?" But Zen dare destroy the treasure of the eye of your          practitioners let say, what do these lines come correct teaching, Master?" Lin Chi said, "In the      down to? When the pure wind arises, among gods future, how will you act when people ask              and humans how many can there be who will questions?" San Sheng then shouted. Lin Chi said,     know? "Who would have known that the treasure of the        Coâng AÙn Tam Toøa Thuyeát Phaùp: Toøa thöù ba noùi eye of my correct teaching would perish in this       phaùp, thí duï thöù 25 cuûa Voâ Moân Quan—Yang- blind donkey?" San Sheng then bowed in homage.        shan's Sermon from the Third Seat, example 25 of Since he was a true son of Lin Chi's, he dared to     the Wu-Men-Kuan—Hoøa Thöôïng Ngöôõng Sôn respond like this. Afterwards Hsueh Tou just          naèm mô thaáy ñeán choã Phaät Di Laëc, ngoài toøa thöù versifies the golden fish who has passed through      ba. Coù moät toân giaû baïch chuøy thöa: "Hoâm nay ñeán the net, revealing where these adepts saw each        phieân toøa thöù ba thuyeát phaùp." Ngöôõng Sôn beøn other. The verse says:                                ñöùng daäy baïch chuøy noùi: "Phaùp Ma ha dieãn (ñaïi "The golden fish who has passed through the net     thöøa) rôøi boán caâu lyù luaän döùt heát saïch traêm caùch Stop saying he tarries in the water.               phuû nhaän (töù cuù baùch phi). Nghe cho kyõ, nghe cho He shakes the heavens and sweeps the earth,        kyõ." Theo Voâ Moân Hueä Khai trong Voâ Moân Quan, He flourishes his mane and wags his tail.          thöû hoûi ñoù laø noùi phaùp hay khoâng noùi phaùp? Môû When a thousand-foot whale sprouts,                mieäng laø sai, ngaäm mieäng laø maát. Khoâng môû vast waves fly,                                   khoâng ngaäm, möôøi vaïn taùm ngaøn—Yang-shan At a single thunderclap, the pure wind gusts.      dreamed he went to Maitreya's realm and was led The pure wind gusts                                to the third seat. A senior monk struck the stand Among gods and humans,                             with a gavel and announced, "Today, the one in how many know? How many?"                          the third seat will preach." Yang-shan arose, "The golden fish who has passed through the net -     struck the stand with the gavel, and said, "The Stop saying he tarries in the water." Wu Tsu said     truth of the Mahayana is beyond the Four that just this one couplet completes the verse.       Propositions and transcends the Hundred Since it's the golden fish who has passed through     Negations. Listen, listen." According to Wu Men the net, how could he linger tarrying in the water?   Hui-Kai in the Wu-Men-Kuan, tell me, did he He must be where the vast swelling floods of          preach or not? If you open your mouth, you are white foamy waves tower up to the skies. But say,     lost. If you cannot speak, then it seems you are during the twenty-four hours of the day, what does    stumped. If you neither open your mouth nor keep he use for food? All of you go back to your places    it closed, you are one hundred and eigth thousand and try to see for sure. Hsueh Tou said, "This        miles off. matter is picked up and played with according to      Coâng AÙn Taïng Ñaàu Baïch Haûi Ñaàu Haéc: Ñaàu one's capacity." When something like the golden       Taïng traéng, Ñaàu Haûi ñen—MaTzu: "Tsang's head fish "flourishes his mane and wags his tail," he      is white, Hai's head is black"—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô

duyeân vaán ñaùp cuûa Thieàn sö Maõ Toå Ñaïo Nhaát vaø       Coâng AÙn Taøo Sôn Hieáu Maõn: Taøo Sôn maõn hai vò ñeä töû noái phaùp laø Taây Ñöôøng Trí Taïng vaø      tang—Ts'ao Shan: End of mourning—Coâng aùn Baùch Tröôïng Hoaøi Haûi vôùi moät vò Taêng. Theo            noùi veà cô duyeân vaán ñaùp cuûa Thieàn sö Taøo Sôn Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån VI, moät hoâm,         Boån Tòch vôùi moät vò Taêng. Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn coù moät vò Taêng hoûi Thieàn sö Maõ Toå Ñaïo Nhaát:         Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån XVII, moät hoâm, coù moät vò Taêng "Lìa töù cuù baët baùch phi, xin Ñaïi sö chæ thaúng cho      ñeán hoûi Thieàn sö Taøo Sôn Boån Tòch: "Luùc khoâng con bieát veà yù chæ cuûa Toå Sö töø Taây Truùc ñeán!" Maõ   maëc linh y (tang phuïc) thì nhö theá naøo?" Taøo Sôn Toå ñaùp: "Hoâm nay ta moûi meät, khoâng noùi cho oâng       ñaùp: "Hoâm nay Taøo Sôn hieáu maõn (maõn tang)." Vò bieát ñöôïc, haõy ñeán hoûi Trí Taïng." Vò Taêng ñeán hoûi   Taêng laïi hoûi: "Sau khi maõn tang thì nhö theá naøo?" Trí Taïng cuøng caâu hoûi, Trí Taïng noùi: "Sao khoâng       Taøo Sôn ñaùp: "Taøo Sôn thích say röôïu." Moät hoâm hoûi Hoøa Thöôïng?" Vò Taêng thöa: "Hoøa Thöôïng             khaùc, coù moät vò Taêng hoûi: "Ngöôøi khoâng laøm baïn daïy con ñeán hoûi Thaày." Trí Taïng noùi hoâm nay laõo      vôùi phaùp laø ngöôøi gì?" Taøo Sôn noùi: "Noùi cho laõo Taêng bò nhöùc ñaàu khoâng noùi cho oâng bieát ñöôïc,        Taêng bieát choã naøo maø nhieàu ngöôøi ôû Hoàng Chaâu oâng haõy ñeán hoûi Sö huynh Hoaøi Haûi. Vò Taêng ñeán       ñeàu ñi ñeán."—The koan about the potentiality and hoûi Hoaøi Haûi, Hoaøi Haûi noùi: "Ñeán choã aáy toâi laïi   conditions of questions and answers between Zen khoâng hieåu." Vò Taêng thöa vieäc naøy leân Maõ Ñaïi        master Ts'ao Shan Pen-Chi and a monk. According Sö, Ñaïi Sö noùi: "Taïng ñaàu baïch, Haûi ñaàu haéc."        to the Records of the Transmission of the Lamp Baïch vaø haéc chæ cho baïch maïo vaø haéc maïo, voán laø    (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), Volume XVII, one day, a ñieån tích xöa. Theo truyeàn thuyeát, coù hai teân aên       monk came and asked Zen master Ts'ao Shan troäm, moät teân ñoäi muõ traéng, moät teân ñoäi muõ ñen;    Pen-Chi, "What happens when the Master is not teân troäm muõ ñen baøy ra quyû keá cöôùp maát vaät maø      wearing the mourning apparel (clothes)?" Ts'ao teân troäm muõ traéng ñaõ ñoaït ñöôïc—The koan about         Shan said, "Today is Ts'ao Shan's end of the potentiality and conditions of questions and             mourning." The monk asked, "What happens after answers of Zen master Ma-Tzu Tao-I and his two               the end of mourning?" Ts'ao Shan said, "Ts'ao dharma-heirs Hsi-t'ang Chih-tsang (735-814) and              Shan likes to get drunk." Another day, a monk Pai-chang-Huai-hai (720-814/or 818?) and a monk.             asked, "Who is it that is not a companion to the According to the Records of the Transmission of              myriad dharmas?" Ts'ao-shan said, "Tell me, the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), Volume VI, one day,               where is it that many people in Hongzhou are a monk asked Grand Master Ma, "Please, teacher,              going?" going beyond the permutations of assertion and               Coâng AÙn Taøo Sôn Mi Muïc Baát Thöùc: Ts'ao- denial, directly point out to me the meaning of the          shan: Can the eyebrows and the eyes distinguish coming from the West." Master Ma said, "I'm tired            each other or not?—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô duyeân vaán today and can't explain for you. Go ask Chih                 ñaùp giöõa Thieàn sö Taøo Sôn Baûn Tòch vaø moät vò Tsang." When the monk asked Chih Tsang, Tsang                Taêng. Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån said, "Why didn't you ask the Teacher?" The monk             XVII, moät hoâm, moät vò Taêng hoûi Taøo Sôn: "Chaân said, "The Teacher had me come here to ask you."             maøy vôùi maét cuøng bieát nhau chaêng?" Sö ñaùp: Tsang said, "I have a headache today and can't               "Chaúng bieát nhau." Vò Taêng hoûi: "Sao laïi chaúng explain for you. Go ask Elder Brother Hai." When             bieát nhau?" Sö ñaùp: "Vì ñoàng taïi moät choã." Vò the monk asked Elder Brother Hai (Pai Chang),                Taêng laïi hoûi: "Theá aáy laø chaúng theå phaân bieät sao?" Hai said, "At this point, after all, I don't                 Sö ñaùp: "Cuoái cuøng thì chaân maøy chaúng phaûi laø understand." When the monk related this to Grand             maét, maét chaúng phaûi laø chaân maøy." Vò Taêng hoûi: Master Ma, Master Ma said, "Tsang's head is                  "Theá naøo laø maét?" Sö ñaùp: "Maét quaû nhieân ñuùng laø white, Hai's head is black." White and Black imply           maét." Vò Taêng hoûi: "Theá naøo laø chaân maøy?" Sö the white hat and black hat in old legends.                  ñaùp: "Ta khoâng chaéc." Vò Taêng hoûi: "Taïi sao Hoøa According to the legends, there were two robbers,            Thöôïng laïi khoâng chaéc?" Sö ñaùp: "Neáu mình one with the white hat and the other with the back           khoâng nghi töùc quaû nhieân ñuùng." Vò Taêng laïi hoûi: hat; the black-hat robber plotted wicked plot to             "Coù chaân lyù naøo trong hình töôùng?" Sö ñaùp: "Hình snatch whatever the white-hat has earned.                    töôùng laø chaân lyù." Vò Taêng noùi: "Laøm sao Hoøa

Thöôïng coù theå bieåu toû vieäc naøy?" Sö caàm laáy caùi   Coâng AÙn Theá Toân Ñaêng Toøa: The World dóa ñeå taùch. Vò Taêng laïi hoûi: "Laøm theá naøo huyeãn   Honored One Ascends the Throne, example 92 of (aûo töôûng) coù theå laø chôn (chaân lyù)?" Sö ñaùp:       the Pi-Yen-Lu—Thí duï thöù 92 cuûa Bích Nham "Huyeãn voán nguyeân chôn (aûo töôûng treân caên baûn       Luïc. Moät hoâm Theá Toân ñaêng toøa, Vaên Thuø baïch laø chaân lyù)." Vò Taêng noùi: "Khi ñoái dieän vôùi aûo    chuøy raèng: "Quaùn kyõ ñaáng Phaùp Vöông, phaùp cuûa töôûng, caùi gì hieån baøy?" Sö ñaùp: "Töùc huyeãn lieàn    ñaáng Phaùp Vöông nhö theá." Theá Toân lieàn xuoáng hieän (thì aûo töôûng lieàn hieän ra)." Vò Taêng thöa:      toøa. Theo Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc, tröôùc "Trong tröôøng hôïp ñoù, töø ñaàu ñeán cuoái, tröôùc sau    khi Theá Toân ñöa caønh hoa, sôùm ñaõ coù tin töùc naày. chaúng lìa huyeãn (khoâng ai coù theå thoaùt khoûi          Buoåi ñaàu töø vöôøn Loäc Uyeån, sau cuøng ñeán soâng huyeãn)." Sö noùi: "Nhöng neáu oâng chaïy theo huyeãn       Baït Ñeà, ñaâu töøng duøng ñeán caây baûo kieám Kim töôùng, oâng khoâng theå naøo ñaït ñöôïc chuùng."—The       Cang Vöông. Trong chuùng khi ñoù, neáu coù ngöôøi coù koan about the potentiality and conditions of               hôi haùm thieàn Taêng nhaän ra ñöôïc, môùi khoûi sau questions and answers between Zen master Ts'ao-             naày Ngaøi ñöa caønh hoa khieán moät tröôøng boái roái. shan and a monk. According to the Records of the            Theá Toân trong khoaûng im laëng bò Vaên Thuø ñaåy Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu),                  moät caùi, lieàn xuoáng toøa. Khi aáy cuõng coù tin töùc Volume XVII, one day, a monk asked Ts'ao-shan,              naày. Ñöùc Thích Ca ñoùng cöûa thaát, ngaøi Tònh Danh "Can the eyebrows and the eyes distinguish each             ngaäm mieäng, ñeàu gioáng caùi naày ñaõ noùi xong vaäy. other or not?" Ts'ao-shan said, "They can't                 Nhö caâu vua Tuùc Toâng hoûi Quoác Sö Hueä Trung veà distinguish each other." The monk said, "Why                thaùp Voâ Phuøng. Nhö lôøi ngoaïi ñaïo hoûi Phaät, chaúng not?" Ts'ao-shan said, "Because they're in the              hoûi moät lôøi, chaúng hoûi khoâng lôøi. Xem haønh lyù cuûa same place." The monk said, "If that's so, one              ngöôøi höôùng thöôïng ñaâu töøng vaøo hang quyû laøm couldn't tell them apart." Ts'ao-shan said,                 keá soáng. Coù ngöôøi noùi yù ôû choã laøm thinh. Coù ngöôøi "Eyebrows, after all, are not eyes." The monk               noùi yù ôû choã im laëng giaây laâu, Duøng coù lôøi ñeå roõ asked, "What are eyes?" Ts'ao-shan said, "Eyes              vieäc khoâng lôøi, khoâng lôøi ñeå roõ vieäc coù lôøi. Vónh are what is upright." The monk asked, "What are             Gia noùi: "Khi im laëng noùi, khi noùi im laëng." Thaûy the eyebrows?" Ts'ao-shan said, "I'm not sure."             hieåu theá aáy thì ba ñôøi saùu möôi kieáp cuõng chöa The monk said, "Why is the master not sure?"                moäng thaáy. Neáu oâng thaúng ñoù thöøa ñöông ñöôïc, Ts'ao-shan said, "If one lacks doubt, one is                chaúng thaáy coù phaøm coù thaùnh, phaùp aáy bình ñaúng upright." The monk asked, "What truth is there in           khoâng coù cao thaáp, moãi ngaøy cuøng chö Phaät ba ñôøi form?" Ts'ao-shan said, "Form is truth." The monk           naém tay ñoàng ñi—One day the World Honored asked, "How would you demonstrate this?" Ts'ao-             One ascended his seat. Manjusri struck the gacel shan picked up his tea cup saucer. The monk                 and said, "Clearly behold the Dharma of the King asked, "How can illusion be truth?" Ts'ao-shan              of Dharma; the Dharma of the King of Dharma is said, "Illusion is fundamentally truth." The monk           thus." The World Honored One then got down off asked, "When illusion is faced, what is revealed?"          the seat. According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, Ts'ao-shan said, "Illusion is revealed." The monk           before the World Honored One had raised the said, "In that case, then from start to finish one          flower, already there was this scene. From the can't escape illusion." Ts'ao-shan said, "But if you        beginning at the Deer Park to the end at the pursue illusive forms you can't attain them."               Hiranyavati River, how many times did he use the Coâng AÙn Taëc Khöù Haäu Tröông Cung: To open               jewel sword of the Diamond King? At that time, if fire after the enemy already left—See Taëc Khöù             among the crowd there had been someone with Haäu Tröông Cung.                                           the spirit of a pathrobed monk who could Coâng AÙn Taây Lai YÙ: The coming of Bodhidharma            transcend, he would have been able to avoid the from India to China—See Taây Lai YÙ.                        final messy scene of raising the flower. While the Coâng AÙn Thaïch Ñaàu Loä Hoaït: The way of Shih-           World Honored One paused, he was confronted by tou is very slippery!—See Thaïch Ñaàu Loä Hoaït.            Majusri, and immediately got down from his seat. Coâng AÙn Thanh Nöõ Ly Hoàn: Wu-tsu: "Which Is              At that time, there was still this scene; Sakyamuni the True Ch'ing?"—See Thanh Nöõ Ly Hoàn.                    barred his door, Vimalakirti shut his mouth, both

resemble this, and thus have already explained it.           sao truyeàn? Laïi giaû nhö Ca Dieáp khoâng cöôøi thì It is like the story of Su Tsung asking National             chính phaùp nhaõn taïng laøm sao truyeàn ñöôïc? Neáu Teacher Chung about making an aimless                        noùi nhaõn taïng chính phaùp coù truyeàn thuï, thì hoùa ra memorial tower, and also like the story of the               Theá Toân ñaõ gaït chuùng hay sao? Coøn neáu baûo outsider asking Buddha, "I do not ask about the              khoâng truyeàn thuï, thì sao laïi chæ truyeàn cho Ca spoken or the unspoken." Observe the behavior of             Dieáp? Daàu sao ñi nöõa, keå töø ñoù caùc ñeä töû Phaät goïi those transcendent people; when did they ever                oâng Ca Dieáp baèng Ñaïi Ca Dieáp, vaø oâng trôû thaønh enter a ghost cave for their subsistence? Some say           vò Toå ñaàu tieân cuûa doøng Thieàn AÁn Ñoä —The story that the meaning lies in the silence; some say it            begins with a sutra, the "Ta-fan T'ien-wang Wen lies in the pause, that speech illumines what                Fo Ching." In it it is told that once Brahma, the cannot be said, and speechlessness illumines what            highest deity in the Hinduist assembly of gods, can be said as Young Chia said, "Speaking when               visited a gathering of disciples of the Buddha on silent, silent when speaking." But if you only               Mount Gridhrakuta (Vulture Peak Mountain). He understand in this way, then past, present, and              presented the Buddha with a garland of flowers future, for sixty aeons, you will still never have           and requested him respectfully to expound the seen it even in dreams. If you can immediately               dharma. However, instead of giving a discourse, and directly attain fulfillment, then you will no            the Buddha only took a flower and twirled it, longer see that there is anything ordinary or holy,          while smiling silently, between the fingers of his this Dharma is equanimous, it has no high or low.            raised hand. None of the gathering understood Every day you will walk hand in hand with all the            except for Kashyapa, who responded with a smile. Buddhas.                                                     According to the somewhat shortened version of Coâng AÙn Theá Toân Nieâm Hoa: The World-                    this episode given in example 6 of the Wu-Men- Honored One Twirls a Flower—Töø ngöõ thieàn noùi             Kuan, the Buddha then said, "I have the treasure leân vieäc truyeàn Phaùp cuûa ñöùc Phaät Thích Ca moät       of the eye of true dharma, the wonderful mind of caùch im laëng cho ñoà ñeä cuûa Ngaøi laø Ca Dieáp, veà      nirvana, the true form of no form, the mysterious sau ñöôïc goïi laø Ñaïi Ca Dieáp. Vieäc truyeàn töø taâm     gate of dharma. It cannot be expressed through sang taâm laø khôûi ñaàu cuûa vieäc 'truyeàn ñaëc bieät,     words and letters and is a special transmission, ngoaøi kinh ñieån', nhö Thieàn ñaõ töï goïi mình. Caâu       outside of all doctrine. This I entrust to chuyeän naày baét nguoàn töø moät boä kinh mang teân         Mahakashyapa." According to Wu Men Hui-Kai in 'Ñaïi Phaïm Thieân Vöông Vaán Phaät Kinh', keå laïi          the Wu-Men-Kuan, as a matter of fact, suppose moät chuyeán thaêm cuûa caùc vò Baø La Moân cuûa moät        that all the monks had smiled, how would the eye ngoâi ñeàn AÁn giaùo ñeán thaêm caùc moân ñoà cuûa Phaät     treasury have been transmitted? Or suppose that treân nuùi Linh Thöùu, ñaõ daâng Phaät moät caønh hoa Ba     Mahakasyapa had not smiled, how could he have La vaøng roài xaû thaân laøm saøng toïa thænh Phaät          been entrusted with it? If you say the eye treasury thuyeát phaùp. Ñöùc Theá Toân ñaêng toïa, giô caønh hoa      can be transmitted, that would be as if the World leân vaø vöøa duøng maáy ngoùn tay xoay boâng cho ñaïi       Honored One were swindling people in a loud chuùng xem, vaø vöøa mæm cuôøi, nhöng khoâng noùi lôøi       voice at the town gate. If you say the eye treasury naøo. Khoâng moät ai ôû ñoù hieåu Theá Toân muoán nhaén      cannot be transmitted, then why did the Buddha nhuû gì, duy chæ moät mình Ca Dieáp mæm cöôøi ñaùp           say that he entrusted it to Mahakasyapa? No laïi thaày mình. Theo söï trình baøy ñöôïc toùm löôïc        matter what had happened, after this event, phaàn naøo veà caâu chuyeän naày trong thí duï thöù 6 cuûa   Kashyapa was called Mahakashyapa, thus became Voâ Moân Quan, nhaân ñoù Ñöùc Theá Toân ñaõ noùi: “Ta        the first patriarch of the Indian transmission coù chính phaùp nhaõn taïng, Nieát Baøn dieä u taâm, thöïc   lineage of Ch'an. töôùng voâ töôùng, phaùp moân vi dieäu, chaúng laäp thaønh   Coâng AÙn Theå Loä Kim Phong: Yun Men's the vaên töï, truyeàn rieâng ngoaøi giaùo, nay trao laïi cho     body exposed in the golden wind, example 27 of Ma Ha Ca Dieáp.” Theo Voâ Moân Hueä Khai trong               the Pi-Yen-Lu—Trong thí duï thöù 27 cuûa Bích Voâ Moân Quan, thaät tình maø noùi, neáu luùc baáy giôø      Nham Luïc, moät hoâm coù moät vò Taêng hoûi Vaân caû ñaùm ñeàu cöôøi caû thì nhaõn taïng chính phaùp laøm     Moân: "Khi laù ruïng caønh khoâ thì theá naøo?" Vaân

Moân ñaùp: "Thaân baøy gioù Thu." Thaân baøy gioù thu,         27 of the Pi-Yen-Lu, one day, a monk asked Yun duï cho söï töï taïi cuûa haønh giaû sau khi kieán taùnh       Men, "How is it when the tree withers and the (taâm khoâng bò raøng buoäc bôûi phieàn naõo). Theo            leaves fall?" Yun Men said, "Body exposed in the Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc, neáu nhaèm trong              golden wind." The term indicates the freedom that aáy tieán ñöôïc môùi thaáy choã vì ngöôøi cuûa Vaân Moân.      practitioners achieve after seeing their own nature Kia neáu chaúng ñöôïc theá, vaãn nhö xöa laø keû chæ nai       (the mind being free from delusion). According to cho laø ngöïa, maét môø tai ñieác, ngöôøi naøo ñeán caûnh      Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, if you can giôùi naày. Haõy noùi Vaân Moân ñaùp thoaïi cho ngöôøi,        comprehend here, then you begin to see where hay vì ngöôøi thuø xöôùng? Neáu noùi Vaân Moân ñaùp            Yun Men helped people. Otherwise, if you still thoaïi cho ngöôøi laø nhaän laàm traùi caân baøn (vôùi tieâu   can't, as before you'll be pointing to a deer and chuaån coá ñònh). Neáu noùi Vaân Moân vì ngöôøi thuø           calling it a horse: your eyes are blind, your ears xöôùng thì naøo coù dính daùng gì. Ñaõ chaúng theá aáy,        are deaf. Who arrives at this realm? Tell me, do cöùu caùnh theá naøo? Neáu oâng thaáy ñöôïc thaáu thì loã      you think Yun Men answered the monk's question, muõi Thieàn Taêng chaúng phaûi bò moät caùi veùo. Neáu         or do you think he was harmonizing with him? If kia chaúng ñöôïc theá, nhö xöa ñi thaúng vaøo hang             you say he answered his question, you are quæ. Phaøm laø ngöôøi döïng laäp toâng thöøa, phaûi laø        wrongly sticking to the zero point of a scale. If you toaøn thaân gaùnh vaùc, chaúng tieác loâng maøy, nhaèm         say he harmonized with the monk, this has nothing mieäng coïp naèm ngang, maëc cho noù loâi ngang keùo           to do with it. Since it's not this way, ultimately, doïc. Neáu chaúng nhö theá thì ñaâu theå vì ngöôøi ñöôïc.      how is it? If you can see all the way through, OÂng Taêng naày ñaët caâu hoûi thaät laø hieåm hoùc, neáu      patchrobed monks' nostrils are not worth a pinch. laáy vieäc taàm thöôøng nhìn oâng chæ gioáng moät vò           Otherwise, if you still can't, as before you'll Taêng nhaøn roãi. Neáu caên cöù vaøo döôùi cöûa Thieàn         plunge into the ghost cave. In general, to uphold Taêng, trong choã maïng maïch maø xem, quaû thaät coù          and establish the vehicle of our sect, you must choã huyeàn dieäu. Thöû noùi laù ruïng caønh khoâ laø caûnh    take up the burden with your entire being and not giôùi cuûa ngöôøi naøo? Trong 'Thaäp Baùt Vaán' cuûa           fear for your eyebrows, you must stretch out in the Phaàn Döông Thieän Chaâu, loái hoûi naày laø 'Bieän chuû',     tiger's mouth and allow others to pull back and cuõng goïi laø 'Taù söï vaán'. Vaân Moân chaúng dôøi ñoåi      forth and drag you down. If you're not like this, moät maûy tô, chæ nhaèm oâng noùi "Thaân baøy gioù thu."       how will you be able to help people? This monk Ñaùp raát hay, cuõng chaúng coâ phuï caâu hoûi cuûa ngöôøi.    posed a question that was indeed dangerous and Bôûi vì choã hoûi kia coù maét saùng, choã ñaùp cuõng ñuùng    lofty. If you look at him in ordinary terms, he just ñaén. Ngöôøi xöa noùi: "Muoán ñöôïc thaân thieát chôù          seems to be a monk involved in idle concerns. If ñem hoûi ñeán hoûi." Neáu laø tri aâm, noùi ra lieàn bieát     you go by the traditions of patchrobed monks, choã rôi. Chæ trong caâu cuûa Vaân Moân, phaàn nhieàu          when you go into his life line and look, then he thích gôïi tình giaûi cuûa ngöôøi. Neáu duøng tình giaûi       undeniably has something marvellous about him. hieåu, chöa khoûi tan heát con chaùu cuûa ta. Vaân Moân        But say, when the tree withers and the leaves fall thích côõi ngöïa cuûa keû troäm ñeå ñuoåi troäm. Ñaâu          off, whose realm is this? In Fen Yang's scheme of chaúng thaáy vò Taêng hoûi: "Theá naøo laø choã phi tö         eighteen kinds of questions, this is called "a töôûng?" Vaân Moân ñaùp: "Thöùc tình khoù löôøng." Vò          question to test the host." It is also called "a Taêng naày hoûi: "Khi laù ruïng caønh khoâ thì theá naøo?"     question that uses things." Yun Men did not stir a Vaân Moân ñaùp: "Thaân baøy gioù thu." Trong caâu quaû         hairbreadth, but just said to him, "Body exposed in thaät chaët ñöùt yeáu taân, chaúng thoâng phaøm thaùnh,        the golden wind." He answered most wondrously, phaûi hieåu Vaân Moân cöû moät roõ ba, cöû ba roõ moät.        and without presuming to turn his back on the Neáu oâng hai caâu ñoù maø tìm thì cuõng nhö oâng nhoå         monk's question either. Since his question had muõi teân sau oùt vaäy. Trong moät caâu cuûa Vaân Moân         eyes, Yun Men's answer too was straight to the phaûi ñuû ba caâu: phuù caùi caøn khoâng; tuøy ba truïc        point. An ancient said, "If you want to attain laõng; caùt tieät chuùng löu, thì töï nhieân thích hôïp.       Intimacy, don't ask with a question." If you really Haønh giaû tu thieàn haõy thöû noùi trong ba caâu naày,        know someone, you know what he's getting at as Vaân Moân duøng caâu naøo tieáp ngöôøi?—In example             soon as he mentions. If you go to the vein of Yun

Men's words to look, you've immediately gone              pointed at a piece of land and said, "This land can wrong. It's just that in his phrases Yun Men was          be used to build a rest house." Wen-yen then often want to provoke people's emotional                  stepped aside and said, "First of all, let's give it to interpretations. If I made up emotional                   an official for testing!" Chao-chou gave him a slap interpretations to understand him, I wouldn't avoid       in the face. Wen-yen said, "The official has being bereft of my successors. Yun Men like to            already tested." ride the thief's horse to pursue the thief in this        Coâng AÙn Thieân Bình Haønh Cöôùc: T'ien way. Haven't you heard: a monk asked him, "What           P'ing's Travel on Foot—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô duyeân is that which is not within reach of thought?" Yun        vaán ñaùp giöõa Thieàn sö Taây Vieän vaø Thieân Bình Men said, "Impossible for cognition to fathom."           Tuøng YÛ trong khi Thieân Bình ñang treân ñöôøng This monk asked, "How is it when the tree withers         haønh cöôùc. Theo Nguõ Ñaêng Hoäi Nguyeân, quyeån and the leaves fall?" Yun Men said, "Body                 XI, Hoøa Thöôïng Thieân Bình khi ñi haønh cöôùc, ñeán exposed in the golden wind." In his words he              tham vaán Taây Vieän, Sö thöôøng töï noùi: "Chôù noùi unstoppably seizes and cuts off the essential             hoäi Phaät phaùp, tìm ngöôøi noùi thoaïi cuõng khoâng coù." bridge and doesn't let ordinary or saintly through.       Moät hoâm, Taây Vieän töø xa thaáy goïi: "Tuøng YÛ!" You must understand how Yun Men raises one                Thieân Bình ngöôõng ñaàu. Taây Vieän noùi: "Laàm!" and illuminates three, raises three and illuminates       Thieân Bình ñi hai ba böôùc, Taây Vieän laïi baûo: one. If you go to his three phrases to seek, then         "Laàm!" Thieân Bình laïi gaàn, Taây Vieän laïi baûo: you're pulling an arrow out of the back of your           "Vöøa roài hai caùi laàm, laø Taây Vieän laàm hay Thöôïng head. In a single phrase of Yun Men's, three              toïa laàm?" Thieân Bình thöa: "Tuøng YÛ laàm!" Taây phrases are inevitably present: the phrase that           Vieän noùi: "Haõy ôû laïi ñaây qua haï, seõ cuøng Thöôïng contains heaven and earth, the phrase that follows        Toïa thöông löôïng hai caùi laàm naày." Khi aáy Thieân the waves and pursues the currents, and the phrase        Bình lieàn ñi. Sau Thieân Bình truï vieän baûo chuùng: that cuts off the myriad streams. What he says is         "Luùc ñaàu khi ta ñi haønh cöôùc bò gioù nghieäp thoåi naturally exactly appropriate. But tell me, Zen           ñeán choã Tröôûng Laõo Tö Minh, lieân tieáp hai caùi practitioners, of the three phrases, which one does       laàm, laïi caàm ta ôû laïi qua haï seõ cuøng ta thöông Yun Men use to receive people?                            löôïng, ta chaúng noùi khi aáy laø laàm, caát böôùc ñi Coâng AÙn Thò Giaû Tuaàn Phoá: Thò giaû: Ngoâi nhaø       phöông Nam, ta sôùm bieát noùi laàm roài." Theo thieàn nghæ—The attendant's rest house—Coâng aùn noùi veà        sö Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc, taéc 98, laõo giaø cô duyeân vaán ñaùp giöõa Thieàn sö Trieäu Chaâu Toøng    naày khi chöa ñi haønh cöôùc khoâng coù nhieàu Phaät Thaåm vaø thò giaû Vaên Vieãn. Theo Caûnh Ñöùc            phaùp thieàn ñaïo, ñeán khi ñi haønh cöôùc bò caù c nôi Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån X, vaø Nguõ Ñaêng Hoäi         quôû. Chaúng baèng khi chöa ñi haønh cöôùc, goïi ñaát laø Nguyeân, quyeån IV, moät hoâm Thieàn sö Trieäu Chaâu      trôøi, goïi nuùi laø nöôùc, may thay khoâng moät vieäc cuøng ñang ñi vôùi thò giaû Vaên Vieãn doïc theo ñöôøng   ñaùng quan ngaïi. Neáu khôûi tieán giaûi löu tuïc theá aáy, nuùi, Trieäu Chaâu chæ maûnh ñaát vaø noùi: "Maûnh ñaát   sao chaúng mua moät chieác muõ ñoäi cho taát caû ñeå qua naøy coù theå xaây ñöôïc moät ngoâi tuaàn phoá (nhaø      thôøi, coù duøng ñöôïc choã naøo? Phaät phaùp chaúng phaûi nghæ)." Vaên Vieãn beøn ñöùng sang moät beân ñöôøng       ñaïo lyù naày. Neáu luaän vieäc naày haù coù nhieàu thöù noùi: "Tröôùc nhaát, haõy ñem cho quan nghieäm xeùt       phöùc taïp. Neáu oâng noùi toâi hoäi, kia chaúng hoäi, laø caùi ñaõ!" Trieäu Chaâu beøn ñaùnh cho Vaên Vieãn moät    gaùnh moät gaùnh thieàn chaïy quanh khaép thieân haï, bò baït tai, Vaên Vieãn noùi: "Quan ñaõ nghieäm xeùt roõ     ngöôøi maét saùng khaùm phaù, moät ñieåm söû duïng cuõng raøng."—The koan about the potentiality and               khoâng xong—The koan about the potentiality and conditions of questions and answers between Zen           conditions of questions and answers between Zen master Chao Chou and his attendant Wen Yuan.              master Hsi Yuan and T'ien P'ing who was a According to the Records of the Transmission of           wandering monk at the time. According to the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), Volume X, and                  Wudeng Huiyuan, volume XI, when the Master of Wudeng Huiyuan, volume IV, one day, when                  T'ien P'ing was travelling on foot, he called on Hsi Chao-chou and his attendant Wen-yen were                  Yuan. He always would say, "Do not say you walking along the mountain road, Chao-chou                understand the Buddhist Teaching; I cannot find a

single man who can quote a saying." One day Hsi                traøng cöôøi vôùi nhöõng thöù aáy. Thieàn laø moät chuyeän Yuan saw him from a distance and called him by                 boâng ñuøa loàng trong moät chuyeän boâng ñuøa, vaø name: "Ts'ung Yi!" P'ing raised his head. Hsi                  cuõng gioáng nhö moïi chuyeän boâng ñuøa, Thieàn Yuan said, "Wrong!" P'ing went two or three                    khoâng "giaûi thích" ñöôïc. Ñoù laø cuoäc soáng giöõa steps; Hsi Yuan again said, "Wrong!" P'ing                     loøng hình töôùng, cuoäc soáng maø lyù luaän coá gaéng approached; Hsi Yuan said, "These two wrongs                   laøm cho trôû neân thieâng lieâng vaø cuõng thöôøng laøm just now: were they my wrongs or your worngs?"                 cho ngoät ngaït. Thieàn laø doøng soâng cuûa cuoäc soáng P'ing said, "My wrongs." Hsi Yuan said, "Wrong!"               khoâng quan taâm gì ñeán nhöõng laâu ñaøi cuûa tö töôûng, P'ing gave up. Hsi Yuan said, "Stay here for the               töø ñieån vaø ñònh nghóa, hay chuyeän thaáu hieåu cuûa summer and wait for me to discuss these two                    nhöõng quyeát ñònh cuûa nhöõng ai coøn ôû beân bôø soâng. wrongs with you." But P'ing immediately went                   Kyõ thuaät Thieàn cuõng gioáng nhö thuoác noå duøng away. Later, when he was dwelling in a temple,                 trong vieäc vaän chuyeån goã suùc ñeå phaù caùc chöôùng he said to his community, "When I was first                    ngaïi treân soâng, ñeå cho nöôùc vaø taát caû nhöõng gì travelling on foot, I was blown by the wind of                 boàng beành treân nöôùc töï do xuoâi ñi—According to events to Elder Ssu Ming's place: twice in a row               Christmas Humphrey in Buddhism, all these koans he said 'Wrong!' and tried to keep me there over               are nonsense, that is, non-sense, and so is Zen. For the summer to wait for him to deal with me. I did              sense is the product of reasoning and logic, of the not say it was wrong then; when I set out for the              laws of thought; Zen roars with laughter at all of South, I already knew that it was wrong."                      them. Zen is the joke in a joke, and cannot, like a According to Zen master Yuan Wu in example 98                  joke, be "explained." It is the life within the form; of the Pi-Yen-Lu, this old fellow has said quite a             it is that which reasoning strives to enshrine and bit; it's just that he's fallen into seventh and eighth        frequently strangles. It is the river of life which place, shaking his head thinking, out of touch.                cares not for the palaces of thought, the When people these days hear him saying, "When I                dictionaries and definitions, the understanding of set out for the South, I already knew that it was              decisions of those upon its banks. Zen technique, wrong," they immediately go figuring it out and                therefore, like the explosives used in logging, is say, "Before even going on foot travels, there is              designed to break the jam in the river, and let the naturally not so much Buddhism or Ch'an; and                   waters and all which float thereon ride free. when you go foot travelling, you are completely                Coâng AÙn Thieát Taät Leâ: An iron thorny thrash or fooled by people everywhere, Even before foot                  club—Chieác chuøy gai baèng saét, yù noùi söï chæ daïy travels, you can't call earth sky or call mountain             nghieâm minh trong caùc truyeàn thoáng thieàn. Theo rivers; fortunately there is nothing to be concerned           thí duï thöù 12 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc, ngaøy noï, coù moät about it at all." If you all entertain such common             oâng Taêng ñeán hoûi Ñoäng Sôn: "Phaät laø gì?" Ñoäng vulgar views, why not busy a bandanna to wear                  Sôn ñaùp: "Thieát taät leâ (chieác chuøy gai baèng saét), and pass your time in the boss's house? What is                naïp Taêng trong thieân haï khoâng nhaûy qua khoûi." the use? Buddha's teaching is not this principle. If           Haønh giaû tu thieàn neân luoân nhôù raèng neáu döôùi caâu you discuss this matter, how could there be so                 noùi cuûa Ñoäng Sôn hieåu nhö theá, tham vaán ñeán many complications? If you say, "I understand,                 Phaät Di Laëc ra ñôøi cuõng chöa moäng thaáy, vì ngoân others do not understand," carrying a bundle of                ngöõ chæ laø moùn ñoà chôû ñaïo. Neáu chaúng bieát yù cuûa Ch'an around the country, when you are tried out               coå nhaân, chæ chaêm vaøo trong caâu tìm caàu coù gì by clear-eyed people, you won't be able to use it              chaân thaät. Coå nhaân noùi: "Ñaïo voán khoân g lôøi, nhôn at all.                                                        lôøi hieåu ñaïo, thaáy ñaïo phaûi queân lôøi."—An iron Coâng AÙn Vaø Thieàn: Koans and Zen—Theo                       thorny thrash or club, the term indicates a strict Christmas Humphrey trong quyeån Phaät Giaùo, taát              guidance in Zen traditions. According to example caû moïi coâng aùn ñeàu laø nhöõng chuyeän phi lyù, nghóa      12 of Pi-Yen-Lu, one day, a monk asked Tung- laø nhöõng ñieàu "voâ yù nghóa" vaø Thieàn laïi cuõng nhö      shan, "What is Buddha?" Tung-shan said, "An iron vaäy. Vì yù nghóa laø keát quaû cuûa bieän luaän, lyù luaän,   thorny club that monks with patched robes cannot vaø caùc qui luaät cuûa tö töôûng. Thieàn roáng leân nhöõng    jump over." Zen practitioners should always

remember that if you seek from Tung-shan's                       "head phrase" is very specific. "Head phrase" words this way, you can search until Maitreya                    denotes only the question, not the whole story; Buddha is born down here and still never see it                  and in most cases only the "gist", "highlight", or even in a dream. For words and speech are just                   "essence", so to speak, of the question is implied. vessels to convey the Path. Far from realizing the               Coâng AÙn Thôøi Nhaân Kieán Hoa Thuï Nhö Moäng: intent of the Ancients, people just search in their              Man of our times sees this blossoming bush like words, what grasp can they get on it? Haven't you                someone who is dreaming—Ngöôøi thôøi nay thaáy seen how an Ancient said, "Originally the Path is                goác hoa naày gioáng nhö côn moäng—Moät trong wordless; with words we illustrate the Path. Once                nhöõng coâng aùn gaây aán töôïng maïnh nhaát veà Nam you see the Path, the words are immediately                      Tuyeàn ñöôïc ghi trong thí duï 40 Bích Nham Luïc. forgotten."—See Ñoäng Sôn Ma Tam Caân.                           Ñaïi sö Luïc Hoaøn noùi vôùi Nam Tuyeàn trong cuoäc Coâng AÙn Vaø Thoaïi Ñaàu: Koans and Head                        troø chuyeän. Luïc Hoaøn hoûi, “Trieäu Phaùp sö noùi phrases—Coâng aùn ñöôïc hình thaønh töø caùc cuoäc               ‘Trôøi ñaát cuøng ta ñoàng goác, vaïn vaät cuøng ta moät vaán ñaùp giöõa thaày troø ngaøy xöa, töø nhöõng ñoaïn           theå,’ thaät laø kyø quaùi! Nam Tuyeàn chæ moät boâng vaên trong caùc baøi thuyeát phaùp hay caùc baøi giaûng          hoa trong vöôøn roài noùi vôùi Ñaïi Sö, “Thôøi nhaân cuûa caùc vò thaày, hoaëc töø nhöõng caâu kinh vaø caùc lôøi     thaáy goác hoa naày gioáng nhö côn moäng.”—One of daïy khaùc. Coâng aùn cuõng coù nghóa laø "chuyeän" hay          the most impressive koans with Nan-Ch’uan is "bieán coá". Trong khi thoaïi ñaàu coù nghóa laø caùc ñaàu       example 40 of the Pi-Yen-Lu. Lu-Huan Tai-Fu cuûa moät caâu vaên. Thí duï, "Ai laø ngöôøi nieäm Phaät?"       said to Nan-Ch’uan in the course of their Thoaïi ñaàu naøy trôû neân, vaø vaãn coøn laø thoaïi ñaàu        conversation, “Chao the Dharma teacher said, phoå caäp nhaát. Maëc daàu caû coâng aùn laãn thoaïi ñaàu        ‘Heaven and Earth and I have the same root; the ñeàu coù theå ñöôïc duøng ñeå chæ "tham hay xuyeân qua           ten thousand things and I are one body.’ vaán ñeà cuûa Thieàn," chöõ "thoaïi ñaàu" coù tính caùch         Absolutely wonderful! Nan-Ch’uan, pointing to a uyeân nguyeân vaø chính xaùc hôn. Coâng aùn bao haøm             blossom in the garden said, “The man of our times toaøn theå caâu truyeän Thieàn, goàm taát caû bieán coá,         sees this blossoming bush like someone who is coäng vôùi vaán ñeà chính ñang ñöôïc thaûo luaän, vì theá        dreaming.” noù laø moät thuaät ngöõ toång quaùt; trong khi "thoaïi          Coâng AÙn Thuû Sôn Sieâu Töù Cuù: Shou-shan: ñaàu" coù tính caùch raát ñaëc bieät. "Thoaïi ñaàu" bieåu        Transcending four extremes—Ngaøy noï, Thuû Sôn thò caùi vaán ñeà, chöù khoâng phaûi laø caû caâu truyeän, vaø   ñöa cao caây truùc beà leân baûo ñoà chuùng: "Naøy maáy trong haàu heát moïi tröôøng hôïp coù theå noùi laø noù chæ      oâng, neáu baûo caùi naøy laø caây gaäy töùc khaúng ñònh, haøm yù caùi "coát yeáu" hay caùi "tinh yeáu" cuûa vaán          neáu baûo chaúng phaûi laø caây gaäy töùc phuû ñònh; ngoaøi ñeà—Koans are constructed from the questions of                  khaúng ñònh vaø phuû ñònh, noùi ñi, noùi ñi! Goïi noù laø disciples together with responses from their                     caùi gì?" YÙ töôûng cuûa Thuû Sôn coát giöõ cho ñaàu oùc masters, from portions of the masters’ sermons or                chuùng ta thoaùt ngoaøi nhöõng raøng buoäc nhò nguyeân discourses, from lines of the sutras, and from other             vaø trieát lyù hö töôûng. Luùc ñoù neáu coù moät vò Taêng teachings. Koan also means "story" or "event".                   böôùc ñeán, naém caây gaäy trong tay Thuû Sôn vaø neùm While head phrase means the "ends", applicable                   xuoáng ñaát. Ñoù coù phaûi laø caâu traû lôøi chaêng? Ñoù coù either in the sense of the beginning or the ending               phaûi laø thuû ñoaïn ñaùp laïi lôøi thuùc giuïc "noùi ñi, noùi of a complete or incomplete sentence in talking.                 ñi" cuûa Thuû Sôn chaêng? Ñoù coù phaûi laø con ñöôøng For example, "Who is the one who recites the                     thoaùt ngoaøi boán meänh ñeà cuûa "töù cuù", sieâu leân neáp name of Buddha?" This "head phrase" (hua-tou)                    tö töôûng luaän lyù chaêng? (see Töù Cuù Chaáp). Toùm then became, and still remains, the most popular                 laïi, con ñöôøng töï do giaûi thoaùt laø nhö vaäy chaêng? of all. Although both "koan" and "head phrase"                   Trong Thieàn khoâng coù caùi gì laø khuoân pheùp heát, (hua-tou) may be used to denote the "inquiry                     moãi ngöôøi tuøy tieän giaûi quyeát noãi khoù khaên rieâng exercise of Zen", the latter is original and more                theo moãi caùch khaùc nhau. Ñoù laø choã baét nguoàn ñoäc accurate. "Koan" implies the entire Zen story,                   ñaùo cuûa Thieàn, ñaày sinh khí vaø saùng taïo—One including all the events, plus the main question at              day, Shou-shan held out his stick and said to a issue, and therefore it is a general term; while                 group of his disciples: "Call it not a shippeù, if you

do, you assert. Nor do you deny" ; if you do, you               forward and asked, "Master, what phrase do you negate its being a shippeù. Apart from affirmation              enter?" Shou-shan said, "The falling moon in the and negation, speak, speak! What do you call it?"               third watch shines through the market." Zen Shou-shan's idea is to get our heads free from                  master Shou-shan specifically taught his disciples dualistic tangles and philosophic subtleties. At that           these three phrases when he knew that they still moment, if a monk came out of the assembly, took                clinged to the Buddha and Patriarchs, He also the shippeù away from Shou-shan's hand, and threw               used these three phrases to help his disciples to it down on the floor. Is this the answer? Is this the           get rid of the duality. That is to say when they way to respond to Shou-shan's request "speak,                   conceive the truth as something external which is speak"? Is this the way to transcend the four                   perceived by a perceiving subject is dualistic and propositions, the logical conditions of thinking? In            appeals to the intellect for its understanding. He short, is this the way to be free? Nothing is                   emphasized that according to Zen, practitioners stereotyped in Zen, and somebody else may solve                 are living right in truth, by the truth, from which the difficulty in quite a different manner. This is             practitioners cannot be separated. where Zen is original, lively and creative.                     Coâng AÙn Thuû Sôn Taân Phuï: Thuû Sôn: Naøng daâu Coâng AÙn Thuû Sôn Tam Cuù : Thuû Sôn: Ba caâu—                 môùi—Shou-shan's new bride—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô Shou-shan's three phrases—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô                 duyeân vaán ñaùp giöõa Thieàn sö Thuû Sôn Tænh Nieäm duyeân tieáp hoùa ngöôøi hoïc cuûa Thieàn sö Thuû Sôn           vaø moät vò Taêng. Theo Nguõ Ñaêng Hoäi Nguyeân, Tænh Nieäm. Theo Thieàn Sö Thuû Sôn Tænh Nieäm                  quyeån XI, moät hoâm, coù moät vò Taêng hoûi Thieàn sö Ngöõ Luïc vaø Nguõ Ñaêng Hoäi Nguyeân, quyeån XI,               Thuû Sôn: "Phaät laø sao?" Thieàn sö Thuû Sôn ñaùp: moät hoâm Thieàn sö Thuû Sôn thöôïng ñöôøng daïy                "Taân phuï kî lö, a gia khieân (naøng daâu môùi côõi löøa, chuùng: "Caâu thöù nhaát nhaäp ñöôïc thì laøm Thaày Phaät       baø meï choàng keùo ñi)." Vò Taêng laïi hoûi: "Chöa bieát Toå; caâu thöù hai nhaäp ñöôïc thì laøm thaày trôøi ngöôøi;     töø ngöõ naøy xeáp vaøo caâu gì?" Thieàn sö Thuû Sôn caâu thöù ba nhaäp ñöôïc thì töï cöùu khoâng noåi." Moät vò     ñaùp: "Tam huyeàn xeáp khoâng ñöôïc, töù cuù haù ñöôïc Taêng böôùc ra hoûi: "Hoøa Thöôïng nhaäp caâu thöù              sao?" Vò Taêng laïi hoûi: "YÙ naøy nhö theá naøo?" Thieàn maáy?" Thuû Sôn ñaùp: "Traêng ruïng canh ba xuyeân              sö Thuû Sôn ñaùp: "Trôøi cao ñaát roäng, maët trôøi maët qua chôï." Thieàn sö Thuû Sôn daïy ñeä töû ñaëc bieät           traêng ñeàu saùng."—The koan about the potentiality baèng ba caâu naøy khi thaáy hoï chaáp tröôùc Phaät Toå,        and conditions of questions and answers between laïi coøn giuùp ngöôøi hoïc phaù boû thöù lôùp ñoái ñaõi nhò    Zen master Shou-shan Hsing-nien (926-993) and a nguyeân. Coù nghóa laø khi hoï quan nieäm chaân lyù nhö         monk. According to Wudeng Huiyuan, volume XI, moät thöù sôû tri ngoaïi thuoäc maø chuû theå naêng tri phaûi   one day, a monk asked Zen master Shou-shan, nhaän ra, phaûi vaän duïng tri thöùc ñeå laõnh hoäi, ñaây laø   "What is Buddha?" Shou-shan said, "The new loaïi kieán giaûi löôõng nguyeân ñoái ñaõi. Sö nhaán maïnh      bride is riding the donkey while the mother-in-law raèng theo Thieàn, haønh giaû hoaøn toaøn soáng ngay            is pulling it." The monk asked, "I don't know what trong chaân lyù, soáng baèng chaân lyù; khi soáng vôùi          phrase is this?" Shou-shan said, "Three wonderful Thieàn haønh giaû khoâng theå naøo taùch rôøi vôùi chaân lyù    instructions of the Lin-Chi cannot be arranged, ñöôïc—The koan about the potentiality and                       much less the four phrases?" The monk asked, conditions of receiving and instructing disciples of            "Master, what do you mean by this?" Shou-shan Zen master Shou-shan Hsing-nien (926-993).                      said, "The sky is lofty, the earth is broad, the sun According to Records of Lectures of Zen master                  and the moon are shining brightly." Shou-shan Hsing-nien, and Wudeng Huiyuan,                       Coâng AÙn Thuû Sôn Truùc Beà: Shou-shan's Short volume XI, one day, Zen master Shou-shan Hsing-                 Bamboo Staff—Chuùng ta gaëp teân cuûa Thuø Sôn nien entered the hall and addressed the monks,                  Tænh Nieäm trong thí duï thöù 43 cuûa Voâ Moân Quan. saying, "Enter the first phrase is to be a Master of            Vaên baûn coâng aùn nhö sau: "Thaày Thuû Sôn ñöa caây Sakyamuni Buddha; enter the second phrase is to                 gaäy leân vaø noùi vôùi caùc moân ñoà raèng, 'Chö Taêng, be a Teacher of devas and men (Sasta Deva-                      neáu caùc oâng noùi raèng ñaây laø moät caây gaäy, thì caùc manusyanam (skt); enter the third phrase one                    oâng laàm. Neáu caùc oâng noùi ñaây khoâng phaûi laø moät cannot save even oneself." A monk stepped                       caây gaäy, thì caùc oâng voâ lyù. Vaäy caùc oâng seõ goïi noù

laø caùi gì?'" Theo Voâ Moân Hueä Khai trong Voâ Moân            phaûi thaáy coå nhaân tuy noùi theá, yù quyeát khoâng ôû Quan, goïi laø gaäy truùc thì xuùc phaïm, khoâng goïi laø        trong aáy. Caàn phaûi chính chaén töï tham cöùu môùi gaäy truùc laø traùi nghòch. Khoâng ñöôïc noùi! Khoâng           ñöôïc. Qua thí duï naày Thuùy Nham muoán nhaéc laïi ñöôïc khoâng noùi! Ñaùp mau! Ñaùp mau!—We                        truyeàn thuyeát cho raèng ngöôøi naøo giaûng sai giaùo encounter Master Shou-shan in example 43 of the                  phaùp cuûa Phaät seõ ruïng heát loâng maøy. Trong suoát Wu-Men-Kuan. The koan is as follows: "Master                     muøa an cö kieát haï, tuy Thuùy Nham giaûng noùi Shou-shan held up his staff during instruction and               nhieàu cho chö huynh ñeä nhöng khoâng moät lôøi noùi said while showing it to the monks, 'Monks, if you               naêng naøo giaûi thích ñöôïc ñaïo phaùp laø gì, vaäy coù leõ call this a staff, that's an offense. If you call it not-        loâng mi cuûa sö ñaõ ruïng heát roài. Ñaây laø moät loái a-staff, that makes no sense. Tell me, monks, what               nhaán maïnh Thieàn khoâng aên nhaäp gì vôùi kinh ñieån will you call it?'" According to Wu Men Hui-Kai                  vaäy—At the end of the summer retreat Ts'ui Yen in the Wu-Men-Kuan, call it a short staff and                    said to his assembly, "All summer long I've been you're entangled. Don't call it a short staff and you            talking to you, brothers; look and see if my ignore the fact. You cannot use words. You cannot                eyebrows are still there." Pao-fu said, "The thief's use words. Speak quickly! Speak quickly!                         heart is cowardly." Ch'ang Ch'ing said, "Grown." Coâng AÙn Thuùy Nham Mi Mao: Ts'ui Yen's                         Yun-men said, "A barrier." Example 8 of the Pi- Eyebrows—Thuùy Nham cuoái haï daïy chuùng: "Töø                  Yen-Lu which allows us to learn more about the ñaàu haï ñeán nay vì huynh ñeä thuyeát thoaïi, xem               mind of Ts'ui Yen's than from all historical data Thuùy Nham loâng maøy coøn chaêng?" Baûo Phöôùc noùi:            concerning his life and significance. According to "Laøm cöôùp loøng ngöôøi roãng." Tröôøng Khaùnh noùi:            Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, in just one word, if "Sanh vaäy." Vaân Moân noùi: "Quan." Thí duï thöù 8              you understand, you can make use of it on the cuûa Bích Nham Luïc cho chuùng ta hieåu veà taâm cuûa            path of cultivation, like a dragon reaching the ngaøi Thuùy Nham nhieàu hôn laø qua nhöõng döõ kieän             water, like a tiger in the mountain. If you don't lòch söû veà cuoäc ñôøi cuûa ngaøi. Theo Vieân Ngoä trong        understand, then the worldly truth will prevail, and Bích Nham Luïc, chæ trong moät chöõ neáu hieåu thì thoï          you will be like a ram caught in a fence, like a duïng ñöôïc treân ñöôøng tu nhö roàng ñöôïc nöôùc, nhö           fool watching over a stump waiting for a rabbit. coïp töïa nuùi. Neáu khoâng hieåu thì tuïc ñeá seõ löôùt         Sometimes a single phrase is like a lion crouching thaéng, nhö deâ ñöïc chaïm raøo, nhö keû ngu oâm caây            on the ground; sometimes a phrase is like the ñôïi thoû. Coù khi chæ moät caâu nhö sö töû ngoài xoåm; coù      Diamond King's jewel sword. Sometimes a phrase khi moät caâu nhö Baûo Kieám Kim Cang Vöông; coù                 cuts off the tongue of everyone on earth, and khi moät caâu ngoài caét ñöùt ñaàu löôõi trong thieân haï;       sometimes a phrase follows the waves and coù moät caâu maø theo moøi ñuoåi soùng. Neáu laø treân          pursues the currents. if you make use of it on the ñöôøng thoï duïng thì gaëp tri aâm, cô nghi rieâng, bieát        road, when you meet with a man of knowledge loãi laàm, cuøng nhau chöùng minh. Neáu laø tuïc ñeá löôùt       you distinguish what's appropriate to the occasion, thaéng, ñuû moät con maét, khaû dó ngoài döùt möôøi              you know what's right and what's wrong and phöông, vaùch ñaù ngaøn nhaãn. Vì theá noùi ñaïi duïng           together you witness each other's illumination. hieän tieàn chaúng coøn pheùp taéc. Coù khi ñem moät             Where the worldly truth prevails, one who has coïng coû laøm thaân vaøng tröôïng saùu; coù khi ñem             single eye can cut off everything in the ten thaân vaøng tröôïng saùu laøm coïng coû. Haõy noùi baèng         directions and stand like a mile high wall. vaøo ñaïo lyù naøo? Laïi roõ bieát chaêng? Thöû cöû ra           Therefore, it is said, "When the great function xem? Coå nhaân coù sôùm tham chieàu thænh, Thuùy                 appears it does not keep to any fixed standards." Nham ñeán cuoái haï laïi daïy chuùng theá aáy, quaû laø          Sometimes we take a blade of grass and use it as cao tuyeät, quaû laø rung trôøi ñoäng ñaát. Caû ñaïi taïng       the sixteen foot golden body of Buddha; kinh naêm ngaøn boán möôi taùm quyeån chaúng khoûi               sometimes we take the sixteen foot golden body noùi taâm noùi taùnh, noùi ñoán noùi tieäm, laïi coù chi tieát   and use it as a blade of grass. But tell me, what naày chaêng? Taát caû chæ laø cô hoäi, maø Thuùy Nham            principle does this depend upon? Do you really thaät laø xuaát chuùng. Xem ngaøi noùi theá, thöû noùi xem       know? To test, I cite this; look! The Ancients had yù ngaøi rôi taïi choã naøo? Haønh giaû tu thieàn ñôøi sau       morning study and evening inquiry, at the end of

summer retreat Ts'ui-yen turned around and spoke            Coâng AÙn Thöôøng Thò Tròch Haï Buùt: Thöôøng Thò to his assembly like this, and he was undeniably            tròch buùt: neùm buùt—Wang Ching Su threw the pen solitary and steep, nothing could stop him from             down—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô duyeân vaán ñaùp giöõa startling the heaven and shaking the earth. But tell        Thieàn sö Vöông Kính Sôn (ñeä töû taïi gia noái phaùp me, in the whole great treasury of teachings, in the        cuûa Thieàn sö Qui Sôn Linh Höïu) vaø baïn ñoàng moân five thousand and forty-eight volumes of the                laø Meã Hoà ôû phuû Kinh Trieäu. Theo Caûnh Ñöùc canon, whether they talk of mind or nature,                 Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån XI, moät hoâm, Thieàn sö whether they preach the sudden or the gradual,              Vöông Thöôøng Thò laøm xong coâng vieäc, Meã Hoøa has there ever been this happening? They're all             Thöôïng ñeán hoûi. Vöông Thöôøng Thò giô caây buùt this kind of occasion, but among them Ts'ui-yen is          leân, Meã Hoøa Thöôïng noùi: "Coù veõ trong hö khoâng outstanding. Look at the way he talks; tell me,             ñöôïc chaêng?" Vöông Thöôøng Thò neùm caây buùt roài where is his true meaning? Future Zen                       ñi vaøo nhaø, khoâng trôû ra nöõa. Meã Hoøa Thöôïng heát practitioners should be very careful, although              söùc nghi ngôø, nhôø ngöôøi cuùng döôøng saép ñaët trai ancient virtues spoke like that, their meaning is           dieân, ñeå nhôø doø xeùt thaâm yù cuûa Vöông Thöôøng definitely not here. This example refers to the             Thò. Khi Thöôøng Thò vöøa ngoài xuoáng, ngöôøi cuùng tradition that when a man makes false statements            döôøng lieàn hoûi: "Hoâm qua vì sao khoâng thaáy nöõa?" concerning the Dharma of Buddhism he will lose              Vöông Thöôøng Thò ñaùp: "Sö töû caén ngöôøi, choù Haøn all the hair on his face. As Ts’ui-Yen gave many            caén vaät." Meã Hoøa Thöôïng môùi hieåu roõ lyù naøy. sermons during the summer retreat for the                   Vöông Thöôøng Thò laïi thöû, Meã Hoøa Thöôïng noùi: edification of his pupils, while no amount of talk          "Ñaây laø Daõ hoà tinh!" Vöông Thöôøng Thò noùi: "Vaán can ever explain what the truth is, his eyebrows            ñeà naøy thì oâng roõ."—The koan about the and beard might perhaps by this time have                   potentiality and conditions of questions and disappeared altogether. This is a way of emphasis           answers between Zen master Wang Ching Su and of no connection between Zen and Sutras.                    his colleague. According to the Records of the Coâng AÙn Thuùy Vi Thieàn Baûn: Shui-Wei's                  Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), meditation plank (zemban)—Trong thieàn, taám vaùn           Volume XI, one day, Wang Ching Su finished his ñoùng vai troø quan troïng. Taám vaùn xuaát hieän trong     work, Master Mei came and asked something. moät soá coâng aùn nhö thí duï soá 20 trong Bích Nham       Wang Ching Su raised the pen, Master Mei said, Luïc, trong ñoù chuùng ta thaáy söï xuaát hieän cuûa caùc   "Can you draw in the space?" Wang Ching Su thieàn sö Thuùy Vi, Laâm Teá vaø Long Nha. Long Nha         threw the pen down and went into the house, hoûi Thuùy Vi: "Vieäc tröôûng laõo ñeán töø Taây phöông     never came out again. Master Mei was extremely coù yù nghóa nhö theá naøo?" Thuùy Vi ñaùp: "Ñöa cho        in doubt, so he asked someone to come to offer a ta taám vaùn." Long Nha ñöa taám vaùn cho Thuùy Vi.         meal to make an inquiry about Wang Ching Su's Thuùy Vi caàm laáy taám vaùn vaø ñaùnh Long Nha.            intention. When Wang Ching Su just sat down, the Long Nha noùi: "Ta bò ñaùnh laø vì ñaùng ñaùnh; noùi        donator immediately asked, "Why didn't you come caùch khaùc, vieäc tröôûng laõo ñeán töø phöông Taây        out again yesterday?" Wang Ching Su said, "The chaúng coù yù nghóa gì caû."—In Zen, meditation             lion bites people, and Han dog bites things." Then plank plays an important role. The Zen board is             Master Mei understood clearly the matter. Wang mentioned in a number of ancient koans, for                 Ching Su tried to test Master Mei again, Master instance, example 20 of the Blue Cliff Record, in           Mei said, "This is an artful (sly) wild fox." Wang which the Zen masters Shui-Wei, Lin Chi and                 Ching Su said, "You understood thoroughly this Lung Ya appear. Lung Ya asked Shui-Wei, "What               matter." is the meaning of the patriarch's coming from the           Coâng AÙn Tòch Töû Phaùc Caûnh: Yang Shan: west?" Shui-Wei said, "Give me the Zen board."              smashing the mirror in pieces—Ngöôõng Sôn ñaäp Lung Ya handed Shui-Wei the Zen board. Shui-                naùt göông—Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, Wei took it and hit him. Lung-Ya said, "If you hit          quyeån XI, luùc Ngöôõng Sôn ñang truï trì ôû nuùi Ñoâng me, I'll let you hit me. In short, the patriarch's          Bình, quaän Thieàu Chaâu, thaày oâng laø Qui Sôn göûi coming from the west has no meaning."                       ñeán cho oâng moät taám göông keøm theo moät phong

thö. Ngöôõng Sôn ñöa göông leân tröôùc ñoà chuùng                 Yang-shan in this case. The Zen method of baûo: "Qui Sôn göûi ta moät taám göông. Maáy oâng noùi            training its followers thus appears so altogether thöû xem göông cuûa Qui Sôn? Hay göông cuûa                       out of reason and unnecessarily inhuman. But the Ngöôõng Sôn? Neáu cuûa Qui Sôn sao naèm trong tay                 master's eyes are always upon the truth absolute Ngöôõng Sôn? Neáu cuûa Ngöôõng Sôn sao do Qui                     and yet attainable in this world of particulars. If Sôn göûi ñeán? Heã maáy oâng noùi ñöôïc thì göông coøn,           this can be gained, what does it matter whether a khoâng noùi ñöôïc ta seõ ñaäp naùt." Ngöôõng Sôn laëp ñi          thing known as precious be broken and an animal laëp laïi ba laàn, nhöng khoâng ai noùi naêng gì vaø taám         be sacrificed? Is not the recovering of the soul göông bò ñaäp naùt. Theo thieàn sö D.T. Suzuki trong              more important than the loss of a kingdom? Thieàn Luaän, Taäp I, tröôøng hôïp taám kieáng cuûa               Coâng AÙn Tòch Töû Tam Thaäp Tröôïng: Yang Ngöôõng Sôn bò ñaäp naùt gioáng heät nhö tröôøng hôïp             Shan's thirty blows—Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Nam Tuyeàn gieát meøo. Trong hai tröôøng hôïp, ñoà                Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån IX, moät hoâm, Thieàn sö Qui Sôn chuùng khoâng cöùu noåi maïng con meøo, khoâng baûo               cuøng chuùng haùi traø, Sö baûo Ngöôõng Sôn: "Troïn veä ñöôïc taám göông quyù, chæ vì taâm hoï chöa côûi boû          ngaøy haùi traø chæ nghe tieáng con maø khoâng thaáy ñöôïc neáp trí thöùc neân khoâng môû ñöôïc moät loái thoaùt       hình con." Ngöôõng Sôn lieàn rung caây traø. Qui Sôn giöõa meâ ñoà do hai sö phuï Nam Tuyeàn vaø Ngöôõng               baûo: "Con chæ ñöôïc caùi duïng cuûa noù, chaúng ñöôïc Sôn chuû taâm gaøi vaøo. Phöông phaùp tu taäp cuûa caùc           caùi theå cuûa noù." Ngöôõng Sôn thöa: "Hoøa Thöôïng thieàn sö luyeän cho moân ñoà döôøng nhö hoaøn toaøn              noùi sao?" Sö im laëng. Ngöôõng Sôn noùi: "Hoøa voâ lyù vaäy, maø coøn taøn nhaãn voâ loái nöõa laø khaùc.        Thöôïng chæ ñöôïc caùi theå cuûa noù, khoâng ñöôïc caùi Nhöng nhaõn quang caùc ngaøi luoân ñaët ôû thöïc taïi,            duïng cuûa noù." Qui Sôn noùi: "Cho con ba chuïc tuy tuyeät ñoái maø vaãn coù theå ñaït tôùi ñöôïc ôû theá giôùi   gaäy." Ngöôõng Sôn noùi: "Neáu con laõnh ba chuïc gaäy töông ñoái dò bieät naøy. Neáu chöùng ñöôïc chaân lyù aáy         cuûa Hoøa Thöôïng thì ai laõnh ba chuïc gaäy cuûa con thì saù gì moät baûo vaät hay moät con thuù phaûi hy              ñaây?" Qui Sôn noùi: "Vaäy tha cho con ba chuïc sinh? Phuïc hoài laïi linh hoàn haù chaúng phaûi laø quan         gaäy."—According to the Records of the troïng gaáp boäi hôn caû caùi khoå maát nöôùc sao?—               Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), According to the Records of the Transmission of                   Volume IX, one day, while Kui-shan and the the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), Volume XI, while                       monks were picking tea leaves, Kui-shan said to Yang-shan was residing at Tung-ping of Shao-                      Yang-shan, "All day today I've heard your voice chou, his master Kuei-shan sent him a mirror                      but I haven't seen your form." Yang-shan then accompanied with a letter. Yang-shan held forth                   shook the tea tree. Kui-shan said, "You attained the mirror before a congregation of monks and                     its function, but you haven't realized its essence." said, "O, monks, Kuei-shan sent here a mirror. Is                 Yang-shan said, "What does the master say?" Kui- this Kuei-shan's mirror or my own? If you say it is               shan was silent. Yang-shan said, "The master has Kuei-shan's, how is it that the mirror is in my                   attained its essence but hasn't realized its hands? If you say it is mine own, has it not come                 function." Kui-shan said, "I give you thirty blows from Kuei-shan? If you make a proper statement,                   with the staff." Yang-shan said, "If I receive thirty it will be retained here. If you cannot, it will be               blows of the master's staff, who then will receive smashed in pieces." He said this for three times,                 thirty blows from me?" Kui-shan said, "You will but nobody even made an attempt to answer. The                    be spared of my thirty blows. mirror was then smashed. According to Zen                         Coâng AÙn Tieàn Ñình Baùch Thuï Töû: Caây baùch master D.T. Suzuki in Essays in Zen Buddhism,                     tröôùc saân—The cypress tree at the front of the First Series (p.277), this case is somewhat like the              courtyard—Moät vò Taêng hoûi: "Theá naøo laø chæ yù case of Nan-ch'uan's kitten. In both cases the                    cuûa Phaät phaùp?" Trieäu Chaâu ñaùp: "Caây baù thoï monks failed to save the innocent victim or the                   tröôùc saân." Ñoù laø caâu noùi ñöôïc trích töø coâng aùn thöù precious treasure, simply because their minds                     37 trong "Voâ Moân Quan". Theo Thieàn sö Ñaïo were not yet free from intellectualism and were                   Nguyeân trong quyeån "Chaùnh Phaùp Nhaõn Taïng", unable to break through the entanglements                         caây baùch tröôùc saân cuûa Trieäu Chaâu chính laø coäi purposely set up by Nan-ch'uan in one case and by                 caây khoâng reã. Ngay caùi traïng thaùi ñôøi soáng giaùc

ngoä töï noù baây giôø ñöôïc dieãn taû nhö laø coäi caây          The enlightened life is not fixed but free, khoâng reã. Cuoäc ñôøi giaùc ngoä cuûa baïn taïi sao laïi laø     unattached to any one thing. And yet, each of us is coäi caây khoâng reã? Cuoäc ñôøi giaùc ngoä khoâng phaûi          fixed or conditioned in certain ways. For instance, laø cuoäc ñôøi coá ñònh maø laø cuoäc ñôøi töï taïi, khoâng coá   we have the condition of human being, of being a chaáp vaøo baát cöù thöù gì. Theá nhöng, moãi ngöôøi              man or a woman, of having a family or being chuùng ta laïi coá ñònh hay bò ñieàu kieän troùi buoäc            alone. We have certain knowledge giving rise to trong nhöõng phöông dieän naøo ñoù. Thí duï nhö                   all sorts of ideas. All these conditions are like chuùng ta coù ñieàu kieän cuûa con ngöôøi, laøm ngöôøi            roots by which we survive. Is there anything nam hay ngöôøi nöõ, coù gia ñình hay ñoäc thaân.                  wrong with this? Is there anything wrong with Chuùng ta coù moät soá kieán thöùc neân töø ñoù khôûi leân        being attached to it? Our lives definitely have moät soá khaùi nieäm ñoái vôùi söï vaät. Taát caû nhöõng          certain conditions. How is this so-called ñieàu kieän naøy chính laø nhöõng caùi reã maø chuùng ta          conditioned life the life of the rootless tree, the nöông vaøo ñoù ñeå toàn taïi. Ñieàu naøy coù gì sai traùi         enlightened life? Zen practitioners should always hay khoâng? Coá chaáp vaøo nhöõng thöù naøy coù gì sai            remember that "Impermanence" is among the traùi hay khoâng? Ñôøi soáng cuûa chuùng ta thöïc söï coù         Buddha's most fundamental teachings. How is moät soá haïn cheá. Ñôøi soáng bò giôùi haïn naøy laøm sao        impermanence generally understood? Instead of coù theå laø coäi caây khoâng reã, laøm sao coù theå laø ñôøi     seeing how everything is constantly changing, we soáng giaùc ngoä? Haønh giaû tu Thieàn neân luoân nhôù            often think that there is something that does not raèng "Voâ thöôøng" laø giaùo phaùp quan troïng nhaát             change. Of course, we recognize certain change cuûa Phaät phaùp. Thay vì nhìn xem moïi vaät bieán                when it is noticeable, such as when there is a chuyeån nhö theá naøo, thì chuùng ta thöôøng nghó raèng           death in our family, or when someone leaves you. coù moät caùi gì ñoù khoâng thay ñoåi. Dó nhieân laø chuùng       But are we aware of constant change or true ta thöøa nhaän moät vaøi thay ñoåi naøo ñoù khi noù roõ           impermanence? Surely no, and consequently we raøng nhö trong gia ñình coù moät ngöôøi quaù vaõng,              live in a self-centered way. This self-centeredness hay phaûi chia ly vôùi ai trong gia ñình. Nhöng                   is not necessarily derogatory of others. We are chuùng ta coù thaät söï tænh thöùc ñöôïc söï thay ñoåi hay        using self-centeredness here to mean that we voâ thöôøng thaät söï hay khoâng? Chaéc chaén laø khoâng,         create distinctions on certain boundaries where vaø vì khoâng thaáy ñöôïc neân haäu quaû laø chuùng ta            there are none. In one way or another, we are all soáng trong söï xem troïng töï ngaõ. Vieäc töï cho mình           self-centered. In one way or another, we are all laø quan troïng khoâng haún laø phaûi xem thöôøng ngöôøi          self-centered. It is obvious that because of these khaùc. Chuùng ta duøng caùi xem troïng töï ngaõ ñeå taïo          conditions, we invite so many problems and ra söï phaân bieät treân nhöõng ñöôøng ranh naøo ñoù khi          afflictions to our own lives. It happens because of maø treân thöïc teá chaúng heà coù phaân bieät hay ranh           this self-centeredness. Zen practitioners should be giôùi naøo caû. Treân phöông dieän naøo ñoù, chuùng ta            very careful! ñeàu cho mình laø quan troïng. Roõ raøng laø do bôûi              Coâng AÙn Tieàn Tam Tam Haäu Tam Tam: Three nhöõng ñieàu kieän naøy maø chuùng ta môøi goïi ñeán              and three before, three and three behind—The cuoäc soáng cuûa chuùng ta quaù nhieàu phieàn naõo. Noù           Dialogue of Manjusri and Wu Cho, example 35 of xaûy ra vì caùi xem troïng töï ngaõ naøy. Haønh giaû tu           the Pi-Yen-Lu—Thí duï thöù 35 cuûa Bích Nham Thieàn phaûi neân luoân caån troïng!—A monk asked                 Luïc. Vaên Thuø hoûi Voâ Tröôùc: "Vöøa rôøi choã naøo?" Chao-Chou, "What is the essential meaning of the                  Voâ Tröôùc ñaùp: "Phöông Nam." Vaên Thuø hoûi: Buddhadharma?" Chao-Chou said, "The cypress                       "Phöông Nam Phaät phaùp truï trì theá naøo?" Voâ tree at the front of the courtyard." That is a line               Tröôùc ñaùp: "Thôøi maït phaùp, Tyø kheo ít giöõ giôùi from the famous Case 37 in the Gateless Gate.                     luaät." Vaên Thuø hoûi: "Chuùng nhieàu ít?" Voâ Tröôùc According to Zen master Dogen in the                              ñaùp: "Hoaëc ba traêm hoaëc naêm traêm." Voâ Tröôùc hoûi "Shobogenzo", Chao-chou's cypress tree in the                     Vaên Thuø: "ÔÛ ñaây truï trì theá naøo?" Vaên Thuø ñaùp: garden as the rootless tree. The very state of                    "Phaøm Thaùnh ñoàng ôû, raén roàng laãn loän." Voâ Tröôùc enlightened life itself is now expressed as this                  hoûi: "Chuùng nhieàu ít?" Vaên Thuø ñaùp: "Tieàn tam rootless tree. How is this rootless tree your life?               tam, haäu tam tam." Nhöõng söï kieän thöïc, ñoái laïi vôùi

nhöõng söï kieän tröøu töôïng (caâu hoûi vaø traû lôøi giöõa    regard for the rules of discipline." Manjusri said, ngaøi Voâ Tröôùc vaø ngaøi Vaên Thuø). Theo Vieân Ngoä          "How numerous are the congregations?" Wu Cho trong Bích Nham Luïc, Voâ Tröôùc daïo Nguõ Ñaøi Sôn,            said, "Some three hundred, some five hundred." ñeán giöõa ñöôøng choã hoang vaéng, Vaên Thuø hoùa moät         Wu Cho asked Manjusri, "How is it being carried caùi chuøa tieáp Sö nghæ ngôi. Cuoäc ñoái ñaùp treân ñaõ        on hereabouts?" Manjusri said, "Ordinary people dieãn ra. Khi uoáng traø, Vaên Thuø ñöa caùi chung pha          and sages dwell together; dragons and snakes leâ hoûi: "Phöông Nam coù caùi naày chaêng?" Voâ Tröôùc         intermingle." Wu Cho said, "How numerous are ñaùp: "Khoâng." Vaên Thuø hoûi: "Bình thöôøng laáy caùi         the congregations?" Manjusri said, "In front, three gì uoáng traø?" Voâ Tröôùc im laëng khoâng traû lôøi ñöôïc,     by three; in back, three by three." Concrete facts beøn töø giaõ ra ñi. Vaên Thuø sai ñoàng töû Quaân Ñeà          as opposed to general abstractions. According to tieãn ra coång. Voâ Tröôùc hoûi Quaân Ñeà: "Vöøa roài noùi      Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, when Wu Cho was 'tieàn tam tam, haäu tam tam' laø nhieàu hay ít?" Quaân         visiting Mount T'ai, when he came to a place on Ñeà goïi: "Ñaïi Ñöùc!" Voâ Tröôùc ñaùp: "Daï!" Quaân Ñeà        the way where it was wild and rough, Manjusri hoûi: "Nhieàu hay ít?" Voâ Tröôùc laïi hoûi: "Ñaây laø          produced a temple to take him in for the night. chuøa gì?" Quaân Ñeà chæ maët sau chuøa Kim Cang.               After finishing the above conversation, they drank Voâ Tröôùc xoay ñaàu nhìn thì chuøa hoùa vaø ñoàng töû          tea, Manjusri held up a crystal bowl and asked, ñeàu aån chaúng thaáy, chæ choã kia laø hang troáng. Sau        "Do they have this in the South?" Wu Cho said, naày goïi laø hang Kim Cang. Coù vò Taêng hoûi Phong            "No." Manjusri said, "What do they usually use to Huyeät: "Theá naøo laø chuû trong nuùi Thanh Löông?"            drink tea?" Wu Cho was speechless. After all he Phong Huyeät ñaùp: "Moät caâu chaúng gaáp Voâ Tröôùc            took his leave and departed. Manjusri ordered hoûi, ñeán nay vaãn laøm Taêng ñoàng queâ." Neáu caàn           Ch'un T'i the servant boy to see him to the gate. tham ñöôïc thaáu ñeán choã bình bình thaät thaät, chaân         When they got to the portals of the gate, Wu Cho ñaïp ñeán choã ñaát thaät, nhaèm döôùi lôøi noùi cuûa Sö        asked the boy, "Before he said, 'In front three by tieán ñöôïc, töï nhieân ôû trong chaûo daàu loø löûa cuõng      three; in back, three by three'; how many is this?" chaúng nghe noùng, ôû treân baêng giaù cuõng chaúng             The boy said, "O Worthy!" Wu Cho responded nghe laïnh. Neáu caàn tham ñöôïc thaáu, cao voùt hieåm          "Yes?" The boy said, "How many is this?" Wu nguy nhö baûo kieám Kim Cang Vöông, neân nhaèm                  Cho also asked, "What temple is this?" The boy döôùi lôøi Vaên Thuø tieán ñöôïc, töï nhieân nöôùc röôùi        pointed beyond the Vajrasattva; when Wu Cho chaúng dính, gioù thoåi chaúng vaøo. Ñòa Taïng Queá             turned his head, the illusory templeand the boy Saâm ôû Chöông Chaâu hoûi moät vò Taêng: "Vöøa rôøi             had vanished completely out of sight: it was just choã naøo?" Vò Taêng thöa: "Phöông Nam." Ñòa Taïng              an empty valley. Later that place was called the hoûi: "Trong kia Phaät phaùp theá naøo?" Vò Taêng thöa:         Vajra or Adamantine Cave. Later on a monk "Tranh caõi oàn naùo." Ñòa Taïng noùi: "Ñaâu nhö ta ôû          asked Feng Hsueh, "What id the Master of Ch'ing ñaây, caáy luùa thoåi côm maø aên." Haõy noùi lôøi ñaùp naày    Liang Mountain?" Hsueh said, "One phrase did cuøng choã ñaùp cuûa Vaên Thuø laø ñoàng hay laø khaùc?         not settle Wu Cho's question; to this very day he is Coù ngöôøi noùi: "Choã ñaùp cuûa Sö chaúng phaûi laø choã       still a monk who sleeps in the fields." If you want ñaùp cuûa Vaên Thuø, vì coøn coù roàng coù raén, coù phaøm      to penetrate the peaceful equanimity of actual coù thaùnh." Hieåu nhö vaäy thì coù gì giao thieäp. Laïi        truth, so that your feet tread upon the real earth, bieän roõ "Tieàn tam tam, haäu tam tam" chaêng? Muõi            go to Wu Cho's words to get attainment; then teân tröôùc coøn nheï, muõi teân sau raát saâu. Haõy noùi laø   naturally though you stay in a cauldron of hot nhieàu hay ít? Neáu nhaèm trong aáy thaáu ñöôïc thì             water or the embers of a stove, still you would not ngaøn caâu muoân caâu chæ laø moät caâu. Neáu ngay döôùi        feel hot, and though you stay on cold ice, neither moät caâu chaët ñöôïc nuùi, naém ñöôïc ñöùng, chính luùc        would you feel cold. If you want to go through to aáy ñeán ñöôïc caûnh giôùi naày—Manjusri asked Wu               use the solitary peril, the steep and sharp, like the Cho, "Where have you just come from?" Wu Cho                    Jewel Sword of Diamond King, go to Majusri's said, "The South." Manjusri said, "How is the                   words to get attainment; then naturally water Buddhist Teaching being carried on in the South?"               poured will not wet, and wind blowing cannot Wu Cho said, "Monks of the Last Age have little                 enter. Have you not seen how Ti Tsang of Cheng

Chou asked a monk, "Where have you just come                     toâng sö ñem röøng gai goùc nhieäm ngöôøi. Vì sao? from?" The monk said, "The Souht." Ti Tsang                      Bôûi vì neáu ôû döôùi caâu thöôøng tình nghieäm ngöôøi said, "How is Buddhism there?" The monk said,                    chaúng ñöôïc. Haøng Thieàn khaùch caàn phaûi trong caâu "There is much deliberation." Ti Tsang said, "How                trình cô, trong lôøi bieän muïc ñích. Neáu laø keû gaùnh can that compare with us here plowing fields and                 baûn, phaàn ñoâng nhaèm trong caâu maø cheát, nghe noùi having a lot of rice to eat?" Now tell me, is this the           deïp heát coå hoïng moâi löôõi thì khoâng coù choã môû same as Manjusri's answer, or is it different?                   mieäng. Neáu laø ngöôøi bieán thoâng, coù loái soáng ngöôïc Some say that Wu Cho's answers were wrong,                       nöôùc, chæ nhaèm treân caâu hoûi coù loái ñi, tay chaúng bò while in Manjusri's answers there is both snake                  thöông tích. Qui Sôn thöa: "Trong tröôøng hôïp ñoù, and dragon, there is both the ordinary and the                   thænh Hoøa Thöôïng noùi." Haõy noùi yù nghóa theá naøo? sage. What bearing does this have on it? Can you                 Trong ñaây nhö choïi ñaù nhaùng löûa, tôï laøn ñieän clearly discern three by three in front, three by                chôùp, nhaân choã hoûi kia lieàn ñaùp, töï coù con ñöôøng three in back? The first arrow will still light; the             xuaát thaân, chaúng toán maûy may khí löïc. Vì theá môùi second arrow went deep. Now tell me, how many                    noùi, kia tham caâu soáng chaúng tham caâu cheát. Baùch is this? If you can pass through here, then a                    Tröôïng chaúng bieän kia, chæ noùi khoâng ngaïi noùi vôùi thousand phrases, ten thousand phrases, are only                 oâng, chæ e veà sau naøy maát heát con chaùu cuûa ta. Khi one phrase. If at this one phrase you can cut off                caùc baäc toâng sö vì ngöôøi phaûi nhoå ñinh thaùo choát. and hold still, in the next moment you will reach                Nhö ngöôøi nay noùi: "Ñaùp naøy chaúng thöøa nhaän, kia this realm.                                                      khoâng laõnh thoaïi. Ñaâu chaúng bieát trong ñaây, moät Coâng AÙn Tính Khöôùc Yeát Haàu Thaàn Vaãn, Taùc                 ñöôøng sanh cô, vaùch ñöùng ngaøn nhaãn, khaùch chuû Ma Sinh Ñaïo?: How can you speak without your                    laãn keùo, soáng linh ñoäng."—One day Kuei-Shan, throat, lips and tongue?—Laøm theá naøo noùi ñöôïc               Wu-feng, and Yun-yen were all attending Pai- maø khoâng caàn ñeán coå hoïng, moâi vaø löôõi—Moät              chang. Pai-chang asked Kuei-Shan, "How can you hoâm Qui Sôn, Nguõ Phong, Vaân Nham cuøng ñöùng                  speak without your throat, lips, and tongue?" haàu Baùch Tröôïng. Baùch Tröôïng hoûi Qui Sôn:                  Kuei-Shan said, "Well, Master, in that case, you "Laøm theá naøo noùi ñöôïc maø khoâng caàn ñeán coå              say it, please." Pai-chang replied, "I don't mind hoïng, moâi vaø löôõi?" Qui Sôn noùi: "Trong tröôøng             saying it to you, but I don't want to murder my hôïp ñoù, môøi thaày noùi cho." Baùch Tröôïng ñaùp: "Ta          posterity." This is an "implicit-negative" koan, a khoâng ngaïi noùi cho caùc oâng, nhöng ta khoâng muoán           kind of koan that illustrates Zen-Truth through gieát boïn haäu sinh." Ñaây laø loaïi coâng aùn "maëc            "nullifying" or abrogating expression. With this nhieân phuû nhaän", nghóa laø, loaïi coâng aùn giaûi minh        type of koan, we usually accuse the Zen masters chaân lyù Thieàn baèng loái phaùt bieåu hö hoùa hoaëc pheá       of being negatory. But in fact, they did not negate boû. Vôùi loaïi coâng aùn naøy, chuùng ta thöôøng caùo           anything. What they have done is to point out our buoäc caùc Thieàn sö laø phuû nhaän. Nhöng kyø thaät hoï         delusions in thinking of the non-existent as chaúng phuû nhaän gì caû, nhöõng gì hoï ñaõ laøm chæ             existent, and the existent as non-existent, and so nhaèm ñeå vaïch roõ ra caùc aûo töôûng cuûa chuùng ta cho        on. According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, in voâ höõu laø höõu, höõu laø voâ höõu, vaân vaân. Theo Vieân      example 70 of the Pi-Yen-Lu, although Pai-chang Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc, trong thí duï thöù 70 cuûa            acted like this, his pot had already been carried off Bích Nham Luïc, Baùch Tröôïng tuy laø haønh söû nhö              by someone else. He also asked Wu-feng this theá, caùi noài cuûa oâng ñaõ bò ngöôøi khaùc cöôùp maát roài,   same question. Wu-feng said, "Teacher, you too oâng xoay qua hoûi Nguõ Phong. Nguõ Phong thöa:                  should shut up." Pai-chang said, "Where there's no "Hoøa Thöôïng cuõng phaûi nín luoân." Baùch Tröôïng              one, I shade my eyes with my hand and gaze out noùi: "Choã khoâng ngöôøi vaïch traùn nhìn oâng." Baùch          towards you." Pai-chang also asked Yun-yen the Tröôïng laïi hoûi Vaân Nham. Vaân Nham thöa: "Hoøa               same question. Yun-yen said, "Teacher, do you Thöôïng coù hay chöa?" Baùch Tröôïng noùi: "Maát heát            have any way to speak or not?" Pai-chang said, "I con chaùu cuûa ta. Ba ngöôøi moãi vò moät nhaø." Coå             have lost my descendants." Each of these three nhaân noùi: "Treân ñaát baèng ngöôøi cheát voâ soá, qua          men was a teacher. An ancient said, "On the level ñöôïc röøng gai goùc laø ngöôøi tay kheùo." Vì theá haøng        ground there are dead people without number.

Those who can pass through the forest of brambles          Sö noùi: "Phaùp sö queø, noùi ñöôïc ñi chaúng ñöôïc." are the skillful ones." Therefore teachers of our          Sau ñoù Sö ñi ñeán phaùp ñöôøng keâu thò giaû ñaùnh school use the forest of brambles to test people.          chuoâng hoïp chuùng. Chuùng Taêng tuï hoïp, Sö noùi: Why? Because they couldn't test people if they             "Laïi bieát laõo Taêng chaêng?" Chuùng khoâng bieát ñaùp stuck to phrases based on ordinary feelings.               theá naøo. Sö neùm naïng caây, ngoài ngay thaúng an Patchrobed monks must be able to display their             nhieân thò tòch—The koan about the potentiality ability in phrases and discern the point within            and conditions of questions and answers Zen words. As for board-carrying fellows, they often           master Hsing-hua Ts'un-chiang and his assembly die within the words and say, "If throat, mouth,           at the time he was going to pass away. According and lips are shut, there's no longer a way to say          to the Records of the Transmission of the Lamp anything." As for those who can adapt                      (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), Volume XII, the emperor successfully, they have waves which go against             T'ang Zhuang-Ts'ung honored master Hsing-hua the current, they have a single road right in the          with the gift of a riding horse. While the master question. They don't cut their hands blundering            was riding the horse it was startled and the master against its sharp point. Kuei-shan said, "Please,          fell off, injuring his foot. Hsing-hua gave teacher, you speak instead." What did Kuei-shan            instruction to the monastery director, saying, mean? Here he was like sparks struck from stone,           "Make me a walking stick." The monastery like a flash of lightning, pressing back against Pai-      director made the stick and brought it to Hsing- chang's question, he answered immediately. He              hua. The master took the stick and proceeded to had his own way to get himself out, without                circle the Dharma hall, and as he did so he asked wasting the slightest effort. Thus it is said, "He         the monks, "Do you recognize me?" The monks studies the living phrase; he doesn't study the dead       answered, "How could we not recognize you?" phrase." Nevertheless, Pai-chang did not take him          The master said, "Dharma Master Foot! He can up on it, but just said, "I don't refuse to speak to       speak but he can't walk." Hsing-hua then went to you, but I fear that if I did, in the future I would be    the hall and instructed his attendant to ring the bell bereft of descendants." Whenever teachers of our           and assemble the monks. Hsing-hua then school help people, they pull out nails and extract        addressed the monks, saying, "Do you recognize pegs. As for people these days who say that this           me?" The monks didn't know what to say. Hsing- answer doesn't approve of Kuei-shan and doesn't            hua then threw down the staff and peacefully comprehend his words, how far they are from                passed away in an upright position. knowing that right here is the one path of his             Coâng AÙn Trang Toâng Ñaéc Baûo: Emperor T'ang living potential, towering up like a thousand              Zhuang-Ts'ung obtained a precious pearl—Theo fathom wall, interchanging guest and host, leaping         Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån XII, moät hoâm, with life.                                                 Vua Ñöôøng Trang Toâng noùi vôùi Thieàn sö Höng Coâng AÙn Toøng Thaåm Taåy Cöôùc: Ts'ung-Sheân: I          Hoùa Toàn Töông: "Traãm thu phuïc nhaân taâm xöù Ñaïi am washing my feet—See Toøng Thaåm Taåy Cöôùc.             Löông, ñöôïc moät vieân minh chaâu voâ giaù, tôùi giôø Coâng AÙn Toàn Töông Phi Maõ: Ts'un-chiang's               chöa coù ngöôøi traû giaù." Sö Höng Hoùa noùi: "Xin Beä galloping a horse—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô duyeân vaán        haï cho laõo Taêng xem haït chaâu naøy!" Vua Trang ñaùp giöõa Thieàn sö Höng Hoùa Toàn Töông vaø Taêng        Toâng im laëng môû khaên bòt ñaàu. Sö Höng Hoù a lieàn chuùng vaøo phuùt Sö saép thò tòch. Theo Caûnh Ñöùc        noùi: "Vaät baùu cuûa Beä haï ai daùm traû giaù!"— Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån XII, Vua Ñöôøng Trang           According to the Records of the Transmission of Toâng ban cho Sö moät con ngöïa. Trong luùc côõi           the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), Volume XII, one ngöïa, Sö chôït bò ngöïa quaêng teù gaõy chaân. Sö goïi:   day, the emperor T'ang Zhuang-Ts'ung told Zen "Vieän Chuû! Chuoát cho ta moät caây naïng." Vieän chuû    master Hsing-hua: "I won over the people of Ta chuoát naïng xong, ñem ñeán cho Sö. Sö caëp naïng ñi       Liang and got an invaluable precious pearl, but so voøng quanh phaùp ñöôøng, Sö hoûi Taêng chuùng: "Caùc      far nobody has yet bargains." Hsing-hua said, oâng coù nhaän ra laõo Taêng khoâng?" Chuùng Taêng         "Your Majesty, would you please let this old ñaùp: "Laøm sao maø khoâng nhaän ra Hoøa Thöôïng?"         monk see it!" Emperor T'ang Zhuang-Ts'ung

silently opened his kerchief. Hsing-hua                         vì kia ñaõ tham kieán Muïc Chaâu roài. Moät hoâm, oân g immediately said, "Your Majesty, nobody dare to                 ñeán tham kieán Töø Phöôùc. Töø Phöôùc thaáy oâng laïi, bargain your invaluable precious pearl!"                        lieàn veõ moät voøng troøn. Töø Phöôùc laø toân tuùc döôùi Coâng AÙn Traàn Thaùo Ñoäc Nhaõn: Ch'en Ts'ao's                 doøng Qui Ngöôõng, bình thöôøng thích laáy caûnh tieáp just one eye, example 33 of the Pi-Yen-Lu—Thí                   ngöôøi, thaáy Traàn Thaùo lieàn veõ moät voøng troøn. Ñaâu duï thöù 33 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Thöôïng thö Traàn              ngôø Traàn Thaùo laø haøng taùc gia chaúng bò ngöôøi löøa, Thaùo ñeán tham vaán Töø Phöôùc. Töø Phöôùc thaáy laïi,         kheùo töï kieåm ñieåm noùi, ñeä töû ñeán theá aáy, sôùm ñaõ lieàn veõ moät voøng troøn. Traàn Thaùo noùi: "Ñeä töû laïi     chaúng tieän, ñaâu kham laïi veõ moät voøng troøn. Tö theá aáy, sôùm ñaõ chaúng ñöôïc tieän, huoáng laø laïi veõ      Phöôùc ñoùng cöûa phöông tröôïng. Loaïi coâng aùn naøy moät voøng troøn." Töø Phöôùc lieàn ñoùng cöûa phöông           goïi laø "Trong lôøi bieän ñích, trong caâu taøng cô." tröôïng. Tuyeát Ñaäu noùi Traàn Thaùo chæ ñuû moät con          Tuyeát Ñaäu noùi: "Traàn Thaùo ñuû moät con maét." maét. Theo Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc,                     Tuyeát Ñaäu ñaùng goïi laø coù con maét treân ñænh. Haõy Thöôïng thö Traàn Thaùo cuøng Buøi Höu, Lyù Cao laø             noùi yù taïi choã naøo? Cuõng kheùo cho moät voøng troøn. ñoàng thôøi. Thaáy Taêng ñeán, oâng tröôùc thænh thoï trai,     Neáu thaûy theá aáy thì nhaø Thieàn laøm sao vì ngöôøi? keá cuùng ba traêm tieàn, sau khaùm bieän. Moät hoâm            Toâi thöû hoûi oâng, khi aáy neá u caùc oâng laø Traàn Thaùo Vaân Moân ñeán tham kieán nhau, oâng hoûi: "Saùch Nho           neân thoát ra nhöõng lôøi gì ñeå khoûi bò Tuyeát Ñaäu noùi thì chaúng hoûi, tam thöøa möôøi hai phaàn giaùo töï coù        chæ ñuû moät con maét?—Ch'en Ts'ao, ministry toïa chuû, theá naøo laø vieäc haønh cöôùc trong nhaø           president, went to see Tzu Fu. When Tzu Fu saw Thieàn?" Vaân Moân hoûi: "Thöôïng thö töøng hoûi bao            him coming, he immediately drew a circle. Ts'ao nhieâu ngöôøi roài?" Traàn Thaùo noùi: "Chính nay hoûi          said, "My coming here like this has already Thöôïng Toïa." Vaân Moân baûo: "Chính nay haõy gaùc             missed the point; how much more so, to go on and laïi, theá naøo laø giaùo yù?" Traàn Thaùo noùi: "Quyeån        draw a circle!" Tzu Fu thereupon closed the door vaøng truïc ñoû." Vaân Moân baûo: "Caùi naày laø vaên töï       of his room. Hsueh Tou said, "Ch'en Ts'ao has just ngöõ ngoân, theá naøo laø giaùo yù?" Traàn Thaùo noùi:          one eye." According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen- "Mieäng muoán baøn maø lôøi maát, taâm muoán duyeân             Lu, ministry president Ch'en Ts'ao was a maø löï queân." Vaân Moân baûo: "Mieäng muoán baøn maø          contemporary of P'ei Hsiu and Li ao. Whenever lôøi maát laø ñoái höõu ngoân, taâm muoán duyeân maø löï        he saw a monk come, he would give him three queân laø ñoái voïng töôûng, theá naøo laø giaùo yù?" Traàn     hundred cash, wishing thereby to test the monk. Thaùo khoâng noùi ñöôïc lôøi naøo nöõa. Vaân Moân hoûi:         One day Yun Men came; seeing him, Ch'en Ts'ao "Nghe noùi Thöôïng thö xem kinh Phaùp Hoa phaæ                  immediately asked, "I do not ask about what is in chaêng?" Traàn Thaùo Noùi: "Phaûi." Vaân Moân baûo:             the Confucian books, and the twelve part "Trong kinh noùi 'Taát caû trò sanh saûn nghieäp ñeàu           teachings of the three vehicles have their own cuøng thaät töôùng chaúng traùi nhau,' haõy noùi phi phi        professors: what is the purpose of a patchrobed töôûng Thieân hieän nay coù bao nhieâu ngöôøi thoái vò?"        monk's journey on foot?" Yun Men said, "How Traàn Thaùo laïi khoâng noùi ñöôïc lôøi naøo nöõa. Vaân         many people have you asked?" Ch'en Ts'ao said, Moân baûo: "Thöôïng thö chôù coù thoâ xuaát, thieàn Taêng       "I am asking you right now." Yun Men said, neùm heát tam kinh nguõ luaän vaøo tuøng laâm möôøi             "Leaving aside right now for the moment, what is naêm hai möôi naêm coøn chöa ñöôïc gì, Thöôïng thö              the meaning of the teachings?" Ch'en Ts'ao said, laïi laøm sao ñöôïc hoäi?" Traàn Thaùo leã baùi roài noùi:      "Yellow scrolls on red rollers." Yun Men said, "Toâi toäi loãi." Laïi moät hoâm, Traàn Thaùo cuø ng quan       "These are written words and letters: what is the lieâu leân laàu, troâng thaáy moät soá Taêng ñi ñeán. Moät vò   meaning of the teachings?" Ch'en Ts'ao said, quan noùi: "Ñeán ñoù ñeàu laø thieàn Taêng." Traàn Thaùo        "When the mouth wishes to speak of it, words baûo: "Chaúng phaûi." Vò quan hoûi: "Sao bieát chaúng           flee; when the mind seeks affinity with it, thought phaûi?" Traàn Thaùo baûo: "Ñôïi ñeán gaàn vì oâng khaùm         vanishes." Yun Men said, "'When the mouth phaù." Chuùng Taêng ñeán tröôùc laàu, Traàn Thaùo goïi to:      wishes to speak of it, words flee the mind seeks "Thöôïng Toïa!" Chuùng Taêng ngöôùc ñaàu nhìn. Traàn            affinity with it, thought vanishes' is to refer to Thaùo baûo quan lieâu: "Toâi noùi maø chaúng tin." Chæ          maintaining verbalization; 'when the the mind coù moät mình Vaân Moân, oâng khaùm phaù chaúng ñöôïc,          seeks affinity with it, thought vanishes' is to refer

to false conceptualization. What is the meaning of      meaning lie? Tzu Fu should have produced the teachings?" Ch'en Ts'ao was speechless. Yun         another circular figure; but if he always acted like Men said, "I have heard it said that you read the       this, how could a patch-robed monk benefit Lotus of Truth scripture; is this true or not?" Ch'en   others? Now let me ask you, if you were Ch'en Ts'ao said, "True." Yun Men said, "In that              Ts'ao at that moment, what could you have said in scripture it says that all livelihood and productive    order to avoid Hsueh Tou's saying that he has just labor are not contrary to the characteristics of        one eye? reality. But tell me, in the heaven that is beyond      Coâng AÙn Trí Moân Baùt Nhaõ Theå: Chih Men's thought and thoughtlessness, right now how many         Body of Wisdom—Thí duï thöù 90 cuûa Bích Nham people fall back from that position?" Ch'en Ts'ao       Luïc cho chuùng ta thaáy Trí Moân vaø loái vaán ñaùp cuûa again was speechless. Yun Men said, "Do not be          oâng vôùi ñeä töû. Moät nhaø sö hoûi Trí Moân: “Vaät theå so careless. A real monk abandons the three             cuûa söï khoân ngoan laø gì?” (theá naøo laø Baùt Nhaõ scriptures and five discourses to enter a               theå?). Trí Moân ñaùp: “Con ngao coù sao Kim mang monastery; after ten or twenty years, he still can      trong mình noù traêng saùng.” (con ngao ngaäm traêng do nothing himself. So how could you, ministry          saùng). Nhaø sö hoûi: “Hieäu quaû cuûa söï khoân ngoan president, be able to understand?" Ch'en Ts'ao          laø gì?” (theá naøo laø Baùt Nhaõ duïng?). Trí Moân ñaùp: bowed and said, "I am at fault." Also one day as        “Con thoû caùi chôø luõ thoû con.” (Con thoû mang thai). Ch'en Ts'ao had climbed up in a tower with a            Theo Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc, khi thieàn sö group of officials, they looked out and saw several     Trí Moân ñaùp: "Con ngao ngaäm traêng saù ng, con thoû monks coming. One of the officials said, "Those         mang thai," troïn duøng yù Trung thu. Tuy nhieân nhö people approaching are all Ch'an monks." Ch'en          theá, coå nhaân yù chaúng ôû treân con ngao, con thoû. Trí Ts'ao said, "No, they're not." The official said,       Moân laø haøng toân tuùc cuûa toâng Vaân Moân, moät caâu "How do you know they're not?" Ch'en Ts'ao said,        noùi phaûi ñuû ba caâu: haøm caùi caøn khoân, tieät ñoaïn "Wait till they come near, and I will put them to a     chuùng löu, vaø tuøy ba truïc laõng, cuõng chaúng an baøi, test for you." When the monks reached the foot of       töï nhieân vöøa vaën, lieàn ñeán choã hieåm. Lôøi Trí Moân the tower, Ch'en Ts'ao suddenly called out, "O          ñaùp cho vò Taêng naày löôïc baøy ñoâi chuùt phaàn muõi Elders!" The monks raised their heads. Ch'en            nhoïn, haún laø phi thöôøng. Choã ñaùp cuûa coå nhaân Ts'ao said to the group of officials, "Didn't you       khoâng coù nhieàu vieäc, trung thu traêng moïc, thoû haù believe what I said?" There was only one man,           mieäng nuoát aùnh saùng maët traêng lieàn thoï thai, trong Yun Men, whom Ch'en Ts'ao could not expose.             mieäng sanh ra con, traêng saùng thì sanh nhieàu, traêng Ch'en Ts'ao had see Mu Chou. One day he went to         toái thì sanh ít. Coå nhaân chæ möôïn yù kia ñeå ñaùp aùnh call upon Tzu Fu. When Tzu Fu saw him coming,           saùng Baùt Nhaõ. Tuy nhieân, coå nhaân chaúng phaûi ôû he immediately drew a circle. Tzu Fu was an             treân ngoân cuù, töï laø ngöôøi sau chaïy treân ngoân cuù ñeå honorable adept in the Kuei-Yang lineage; he            kieám soáng maø thoâi. Baøn Sôn noùi: "Taâm nguyeät always liked to use the meeting of perspectives to      rieâng troøn, saùng truøm muoân töôïng, saùng khoâng deal with people. When he saw the ministry              chieáu caûnh, caûnh cuõng chaúng coøn, saùng caûnh ñeàu president Ch'en Ts'ao coming, he thereupon drew         queân, laïi laø vaät gì?" Ngöôøi ñôøi nay chæ tröøng maét a circular figure. But what could he do? Ch'en          goïi laø saùng, ñi treân tình giaûi, trong khoâng trung maø Ts'ao was after all an adept, and didn't submit to      ñoùng ñinh. Coå nhaân noùi: "Taát caû caùc oâng ôû cöûa saùu the deceit of others; he knew himself how to make       caên ngaøy ñeâm phoùng ñaïi quang minh, chieáu phaù a test; he said, "My coming here like this has          nuùi soâng ñaïi ñòa, khoâng nhöõng chæ nhaõn caên phoùng already missed the point; how is it worth going on      quang, tyû thieät thaân yù ñeàu phoùng quang." Ñeán to draw a circle?" Tzu Fu closed the door. This         trong ñaây phaûi nhoài ñaäp saùu caên khoâng coøn moät kind of public case is called "discerning the target    vieäc, loät traàn baøy loà loä, môùi thaáy ñöôïc choã rôi cuûa within the words, concealing ability within a           caâu naày vaäy!—Example 90 of the Pi-Yen-Lu phrase." Hsueh Tou says, "Ch'en Ts'ao has just          shows us Master Chih-Men in a conversation with one eye." Hsueh Tou may be said to have an eye          his disciples as followed: A monk asked Chih- on his forehead. But tell me, where does his            Men, “What is the wisdom body?” Chi-Men said,

“The Venus mussel bears the bright moon in it.”         ra khoûi nöôùc thì theá naøo?" Trí Moân ñaùp: "Hoa The monk asked, “And what is the effect of              sen." Vò Taêng laïi hoûi: "Sau khi ra khoûi nöôùc thì theá wisdom?” Chih-Men said, “The female hare gets           naøo?" Trí Moân ñaùp: "Laù coïng." Trí Moân laø moät pregnant.” According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-          trong nhöõng thieàn sö ñaàu tieân duøng thô ca ngôïi Lu, when Chih Men said, "An oyster swallowing           nhöõng caâu chaâm ngoân hay lôøi daïy cuûa caùc thaày the bright moon, and a rabbit getting pregnant," he     thôøi xöa, ñaây laø moät ngheä thuaät maø sau naày hoïc used a mid-autumn sense; even so, the Ancient's         troø cuûa oâng laø Tuyeát Ñaäu coøn vöôït troäi hôn oâng meaning was not in the oyster or the rabbit. As         nöõa. Theo Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc, Trí Chih Men was a venerable adept in the                   Moân neáu laø öùng cô tieáp vaät, coøn xa ñoâi phaàn. Neáu congregation of Yun Men, each of his phrase had         laø caét ñöùt caùc doøng thì ngaøn daëm muoân daëm. Haõy to contain three phrases; that is, the phrase that      noùi, hoa sen ra khoûi nöôùc cuøng chöa ra khoûi nöôùc, contain heaven and earth, that phrase that cuts off     laø moät laø hai? Neáu theá aáy thaáy ñöôïc, höùa oâng coù the myriad stream, and the phrase that follows the      choã vaøo. Tuy nhieân nhö theá, neáu noùi laø moät thì laãn waves. Moreover, without using any prearranged          loän Phaät taùnh, loän xoän chaân nhö. Neáu noùi laø hai thì maneuvers, each of his phrase is spontaneously          taâm caûnh chöa queân, rôi treân ñöôøng giaûi, chaïy bieát appropriate. Thus he went to the danger point to        bao giôø döøng. Thöû noùi yù coå nhaân theá naøo? Kyø thaät answer this monk's questions, showing a bit of his      khoâng coù nhieàu vieäc. Vì theá Ñaàu Töû noùi: "OÂng chæ sharp point, he was undeniably extraordinary.           chôù keït danh ngoân soá cuù, neáu roõ caùc vieäc töï nhieân That Ancient's, in mid-autumn when the moon             chaúng keït, töùc khoâng coù nhieàu vò thöù chaúng ñoàng, comes out, the rabbits open their mouths and            oâng nhieáp taát caû phaùp, taát caû phaùp nhieáp oâng swallow its light, thus becoming pregnant. Here         chaúng ñöôïc, voán khoâng ñöôïc maát, moäng huyeãn too, if there's moonlight the offspring are many;       danh muïc nhieàu nhö theá, khoâng neân gaéng göôïng vì without a moon, they're few. The Ancient jus            noù an laäp danh töø, doái gaït caùc oâng ñöôïc chaêng? Vì made temporary use of these meanings to answer          caùc oâng hoûi neân coù noùi, neáu caùc oâng chaúng hoûi, about the light of wisdom. Although his answer          baûo toâi nhaèm caùc oâng noùi caùi gì? Chính ñöôïc taát caû was this way, his meaning wasn't in the words and       vieäc ñeàu do caùc oâng ñem ñöôïc ñeán, troïn chaúng can phrases. It's just that later people go to his words    gì vieäc cuûa ta." Coå nhaân noùi: "Muoán bieát nghóa to make a living. P'an Shan said, "The mind-moon        Phaät taùnh, phaæ xem thôøi tieát nhaân duyeân." Vaân is solitary and full: its light engulfs the myriad      Moân nhaéc vieäc Taêng hoûi Linh Vaân: "Khi Phaät forms. The light is not shining on objects. Nor do      chöa ra ñôøi thì theá naøo?" Linh Vaân döïng ñöùng caây the objects exist. Light and objects both forgotten.    phaát töû. Vò Taêng hoûi: "Sau khi ra ñôøi thì theá naøo?" Then what is this?" People these days just stare        Linh Vaân cuõng döïng ñöùng caây phaát töû. Vaân Moân and call this the light: from their feelings they       noùi: "Ñaàu tröôùc ñaùnh ñöôïc, ñaàu sau ñaùnh chaúng produce interpretations, driving spikes into empty      ñöôïc." Laïi noùi: "Chaúng noùi ra ñôøi cuøng chaúng ra space. An Ancient said, "Day and night all of you       ñôøi." Choã naøo coù thôøi tieát y hoûi: "Coå nhaân moät hoûi people release a great light from the gates of your     moät ñaùp, hôïp thôøi hôïp tieát, khoâng coù nhieàu vieäc. six senses; it shines through mountains, rivers, and    Neáu oâng tìm lôøi theo caâu, troïn khoâng giao thieäp. the great earth. It's not only your eyes that release   Neáu oâng trong lôøi noùi thaáu ñöôïc lôøi noùi, trong yù light, nose, tongue, body and mind also all release     thaáu ñöôïc yù, trong cô thaáu ñöôïc cô, buoâng ñi khieán light." To get here you simply must clean up your       ñöôïc thaûnh thôi, môùi thaáy choã ñaùp thoaïi cuûa Trí six sense faculties so that you're without the          Moân." Nhöõng caâu hoûi: Khi Phaät chöa ra ñôøi thì theá slightest concern, purified and naked, free and         naøo? Khi Ngöu Ñaàu chöa thaáy Toå thì theá naøo? Khi unbound, only then will you see where this story is     laãn loän trong ñaù hoãn ñoän chöa phaân thì theá naøo? at!                                                     Khi cha meï chöa sanh thì theá naøo? Vaân Moân noùi: Coâng AÙn Trí Moân Lieân Hoa Haø Dieäp: Chih-           "Töø xöa ñeán nay chæ laø moät ñoaïn söï, khoâng phaûi Men's Lotus Flower, Lotus Leaves, example 21 of         khoâng quaáy, khoâng ñöôïc khoâng maát, khoâng sanh the Pi-Yen-Lu—Thí duï thöù 21 cuûa Bích Nham            cuøng chöa sanh." Coå nhaân ñeán trong aáy tung moät Luïc. Moät vò Taêng hoûi Trí Moân: "Khi hoa sen chöa    caùi, noùi: "Coù ra coù vaøo. Neáu laø ngöôøi chöa lieãu thì

sôø reøm moø vaùch, nöông coû gaù caây. Hoaëc daïy y          you descend to travel the road of interpretation. buoâng saïch ñi, hoaëc ñaùnh cho y chaïy vaøo röøng           When will you ever cease? Tell me, what is the hoang raäm raïp meânh moâng. Neáu laø ngöôøi ñöôïc            ancient's meaning? In reality there aren't so many suoát 12 giôø chaúng gaù nöông moät vaät, tuy chaúng gaù      concerns. That is why T'ou Tzu said, "Just don't nöông moät vaät, maø baøy moät cô moät caûnh laøm sao         attach names and words, classification and moø tìm?" OÂng Taêng naày hoûi: "Khi hoa sen chöa ra          phrasing. If you have understood all things, khoûi nöôùc thì theá naøo?" Trí Moân ñaùp: "Hoa sen."         naturally you won't be attached to them. Then Ñoù chæ laø ngaên hoûi. Moät caâu ñaùp naày quaû laø phi      there is no multiplicity of gradations of thöôøng. Caùc nôi ñeàu goïi laø lôøi ñieân ñaûo, trong aáy    differences; you take in all things; but all things nhö theá. Nham Ñaàu noùi: "Thöôøng quí tröôùc khi             won't be able to take you in. Fundamentally there chöa môû mieäng, vaãn coøn so saùnh ñoâi phaàn. Coå           is no gain or loss, no illusions or dreams, no nhaân baøy cô ñaõ laø loù ñuoâi roài." Hieän nay, hoïc giaû   multiplicity of names. You should not insist on chaúng hieåu yù coå nhaân, chæ caàn lyù luaän, ñaõ ra khoûi   setting up names for them. Can I fool all of you nöôùc cuøng chöa ra khoûi nöôùc, coù dính daùng chuùt         people? Since all of you ask questions, therefore naøo? Coù vò Taêng hoûi Trí Moân: "Theá naøo laø Baùt         there are words. If you don't ask, what could you Nhaõ theå?" Trí Moân ñaùp: "Con trai ngaäm traêng             have me say that would be right? Al concerns are saùng." Vò Taêng hoûi: "Theá naøo laø Baùt Nhaõ duïng?"       what you "take up: none of it is any business." Trí Moân ñaùp: "Con thoû mang thai." Xem Trí Moân             Haven't you seen Yun Men cite this story: A monk ñoái ñaùp nhö theá, ngöôøi khaép thieân haï thaûo luaän veà   asked Ling Yun, "How was it before the Buddha ngöõ maïch cuûa Sö chaúng ñöôïc. Hoaëc coù ngöôøi hoûi        appeared in the world?" Ling Yun raised his Giaùp Sôn: "Khi hoa sen chöa ra khoûi nöôùc thì theá          whisk. The monk asked, "What about after the naøo?" Giaùp Sôn ñaùp: "Coät caùi, loàng ñeøn." Haõy noùi     Buddha appeared in the world?" Again Ling Yun cuøng hoa sen laø ñoàng laø dò? Taêng hoûi: "Sau khi ra       raised his whisk. Yun Men said, "The first time he khoûi nöôùc thì theá naøo?" Sö ñaùp: "Ñaàu gaäy kheâu         hit, the second time he missed." He also said, nhaät nguyeät, döôùi chaân sình raát saâu." OÂng thöû noù i   "Without speaking of appearing and not phaûi hay chaúng phaûi? Qua thí duï naày coå nhaân            appearing, where would be the time of his muoán nhaén nhuû haønh giaø chôù laàm nhaän traùi caân        asking?" With one answer for one question the baøn (moät tieâu chuaån coá ñònh), maø phaûi ñaäp phaù        ancients accorded with the time and season tình traàn—A monk asked Chih Men, "How is it                  without a multitude of concerns. If you pursue when the lotus flower has not yet emerged from                words and follow after phrases, there will never the water?" Chih Men said, "A Lotus flower." The              be any connection. If in the midst of words you monk said, "What about after it has emerged from              can penetrate through words, if in the midst of the water?" Chih Men said, "Lotus Leaves." Zen                meanings you can pass through meanings, if master Kuang-Zuo Zhi-Men was one of the first                 within a device you can penetrate through the masters of Ch’an tradition to celebrate the words             device, and if you let go and let yourself be at of the old masters in poetic form, and art at which           ease, only then will you see Chih Men's his disciple Hsueh-T’ou was even better than his              answer.Yun Men said, "From ancient times till teacher. According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu,               today, it's just been one thing. There is no right or as for dealing with people in accordance with their           wrong, no gain or loss, no born or not born." When potentials, Chih Men has attained a little. When it           they got here the ancients laid down one single comes to cutting off the myriad streams, he's a               path where there's an entrance and an exit. If it's a million miles away. But say, is this flower before            man who hasn't yet understood, then he's pressing and after it emerges from the water the same or               against a fence, running his hands over a wall, like different? If you can see this way, I'll grant that           a ghost haunting the weeds and trees. If you make you've had an entry. Nevertheless, if you say it's            him let go, he still goes into the wild vast the same, you confuse your Buddha-nature and                  desolation. If it is a man who has attained, then becloud true thusness. If you say it's different,             twenty-four hours a day he won't depend on a mind and environment are not yet forgotten, and               single thing. While he doesn't depend on a single

thing, when he reveals one device, one object,                nhaãn, choã ñaùp cuõng chaúng nheï hôn. Neáu nhö theá how will you search him out? This monk asked,                 aáy hoäi, chính laø ñöông ñaàu; neáu chaúng theá aáy hoäi, "How is it when the lotus flowers have not yet                chôù khôûi so tính ñaïo lyù. Ñaâu chaúng thaáy Toâng Ñaïo emerged from the water?" Chih Men said, "A                    giaû truï Ñaàu Töû, luùc coøn ôû trong hoäi Tuyeát Ñaäu laøm Lotus flower." This then is just an answer that               thô kyù, Tuyeát Ñaäu daïy tham "Chí ñaïo khoâng khoù, blocks the question, nevertheless it's exceptional.           duy hieàm giaûn traïch", nôi ñaây coù tænh. Moät hoâm, All over it's called "upside-down words." How so?             Tuyeát Ñaäu hoûi: "Chí ñaïo khoâng khoù, duy hieàm Haven't you heard: Yen T'ou said, "I always hope              giaûn traïch, yù nghóa theá naøo?" Toâng Ñaïo noùi: "Suùc you would attain a little before you open your                sanh, suùc sanh." Veà sau, Toâng Ñaïo ôû aån taïi Ñaàu mouths." Where the ancient one Chih Men                       Töû, phaøm ñi ôû ñeàu laáy caø sa goùi giaày coû chung vôùi revealed his mind, he was already leaking and                 kinh saùch. Coù vò Taêng hoûi: "Theá naøo laø toâng phong tarrying. Students these days don't wake up to the            cuûa Ñaïo giaû?" Toâng Ñaïo ñaùp: "Caø sa goùi giaày coû." ancient's meaning: they just go on talking                    Vò Taêng laïi hoûi: "Chöa bieát yù chæ theá naøo?" Toâng theoretically of "emerged from the water" and                 Ñaïo noùi: "Döôùi chaân traàn toaøn gai goùc." Vì theá, "not yet emerged from the water." What                        noùi cuùng Phaät chaúng ôû nhieàu höông, neáu vöôït qua connection is there? Haven't you heard: A monk                khoûi thì baét tha taïi ta. Ñaõ laø moät hoûi moät ñaùp roõ asked Chih Men, "What is the body of Wisdom?"                 raøng hieän thaønh, taïi sao Trieäu Chaâu laïi noùi boái roái? Chih Men said, "An oyster enclosing the bright                Haõy noùi phaûi laø saøo huyeät cuûa thôøi nhôn chaêng? moon." The monk asked, "What is the functioning               Trieäu Chaâu ôû trong saøo huyeät ñaùp y, hay ôû ngoaøi of Wisdom?" Chih Men said, "A rabbit becomes                  saøo huyeät ñaùp y? Phaûi bieát vieäc naøy khoâng ôû treân pregnant." Look at him responding like this: no               ngoân cuù. Coù ngöôøi tin ñöôïc ñeán thaáu xöông thaáu one on earth can searth out the stream of his                 tuûy, nhö roàng gaëp nöôùc, nhö coïp töïa nuùi —A monk words. If someone asked me, "How is it when the               asked Chao-Chou, "The Ultimate Path has no lotus flowers have not yet emerged from the                   difficulties; just avoid picking and choosing; isn't water?" I would just answer him by saying, "The               this a clicheù for people of these times?" Chao- pillar and the lamp." Tell me, is this the same as            Chou said, "Once someone asked me, and I really the lotus flowers or different? If I were asked,              couldn't explain for five years." According to "What about after they've emerged from the                    Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, Chao-Chou usually water?" I would answer, "The staff upholds the                didn't use blows or shouts his action went beyond sun and moon, underfoot how muddy and deep!"                  blows and shouts. This monk's question was also You tell me, is this right or wrong? Through this             very special; it would have been hard for anyone example, the ancient virtues want to advise Zen               but Chao-Chou to answer him. Since Chao-Chou practitioners that they should never mistakenly               was an adept, he just said to him, "Once someone stick by the zero point of a scale, but break up              asked me, and I really couldn't explain for five people's emotional interpretations.                           years." The question towered up like a mile-high Coâng AÙn Trieäu Chaâu Boái Roái: Chao-Chou Can't             wall, and the answer didn't make light of it. Just Explain, example 58 of the Pi-Yen-Lu—Thí duï                  understand it this way and it's right here. If you thöù 58 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Moät vò Taêng hoûi Trieäu        understand, then don't make rational calculations. Chaâu: "Chí ñaïo voâ nan, duy hieàm giaûn traïch, phaûi       Haven't you heard now when the man of the Path laø saøo huyeät cuûa thôøi nhôn chaêng?" Trieäu Chaâu         Tsung of T'ou Tzu was the scribe in Hsueh Tou's ñaùp: "Ñaõ coù ngöôøi hoûi toâi, maø maõi ñeán naêm naêm      community, Hsueh Tou had him immerse himself vaãn coøn boái roái." Theo Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham         in "The Ultimate Path has no difficulties; just Luïc, Trieäu Chaâu bình sanh chaúng haønh gaäy heùt,          avoid picking and choosing." Thereby Tsung had maø duøng ñöôïc coøn hôn gaäy heùt. Vò Taêng naøy hoûi        an awakening. One day Hsueh Tou asked him, raát kyø quaùi, neáu khoâng phaûi laø Trieäu Chaâu thì khoù   "What is the meaning of 'The Ultimate Path has no ñaùp ñöôïc cho y. Bôûi Trieäu Chaâu laø haøng taùc gia,       difficulties; just avoid picking and choosing'?" chæ noùi vôùi y "Ñaõ coù ngöôøi hoûi toâi, maø maõi ñeán      Tsung said, "Animal, animal." Later he dwelt in naêm naêm vaãn coøn boái roái." Choã hoûi vaùch cao ngaøn     seclusion on Mount T'ou Tzu. Whenever he went

to serve as an abbot, he wrapped his straw sandals            coù theå laøm chaùy böøng leân ngoïn ñuoác Phaùp. Thaät and his scriptural texts in his robe. A monk asked            vaäy, töø khi nhöõng lôøi cuûa caùc thaày thieàn ñöôïc coi him "What is your family style, Wayfarer?" Tsung              nhö nhöõng phöông tieän ñaøo taïo thì coâng aùn 'Voâ' ñaõ said, "Straw sandals wrapped in a robe." The                  giuùp cho haøng ngaøn thieàn sinh thöïc hieän ñöôïc theå monk said, "What does this mean?" Tsung said,                 nghieäm ñaàu tieân cuûa ñaïi giaùc. Maõi ñeán ngaøy nay "T'ung Ch'eng (the neighboring city) is under my              ngöôøi ta vaãn daïy noù cho moân ñoà treû tuoåi nhö coâng bare feet." Thus it is said, "Making offerings to the         aùn ñaàu tieân—Chao-Chou's Dog, example 1 of the Buddha is not a matter of a lot of license." If you           Wu-Men-Kuan. One day a monk asked Chao- can penetrate through and escape, then letting go             chou: 'Does a dog really have Buddha-nature, or or holding on rest with oneself. Since this case is           not?' Chao-chou said: 'Wu'. According to Wu Men one question and one answer, clear and perfectly              Hui-Kai in the Wu-Men-Kuan, for the practice of obvious, why then did Chao-Chou say that he                   Zen, it is imperative that you pass through the couldn't explain? But tell me, is this a clicheù for          barrier set up by the Ancestral Teachers. For people of these times or not? Did Chao-Chou                   subtle realization, it is of the utmost importance answered him inside or outside the nest of clicheù.           that you cut off the mind road. If you do not pass You must realize that this matter isn't in words and          the barrier of the ancestors, if you do not cut off phrases. If there's a fellow who penetrates the               the mind road, then you are a ghost clinging to marrow, whose faith is thoroughgoing, then he's               bushes and grasses. What is the barrier of the like a dragon reaching the water, like a tiger                Ancestral Teachers? It is just this one word "Mu" taking to the mountains.                                      (Wu), the one barrier of our faith. We call it the Coâng AÙn Trieäu Chaâu Caåu Töû: Chao-Chou's                  Gateless Barrier of the Zen Tradition. When you Dog—Con Choù cuûa Trieäu Chaâu, thí duï thöù 1 cuûa           pass through this barrier, you will not only Voâ Moân Quan. Moät hoâm coù moät vò Taêng hoûi Trieäu        interview Chao-Chou intimately. You will walk Chaâu: "Moät con choù coù Phaät taùnh hay khoâng?"            hand in hand with all the Ancestral Teachers in Trieäu Chaâu ñaùp: "Voâ." (Mu). Theo Voâ Moân Hueä            the successive generations of our lineage, the hair Khai trong Voâ Moân Quan, tham thieàn phaûi loït qua          of your eyebrows entangled with theirs, seeing cöûa Toå, dieäu ngoä phaûi döùt tuyeät ñöôøng taâm. Cöûa      with the same eyes, hearing with the same ears. Toå khoâng loït, ñöôøng taâm khoâng döùt thì cuõng nhö        Won't that be fulfilling? Is there anyone who boùng ma nöông nhôø caây coû. Thöû hoûi cöûa Toå laø gì?      would not want to pass this barrier? To do this, Chæ moät chöõ "Khoâng" chính laø cöûa aáy, beøn goïi laø      make your whole body a mass of doubt to Voâ Moân Quan cuûa Thieàn toâng vaäy. Haønh giaû neân         concentrate on this one word "Mu". Day and night, nhôù raèng qua ñöôïc cöûa aáy chaúng nhöõng thaáy ñöôïc       keep digging into it. Don't consider it to be Trieäu Chaâu maø coøn cuøng chö Toå xöa naém tay              nothingness. Don't think in terms of 'has' and 'has chung böôùc, thaâm saâu giao keát, cuøng moät maét maø        not.' Try to eliminate mistaken knowledge and thaáy, moät tai maø nghe. Haù chaúng vui thuù laém sao?       atttitudes you have held from the past. Inside and Haù chaúng ai muoán qua cöûa aáy laém sao? Muoán              outside become just one. Exhaust all your life ñöôïc nhö vaäy haõy vaän duïng caû thaân taâm khôûi           energy on this one word "Mu." Some day the thaønh moät moái nghi, ngaøy ñeâm nghieàn ngaãm tham          "Mu" will suddenly break open, at the very cliff thaúng chöõ "Khoâng". Chôù neân cho Khoâng laø Khoâng         edge of birth-and-death, you find the Great theo nghóa troáng roãng, chôù neân cho Khoâng laø             Freedom. In the Six Worlds and the Four Modes Khoâng theo nghóa coù, khoâng. Haõy coá gaéng loaïi boû       of Birth, you enjoy a samadhi without any nhöõng thaùi ñoä vaø söï hieåu bieát laàm laãn trong quaù     obstruction. At that time, just a single spark can khöù. Trong ngoaøi ñeàu trôû thaønh moät khoái. Haõy          light up your Dharma candle. As a matter of fact, duøng heát söùc löïc maø nghieàn ngaãm chöõ "Khoâng"          since the time when words of the old masters aáy. Moät ngaøy naøo ñoù, chöõ "Khoâng" aáy seõ thình         began being used as a means of training, this so- lình boäc phaùt. Khi aáy, baïn seõ döûng döng vôùi bôø        called koan 'Mu' has helped thousands of Zen sinh töû, daïo chôi trong choán luïc ñaïo töù sanh moät       students to a first enlightenment experience. Still caùch voâ ngaïi. Ngay luùc ñoù, chæ caàn moät tia löûa nhoû   today it is given to many Zen students as their first

koan.                                                            not found in understanding, what is to be upheld Coâng AÙn Trieäu Chaâu Chí Ñaïo Voâ Nan: Chao                    and sustained?” Chao-Chou said: “I don’t know.” Chou's Stupid Oaf, example 57 of the Pi-Yen-                     The monk said: “Since the master doesn’t know Lu—Thí duï thöù 57 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Trieäu                   what it is, how can you say it isn’t within Chaâu thöôïng ñöôøng thuyeát phaùp: “Ñaïo chaúng khoù,           understanding?” Chao-Chou said: “Ask and you chæ hieàm löïa choïn, vöøa coù noù i naêng laø löïa choïn, laø   have an answer, then bow and withdraw.” minh baïch. Laõo Taêng chaúng ôû trong minh baïch,               According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, the caùc ngöôi laïi tieác giöõ chaêng?” Coù vò Taêng ñöùng ra        monk questioned Chao-Chou about the saying hoûi: “Ñaõ chaúng ôû trong minh baïch thì tieác giöõ caùi        "The Ultimate Path has no difficulties; just avoid gì?” Trieäu Chaâu baûo: “Ta cuõng chaúng bieát.” Vò              picking and choosing." The Third Patriarch's Taêng noùi: “Hoøa Thöôïng ñaõ chaúng bieát, vì sao               Inscription of the Believing Heart starts off chaúng ôû trong minh baïch?” Trieäu Chaâu noùi: “Hoûi            directly with these two lines. There are quite a thì ñöôïc. Leã baùi xong lui ra.” Theo Vieân Ngoä trong          few people who misunderstand. How so? Bích Nham Luïc, vò Taêng hoûi Trieäu Chaâu chí ñaïo              According to them, the Ultimate Path is khoâng khoù chæ hieàm giaûn traïch, trong baøi Tín Taâm          fundamentally without difficulties, but also Minh cuûa Tam Toå Taêng Xaùn, môû ñaàu laø hai caâu              without anything that's not difficult; it's just that it's naøy. Coù nhieàu ngöôøi hieåu laàm. Vì sao chí ñaïo voán         only adverse to picking and choosing. If you khoâng khoù cuõng khoâng chaúng khoù, chæ laø hieàm nôi          understand in this fashion, in ten thousand years giaûn traïch? Neáu hieåu theá aáy thì moät muoân naêm            you won't even see it in dreams. Chao-Chou often cuõng chöa moäng thaáy. Trieäu Chaâu thöôøng laáy caâu           used this saying to question people. This monk naøy hoûi ngöôøi. Vò Taêng ñem caâu naøy hoûi laïi Trieäu        reversed this by taking this saying to question him. Chaâu. Neáu nhaèm treân ngoân cuù tìm thì vò Taêng naøy          If you look to the words, then this monk does after laø kinh thieân ñoäng ñòa. Neáu chaúng ôû treân ngoân cuù        all startle heaven and shake the earth. If it is not in laïi laøm sao? Laïi tham ba möôi naêm. Caây choát cöûa           the words, then what? You must be able to turn naøy phaûi xoay ñöôïc môùi mong nhoå raâu coïp. Phaûi            this little key before it will open. To grab the laø coù boån phaän thuû ñoaïn môùi ñöôïc. Vò Taêng naøy          tiger's whiskers, you must be able to do it on your chaúng ngaïi nguy vong, daùm nhoå raâu coïp, noùi raèng:         own abilities. Heedless of the mortal danger, this "Vaãn coøn giaûn traïch." Trieäu Chaâu nhaèm mieäng              monk dared to grab the tiger's whiskers, so he lieán bít, noùi: "Keû tôù nhaø ruoäng, choã naøo laø giaûn       said, "This is still picking and choosing." Chao- traïch?" Neáu hoûi ñeán keû khaùc lieàn thaáy tay chaân roái     Chou immediately blocked off his mouth by loaïn, ñaâu ngôø laõo naøy laø baäc taùc gia, nhaèm choã         saying, "Stupid oaf! Where is the picking and ñoäng khoâng ñöôïc lieàn ñoäng, choã xoay khoâng ñöôïc           choosing?" If the monk had asked someone else, lieàn xoay. Neáu oâng thaáu ñöôïc, taát caû ngoân cuù aùc        he would have seen him flustered and confused. ñoäc, nhaãn ñeán ngaøn sai muoân traïng hyù luaän ôû theá        But what could he do about this old fellow who gian, ñeàu laø thöôïng vò ñeà hoà. Neáu ñeán ñöôïc choã          was an adept? Chao-Chou moved where it was thaät, môùi thaáy Trieäu Chaâu loøng son töøng maûnh. Keû        impossible to move, turned around where it was tôù nhaø ruoäng laø tieáng ngöôøi laøng Phöôùc Ñöôøng            impossible to turn around. If you can penetrate all maéng ngöôøi gioáng nhö khoâng yù trí. Vò Taêng naøy             evil and poisonous words and phrases, even down noùi: "Vaãn coøn giaûn traïch." Trieäu Chaâu baûo: "Keû tôù      to a thousand differences and ten thousand forms, nhaø ruoäng, choã naøo laø giaûn traïch?" Caëp maét Toâng        then all conventional fabrications will be the sö phaûi ñeán theá aáy, nhö chim caùnh vaøng vaïch bieån         excellent flavor of purified ghee. If you can get to baét roàng nuoát—Zen master Chao-Chou entered                    where you touch reality, then you will see Chao- the hall to address the monks: “Attaining the Way                Chou's naked heart in its entirety. "Stupid oaf" is a is not difficult, just disdain choosing. As soon as              country expression of the people of Fu Chou, to words are present there is choosing, there is                    revile people for being without intelligence. When understanding. It’s not to be found in                           the monk said, "This is still picking and choosing," understanding. Is understanding the thing you                    Chao-Chou said, "Stupid oaf! Where is the picking uphold and sustain?” A monk asked: “Since it is                  and choosing?" The eye of teachers of our school

must be thus, like the golden winged Garuda bird                 who first tied it." The monks then say: "You have parting the ocean waters to seize a dragon directly              answered your own silly question. Now open the and swallow it.                                                  door!" Coâng AÙn Trieäu Chaâu Cöùu Hoûa: Chao-chou's                    Coâng AÙn Trieäu Chaâu Ñaïi Thaùi: Chao Chou's Big Fire! Fire!—Ngaøy noï, Hoøa Thöôïng Nam Tuyeàn                   Turnips, example 30 of the Pi-Yen-Lu—Thí duï cuøng Taêng chuùng ñang laøm vieäc beân ngoaøi, Trieäu           thöù 30 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Moät vò Taêng hoûi Trieäu Chaâu ôû laïi chuøa canh löûa. Trieäu Chaâu boãng hoâ to:        Chaâu: "Ñöôïc nghe Hoøa Thöôïng thaân kieán Nam "Cöùu löûa! Cöùu löûa!" Moïi ngöôøi ñoå doàn veà, chaïy          Tuyeàn phaûi chaêng?" Trieäu Chaâu ñaùp: "ÔÛ Traán vaøo phoøng nguû. Trieäu Chaâu thaáy theá beøn ñoùng aäp         Chaâu phaùt xuaát cuû caûi to." Theo Vieân Ngoä trong cöûa laïi, baûo: "Noùi ñöôïc, toâi môû cöûa cho vaøo."           Bích Nham Luïc, vò Taêng naày cuõng thuoäc haïng Khoâng ai bieát noùi gì. Nam Tuyeàn neùm chieác chìa             tham cöùu laâu, trong caâu hoûi quaû laø coù maét. Tuy khoùa qua song cöûa vaøo phoøng cho Trieäu Chaâu.                nhieân, Trieäu Chaâu laø haøng taùc gia, lieàn ñaùp: "ÔÛ Trieäu Chaâu beøn môû cöûa. Trong Thieàn, söï "Taùc thí"         Traán Chaâu phaùt xuaát cuû caûi to." Ñaùng goïi laø lôøi noùi luoân luoân ñöôïc caùc Thieàn sö thi haønh baèng nhöõng          voâ vò, bít laáp mieäng ngöôøi. Trieäu Chaâu cuõng gioáng thuû ñoaïn trieät ñeå vaø kinh dò. Trong tröôøng hôïp naøy,      nhö keû cöôùp ban ngaøy, oâng Taêng vöøa môû mieäng bôûi vì khoâng coù vò Taêng naøo trong töï vieän coù theå        lieàn moùc troøng maét cuûa oâng. Neáu laø ngöôøi xuaát ñöa ra moät caâu traû lôøi thích ñaùng vôùi haønh ñoäng          chuùng thì ngay ñoù nhaèm khoaûng ñaù nhaùng ñieän kinh ngaïc cuûa Trieäu Chaâu, söï khieám khuyeát tri             xeït, vöøa nghe noùi ñeán xeù tan lieàn ñi. Neáu laø laëng thöùc noäi taïi cuûa hoï vì theá ñaõ bò phôi baøy hoaøn toaøn.   nghó döøng suy chaúng khoûi tan thaân maát maïng. ÔÛ Nhöng vaán ñeà lyù thuù ôû ñaây laø caùc vò Taêng neân yeâu      Giang Taây, Tröøng Taùn Thaùnh Phaùn noùi ñoù laø hoûi caàu Trieäu Chaâu tröôùc tieân traû lôøi caâu hoûi sau ñaây      Ñoâng ñaùp Taây, baûo laø chaúng ñaùp thoaïi, chaúng vaøo cuûa hoï caùi ñaõ, roài hoï seõ traû lôøi cho caâu hoûi cuûa     loàng vaøo loïp cuûa ngöôøi. Neáu hieåu theá aáy ñaâu theå oâng: "Ai coù theå côûi sôïi daây chuoâng treân coå cuûa con     ñöôïc. Vieãn Luïc Coâng noùi: "Ñaây laø lôøi nhìn beân, coïp?" Coù leõ Trieäu Chaâu seõ phaûi traû lôøi: "Ai coät        naèm trong cöûu ñôùi. Neáu hieåu theá aáy, khi moäng ñaàu tieân thì phaûi môû." Roài caùc vò Taêng noùi: "OÂng        cuõng chöa moät thaáy, laïi coøn ñôùi luïy Trieäu Chaâu." ñaõ töï traû lôøi cho caâu hoûi ngu xuaãn cuûa oâng roài ñoù.    Coù ngöôøi noùi ôû Traán Chaâu töø xöa ñeán giôø saûn xuaát Baây giôø môû cöûa mau leân!"—One day, when Nan-                 cuû caûi to, moïi ngöôøi ñeàu bieát, Trieäu Chaâu töø khi ch'uan was working outdoors with his monks,                      ñeán tham kieán Nam Tuyeàn moïi ngöôøi ñeàu bieát. Vò Chao-chou, who was told to watch over a fire,                    Taêng naày ñeán hoûi, "Ñöôïc nghe Hoøa Thöôïng thaân suddenly cried out: "Fire! Fire!" The alarm made                 kieán Nam Tuyeàn phaûi chaêng?" Vì theá Trieäu Chaâu all the monks rush back to the dormitory hall.                   duøng Traán Chaâu xuaát phaùt cuû caûi to ñeå ñaùp. Hieåu Seeing this, Chao-chou closed the gate and                       nhö vaäy thaät laø khoâng dính daùng gì. Troïn chaúng declared, "If you could say a word the doors                     ñöôïc hieåu theá aáy, cöùu caùnh laøm sao hieåu? Nhaø moãi would be opened." The monks did not know what                    ngöôøi töï coù ñöôøng thaáu trôøi. Ñaâu chaúng thaáy coù vò to say. Nan-ch'uan, the master, however, threw the               Taêng hoûi Cöûu Phong: "Ñöôïc nghe Hoøa Thöôïng key into the hall through a window. Thereupon                    thaân kieán Dieân Thoï phaûi chaêng?" Cöûu Phong ñaùp: Chao-chou flung open the gate. In Zen, the                       "Tröôùc nuùi maïch chín chöa?" Ñaây hôïp vôùi lôøi cuûa "Behaviour test" is often conducted by Zen                       Trieäu Chaâu ñaùp cho vò Taêng, gioáng nhö hai caùi masters through radical and astonishing                          chuøy saét khoâng coù loã. Trieäu Chaâu laø ngöôøi voâ söï, manoeuvres. In this case, not one of the monks in                vò Taêng nheø nheï hoûi ñeán, lieàn moùc troøng maét oâng. the monastery could give a proper answer to                      Neáu laø "tri höõu" nhai kyõ thì thaáy thuù vò. Neáu laø Chao-chou's astonishing act, their lack of inner                 ngöôøi "chaúng tri höõu" gioáng nhö nuoát troäng traùi understanding was thus fully exposed. But the                    chaø laø vaäy—A monk asked Chao Chou, "Teacher, interesting question here is that the monks should               I have heard that you have personally seen Nan request Chao-chou to to answer the following                     Ch'uan. Is this true or not?" Chao Chou said, question first, then they shall answer his: "Who                 "Chen Chou produces big turnips." According to can untie the bell-string on the neck of a tiger?"               Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, this monk too is one Then Chao-chou might have replied: "The person                   who has studied for a long time: inevitably, there's

an eye in his question. Nevertheless, Chao Chou         Luïc. Trieäu Chaâu hoûi Ñaàu Töû: "Ngöôøi ñaïi töû khi is an adept: he immediately says to him, "Chen          soáng laïi thì theá naøo?" Ñaàu Töû ñaùp: "Chaúng cho ñi Chou produces big turnips." This can be called          ñeâm, ñôïi saùng seõ ñeán." Theo Vieân Ngoä trong Bích flavorless talk that blocks off people's mouths.        Nham Luïc, cuoäc vaán ñaùp giöõa Trieäu Chaâu vaø Ñaàu This old fellow Chao Chou greatly resembles a           Töû laø thôøi tieát gì? OÁng saùo khoâng loã naém ñeán lieàn thief who steals in broad daylight. As soon as you      voã nhòp haùt. Ñaây goïi laø hoûi nghieäm chuû, cuõng goïi open your mouth he immediately plucks your eyes         laø hoûi taâm haïnh. Ñaàu Töû, Trieäu Chaâu caùc nôi ñeàu out. If you are an exceptional brave-spirited           ngôïi khen, ñöôïc caùi bieän luaän sieâu quaàn. Hai vò fellow, then amidst sparks struck from stone and        tuy keá thöøa khaùc nhau, xem cô phong gioáng nhau the brilliance of a lightning flash, as soon as you     moät loaïi. Moät hoâm, Ñaàu Töû vì Trieäu Chaâu thieát hear it raised, you immediately get up and go.          tieäc traø ñaõi nhau, töï tay ñöa baùnh cho Trieäu Chaâu, Otherwise, if you linger in thought and hold back       Trieäu Chaâu ngoù lô. Ñaàu Töû sai cö só ñöa baùnh cho your potential, you won't avoid losing your body        Trieäu Chaâu, Trieäu Chaâu leã cö só ba laïy. Haõy noùi yù and your life. In judging this case the wild sage       Trieäu Chaâu theá naøo? Quaû laø Trieäu Chaâu nhaèm treân Ch'eng of Kiangsi called it "asking about the east,     caên baûn neâu vieäc boån phaän vì ngöôøi. Coù vò Taêng answering about the west." He said that Chao            hoûi: "Theá naøo laø ñaïo?" Ñaàu Töû ñaùp: "Ñaïo." Laïi Chou didn't answer and didn't climb into his trap. If   hoûi: "Theá naøo laø Phaät?" Ñaàu Töû ñaùp: "Phaät." Vò you understand this way, how will you get it?           Taêng laïi hoûi: "Khi khoùa vaøng chöa môû thì theá Jurist Yuan said, "These are words affording a          naøo?" Ñaàu Töû ñaùp: "Môû." Laïi hoûi: "Khi gaø vaøng glimpse from the side." This is contained in the        chöa gaùy thì theá naøo?" Ñaàu Töû ñaùp: "Moãi töï bieát Nine Belts. If you understand this way, you             thôøi." Bình sanh Ñaàu Töû ñaùp nhö theá. Xem Trieäu haven't even seen it in dreams, and, moreover,          Chaâu hoûi: "Ngöôøi ñaïi töû khi soáng laïi thì theá naøo?" you're dragging Chao Chou down. Some say,               Ñaàu Töû lieàn ñaùp: "Chaúng cho ñi ñeâm, ñôïi saùng seõ "Chen Chou has always produced big turnips, as          ñeán." Haún nhö choïi ñaù nhaùng löûa, tôï laøn ñieän everyone in the country knows. Chao Chou had            chôùp, traû laïi cho ngöôøi höôùng thöôïng môùi ñöôïc. called on Nan Ch'uan: everyone in the country           Ngöôøi ñaïi töû troïn khoâng coù Phaät phaùp ñaïo lyù knows this. That's why, when this monk                  huyeàn dieäu ñöôïc maát, phaûi quaáy, daøi ngaén. Ñeán nevertheless still asked whether or not Chao Chou       trong naøy chæ theá aáy thoâi. Coå nhaân goïi ñoù laø treân had personally seen Nan Ch'uan, Chao Chou said          ñaát baèng ngöôøi cheát voâ soá, qua ñöôïc röøng gai goác to him, 'Chen Chou produces big turnips.'" But this     laø ngöôøi tay kheùo, phaûi qua loït beân kia môùi ñöôïc. has nothing to do with it. If you don't understand      Tuy vaäy, hieän nay ngöôøi ñeán loaïi ñieàn ñòa naøy, these ways, in the end, how will you understand?        sôùm ñaõ khoù ñöôïc. Hoaëc coù nöông töïa, coù giaûi hoäi Chao Chou has his own road through the skies.           thì khoâng giao thieäp. Hoøa Thöôïng Trieát goïi ñoù laø Haven't you heard: A monk asked Chiu Feng,              thaáy chaúng tònh khieát. Nguõ Toå tieân sö baûo ñoù laø "Teacher, I have heard that you personally saw          maïng caên chaúng ñoaïn, phaûi moät phen ñaïi töû soáng Yen Shou. Is this true or not?" Chiu Feng said, "Is     laïi môùi ñöôïc. Hoøa Thöôïng Vónh Quang ôû Chieát the wheat in front of the mountain ripe yet or          Trung noùi: "Ngoân phong neáu sai thì coång laøng queâ not?" This matches exactly what Chao Chou said          caùch xa muoân daëm, phaûi laø bôø cao voùt buoâng tay, to the monk: both are iron hammer heads with no         töï nhaän thöøa ñöông, sau khi cheát soáng laïi chaúng handle holes. Old man Chao Chou is an                   daùm khi anh, yù chæ phi thöôøng, ngöôøi naøo thöôøng unconcerned man. If you question him carelessly         ö?" YÙ Trieäu Chaâu hoûi nhö theá, Ñaàu Töû laø haøng taùc he immediately snatches your eyes out. If you're a      gia cuõng khoâng coâ phuï caâu hoûi kia. Chæ laø tuyeät man who knows what is, you'll chew carefully and        tình baët daáu, quaû thaät khoù hieåu, chæ hieän baøy tröôùc swallow it. If you're a man who doesn't know what       maét ñoâi chuùt. Vì theá coå nhaân noùi: "Muoán ñöôïc is, it will be like swallowing a date whole.            thaân thieát chôù ñem hoûi ñeán hoûi, hoûi taïi choã ñaùp, Coâng AÙn Trieäu Chaâu Ñaïi Töû Nhaân: Chao Chou's      ñaùp taïi choã hoûi." Neáu chaúng phaûi Ñaàu Töû, bò Trieäu Man Who Has Died the Great Death, example 41            Chaâu moät caâu hoûi cuõng khoù ñaùp ñöôïc. Chæ vì kia laø of the Pi-Yen-Lu—Thí duï thöù 41 cuûa Bích Nham         keû taùc gia, nhaéc ñeán lieàn bieát choã rôi—Chao Chou

asked T'ou Tzu, "How is it when a man who has             hand." Yet one must pass beyond that Other Side died the great death returns to life?" T'ou Tzu           too to begin to attain. Even so, for present day said, "He must not go by night: he must get there         people even to get to this realm is already difficult in daylight." According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-         to achieve. If you have any learning or Lu, Chao Chou asked T'ou Tzu, "How is it when a           dependence, any interpretative understanding, man who has died the great death returns to life?"        then there is no connection. Master Che called this T'ou Tzu answered him, saying, "He must not go            "vision that is not purified." My late teacher Wu by night: he must get there in daylight." But say,        Tsu called it "The root of life not cut off." One what time and season is this? A flute with no holes       must die the great death once, then return to life. strikes against a felt-pounding board. This is            Master Yung Kuang of central Chekiang said, "If called "a question to test the host"; it is also called   you miss at the point of their words, then you're a "an intentional question." All over they praised          thousand miles from home. In fact you must let go T'ou Tzu and Chao Chou for having outstanding             your hands while hanging from a cliff, trust eloquence. Though the two old men succeeded to            yourself and accept the experience. Afterwards different masters, observe how their active edges         you return to life again. I can't deceive you; how accord as one. One day T'ou Tzu spread the tea            could anyone hide this extraordinary truth?" The setting to entertain Chao Chou. T'ou Tzu himself          meaning of Chao Chou's question is like this. T'ou passed some steamed cakes to Chao Chou, but               Tzu is an adept, and he didn't turn his back on Chou paid no attention. T'ou Tzu ordered his              what Chao Chou asked: it's just that he cut off his attendant to give the seasame cakes to Chao               feelings and left no traces, so unavoidably he's Chou. Chou bowed to the attendant three times.            hard to understand. He just showed the little bit But say, what was his meaning? Observe how he             before the eyes. Thus an Ancient said, "If you always went right to the root to uphold this              want to attain Intimacy, don't ask with questions. fundamental thing for the benefit of others. There        The question is in the answer, and the answer is in was a monk who asked T'ou Tzu, "What is the               the question." It would have been very difficult for Way?" T'ou Tzu answered, "The Way." The monk              someone other than T'ou Tzu to reply when asked, "What is the Buddha?" T'ou Tzu answered,           questioned by Chao Chou. But since T'ou Tzu is "Buddha." Again he asked, "How is it before the           an expert, as soon as it's raised he knows where it golden lock open?" T'ou Tzu answered, "Open."             comes down. He asked, "How is it before the golden rooster has        Coâng AÙn Trieäu Chaâu Khaùm Am Chuû: Chao- crowed?" T'ou Tzu answered, "This sound does              Chou and the Hermits—Thí duï thöù 11 cuûa Voâ Moân not exist."The monk asked, "How is it after he            Quan. Ngaøy noï Trieäu Chaâu gheù thaêm moät am chuû, crows?" T'ou Tzu answered, "Each knows the time           hoûi: "Coù chaêng? Coù chaêng?" Chuû am giô naém tay for himself." His whole life T'ou Tzu's questions         leân. Sö noùi: "Nöôùc caïn khoâng phaûi choã ñaäu and answers were all like this. Look: when Chao           thuyeàn." Noùi xong Sö beøn boû ñi. Laïi gheù moät am Chou asked, "How is it when a man who has died            khaùc, hoûi: "Coù chaêng? Coù chaêng?" Chuû am cuõng the great death returns to life?" T'ou Tzu                giô naém tay leân. Sö noùi: "Buoâng ñöôïc, baét ñöôïc, immediately said, "He must not go by night: he            gieát ñöôïc, cöùu ñöôïc." Noùi xong sö beøn leã baùi. must get there in daylight." Direct as sparks struck      Theo Voâ Moân Hueä Khai trong Voâ Moân Quan, from stone, like the brilliance of a lightning flash.     haønh giaû tu thieàn neân ñeå yù ôû choã caû hai am chuû Only a transcendental man like him could do this.         ñeàu ñöa naém tay leân, sao Trieäu Chaâu laïi chòu moät A man who has died the great death has no                 cheâ moät? Thöû hoûi ngoa ngaïnh ôû ñaâu? Neá u haï ñöôïc Buddhist doctrines and theories, no mysteries and         choã naày moät caâu chuyeån ngöõ thì thaáy ngay Trieäu marvels, no gain and loss, no right and wrong, no         Chaâu, löôõi khoâng xöông, khen cheâ maëc tình. Tuy long and short. When he gets here, he just lets it        nhieân, ngaët noãi Trieäu Chaâu laïi bò hai oâng chuû am rest this way. An Ancient said of this, "On the           khaùm phaù. Neáu baûo hai oâng chuû am coù hôn coù keùm level ground the dead are countless; only one who         thì toû ra khoâng coù maét tham hoïc; coøn neáu baûo can pass through the forest of thorns is a good           khoâng hôn khoâng keùm thì cuõng khoâng coù maét tham

hoïc—Example 11 of the Wu-Men-Kuan. One day,                     heard about this, he said, "Hold on! I'll go and Chao-Chou went to a hermit's cottage and asked,                  investigate that old woman thoroughly for you." "Anybody in? Anybody in?" The hermit lifted up                   Next day, Chao-chou went and asked her the his fist. Chao-Chou said, "The water is too shallow              same question, and she replied in the same way. for a ship to anchor." And he left. Again, Chao-                 Chao-chou returned and announced to his Chou went to another hermit's cottage and asked,                 assembly, "I have investigated and seen through "Anybody in? Anybody in?" This hermit too lifted                 that old woman of Mount T'ai for you." According up his fist. Chao-Chou said, "Freely you give,                   to Wu Men Hui-Kai in the Wu-Men-Kuan, the old freely you take away, freely you kill, freely you                woman knew how to sit in her tent and plans give life." Then Chao-Chou made a full bow and                   strategy, but she didn't recognize the notorious left. According to Wu Men Hui-Kai in the Wu-                     bandit. Old Chao-chou could steal skillfully into Men-Kuan, Zen practitioners should notice that                   camp and threaten the fortress and the frontier. both hermits held up their fists in the same way.                Still, he didn't have the aspect of a great person. Why did Chao-Chou approve one and not the                        When you examine them closely, you find they other? Who can tell what is the core of the                      are both at fault. Now tell me, what did Chao-chou complication? If you can give a turning word on                  determine when he investigated the old woman? this matter, you will realize that Chao-Chou's                   Coâng AÙn Trieäu Chaâu Sao Chaúng Daãn Heát: Why tongue has no bone in it. He is free, now to raise               Don't You Quote This Saying in Full, example 59 up, now to thrust down. Be that as it may, can you               of the Pi-Yen-Lu—Thí duï thöù 59 cuûa Bích Nham realize also that Chao-Chou was seen through by                  Luïc. Moät vò Taêng hoûi Trieäu Chaâu: "'Chí ñaïo khoâng the two hermits? Furthermore, if you say that one                khoù, duy hieàm giaûn traïch, vöøa coù noùi naêng laø giaûn hermit was superior to the other, you do not yet                 traïch', Hoøa Thöôïng vì ngöôøi theá naøo?" Trieäu Chaâu have the eye of reflective study. And if you say                 baûo: "Sao chaúng daãn heát lôøi naøy?" Vò Taêng thöa: there is no difference between them, you do not                  "Con chæ nhôù ñeán ñoù." Trieäu Chaâu baûo: "Chæ laø chí yet have the eye of reflective study.                            ñaïo khoâng khoù, duy hieàm giaûn traïch." Theo Vieân Coâng AÙn Trieäu Chaâu Khaùm Baø: Chao-Chou                      Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc, Trieäu Chaâu noùi chæ laø Investigates the Old Woman, example 31 of the                    chí ñaïo khoâng khoù, duy hieàm giaûn traïch, nhö choïi Wu-Men-Kuan—Thí duï thöù 31 cuûa Voâ Moân Quan.                  ñaù nhaùng löûa, tôï laøn ñieån chôùp, baét tha soáng cheát, Coù moät oâng Taêng hoûi moät baø laõo: "Ñöôøng naøo ñi          ñöôïc töï taïi nhö theá. Caùc nôi ñeàu noùi: "Trieäu Chaâu nuùi Ñaøi Sôn?" Baø laõo ñaùp: "Cöù ñi thaúng." OÂng             coù loái bieän luaän sieâu quaàn" Trieäu Chaâu bình Taêng môùi böôùc ñi naêm baûy böôùc, baø laõo laïi noùi:         thöôøng daïy chuùng coù moät thieân naøy: "Chí ñaïo "Ñöôøng ñöôøng laø moät oâng thaày tu, cöù theá maø ñi           khoâng khoù, duy hieàm giaûn traïch," vöøa coù noùi naêng kìa!" Sau coù ngöôøi keå laïi cuøng ngaøi trieäu Chaâu.          laø giaûn traïch laø minh baïch. Laõo Taêng chaúng ôû Trieäu Chaâu beøn noùi: "Ñeå ta tôùi xem baø laõo naày ra        trong minh baïch, caùc oâng laïi tieác giöõ hay khoâng? sao." Hoâm sau Trieäu Chaâu beøn ñeán, cuõng hoû i nhö           Coù vò Taêng hoûi: "Ñaõ chaúng ôû trong minh baïch laïi vaäy, baø laõo cuõng ñaùp nhö vaäy. Sö trôû veà noùi laïi vôùi   tieác giöõ caùi gì?" Trieäu Chaâu noùi: "Ta cuõng khoâng Taêng chuùng: "Baø laõo ôû Ñaøi Sôn, ta ñaõ khaùm phaù           bieát." Vò Taêng thöa: "Hoøa Thöôïng ñaõ khoâng bieát, cho caùc oâng roài ñoù." Theo Voâ Moân Hueä Khai                 vì sao noùi chaúng ôû trong minh baïch?" Trieäu Chaâu trong Voâ Moân Quan, laõo baø chæ bieát ngoài trong              baûo: "Hoûi vieäc thì ñöôïc, leã baùi roài ra." Veà sau vò tröôùng lo vieäc binh, bò giaëc ñeán maø khoâng bieát.           Taêng naøy chæ baùm choã sô hôû kia ñi hoûi Trieäu Chaâu, Coøn laõo Trieäu Chaâu gioûi vieäc cöôùp traïi, laïi khoâng      hoûi haún laø kyø ñaëc, song chæ laø taâm haønh. Neáu laø ra ngöôøi lôùn ñaøng hoaøng. Xeùt kyõ laïi, caû hai ñeàu coù     ngöôøi khaùc khoâng laøm gì ñöôïc y, nhöng vôùi Trieäu loãi. Thöû hoûi ñaâu laø choã Trieäu Chaâu khaùm baø             Chaâu laø haøng taùc gia, lieàn noùi: "Sao chaúng daãn heát laõo?—A monk asked an old woman, "What is the                    lôøi naøy?" Vò Taêng cuõng bieát chuyeån thaân nhaû hôi, way to Mount T'ai?" The old woman said, "Go                      lieàn noùi: "Con chæ nhôù ñeán ñoù," döôøng nhö ñaõ ñöôïc straight ahead." When the monk had proceeded a                   an baøi. Trieäu Chaâu tuøy thinh nieâm khôûi lieàn ñaùp few steps, she said, "A good respectable monk,                   chaúng caàn suy tính. Coå nhaân goïi ñoù laø töông tuïc, but he too goes off like that." When Chao-chou                   cuõng raát khoù. Sö bieän roàng raén, phaân toát xaáu, quaû

laø haøng boån phaän taùc gia. Trieäu Chaâu moùc ñi troøng   Chou immediately answered him; he didn't need maét cuûa vò Taêng naøy, maø chaúng phaïm beùn nhoïn,        any calculations. An Ancient said of this, chaúng maéc suy tính, töï nhieân hay kheùo. OÂng goïi laø    "Continuity is indeed very difficult." Chao Chou coù caâu cuõng chaúng ñöôïc, goïi laø khoâng caâu cuõng      distinguished        dragons      from      snakes       and chaúng ñöôïc, ly töù cuù tuyeät baùch phi. Vì sao? Neáu      differentiated right from wrong; this goes back to luaän vieäc naøy nhö choïi ñaù nhaùng löûa, tôï laøn ñieån   his being an adept in his own right. Chao Chou chôùp, phaûi nhìn nhanh môùi thaáy. Neáu laø truø tröø       snatched this monk's eyes away without running nghó ngôïi chaúng khoûi tan thaân maát maïng—A monk          afoul of his sharp point. Without relying on asked Chao-Chou, "'The Ultimate Path has no                  calculations, he was spontaneously exactly difficulties; just avoid picking and choosing. As            appropriate. It's wrong to say either that he had soon as there are words and speech, this is picking          words or didn't have words; nor will it do to say and choosing.' So how do you help people,                    that his answer neither had nor didn't have words. Teacher?" Chao-Chou said, "Why don't you quote               Chao Chou left behind the permutations of logic. this saying in full?" The monk said, "I only                 Why? If one discusses this matter, it is like sparks remember up to here." Chao-Chou said, "It's just             struck from stone, like flashing lightning. Only if this: 'The Ultimate Path has no difficulties; just           you set your eyes on it quickly can you see it. If avoid picking and choosing.'" According to Yuan-             you hesitate and vascillate you won't avoid losing Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, Chao-Chou saying, "It's just            your body and life. this: 'The Ultimate Path has no difficulties; just           Coâng AÙn Trieäu Chaâu Tam Chuyeån Ngöõ: Chao avoid picking and choosing,'" is like a stone-struck         Chou's Three Turning Words, example 96 of the spark, like a flash of lightning. Capturing and              Pi-Yen-Lu—Thí duï thöù 96 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. releasing, killing and giving life; he has such              Trieäu Chaâu daïy chuùng ba chuyeån ngöõ: Phaät vaøng independent mastery. All over they said that Chao            khoâng qua ñöôïc loø ñuùc; Phaät caây khoâng qua ñöôïc Chou had an eloquence beyond the common                      löûa; vaø Phaät ñaát khoâng qua ñöôïc nöôùc, Sau khi daïy crowd. Chao Chou often taught his community                  chuùng ba chuyeån nöõ naày Trieäu Chaâu laïi noùi: with this speech, saying, "'The Ultimate Path has            "Chôn Phaät ngoài trong thaát." Moät caâu naày roõ quaù no difficulties; just avoid picking and choosing. As         möùc. Coå nhaân ñaõ môû moät con maét ñöa tay tieáp soon as there are words and speech, this is picking          ngöôøi, taïm möôïn lôøi naày ñeå thoâng tin töùc, coát yeáu and choosing,' 'this is clarity.' This old monk does         vì ngöôøi. Neáu oâng moät beà toaøn neâu chaùnh leänh thì not abide within clarity; do you still preserve              tröôùc phaùp ñöôøng coû cao moät tröôïng. Tuyeát Ñaäu anything or not?" Once there was a monk who                  khoâng haøi loøng caâu noùi roát sau loù ñuoâi cuûa Sö, vì asked, "Since you do not abide in the clarity, what          theá boû bôùt chæ tuïng ba caâu. Phaät ñaát neáu ñoä ñöôïc is to be preserved?" Chao Chou said, "I don't know           nöôùc thì tan hoaïi. Phaät vaøng neáu ñoä ñöôïc loø ñuùc either." The monk said, "Since you don't know,               thì chaûy. Phaät goã neáu ñoä löûa thì bò ñoát chaùy. Coù caùi Teacher, why do you say you don't abide in                   gì khoù hieåu ñaâu? Tuyeát Ñaäu tuïng coå ñöùc moät traêm clarity?" Chao Chou said, "It's enough just to ask           taéc, so saùnh saén bìm, chæ coù ba baøi tuïng naày quaû coù about this matter. Now bow and withdraw." Later              gì hôn haùm thieàn Taêng. Chæ baøi tuïng naày cuõng thöïc a monk picked on his gap and went to question                khoù hieåu. Neáu oâng thaáu ñöôïc ba baøi tuïng naày, cho him; this monk's questioning was undeniably                  oâng khoûi tham—Chao Chou expressed three extraordinary, but nevertheless it was just mental           turning words to his community. A gold Buddha activity. Someone other than Chao Chou would                 does not pass through a furnace; a wood Buddha have been unable to handle this monk. But what               does not pass through fire; a mud Buddha does not could he do? Chao Chou was an adept and                      pass through water. According to Yuan-Wu in the immediately said, "Why don't you quote this                  Pi-Yen-Lu, after Chao Chou had spoken these saying in full?" This monk too understood how to             three turning words, in the end he said, "The real turn himself around and show his mettle; he said,            Buddha sits within." This phrase is exceedingly "I only remember up to here." It seems just like an          indulgent. That man of old set forth a single eye, arrangement. Directly after the monk spoke, Chao             extended his hand to guide people; briefly making

use of these words to convey the message, he                Lu—Thí duï thöù 52 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Moät vò wanted to help others. If you one-sidedly bring up          Taêng hoûi Trieäu Chaâu: "Nghe tieáng caàu ñaù Trieäu the true imperative in its entirety, there would be         Chaâu ñaõ laâu, ñeán nôi chæ thaáy caàu khæ." Trieäu weeds ten feet deep in front of the teaching hall.          Chaâu baûo: "OÂng chæ thaáy caàu khæ, neân chaúng thaáy Hsueh Tou dislikes the indulgence of that final             caàu ñaù." Vò Taêng hoûi: "Theá naøo laø caàu ñaù?" Trieäu phrase, so he omits it and just versifies three             Chaâu ñaùp: "Ñoä löøa ñoä ngöïa." Theo Vieân Ngoä phrases. If a mud Buddha passes through water it            trong Bích Nham Luïc, thaønh Trieäu Chaâu coù caây will dissolve; if a gold Buddha passes through a            caàu ñaù do Lyù Öng taïo, ñeán nay noåi tieáng trong furnace it will melt; if a wood Buddha passes               thieân haï. Caàu khæ töùc laø loaïi caàu baét moät caây. Vò through fire it will burn up. What is difficult to          Taêng naøy coá yù laøm giaûm uy quang Trieäu Chaâu, understand about this? Hsueh Tou's hundred                  neân hoûi: "Nghe tieáng caàu ñaù Trieäu Chaâu ñaõ laâu, examples of eulogizing the Ancients are                     ñeán nôi chæ thaáy caàu khæ." Trieäu Chaâu lieàn baûo: complicated with judgments and comparisions;                "OÂng chæ thaáy caàu khæ, neân chaúng thaáy caàu ñaù." Cöù only these three verses directly contain the breath         choã hoûi cuûa vò Taêng gioáng nhö loái noùi chuyeän bình of a patchrobed monk. However, these verses are             thöôøng, nhöng Trieäu Chaâu duøng noù ñeå caâu oâng nevertheless difficult to understand. If you can            Taêng naøy, quaû nhieân oâng Taêng bò maéc caâu. Theo pass through these three verses, I'll allow as you          sau ñoù vò Taêng hoûi: "Theá naøo laø caàu ñaù?" Trieäu have finished studying.                                     Chaâu ñaùp: "Ñoä löøa ñoä ngöïa." Quaû thöïc, trong lôøi Coâng AÙn Trieäu Chaâu Taåy Baùt: Chao-Chou:                töï coù choã xuaát thaân. Trieäu Chaâu khoâng gioáng Laâm "Wash Your Bowl"—Trieäu Chaâu Röûa Baùt, thí duï            Teá hay Ñöùc Sôn duøng gaäy duøng heùt, chæ duøng ngoân thöù 7 cuûa Voâ Moân Quan. Moät ngaøy noï, moät vò          cuù soáng cheát. Coâng aùn naøy kheùo xem chæ gioáng Taêng môùi ñeán töï vieän, noùi: “Con môùi ñeán xin thaày   nhö bình thöôøng daáu cô phong. Tuy vaäy, cuõng thaät chæ giaùo.” Trieäu Chaâu hoûi: “Ngöôi aên chöa?” Vò         khoù nöông gaù. Thaät ra, neáu xeùt theo taâm ñaïo, caâu Taêng ñaùp: “Daï roài!” Trieäu Chaâu noùi: “Ñi röûa cheùn   chuyeän haøm aån nhieàu caùi thaät lieân heä ñeán trung baùt ñi.” Nghe xong nhöõng lôøi naày Taêng lieàn giaùc      taâm cuûa sinh hoaït taâm linh con ngöôøi. Haõy xem ngoä. Theá ra caùi ngoä thöôøng tuïc bieát chöøng naøo!     xeùt coi ñaây laø thöù caàu gì? Phaûi chaêng Trieäu Chaâu Theo Voâ Moân Hueä Khai trong Voâ Moân Quan,                chæ noùi ñeán caây caàu ñaù trong khu ñaát chuøa, khaù Trieäu Chaâu môû mieäng ra laø baøy caû ruoät gan. OÂng     chaéc chaén ñeå cho ñuû haïng khaùch boä haønh ñi qua Taêng nghe khoâng hieåu, hy voïng laø oâng Taêng naày       ñöôïc? Haønh giaû haõy thöû hoûi ôû trong chuùng ta coù khoâng laàm goïi caùi chuoâng laø caùi lu—Chao-Chou:        chöa moät caùi caàu coù theå chaúng nhöõng cho ngöïa "Wash Your Bowl", example 7 of the Wu-Men-                  qua, löøa qua, ñaøn oâng qua, ñaøn baø qua, xe naëng xe Kuan. One day, a new monk came to the                       nheï qua, maø caû theá giôùi ñeàu qua ñöôïc vôùi ñaày ñuû monastery. He said to Zhao-Chou: “I’ve just                 nhöõng thöù dô daùy, ñieân roà, beänh taät, moät caùi caàu arrived here. I asked the master to provide me              khoâng phaûi chæ ñeå qua thoâi, maø coøn chaø ñaïp leân, instruction.” Zhao-Chou said: “Have you eaten?”             coøn xæ vaû xaøi xeå nöõa, moät caùi caàu nhaän chòu taát caû The monk said: “Yes, I’ve eaten.” Zhao-Chou                 söï ñaõi ngoä, xaáu cuõng nhö toát, maø vaãn nhaãn nhuïc, said: “Go wash your bowl.” Upon hearing these               khoâng heà oaùn traùch. Coù phaûi thieàn sö Trieäu Chaâu words the monk was enlightened. This is enough              muoán aùm chæ ñeán caùi caàu aáy? Daàu muoán hay to show what a commonplace thing enlightenment              khoâng muoán, thieàn sinh haäu boái chuùng ta neân is! According to Wu Men Hui-Kai in the Wu-Men-              ngaàm hieåu yù cuûa ngaøi nhö vaäy. Moät hoâm, Trieäu Kuan, Chao-chou opened his mouth and showed                 Chaâu cuøng Thuû Toïa xem caàu ñaù. Trieäu Chaâu hoûi: his gallbladder, his heart, and his liver. I wonder if      "Laø ngöôøi naøo taïo?" Thuû Toïa ñaùp: "Lyù Öng taïo." the monk really heard the truth. I hope he did not          Trieäu Chaâu laïi hoûi: "Khi taïo nhaèm choã naøo haï mistake the bell for a jar.                                 thuû?" Thuû Toïa khoâng ñaùp ñöôïc. Trieäu Chaâu baûo: Coâng AÙn Trieäu Chaâu Taåy Cöôùc: Ts'ung-Sheân: I          "Bình thöôøng noùi caàu ñaù, hoûi ñeán choã haï thuû cuõn g am washing my feet—See Toøng Thaåm Taåy Cöôùc.              khoâng bieát." Moät hoâm khaùc, Trieäu Chaâu queùt ñaát, Coâng AÙn Trieäu Chaâu Thaïch Kieàu: The stone              coù vò Taêng ñeán hoûi: "Hoøa Thöôïng laø thieän tri thöùc bridge of Chao Chou, example 52 of the Pi-Yen-              vì sao laïi coù buïi?" Trieäu Chaâu ñaùp: "Beân ngoaøi

ñeán." Vò Taêng laïi hoûi: "Giaø lam thanh tònh vì sao      horses and asses, men and women, carts heavy laïi coù buïi?" Trieäu Chaâu ñaùp: "Laïi coù moät ñieåm."   and light, but the whole world with its insanities Coù vò Taêng hoûi: "Theá naøo laø ñaïo?" Trieäu Chaâu       and morbidities, and which is not only thus passed ñaùp: "Ngoaøi töôøng aáy." Vò Taêng thöa: "Chaúng phaûi     over but quite frequently trampled down and even hoûi ñaïo naøy, hoûi ñaïi ñaïo." Trieäu Chaâu ñaùp: "Ñaïi   cursed; a bridge which suffers all these ñaïo thaáu Tröôøng An." Trieäu Chaâu rieâng duøng cô        treatments, good as well as despised, patiently and naøy, Sö ñeán choã bình thaät an oån, vì ngöôøi cuõng       uncomplainingly. Was Chao-chou referring to this khoâng chaïm beùn ñöùt tay, töï nhieân cao voùt, duøng      kind of bridge? In any event, Zen practitioners ñöôïc cô naøy quaù kheùo—A monk asked Chao                  should understand this story as above cited. One Chou, "For a long time I've heard of the stone              day Chao Chou was with the head monk looking bridge of Chao Chou, but now that I've come here            at the stone bridge when he asked the head monk, I just see a simple log bridge." Chao Chou said,            "Who built this?" The head monk said, "Li Ying "You just see the log bridge; you don't see the             built it." Chao Chou said, "When he built it, where stone bridge." The monk said, "What is the stone            did he start?" The head monk had no reply. Chao bridge?" Chao Chou said, "It lets asses cross, it           Chou said, "You're always talking about the stone lets horses cross." According to Yuan-Wu in the             bridge, but when you're asked about where it was Pi-Yen-Lu, in the place of Chao Chou there's a              started, you don't even know." Also one day when stone bridge; ever since it was built in the Latter         Chao Chou was sweeping the floor, a monk asked, Han dynasty by Li Ying, it has been famous                  "Teacher, you are a man of knowledge; why is throughout the country. A simple log bridge is a            there dust?" Chao Chou said, "It's something that bridge made of a single log. Intentionally                  comes from outside." Again the monk asked, "In a downgrading Chao Chou's grandeur, this monk                 pure and clean monastery, why is there dust?" questioned him saying, "For a long time I've heard          Chao Chou said, "There's another little bit." Also a of the stone bridge of Chao Chou, but now that              monk asked, "What is the Path?" Chao Chou said, I've come here I just see a simple log bridge."             "It's outside the wall." The monk said, "I'm not Chao Chou immediately said, "You just see the               asking about that path, I'm asking about the Great log bridge, but you don't see the stone bridge,"            Way." Chao Chou said, "The Great Way runs based on the other man's question. This seems just          through the capital." Chao Chou was partial to like ordinary conversation, but Chao Chou used it           using such devices; he would go to the safe secure to hook him. This monk after all climbed onto the           place of ordinary reality to help people. He never hook; he followed up behind and asked, "What is             cut his hand on the sharp point; naturally he was a stone bridge?" Chao Chou said, "It lets asses             solitary and lofty, using these devices most cross, it lets horses cross." Inevitably Chao Chou          wondrously. naturally has a place to show himself in his words.         Coâng AÙn Trieäu Chaâu Töù Moân: Chao-chou's Four Chao Chou is not like Lin Chi or Te Shan, carrying          Gates, example 9 of the Pi-Yen-Lu—Boán cöûa cuûa on with blows and shouts; he just uses words and            Trieäu Chaâu, thí duï thöù 9 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Moät speech to kill and bring to life. Take a good look          oâng Taêng hoûi Trieäu Chaâu: "Theá naøo laø Trieäu at this case. It seems to be an ordinary battle of          Chaâu?" Trieäu Chaâu ñaùp: "Cöûa Ñoâng, cöûa Taây, cöûa wits; it is nevertheless hard to approach. In fact, if      Nam, cöûa Baéc." Theo Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham considered from the inner way of looking at this            Luïc, phaøm keû tham thieàn hoûi ñaïo xeùt roõ chính case, there is a great deal of truth touching the           mình, toái kî giaûn traïch ngoân cuù. Ñaâu chaúng thaáy centre of one's spiritual life. Let see what kind of        Trieäu Chaâu ñaõ noùi: "Chí ñaïo voâ nan, chæ hieàm giaûn bridge is presented here. Was Chao-chou speaking            traïch." Laïi chaúng thaáy Vaân Moân noùi: "Hieän nay only a stone bridge in his monastery premises,              thieàn khaùch tuïm ba tuïm naêm noùi chuyeän oàn aøo, which was strong enough for all kinds of                    noùi caùi naày laø cuù ngöõ 'thöôïng taøi', caùi kia laø cuù ngöõ passengers over it? Zen practitioners! Let each             'töï thaân xöù.'" Hoï khoâng nhaän ra raèng ñaây chæ laø cöûa one of us reflect within himself and see if he is in        phöông tieän cuûa coå nhaân, vì keû sô cô haäu hoïc chöa possession of one bridge over which pass not only           roõ choã taâm ñòa, chöa thaáy baûn taùnh, neân baát ñaéc dó

maø laäp ra ngöõ cuù phöông tieän. Nhö Toå töø Thieân          of expedient means the Ancients couldn't help but truùc sang ñaây rieâng truyeàn taâm aán, chæ thaúng taâm       establish expedient verbal formulae for ngöôøi, kieán taùnh thaønh Phaät. Trong ñaây saén bìm          latecoming students of elementary capacities who nhö theá caàn phaûi chaët ñöùt ngöõ ngoân, caùch ngoaïi        had not yet clarified their mind ground nor seen thaáy Phaät, thaáu thoaùt ñöôïc roài, ñaùng goïi nhö roàng     their fundamental nature. For the Patriarch's gaëp nöôùc, nhö coïp töïa nuùi. Chính vì theá maø ngaøi        coming from the West for the sole transmission of Vaân Moân ñaõ noùi: "Vieäc naày neáu ôû treân ngoân cuù thì    the mind seal, directly pointing to the human ba thöøa möôøi hai phaàn giaùo haù khoâng ngoân cuù, caàn      mind for the perception of nature and fulfillment gì Toå Ñaït Ma töø AÁn Ñoä sang ñaây?" Thaät vaäy, haønh       of Buddhahood, where were there any such giaû tu thieàn phaûi thaáy cho thaät roõ raèng söï nhaán       complications? It is necessary to cut off words, to maïnh chính trong nhaø Thieàn laø khoâng döïa vaøo vaên        see the truth outside of any pattern. When you töï. Theo lôøi Phaät daïy trong Kinh Laêng Giaø, nhaø          penetrate through liberation, this can be compared Thieàn döïa vaøo thöïc taäp hôn laø vaên töï saùch vôû.        to a dragon reaching the water or a tiger at home Ngöôøi thöïc taäp thieàn thöôøng khuyeân “baát laäp vaên       in the mountains. That is why Yun-men said, "if töï.” Ñaây khoâng nhaát thieát laø ñeå phuû nhaän khaû naêng   this matter were in words, are there no words in dieãn ñaït cuûa vaên töï maø chæ ñeå traùnh söï nguy hieåm     the twelve part canon of the three vehicles? What cuûa söï maéc keït vaøo ngoân ngöõ maø thoâi. Ngöôøi ta        need would there have been for Bodhidharma's khuyeân chuùng ta neân duøng vaên töï moät caùch kheùo         coming from the West?" As a matter of fact, Zen leùo vì lôïi ích cuûa ngöôøi nghe. Vaøo theá kyû thöù 2,       practitioners should see clearly that the main ngaøi Long Thoï ñaõ vieát boä Trung Quaùn Luaän, bieåu         emphasis in Zen is "no establishment of words and tröng cho yù thöùc muoán söû duïng yù nieäm ñeå ñaäp vôõ yù    letters." According to the Buddha’s teachings in nieäm. Trung Quaùn Luaän khoâng nhaém tôùi söï thaønh          the Lankavatara Sutra, the Zen or intuitive school laäp moät yù nieäm hay moät luaän thuyeát naøo heát maø        does “not set up scriptures.” It lays stress on chæ nhaém tôùi vieäc phaù boû taát caû moïi yù nieäm, ñaäp     meditation and intuition rather than on books and vôõ heát taát caû moïi chai loï, oáng vaø bình ñeå cho ta      other external aids. People who practice Zen often thaáy nöôùc laø caùi gì khoâng caàn hình töôùng maø vaãn       advise not using words. This is not to discredit hieän thöïc. Ngaøi ñaõ phaùc hoïa ra moät ñieäu muùa cho       words, but to avoid the danger of becoming stuck chuùng ta nhaèm giuùp chuùng ta loaïi boû caùc khuoân          in them. It is to encourage us to use words as khoå yù nieäm tröôùc khi ñi vaøo söï theå nghieäm thöïc        skillfully as possible for the sake of those who taïi, ñeå khoâng töï maõn vôùi chính chuùng ta baèng           hear them. In the second century, Nagarjuna wrote nhöõng hình aûnh cuûa thöïc taïi. Ñaây laø moät trong taùm     “The Madhyamika Sastra,” in which he used nguyeân taéc caên baûn, cuûa tröïc giaùc hay lieân heä tröïc   concepts to destroy concepts. He was not trying to tieáp vôùi taâm linh cuûa tröôøng phaùi Thieàn Toâng—A         create a new doctrine, but to break all the bottles, monk asked Chao-chou, "What is Chao-chou?"                     all the flasks, all the vases, all the containers, to Chao-chou replied, "East gate, west gate, south                prove that water needs no form to exist. He gate, north gate." According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-             outlined a dance for us, a dance for us to drop our Yen-Lu, when you immerse yourself in meditation                categories and barriers so that we can directly and inquire about the Path, it is in order to clearly          encounter reality and not content ourselves with understand yourself; just avoid picking and                    its mere reflection. This is one of the eight choosing among verbal formulations. Why?                       fundamental principles, intuitional or relating to Haven't you read what Chao-chou said "The                      direct mental vision of the Zen School. ultimate path has no difficulties; just avoid picking          Coâng AÙn Tuyeát Phong Ñaïi Xaø: Hsueh Feng's and choosing." An haven't you read what Yun-                   Turtle-Nosed Snake, example 22 of the Pi-Yen- men said "These days whenever followers of                     Lu—Thí duï thöù 22 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Tuyeát Ch'an gather in threes and fives their mouths                  Phong daî chuùng: "Nuùi Nam coù con raén to, caû thaûy chatter on and on; they say 'these are words of                caùc oâng caàn phaûi kheùo xem." Tröôøng Khaùnh noùi: high ability, those are words uttered in reference             "Ngaøy nay trong nhaø coù ngöôøi tan thaân maát maïng." to the self.'" They don't realize that within the gate         Coù vò Taêng keå laïi cho Huyeàn Sa nghe, Huyeàn Sa

noùi: "Phaûi laø Laêng huynh môùi ñöôïc, tuy nhieân nhö       I am not this way." The monk asked, "What about theá, toâi thì chaúng vaäy." Vò Taêng hoûi: "Hoøa Thöôïng     you, Teacher?" Hsuan Sha said, "Why make use theá naøo?" Huyeàn Sa ñaùp: "Duøng nuùi Nam laøm gì?"         of 'South Mountain'?" Yun Men took his staff and Vaân Moân laáy caây gaäy neùm tröôùc Tuyeát Phong laøm        threw it down in front of Hsueh Feng, making a theá sôï. Theo Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc, neáu          gesture of fright. According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi- oâng an oån maëc tình an oån, neáu oâng ñaäp phaù maëc        Yen-Lu, if you speak it out evenly, I let you tình ñaäp phaù. Tuyeát Phong cuøng Nham Ñaàu, Khaâm           spread it out evenly; if you break it up, I let you Sôn laø baïn ñoàng haønh, ba phen ñeán Ñaàu Töû, chín         break it up. Hsueh Feng travelled with Yen T'ou laàn leân Ñoäng Sôn, sau tham vôùi Ñöùc Sôn môùi ñaäp         and Ch'in Shan. In all, he went to Mount T'ou Tzu beå thuøng sôn. Moät hoâm sö hoái thuùc Nham Ñaàu ñi          three times, and climbed Mount Tung nine times. tìm Khaâm Sôn, ñeán quaùn troï taïi Ngao Sôn gaëp luùc        Later he called on Te Shan, and only then did he trôû tuyeát. Nham Ñaàu moãi ngaøy chæ nguû khoø, Tuyeát       smash the lacquer bucket. One day he went along Phong moät beà toïa thieàn. Nham Ñaàu naït: "Nguû ñi!         with Yen T'ou to visit Ch'in Shan. They got as far Moãi ngaøy ngoài treân giöôøng gioáng nhö thoå ñòa troâng     as an inn on Tortoise Mountain in Hunan when baûy thoân, ngaøy sau ma mò nam nöõ nhaø ngöôøi."             they were snowed in. Day after day Yen T'ou just Tuyeát Phong töï chæ trong ngöïc noùi: "Toâi trong aáy        slept, while Hsueh Feng constantly sat in chöa oån, chaúng daùm töï doái." Nham Ñaàu baûo: "Toâi        meditation. Yen T'ou yelled at him and said, "Get baûo oâng veà sau leân ñænh coâ phong caát chieác am coû      some sleep! Every day you're on the meditation truyeàn baø ñaïi giaùo, vaãn coøn noùi lôøi naày." Tuyeát     seat, exactly like a clay image. Another time, Phong noùi: "Toâi thaät chöa oån." Nham Ñaàu baûo:            another day, you'll fool the sons and dughters of "Neáu oâng thaät nhö theá, cöù choã thaáy cuûa oâng moãi      other people's families." Hsueh Feng pointed to moãi thoâng qua, choã phaûi toâi chöùng minh cho oâng,        his breast and said, "I am not yet at peace here; I choã chaúng phaûi toâi deïp boû." Tuyeát Phong beøn thuaät    don't dare deceive myself." Yen T'ou said, "I had laïi: "Khi thaáy Dieâm Quan thöôïng ñöôøng noùi veà           thought that later on you would go to the summit nghóa saéc khoâng lieàn ñöôïc choã vaøo." Nham Ñaàu           of a solitary peak, build a hut of straw, and baûo: "Caùi naày ba möôi naêm toái kî nhaéc laïi." Tuyeát     propagate the great teaching: but you're still Phong keå tieáp: "Thaáy baøi tuïng qua caàu cuûa Ñoäng        making such a statement as this." Hsueh Feng Sôn lieàn ñöôïc choã vaøo." Nham Ñaàu baûo: "Neáu theá        said, "I am really not yet at peace." Yen T'ou said, aáy töï cöùu chaúng xong." Tuyeát Phong keå: "Sau ñeán        "If you're really like this, bring forth your views Ñöùc Sôn hoûi 'Vieäc trong Toâng thöøa veà tröôùc, con        one by one; where they're correct I'll approve coù phaàn chaêng?' Bò Ñöùc Sôn ñaùnh cho moät gaäy,           them for you, and where they're wrong I'll prune 'hoûi caùi gì?' Khi aáy toâi nhö thuøng luûng ñaùy." Nham     them away for you." Then Hsueh Feng related, Ñaàu naït baûo: "OÂng chaúng nghe noùi 'Töø cöûa vaøo         "When I saw Yen Kuan up in the hall bringing up chaúng phaûi cuûa baùu trong nhaø?'" Tuyeát Phong hoûi:       the meaning of form and void, I gain an entry." "Sau naày theá naøo môùi phaûi?" Nham Ñaàu baûo:              Yen T'ou said, "Henceforth for thirty years avoid "Ngaøy sau neáu muoán truyeàn baù ñaïi giaùo thì moãi         mentioning this." Again Hsueh Feng said, "When I moãi phaûi töø hoâng ngöïc löu xuaát, mai kia seõ cuøng ta    saw Tung Shan's verse on crossing the river, I had che trôøi che ñaát ñi." Tuyeát Phong ngay lôøi naày ñaïi      an insight." Yen T'ou said, "This way, you won't ngoä, leã baùi, ñöùng daäy keâu lieân hoài: "Ngaøy nay môùi   be able to save yourself." Hsueh Feng went on, thaønh ñaïo ôû Ngao Sôn! Ngaøy nay môùi thaønh ñaïo ôû        "Later when I got to Te Shan I asked, 'Do I have a Ngao Sôn!"—Hsueh Feng taught the assembly                     part in the affair of the vehicle of the most ancient saying, "On South Mountain there's a turtle-nosed             sect, or not?' Te Shan struck me a blow of his staff snake. All of you people must take a good look."              and said, 'What are you saying?' At that time it Ch'ang Ch'ing said, "In the hall today there                  was like the bottom of the bucket dropping out for certainly are people who are losing their bodies              me." Thereupon Yen T'ou shouted and said, and their lives." A monk related this to Hsuan Sha.           "Haven't you heard it said that what comes in Hsuan She said, "It takes Elder Brother Leng (Hui             through the gate is not the family jewels?" Hsueh Leng Ch'ang Ch'ing) to be like this. Nevertheless,            Feng said, "Then what should I do?" Yen T'ou

said, "In the future, if you want to propagate the           sau, neáu noùi vôùi y thì ngöôøi trong thieân haï laøm gì great teaching, let each point flow out from your            ñöôïc laõo Tuyeát." Taêng ñeán cuoái haï nhaéc laïi vieäc own breast, to come out and cover heaven and                 tröôùc thöa hoûi. Nham Ñaàu hoûi: "Sao khoâng hoûi earth for me." At these words Hsueh Feng was                 sôùm?" Taêng thöa: "Chöa daùm khinh thöôøng." greatly enlightened. Then he bowed, crying out               Nham Ñaàu noùi: " Tuyeát Phong tuy cuøng ta ñoàng again and again, "Today on Tortoise Mountain                 ñieàu sanh, chaúng cuøng ta ñoàng ñieàu töû, caàn bieát I've finally achieved the Way! Today on Tortoise             caâu roát sau chæ laø nhö theá." Theo Vieân Ngoä trong Mountain I've finally achieved the Way!"                     Bích Nham Luïc, phaøm laø ngöôøi phuø trì toâng giaùo Coâng AÙn Tuyeát Phong Ñaøo Meã Thoaïi: Hsueh-               phaûi bieän roõ ñöông cô, bieát tieán thoái phaûi quaáy, feng's straining the rice—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô duyeân       raønh gieát soáng giöõ tha. Neáu nhö con maét môø môø vaán ñaùp giöõa Thieàn sö Khaâm Sôn vaø Tuyeát Phong         mòt mòt ñeán nôi gaëp hoûi thì hoûi, gaëp ñaùp thì ñaùp, taïi Ñoäng Sôn. Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc,          khoâng bieát loã muõi ôû trong tay ngöôøi khaùc. Tuyeát quyeån XVI, taïi Ñoäng Sôn, Tuyeát Phong laøm                Phong, Nham Ñaàu ñoàng tham kieán Ñöùc Sôn. Vò tröôûng ban trai phaïn (Phaïn Ñaàu) ñang ñaõi gaïo.          Taêng naøy tham vaán Tuyeát Phong kieán giaûi chæ ñeán Khaâm Sôn hoûi: “Ñaõi caùt boû gaïo hay ñaõi gaïo boû        theá aáy, cho ñeán yeát kieán Nham Ñaàu cuõng chaúng caùt?” Sö ñaùp: “Gaïo caùt ñoàng thôøi boû.” Khaâm Sôn       töøng thaønh ñöôïc moät vieäc, luoáng phieàn hai vò laõo hoûi: “Nhö vaäy ñaïi chuùng laáy gì aên?” Tuyeát Phong       Toân tuùc, moät hoûi moät ñaùp, moät giöõ moät tha, thaúng beøn laät uùp thau ñaõi gaïo. Khaâm Sôn noùi: “Cöù theo      ñeán ngaøy nay ngöôøi trong thieân haï thaønh aâm thanh nhôn duyeân naày, huynh hôïp ôû Ñöùc Sôn.”—The               kyø quaùi roái loaïn. Haõy noùi aâm thanh kyø quaùi ôû taïi koan about the potentiality and conditions of                choã naøo? Tuyeát Phong tuy traûi khaép nôi, roát sau ôû questions and answers between Zen master Ch'in-              quaùn troï Ngao Sôn nhôø Nham Ñaàu kích phaùt môùi Shan and Hsueh-feng at T’ung-Shan's place.                   ñöôïc döùt baët ñaïi trieät. Nham Ñaàu sau bò sa thaûi, ôû According to The Records of the Transmission of              beân hoà laøm ngöôøi ñöa ñoø, hai beâ n bôø treo moãi beân the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), Volume XVI,                       moät caùi baûn, coù ngöôøi caàn qua goõ moät tieáng baûn. Hsueh-Feng served as a rice cook at T'ung-Shan.              Nham Ñaàu noùi: "OÂng qua bôø kia, lieàn trong luøm One day as he was straining the rice, Ch'in-Shan             lau muùa cheøo chui ra." Tuyeát Phong veà Laõnh Nam asked him: “Do you strain the rice out from the              ôû am, vò Taêng naøy cuõng laø ngöôøi cöûu tham, Tuyeát sand, or do you strain the sand out from the rice?”          Phong thaáy ñeán laáy tay ñoùng cöûa am phoùng thaân ra Hsueh-Feng said: “Sand and rice are both strained            ngoaøi noùi laø caùi gì? Nhö hieän nay coù hoûi theá aáy, out at once.” Ch’in-Shan said: “In that case, what           lieàn chuïp laáy nghieàn ngaãm. Vò Taêng naøy cuõng laï, will the monks eat?” Hsueh-Feng then tipped over             chæ ñaùp laïi laø caùi gì? Tuyeát Phong cuùi ñaàu veà am. the rice pot. Ch’in-Shan said: “Go! Your affinity            Thöôøng thöôøng baûo ñaây laø voâ ngöõ hoäi vaäy. Vò accords with Te-Shan!”                                       Taêng naøy doø tìm chaúng ñöôïc. Coù ngöôøi noùi Tuyeát Coâng AÙn Tuyeát Phong: Thaäm Ma?: Hsueh                     Phong bò moät caâu hoûi cuûa vò Taêng naøy khieán phaûi Feng's What Is It?, example 51 of the Pi-Yen-                laëng caâm veà am. Ñaâu chaúng bieát yù Tuyeát Phong coù Lu—Tuyeát Phong Laø Caùi Gì? Thí duï thöù 51 cuûa            choã ñoäc haïi. Tuyeát Phong tuy ñöôïc tieän nghi sao Bích Nham Luïc. Khi Tuyeát Phong ôû am coù hai vò            laïi giaáu thaân baøy boùng? Sau vò Taêng mang coâng aùn Taêng ñeán leã baùi. Tuyeát Phong thaáy ñeán, laáy tay       naøy töø Tuyeát Phong ñeán Nham Ñaàu nhôø phaùn xeùt. ñoùng cöûa am, phoùng thaân ra ngoaøi, noùi: "Laø caùi       Ñeán nôi, Nham Ñaàu hoûi: "ÔÛ ñaâu ñeán?" Taêng thöa: gì?" Taêng cuõng noùi: "Laø caùi gì?" Tuyeát Phong cuùi      "Laõnh Nam ñeán." Nham Ñaàu laïi hoûi: "Töøng ñeán ñaàu veà am. Hai vò Taêng sau ñeán Nham Ñaàu, Nham           choã Tuyeát Phong chaêng?" Neáu caàn thaáy Tuyeát Ñaàu hoûi: "ÔÛ ñaâu ñeán?" Taêng thöa: "Laõnh Nam            Phong chæ moät caâu hoûi naøy kheùo ñeå maét xem thaáy. ñeán." Nham Ñaàu hoûi: "Töøng ñeán Tuyeát Phong              Vò Taêng ñaùp: "Töøng ñeán." Nham Ñaàu laïi hoûi: "Coù chaêng?" Taêng thöa: "Töøng ñeán." Nham Ñaàu hoûi:           ngoân cuù gì?" Lôøi naøy cuõng chaúng phaûi qua suoâng. "Coù nhöõng ngoân cuù gì?" Taêng thuaät laïi vieäc tröôùc.   Vò Taêng chaúng hieåu, chæ thieát chaî theo ngöõ maïch Nham Ñaàu hoûi: "OÂng aáy noùi gì?" Taêng thöa:              kia chuyeån. Nham Ñaàu hoûi: "Tuyeát Phong noùi gì?" "Khoâng noùi, chæ cuùi ñaàu veà am." Nham Ñaàu noùi:         Vò Taêng ñaùp: "Sö chæ cuùi ñaàu khoâng noùi maø ñi veà "OÂi! Ta hoái haän buoåi ñaàu chaúng noùi vôùi y caâu roát   am." Vò Taêng naøy ñaâu phaûi khoâng bieát Nham Ñaàu

mang giaøy coû ñi trong buïng oâng maáy löôït roài.               Phaät ba ñôøi ñöùng ôû döôùi gioù. Neáu oâng thaáu chaúng Nham Ñaàu noùi: "OÂi! Ta hoái haän buoåi ñaàu chaúng              ñöôïc thì tham: Nham Ñaàu noùi "Tuyeát Phong tuy noùi vôùi y caâu roát sau, neáu noùi vôùi y thì ngöôøi trong      cuøng ta ñoàng ñieàu sanh, chaúng cuøng ta ñoàng ñieàu thieân haï laøm gì ñöôïc laõo Tuyeát." Nham Ñaàu cuõng            töû," chæ moät caâu naøy töï nhieân coù choã xuaát thaân— laø giuùp maïnh chaúng giuùp yeáu. Vò Taêng nhö tröôùc            When Hsueh Feng was living in a hut, there were vaãn toái mòt chaúng phaân traéng ñen, oâm moät buïng             two monks who came to pay their respects. Seeing nghi, cho thöïc laø Tuyeát Phong chaúng hoäi, ñeán cuoái          them coming, he pushed open the door of the hut haï laïi nhaéc ñeán vieäc aáy ñeå thöa thænh. Nham Ñaàu           with his hand, popped out, and said, "What is it?" baûo: "Sao chaúng hoûi sôùm?" OÂng giaø naøy möu moâ              A monk also said, "What is it?" Hsueh Feng laøm sao? Vò Taêng thöa: "Chaúng daùm khinh                       lowered his head and went back inside the hut. thöôøng." Nham Ñaàu noùi: "Tuyeát Phong tuy cuøng ta              Later the monk came to Yen T'ou. Yen T'ou ñoàng ñieàu sanh, chaúng cuøng ta ñoàng ñieàu töû, caàn           asked, "Where are you coming from?" The monk bieát caâu roát sau chæ laø nhö theá." Nham Ñaàu quaù             said, "I've come from Ling Nan." Yen T'ou said, möïc chaúng tieác loâng maøy, caùc oâng cöùu caùnh laøm           "Did you ever go to Hsueh Feng?" The monk said, sao hoäi? Tuyeát Phong ôû trong hoäi Ñöùc Sôn laøm                "I went there." Yen T'ou said, "What did he have tröôûng trai phaïn, moät hoâm trai treã, Ñöùc Sôn oâm baùt        to say?" The monk recounted the preceding story. ñeán phaùp ñöôøng, Tuyeát Phong noùi: "Chuoâng chöa               Yen T'ou said, "What did he say?" The monk said, keâu, troáng chöa ñaùnh, oâng giaø oâm baùt ñi ñaâu?"             "He said nothing; he lowered his head and went Ñöùc Sôn khoâng noùi, cuùi ñaàu ñi veà phöông tröôïng.            back inside the hut." Yen T'ou said, "Alas! It's too Tuyeát Phong thuaät laïi vôùi Nham Ñaàu. Nham Ñaàu                bad I didn't tell him the last word before; if I had noùi: "Caû nhaø Ñöùc Sôn chaúng hoäi caâu roát sau." Ñöùc         told him, no one on earth could cope with old Sôn nghe, baûo thò giaû goïi ñeán phöông tröôïng hoûi:            Hsueh." At the end of the summer the monk again "OÂng chaúng nhaän laõo Taêng sao?" Nham Ñaàu thöa                brought up the preceding story to ask for thaàm yù naøy. Ñeán hoâm sau, Ñöùc Sôn thöôïng ñöôøng             instruction. Yen Tou said, "Why didn't you ask chaúng gioáng bình thöôøng. Nham Ñaàu ôû tröôùc Taêng             earlier?" The monk said, "I didn't dare to be ñöôøng voã tay cöôøi to, noùi: "Ñaùng möøng oâng giaø             casual." Yen T'ou said, "Though Hsueh Feng is hieåu caâu roát sau, sau naøy trong thieân haï khoâng laøm        born of the same lineage as me, he doesn't die in gì ñöôïc oâng; tuy vaäy, chæ ñöôïc ba naêm." Coâng aùn            the same lineage as me. If you want to know the naøy nhö Tuyeát Phong thaáy Ñöùc Sôn ñeàu khoâng                  last word, just this is it." According to Yuan-Wu in noùi. Seõ baûo laø ñöôïc tieän nghi, ñaâu bieát laøm giaëc roài   the Pi-Yen-Lu, whoever would uphold the vaäy. Bôûi Sö töøng laøm giaëc, sau naøy cuõng kheùo laøm         teaching of our school must discern how to take giaëc. Vì theá coå nhaân noùi: "Moät caâu roát sau môùi ñeán      charge of the situation; he must know advance and cöûa lao quan." Coù ngöôøi noùi Nham Ñaàu hôn Tuyeát              retreat, right and wrong; he must understand Phong. Haún laø hieåu laàm roài vaäy. Nham Ñaàu                   killing and giving life, capturing and releasing. If thöôøng duøng cô naøy daïy chuùng: "Keû maét saùng                one's eyes suddenly blur and go sightless, khoâng hang oå, boû vaät laø thöôïng, theo vaät laø haï, caâu     everywhere he goes, when he encounters a roát sau giaû söû thaân thaáy Toå sö ñeán cuõng lyù hoäi          question, he questions, and when he encounters an chaúng ñöôïc." Trai treã, Ñöùc Sôn oâm baùt ñeán phaùp            answer, he answers, scarcely realizing that his ñöôøng. Nham Ñaàu noùi caû nhaø Ñöùc Sôn chöa hoäi                nostrils are in the hands of others. As for Hsueh ñöôïc caâu roát sau. Tuyeát Ñaäu nieäm: "Töøng nghe               Feng and Yen T'ou, they were fellow students noùi ñoäc nhaõn long nguyeân lai chæ moät con maét."              under Te Shan. When these monks called on Ñaâu bieát Ñöùc Sôn laø con coïp khoâng raêng, neáu               Hsueh Feng their views only reached to such a chaúng phaûi Nham Ñaàu bieát ñöôïc, sao bieát hoâm qua            place as seen in this case; when the monk saw cuøng ngaøy nay chaúng ñoàng. Caùc oâng caàn hoäi caâu            Yen T'ou, he still didn't complete his business. He roát sau chaêng? Chæ cho laõo Hoà bieát, chaúng cho laõo          troubled these two worthies to no purpose. One Hoà hieåu. Töø xöa ñeán nay, coâng aùn muoân sai ngaøn            question, one answer, one capture, one release; khaùc nhö röøng gai goùc, neáu oâng thaáu ñöôïc thì               right up till today this case has been impenetrably ngöôøi trong thieân haï khoâng laøm gì ñöôïc oâng, chö            obscure and inexplicable for everyone in the

world. But tell me, where is it impenetrable and    cope with old Hsueh." Yen T'ou too supports the obscure? Though Hsueh Feng had travelled all        strong but doesn't help the weak. As before the over the various localities, at last it was at      monk was flooded with darkness and didn't Tortoise Mountain because Yen T'ou spurred him      distinguish initiate from naive. Harboring a on that he finally attained annihilation of doubt   bellyful of doubt, he really thought that Hsueh and great penetration. Later, due to a purge, Yen   Feng did not understand. At the end of the summer T'ou became a ferryman by the shores of Lake O      he again brought up this story and asked Yen T'ou Chu (in Hu-Peh). On each shore hung a board:        for more instruction. Yen T'ou said, "Why didn't Yen T'ou would call out, "Which side are you        you ask earlier?" This old fellow was crafty. The crossing to?" Then he would wave his oar and        monk said, "I didn't dare to be casual." Yen T'ou come out from among the reeds. After his            said, "Though Hsueh Feng is born of the same enlightenment with Yen T'ou, Hsueh Feng             lineage as me, he doesn't die in the same lineage returned to Ling Nan and lived in a hut. These      as me. If you want to knowthe last word, just this monks were people who had studied for a long        is it." Yen T'ou indeed did not spare his eyebrows! time. When he saw them coming, Hsueh Feng           In the end, how will all of you people understand? pushed open the door of the hut, popped out and     Hsueh Feng was the cook in Te Shan's said, "What is it?" Some people these days when     community. One day the noon meal was late; Te questioned in this way immediately go and gnaw      Shan took his bowl and went down to the teaching on his words. But these monks were unusual too;     hall. Hsueh Feng said, "The bell hasn't rung yet, they just said to him "What is it?" Hsueh Feng      the drum hasn't been sounded; where is this old lowered his head and went back into the hut. This   fellow going with his bowl?" Without saying is frequently called "wordless understanding;"      anything, Te Shan lowered his head and returned hence, these monks couldn't find him. Some say      to his abbot's quarters. When Hsueh Feng took this that, having been questioned by these monks,        up to Yen T'ou, T'ou said, "Even the great Te Hsueh Feng was in fact speechless, and so he        Shan doesn't understand the last word." Te Shan returned to the hut. How far they are from          heard of this and ordered his attendant to summon knowing that there is something deadly poisonous    Yen T'ou to the abbot's quarters. Shan said, "So in Hsueh Feng's intention. Though Hsueh Feng        you don't approve of me?" Yen T'ou tacitly gained the advantage, nevertheless while he hid     indicated what he meant. The next day Te Shan his body, he revealed his shadow. Later one monk    went up to the hall and taught in a way which was left Hsueh Feng and took this case to have Yen      different from usual; in front of the monks' hall T'ou decide it. Once he got there, Yen T'ou asked   Yen T'ou clapped his hands and laughed loudly him, "Where are you coming from?" The monk          saying, "Happily the old fellow doesn't understand said, "I've come from Ling Nan." Yen T'ou said,     the last word! After this no one on earth will be "Did you get to Hsueh Feng?" If you want to see     able to do anything about him. Nevertheless, he's Hsueh Feng, you better hurry up and look at this    only got three years." When Hsueh Feng saw Te question. The monk said, "I went there." Yen T'ou   Shan speechless, he thought that he had gained said, "What did he have to say?" This question      the advantage. He certainly didn't know that he was not posed to no purpose. But the monk did not   had run into a thief. Since he had met a thief, later understand: he just turned around following the     Hsueh Feng too knew how to be a thief. Thus an trend of his words. Yen T'ou said, "What did he     Ancient said, "At the final word, one first reaches say?" The monk said, "He lowered his head and       the impenetrable barrier." Some say that Yen T'ou went back into the hut without saying anything."    excelled Hsueh Feng; they have misunderstood. This monk was far from knowing that Yen T'ou        Yen T'ou always used this ability; he taught his had put on straw sandals and had already walked     community saying, "Clear-eyed folks have no around inside his belly several times. Yen T'ou     clicheùs to nest in. Spurning things is considered said, "Too bad I didn't tell him the last word      superior, pursuing things is considered inferior. As before; if I had told him, no one on earth could    for this last word, even if you've personally seen

the Patriarchs, you still wouldn't be able to                 He was indefatigably rigorous; three times he understand it rationally." When Te Shan's noon                climbed Mount T'ou-Tzu, nine times he went to meal was late, the old fellow picked up his bowl              Tung Shan. Wherever he went, he would set up himself and went down to the teaching hall. Yen               his lacquer tub and wooden spoon and serve as the T'ou said, "Even great Te Shan doesn't understand             rice steward, just for the sake of penetrating this the last word." Hsueh Tou picked this out and said,           matter. Zen practitioners should always remember "I've heard that from the beginning a lone-eyed               that ancient virtues' verse is this way, their dragon has only one eye. You certainly didn't                 intention is not like this. They have never made up know that Te Shan was a toothless tiger. If it                principles to bind people. That's why Hsueh-tou hadn't been for Yen T'ou seeing through him, how              said, "In the mirror of Ts'ao Ch'i, absolutely no could we know that yesterday and today are not                dust." Someone says this has nothing to do with the same?" Do all of you want to understand the               the above head phrase, but the truth is always the last word? An Ancient said, "I only allow that the            truth: a still mind is the bright mirror itself. old barbarian knows; I don't allow that he                    Coâng AÙn Tuyeát Phong Voâ Dieän Nhaân: Hsueh- understands." From ancient times up till now, the             Feng's no-faced man—T’ung-Shan's questioning a public cases have been extremely diverse, like a              monk "Have you reached the peak?"—Coâng aùn forest of brambles. If you can penetrate through,             noùi veà cô duyeân vaán ñaùp giöõa Thieàn sö Tuyeát no one on earth can do anything about you, and all            Phong vaø Ñoäng Sôn Löông Giôùi. Theo Caûnh Ñöùc the Buddhas of past, present, and future defer to             Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån XVI, khi Tuyeát Phong you. If you are unable to penetrate, study Yen                ñeán taïm bieät Ñoäng Sôn, Ñoäng Sôn hoûi: “Ngöôi ñi T'ou's saying, "Though Hsueh Feng is born in the              ñaâu?” Tuyeát Phong thöa: “Ñi veà trong ñaûnh nuùi.” same lineage as me, he doesn't die in the same                Ñoäng Sôn hoûi: “Ñöông thôøi töø ñöôøng naøo ra?” Sö lineage as me." Spontaneously, in just this one               thöa: “Töø ñöôøng vöôïn bay ñaûnh nuùi ra.” Ñoäng Sôn sentence, he had a way to express himself.                    hoûi: “Nay quay laïi ñöôøng naøo ñi?” Sö thöa: “Töø Coâng AÙn Tuyeát Phong Tuùc Laïp: Hsueh-feng's                ñöôøng vöôïn bay ñaûnh nuùi ñi.” Ñoäng Sôn baûo: “Coù Grain of Rice, example 5 of the Pi-Yen-Lu—Thí                 ngöôøi chaúng töø ñöôøng vöôïn bay ñaûnh nuùi ñi, ngöôi duï thöù 5 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Tuyeát Phong daïy             bieát chaêng?” Sö thöa: “Chaúng bieát.” Ñoäng Sôn hoûi: chuùng: "Caû quaû ñaát naém laïi lôùn baèng haït luùa haït    “Taïi sao chaúng bieát?” Sö thöa: “Y khoâng maët gaïo, neùm ñeán tröôùc maët, chaúng hieåu, thuøng sôn,        maøy.” Ñoäng Sôn baûo: “Ngöôi ñaõ chaúng bieát, sao ñaùnh troáng phoå thænh xem." Thaät tình maø noùi, coå        bieát khoâng maët maøy?” Sö khoâng ñaùp ñöôïc—The nhaân tieáp vaät lôïi sanh coù choã kyø ñaëc. Tuyeát Phong    koan about the potentiality and conditions of chaúng quaûn gian lao, ba phen leân Ñaàu Töû, chín laàn       questions and answers between Zen master ñeán Ñoäng Sôn, mang thuøng thoâng muoãng goã, ñeán           Hsueh-feng and T’ung-Shan. According to The nôi laøm tröôûng trai phaïn, cuõng chæ vì thaáu thoaùt        Records of the Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan- vieäc naày. Haønh giaû Tu thieàn neân luoân nhôù raèng        Teng-Lu), Volume XVI, when Hsueh-Feng left ngöôøi xöa caâu tuy nhö theá, yù chaúng nhö theá, troïn       T’ung-Shan, T’ung-Shan asked him: “Where are khoâng taïo ñaïo lyù ñeå troùi buoäc ngöôøi. Chính vì vaäy    you going?” Hsueh-Feng said: “I’m returning to maø Thieàn sö Tuyeát Ñaäu ñaõ nhaéc nhôû: "Trong vaét         Ling-Zhong. T’ung-Shan said: “When you left Taøo Kheâ göông chaúng nhô." Coù ngöôøi noùi khoâng           Ling-Zhong to come here, what road did you dính daùng ñeán caâu thoaïi treân, nhöng söï thaät vaãn laø   take?” Hsueh-Feng said: “I took the road through söï thaät: taâm laëng lieàn laø göông saùng—Hsueh-feng,       the Flying Ape Mountain.” T’ung-Shan asked: teaching his assembly, said, "Pick up the whole               “And what road are you taking to go back there?” great earth in your fingers, and it's as big as a             Hsueh-Feng said: “I’m returning through the grain of rice. Throw it down before you: if, like a           Flying Ape Mountains as well.” T’ung-Shan said: lacquer bucket, you don't understand, I'll beat the           “There’s someone who doesn’t take the road drum to call everyone to look." As a matter of                through Flying Ape Mountains. Do you know fact, there was something extraordinary in the way            him?” Hsueh-Feng said: “I don’t know him.” this Ancient guided people and benefited beings.              T’ung-Shan said: “Why don’t you know him?”

Hsueh-Feng said: “Because he doesn’t have a                   zazen endlessly. What is nonthinking? Think face.” T’ung-Shan said: “If you don’t know him,               without thinking! Sit without sitting. What kind of how do you know he doesn’t have a face?”                      thinking is this? What kind of zazen is this? Or, Hsueh-Feng was silent.                                        what is the thinking of zazen? What does zazen Coâng AÙn Töôûng Voâ Töôûng: Think of not                     think when zazen is doing zazen? When doing thinking—Theá naøo laø suy nghó caùi khoâng suy nghó?         zazen, you really drop body and mind. This is the Chaúng suy nghó gì caû. Ñoù chính laø ngheä thuaät cô         most important way to do zazen. What is he baûn cuûa Toïa thieàn. Ñaây laø chæ cho coâng aùn cuûa        talking about? And what is the difference between Döôïc Sôn Hoaèng Ñaïo (751-834). Coù moät vò Taêng            koan and zazen in dropping body and mind? hoûi Thieàn sö Döôïc Sôn: "Khi toïa thieàn, chuùng ta         Maintain this one Buddha-mind seal. What is this suy nghó ñieàu gì?" Döôïc Sôn ñaùp: "Caùi laõo Taêng          Buddha-mind seal? It's koan. It's shikantaza. It's suy nghó laø khoâng suy nghó." Noùi caùch khaùc, ñieàu        Shobogenzo, the treasury of the true dharma eye Döôïc Sôn suy nghó laø khoâng suy nghó hay chaúng             and subtle mind of nirvana. And how to maintain suy nghó gì caû. Vò Taêng laïi hoûi moät caùch töï nhieân:    this one Buddha-mind seal is our practice, our life! "Khoâng suy nghó laø suy nghó theá naøo? Khoâng ñöôïc         Our vows, our aspirations, are to truly maintain suy nghó, chaúng suy nghó laø suy nghó ra sao?" Döôïc         this Buddha-mind seal. Do not let this torch die Sôn ñaùp: "Khoâng suy nghó gì caû." Theo Thieàn sö            out! Ñaïo Nguyeân trong quyeån Chaùnh Phaùp Nhaõn Taïng,           Coâng AÙn Vaïn Phaùp Qui Nhaát; Nhaát Qui Haø chuùng ta coù theå ñi thaúng vaøo baûn chaát cuûa Toïa        Xöù?: Muoân phaùp ñeàu quy veà moät moái: bình ñaúng Thieàn. Theá naøo laø khoâng suy nghó? Ñoù laø suy nghó       vaø baát nhò—Everything reverts to one: equal and caùi khoâng suy nghó (töôûng caùi voâ töôûng). Ngoài maø      non-dual—Chao Chou's Seven Pound Cloth Shirt, khoâng ngoài! Suy nghó naøy laø suy nghó nhö theá naøo?       example 45 of the Pi-Yen-Lu—Thí duï thöù 45 cuûa Khi Toïa Thieàn thì caû thaân laãn taâm ñeàu giaûi thoaùt.    Bích Nham Luïc. Moät vò Taêng hoûi Trieäu Chaâu: Ñaây laø phöông phaùp quan troïng nhaát cuûa Toïa             "Muoân phaùp veà moät, moät veà choã naøo?" Trieäu Chaâu Thieàn. Vaäy thì Thieàn sö Ñaïo Nguyeân muoán noùi veà        ñaùp: "Ta ôû Thanh Chaâu deät ñöôïc moät taám vaûi boá caùi gì? Vaø khi thaân taâm giaûi thoaùt thì coâng aùn vaø    naëng baûy caân." Theo Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham Toïa Thieàn coù gì khaùc nhau? Phaûi duy trì cho ñöôïc        Luïc, neáu nhaèm choã moät kích ñoäng lieàn ñi hoäi caùi Phaät Taâm AÁn naøy. Phaät Taâm AÁn naøy laø caùi gì?    ñöôïc, loã muõi caùc vò Hoøa Thöôïng giaø ôû moïi nôi, Noù chính laø coâng aùn, laø Chæ quaùn ñaû toïa, laø Chaùnh   moät luùc xoû xong, khoâng laøm gì ñöôïc oâng, töï nhieân phaùp nhaõn taïng, laø Nieát baøn dieäu taâm. Vaø laøm        nöôùc doàn thaønh ñaàm. Neáu laø nhaûy nhoùt thì laõo caùch naøo ñeå duy trì caùi Phaät Taâm AÁn naøy chính laø     Taêng ôû döôùi goùt chaân oâng. Choã tinh yeáu cuûa Phaät söï tu haønh cuûa mình, laø ñôøi soáng cuûa chính mình!       phaùp chaúng phaûi ôû nhieàu lôøi, chaúng phaûi ôû noùi laém. Theä nguyeän cuûa chuùng ta, nguyeän voïng cuûa chuùng        Chæ nhö vò Taêng naøy hoûi Trieäu Chaâu "Muoân phaùp ta ñeàu laø giöõ laáy caùi Phaät Taâm AÁn naøy moät caùch     veà moät, moät veà choã naøo?" Trieäu Chaâu laïi ñaùp: "Ta chaân thaät. Ñöøng ñeå cho aùnh ñuoác naøy bò daäp taét!—     ôû Thanh Chaâu deät ñöôïc moät taám vaûi boá naëng baûy How do you think of not-thinking? Nonthinking.                caân." Neáu nhaèm treân ngöõ cuù maø bieän thì laàm nhaän This is in itself the essential art of sitting                ñònh baøn tính (moät tieâu chuaån coá ñònh). Neáu chaúng meditation (zazen). This refers to a famous koan              nhaèm treân ngöõ cuù maø bieän, taïi sao laïi noùi theá aáy? by Matser Yakusan Igen. A monk asked Zen                      Coâng aùn naøy tuy khoù thaáy maø deã hoäi, tuy deã hoäi master Yakusan Igen, "When we do zazen, what                  laïi khoù thaáy. Khoù thì nuùi baïc vaùch saét, deã thì lieàn do we think about?" Matser Yakusan replied,                   ñoù tænh tænh, khoâng coù choã cho oâng suy nghó phaûi "Think of the unthinkable." In other words, think             quaáy. Qua caâu traû lôøi cuûa Trieäu Chaâu, roõ raøng of nothing, or no-thinking. The monk's question               Thieàn muoán coù moät taâm hoàn töï do vaø khoâng bò trôû naturally follows: "How can we think of not-                  ngaïi daàu laø khaùi nieäm veà "moät" hay "toaøn theå" thinking?" Or of the unthinkable, or no-thinking?             cuõng ñeàu laø chöôùng ngaïi vaät vaø moät caùi baãy ñe Matser       Yakusan         replied,    "Nonthinking."       doïa ñeán söï töï do ban ñaàu cuûa tinh thaàn. Giaû söû, coù According to Zen master Dogen in the                          ngöôøi khoâng traû lôøi ñöôïc caâu hoûi ngay luùc ñoù, maø "Shobogenzo", we could penetrate this essence of              trôû veà Thieàn thaát nghieàn ngaãm roài hoâm sau trôû laïi

traû lôøi Trieäu Chaâu: "Baây giôø thì toâi ñaõ coù caâu traû    troïng!—A monk asked Chao Chou, "The myriad lôøi ñuùng cho caâu hoûi cuûa Thaày ñaây: 'Vaïn phaùp qui        things return to one. Where does the one return nhaát, nhaát qui vaïn phaùp.'" Nhöng coù leõ Trieäu Chaâu        to?" Chao Chou said, "When I was in Ch'ing Chou seõ noùi: "Theo tinh thaàn nhaø Thieà n thì caâu traû lôøi       I made a cloth shirt. It weighed seven pounds." cuûa oâng ñeán quaù treã. OÂng ñaùng laõnh ba chuïc heøo         According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, if you laâu roài." Thieàn hoaøn toaøn khoâng thích hôïp vôùi            understand "going immediately at one stroke," nhöõng danh xöng nhö vaäy. Trong Thieàn, hoaøn toaøn             then you've pierced the nostrils of the world's old khoâng coù ñoái töôïng naøo ñeå naém baét, daàu ñoù laø          teachers all at once, and they can't do a thing "Phaät" hay "Boà Taùt". Thieàn laø ñaùm maây phieâu              about you. Naturally where water goes, a channel laõng treân baàu trôøi. Khoâng coù con oác naøo coù theå sieát   forms. But if you vacillate and hesitate, the old chaët ñöôïc noù, khoâng coù sôïi daây naøo coù theå troùi noù    monk Chao Chou is under your feet. The essential ñöôïc caû, noù maëc tình töï taïi. Thoaïi naøy cuøng caâu        point of the Buddhist Teaching is not a matter of Phoå Hoùa noùi "Ngaøy mai ôû trong vieän Ñaïi Bi coù             many words or verbose speech. A monk asked trai," laïi khoâng coù hai thöù. Moät hoâm, coù vò Taêng         Chao Chou, "The myriad things return to one. hoûi Trieäu Chaâu: "Theá naøo laø yù Toå Sö töø Taây             Where does the one return to?" Yet Chao Chou sang?" Trieäu Chaâu ñaùp: "Caây baùch tröôùc saân." Vò           answered him saying, "When I was in Ch'ing Chou Taêng thöa: "Hoøa Thöôïng chôù ñem caûnh chæ                     I made a cloth shirt; it weighed seven pounds." If ngöôøi." Trieäu Chaâu baûo: "Laõo Taêng chaúng töøng             you go to the words to discriminate you are ñem caûnh chæ ngöôøi." Xem kia theá aáy, nhaèm choã              mistakenly abiding by the zero point of a scale. If cöïc taéc chuyeån chaúng ñöôïc, neáu chuyeån ñöôïc töï           you don't go to the words to discriminate, what can nhieân che trôøi che ñaát. Neáu chuyeån chaúng ñöôïc thì         you do about it that he did nevertheless speak this chaïm ñeán lieàn thaønh keït. Haõy noùi Trieäu Chaâu coù         way? This case, though hard to see, is Phaät phaùp thöông löôïng hay khoâng? Neáu noùi coù              nevertheless easy to understand; though easy to Phaät phaùp, Trieäu Chaâu ñaâu töøng noùi taâm noùi taùnh,       understand, it's still hard to see. Insofar as it's hard, noùi huyeàn noùi dieäu. Neáu noùi khoâng coù chæ thuù Phaät      it's a silver mountain, an iron wall. Insofar as it's phaùp, Trieäu Chaâu chaúng töøng coâ phuï lôøi hoûi cuûa         easy, you are directly aware. There is no place for oâng. Ñaâu chaúng thaáy Taêng hoûi Hoø a Thöôïng Moäc            your calculations of right and wrong. Through Bình: "Theá naøo laø ñaïi yù Phaät phaùp?" Moäc Bình             Chao-chou's reply, it is clear that Zen wants to ñaùp: "Traùi ñoâng qua naøy lôùn nhö theá." Laïi coù moät        have one's mind free and unobstructed; even the vò Taêng hoûi coå ñöùc: "Choã nuùi saâu vöïc thaúm vaéng         idea of "oneness" or "allness" is a stumbling-block baët khoâng ngöôøi, laïi coù Phaät phaùp hay khoâng?" Coå        and a strangling snare which threatens the original ñöùc ñaùp: "Coù." Vò Taêng laïi hoûi: "Theá naøo laø Phaät       freedom of the spirit. Supposed, someone could phaùp trong nuùi saâu?" Coå ñöùc ñaùp: "Cuïc ñaù lôùn laø        not answer the question right at that moment, but lôùn, nhoû laø nhoû." Xem loaïi coâng aùn naøy lôøi kyø quaùi    went back to the meditation hall to reflect on the taïi choã naøo? Haønh giaû tu Thieàn phaûi neân luoân nhôù       question, and came back the next day to answer raèng Thieàn khoâng caàn chuùng ta suy nghó "taám vaûi           Chao-chou: "Now I have the right answer to your boá naëng baûy caân" coù thaàn tính hay khoâng. Vì neáu          question: 'All things are to be returned to the One, nhö theá thì Thieàn seõ rôi vaøo heä thoáng trieát hoïc, vaø     and this One is to be returned to all things.'" Chao- seõ khoâng coøn laø Thieàn nöõa. Kyø thaät, Thieàn chæ caûm      chou might have said to him: "According to the giaùc söï aám aùp cuûa löûa, caùi laïnh giaù cuûa baêng, vì      spirit of Zen, your answer came much too late. khi trôøi laïnh thì chuùng ta seõ bò laïnh vaø tìm caùch ñi      You should have received thirty blows a long time söôûi aám. Trong Thieàn, caûm giaùc laø taát caû vaø caûm        ago." Zen defies all such designations, even giaùc phaûi ñöôïc hieåu theo yù nghóa saâu saéc nhaát hay        though these are "Buddhas" or "Bodhisattvas". In hình thöùc thuaàn tuùy nhaát. Vaø ñieàu quan troïng nhaát        Zen, there is no object upon which to fix the maø chuùng ta phaûi luoân nhôù laø Thieàn laø tri giaùc          thought. Zen is a wafting cloud in the sky. No hoaëc caûm giaùc chöù khoâng phaûi tröøu töôïng hay traàm        screw fastens it, no string holds it; it moves as it tö, nhöng Thieàn laïi maïnh meõ baát chaáp khaùi nieäm.          pleases. This story is the same kind as the story of Chính vì vaäy maø Thieàn raát khoù naém baét ñöôïc. Caån         P'u Hua saying, "Tomorrow there's a feast at the

Temple of Great Compassion." One day a monk               giao laø cô thöù maáy?" Noùi xong Vaân Moân töï ñaùp: asked Chao Chou, "What is the meaning of the              "Nuùi Nam khôûi maây, nuùi Baéc rôi möa." Theo Vieân Patriarch coming from the West?" Chao Chou                Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc, Ñaïi sö Vaân Moân xuaát saod, "The cypress tree in the garden." The monk          phaùt hôn taùm möôi vò thieän tri thöùc. Baûy möôi naêm said, "Don't use objects to teach people with,            sau khi Sö thò tòch, ngöôøi ta khai thaùp thaáy thaân Teacher." Chao Chou said, "I've never use objects         nghieãm nhieân nhö xöa. Choã thaáy cuûa Sö minh to teach people." Observe how, at the ultimate            baïch cô caûnh chôùp nhoaùng, Ñaïi phaøm buoâng lôøi, point, where it is impossible to turn, he does turn,      noùi rieâng, thay noùi, haún laø cao voùt. Coâng aùn naøy and spontaneously covers heaven and earth. If you         nhö choïi ñaù nhaùng löûa, tôï laøn ñieån chôùp, quaû laø can't turn, wherever you set foot on the road you         thaàn ra quæ vaøo. Taïng Chuû Khaùnh noùi: "Moät ñaïi get stuck. But say, did Chao Chou ever have               taïng giaùo laïi coù ba loaïi thuyeát thoaïi chaêng?" Hieän discussions of Buddhist doctrine or not? If you say       nay ña phaàn ngöôøi ta nhaèm treân tình giaûi laøm keá he did, when has he ever spoken of mind or of             soáng, noùi: "Phaät laø baäc Ñaïo Sö cuûa tam giôùi, laø Töø nature, of mysteries or of marvels? If you say he         Phuï cuûa boán loaøi, ñaõ laø coå Phaät vì sao laïi cuøng coät didn't have the source meaning of the Buddhist            caùi töông giao?" Neáu hieåu theá aáy, chôït doø tìm Teaching, when has he ever turned his back on             chaúng ñöôïc. Coù ngöôøi baûo trong caùi khoâng noùi ra. anyone's question? Haven't you heard: a monk              Ñaâu chaúng bieát baäc toâng sö thuyeát thoaïi tuyeät yù asked Mu P'ing, "What is the great meaning of the         thöùc, tuyeät tình löôïng, tuyeät sanh töû, tuyeät phaùp Buddhist Teaching?" Mu P'ing said, "This winter           traàn, vaøo chaùnh vò laïi chaúng coøn moät phaùp. OÂng melon is so big." Again: a monk asked an ancient          vöøa khôûi ñaïo lyù so tính, lieàn bò troùi tay troùi chaân. worthy, "Deep in the mountains on an                      Haõy noùi coå nhaân kia yù theá naøo? Chæ khieán taâm overhanging cliff, in a remote, inaccessible,             caûnh nhaát nhö, toát xaáu phaûi quaáy lay ñoäng kia uninhabited place, is there any Buddhist Teaching         chaúng ñöôïc, noùi coù cuõng ñöôïc, noùi khoâng coù cuõng or not?" The ancient worthy said, "There is." The         ñöôïc, coù cô cuõng ñöôïc, khoâng cô cuõng ñöôïc, ñeán monk said, "What is Buddhist Teaching deep                trong ñaây nhòp nhòp ñeàu laø leänh. Nguõ Toå tieân sö within the mountains?" The ancient worthy said,           noùi: "Caû thaûy Vaân Moân xöa nay maät nhoû, neáu laø "The large rocks are large, the small ones small."        sôn Taêng chæ noùi vôùi Sö cô thöù taùm." Vaân Moân When you look at such a case, where are the               noùi: "Coå Phaät cuøng coät caùi töông giao laø cô thöù obscurities? Zen practitioners should always              maáy?" Khoaûng moät choác, haõy nhaèm bao truøm remember that Zen does not ask us to concentrate          tröôùc maët. Vò Taêng hoûi: "Chöa bieát yù chæ theá naøo?" our thought on the idea that a piece of "seven-           Vaân Moân ñaùp: "Moät sôïi daây baùn ba möôi xu." Sö pound cloth shirt" is divine. For when Zen does           coù con maét ñònh caøn khoân. Ñaõ khoâng coù ngöôøi hoäi, this, it commits itself to a definite system of           sau laïi töï thay noùi: "Nuùi Nam khôûi maây, nuùi Baéc philosophy, and there is no more Zen. In fact, Zen        rôi möa." Vì keû haäu hoïc môû moät loái vaøo. Do ñoù just feels fire warm and ice cold, because when it        Tuyeát Ñaäu chæ nieâm Sö ôû choã ñònh caøn khoân khieán freezes we shiver and welcome fire. In Zen, the           ngöôøi thaáy. Neáu phaïm suy tính, baøy muõi nhoïn aáy feeling is all and all, and the feeling must be           ñoái maët laàm qua. Chæ coát nguyeân veïn toâng chæ Vaân understood in its deepest sense or in its purest          Moân vaø roõ caùi cô cao voùt—Yun Men, teaching the form. And the most important thing that Zen               community said, "The ancient Buddhas and the practitioners should always remember is that Zen          pillar merge' what level of mental activity is this?" perceives or feels, and does not abstract nor             He himself said on their behalf, "On South meditate, but Zen strongly defies concept-making.         Mountain clouds gather, on North Mountain rain That is why Zen is difficult to grasp. Be careful!        falls." According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, Coâng AÙn Vaân Moân Coå Phaät Döõ Chaùnh Truï:            Great Master Yun Men produced more than Vaân Moân: Caây truï giöõa ñaát troáng—Yun Men's          eighty men of knowledge. Seventeen years after Ancient Buddhas and the Pillar, example 83 of the         he passed on, when they opened his tomb and Pi-Yen-Lu—Thí duï thöù 83 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc.            beheld him, his body was not decomposed, but Vaân Moân daïy chuùng: "Coå Phaät cuøng coät caùi töông   upright and sound formerly. The field of his vision

had been bright and clear, his mentality and            source of Yun Men's fundamental meaning to perspective swift. All his instructions, alternative    clearly understand his lofty mind. remarks, and words spoken on behalf of others           Coâng AÙn Vaân Moân Cöôùc Baû: Vaân Moân bò daäp were direct, solitary, and steep. This present case     chaân—Yun Men: The leg broke—Coâng aùn veà cô is like sparks struck from stone, like flashing         duyeân giaùc ngoä cuûa Thieàn sö Vaân Moân. Theo lightning; in fact, it's "a spirit appearing and a      Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån XIX, cô demon disappearing." Librarian Ch'ing said, "Is         duyeân giaùc ngoä cuûa Vaân Moân giôùi hoïc thieàn ñeàu there such talk in the whole great treasury of the      ñöôïc bieát ñeán. Khi tìm ñeán “tham ñoäc” vôùi Muïc Teachings?" People these days make their living         Chaâu, ngöôøi sau naày trôû thaønh Thaày cuûa oâng, Vaân on emotional interpretations and say "Buddha is         Moân goõ caùnh cöûa nhoû beân caïnh coång lôùn ñi vaøo the guide for the three realms, the compassionate       chuøa Muïc Chaâu. Muïc Chaâu goïi ra: “Ai theá?” Vaân father of the four others of living beings. Why then    Moân ñaùp: “Vaên Yeån.” Muïc Chaâu thöôøng khoâng do the ancient Buddhas merge with the pillar?" If       cho ai “ñoäc tham” tröø phi ngöôøi aáy coù nhieät tình. you understand this way, you'll never be able to        Tuy nhieân, oâng caûm thaáy haøi loøng vôùi caùch goõ cöûa find it. Some call Yun Men's saying "Calling out        cuûa Vaân Moân, chöùng toû Vaân Moân raát haêng say noã from within nothingness." They are far from             löïc vì ñaïo vaø chaáp nhaän cho Vaân Moân “ñoäc tham.” knowing that the talk of the teaching masters of        Vaân Moân vöøa böôùc vaøo thì Muïc Chaâu nhaän ra our schoolcuts off conceptual consciousness, cuts       ngay phong thaùi cuûa Vaân Moân, beøn naém vai baûo off emotional evaluation, cuts off birth and death,     Vaân Moân: “Nhanh leân, noùi ñi, noùi ñi!” Nhöng Vaân and cuts off the defilement of doctrine, enters the     Moân vaãn chöa ngoä neân khoâng theå ñaùp öùng ñöôïc. correct state without retaining anything at all. As     Ñeå ñaåy taâm Vaân Moân ñeán choã giaùc ngoä, ñoät nhieân soon as you rationalize and calculate, you tie your     Muïc Chaâu ñaåy Vaân Moân qua caùnh cöûa ñang heù hands and feet. But tell me, what was old Yun           môû vaø ñoùng saàm caùnh cöûa vaøo chaân cuûa Vaân Moân, Men's meaning? Just make mind and objects a             heùt: “Ñoà voâ tích söï,” cuøng vôùi tieáng keâu: “UÙi chaø!” single thusness; then good and bad, right and           Muïc Chaâu lieàn ñaåy Vaân Moân ra khoûi cöûa, caùnh wrong, won;t be able to shake you. Then it it will      cöûa ñoùp saäp laïi laøm cho moät baøn chaân cuûa Vaân be all right whether you say "there is" or "there       Moân bò keït laïi trong ñoù vaø gaõy ñi. Trong côn ñau isn't"; then it will be all right whether you have      ngaát, taâm cuûa Vaân Moân luùc aáy ñaõ troáng roãng moïi mental activity or you don't. When you get here,        tö nieäm, boãng nhieân giaùc ngoä. Tröôøng hôïp cuûa sö each and every clap of the hands is the true            khoâng phaûi laø moät bieät leä, vì tröôùc ñoù nhò Toå Hueä imperative. My late teacher Wu Tsu said, "Yun           Khaû cuõng ñaõ töøng chaët moät caùnh tay khi ñöùng Men, supposedly so great, really didn't have much       trong tuyeát laïnh, vaø Ñöùc Khoång Phu Töû cuõng töøng guts." If it were me, I just would have told him,       noùi “Sôùm nghe ñöôïc ñaïo, chieàu daãu coù cheát cuõng "The eighth level of mental activity." He said,         cam.” Treân ñôøi naày quaû coù nhieàu ngöôøi coi troïng "The ancient Buddhas and the pillar merge; what         chaân lyù hôn thaân maïng—The koan about the level of mental activity is this?" In that moment he    potentiality and conditions of enlightenment of wrapped it all up in front of you. When a monk          Zen master Yun-meân. According to the Records of asked him what this meant, Yun Men said, "one           the Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), belt worth thirty cents." He has the eye to judge       Volume XIX, the circumstances of Yun-Men’s heaven and earth. Since no one understood,              enlightenment are known to all Zen practitioners. afterwards he himself spoke on their behalf: "On        Seeking “private consultation” with Mu-Chou, South Mountain clouds gather, on North Mountain         who became his master later on, Yun-Meân rapped rain falls." Thus he opened up a route of entry for     on the little door on the side of the large gateway future students. That's why Hsueh Tou picks out         leading to Mu-Chou’s temple. Mu-Chou called the place where he settles heaven and earth to          out: “Who is it?” Yun Meân answered, “Wen-Yen” make people see. But as soon as you blunder into        Mu-Chou, whose habit it was to refuse “private calculation, you stumble past and miss it, though       consultation” to all but the most ardent truth- it's right in front of you. You simply must go to the   seekers, felt satisfied from Yun-Meân’s knock and

the tone of his voice that he was earnestly striving           cuûa oâng. Thuoác beänh trò nhau, cuõng chæ laø lôøi noùi for truth, and admitted him. Scarcely had he                   taàm thöôøng. Neáu oâng chaáp coù, vì oâng noùi khoâng, entered when Mu-Chou, perceiving the state of                  neáu oâng chaáp khoâng, vì oâng noùi coù, neáu oâng chaáp his mind, seized him by the shoulders and                      chaúng coù chaúng khoâng vì oâng queùt buïi deïp phaân. demanded: “Quick, say it, say it!” But Yun-Men                 Hieän kim thaân tröôïng saùu, vöøa hieän vöøa maát. Hieän not yet undrstanding, could not respond. To jolt his           nay caû ñaïi ñòa sum la vaïn töôïng cho ñeán chính mind into understanding, Mu-Chou suddenly                      mình ñoàng thôøi laø thuoác, ngay khi ñoù goïi caùi gì laø shoved him out through the partly opened door                  chính mình? OÂng moät beà goïi laø thuoác, ñeá n ñöùc and slammed it on his leg, shouting: “You good-                Phaät Di Laëc ra ñôøi cuõng chöa moäng thaáy Vaân for-nothing!” With a cry of “Ouch!” While the                  Moân. Cöùu caùnh theá naøo? Bieát laáy yù ñaàu löôõi caâu, door was hastily shut, one of Yun-Men’s legs was               chôù nhaän traùi caân baøn. Boà Taùt Vaên Thuø moät hoâm caught and broken. Yun-Meân , whose mind at that               sai Thieän Taøi ñi haùi thuoác, daën: "Chaúng phaûi thuoác moment was emptied of every thought. The                       haùi ñem veà." Thieän Taøi xem khaép ñeàu laø thuoác, trôû intense pain resulting from this apparently                    laïi baïch: "Caû thaûy ñeàu laø thuoác." Vaên Thuø baûo: awakened the poor fellow to the greatest fact of               "Laø thuoác haùi ñem veà." Thieän Taøi beøn caàm moät life. He suddenly became enlightened. The                      coïng coû ñöa Vaên Thuø. Vaên Thuø ñöa leân baûo realization now gained paid more than enough for               chuùng: "Thuoác naøy hay gieát ngöôøi cuõng hay cöùu the loss of his leg. He was not, however, a sole               ngöôøi." Caâu thuoác trò beänh nhau naøy raát khoù khaùn, instance in this respect, there were many such in              Vaân Moân ôû trong thaát, bình thöôøng duøng ñeå tieáp the history of Zen who were willing to sacrifice a             ngöôøi. Tröôûng laõo Kim Nga moät hoâm ñeán phoûng part of the body for the truth, i.e., Hui-K’o, the             vaán Tuyeát Ñaäu. Sö laø haøng taùc gia, chính laø baäc second patriarch, who cut his hand while standing              toân tuùc trong toâng Laâm Teá. Hai vò luaän caâu "Thuoác in the snow. Confucius also said: “If a man                    trò beänh nhau" suoát ñeâm, ñeán maët trôøi leân môùi toät understands the Tao in the morning, it is well with            lyù. Ñeán trong ñaây hoïc hieåu so saùnh suy nghó thaûy him even when he dies in the evening.” In this                 söû duïng khoâng ñeán—According to example 87 of life, some would feel indeed that truth is of more             the Pi-Yen-Lu, Yun Men, teaching his community, value than their own lives.                                    said, "Medicine and disease subdue each other: Coâng AÙn Vaân Moân Döôïc Beänh Töông Öng Ñieàu                the whole earth is medicine; what is your self?" Phuïc: Yun Men's Medicine and Disease Subdue                   According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, do all of Each Other—Theo thí duï thöù 87 cuûa Bích Nham                 you have a way to get out? Twenty-four hours a Luïc. Vaân Moân daïy chuùng: "Thuoác beänh trò nhau,           day, concentrate on "towering like a mile-high caû ñaïi ñòa ñeàu laø thuoác, caùi gì laø chính mình."         wall." Te Shan's blows fall like rain, Lin Chi's Theo Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc, Vaân Moân                shouts roll like thunder; putting this aside for the noùi thuoác beänh trò nhau, caû ñaïi ñòa ñeàu laø thuoác,      moment, Sakyamuni is himself Sakyamuni and caùi gì laø chính mình, caùc ngöôi laïi coù choã xuaát thaân   Maitreya is himself Maitreya. Those who don't chaêng? Trong möôøi hai giôø xem xeùt laáy, vaùch              know what it comes down to frequently ñöùng ngaøn nhaãn. Ñöùc Sôn gaäy ñaùnh nhö möa rôi.            understand by calling it "medicine and disease Laâm Teá heùt tôï saám vang; taïm gaùc laïi. Thích Ca töï      merging with each other." For forty-nine years, in Thích Ca, Di Laëc töï Di Laëc. Ngöôøi chöa bieát choã          more than three hundred assemblies, the World rôi, thöôøng baûo thuoác beänh hôïp nhau hieåu laáy. Theá      Honored One adapted to potential to set up the Toân 49 naêm hôn ba traêm hoäi, öùng cô noùi giaùo ñeàu        teachings; all of this was giving medicine in laø hôïp beänh cho thuoác, gioáng nhö ñem vieân maät           accordance with the disease, like exchanging ngoït nheùt trong traùi ñaéng, gaïn loïc nghieäp caên cuûa     sweet fruit for bitter gourds. Having purified your caùc oâng, khieán saïch trôn thong dong. Caû quaû ñaát laø     active faculties, he made you clean and free. "The thuoác, oâng nhaèm choã naøo caém moû? Neáu caém ñöôïc         whole earth is medicine." Where will you sink moû, cho oâng coù choã chuyeån thaân nhaû hôi, lieàn dieän     your teeth into this? If you can sink your teeth in, kieán Vaân Moân. Neáu oâng ngoù ngoaùi laïi truø tröø, haún    I'll grant that you have a place to turn around and laø caêm moû chaúng ñöôïc, Vaân Moân ôû döôùi goùt chaân       show some life; then you see Yun Men in person.

If you look around and hesitate, you won't be able         ngoân ngöõ vaø chieán thuaät maïnh baïo ñeå taùc ñoäng to get your teeth into it; Yun Men is the one under        moân sinh ñaït töï ngoä. Nhöõng caâu traû lôøi vaø chaâm your feet. "Medicine and disease subdue each               ngoân cuûa Vaân Moân raát ñöôïc coi troïng trong truyeàn other." This is just an ordinary proposition. If you       thoáng nhaø Thieàn. Khoâng moät thaày naøo ñöôïc daãn ra cling to existence, he speaks of nonexistence for          nhieàu nhö oâng trong caùc söu taäp coâng aùn. Nhöõng you; if you are attched to nonexistence, he speaks         lôøi cuûa oâng bao giôø cuõng coù ñuû ba ñieàu kieän cuûa of existence for you. If you are attached to neither       moät chaâm ngoân Thieàn coù hieäu quaû. Thöôøng thì existence nor nonexistence, he manifests the               nhöõng caâu traû lôøi cuûa oâng ñaùp öùng ñuùng nhöõng caâu sixteen-foot golden body for you in a pile of crap         hoûi ñaët ra nhö “caùi naép vöøa khít caùi hoäp.” Nhöõng and rubbish, appearing and disappearing. Right             caâu traû lôøi cuûa oâng coù söùc maïnh nhö moät löôõi kieám now this whole great is a profuse array of myriad          saéc beùn choïc thuûng söï muø quaùng, nhöõng yù nghó vaø forms, up to and including one's own self. At once         tình caûm nhò nguyeân cuûa hoïc troø. Nhöõng caâu traû lôøi it's medicine; at such time, what will you call your       cuûa oâng thích hôïp vôùi trình ñoä hieåu vaø vôùi traïng self? If you only call it medicine, even by the time       thaùi yù thöùc choác laùt cuûa ngöôøi nghe moät caùch töï Maitreya Buddha is born down here, you still               nhieân, gioáng nhö “heát ñôït soùng naày ñeán ñôït soùng won't have seen Yun Men even in dreams.                    khaùc.” Theo Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc, Ultimately, how is it? "Perceive the meaning on            trong thí duï thöù 15 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc, vò Taêng the hook; don't stick by the zero point of the             ñeán hoûi Vaân Moân quaû laø haøng taùc gia kheùo noùi theá scale." One day Manjusri ordered Sudhana to pick           aáy. ÔÛ ñaây goïi laø trình giaûi, cuõng goïi laø taøng phong. medicinal herbs. He said, "If there is something           Neáu khoâng phaûi Vaân Moân thì chaúng kham ñaùp that is not medicine, bring it to me." Sudhana             ñöôïc. Vaân moân coù thuû ñoaïn naày, kia ñaõ ñem hoûi searched all over, but there was nothing that was          ñeán thì ñaây baát ñaéc dó phaûi ñaùp. Vì sao? Vì haøng not medicine. So he went back and told Manjusri,           taùc gia Toâng sö nhö göông saùng treân ñaøi. Hoà ñeán "There is nothing that is not medicine." Manjusri          hieän hoà, Haùn ñeán hieän Haùn. Coå nhaân noùi: "Muoán said, "Gather something that is medicine."                 ñöôïc thaân thieát, chôù ñem hoûi ñeán hoûi." Taïi sao? Vì Sudhana then picked up a blade of grass and                hoûi ôû choã ñaùp, ñaùp taïi choã hoûi. Töø tröôùc chö Thaùnh handed it to Manjusri. Manjusri held it up and             ñaâu töøng coù moät phaùp cho ngöôøi. Trong kia coù showed it to the assembly, saying, "This medicine          thieàn coù ñaïo cho oâng chaêng? Neáu oâng chaúng taïo can kill people and it can also bring people to            nghieäp ñòa nguïc töï nhieân chaúng chieâu quaû ñòa life." This talk of medicine and disease subduing          nguïc. Neáu oâng chaúng taïo nhôn thieân ñöôøng thì each other is extremely difficult to see. Yun              chaúng thoï quaû thieân ñöôøng. Taát caû nghieäp duyeân Menoften used it in his room to guide people. One          ñeàu töï laøm töï chòu. Ngöôøi xöa ñaõ vì oâng phaân bieät day Elder Chin O called on Hsueh Tou. Chin O               giaûi noùi roõ raøng. Neáu luaän vieäc naày chaúng ôû trong was an adept, an honorable worthy of the Yun               ngoân cuù, laïi ñaâu caàn Toå sö töø Thieân Truùc qua Men succession. They discussed this statement              ñaây?—A monk asked Yun-men, "When it's not the "medicine and disease subdue each other" all               present intelect and it's not the present night until dawn before they were finally able to          phenomenon, what is it?" Yun-men said, "An exhaust its excellence. At this point no learned           upside-down statement." Yun-men was a noted interpretations, thought or judgment can be                monk during the end of the T’ang dynasty, who, employed.                                                  like Lin-Ji, used vigorous language and jarring Coâng AÙn Vaân Moân Ñaûo Nhaát Thuyeát : Yun-              tactics to bring his disciples to self-awakening. men's Upside-Down Statement, example 15 of the             Master Yun-Men’s sayings and answers are highly Pi-Yen-Lu—Thí duï thöù 15 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc.             prized in Ch’an tradition. No other master’s words Moät oâng Taêng hoûi Vaân Moân: "Khi chaúng phaûi cô       are so frequently cited in the great koan colections tröôùc maét, cuõng chaúng phaûi söï tröôùc maét thì theá   as his. It is said that his words always fulfill three naøo?" Vaân Moân ñaùp: "Ñaûo Nhaát Thuyeát." Vaân          important qualificationsof a “Zen word.” Usually Moân laø moät thieàn sö noåi tieáng vaøo cuoái ñôøi nhaø   his answers correspond to the question posed “the Ñöôøng, moät ngöôøi gioáng nhö Laâm Teá, söû duïng         way a lid fits a jar.” These answers have the

power to cut through the delusion of his students’           nhöõng lôøi oâng daïy treân moät chieác aùo daøi baèng giaáy dualistic way of thinking and feeling like a sharp           khi döï caùc buoåi giaûng, maø nhieàu chaâm ngoân vaø lôøi sword. His answers follow the capacity foe                   giaûi thích baát huû cuûa ñaïi sö môùi coøn laïi ñeán ngaøy understanding and momentary state of mind of the             nay. Theo Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc, qua thí questioner “as one wave follows the previous                 duï 14, Vaân Moân muoán nhaén nhuû trong doøng thieàn one.” According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, in              gia muoán bieát nghóa Phaät taùnh phaûi quaùn thôøi tieát example 15 of the Pi-Yen-Lu, the monk (who                   nhaân duyeân, goïi ñoù laø "truyeàn rieâng ngoaøi giaùo lyù, asked Yun-men) is unquestionably an adept, to                rieâng truyeàn taâm aán, chæ thaúng taâm ngöôøi, thaáy know how to pose questions like this. The                    taùnh thaønh Phaät." OÂng giaø Thích Ca boán möôi chín question by the monk in this case is a question to           naêm ôû ñôøi, ba traêm saùu möôi hoäi baøn ñoán tieäm demonstrate understanding, and it can also be                quyeàn thaät, goïi ñoù laø giaùo lyù moät ñôøi. Vò Taêng naày called a question with a concealed barb. For                 ñöa ra caâu hoûi Vaân Moân theá naøo laø giaùo lyù moät anyone but Yun-men, there would have been no                 ñôøi. Taïi sao Vaân Moân khoâng vì oâng Taêng aáy maø way to cope with this monk. Yun-men posseses                 giaûi thích raønh reõ, laïi chæ noùi "Ñoái Nhaát Thuyeát"? such ability that he cannot but reply once the               Bình thöôøng Vaân Moân trong moät caâu phaûi ñuû ba question is raised. Why? An expert teaching                  caâu, nghóa laø caâu phuù caùi caøn khoân, caâu tuøy ba truïc master is like a bright mirror on its stand; if a            laõng, caâu tieät ñoaïn chuùng löu. Buoâng ñi giöõ laïi töï foreigner comes a foreigner is reflected, and if a           nhieân moät caùch phi thöôøng nhö chaët ñinh caét saét. native comes a native is reflected. An ancient               Vaân Moân laøm cho ngöôøi khaùc khoâng theå hieåu hay said, "If you want to attain intimate understanding,         möôøng töôïng ra ñöôïc oâng. Moät ñaïi taïng giaùo chæ don't use a question to ask a question. Why?                 tieâu coù ba chöõ. Boán phöông taùm höôùng khoâng coù Because the answer is where the question is."                choã naøo cho oâng ñaøo xôùi. Nhieàu ngöôøi hieåu laàm Since when have the sages from past times ever               noùi: "Vieäc ñoái cô nghi moät thôøi neân noùi theá." Laïi had anything to give to people? Where is there               coù ngöôøi khaùc noùi: "Sum la vaïn töôïng ñeàu laø sôû aán Ch'an or Tao that can be given to you? If you don't          cuûa moät phaùp, neân noùi 'ñoái nhaát thuyeát'." Laïi coù do hellish deeds, naturally you will not bring on            ngöôøi khaùc nöõa noùi: "Chæ laø noùi moät phaùp kia." hellish results. If you don't create heavenly                Quaû thöïc khoâng coù gì dính daùng. Chaúng nhöõng conditions, naturally you won't receive heavenly             khoâng hieåu laïi vaøo ñòa nguïc nhanh nhö teân baén. rewards. All circumstances of activity are self-             Ñaâu chaúng bieát coå nhaân yù khoâng nhö theá. Vì theá made and self-received. The ancient Yun-men                  noùi: "Tan xöông naùt thòt chöa ñuû ñeàn, moät caâu roõ clearly tells you, "When we discuss this affair, it's        thaáu vöôït traêm öùc," thaät laø phi thöôøng. Theá naøo laø not in the words and phrases. If it were in words            giaùo lyù moät ñôøi? Chæ tieâu ñöôïc moät caâu "Ñoái Nhaát and phrases, doesn't the twelve part canon of the            Thuyeát." Neáu ngay ñoù tieán ñöôïc lieàn veà nhaø ngoài three vehicles have words and phrases? Then                  an oån. Neáu chöa tieán ñöôïc, haõy tieáp tuïc duïng coâng what further use would there be for the Patriarch's          tu haønh hoaëc möôøi naêm, hoaëc hai möôi naêm, hoaëc coming from the West."                                       caû ñôøi nhö caùc baäc coå ñöùc ñaõ töøng laøm trong quaù Coâng AÙn Vaân Moân Ñoái Nhaát Thuyeát: Yun-men's            khöù—A monk asked Yun-men, "What are the Appropriate Statement—Vaân Moân giaùo lyù moät               teachings of a whole lifetime?" Yun-men said, ñôøi, thí duï thöù 14 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Moät oâng         "An appropriate statement." Yun-Men, who made Taêng ñeán hoûi Vaân Moân: "Theá naøo laø giaùo lyù moät     such skillful use himself of the words of the ñôøi?" Vaân Moân ñaùp: "Ñoái nhaát thuyeát." Tuy Vaân        ancient masters, was at the same time very Moân laø ngöôøi bieát xöû duïng nhöõng lôøi daïy sinh        mistrustful of the written word, which could all too ñoäng cuûa caùc thaày xöa, nhöng oâng toû ra raát ngôø       easily be understood literally but not really vöïc nhöõng töø ngöõ ñöôïc vieát ra, nhöõng töø naày deã     grasped. Thus he forbade his students to write his ñoïc nhöng khoâng phaûi luùc naøo ngöôøi ta cuõng hieåu      sayings down. Owing to one of his followers, who ñöôïc yù nghóa saâu saéc cuûa chuùng. Vì theá oâng caám      attended his discourses wearing a paper robe on khoâng cho ñeä töû vieát laïi nhöõng lôøi cuûa mình. Chính   which he took notes in spite of the ban, that many nhôø moät moân ñoà ñaõ baát chaáp söï caám ñoaùn, ghi laïi   of the imperishable sayings and explanations of

the great Ch’an master have been preserved.            immediately, then you can return home and sit in According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, through         peace. If you can't get it, continue to strive to example 14 of the Pi-Yen-Lu, Yun-men wanted to         cultivate ten years, twenty years or your whole advise members of the Ch'an family, if you want        life as our ancient virtues did in the past—See Voâ to know the meaning of Buddha-nature, you must         Khoång Thieát Chuøy. observe times and seasons, causes and conditions.      Coâng AÙn Vaân Moân Hoaøn Phaïn Tieàn Lai: Vaân This is called the special transmission outside the    Moân: traû laïi tieàn aên ôû—Yun Men: Return to me written teachings, the sole transmission of the        the money for 90 days of your room and board— mind seal, directly pointing to the human mind for     Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån XIX, the perception of nature and realization of            moät hoâm, coù moät vò Taêng hoûi: "Ñaàu thu cuoái haï coù Buddhahood. For forty-nine years old Sakyamuni         ngöôøi hoûi caùi gì laø Thieàn, phaûi traû lôøi laøm sao?" stayed in the world; at three hundred and sixty        Vaân Moân ñaùp: "Ñaïi chuùng lui roài!" Vò Taêng laïi assemblies he expounded the sudden and the             hoûi: "Chaúng hay loãi ôû choã naøo?" Vaân Moân ñaùp: gradual, the temporary and the true. These are         "Traû tieàn côm 90 ngaøy tieàn aên ôû cho laõo Taêng what is called the teachings of a whole lifetime. In   (Hoaøn ngaõ cöûu thaäp nhaät phaïn tieàn lai)." Hoâm this case, the monk picked this out to ask, "What      khaùc, coù moät vò Taêng hoûi: "Neáu cha meï khoâng cho are the teachings of a whole lifetime?" Why didn't     xuaát gia thì laøm caùch naøo ñeå xuaát gia?" Vaân Moân Yun-men explain for him in full detail, but instead    ñaùp: "Caïn." Vò Taêng noùi: "Con khoâng laõnh hoäi." said to him, "An appropriate statement"? As usual,     Vaân Moân noùi: "Saâu."—According to the Records within one sentence of Yun-men three sentences         of the Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng- are bound to be present. These are called the          Lu), Volume XIX, one day, a monk asked, "From sentence that encloses heaven and earth, the           the end of summer and beginning of autumn, if sentence that follows the waves, and the sentence      someone asks what is Zen, what should I that cuts off the myriad streams. He let go and        respond?" Yun-Men said, "The assembly already gathers up; he is naturally extraordinary, like        retreated!" The monk asked, "Where is the cutting nails or shearing through iron. He makes       problem?" Yun-Men said, "Return to me the people unable to comprehend him or figure him          money for 90 days of your room and board." out. The whole great treasure-house of the             Another day, a monk asked, "If one's parents won't teachings just comes down to three words (an           allow it then one can't leave home. How can one appropriate statement); there is no facer or aspect    leave home?" Yun-Men said, "Shallow." The in which you can rationalize this. People often        monk said, "I don't understand." Yun-Men said, misunderstand and say, "Buddha's preaching was         "Deep." appropriate to the conditions of one time." Or they    Coâng AÙn Vaân Moân Hoà Bænh: Yun Men's Cake— say, "The multitude of appearances and myriad          Theo thí duï thöù 77 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc, coù moät vò forms are all the impressions of a single truth,"      Taêng hoûi Vaân Moân: "Theá naøo laø noùi sieâu Phaät vieät and call this "an appropriate statement." Then         Toå?" Vaân Moân ñaùp: "Baùnh hoà." Theo Vieân Ngoä there are those who say, "It's just talking about      trong Bích Nham Luïc, khi vò Taêng hoûi Vaân Moân: that one truth." What connection is there? Not only    "Theá naøo laø noùi sieâu Phaät vieät Toå?" Vaân Moân ñaùp: do they not understand, they also enter hell as fast   "Baùnh hoà." Nghe coù caûm giaùc rôïn ngöôøi, toùc gaùy as an arrow flies. They are far from knowing that      döïng ñöùng chaêng? Haøng thieàn khaùch hoûi Phaät hoûi the meaning of that man of old is not like this.       Toå, hoûi thieàn hoûi ñaïo, hoûi höôùng thöôïng höôùng haï Therefore it is said, "Shattering one's bones and      xong, laïi choã khoâng theå ñaët thaønh caâu hoûi, maø hoûi crushing one's body is still not sufficient            sieâu Phaät vieät Toå. Vaân Moân laø taùc gia, nöôùc daøi thì recompense; when a single phrase is understood,        thuyeàn cao, ñaát nhieàu thì Phaät lôùn, ñaùp raèng: you     transcend    ten     billion."  Undeniably     "Baùnh hoà." Ñaùng goïi laø noùi khoâng luoáng roãng, extraordinary: " What are the teachings of a whole     coâng chaúng uoång baøy. Vaân Moân daïy chuùng: "OÂng lifetime?" just boils down to his saying, "An          chôù khôûi lieãu, nghe ngöôøi noùi ñeán yù Toå sö lieàn hoûi appropriate statement." If you can grasp this          ñaïo lyù sieâu Phaät vieät Toå." OÂng haõy noùi theá naøo laø

Phaät? Theá naøo laø Toå? Roài seõ hoûi sieâu Phaät vieät Toå.   Way is not carried out in vain, that his effort is not Nhö hoûi ra khoûi tam giôùi, oâng ñem tam giôùi laïi             wasted. Yun Men also taught the assembly saying, xem? Coù caùi thaáy nghe hieåu bieát gì caùch ngaïi ñöôïc        "Without any understanding, when you see people oâng? Coù thinh saéc Phaät phaùp gì cho oâng neân lieãu?         talking about the intent of the Patriarchal Teachers Lieãu caùi baùt gì? Do kieán giaæ gì laøm sai thuø? Coå          you immediately ask for theories of talk that goes Thaùnh kia coù laøm gì ñöôïc oâng? Thaân ñi ngang laø            beyond Buddhas and Patriarchs. But what do you vaät, noùi caû thaân toaøn chôn, moïi vaät thaáy theå khoâng     call 'Buddhas,' what do you call 'Patriarchs,' that theå ñöôïc. Toâi noùi vôùi oâng thaúng ñoù laø vieäc gì? Sôùm    you immediately speak of talk that transcends ñaõ choân vuøi roài vaäy. Hieåu ñöôïc lôøi naøy lieàn bieát      Buddhas and Patriarchs? Then you ask about ñöôïc baùnh hoà. Nguõ Toå noùi: "Phaân löøa saùnh haï            escape from the triple world, but you take hold of höông." Neân noùi: "Caét thaúng coäi nguoàn Phaät ñaõ aán,       the triple world to see. What seeing, hearing, vaïch laù tìm caønh toâi chaúng hay." Ñeán trong ñaây            feeling and knowing are there to hinder you? muoán ñöôïc thaân thieát chôù ñem hoûi ñeán hoûi. Xem            What phenomena of sound and form are there that vò Taêng naøy hoûi theá naøo laø sieâu Phaät vieät Toå. Vaân     you can be made to understand? What 'bowl' do Moân noùi: "Baùnh hoà." Laïi bieát hoå theïn chaêng? Laïi        you know how to use? On what basis do you hieåu loù ñuoâi chaêng? Coù moät nhoùm ngöôøi Ñoå Soaïn          entertain views of differentiations? Those ancient noùi Vaân Moân thaáy thoû thaû chim öng, neân noùi baùnh         sages can't do anything for you, though they hoà. Neáu theá aáy ñem baùnh hoà cho laø sieâu Phaät vieät       extend themselves to help living beings. Even if Toå laøm choã thaáy, laøm sao coù con ñöôøng soáng? Chôù         they say that the whole Body is entirely real, that khôûi baùnh hoà hoäi, laïi chaúng khôûi sieâu Phaät vieät Toå    in everything we see the Essence; this is hoäi, môùi laø con ñöôøng soáng. Saùnh vôùi "Ba caân             ungraspable. When I say to you, 'In fact, what gai," "Bieát ñaùnh troáng" cuøng moät loaïi. Tuy nhieân,         concerns are there?' This has already buried it." If chæ noùi baùnh hoà quaû laø thaät khoù thaáy. Ngöôøi ñôø i       you can understand this statement, then you can sau phaàn nhieàu khôûi ñaïo lyù noùi: "Noùi thoâ vaø lôøi teá    recognize the "Cake." Wu Tsu said, "Donkey shit ñeàu veà ñeä nhaát nghóa." Neáu hieåu theá aáy, haõy ñi          is like horse shit." This is what Yung Chia called laøm Toïa chuû, moät ñôøi gaày döïng ñöôïc nhieàu tri            "Going direct to the root source, as the Buddhas nhieàu giaûi. Hieän nay thieàn khaùch noùi: "Khi sieâu           have sealed; picking through leaves and searching Phaät vieät Toå thì chö Phaät ñaïp taïi goùt chaân, Toå sö       through twigs I cannot do." When you get to this cuõng ñaïp taïi goùt chaân." Vì theá Vaân Moân chæ nhaèm         point, if you want to attain Intimacy, don't ask with kia noùi baùnh hoà. Ñaõ laø baùnh hoà haø hieåu sieâu Phaät      questions. Observe how this monk asked, "What is vieät Toå, thöû tham kyõ xem?—According to                       talk that goes beyond Buddhas and Patriarchs?" example 77 of the Pi-Yen-Lu, a monk asked Yun                    and Yun Men said, "Cake." Does Yun Men know Men, "What is talk that goes beyond Buddhas and                  shame? Is he aware of indulging? There's a type Patriarchs?" Yun Men said, "Cake." According to                  of phoney person who says, "Yun Men saw the Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, this monk asked Yun                    rabbit and released the hawk; thus he said, Men "What is talk that goes beyond Buddhas and                   'Cake.'" If you take such a view, that "Cake" is Patriarchs?" Yun Men said, "Cake." Do you feel                   talk that goes beyond Buddhas and Patriarchs, your hairs standing on end with the chill?                       how can there be a living road? Don't understand Patchrobed monks have asked about Buddhas and                    it as cake and don't understand it as going beyond asked about Patriarchs, asked about Ch'an and                    Buddhas and Patriarchs; this, then, is the living asked about Tao, asked about facing upwards and                  road, Yun Men's "Cake" is the same as Tung facing downwards; there's nothing more that can                  Shan's "Three pounds of hemp" and Ho Shan's be aksed, yet this one posed a question and asked                "Knowing how to beat the drum": though he just about talk that goes beyond Buddhas and                          said "Cake," its reality is hard to see. Later people Patriarchs. Yun Men was an adept: thus, when the                 often made up rationalizations and said, "Coarse water rises, the boats ride high, and when there is              words and subtle talk all come back to the primary much mud the Buddha-image is big. So he                          truth." If you understand in this fashion, just go be answered saying "Cake." It can be said that the                  a lecturer and spend your life collecting much

knowledge and many interpretations. Followers of                Caàn thaáy lieàn thaáy, khoâng coù choã cho oân g ñuïc ñeõo. Ch'an these days say, "When you go beyond the                   Trong kinh noùi: "Phaùp aáy chaúng phaûi choã suy nghó Buddhas and Patriarchs you are trampling both                   phaân bieät hay hieåu." Vaân Moân ñaùp caâu hoûi phaàn Buddhas and Patriarchs underfoot; that's why Yun                nhieàu gôïi leân tình giaûi cuûa ngöôøi. Vì theá, trong moät Men just said to him, 'Cake.'" Since it's "Cake,"               caâu phaæ ñuû ba caâu, laïi chaúng coâ phuï lôøi hoûi cuûa how does this explain going beyond the Buddhas                  oâng, hôïp thôøi hôïp tieát, moät lôøi moät caâu, veõ moät and Patriarchs? Try to investigate thoroughly and               chaám cuõng coù choã xuaát thaân. Cho neân noùi: "Moät see.                                                            caâu thaáu, ngaøn caâu muoân caâu ñoàng thôøi thaáu." Haõy Coâng AÙn Vaân Moân Luïc Caên Baát Thaâu Luïc                   noùi laø Phaùp thaân, laø Toå Sö? Tha ngöôi ba möôi Traàn Luïc Thöùc: Yun Men's Six Do Not Take It                  gaäy—A monk asked Yun Men, "What is th Body In, example 47 of the Pi-Yen-Lu—Thí duï thöù 47                 of Reality?" Yun Men said, "Six do not not take it cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Moät vò Taêng hoûi Vaân Moân:              in." According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, this "Theá naøo laø Phaùp thaân?" Vaân Moân ñaùp: "Saùu              is indeed hard to understand: even if you reach it chaúng thaâu." Theo Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham                  before the first indications are distinct, this is Luïc, Vaân Moân noùi saùu chaúng thaâu haún laø khoù naém.      already the secondary. If you understand after the Neáu nhaèm khi ñieàm öùng chöa phaân naém ñöôïc, ñaõ            first indications arise, then you've fallen into the laø ñaàu thöù hai. Neáu nhaèm khi ñieàm öùng ñaõ sanh           tertiary. If you go to the words and phrases to tieán ñöôïc, laïi rôi vaøo ñaàu thöù ba. Neáu nhaèm treân       discern his meaning, you will search without ever ngoân cuù bieän minh, chôït doø tìm chaúng ñöôïc. Cöùu          being able to find it. But ultimately, what do you caùnh caùi gì laø Phaùp thaân? Neáu laø haøng taùc gia vöøa     take as the Body of Reality? Those who are nghe cöû leân lieàn ñöùng daäy ñi ra. Neáu chôø suy ñôïi        adepts immediately get up and go as soon as they cô, haõy laéng nghe xöû phaân. Thöôïng Toïa Phuø ôû             hear it raised. If on the other hand you linger in Thaùi Nguyeân tröôùc laø giaûng sö, moät hoâm leân toøa         thought and hold back your potential, you should giaûng veà Phaùp thaân, noùi: "Doïc cuøng tam teá, ngang        listen humbly to this treatment. The senior monk khaép möôøi phöông." Coù moät thieàn khaùch ôû döôùi            Fu of T'ai Yuan was originally a lecturer. One day toøa nghe lieàn baät cöôøi. Phuø xuoáng toøa, hoûi: "Vöø a      when he had gone up to his seat to lecture, he roài toâi coù choã naøo dôû, mong thieàn giaû vì toâi maø chæ   spoke of the Body of Reality saying, "Vertically it cho." Thieàn khaùch noùi: "Toïa Chuû chæ giaûng ñöôïc           reaches through the three times, and horizontally beân löôïng cuûa Phaùp thaân, maø chaúng thaáy Phaùp            it extends through the ten directions." There was a thaân." Thöôïng Toïa Phuø hoûi: "Cöùu caùnh theá naøo           Ch'an traveller in the audience who let out a laugh môùi phaûi?" Thieàn khaùch baûo: "Haõy taïm baõi giaûng,        as he heard this. Fu came down from his seat and ngoài trong thaát, aét ñöôïc töï thaáy." Thöôïng Toïa Phuø      said, "What was my shortcoming just now? Please, laøm nhö lôøi thieán khaùch. Moät ñeâm ngoài yeân laëng         Ch'an man, explain so I can see." The Ch'an man boãng nghe ñaùnh chuoâng canh naêm, hoát nhieân ñaïi            said, "Lecturer, you only lecture on that which ngoä, lieàn chaïy goõ cöûa thieàn khaùch, noùi: "Toâi ngoä      pertains to the extent of the Body of Reality; you roài." Thieàn khaùch hoûi: "OÂng thöû noùi xem?" Thöôïng        don't see the Body of Reality." Fu said, "After all, Toïa Phuø noùi: "Keå töø ngaøy nay toâi chaúng naém caùi        what would be right?" The Ch'an man said, "You loã muõi cuûa cha meï sanh ra." Trong kinh noùi: "Chôn          should temporarily stop lecturing and sit in a quiet Phaùp thaân Phaät ví nhö hö khoâng, öùng vaät hieän hình        room, You have to see it for yourself." Fu did as nhö traêng trong nöôùc." Laïi vò Taêng hoûi Giaùp Sôn:          he said and sat quietly all night. Suddenly he "Theá naøo laø Phaùp thaân?" Giaùp Sôn ñaùp: "Phaùp             heard them hitting the bell for the fifth watch: thaân khoâng töôùng." Vò Taêng laò hoûi: "Theá naøo laø         suddenly he was greatly enlightened. So he went Phaùp Nhaõn?" Giaùp Sôn ñaùp: "Phaùp Nhaõn khoâng               and knocked on the Ch'an man's door saying, "I tyø." Vaân Moân noùi: "Saùu chaúng thaâu." Coâng aùn naøy       have understood." The Ch'an man said, "Try to say coù ngöôøi noùi: "Chæ laø saùu caên saùu traàn saùu thöùc,      something so I can see." Fu said, "From today saùu caùi naøy töø Phaùp thaân sanh, neân saùu caên thaâu       onwards I'll no longer twist these nostrils born of noù khoâng ñöôïc." Neáu tình giaûi nhö theá aáy, quaû           my parents." Again: in the scriptures it says, "The thöïc chaúng dính daùng, laïi laøm ñôùi luïy Vaân Moân.         Buddha's true Body of Reality is like empty space.

It manifests shapes in response to things like the           deepest and indescribable place like Yun Men's moon reflected in the water." Again: a monk                  loud screaming: "Kwan". According to the asked Chia Shan, "What is the Body of Reality?"              Records of the Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan- Chia Shan said, "The Body of Reality has no                  Teng-Lu), Volume XIX, Zen master Yun-men, form." The monk asked, "What is the Eye of                   one of the great Zen masters towards the end of Reality?" Chai Shan said, "The Eye of Reality has            the T'ang dynasty, often exclaimed, "Kwan!" no flaws." Yun Men said, "Six do not take it in."            Kwan literally means the gate on a frontier pass Some say of this case, "This is just the six sense-          where travellers and their baggage are inspected. organs, the six sense-objects, the six                       In this case, however, the term does not mean consciousnesses. These sixes all arise from the              anything of the sort; it is simply "Kwan!", an Body of Reality, so the six faculties cannot take it         exclamatory utterance which does not allow any in." Intellectual interpretations such as this,              analytical or intellectual interpretation. Sincere though, are irrelevant. Moreover, they drag down             Zen practitioners should always remember when Yun Men. If you want to see, then see: there's no            we try anything approaching a conceptual place for your attempts to rationalize. Haven't you          interpretation on the subject we shall be 'ten seen how it says in the scripture: "This Truth is not        thousand miles away beyond the clouds'. something       that     calculating      thought      and   Coâng AÙn Vaân Moân Nhaät Nhaät Thò Haûo Nhaät : discrimination can understand." Yun Men's                    Ngaøy naøo cuõng laø ngaøy toát—Any day is a good answers have often provoked people's intellectual            day (everyday is a good day)—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô interpretations. Thus in every phrase of Yun                 duyeân vaán ñaùp giöõa Thieàn sö Muïc Chaâu vaø Vaân Men's there are inevitably three phrases present.            Moân Vaên Yeån trong Bích Nham Luïc, taéc 6. Theo Nor does he turn his back on your questions:                 Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån XIX, Vaân responding to the time, adapting to the season,              Moân daïy: "Ngaøy möôøi laêm veà tröôùc chaúng hoûi with one word, one phrase, one dot, one line, he             oâng; ngaøy möôøi laêm veà sau noùi cho moät caâu xem?" indeed has a place to show himself. Thus it is said,         Roài Vaân Moân cuõng töï traû lôøi cho moïi ngöôøi: "Moãi "When a single phrase is penetrated, a thousand              ngaøy ñeàu laø ngaøy toát." Caâu naày thoâng suoát coå kim, phrases, ten thousand phrases, are penetrated all            töø tröôùc ñeán sau ñoàng thôøi ngoài döùt. Sôn Taêng at once." But say, is "Six do not take it in" the            (Tuyeát Ñaäu) noùi thoaïi nhö theá cuõng laø theo lôøi Body of Reality? Is it the Patriarchs? I give you            sanh hieåu, ngöôøi gieát khoâng baèng töï gieát, vöøa khôûi thirty blows.                                                ñaïo lyù laø rôi haàm rôùt hoá. Vaân Moân trong moät caâu Coâng AÙn Vaân Moân Nhaát Khuùc: Yun Men's A                 ñeàu ñaày ñuû ba caâu trong toâng chæ nhaø ngöôøi. Nhö Chinese Classical Music—Teân moät khuùc nhaïc xöa            theá noùi moät caâu caàn thieát phaûi qui toâng, neáu khoâng cuûa Trung Hoa. Thieàn toâng duøng töø naøy ñeå dieãn taû    nhö theá töùc laø Ñoå Soaïn. Vieäc naày khoâng cho nhieàu choã thaâm saâu khoâng theå dieãn taû ñöôïc nhö tieáng       luaän thuyeát. Song ngöôøi chöa thaáu caàn phaûi nhö quaùt lôùn cuûa Vaân Moân: "Quan". Theo Caûnh Ñöùc           theá, neáu ngöôøi ñaõ thaáu lieàn thaáy yù chæ coå nhaân — Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån XIX, Thieàn sö Vaân Moân          The koan about the potentiality and conditions of thöôøng quaùt lôùn: "Quan!" Quan theo nghóa ñen laø          questions and answers between Zen master Mu- cöûa aûi vuøng bieân giôùi giöõa hai nöôùc ñeå kieåm soaùt   Chou and Yun-meân in Pi-Yen-Lu, example 6. khaùch löõ haønh vaø haønh lyù cuûa hoï. Tuy nhieân, trong   According to the Records of the Transmission of tröôøng hôïp naøy, chöõ "Quan" cuûa Vaân Moân chæ laø        the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), Volume XIX, Yun- moät thaùn töø, noù khoâng cho pheùp baát cöù söï phaân      men said, "I don't ask you about before the taùch hay giaûi thích baèng tri thöùc naøo caû. Haønh giaû   fifteenth day; try to say something about after the tu Thieàn chaân chaùnh phaûi neân nhôù raèng khoâng theå     fifteenth day." Yun-men himself answered for naøo bình giaûng gì khaùc hôn ñöôïc tieáng quaùt aáy cuûa    everyone, "Every day is a good day." These words Vaân Moân. Neáu chuùng ta coá gaéng gaùn cho chöõ            pervade past and present, from before until after, "Quan" aáy moät khaùi nieäm tri thöùc aét laïc maát ngaøn    and settle everything at once. This mountain monk truøng treân maây xanh—Name of a Chinese                     (Hsueh-tou) is following Yun-men's words to classical music. Zen uses this term to express the           produce interpretations when talking like this.

Killing others is not as good as killing yourself. As         Sö vaãn môû loøng töø bi, vì oâng chuù cöôùc noùi: "Caàm soon as you make a principle, you fall into a pit.            loàng ñeøn ñeán trong ñieän Phaät, ñem ba cöûa ñeán treân Three phrases are inherent in every one phrase of             loàng ñeøn." Thöû hoûi Vaân Moân noùi theá aáy, yù taïi choã Yun-men; since the source inspiration of his                  naøo? Coå nhaân noùi: "Thaät taùnh voâ minh töùc Phaät family is like this, when Yun-men utters a phrase,            taùnh, thaân khoâng huyeãn hoùa töùc Phaùp thaân." Laïi it must be returned to the source. Anything but this          noùi: "Chính phaøm taâm maø thaáy Phaät taâm." Hình will always be phony. The affair has no multitude             sôn töùc laø töù ñaïi nguõ aám. Trong coù hoøn ngoïc baùu of arguments and propositions, though those who               aån taïi hình sôn, nhö noùi: "Chö Phaät taïi ñaàu taâm, have not yet penetrated want to go on like this. If           ngöôøi meâ chaïy ngoaøi taàm, trong oâm baùu voâ giaù, you do penetrate, then you will immediately see               chaúng bieát moät ñôøi thoâi." Laïi noùi: "Phaät taùnh roõ the essential meaning of the Ancient.                         raøng hieån hieän, truï töôùng höõu tình khoù thaáy, neáu Coâng AÙn Vaân Moân Noäi Chaâu: Yun Men's Within              ngoä chuùng sanh voâ ngaõ, maët ta naøo khaùc maët Phaät. There Is a Jewel, example 62 of the Pi-Yen-Lu—                Taâm laø taâm xöa nay, maët laø maët thuôû beù, kieáp Theo thí duï thöù 62 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Vaân Moân           thaïch khaù ñoåi dôøi, caùi kia khoâng caûi bieán." Coù daïy chuùng: "Trong caøn khoân giöõa vuõ truï, ôû trong       ngöôøi chæ nhaän caùi saùng toû linh minh laø baûo, theá laø coù hoøn ngoïc baùu aån taïi hình sôn, caàm loàng ñeøn ñeán   chaúng ñöôïc caùi dieäu cuûa noù. Vì theá, ñoäng chuyeån trong ñieän Phaät, ñem ba cöûa ñeán treân loàng ñeøn."        chaúng ñöôïc, xoâ laên chaúng ñi. Coå nhaân noùi: "Cuøng Theo Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc, Vaân Moân               thì bieán, bieán thì thoâng." Caâu "Caàm loàng ñeøn ñeán noùi trong caøn khoân giöõa vuõ truï, ôû trong coù hoøn       trong ñieän Phaät," neáu laø thöôøng tình coøn coù theå ngoïc baùu aån taïi hình sôn, haõy noùi Vaân Moân yù taïi     löôøng xeùt ñöôïc. Caâu "Ñem ba cöûa ñeán treân loàng caàn caâu, hay yù taïi loàng ñeøn? Ñaây laø maáy caâu trong   ñeøn" laïi löôøng xeùt ñöôïc chaêng? Vaân Moân vì oâng Luaän Baûo Taïng cuûa Taêng Trieäu Phaùp Sö, Vaân             ñaû phaù tình thöùc yù töôûng, ñöôïc maát phaûi quaáy roài. Moân trích ra daïy chuùng. Khi Trieäu Coâng ôû vöôøn          Tuyeát Ñaäu noùi: "Toâi meán Thieàu Döông môùi ñònh Tieâu Dao thôøi Haäu Taàn laøm luaän, vieát kinh Duy          cô, moät ñôøi vì ngöôøi thaùo ñinh nhoå choát." Laïi noùi: Ma Caät, môùi bieát Laõo Trang chöa phaûi hay toät.           "Ngoài treân giöôøng goã bieát bao nhieâu, ñao beùn caét Trieäu Coâng leã Cöu Ma La Thaäp laøm thaày, laïi ñeán        ñi khieán ngöôøi meán." Vaân Moân noùi caàm loàng ñeøn tham vaán Boà Taùt Baït Ñaø Ba La ôû chuøa Ngoõa              vaøo trong ñieän Phaät, moät caâu naøy ñaõ caét ñöùt roài Quan, voán laø ñeä töû ñöôïc truyeàn taâm aán cuûa vò Toå     vaäy. Laïi ñem ba cöûa ñeán treân loàng ñeøn, neáu luaän thöù 27 ôû AÁn Ñoä. Trieäu Coâng thaâm nhaäp ñöôïc choã       vieäc naøy nhö choïi ñaù nhaùng löûa, tôï laøn ñieån chôùp. saâu kín. Moät hoâm, Trieäu Coâng bò naïn saép bò haønh       Vaân Moân noùi: "Neáu oâng töông ñöông haõy tìm hình, xin heïn laïi baûy ngaøy vieát xong boä luaän Baûo      ñöôøng vaøo. Chö Phaät nhö vi traàn ôû döôùi goùt chaân Taïng. Vaân Moân trích boán caâu trong boä luaän daïy         oâng, ba taïng thaùnh giaùo ôû treân ñaàu löôõi oâng, chaúng chuùng. Ñaïi yù noùi laøm sao laáy ñöôïc hoøn ngoïc baùu      baèng ngoä ñi thì toát. Hoøa Thöôïng con, chôù voïng aån trong aám giôùi. Lôøi noùi trong luaän cuøng loái         töôûng, trôøi laø trôøi, ñaát laø ñaát, nuùi laø nuùi, nöôùc laø thuyeát thoaïi trong toâng moân phuø hôïp nhau. Caûnh         nöôùc, Taêng laø Taêng, tuïc laø tuïc." Sö im laëng giaây Thanh hoûi Taøo Sôn: "Lyù thanh hö khi cöùu caùnh             laâu, noùi tieáp: "Ñem aùn sôn tröôùc maët laïi cho ta khoâng thaân, thì theá naøo?" Taøo Sôn ñaùp: "Lyù töùc        xem?" Coù vò Taêng böôùc ra hoûi: "Hoïc nhôn khi thaáy nhö theá, söï laïi laøm sao?" Caûnh Thanh thöa: "Nhö          nuùi laø nuùi, nöôùc laø nöôùc thì theá naøo?" Vaân Moân lyù nhö söï." Taøo Sôn baûo: "Löøa moät mình Taøo Sôn         baûo: "Ba cöûa vì sao töø trong naøy qua, e oâng cheát thì ñöôïc, ñoái vôùi con maét chö Thaùnh thì theá naøo?"      ñi." Sö beøn laáy tay veõ moät neùt noùi: "Khi bieát ñöôïc Caûnh Thanh thöa: "Neáu khoâng coù con maét chö               laø thöôïng vò ñeà hoà, neáu bieát chaúng ñöôïc trôû thaø nh Thaùnh, ñaâu bieát chaúng theá aáy." Taøo Sôn baûo:           ñoäc döôïc." Vì theá noùi: "Lieãu lieãu, khi lieãu khoâng "Quan chaúng cho loït muõi kim, huoáng laø xe ngöïa           sôû lieãu huyeàn huyeàn, choã huyeàn caàn phaûi cheâ." leùn qua." Vì theá noùi: "Trong caøn khoân giöõa vuõ truï,    Tuyeát Ñaäu nieâm raèng: "Trong caøn khoân giöõa vuõ trong coù hoøn ngoïc baùu aån taïi hình sôn." Ñaïi yù noùi    truï trong coù hoøn ngoïc baùu aån taïi hình sôn, treo ôû ngöôøi ngöôøi ñaày ñuû, moãi moãi vieân thaønh. Vaân Moân     treân vaùch, Ñaït Ma chín naê m chaúng daùm ñeå maét trích ra daïy chuùng ñaõ laø thaäp phaàn hieän thaønh,        nhìn thaúng, nay thieàn Taêng caàn thaáy, nhaèm ngay khoâng theå gioáng nhö Toïa Chuû laïi vì oâng chuù giaûi.     xöông soáng lieàn ñaùnh." Xem Sö laø boån phaän Toâng

sö troïn chaúng ñem thaät phaùp troùi buoäc ngöôøi.        why it was said, "Within heaven and earth, in Huyeàn Sa noùi: "Buûa vaây chaúng chòu ñöùng, keâu goïi    space and time, there is a jewel, hidden in the chaúng quay ñaàu; tuy vaäy, theá aáy cuõng laø ruøa linh   mountain of form." The great meaning of this is to keùo leâ caùi ñuoâi."—According to example 62 of the       show that everyone is fully endowed, each Pi-Yen-Lu, Yun Men said to the community,                  individual is perfectly complete. Yun Men thus "Within heaven and earth, through space and time,          brought it up to show his community; it is totally there is a jewel, hidden inside the mountain of            obvious; he couldn't go on and add interpretations form. Pick up a lamp and go into the Buddha-hall;          for you like a lecturer. But he is compassionate take the triple gate and bring it on the lamp."            and adds a footnote for you, saying, "Pick up a According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, Yun                 lamp and go into the Buddha-hall; bring the triple Men says, "Within heaven and earth, through                gate on the lamp." Now tell me, when Yun Men space and time, there is a jewel, hidden inside the        speaks this way, what is his meaning? Have you mountain of form." Now tell me, is Yun Men's               not seen how an Ancient said, "The true nature of meaning in the "fishing pole," or is the meaning in        ignorance is identical to Buddhahood; the empty the lamp? These lines are paraphrased from a               body of illusion is identical to the body of reality." treatise of Seng Chao, Master of the Teachings,            It is also said, "See the Buddha mind right in the called "Jewel Treasury;" Yun Men brought them              ordinary mind." The "mountain of form" is the up to teach his community. In the time of the              four gross elements and five heaps which Latter Ch'in, Seng Chao was in the Garden of               constitute human life. "Within there is a jewel, Freedom composing his treatise. When he was                hidden in the mountain of form." That is why it is copying the old Vimalakirtinirdesa scripture he            said, "All Buddhas are in the mind; deluded realized that Chuang-tzu and Lao-tzu had still not         people go seeking outside. Though within they exhausted the marvel; Chao then paid obeisance             embosom a priceless jewel, they do not know it, to Kumarajiva as his teacher. He also called on            and let it rest there all their lives." It is also said, the Bodhisattva Buddhabhadra at the Tile Coffin            "The Buddha-nature clearly manifests, but the Temple, who had transmitted the Mind Seal from             sentient beings dwelling in form hardly see it. If the Twenty-seventh Patriarch (Prajnatara) in               one realizes that sentient beings have no self, how India. Chao entered deeply into the inner sanctum.         does his own face differ from a Buddha's face?" One day Chao ran into trouble; when he was about           "The mind is the original mind; the face is the face to be executed, he asked for seven days' reprieve,         born of woman; the Rock of Age may be moved, during which time he composed the treatise                 but here there is no change." Some people "Jewel Treasury." So Yun Men cited four phrases            acknowledge this radiant shining spirituality as from that treatise to teach his community. The             the jewel; but they cannot make use of it, and they main idea is "how can you take a priceless jewel           do not realize its wondrousness. Therefore they and conceal it in the heaps and elements?" The             cannot set it in motion and cannot bring it out in words spoken in the treatise are all in accord with        action. An Ancient said, "Reaching an impasse, the talk of our school. Have you not seen how              then change; having changed, then you can pass Ching Ch'ing asked Ts'ao Shan, "How is it when in          through." "Pick up a lamp and head into the the principle of pure emptiness ultimately there is        Buddha-hall"; if it is a matter of ordinary sense, no body?" Ts'ao Shan said, "The principle being            this can be fathomed, but can you fathom "bring like this, what about phenomena?" Ching Ch'ing             the triple gate on the lamp"? Yun Men has broken said, "As is principle, so are phenomena." Ts'ao           up emotional discrimination, intellectual ideas, Shan said, "You can fool me, one person, but what          gain, loss, affirmation, and negation, all at once can you do about the eyes of all the sages?" Ching         for you. Hsueh Tou has said, "I like the freshly Ch'ing said, "Without the eyes of all the sages,           established devices of Shao Yang (Yun Men); all how could you know it is not so?" Ts'ao Shan said,         his life he pulled out nails and drew out pegs for "Officially, not even a needle is admitted;                others." He also said, "I do not know how many sit privately, even a cart and horse can pass." That is        on the chair of rank; but the sharp sword cutting

away causes others' admirationha." When he said,           ngöôøi coù moät ñoaïn aùnh saùng soi thaáu coå kim, vöôït "Pick up a lamp and go into the Buddha-hall," this         haún thaáy bieát. Tuy nhieân aùnh saùng vöøa ñeán hoûi ra one phrase has already cut off completely; yet,            laïi chaúng hoäi, haù chaúng phaûi toái muø muø." Lôøi noùi "bring the triple gate on the lamp." If you discuss        naøy ñeán hai möôi naêm troïn khoâng coù ngöôøi hieåu this matter, it is like sparks struck from stone, like     ñöôïc yù Sö. Sau Höông Laâm caàu xin thay ñaùp. Vaân the flash of a lightning bolt. Yun Men said, "If you       Moân ñaùp: "Kho truø ba cöûa." Laïi ñaùp: "Vieäc toát would attain, just seek a way of entry; Buddha             chaúng baèng khoâng." Bình thöôøng lôøi ñaùp thay chæ numerous as atoms are under your feet, the three           laø moät caâu, taïi sao trong ñaây laïi hai caâu? Caâu treasuries of the holy teachings are on your               tröôùc vì oâng môû moät con ñöôøng cho oâng thaáy. Neáu tongues; but this is not as good as being                  laø keû kia, vöøa nghe noùi ñeán lieàn ñöùng daäy ra ñi. Sö enlightened. Monks, do not think falsely; sky is           sôï ngöôøi keït ôû ñaây, laïi noùi: "Vieäc toát chaúng baèng sky, earth is earth, mountains are mountains,              khoâng." Nhö tröôùc vì oâng queùt saïch. Ngöôøi ngaøy rivers are rivers, monks are monks, lay people are         nay vöøa nghe noùi aùnh saùng lieàn trôïn tröøng ñoâi maét lay people." After a long pause he said, "Bring me         noùi: "Trong kia laø kho truø, trong kia laø ba cöûa." the immovable mountain before you." Then a                 Vaãn khoâng dính daùng. Vì theá noùi: "Hieåu laáy yù ñaàu monk came forth and asked, "How is it when a               löôõi caâu, chôù nhaän quaû caân baøn." Vieäc naøy khoâng student sees that mountains are mountains and              ôû treân maét, cuõng chaúng ôû treân caûnh, caàn phaûi baët rivers are rivers?" Yun Men drew a line with his           tri kieán, queân ñöôïc maát, saïch heát moïi thöù baøy loà hand and said, "Why is the triple gate going from          loä. Moãi moãi treân phaàn cuûa ngöôøi, hieän taïi nghieân here?" He feared you would die, so he said,                cöùu laáy môùi ñöôïc. Vaân Moân noùi: "Trong ngaøy qua "When you know, it is the superb flavor of ghee; if        laïi, trong ngaøy bieän ngöôøi, boãng nhieân giöõa ñeâm you do not know, instead it becomes poison." This          khoâng maët trôøi, maët traêng, ñeøn, choã töøng ñeán thì is why it is said, "When completely thoroughly             vaãn ñeán ñöôïc, choã chöa töøng ñeán laáy laïi moät vaät , understood, there is nothing to understand; the            laïi laáy ñöôïc chaêng?" Trong Tham Ñoàng Kheá noùi: most abstruse profundity of mystery is still to be         "Chính trong saùng coù toái, chôù laáy toái xem nhau, scorned." Hsueh Tou again brought it up and said,          chính trong toái coù saùng, chôù laáy saùng gaëp nhau." "Within heaven and earth through space and time,           Neáu ngoài döùt saùng toái, haõy noùi laø caùi gì? Do ñoù therein is a jewel; it lies hidden in the mountain of      noùi: "Taâm hoa phaùt minh soi saùng coõi nöôùc ôû möôøi form. It is hung on a wall; for nine years                 phöông." Baøn Sôn noùi: "Saùch chaúng soi caûnh, caûnh Bodhidharma did not dare to look at it straight on.        cuõng chaúng coøn, saùng caûnh ñeàu queân, laïi laø vaät If any patchrobed monk wants to see it now, I will         gì?" Laïi noùi: "Chính nôi thaáy nghe chaúng thaáy hit him right on the spine with my staff." See how         nghe, khoâng coøn thinh saéc ñaùng trình anh, trong these self-possessed teachers of our school never          ñaây neáu lieãu toaøn voâ söï, theå duïng ngaïi gì phaân use any actual doctrine to tie people up. Hsuan            chaúng phaân". Chæ hieåu caâu sau roài, ñeán caâu tröôùc Sha said, "Though you try to enmesh him in a trap,         daïo chôi, cöùu caùnh chaúng ôû trong aáy laøm keá soáng. he doesn't consent to stay; though you call after          Coå nhaân noùi: "Laáy goác khoâng truï laäp taát caû phaùp." him, he doesn't turn his head. Even though he is           Chaúng ñöôïc ñeán trong naøy ñuøa quang aûnh ñuøa tinh like this, still he is a sacred tortoise dragging his      hoàn, laïi chaúng ñöôïc hieåu laø voâ söï. Coå nhaân noùi: tail."                                                     "Thaø khôûi chaáp COÙ baèng nuùi Tu Di, chaúng neân Coâng AÙn Vaân Moân Quang Minh: Yun Men's                  chaáp KHOÂNG baèng haït caûi." Haøng nhò thöøa phaàn Everybody Has a Light—Theo thí duï thöù 86 cuûa            nhieàu hay rôi vaøo caùi chaáp naøy—According to Bích Nham Luïc. Vaân Moân daïy: "Moãi ngöôøi troïn         example 86 of the Pi-Yen-Lu, Yun Men imparted coù aùnh saùng hieän taïi, khi xem thì chaúng thaáy toái   some words saying, "Everyone has a light; when muø. Theá naøo laø aùnh saùng cuûa quí vò?" Noùi xong      you look at it, you don't see it and it's dark and Vaân Moân laïi töï ñaùp: "Kho truø ba cöûa." Laïi ñaùp:    dim. What is everybody's light?" He himself "Vieäc toát chaúng baèng khoâng." Theo Vieân Ngoä          answered on their behalf, "The kitchen pantry and trong Bích Nham Luïc, Vaân Moân ôû trong thaát ñeå lôøi    the main gate." He also said, "A good thing isn't as tieáp ngöôøi: "Caû thaûy caùc oâng döôùi goùt chaân moãi   good as nothing." According to Yuan-Wu in the

Pi-Yen-Lu, in his room Yun Men imparted some              can be offered to you. Here, if you can understand words to teach people: "All of you, right where           that there's nothing at all, you are free to separate, you stand, each and every one of you has a beam           or not, essence and action." Just understand Yun of light shining continuously, now as of old, far         Men's final statement thoroughly, then you can go removed from seeing or knowing. Though it's a             back to the former one to roam at play. But light, when you're asked about it you don't               ultimately, you do not make a living there. The understand; isn't it dark and dim?" For twenty            ancient Vimalakirti said, "All things are years he handed down this lesson, but there was           established on a non-abiding basis." You mustn't never anyone who understood his meaning. Later            go here to play with lights and shadows and give Hsiang Lin asked Yun Men to speak on their                play to your spirit. Nor will it do to make up an behalf. Yun Men said, "The kitchen pantry and the         understanding in terms of nothingness. An Ancient main gate." He also said, "A good thing isn't as          said, "Better you should give rise to a view of good as nothing." Usually what he said in place of        existence as big as Mount Sumeru, than that you others was just a single sentence; why then are           produce a view of nothingness as small as a there two here? The first sentence barely opens a         mustard seed." People of the lesser two vehicles road for you to let you see. If you're for real, as       often fall onesidedly into this view. soon as you hear it mentioned, you get right up           Coâng AÙn Vaân Moân Sa Moân Haïnh: Yun Men: and go. Yun Men feared people would get stuck             Sramana's manner of action—Theo Caûnh Ñöùc here, so he also said, "A good thing isn't as good        Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån XVII, moät hoâm Vaân as nothing." As before, he's swept it away for you.       Moân hoûi Thieàn sö Taøo Sôn Boån Tòch: "Theo con, As soon as they hear you mention "light," people          Sa moân laø moät nhaø tu Phaät giaùo, töø boû gia ñình, töø these days immediately put a glare in their eyes          boû duïc voïng, coá coâng tu haønh vaø thanh baàn tònh and say, "Where is the kitchen pantry? Where is           chí. Theo Hoøa Thöôïng, theá naøo laø Sa Moân haïnh?" the main gate?" But this has nothing to do with it.       Taøo Sôn ñaùp: "AÊn côm gaïo cuûa thöôøng truï." Vaân Thus it is said, "Perceive the meaning on the hook;       Moân hoûi: "Khi ñi nhö vaäy thì theá naøo?" Taøo Sôn don't abide by the zero point of the scale." This         ñaùp: "OÂng giöõ laïi ñöôïc khoâng?" Vaân Moân noùi giöõ matter is not in the eye or in the environment. To        ñöôïc. Taøo Sôn hoûi: "OÂng giöõ theá naøo?" Vaân Moân begin to understand you must cut off knowing and          thöa: "Chæ aên côm vaø maëc aùo, thì choã naøo laø khoù?" seeing, forget gain and loss, and become purified,        Taøo Sôn noùi: "Sao oâng khoâng noùi 'mang loâng ñoäi naked, and perfectly at ease; each and every one          söøng'?" Vaân Moân leã baùi roài lui ra. Hoâm khaùc, Vaân must investigate on his own. Yun Men said, "You           Moân hoûi: "Ngöôøi khoâng thay ñoåi ñeán, Sö coù tieáp come and go by daylight; you distinguish people           khoâng?" Taøo Sôn noùi: "Taøo Sôn ta khoâng raûnh cho by daylight. Suddenly it's midnight, and there's no       loaïi ñoù." Coù moät vò Taêng hoûi: "Ngöôøi xöa coù noùi: sun, moon, or lamplight. If it's some place you've        'Ngöôøi ngöôøi ñeàu coù huynh ñeä taïi traàn.' Thaày coù been to, then of course it's possible; in a place you     theå trình baøy cho con bieát roõ hay khoâng?" Taøo Sôn have never been, can you even manage to get               noùi: "Ñöa baøn tay oâng cho laõo Taêng xem." Ñoaïn hold of something?" Shih T'ou's Merging of                Taøo Sôn chæ vaøo nhöõng ngoùn tay vaø ñeám: "Moät, Difference and Sameness says, "Right within light         hai, ba, boán, naêm. Ñuû caû maø."—According to the there's darkness, but don't see it as darkness: right     Records of the Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan- within darkness there's light, but don't meet it as       Teng-Lu), Volume XVII, one day, Yun Men asked light." If you cut off light and darkness, tell me,       Zen master Ts'ao-shan Pen-chi, "To me, a what is it? Thus it is said, "The mind flower emits       Sramana is a Buddhist monk who have left home, light, shining on all the lands in the ten directions."   quitted the passions and have the toilful P'an Shan said, "Light isn't shining on objects, nor      achievement, diligent quieting of the mind and the do the objects exist. Light and objects both              passions, purifying of mind and living in poverty. forgotten, then what is this?" Also it was said,          What about you, Master?" Ts'ao-shan replied, "To "This very seeing and hearing is not seeing and           eat rice meal from offerings." Yun men asked, hearing, but there's no other sound and form that         "What happens if going like that?" Ts'ao-shan

replied, "Can you keep that?" Yun men said,                the sound; knowing the mind when seeing form "Yes, I can." Ts'ao-shan asked, "How can you               objects. Just the same way as Bodhisattva keep it?" Yun Men said, "Just eat meal and wear            Avalokitesvara takes the money to buy a rice robes, where is the difficulty?" Ts'ao-shan said,          cake, but when opening the hand it's a mien-pao." "Why don't you say 'wearing hair and horn'?" Yun           Coâng AÙn Vaân Moân Thæ Quyeát: Yun-men's Dried Men bowed Ts'ao-shan and retreated. Another                Shitstick—Que cöùt cuûa Vaân Moân, thí duï thöù 21 day, Yunmen asked, "The unchanging person has              cuûa Voâ Moân Quan. Moät oâng Taêng hoûi ngaøi Vaân come, Will the master receive him or not?" Ts'ao-          Moân: "Phaät laø gì?" Vaân Moân ñaùp: "Que cöùt khoâ." shan said, "On Mt. Ts'ao there's no spare time for         Theo Voâ Moân Hueä Khai trong Voâ Moân Quan, Vaân that." A monk asked, "An ancient said, 'Everyone           Moân coù theå noùi laø ngheøo ñeán khoâng doïn noãi böõa has brothers in the dust.' Can you demonstrate this        côm chay, baän vieäc ñeán khoâng coù thì giôø thaûo thö. to me?" Ts'ao-shan said, "Give me your hand."              Tieän tay vô laáy que cöùt, choáng cöûa ñôõ nhaø. Xem Ts'ao-shan then pointed at the monk's fingers and          ñoù thì thaáy ngay leõ thaïnh suy cuûa Phaät phaùp. Ñaây counted, "One, two, three, four, five. That's              laø loaïi coâng aùn "maëc nhieân phuû nhaän", nghóa laø, enough."                                                   loaïi coâng aùn giaûi minh chaân lyù Thieàn baèng loái phaùt Coâng AÙn Vaân Moân Tam Nhaät: Vaân Moân: Ba               bieåu hö hoùa hoaëc pheá boû. Vôùi loaïi coâng aùn naøy, ngaøy—Yun Men: Three days—Coâng aùn noùi veà cô            chuùng ta thöôøng caùo buoäc caùc Thieàn sö laø phuû duyeân tieáp hoùa ngöôøi hoïc cuû a Thieàn sö Vaân Moân    nhaän. Nhöng kyø thaät hoï chaúng phuû nhaän gì caû, Vaên Yeån. Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc,             nhöõng gì hoï ñaõ laøm chæ nhaèm ñeå vaïch roõ ra caùc aûo quyeån XIX, moät hoâm Thieàn sö Vaân Moân thöôïng          töôûng cuûa chuùng ta cho voâ höõu laø höõu, höõu laø voâ ñöôøng daïy chuùng: "Ba ngaøy khoâng thaáy nhau,           höõu, vaân vaân—Yun-men's Dried Shitstick, khoâng ñöôïc thaáy nhau nhö khi xöa, phaûi laøm sao?"      example 21 of the Wu-Men-Kuan. A monk asked Noùi xong Sö töï ñaùp: "Thieân."—The koan about            Yun-men, "What is Buddha?" Yun-men said, the potentiality and conditions of receiving and           "Dired shitstick." According to Wu Men Hui-Kai instructing disciples of Zen master Wen Men.               in the Wu-Men-Kuan, it must be said of Wen-men According to the Records of the Transmission of            he was too poor to prepare even a plainest food the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), Volume XIX, one                 and too busy to make a careful draft. Probably day, Zen master Yun Men entered the hall and               people will bring forth this dried shitstick to shore addressed the assembly, saying, "Not seeing for            up the gate and prop up the door. The Buddha three days, not seeing as we used to do, what can          Dharma is thus sure to decay. This is an "implicit- we do?" After speaking, the Master gave an                 negative" koan, a kind of koan that illustrates Zen- answer: "Heaven."                                          Truth through "nullifying" or abrogating Coâng AÙn Vaân Moân Thanh Saéc: Vaân Moân: Vaên            expression. With this type of koan, we usually thanh      ngoä      ñaïo—Yun       Men:       Attaining   accuse the Zen masters of being negatory. But in enlightenment when hearing the sound—Coâng aùn             fact, they did not negate anything. What they have noùi veà cô duyeân tieáp hoùa ngöôøi hoïc cuûa Thieàn sö   done is to point out our delusions in thinking of the Vaân Moân Vaên Yeån. Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng         non-existent as existent, and the existent as non- Luïc, quyeån XIX, moät hoâm Thieàn sö Vaân Moân            existent, and so on. thöôïng ñöôøng daïy chuùng: "Nghe tieáng ngoä ñaïo,        Coâng AÙn Vaân Moân Thoaïi Ñoïa: Misspoken thaáy saéc roõ taâm. Boà Taùt Quaùn Theá AÂm ñem tieàn     Words—Vaân Moân Saåy Lôøi, thí duï thöù 39 cuûa Voâ mua baùnh ñuùc, buoâng tay ra laïi laø baùnh bao."—        Moân Quan. Moät oâng Taêng hoûi ngaøi Vaân Moân: The koan about the potentiality and conditions of          "Quang minh tòch chieáu bieán haø sa." Lôøi noùi chöa receiving and instructing disciples of Zen master          döùt, Vaân Moân voäi hoûi: "Chaúng phaûi thô cuûa Tuù Taøi Wen Men. According to the Records of the                   Tröông Chuyeát ñoù sao?" OÂng Taêng ñaùp: "Phaûi." Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu),                 Vaân Moân noùi: "Saåy lôøi roài vaäy!" Veà sau Töû Taâm Volume XIX, one day, Zen master Yun Men                    nhaéc chuyeän laïi, baøn raèng: "Thöû hoûi ñaâu laø choã entered the hall and addressed the assembly,               oâng Taêng saåy lôøi?" Theo Voâ Moân Hueä Khai trong saying, "Attaining enlightenment when hearing              Voâ Moân Quan, neáu ôû ñaây maø thaáy ñöôïc choã duïng

bí hieåm cuûa Vaân Moân cuøng choã saåy lôøi cuûa oâng           "Khi theá aáy ñi thì sao?" Vaân Moân baûo: "Sö töû loâng Taêng, thì coù theå laøm thaày ôû hai coõi trôøi ngöôøi. Coøn    vaøng." Haõy noùi laø chaáp nhaän y hay chaúng chaáp neáu chöa roõ thì töï cöùu mình cuõng khoâng xong—               nhaän y, laø bao y hay bieám y? Nham Ñaàu noùi: "Neáu Yun-men: "You Have Misspoken" Misspoken                          luaän chieán thì moãi ngöôøi ôû choã chuyeån." Laïi noùi: Words, example 39 of the Wu-Men-Kuan. A                          "Kia tham caâu soáng chaúng tham caâu cheát. Caâu monk said to Yun-men, "The radiance serenely                     soáng tieán ñöôïc thì vónh kieáp chaúng queân, caâu cheát illumines the whole universe..." Before the monk                 tieán ñöôïc thì töï cöùu chöa xong." Laïi coù vò Taêng hoûi had finished the line, Yun-men interrupted him                   Vaân Moân: "Phaät phaùp nhö traêng trong nöôùc phaûi and asked, "Aren't those the words of Chang-cho?"                chaêng?" Vaân Moân ñaùp: "Soùng trong khoâng ñöôøng The monk said, "Yes, they are." Yun-men said,                    thoâng." Vò Taêng thöa: "Hoøa Thöôïng töø ñaâu maø "You have misspoken." Later, the master Ssu-hsin                 ñöôïc?" Vaân Moân ñaùp: "Hoûi laïi thì ñaâu ñeán." Vò took up this matter and asked, "Tell me, where did               Taêng thöa: "Chính khi ñi theá aáy laø sao?" Vaân Moân the monk misspeak?" According to Wu Men Hui-                     ñaùp: "Ñöôøng nuùi coång truøng ñieäp. Phaûi bieát vieäc Kai in the Wu-Men-Kuan, if you can see the                       naøy chaúng ôû treân ngoân cuù, nhö choïi ñaù nhaùng löûa, uncompromising and rigorous operation of Yun-                    tôï laøn ñieån chôùp, naém ñöôïc naém chaúng ñöôïc chöa men's method and how the monk misspoke, then                     khoûi tan thaân maát maïng."—A monk asked Yun you qualify as a teacher of people and devas. If it              Men, "What is the Pure Body of Reality?" Yun is not yet clear, then you cannot save even                      Men said, "A flowering hedge." The monk asked, yourself.                                                        "What is it like when one goes on in just such a Coâng AÙn Vaân Moân Thöôïc Lan Hoa: Yun Men's                    way?" Yun Men said, "A golden-haired lion." Flowering Hedge, example 39 of the Pi-Yen-Lu—                    According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, people, Thí duï thöù 39 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Moät vò Taêng               do you know the point of this monk's questions and hoûi Vaân Moân: "Theá naøo laø Phaùp thaân thanh tònh?"          the point of Yun Men's answers? If you do know, Vaân Moân ñaùp: "Thöôïc Lan Hoa." Vò Taêng laò hoûi:             their two mouths are alike without a single tongue. "Khi theá aáy thì sao?" Vaân Moân ñaùp: "Sö töû loâng            If you do not know, you will not avoid being vaøng." Theo Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham Luïc, caùc               fatheaded. A monk asked Hsuan Sha, "What is the oâng bieát choã hoûi cuûa vò Taêng vaø choã ñaùp cuûa Vaân       Pure Body of Reality?" Hsuan Sha said, "Dripping Moân chaêng? Neáu hieåu ñöôïc thì hai mieäng ñoàng               with pus." He had the adamantine eye: as a test, I khoâng coù moät caùi löôõi. Neáu chaúng bieát chöa khoûi         ask you to try to discern it. Yun Men was not the laàm laãn. Coù vò Taêng hoûi Huyeàn Sa: "Theá naøo laø           same as others. Sometimes he held still and stood Phaùp thaân thanh tònh?" Huyeàn Sa ñaùp: "Muû gioït              like a wall ten miles high, with no place for you to gioït." Ngöôøi ñuû con maét Kim Cang môøi thöû bieän             draw near. Sometimes he would open out a path xem? Vaân Moân khoâng ñoàng ngöôøi khaùc, coù khi                for you, die along with you and live along with naém ñöùng vaùch cao ngaøn tröôïng, khoâng coù choã cho          you. Yun Men's tongue was very subtle; some oâng nghó suy, coù khi vì oâng môû moät con ñöôøng               people say he was answering him figuratively; but ñoàng cheát ñoàng soáng. Ba taác löôõi cuûa Vaân Moân raát       if you understand it this way, then tell me where saâu kín. Coù ngöôøi noùi ñoù laø loái ñaùp tín theå (tin maøu   Yun Men is at. This was a household affair; do not saéc). Neáu hieåu theá aáy, thöû noùi Vaân Moân rôi taïi choã    try to figure it out from outside. This was the naøo? Caùi naøy laø vieäc ôû trong thaát, chôù nhaèm ra          reason Pai Chang said, "Manifold appearances ngoaøi suy tính. Vì theá, Baùch Tröôïng noùi: "Sum la            and myriad forms, and all spoken words, each vaïn töôïng, taát caû ngöõ ngoân, ñeàu xoay veà nôi mình,        should be turned and returned to oneself and made khieán laên truøng truïc, nhaèm choã soáng linh ñoäng."          to turn freely." Going to where life springs forth, Laïi noùi: "Neáu nghó nghò suy tìm, lieàn rôi vaøo caâu          he immediately speaks; if you try to discuss it and thöù hai." Vónh Gia noùi: "Phaùp thaân ngoä roài khoâng          seek it in thought, immediately you have fallen moät vaät, baûn nguyeân töï taùnh thieân chôn Phaät." Vaân       into the secondary phase. Yung Chia said, "When Moân nghieäm vò Taêng naøy, vò Taêng naøy cuõng laø              the Body of Reality awakens fully, there is not a ngöôøi ôû trong thaát cuûa Sö, laø ngöôøi tham cöùu ñaõ          single thing; the inherent nature of the original laâu, bieát ñöôïc vieäc trong thaát cuûa Sö, neân tieán ngöõ:    source is the natural real Buddha." Yun Men

tested this monk; the monk was also a member of               has phrases that cut nails and shear through iron. his household and was himself a longtime student.             In this one phrase three phrases are present. When He knew the business of the household, so he                  questioned about this case, some say, "Each grain went on to say, "What is it like to go on like this?"         of the food in the bowl is round; each drop of the Yun Men said, "A golden-haired lion." But tell                water in the bucket is wet." If you understand in me, is this agreeing with him or not agreeing with            this fashion, then you didn't see how Yun Men him? Is this praising him or censuring him? Yen               really helped the man. T'ou said, "If you engage in a battle, each                   Coâng AÙn Vaân Moân Truï Tröôïng Hoùa Long: Yun individual stands in a pivotal position." It is also          Men's Staff Changes into a Dragon, example 60 of said, "He studies the living phrase; he does not              the Pi-Yen-Lu—Thí duï thöù 60 cuûa Bích Nham study the dead phrase. If you get understanding at            Luïc. Vaân Moân caàm caây gaäy chæ chuùng noùi: "Caây the living phrase, you will never ever forget; if             gaäy hoùa laøm roàng, nuoát heát caøn khoân roài vaäy, nuùi you get understanding at the dead phrase, you will            soâng ñaát lieàn choã naøo ñöôïc?" Theo Vieân Ngoä be unable to save yourself." Another monk asked               trong Bích Nham Luïc, nhö Vaân Moân noùi caây gaäy Yun Men, "Is it true or not that 'the Buddha                  hoùa laøm roàng, nuoát heát caøn khoân roài vaäy, nuùi soâng Dharma is like the moon in the water'?" Yun Men               ñaát lieàn choã naøo ñöôïc? Neáu noùi coù aét muø, neáu noùi said, "There is no way through the clear waves."              khoâng aét cheát, laïi thaáy Vaân Moân choã vì ngöôøi The monk went on to say, "How did you                         chaêng? Traû caây gaäy laïi cho ta. Ngöôøi thôøi nay manage?" Yun Men said, "Where does this second                chaúng hoäi choã rieâng baøy cuûa Vaân Moân, laïi noùi töùc question come from?" The monk said, "How is it                saéc minh taâm, gaù vaät baøy lyù. Nhö ñöùc Phaät Thích when going on in just this way?" Yun Men said,                Ca 49 naêm thuyeát phaùp, khoâng theå khoâng bieát caùi "Further complications block the mountain path."              nghò luaän naøy, côù sao laïi ñöa caønh hoa, Ca Dieáp You must realize that this matter does not rest in            cöôøi chuùm chím? OÂng giaø naøy laïi hoà ñoà noùi: "Ta words and phrases: like sparks from struck flint,             coù chaùnh phaùp nhaõn taïng nieát baøn dieäu taâm, phaân like the brilliance of flashing lightning, whether            phoù cho Ma Ha Ca Dieáp." Laïi ñaâu caàn rieâng you reach it or not, you still will not avoid losing          truyeàn taâm aán. Quí vò ñaõ laø khaùch döôùi cuûa Toå Sö, your body and life.                                           laïi roõ ñöôïc rieâng truyeàn taâm aán chaêng? Trong ngöïc Coâng AÙn Vaân Moân Traàn Traàn Tam Muoäi : Yun               neáu coù moät vaät thì nuùi soâng ñaát lieàn quaû nhieân Men's Every Atom Samadhi, example 50 of the                   hieän tieàn; trong ngöïc neáu khoâng moät vaät thì beân Pi-Yen-Lu—Thí duï thöù 50 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc.                ngoaøi toaøn khoâng maûy tô, noùi gì lyù cuøng trí hieäp, Moät vò Taêng hoûi Vaân Moân: "Theá naøo laø traàn traàn      caûnh cuøng thaân hoäi. Côù sao? Bôûi moät hoäi thì taát caû tam muoäi?" Vaân Moân ñaùp: "Côm trong baùt, nöôùc            hoäi, moät saùng thì taát caû saùng. Tröôøng Sa noùi: trong thuøng." Theo Vieân Ngoä trong Bích Nham                "Ngöôøi hoïc ñaïo maø chaúng bieát chôn, chæ vì töø xöa Luïc, caùc oâng laïi ñònh ñuùng ñöôïc chaêng? Neáu caùc       nhaän thöùc thaàn, voâ löôïng kieáp nay goác sanh töû, keû oâng ñònh ñuùng ñöôïc thì loã muõi Vaân Moân ôû trong         só lieàn goïi ngöôøi xöa nay." Neáu chôït ñaäp tan aám tay caùc oâng. Neáu ñònh ñuùng chaúng ñöôïc thì loã muõi      giôùi, thaân taâm nhaát nhö, ngoaøi thaân khoâng thöøa, caùc oâng ôû trong tay Vaân Moân. Vaân Moân coù caâu          vaãn chöa ñöôïc moät nöûa, noùi gì laø töùc saéc minh chaët ñinh caét saét, trong moät caâu ñuû ba caâu. Coù        taâm, gaù vaät baøy lyù. Coå nhaân noùi: "Moät haït buïi vöøa ngöôøi hoûi ñeán lieàn noùi, côm trong baùt, moãi haït ñeàu   daáy, ñaïi ñòa toaøn thaâu." Haõy noùi caí naøo laø moät haït troøn; nöôùc trong thuøng, moãi gioït ñeàu öôùt. Neáu hieåu   buïi? Neáu bieát ñöôïc haït buïi naøy thì bieát ñöôïc caây theá aáy, chaúng thaáy choã Vaân Moân ñoan ñích vì            gaäy. Vöøa naém caây gaäy ñöa leân lieán thaáy tung ngöôøi—A monk asked Yun Men, "What is every                   hoaønh dieäu duïng. Noùi thoaïi theá aáy, sôùm thaønh saén atom samadhi?" Yun Men said, "Food in the bowl,               bìm roài, huoáng laïi laø hoùa laøm roàng. Taïng Chuû water in the bucket." According to Yuan-Wu in                 Khaùnh noùi: "5048 quyeån laïi coù noùi thoaïi theá aáy the Pi-Yen-Lu, can you settle this case properly?             chaêng?" Vaân Moân coù khi nhaèm choã caây gaäy naém If you can, then Yun Men's nostrils are in your               laáy thì toaøn cô ñaïi duïng, vì ngöôøi moät caùch linh hands. If you are unable to settle in properly, then          ñoäng. Ba Tieâu daïy chuùng: "Loã muõi cuûa thieàn Taêng your nostrils are in Yun Men's hands. Yun Men                 troïn ôû treân ñaàu caây gaäy." Vónh Gia cuõng noùi:

"Chaúng phaûi tieâu hình vieäc truyeàn roãng, gaäy baùu       of births and deaths, fools call the original Nhö Lai coøn daáu veát." Thuôû xöa Nhö Lai ôû choã            person." If you suddenly smash the shadowy world Phaät Nhieân Ñaêng noùi: "Choã naøy neân caát chuøa."         of the heaps and elements of life so that body and Khi aáy coù moät vò thieân töû beøn caëm moät coïng coû,      mind are one likeness and there is nothing else noùi: "Caát chuøa xong." Quí vò haõy noùi tin töùc naøy töø   outside your body, you still haven't attained the choã naøo ñöôïc? Toå Sö noùi: "Ñaàu gaäy thuû chöùng,         other half. How can you talk about going to form döôùi heùt thöøa ñöông." Haõy noùi thöøa ñöông caùi gì?       to reveal the mind, using things to demonstrate Chôït coù ngöôøi hoûi theá naøo laø caây gaäy? Phaûi chaêng   principle? An Ancient said, "As soon as one atom lieàn nhaøo loän? Phaûi chaêng lieàn voã tay? Thaûy ñeàu      of dust arises, the whole world is contained laø ñuøa tinh hoàn, töùc cöôøi khoâng dính daùng—Yun          therein." But say, which atom of dust is this? If Men showed his staff to the assembly and said,                you can know this atom of dust, then you can "The staff has changed into a dragon and                      know the staff. As soon as Yun Men picks up his swallowed the universe. Mountains, rivers, the                staff, we immediately see his unconfined great earth; where are they to be found?"                     marvelous activity. Such talk is already a mass of According to Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, as for                 entangling views, complications; how much the Yun Men's saying, "The staff has changed into a               more so is transforming the staff into a dragon! dragon and swallowed the universe. Mountains,                 Librabrian Ch'ing said, "Has there ever been such rivers, the great earth; where are they to be                 talk in the five thousand and forty-eight volumes found?" If you say it exists, then you are blind; if          of the canon?" Every time he turned to his staff, you say it doesn't exist, then you are dead. Do you           Yun Men brought out the great function of his see where Yun Men helped people? Bring the                    wholecapacity and helped people in a way that staff back to me! People these days do not                    was leaping with life. Pa Chiao said, "If you have understand where Yun Men stood alone and                      a staff, I'll give you a staff; if you have no staff, I'll revealed. Instead they say that he went to form to            take your satff away." Yung Chia said, "This is not explain mind, that he relied on things to reveal              an empty exhibition displaying form; it is the principle. But old Sakyamuni couldn't have not                actual traces of the Tathagata's precious staff." known this theory as he taught the Dharma for                 Long ago in the time of Dipamkara Buddha, the forty-nine years; why then did he also need to                future Tathagata (Sakyamuni) spread his hair to hold up the flower for Kasyapa's smile? This old              cover some mud for that Buddha. Dipamkara said, fellow caused confusion saying, "I have the                   "A temple should be built here." Also present then treasury of the eye of the correct teaching, the              was an elder who thereupon set up a blade of wondrous mind of nirvana; these I pass on to                  grass right there and said, "The temple has been Maha-Kasyapa." Why was there still a need for                 built." All of you tell me, where is this scene to be the specially transmitted mind seal? Given that all           found? The ancestral teacher Hsueh Tou said, "At of you are guests in the house of the ancestral               a blow, experience it; at a shout, receive it teachers, do you understand this specially                    rightly." But tell me, receive what rightly? transmitted mind? If there is a single thing in your          Supposing there's someone who asks, "What is the breast, then mountains, rivers, and the great earth           staff?" Shouldn't you turn a backflip? Shouldn't appear in profusion before you; if there isn't a              you clap your hands? All of this would be giving single thing in your breast, then outside there is            play to your spirits, and has nothing to do with it. not much as a fine hair. How can you talk about               Coâng AÙn Vaân Moân Tu Di: Yun Men: Mount principle and knowledge fusing, about objective               Sumeru—Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, world and mind merging? What's the reason?                    quyeån XVII, moät hoâm, thieàn sö Vaân Moân thöôïng When one understood, all are understood; when                 ñöôøng noùi: "Maáy oâng khaù tìm ra con ñöôøng vaøo. one is clear, all are clear. Ch'ang Sha said,                 Chö Phaät nhieàu nhö vi traàn naèm döôùi goùt chaân "People studying the Path don;t know the real,                maáy oâng. Ba taïng thaùnh giaùo naèm treân ñaàu löôõi because they've always given recognition to their             maáy oâng. Tuy nhieân, khi ngoä laø xong heát. Maáy oâng cognizing mind; this, the basis of countless aeons            chôù nghó nhaûm. Trôøi laø trôøi, ñaát laø ñaát, nuùi laø nuùi,

nöôùc laø nöôùc, taêng laø taêng, tuïc laø tuïc." Giaây laâu Sö   noùi con maét ôû choã naøo?" Vaân Nham lieàn noùi: "Toâi noùi tieáp: "Mang ngoïn Tu Di vaøo ñaây ta xem                    hieåu." Ñaïo Ngoä hoûi: "OÂng hieåu theá naøo?" Vaân thöû!"—According to the Records of the                            Nham noùi: "Toaøn thaân laø tay maét." Ñaïo Ngoä baûo: Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu),                        "Noùi ñeán toät cuøng chæ noùi ñöôïc taùm phaàn." Vaân Volume XVII, one day, Zen master Yun-men                          Nham hoûi: "Sö huynh theá naøo?" Ñaïo Ngoä noùi: entered the hall and said, "O you, venrable                       "Khaép thaân laø tay maét." Haõy noùi khaép thaân laø phaûi monks! You'd rather find out the Way for                          hay toaøn thaân laø phaûi? Tuy gioáng nhö buøn maø laïi yourselves. All the Buddhas as numberless as                      thong thaû. Ngöôøi ñôøi nay phaàn nhieàu khôûi tình giaûi sands are here under your heels. Three baskets of                 noùi: "Khaép thaân laø chaúng phaûi, toaøn thaân laø phaûi." Sacred Teachings are also right here on your lips.                Chæ thieát nhai ngoân cuù cuûa coå nhaân, cheát döôùi lôøi However, every thing is done just with your                       noùi cuûa coå nhaân. Ñaâu chaúng bieát yù cuûa coå nhaân, yù enlightenment. Don't get confused in thought.                     chaúng ôû treân ngoân cuù, ñaây ñeàu laø vieäc baát ñaéc dó heaven is heaven, earth is earth, mountains are                   maø thoâi. Nhö nay chuù thích laäp phöông thöùc, noùi: mountains, water is water, monks are monks,                       "Neáu thaáu ñöôïc coâng aùn naày lieàn hieåu baõi tham, laymen are laymen." He paused for a while, and                    roài laáy tay moø khaép thaân, moø ngoïn ñeøn caây coät, continued, "Bring me out here that mountain of                    troïn cho laø hieåu ñöôïc caâu toaøn thaân. Neáu hieåu theá Sumeru and let me see!"                                           aáy, phaù hoaïi coå nhaân chaúng ít." Vì theá noùi : "Kia Coâng AÙn Vaân Nham Ñaïi Bi Thieân Nhaõn: Yun                     tham caâu soáng khoâng tham caâu cheát." Caàn phaûi baët Yen's the Hands and Eyes of the Bodhisattva of                    tình traàn yù töôûng, loät traàn baøy loà loä, môùi coù theå Great Compassion, example 89 of the Pi-Yen-                       thaáy ñöôïc caâu Ñaïi Bi. Ñaâu chaúng thaáy Taøo Sôn Lu—Thí duï thöù 89 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Vaân                      hoûi Taêng: "Khi öùng vaät hieän hình nhö traêng trong Nham hoûi Ñaïo Ngoä: "Boà Taùt Ñaïi Bi duøng tay maét             nöôùc thì theá naøo?" Vò Taêng ñaùp: "Nhö löøa nhìn nhieàu laém ñeå laøm gì?" Ñaïo Ngoä noùi: "Nhö ngöôøi             gieáng." Taøo Sôn noùi: "Noùi ñeán toät cuøng chæ noùi giöõa ñeâm voùi tay laïi phía sau moø chieác goái." Vaân          ñöôïc taùm phaàn." Vò Taêng hoûi: "Hoøa Thöôïng laïi theá Nham noùi: "Toâi hieåu." Ñaïo Ngoä hoûi: "OÂng hieåu              naøo?" Taøo Sôn ñaùp: "Nhö gieáng nhìn löøa." Theá laø theá naøo?" Vaân Nham noùi: "Toaøn thaân laø tay maét."           Taøo Sôn ñaõ ñoàng yù vôùi Ñaïo Ngoä vaäy. Neáu caùc oâng Ñaïo Ngoä noùi: "Noùi ñeán toät cuøng chæ noùi ñöôïc taùm         chaïy treân lôøi noùi maø thaáy, hoaøn toaøn khoâng thoaùt phaàn." Vaân Nham hoûi: "Sö huynh theá naøo?" Ñaïo                khoûi caùi loàng baãy cuûa Ñaïo Ngoä vaø Vaân Nham. Ngoä noùi: "Khaép thaân laø tay maét." Theo Vieân Ngoä            Haønh giaû tu thieàn khoâng neân nhaèm döôùi caâu cheát, trong Bích Nham Luïc, Vaân Nham vaø Ñaïo Ngoä                     maø neân nhaèm treân ñaàu ñi—Yun Yen asked Tao cuøng tham vôùi Döôïc Sôn boán möôi naêm hoâng                    Wu, "What does the Bodhisattva of Great khoâng dính chieáu. Döôïc Sôn xuaát phaùt moät toâng              Compassion use so many hands and eyes for?" Taøo Ñoäng coù ba ngöôøi khieán ñaïo phaùp thònh haønh.           Tao Wu said, "It's like someone reaching back Döôùi Vaân Nham coù Ñoäng Sôn; döôùi Ñaïo Ngoä coù                groping for a pillow in the middle of the night." Thaïch Söông; döôùi Thuyeàn Töû coù Giaùp Sôn. Boà                Yun Yen said, "I understand." Tao Wu said, "How Taùt Ñaïi Bi coù taùm muoân boán ngaøn caùnh tay Maãu             do you understand it?" Yun Yen said, "All over Ñaø La. Ñaïi Bi coù laém tay maét, caùc oâng laïi coù hay         the body are hands and eyes." Tao Wu said, "You khoâng? Baùch Tröôïng noùi: "Taát caû ngöõ ngoân vaên töï         have said quite a bit there, but you're only said thaûy ñeàu xoay veà chính mình." Vaân Nham thöôøng                eighty percent of it." Yun Yen said, "What do you theo Ñaïo Ngoä thöa hoûi giaûi nghi, moät hoâm hoûi               say, Elder Brother?" Tao Wu said, "Throughout Ñaoï Ngoä: "Boà Taùt Ñaïi Bi duøng nhieàu tay maét ñeå            the body are hands and eyes." According to Yuan- laøm gì?" Ngay ban ñaàu neân vì Vaân Nham maø                     Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, Yun Yen and Tao Wu were nhaèm xöông soáng ñaùnh, veà sau khoûi thaáy nhieàu               fellow students under Yao Shan. For forty years saén bìm. Ñaïo Ngoä laïi töø bi khoâng theå laøm nhö theá,        Yun Yen's side did not touch his mat. Yao Shan laïi vì Vaân Nham noùi ñaoï lyù, coát yù khieán cho Vaân          produced the whole Ts'ao-Tung school. There Nham lieàn hieåu. Noùi: "Nhö ngöôøi giöõa ñeâm voùi tay           were three men with whom the Path of Dharma laïi phía sau moø chieác goái. Chính khi ñeâm khuya               flourished: descended from Yun Yen was Tung khoâng coù aùnh saùng ñeøn, laáy tay moø chieác goái. Haõy        Shan; descended from Tao Wu was Shih Shuang;

and descended from Ch'uan Tzu was Chia Shan.            phrase." You must cut off emotional defilements The Bodhisattva of Great Compassion has eighty-         and conceptual thinking, become clean and naked, four thousand symbolic arms. Great Compassion           free and unbound; only then will you be able to has this many hands and eyes, do all of you? Pai        see this saying about Great Compassion. Haven't Chang said, "All sayings and writings return to         you heard how Ts'ao Shan asked a monk, "How is one's self." Yun Yen often followed Tao Wu, to          it when the Dharmakaya (the body of reality) is study and ask questions to settle his discernment       manifesting from in accordance with beings, like with certainty. One day he asked him, "What does        the moon (reflected) in the water?" The monk Bodhisattva of Great Compassion use so many             said, "Like an ass looking at a well." Ts'ao Shan hands and eyes for?" Right at the start Tao Wu          said, "You have said quite a lot, but you've only should have given him a blow of the staff across        said eighty percent of it." The monk said, "What his back, to avoid so many complications                do you say, Teacher?" Ts'ao Shan said, "It's like appearing later. But Tao Wu was compassionate,          the well looking at the ass." This is the same he couldn't be like this. Instead, he gave Yun Yen      meaning as the main case. If you go to their words and explanation of the reason, meaning to make          to see, you'll never be able to get out of Tao Wu's him understand immediately. Instead of hitting          and Yun Yen's trap. Zen practitioners should Yun Yen, Tao Wu said, "It's like someone                never die in the words; but walk right on Tao Wu's reaching back groping for a pillow in the middle of     and Yun Yen's heads to versify. the night." Groping for a pillow in the depths of       Coâng AÙn Vaân Nham Thuï Khôûi Taûo Tueä: Yun- the night without any lamplight, tell me, where are     Yen held up the broom—Theo Caûnh Ñöùc Truyeàn the eyes? Yun Yen immediately said, "I                  Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån XIV, coù moät laàn khi Vaân Nham understand." Tao Wu said, "How do you                   ñang queùt doïn saân chuøa, Ñaïo Ngoä baûo oâng: "OÂng understand it?" Yun Yen said, "All over the body        queùt voäi quaù!" Vaân Nham noùi: "OÂng neân bieát raèng are hands and eyes." Tao Wu said, "You have said        coù moät thöù khoâng voäi." Ñaïo Ngoä noùi: "Trong quite a bit there, but you've only said eighty          tröôøng hôïp ñoù, coù phaûi laø vaàng traêng thöù nhì hay percent of it." Yun Yen said, "What do you say,         khoâng?" Vaân Nham ñöa caây choåi leân vaø noùi: Elder Brother?" Tao Wu said, "Throughout the            "Vaàng traêng naøo ñaây?" Ñaïo Ngoä boû ñi. Veà sau, body are hands and eyes." But say, is "all over the     Huyeàn Sa Sö Bò nghe chuyeän naøy noùi: "Chính xaùc body" right, or is "throughout the body" right?         laø vaàng traêng thöù nhì."—According to the Records Although they seem covered with mud,                    of the Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng- nevertheless they are bright and clean. People          Lu), Volume XIV, once, when Yun-Yan was these days often make up emotional                      sweeping the temple yard, Daowu said to him, interpretations and say that "all over the body" is     "Too hurried!" Yun-Yan said, "You should know wrong, while "throughout the body" is right;            that there is a something that is not hurried." they're marely chewing over the Ancients' words         Daowu said, "In that case, is there a second and phrases. They have died in the Ancients'            moon?" Yun-Yan held up the broom and said, words, far from realizing that the Ancients'            "What moon is this?" Daowu then went off. Later, meaning isn't in the words, and that all talk is used   Hsuan-sha heard about this and said, "Exactly the as something that can't be avoided. People these        second moon." days add footnotes and set up patterns, saying that     Coâng AÙn Vaán Vöông Laõo Sö Taùc Thaäp Ma: To if one can penetrate this case, then this can be        ask master Old Vuong on what he is doing—See considered understanding enough to put an end to        Vaán Vöông Laõo Sö Taùc Thaäp Ma. study. Groping with their hands over their bodies       Coâng AÙn "Voâ": Mu (jap)—Muji (jap)—Mu koan and over the lamp and pillar, they all make a           (jap)—Khoâng—Voâ—See Coâng AÙn veà “Khoâng.” literal understanding of "throughout the body." If      Coâng AÙn Voâ Khoång Ñòch: A flute with no you understand this way, you degrade those              holes—Theo thí duï thöù 82 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Coù Ancients quite a bit. Thus it is said, "He studies      moät vò Taêng hoûi Ñaïi Long: "Saéc thaân baïi hoaïi, theá the living phrase; he doesn't study the dead            naøo laø Phaùp thaân kieân coá?" Ñaïi Long ñaùp: "Hoa

nuùi nôû döôøng gaám, nöôùc khe trong tôï chaøm." Ñaïi         ñaùp." Ñaây laø baøi tuïng cuûa Höông Nghieâm Trí Long ñaùp: "Hoa nuùi nôû döôøng gaám, nöôùc khe trong          Nhaøn, Tuyeát Ñaäu daãn duøng. Moät vò Taêng hoûi Trieäu tôï chaøm." Moät vò Taêng khaùc hoûi Vaân Moân: "Khi laù       Chaâu: "Chaúng ñem noùi nín ñaùp, chöa bieát ñem caùi ruïng caønh khoâ thì theá naøo?" Vaân Moân ñaùp: "Thaân        gì ñaùp?" Trieäu Chaâu ñaùp: "Trình ñoà ñöïng sôn." Caùi baøy gioù thu." Ñaây goïi laø hai muõi teân choáng nhau.       naøy ñoàng vôùi caâu vöøa roài noùi, chaúng rôi vaøo tình Döôøng theå anh ñeán Taây Taàn, toâi ôû Ñoâng Loã. Kia         traàn yù töôûng cuûa oâng. Gioáng nhö caùi gì? Gioáng ñaõ ñi theá aáy, toâi chaúng ñi theá aáy, cuøng vôùi Vaân      "Tay caàm roi baïch ngoïc, ñaäp tan naùt ly chaâu." Theá Moân moät khoái traùi nhau. Gaõ kia ñi theá aáy laø deã        neân Toå leänh ñöông haønh möôøi phöông ngoài ñoaïn. thaáy, gaõ naøy chaúng ñi theá aáy laïi khoù thaáy. Quaû       Ñaây laø vieäc treân kieám beùn, phaûi coù taùc löôïc theá aáy. thöïc ba taác löôõi cuûa Ñaïi Long raát vi teá.                Neáu chaúng theá aáy, ñeàu coâ phuï chö Thaùnh töø tröôùc. "Vaán taèng baát tri                                   Ñeán trong ñaây caàn khoâng coù chuùt xíu vieäc, töï coù Ñaùp hoaøn baát hoäi                                 choã toát, töùc laø choã haønh lyù cuûa ngöôøi höôùng Nguyeät laõnh phong cao                              thöôïng. Ñaõ chaúng ñaäp naùt aét sanh tyø veát, lieàn thaáy Coå nham haøn coái                                   loù ñuoâi. Cöùu caùnh phaûi laøm sao ñöôïc? "Nöôùc coù Kham tieáu loä phuøng ñaït ñaïo nhaân                hieán chöông, ba ngaøn ñieàu toäi" moät luùc phaïm heát Baát töông ngöõ maëc ñoái                            vaäy. Côù sao nhö theá? Chæ vì chaúng laáy vieäc boån Thuû baû baïch ngoïc tieân                           phaän tieáp ngöôøi. Neáu laø Ñaïi Long haún khoâng theá Ly chaâu taän kích toaùi                             aáy—According to example 82 of the Pi-Yen-Lu, a Baát kích toaùi                                      monk asked Ta Lung, "The physical body rots Taèng haø hoaïi                                      away: what is the hard and fast body of reality?" Quoác höõu hieán chöông                              Ta Lung said, "The mountain flowers bloom like Tam thieân ñieàu toäi."                              brocade, the valley streams are brimming blue as (Hoûi töøng chaúng bieát. Ñaùp laïi chaúng thoâng. Gioù        indigo." Another monk asked Yun Men, "How is it cao traêng laïnh. Caây haøn nuùi xöa. Cöôøi ngaát ñöôøng       when the tree withers and the leaves fall?" Yun gaëp ñaït ñaïo nhaân. Chaúng ñem noùi nín ñaùp. Tay            Men said, "The body exposed in the golden wind." caàm roi baïch ngoïc. Ñaäp tan naùt ly chaâu. Chaúng           This is called "Arrowpoints meeting." This is just ñaäp naùt, theâm tyø veát. Nöôùc coù hieán chöông. Ba          like "you go west to Ch'in, I go east to Lu": since ngaøn ñieàu toäi). Thieàn sö Tuyeát Ñaäu tuïng raát coù        he acts this way, I don't act this way. Matching Ta coâng phu, ôû tröôùc lôøi tuïng Vaân Moân noùi: "Hoûi ñaõ      Lung's answer with Yun Men's, they're opposites. coù toâng, ñaùp cuõng vaãn ñoàng." ÔÛ ñaây laïi chaúng theá,   It's easy to see Yun Men acting thus, but it's hard noùi: "Hoûi töøng chaúng bieát. ñaùp laïi chaúng thoâng."      to see Ta Lung acting otherwise. Nevertheless, Ta Choã ñaùp cuûa Ñaïi Long ñöùng beân nhìn haún laø kyø          Lung's tongue is very subtle. ñaëc. Phaân minh ai hoûi theá aáy, tröôùc khi chöa hoûi             "Asking without knowing. sôùm ñaõ hö hoûng roài. Choã ñaùp cuûa sö raát möïc vöøa             Answering, still not understanding. vaën hôïp cô ngôi, noùi: "Hoa nuùi nôû döôøng gaám,                  The moon is cold, the wind is high nöôùc khe trong tôï chaøm." Hoâm nay moïi ngöôøi laøm                On the ancient cliff, frigid juniper. sao hieåu yù Ñaïi Long? Lôøi ñaùp baøng quan thaáy thöïc             How delightful: on the road he met a man kyø ñaëc. Vì theá, Tuyeát Ñaäu tuïng ra khieán ngöôøi                who had attained the Path, bieát, noùi "Gioù cao traêng laïnh, caây haøn nuùi xöa."             And didn't use speech or silence to reply. Haõy noùi yù ñoù laøm sao hieåu? Sôû dó vöøa roài noùi:              His hand grasps the white jade whip. "Chieác saùo khoâng loã (Voâ Khoång Ñòch), naém ñöôïc                And smashes the black dragon's pearl. nhòp vaùn." Chæ boán caâu naøy tuïng xong vaäy. Thieàn               If he hadn't smashed it, sö Tuyeát Ñaäu laïi sôï ngöôøi khôûi ñaïo lyù, laïi noùi:            He would have increased its flaws. "Cöôøi ngaát ñöôøng gaëp ñaït ñaïo nhaân, chaúng ñem                 The nation has a code of laws noùi nín ñaùp." Vieäc naøy chaúng phaûi thaáy nghe hieåu             Three thousand articles of offenses." bieát, cuõng chaúng suy nghó phaân bieät. Vì theá noùi:        According to Zen master Yuan Wu K'e Chin, "Rôõ rôõ khoâng goàm keït, duïng rieâng naøo nöông nhôø,       Hsueh Tou versifies here with much skill. Before treân ñöôøng gaëp ñaït ñaïo nhaân, chôù ñem noùi nín           when he was versifying Yun Men's words "Body

exposed in the golden wind" he said, "Since the         on the sword's edge, for which one must have this question has the source, the answer too is in the       kind of strategy. Otherwise you turn your back on same place." Since it is not so with this case,         the sages since antiquity. When you get here you Hsueh Tou instead says, "Asking without                 must be without the slightest concern, then knowing; answering, still not understanding." Ta        naturally you'll have the advantage. This, then, is Lung's answer was a glimpse from the side that          how a transcendent man comports himself. "If he was simply amazing. His answer was so clear that        hadn't smashed it," necessarily "He would have whoever questioned him this way had already             increased its flaws," and thus he would have incurred defeat even before he asked. With his          seemed broken down and decrepit. But in the end, answer he was able to bend down to the monk and         how can you be right? " The nation has a code of match him perfectly; adapting to his capacity he        laws, three thousand articles of offenses." There rightly said, "The mountain flowers bloom like          are three thousand subdivisions of the five brocade, the valley streams are brimming blue as        punishments, and none is greater than the indigo." How will all of you understand Ta Lung's       punishment for not being respectful. This monk meaning right now? As a glimpse from the side,          offended against all three thousand articles at his answer was truly extraordinary. Thus Hsueh          once. How so? Because he didn't deal with people Tou comes out with his verse to make people             on the basis of his own thing. As for Ta Lung, he realize that the moon is cold, the wind is high and     of course was not this way—See Ñaïi Long Kieân still beats against the frigid juniper on the ancient   Coá Phaùp Thaân. cliff. But say, how will you understand Hsueh           Coâng AÙn Voâ Khoång Thieát Chuøy : An iron Tou's meaning? Thus I just said that it's a flute       hammerhead with no hole—Chuøy saét khoâng loã, with no holes hitting against a felt-pounding board.    Thieàn toâng duøng töø naày ñeå chæ ngöôøi tham hoïc ngu The verse is completed with just these first four       si ñaàn ñoän, khieán cho baäc thaày phaûi khoù khaên laém lines, but Huseh Tou was still fearful that people      môùi daãn daét ñöôïc. Theo thí duï thöù 14 cuûa Bích would make up rationalizations, so he said, " How       Nham Luïc, moät hoâm, coù moät vò Taêng ñeán hoûi Vaân delightful: on the road he met a man who had            Moân: "Theá naøo laø giaùo lyù moät ñôøi?" Vaân Moân ñaùp: attained the Path.       And didn't use speech or       "Ñoái nhaát thuyeát." Theá naøo laø giaùo lyù moät ñôøi? Chæ silence to reply." This matter, then, is not seeing,    tieâu ñöôïc moät caâu "Ñoái Nhaát Thuyeát." Neáu ngay hearing, discernment, or knowledge; nor is it the       ñoù tieán ñöôïc lieàn veà nhaø ngoài an oån. Neáu chöa tieán discriminations of calculating thought. Therefore it    ñöôïc, haõy tieáp tuïc duïng coâng tu haønh hoaëc möôøi was said: "Direct and truthful, without bringing        naêm, hoaëc hai möôi naêm, hoaëc caû ñôøi nhö caùc baäc anything else along. Moving on alone, what is           coå ñöùc ñaõ töøng laøm trong quaù khöù. Baây giôø chuùng there to depend on? On the road, if you meet            ta haõy laéng nghe baøi keä cuûa Thieàn sö Tuyeát Ñaäu anyone who has attained the Path, don't use             Truøng Hieån: speech or silence to reply." This is a verse of               "Ñoái Nhaát Thuyeát Hsiang Yen's that Hsueh Tou has drawn on.                      Thaùi coâ tuyeät Haven't you heard? A monk asked Chao Chou,                     Voâ khoång thieát Chuøy truøng haï khieát "Without using speech or silence to answer, I                  Dieâm phuø thoï haï tieáu ha ha wonder with what should one answer?" Chao                      Taïc daï Ly Long aûo giaùc chieát Chou said, "Show your lacquer vessel." These                   Bieät bieät sayings of Hsiang Yen and Chao Chou are the                    Thieàu Döông laõo nhaân ñaéc nhaát quyeát." same as Ta Lung's statement in the case: they           (Ñoái moät noùi, raát coâ tuyeät. Chuøy saét khoâng loã theâm don't fall within the scope of your feelings or         haï choát. Döôùi coäi Dieâm Phuø cöôøi ha ha. Ñeâm qua conceptual thoughts. What is this like? "His hand       Ly Long söøng beû gaõy. Khaùc khaùc, Laõo nhaân Thieàu grasps the white jade whip, and smashes the black       Döông ñöôïc moät maûnh). Theo Thieàn sö Vieân Ngoä, dragon's pearl." Thus the command of the                "Ñoái moät noùi, raát coâ tuyeät" laø lôøi khen cuûa Tuyeát patriarchs must be carried out, cutting off             Ñaäu. Caâu noùi naøy cuûa Vaân Moân thaät laø töï do töï everything in the ten directions. This is the matter    taïi, ñoäc thoaùt coâ nguy quang tieàn tuyeät haäu, nhö bôø

cao muoân tröôïng, nhö quaân traän traêm muoân, khoâng               He wedges a stake into the iron hammerhead coù choã cho oâng vaøo, chæ laø quaù ngaët coâ nguy.                 with no hole. Ngöôøi xöa noùi: "Muoán ñöôïc thaân thieát chôù ñem                  Under the Jambu Tree I'm laughing; ha, ha! caâu hoûi ñeán ñeå hoûi, hoûi taïi choã ñaùp, ñaùp taïi ñieåm        Last night the black dragon had his horn hoûi," haún laø coâ ñoäc vaø nguy hieåm voâ cuøng. Haõy              wrenched off: noùi xem choã naøo laø coâ ñoäc vaø nguy hieåm? Ngöôøi               Exceptional, exceptional khaép thieân haï laøm gì cuõng chaúng ñöôïc. Vò Taêng                The old man of Shao Yang got one horn." naøy laø haøng taùc gia neân môùi hoûi nhö theá. Vaân Moân      According to Zen master Yuan Wu, "An ñaùp laò theá aáy, gioáng nhö "Chuøy saét khoâng loã theâm      appropriate statement; how utterly unique!" Hsueh haï choát." Tuyeát Ñaäu duøng vaên ngoân tuyeät kheùo.          Tou cannot praise him enough. These words of Caâu "Döôùi coäi Dieâm Phuø cöôøi ha ha", trong Kinh            Yun Men are independent and free, unique and Khôûi Theá noùi: "Phía Nam nuùi Tu Di coù caây pheä             lofty, prior to light and after annihilation. They are löu ly aùnh saùng chieáu chaâu Dieâm Phuø ñeàu saéc             like an overhanging cliff ten thousand fathoms xanh. Chaâu naøy laáy teân ñaïi thoï laøm teân chaâu, neân      high. Then, too, they are like a million man battle goïi laø Dieâm Phuø Ñeà. Caây naøy beà cao beà roäng baûy       line; there is no place for you to get in. It's just that ngaøn do tuaàn, phía döôùi coù ñoáng vaøng Dieâm Phuø           it's too solitary and perilous. An Ancient said, "If Ñaøn cao hai möôi do tuaàn, bôûi vaøng töø döôùi ñaùy           you want to attain intimacy, don't use a question to caây sinh ra, neân goïi laø caây Dieâm Phuø." Vì theá           ask a question; the question is in the answer and Tuyeát Ñaäu töï noùi kia ôû döôùi coäi Dieâm Phuø cöôøi ha      the answer is in the point of the question." Of ha. Thöû noùi kia cöôøi laø caùi gì? Cöôøi "Ñeâm qua Ly         course it's solitary and steep, but tell me, where is Long söøng beû gaõy." Chæ coù chieâm ngöôõng taùn thaùn         it that it's solitary and steep? No one on earth can Vaân Moân thoâi. Vaân Moân noùi: "Ñoái moät noùi", gioáng       do anything about it. The monk in this case was caùi gì? Gioáng nhö beû gaõy moät söøng con Ly Long.            also an adept, and that is why he could question Ñeán trong ñoù, neáu khoâng coù vieäc theá aáy, ñaâu theå       like this. And Yun Men too answered this way, noùi lôøi theá aáy. Tuyeát Ñaäu moät luùc tuïng xong, roát      much like "wedging a stake into the iron sau laïi noùi: "Khaùc khaùc, Laõo nhaân Thieàu Döông            hammerhead with no hole." Hsueh Tou employs ñöôïc moät maûnh." Sao chaúng noùi ñöôïc troïn veïn, maø        literary language so artfully! " Under the Jambu chæ noùi ñöôïc moät maûnh? Thöû noùi moät maûnh kia ôû          Tree I'm laughing; ha, ha!" In the scripture on the choã naøo? Haønh giaû tu Thieàn neân luoân nhôù raèng           Creation of the World it says, "On the south side neáu ngay ñoù tieán ñöôïc lieàn veà nhaø ngoài an oån. Neáu     of Sumeru a crystal tree shines over the continent chöa tieán ñöôïc, haõy tieáp tuïc duïng coâng tu haønh          of Jambu, making all in between a clear blue hoaëc möôøi naêm, hoaëc hai möôi naêm, hoaëc caû ñôøi           color. This continent takes its name from this great nhö caùc baäc coå ñöùc ñaõ töøng laøm trong quaù khöù —         tree; hence it is called Jambudvipa. This tree is An ignorant and stupid student who causes so                    seven thousand leagues high; beneath it are the much difficulty for the master to instruct and                  golden mounds of the Jambu altar, which is twenty guide. According to example 14 of the Pi-Yen-Lu,                leagues high. Since gold is produced from beneath one day, a monk asked Yun-men, "What are the                    the tree, it is called the Jambu tree." Thus Hsueh teachings of a whole lifetime?" Yun-men said,                   Tou says of himself that he is under the Jambu "An appropriate statement." What are the                        tree laughing out loud. But tell me, what is he teachings of a whole lifetime?" just boils down to              laughing at? He is laughing at the black dragon his saying, "An appropriate statement." If you can              who last night got his horn wrenched off. He's just grasp this immediately, then you can return home                looking up respectfully; he can only praise Yun and sit in peace. If you can't get it, continue to              Men. When Yun Men says, "An appropriate strive to cultivate ten years, twenty years or your             statement," what's it like? It's like breaking off one whole life as our ancient virtues did in the past.              of the black dragon's horns. At this point, if there Now let's listen to Hsueh Tou's verse:                          were no such thing, how could he have spoken as "An appropriate statement;                                   he did? Hsueh Tou has finished his verse all at How utterly unique!                                        once, but he still has something to say at the very

end: "Exceptional, exceptional - The old man of                 maét. Neáu laø ñieän xeït sao baêng thì haønh giaû coù theå Shao Yang got one horn." Why doesn't Hsueh Tou                  nghieâng hoà laät nuùi ñöôïc. Haønh giaû tu Thieàn, haõy say he got them both? How is it that he just got                xem coi neáu mình coù theå quaùn xuyeán ñöôïc chuyeän one horn? Tell me, where is the other horn? Zen                 naøy hay khoâng—According to example 14 of the practitioners should always remember that if you                Wu-Men-Kuan, one day, Zen master Nan-ch'uan can grasp this immediately, then you can return                 found monks of the eastern and western halls home and sit in peace. If you can't get it, continue            arguing about a cat. He held up the cat and said, to strive to cultivate ten years, twenty years or               "Everyone, if you can say something, I will spare your whole life as our ancient virtues did in the               this cat. If you can't say anything, I will cut off its past—See Coâng AÙn Vaân Moân Ñoái Nhaát Thuyeát.                head." No one could say a word, so Nan-ch'uan Coâng AÙn YÙ Loä Baát Ñaùo: Nôi yù thöùc khoâng theå            cut the cat into two. That evening, Chao-chou ñeán ñöôïc—Where the road of ideation cannot                    returned from outside and Nan-ch'uan told him reach—Theo thí duï 14 cuûa Voâ Moân Quan, ngaøy                 what happened. Chao-chou removed a sandal noï, Taêng chuùng hai chaùi ñoâng taây tranh nhau con           from his foot, put it on his head, and walked out. meøo. Hoøa Thöôïng Nam Tuyeàn giô con meøo leân                 Nan-ch'uan said, "If you had been there, the cat maø noùi: "Caùc oâng noùi ñöôïc thì tha, khoâng noùi ñöôïc      would have been spared." The fact is that at that thì cheùm." Chaúng ai bieát noùi sao. Nam Tuyeàn beøn           time he really did not kill. This story does not lie cheùm con meøo. Ñeán toái Trieäu Chaâu veà, Nam                 in killing or not killing. This matter is clearly Tuyeàn keå chuyeän laïi cho nghe. Trieäu Chaâu beøn             known; it is so distinctly clear. It is not to be found côûi deùp, ñeå leân ñaàu maø ñi ra. Nam Tuyeàn noùi:            in emotions or opinions; if you go searching in "Neáu luùc aáy coù oâng thì cöùu ñöôïc con meøo roài." Kyø      emotions and opinions, then you turn against Nan thaät ñöông thôøi voán chaúng cheùm, thoaïi naøy cuõng          Ch'uan. Just see it right on the edge of the knife. If chaúng ôû choã cheùm cuøng chaúng cheùm. Vieäc naøy             it exists, all right; if it does not exist, all right; if it thaät bieát roõ raøng nhö theá, chaúng ôû treân tình traàn yù   neither exists nor doesn't exist, that is all right too. kieán thaûo luaän. Neáu nhaèm treân tình traàn yù kieán         That is why an Ancient said, "When at an impasse, thaûo luaän thì coâ phuï Nam Tuyeàn. Chæ nhaèm treân            change; when you change, then you can pass muõi nhoïn kieám beùn xem thì coù cuõng ñöôïc, khoâng           through." People nowadays do not know how to cuõng ñöôïc, chaúng coù chaúng khoâng cuõng ñöôïc. Vì           change and pass through; they only go running to theá coå nhaân noùi: "Cuøng taéc bieán, bieán taéc thoâng."     the spoken words. When Nan Ch'uan held up the Ngöôøi ñôøi nay chaúng hieåu bieán thoâng, chæ nhaèm            cat in this way, he could not have been telling treân ngoân cuù maø chaïy. Nam Tuyeàn ñeà khôûi theá aáy,       people they should be able to say something; he khoâng theå baûo ngöôøi haï ñöôïc lôøi gì? Chæ caàn baûo        just wanted people to attain on their own, each act ngöôøi töï tieán, moãi moãi töï duïng töï bieát. Neáu chaúng    on their own, and know for themselves. If you do hieåu theá aáy, chôït doø tìm khoâng ñeán. Hôn nöõa, khi        not understand it in this way, after all you will khoâng ai ñaùp ñöôïc, vaø Nam Tuyeàn lieàn gieát cheát          grope without finding it. Furthermore, when no con meøo voâ phöôùc. Nam Tuyeàn döôøng nhö laø moät             one made a response, and the master slew the keû quaù nhaãn taâm, nhöng quan ñieåm cuûa Sö coù theå          poor kitten. Nan-ch'uan looks like a hard-hearted laø nhö vaày: "Noùi 'coù' laø keït ôû caùi theá nhò nguyeân.    man, but his point may be this: "To say it is Noùi 'khoâng' cuõng keït nhö nhau. Muoán ñaït chaân lyù         involves us in a dilema; to say it is not puts us in caàn phaûi traùnh thaùi ñoä nhò nguyeân ñoái ñaõi aáy. Laøm     the same predicament. To attain the truth, this sao traùnh? Neáu maáy oâng (ñeä töû cuûa Nam Tuyeàn)            dualism must be avoided. How do you avoid it? It khoâng traùnh khoûi ngoõ cuït aáy thì khoâng nhöõng con         may not only be the loss of the life of a kitten, but meøo maát maïng, maø caû chính maïng cuûa maáy oâng,            also the loss of your own life and soul, if you fail vaø caû linh hoàn nöõa cuõng maát luoân." Do ñoù, Nam           to ride over this impasse." Therefore, Nan-ch'uan Tuyeàn môùi duøng ñeán moät thuû ñoaïn heát söùc cöïc           utilized a drastic procedure to open the eye of his ñoan ñeå nhaèm caûnh tænh ñeä töû cuûa mình. Khi treân          disciples. When the road of ideation cannot reach, ñöôøng maø yù chaúng theå ñeán ñöôïc (yù loä baát ñaùo), noùi   that is just right to bring to attention; where verbal naêng chaúng kòp, thì haønh giaû tu Thieàn phaûi mau ñeå        explanation cannot reach, practitioners must set

their eyes on it quickly. If your thunder rolls and               practices to improve oneself such as comets fly, then practitioners can overturn lakes                 decreasing greed, anger, and ignorance. Both and topple mountains. Zen practitioners, let see if               merit and virtue should be cultivated side by you can manage this.                                              side. These two terms are sometimes used Coâng Baát Laõng Thí: Khoâng uoång phí coâng phu—                 interchangeably. However, there is a crucial Not to waste the effort.                                          difference. Merits are the blessings (wealth, Coâng Bieän Tö Bieän: Giaûi quyeát toaøn boä coâng                intelligence, etc) of the human and celestial vieäc—To solve the whole task (problem).                          realms; therefore, they are temporary and Coâng Can: See Coâng Phu.                                         subject to birth and death. Virtue, on the other Coâng Chính: Just—Fair—Equitable.                                 hand, transcend birth and death and lead to Coâng Duïng: 1) Taùc duïng: Action, effect; 2) Thöïc              Buddhahood. The same action of giving hieän chöùc naêng cuûa söï thöïc haønh vaø thaønh töïu:           charity with the mind to obtain mundane Functioning in practice and achievement.                          rewards, you will get merit; however, if you Coâng Duïng Ñòa: Boà Taùt töø sô ñòa ñeán thaát ñòa               give charity with the mind to decrease greed luoân phaûi luoân heát söùc coá gaéng duïng coâng tu              and stingy, you will obtain virtue. haønh—Bodhisattvas from the first to the seventh             (II) “Coâ  ng Ñöùc” trong quan ñieåm Phaät giaùo Ñaïi stages must always try with their best efforts in                 Thöø  a —“Merit and Virtue” in the point of cultivation.                                                      view    of the Mahayana Buddhism: Coâng ñöùc Coâng Ñaïo: Fairness—Justice.                                     laø tính chaát trong chuùng ta baûo ñaûm nhöõng ôn Coâng Ñöùc: Punnupaga (p)—Coâng vaø Ñöùc—                         phöôùc saép ñeán, caû vaät chaát laãn tinh thaàn. Virtue achieved—Power to do meritorious                           Khoâng caàn khoù khaên laém ngöôøi ta cuõng nhìn works—Meritorious           virtue—Power         to      do       thaáy ngay raèng öôùc ao coâng ñöùc, taïo coâng ñöùc, meritorious works—Virtue achieved—Virtue                          taøng chöùa coâng ñöùc, hay thu thaäp coâng ñöùc, duø (which will help transcend birth and death and                    xöùng ñaùng theá naøo chaêng nöõa vaãn aån taøng moät lead to Buddhahood)—Merit and virtue.                             möùc ñoä ích kyû ñaùng keå. Coâng ñöùc luoân luoân laø (I) Nghóa cuûa “Coâng Ñöùc”—The meanings of                       nhöõng nhöõng chieán thuaät maø caùc Phaät töû, “Merit and Virtue: Söùc maïnh laøm nhöõng vieäc              nhöõng thaønh phaàn yeáu keùm veà phöông dieän coâng ñöùc, giuùp vöôït qua bôø sanh töû vaø ñaït ñeán       taâm linh trong giaùo hoäi, duøng ñeå laøm yeáu ñi quaû vò Phaät. Phöôùc ñöùc ñöôïc thaønh laäp baèng           nhöõng baûn naêng chaáp thuû, baèng caùch taùch rôøi caùch giuùp ñôû ngöôøi khaùc, trong khi coâng ñöùc           mình vôùi cuûa caûi vaø gia ñình, baèng caùch ngöôïc nhôø vaøo tu taäp ñeå töï caûi thieän mình vaø laøm          laïi höôùng daãn hoï veà moät muïc ñích duy nhaát, giaûm thieåu nhöõng ham muoán, giaän hôøn, si meâ.           nghóa laø söï thuû ñaéc coâng ñöùc töø laâu vaãn naèm Caû phöôùc ñöùc vaø coâng ñöùc phaûi ñöôïc tu taäp           trong chieán thuaät cuûa Phaät giaùo. Nhöng, dó song haønh. Hai töø naày thænh thoaûng ñöôïc duøng           nhieân vieäc naøy chæ coù giaù trò ôû möùc ñoä tinh laãn loän. Tuy nhieân, söï khaùc bieät chính yeáu laø        thaàn thaáp keùm. ÔÛ nhöõng giai ñoaïn cao hôn phöôùc ñöùc mang laïi haïnh phuùc, giaøu sang,               ngöôøi ta phaûi quay löng laïi vôùi caû hình thöùc thoâng thaùi, vaân vaân cuûa baäc trôøi ngöôøi, vì theá      thuû ñaéc naøy, ngöôøi ta phaûi saün saøng buoâng boû chuùng coù tính caùch taïm thôøi vaø vaãn coøn bò            kho taøng coâng ñöùc cuûa mình vì haïnh phuùc cuûa luaân hoài sanh töû. Coâng ñöùc, ngöôïc laïi giuùp           ngöôøi khaùc. Ñaïi Thöøa ñaõ ruùt ra keát luaän naøy, vöôït thoaùt khoûi luaân hoài sanh töû vaø daãn ñeán         vaø mong moûi tín ñoà caáp cho chuùng sanh khaùc quaû vò Phaät. Cuøng moät haønh ñoäng boá thí vôùi           coâng ñöùc cuûa rieâng mình, nhö kinh ñieån ñaõ taâm nieäm ñaït ñöôïc quaû baùo traàn tuïc thì mình          daïy: “Hoài höôùng hay trao taëng coâng ñöùc cuûa seõ ñöôïc phöôùc ñöùc; tuy nhieân, neáu mình boá thí         hoï cho söï giaùc ngoä cuûa moïi chuùng sanh.” vôùi quyeát taâm giaûm thieåu tham lam boûn xeûn,            “Qua coâng ñöùc cuûa moïi thieän phaùp cuûa toâi, toâi mình seõ ñöôïc coâng ñöùc—Virtue (which will                 mong öôùc xoa dòu noãi khoå ñau cuûa heát thaûy help transcend birth and death and lead to                   chuùng sanh, toâi ao öôùc laø thaày thuoác vaø keû Buddhahood). Merit is what one established                   nuoâi beänh chöøng naøo coøn coù beänh taät. Qua by benefitting others, while virtue is what one              nhöõng côn möa thöïc phaåm vaø ñoà uoáng, toâi ao

öôùc daäp taét ngoïn löûa cuûa ñoùi vaø khaùt. Toâi ao öôùc laø moät kho baùu voâ taän cho keû baàn cuøng,          Phöôùc ñöùc töùc laø coâng ñöùc beân ngoaøi, coøn moät toâi tôù cung caáp taát caû nhöõng gì hoï thieáu.       coâng ñöùc laø do coâng phu tu taäp beân trong maø Cuoäc soáng cuûa toâi, vaø taát caû moïi cuoäc taùi          coù. Coâng ñöùc do thieàn taäp, duø trong choác laùt sanh, taát caû moïi cuûa caûi, taát caû moïi coâng ñöùc      cuõng khoâng bao giôø maát. Coù ngöôøi cho raèng maø toâi thuû ñaéc hay seõ thuû ñaéc, taát caû nhöõng        ‘Neáu nhö vaäy toâi khoûi laøm nhöõng phöôùc ñöùc ñieàu ñoù toâi xin töø boû khoâng chuùt hy voïng lôïi        beân ngoaøi, toâi chæ moät beà tích tuï coâng phu tu loäc cho rieâng toâi, haàu söï giaûi thoaùt cuûa taát caû    taäp beân trong laø ñuû’. Nghó nhö vaäy laø hoaøn chuùng sanh coù theå thöïc hieän.”—Merit is the              toaøn sai. Ngöôøi Phaät töû chôn thuaàn phaûi tu taäp quality in us which ensures future benefits to               caû hai, vöøa tu phöôùc maø cuõng vöøa tu taäp coâng us, material of spiritual. It is not difficult to            ñöùc, cho tôùi khi naøo coâng ñöùc troøn ñaày vaø perceive that to desire merit, to hoard, store,              phöôùc ñöùc ñaày ñuû, môùi ñöôïc goïi laø ‘Löôõng and accumulate merit, does, however                          Tuùc Toân.’ Phöôùc ñöùc laø caùi maø chuùng ta laøm meritorious it may be, imply a considerable                  lôïi ích cho ngöôøi, trong khi coâng ñöùc laø caùi maø degree of self-seeking. It has always been the               chuùng ta tu taäp ñeå caûi thieän töï thaân nhö giaûm tactics of the Buddhists to weaken the                       thieåu tham saân si. Hai thöù phöôùc ñöùc vaø coâng possessive instincts of the spiritually less-                ñöùc phaûi ñöôïc tu taäp cuøng moät luùc. Hai töø naày endowed members of the community by                          thænh thoaûng ñöôïc duøng laãn loän. Tuy nhieân, coù withdrawing them from such objects as wealth                 söï khaùc bieät ñaùng keå. Phöôùc ñöùc bao goàm taøi and family, and directing them instead                       vaät cuûa coõi nhaân thieân, neân chæ taïm bôï vaø coøn towards one aim and object, i.e. the                         trong voøng luaân hoài sanh töû. Traùi laïi, coâng ñöùc acquisition of merit. But that, of course, is                sieâu vieät khoûi luaân hoài sanh töû ñeå daãn ñeán good enough only on a fairly low spiritual                   Phaät quaû. Cuøng moät haønh ñoäng coù theå daãn ñeán level. At higher stages one will have to turn                hoaëc phöôùc ñöùc, hoaëc coâng ñöùc. Neáu chuùng ta also against this form of possessiveness, one                boá thí vôùi yù ñònh ñöôïc phöôùc baùu nhaân thieân will have to be willing to give up one’s store               thì chuùng ta gaët ñöôïc phaàn phöôùc ñöùc, neáu of merit for the sake of the happiness of                    chuùng ta boá thí vôùi taâm yù giaûm thieåu tham saân others. The Mahayana drew this conclusion                    si thì chuùng ta ñaït ñöôïc phaàn coâng ñöùc—Merit and expected its followers to endow other                    is obtained from doing the Buddha work, beings with their own merit, or, as the                      while virtue gained from one’s own practice Scriptures put it, ‘to turn over, or dedicate,               and cultivation. If a person can sit stillness for their merit to the enlightenment of all beings.’             the briefest time, he creates merit and virtue “Through the merit derived from all my good                  which will never disappear. Someone may deeds I wish to appease the suffering of all                 say, ‘I will not create any more external merit creatures, to be the medicine, the physician,                and virtue; I am going to have only inner and the nurse of the sick as long as there is                merit and virtue.’ It is totally wrong to think sickness. Through rains of food and drink I                  that way. A sincere Buddhist should cultivate wish to extinguish the fire of hunger and                    both kinds of merit and virtue. When your thirst. I wish to be an exhaustible treasure to              merit and virtue are perfected and your the poor, a servant who furnishes them with                  blessings and wisdom are complete, you will all they lack. My life, and all my re-birth, all             be known as the ‘Doubly-Perfected Honored my possessions, all the merit that I have                    One.’ Merit is what one establishes by acquired or will acquire, all that I abandon                 benefitting others, while virtue is what one without hope of any gain for myself in order                 practices to improve oneself such as that the salvation of all beings might be                    decreasing greed, anger and ignorance. Both promoted.”                                                   merit and virtue should be cultivated side by (III) Söï khaùc bieät giöõa Phöôùc Ñöùc vaø Coâng Ñöùc —           side. These two terms are sometimes used The differences between Merit and Virtue:                    interchangeably. However, there is a crucial

difference. Merits are the blessings (wealth,              khoâng coù ñöùc, vì ngoâ ngaõ töï ñaïi thöôøng khinh intelligence, etc) of the human and celestial              taát caû. Naøy thieän tri thöùc, moãi nieäm khoâng coù realms; therefore, they are temporary and                  giaùn ñoaïn aáy laø coâng, taâm haønh ngay thaúng aáy subject to birth and death. Virtue, on the                 laø ñöùc; töï tu taùnh, aáy laø coâng, töï tu thaân aáy laø other hand, transcend birth and death and lead             ñöùc. Naøy thieän tri thöùc, coâng ñöùc phaûi laø nôi to Buddhahood. The same action of giving                   töï taùnh maø thaáy, khoâng phaûi do boá thí cuùng charity can lead to either Merit or Virtue. If             döôøng maø caàu ñöôïc. AÁy laø phöôùc ñöùc cuøng vôùi you give charity with the mind to obtain                   coâng ñöùc khaùc nhau. Voõ Ñeá khoâng bieát chaân mundane rewards, you will get Merit;                       lyù, khoâng phaûi Toå Sö ta coù loãi—The Patriarch however, if you give charity with the mind to              emphasized that all acts from king Liang-Wu- decrease greed, you will obtain virtue.                    Ti actually had no merit and virtue. Emperor (IV) Coâng Ñöùc theo quan nieäm cuûa Toå Boà Ñeà Ñaït           Wu of Liang’s mind was wrong; he did not Ma—“Merit and Virtue” according to                         know the right Dharma. Building temples and Bodhidharma Patriarch’s point of view: Vua                 giving sanction to the Sangha, practicing Löông Voõ Ñeá, Voõ Ñeá hoûi Boà Ñeà Ñaït Ma                giving and arranging vegetarian feasts is raèng: “Traåm moät ñôøi caát chuøa ñoä Taêng, boá thí      called ‘seeking blessings.’ Do not mistake thieát trai coù nhöõng coâng ñöùc gì?” Toå Ñaït Ma         blessings for merit and virtue. Merit and baûo: “Thaät khoâng coù coâng ñöùc.”—King Liang-           virtue are in the Dharma body, not in the Wu-Ti asked Bodhidharma: “All my life I                    cultivation of blessings.” The Master further have built temples, given sanction to the                  said, “Seeing your own nature is merit, and Sangha, practiced giving, and arranged                     equanimity is virtue. To be unobstructed in vegetarian feasts. What merit and virtue have              every thought, constantly seeing the true, real, I gained?” Bodhidharma said, “There was                    wonderful function of your original nature is actually no merit and virtue.”                             called merit and virtue. Inner humility is merit (V) Coâng Ñöùc theo söï giaûi thích cuûa Luïc Toå Hueä          and the outer practice of reverence is virtue. Naêng trong Kinh Phaùp Baûo Ñaøn—The Sixth                 Your self-nature establishing the ten thousand Patriarch Hui-Neng interpreted about “Merit                dharmas is merit and the mind-substance and Virtue” in the Dharma Jewel Platform                   separate from thought is virtue. Not being Sutra: Toå nhaán maïnh nhöõng vieäc laøm cuûa vua          separate from the self-nature is merit, and the Löông Voõ Ñeá thaät khoâng coù coâng ñöùc chi caû.         correct use of the undefiled self-nature is Voõ Ñeá taâm taø, khoâng bieát chaùnh phaùp, caát          virtue. If you seek the merit and virtue of the chuøa ñoä Taêng, boá thí thieát trai, ñoù goïi laø caàu    Dharma body, simply act according to these phöôùc, chôù khoâng theå ñem phöôùc ñoåi laøm              principles, for this is true merit and virtue. coâng ñöùc ñöôïc. Coâng ñöùc laø ôû trong phaùp            Those who cultivate merit in their thoughts, thaân, khoâng phaûi do tu phöôùc maø ñöôïc.” Toå laïi      do not slight others but always respect them. noùi: “Thaáy taùnh aáy laø coâng, bình ñaúng aáy laø       Those who slight others and do not cut off the ñöùc. Moãi nieäm khoâng ngöng treä, thöôøng thaáy          ‘me and mine’ are without merit. The vain baûn taùnh, chaân thaät dieäu duïng, goïi laø coâng        and unreal self-nature is without virtue, ñöùc. Trong taâm khieâm haï aáy laø coâng, beân            because of the ‘me and mine,’ because of the ngoaøi haønh leã pheùp aáy laø ñöùc. Töï taùnh döïng       greatness of the ‘self,’ and because of the laäp muoân phaùp laø coâng, taâm theå lìa nieäm aáy laø    constant slighting of others. Good Knowing ñöùc. Khoâng lìa töï taùnh aáy laø coâng, öùng duïng       Advisors, continuity of thought is merit; the khoâng nhieãm laø ñöùc. Neáu tìm coâng ñöùc phaùp          mind practicing equality and directness is thaân, chæ y nôi ñaây maø taïo, aáy laø chôn coâng         virtue. Self-cultivation of one’s nature is merit ñöùc. Neáu ngöôøi tu coâng ñöùc, taâm töùc khoâng coù      and self-cultivation of the body is virtue. khinh, maø thöôøng haønh khaép kænh. Taâm                  Good Knowing Advisors, merit and virtue thöôøng khinh ngöôøi, ngoâ ngaõ khoâng döùt töùc laø       should be seen within one’s own nature, not khoâng coâng, töï taùnh hö voïng khoâng thaät töùc töï     sought through giving and making offerings.

That is the difference between blessings and              dieän thöïc tieãn nöõa. Tröø phi chuùng ta thöïc hieän merit and virtue. Emperor Wu did not know                 ñöôïc ñieàu naøy, vieäc tu taäp coâng ñöùc bí maät trong the true principle. Our Patriarch was not in              Thieàn seõ chæ laø caùi gì ñoù noâng caïn vaø do ñoù chæ laø error.”                                                   giaû doái maø thoâi—Not to let your left hand know Coâng Ñöùc Baûo: Gunaratna (skt)—1) Kho baûo                    what your right hand does, this is known in the coâng ñöùc: Treasure of merits; 2) Teân cuûa moät vò sö         Zendo life as practicing "secret virtue." It is also ngöôøi AÁn: Name of an Indian monk.                             the spirit of service and one of the most important Coâng Ñöùc Baûo Keá Trí Sanh: Born of Wisdom                    methods of of cultivation in Zen. Secret virtue is and Adorned with Virtue.                                        the deed done for its own sake, not looking for any Coâng Ñöùc Baûo Sôn Thaàn Chuù: Meritorious                     form of compensation anywhere, neither in Virtue Jewelled Mountain Spirit Mantra.                         heaven nor on earth. The trouble of our social life Coâng Ñöùc Baùt Nhaõ Ba La Maät: Virtue of the                  is that we are always seeking for a reward, and prajna paramita—Nhöõng vò “Nhaäp löu,” “Nhaát                   more frequently for one enormously out of lai,” “Baát lai,” “ÖÙng cuùng,” vaân vaân, thöôøng ñaït         proportion to the merit of the deed itself. When ñöôïc Coâng ñöùc Baùt nhaõ Ba la maät baèng tu taäp             this is not forcoming, we are disatisfied, and this Thaäp thieän, Töù thieàn, Töù voâ saéc ñònh, vaø nguõ thaàn     dissatisfaction causes all sorts of trouble in our thoâng—Those who are “Stream-winner,” “Once-                    daily walk of life. Human life is not always return,” “Never-return,” and “Arhat,” and so on,                governed by economic principles: there is always attain realization of the virtue of the prajna           something more in it, and the peace and happiness paramita by practicing the ten cirtuous paths of                we all are seeking is attained only when this actions, the four states of meditation, the four                "something more" is understood. It is most immaterial states, and the five mystical powers.                unfortunate that our modern life is systematically Coâng Ñöùc Bí Maät: Secret virtue—Khoâng ñeå cho                moving away from this thought, in fact tay traùi bieát tay phaûi mình laøm gì, ñieàu naøy ñöôïc        deliberately trying to stifle the inner voice. bieát nhö laø "coâng ñöùc bí maät" trong ñôøi soáng thieàn      Buddhist masters, therefore, earnestly urge to ñöôøng. Ñaây cuõng laø tinh thaàn phuïc vuï vaø laø moät        make us grasp the doctrine of "Emptiness" not trong nhöõng phöông caùch tu taäp raát quan troïng              only philosophically but in the most practical way. trong Thieàn. Coâng ñöùc bí maät laø moät vieäc laøm vì         Unless this is done, the practice of secret virtue chính noù, chöù khoâng tìm baát cöù söï buø ñaép naøo töø       will be only something artificial and, therefore, baát cöù nôi ñaâu, khoâng töø treân trôøi maø cuõng khoâng      hypocritical. töø döôùi ñaát. Vaán ñeà cuûa ñôøi soáng xaõ hoäi cuûa chuùng   Coâng Ñöùc Chuû: Danapati (skt)—Ñaøn Vieät Baùt ta laø mình luoân tìm kieám phaàn thöôûng, vaø thöôøng          Ñeå—See Thí Chuû. laø phaàn thöôûng vôùi tyû leä quaù lôùn so vôùi coâng ñöùc     Coâng Ñöùc Du: Coâng ñöùc maø ngöôøi tu ñaït ñöôïc cuûa vieäc mình laøm. Khi khoâng ñöôïc nhö vaäy laø             trong luùc vöøa ñi vöøa nieäm, sau khi laøm xong nhieäm chuùng ta baát maõn, vaø söï baát maõn naøy taïo ra ñuû loaïi   vuï—Meritorious exercise, i.e. walking about phieàn naõo trong ñôøi soáng haèng ngaøy cuûa chuùng ta.        intoning after duty. Ñôøi soáng con ngöôøi khoâng phaûi luùc naøo cuõng ñöôïc        Coâng Ñöùc Ñieàn: Ruoäng phöôùc coâng ñöùc, nhö Tam ñieàu haønh bôûi nhöõng nguyeân taéc kinh teá: ñôøi soáng       Baûo, moät trong ba ruoäng phöôùc—The field of nhieàu hôn chæ coù nhö vaäy, vaø söï an bình haïnh phuùc        merit and virtue, i.e. the Triratna, to be cultivated maø chuùng ta ñang tìm kieám chæ coù theå ñaït ñöôïc khi        by the faithful; it is one of the three fields for naøo maø chuùng ta hieåu ñöôïc "moät vaøi thöù theâm            cultivating welfare—See Tam Phöôùc. nöõa" naøy. Heát söùc baát haïnh laø cuoäc soáng hieän ñaïi     Coâng Ñöùc Haûi: 1) Bieån coâng ñöùc: Ocean of merit cuûa chuùng ta ñang daàn lìa xa moät caùch coù heä thoáng       and virtue; 2) Teân cuûa moät vò sö ngöôøi AÁn: tö töôûng naøy, thaät ra, chuùng ta coøn coá gaéng boùp         Gunasaraga (skt)—Name of an Indian monk. ngheït tieáng noùi töø beân trong naøy. Do ñoù, maø nhöõng      Coâng Ñöùc Haønh: Puabhisankhara (p)— vò thaày Phaät giaùo tha thieát thuùc giuïc chuùng ta phaûi     Meritorious kamma formations. naém ñöôïc giaùo phaùp "Khoâng taùnh," chaúng nhöõng            Coâng Ñöùc Hieàn: Gunabhadra (skt)—See Caàu Na treân phöông dieän trieát lyù maø coøn phaûi treân phöông       Baït Ñaø La.

Coâng Ñöùc Hoa: Punyatara (skt)—See Phaát Nhaõ                  phöôùc, chôù khoâng theå ñem phöôùc ñoåi laøm coâng Ña La.                                                          ñöùc ñöôïc. Coâng ñöùc laø ôû trong phaùp thaân, khoâng Coâng Ñöùc Höõu Laäu: Tainted merits.                           phaûi do tu phöôùc maø ñöôïc.” Toå laïi noùi: “Thaáy taùnh Coâng Ñöùc Khaûi: Gunavarman (skt)—See Caàu Na                  aáy laø coâng, bình ñaúng aáy laø ñöùc. Moãi nieäm khoâng Baït Ma.                                                        ngöng treä, thöôøng thaáy baûn taùnh, chaân thaät dieäu Coâng Ñöùc Kinh: Pua-sutta (p)—Sutra To Punna.                  duïng, goïi laø coâng ñöùc. Trong taâm khieâm haï aáy laø Coâng Ñöùc Löïc: Löïc cuûa coâng ñöùc—Power of                  coâng, beân ngoaøi haønh leã pheùp aáy laø ñöùc. Töï taùnh merit.                                                          döïng laäp muoân phaùp laø coâng, taâm theå lìa nieäm aáy Coâng Ñöùc Phaùp Thaân: 1) Heát thaûy coâng ñöùc                laø ñöùc. Khoâng lìa töï taùnh aáy laø coâng, öùng duïng thaønh töïu: Sambhogakaya (skt)—The spiritual                   khoâng nhieãm laø ñöùc. Neáu tìm coâng ñöùc phaùp thaân, body of all virtuous achievement; 2) Thaân do                   chæ y nôi ñaây maø taïo, aáy laø chôn coâng ñöùc. Neáu muoân ñöùc cuûa Nhö Lai maø hôïp thaønh: The                    ngöôøi tu coâng ñöùc, taâm töùc khoâng coù khinh, maø dharmakaya evolved by Buddha-virtue, or                         thöôøng haønh khaép kænh. Taâm thöôøng khinh ngöôøi, achievement.                                                    ngoâ ngaõ khoâng döùt töùc laø khoâng coâng, töï taùnh hö Coâng Ñöùc Phöôùc Ñöùc: Virtue and Merit—Coâng                  voïng khoâng thaät töùc töï khoâng coù ñöùc, vì ngoâ ngaõ töï ñöùc laø thöïc haønh caùi gì thieän laønh nhö giaûm thieåu      ñaïi thöôøng khinh taát caû. Naøy thieän tri thöùc, moãi tham, saân, si. Coâng ñöùc laø haïnh töï caûi thieän mình,      nieäm khoâng coù giaùn ñoaïn aáy laø coâng, taâm haønh vöôït thoaùt khoûi voøng luaân hoài sanh töû ñeå ñi ñeán        ngay thaúng aáy laø ñöùc; töï tu taùnh, aáy laø coâng, töï tu Phaät quaû. Söùc maïnh laøm nhöõng vieäc coâng ñöùc,            thaân aáy laø ñöùc. Naøy thieän tri thöùc, coâng ñöùc phaûi laø giuùp vöôït qua bôø sanh töû vaø ñaït ñeán quaû vò Phaät.       nôi töï taùnh maø thaáy, khoâng phaûi do boá thí cuùng Phöôùc ñöùc ñöôïc thaønh laäp baèng caùch giuùp ñôû             döôøng maø caàu ñöôïc. AÁy laø phöôùc ñöùc cuøng vôùi ngöôøi khaùc, trong khi coâng ñöùc nhôø vaøo tu taäp ñeå        coâng ñöùc khaùc nhau. Voõ Ñeá khoâng bieát chaân lyù, töï caûi thieän mình vaø laøm giaûm thieåu nhöõng ham           khoâng phaûi Toå Sö ta coù loãi.”—Virtue is practicing muoán, giaän hôøn, si meâ. Caû phöôùc ñöùc vaø coâng ñöùc       what is good like decreasing greed, anger and phaûi ñöôïc tu taäp song haønh. Hai töø naày thænh              ignorance. Virtue is to improve oneself, which will thoaûng ñöôïc duøng laãn loän. Tuy nhieân, söï khaùc bieät      help transcend birth and death and lead to chính yeáu laø phöôùc ñöùc mang laïi haïnh phuùc, giaøu         Buddhahood. Merit is what one established by sang, thoâng thaùi, vaân vaân cuûa baäc trôøi ngöôøi, vì theá   benefitting others, while virtue is what one chuùng coù tính caùch taïm thôøi vaø vaãn coøn bò luaân hoài    practices to improve oneself such as decreasing sanh töû. Coâng ñöùc, ngöôïc laïi giuùp vöôït thoaùt khoûi      greed, anger, and ignorance. Both merit and virtue luaân hoài sanh töû vaø daãn ñeán quaû vò Phaät. Cuøng moät     should be cultivated side by side. These two terms haønh ñoäng boá thí vôùi taâm nieäm ñaït ñöôïc quaû baùo        are sometimes used interchangeably. However, traàn tuïc thì mình seõ ñöôïc phöôùc ñöùc; tuy nhieân,          there is a crucial difference. Merits are the neáu mình boá thí vôùi quyeát taâm giaûm thieåu tham            blessings (wealth, intelligence, etc) of the human lam boûn xeûn, mình seõ ñöôïc coâng ñöùc. Phöôùc ñöùc           and celestial realms; therefore, they are töùc laø coâng ñöùc beân ngoaøi, coøn coâng ñöùc laø do         temporary and subject to birth and death. Virtue, coâng phu tu taäp beân trong maø coù. Coâng ñöùc do             on the other hand, transcend birth and death and thieàn taäp, duø trong choác laùt cuõng khoâng bao giôø         lead to Buddhahood. The same action of giving maát. Coù ngöôøi cho raèng ‘Neáu nhö vaäy toâi khoûi laøm       charity with the mind to obtain mundane rewards, nhöõng phöôùc ñöùc beân ngoaøi, toâi chæ moät beà tích tuï      you will get merit; however, if you give charity coâng phu tu taäp beân trong laø ñuû’. Nghó nhö vaäy laø        with the mind to decrease greed and stingy, you hoaøn toaøn sai. Ngöôøi Phaät töû chôn thuaàn phaûi tu          will obtain virtue. Merit is obtained from doing the taäp caû hai, vöøa tu phöôùc maø cuõng vöøa tu taäp coâng       Buddha work, while virtue gained from one’s own ñöùc, cho tôùi khi naøo coâng ñöùc troøn ñaày vaø phöôùc        practice and cultivation. If a person can sit ñöùc ñaày ñuû, môùi ñöôïc goïi laø ‘Löôõng Tuùc Toân.'          stillness for the briefest time, he creates merit and Theo kinh Phaùp Baûo Ñaøn, phaåm thöù ba, Toå baûo Vi           virtue which will never disappear. Someone may Thöù Söû: “Voõ Ñeá taâm taø, khoâng bieát chaùnh phaùp,         say, ‘I will not create any more external merit and caát chuøa ñoä Taêng, boá thí thieát trai, ñoù goïi laø caàu    virtue; I am going to have only inner merit and

virtue.’ It is totally wrong to think that way. A       Coâng Ñöùc Söù Giaû: 1) Ñaëc söù giaùm saùt coâng ñöùc: sincere Buddhist should cultivate both kinds of         Envoy to the virtuous or officer supervising virtue; merit and virtue. When your merit and virtue are        2) Vò Giaùm Taêng ñöôïc trieàu ñình nhaø Ñöôøng boå perfected and your blessings and wisdom are             nhieäm ñeå kieåm soaùt Taêng Ni: Controller of monks complete, you will be known as the ‘Doubly-             and nuns appointed by the T’ang Court. Perfected Honored One.’ According to the                Coâng Ñöùc Taïng: Treasure of merit and virtue. Flatform Sutra, Chapter Three, the Master told          Coâng Ñöùc Thang: Nöôùc noùng ñöôïc chuaån bò trong Magistrate Wei, “Emperor Wu of Liang’s mind             buoåi leã taém Phaät—Hot water prepared in the was wrong; he did not know the right Dharma.            ceremony of bathing the Buddha. Building temples and giving sanction to the             Coâng Ñöùc Thaân Haønh Nieäm: Merits of the Sangha, practicing giving and arranging                 cultivation of the mindfulness of the body—Theo vegetarian feasts is called ‘seeking blessings.’ Do     Kinh Tu Taäp Thaân Haønh Nieäm trong Trung Boä, tu not mistake blessings for merit and virtue. Merit       taäp thaân haønh nieäm laø khi ñi bieát raèng mình ñang and virtue are in the Dharma body, not in the           ñi; khi ñöùng bieát raèng mình ñang ñöùng; khi naèm cultivation of blessings.” The Master further said,     bieát raèng mình ñang naèm; khi ngoài bieát raèng mình “Seeing your own nature is merit, and equanimity        ñang ngoài. Thaân theå ñöôïc xöû duïng theá naøo thì is virtue. To be unobstructed in every thought,         mình bieát thaân theå nhö theá aáy. Soáng khoâng phoùng constantly seeing the true, real, wonderful             daät, nhieät taâm, tinh caàn, caùc nieäm vaø caùc tö duy veà function of your original nature is called merit and    theá tuïc ñöôïc ñoaïn tröø. Nhôø ñoaïn tröø caùc phaùp aáy virtue. Inner humility is merit and the outer           maø noäi taâm ñöôïc an truù, an toïa, chuyeân nhaát vaø practice of reverence is virtue. Your self-nature       ñònh tónh. Nhö vaäy laø tu taäp thaân haønh nieäm — establishing the ten thousand dharmas is merit and      According to the Kayagatasati-Sutta in the Middle the mind-substance separate from thought is             Length Discourses of the Buddha, cultivation of virtue. Not being separate from the self-nature is      mindfulness of the body means when walking, a merit, and the correct use of the undefiled self-       person understands that he is walking; when nature is virtue. If you seek the merit and virtue of   standing, he understands that he is standing; when the Dharma body, simply act according to these          sitting, he understands that he is sitting; when principles, for this is true merit and virtue. Those    lying, he understands that he is lying. He who cultivate merit in their thoughts, do not slight    understands accordingly however his body is others but always respect them. Those who slight        disposed. As he abides thus diligent, ardent, and others and do not cut off the ‘me and mine’ are         resolute, his memories and intentions based on the without merit. The vain and unreal self-nature is       household life are abandoned. That is how a without virtue, because of the ‘me and mine,’           person develops mindfulness of the body. because of the greatness of the ‘self,’ and because     Coâng Ñöùc Thi Boà Taùt: Ganuda (skt)—Ganuda of the constant slighting of others. Good Knowing       Bodhisattva. Advisors, continuity of thought is merit; the mind      Coâng Ñöùc Thí: Giving for personal virtue—Boá thí practicing equality and directness is virtue. Self-     ñeå giuùp cho taâm ñöôïc trang nghieâm, taäp haïnh cultivation of one’s nature is merit and self-          buoâng xaû vaø doïn ñöôøng cho coâng cuoäc tu haønh giaûi cultivation of the body is virtue. Good Knowing         thoaùt. Ñaây laø moät trong taùm loaïi boá thí theo Caâu Advisors, merit and virtue should be seen within        Xaù Luaän—Giving for personal virtue or for the one’s own nature, not sought through giving and         adornment of the heart and life—See Baùt Chuûng making offerings. That is the difference between        Boá Thí. blessings and merit and virtue. Emperor Wu did          Coâng Ñöùc Thieân: See Ñaïi Caùt Töôøng Thieân. not know the true principle. Our Patriarch was not      Coâng Ñöùc Thieân Nöõ: Caùt Töôøng thieân nöõ— in error.”                                              Laksmi—Goddess of fortune. Coâng Ñöùc San Hoâ Thöôïng: Born of Radian of           Coâng Ñöùc Thieän Nöõ: Laøm cho ngöôøi ñöôïc cuûa caûi Virtues.                                                chaâu baùu—The deva “merit” or “achieving” Coâng Ñöùc Sôn Oai Löïc: Virtue Mountain Energy.        who causes people to acquire wealth.

Coâng Ñöùc Thuø Thaéng: Thöôïng thuû coâng ñöùc—            Coâng Ñöùc Tuøng Laâm: Thieàn vieän hay töï vieän hay Superior virtue or virtue of the prajna paramita.           thieàn phaùp—The grove of merit and virtue— Coâng Ñöùc Thuûy: Coâng ñöùc trì hay taùm hoà coâng         Buddhist hall or monastery, or the scriptures. ñöùc nôi coõi Cöïc Laïc—The water or eight lakes of         Coâng Ñöùc Töï Taïi Vöông Ñaïi Quang: Great meritorious deeds, or virtue in Paradise.                   Light of Sovereign Virtue. Coâng Ñöùc Tieán: Gunavrdhi (skt)—Caàu Na Tyø               Coâng Ñöùc Töôùng Nghieâm Boà Taùt: The Ñòa, teân cuûa moät vò sö ngöôøi AÁn—Name of an             Bodhisattva of Majestic Merits. Indian monk.                                                Coâng Ñöùc Uaån: Merit. Coâng Ñöùc Trang Nghieâm: Meritoriously                     Coâng Ñöùc Vaân Tyø Kheo: Megha-sri (skt)—Caùt adorned.                                                    Töôøng Vaân—Meâ Giaø Thaát Lôïi—Name of a monk. Coâng Ñöùc Trang Nghieâm Kinh: Teân taét cuûa kinh          Coâng Ñöùc Voâ Laäu: Taintless merits. Nhaát Thieát Phaùp Coâng Ñöùc Trang Nghieâm                 Coâng Ñöùc Voâ Löôïng: Immesurable merits. Vöông—Meritorious Adornment Sutra.                          Coâng Ñöùc Xuaát Theá: Virtue of liberation—Chæ Coâng Ñöùc Trí Tueä: Merits and wisdom—Theo                 nhöõng ngöôøi ñaõ ñaït tôùi Thaùnh quaû A-la-haùn hay kinh Duy Ma Caät, chöông moät, caùc vò Boà Taùt luoân       cao hôn môùi coù ñöôïc coâng ñöùc naày—Coâng ñöùc duøng coâng ñöùc trí tueä ñeå trau söûa taâm mình, baèng    xuaát theá gian vöøa giuùp töï thaân vöøa giuùp tha nhaân caùch laáy töôùng toát trang nghieâm thaân hình saéc        cuøng tieán tu—Possessed only by those already töôùng dung nhan baäc nhaát, vì theá boû haún taát caû      attained Arhats or higher—Such virtue enables trang söùc toát ñeïp trong ñôøi. Danh tieáng caùc ngaøi     cultivators to help themselves and help others. cao xa vöôït haún nuùi Tu Di. Loøng tin thaäm thaâm         Coâng Ñöùc Y: Kathina (skt)—Ca Hi Na—Coâng cuûa caùc ngaøi beàn chaéc khoâng bò phaù vôû nhö kim       ñöùc y hay aùo caø sa cuûa chö Taêng sau 90 ngaøy an cöông. Phaùp baûo cuûa caùc ngaøi soi khaép, vaø möa        cö kieát haï; bieåu töôïng cho coâng ñöùc maø chö Taêng cam loà tuoân ñoå nôi nôi. Tieáng thuyeát phaùp cuûa caùc   ñaõ ñaït ñöôïc trong muøa an cö—The garment of ngaøi laø thaäm thaâm vi dieäu baäc nhaát —According to     merits, given to monks after their summer retreat the Vimalakirti Sutra, Chapter One, Bodhisattvas            of ninety days; it symbolized merits to which they always cultivate their minds by means of merits             had attained. and wisdom, with which they embellished their               Coâng Ñöôøng: Public office. physical features which were unsurpassable, thus,           Coâng Gia Caùt Laït Tö: Ñaûm Ba (Vi Dieäu)—See giving up all earthly adornments. Their towering            Phoå Hyû Danh Vaên. reputation exceeded the height of Mount Sumeru.             Coâng Giôùi: 1) Nôi choán coâng coäng: A public place Their profound faith (in the uncreate) was                  in public; 2) Thieàn laâm vaø caùc töï vieän khaùc: Zen unbreakable like a diamond. Their treasures of              and other monasteries. the Dharma illuminated all lands and rained down            Coâng Haïnh: Arthakrtya (skt)—Haïnh tu laøm lôïi nectar.      Their speeches were profound and               laïc tha nhaân nhaèm ñöa hoï ñeán vôùi chaân lyù — unsurpassed.                                                Performance of conduct profitable to others in Coâng Ñöùc Trì: Eight excellent qualities of the            order to lead them toward the truth. water—See Baùt Coâng Ñöùc Thuûy.                            Coâng Haïnh Boá Thí Vieân Maõn: Perfection in Coâng Ñöùc Trò: Gunabharma (skt)—Teân cuûa moät             Giving. vò taêng phieân dòch kinh ñieån vaøo theá kyû thöù V—       Coâng Haïnh Chaân Thaät Vieân Maõn: Perfection in Name of an Indian monk who translated sutras in             Truthfulness. the fifth century.                                          Coâng Haïnh Nguyeän Löïc Vieân Maõn: Perfection Coâng Ñöùc Tu Haønh: Virtues achieved as a result           in Resolution. of cultivation.                                             Coâng Haïnh Nhaãn Nhuïc Vieân Maõn: Perfection in Coâng Ñöùc Tuï: 1) Hoäi tuï coâng ñöùc cuûa Phaät: The      Patience. assembly of all merit and virtue, i.e. the Buddha;          Coâng Haïnh Phi Coâng Haïnh Nieát Baøn: 2) Thaùp Phaät cuõng laø moät bieåu hieäu Coâng Ñöùc Tuï    Punyapunya (skt)—Nieát Baøn goàm söï daäp taét caû cuûa Ngaøi: A stupa is also considered as a symbol          coâng haïnh vaø phi coâng haïnh—Nirvana consists in of the Buddha’s assembly of all merit and virtue.

the extinction of both merit and demerit.                   after the good. Coâng Haïnh Taäp Khí: Taäp khí coâng haïnh—The              Coâng Lyù: Ajjava (p)—Justice. habit energy of enlightening practice.                      Coâng Minh Luaän: Silpasthana-Vidya-sastra— Coâng Haïnh Thanh Tònh: Coâng haïnh thanh tònh,             Luaän veà ngheä thuaät vaø khoa hoïc, moät trong naêm vì duøng haïnh Phoå Hieàn maø xuaát ly—Purity of            taùc phaåm veà kieán thöùc (ngheä thuaät, cô khí, nhò practices, riding the vehicle of Universal Good to          nguyeân lyù luaän, vaø tính toaùn thaùng naêm)—The emancipation.                                               sastra of arts and sciences, one of the five works Coâng Haïnh Tinh Taán Vieân Maõn: Perfection in             on knowledge (Arts, Mechanics, Dual philosophy, Energy.                                                     Calendaric calculation). Coâng Haïnh Trí Tueä Vieân Maõn: Perfection in              Coâng Naêng: Samartha (skt)—Achieving power— Wisdom.                                                     Ability—Power. Coâng Haïnh Trì Giôùi Vieân Maõn: Perfection in             Coâng Nghóa: Social duty. Morality.                                                   Coâng Nghieäm: Giaáy chöùng nhaän thoï giôùi— Coâng Haïnh Tu: The amount of practice or                   Certificate of Ordination. duration of cultivation.                                    Coâng Nhaän: To acknowledge—To recognize. Coâng Haïnh Töø Vieân Maõn: Perfection in Loving-           Coâng Phu: Searching and contriving—1) Söû duïng kindness.                                                   söùc löïc vaø thôøi gian trong tu taäp: Labor and time Coâng Haïnh Vieãn Ly Vieân Maõn: Perfection in              spent on cultivation; 2) Thôøi gian duïng coâng tu taäp Renunciation.                                               thieàn ñònh: Time (period of time) for meditation. Coâng Haïnh Xaû Vieân Maõn: Perfection in                   Coâng Phu Bieän Ñaïo: The Discourse on the Equanimity.                                                 Practice of the Way—See Bendoâwa. Coâng Huaân: Great merit.                                   Coâng Phu Chieàu: See Coâng Phu Toái. Coâng Huaân Bieân Söï: Tích luõy coâng ñöùc chæ ñöôïc       Coâng Phu Khuya: Morning prayer session. coi nhö laø phaùp phöông tieän trong nhaø thieàn bôûi vì    Coâng Phu Saùng: Morning service—Khoùa leã buoåi noù khoâng ñöa ñeán giaùc ngoä vaø vöôït thoaùt sanh        saùng trong chuøa—See Töù Thöôïng. töû—To accumulate great merit is only considered            Coâng Phu Thaønh Phieán: Khoâng ngöøng coâng phu expedient skill in means in Zen because it does             trong vieäc khaùn thoaïi ñaàu. Ñaây laø söï taäp trung tö not lead practitioner to attaining enlightenment            töôûng moät caùch quyeát lieät vaøo caâu hoûi moät chöõ coù and surpassing the cycle of birth and death.                khaû naêng chaúng nhöõng loaïi boû baát cöù caâu traû lôøi Coâng Hueä Löïc: Löïc cuûa coâng ñöùc vaø trí hueä—         naøo maø coøn khoâng cho pheùp caâu traû lôøi naøo caû — Powers of merits and wisdom.                                To incessantly watch over the head phrase. This is Coâng Höõu: Public property.                                an intense concentration on a question-word which Coâng Khoùa: Thôøi khoùa tu haønh trong töï vieän—          defies any answer and allows no answer at all. Sessions of meditation in a monastery.                      Coâng Phu Toái: Banka (jap)—Evening prayer Coâng Khuy Nhaát Quyõ: Thieáu moät tí coá gaéng maø         session—Buoåi coâng phu toái, moät trong ba thôøi coâng vieäc (giaùc ngoä) phaûi boû dôû —Just a little bit   coâng phu trong moät töï vieän Thieàn: saùng, tröa vaø short of effort, the task (enlightenment) is                toái. Thôøi coâng phu toái thöôøng ñöôïc cöû haønh trong unfinished.                                                 chaùnh ñieän tröôùc buoåi hoaøng hoân. Thôøi khoùa naøy Coâng Kyû Nhi: Nata (skt)—1) Kyû nöõ gioûi: A skilful       bao goàm vieäc ñoïc kinh vaø caàu nguyeän —Evening or wily dancer; 2) Taâm: The heart or mind; 3) Thaùi        service; one of the three periods of ritual chanting, töû Na Tra, con trai cuûa Tyø Sa Moân Thieân Vöông,         along with morning and midday services, held moät Quyû Vöông huøng traùng, ba maët, taùm tay: A          daily in a Zen monastery. The evening service is powerful demon king, said to be the eldest son of           held before dusk in the main hall. It includes the Vaisravana, and represented with three faces,               chanting of various sutras and other prayers. eight arms; 4) Moät trong nhöõng danh hieäu cuûa ñöùc       Coâng Phuû Chi AÙn Ñoäc: Koan—Official Phaät: Natha (skt)—One of the titles of the Buddha.         government law-text—See Coâng AÙn. Coâng Löïc: Achieving strength—earnest effort               Coâng Quaù Caùch: Cuoán soå ghi cheùp vieäc thieän aùc haèng ngaøy, ñeå nhôù maø xeùt laïi haønh vi cuûa mình vaø

laøm toát hôn—A notebook for recording all the             Coång Tam Quan: The three entrance gate. good and bad actions everyday, so that one can             Coäng: Together—Both—Same—In common. reflect on them to better oneself.                         Coäng Baùo: Collective retribution—Shared Coâng Quaû: Effect—Fruits—Meritorious deeds—               retribution—Loaïi quaû baùo maø töï tha chung trong Results.                                                   moät quoác ñoä hay coäng ñoàng ñeàu coù theå thoï duïng. Coâng Saûnh: Public buildings.                             Ñaây laø söï caûm öùng cuûa coäng nghieäp—Reward or Coâng Taøo: Moät chöùc quan ñôøi Haùn, troâng coi vieäc    punishment of the community or in common, for xeùt xöû, duï cho caên baûn voâ minh khôûi leân voâ soá    the deeds of the community or even of the phieàn naõo—A mandarin under the Han Dynasty               individual in their effects on the community. which is responsible for judging cases in court,           Coäng Baùt Nhaõ: 1) Nhöõng phaùp chung cho Thanh i.e., basic ignorance (innate ignorance) which             Vaên, Duyeân Giaùc vaø Boà Taùt. Baùt Nhaõ cuûa ba giai causes innumerable afflictions.                            ñoaïn Thanh vaên, Duyeân giaùc vaø Boà Taùt : The Coâng Taâm: Sense of justice.                              things for (in common with) Sravakas, pratyeka- Coâng Trung: Upright and loyal.                            buddhas and Bodhisattvas. Prajna of the three Coâng Vò: Ñòa vò sai khaùc trong giai ñoaïn tu haønh       stages of Sravaka and Pratyeka-buddha and the cuûa sô taâm nhö nhaãn nhuïc, traùnh kieän tuïng, nhieàu   imperfect bodhisattva sect; 2) Söï giaûi thích Baùt hyû laïc, haïnh phuùc taâm, thanh tònh taâm, thöông xoùt   Nhaõ chung cho ngöôøi sô cô cuõng nhö caùc baäc chuùng sanh, vaø khoâng thuø gheùt baát cöù chuùng sanh    thöôïng thöøa, ñoái laïi vôùi thaâm nghóa chæ daønh cho naøo—Different stages of cultivation for the the           caùc baäc Boà Taùt Ñaïi Thöøa: The interpretation of initial resolve or mind: forebearance, avoiding            the Prajnaparamita (Thoâng Giaùo) that advanced lawsuits (avoid disputing), having much joy,               and ordinary students have in common, as having much happiness in mind (happiness),                 contrasted with its deeper meaning (Bieät Giaùo), seeking permanent purity of the mind (purity of            only understood by the Mahayana Bodhisattvas; 3) heart), feeling pity for all sentient beings               Trí hueä chung: Shared wisdom. (compassion), and bearing no enemy toward                  Coäng Baát Ñònh: Sadharana (skt)—Moät trong saùu sentient beings (not getting angry).                       ñieàu baát ñònh trong Lyù Luaän (Luïc Baát Ñònh), töùc laø Coâng Vò Tieåu Tuyeät: Haønh giaû ñaõ tieán vaøo caûnh     sai laàm veà phaùp coù quan heä toaøn phaàn. Noùi raèng giôùi giaùc ngoä cao toät—Practitioners who reach the      “thanh” laø khoâng tröôøng cöûu, vì thanh laø moät saûn highest realm of enlightenment.                            phaåm; raèng “thanh” laø thöôøng haèng vì thanh ñoàng Coâng Vieäc Chöa Ñöôïc Saép Ñaët: Unsettled                phaåm vôùi hö khoâng. Thanh vöøa thöôøng laïi vöøa voâ projects or work.                                          thöôøng taïo neân “baát ñònh.”—Both indetermined, Coâng Vieäc Haèng Ngaøy Trong Töï Vieän: Daily             i.e. one of the six indeterminates in Logic, when a activities in a monastery—See Taêng Ni Thöôøng             thesis and its contradiction are both supported by Nhaät Söï.                                                 equally valid reasons, “that sound is not eternal, Coâng Xaûo Luaän: See Coâng Xaûo Minh and Nguõ             because it is a product, that it is eternal, because it Minh.                                                      is audible.” Coâng Xaûo Minh: Silapakamasthana-vidya (skt)—             Coäng Caûm: Kinh nghieäm hay caûm nghieäm Silapasthana-vidya (skt)—Moät trong Nguõ Minh,             chung—Shared experience. coøn goïi laø Coâng Nghieäp Minh—One of the five           Coäng Coâng Ñöùc: Coäng Phaùp—Ñoái laïi vôùi Baát departments of knowledge dealing with the arts             Coäng Phaùp. Caùc coâng ñöùc saún coù cuûa Ñöùc Phaät, coù and mathematics.                                           nhöõng coâng ñöùc maø caùc baäc Thaùnh giaû vaø caùc loaïi Coâng Xaûo Minh Luaän: Luaän veà Coâng Xaûo                chuùng sanh khaùc cuõng coù—The totality of truth or Minh—Commentary on the Learning of                         virtue, common to all sages, is found in the Technology.                                                Buddha. Coáng Cao: Elevated proud.                                 Coäng Ñoàng: Community. Coáng Du: Raiyu (jap)—Sö Coáng Du (1226-1304),             Coäng Ñoàng Taêng Giaø: Buddhist community— Phaät giaùo Nhaät Baûn—Name of a Japanese monk.            Taêng Giaø coù nghóa laø coäng ñoàng cuûa caùc vò Thaùnh Coång: Gate.                                               Phaät giaùo, nhöõng ngöôøi ñaõ nhaän thöùc ñöôïc giaùo

phaùp. Taêng Giaø cuõng nhaèm chæ coäng ñoàng chö               nghieäp naøo, maø hoaøn toaøn nhôø vaøo nhöõng nhu caàu Taêng Ni soáng theo giôùi luaät töï vieän; vaø theo nghóa       theá tuïc cuûa nhöõng ngöôøi taïi gia. Trong khi ñoù taïi roäng hôn, Taêng Giaø keå luoân caû nhöõng vò taïi gia hoã      nhieàu nôi nhö ôû Trung Hoa, Nhaät Baûn, Ñaïi Haøn, trôï cho chö Taêng Ni qua loøng töø thieän vaø nhaän            Taây Taïng vaø Vieät Nam, nôi maø truyeàn thoáng Phaät ñöôïc giaùo phaùp cuûa hoï truyeàn daïy. Söï saùng taïo         giaùo Ñaïi Thöøa chieám öu theá, moät soá töï vieän tích cuûa Taêng Giaø laø moät vaán ñeà roõ raøng, moät trong         luõy taøi saûn vaø trôû neân coù theá löïc veà chính trò—The nhöõng thaønh quaû lôùn lao nhaát cuûa Ñöùc Phaät. Noù ñaõ      Sangha means the noble community (ariya- toàn taïi qua söï bieán ñoåi vaø môû roäng cho ñeán ngaøy       sangha) of Buddhist saints who have realized the nay, ñem laïi cho, taïo cho moãi ngöôøi moät cô hoäi ñeå        teachings. Sangha also designates the community theo ñuoåi khoùa tu taäp ñeå daãn ñeán söï giaùc ngoä,          of monks and nuns who live according to the baèng caùch daâng hieán ñôøi mình cho cuoäc soáng               monastic code (vinaya); and in its broadest sense phaïm haïnh thieâng lieâng. Moät söï kieän theo ñuoåi           it includes the lay people who sustain the monks nhö theá theo quan ñieåm Phaät giaùo khoâng phaûi laø           and nuns through charity and receive their haønh ñoäng vò kyû, bôûi vì Taêng Giaø laø moät cô caáu         teaching. The creation of the Sangha is without giöõ gìn giaùo phaùp khi khoâng coù maët cuûa Ñöùc Phaät        question one of the Buddha’s most remarkable vì lôïi ích cho taát caû chuùng sanh. Töø nhöõng ngaøy xa       achievements.           It    has       survived      through xöa nhaát, Taêng Giaø ñaõ khoâng coù moät ngöôøi coù            diversification and expansion up to the present thaåm quyeàn toái cao, bôûi vì Ñöùc Phaät töø choái thaønh      day, offering an individual the chance to pursue laäp moät heä thoáng thöù baäc hoaëc chæ ñònh moät ngöôøi       the course of training leading to enlightenment, by keá vò. AÛnh höôûng laø chung cuûa taäp theå vaø ñòa vò         dedicating him or herself to the holy life. Such a cao hôn chæ ñöôïc baäc tröôûng laõo cho pheùp. Theo             pursuit would not be deemed a selfish act in Ñöùc Phaät, söï trung thaønh trieät ñeå vôùi giaùo phaùp        Buddhist eyes, because the Sangha, as an caàn phaûi döïa vaøo lyù trí caù nhaân vaø söï caûm nhaän,      institution, maintains the Dharma in the absence chöù khoâng thuaàn tuùy döïa vaøo söï truyeàn daïy. Taêng       of the Buddha for the welfare of all. From its Giaø ñoùng moät vai troø cöïc kyø quan troïng trong ñaïo        earliest days the Sangha has lacked a supreme Phaät nhö laø ngöôøi baûo veä vaø giöõ gìn giaùo phaùp.         authority, because the Buddha refused to Vaøo theá kyû thöù 1 tröôùc Taây lòch, giaùo hoäi Taêng Giaø    established a functional hierachy or name of nguyeân thuûy ñaõ coù söï phaân bieät giöõa caùc nhaø sö,       successor. Influence is collective and precedence moät soá vò cho raèng phaûi coù soá phaän tu taäp thieàn vaø    is allowed only by seniority. According to the nhöõng vò khaùc cam keát giöõ gìn kinh ñieån. Neàn taûng        Buddha, adherence to the Dharma should be cuûa Phaät giaùo, ít nhaát laø trong truyeàn thoáng nguyeân     based on personal reasoning and experience, not thuûy, haàu nhö luoân quan taâm ñeán vieäc baûo toàn            purely on instruction. The Sangha plays an giaùo phaùp do bôûi coäi nguoàn cuûa coäng ñoàng Taêng          extremely important role in Buddhism as the Giaø coù söï uûy thaùc hôn laø nhôø nhöõng cô caáu chaùnh       protector and maintainer of the Dharma. As early trò maïnh meû. Thaät vaäy, ñaây laø moät trong nhöõng neùt      as the first century B.C., the Theravadin Sangha ñaëc tröng caên baûn laøm cho Phaät giaùo trôû neân khaùc       distinguished between monks who assumed the bieät trong khi caùc toân giaùo khaùc tham gia tích cöïc        duty of meditating and those who were committed vaø chi phoái cuoäc soáng haèng ngaøy baèng nhöõng nghi         to preserving the scriptures. The core of thöùc vaø leã nghi. Ñoù khoâng phaûi laø tieâu chuaån daønh     “institutional” Buddhism, at least in the cho Phaät giaùo ñöôïc lieân keát vôùi moät nôi hoaëc moät       Theravadin tradition, has almost always been xaõ hoäi ñaëc bieät, chính vì vaäy Phaät giaùo coù theå soáng   preoccupied with preserving the Dharma through hoøa hôïp vôùi nhöõng ñöùc tin baûn xöù vaø caùc taäp quaùn     the lineage of a committed community rather than maø noù ñaõ töøng ñoái maët khi môû roäng öu theá, ñaëc         through political power structures. This is one of bieät nhöõng ñöùc tin vaø taäp quaùn ñoù thöôøng ñöôïc keát     the essential features that distinguishes Buddhism hôïp phong tuïc xaõ hoäi. Moái quan heä giöõa Taêng Giaø        from religions that actively participate in, and vaø giôùi taïi gia hoaøn toaøn khaùc bieät trong caùc           indeed, govern, the passage of life through rites truyeàn thoáng. caùc nhaø sö Theravada khoâng naém              and rituals. It is not the norm for Buddhism to be giöõ tieàn baïc hoaëc kieám soáng baèng baát cöù ngheà          linked to a specific place or society, which is why

it has generally been able to coexist harmoniously              two heads on one body, i.e. mind and perception with the indigenous beliefs and practices it has                differing, but the karma for both is just one. A bird encountered in its expansion, especially those that             of parttridge family; there is a fable about such a are traditionally associated with social customs.               bird having two heads; one called “garuda” and The relationship between the Sangha and the laity               the other “upagaruda.” One ate a delicious flower varies greatly among the different traditions. In               while the other was asleep; when the other general, monks do not handle money or make a                    awoke; it was so annoyed at not sharing it that it living from any profession, but rather rely                     ate a poisonous flower and the bird died; thus completely on the laity for worldly needs. In such              there is a Jekyll and Hyde in everyone. places as China, Japan, Korea, Tibet and Vietnam,               Coäng Nghieäp: Nghieäp chung—Shared karma. where Mahayana Buddhism is dominant, some                       Coäng Nieäm Xöù: Goác chung cuûa söï quaùn töôûng— monasteries have been known to accumulate great                 Shared base of mindfulness. wealth and political power.                                     Coäng Phaùp: Phaùp chung—Shared dharma—See Coäng Giaùo: See Coäng Baùt Nhaõ.                               Coäng Coâng Ñöùc. Coäng Höùa: Ñöôïc höùa khaû cho toaøn theå —What is             Coäng Phaùt Taâm Phaùp Luaân Boà Taùt: commonly admitted.                                              Sahacittopada-Dharmacakra (skt)—Name of a Coäng Höôûng: To enjoy together.                                Bodhisattva. Coäng Höõu: Common property.                                    Coäng Phaùt YÙ Chuyeån Luaân Boà Taùt: Saha- Coäng Höõu Phaùp: Chö phaùp (töù ñaïi ñòa, thuûy, hoûa,         cittopada-Dharmacakra Bodhisattva (skt)—Name phong) cuøng hieän höõu vaø cuøng laø taùc nhaân trong          of a Bodhisattva. moïi ñieàu kieän hay hoaøn caûnh—Co-existent, co-               Coäng Thaäp Ñòa: Möôøi “ñòa” chung cho caû ba thöøa operative things, conditions, or circumstances.                 Thanh Vaên, Duyeân Giaùc vaø Boà Taùt—The ten Coäng Hyû Sinh Ñònh: Sô Thieàn laø coõi hyû laïc xa lìa         stages which sravakas, pratyeka-buddhas, and caûnh gaây toäi taïo nghieäp vaø Nhò Thieàn laø coõi hyû laïc   bodhisattvas have in common. Tam ma ñòa—The first dhyana is the ground of joy                Coäng Toâng: Shared doctrine—Ñieàu maø moïi toâng of separation from production, and the second                   phaùi Phaät Giaùo ñeàu gioáng nhau hay ñeàu coù —That dhyana is the ground of joy of production of                    which all Buddhist schools have in common. samadhi—See Töù Thieàn Thieân (I) and (II).                     Coäng Tuïc Hoøa Quang: AÅn giaáu taøi naêng vaø hoøa Coäng Keát: Moái raøng buoäc chung—Shared bonds.                mình cuøng ngöôøi traàn tuïc—To hide one's talent Coäng Laïc Sinh Ñònh: Tam Thieàn Thieân laø coõi kyø            and to mix oneself with worldly people. laïc vaø ngöng baët moïi tö töôûng—The third dhyana             Coäng Töôùng: Samanyalakshana (skt). is the ground of wonderful bliss and cessation of               1) Ñaëc tính chung hay tính phoå quaùt hay nhöõng thought—See Töù Thieàn Thieân (III).                                 töôùng traïng chung cho taát caû caùc söï vaät höõu vi, Coäng Maïng Chi Ñieåu: See Coäng Meänh Ñieåu.                        nhö voâ thöôøng, khoå, khoâng, vaø voâ ngaõ, vaân Coäng Meänh Ñieåu: Jivajiva or Jivanjiva (skt)—                      vaân: Shared characteristics or marks that are Two-headed bird—Meänh Meänh Ñieåu—Sinh Sinh                          common to all things conditioned, such as Ñieåu—Loaøi chim moät thaân hai ñaàu, ví nhö taâm                    impermanence, suffering, emptiness, and thöùc khaùc nhau nhöng nghieäp baùo laïi gioáng nhau.                egolessness, etc. Kinh Nieát Baøn goïi laø Meänh Meänh Ñieåu. Kinh A              2) Töôùng chung hay toång theå, ñoái laïi vôùi töï Di Ñaø goïi laø Coäng Meänh Ñieåu. Tieáng Phaïn laø Kyø              töôùng: Totality—Generality—The whole—In Baø Kyø Baø, laø moät loaøi chim moät thaân hai ñaàu ôû nuùi         common, as contrasted with individuality, or Tuyeát AÁn Ñoä. Coù moät huyeàn thoaïi veà loaøi chim                component parts. naày nhö sau: Loaïi chim moät thaân hai ñaàu naày moät          Coäng Töôùng Hoaëc: Coäng Hoaëc—Ñoái laïi vôùi Töï con goïi laø Ca Laâu La, con kia laø Öu Ba Ca Laâu              Töôùng Hoaëc. Phieàn naõo khôûi leân töø caùch nhìn söï La. Moät con thì aên hoa thôm khi con kia ñang nguû;            vaät nhö moät toång theå maø khoâng xeùt ñeán quan heä khi thöùc giaác, bieát mình khoâng ñöôïc chia xeû hoa           töøng phaàn (caùi naày coù môùi coù coù caùi kia)— thôm, con kia töùc giaän beøn aên moät loaøi hoa ñoäc,          Delusion arising from observing things as a whole, keát quaû laø con chim bò cheát—A bird said to have             or apart from their relationships.

Coäng Tyû Löôïng: Luaän thöùc y cöù vaøo söï ñoàng yù        Buddhas: chung cuûa caû hai ngöôøi hoûi vaø ñaùp—Shared               1) Chö aùc maïc taùc: Khoâng laøm caùc vieäc aùc—Not agreement of the questioner and the one who                        to do any evil. replies.                                                     2) Chuùng thieän phuïng haønh: Sieâng laøm caùc haïnh Coäng Xaû Sinh Ñònh: Töù Thieàn Thieân laø coõi thanh              laønh—To cultivate good. tònh vaø xaû boû moïi tö töôûng (chæ coù xaû thuï maø        3) Töï tònh kyø yù: Giöõ cho taâm yù thanh saïch—To thoâi)—The fourth dhyana is the ground of purity                   purify one’s mind. and renunciation of thought—See Töù Thieàn Thieân            4) Thò chö Phaät Giaùo: AÁy lôøi chö Phaät daïy—This (IV).                                                              is the Teaching of the Buddhas. Coäng Y: Goác chung—Shared base.                             Coát Loõi Thieàn: Essence of Zen—Theo Thieàn sö Coát: Kotsu (jap)—Bones—Relics—Trong thuaät                  Ritangen: “Tröôùc khi toâi thöïc haønh thieàn, toâi thaáy ngöõ thieàn cuûa Phaät giaùo Nhaät Baûn, "coát" hay          nuùi laø nuùi, soâng laø soâng. Khi toâi haønh thieàn thì nuùi "xöông" coù nghóa laø chieác gaäy daøi khoaûng 35 phaân      khoâng coøn laø nuùi, soâng khoâng coøn laø soâng. Nhöng maø moät Thieàn sö nhaän ñöôïc töø vò thaày cuûa mình        baây giôø toâi ñaõ hieåu coát loõi cuûa thieàn, thì toâi laïi nhö daáu hieäu ñaït tôùi trình ñoä cuûa moät baäc thaày.     thaáy nuùi laø nuùi vaø soâng laø soâng.”—According to Chieác gaäy naøy coù hình hôi cong theo hình chöõ S,         Zen Master Ritangen: “Before I practiced Zen, I nhö coät xöông soáng cuûa ngöôøi ta. Vò thaày duøng          saw mountains as mountains, rivers as rivers. chieác gaäy naøy ñeå chæ cho ñeä töû caùi gì ñoù, ñeå töïa   When I practiced Zen, mountains were no longer vaøo maø ngoài hay coù khi ñeå ñaùnh hoïc troø —A            mountains, and the rivers no longer rivers. But Japanese Zen term, “bones” literally means “Ju-              now I have grasped the essence of Zen, I again i,” the scepter, about 35 centimeters long, of a Zen         see mountains as mountains, and rivers as rivers.” master, which is bestowed on him by his master as            Coát Luaân: Hoàn Loân—Hoãn Luaân—Traïng thaùi hoån a sign of his mastership. The scepter has a slight           ñoän—Confused state—Chaotic state. S-shaped curve, like a human spinal cord. The                Coát Muïc: Xöông vaø maét, yù noùi nhöõng ñieàu coát master used this scepter to point at something, or           yeáu quan troïng nhöùt—The bones and eyes (the to lean on when sitting, or also occasionally to             essentials). strike a student.                                            Coát Nhaân: Boä xöông (toïa thieàn quaùn saùt veà boä Coát Buùt: Buùt baèng xöông—Pens made of bones.              xöông khoâ ñeå tröø boû tham duïc)—A skeleton—To Coát Caùch: Character—Manner.                                contemplate a skeleton to eliminate passions. Coát Döông: Gom thaâu xöông vaø xaù lôïi sau khi             Coát Nhuïc: Bone and flesh (sibling)—Of the same hoûa taùng—To collect the bones or relics after              parents. cremation.                                                   Coát Nhuïc Töông Taøn: Inter-familial quarrel— Coát Ñeå Coát Ñoång: See Coát Ñoång.                         Quarrel between brothers. Coát Ñoång: Ngöôøi coù ñaàu oùc baûo thuû—A person           Coát Phaät: 1) Phaät baèng xöông: A bone-Buddha; 2) with a conservative mind—To stick to one's                   Coù Phaät tính: To have the Buddha-nature. conservative opinion.                                        Coát Sôn: Nuùi xöông—A mountain of bones. Coát Hoà: Bình ñöïng xaù lôïi—A container (vase) of          Coát Thaùp: Thaùp chöùa coát—A pagoda for the relics.                                                      ashes of the dead. Coát Loõi: Core.                                             Coát Thaân: Xaù lôïi hay nhöõng gì coøn laïi sau khi hoûa Coát Loõi Kinh Kim Cang: Baát öng truï saéc, thinh,          thieâu—The bones of the body, the sarira or remain höông, vò, xuùc, phaùp sanh taâm; öng voâ sôû truï nhi       after cremation. sanh kyø taâm—Do not attach to forms, sounds,                Coát      Toûa      Chuû:      Samkarasvamin          (skt)— scents, tastes, textures, and mental objects or              Sankarasvamin (p)—Teân cuûa moät vò ñeä töû cuûa dharma to develop your thoughts; It is said that the         ngaøi Traàn Na—Name of a disciple of Dinnaga. emptiness is the wonderful place that mind will be           Coát Toûa Chuû Boà Taùt: Sankarasvamin (p)— arisen.                                                      Samkarasvamin (skt)—Thöông Yeát La Chuû— Coát Loõi Phaät Phaùp: Giaùo phaùp coát tuûy cuûa Ñaïo       Name of a disciple of Dinnaga—Teân cuûa moät vò Phaät—The core (essence) of the Teaching of                  ñeä töû cuûa ngaøi Traàn Na.

Coát Toûa Thieân: Samkara (skt)—Sankara (p)—                Cô Cô: Baûn tính hay caên tính cuûa baäc thaày vaø Thöông Yeát La—Coát Toûa Thieân laø hoùa thaân cuûa         ngöôøi ñeä töû thaàm kheá hôïp nhau—Master's natural Töï Taïi Thieân—The bone-chain deva.                        or fundamental quality and disciple's original Coát Tuûy Boà Taùt Ñaïo: Essence of                         endowment and nature are silently suitable with Bodhisattvaship—Coát tuûy cuûa Boà Taùt ñaïo—               each other. Khoâng aên thòt vì coát tuûy cuûa Boà Taùt ñaïo laø loøng   Cô Cô Ñaàu Hôïp: See Cô Cô. ñaïi bi, vì neáu khoâng coù loøng ñaïi bi thì Boà Taùt      Cô Cô Töông Phoù: See Cô Cô. khoâng coøn laø Boà Taùt nöõa—A Bodhisattva must            Cô Cô Töông ÖÙng: See Cô Cô. have a great compassionate heart, if eating meat a          Cô Duïng: Phöông phaùp sieâu vieät ngoân ngöõ vaên Bodhisattva looses his being.                               töï. Caùc thieàn sö thöôøng ñaùnh baèng gaäy hay ñöa ra Coát Töôûng: Quaùn xaùc chæ coøn laïi xöông traéng          moät tieáng heùt thaät to nhaèm giuùp ñoà ñeä tieán saâu hôn (asthis (skt). Töôûng naéng chan möa goäi, thaây nay        vaøo caûnh giôùi thieàn—Methods surpass words and chæ coøn trô laïi moät boä xöông traéng, moät trong cöûu    speeches. Zen masters usually strike with a staff töôûng quaùn nhaèm giuùp haønh giaû thoaùt ly chaáp         or give an extremely loud cry to help disciples to tröôùc veà thaân—To contemplate on left-over white          advance deeper into the realm of Zen. bones, one of the nine types of meditation on               Cô Duyeân: 1) Caên Cô vaø Nhaân Duyeân: corpse which helps free us from attachment to the           Potentiality and conditions; 2) Do haønh ñoäng thieän human body—See Cöûu Töôûng Quaùn.                           laønh hay cô vi thieän maø coù nhaân duyeân thuï nhaän Cô: 1) Ñoùi: Hungry, famine; 2) Cheâ traùch:                ñöôïc Phaät phaùp: Favourable circumstances or Ridicule (see Baùt Phong).                                  opportunities. Cô Baûn: Base—Foundation—Fundamental—                       Cô Duyeân Ñoán Ngoä: Potentiality and conditions Groundwork—Principle—Radical—Root or germ.                  and instantly to apprehend, or attain to Buddha- Cô Baûn Chuû Nghóa: Chuû nghóa cô baûn, ñoái laïi vôùi      enlightenment—Cô duyeân cho moät vò thieàn sö thuyeát duy taân hay ñoåi môùi—Fundamentalism, in           giuùp ñeä töû cuûa mình ñoán ngoä. Theo thieàn sö D.T. contrast with the modernism.                                Suzuki trong Thieàn Luaän, Taäp I, chuùng ta phaûi Cô Baàn: Poverty.                                           nhaän raèng trong Thieàn coù caùi gì thaùch ñoá taát caû söï Cô Bieán: Cô phong bieán hoùa hay tính caùch saéc           giaûi thích; caùi gì aáy, khoâng moät thieàn sö naøo, daàu beùn bieán hoùa tuøy thôøi tuøy luùc cuûa moät vò thieàn    thieän xaûo theá maáy, coù theå duøng trí oùc phaän taùch sö—Flexible and sharp characters of a Zen                   maø ñoä ñöôïc con ngöôøi. Höông Nghieâm ñoù, vaø Ñöùc master.                                                     Sôn nöõa, hoïc ñuû taát caû kinh ñieån, nghe ñuû taát caû lôøi Cô Bình: Pheâ bình hay kieåm duyeät—Censure—                giaûng cuûa caùc thaày; nhöng khi hoûi veà caùi thöïc töï Criticize.                                                  chöùng nghieäm laáy thì muø mòt khoâng bieát noùi gì khaû Cô Caûm: Chuùng sanh coù cô caên thieän maø caûm öùng       dó ñeïp yù mình, huoáng laø caàu ñöôïc thaày aán chöùng. vôùi Phaät hay vì chuùng sanh coù nhöõng haønh ñoäng        Ngoä laø moät söï kieän ñaày yù nghóa, vì ngoä, roát cuøng, thieän laønh neân ñöôïc Phaät caûm öùng—Potentiality        khoâng phaûi laø caùi coù theå hieåu baèng trí thöùc. Nhöng and response—The potentiality of all to respond             moät khi naém ñöôïc chieác chìa khoùa roài thì taát caû to the Buddha. The response of the Buddha to the            nhö phôi traàn ra heát; toaøn theå vuõ truï hieän ra döôùi good in all the living.                                     moät saéc thaùi môùi laï khaùc thöôøng. Chæ ngöôøi naøo Cô Caên: 1) Baûn tính hay caên tính cuûa chuùng sanh:       bieát môùi nhaän ra söï thay ñoåi beân trong aáy. Coù khi Natural or fundamental quality, original                    cô duyeân thaät laø voâ nghóa nhaát ñôøi, nhöng haäu quaû endowment and nature; 2) Khaû Naêng Thích ÖÙng:             ñoái vôùi taâm trí thaät laø voâ cuøng taän, vöôït ngoaøi taát Suitability, capacity.                                      caû nhöõng ñieàu mong öôùc. Ñuùng laø moät ñoùm löûa Cô Caån Tai: Naïn ñoùi (theo thuyeát nhaø Phaät ñaây laø    chaâm vaøo moät ngoøi noå vaø cuoäc ñòa chaán boäc phaùt moät trong ba tai naïn nhoû hay tieåu tam tai, xaõy ra      leân taän ñaùy cuûa ñòa caàu. Thaät vaäy, taát caû nguyeân döôùi thôøi trung kieáp, hai naïn kia laø naïn binh ñao     nhaân giaùc ngoä ñeàu naèm ôû taâm. Cho neân heã coù caùi vaø naïn beänh dòch)—The calamity of famine to end          aán tay laø taát caû nhöõng gì tieàm aån ôû taâm ñeàu vuøng the world.                                                  daäy heát, boác chaùy nhö nuùi löûa, hoaëc nhaùng leân nhö Cô Caáu: Structure.                                         tia chôùp. Thieàn goïi ñoù laø 'Quay ñaàu trôû veà nhaø',

ñuùng nhö caùc haønh giaû tu thieàn thöôøng noùi: "Ñoù laø       in the mind. That is why when the clock clicks, all gaëp laïi chính mình. Töø ñôøi thuôû naøo khoâng coù gì          that has been lying there bursts up like a volcanic ñaùnh maát ôû mình heát. Chính taïi mình nhaém maét              eruption or flashes out like a bolt of lightning. Zen laøm ngô tröôùc caùi thöïc maø thoâi." Ñaïo Khieâm tröôùc        calls this 'returning to one's own home', for its ngaøy ñi haønh cöôùc vaø Ñaïo Khieâm sau ngaøy chöùng            practitioners will declare: "You have now found ngoä, beân ngoaøi vaãn laø moät; chæ coù thieàn sö Ñaïi          yourself; from the very beginning nothing has Hueä vöøa thaáy laø bieát ngay cô huyeàn dieäu dieãn ra          been kept away from you. It was yourself that trong oâng, khoûi caàn oâng thöa gôûi gì heát. Maõ Toå           closed the eye to the fact." The Tao-Ch’ien vaën muõi Baùch Tröôïng, vaø Baùch Tröôïng bieán ñoåi            (Doken) before he started on his mission and the lieàn thaønh moät baûn laõnh uy duõng ñeán noãi daùm caû         Tao-Ch’ien after the realization were apparently gan cuoán chieáu deïp laïi khi thaày oâng saép thöôïng           the same person; but as soon as Ta-Hui (Daiye) ñöôøng noùi phaùp. Caùi thöïc nghieäm caùc ngaøi vöøa            saw him he knew what had taken place in him, chöùng qua khoâng phaûi laø thöù kheùo luyeän gioûi taäp,        even when he uttered not a word. Ma Tsu (Baso) coù theå minh giaûi ñöôïc baèng tri thöùc, neân khoâng vò        twisted Huang-po's (Hyakujo) nose, and the latter naøo coù yù ñònh trình baøy noù baèng moät loaït baøi giaûng     turned into such a wild soul as to have the thoâng thaùi; caùc ngaøi chæ laøm moät haønh vi naøo ñoù,        audacity to roll up the matting before his master's noùi leân moät caâu noùi naøo ñoù, ñieân ñaûo ñoái vôùi ngöôøi   discourse had hardly begun. The experience they ngoaøi cuoäc, vaø nhö theá laø xong heát, thaày cuõng nhö        have gone through within themselves is not a very troø ñeàu haøi loøng nhö nhau. Ngoä khoâng theå laø moät         elaborate,     complicated,       and      intellectually aûo aûnh troáng roãng khoâng chöùa ñöïng gì heát, khoâng         demonstrable thing; for none of them ever try to chaân giaù trò naøo heát; traùi laïi, ñoù phaûi laø moät kinh    expound it by a series of learned discourses; they nghieäm ñôn giaûn khoâng gì hôn, vì ñoù laø kinh                 do just this thing or that, or utter a single phrase nghieäm caên baûn cuûa taát caû kinh nghieäm —                   unintelligible to outsiders, and the whole affair Favourable circumstances or opportunities for a                  proves most satisfactory both to the master and to Zen master to help his disciples come up with a                  the disciple. The enlightenment (satori) cannot be sudden enlightenment. According to Zen master                    a phantasm, empty and contentless, and lacking in D.T. Suzuki in Essays in Zen Buddhism, First                     real value, while it must be the simplest possible Series (243), there is something, we must admit, in              experience perhaps because it is the very Zen that defies explanation, and to which no Zen                 foundation of all experiences. master however ingenious can lead his disciples                  Cô Giaùo: 1) Caên cô cuûa chuùng sanh vaø giaùo lyù cuûa through intellectual analysis. Hsiang-Yen-Zhi-                   Ñöùc Phaät: Potentiality and the Buddha’s teaching; Hsien (Kyogen) or Te-shan (Tokusan) had enough                   2) Tuøy caên cô cuûa chuùng sanh maø daïy baûo khaùc knowledge of the canonical teachings or of the                   nhau: Opportune teaching suited to the occasion. master's expository discourses; but when the real                Cô Giaùo Töông Öng: Giaùo phaùp cuûa Ñöùc Phaät vaø thing was demanded of them they significantly                    caên cô cuûa chuùng sanh kheá hôïp vôùi nhau—The failed to produce it either to their inner                       Buddha’s teachings are suitable with sentient satisfaction or for the master's approval. The satori            beings' capacities. (enlightenment), after all, is not a thing to be                 Cô Haøn Thieát Thaân, Baát Coá Lieâm Sæ: Hunger gained through the understanding. But once the                   and cold work against the sense of decency—Ñoùi key is within one's grasp, everything seems to be                laïnh laøm cho ngöôøi ta queân caû lieâm sæ—When cold laid bare before him; the entire world assumes                   and hunger come upon men, honesty and shame then a different aspect. By those who know, this                 depart. inner change is recognized. Sometimes a most                     Cô Hieàm: Cheâ bai vieäc laøm cuûa ngöôøi— insignificant happening, and yet its effect on the               Contempt. mind infinitely surpasses all that one could expect              Cô Hoäi Nguyeân Nhaân: Occasional cause. of it. A light touch of an ignited wire, and an                  Cô Hoäi Quyù Baùu: Precious opportunity—Chuùng explosion shaking the very foundation of the                     sanh con ngöôøi coù cô hoäi quyù baùu thöïc haønh Phaät earth. In fact, all the causes of enlightenment are              phaùp, haàu chaám döùt nhöõng yù töôûng tieâu cöïc töø ñoù

khôûi leân quaû khoå—Human beings have the                        when you are hungry and to sleep when you are precious opportunity to practice Dharma to stop                   tired. As soon as you wake from sleep, alert your negative thoughts from arising and to prevent                     mind and ask yourself, Who is the Master of this resultant suffering.                                              awakening, and where does he rest his body and Cô Kieán: 1) Caùi thaáy theo caên cô cuûa töøng chuùng            lead his life?' I them made up my mind that I sanh: Vision according to natural capacity; 2) Tuøy               would understand this thing in one way or another theo caên taùnh maø thaáy Phaät: Seeing the Buddha                even though it meant that I should appear to be an according to natural endowment.                                   idiot for the rest of my life. Five years passed. Cô Lai Khieát Phaïn, Khoán Lai Ñaû Mieân: Ñoùi thì                One day, when I was questioning this matter while aên, meät thì nguû—To eat when we are hungry and                  sleeping, my brother monk who slept beside me in to sleep when we are tired—Trong Cao Phong Töï                    the dormitory pushed his pillow so that it fell with Truyeän, Thieàn sö Cao Phong vieát: "Khoaûng naêm                 a heavy thud to the floor. At that moment my 1255, toâi ñeán gaëp ngaøi Tuyeát Nham, thaày hoûi,               doubts were suddenly broken up. I felt as if I had 'Ngay giöõa ban ngaøy raønh raønh oâng laøm chuû ñöôïc            jumped out of a trap. It turned out to be all the mình khoâng?' Toâi ñaùp, 'Ñöôïc.' Tuyeát Nham laïi hoûi,          puzzling koans of the Masters and the Buddhas 'Trong khi nguû naèm moäng, coù laøm chuû ñöôïc mình              and all the different issues and events of both khoâng?' Toâi ñaùp, 'Ñöôïc.' Thaày laïi hoûi, 'Ngay luùc          present and ancient times became transparently nguû khoâng moäng, thì oâng chuû ôû choã naøo?' Nghe              clear to me. Henceforth all things were settled; caâu hoûi ñoù toâi khoâng coù lôøi naøo ñaùp ñöôïc, khoâng        nothing under the sun remained but peace." coù lyù leõ naøo ñeå trình baøy. Thaày daën doø: 'Töø nay toâi    Cô Luaân: Baùnh xe taâm—Wheel of mental khoâng caàn oâng hoïc Phaät, hoïc Phaùp, thaáu trieät coå         activities. kim, chæ caàn oâng ñoùi thì aên, meät thì nguû. Ngay khi          Cô Naêng (1618-?): Zen master Chi-neng—Teân vöøa nguû daäy, phaán chaán tinh thaàn töï hoûi, khi ta           cuûa moät vò Thieàn sö Trung Hoa doøng Laâm Teá vaøo thöùc daäy, chuû nhaân roát cuoäc an thaân laäp meänh ôû          thôøi nhaø Minh—Name of a Chinese Zen master, choã naøo?' Toâi nguyeän nhaát ñònh phaûi minh baïch              of the Lin-chi lineage, in the Ming dynasty (1368- cho baèng ñöôïc söï vieäc naøy daàu coù phaûi boû caû ñôøi        1644). coù veû nhö laø keû ngu si ngôù ngaån. Naêm naêm troâi            Cô Ngaï Ñòa Nguïc: Ñòa nguïc ñoùi, moät trong 16 ñòa qua, moät hoâm ñang nguû thöùc giaác, chính vì vaãn               nguïc—The hell of hunger, one of the sixteen ñang hoaøi nghi veà vieäc aáy, boãng vò ñaïo höõu nguû            hells. chung phoøng laøm rôi caùi goái xuoáng ñaát gaây neân             Cô Nghi: Opportune and suitable—Natural tieáng ñoäng, luùc aáy töï nhieân toâi thaáu trieät ñöôïc khoái   qualification for receiving the truth. nghi nhö môùi vöøa thoaùt ra khoûi löôùi baãy. Thì ra taát        Cô Nghieäp: Fortune. caû nhöõng coâng aùn bí hieåm cuûa Phaät, cuûa Toå; caùc          Cô Ngöõ: Tuøy theo cô duyeân maø thuyeát phaùp— nhaân duyeân sai bieät coå kim, chaúng coù gì maø khoâng          Opportune words—Fundamental words. hieåu roõ. Töø ñaây nhaø yeân nöôùc ñònh, thieân haï thaùi        Cô Nhö (1632-?): Zen master Chi-Ru—Teân cuûa bình. Nhaát nieäm voâ vi, thaäp phöông toïa ñoaïn."—In            moät vò Thieàn sö Trung Hoa doøng Laâm Teá vaøo thôøi Kao Feng's autobiography, Zen Master Kao Feng                     nhaø Minh—Name of a Chinese Zen master, of the wrote: "Around 1253, I was asked by Zen Master                    Lin-chi lineage, in the Ming dynasty (1368-1644). Hsueh Yen, 'Can you master yourself in the                        Cô Phaùp: Caùch thöùc khaùm phaù vaø chuyeån hoùa caên daytime?' I answered, 'Yes, I can.' The Zen                       cô ngöôøi hoïc cuûa moät baäc thaày giaùc ngoä —An Master asked again, 'Can you master yourself                      enlightened master's methods of discovering and when dreaming?' Again my answer was, 'Yes, I                      transforming disciples in accordance with their can.' The Zen Master asked again, 'Where, in                      capabilities. dreamless sleep, is the Master?' To this question I               Cô Phaùp Nhaát Theå: Theo Tònh Ñoä Chaân Toâng had no answer or explanation. Master Hsueh Yen                    Nhaät Baûn, giaùo phaùp vaø caên cô vôùi loøng tin laø said to me, 'From now on I do not want you to                     ñoàng moät theå—According to the True Pure Land study Buddhism or learn the Dharma, nor to study                  Sect (Jodo Shinshu (jap), sentient beings' anything, either old or new. I just want you to eat               capacities with faith and the teachings of the

school are in nature the same (of one nature).                    profoundly aspects of Zen. This proves that the Cô Phong: Chi-feng (chi)—Thuaät ngöõ "Cô phong"                   Zen question and answer are sharp and pointed, raát khoù dòch sang baát cöù ngoân ngöõ naøo, vì trong            like the tips of two keen weapons point to point. nhaø Thieàn Trung Hoa, noù coù raát nhieàu yù nghóa vi            "Chi-feng", therefore, implies that the Zen dieäu thaâm aùo cuûa thieàn. Theo nghóa ñen, "cô" coù             question is like a sharp, needle-pointed rapier nghóa laø coát yeáu, troïng yeáu hay then choát, vaân             constantly threatening to pierce to the heart vaân; coøn "phong" laø ñaàu nhoïn cuûa moät loaïi vuõ khí         without mercy; and that as soon as a poignant saéc beùn. Theá neân "Cô phong" nghóa ñen laø "ñaàu               question is thrust at one, one must parry it and nhoïn coát yeáu" hay "ñieåm nhoïn coát yeát." Nhöng               instantly return an answer just as pointed. When a Thieàn duøng töø naøy nhö nhöõng khía caïnh vi dieäu vaø          Zen question is asked, there is no time for thaâm aùo cuûa noù. Ñieàu naøy chöùng toû nhöõng vaán ñaùp        thinking, ratiocination or seeking. Any answer that trong Thieàn thì beùn nhoïn, nhö ñaàu nhoïn cuûa hai vuõ          is not directly, immediately, instantaneously, khí chaïm vaøo nhau. Do ñoù "Cô phong" haøm yù raèng              spontaneously, and effortlessly given is not caâu hoûi cuûa Thieàn gioáng nhö moät tröôøng kieám beùn          acceptable to Zen. Therefore, as Zen questions nhoïn chæ chöïc chôø ñaâm thuûng vaøo taän tim khoâng             are often unanswerable and baffling, when the heà thöông haïi, vaø raèng ngay khi moät caâu hoûi ñau            student fails to reply immediately because he is ñieáng aäp ñeán vôùi chuùng ta, chuùng ta phaûi traùnh neù        trying to find the "right" answer by means of vaø laäp töùc ñöa ra moät caâu traû lôøi cuõng beùn nhoïn         logical reasoning, this time-lag immediately nhö vaäy. Khi moät caâu hoûi Thieàn ñöôïc ñeà ra chuùng           express his lack of inner understanding. Thus, no ta chaúng coù thì giôø ñeå maø suy nghó, lyù luaän hay tìm        matter how "correct" his answer may appear to be, kieám. Baát cöù caâu traû lôøi naøo khoâng ñöôïc traû lôøi        it will not be accepted by an enlightened Zen moät caùch tröïc tieáp vaø ngay töùc thì hay ngaãu phaùt,         Master. This "crucial-verbal-contest", therefore, is vaø deã daøng ñeàu khoâng ñöôïc Thieàn chaáp nhaän. Do            a special technique, devised long ago by the Zen ñoù, vì caùc caâu hoûi Thieàn thöôøng laø khoâng theå traû        Masters to test the inner understanding of their lôøi ñöôïc vaø laøm chuùng ta chöng höûng, khi ngöôøi ñeä         students. An enlightened being should be able to töû khoâng traû lôøi ñöôïc thì laäp töùc anh ta coá tìm caâu      answer immediately any baffling question put to traû lôøi "ñuùng" baèng caùch suy luaän luaän lyù, söï trì treä   him, easily and without hesitation. The answer naøy tieát loä ngay caùi khieám khuyeát tri thöùc noäi taïi       should be like lightning, like a flashing spark cuûa anh ta. Vì theá, daàu caâu traû lôøi cuûa anh ta coù veû     struck from a stone. There is no room for chính xaùc ñeán ñaâu ñi nöõa, chaéc haún noù khoâng bao           "cultivation", no time for "framing". On the other giôø ñöôïc moät Thieàn sö ñaõ ngoä chaáp nhaän. Do ñoù            hand, for a Zen Master, chi-feng also means his caùi "Cô phong-vaán ñaùp" naøy laø moät kyõ thuaät ñaëc           sharp characters. bieät, do caùc Thieàn sö nghó ra töø laâu laém roài, duøng        Cô Phong Tieãu Tuaán: Tính caùch saéc beùn cuûa moät ñeã thöû tri thöùc noäi taïi cuûa ñeä töû cuûa hoï. Moät ngöôøi   vò thieàn sö khieán ngöôøi ngöôøi kính sôï—Sharp ñaõ ngoä phaûi coù ñuû khaû naêng traû lôøi ngay laäp töùc        characters of a Zen master that gain awing respect baát cöù caâu hoûi laät loïng naøo ñaët ra cho mình, moät         from people. caùch deã daøng khoâng heà löôõng löï. Caâu traû lôøi phaûi       Cô Quan: 1) Möu chöôùc: Expedient, trick; 2) Söùc nhö ñieän chôùp, nhö moät tia löûa nhaùng leân töø moät           khuyeán taán: Motive force, cause, opportunity. taûng ñaù. Khoâng coù choã ñeå "toâi luyeän", khoâng coù thì      Cô Quan Moäc Nhaân: Ngöôøi maùy baèng goã—A giôø ñeå "ñuùc khuoân". Maët khaùc, veà phaàn vò Thaày,           wooden robot—Thaân taâm laø chaùnh baùo cuûa loaøi cô phong cuõng coù nghóa laø tính caùch saéc beùn cuûa            höõu tình. Trong nguõ uaån, saéc uaån laø thaân. Taâm bao moät vò thieàn sö—The term "Chi-feng" is very                     goàm boán uaån, thoï, töôûng, haønh, thöùc. Chuùng chæ laø difficult to translate into any language, because it              söï keát hôïp taïm thôøi vaø khoâng coù töï tính, cuõng has manifold and subtle meanings. Literally, "chi"                gioáng nhö töôïng goã maø thoâi —Body and mind, the means crucial, critical or the key point, etc.; and               direct fruit of the previous life. The body is rupa, "feng" is the tip of a sharp weapon. So "Chi-feng"                the first skandha. Mind embraces other four, means literally "crucial sharp tip or point." But                 consciousness, perception, action, and knowledge. Zen schools use the term as the wonderful and                     Both the body and mind are made up of temporary

substances without own nature, just like a wooden             Cô Yeáu: 1) Quan troïng: Important, important statue or a robot.                                            point; 2) Cô hoäi quan troïng: Strategical possibility Cô Quan Töø Thieän: Charitable establishment                  or opportunity; 3) Luùc hieän taïi naøy ñaây: The (organization).                                               moment of the present. Cô Taéc Ngaät Phaïn, Khoán Taéc Ñaû Mieân, Haøn               Côø Phaät Giaùo: Buddhist flag—Phaät giaùo kyø— Taéc Höôùng Hoûa, Nhieät Taéc Thöøa Löông: Ñoùi thì           Theo lòch söû Phaät giaùo thì khi Ñöùc Phaät ngoài döôùi aên, meät thì nguû, laïnh thì söôûi aám, noùng thì hoùng      goác Boà Ñeà, nhöõng tia saùng ñaõ phaùt ra töø kim thaân maùt. Ñaây laø baûn theå cuûa töï taùnh bình thöôøng cuøng    cuûa Ngaøi sau khi Ngaøi ñaït ñöôïc giaùc ngoä. Döïa vaøo khaép thôøi gian khoâng gian, nôi phaøm chaúng bôùt,          yeáu toá naøy, maø laù côø Phaät giaùo ñöôïc laøm vôùi nhieàu nôi Thaùnh chaúng theâm. Taâm naày bình ñaúng, chaúng         maøu, traéng, xanh, vaøng, ñoû... chæ nhöõng chuûng toäc sanh chaúng dieät, chuùng sanh y theo taâm naày öùng          khaùc nhau ñeàu coù theå soáng haïnh phuùc döôùi söï che duïng trong cuoäc soáng haèng ngaøy, neân goïi bình           chôû cuûa trí tueä cuûa Ñöùc Phaät. Laù côø Phaät giaùo laøm thöôøng taâm laø ñaïo vaäy—To eat when one is                 bôûi naêm maøu: xanh, vaøng, ñoû, traéng vaø cam, ñaõ hungry; to take a rest when one feels tired; to               ñöôïc Tích Lan duøng töø naêm 1882. Vaøo naêm 1950, warm oneself when one feels cold; and to take                 taïi Hoäi Nghò Phaät giaùo ñaàu tieân, ñöôïc cöû haønh taïi fresh air when one feels hot. This is the original            Coâ Loâm Boâ, moät nghò quyeát ñaõ ñöôïc thoâng qua substance of the self-nature exists all over and at           coâng nhaän laù côø naøy laø bieåu töôïng cuûa Phaät giaùo all times. It is not less in ordinary people and not          Theá giôùi. Naêm maøu cuûa laù côø töôïng tröng cho aùnh more in the sage. This is the equal mind in                   haøo quang ñöôïc nhìn thaáy treân thaân cuûa Ñöùc Phaät everyone, and it is neither arising nor ceasing.              vaøo ngaøy maø Ngaøi giaùc ngoä. Maøu xanh töôïng Sentient beings just follow this mind in daily                tröng cho söï tinh taán, maøu vaøng cho trí tueä, maøu activities. That's why it is called: "Ordinary mind           ñoû cho söï yeâu thöông, maøu traéng cho söï thanh tònh is the Way."                                                  vaø maøu cam cho nghò löïc—According to Buddhist Cô Tieân: Ñieàm baùo tröôùc veà ñieàu gì, duï cho moät        records, as the Buddha sat under the Bodhi Tree, nieäm chöa khôûi hay tröôùc khi khôûi leân nhöõng phaân       six rays of light emitted from his body after his bieät töø voïng töôûng—Something that gives advance           Enlightenment. Based on this, the Buddhist flag notice, i.e., a thought has not yet developed or              indicates that all the different races in the world before the arising of discriminations from deluded            can live happily under the shield of the Buddha’s thoughts.                                                     wisdom. The Buddhist flag is made of five colors: Cô Tieân Cô Haäu: Kisen-Kigo (jap)—Trong                      blue, yellow, red, white, and orange, has been Thieàn, thuaät ngöõ naøy chæ tröôùc khi khôûi leân vaø sau    used in Sri Lanka since 1882. In 1950, at the first khi khôûi leân nhöõng phaân bieät töø voïng töôûng—           World Buddhist Conference, held in Colombo, a Before the moment, after the moment. In Zen, the              resolution was passed to accept the flag as the term indicates moments before the arising and                 International Buddhist Symbol. The five colors of after the arising of discriminations from deluded             the flag represented the aura of the Buddha’s thoughts.                                                     body which was seen on the day of his Cô Tieân Cuù Haäu: Kisen-Kugo (jap)—Trong                     Enlightenment. Blue stands for devotion, yellow Thieàn, khi noùi veà haønh ñoäng, tröïc giaùc ñi tröôùc vaø   for intellect, red for love, white for purity and suy suy xeùt theo sau—In Zen, when talking about              orange for energy. action, intuition before and consideration after.             Côn Voâ Thöôøng Mau Choùng, Söï Soáng Cheát Lôùn Cô Tính: See Cô Caên.                                         Lao: The wave of impermanence is swift, the Cô Trung Cuù Lyù: Kichu-Kuri (jap)—Ngay töï luùc              issue of life and death is a great matter. naøy vaø beân trong ngoân cuù—At this moment itself,          Cuù: Pada (skt)—Moät caâu, moät töø ngöõ hay meänh and the inside of a word.                                     ñeà—A sentence—Phrase—Clause. Cô Tö: Cô phong taøi trí hay taøi trí coäng vôùi tính         Cuù Cuù: Töø caâu naày qua caâu kia—Sentence by caùch saéc beùn cuûa moät vò thieàn sö—Talents and            sentence. sharp characters of a Zen master.                             Cuù Lyù Trình Cô: Trong lôøi noùi hieån baøy cô phong Cô ÖÙng: Potentiality and response—See Cô Caûm.               hay tính caùch saéc beùn cuûa moät vò thieàn sö cuøng

vôùi khía caïnh vi dieäu thaâm aùo cuûa thieàn—Words      Luaän—Name of a monk who wrote the and speeches that reveal sharp characters of a Zen        Abhidharma mrta-sastra. master and wonderful and profoundly aspects of            Cuø Sö La Tröôûng Giaû: Goshila (skt)—Myõ AÂm Zen.                                                      Tröôûng Giaû—Teân cuûa con trai cuûa Sudhira vaø Cuù Nghóa: Nghóa cuûa moät caâu hay moät meänh ñeà —      Sumitra, ngöôøi quy-y ñaàu Phaät theo A Nan Ñaø— Meaning of a sentence, a phrase, or a clause.             Name of the son of Sudhira and Sumitra, Cuù Nghóa Phaùp Cöông Yeáu: Padartha-dharma-              converted by Ananda. samgraha (skt)—Padhana-sutta (p)—Luïc Cuù                 Cuø Sö La Vieân: Ghositarama (p)—Myõ Vieân Tònh Nghóa Cöông Yeáu—Sutra on exertion—Sutra on               Xaù—Name of a temple in India. the great struggle.                                       Cuø Xí La Ñieåu: Kokika (skt)—Kokila (skt)—Cöu Cuù Phaùp: Syntax.                                        Di La—Teân moät loaøi chim cu—A kind of cuckoo. Cuù Thaân: Padakaya (skt)—Pratipadika (skt)—              Cuû: Caây thöôùc, hay thöôùc vuoâng cuûa thôï moäc —A Bodies of sentences—Chöõ bieán chuyeån trong              carpenter’s square—A ruler. caâu—An inflected word in a sentence.                     Cuû Cuû Tra: Cuù Trung Höõu Cô: Trong lôøi noùi coù haøm chöùa cô      1) Dòch laø Keâ Quyù: Kukkuta (skt)—Gaø vòt—A phong hay tính caùch saéc beùn cuûa moät vò thieàn sö           cock—A fowl. cuøng vôùi khía caïnh vi dieäu thaâm aùo cuûa thieàn—     2) Teân khaùc cuûa nöôùc Cao Ly: Kukkutesvara Words and speeches that imply sharp characters of               (skt)—Another name for Korea. a Zen master and wonderful and profoundly                 Cuû Cuû Tra EÁ Thuyeát La: Kukkutesvara (skt)— aspects of Zen.                                           See Cuû Cuû Tra (2). Cuø Baø Giaø: Gopaka (skt)—Thieân töû Cuø Baø Giaø—       Cuû Xa Yeát La Boå La: Kusagrapura (skt)—Coøn Name of a deva-son.                                       goïi laø kinh thaønh Thöôïng Mao cuûa xöù Ma Kieät Ñaø Cuø Baø La: Gopala (skt)—Long vöông Cuø Baø               (nôi caùc vöông quoác coå thöôøng ñoùng ñoâ) —An La—Name of a dragon-king.                                 ancient capital of Magadha. Cuø Baø La Long Vöông: See Cuø Baø La.                    Cuï: 1) Sôï: Fear, dread; 2) Troøn ñaày: Complete. Cuø Cuø Chung Nhaät: Laøm vieäc vaát vaû suoát ngaøy—     Cuï Chi Quaùn Ñaûnh: Moät trong ba pheùp Quaùn Toil all day.                                             Ñaûnh trong Kinh Ñaïi Nhöït. Ñaây laø pheùp quaùn Cuø Di: Gopika (skt)—Coà Tyø Gia—Name of                  ñaûnh thoï nhaän nöôùc raõi hay saùi thuûy treân ñaàu cuûa Siddhartha-gautama's second royal concubine—              quoác vöông vôùi nöôùc töø bieån hay soâng trong laõnh Teân cuûa baø phi thöù hai cuûa thaùi töû Taát Ñaït Ña.   thoå cuûa vöông trieàu. Pheùp naày cuõng ñöôïc duøng cho Cuø Ñaø Ni Chaâu: Apara-godaniya (skt)—                   nhöõng chöùc saéc cao trong haøng Giaùo Phaåm Phaät Godaniya (skt)—See Taây Ngöu Hoùa Chaâu.                  Giaùo—One of the three abhiseka or baptisms of Cuø Ñaøm: Gautama (skt)—Siddhartha—See Phaät.             The Vairocana Sutra. A ceremony sprinkling of Cuø Ñaøm Di: See Ma Ha Ba Xaø Ba Ñeà.                     the head of a monarch at his investiture with water Cuø Lao Cuùc Duïc: Parents’ painful task of rearing       from the seas and rivers (in his domain). It is a children.                                                 mode also employed in the investiture of certain Cuø Ma Di: Gomaya (skt)—Cow dung—Cöùt                     high officials of Buddhism. traâu—See Ngöu Phaån.                                     Cuï Duyeân: Söï coù ñuû caùc duyeân (ñieàu kieän)— Cuø Moâ Ñaùt La: Cow-urine—Nöôùc tieåu traâu boø—         Fulfillment of conditions. See Ngöu Nieäu.                                           Cuï Duyeân Phaùi: Prasanghika (skt)—ÖÙng Thaønh Cuø Nhöõ Taéc: Pan-T'an (chi)—Cuõng goïi laø Baøn         Toâng—See Cuï Duyeân Toâng. Ñaøm, teân cuûa moät vò cö só Trung Hoa ôû tænh Giang     Cuï Duyeân Toâng: Prasanghika (skt)—ÖÙng Thaønh Toâ vaøo theá kyû thöù XVII—Name of a Chinese lay-        Toâng—Moät nhaùnh cuûa tröôøng phaùi Madhyamika, person in Jiang-Ssu Province in the seventeenth           do nhaø hieàn trieát Phaät giaùo Buddhapajita (moân ñoà century.                                                  cuûa Ngaøi Long Thoï) saùng laäp—Making Use of Cuø Sa: Srighosaka (skt)—Teân cuûa moät vò Tyø            Consequences, a subschool of the Madhyamika Kheo, ngöôøi vieát boä A Tyø Ñaït Ma Cam Loä Vò           founded by the Buddhist sage Buddhapajita, a student of Nagarjuna.

Cuï Ñaøm: Gautama (skt)—Siddhartha.                         töû hay tröôûng laõo Tyø Kheo goïi caùc Tyø Kheo treû (yù Cuï Giôùi: See Cuï Tuùc Giôùi.                              noùi caùc vò aáy coù ñuû thoï meänh theá gian vaø tueä meänh Cuï Giôùi Ñòa: Ñeä nhò ñòa trong Thaäp Ñòa, trong ñoù       phaùp thaân)—Having long life, a term by which a coù ñuû giôùi luaät phaûi trì giöõ —The second of the       monk, a pupil, or a youth may be addressed. Bodhisattva ten stages in which the rules are kept.         Cuï Thuyeát: Giaùo thuyeát ñaày ñuû—To discuss Cuï Giôùi Phöông Tieän: Phaùp phöông tieän baèng            completely, state fully. caùch cho thoï trì cuï tuùc giôùi töøng böôùc (tröôùc cho   Cuï Traïch Phaùp Nhaõn: Zen practitioners should thoï 5, roài 8, roài 10, vaân vaân)—The expedient           have the distinguishing "Eye-of-Dharma"—Haønh method of giving the whole rules by stages (first           giaû phaûi coù con maét traïch phaùp. Nhö vaäy, theo by 5, then 8, then 10, etc).                                Thieàn sö Nguyeân Tónh, "Phaùp Nhaõn" phaân bieät coù Cuï Laïp Ba: Kurava (p)—Thaéng Bieän Chaâu, moät            nghóa laø khaû naêng phaân bieät vaø ñaùnh giaù ñuùng taát trong hai trung chaâu cuûa Baéc Cu Loâ chaâu—One of         caû caùc giaùo lyù vaø taát caû nhöõng söï vaät—Zen the two middle continents of Uttarakuru.                    practitioners must have the eye of distinguishment Cuï Lieân Maãn: Traøn ñaày loøng töø—Replete with           (investigation or choosing of the law). Thus, kindness—Fill with kindness.                                according to Zen master Yuan Tsin, the Cuï Nhaõn Naïp Taêng: See Cuï Nhaõn Quaû.                   distinguishing "Eye of Dharma" means the Cuï Nhaõn Quaû: Cuï Nhaõn Naïp taêng—Ngöôøi coù             capability of making correct discriminations and phaùp nhaõn—A person who has the dharma-eye.                evaluations of all teachings and all things—See Cuï Phaï: Sôï haõi khoâng yeân—Apprehensive—                Nguyeân Tónh Thaäp Moân. Fearful.                                                    Cuï Tri Caên: Annata-indriyam (p)—The faculty of Cuï Phöôïc: Saka-bandhana (skt)—Heát thaûy phaøm            the one who knows—Trí caên cuûa baäc thöùc giaû. phu ñeàu bò troùi buoäc vaøo phieàn tröôïc (ai cuõng coù    Cuï Tri Caên Löïc: Ajnata-Vindriya (skt)—Löïc saún phieàn naõo)—Completely bound, all men are in          hieåu bieát töù dieäu ñeá moät caùch toaøn haûo—Power of bondage to illusion.                                        perfect knowledge of the four Noble Truths. Cuï Sinh Caùt Töôøng (?-1381): Sahajasri (skt)—             Cuï Tuùc: Troøn ñaày—All—Complete—Replete Teân cuûa moät vò Thieàn sö AÁn Ñoä vaøo thôøi nhaø         with endowments—See Thaát Thieän. Minh. Vaøo naêm 1369, Sö ñeán Nguõ Ñaøi Sôn vaø truï        Cuï Tuùc An Truï: Söï an truï hoaøn toaøn—Söï chaéc taïi Thoï An Thieàn Töï. Ñeán naêm 1374, Sö du haønh        chaén hoaøn toaøn—Perfectly steadfastness. ñeán caùc vuøng ôû phía Nam Trung Hoa ñeå truyeàn baù       Cuï Tuùc Coâng Ñöùc: Traøn ñaày coâng ñöùc—Replete Phaät phaùp—Name of an Indian Zen master in the             with merit. Ming dynasty (1368-1644). In 1369, he came to               Cuï Tuùc Ñöùc Boån Nguyeän: Vow to the full Wu Tai Shan and dwelt at Shou-An Zen                        attainment of virtue—Nguyeän ñaït thaønh myõ maõn Monastery. In 1374, he traveled to the Southern             ñöùc haïnh. Lôøi nguyeän thöù 44 trong boán möôi taùm regions of China to spread Buddha-dharma.                   lôøi nguyeän cuûa Phaät A Di Ñaø, taát caû chuùng sanh Cuï Söû La: Ghosira (skt)—1) Haûo Thanh Ñieåu, teân         ñeàu coù ñaày ñuû coâng ñöùc —The forty-fourth of moät loaøi chim coù gioïng hoùt raát hay: Name of a bird    Amitabha’s forty-eight vows, that all universally that has an excellent voice; 2) Teân cuûa moät vò           should acquire his virtue. tröôûng giaû taïi Kausambi, ngöôøi ñaõ daâng hieán Cuï      Cuï Tuùc Giôùi: Complete precepts of a monk or a Söû La vieân vaø tònh xaù cho Ñöùc Phaät: A wealthy         nun—Full ordination—Cuï tuùc giôùi cuûa Tyø Kheo householder of Kausambi, who gave Sakyamuni                 hay 250 giôùi troøn ñaày cuûa chö Taêng. 250 giôùi the Ghosiravana park and vihara.                            thöôøng cho Tyø Kheo Taêng, vaø 348 giôùi cho Tyø Cuï Thanh: Kartrkarana (skt)—Cuï thanh hay töø              Kheo Ni (coù nôi cho laø 500 giôùi cho Tyø Kheo bieåu thò coâng cuï cuûa caùi naêng taùc. Ñaây laø moät     Ni)—The perfect or complete (full) 250 trong taùm tröôøng hôïp chuyeån thanh trong Phaïn ngöõ      commandments, which are obligatory on monks (subanta)—This is one of the eight cases of nouns           and nuns. 250 commandments are usually for in Sanskrit.                                                monks, those for nuns are 348 (some says 500 Cuï Thoï: Ayusmant (skt)—Guju (jap)—Tieáng                  commandments for the nuns). xöng hoâ chung cuûa caùc Tyø Kheo, caùc Thaày goïi ñeä      Cuï Tuùc Giôùi Tyø Kheo: Hai traêm hai möôi baûy

hoaëc hai traêm naêm chuïc giôùi cho Tyø Kheo—Two                giôùi cho Tyø Kheo Ni—Three hundred forty-eight hundred twenty-seven or two hundred fifty moral                  moral precepts for nuns. precepts for monks.                                              Cuï Tuùc Thanh Tònh: Complete purification— (I) Ba-la-di phaùp: Parajika (skt)—Boán giôùi Saùt,              Thanh tònh hoaøn toaøn. ñaïo, daâm, voïng—Four unpardonable offenses               Cuï Tuùc Thieân Vaïn Quang Minh Nhö Lai: of killing, theft, sexual intercourse and lying.           Rasmisatasahasraparipurnadhvadja (skt)—Trong (II) Taêng taøn: Samgha-Avashesha (skt)—Möôøi ba                 hoäi chuùng Phaùp Hoa, ñöùc Phaät ñaõ thoï kyù cho baø giôùi caám goàm: laäu thaát, ma xuùc, thoâ ngöõ, thaùn     Da Du Ñaø La sau naày thaønh Phaät hieäu laø Quang thaân, moâi nhôn, voâ chuû phoøng, höõu chuû phoøng,       Minh Phaät vôùi troøn ñaày voâ soá keå coâng ñöùc— voâ caên baùng, giaû caên baùng, trôï phaù taêng, oâ gia   Complete Countless Myriads of Bright and Clear taán,    cöï    taêng     giaùn—Thirteen         major     Light Buddha. In the Lotus Assembly, the Buddha prohibitions. Monks who violate these are                  predicted that Yasodhara will become a Buddha divested of membership in the Order of a                   with               the                 name                  of certain period.                                            Rasmisatasahasraparipurnadhvadja. (III) Nhò      Baát     ñònh:     Aniyata        (skt)—The       Cuï Tuùc Töôùng: Söï tuyeät myõ cuûa hình töôùng— indeterminate group—Bình xöù baát ñònh vaø Loä             Perfection of bodily characteristics. xöù baát ñònh—Prohibitions related to offenses             Cuï Tuùc Voâ Khuyeát: Complete without lack. which are committed either in a place where                Cuï Töôùng Thaân: Thaân cuï töôùng, vì thò hieän töôùng one can be seen or in a place where one                    traêm phöôùc thanh tònh—The formal body, cannot (being alone with a woman). The                     manifesting pure marks of virtue. punishment for this type of sin varies                     Cuûa Caûi Tích Luõy: Hoard of acquired wealth. according to the circumstances.                            Cuûa Thieân Traû Ñòa: Ill-goten, ill-spent. (IV) Ni Taùt Kyø Ba Daät Ñeà: Naihisargika-                      Cuùc: Boâng cuùc: Chrysanthemum—Cuùc duïc: Nuoâi prayashchittika (skt)—Ba möôi giôùi veà y baùt             döôõng—To nourish. vaät duïng—Xaû ñoïa, öng xaû ñoái trò—Thirty               Cuùc Duïc: To bring up. standards, whose violation is said to cause                Cuùc Ña: 1) Caáp Ña, Quaät Ña, teân cuûa moät trong one to fall into the three evil paths.                     Hai Möôi Taùm Toå AÁn Ñoä: Upagupta (skt)—Name (V) Ba Daät Ñeà: Shuddha-prayashchittika (skt)—                  of one of twenty-eight Indian patriarchs; 2) Teân 90 giôùi öùng ñoái trò phaûi phaùt loà tröôùc töù          cuûa moät trieàu ñaïi taïi AÁn Ñoä, toàn taïi vaøo theá kyû thöù chuùng—Ninety standards, violation of which                III vaø thöù IV: Gupta (skt)—A dynasty in India in requires public confession.                                the third and fourth centuries. (VI) Töù Ñeà Xaù Ni: Pratideshaniya (skt)—Boán giôùi Cuùc Ñaêng: Moät loaïi ñeøn cuùng trong chuøa, thuôøng khinh öng phaùt loà khi coù ngöôøi bieát (phi thaân tröôùc baøn Phaät—A chrysanthemum-shaped lamp nhi thuû thöïc, thöïc nhi chæ thoï thöïc, hoïc gia thoï used in temples, usually in front of the Buddha. thöïc, lan nhaõ thoï thöïc)—Four lesser Cuùc Khaùm: Thaåm vaán—To interrogate—To standards, the breaking of which requires question. confession when one becomes aware of his Cuùc Lôïi Nhai Na: Kuryana or Kuvayana (skt)— error. Theo Eitel trong Trung Anh Phaät Hoïc Töø Ñieån, (VII)Baù chuùng hoïc phaùp: Shaiksha-dharma (skt)— Cuùc Lôïi Nhai Na laø moät vöông quoác coå naèm veà 100 giôùi nhoû caàn phaûi hoïc cho bieát—One phía taây nam Ferghana, phía baéc thöôïng nguoàn hundred very minor standards, which are soâng Baùc Xoa (Oxus), baây giôø laø Kurrategeen— easily broken but which should be borne in According to Eitel in The Dictionary of Chinese- mind for one’s self-development. English Buddhist Terms, Kuvayana is an ancient (VIII)Thaát Dieät Traùnh: Adhikarana-shamatha kingdom south-west of Ferghana, north of the (skt)—Baûy ñieàu leä duøng ñeå giaûi hoøa trong upper Oxus, the present Kurrategeen. Giaùo Hoäi—Seven rules for settling disputes Cuùc Thuûy Nguyeät Taïi Thuû, Loäng Hoa Höông within the Order. Maõn Y: Voác nöôùc thì maët traêng trong tay, ñuøa hoa Cuï Tuùc Giôùi Tyø Kheo Ni: Ba traêm boán möôi taùm thì höông thôm toûa khaép quaàn aùo, duï Phaät giaùo

tröôøng toàn khaép nôi—To scoop up water in a                 ñaùnh chuoâng trong Taêng ñöôøng, Phaät ñöôøng vaø Töø handful, the moon is in the joining palms; to play            ñöôøng—A monk who is responsible for with flowers, fragrance will spread all over the              distributing foods, soups, tea, fruits, burning lamps clothes, i.e., Buddhism lasts forever every where.            and incense, striking the bell, etc., in the Sangha Cuïc Cuïc: See Cuïc Khuùc.                                    Hall, Buddha Hall and Ancestors Hall. Cuïc Khuùc: Caâu neä hình thöùc—To stick too much             Cung Ñieän Thaønh Quaùch Treân Nuùi Kyø Xaø to the formalities.                                           Quaät: The City of Royal Palaces on Mount Cuùi Chaøo: To bow to someone.                                Grdhrakuta. Cuùi Ñaàu Caàu Nguyeän: To bow one’s head in                  Cung Giaûng: Vaøo cung giaûng kinh cho hoaøng prayers.                                                      gia—To enter the royal palace to preach the sutras Cung: 1) Caây cung: Dhanus (skt)—A bow. 2)                    to the royal family. Cung ñieän: A palace, mansion. 3) Cung kính:                  Cung Haï: To congratulate. Respect, reverence.                                           Cung Haønh: To do something by oneself. Cung Baøn Traø: Quyû Cung Baøn Traø—Kumbhanda                 Cung Hieán: To offer. demons.                                                       Cung Kieán Na Boå La: Konkanapura (skt)—Theo Cung Baûn Chính Toân (1893-1983): Miyamo                      Eitel trong Trung Anh Phaät Hoïc Töø Ñieån, Cung Shoson (jap)—Teân cuûa moät vò hoïc giaû Phaät giaùo          Kieán Na Boå La laø moät vöông quoác coå naèm veà bôø Nhaät Baûn, queâ ôû Niigata. OÂng laø taùc giaû cuûa nhöõng   bieån phía taây cuûa AÁn Ñoä, bao goàm caùc vuøng taäp saùch: Ñaïi Thöøa vaø Tieåu Thöøa, Ñaïi Thöøa Phaät      Konka, Goa, vaø phía baéc Kanara—According to Giaùo, Long Thoï, vaân vaân—Name of a Japanese                Eitel in The Dictionary of Chinese-English Buddhist scholar. He came from Niigata, Japan.                Buddhist Terms, Konkanapura, an ancient He was the author of several books: Mahayana                  kingdom on the West Coast of India, including and Hinayana, Mahayana Buddhism, and                          Konkan, Goa, and North Kanara. Nagarjuna, etc.                                               Cung       Kính:     Satkara     (skt)—Respectful— Cung Baïn Traø: Kumbandha.                                    Reverent—Worship. Cung Chuùng: Cung caáp thöïc phaåm cho Taêng                  Cung Kính Cuùi Ñaàu: To bow respectfully. giaø—To provide foods and supplies to the Sangha.             Cung       Kính      Ñi      Nhieãu:      Respectfully Cung Ñaïo: Kyu-do (jap)—Cung ñaïo coù nghóa laø               circumambulating (circling on foot). con ñöôøng cuûa chieác cung hay ngheä thuaät baén             Cung Kính Thí: Cung kính cuõng laø moät caùch cuùng cung, moät trong nhöõng con ñöôøng reøn luyeän theå           döôøng—Offer with reverence or worship as an chaát vaø taâm linh ñöôïc thöïc haønh ôû Nhaät theo tinh      offering. thaàn cuûa thieàn. Nhöõng goác reã taâm linh cuûa cung        Cung Kính Thænh Phaät Thuyeát Phaùp: ñaïo ñöôïc giaûi thích trong cuoán saùch cuûa Eugen           Reverently asked the Buddha to preach the Herrigel vôùi nhan ñeà "Thieàn Qua Ngheä Thuaät Baén          dharma. Cung," moät trong nhöõng quyeån saùch hay nhaát ñöôïc         Cung Kính Thænh Sö Thuyeát Phaùp: Reverently ngöôøi Taây phöông bieân soaïn theo tinh thaàn thieàn         asked the master to preach the dharma. (New York, 1971)—Art of archery or "Way of the                Cung Mieáu: Royal temples. bow," one of spiritual physical training ways of              Cung Ngöï Ñaø: Konyodha (skt)—Theo Eitel trong Japan, the practice of which is permeated by the              Trung Anh Phaät Hoïc Töø Ñieån, Cung Ngöï Ñaø ñöôïc mind of Zen. The spiritual roots of the "art of               ngaøi Huyeàn Trang noùi ñeán laø moät vöông quoác coå archery" are treated in Eugen Herrigel's book                 cuûa nhöõng ngöôøi khoâng tin Phaät, naèm veà phía ñoâng "Zen in the Art of Archery", which is among the               nam Orissa, coù leõ baây giôø laø thò traán Ganjam— best books written by a Westerner on the spirit of            According to Eitel in The Dictionary of Chinese- Zen.                                                          English Buddhist Terms, Konyodha, an ancient Cung Ñaàu: Cung Quaù Haønh Giaû—Cung Tö—See                   kingdom mentioned by Hsuan-Tsang as a Cung Ñaàu Haønh Giaû.                                         stronghold of unbelievers; it is said to be in south- Cung Ñaàu Haønh Giaû: Vò Taêng phuï traùch vieäc              east Orissa, possibly the present Ganjam town. phaân phoái côm canh, traø quaû, ñoát ñeøn, höông vaø

Cung Phuïng: 1) Hieán: To offer; 2) Vò Taêng coù             Taùt ñeå toû loøng bieát ôn. Ñieàu naày cuõng gioáng nhö chöùc vò cao nhaát trong Taêng ñoaøn: Director of            con caùi toû loøng cung kính cha meï, hay nhö hoïc troø monks, a monk who has the most seniority in the              toân kính thaày vaäy—To make offerings to means to Order.                                                       provide whatever nourishes, e.g. food, goods, Cung Quaù Haønh Giaû: Cung Tö—See Cung Ñaàu                  incense, lamps, scriptures, the doctrine, etc, any Haønh Giaû.                                                  offerings for body or mind. Buddhists should Cung Quaûng: Palace in the moon.                             always remember that offerings to the Buddha and Cung Thai: Thai cung nôi nhöõng ngöôøi nieäm Phaät           Bodhisattvas mean to express respect and vaõng sanh maø coøn nghi ngôø nôi Ñöùc Phaät A Di Ñaø        gratitude to them. It is similar to children paying seõ ñöôïc veà ôû taïi ñaây trong 500 naêm cho ñeán khi ñuû   respect to their parents, as well as students coâng ñöùc sanh veà Tònh Ñoä —The palace womb,               showing gratitude toward their teachers. where those who call on Amitabha but are in                  Cuùng Döôøng Cao Quyù Nhaát: Worthiest offering doubt of him are confined for 500 years, devoid of           to the Buddha—Caùch cuùng döôøng cao quyù nhaát the riches of Buddha-truth, till born into th Pure           ñeán vôùi Ñöùc Phaät—Coù moät vaøi ngöôøi khoâng hieåu Land—See Nghi Thaønh Thai Cung.                              ñöôïc yù nghóa cuûa vieäc cuùng döôøng trong ñaïo Phaät, Cung Thaán: Daksina (skt)—Troïng Thaán—See                   neân voäi vaøng keát luaän raèng ñaïo Phaät laø moät toân Ñaït Thaán.                                                  giaùo thôø ngaãu töôïng. Hoï ñaõ hoaøn toaøn sai laàm. Cung Thoâng: Traàn thuaät—To relate.                         Trong giôø phuùt cuoái cuøng cuûa cuoäc ñôøi, giöõa röøng Cung Thöôøng Laïc: Palace of perenial delight—               Ta La Song Thoï taïi thaønh Caâu Thi Na, Ñöùc Phaät Palace of permanent delight.                                 ñaõ 80 tuoåi, ngaém nhìn nhöõ ng boâng hoa rôi raéc cuùng Cung Trieâu Tòch: Vieäc chi duïng haèng ngaøy trong          döôøng Ngaøi laàn cuoái, Ngaøi ñaõ noùi vôùi A Nan: “Nhö töï vieän—Daily expenditures in a monastery.                 theá khoâng phaûi laø kính troïng, toân suøng, ñaûnh leã, Cung Trôøi Ñaâu Suaát: Tusita (skt)—Tosotsu                  cuùng döôøng Nhö Lai. Naøy A Nan, neáu coù Tyø (jap)—See Ñaâu Suaát.                                        Kheo, Tyø Kheo Ni, hay nam nöõ cö só naøo thaønh Cung Tröôùng: Soå boä ghi cheùp teân hoï vaø ngaøy           töïu chaùnh phaùp vaø soáng tuøy phaùp, soáng chaân chaùnh xuaát gia cuûa Taêng Ni trong töï vieän—Registers            trong chaùnh phaùp thì ngöôøi aáy ñaõ kính troïng, toân recording names and dates of renunciation of                 suøng, ñaûnh leã, cuùng döôøng Nhö Lai, vôùi söï cuùng monks and nuns in a monastery.                               döôøng toái thöôïng. Do vaäy, naày A Nan, haõy thaønh Cung Tö: See Cung Ñaàu Haønh Giaû.                           töïu chaùnh phaùp, haõy soáng chaân chaùnh trong chaùnh phaùp vaø haønh trì ñuùng chaùnh phaùp. Naày A Nan, Cung Tyø La: Coøn goïi laø Kim Tyø La, dòch laø caù caùc ngöôøi phaûi hoïc taäp nhö vaäy.” Lôøi khuyeán hoùa saáu—A crocodile. soáng tuøy thuaän chaùnh phaùp naày cuûa Ñöùc Phaät ñaõ Cung Tyø La Ñaïi Töôùng: Kumbhira (skt)—Moät chæ roõ cho thaáy raèng vaán ñeà toái troïng yeáu vaãn laø tu trong möôøi hai vò thaàn lieân heä vôùi ñöùc Phaät Döôïc taäp taâm vaø chaùnh haïnh trong lôøi noùi vaø vieäc laøm, Sö—One of the the twelve spirits connected with chöù khoâng phaûi ñôn thuaàn cuùng döôøng höông hoa the Master of Healing Buddha. ñeán baäc Giaùc Ngoä. Soáng chaân chaùnh theo Giaùo Cuùng: Puja (skt)—To offer or honour in Phaùp laø ñieàu maø Ñöùc Nhö Lai thöôøng xuyeân nhaán worship—To supply—To offer to Buddha. maïnh. Nhö vaäy khi ngöôøi Phaät töû cuùng döôøng Cuùng Cuï: Cuùng Vaät—Caùc leã vaät daâng cuùng leân höông hoa, nhang ñeøn tröôùc kim thaân Ñöùc Phaät chö Phaät vaø chö Boà Taùt nhö hoa, höông (ñoà boâi), hay moät ñoái töôïng thieâng lieâng naøo ñoù, vaø suy nöôùc, nhang, thöùc aên, ñeøn—Offerings, i.e. flowers, gaãm ñeán nhöõng aân ñöùc cao quyù cuûa Phaät, maø unguents, water, incense, food, light. khoâng heà caàu nguyeän moät ai caû. Nhöõng vieäc laøm Cuùng Döôøng: Pajana (skt)—To support—To nhö vaäy khoâng mang tính chaát suøng baùi hay leã offer—To make offerings—Offerings—Cuùng nghi meâ tín. Nhöõng boâng hoa ñoù chaúng bao laâu sau döôøng laø cung caáp nuoâi döôõng hay cuùng döôøng seõ taøn uùa, nhöõng ngoïn neán kia roài seõ taét lòm nhö ñeå nhöõng thöù leã vaät nhö thöùc aên, höông, hoa, nhang, noùi vôùi hoï, nhaéc nhôû hoï veà tính chaát voâ thöôøng cuûa ñeøn, kinh saùch, giaùo thuyeát, vaân vaân. Phaät töû neân vaïn phaùp. Hình töôïng ñoái vôùi ngöôøi Phaät töû laø moät luoân nhôù raèng cuùng döôøng ñeán chö Phaät vaø chö Boà ñeà muïc taäp trung, laø moät ñeà muïc ñeå haønh thieàn; töø

nôi kim thaân cuûa Ñöùc Phaät ngöôøi Phaät töû tìm ñöôïc     ngoaøi toû loøng kính troïng Phaät. Khi cuùng döôøng söï truyeàn caûm vaø khích leä ñeå noi theo nhöõng phaåm     hoa, chuùng ta neân nghó raèng hoa naày roài seõ taøn haïnh cao quyù cuûa Ngaøi—Some who do not                    phai heùo uùa vaø hoaïi dieät ñi, chuùng ta cuõng seõ hoaïi understand the significance of offering in                   dieät nhö vaäy, khoâng coù moät thöù gì treân ñôøi naày Buddhism, hastily conclude that Buddhism is a                ñaùng cho ta baùm víu—Buddhists offer flowers and religion of idol worship. They are totally wrong.            incense to the Buddha as an outward form of While lying on his death-bed between the two                 respect to the Buddha. When we offer flowers, we Sala trees at Kusinara, the eighty-year-old Buddha           think that as those flowers fade we also fade and seeing the flowers offered to him, addressed the             die; therefore, there is nothing in this world for us Venerable Ananda thus: “They who, Ananda, are                to cling on. correct in life, living according to the Dhamma --           Cuùng Döôøng Maïn Ñaø La: Mandala offering— it is they who right honor, reverence and venerate           Theo truyeàn thoáng Phaät giaùo Taây Taïng, maïn ñaø la the Tathagata with the worthiest homage.                     coù nghóa laø voøng quanh trung taâm. Theo tieáng Taây Therefore, Ananda, be you correct in life, living            Taïng laø “Kyil-Kor”, haøm yù cuûa “Kyil” laø tinh tuùy according to the Dhamma. Thus, should you train              vaø cuûa “Kor” laø laáy ra. Do ñoù, maïn ñaø la coù nghóa yourselves.” This encouragement of the Buddha                laø laáy ra tinh tuùy. Cuùng döôøng maïn ñaø la laø moät on living according to the Dhamma shows clearly              phöông phaùp raát hieäu nghieäm ñeå tích luõy coâng ñöùc that what is of highest importance is training in            vaø thanh tònh hoùa chöôùng ngaïi—According to the mental, verbal and bodily conduct, and not the               Tibetan Buddhist tradition, the term Mandala mere offering of flowers to the Enlightened Ones.            means circling the center. The term “Mandala” in The emphasis is on living the right life. Now when           Tibetan is “Kyil-Kor”, the implied meaning of a Buddhist offers flowers, or lights a lamp before           “Kyil” is “essence” and “Kor” is “extracting.” the Buddha image or some sacred object, and the              Therefore, mandala means extracting the essence. ponders over the supreme qualities of the Buddha,            Mandala offering is a very effective means of he is not praying to anyone; these are not ritual,           accumulating merit and purifying obscurations. rites, or acts of worship. The flowers that soon             Cuùng Döôøng Nhaát Thieát Phaät Saùt Haïnh: Haïnh fade, and the flames that die down speak to him,             taát caû coõi Phaät, vì leã baùi cuùng döôøng chö Phaät— and tell him of the impermanency of all                      Practice of action in all Buddha-lands, honoring all conditioned things. The image serves him as an               Buddhas. object from concentration, for meditation; he gains          Cuùng Döôøng Phaùp: Dharmapuja (skt)—See Phaùp inspiration and endeavors to emulate the qualities           Cuùng Döôøng. of the Master.                                               Cuùng Döôøng Phaùp Vaät: Caùc vaät phaåm cuùng Cuùng Döôøng Chuû: Vò Taêng khuyeán hoùa tín ñoà ñeå         döôøng Tam Baûo nhö nhö höông, hoa, nhang, ñeøn, hoï cuùng döôøng Tam Baûo—A monk who exhorts                 kinh saùch, giaùo thuyeát, vaân vaân—Offerings to the believers to give alms for worship.                          Triratna, i.e., incense, lamps, scriptures, the Cuùng Döôøng Chö Phaät Phoå: Power of universal              doctrine, etc. service of all Buddhas.                                      Cuùng Döôøng Phaät: An offering to Buddha. Cuùng Döôøng Chö Phaät Thuû: Tay cuùng döôøng chö            Cuùng Döôøng Sinh Thaân Phaät: Offerings to the Phaät, vì chöùa nhoùm nhöõng phöôùc ñöùc khoâng moûi         Birth-Body of the Buddha. nhaøm—Hands of honoring Buddhas, tirelessly                  Cuùng Döôøng Tam Nghieäp: Offering of the three gathering blessings and virtues.                             activities. Cuùng Döôøng Hoäi: Moksa-maha-parisad (skt)—                 Cuùng Döôøng Thöùc AÊn Cho Chö Taêng: To Ñaïi hoäi boá thí cho taát caû moïi ngöôøi, töø giaøu ñeán   bestow food on monks. ngheøo, treân danh nghóa naêm naêm moät laàn—A               Cuùng Döôøng Trai Taêng: Trai Taêng hay cuùng great gathering for almsgiving to all, rich and              döôøng thöïc vaät leân chö Taêng Ni trong ngaøy trai poor, nominal quinquenial.                                   nhaät—Offer presents to monks and nuns on a Cuùng Döôøng Höông Hoa: To offer flowers and                 fasting ceremony. incense—Phaät töû cuùng döôøng höông hoa laø beân            Cuùng Döôøng Traøng Phan Baûo Caùi: Offering

pennants and banners to the Buddhist temple.               caûn cuûa nguõ quan vaø trí naêng bieän bieät (thöùc thöù Cuùng Döôøng Vaân Haûi Boà Taùt: Puja-megha-               saùu). Ñieàu ñoù ñoøi hoûi naêng löïc, söï quyeát taâm vaø sagarah (skt)—Cloud and Sea Offering                       loøng can ñaûm. Thieàn sö An Coác Baïch Vaân goïi ñoù Bodhisattva.                                               laø "cuoäc chieán giöõa caùc theá löïc ñoái nghòch meâ Cuùng Döôøng Voâ Löôïng Chö Phaät Trong Quaù               hoaëc vaø giaùc ngoä." Taâm thaùi aáy ñöôïc ñöùc Phaät moâ Khöù: To serve countless Buddhas in the past.              taû moät caùch soáng ñoäng khi ngaøi ngoài döôùi coäi Boà Cuùng Hoa: Cuùng döôøng hoa—To offer flowers.              ñeà trong noå löïc toái thöôïng, vaø lôøi cuûa ngaøi thöôøng Cuùng Meã: Cuùng döôøng gaïo—To offer rice.                ñöôïc trích daãn trong caùc buoåi nhieáp taâm trong caùc Cuùng Phaïn: Cuùng côm—To offer cooked rice.               thieàn ñöôøng: "Cho daàu chæ coøn da, xöông vaø gaân, Cuùng Phaät: To offer to Buddha.                           cho daàu maùu vaø thòt khoâ ñi vaø heùo taøn, seõ khoâng Cuùng Phuïng: Cuùng döôøng: To offer—Vò sö chuû leã        rôøi choã naøy cho ñeán khi naøo ñaït ñeán toaøn giaùc." trong Ñaïi Huøng Baûo Ñieän: The monk who serves           Thoâi thuùc höôùng ñeán giaùc ngoä moät maët baét nguoàn at the great altar.                                        töø caûm giaùc khoå ñau veà troùi buoäc noäi taâm, nhöõng Cuùng Raèm: Full Moon Ceremony.                            noãi eâ cheá trong cuoäc soáng, söï sôï haõi veà caùi cheát, Cuùng Söï Phaàn Tyø Baø Sa Abhidharma-prakarana-           hoaëc caû hai; vaø maët khaùc, töø nieàm xaùc tín raèng pada-vibha-sastra (skt)—A Tyø Ñaït Ma Cuùng Söï            giaùc ngoä ñöa ñeán giaûi thoaùt. Chính nhôø toïa thieàn Tyø Baø Sa—Name of a work of commentary.                   maø söùc maïnh vaø sinh löïc cuûa thaân vaø taâm gia taêng vaø chung söùc ñoät phaù vaøo theá giôùi töï do môùi meû Cuùng Thieân: Thieân Cuùng—Cuùng döôøng caùc vò aáy—Zen Master Philip Kapleau wrote in The Trôøi, Phaïm Thieân, Ñeá Thích Thieân, Coâng Ñöùc Three Pillars of Zen: "Zazen that leads to Self- Thieân, Hoan Hyû Thieân—To make offerings to the realization is neither idle reverie nor vacant devas, Brahma, Indra, etc. inaction but an intense inner struggle to gain Cuùng Toå: To worship ancestors. control over the mind and then to use it, like a Cuùng Tröôùng: Ñôøi nhaø Ñöôøng chö Taêng Ni phaûi silent missile, to penetrate the barrier of the five ñaêng kyù ba naêm moät laàn—The T’ang dynasty senses and the discursive intellect (that is, the register, or census of monks and nuns, supplied to sixth sense). It demands energy, determination the government every three years. and courage. Yasutani-roshi (Zen master Hakuun Cuùng Tröôùng Vaân: Maây cuûa caùc vò Boà Taùt phuïng Yasutani 1885-1973) calls it 'a battle between the söï Nhö Lai—The cloud of Bodhisattvas who serve opposing forces of delusion and bodhi.' This state the Tathagata. of mind has been vividly described in these words, Cuøng: Ngheøo: Impoverished, exhausted, poor— said to have been uttered by the Buddha as he sat Xem xeùt töôøng taän: To investigate throroughly. beneath the Bo tree making his supreme effort, Cuøng Lyù Taän Tình: To probe a doctrine to the and often quoted in the zendo during sesshin: depths. 'Though only my skin, sinews, and bones remain Cuøng Sinh Töû Uaån: Mula-tikaskandha (skt)—Uaån and my blood and flesh dry up and wither away, goác—Root aggregate—Chaám döùt caùi uaån caên baûn yet never from this seat will I stir until I have daãn ñeán luaân hoài sanh töû—To exhaust the attained full enlightenment.' The drive toward concomitants of reincarnation or to be free from enlightenment is powered on the one hand by a transmigration. painful felt inner bondage, a frustration with life, a Cuøng Töû: Daridra-purusa (skt)—The poor son—              fear of death, or both; and on the other by the See Phuù Gia Töû Tha Phöông Caàu Thöïc.                    conviction that through awakening one can gain Cuoäc Chieán Noäi Taâm: An inner struggle—Thieàn           liberation. But it is in zazen that the body-mind's sö Philip Kapleau vieát trong quyeån 'Ba Truï Thieàn':     force and vigor are enlarged and mobilized for the Toïa thieàn giuùp ñöa ñeán söï töï chöùng ngoä, khoâng     breakthrough into this new world of freedom." phaûi laø mô maøng vaån vô, hay khoaûnh khaéc baát         Cuoäc Soáng Baát Haïnh: A wretched life. ñoäng troáng khoâng, nhöng laø moät cuoäc chieán noäi Cuoäc Soáng Cao Quyù: Noble life—Unblemished taâm ñeå ñöôïc quyeàn kieåm soaùt taâm thöùc, roài duøng life. noù nhö moät hoûa tieån thaàm laëng ñeå vöôït qua raøo Cuoäc Soáng Cuûa Chuùng Ta Chính Laø Cuoäc Soáng

Naøy: Our life is always just this life—Charlotte             mình caùi taâm bình an vaø haïnh phuùc. Coøn chö Taêng Joko Beck vieát trong quyeån 'Khoâng Coù Thöù Gì              Ni, hoï neân luoân tri tuùc vaø töï nguyeän tu taäp. Chöøng Ñaëc Bieät Caû': "Khoâng yù thöùc caûm giaùc cuûa mình,       naøo maø moät ngöôøi coøn oâm aáp söï thuø haèn, chöøng ñoù chuùng ta soáng khoâng troïn veïn. Ña soá ngöôøi ta           taâm thöùc ngöôøi aáy chöa haøm chöùa theå caùch lyù khoâng thoûa maõn vôùi cuoäc soáng cuûa mình vì hoï           töôûng cuûa moät Phaät töû thuaàn thaønh; duø baát cöù baát luoân vaéng maët vaø boû lôõ cô hoäi kinh nghieäm. Neáu       haïnh naøo giaùng xuoáng cho ngöôøi aáy, ngöôøi aáy vaãn chuùng ta toïa thieàn trong nhieàu naêm, chuùng ta ít         phaûi giöõ moät caùi taâm bình an tónh laëng—According maéc phaûi sai laàm naøy. Tuy nhieân, toâi khoâng bieát coù   to Buddhist theory, a happy life means always to ai luoân luoân saün saøng ñeå khoâng boû lôõ cô hoäi.         maintain a peaceful and happy mind. For monks Chuùng ta gioáng nhö nhöõng con caù vöøa bôi lang             and nuns, they should be always self-content and thang ñeå tìm ñaïi döông cho cuoäc ñôøi, maø queân maát       willing to practice religious disciplines. So long as ñi moâi tröôøng chung quanh mình. Gioáng nhö con              a person still cherishes resentment, his mental caù, chuùng ta chæ lang thang ñi tìm yù nghóa cuoäc ñôøi      attitude does not embody the ideal way of true maø khoâng yù thöùc raèng nöôùc quanh ta vaø chính            believer of the Buddhist teaching; whatever chuùng ta laø ñaïi döông. Vaø cuoái cuøng khi con caù         misfortune may befall him, he must maintain a gaëp moät vò ñaïi sö ngöôøi thaáu hieåu moïi thöù. Con caù    peaceful and calm mind. hoûi: 'Ñaïi döông laø gì?' Thaày chæ cöôøi. Taïi sao vaäy?    Cuoäc Soáng Heøn Moïn: Ignoble life. Ñaïi döông chính laø cuoäc soáng cuûa noù. Khi taùch con      Cuoäc Soáng Khoå Haïnh: Life of asceticism. caù ra khoûi nöôùc, con caù khoâng soáng ñöôïc. Töông         Cuoäc Soáng Mong Manh: Life is uncertain. töï, neáu chuùng ta töï taùch rôøi khoûi cuoäc soáng cuûa     Cuoäc Soáng Sieâu Nhieân: A supernatural life. mình, voán laø nhöõng gì mình thaáy, nghe, xuùc chaïm,        Cuoäc Soáng Theá Tuïc: A lay life. ngöûi, vaân vaân, chuùng ta bò chia caét vôùi chính mình.     Cuoäc Soáng Thuaàn Khieát: An unblemished life. Cuoäc soáng cuûa chuùng ta luoân luoân chính laø cuoäc        Cuoäc Soáng Töï Taïi: A carefree life. soáng naøy."—Charlotte Joko Beck wrote in                     Cuoäc Soáng Vaät Chaát: Material life—Theo Kinh Nothing Special: "Without awareness of our                    Töù Thaäp Nhò Chöông, Chöông 42, Ñöùc Phaät daïy: sensations, we are not fully alive. Life is                   “Ta xem ñòa vò vöông haàu nhö buïi qua keõ hôû, xem unsatisfactory for most people because they are               vaøng ngoïc quyù giaù nhö ngoùi gaïch, xem y phuïc tô absent from their experience much of the time. If             luïa nhö gieû raùch, xem ñaïi thieân theá giôùi nhö moät we have been sitting for several years, we do it              haït caûi, xem cöûa phöông tieän nhö caùc vaät quyù giaù somewhat less. I don't know anyone who is fully               hoùa hieän, xem phaùp voâ thöôïng thöøa nhö moäng thaáy present all of the time, however. We're like the              vaøng baïc luïa laø, xem Phaät ñaïo nhö hoa ñoám tröôùc fish that is swimming about, looking for the great            maét, xem thieàn ñònh nhö nuùi Tu Di, xem Nieát Baøn ocean of life, yet oblivious to its surroundings.             nhö ngaøy ñeâm ñeàu thöùc, xem phaûi traùi nhö saùu con Like the fish, we wonder about the meaning of                 roàng muùa, xem phaùp bình ñaúng nhö nhaát chaân ñòa, life, not awake to the water all around us and the            xem söï thònh suy nhö caây coû boán muøa.”— ocean that we are. The fish finally met a teacher             According to the Sutra In Forty-Two Sections, who understood. The fish asked, 'What is the great            Chapter 42, the Buddha said: “I look upon royal ocean?' And the teacher simply laughed. Why?...               and official positions as upon the dust that floats The ocean was its life. Separate a fish from water,           through a crack. I look upon the treasures of gold and there is no life for the fish. Likewise, if we            and jade as upon broken tiles. I look upon clothing separate ourselves from our life, which is what we            of fine silk as upon coarse cotton. I look upon a see, hear, touch, smell, and so on, we have lost              great thousand world-system as upon a small nut. I touch with what we are. Our life is always just this          look upon the door of expedient means as upon life."                                                        the transformations of a cluster of jewels. I look Cuoäc Soáng Giaùc Ngoä: An enlightened life.                  upon the unsurpassed vehicle as upon a dream of Cuoäc Soáng Haïnh Phuùc: A happy life—Theo giaùo              gold and riches. I look upon the Buddha-Way as thuyeát nhaø Phaät, cuoäc soáng haïnh phuùc coù nghóa laø     upon flowers before my eyes. I look upon Zen cuoäc soáng maø trong ñoù con ngöôøi luoân duy trì cho        Samadhi as upon the pillar of Mount Sumeru. I

look upon Nirvana as upon being awake day and                      Cuoáng Taäp Nhaân: Habits of lying—Ñaây laø moät night. I look upon deviancy and orthodoxy as upon                  trong möôøi nhaân möôøi quaû. Theo Kinh Thuû Laêng the one true ground. I look upon the prosperity of                 Nghieâm, quyeån Taùm, Ñöùc Phaät ñaõ nhaéc nhôû ngaøi the teaching as upon a tree during four seasons.”                  A Nan veà Cuoáng Taäp Nhaân nhö sau: “Cuoán taäp Cuoäc Soáng Xöùng Ñaùng Cho Ngöôøi Phaät Töû:                      doái nhau, phaùt töø nôi doái gaït nhau, doái vaø vu Worthwhile life for a Buddhist—Moät cuoäc soáng                    khoáng maõi khoâng thoâi, buoâng taâm laøm gian. Nhö xöùng ñaùng cuûa ngöôøi Phaät töû, theo quan ñieåm cuûa            vaäy neân coù ñoà baån thæu, buïi baäm oâ ueá, nhö buïi Phaät giaùo Ñaïi Thöøa, khoâng phaûi laø chæ traûi qua moät        theo gioù, ñeàu khoâng thaáy. Hai taäp giao nhau, neân cuoäc soáng bình an, tænh laëng maø chính laø söï saùng            coù caùc vieäc chìm ñaém, vuït, bay. Vì theá möôøi taïo moät caùi gì toát ñeïp. Khi moät ngöôøi noã löïc trôû         phöông Phaät goïi löøa gaït laø cöôùp gieát. Boà Taùt traùnh thaønh moät ngöôøi toát hôn do tu taäp thì söï taän löïc           doái gaït nhö traùnh raén ñoäc.”—This is one of the ten naøy laø söï saùng taïo veà ñieàu toát. Khi ngöôøi aáy laøm        causes and effects. According to the Surangama ñieàu gì lôïi ích cuûa ngöôøi khaùc thì ñaây laø söï saùng         Sutra, book Eight, the Buddha reminded Ananda taïo moät tieâu chuaån cao hôn cuûa söï thieän laønh. Caùc         about the habit of lying as follows: “Habits of ngheä thuaät laø söï saùng taïo veà caùi ñeïp, vaø taát caû caùc   lying and combined fraudulence which give rise nghieäp vuï löông thieän ñeàu laø söï saùng taïo nhieàu            to mutual cheating. When false accusations loaïi naêng löïc coù ích lôïi cho xaõ hoäi. Söï saùng taïo         continue without cease, one becomes adept at chaéc chaén cuõng mang theo vôùi noù söï ñau khoå, khoù            corruption. From this there come into being dust khaên. Tuy nhieân, ngöôøi ta nhaän thaáy cuoäc ñôøi ñaùng          and dirt, excrement and urine, filth, stench, and soáng khi ngöôøi ta noã löïc vì ñieàu gì thieän laønh. Moät        impurities. It is like the obscuring of everyone’s ngöôøi noã löïc ñeå trôû neân moät ngöôøi toát hôn moät            vision when the dust is stirred up by the wind. chuùt vaø laøm lôïi ích cho ngöôøi khaùc nhieàu hôn moät           Because these two habits augment one another, chuùt, nhôø söï noã löïc tích cöïc nhö theá chuùng ta coù          there come into being sinking and drowning, theå caûm thaáy nieàm vui saâu xa trong ñôøi ngöôøi —A             tossing and pitching, flying and falling, floating worthwhile life for a Buddhist, according to                       and submerging, and other such experiences. Mahayana Buddhist point of view, does not consist                  Therefore, the Thus Come Ones of the ten in merely spending one’s life in peace and quiet                   directions look upon lying and name it ‘robbery but in creating something good for other beings.                   and murder.’ Bodhisattvas regard lying as they When one tries to become a better person through                   would treading on a venomous snake.” his practice, this endeavor is the creation of good.               Cuoàng: Crazy—Mad—Deranged—Wild. When he does something for the benefit of other                    Cuoàng Baïo: Mad and cruel. people, this is the creation of a still higher                     Cuoàng Caåu: A mad dog (deluded mind). standard of good. The various arts are the creation                Cuoàng Hoa: Hoa doám nhaûy muùa tröôùc maét— of beauty, and all honest professions are the                      dancing flowers before the eyes. creation of various kinds of energy that are                       Cuoàng Hueä: Mad wisdom—Keû trí tueä bò taùn loaïn beneficial to society. Creation is bound to bring                  maø phaùt cuoàng (ñònh maø khoâng tueä goïi laø si ñònh, with it pain and hardship. However, one finds life                 gioáng nhö ngöôøi muø cöôõi ngöïa taát phaûi teù nhaøo; worth living when one makes a strenuous effort                     ngöôïc laïi tueä maø khoâng ñònh goïi laø cuoàng tueä, for the sake of something good. He endeavors to                    gioáng nhö ñeøn baûo tröôùc gioù lung linh khoâng soi become a little better a person and to do just a                   saùng ñöôïc gì)—Foolish wisdom—Clever or little more for the good of other people, through                  intelligence but without calm meditation. such positive endeavor we are enabled to feel                      Cuoàng Khuyeån Truïc Loâi Thinh: Choù ñieân suûa deep joy in our human lives.                                       theo tieáng saám, duï cho söï uoång coâng voâ ích trong Cuoáng: Maya (skt)—Sathya (skt)—Deceit or                          tu taäp—The dog barks in rhythm with the manipulation—Doái traù—Lôøi noùi löøa doái—                        lightnings, i.e., a wasteful and useless effort of Deception—Lying—Imposition—Unsincerity.                            cultivation. Cuoáng Cuoàng: To lose one’s head.                                 Cuoàng Loaïn: Distracted. Cuoáng Ngöõ: Deceitful words—Lôøi noùi doái traù.                  Cuoàng Loaïn Vaõng Sanh: Ngöôøi gaây toäi taïo

nghieäp ngay luùc laâm chung, taâm thaàn taùn loaïn sôï       enlightenment, those who are still eating sentient haõi, thaáy ngoïn löûa trong ñòa nguïc, giô tay leân naém     beings’ flesh and drinking wine everyday, but baét giöõa khoâng trung. Ñang luùc aáy maø coù cô             always pretending themselves as Zen Master. In duyeân coù ngöôøi khuyeân nieäm ñöôïc hoàng danh chö          Zen master Hakuin's congregation there was a Phaät möôøi laàn hay ngay caû moät laàn cuõng ñöôïc           crazy monk who thought he had realized the vaõng sanh Tònh Ñoä—Saved out of terror into the              identity of self and Buddhahood. He tore up next life; however, distressed by thoughts of hell            Buddhist scriptures and used the pages for toilet as the result of past evil life, ten repetition or even       paper. Other monks advised him not to do this, but one, of the name of Amitabha ensures entry into               he paid no attention, haughtily retorting, "What's his Paradise.                                                 wrong with using Buddhist scriptures to wipe a Cuoàng Ngoân: Foolish talk.                                   Buddha's ass?" Now someone reported this to the Cuoàng Nhieät: Excessive enthusiasm                           master Hakuin, who asked the crazy monk , "They Cuoàng Phong: A pierce wind—Hurricane.                        say you are using Buddhist scriptures for toilet Cuoàng Taâm Töùc, Boà Ñeà Loä: When your                      paper. Is that true?" The crazy monk said, "Yes, I perverted mind is expelled, it is precisely Bodhi             myself am a Buddha. What is wrong with using mind.                                                         Buddhist scriptures to wipe a Buddha's ass?" Cuoàng Thieàn: Mad Zen—Thieàn baäy baï, khoâng                Hakuin said, "You're wrong. Since it's a Buddha's ñuùng theo Chaùnh Phaùp Phaät Giaùo. Ngöôøi tu theo           ass, why use old paper with writing on it? You loaïi thieàn naày thöôøng bò aâm ma aùm nhaäp trôû neân       should wipe it with clean white paper." The crazy ñieân cuoàng. Cuoàng Thieàn cuõng bao goàm nhöõng keû         monk was shamed, and he apologized. khoâng thöïc haønh maø noùi thöïc haønh, khoâng ñaéc maø      Cuoàng Tín: Fanaticism. noùi ñaéc, ngaøy ngaøy hoï haõy coøn aên thòt uoáng röôïu     Cuoàng Tueä: See Cuoàng Hueä. maø voã ngöïc xöng teân laø Thieàn Sö naày noï . Trong        Cuoàng Töôïng: Voïng taâm meâ cuoàng ví nhö voi ñaïo traøng cuûa thieàn sö Baïch AÅn Hueä Haïc coù moät       ñieân—A mad elephant, such is the deluded mind. vò Taêng cuoàng voïng töï cho mình ñaõ chöùng ngoä töï        Cuoàng Vaân: Kyoun-shu (jap)—Cuoàng Vaân Söu taùnh vaø Phaät quaû. OÂng ta xeù kinh Phaät ñeå duøng        Taäp laø teân cuûa taäp "Söu taäp ñaùm maây ñieân". Söu laøm giaáy veä sinh. Taêng chuùng khuyeân oâng ta             taäp nhöõng baøi thô cuûa thieàn sö Nhaát Höõu Toâng khoâng neân laøm nhö vaäy, nhöng oâng ta khoâng ñeå yù        Thuaàn, ngöôøi töï ñaët cho mình bieät hieäu "Ñaùm Maây ñeán maø coøn cao gioïng khinh maïn: "Coù gì sai traùi        Ñieân". Trong nhöõng baøi thô vieát theo loái Trung khi söû duïng kinh Phaät ñeå chuøi ñích Phaät kia chöù?"      Hoa cuûa mình, Nhaát Höõu Toâng Thuaàn ca ngôïi caùc Caâu chuyeän ñöôïc baùo leân thieàn sö Baïch AÅn Hueä         ñaïi sö trong quaù khöù, ngaäm nguøi thöông xoùt cho söï Haïc. Baïch AÅn cho goïi vò Taêng aáy vaøo thieàn phoøng      suy taøn cuûa thieàn thôøi ñoù vôùi söï mæa mai cay ñoäc, vaø hoûi: "Taêng chuùng noùi raèng oâng duøng kinh Phaät      ñaû kích nhöõng yeáu ñieåm cuûa caùc vò Taêng tu haønh laøm giaáy veä sinh, coù ñuùng vaäy khoâng?" Vò Taêng         thoaùi hoùa baèng caùch ñoái laäp loái soáng cuûa hoï vôùi loái ñaùp: "Ñuùng vaäy! Ta cuõng laø Phaät. Coù gì sai traùi khi   soáng cuûa mình, chuû tröông khoâng theo khuoân söû duïng kinh Phaät ñeå chuøi ñích Phaät ñaâu naøo?"         pheùp, bao giôø cuõng döïng laïi nöûa ñöôøng giöõa nôi aån Baïch AÅn Hueä Haïc noùi: "OÂng sai roài! Neáu ñoù quaû       daät vaø ngoâi nhaø khoaùi laïc cuûa mình. Nhöõng baøi thô laø ñích Phaät, taïi sao laïi duøng giaáy cuõ ñaõ coù chöõ    taëng cho ngöôøi yeâu cuûa mình, moät coâ ñaày tôù muø vieát ñeå chuøi? OÂng phaûi duøng giaáy traéng tinh saïch     teân laø Shin, naèm trong nhöõng baøi thô daâm hay nhaát ñeå chuøi chöù?" Vò Taêng caûm thaáy xaáu hoã vaø xin         cuûa Nhaät Baûn. Döôùi ñaây laø moät baøi thô ñaëc tröng loãi—Mad Zen is a false method of practicing Zen.             cuûa "Söu taäp ñaùm maây ñieân": "Theá giôùi thieàn ñaày It is erronous and not according to the proper                nhöõng giaøu coù vaø vinh quang. Nhöng söï suy suïp Dharma teachings of the Buddha. People who                    cuûa noù thaät taøn nhaãn. Chaúng coøn moät thaày thöïc follow this type of Zen practice are often                    thuï naøo. Chæ coøn nhöõng thaày tu giaû. Phaûi caàm laáy possessed by demonic spirits and eventually                   moät maùi cheøo. Ñeå mình bieán thaønh moät ngö phuû. become mad. Mad Zen also includes those who                   Treân nhöõng vuøng bieån caû soâng ngoøi. Moät ngoïn gioù never practice but saying practicing, never                   laïnh vaø ngöôïc. Ngaøy nay ñang thoåi."—A Japanese obtaining enlightenment but saying obtaining                  term, literally means "Anthology of the Mad

Cloud"; anthology of the poetry of the Japanese         Phaät Hoïc Töø Ñieån, ñaây laø con vua A Duïc teân Zen master Ikkyu-Sojun, who gave himself the            Dharmavivardhana, maø con trai teân Sampadi ñaõ literary name "Mad Cloud." The poems collected          trôû thaønh ngöôøi keá vò vua A Duïc. Theo truyeàn here are written in the Chinese style; in them          thuyeát Phaät giaùo, Ñaït Ma Baø Ñaø Na tin saâu vaøo Ikkyu celebrates the great Zen masters of ancient       nhaân quaû neân khoâng bao giôø baùo caùo vôùi vua cha times, laments with biting mockery the decline of       nhöõng khoå hình maø ngöôøi dì gheû ñaõ ñaøy ñoïa oâng— Zen in the Japan of his times, castigates corrupt       According to Professor Soothill in The Dictionary priests and their foibles and compares their            of Chinese-English Buddhist Terms, this was the lifestyle to his own nonconformist life, which          name of Dharmavivardhana, son of Asoka, whose spanned the worlds of hermitage and brothel. The        son Sampadi became the successor of Asoka. poems about his lover the blind serving-woman           According to Buddhist legends, Dharma-vardhana Shin, are among the most beautiful erotic poems         deeply believed in the law of cause and effect; so in Japanese literature. A typical poem from the         he never reported to his father what his "Kyoun-shu" is as follows: "The status and wealth       stepmother tortured him. of the Zen world is great,       Horrendous is its      Cö Nguï: To dwell—To reside. decline. Naught but false priests,         No true      Cö Nhaân Haïnh: Haïnh cuûa ngöôøi taïi gia—The masters. One should get hold of a boatpole. And         virtue of the lay disciple. become a fisherman. On the lakes and rivers.            Cö Noät (1010-1071): Zen master Ji-Nui—Teân cuûa These day, a fresh headwind is blowing."                moät vò Thieàn sö Trung Hoa, Thieàn phaùi Vaân Moân Cuoàng Voïng: Crazy ambition.                           vaøo thôøi nhaø Toáng—Name of a Chinese Zen Cö: See Cö Nguï.                                        master, of the Yun-meân lineage, in the Sung Cö Chuùng: Cuøng vôùi ñaïi chuùng trong thieàn vieän    dynasty (960-1279). tham thieàn—To meditate with everybody in a Zen         Cö Só: Grhapati or Kulampuriso (p)—Kulapati or monastery.                                              Kulapurusha (skt)—Caâu La Baùt Ñeå—Ca La Cö Ñænh (?-1404): Zen master Ji-T'ing—Teân cuûa         Vieät—A chief (head) of a family—A landlord— moät vò Thieàn sö Trung Hoa doøng Laâm Teá vaøo thôøi   Householder—The master of a household—Lay nhaø Minh—Name of a Chinese Zen master, of the          devotee—Lay people—Secular people—Vò Phaät Lin-chi lineage, in the Ming dynasty (1368-1644).       töû taïi gia nam hay nöõ, vaãn ôû nhaø maø giöõ 8 giôùi. Cö Ñoän Thieàn Sö: Ryuge Kodon (jap)—Lung-ya            Phaät giaùo khoâng ñoøi hoûi ngöôøi cö só taïi gia taát caû Chu-tun—See Long Nha Cö Ñoän Thieàn Sö.                 nhöõng ñieàu maø moät thaønh vieân cuûa Taêng ñoaøn Cö Giaùc Sinh: Ji-Jie-Seng (chi)—Teân cuûa moät vò      phaûi coù traùch nhieäm gìn giöõ. Nhöng duø laø vò sö hay cö só Trung Hoa ôû tænh Hoà Baéc vaøo theá kyû thöù     cö só, chaùnh haïnh cuõng laø neàn taûng cô baûn cho con XX—Name of a Chinese lay-person in Hu-bei               ñöôøng höôùng thöôïng. Moät ngöôøi trôû thaønh Phaät töû Province in the twentieth century.                      baèng caùch thoï Tam Quy, ít nhaát hoï cuõng phaûi gìn Cö Giaûn (1164-1264): Zen master Ji-Jian—Teân           giöõ naêm giôùi caên baûn, ñöôïc coi laø khôûi ñieåm cuûa cuûa moät vò Thieàn sö Trung Hoa doøng Laâm Teá vaøo    ñaïo loä giaûi thoaùt. Nguõ giôùi naày khoâng haïn cuoäc thôøi nhaø Toáng—Name of a Chinese Zen master,          trong moät ngaøy ñaëc bieät hay nôi ñaëc bieät naøo, maø of the Lin-chi lineage, in the Sung dynasty (960-       caàn phaûi ñöôïc thöïc haønh suoát ñôøi duø ôû ñaâu vaø baát 1279).                                                  cöù luùc naøo—Laymen or laywomen who remain at Cö Hoái Ñaïi Quang Thieàn Sö: Ta-kuang Chu-hui          home and observe the eight commandments. —See Ñaïi Quang Cö Hoái Thieàn Sö.                      Buddhism does not demand of the lay follower all Cö Kính: Master Ji-Ching—Teân cuûa moät vò Taêng        that a member of the Order is expected to Trung Hoa vaøo thôøi nhaø Minh—Name of a                observe. But whether monk or layman, moral Chinese monk in the Ming dynasty (1368-1644).           habits are essential to the upward path. One who Cö Luaân: Ajnata-Kaudinya (skt)—A Nhaõ Kieàu            becomes a Buddhist by taking the three refuges is Traàn Nhö.                                              expected, at least, to observe the five basic Cö Na La: Kunala (skt)—Ñaït Ma Baø Ñaø Na—              precepts which is the very starting point on the Phaùp Ích—Theo Giaùo Sö Soothill trong Trung Anh        path. They are not restricted to a particular day or

place, but are to be practiced throughout life                 accomplish their wish—See Tam Thaäp Nhò ÖÙng everywhere, always.                                            Thaân. Cö Só Ñaàu Troïc: Shaven-headed laymen—Thieàn                  Cö Söông: Moät caùi röông nhoû ñeå ñoà laët vaët, ñöôïc sö Sô Thaïch Moäng Sôn (1275-1316) ñaõ töøng leân              ñaët beân caïnh choã ngoài cuûa vò Taêng—A small trunk tieáng dieãn taû moät caùch mieät thò caùc vò Taêng daønh      for miscellaneous things, placed next to the thì giôø cuûa hoï cho caùc noã löïc vaên chöông nhö vaäy       monk's seat. laø nhöõng "cö só ñaàu troïc," nhöõng ngöôøi maø Sö xeáp       Cö Taùt La: Kausala (skt)—Kosala (skt)—Coøn goïi döôùi cuøng trong haøng moân ñeä cuûa mình—Zen                 laø Caâu Taùt La, hay Caâu Sa La—See Kieàu Taùt La. master Muso Soseki scornfully described monks                  Cö Traàn Laïc Ñaïo: Taking Delight in Religion who devoted their time to poetry and literary                  While Dwelling in the World—Cö Traàn Laïc Ñaïo, endeavors as mere "shaven-headed laymen" who                   teân cuûa moät baøi phuù ñöôïc Vua Traàn Nhaân Toâng, vò ranked below the lowest of his disciples.                      Sô Toå cuûa Thieàn phaùi Truùc Laâm, saùng taùc vaøo theá Cö Só Ñoã Töø: A silent lay devotee—Trong kinh                 kyû thöù XIII. Ñoái vôùi Thieàn sö Traàn Nhaân Toâng Duy Ma Caät, khi ngaøi Vaên Thuø Sö Lôïi hoûi oâng             (1258-1308), bí quyeát cuûa ñôøi soáng haïnh phuùc vaø Duy Ma Caät raèng: “Chuùng toâi ai ai cuõng noùi roài,         thaønh coâng laø phaûi laøm nhöõng gì caàn laøm ngay töø ñeán löôït nhaân giaû noùi theá naøo laø Boà Taùt vaøo phaùp   baây giôø, khi ñoùi thì aên, khi khaùt thì uoáng, meät thì moân khoâng hai?” OÂng Duy Ma Caät im laëng khoâng             nguû, chöù ñöøng lo laéng veà quaù khöù cuõng nhö töông noùi moät lôøi. Baáy giôø Ngaøi Vaên Thuø Sö Lôïi khen         lai. Chuùng ta khoâng theå trôû laïi taùi taïo ñöôïc quaù raèng: “Hay thay! Hay thay! Cho ñeán khoâng coù vaên           khöù vaø cuõng khoâng theå tieân lieäu moïi thöù coù theå töï ngöõ ngoân, ñoù môùi thaät laø vaøo phaùp moân khoâng      xaõy ra cho töông lai. Chæ coù khoaûng thôøi gian maø hai.”—In the Vimalakirti Sutra, Manjusri asked                 chuùng ta coù theå phaàn naøo kieåm soaùt ñöôïc, ñoù laø Vimalakirti: “All of us have spoken; please tell us            hieän taïi. Tính chaát troïng yeáu cuûa Thieàn phaùi Truùc what is the Bodhisattva’s initiation into the non-             Laâm laø ôû choã chuù troïng vaøo vieäc tu taäp noäi taâm dual Dharma.” Vimalakirti kept silent without                  trong baát cöù hoaøn caûnh naøo maø coù ngöôøi coù theå saying a word. At that, Manjusri exclaimed:                    gaëp trong cuoäc soáng. Ñoù laø caùch tu höôùng noäi “Excellent, excellent! Can there be true initiation            (bieän taâm) cho ngöôøi Phaät töû, baát keå laø Taêng Ni into the non-dual Dharma until words and speech                hay Phaät töû taïi gia. Caùch tu taäp naøy ñöôïc dieãn taû are no longer written or spoken?”                              roõ raøng nhaát trong baøi phuù coù töïa ñeà laø "Cö Traàn Cö Só Nam: Upasaka (p & skt)—Caän söï nam—                     Laïc Ñaïo". Vua Traàn Nhaân Toâng thöôøng nhaéc nhôû Layman—See Upasaka.                                            moïi ngöôøi baèng phaàn keát luaän cuûa baøi keä sau ñaây: Cö Só Nöõ: Upasika (p & skt)—Caän söï nöõ—                              “Cö traàn laïc ñaïo thaû tuøy duyeân, Laywoman—See Upasika.                                                    Cô taéc xan heà khoán taéc mieân, Cö Só Thuaàn Thaønh: Devout layman—Sincere                               Gia trung höõu baûo höu taàm mích, layman.                                                                  Ñoái caûnh voâ taâm maïc vaán thieàn.” Cö Só Truyeän: Truyeän bieân soaïn tieåu söû haønh                      (ÔÛ traàn vui ñaïo haõy tuøy duyeân, traïng cuûa nhöõng Phaät töû taïi gia heát loøng vì ñaïo (do             Ñoùi ñeán thì aên,meät nguû lieàn. Baønh Teá Thanh ñôøi nhaø Thanh bieân soaïn)—A                           Trong nhaø coù baùu thoâi tìm kieám, compilation giving biography of many devout                              Ñoái caûnh khoâng taâm chôù hoûi thieàn). Buddhists.                                                     Thaät vaäy, neáu chuùng ta coù theå soáng troïn veïn theo Cö Só ÖÙng Thaân: The body of an upasaka—Theo                  lôøi daïy cuûa thieàn sö Traàn Nhaân Toâng, laø chuùng ta Kinh Thuû Laêng Nghieâm, quyeån Saùu, Ñöùc Quaùn               coù theå soáng vôùi nöôùc chöù khoâng soáng vôùi nhöõng Theá AÂm Boà Taùt ñaõ baïch tröôùc Phaät veà vieäc öùng        ñôït soùng sanh roài dieät; soáng vôùi taùnh saùng cuûa thaân laøm Cö Só noùi phaùp, khieán cho chuùng sanh            göông chöù khoâng soáng vôùi caùc aûnh ñeán roài ñi; soáng ñöôïc thaønh töïu—According to The Surangama                   vôùi töï taùnh cuûa taâm chöù khoâng soáng vôùi caùc nieäm Sutra, book Six, Avalokitesvara Bodhisattva                    sanh dieät. Nhö vaäy chuùng ta coù theå goïi cuoäc soáng vowed in front of the Buddha about his                         cuûa chuùng ta laø gì neáu khoâng phaûi laø Nieát Baøn? appearance as an upasaka before sentient beings                Theá giôùi maø chuùng ta ñang soáng laø theá giôùi Ta Baø, and speak Dharma for them, enabling them to                    nôi maø chuùng ta nhìn thaáy söï sanh dieät cuûa moïi

hieän töôïng thì laøm sao chuùng ta coù theå noùi taát caû       teachings of Zen master Traàn Nhaân Toâng, we are caùc phaùp khoâng sanh khoâng dieät ñöôïc? Haønh giaû            able to live with the water, not with the waves neân nhôù raèng moät khi ñaõ quyeát chí tu trì theo Phaät,       risign and falling; live with the nature of mirror to chuùng ta phaûi laéng nghe lôøi daïy cuûa Phaät vaø chö          reflect, not with the images appearing and Toå, phaûi nhìn vaøo beân trong ñeå thaáy ñöôïc chôn             disappearing; and live with the essence of the taâm cuûa mình, chöøng ñoù mình môùi coù khaû naêng              mind, not with the thoughts arising and vanishing. thaáy ñöôïc chö phaùp baát sanh baát dieät. Haõy nhìn            Therefore, what can we call our life if not a vaøo taâm mình vaø haõy thaønh thaät vôùi chính mình,            Nirvana? The world we are living now is the Saha roài thì mình seõ coù theå thaáy baûn chaát cuûa moïi vaät laø   World, where we physically see all phenomena troáng roãng vaø baát sanh baát dieät. Caùc nieäm ñeán roài      born and passed away, how can we say ‘all ñi, nhöng taùnh ‘thaáy bieát’ cuûa taâm luoân baát ñoäng—        phenomena are unborn and undying’? Zen Taking Delight in Religion While Dwelling in the                 practitioners should always remember once we World, name of a Hymn which was composed in                      make up our mind to follow the Buddha’s Path, we the thirteenth century by King Tran Nhan Tong,                   should listen to the Buddha’s and Patriarchs’ the First Truc Lam Patriarch. It was king Tran                   teachings; we should look inward to see our real Nhan Tong who was able to utilize the potential of               mind, then we will have the ability to see that ‘all Buddhism to serve his country and people. The                    phenomena are unborn and undying’. Let’s look fact of king Tran Nhan Tong’s renunciation and                   into our mind and be honest with ourselves, then his years of practicing meditation and spreading                 we can see the real nature of everything: Buddhism all over the country made the Truc Lam                  emptiness, unborn and undying. The thoughts Zen Sect strong enough to support the entire                     coming and going, but the nature of ‘seeing and dynasty. For Zen master Traàn Nhaân Toâng, the                   knowing’ of the mind is unmoved. secret of happy, successful living lies in doing                 Cö Truù Baát Tònh: The impurity of its dwelling— what needs to be done now; when hungry, just eat;                Thai nhi naèm trong buïng meï, laø nôi khoâng tònh— when htirsty, just drink; when tired, just sleep; and            The embryo dwells in the mother’s womb which is not worrying about the past and the future. We                   not pure. cannot go back into the past and reshape it, nor                 Cö Xöû: To behave—To conduct oneself. can we anticipate everything that may happen in                  Cöù: To lay hold of. the future. There is one moment of time over                     Cöù Hôïp: Giaûn löôïc ngöõ (lôøi noùi giaûn löôïc hay ñôn which we have some conscious control and that is                 giaûn hoùa)—Simplified speeches. the present. What is essential of Truc Lam Ch'an                 Cöù Khoaûn Keát AÙn: Caên cöù vaøo moät soá ñieåm then Buddhism is that it lays the emphasis on the                     choát maø keát thuùc coâng aùn. Theo Bích Nham Luïc, mental cultivation in whatever condition one may                 taéc 1, Thieàn sö Tuyeát Ñaäu chæ duøng boán caâu tuïng live. It is a mind-oriented training for every                   ñuû ñeå quyeát ñònh moät coâng aùn. Phaøm tuïng coå chæ Buddhist, whether he is a monk, or she is a nun, or              laø “nhieãu loä noùi Thieàn,” hay giaûng veà Thieàn moät a lay person. This way of practicing the Dharma is               caùch loanh quanh; coøn nieâm coå ñaïi cöông noùi laø best expressed in a hymn titled "Taking Delight in               “cöù ai keát aùn”, töùc laø caên cöù vaøo nhöõng ñieåm then Religion While Dwelling in the World". King Tran                 choát ñeå keát thuùc coâng aùn maø thoâi —Based on some Nhan Tong always reminded his disciples with the                 key points to conclude a koan. According to the conclusion of the verses:                                        Pi-Yen-Lu, case 1, Zen master Hsueh-tou just “Living in the world, happy with the Way.                     used four lines to settle the entire public case. We should let all things take their course.                 Generally speaking, eulogies of the Ancients When hungry, just eat; when tire, just sleep.               express Zen in a roundabout way, picking out the The treasure is in our house; do not search                 main principles of the old story, settling the case any more.                                                   on the basis of the facts, and that is all. Face the scenes, and have no thoughts,                      Cöù Nha Ñòa Nguïc: Ñòa Nguïc Cöù Nha, nôi toäi Then we do not need to ask for Zen.”                        nhaân bò haønh hình baèng caùch cöa raêng—Hell of In fact, if we can completely live with the                      Sawing Teeth.

Cöø Khoâi: Outstanding.                                         of all things. This is a clear realization in which Cöû: 1) Neâu leân: To raise (a thing, a matter,                 practitioners open the mind’s eye and awakening subject, etc.); 2) Keå laïi: To reiterate, to relate; 3)        to one’s True-nature and hence of the nature of all Tieán cöû Taêng taøi: To recommend talented monks;              existence. 4) Toaøn theå: All, the whole.                                  Cöû Thò: Cöû Höôùng—See Cöû Xöôùng. Cöû Ai: Bi ai (toaøn theå ñaïi chuùng ñeán tröôùc baøn thôø     Cöû Toïa: Audience—Hearer. cuûa vò hoøa thöôïng vöøa môùi vieân tòch, ñoàng xöôùng         Cöû Tôï: Cöû Höôùng—Cöû Thò—See Cöû Xöôùng. leân ba tieán Ai! Ai! Ai!)—Mourn.                               Cöû Töï: To raise a topic with words—Ngoân ngöõ Cöû Gia: Toaøn gia—The whole family.                            vaãn ñuùng, nghóa laø duøng ngoân ngöõ ñeå hieåu chaân yù Cöû Haønh: To obey and do the Buddha’s teaching.                cuûa Phaät vaø chö toå ñeå tu taäp giaùc ngoä. Nhôù raèng Cöû Haùt: Heùt—To give a loud sharp cry.                        neáu chaáp chaët vaøo vaên töï ngoân ngöõ coù theå maát ñi Cöû Höôùng: See Cöû Xöôùng.                                     chaân yù. Vì lyù do naày maø haønh giaû tu Thieàn chuùng Cöû Kinh: Ngöôøi lôùn tieáng xöôùng teân kinh—A                 ta phaûi luoân 'döïa vaøo nghóa chöù khoâng phaûi ôû töø person who announces the title of the sutra in a                ngöõ'—It is alright to utilize words and speeches; loud voice.                                                     however, practitioners should always remember Cöû Leã: To celebrate—To begin to celebrate.                    that to use words and speeches to get the correct Cöû Muïc Döông My: Nhöõng ñoäng taùc nhö ngöôùc                 instructions from the Buddha and patriarchs, so maét hay nhöôùng maøy ñeàu laø nhöõng thuû thuaät linh          that we can cultivate to attain enlightenment. lôïi cuûa thieàn sö trong vieäc giaùo daãn ñoà ñeä —            Remember if we totally attach to words and we Raising the eyes and wrinkling the eyebrows are                 can miss the real meanings of the Buddha. For this lively expedient tricks of welcoming and leading                reason, we, Zen practitioners, must always 'relying disciples.                                                      on the meaning and not on the words.' Cöû Nhaân: Ngöôøi ñaõ hoaøn taát baèng Ñaïi Hoïc boán           Cöû Xöôùng: 1) Neâu ra moät coâng aùn: To present a naêm—One who has finished four-year college                     koan; 2) Tuyeân Löu, hoaèng hoùa giaùo phaùp: To degree.                                                         spread abroad, widespread. Cöû Nhaát Minh Tam: Neâu moät bieát ba, duï cho söï             Cöõ: To abstain hieån baøy thuû thuaät linh lôïi trong vieäc giaùo daãn ñeä     Cöï: Lôùn—Nhieàu—Great. töû nhaø thieàn. Noùi caùch khaùc, moät khi ñöôïc vò thieàn     Cöï Coâng: Vieäc lôùn, duï cho söï tu haønh—Great sö khôi gôïi ngöôøi hoïc lieàn laõnh hoäi hoaøn toaøn yeáu      work, i.e., cultivation. chæ nhaø thieàn—To bring up one, but to get three,              Cöï Danh: Great reputation. i.e., lively expedient tricks of welcoming and                  Cöï Ñaïi Thaønh Töïu: Thaønh töïu lôùn, duï cho söï leading disciples. In other words, practitioners                giaùc ngoä—Great achievement, i.e., enlightenment. obtain an absolute comprehension of the important               Cöï Ích: Lôïi ích lôùn lao—Great benefit. meaning or aim of Zen in just one conversation                  Cöï Ma: Gomaya (skt)—Phaân boø—Cow-dung. with the master—See Ñeä Nhaát Nghóa Ñeá (2).                    Cöï Nhieân: Master Ji-Ran—Teân cuûa moät danh Cöû Taéc: Cöû Höôùng—Cöû Thò—Cöû Tôï—See Cöû                    Taêng kieâm hoïa só danh tieáng Trung Hoa vaøo thôøi Xöôùng.                                                         nhaø Ñöôøng—Name of a Chinese monk and a Cöû Theå Baát Tònh: Trong lôùp da ngoaøi che ñaäy               famous painter in the T'ang dynasty (618-907). thaân naày laø taát caû söï hoâi nhô cuûa caùc chaát, thòt,     Cöï Phaùch: Eminent person. xöông, maùu, ñaøm, ñaïi, tieåu, vaân vaân—Inside a thin         Cöï Taùn (1908-1984): Master Ji-Tsan—Teân cuûa layer of skin, the body contains nothing but flesh,             moät danh Taêng Trung Hoa ôû Giang Toâ vaøo theá kyû bones, blood, sputum, urine, and stool, etc.                    thöù XX—Name of a Chinese famous monk in Cöû Theå Loä Ñöôøng Ñöôøng: Vaïn höõu hieån loä roõ             Jiang-Ssu Province in the twentieth century. raøng, yù chæ söï theå nghieäm hoaøn toaøn thöïc taùnh cuûa     Cöï Teá: To vaø nhoû—Great and small size. vaïn höõu. Ñaây laø söï toû ngoä thieàn, trong ñoù haønh giaû   Cöï Thöôûng Di: Kausambi (skt)—Kosambi or töï môû maét taâm, ñeå bieát roõ baûn taùnh vaø do ñoù bieát    Vatsa-pattana (p)—Caâu Dieãm Di—Caâu La Cuø— roõ baûn taùnh cuûa cuoäc sinh toàn—All things manifest         Vöông quoác cuûa vua Udayana vôùi kinh ñoâ noåi clearly, i.e., to experience thoroughly the reality

tieáng ñöôïc ghi laïi trong Taây Vöïc Kyù. Nôi coù moät      thaâm. Ngaøi khoâng thoûa maõn vôùi nhöõng tö töôûng hình töôïng Phaät thaät lôùn. Ñaây laø moät trong nhöõng     cuûa caùc tö töôûng gia ñöông thôøi. Coù moät soá nhìn thaønh phoá coå nhöùt cuûa AÁn Ñoä—The country of            cuoäc soáng treân theá gian queân raèng nhöõng thaát baïi King Udayana in “Central India” with a famous                vaø thaát voïng coøn ñang chôø neân hoï luoân nhìn ñôøi capital mentioned in the Vogage to the West.                 baèng caëp maét yeâu ñôøi vaø laïc quan. Moät soá khaùc laïi There was a great image of the Buddha. It was                nhìn ñôøi baèng bi quan thoáng khoå thì hoï laïi boû qua one of the most ancient cities of India.                     nhöõng caûm giaùc baát toaïi vôùi cuoäc ñôøi, nhöng khi Cöï Tröôùc: Tuyeät taùc—Great masterpiece.                   hoï baét ñaàu boû qua cuoäc soáng voâ voïng naøy ñeå thöû Cöï Töôøng (1662-1695): Zen master Ji-Hsiang—                tìm loái thoaùt cho mình baèng caùch eùp xaùc khoå haïnh, Teân cuûa moät vò Thieàn sö Trung Hoa, Thieàn phaùi          thì hoï laïi ñaùng kinh tôûm hôn. Ñöùc Phaät daïy raèng Laâm Teá vaøo thôøi nhaø Thanh—Name of a Chinese             phaûi traùnh xa caû hai cöïc ñoan höôûng laïc vaø khoå Zen master, of the Lin-chi lineage, in the Ch'ing            haïnh, vaø trung ñaïo môùi laø con ñöôøng lyù töôûng ñeå dynasty (1644-1912).                                         theo. Ñieàu ñoù khoâng coù nghóa laø chæ caàn traùnh xa Cöûa Ñòa Nguïc: Gates of the hells.                          hai thaùi cöïc vaø ñi theo con ñöôøng trung ñaïo nhö laø Cöûa Giaûi Thoaùt: Theo Phaät giaùo Ñaïi thöøa, cöûa         con ñöôøng duy nhaát coøn laïi ñeå troán chaïy cuoäc ñôøi. giaûi thoaùt cuûa Boà Taùt naèm ngay beân trong töï taùnh,   Maø ñuùng hôn laø ta phaûi sieâu vieät chuùng, chöù khoâng chöù khoâng phaûi beân ngoaøi. Cöûa môû roäng baèng tu       phaûi chaïy troán moät caùch ñôn giaûn caû hai cöïc ñoan taäp Luïc Ba La Maät vaø trì giôùi cuï tuùc —The gate of     aáy—The Buddha was a deep thinker. He was not diliverence—Door of liberation—According to the              satisfied with the ideas of his contemporary Mahayana Buddhism, Bodhisattva door of                       thinkers. Those who regard this earthly life as liberation is within our self-nature, not outside.           pleasant or optimists are ignorant of the The door open through practice, cultivation of the           disappointment and despair which are to come. paramitas and holding the complete precepts.                 Those who regard this life as a life of suffering or Cöûa Khoâng: Pagoda—Temple—Monastery                         pessimists may be tolerated as long as they are Cöûa Khoång: Confucianist School                             simply feeling dissatisfied with this life, but when Cöûa Phaät: Pagoda.                                          they begin to give up this life as hopeless and try Cöûa Thaùnh: Saint door.                                     to escape to a better life by practicing austerities Cöûa Thieân Ñaøng: The gates of heaven.                      or self-mortifications, then they are to be Cöûa Thieàn: Pagoda—Zen door—Zen gate.                       abhorred. The Buddha taught that the extremes of both hedonism and asceticism are to be avoided Cöïc: 1) Cöïc bieân: Extreme; 2) Cöïc ñieåm, ñieåm and that the middle course should be followed as cao nhaát: Highest point, apex; 3) Cöïc ñoä: Utmost, the ideal. This does not mean that one should ultimate. simply avoid both extremes and take the middle Cöïc AÙi Nhaát Töû Ñòa: Giai vò Boà Taùt ñaõ chöùng course as the only remaining course of escape. quaû saün saøng giaùo hoùa quaàn sanh—The stage and Rather, one should transcend, not merely escape position in which a Bodhisattva is ready to teach from such extremes. and convert or transform men. Cöïc Ñoä: Extremely—Highest degree. Cöïc Dieäu: Cöïc kyø huyeàn dieäu—Of utmost beauty, Cöïc Giaùc: Teân khaùc cuûa Dieäu giaùc—Profound wonder, or mystery. enlightenment, or utmost awareness—See Dieäu Cöïc Dieäu Thieân: Vrhatphala (skt)—Heaven of Giaùc. existence rewards—See Quaûng Quaû Thieân. Cöïc Haûo AÂm: Beautiful voice. Cöïc Ñòa: Ñaït ñöôïc vò trí cao nhaát trong taát caû, nhö Cöïc Hyû Ñòa: Pramudita-bhumi (skt)—Coøn goïi laø Phaät—Reaching the ground; utmost; fundamental Hoan Hyû Ñòa, ñòa thöù nhaát trong Thaäp Ñòa Boà Taùt principle; the highest of all, i.e. Buddha. (Boà Taùt sau khi ñaõ hoaøn thaønh tu haønh trong ñeä Cöïc Ñoan Ñam Meâ Laïc Thuù: The extreme of nhaát A taêng kyø, töø voâ thuûy ñeán nay, giôø môùi phaùt indulgence in pleasure. ra chaân voâ laäu maø ñaït ñeán lyù nhaát phaàn nhò khoâng, Cöïc Ñoan Vaø Trung Ñaïo: Extremes and the döùt boû heát phieàn naõo phaân bieät, nhaân ñoù maø lìa boû Middle Path—Ñöùc Phaät laø moät tö töôûng gia uyeân ñöôïc caùi tính phaøm phu, trôû thaønh Boà Taùt phaùp

thaân, ôû vaøo ngoâi vò cöïc sinh hoan hyû ñòa)—The       invincibility—The stage of mastery of utmost or stage of utmost joy, the first of the ten stages of       final difficulties—Giai ñoaïn haønh giaû vöôït thaéng Bodhisattva—See Thaäp Ñòa.                                moïi aûo töôûng cuoái cuøng cuûa voâ minh. Caûnh giôùi Cöïc Laïc: Shukhavati (skt)—Sukhavati (skt)—              lieãu ngoä ñöôïc töù ñeá vaø chaân nhö. Haøng thöù naêm Extremely happy, ultimate Bliss, highest joy—             trong Thaäp Ñòa Boà Taùt, coøn goïi laø Nan Thaéng Ñòa. Supreme happiness—Teân moät coõi Phaät, quoác ñoä         Giai ñoaïn Boà taùt vöôït thaéng moïi khoù khaên vaø cuûa Ñöùc Phaät A Di Ñaø, coøn goïi laø Taây Phöông       phieàn naõo cuoái cuøng. Trong giai ñoaïn naày, Boà Taùt Tònh Ñoä, coøn goïi laø An Döôõng, An Laïc, Voâ Löôïng    phaùt huy tinh thaàn bình ñaúng ñoàng nhaát vaø ñaém Thanh Tònh Ñoä, Voâ Löôïng Quang Minh Ñoä, Voâ            mình vaøo thieàn ñònh, ñaït ñöôïc söï vieân maõn cuûa Löôïng Thoï Phaät Ñoä, Lieân Hoa Taïng Theá Giôùi,        thieàn ñònh nhaèm ñaït ñöôïc nhaän thöùc tröïc giaùc veà Maät Nghieâm Quoác, hay Thanh Thaùi Quoác: name           chaân lyù, hieåu ñöôïc töù ñeá, töø boû moïi hoaøi nghi vaø of the Land of Ultimate Bliss, or the Pure Land of        do döï, bieát phaân bieät ñuùng sai, trong khi vaãn tieáp Amitabha in the West—See A Di Ñaø.                        tuïc hoaøn thieän ba möôi baûy phaåm trôï ñaïo (trong Cöïc Laïc Baùo Hoùa: See Nhò Ñoä (A).                     giai ñoaïn naày Boà Taùt thuaän nhaãn tu ñaïo, caù c loaïi Cöïc Laïc Hoùa Sanh: Vaõng sanh vaøo coõi Cöïc Laïc       voâ minh, nghi kieán cuûa tam giôùi, heát thaûy ñeàu thaáy baèng caùch hoùa sanh qua Lieân Hoa—Birth in the          laø khoâng)—The stage of overcoming final happy land of Amitabha by formation throught the          illusions of darkness. The fifth stage, the stage of Lotus.                                                    mastery of utmost or final difficulties, or illusions Cöïc Laïc Quoác Ñoä: The Land of Ultimate Bliss.          of darkness, or ignorance. In this stage, the Cöïc Laïc Quoác Ñoä Thaønh Töïu: The realization          Bodhisattva develops the spirit of sameness and (achievement) of the land of ultimate bliss.              absorbs himself in meditation, gets the perfection Cöïc Laïc Theá Giôùi: Sukhavati (skt)—Dieäu Laïc          of meditative concentration, in order to achieve an Theá Giôùi—Lieân Hoa Taïng Theá Giôùi—The world           intuitive grasp of the truth, to understand the four of utmost joy—See Cöïc Laïc.                              noble truths, to clear away doubt and uncertainty, Cöïc Laïc Theá Giôùi A Di Ñaø Phaät: Amitabha             to know what is proper and what is not. During this Buddha of the Land of Ultimate Bliss.                     stage Bodhisattva continues to work on the Cöïc Laïc Töï: Gokuraku-ji (jap)—Pure Land                perfection of the thierty-seven requisites of temple—Land of utmost bliss temple.                       enlightenment. Cöïc Laïp: Vò Taêng coù tuoåi haï laïp cao nhaát trong    Cöïc Nhieät Ñòa Nguïc: Pratapana, or giaùo ñoaøn—The oldest monk in the orders (highest        Mahapratapana (skt)—Ñòa nguïc noùng nhaát, ñòa number of years in the orders).                           nguïc thöù baûy trong taùm ñòa nguïc noùng—The Cöïc Loøng: Despair.                                      hottest hell, the seventh of the eight hells. Cöïc Löïc: Energetically—Strongly—With the                Cöïc Nieát Baøn: Abhinirvana (skt)—Abhinibbuta utmost effort.                                            (p)—Complete serenity and passionlessness— Cöïc Löôïc Saéc: Phaàn töû nhoû nhaát maø vaät theå coù   Ultimate bliss nirvana—Ultimate nirvana. theå ñöôïc phaân taùch, ñoù laø nguyeân töû—The           Cöïc Quaû: Supreme fruition—Toái Cöïc Quaû—Vieân smallest perceptible particle into which matter can       Cöïc Quaû—Chöùng quaû cöïc chæ, hay quaû vò giaùc ngoä be divided, an atom.                                      toái thöôïng cuûa Phaät—The highest fruit, perfect Cöïc Löông: Paramiti (skt)—Baùt Laït Maät Ñeá—            Buddha-enlightenment. Moät vò Taêng ngöôøi Trung AÁn, ñeán Quaûng Chaâu         Cöïc Quang: Osel (tib)—Clear light—Ultimate döôùi thôøi nhaø Ñöôøng. Ngaøi ñaõ dòch boä Kinh Thuû     light. Laêng Nghieâm sang Hoa ngöõ vaøo khoaûng naêm 705         Cöïc Quang Tònh: Utmost light-purity. sau Taây Lòch—A monk from Central India, came             Cöïc Quang Tònh AÂm Thieân: Abhasvara (skt)— to Kuang-Chou, China during the T’ang dynasty.            Pure Heaven of Utmost Light and Sound—Coõi trôøi He translated the Surangama Sutra into Chinese            cao nhaát trong Saéc Giôùi Nhò Thieàn Thieân; coõi ñöôïc around 705 A.D.                                           taùi thaønh laäp ñaàu tieân ngay khi vuõ truï hoaïi dieät, vaø Cöïc Nan Thaéng Ñòa: Sudurjaya (skt)—The land             trong ñoù Phaïm Thieân vaø chö Thieân khaùc ra ñôøi — extremely difficult to conquer, or the ground of          Pure heaven of utmost light, the highest of the

second dhyana heavens of the form-world; the                  Ñöùc Phaät—The highest revered one, Buddha. first to be re-formed after a universal destruction           Cöïc Trí: 1) Dieäu lyù toät cuøng, nguyeân lyù thaâm saâu and in it Brahma and devas come into existence.               nhieäm maàu: Ultimate deep principle, utmost Cöïc Quang Tònh Thieân: Abhasvara-deva (skt)—                 wonderful theory, utmost wondrous principle; 2) A Ba Hoäi Thieân—Quang AÂm Thieân—Utmost                      Trí tueä cao toät, ñieåm ñeán cao toät cuûa haønh giaû: Light Purity Heaven—Coøn goïi laø Cöïc Quang AÂm              Utmost wisdom, an ultimate or final point for Thieân, coõi trôøi cao nhaát trong Saéc Giôùi Nhò Thieàn      practitioner to reach to. Thieân; coõi ñöôïc taùi thaønh laäp ñaàu tieân ngay khi vuõ   Cöïc Troïng Nghieäp: Garuka-kamma (p)—Serious truï hoaïi dieät, vaø trong ñoù Phaïm Thieân vaø chö          karma—Weighty karma—See Troïng Nghieäp. Thieân khaùc ra ñôøi. Ñaây laø moät trong nhöõng coõi trôøi   Cöïc Troïng Thuïy Mieân: Thuïy mieân hay buoàn nguõ thuoäc coõi Nhò Thieàn Thieân. Trong Kinh Thuû Laêng          traàm troïng laøm môø mòt taâm trí (taâm trôû neân tieâu Nghieâm, quyeån Chín, nhöõng ngöôøi haáp thuï vaø giöõ        cöïc, thuï ñoäng khi buoàn nguû coù maët, moät trong gìn caùi aùnh saùng hoaøn toaøn, thaønh töïu ñöôïc giaùo      nhöõng baát ñònh phaùp taùc ñoäng vaøo taâm thaàn laøm theå, phaùt ra söï hoùa ñaïo thanh tònh, öùng duïng voâ       cho noù aùm muoäi, maát söï tri giaùc)—Serious or cuøng. Goïi laø trôøi Quang AÂm hay Cöïc Quang Tònh           severe dullness and drowsiness. Thieân—Pure heaven of utmost light, the highest of            Cöïc Vi: Paramanu (skt)—Cöïc Teá Traàn, Cöïc Vi the second dhyana heavens of the form-world; the              Traàn—An atom—See Cöïc Vi Traàn. first to be re-formed after a universal destruction           Cöïc Vi Traàn: Paramanu (skt)—Fine motes of and in it Brahma and devas come into existence.               dust—Coøn goïi laø Cöïc Teá Traàn, Cöïc Vi Traàn, caùch This is one of the sublevels of the Second Dhyana             dòch cuõ laø Laân Hö, moät nguyeân töû hay laø ñôn vò Heaven. In the Surangama Sutra, book Nine, those              vaät chaát phaân tích ñeán nhoû nhaát, khoâng theå phaân who take in and hold the light to perfection                  chia ñöôïc nöõa, chæ ñöôïc nhìn thaáy baèng maét chö accomplish the substance of the teaching. Crating             Thieân, chöù khoâng thaáy ñöôïc baèng maét ngöôøi and transforming the purity into endless responses            thöôøng. Cho tôùi baây giôø ngöôøi ta vaãn coøn baøn caõi and functions, they are among those in the Light-             veà söï hieän höõu cuûa cöïc vi, coù hieän höõu, coù vónh Sound Heaven or the Utmost Light Purity Heaven.               haèng khoâng thay ñoåi hay khoâng—An atom, Cöïc Quang Tònh Thieân Töû: Abhasvara-deva                    especially as a mental concept, in contrast with a (p)—Inhabitants of the realm of radiance—Nhöõng               material atom which has a centre and the six vò trôøi trong coõi cöïc quang tònh thieân.                   directions, an actual but imperceptible atom, Cöïc Taéc: 1) Cöùu caùnh: Final aim; 2) Tieâu chuaån:         seven atoms make a molecule, the smallest Standard.                                                     perceptible aggregation, called an anu; the Cöïc Thaùnh: Vò Thaùnh cao nhaát, chæ Ñöùc Phaät—             perceptibility is ascribed to the deva-eye rather The highest saint, Buddha.                                    than to the human eye. There is much Cöïc Thaønh: Prasiddha (skt)—Söï thaønh töïu toät             disputationas to whether the ultimate atom has cuøng—Ultimate accomplishment.                                real existence or not, whether it is eternal and Cöïc Thònh: Apogee.                                           immutable and so on. Cöïc Thuïy Mieân: See Cöïc Troïng Thuïy Mieân.                Cöïc Vò: Ngoâi vò chöùng ngoä cao nhaát hay Phaät Cöïc Tinh Taán Danh Xöng Quang Thieân Vöông:                  quaû—The highest stage of enlightenment, that of Light of Fame of extreme Exertion—Vò Thieân                   Buddha. Vöông ñöôïc giaûi thoaùt moân an truï nôi choã töï ngoä,      Cöïc Voâ Töï Taùnh Taâm: Mind of disciples of the maø duøng voâ bieân caûnh giôùi roäng lôùn laøm caûnh sôû     One Vehicle—Nhaát Ñaïo Voâ Vi Taâm—Nhaát Thöøa, duyeân—Who found the door of liberation by                    cho raèng chæ coù moät thöøa laø chaân thaät, giai ñoaïn abiding in his own enlightenment, yet having an               cuûa Hoa Nghieâm vaø Thieân Thai—Mind apart from infinitely broad perspective—See Ñaïi Töï Taïi                all ideas of activity or inactivity. The doctrine of Thieân Vöông.                                                 One Vehicle, holding the one Vehicle as real, the Cöïc Tònh: Thanh tònh cöïc ñoä—Utmost                         stage of Hua-Yen and T’ien-T’ai schools, one of quiescence, or mental repose, meditation, trence.             the ten stages of spiritual development. Cöïc Toân: Baäc Toân tuùc ñaùng toân kính nhaát, hay          Cöôùc: Chaân—Fot—Leg.

Cöôùc Baû: Bò daäp chaân—Vaân Moân bò daäp chaân—              Cöôùc Caân: Caùi goùt chaân, chæ cho söï giaùc ngoä— Yun Men: The leg broke—Theo Caûnh Ñöùc                         The heel, i.e., an enlightenment. Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån XII, Thieàn sö Muïc Chaâu           Cöôùc Caân Ñieåm Ñòa: Goùt chaân chaám ñaát, chæ cho Ñaïo Minh cuõng noåi tieáng veà söï ñaøo taïo nghieâm          söï trieät ngoä—The heel touches the ground, i.e., khaéc cuûa mình ñoái vôùi Vaân Moân Vaên Yeån. Ngöôøi          absolutely complete enlightenment or perfectly ta keå veà Muïc Chaâu raèng oâng luoân luoân nghe              enlightened—See Trieät Ngoä. ngoùng caùnh cöûa ñoùng kính cuûa caên phoøng mình.            Cöôùc Caân Haï: Vieäc döôùi goùt chaân, chæ cho vaïn Khi moät vò Taêng ñeán ñeå xin 'Ñoäc tham', oâng ñoaùn         höõu ôû beân mình hay ôû tröôùc maët mình ñang dieãn tröôùc ñöôïc traïng thaùi yù thöùc cuûa ngöôøi ñoù chæ qua     noùi ñaïo phaùp—Task under one's heel, i.e., tieáng böôùc chaân ñi. Neáu traïng thaùi aáy ñoái vôùi oâng    everything right in front of us is preaching the laø toát, oâng baûo, "Vaøo ñi", roài oâng seõ tuùm laáy ngay   dharma. vò Taêng môùi böôùc vaøo, lay thaät maïnh vaø keâu to,         Cöôùc Caân Haï Baát Minh: Vieäc döôùi goùt chaân maø "Noùi ñi! Noùi ñi!" Neáu vò Taêng ngaäp ngöøng moät            chaúng roõ, chæ cho vieäc chöa roõ boån phaän söï chính chuùt, lieàn bò Muïc Chaâu toáng coå ra khoûi phoøng vaø       cuûa thieàn nhaân laø thaáy töï taùnh cuûa chính mình— ñoùng saàm cöûa laïi. Ñieàu naày ñaõ xaûy ra vôùi Vaân         Not be clear the task under one's heel, i.e., not be Moân Vaên Yeån, nhöng chaân cuûa Vaân Moân laïi bò             clear the main duty of a Zen practitioner is to see keït vaøo cöûa khi Muïc Chaâu ñoùng cöûa laïi. Vaân Moân       into one’s own nature. bò gaãy chaân vaø keâu leân moät tieáng "UÙi da ñau quaù!"     Cöôùc Caân Haï Söï: Vieäc döôùi goùt chaân, chæ vieäc Ngay khi aáy cuõng laø luùc Vaân Moân ñaït ñöôïc ñaïi          boån phaän söï chính cuûa thieàn nhaân laø laøm cho taâm giaùc—According to the Records of the                          giaùc ngoä ñeå thaáy töï taùnh cuûa chính mình vaø ngoä Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu),                     nhaäp töùc thì—Task under one's heel, i.e., the main Volume XII, Mu-chou is known as the strict                     duty of a Zen practitioner is to enlighten the mind master of Yun-men Wen-yen. It is reported                      in order to see into one’s own nature, and to attain concerning Mu-chou that he always kept the door                awakening immediately. of his room shut. If a monk came for a private                 Cöôùc Caân Vò Ñieåm Ñòa: 1) Taâm tính chöa ngoä: consultation (dokusan), Mu-chou was able to                    Unelightened mind; 2) Taâm taùnh khoâng saùng: discern the monk's state of mind by the sound of               Slow-witted mind. his step. If he considered this state of mind                  Cöôùc Ñaïp: See Cöôùc Ñaéng. promising, he called out, "Come in!" grabbed hold              Cöôùc Ñaéng: Ñaéng Töû—Cöôùc Ñaïp—Ñaïp Saøng— of the monk as soon as he entered, shook him, and              Thöøa Tuùc Saøng—Caùi buïc nhoû—A small platform. shouted, "Say it! Say it!" If the monk hesitated               Cöôùc Ñaàu Baï: Soå ghi tieàn cuùng döôøng cuûa taát caû only for an instant, he shoved him out and                     thí chuû—A book of records of donations from all slammed the door behind him. This very sequence                almsgivers. of events befell Yun-men one day, but his leg                  Cöôùc Haï Yeân Sinh: Höôùng Ngoaïi Caàu Phaät— caught the door when Mu-chou slammed it. The                   Höôùng ra ngoaøi tìm Phaät. Trong thieàn, töø naày coù leg broke and Yun-men shouted 'ouch!' with pain.               nghóa laø khoâng thaáy chaân taùnh nhaø mình, laïi chaïy In that very moment he came abruptly to                        ñoâng chaïy taây tìm kieám beân ngoaøi. Chuyeän veà caùi enlightenment.                                                 ñaàu cuûa Dieãn Nhaõ Ñaït Ña. Taïi thaønh Thaát La coù Cöôùc Baùn: Laáy vaûi quaán chaân tröôùc moät cuoäc            ngöôøi cuoàng teân Dieãn Nhaõ Ñaït Ña. Moät buoåi noï haønh trình daøi cuûa caùc vò haønh cöôùc Taêng—To             baø laáy göông soi maët, nhìn thaáy loâng mi vaø maét twine (wind) legs with cloths before a long trip for           hieän ra trong göông, nhöng laïi khoâng thaáy ñöôïc wandering monks.                                               loâng mi vaø maét treân ñaàu cuûa mình neân hoaûng sôï boû Cöôùc Banh: See Cöôùc Baùn.                                    chaïy moät caùch ñieân cuoàng. ÔÛ ñaây maét vaø ñaàu ví Cöôùc Boá: Taám vaûi lau chaân—Foot-towel.                     vôùi chaân tính, taát caû nhöõng gì hieän ra trong göông Cöôùc Cao Cöôùc Ñeâ: Chaân cao chaân thaáp, chæ cho            ñeàu laø voïng töôûng (Dieãn Nhaõ Ñaït Ña möøng khi söï giaùc ngoä khoâng hoaøn toaøn—One foot is shorter          thaáy ñaàu trong göông ví vôùi vieäc chuùng sanh chaáp than the other one, i.e., an incomplete                        voïng laøm chaân, coá chaáp khoâng boû. Khoâng thaáy enlightenment.                                                 mình voán coù ñaàu, treân ñaàu voán coù loâng mi vaø maét

thaät, ñöôïc ví vôùi chaân tính)—To turn outward to          nhau trong toaøn theå—The “eyes” or meshes of a look for Buddha. Yajnadatta, a crazy woman who               net. The term implies the identity of things in the saw her eyebrows and eyes in a mirror but not                whole. seeing them in her own head thought herself                  Cöông Sa Laïc: Samsara (skt)—Doøng luaân hoài bedevilled; the eyes and head are a symbol of                sanh töû—The course of transmigration. reality. Those in the mirror of unreality.                   Cöông         Thöôøng:        Cang      thöôøng—Constant Cöôùc Saéc: Phieáu baùo danh, chæ giaáy lyù lòch maø         obligations of morality—The restraints of moät vò Taêng trình cho vò Duy na khi ñeán moät töï          society—Social nexus. vieän—Name identification paper, implies a                   Cöông Toâng: Cöông yeáu Thieàn toâng—Essentials curriculum vitae (life-s story) paper that a new             of the Zen sect. coming monk must present to a monk who is in                 Cöông Yeáu Nieäm Phaät: Vì söï sanh töû, maø phaùt charge of the pagoda.                                        taâm Boà ñeà vôùi tín nguyeän saâu nieäm trì Hoàng danh Cöông: 1) Cöùng nhaéc: Stiff, rigid; 2) Maïnh meõ raén       Phaät A Di Ñaø cho ñeán luùc vaõng sanh Tònh Ñoä— chaéc: Firm, determined, hard, decided, strong,              The core (kernel) of the Pure Land Method: forceful; 3) Sôïi daây: A net rope, a bond.                  “Because of the birth and death, develop the Cöông Caùch: Kyû cöông pheùp taéc cuûa nhaø Phaät—           Bodhi mind with deep faith and vow to recite Rules and precepts in Buddhism.                              Amitabha Buddha’s name until the time of rebirth Cöông Duy: Vò kieåm soaùt coâng vieäc trong chuøa —          in the Pure Land.” The controller of a monastery.                               Cöôøng: Strong—Forceful—Violent. Cöông Ñòa: Coá yù laøm traùi yeâu caàu—To do                 Cöôøng Löïc: Energy—Power of energy— something opposite intentionally.                            Strength—Moät trong thaäp ñaïi löïc coù theå ñaït ñöôïc Cöông Ñieàn Nghi Phaùp (1882-1961): Teân cuûa                bôûi moät vò Boà Taùt—One of the ten great powers moät vò hoïc giaû Phaät giaùo Nhaät Baûn. Vaøo naêm          obtainable by a Bodhisattva—See Thaäp Löïc Boà 1906, oâng toát nghieäp tröôøng Ñaïi Hoïc cuûa toâng Taøo    Taùt. Ñoäng. Sau khi höu trí, oâng döï tính bieân soaïn hai        Cöôøng Ngaïnh: Stubborn. boä Töø Ñieån laø boä Töø Ñieån Thieàn vaø Thuaät Ngöõ       Cöôøng Nghi Ñaïi Ngoä: The stronger the inquiring Phaät Giaùo vaø Töø Ñieån Chaùnh Phaùp Nhaõn Taïng,          spirit the greater the resulting satori—Trong nhöng oâng maát vaøo naêm 1961 maø chöa hoaøn thaønh         Thieàn, tin vaø nghi khoâng phaûi laø nhöõng töø ngöõ maâu ñöôïc boä töø ñieån naøo. Tuy nhieân, oâng ñaõ vieát vaø     thuaãn; chuùng boå tuùc vaø phuï trôï laãn nhau. Lyù do taïi xuaát baûn nhieàu boä saùch Phaät giaùo raát coù giaù trò—   sao coå nhaân kieân quyeát giöõ vöõng tinh thaàn ñaò nghi Name of a Japanese Buddhist scholar. In 1906, he             trong loái thöïc taäp coâng aùn baây giôø ñaõ coù theå deã graduated from a university of the Ts’ao-Tung                hieåu. Coù leõ hoï khoâng chuù yù ñeán caùi luaän lyù laån School. After retired, he planned to compose a               quaån sau loái giaùo huaán cuûa mình. Söï hieän dieän cuûa Dictionary of Zen & Buddhist Terms and a                     Phaät taùnh chæ coù theå nhaän ra ñöôïc bôûi moät haønh vi Dictionary of The Correct Law Eye-Treasury, but              goõ cöûa lieân hoài vaø caùi goõ naøy haù chaún g phaûi laø doø he passed away in 1961 without finishing none of             loái ñi vaøo hay sao? Nghi hay nghi tình trong Thieàn these two projects; however, he wrote and                    coù nghóa laø "tinh thaàn doø hoûi" thì laïi caøng thích published several valuable Buddhist books.                   ñaùng hôn. Nhö vaäy, cöôøng nghi hay ñaïi nghi coù Cöông Giaø: Soâng Haèng—The Ganges River.                    nghóa laø "söï ngöng chuù kòch lieät cuûa tinh thaàn do Cöông Lónh: Fundamental.                                     cöôøng ñoä maõnh lieät cuûa tinh thaàn doï hoûi." Trong Cöông Löông Da Xaù: Kalayasa (skt)—See Thôøi                 moät böùc thö gôûi ñeä töû cuûa mình, thieàn sö Baïch AÅn Xöùng.                                                       ñaõ vieát: "Trong vieäc hoïc Thieàn, caùi heä troïng nhaát Cöông Löông Laâu Chí: Kalaruci (skt)—Kararuci                laø cöôøng ñoä maõnh lieät cuûa nghi taâm. Vì vaäy, ngöôøi (skt)—Chaân Hyû—Teân cuûa moät vò Taêng AÁn Ñoä              ta noùi nghi maïnh thì ngoä lôùn, vaø coù moä t nghi taâm ñeán Vieät Nam dòch kinh ñieån vaøo khoaûng 255-256          khaù maïnh thì chaéc chaén ñöôïc ngoä lôùn." Laïi nöõa, A.D.—Name of an Indian monk who come to                      theo thieàn sö Phaät Quoác thì loãi laàm lôùn nhaát ñoái Vietnam to translate sutras around 255-256 A.D.              vôùi haønh giaû laø thieáu moät nghi taâm ñaët treân coâng Cöông Muïc: Maét löôùi, duï cho nhöõng phaàn gioáng          aùn. Khi nghi taâm cuûa haønh giaû leân ñeán ñieåm cao

choùt voùt thì coù cô buøng vôõ. Giaû söû nhö coù haøng         resulting from the utmost intensification of an traêm haøng ngaøn haønh giaû nhö vaäy, ta ñoan chaéc            inquiring spirit." In a letter to one of his disciples, moãi ngöôøi ñeàu seõ tôùi choã cöùu caùnh. Thaät vaäy,          Hakuin wrote, "In the study of Zen what is most chính nhôø moái nghi tình boái roái tröôùc ñaây laø nhöõng      important is the utmost intensification of an thaønh phaàn coát yeáu ñaõ ñöa haønh giaû tôùi tieán trình      inquiring spirit. Therefore, it is said that the chöùng ngoä vaø möùc ñoä cuûa söï chöùng ngoä töông hôïp        stronger the inquiring spirit, the greater the vôùi söùc maïnh cuûa nghi tình. Khi thôøi cô cuûa cöôøng        resulting satori, and that a sufficiently strong spirit nghi xuaát hieän, haønh giaû caûm thaáy mình nhö ñang           of inquiry is sure to result in strong satori." ôû giöõa hö khoâng môû roäng caû boán phöông vaø traûi          Further, according to Zen master Fo-kuo, the roäng ñeán voâ taän. Luùc ñoù, haønh giaû khoâng bieát mình     greatest fault with Zen practitioners is the lack of soáng hay cheát; hoï caûm thaáy trong suoát laï thöôøngvaø      an inquiring spirit over the koan. When their döùt khoûi moïi ueá tröôïc, töïa hoà nhö ñang ôû trong          inquiring spirit reaches its highest point of fixation moät caùi boàn pha leâ, hay trong moät khoái baêng cöùng        there is a moment of outburst. If there are a meânh moâng. Laïi y nhö moät ngöôøi maát heát caû m             hundred of such practitioners, or a thousand of giaùc; ngoài thì queân ñöùng, maø ñi thì queân ngoài. Luùc      them, I assure you, every one of them will attain ñoù, khoâng moät tö töôûng, khoâng moät xuùc caûm naøo          the final stage. In fact, such perplexity is an moùng khôûi trong taâm, caùi taâm giôø ñaây hoaøn toaøn         essential ingredient of the awakening process and ñoäc nhaát chuyeân vaøo coâng aùn maø thoâi. Luùc baáy          that the level of realization is comparable to the giôø, haønh giaû ñöøng neân sôï haõi, ñöøng neân phaân bieät,   intensity of the doubt. When the moment of the cöù thaúng ñöôøng maø tieán tôùi coâng aùn. Ñoät nhieân         greatest fixation presents itself, practitioners feel haønh giaû nghieäm thaáy nhö coù moät söï buøng noå, töïa       as if they were sitting in an empty space, open on hoà caùi chaäu baêng giaù vôõ tan töøng maûnh, töïa hoà nhö     all sides and extending boundlessly; they feel so caùi laàu ngoïc bò lung lay, vaø hieän töôïng bieán ñoåi        extraordinarily transparent and free from all naøy ñöôïc keøm theo moät caûm giaùc hoan laïc bao la           impurities, as if they were in a great crystal basin, chöa töøng kinh nghieäm trong suoát cuoäc ñôøi. Vì              or shut up in an immense mass of solid ice; they vaäy, maáy oâng neân ñaët nghi vaán vaøo coâng aùn "Voâ"        are again like a man devoid of all sense; if sitting, vaø nhìn xem coù yù gì trong ñoù. Neáu nghi taâm cuûa           they forget to rise; and if standing, they forget to maáy oâng khoâng heà xao laõng, luoân luoân chaêm chuù          sit. At that very moment, not a thought, not an treân chöõ "Voâ", döùt heát moïi yù nieäm, xuùc caûm vaø        emotion is stirred in the mind which is now töôûng töôïng, chaéc chaén maáy oâng seõ ñaït ñeán choã         entirely and exclusively occupied with the koan hoaøn toaøn ngöng chuù. Ñoù, taát caû laø do söï hieän dieän    itself. At this moment they are advised not to cuûa nghi taâm trong maáy oâng; vì neáu khoâng coù nghi         cherish any feeling of fear, to hold no idea of taâm thì khoâng ñi tôùi choã cao toät naøy, vaø ta ñoan         discrimination, but to go on resolutely ahead with chaéc vôùi maáy oâng, nghi taâm laø ñoâi caùnh mang maáy        their koan, when all of a sudden they experience oâng ñi ñeán cuøng ñích—In Zen, faith and an                    something akin to an explosion, as if an ice basin inquiring spirit are not contradictory terms, but are           were shattered to pieces, or as if a tower of jade complementary and mutually conditioning. The                    had crumbled, and the event is accompanied with reason why the old masters were so persistent in                a feeling of immense joy such as never before has keeping up a great spirit of inquiry in the koan                been experienced in their lives. Therefore, you exercise becomes now intelligible. Probably they                are instructed to inquire into the koan of "Mu" and were not conscious of the logic that was alive                  see what sense there is in it. If your inquiring spirit behind their instruction. The presence of Buddhata              is never relaxed, always intent on "Mu" and free could only be recognized by a perpetual knocking                from all ideas and emotions and imaginations, you at a door, and is not this knocking an inquiring                will most decidedly attain the stage of great into? An inquiring spirit in Zen literally means "to            fixation. This is all due to the presence of an doubt" or "to suspect", but in the present case "to             inquiring spirit in you; for without that the climax inquire" will be more appropriate. Thus, a stronger             will never be reached, and, I assure you, an inquiring spirit will mean "great mental fixation               inquiring spirit is the wings that bear you on to the

goal.                                                        Cöu Ma La Ca Dieáp: Kumara-Kasyapa (p)—Teân Cöôõng Sinh Tieát Muïc: Voán khoâng vieäc maø baøy ra        cuûa moät vò Taêng AÁn Ñoä—Name of an Indian cho laém vieäc hay baøy bieän ra ñuû thöù —To indulge        monk. in superfluities—To add to an original plan                  Cöu Ma La Dieân: Kumarayana (skt)—Cöu Ma something beyond what is necessary.                          La Giaø Vieâm—Father of Kumarajiva—Cha cuûa Cöôõng Töø Ñoaït Lyù: Duøng ngoân töø böôùng bænh ñeå        Ngaøi Cöu Ma La Thaäp. cho mình coù lyù—To argue with obstinacy.                    Cöu Ma La Ña: Kumaralabdha (skt)—Caâu Ma La Cöu: 1) Cuoäc thaêm doø: A tally; 2) Phieáu baàu (laøm       Laù Ña—See Caâu Ma La Ña. baèng goã hay giaáy): Ballot (made of wood or                Cöu Ma La Giaø: Kumaraka (skt)—See Cöu Ma paper).                                                      La. Cöu Baøn Ñoà: Kumbhanda (skt)—Demons of                      Cöu Ma La Giaø Ñòa: Coøn goïi laø Cöu Ma La Phuø monstrous form—Caùt Baøn Traø—See Cöu Baøn Traø.             Ñòa, Cöu Ma La Phuø Ña Ñòa, hay Ñoàng Töû Ñòa, Cöu Baøn Traø: Kumbhanda (skt)—Demons of                     Ñoàng Chaân Ñòa, Ñoàng Töôùng Ñòa, vaân vaân. Teân monstrous form—Caùt Baøn Traø—Kieát Baøn Traø—               goïi chung cho Boà Taùt Ñòa, saép söûa böôùc leân Phaät Yeåm Mò Quyû—Cöu Baøn Traø, moät loaøi quyû coù hình         Ñòa cuõng nhö moät vò Thaùi töû saép leân ngoâi vua— nhö traùi baàu hay caùi bình, loaïi quyû aên heát tinh khí   Kumaraka-stage, or Kumara-bhuta, youthful cuûa con ngöôøi. Ñaây laø moät trong taùm boä quyû           stage, i.e. a bodhisattva state or condition, e.g. the chuùng—Kumbhandas, a demon shaped like a                     position of a prince to the throne. gourd, or pot, it devours the vitality of men (sucks         Cöu Ma La Giaø Vieâm: Kumarayana (skt)—Cha the life energy from living creatures, including             cuûa Ngaøi Cöu Ma La Thaäp—Father of humans). This is one of the eight groups of demon-           Kumarajiva. followers of the four maharajas—See Thieân Long              Cöu Ma La Thaäp (344-412): Kumarajiva—Cöu Baùt Boä.                                                    ma la thaäp laø moät giaûng sö vaø dòch giaû ngöôøi AÁn. Cöu Baøn Traø Vöông: Kumbhanda-raja (skt)—                   Ngaøi ñaõ chuyeån dòch raát nhieàu kinh ñieån quan King of demons of monstrous form—Caùc Cöu Baøn               troïng töø Phaïn sang Haùn cho Trung quoác. Ngaøi laø Traø Vöông naày ñeàu sieâng tu hoïc phaùp moân voâ           moät trong boán “maët trôøi” cuûa Phaät Giaùo Ñaïi Thöøa ngaïi, phoùng quang minh lôùn—They all diligently            thuôû ban sô taïi Trung Quoác. Ngaøi xuaát thaân töø moät practiced and studied the teachings of freedom               gia ñình quyeàn quí ôû Kucha, nay thuoäc tænh Taân from impediment, and emitted great light—See                 Cöông. Teân ngaøi goïi ñuû laø Cöu Ma La Thaäp Baø, Cöu Baøn Traø.                                               Haùn dòch laø “Ñoàng Thoï,” nghóa laø tuoåi treû, ngöôøi Cöu Cöu Tra: Kukkuta (skt)—Loaøi keâ ñieåu—A                 treû maø taøi naêng, ñöùc ñoä baèng caùc baäc tröôûng fowl.                                                        thöôïng. Cha ngaøi laø ngöôøi Thieân Truùc, ñeán nöôùc Cöu Cöu Tra Boä: Teân tieáng Phaïn cuûa Keâ Daãn             Quy-Tö cöôùi meï ngaøi laø coâng chuùa cuûa nöôùc naày. Boä, moät trong soá 18 boä cuûa Tieåu Thöøa—Sanskrit         Nguyeân doøng hoï cuûa cha oâng laø moät gia ñình noái name for Kukkuta Sect, one of the eighteen                   truyeàn nhau laøm chöùc “Töôùng Quoác,” töông ñöông Hinayana sects.                                              vôùi chöùc Thuû Töôùng baây giôø, nhöng khi truyeàn ñeán Cöu Di La: Kokila (skt)—Teân moät loaøi chim                 ñôøi cuûa oâng Cöu Ma La Vieâm thì oâng naày boû ngoâi cu—A kind of cuckoo.                                         töôùng quoác, xuaát gia tu theo Phaät giaùo. Luùc 7 tuoåi Cöu La Taàn: Krakucchanda or Kakuda-                         oâng ñaõ cuøng meï xuaát gia ñaàu Phaät. Ngaøi thoâng Katyayana (skt)—Ca La Toân Ñaïi Phaät—See Caâu               hieåu lyù “Vaïn Phaùp Duy Taâm,” nghóa laø vieäc gì Löu Toân Phaät.                                              cuõng do nôi taâm mình töôûng nghó ra caû, heã nghó chi Cöu Lan Ñôn Traø Baùn Chæ La: Pancika (skt)—                 thì coù naáy khoâng sai. Sau khi xuaát gia khoâng laâu, Panika (skt)—Baùn Chæ La—See Baùn Chæ Ca.                    ngaøi hoïc hieåu vaø thoâng suoát caû Tam Taïng Kinh Cöu Laâu Toân Phaät: Krakucchanda or Kakuda-                 Ñieån, phaùt sanh ñaïi trí hueä, bieän taøi voâ ngaïi. Chæ Katyayana (skt)—See Caâu Löu Toân Phaät.                     trong moät vaøi naêm, Cöu Ma La Thaäp ñaõ thoâng Cöu Ma La: Kumara (skt)—1) Ñoàng töû: A youth,               hieåu heát caùc giaùo lyù cuûa caùc chi phaùi Phaät giaùo vaø a child; 2) Thaùi töû: A prince; 3) See Caâu Thi Na.         sau cuøng cuøng vôùi meï quay veà nöôùc Tö Quy. Treân ñöôøng ñi, ngaøi ñaõ ñeán thaêm nhieàu trung taâm

nghieân cöùu Phaät giaùo taïi Trung AÙ. Caùc quoác vöông   learning, and at last returned to Kuchi with his toaøn coõi Taây Vöïc ñeàu quyø moïp nghe ngaøi giaûng      mother. On the way he visited several centres of kinh. Ngaøi soáng veà ñôøi nhaø Dao Taàn (ñôøi Nam         Buddhist studies in Central Asia. All kings in the Baéc Trieàu beân Trung Quoác, khoaûng töø naêm 320         entire Western Region knelt before the Great ñeán 588 sau Taây Lòch). Töø ñoù Cöu Ma La Thaäp trôû      Master to hear him teach and explain the sutras. thaønh moät hoïc giaû xuaát chuùng ñeán möùc thu huùt      He lived in China during the Dao Taàn Dynasty ñöôïc nhieàu tín ñoà Phaät giaùo töø Khotan, Kashgar,      (during the North-South monarchy era in China Yarkand vaø caùc nôi khaùc ôû mieàn ñoâng Turkestan.       from 320-588 A.D.). Since then Kumarajiva Trong laàn ñeán thaêm Kashgar vaøo naêm 355, Cöu           acquired such eminence as a scholar that he Ma La Thaäp ñaõ ñöôïc Suryasoma giôùi thieäu giaùo lyù     attracted so many Buddhists from Khotan, Ñaïi Thöøa vaø ñaõ chuyeân taâm nghieân cöùu caùc luaän    Kashgar, Yarkand, and other parts of Eastern thuyeát cuûa Trung Luaän toâng (Madhyamika                 Turkestan. While on a visit to Kashgar in 355 treatise) vaø giôùi luaät cuûa Nhaát Thieát Höõu Boä       A.D., Kumarajiva was introduced by Suryasoma in (Sarvastivada Vinaya). Sau ñoù ngaøi hôïp taùc vôùi        the Mahayana doctrine and made a special study Vimalaksa, moät tu só ñeán töø Trung AÙ, trong coâng       of the Madhyamika treatises. Vimalaksa, a vieäc dòch thuaät maø Cöu Ma La Thaäp raát noåi tieáng     Buddhist monk of Kashmir who travelled to China veà sau naày. Ngaøi cuøng nhöõng vò phuï taù ñaõ phieân    by the Central Asian route, also instructed dòch toång coäng 390 quyeån kinh. Ngöôøi ta cuõng cho      Kumarajiva in the Sarvastivada Vinaya and raèng Ngaøi chính laø ngöôøi saùng laäp ra Tam Luaän       subsequently collaborated with him in the work of Toâng, moät toâng phaùi baét nguoàn töø truyeàn thoáng     translation for which Kumarajiva is famous. He Trung Ñaïo beân AÁn Ñoä—An influential Indian              and other assistants translated 390 volumes of teacher and translator. He translated a lot of sutras      sutra teachings. He is also credited with from Sanskrit into Chinese. Kumarajiva, one of             establishing the San Lun school, which is derived the “four suns” of Mahayana Buddhism, of which             from the Indian Madhyamaka tradition. he was the early and most effective propagator in          Cöu Ma La Vieâm: Kumarayana (skt)—Cöu Ma China. He came from a noble family in Kuchi,               La Giaø Vieâm—Father of Kumarajiva—Cha cuûa present-day Sinkiang. His name in Sanskrit is              Ngaøi Cöu Ma La Thaäp—See Cöu Ma La Thaäp. Kumarajiva, in Chinese “Elderly Young,” which              Cöu Mang: To bear—To keep up. means though young, his talents and virtues are            Cöu Na La: Kunala (skt)—See Cöu Di La and equal to the elders. His father was an Indian, his         Caâu Na La. mother a princess of Karashahr. His family line            Cöùu: Cöùu ñoä—To save—To rescue—To prevent succeeded each other in holding the Great                  from ill. General position, equal to present-day prime-              Cöùu Ban Thöôïng Truøng Thieâm Ngaõi Truï: Treân minister, but when it was passed to Kumarayana,            veát boûng laïi ñoát theâm ngaõi cöùu, duï cho haønh vi voán he chose to forgo this position to take the religious      dó sai laàm laïi tieáp tuïc theâm nhöõng haønh vi vaø lôøi path and became a Buddhist Master. Kumarajiva              noùi hö voïng laøm cho noù caøng teä theâm—To add entered the Buddhist monastic order, together with         more burning artemisia on a burn, i.e., to continue his mother at the time he was 7 years of age. He           to add the unreal to a naturally wrong action to was able to penetrate clearly the theory “All              make it worse. Dharma Arises From Within The Mind,” meaning               Cöùu Baït: Cöùu ra khoûi nhöõng khoå sôû—To save and everything comes from the mind; undoubtedly, if            drag out of suffering. it can be thought of, then it can exist. Not long          Cöùu Baït Minh Ñoà: Cöùu ra khoûi noåi khoå cuûa ñòa after he became a Buddhist Master, the Great               nguïc—To save and drag out of suffering in the Venerable Master learned and understood the                hells. Tripitaka. He developed great wisdom and was               Cöùu Caùnh: Atyanta (skt)—1) Muïc ñích cuoái cuøng: able to speak and elucidate the Dharma without             End, final, at the end, finality, utmost; 2) Nghieân limitation. In a few years Kumarajiva acquired             cöùu tæ mæ: Examine exhaustively. great proficiency in all branches of Buddhist              Cöùu Caùnh Baát Tònh: Impurity of the death—Cuoái

cuøng thì toaøn thaân thoái röûa baát tònh. Ñeán khi cheát       Cöùu Caùnh Giaûi Thoaùt: Final emancipation— roài, thaân naày laø moät ñoáng thòt sình thuùi raõ rôøi, maëc   Principle of Perfect Freedom—The Principle of cho gioøi töûa boø lan hoaëc quaï dieàu tha moå—One’s            Nirvana or Perfect Freedom—Söï giaûi thoaùt cuoái own putrid corpse is not clean at all. After death,              cuøng—Söï giaûi thoaùt cuoái cuøng hay cöùu caùnh toái the body swelling up and rotting away, with flesh                haäu cuûa ñaïo Phaät, khoâng theå ñaït ñeán ngay laäp töùc and bones disarray, feeding feelers and crows.                   ñöôïc. Ñoù laø moät tieán trình tuaàn töï, moät söï ñaøo Cöùu Caùnh Chaân Tònh: Söï thanh tònh toät ñænh—                 luyeän töøng böôùc. Nhö kinh ñieån thöôøng noùi: söï Consummate purity.                                               thanh tònh taâm chæ ñaït ñöôïc sau khi ñaõ thaønh töïu Cöùu Caùnh Dieät Taän: Dieät taân hoaøn toaøn—                   giôùi haïnh. Thanh tònh taâm vaø trí tueä laø ñieàu khoâng Thoroughly extinguished.                                         theå coù neáu khoâng thanh tònh giôùi. Ñöùc Phaät thuùc Cöùu Caùnh Ñaïo: Parayana (skt)—Ultimate path—                   duïc caùc ñeä töû cuûa Ngaøi tröôùc tieân haõy töï ñaët mình Con ñöôøng toái thöôïng thöøa —Ultimate path—Con                 vaøo neáp soáng giôùi haïnh, sau ñoù môùi böôùc vaøo con ñöôøng toái thöôïng thöøa—Con ñöôøng ñi ñeán toái                ñöôøng thieàn ñònh vaø trí tueä. Chính vì vaäy caàn phaûi thöôïng thöøa laø con ñöôøng ñi ñeán Phaät quaû, chöù            khôûi söï ngay töø böôùc ñaàu. Ñieåm khôûi ñaàu trong khoâng phaûi A La Haùn, maø cuõng khoâng phaûi laø con           giaùo phaùp laø Giôùi. Sau khi ñaõ ñöùng vöõng treân vuøng ñöôøng ñi ñeán coõi nhaân thieân. Neáu mình muoán laøm           ñaát giôùi, haønh giaû seõ noã löïc laøm chuû caùi taâm dao vieäc phöôùc thieän vôùi mong moûi ñöôïc giaøu coù hay           ñoäng cuûa mình—The final emancipation, the haïnh phuùc trong ñôøi sau, mình khoâng ñang ñi treân            highest goal, in Buddhism, is not attained at once. con ñöôøng toái thöôïng. Ngöôïc laïi, neáu mình hoài             It is a gradual process, a gradual training. As the höôùng taát caû coâng ñöùc cho chuùng sanh ñeå hoï vaø           discourses often point out mental purity is gained mình cuøng ñaéc thaønh Phaät quaû, töùc laø mình ñang ñi         after a thorough training in virtuous behavior. treân con ñöôøng ñi ñeán toái thöôïng thöøa—The                  Mental purity and attainments are not possible ultimate path is the path to Buddhahood, not                     without moral purity. The Buddha exhorts his Arhatship, not the paths to gods or humans. If one               disciples first to establish themselves in virtue or wants to perform donation with the hope of                       moral habits before entering on the path of receiving wealth in a future lifetime or obtaining               meditation and wisdom. Hence the need to start happiness, one would not be following the                        from the very beginning. The starting point in the ultimate path. In the contrary, transferring all                 Dispensation of the Buddha is sila, virtuous merits one has accrued to other sentient beings so               behavior. Standing on the firm ground of sila one that they, as well as oneself, may achive                        should endeavor to master the fickle mind. Buddhahood is the ultimate path.                                 Cöùu Caùnh Laïc: Dieäu laïc cuûa Nieát Baøn—The Cöùu Caùnh Ñòa: Giai ñoaïn cuoái cuøng treân böôùc               supreme joy (nirvana). ñöôøng giaûi thoaùt—Final stage.                                 Cöùu Caùnh Muïc Ñích: Muïc ñích cuoái cuøng, duï cho Cöùu Caùnh Ñôøi Soáng: The aim of life—Phaät Giaùo               thaønh Phaät—The final objective, i.e., to become a khoâng xem lôïi ích vaät chaát laø cöùu caùnh cuûa haïnh         Buddha phuùc trong ñôøi soáng: Buddhism does not consider               Cöùu Caùnh Nhaát Thöøa Baûo Taùnh Luaän: material welfare as an end in happiness in life.                 Ratnagotra-sastra (skt)—Baûo Taùnh Luaän—Phaân Cöùu Caùnh Giaùc: Ñaõ ñoaïn heát caên baûn voâ minh,             Bieät Baûo Taùnh Ñaïi Thöøa Toái Thaéng Yeáu Nghóa tieán ñeán toaøn giaùc (chöùng ñöôïc chaân giaùc cöùu            Luaän. Boä Luaän Do Naëc Na Ma Ñeà soaïn veà Nhö caùnh), moät trong boán baäc giaùc theo Ñaïi Thöøa Khôûi         Lai taïng trong Phaät giaùo Ñaïi Thöøa—Treatise on Tín Luaän, ñaây laø luùc Boà Taùt ñaït ñeán möùc giaùc ngoä      Precious nature or Tathagatagarbha. The sastra troøn ñaày toät cuøng hay ñaït tôùi ngoâi vò Phaät —Reach        was       composed        by      Ratnamati        on    the the final or complete enlightenment (to reach the                Tathagatagarbha in Mahayana Buddhism—See perfect quiescent stage of orginal bodhi). The                   Nhö Lai Taïng. supreme              enlightenment           (Enlightened        Cöùu Caùnh Nieát Baøn: Final Nirvana. apprehension of a Buddha), one of the four kinds                 Cöùu Caùnh Phaùp Thaân: The supreme of enlightenment mentioned in the Awakening of                   Dharmakaya—The highest conception of Buddha Faith—See Dieäu Giaùc.                                           as the absolute.

Cöùu Caùnh Phaät: Phaät trong chaân lyù toái thöôïng—        Töø ñoù ngaøi xuaát gia laøm ñeä töû cuûa Thieàn sö Ñònh The fundamental, ultimate or supreme Buddha,                 Höông taïi chuøa Caûm ÖÙng, vaø trôû thaønh Phaùp töû ñôøi who has complete comprehension of truth—                     thöù 7 doøng Voâ Ngoân Thoâng. Veà sau, ngaøi dôøi veà Buddha in his supreme reality.                               chuøa Töø Quang treân nuùi Tieân Du ñeå tu khoå haïnh. Cöùu Caùnh Phaät Ñaïo: Final goal of Buddhism—               Ngaøi thöôøng daïy ñoà ñeä veà ‘Taâm vaø Phaùp Khoâng Final end of Buddhism—Utmost end of                          Hai’: “Phaøm taát caû caùc phaùp moân voán töø chính Buddhism—Cöùu caùnh cuûa ñaïo Phaät (muïc ñích               taùnh cuûa caùc ngöôøi, taùnh cuûa taát caû phaùp voán töø cuoái cuøng cuûa ñaïo Phaät)—Phaät Giaùo khoâng xem          chính taâm cuûa caùc ngöôøi. Taâm phaùp nhaát nhö, voán lôïi ích vaät chaát laø cöùu caùnh cuûa haïnh phuùc trong    khoâng hai phaùp. Phieàn naõo troùi buoäc, taát caû ñeàu ñôøi soáng—Buddhism does not consider material               khoâng. Toäi phöôùc phaûi quaáy, taát caû ñeàu huyeããn.” welfare as an end in happiness in life.                      Thaät vaäy, haønh giaû tu Thieàn neân luoân nhôù lôøi daïy Cöùu Caùnh Truï: Giai ñoaïn ñaït ñöôïc Boà taùt toaøn        cuûa ngaøi laø ñöøng nghó ngôïi, ñöôøng bieän luaän; maø thieän trong Thaäp ñòa Boà Taùt, nhöng chöa tôùi Phaät       haõy caûm nhaän vaø haõy soáng vôùi Thieàn. Haõy thöû ñòa—Attainment of the perfect Bodhisattva-stage              soáng vôùi Thieàn roài seõ coù ñöôïc kinh nghieäm tuyeät in the ten stages of Bodhisattva, but not including          dieäu cuûa Thieàn trong ñôøi soáng haèng ngaøy cuûa the Buddha-stage.                                            mình. Vaøo thôøi ñoù, Teå Töôùng Döông Ñaïo xaây Cöùu Caùnh Töùc: Vò thöù saùu trong luïc Töùc Vò theo        chuøa Dieân Linh vaø thænh ngaøi veà truï. Khoâng theå töø thuyeát cuûa toâng Thieân Thai, giai ñoaïn trí tueä giaùc    choái, ngaøi veà truï trì taïi ñaây vaø vieân tòch ba naêm lieãu chaân lyù troøn ñaày—The stage of complete             sau ñoù. Ngaøi cuõng daïy ñoà ñeä veà caùi taâm tòch laëng: comprehension of truth, being the sixth stage of             “Caùc oâng phaûi neân luoân giaùc ngoä thaân taâm voán the T’ien-T’ai School—See Luïc Töùc Phaät.                   laëng yeân, nhöng roài caùc töôùng hieån hieän, vaø höõu vi Cöùu Caùnh Töùc Phaät: The attainment of Perfect             voâ vi ñeàu töø ñaây maø coù. Theo Phaät giaùo noùi chung, enlightenment—Cöùu Caùnh Töùc Phaät laø giai ñoaïn           vaø ñaëc bieät laø theo nhaø Thieàn, taát caû chuùng ta ñeàu haønh giaû phaù tröø taát caû voâ minh vaø phieàn naõo ñeå   coù saün Phaät taùnh phaùt sinh Baùt Nhaõ, soi saùng moïi ñaït tôùi toaøn giaùc. Ñaây laø giai ñoaïn thöù saùu trong   sinh hoaït tinh thaàn vaø theå xaùc cuûa chuùng ta. Phaät saùu giai ñoaïn phaùt trieån cuûa Boà Taùt ñöôïc noùi roõ    taùnh cuõng taùc ñoäng nhö maët trôøi phaùt sinh ra aùnh trong Thieân Thai Vieân Giaùo, ñoái laïi vôùi saùu giai      saùng vaø söùc noùng, hay nhö taám göông phaûn aûnh taát ñoaïn phaùt trieån hay Luïc Vò cuûa Bieät Giaùo—The          caû nhöõng gì xuaát hieän tröôùc noù, nghóa laø moät caùch destroy of all ignorance and delusions to attain             voâ thöùc, vôùi ‘voâ taâm’ theo nghóa traïng töø. Vì vaäy Perfect enlightenment (Fruition of holiness). This           ngöôøi ta noùi raèng ‘Phaät voâ taâm’ hay ‘nhôø thaønh is the sixth of the six stages of Bodhisattva                Phaät ngöôøi ta hieåu voâ nieäm.’ Do ñoù, khoâng caàn baát developments as defined in the T’ien-T’ai Perfect            cöù moät noã löïc coù yù thöùc naøo caû, kyø thaät chuùng chæ or Final Teaching, in contrast with the ordinary six         laø nhöõng chöôùng ngaïi cho söï thaønh Phaät maø thoâi. developments as found in the Differentiated or               Chuùng ta voán laø nhöõng vò Phaät. Noùi thaønh moät caùi Separated School—See Luïc Töùc Phaät.                        gì ñoù laø phaïm Thaùnh vaø theo lyù luaän hoïc, laø moät Cöùu Caùnh Vò: Paraya-navagga (p)—Ultimate                   söï truøng laäp. Do ñoù ‘khoâng coù taâm’ hay ‘yeâu thích position—Phaät quaû toái thöôïng, giai ñoaïn cao nhaát       voâ nieäm,’ do vaäy noù coù nghóa laø khoâng coù taát caû trong naêm giai ñoaïn tieán ñeán Phaät Quaû cuûa Phaät       moïi noã löïc xaûo dieäu, töï taïo hay giaû doái beân ngoaøi, Giaùo Ñaïi Thöøa—The supreme class or stage of               taát caû ñeàu traùi ngöôïc vôùi taâm khoâng. Caùc oâng chæ Buddhahood, the highest of the five stages of                caàn giaùc ngoä raèng thaân mình ñang bieán ñoåi, vaø taâm attainment of Buddhahood.                                    mình ñang nhaûy nhoùt loaïn ñoäng nhö con vöôïn, yù Cöùu Caùnh Voâ Vi: Voâ ñieàu kieän hoaøn toaøn—              ñang chaïy lung tung nhö con ngöïa. Sau moät thôøi Perfectly unconditioned.                                     gian coâng phu tu taäp, caùc oâng seõ töï nhieân thaáy Cöùu Chæ Thieàn Sö: Zen Master Cöùu Chæ—Thieàn               raèng taâm naày voán tòch laëng, cuõng nhö nöôùc voán sö Vieät Nam, queâ ôû Chu Minh, Baéc Vieät. Khi haõy         tòch laëng, baát bieán vaø baát ñoäng, cho daàu soùng cöù coøn nhoû, ngaøi ñaõ laøu thoâng Khoång Laõo, nhöng ngaøi    traøo leân vaø laën xuoáng, hay cho daàu boït soùng cöù than phieàn raèng Khoång chaáp “höõu,” Laõo chaáp            thaønh hình vaø vôõ tan nhö theá naøo ñi nöõa thì nöôùc “voâ,” chæ coù ñaïo Phaät laø khoâng chaáp vaøo ñaâu caû.    vaãn vaäy. Khi taâm caùc oâng nhaän thöùc ñöôïc nhö vaäy,

laø thaân caùc oâng cuõng töï nhieân thaät söï tónh laëng        minister Döông Ñaïo built Dieân Linh Temple on trong moïi oai nghi, töø ñi, ñöùng, naèm, ngoài. Roài caùc       Mount Long Ñoäi and invited him to stay there. He oâng cuõng seõ thaáy raèng khoâng coù caùi gì coù theå ñöôïc     could not refuse the order. He stayed there for goïi laø thaân vaø taâm cuûa caùc oâng caû. Luùc ñoù thì thaân   thee years and passed away. He also taught his taâm caùc oâng môùi thaät söï tónh laëng vaø baát ñoäng. Roài    disciples about a ‘serene mind’: “You should sau ñoù, caùc oâng cuõng nhaän thöùc ñöôïc söï baát ñoäng        always realize that your body and mind are cuûa vaïn phaùp. Vaïn phaùp luoân chieáu saùng trong taâm        originally serene, but then you see all kinds of caùc oâng, thaât söï tónh laëng vaø baát bieán.” Döôùi ñaây      form manifest in fron of you, and from there laø moät trong nhöõng baøi keä thieàn noåi tieáng veà ‘thaân     emerge all the conditioned and the unconditioned. vaø taâm’ cuûa ngaøi:                                            According to Buddhism, in general, and “Giaùc lieãu thaân taâm baûn ngöng tòch                     specifically according to Zen, we are all endowed Thaàn thoâng bieán hoùa hieän chö töôùng                  with the Buddha-nature from which Prajna issues, Höõu vi voâ vi tuøng thöû xuaát                           illumining all our activities, mental and physical. Haø sa theá giôùi baát khaû löôïng                        The Buddha-nature does this in the same way as Tuy nhieân bieán maõn hö khoâng giôùi                     the sun radiates heat and light, or as the mirror Nhaát nhaát quan lai moät hình traïng                     reflects everything coming before it, that is to say, Thieân coå vaïn coå nan tyû huoáng                        unconsciously, with ‘no-mind’, in its adverbial Giôùi giôùi xöù xöù thöôøng laõng laõng.”                 sense. Hence it is declared that ‘Buddha is (Giaùc ngoä thaân taâm voán laëng yeân,                    unconscious’ or ‘By Buddhahood is meant the Thaàn thoâng caùc töôùng bieán hieän tieàn.               unconscious.’ Therefore, no special conscious Höõu vi voâ vi töø ñaây coù,                              strivings are necessary; in fact they are a Theá giôùi haø sa khoâng theå löôøng,                     hindrance to the attainment of Buddhahood. We Moãi moãi xem ra chaúng töôùng hình.                      are already Buddhas. To talk about any sort of Muoân ñôøi ngaøn ñôøi naøo saùnh ñöôïc,                   attainment is a desecration, and logically a Choán choán nôi nôi thöôøng raïng ngôøi).                 tautology (moân Laäp Thöøa). ‘Having no-mind,’ or A Vietnamese Zen Master from Chu Minh, North                     ‘cherishing the unconscious,’ therefore means to Vietnam. When he was still young, he was good in                 be free from all these artificial, self-created, both Tao and Confucian, but complaining that                     double-roofing efforts. Even this ‘having’, this Confucian attached to the “existing” and Tao                     ‘cherishing’, goes against “Mind of No-Existence. attached to the “non-existing.” Only Buddhism                    You only need to realize that your body is attached to none. He left home and became a                      changing, and your mind is like a monkey, the disciple of Ñònh Höông at Caûm ÖÙng Temple, and                  thought is like a horse. After some times of became the Dharma heir of the seventh                            practicing, you will naturally realize that the mind generation of the Wu-Yun-T’ung Zen Sect. Later,                  is originally serene, unchanging, unmoving, he moved to Töø Quang Temple on Mount Tieân Du                   despite the waves keep rising and falling, and to practise ascetics. He always taught his disciples             despite the bubbles keep forming and vanishing. about ‘Mind and Dharma are not Two Things’:                      When your mind is able to realize as such, your “All Dharma doors are from your won essence,                     body will naturally quiet and unmoving while you and all the essence of all things are from your own              are walking, standing, lying and sitting. Then, you mind. Your mind and all things are just one, not                 will see that nothing could be called as your body two things. The afflictions and fetters of this                  and mind at all. At that time, both your body and samsara are all void. Sins and merits, right and                 mind are truly quiet and unmoving. You, then, will wrong, all are illusions.” As a matter of fact, Zen              also realize that everything is truly quiet and pratictioners should always remember his teaching                unmoving. Everything is luminous in your mind by not thinking, not reasoning; but feeling Zen and              and truly quiet and unmoving.” Below is one of his living with Zen. Let’s try to feel Zen, even in a                famous Zen poems about the ‘body and mind’: short moment everyday, we will have wonderful                    “After realizing that your body and mind are experience in our daily life. At that time, prime                  originally non-arising,

From it manifests wondrously all phenomena.               Cöùu Nhaân Ñoä Theá: Cöùu ngöôøi giuùp ñôøi—To From there emerge all the conditioned                     rescue people and save the world. and the unconditioned,                                    Cöùu Nhaân Nhaát Meänh Thaéng Taïo Thaát Caáp Countless universes appear immeasurably.                  Phuø Ñoà: Cöùu moät maïng ngöôøi coøn hôn xaây thaùp Though everything fully revealed,                         baûy taàng—To rescue and save one person is better None of them really has shape or form,                    than building a seven-storied stupa. Thousands or even ten thousands of                        Cöùu Sinh (1696-1733): See Nhö Tröøng Laân Giaùc your old lives in the past,                               Thieàn Sö. Cannot be compared with what you have today.              Cöùu Teá: Cöùu hoä, giuùp ñôõ vaø ñoä thoaùt chuùng Always being luminious at anywhere and at any             sanh—To rescue, help and save people. place.”                                                   Cöùu Theá: Nhöõng baäc cöùu ñoä theá gian nhö chö Cöùu Ñoä: Salvation—To emancipate—Saving—                   Phaät vaø chö Boà Taùt, ñaëc bieät laø Ñöùc Quaùn Theá AÂm Rescue and ferry—Taking across—Nhöõng baäc                  Boà Taùt (taàm thanh cöùu khoå)—To save the world— cöùu ñoä theá gian nhö chö Phaät vaø chö Boà Taùt, ñaëc     A saviour of the world, Buddhas and Bodhisattvas bieät laø Ñöùc Quaùn Theá AÂm Boà Taùt (taàm thanh cöùu     as      world-saviours,         especially        Kuan-Yin khoå)—A saviour of the world, Buddhas and                   Bodhisattva. Bodhisattvas as world-saviours, especially Kuan-            Cöùu Theá Boà Taùt: Chö Phaät vaø chö Boà Taùt thò hieän Yin Bodhisattva.                                            cöùu ñoä theá gian, moät danh hieäu khaùc cuûa Boà Taùt Cöùu Ñoä AÂn: Grace of salvation—AÂn Cöùu ñoä               Quaùn AÂm—Buddhas and Bodhisattvas as world- chuùng sanh, moät trong möôøi aân cuûa Phaät—Grace          saviours, another title for Kuan-Yin Bodhisattva. of Initial resolve to universalize (salvation), one of      Cöùu Theá Luaân: Goïi phaùp luaân cuûa Phaät laø “Cöùu ten kinds of the Buddha’s grace.                            Theá Luaân”—The wheel of salvation. Cöùu Hoä: Cöùu ñoä vaø baûo hoä—To save and protect.        Cöùu Theá Vieân Maõn: Teân goïi khaùc cuûa Boà Taùt Cöùu Hoä Chuùng Sanh Thaàn: Rescuing Sentient               Quaùn AÂm—Complete saviour of the world, Beings Deity (Spirit).                                      another name of Kuan-Yin Bodhisattva. Cöùu Hoä Hueä Boà Taùt: Paritrana-sayamatri (skt)—          Cöùu Theá Vieân Thoâng: See Cöùu Theá Vieân Maõn. Vò Boà Taùt cöùu ñoä vaø baûo hoä chuùng sanh baèng caùch   Cöùu Theá Xieån Ñeà: Xieån ñeà laø ngöôøi khoâng coøn daïy hoï trí tueä giaûi thoaùt—A Bodhisattva who            caên cô vaõng sanh nöõa, cuõng coù nghóa laø vò Boà Taùt saves and protects sentient beings by teaching              vì loøng töø bi voâ haïn neân khôûi leân ñaïi nguyeän töø them with wisdom of liberation.                             choái vaøo Nieát baøn ñeå tieáp tuïc cöùu ñoä chuùng sanh— Cöùu Hoä Nhöùt Thieát Chuùng Sanh Ly Chuùng                 The world-saving icchanti, i.e. the Bodhisattva Sanh Töôùng Hoài Höôùng: To save all sentient               who defers entry into Buddhahood to fulfil his beings without any mental image of sentient                 vow of saving all beings. beings.                                                     Cöùu Thoaùt Boà Taùt: Vò Boà Taùt cöùu ngöôøi thoaùt Cöùu Khoûi: To deliver (save) someone from.                 khoûi beänh hoaïn tai öông. Chö Phaät vaø chö Boà Taùt Cöùu Khoå: Cöùu ai thoaùt khoûi khoå ñau—To save            thò hieän cöùu ñoä theá gian, moät danh hieäu khaùc cuûa someone from unhappiness or suffering.                      Boà Taùt Quaùn AÂm—A Bodhisattva who save Cöùu Khoå AÂn: AÂn cöùu khoå vaø vieãn ly sanh töû, moät    people from sicknesses and calamities. Buddhas trong möôøi aân cuûa Phaät—Grace of relief of the           and Bodhisattvas as world-saviours, another title living from distress and mortality, one of ten kinds        for Kuan-Yin Bodhisattva. of the Buddha’s grace.                                      Cöûu: Navan (skt)—Nine. Cöùu Khoå Ban Vui: To save from suffering and to            Cöûu AÂm: Nine elements or nine substances. give joy.                                                   1-5) Nguõ Ñaïi: ñaát, nöôùc, löûa, gioù, hö khoâng—The Cöùu Khoå Trai: Phaùp hoäi caàu nguyeän cöùu khoå do             five elements: earth, water, fire, wind, space. vua Löông Voõ Ñeá toå chöùc—An assembly for                 6-9) Nhöõng Yeáu Toá Khaùc: thôøi, taâm, a laïi da, vaø praying to save someone from unhappiness or                      ñaïi ngaõ—Other substances: time, mind or suffering, organized by King Liang Wu Ti (502-                   spirit (manas), alaya, and soul (atman). 550).                                                       Cöûu Baùch: Lôø môø—Dim—Not clear about some-

thing—Vague.                                                          (Siksamana (skt), Sa di (Sramanera (skt), Sa Cöûu Baùi: Chín laïy, quyø ba laàn moãi laàn laïy ba laî,             Di Taäp Söï thoï trì taùm giôùi, Sa di ni moät trong nhöõng nghi thöùc quan troïng trong nhaø                   (Sramanerika (skt), Sa Di Ni Taäp Söï thoï trì thieàn—Nine bows with three prostrations, each                        taùm giôùi—Those who have left home: a prostration bowing three times, this is one of the                    monk, a female observer of all the most important rituals in Zen monasteries.                            commandments, a novice nun (a novice or Cöûu Bieán Tri: Chín hình thöùc cuûa toaøn tri (bieát                 observer of the six commandments), a male heát thaûy) veà boán chaân lyù (kieán khoå, kieán taäp, kieán         observer of the minor commandments, a dieät vaø kieán ñaïo) cuõng nhö nhöõng phöông caùch caét              Junior monk who has received the eight ñöùt duïc voïng vaø aûo töôûng—The nine forms of                      commandments, a female observer of the complete knowledge of the four Noble Truths                           minor commandments, and a Junior nun or a (knowledge of sufferings, accumulation of                             novice nun who has received the eight sufferings, termination of sufferings and                             commandments. knowledge of the path) as well as the cutting off               8-9) Hai chuùng taïi gia: öu baø taéc (cö só nam), öu baø passion and delusion.                                                 di (cö só nöõ)—Those who still remain at Cöûu Boä: Navanga-Buddha-sasana (p & skt)—                            home: Lay man (Upasaka (skt) and Lay Chín boä kinh Tieåu thöøa, gioáng nhö 12 boä kinh Ñaïi                woman (Upasika (skt). thöøa, ngoaïi tröø Phöông Quaûng, Thoï kyù vaø Voâ vaán         Cöûu Chuùng Giôùi: See Cöûu Chuùng. töï thuyeát—Nine Hinayana sutras which are the                  Cöûu Chuùng Sanh Cö: See Cöûu Höõu. same as the twelve sutras in Mahayana except                    Cöûu Chuûng Ñaïi Thieàn: Chín loaïi thieàn Ñaïi thöøa Vaipulya (Phöông quaûng), Vyakarana (Thoï Kyù),                 cho chö Boà taùt: Thöù nhaát laø Töï Taùnh Thieàn hay and Udana (Voâ vaán töï thuyeát).                               thieàn quaùn veà töï taùnh cuûa chö phaùp. Thöù nhì laø Cöûu Boä Kinh: Navanga-sasana (skt)—See Cöûu                    Nhaát Thieát Thieàn hay thieàn quaùn nhaèm phaùt trieån Boä.                                                            töï giaùc vaø giaùc tha ñeán möùc toái thöôïng. Thöù ba laø Cöûu Boä Phaùp Kinh: Navanga-buddha-sasana                      Nan Thieàn hay thieàn quaùn veà nhöõng vaán ñeà khoù (p)—Navanga-sasana (skt)—See Cöûu Boä.                          khaên. Thöù tö laø Nhaát Thieát Moân Thieàn hay thieàn Cöûu Chaáp: Nava Graha (skt)—Nine seizers or                    veà cöûa vaøo toái thöøa thieàn ñònh. Thöù naêm laø Thieän upholders—Nine luminaries or planets—See Cöûu                   Nhaân Thieàn hay thieàn veà nhöõng ñieàu thieän. Thöù Dieäu.                                                          saùu laø Nhaát Thieát Haønh Thieàn hay thieàn veà thöïc Cöûu Boä Tieåu Thöøa: Nine classes of work                      taäp vaø haønh ñoäng Ñaïi thöøa. Thöù baûy laø Tröø Phieàn belonging to the Hinayana—Chín boä kinh thuoäc                  Naõo Thieàn. Thöù taùm laø Thöû Theá Tha Theá Laïc veà Tieåu Thöøa, goàm 12 boä cuûa Ñaïi Thöøa boû ra ba          Thieàn hay thieàn veà caùch mang laïi an laïc cho moïi boä Voâ Vaán Töï Thuyeát, Phöông Quaûng vaø Thoï                ngöôøi trong ñôøi naày vaø ñôøi sau. Thöù chín laø Thanh Kyù—The nine classes of work belonging to the                   Tònh Tònh Thieàn hay thieàn veà thanh tònh nhaèm Hinayana, including the whole of the twelve                     chaám döùt aûo giaùc vaø phieàn naõo ñeå ñaït ñöôïc ñaïi classes of the mahyana less (minus) the Udana or                giaùc—The nine kinds of Mahayana dhyana for Voluntary Discourses, the Vaipulya or Broader                   bodhisattvas: First, meditation on the original Teaching, and the Vyakarana or Prophecies.                      nature of things, or mind as the real nature, from Cöûu Chaân Lyù: Chín chaân lyù—Nine truths or                   which all things derived. Second, meditation on postulates—See Cöûu Ñeá.                                        achieving the development of self and all others to Cöûu Chuùng: Chín chuùng ñeä töû goàm Thaát Chuùng              the utmost. Third, meditation on the difficulties of coäng vôùi hai chuùng Sa Di vaø Sa Di Ni Taäp Söï thoï          certain dhyana conditions. Fourth, meditation on trì taùm giôùi—Nine kinds of disciples include seven            the entrance to all the superior dhyana conditions. kinds plus junior monks and nuns or novice who                  Fifth, meditation on the good. Sixth, meditation on have received the eight commandments—See                        all Mahayana practices and actions. Seventh, Nine classes of disciples.                                      meditation on ridding all suffers from the miseries 1-7)Baûy chuùng xuaát gia: Tyø kheo (Bhiksu (skt),             of passion and delusion. Eighth, meditation on the Tyø kheo ni (Bhiksuni (skt), Thöùc xoa ma na              way to bring joy to all people both in this life and

hereafter. Ninth, meditation on perfect purity in                      the Tathagatas mentioned countless forms of the termination of all delusion and distress and the                   untimely death; however, there nine major obataining of perfect enlightenment.                                   forms of untimely death. First, some sentient Cöûu Chuûng Hoaïnh Töû: Chín thöù cheát baát ñaéc kyø                  beings contract a minor illness which goes töû—Nine major forms of untimely death.                                untreated for lack of a physician or medicine; (I) Chín loaïi hoaïnh töû theo truyeàn thoáng caùc toâng               or else, even though there is a physician, he phaùi Phaät giaùo nguyeân thuûy: khoâng neân aên maø              prescribes the wrong medicine, causing cöù aên; aên quaù löôïng; chaúng aên quen maø cöù aên;            premature death. Or, the patients, believing aên khoâng tieâu ñöôïc; aên thöù chöa ñöôïc naáu                  the false pronouncements of earthly demons, chín; khoâng giöõ giôùi luaät; gaàn guûi aùc tri thöùc;           heretics or practitioners of black magic, may vaøo xoùm laøng chaúng ñuùng luùc; ñaùng traùnh maø               panic, unable to calm their minds. They may chaúng traùnh (cheát chìm)—Nine major forms of                    then engage in divination or perform animal untimely death according to the Early                             sacrifices in order to propitiate the spirits, Buddhist Sects: to eat what is not allowed to;                    praying for blessings and longevity, all in to eat too much; to eat what is not suitable for                  vain. Through ignorance, confusion and the stomach; to eat what is difficult for the                     reliance on wrong, inverted views, they meet stomach to digest; to eat uncooked food; to                       with untimely death and sink into the hells, break precepts (law-breaking); to associate                       with no end in sight. Second, excecuted by with bad friends; to set out at the wrong time;                   royal decree. Third, losing one’s vitality to the and drowning (should avoid but not avoid).                        demons         through      hunting,      gambling, (II) Theo Kinh Döôïc Sö, Cöùu Thoaùt Boà Taùt ñaõ                      debauchery,        drunkenness       or     extreme baûo Ngaøi A Nan laø coù chín thöù hoaïnh töû. Thöù               dissipation. The fourth major form of untimely nhaát, neáu coù chuùng höõu tình naøo bò beänh tuy                death is death by fire. The fifth major form of nheï, nhöng khoâng thaày, khoâng thuoác, khoâng                   untimely death is death by drowning. The ngöôøi saên soùc, hay giaù coù gaëp thaày laïi uoáng              sixthth major form of untimely death is being laàm thuoác, neân beänh khoâng ñaùng cheát maø laïi               devoured by wild animals. The seventh major cheát ngang. Ñang luùc beänh laïi tin theo nhöõng                 form of untimely death is falling off a thuyeát hoïa phuùc vu vô cuûa boïn taø ma ngoaïi                  mountain or a cliff. The eighth major form of ñaïo, yeâu nghieät trong ñôøi, sanh loøng run sôï                 untimely death is death by poison, khoâng coøn töï chuû ñoái vôùi söï chaân chaùnh, ñi               incantations, evil mantras and demons-raised- boùi khoa ñeå tìm hoûi roài gieát haïi loaøi vaät ñeå taáu        from-the-death. The ninth major form of vôùi thaàn linh, vaùi van voïng löôïng caâu xin ban               untimely death is death from hunger or thirst, phuùc, mong ñöôïc soáng laâu, nhöng roát cuoäc                    for lack of food and water. khoâng theå naøo ñöôïc. Bôûi si meâ laàm laïc, tin           Cöûu Coâng Ñöùc Haïnh: Chín coâng ñöùc tu taäp: loøng theo taø kieán ñieân ñaûo neân bò hoaïnh töû, ñoïa           nhaãn nhuïc, loøng thöông xoùt lôùn, loøng bi maãn lôùn, vaøo ñòa nguïc ñôøi ñôøi khoâng ra khoûi. Thöù nhì,          trí hueä, tænh thöùc, quyeát ñònh taâm, khoâng tham lam, bò pheùp vua tru luïc. Thöù ba, sa ñoïa ñaém say             khoâng saân haän, vaø khoâng si meâ—Nine elements of nôi söï chôi bôøi, saên baén, ñam meâ töûu saéc,             virtue: forbearance,           great mercy, great buoâng lung voâ ñoä, bò loaøi quyû ñoaït maát tinh           compassion, wisdom, mindfulness, resolute mind, khí. Hoaïnh töû thöù tö laø cheát thieâu. Hoaïnh töû         absence of greed, absence of anger, and absence thöù naêm laø cheát chìm. Hoaïnh töû thöù saùu laø           of stupidity. cheát vì bò thuù döõ aên thòt. Hoaïnh töû thöù baûy laø      Cöûu Cuù Nhaân: Moät töø ngöõ lyù luaän trong Phaät cheát vì bò rôi töø nuùi cao xuoáng vöïc thaúm.              giaùo; chín söï phoái hôïp khaû dó veà ñoàng phaåm vaø dò Hoaïnh töû thöù taùm laø cheát vì thuoác ñoäc, eám           phaåm—A term in Buddhist logic; the nine possible ñoái, ruûa noäp, truø eûo vaø bò quyû töû thi laøm haïi.     combination of like and unlike examples in a Hoaïnh töû thöù chín laø cheát vì ñoùi khaùt khoán           syllogism. khoå—According to The Medicine Buddha                        Cöûu Cö: See Cöûu Höõu. Sutra, Salvation Bodhisattva told Ananda that                Cöûu Dieäu: Chín ngoâi sao: nhaät, nguyeät, hoûa tinh,

thuûy tinh, moäc tinh, kim tinh, thoå tinh, la haàu vaø keá         nothingness (Tam Ñònh—Third samadhi), and ñoâ—The nine luminaries: the sun (aditya), the                      the land of knowledge without thinking or not moom (soma), mars, mercury, jupiter, venus,                         thinking, or where ther is neither saturn, the spirit that causes eclipses, and a                      consciousness nor unconsciousness (Töù comet.                                                              Ñònh—Fourth samadhhi). Cöûu Duï: Chín duï: tinh (sao), hoa ñoám, ñaêng (ñeøn),       Cöûu Ñieàu Caø Sa: See Cöûu ñieàu Y. aûo (aûo thuaät), söông (söông muø), baøo (bong boùng),       Cöûu Ñieàu Y: AÙo caø sa coù phaåm traät thaáp nhaát— moäng, ñieån chôùp, vaø maây—The nine similes: stars,         The lowest rank of the patched robe. eye-film, lamp, prestidigitation, dew, bubble,                Cöûu Ñôùi: Chín boä moân trong thieàn phaùp do ngaøi dream, lightning, and cloud.                                  Phaùp Dieãn laäp ra—Nine subjects in Fa-Yan's Zen Cöûu Ñaïo: Chín ñöôøng höõu tình cö—Nine realms               method—See Cöûu Ñôùi Thieàn and Phaùp Dieãn of living beings.                                             Thieàn Sö. Cöûu Ñeá: Kyutai (jap)—Chín chaân lyù: Voâ Thöôøng            Cöûu Ñôùi Thieàn: Thieàn phaùp do ngaøi Phaùp Dieãn ñeá, Khoå ñeá, Khoâng ñeá, Voâ Ngaõ ñeá, Höõu AÙi ñeá, Voâ    laäp ra. Trong thieàn phaùp naày, thieàn sö duøng cô ngöõ Höõu AÙi ñeá, Bæ Ñoaïn Phöông Tieän ñeá, Höõu Dö Nieát        saéc beùn maïnh meõ nhaèm môû con maét trí hueä cho ñeä Baøn ñeá, Voâ Dö Nieát Baøn ñeá—Nine truths or                töû—Name of Fa-Yan's Zen method. In this postulates: Impermanence, Suffering, Voidness                 Zenmethod, Zen masters use sharp and strong (unreality of things, the void), No permanent ego             words to open their students' wisdom eye—See or soul, Love of existence or possession resulting            Phaùp Dieãn Thieàn Sö. in suffering, Fear of being without existence or              Cöûu Giaûi Thoaùt Ñaïo: Trong tam giôùi coù cöûu ñòa, possession also resulting in suffering, Cutting of            moãi ñòa ñeàu coù kieán hoaëc, tö hoaëc, vaø tu hoaëc —In suffering and its cause, Nirvana with remainder               the nine stages of the trailokya each has its still to be worked out, and Complete Nirvana.                 possible delusions and erroneous performances— Cöûu Ñòa: Nine worlds—Chín giôùi—Chín coõi—                   See Cöûu Voâ Giaùn Ñaïo. Chín ñaát—The nine lands:                                     Cöûu Giôùi: Chín giôùi haõy coøn trong sai traùi vaø vaãn 1) Duïc Giôùi Nguõ Thuù Ñòa: The realm of desire—             coøn bò duïc voïng chi phoái; taát caû caùc giôùi cuûa chuùng Sensuous realm.                                         höõu tình töø Boà Taùt xuoáng haøng ñòa nguïc, ngoaïi tröø 2-5) Boán coõi Saéc Giôùi: Ly Sanh Hyû Laïc Ñòa, Ñònh         Phaät giôùi laø giôùi cao nhaát—The nine realms of Sanh Hyû Laïc Ñòa, Ly Hyû Dieäu Laïc Ñòa, Xaû           error, or subjection to the passion; all the realms Nieäm Thanh Tònh Ñòa—Four Realms of form                of the living from Bodhisattvas down to hells, (Material forms): Paradise after earthly life           except the tenth and highest, the Buddha realm— (Sô thieàn—First dhyana), Paradise of                   See Cöûu Ñòa. cessation of rebirth (Nhò thieàn—Second                 Cöûu Hình: See Cöïu Cheá Cöûu Hình. dhyana), Land of wondrous joy after the                 Cöûu Hoa Sôn: Chiu-Fa San—Moät trong boán ngoïn previous joys (Tam thieàn—Third dhyana), the            nuùi thieâng lieâng cuûa Phaät Giaùo, toïa laïc trong vuøng Pure Land of abandonment of thought or                  An Hoäi beân Trung Quoác, nôi truï trì cuûa Ngaøi Ñòa recollection of past delights (Töù thieàn—              Taïng Boà Taùt—One of the four sacred mountains Fourth dhyana).                                         of Buddhism situated in Anhui in China, and its 6-9)Boán coõi Voâ Saéc Giôùi: Khoâng Voâ Bieân Xöù Ñòa       patron is Earth –Store Bodhisattva (Ti-tsang)— (Akasanantyayatanam (skt), Thöùc Voâ Bieân              See Hoa Sôn. Xöù Ñòa (Vijnana-nantyayatanam (skt), Voâ Sôû           Cöûu Hoaïnh Töû: Chín nguyeân nhaân gaây ra caùi cheát Höõu Xöù Ñòa (Atkincanyayatana (skt), Phi               baát ñaéc kyø töû—Nine kinds of irregular death— Töôûng Phi Phi Töôûng Xöù Ñòa (Naivasanjnana-           Nine major forms of untimely death—See Cöûu samjnayatana (skt)—Four Formless realms                 Chuûng Hoaïnh Töû. (realms beyond form): the land of infinite              Cöûu Hoäi Maïn Ñaø La: Cöûu hoäi thuyeát—The nine space (Nhöùt Ñònh—First samadhi), the land of           groups in the diamond-realm mandala. omniscience or infinite perception (Nhò                 Cöûu Höôûng Long Ñaøm: Lung-t'an: Renowned Ñònh—Second samadhi), the land of                       Far and Wide—See Long Ñaøm Cöûu Höôûng.

Cöûu Höõu: Chín coõi trôøi hyû laïc: Thöù nhaát laø Duïc       (possession),         Doubt,     Envy,        and      Selfish Giôùi Nhaân Thieân hay Sô chuùng sanh cö. Theá giôùi           (meanness). Ta Baø vaø saùu coõi trôøi duïc giôùi trong ñoù chuùng sanh    Cöûu Khieáu: See Cöûu Khoång Baát Tònh. coù nhieàu loaïi thaân vaø nhieàu loaïi töôûng. Thöù nhì laø   Cöûu Khoång: See Cöûu Khoång Baát Tònh. Phaïm Chuùng Giôùi Thieân, nôi chuùng sanh coù nhieàu          Cöûu Khoång (Khieáu) Baát Tònh: Chín loå baát tònh thaân khaùc nhau nhöng töôûng laïi gioáng nhau. Thöù           trong thaân: hai maét, hai loå tai, hai loå muõi, mieäng, ba laø Cöïc Quang Tònh Thieân, nôi chuùng sanh chæ             tieåu tieän, ñaïi tieän. Ñöùc Phaät daïy coù chín loå baát tònh coù moät loaïi thaân nhöng nhieàu loaïi töôûng khaùc           trong cô theå chuùng ta, töø moãi loå naày luoân ræ ra moïi nhau. Thöù tö laø Bieán Tònh Thieân, nôi chuùng sanh           thöù caën baõ nhö ñôøm nôi coå hoïng, moà hoâi töø loå loâng chæ coù moät thaân vaø moät töôûng gioáng nhau. Thöù           nôi da, vaân vaân. Khoâng coù söï baøi tieát naøo coù theå naêm laø Voâ Töôûng Thieân, nôi chuùng sanh khoâng coù         ngöõi, rôø hay neám cho voâ. Taát caû ñeàu baát tònh— töôûng maø cuõng khoâng coù giaùc tri. Thöù saùu laø           Nine impure openings in our body: eyes, ears, Khoâng Voâ Bieân Xöù, nôi chuùng sanh khoân g xöù truï.        nose (nostrils), mouth, anus, and rectum. The Thöù baûy laø Thöùc Voâ Bieân Xöù, nôi chuùng sanh truï        Buddha teaches us that there are nine openings in nôi thöùc. Thöù taùm laø Voâ Sôû Höõu Xöù, nôi chuùng          our body and from each of them exudes all kinds sanh baát duïng xöù truï. Thöù chín laø Phi Töôûng Phi         of excretions all the the time, i.e., phlegm from Phi Töôûng, nôi chuùng sanh höõu töôûng voâ töôûng             throat, sweat from the pores of skin, etc. None of xöù—The nine realities, states or conditions in                the things excreted are pleasant to smell or touch which sentient beings enjoy to dwell: First, the               or taste. They are all unclean things. world and the six deva heavens of desire in which              Cöûu Kieáp: The nine kalpas—Theo Kinh Ñaïi Baûo there is variety of bodies and thinking or ideas.              Tích, duø Phaät Thích Ca vaø Di Laëc cuøng khôûi ñaàu Second, the three Brahma-heavens where bodies                  moät löôït, nhöng söï tinh taán ñaõ khieán cho Ngaøi differ but thinking is the same (the first dhyana              Thích Ca thaønh Phaät sôùm hôn Ngaøi Di Laëc ñeán 9 heaven—Sô thieàn thieân). Third, the three bright              tieåu kieáp—According to the Maharatnakuta Sutra, and pure heavens where bodies are identical but                though Sakyamuni and Maitreya started together, thinking differs (the second dhyan heaven—Nhò                  the zeal of the first enabled him to become thieàn thieân). Fourth, the three universally pure             Buddha nine kalpas sooner. heavens where bodies and thinking are the same                 Cöûu Kinh: See Cöûu Boä Kinh and Thaäp Nhò Ñaïi (the third dhyana heaven—Tam thieàn thieân). Fifth,            Thöøa Kinh. the no-thinking or no-thought heaven (The highest              Cöûu Lieân: See Cöûu Phaåm Lieân Hoa. of the four dhyana heavens—Töù thieàn thieân).                 Cöûu Laäp: Phieàn ñöùng laâu, lôøi an uûi cuûa vò thieàn sö Sixth, limitless space (First of the formless                  sau buoåi thuyeát phaùp daøi—Sorry to let you realms). Seventh, limitless perception (the second             (someone) stand so long! This is a word of console of the formless realms). Eighth, nothingness, the              from a Zen master after a long preaching. place beyong things (the third of the formless                 Cöûu Laäu: Nine leakages—See Cöûu Khoång. realms). Ninth, beyond thought or non thought (the             Cöûu Loaïi Sanh: Chín loaïi sanh—Nine kinds of fourth formless realms).                                       birth. Cöûu Höõu Tình Cö: See Cöûu Höõu.                              1-4) Boán loaïi ñaàu cho chuùng sanh caùc coõi trôøi, Cöûu Keát: Chín moái phieàn tröôïc ñaõ keát noái con                 ngöôøi vaø ñòa nguïc: thai sanh, noaõn sanh, thaáp ngöôøi trong sanh töû: AÙi Keát (thöông yeâu hay tham                sanh vaø hoùa sanh—The first four kinds are aùi), Nhueá Keát (söï hôøn giaän), Maïn Keát (ngaõ maïn              common to devas, earth, and hells: birth from hay kieâu maïn), Si Keát (si meâ hay söï voâ minh cuûa               the womb, birth from the egg, birth from the vieäc khoâng hieåu söï lyù), Kieán Keát (taø kieán), Thuû            moisture, and birth from transformation. Kieán Keát (chaáp thuû), Nghi Keát (nghi hoaëc Tam             5-9) Naêm loaïi thöù nhì cho caùc baäc thaùnh coõi saéc Baûo), Taät Keát (ganh gheùt vôùi söï giaøu sang hoaëc               giôùi vaø voâ saéc giôùi: höõu saéc, voâ saéc, höõu hay ho cuûa ngöôøi), Kieân Keát (vò kyû)—The nine                    töôûng, voâ töôûng, vaø phi töôûng phi phi töôûng— bonds that bind men to mortality: Love, Hate,                        The second five for upper sages and saints in Pride, Ignorance, Wrong views, Grasping                              the realms of form and non-form: birth into

the heavens of form, birth into the heavens of             mình chæ keùm ngöôøi chuùt ít thoâi. Thöù baûy laø Voâ non-form, birth into the heavens of thought,               Thaéng Ngaõ Maïn. Ñoái vôùi ngöôøi baèng mình, laïi birth into the heavens of non-thought, and                 sanh taâm kieâu maïn cho raèng khoâng ai coù theå hôn birth into the heavens of neither thought nor              mình ñöôïc. Thöù taùm laø Höõu Ñaúng Ngaõ Maïn. Duø non-thought.                                               bieát ngöôøi cuõng baèng mình, nhöng vaãn sanh taâm Cöûu Long: Nine Dragons.                                        kieâu maïn cho raèng hoï chæ baèng ta thoâi. Thöù chín laø Cöûu Luaân: Khoâng Luaân—Vaønh kim luaân (chieác                Höõu Lieät Ngaõ Maïn. Ñoái vôùi ngöôøi baèng mình, laïi loïng) coù chín taàng ñaët treân ñænh chuøa thaùp —Also         khôûi taâm kieâu maïn cho raèng hoï teä hôn mình— called the wheel of space—The nine wheel or                     According to Abhidharma, there are nine forms of circles on the top of a pagoda.                                 pride: First, that I surpass those who are equal to Cöûu Löïc: Nine Powers—Theo Tyø Kheo Boà Ñeà                    me. Second, that I am equal to those who surpass trong Vi Dieäu Phaùp, coù chính thöù löïc—According             me (the pride of thinking oneself equal to those to Bhikkhu Bodhi in Abhidhamma, there are nine                  who surpass us). Third, that I am not so bad as powers:                                                         others. Fourth, that others surpass me. Fifth, none 1-5)Naêm löïc thieän hay trung tính: tín löïc, nieäm löïc,      are equal to me. Sixth, none are inferior to me. tueä löïc, taøm löïc (bieát hoå theïn khi gaây neân toäi   Seventh, none surpass me. Eighth, that are equal loãi), quyù löïc (bieát gheâ sôï haäu quaû cuûa toäi       to me. Ninth, that are worse than me. loãi)—Five powers that are either wholesome                Cöûu Moân: Chín cöûa—Nine gates—See Cöûu Höõu. or indeterminate: the power of faith, the                  Cöûu Nan Söï: Chín ñieàu khoù trong Kinh Töù Thaäp power of mindfulness, the power of wisdom,                 Nhò Chöông—Chöông 36): Thöù nhaát laø keû thoaùt the power of shame, and the power of fear of               ñöôïc aùc ñaïo ñeå ñöôïc sanh laøm ngöôøi laø khoù. Thöù wrongdoing.                                                nhì laø ñöôïc laøm ngöôøi maø thoaùt ñöôïc thaân nöõ ñeå 6-7)Hai löïc baát thieän: voâ taøm löïc (khoâng bieát hoå       laøm thaân nam laø khoù. Thöù ba laø laøm ñöôïc thaân theïn khi gaây neân toäi loãi) vaø voâ quyù löïc (khoâng   nam maø saùu giaùc quan ñaày ñuû laø khoù. Thöù tö laø bieát gheâ sôï haäu quaû cuûa toäi loãi)—Two               moät khi ñaõ coù saùu caên ñaày ñuû, vaãn khoù ñöôïc sanh unwholesome powers: the power of                           vaøo xöù trung taâm. Thöù naêm laø ñaõ sanh ñöôïc vaøo shamelessness and the power of fearlessness                xöù trung taâm, vaãn khoù ñöôïc sanh vaøo thôøi coù Phaät. of wrongdoing.                                             Thöù saùu laø ñaõ sanh vaøo thôøi coù Phaät, vaãn khoù ñöôïc 8-9)Hai löïc hoaëc thieän, hoaëc baát thieän, hoaëc trung       gaëp Ñaïo. Thöù baûy laø ñaõ gaëp Ñaïo, vaãn khoù khôûi tính: taán löïc vaø ñònh löïc —Two powers, either          ñöôïc nieàm tin. Thöù taùm laø ñaõ coù ñöôïc nieàm tin, wholesome            or        unwholesome            or   vaãn khoù phaùt taâm Boà Ñeà. Thöù chín laø phaùt taâm Boà indeterminate: the power of energy and the                 Ñeà maø ñaït ñeán choã voâ tu voâ chöùng laø khoù —Nine power of concentration.                                    difficulties (Sutra in Forty-Two Sections—Chapter Cöûu Löu: Nine entrances—Nine suppurations—                     36): First, it is difficult for one to leave the evil See Cöûu Khoång.                                                paths and become a human being. Second, it is Cöûu Maïn: Theo Vi Dieäu Phaùp thì coù chín loaïi               still difficult to become a male human being (a maïn: Thöù nhaát laø Ngaõ Thaéng Maïn. Ñoái vôùi ngöôøi         man rather than a woman). Third, once one baèng mình, laïi sinh taâm quaù maïn cho raèng mình             becomes a man, it is difficult to have the six hôn hoï. Thöù nhì laø Ngaõ Ñaúng Maïn. Ñoái vôùi ngöôøi         organs complete and perfect. Fourth, once the six hôn mình, laïi sinh taâm quaù maïn cho raèng mình               organs are complete and perfect, it is still difficult baèng hoï. Thöù ba laø Ngaõ Lieät Maïn. Khôûi taâm kieâu        for one to be born in the central county. Fifth, if maïn cho raèng mình khoâng ñeán noãi teä nhö ngöôøi             one is born in the central country, it is still difficult khaùc. Thöù tö laø Höõu Thaéng Ngaõ Maïn. Vaãn khôûi            to be born at the time of a Buddha. Sixth, if one is taâm kieâu maïn duø bieát raèng ngöôøi ñoù hôn mình.            born at the time of a Buddha, it is still difficult for Thöù naêm laø Voâ Ñaúng Ngaõ Maïn. Khôûi taâm kieâu             one to encounter the Way. Seventh, if one does maïn cho raèng khoâng ai baèng mình. Thöù saùu laø Voâ          encounter the Way, it is still difficult for one to Lieät Ngaõ Maïn. Duø bieát raèng khoâng ai keùm hôn             bring forth faith. Eighth, if one does have mình nhöng vaãn sanh loøng kieâu maïn cho raèng                 sufficient faith, it is still difficult for one to resolve

one’s mind on Bodhi. Ninth, if one does resolve               ba, Cöû Thuû Cao Aáp hay ñöa tay leân cao ñeå chaøo. one’s mind on Bodhi, it is still difficult to be              Thöù tö, Hôïp Chöôûng Bình Cuûng hay chaáp tay cuùi without cultivation and without attainment.                   ñaàu chaøo. Thöù naêm, Khuaát Taát hay nhuùn cong ñaàu Cöûu Naïn: Nine difficulties—Nine distresses—                 goái chaøo. Thöù saùu, Tröôøng Quyø hay quyø goái ñeå See Cöûu Naõo.                                                chaøo. Thöù baûy, Thuû taát Cöù Ñòa hay chaøo baèng Cöûu Naõo: Cöûu Nan—Nine difficulties—Chín söï                caùch ñeå hai baøn tay vaø hai ñaàu goái xuoáng ñaát. Thöù phieàn naõo hay chín tai naïn maø Ñöùc Phaät ñaõ gaëp         taùm, Nguõ Luaân Caâu Khaát hay chaøo baèng caùch cho phaûi khi Ngaøi coøn taïi theá: Thöù nhaát, Ngaøi bò naøng    hai cuøi choû vaø hai ñaàu goái xuoáng ñaát. Thöù chín, Toân Ñaø Lôïi phæ baùng thaäm teä. Thöù nhì, naøng Chieân     Nguõ Theå Ñaàu Ñòa hay chaøo baèng caùch phuû phuïc Giaø coá tình laøm nhuïc Ngaøi baèng caùch giaû buïng         caû thaân ngöôøi saùt ñaát—According to Hsuan-Tsang, chöûa roài vu caùo. Thöù ba, Ñeà Baø Ñaït Ña, ngöôøi em       there are nine ways of showing respect in Indian hoï cuûa Ngaøi, ñaõ aâm möu aùm saùt Ngaøi baèng caùch        at his time: First, saluting by asking about welfare laên ñaù xuoáng ñoài khi Ngaøi ñi ngang qua khu nuùi.         (speaking softly). Second, saluting by bowing the Thöù tö, Ngaøi bò muõi teân töï döng lao tôùi ñaâm vaøo       head. Third, saluting by holding high hands. chaân. Thöù naêm, Ngaøi bò Löu Li Vöông Thaùi töû con         Fourth, saluting by bowing head with folded vua Ba Tö Naëc ñem quaân ñeán gieát heát nhöõng               hands. Fifth, saluting by bending the knee. Sixth, ngöôøi trong doøng hoï Thích Ca. Thöù saùu, vì loøng töø      saluting by kneeling. Seventh, saluting by placing bi, Ngaøi nhaän lôøi thænh caàu ñeán nhaø moät ngöôøi Baø     two hands and knees on the ground. Eighth, La Moân ñeå nhaän cuùng döôøng, nhöng khi ñeán ngöôøi         saluting by placing two elbows and knees on the aáy khoâng cuùng. Phaät vaø Taêng ñoaøn cuûa Ngaøi phaûi      ground. Ninth, saluting by humbly and aên luùa ngöïa cuûa moät ngöôøi chaên ngöïa ñem cho.          submissively prostrating the whole body on the Thöù baûy, bò gioù laïnh thoåi laøm ñau löng. Thöù taùm laø   ground. saùu naêm khoå haïnh. Thöù chín, vaøo xoùm Baø La Moân        Cöûu Nghieäp: Chín Loaïi Nghieäp—Nine kinds of khaát thöïc trong ba ngaøy lieàn, khoâng ai cuùng döôøng,     karma—Nine evil acts by the body, speech and phaûi mang baùt khoâng veà—Nine distresses borne              mind which produce three kinds of retribution: by the Buddha while he was still alive: First, He             retribution in the present life, in the next life, and was badly slandered by Sundara. Second, Canca                 in the life after next. tried to dishonor him by pretending to pregnant               1-3) Ba nghieäp trong Duïc Giôùi: Taùc Nghieäp, Voâ and falsely accusing him. Third, Devadatta, his                     Taùc Nghieäp, vaø Phi Taùc Phi Voâ Taùc —Three cousin, plotted to assassinate him by rolling stones                kinds of Karma in the Desire realm: Conduct down hill when he passed by the creek. Fourth,                      that causes karma, Conduct that does not pierced by an arrow accidentally. Fifth, son of                     cause karma, and Conduct that is neutral. King Prasenajit killed all people in the Sakya                4-6) Ba nghieäp trong Saéc Giôùi: Taùc Nghieäp, Phi tribe. Sixth, due to his compassion, the Buddha                     Taùc Nghieäp, vaø Phi Taùc Phi Voâ Taùc —Three accepted an invitation from a Brahman; however,                     kinds of Karma in the Form realm: Conduct when the Buddha and his order arrived, the                          that causes karma, Conduct that does not Brahman refused to serve them. As a result, the                     cause karma, and Conduct that is neutral. Buddha and his order had to accept offering from              7-9) Ba nghieäp trong Voâ Saéc Giôùi: Voâ Taùc Nghieäp, the stable-keeper. Seventh, cold wind to cause                      Phi Taùc Phi Voâ Taùc, vaø Voâ Laäu Nghieäp— back pain. Eighth, six years of ascetics. Ninth,                    Three kinds of Karma in the Formless realm: entering the village for alms for three consecutive                 Non-causative        deeds,    Neutrality,      and days without receiving any food (returning with                     Immortality. empty bowl).                                                  Cöûu Nguõ: Ngoâi vua—The throne. Cöûu Nghi: Chín oai nghi—Theo Ngaøi Huyeàn                    Cöûu Nhaân Nhöùt Quaû: Chín cuûa möôøi phaùp giôùi laø Trang, coù chín phöông caùch toû veû toân kính cuøa AÁn       nhaân, phaùp giôùi thöù möôøi laø quaû—Nine of the ten Ñoä: Thöù nhaát, Phaùt Ngoân UÙy Vaán hay toû lôøi chaøo      dhatu or regions are causative, the tenth is the hoûi (hoûi thaêm söùc khoûe vaø aên noùi nhoû nheï). Thöù     effect or resultant—See Phaät Giôùi. nhì, Phuû Thuû Thò Kính hay cuùi ñaàu kính chaøo. Thöù        Cöûu Nhaäp: See Cöûu Khoång.

Cöûu Nieân Dieän Bích: Face stone in nine years—             Cöûu Phaåm Giaùc Vöông: Vua Boà Ñeà nôi coõi Tònh To face wall in nine years—Toïa thieàn maët xoay             Ñoä—The king or lord of the bodhi of the Pure vaøo töôøng, nhö Toå Boà Ñeà Ñaït Ma ñaõ 9 naêm dieän        Land—Amitabha. bích maø khoâng noùi moät lôøi—To sit in meditation          Cöûu Phaåm Haïnh Nghieäp: Chín haïnh nghieäp ñaït with the face to a wall, as did Bodhidharma for              ñöôïc qua tu taäp, nhôø ñoù con ngöôøi ñöôïc vaõng sanh nine years, without uttering a word—See Boà Ñeà              Tònh Ñoä—The nine karma to be attained by the Ñaït Ma.                                                     conduct or practice through which one may be Cöûu Phaïm: Chín coõi trôøi thuoäc Töù Thieàn Thieân:        born into the Pure Land—See Cöûu Phaåm Lieân Voâ Vaân Thieân, Phuùc Sinh Thieân, Quaûng Quaû              Hoa. Thieân, Voâ Töôûng Thieân(Asamjni-sattvah (skt), Voâ         Cöûu Phaåm Lieân Ñaøi: See Cöûu Phaåm An Döôõng Phieàn Thieân, Voâ Nhieät Thieân (Anavatapta (skt),          and Cöûu Phaåm Lieân Hoa. Thieän Hieän Thieân (Sudrsd (skt), Thieän Kieán Thieân       Cöûu Phaåm Lieân Hoa: Nine grades of aspirants— (Sudarsana (skt), Saéc Cöùu Caùnh Thieân (Akanistha          Nine Lotus grades—Chín phaåm Lieân Hoa—Nine (skt)—The nine heavens of the fourth dhyana                  Holy Grades of Lotus: heaven: Cloudless Heaven, Producing Blessing                 1-3) HAÏ PHAÅM—Ba baäc thaáp nhaát trong vaõng Rewards, Broad Phala (the 12th Brahmaloka, great                  sanh Tònh ñoä: Haï Phaåm Haï Sanh, Haï Phaåm fruit or abundant merits), Absence of thinking or                 Trung Sanh, vaø Haï Phaåm Thöôïng Sanh—The the Heaven above Thought., Free from trouble                      three lowest stages of the nine stages of birth (the 13th Brahmaloka, the 5th region of the fourth                in the Pure Land: the lowest of the three Dhyana—see Töù Thieàn Thieân), the Heaven                         lowest classes who enter the Pure Land of without heat or affliction, the 7th Brahmaloka (8th               Amitabha, the middle of the three lowest of the Dhyana Heavens), Good to see Heaven,                       classes (grades), and the highest of the three and the highest of the material heavens (See Saéc                 lowest classes (grades). Giôùi, and Thieân).                                          4-6) TRUNG PHAÅM—Ba baäc giöõa cuûa vaõng sanh Cöûu Phaïm Thieân: The nine heavens of the fourth                 Tònh ñoä: Trung Phaåm Haï Sanh, Trung Phaåm dhyana heaven—See Töù Thieàn Thieân.                              Trung Sanh, vaø Trung Phaåm Thöôïng Sanh— Cöûu Phaåm: Nine grades of rebirth—See Cöûu                       The three middle stages of the nine stages of Phaåm Lieân Hoa.                                                  birth in the Pure Land: the lowest of the three Cöûu Phaåm An Döôõng: Chín phaåm Tònh Ñoä, töông                  middle classes who enter the Pure Land of öùng vôùi chín söï phaùt trieån trong tieàn kieáp, khoaûng        Amitabha, the middle of the three middle caùch vôùi Ñöùc A Di Ñaø trong kieáp töông lai seõ tuøy           classes, and the highest of the three middle thuoäc vaøo ñoù maø hoa sen nôû sôùm hay muoän—The                classes. nine grades or rewards of the Pure Land,                     7-9) THÖÔÏNG PHAÅM—Ba baäc cao nhaát cuûa vaõng corresponding to the nine grades of development                   sanh Tònh ñoä: Thöôïng Phaåm Haï Sanh, Thöôïng in the previous life, upon which depends, in the                  Phaåm Trung Sanh, vaø Thöôïng Phaåm Thöôïng next life, one’s distance from Amitabha, the                      Sanh —The three highest of the nine stages of consequent aeons that are needed to approach                      birth in the Pure Land of Amitabha: the him, and whether one’s lotus will open early or                   lowest of the three highest classes who enter late—See Cöûu Phaåm Lieân Hoa.                                    the Pure Land of Amitabha, the middle of the Cöûu Phaåm An Döôõng Hoùa Sanh: Nhöõng chuùng                     three highest classes, and the highest of the sanh hoùa sanh töø hoa sen vaøo cöûu phaåm An Döôõng              three highest classes. ñòa—Those born by transformation from the                    Cöûu Phaåm Thöôïng: Ba baäc cao nhaát cuûa vaõng heavenly lotus into the ninefold Paradise.                   sanh veà Tònh Ñoä cuûa Phaät A Di Ñaø—The three Cöûu Phaåm Di Ñaø: Chín hình thöùc cuûa Di Ñaø Tònh          highest of the nine stages of birth in the Pure Land Ñoä, töông öùng vôùi chín phaåm trong coõi nöôùc Tònh        of Amitabha—See Cöûu Phaåm Lieân Hoa. Ñoä—The nine forms of Amitabha, corresponding                Cöûu Phaåm Thöôïng Sanh: See Cöûu Phaåm Lieân to the nine departments of the Pure Land.                    Hoa. Cöûu Phaåm Ñaïi Y: See Cöûu Ñieàu Y.                         Cöûu Phaåm (Thöôïng) Y: Trong Taêng Giaø Leâ, coù

chín loaïi aùo khaùc nhau—The sanghati, there are                 Way." Chiu Feng Ch'in said, "The Buddha nine grades of the monk’s patched robe.                           does not fight against people's wishes." The 1-3)Ba loaïi Thöôïng Taêng Giaø Leâ (cao nhaát): aùo             monk said, "Thank you, Master, for this hai möôi moát maûnh, aùo hai möôi ba maûnh, vaø              expedient." Chiu Feng Ch'in said, "You still aùo hai möôi laêm maûnh—Three superior:                      earn blows from the staff." twenty-one patched robe, twenty-three                   Moät hoâm, Thieàn sö Cöûu Phong Caàn thöôïng patched robe, and twenty-five patched robe.                  ñöôøng daïy chuùng: "Daàu cho maáy oâng coù noùi 4-6)Ba loaïi Trung Taêng Giaø Leâ: aùo möôøi laêm                cho ñeán khi xanh caû maët, hay noùi: 'AÄy!' moät maûnh, aùo möôøi baûy maûnh, vaø aùo möôøi chín              ngaøn laàn, hay heùt leân caû vaïn laàn. Taïi sao caây maûnh—Three middle: fifteen patched robe,                    coät ñình khoâng nhìn nhaän oâng?" Sau khi seventeen patched robe, and nineteen patched                 ngöøng moät luùc laâu, Cöûu Phong Caàn noùi tieáp: robe.                                                        "Ñoà aên ngon khoâng thoûa maõn côn ñoùi." Noùi 7-9)Ba loaïi Haï Taêng Giaø Leâ: aùo chín maû nh, aùo            xong Sö xuoáng toøa—One day, Zen master möôøi moät maûnh, vaø aùo möôøi ba maûnh —Three              Chiu Feng Ch'in entered the hall and lowest ranks: nine patched robe, eleven                      addressed the monks, saying, "No matter if patched robe, and thirteen patched robe.                     you talk until you're blue in the face, or say Cöûu Phaåm Tònh Ñoä: The nine grades (classes) of                 'Hey!' a thousand times, or shout ten thousand the Pure Land—See Cöûu Phaåm Lieân Hoa.                           times. Why is it that the temple pillar still Cöûu Phaåm Vaõng Sanh: Vaõng sanh veà cöûu phaåm                  won't acknowledge you?" After a long pause, Lieân Hoa Tònh Ñoä—The ninefold future life in the                Chiu Feng Ch'in said, "Delicious food doesn't Pure Land—See Cöûu Phaåm Lieân Hoa and Cöûu                       satisfy the hungry." He then got down from Phaåm An Döôõng.                                                  the Dharma seat. Cöûu Phong Caàn Thieàn Sö: Kyuho Gon (jap)—                 Cöûu Phong Chaân Tònh: Chiu Feng Chen Ching— Chiu-feâng Ch'in (Wade-Giles Chinese)—Jiufeng               Teân cuûa moät vò Thieàn Taêng—Name of a Zen Qin (Pinyin Chinese)—Hieän nay chuùng ta khoâng             monk. coù nhieàu taøi lieäu chi tieát veà Thieàn sö Cöûu Phong    Cöûu Phong Ñaïo Kieàn Thieàn Sö (?-923): Kyuho- Caàn; tuy nhieân, coù moät vaøi chi tieát lyù thuù veà vò   Doken (jap)—Chiu-feâng Tao-ch'ien (Wade-Giles Thieàn sö naøy trong Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc: Thieàn sö          Chinese)—Jiufeng Daoqian (Pinyin Chinese)— Cöûu Phong Caàn laø ñeä töû cuûa Thieàn sö Trí Moân         Teân cuûa moät vò Thieàn sö Trung Hoa vaø o theá kyû thöù Quang Toä. OÂng soáng vaø daïy Thieàn trong khu Cao         X. Hieän nay chuùng ta khoâng coù nhieàu taøi lieäu chi An, baây giôø thuoäc tænh Giang Taây—We do not              tieát veà Thieàn sö Cöûu Phong Ñaïo Kieàn; tuy nhieân, have detailed documents on this Zen Master;                 coù moät vaøi chi tieát nhoû veà vò Thieàn sö naøy trong however, there is some interesting information on           Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån XVI: OÂng ñeán töø coå him in The Records of the Transmission of the               thaønh Phuùc Chaâu. Sö töøng laøm thò giaû cho ñeán khi Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu): Zen master Chiu Feng                 Thieàn sö Thaïch Söông Khaùnh Chö thò tòch. Sau khi Ch'in was a disciple of Zen master Kuang-Zuo-               thaày mình thò tòch, theo lôøi thænh caàu cuûa Taêng Zhi-Men (Kuang-zuo Chih-men). He lived and                  chuùng, Sö nhaän chöùc truï trì. Veà sau naøy, Sö ñi ñeán taught Zen in the area of Gao-an in modern                  nuùi Cöûu Phong (Chín ngoïn) ôû Nhöï Chaâu, trong tænh Jiangxi Province.                                           Giang Taây ngaøy nay, nôi oâng nhaän ñöôïc teân nuùi  Moät vò Taêng noùi vôùi Cöûu Phong Caàn: "Con             naøy. Thieàn sö Cöûu Phong Ñaïo Kieàn laø thaày cuûa thænh Hoøa Thöôïng tieát loä moät phöông tieän         Hoøa Sôn Nguõ AÂm—Zen Master Chiu-feng, name thieän xaûo ñeå vaøo Ñaïo." Cöûu Phong Caàn noùi:      of a Chinese Zen monk in the tenth century. We "Phaät khoâng choáng laïi yù nguyeän cuûa con          do not have detailed documents on this Zen ngöôøi." Vò Taêng noùi: "Caûm taï, Hoøa Thöôïng,       Master; however, there is some brief information ñaõ cho moät phöông tieän thieän xaûo." Cöûu           on him in The Records of the Transmission of the Phong Caàn noùi: "OÂng ñaùng aên gaäy."—A monk         Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), Volume XVI: Zen said to Chiu Feng Ch'in, "I ask the master to          master Chiu-feng came from ancient Fuzhou. reveal an expedient method to enter the                Until Master Shih-shuang's death, Chiu-feng

served as his student and personal attendant. At                    Monk answered, "This is only a sentence to the invitation of other monks Chiu-feng then                        illustrate the subject matter of the One Form." assumed the vacant abbacy of the monastery.                         (a state of absolute annihilation). Later he moved to Chiu-feng (Nine Peaks) in                        Cöûu Phong la leân: "Ñoù! Toâi bieát oâng chaúng heà Ruizhou, in modern Jiangxi Province, where he                       hieåu giaùo lyù cuûa Thaày!"—Chiu-feng then acquired his mountain name. Zen master Chiu-                        cried out loudly: "See! I knew you didn't feng was the master of Ho-shan-Wu-yin.                              understand our late Master's teaching at all!"  Khi Thaïch Söông thò tòch, chuùng Taêng trong töï                Ñeä Nhaát Toøa hoûi: "OÂng khoâng chaáp nhaän kieán vieän hoïp vaø quyeát ñònh choïn Ñeä Nhaát Toøa                 giaûi naøo cuûa toâi? Baây giôø haõy ñoát moät neùn laøm truï trì môùi. Nhöng Cöûu Phong ñöùng leân                 höông cho toâi. Neáu toâi khoâng theå cheát tröôùc noùi vôùi cöû toïa: "Tröôùc heát chuùng ta phaûi bieát          khi höông chaùy heát, luùc aáy toâi chòu nhaän laø toâi raèng Ñeä Nhaát Toøa coù thöïc söï hieåu giaùo lyù cuûa         khoâng hieåu yù Thaày ta muoán noùi gì!"—The Thaày khoâng ñaõ."—When Shih-shuang died,                       Chief Monk then asked, "What understanding all the monks in his monastery held a                           of mine is it that you do not accept? Now light conference and decided to nominate the Chief                    a stick of incense for me. If I cannot die Monk there as the new Abbot. But Chiu-feng                      before it has burned out, the I'll admit that I rose and said to the assembly: "We must                         do not understand what our late Master know first whether he truly understands the                     meant!" teaching of our late Master."                                  Roài moät neùn höông ñöôïc ñoát vaø Ñeä Nhaát Toøa  Ñeä Nhaát Toøa hoûi: "OÂng ñònh hoûi gì veà giaùo lyù             baét ñaàu ngoài, thaúng nhö moät caây gaäy. Vaø kia, cuûa Thaày?"—The Chief Monk then asked,                         tröôùc khi neùn höông chaùy heát, vò Ñeä Nhaát Toøa "What question have you in mind concerning                      ñaõ vieân tòch ngay choã oâng ngoài!—Whereupon our late Master's teachings?"                                   the incense was lighted and the Chief Monk  Cöûu Phong ñaùp: "Thaày noùi, 'Queân taát caû, ñöøng              assumed his seat, sitting straight as a pole. ñoäng gì, coá ngôi nghæ hoaøn toaøn! Coá traûi qua              And before the stick of incense was möôøi ngaøn naêm trong moät nieäm! Coá trôû thaønh              completely consumed, the Chief Monk had tro laïnh vaø caây khoâ! Coá ôû gaàn lö höông trong             actually passed away right there where he ngoâi coå töï! Coá trôû neân moät daûi luïa traéng!' Toâi       sat! khoâng hoûi ngaøi veà phaàn ñaàu cuûa lôøi daïy naøy,          Trong caâu truyeän treân, khi vò Ñeä Nhaát Toøa bò maø chæ veà caâu cuoái; 'Coá trôû neân moät daûi luïa           Cöûu Phong thaùch, oâng ñaõ can ñaûm quaû quyeát traéng?' Theá coù nghóa laø gì?"—Chiu-feng                      tri thöùc noäi taïi cuûa mình baèng caùch thöïc hieän replied, "Our late Master said: 'Forget                         söï giaûi thoaùt caùi taâm yù thöùc khoûi thaân xaùc vaät everything, stop doing anything, and try to                     lyù trong moät vaøi phuùt. Coù ai, khoâng coù ñoâi rest completely! Try to pass ten thousand                       chuùt giaùc ngoä noäi taïi veà Chaân Lyù Thieàn, maø years in one thought! Try to be cold ashes and                  laïi coù theå thöïc hieän moät vieäc taùo baïo ñaùng keå a worn-out tree! Try to be near the censer in                   nhö vaäy? Nhöng ngaïc nhieân thay, ngay caû the old temple! Try to be a length of white                     thaønh tích phi thöôøng naøy cuõng khoâng ñuùng silk'. I do not ask you about the first part of                 vôùi tieâu chuaån cuûa Thieàn! Coù theå giaûi thoaùt this admonition, but only about the last                        mình khoûi sanh töû theo ñuùng nghóa ñen cuûa noù sentence: 'Try to be a length of white silk.'                   cuõng vaãn coøn caùch xa muïc tieâu cuûa giaùo lyù What does it mean?" (Stop all your                              Thieàn Sö! Luùc aáy Cöûu Phong voã vai töû thi vaø hankerings; be like cold ashes and withered                     noùi: "OÂng coù theå ngoài vaø thò tòch ngay töùc thì plants; keep the mouth tightly closed until                     cuõng ñöôïc; coøn veà yù nghóa nhöõng lôøi cuûa mould grows about it; be like pure white                        Thaày, oâng vaãn chaúng hieåu chuùt naøo!" Qua linen; thoroughly immaculate; be as cold and                    ñaây, chuùng ta thaáy truyeàn thoáng Thieàn ñaõ bieåu dead as a censer in a deserted shrine)                          loä moät caùch hieån nhieân thaùi ñoä khinh thò ñoái  Ñeä Nhaát Toøa ñaùp: "Ñoù chæ laø moät caâu giaûi                 vôùi thaàn thoâng. Thieàn khoâng mong caàu maø thích veà vaán ñeà Nhaát Töôùng."—The Chief                     cuõng chaúng quan taâm ñeán baát cöù loaïi thaàn

thoâng naøo. Ñieàu maø Thieàn thaät söï quan taâm           moät caâu ñeå chæ maët traêng. Khi maáy oâng ôû giöõa ñeán laø söï lieãu tri vaø chöùng ngoä caùi huyeàn dieäu    söï töùc laø thoaïi nguyeät. Chuyeän trong toâng moân cuûa taát caû nhöõng huyeàn dieäu, caùi Phaùp thaân         cuûa chö Toå döôøng nhö laø maáy oâng duøng côø baát khaû tö nghì maø chuùng ta coù theå tìm thaáy ôû       phöôùn laøm tin trong moãi luùc. Coøn nhö sieâu taát caû moïi choã vaø vaøo taát caû moïi thôøi—In the      vieät ñöùc maø ñeán tröôùc khi kieán laäp soá nhieàu preceding story, when the Chief Monk was                    danh muïc trong caùc coõi. Hôõi chö huynh ñeä, challenged by Chiu-feng, he courageously                    thaân khaåu naøo troùi buoäc maáy oâng? Ngay taïi testified to his understanding by actually                  choã naøy ñaây. Laõo Taêng khoâng gaït maáy oâng tí liberating his consciousness-soul from his                  naøo caû. Haõy xem xeùt nhöõng lôøi laõo Taêng noùi physical body within a few minutes. Who,                    roài maáy oâng seõ thaáy. Laõo Taêng khoâng phænh without having some inner realization of Zen                gaït loã tai cuûa maáy oâng. Haõy thöû nghieäm lôøi Truth, could possibly perform such a                        noùi cuûa laõo Taêng. Laõo Taêng khoâng phænh gaït remarkable feat? But, surprisingly, even this               nhôõn quang cuûa maáy oâng. Haõy bieän baïch roõ outstanding achievement failed to meet the                  raøng xem sao! Do ñoù môùi noùi 'Tröôùc khi leân standard of Zen! To be able to free oneself                 tieáng khoâng theå traùnh. Caùi theo sau lôøi noùi from life and death in their literal sense is still         chaúng theå caát laïi. Caû trôøi ñaát ñeàu laø caù theå cuûa far from the objective of Zen Master's                      maáy oâng. Vaäy thì maáy oâng seõ ñi ñaâu ñeå coù teaching! Chiu-feng then tapped the corpse's                ñöôïc söï an bình nôi maét, tai, muõi, vaø löôõi ñaây? shoulder and said: "You can sit down and die                Neáu maáy oâng coá höôùng ñeá n yù caên maø tìm immediately all right; but as to the meaning of             nghóa, thì troïn caùi khoâng bao giôø döùt vò lai our late Master's words, you still have not the             cuõng chöa coù phaàn nghæ ngôi.' Cho neân coå ñöùc slightest idea!" Through this, we see the                   coù noùi: 'Coá ñem taâm yù ñeå hoïc huyeàn toâng tradition of Zen has shown unmistakenly its                 (Thieàn toâng), cuõng nhö ñang xoay maët veà scornful attitude towards miracle working.                  höôùng Taây maø laïi ñi veà Ñoâng vaäy.'"—After Zen does not court or care about miraculous                 Chiu-feng became abbot, a monk asked, "On powers of any sort. What it does care about is              what path are those who do not adhere to the the understanding and realization of that                   nine paths (that cut off defilement)?" Chiu- wonder of all wonders, the indescribable                    feng said, "The path of beasts." The monk Dharmakaya which can be found in all places                 said, "Then what path is it that beasts travel?" and at all times.                                           Chiu-feng said, "Not the nine paths." The    Sau khi Cöûu Phong trôû thaønh truï trì, coù moät vò        monk said, "On that path there are many Taêng hoûi: "Nhöõng ngöôøi trong voâ giaùn ñaïo thì         transmigrations before one becomes a haønh haïnh gì?" Cöûu Phong noùi: "Haønh haïnh              person." Chiu-feng said, "You should suùc sanh." Vò Taêng laïi hoûi: "Vaäy thì suùc sanh         understand that there are those without a haønh haïnh gì?" Cöûu Phong ñaùp: "Haïnh voâ                common life." The monk said, "What life is it giaùn." Vò Taêng noùi: "Treân con ñöôøng ñoù coù            that isn't common?" Chiu-feng said, nhieàu laên troâi tröôùc khi thaønh ngöôøi." Cöûu           "Immortality with the breath ceasing." Then Phong noùi: "OÂng phaûi bieát laø coù laém ngöôøi           Chiu-feng said to the monks, "Have you all khoâng chung maïng." Vò Taêng laïi hoûi: "Maïng             gained an understanding of life? You should gì maø khoâng chung?" Cöûu Phong noùi: "Baát töû            want to know about it. A flowing spring is life. khí khoâng ngöøng." Ñoaïn Cöûu Phong noùi vôùi              Profound solitude is the body. The thousand chuùng Taêng: "Maáy oâng coù ñöôïc laõnh hoäi veà           surging waves are Manjusri's condition. The maïng hay khoâng? Maáy oâng neân bieát veà noù.             revolving            empty          firmament             is Moät doøng suoái chaûy laø maïng. Traïm nhieân tòch         Samantabhadra's bed. Or next time I explain tònh laø thaân. Ngaøn soùng tranh nhau phun voït laø        it, I may borrow a phrase and say it's pointing caûnh giôùi Vaên Thuø. Hö khoâng luaân chuyeån              at the moon. When you meet daily affairs it's trong saùng laø Phoå Hieàn saøng (giöôøng). Hay laø         talking about the moon. When from the gate keá tieáp laõo Taêng giaûi thích baèng caùch möôïn          of our ancestors you meet daily affairs it's as

if you're employing the banner of truth in                 methods., to others, universally, past, present and each moment. Or it's the transcendent virtue               future. that comes before the ordered creation of                  Cöûu Phöông Tieän Thaäp Ba La Maät Boà Taùt: myriad names in all realms. Brothers, what                 Chín giai ñoaïn thích hôïp laøm phöông tieän hoaèng body and speech bind you? It's right here. I'm             phaùp cuûa Thaäp Ba La Maät Boà Taùt—The nine not deceiving you an inch. Examine my words                suitable stages in religious services of the ten and you'll see. I don't deceive your ears. Test            paramita Bodhisattvas—See Thaäp Ba La Maät. my words. I don't deceive your eyes. Sort it               Cöûu Quaù: Nine faults—Chín Ñieàu Laàm Loãi: out and see it clearly. Thus, what precedes the            khoâng chòu nghe phaùp; khoâng chòu tin daàu nghe; sound of words can't be avoided. What                      khoâng chaáp nhaän trong taâm daàu tin; khoâng trì tuïng follows words can't be stored away. All of                 daàu chaáp nhaän; khoâng thoâng hieåu nghóa daàu trì heaven and earth come forth from your own                  tuïng; khoâng giaûng giaûi cho ngöôøi khaùc daàu thoâng body. So where would you go to gain peace                  hieåu; khoâng tu taäp daàu ñaõ chæ daïy cho ngöôøi khaùc; for the eyes, the ears, the nose, and the                  daàu tu taäp nhöng laïi khoâng tu taäp lieân tuïc; daàu tu tongue? If you try to realize it by delving                taäp lieân tuïc nhöng khoâng tu taäp ñuùng möùc —Nine beneath the root of meaning, then through an               faults: not wishing to hear the dharma; not endless future you will never have a bit of                believing in it even if one hears it; not accepting it rest. The unending future meets us without                 in mind even if one believes in it; not chanting it rest. Therefore the ancients said, 'Trying to              even if one accepts it; not understanding the use your mind to study the great mystery, you              meaning of it even if one chants it; not seem to face the west, but you're traveling                expounding it to others even if one understands its east.'"                                                    meaning; not practicing it as prescribed even if Cöûu Phong Phoå Maõn: Chiu Feng Pu Man—Name                     one expounds it to others; not practicing it of a monk.                                                      continuously even if one practices it; and not Cöûu Phöôïc Nhöùt Thoaùt: Chín traïng thaùi troùi buoäc         practicing it well even if one practices it vaø moät traïng thaùi giaûi thoaùt—The nine states of           continuously. bondage and the one state of liberation:                        Cöûu Quyû: Chín loaïi quyû: Thöù nhaát laø Cöï Khaåu (A) Cöûu Phöôïc: Chín traïng thaùi troùi buoäc: hoûa ñoà,       Quyû, loaøi quyû mieäng boác löûa nhö ngoïn ñuoác. Thöù huyeát ñoà, ñao ñoà, a tu la, nhaân, thieân, ma, ni        nhì laø Chaâm (Kim) Khaåu Quyû, loaøi quyû coù mieäng kieàn ñaø (ngoaïi ñaïo), vaø saéc vaø voâ saéc —The        nhoïn nhö kim. Thöù ba laø Xuù Khaåu Quyû, loaøi quyû nine states of bondage: hell of fire, hell of              mieäng thoái. Thöù tö laø Chaâm Mao Quyû, loaøi quyû coù blood, hell of sword, asuras, men, devas,                  loâng nhoïn nhö kim. Thöù naêm laø Xuù Mao Quyû, loaøi maras, nirgranthas, form and formless states.              quyû coù loâng thoái. Thöù saùu laø Anh Quyû, loaøi quyû (B) Nhaát Thoaùt: Moät traïng thaùi giaûi thoaùt: Nieát         thaân theå ñaày muïn nhoït. Thöù baûy laø Hy Töø Quyû, Baøn—The one state of liberation: Freedom of               loaøi quyû thöôøng laån khuaát trong ñeàn mieáu, hy voïng Nirvana.                                                   ñöôïc aên uoáng. Thöù taùm laø Hy Thí Quyû, loaøi quyû Cöûu Phöông Tieän: Chín giai ñoaïn thích hôïp trong             thöôøng aên ñoà thöøa thaûi cuûa ngöôøi khaùc, hoaëc ñoà phuïc vuï toân giaùo: Taùc leã, xuaát toäi, quy y, thí thaân,   cuùng hay baát cöù thöù gì coøn thöøa. Thöù chín laø Ñaïi phaùt Boà Ñeà Taâm, tuøy hyû, caàn giaûng, caàu vaõng           Theá Quyû, loaøi quyû giaøu coù phuùc lôùn. Ñaây laø loaïi sanh, vaø hoài höôùng coâng ñöùc—The nine suitable              quyû coù theá löïc nhö Daï Xoa, La Saùt, chuùng ôû raûi stages in religious services: salutation to the                 raùc khaép nôi töø trong phoøng oác, ñeán phoá chôï, soâng universal Triratna, repentance and confession,                  hoà, caây coái—Nine classes of ghosts: First, burning trust in Triratna, giving of self to the Tathagata,             torch-like ghost. Second, narrow needle-mouth vowing to devote the mind to bodhi, rejoicing in                ghosts. Third, stinking mouth ghosts. Fourth, all good, beseeching all Tathagatas to rain down                needle-like hair ghosts, self-piercing. Fifth, hair- the saving law, praying for the Buddha-nature in                sharp and stinking, or stinking hair ghosts. Sixth, self and others for entry in the Pure Land, and                 ghosts of which bodies are full of tumours. demitting the good produced by the above eight                  Seventh, ghosts that haunt sacrifices to the dead.

Eighth, ghosts that eat human leavings. Demons                beân trong cuûa thieàn nhaân laø laø laøm cho taâm giaùc that live on the remains of sacrifices, or any                ngoä ñeå thaáy töï taùnh cuûa chính mình vaø sieâu thoaùt leavings in general. Ninth, rich ghosts, or powerful          sanh töû—To enlighten the mind in order to see demons, i.e. yaksas, raksasas, picasas, etc. All              into one’s own nature, and to go beyond the cycle belong to the realm of Yama whence they are sent              of birth and death. everywhere, consequently are ubiquitous in every              Cöûu Tham Thöôïng Ñöôøng: Chín laàn thöôïng house, lane, market, mound, stream, tree, etc.                ñöôøng haønh leã trong thaùng, cöù ba ngaøy moät laàn — Cöûu Sang: See Cöûu Khoång.                                   The nine monthly visits or ascents to the hall for Cöûu Sanh: Chín loaïi sanh—Nine kinds of birth—               worship, every third day. See Cöûu Loaïi Sanh.                                          Cöûu Thaäp Baùt Söù: Chín möôi taùm söù giaû—Chín Cöûu Sôn Baùt Haûi: Nine Cakravala (skt)—Chín                 möôi taùm söï caùm doã hay thaùch thöùc ñöôïc noùi ñeán raëng nuùi hay luïc ñòa bò phaân caùch bôûi taùm bieån cuûa   trong giaùo lyù Tieåu Thöøa. Ñaây laø 98 phieàn naõo cuûa vuõ truï—Nine concentric mountain ranges or                   kieán tö giôùi, hay laø nhöõng yù kieán töø beân trong laãn continents, separated by eight seas, of a universe:           beân ngoaøi—The Hinayana ninety-eight tempters (I) Theo Ñaïi Thöøa, coù cöûu sôn hay chín raëng nuùi.        or temptations, that follow men with all subtlety to Taïi trung taâm hoøn nuùi cao nhöùt laø nuùi Tu Di,      induce laxity. They are ninety-eight klesas vaø xung quanh laø caùc nuùi khaùc: nuùi Yeát Ñòa        (afflictions), or moral temptations in the realm of Laïc Ca, nuùi Y Sa Ñaø La, nuùi Du Caùn Ñaø La,          view and thought, or external and internal ideas. nuùi Toâ Ñaït Leâ Xaù Na, nuùi An Thaáp Phöôïc Yeát      Cöûu Thaäp Giôùi Ñoïa: Navati-Prayascittiya (p)— Noâ, nuùi Ni Daân Ñaø La, nuùi Tyø Na Ña Ca, nuùi        Pacittiya (skt)—Chín möôi giôùi Ba Daät Ñeà, neáu Sôû Ca La—Nine mountain ranges according                 phaïm moät trong nhöõng toäi naày maø chí thaønh phaùt to the Mahayana. The central mountain of the             loà saùm hoái tröôùc Taêng chuùng, thì toäi ñöôïc tieâu nine is Sumeru, and around it are the ranges             khieân. Neáu khoâng chí thaønh phaùt loà saùm hoái, of other mountains: Khadiraka (skt), Isadhara            chaúng nhöõng seõ trôû ngaïi cho vieäc khôûi sanh thieän (skt), Yugamdhara (skt), Sudarsana (skt),                phaùp, maø seõ coøn bò ñoïa vaøo ñòa nguïc, ngaï quyû, suùc Asvakarna (skt), Nemimdhara (skt), Vinataka              sanh—Ninety Pacittiya offences which require (skt), and Cakravada (skt).                              confession and repentance. If a monk doing any of (II) Vi Dieäu Phaùp Caâu Xaù laïi cho moät thöù töï khaùc:    them, makes a confession of it before the Sangha nuùi Tu Di ôû giöõa, nuùi Du Caùn Ñaø La, nuùi Y Sa      with clear heart, he will become free from the Ñaø La, nuùi Yeát Ñòa Laïc Ca, nuùi Toâ Ñaït Leâ Xaù     offence. If he doesn’t, the offence itself will not Na, nuùi An Thaáp Phöôïc Yeát Noâ, nuùi Tyø Na Ña        only obstruct his development of wholesome acts, Ca, nuùi Ni Daân Ñaø La, vaø nuùi Thieát Luaân bao       but it will also cause his rebirth in lower realms, boïc caùc nuùi vöøa keå tröôùc—The Abhidharma            i.e., hell, hungry ghosts, or animal. Kosa gives a different order: Sumeru in the              Cöûu Thaäp Luïc Chuûng Ngoaïi Ñaïo: Chín möôi saùu center, Yugamdhara, Isadhara, Khadiraka,                 phaùi ngoaïi ñaïo—Vaøo thôøi Ñöùc Phaät coøn taïi theá, coù Sudarsana,                  Asvakarna, Vinataka,         hôn 96 phaùi ngoaïi ñaïo—At the time of the Nemimdhara, and an Iron-Wheel mountain                   Buddha, there were more than ninety-six classes encompassing all these above mentioned                   of non-Buddhists or heretics and their practices. mountains.                                               Cöûu Theá: Theá giôùi cuûa quaù khöù, hieän taïi vaø vò lai, Cöûu Tai Thaäp Baùt Naïn: Tai naïn lieân tieáp—               moãi thôøi theá giôùi laïi coù rieâng quaù khöù, hieän taïi vaø Misfortunes aplenty.                                          vò lai cuûa chính noù—Past, present and future Cöûu Taâm Luaân: Chín söï luaân chuyeån cuûa taâm             worlds, each has its own past, present and future. töôûng—The nine evolutions or movements of the                Cöûu Theá Gian: Chín theá giôùi thaáp trong möôøi theá mind in perception.                                           giôùi, theá giôùi cao nhaát hay theá giôùi thöù möôøi laø Cöûu Tham: Baõo Tuøng Laâm—Cöïu Tham—Laõo                     Phaät giôùi. Chín theá giôùi coøn laïi luoân bò aûo giaùc meâ Tham—Ngöôøi tham thieàn hoïc ñaïo laâu naêm —A                muoäi cuûa giaùc quan chi phoái—The nine lower of long-standing Zen practitioner.                               the ten worlds, the highest or tenth being the Cöûu Tham Söï: Vieäc tham thieàn ñaõ laâu, chæ vieäc          Buddha-world. The rest nine are always subject to

illusion, confused by the senses.                              töôûng hö khoâng voâ bieân xöù ñoaïn dieät. Thöù baûy laø Cöûu Thöù Ñeä Dieät: Anupubha-nirodha (p)—Nine                 thaønh töïu Voâ Sôû Höõu Xöù, thöùc voâ bieân xöù bò ñoaïn successive cessations—Theo Kinh Phuùng Tuïng                   dieät. Thöù taùm laø thaønh töïu Phi Töôûng Phi Phi trong Tröôøng Boä Kinh, coù chín thöù ñeä dieät. Thöù          Töôûng Xöù, voâ sôû höõu xöù töôûng bò ñoaïn dieät. Thöù nhaát laø thaønh töïu Sô Thieàn, caùc duïc töôûng bò ñoaïn     chín laø thaønh töïu Dieät Thoï Töôûng Ñònh, caùc töôûng dieät. Thöù nhì laø thaønh töïu Nhò Thieàn, taàm töù ñoaïn     vaø caùc thoï ñeàu bò ñoaïn dieät—According to the dieät. Thöù ba laø thaønh töïu Tam Thieàn, hyû ñoaïn dieät.    Sangiti Sutta in the Long Discourses of the Thöù tö laø thaønh töïu Töù Thieàn, hôi thôû vaøo hôi thôû     Buddha, there are nine successive cessations: ra bò ñoaïn dieät. Thöù naêm laø thaøn h töïu Hö Khoâng        First, by the attainment of the first jhana, Voâ Bieân Xöù, saéc töôûng bò ñoaïn dieät. Thöù saùu laø       perceptions of sensuality cease. Second, by the thaønh töïu Thöùc Voâ Bieân Xöù, töôûng hö khoâng voâ          attainment of the second jhana, thinking and bieân xöù ñoaïn dieät. Thöù baûy laø thaønh töïu Voâ Sôû       pondering cease. Third, by the attainment of the Höõu Xöù, thöùc voâ bieân xöù bò ñoaïn dieät. Thöù taùm laø    third jhana, delight (piti) ceases. Fourth, by the thaønh töïu Phi Töôûng Phi Phi Töôûng Xöù, voâ sôû höõu        attainment of the fourth jhana, in-and-out xöù töôûng bò ñoaïn dieät. Thöù chín laø thaønh töïu Dieät     breathing ceases. Fifth, by the attainment of the Thoï Töôûng Ñònh, caùc töôûng vaø caùc thoï ñeàu bò ñoaïn      Sphere of Infinite Space, the perception of dieät—According to the Sangiti Sutta in the Long               materiality ceases. Sixth, by the attainment of the Discourses of the Buddha, there are nine                       Sphere of Infinite Consciousness, the perception successive cessations: First, by the attainment of             of the Sphere of Infinite Space ceases. Seventh, the first jhana, perceptions of sensuality cease.              by the attainment of the Sphere of No-Thingness, Second, by the attainment of the second jhana,                 the perception of the Sphere of Infinite thinking and pondering cease. Third, by the                    Consciousness ceases. Eighth, by the attainment attainment of the third jhana, delight (piti) ceases.          of the sphere of Neither-Perception-Nor-Non- Fourth, by the attainment of the fourth jhana, in-             Perception, the perception of the Sphere of No- and-out breathing ceases. Fifth, by the attainment             Thingness ceases. Ninth, by the attainment of the of the Sphere of Infinite Space, the perception of             Cessation-of-Perception-and-Feeling, perception materiality ceases. Sixth, by the attainment of the            and feeling cease—See Töù Thieàn Thieân, Töù Voâ Sphere of Infinite Consciousness, the perception               Bieân Xöù and Töù Voâ Bieân Xöù Ñònh. of the Sphere of Infinite Space ceases. Seventh,               Cöûu Thöù Ñeä Truù: Nine successive abidings— by the attainment of the Sphere of No-Thingness,               Chín Thöù Ñeä Truù—Theo Kinh Phuùng Tuïng trong the perception of the Sphere of Infinite                       Tröôøng Boä Kinh, coù chín thöù ñeä truù: Nhaát Thieàn Consciousness ceases. Eighth, by the attainment                Thieân, Nhò Thieàn Thieân, Tam Thieàn Thieân, Töù of the sphere of Neither-Perception-Nor-Non-                   Thieàn Thieân, Khoâng Voâ Bieân Xöù, Thöùc Voâ Bieân Perception, the perception of the Sphere of No-                Xöù, Voâ Sôû Höõu Xöù, Phi Töôûng Phi Phi Töôûng Xöù, Thingness ceases. Ninth, by the attainment of the              vaø Dieät Thoï Töôûng Ñònh Xöù—According to the Cessation-of-Perception-and-Feeling, perception                Sangiti Sutta in the Long Discourses of the and feeling cease.                                             Buddha, there are nine successive abidings: the Cöûu Thöù Ñeä Ñònh: Anupubha-nirodha (p)—Nine                  first jhana heaven, the second jhana heaven, the successive cessations—Chín möùc ñoä thieàn ñònh—               third jhana heaven, the fourth jhana heaven, the The samadhi of the nine degrees—Theo Kinh                      Sphere of Infinite Space, the Sphere of Infinite Phuùng Tuïng trong Tröôøng Boä Kinh, coù chín thöù ñeä         Consciousness, the Sphere of No-Thingness, the dieät. Thöù nhaát laø thaønh töïu Sô Thieàn, caùc duïc         Sphere         of       Neither-Perception-Nor-Non- töôûng bò ñoaïn dieät. Thöù nhì laø thaønh töïu Nhò            Perception, and the Sphere of Cessation of Thieàn, taàm töù ñoaïn dieät. Thöù ba laø thaønh töïu Tam      Perception and Feeling. Thieàn, hyû ñoaïn dieät. Thöù tö laø thaønh töïu Töù Thieàn,   Cöûu Thöùc: Chín loaïi yù thöùc: Nhaõn Thöùc, Nhó hôi thôû vaøo hôi thôû ra bò ñoaïn dieät. Thöù naêm laø        Thöùc, Tyû Thöùc, Thieät Thöùc, Thaân Thöùc, YÙ Thöùc, thaønh töïu Hö Khoâng Voâ Bieân Xöù, saéc töôûng bò            Maït Na Thöùc (A Ñaø Na Thöùc hay yù caên), A Laïi ñoaïn dieät. Thöù saùu laø thaønh töïu Thöùc Voâ Bieân Xöù,    Da Thöùc, A Ma La Thöùc (Phaät Thöùc, Voâ Caáu

Thöùc, Thanh Tònh Thöùc, Chaân Nhö hay chaân                    chín ngoïn löûa xung quanh cuûa Baát Ñoäng Minh taâm)—The nine kinds of cognition or                            Vöông, moät bieåu töôïng cuûa söï phaù huûy phieàn naõo consciousness (Vijnana): consciousness of the                   vaø chöôùng ngaïi trong tam giôùi cöûu ñòa—The nine sight, consciousness of the hearing, consciousness              penetrating flames          of the sword of Acala, of the smelling, consciousness of the tasting,                  emblem of the destruction of illusions and consciousness of touch, consciousness of the mind,              hindrances in the nine realms. consciousness of manas, consciousness of the                    Cöûu Truï Taâm: Chín giai ñoaïn truï taâm—Nine mental perception (taøng thöùc), and Purified or                stages of mental concentration when in dhyana Buddha consciousness.                                           meditation (An, Nhieáp, Giaûi, Chuyeån, Phuïc, Töùc, Cöûu Tònh Nhuïc: Chín loaïi thòt thanh tònh: Töø 1              Dieät, Tính, Trì). ñeán 5 gioáng nhö Nguõ Tònh Nhuïc. Thöù saùu laø con            Cöûu Truøng: Heaven—The imperial abode. vaät khoâng phaûi vì mình maø bò gieát. Thöù baûy laø thòt      Cöûu Tuøng Chaân Nhaát (1889-?): Teân cuûa moät vò khoâ töï nhieân, do con vaät töï cheát laâu ngaøy döôùi aùnh    hoïc giaû Phaät giaùo Nhaät Baûn vaøo theá kyû XX— naéng laøm cho thòt khoâ laïi. Thöù taùm laø nhöõng moùn        Name of a Japanese Buddhist scholar in the khoâng phaûi do öôùc heïn, nhöng tình côø gaëp maø aên.         twentieth century. Thöù chín laø moùn thòt ñaõ laøm töø tröôùc khi coù söï hieän   Cöûu Tuyeàn: Suoái vaøng—The nine springs— dieän cuûa mình taïi ñoù—Nine kinds of clean flesh:             Hells—Hades. From 1 to 5 (see Nguõ Tònh Nhuïc). Sixth, the                   Cöûu Töï Cuø Lao: Hard labour of one’s parents— creatures not killed for me. Seventh, naturally                 Chín chöõ cuø lao, yù noùi coâng lao cuûa cha meï vôùi dried meat. Eighth, things not seasonable or at the             chín chöõ cao saâu töø sinh, cuùc (meï ñôõ ñaàn), phuû (voå right time. Ninth, things previously killed.                    veà), suùc (buù môùm), tröôûng (nuoâi cho lôùn), duïc (daïy Cöûu Toäi Baùo: See Cöûu Naõo.                                  doã), coá (khieán con caùi nhôù ôn oâng baø cha meï), Cöûu Toân: Chín baäc ñaùng toân vinh treân boâng sen            phuïc (xem tính tình maø daïy baûo), vaø phuùc (che taùm caùnh, Phaät Tyø Loâ Giaù Na ôû trung taâm, boán vò        chôû). Phaät vaø boán vò Boà Taùt treân moãi caùnh sen. Boâng          Cöûu Töï Maïn Ñoà La: Chín chöõ Maïn Ñoà La chín sen bieåu tröng cho nhaân taâm—The nine honoured                chöõ huyeàn dieäu. Boâng sen taùm caùnh vôùi Quaùn Töï ones in the eight-petalled hall of the Garbhadhatu;             Taïi Boà Taùt ôû trung ñaøi vaø Phaät A Di Ñaø treân moãi Vairocana in the center of the lotus, with four                 caùnh, thöôøng ñöôïc kieán laäp thaønh hình chöõ “Haát Buddhas and four Bodhisattvas on the petals; the                Lyù” (chuûng) trong Phaïn ngöõ—The nine magical lotus representing the human heart.                             character Mandala—The lotus with its eight petals Cöûu Toâng: The nine sects in Buddhism—See                      and its center; Avalokitesvara may be placed in Toâng Phaùi.                                                    the heart and Amitabha on each petal, generally Cöûu Trai Nhöït: Chín ngaøy aên chay, trì giôùi, vaø cöû        the shape of the Sanskrit “Seed” letter. aên quaù ngoï. Trong chín ngaøy naày vua Trôøi Ñeá              Cöûu Töôûng Quaùn: Nivasamjna (skt)—Chín loaïi Thích vaø Töù Thieân vöông doø xeùt söï thieän aùc cuûa         thieàn quaùn veà thaân theå giuùp ta thoaùt ñöôïc luyeán aùi nhaân gian: moãi ngaøy trong thaùng gieâng; moãi ngaøy          veà thaân: Thöù nhaát laø quaùn xaùc sình leân trong thaùng naêm; moãi ngaøy trong thaùng chín; caùc           (Vyadhmatakasamjna (skt). Töôûng thaây vöøa môùi thaùng khaùc moãi thaùng saùu ngaøy: moàng taùm , moàng         cheát vaø baét ñaàu sình leân. Thöù nhì laø quaùn xaùc ñoåi chín, 14, haêm ba, haêm chín vaø ba möôi—Nine                   saéc baàm tím (Vinilakas (skt) hay töôûng thaây cheát days of abstinence on which no food is eaten after              ñoåi saéc baàm xanh tím. Thöù ba laø quaùn xaùc ruùt nhoû twelve o’clock and all the commandments must be                 laïi (Vipadumakas (skt) hay töôûng thaây ñang hoaïi observed. On these days Indras and the four deva-               dieät. Thöù tö laø quaùn xaùc ræ maùu (Vilohitakas (skt) kings investigate the conduct of men: every day of              hay töôûng thaây sình baáy nöùc raõ vaø ræ maùu. Thöù the first month; every day of the fifth month;                  naêm laø quaùn xaùc bò phuû ñaày maù u muû (Vipuyakas everyday of the ninth month; other months each                  (skt). Töôûng thaây cheát sình leân ñaày daãy maùu muû month six days as follow: the 8th, the 9th, the 14th,           vaø saép raõ. Thöù saùu laø quaùn xaùc bò thuù aên the 23rd, the 29th, and the 30th.                               (Vikhaditakas (skt). Töôûng thaây raõ ra töøng khuùc, Cöûu Trieät: Baát ñoäng cöûu trieät hay kieám saéc coù          laøm moài cho chim thuù. Thöù baûy laø quaùn xaùc bò raû

ra töøng phaàn (Viksiptakas (skt). Töôûng thaây ñang (I) Chín phaùp voâ vi: Thöù nhaát laø Traïch dieät tan raõ ra töøng phaàn. Thöù taùm laø quaùn xaùc chæ coøn     (Pratisamkhyanirodha (skt) hay ñoaïn dieät laïi xöông traéng (Asthis (skt). Töôûng naéng chan            baèng tri thöùc. Thöù nhì laø Phi traïch dieät möa goäi, thaây nay chæ coøn trô laïi moät boä xöông          (Apratisamkhyanirodha (skt). Ñoaïn dieät traéng. Thöù chín laø quaùn tro coøn laïi (Vidagdhakas        khoâng baèng tri thöùc, nghóa laø do söï ñoaïn dieät (skt). Töôûng xöông tieâu muït theo thôøi gian, nay chæ       töï nhieân cuûa nguyeân nhaân. Thöù ba laø Hö coøn trô laïi moät nhuùm tro—Nine types of                    khoâng. Thöù tö laø Khoâng voâ bieân xöù. Thöù naêm meditation on corpse which helps free us from                 laø Thöùc voâ bieân xöù. Thöù saùu laø Voâ sôû höõu xöù. attachment to the human body: First, contemplate              Thöù baûy laø Phi töôûng phi phi töôûng xöù. Thöù on a bloated corpse. Second, contemplate on a                 taùm laø Duyeân khôûi chi taùnh. Thöù chín laø corpse changing color to dark purple. Third,                  Thaùnh ñaïo chi taùnh—Nine kinds of non- contemplate on a decaying corpse. Fourth,                     action: First, cessation through knowledge contemplate on blood leaking out from a corpse.               (see Traïch Dieät). Second, cessation without Fifth, contemplate on a corpse covered with pus.              knowledge, i.e., through the natural cessation Sixth, contemplate on a corpse that torn apart by             of the causes (see Traïch Dieät). Third, sunya wild birds and wild beasts. Seventh, contemplate              or space (see Hö Khoâng). Fourth, on the scattered limbs of a corpse. Eighth,                   akasanantyayatana (see Khoâng Voâ Bieân Xöù). contemplate on left-over white bones. Ninth,                  Fifth, the state of boundless knowledge (see contemplate on the bones reduced to ashes.                    Thöùc Voâ Bieân Xöù). Sixth, the state of nothing Cöûu Voâ Giaùn Ñaïo: Chín ñaïo voâ giaùn—Tam giôùi            (see Voâ Sôû Höõu Xöù). The seventh kind of coù chín ñòa, tö hoaëc trong moãi ñòa laïi coù chín caùch     non-action (see Phi Töôûng Phi Phi Töôûng Xöù). laøm giaûm nheï, töø ñoù vöôït thaéng chöôùng ngaïi; laïi     Eighth, the nature of conditioned arising. cuõng coù chín ñaïo voâ giaùn vaø ñi töø giai ñoaïn naày      Ninth, the nature of the holy way. ñeán giai ñoaïn khaùc trong tam giôùi ñeå giaûi thoaùt (II) Theo Hoùa Ñòa Boä, coù chín phaùp voâ vi hay chín baèng trí tueä ñeå vöôït thoaùt phieàn naõo trong moãi giai   phaùp giuùp haønh giaû töï taïi khoâng bò bieán thieân ñoaïn—In every universe there are nine realms, in             vì boán töôùng: Töø 1 ñeán 3 gioáng nhö phaàn (A). every realm there are nine illusions in practice              Thöù tö laø Baát ñoäng voâ vi. Thöù naêm laø Thieän and nine ways of relief; hence the nine ways of               Phaùp Chaân Nhö. Thöù saùu laø Baát Thieän Phaùp overcoming hindrances; also there are nine                    Chaân Nhö. Thöù baûy laø Voâ Kyù Phaùp Chaân Nhö interrupted ways of advance from one stage to                 (Avyakrta-dharma-tathata (skt), coù nghóa laø another of the nine stages of the trailokya by the            chaân nhö cuûa vaïn phaùp voán laø toát ñeïp, khoâng wisdom of overcoming delusion in each stage.                  toát ñeïp, chaúng phaûi toát ñeïp maø cuõng chaúng Cöûu Voâ Hoïc: Chín loaïi voâ hoïc cuûa caùc baäc A-La-       phaûi chaúng toát ñeïp. Thöù taùm laø Ñaïo Phaàn Haùn ñaõ ñaït ñöôïc muïc ñích toái haäu khoâng caàn phaûi     Chaân Nhö. Thöù chín laø Duyeân Khôûi Chaân Nhö hoïc nöõa: baát thoaùi töôùng (Asaiksa (skt ), baát thuû      (Pratitya-samutpada-tathata (skt)—According töôùng, baát töû töôùng, baát truï töôùng, khaû tieán töôùng, to the Mahisasakah school, there are nine baát hoaïi töôùng (Avinasya (skt), baát khoaùi töôùng,        kinds of non-action: From 1 to 3, same as in tueä giaûi thoaùt töôùng, vaø caâu giaûi thoaùt töôùng—The    (A). Fourth, anenjata, which means nine grades of arhats who are no longer learning,             immovability. Fifth, kusala-dharma-tathata, having atained their goal: the stage beyond study,            which means wholesome tathata. Sixth, where intuition rules, ungrasping mark, immortal              akusala-dharma-tathata,            which        means mark, undwelling mark, mark of advancement,                   unwholesome tathata. The seventh immobility indestructible mark, unpleasurable mark, mark of              is, suchness of the dharma that are wisdom of liberation, and mark of complete                    meritorious, unmeritorious and neither the release.                                                      one, nor the other. Eighth, marganga-tathata Cöûu Voâ Ngaïi: See Cöûu Voâ Giaùn Ñaïo.                      (skt). Ninth, suchness of the factors of the Cöûu Voâ Vi: Chín phaùp voâ vi—Nine kinds of non-             Path and suchness of the Law of Dependent action:                                                       Origination.

Cöûu Vöïc: See Cöûu Ñòa. Cöûu Xöù: See Cöûu Höõu. Cöïu: Xöa—Old—Ancient.                                      CH Cöïu Cheá Cöûu Hình: Chín thöù hình phaït thôøi coå hay Cöïu cheá cöûu hình: thích chöõ vaøo maët, tî hay       Cha: Father—Ñaây laø moät trong naêm choã ñeå cuùng caét muõi, ngoaïc phi hay chaët chaân, cung hay thieán,     döôøng. Cha cuõng laø moät trong hai AÂn Ñieàn thuoäc ñaïi tòch hay xöû töû, löu hay ñi ñaøy, thuïc hay duøng     taùm ruoäng phöôùc ñieàn—This is one of the five to tieàn chuoäc toäi, tieân hay ñaùnh baèng tröôïng, phaùc     be constantly served. Father is also one of the two hay ñaùnh baèng roi—Nine punishments of the                 grace or gratitude-fields which belong to the eight ancient: branding, cutting off the nose, severrance         fields for cultivating blessedness. of the feet, castration, death, banishment, money           Chaùn Ñôøi: Yeám Theá—To be tired of this world— fine, whipping, and flogging.                               Weary of the world. Cöïu Dòch: Caùc baûn dòch töø ñôøi Ñöôøng veà tröôùc goïi   Chaùn Ta Baø Neân Tìm Vui Tònh Ñoä: To be tired laø baûn dòch cuõ hay cöïu dòch (nhö nhöõng baû n dòch      of the Saha world, to seek the happiness in the cuûa ngaøi Cöu Ma La Thaäp); caùc baûn dòch töø ñôøi        Pure Land. Ñöôøng veà sau goïi laø baûn dòch môùi hay taân dòch        Chaùnh: Samma (p)—Samyak (skt)—1) Ñuùng: (nhö nhöõng baûn dòch cuûa ngaøi Huyeàn Trang)—The          Right, proper, correct, just; 2) Chaùnh Yeáu: Chief, older translations, i.e. before the T’ang dynasty,          principal; 3) Chính Xaùc: Exact. those of Kumarajiva; those of the Hsuan-Tsang               Chaùnh AÙn: Presiding judge. and afterwards are called the new.                          Chaùnh Baùo: One’s body—Thaân Ñoä—Thaân ta Cöïu Kinh: Kinh xöa hay kinh vieát theo loái xöa—           hoâm nay chính laø keát quaû tröïc tieáp cuûa tieàn Old writings, or versions.                                  nghieäp; hoaøn caûnh xung quanh chính laø keát quaû Cöïu Laïc Taân Sinh: Caùi cuõ ruïng ñi caùi môùi troài      giaùn tieáp cuûa tieàn nghieäp. Laøm con ngöôøi hieän taïi, leân. Ñaây laø ñuùng theo luaät sanh töû voâ thöôøng cuûa   toát hay xaáu, tuøy thuoäc vaøo keát quaû cuûa nghieäp ñôøi nhaø Phaät— Old things will die and new things will         tröôùc, nhö phaûi giöõ caên baûn nguõ giôùi neáu muoán taùi emerge. In Buddhism, this is the process of life            sanh trôû laïi laøm ngöôøi—Body and environment and death.                                                  (the body is the direct fruit of the previous life; the Cöïu Ngoân:                                                 environment is the indirect fruit of the previous 1) Tieáng noùi xöa cuûa xöù Ma Kieät Ñaø, naèm veà          life). Body and environment (the body is the direct phía nam cuûa Behar, goïi laø Magadhi-Prakrit:        fruit of the previous life; the environment is the The vernacular language of Magadha, the               indirect fruit of the previous life). Being the country South behar, called Magadhi-Prakrit.          resultant person, good or bad, depends on or 2) Phaät töû ôû Tích Lan cho raèng tieáng Pali, ngoân       results from former karma. Direct retribution of ngöõ trong kinh ñieån Tích Lan laø cöïu ngoân ngöõ    the individual’s previous existence, such as being cuûa xöù Ma Kieät Ñaø, nhöng hai thöù naày hoaøn      born as a man is the result of keeping the five toaøn khaùc nhau: Pali, which is the language of      basic commandments for being reborn as a man. the Ceylon canon. The Ceylon Buddhists                Chaùnh Baùo Y Baùo: Giaùo phaùp cuûa Phaät chuû speak of it as Magadhi, but that was quite a          tröông chaùnh baùo vaø y baùo hay taát caû thaân theå vaø different dialect from Pali.                          sôû truï cuûa chuùng sanh ñeàu do taâm cuûa hoï bieán Cöïu Tham: Baõo Tuøng Laâm—Cöûu Tham—Laõo                   hieän—Buddhist doctrine believes that direct Tham—Ngöôøi tham thieàn hoïc ñaïo laâu naêm —A              retribution of individual’s previous existence and long-standing Zen practitioner.                             the dependent condition or environment created Cöïu Truï: Ñaõ truï taïi ñoù töø tröôùc—Formerly lived      by the beings’ minds—See Chaùnh Baùo and Y Baùo. there.                                                      Chaùnh Bieán Giaùc: Samyak-sambuddha (skt)— Cöïu Truï Boà Taùt: Boà Taùt ñaõ vaõng sanh veà coõi        See Chaùnh Bieán Tri. Tònh Ñoä töø tröôùc—Bodhisattvas who had formerly           Chaùnh Bieán Tri: Samma-sambuddha (p)— reborn and lived in the Pure Land.                          Samyaksambuddha (skt)—Shohenchi (jap)— Cöïu Truyeàn: Traditional.                                  Chaùnh Bieán Giaùc—Chaùnh Ñaúng Chaùnh Giaùc—

Chaùnh Taän Giaùc—Phoå giaùc nhöùt thieát phaùp (bieát             trung tö töôûng ñuùng laø taäp trung vaøo vieäc töø boû roäng vaø bieát ñuùng veà taát caû chö phaùp)—Correct              nhöõng ñieàu baát thieän vaø taäp trung tinh thaàn equal or universal enlightenment—Completely                        ñöôïc hoaøn taát trong boán giai ñoaïn thieàn ñònh. enlightened—The omniscient knowledge—The                           Chaùnh ñònh coøn coù nghóa laø taäp trung tö töôûng universal knowledge of a Buddha.                                   vaøo moät vaán ñeà gì ñeå thaáy cho roõ raøng, ñuùng Chaùnh Bieán Tri Haûi: Bieån phoå giaùc hay bieån tri              vôùi chaân lyù, coù lôïi ích cho mình vaø cho ngöôøi. thöùc cuûa chö Phaät—The ocean of omniscience                      Chaùnh ñònh laø söï an ñònh vöõng chaéc cuûa taâm (universal knowledge of a Buddha).                                 coù theå so saùnh vôùi ngoïn ñeøn chaùy saùng khoâng Chaùnh Caàn: Prahana (skt & p)—Sammappadhana                       dao ñoäng ôû nôi kín gioù. Chính söï taäp trung ñaõ (p)—Right effort—Right                                             laøm cho taâm an truù vaø khieán cho noù khoâng bò endeavor—Right exertion.                                           dao ñoäng, xaùo troän. Vieäc thöïc haønh ñònh taâm Chaùnh Chuû Khaûo: Chairman of the examining                       (samadhi) ñuùng ñaén seõ duy trì taâm vaø caùc taâm board.                                                             sôû ôû traïng thaùi quaân bình. Haønh giaû coù theå Chaùnh Ñaùng: Righteousness.                                       phaûi ñöông ñaàu vôùi raát nhieàu chöôùng ngaïi cuûa Chaùnh Ñaïo: Right path.                                           tinh thaàn, nhöng vôùi söï hoã trôï cuûa chaùnh tinh Chaùnh Ñaúng Chaùnh Giaùc: Samyaksambuddha                         taán vaø chaùnh nieäm, taâm ñònh vöõng vaøng coù (skt)—A Naäu Ña La Tam Mieäu Tam Boà Ñeà—                          khaû naêng ñaåy luøi nhöõng chöôùng ngaïi, nhöõng Perfect universal enlightenment, knowledge, or                     tham duïc ñang khuaáy ñoäng taâm cuûa vò haønh understanding—Supreme                   or          perfect        giaû. Taâm ñònh vöõng chaéc khoâng bò caùc phaùp enlightenment          (Anuttara-samyak-sambodhi—A                 traàn laøm cho xao laõng, vì noù ñaõ cheá ngöï ñöôïc Naäu ña la tam mieäu Tam boà ñeà)—See Chaùnh                       naêm trieàn caùi—Detached from sensual Bieán Tri.                                                         objects, detached from unwholesome things, Chaùnh Ñaúng Giaùc: Samyakbuddhi (bodhi)                           and enters into the first, second, third and Highest wisdom—Chaùnh trí voâ thöôïng cuûa Phaät                   fourth absorption. Right concentration means (trí giaùc bieát caùc phaùp khoâng sai leäch)—Correct              a strong concentration of our thoughts on a universal         perfect       enlightenment—Highest              certain subject in order to set it clearly, knowledge—The perfect universal wisdom of a                        consistent with Buddhist doctrine and for the Buddha.                                                            benefit of others and ourselves. Right Chaùnh Ñòa Boä: Mahisasakah (skt)—See Hoùa Ñòa                     concentration is the intensified steadiness of Boä.                                                               the mind comparable to the unflickering Chaùnh Ñieän: The Main Hall—Buddha hall—                           flame of a lamp in a windless place. It is Shrine.                                                            concentration that fixes the mind right and Chaùnh Ñònh: Samyak-samadhi (skt)—Samma-                           causes it to be unmoved and undisturbed. The samadhi (p)—Right concentration.                                   correct practice of “samadhi” maintains the (I) Toång quan veà Chaùnh ñònh—An overview of                      mind and the mental properties in a state of “Right Concentration”: Chaùnh ñònh laø taâm coá               balance. Many are the mental impedments ñònh vaø khoâng bò khuaáy roái, laø giai ñoaïn cuoái          that confront a practitioner, a meditator, but cuøng trong Baùt Thaùnh Ñaïo. Chaùnh Ñònh coøn                with support of Right Effort and Right laø yeáu toá kyû luaät tinh thaàn cuoái cuøng daãn ñeán       Mindfulness the fully concentrated mind is Töù Thieàn hay boán giai ñoaïn cuûa Thieàn—Right              capable of dispelling the impediments, the concentration or abstraction so that becomes                  passions that disturb man. The perfect vacant and receptive. Right concentration is                  concentrated mind is not distracted by sense where the mind fixed and undisturbed, the last                objects, for it sees things as they are, in their link of the Eightfold Path. Right Concentration               proper perspective. is also the last mental discipline that leads to        (III) Chaùnh       ñònh       vaø    Tam     muoäi—Right the four stages of jhana.                                     Concentration and Samadhi: Chaùnh Ñònh laø (II) The meanings of “Right Concentration”—                        moät trong ba phaàn hoïc cuûa Thieàn Ñònh (hai Nghóa cuûa Chaùnh ñònh: Chaùnh ñònh laø taäp                  phaàn khaùc laø Chaùnh Tinh Taán vaø Chaùnh

Nieäm). Chaùnh ñònh laø taäp trung taâm vaøo moät        Ba La Maät Ña, baøn veà baûn chaát ñoàng nhaát cuûa vaïn ñoái töôïng. Chaùnh ñònh tieán boä töø töø ñeán traïng   höõu—A Mahayana Sutra, of which teaching is thaùi taâm an truù nhôø vaøo Chaùnh Tinh Taán vaø        related to that of the Prajnaparamita-Sutra, and Chaùnh Nieäm. Chaùnh ñònh coøn coù theå giuùp            deals with the essential identity of all things. chuùng ta tieán saâu vaøo söï nhaát taâm cao hôn,        Chaùnh Ñöông Nhaâm Ma Thôøi: Just at such and hay nhöõng taàng thieàn (saéc giôùi vaø voâ saéc         such an hour. giôùi)—Right Concentration is one of the three           Chaùnh        Giaùc:       Sambodhi         (skt)—Correct trainings in Samadhi (two other trainings are            awakening—Right realization—Tam Boà Ñeà—Söï Right Effort and Right Mindfulness). Right               nhaän thöùc ñuùng ñaén—Thöïc trí cuûa Nhö Lai hay concentration means to concentrate the mind              giaùc trí chaân chaùnh veà chö phaùp. Khi taâm thöùc tòch single-pointedly      on     an     object.       Our    dieät, khoâng coøn choã ñoäng nieäm naøo, ñoù laø chaùnh concentration or single-pointedness slowly               giaùc. Moät khi ñaõ coù chaùnh giaùc roài thì caùc hoaït improves through effort and mindfulness, until           ñoäng thöôøng ngaøy nhö thaáy vaät, nghe tieáng, ngöûi we attain calm abiding. Right Concentration              muøi, bieát vò, xuùc tri caùc phaùp, ñi, ñöùng, naèm, ngoài, may also help us progress to deeper states of            nguû nghæ, noùi im ñoäng tónh, khoâng haønh ñoäng naøo concentration,      the      actual      meditative      maø khoâng traïm nhieân. Töï mình chaúng coù nghó stabilizations (form and formless realms).               töôûng ñieân ñaûo. Töôûng hay voâ töôûng ñeàu thanh Chaùnh Ñònh Löïc: Samadhibhala (skt)—Ñònh löïc                tònh—The wisdom or omniscience of a Buddha. cuûa taâm hay ñònh löïc thieàn giuùp ta khoâng laàm laãn      When the consciousness, wholly liberated in cuõng nhö dong ruoãi—The power of concentration               tranquility and having no thought whatsoever, of mind or meditation which helps destroying                  moves on, it is called 'right realization'. He who confused or wandering thoughts.                               has attained this correct realization is then able to Chaùnh Ñònh Nghieäp: Thuaän theo 18 lôøi nguyeän              become tranquilly natural at all times and in all cuûa Phaät A Di Ñaø vaø coõi Taây Phöông Cöïc Laïc maø        activities such as seeing, hearing, smelling, nhaát taâm chuyeân nieäm hoàng danh cuûa Ngaøi —              tasting, and touching; while walking or standing, Concentration upon the eighteen vows of                       lying or sitting, sleeping or resting, talking or Amitabha and the Western Paradise, in repeating               remaining silent. He will never be confused under the name of Amitabha.                                         any circumstance. Thought and thoughtlessness Chaùnh Ñònh Phaùp Tuùc: Phaùp ñaïo ñi vaøo chaùnh             both become pure. ñònh, moät trong boán phaùp tuùc theo Kinh Phuùng             Chaùnh Giaùc Hoaèng Trí Thieàn Sö (1091-1157): Tuïng trong Tröôøng Boä Kinh—Way of Dhamma                    Wanshi Shogaku (jap)—Hung-chih Cheâng-chueh with right concentration, one of the four ways of             (Wade-Giles          Chinese)—Hongzhi            Zhengjue Dhamma according to the Sangiti Sutta in the                  (Pinyin Chinese)—See Hoaèng Trí Chaùnh Giaùc Long Discourses of the Buddha.                                Thieàn Sö. Chaùnh Ñònh Saéc Giôùi Caäp Voâ Saéc Giôùi Haïnh:             Chaùnh Giaùc Phaät: Voâ Tröôùc Phaät—Bodhi-body Haïnh chaùnh ñònh saéc giôùi vaø voâ saéc giôùi, vì laøm      in possession of complete enlightenment—See Boà cho hoï mau xoay trôû laïi—Practice of                        Ñeà Thaân. concentration in the realm of form and                        Chaùnh Giaûi Thoaùt: Right emancipation—Giaûi formlessness, to foster quick return to                       thoaùt ñuùng. noncontamination.                                             Chaùnh Giaùo: 1) Giaùo duïc chaùnh trò: Political Chaùnh Ñònh Tuï: Samyak-traniyatarasi (skt)—                  teaching, governmental education; 2) Chaùnh trò vaø Sammatta-niyato rasi (p)—Ngöôøi chaéc chaén seõ               toân giaùo: Politics and religion. thöïc chöùng nôi töï thaân—Good accumulation with             Chaùnh Giôùi: Correct rules (precepts). fixed result—A person who will surely attain truth            Chaùnh Haïnh: Samyak-praptipatti (skt)—1) Haønh by personal experience.                                       ñoäng ñuùng: Right behavior, right conduct; 2) Chaùnh Ñònh Vöông Kinh: Samadhi-raja-Sutra                    Chaùnh haïnh nôi thaân laø moät trong nhöõng cöûa ngoõ (skt)—Sutra of the King of Concentration—Kinh                 quan troïng ñi vaøo ñaïi giaùc, vì nhôø ñoù maø tam ñieån Ñaïi thöøa, noäi dung cuûa noù gaàn nhö Baùt Nhaõ       nghieäp haèng thanh tònh: Right conduct of the

actions of the body is one of the most important              what you view with your eyes. Right entrances to the great enlightenment; for with it,            understanding is of the highest importance of the three kinds of behavior are pure—See Tam                  the Eighfold Noble Path, for the remaining Thieän Haïnh.                                                 seven factors of the path are guided by it. It Chaùnh Haïnh Chaân Nhö: Samyak-Praptipatti-                   ensures that right thoughts are held and it co- tathata (skt)—Chaùnh Haïnh Nhö—Right behavior                 ordinates ideas; when as a result thoughts and of Suchness.                                                  ideas become clear and wholesome, man’s Chaùnh Haïnh Kinh: Phaät Thuyeát A Haøm Chaùnh                speech and action are also brought into proper Haïnh Kinh—Kinh Ñöùc Phaät daïy veà chaùnh haïnh              relation. It is through right understanding that nôi thaân—The sutra in which the Buddha taught                one gives up harmful or profitless effort and about right deeds of the body.                                cultivates right effort which aids the Chaùnh Haïnh Nhö: See Chaùnh Haïnh Chaân Nhö.                 development of right mindfulness. Right Chaùnh Haïnh Nôi YÙ: Mano-succaritam (p)—Right                effort and right mindfulness guided by right conduct in thought—YÙ Thieän Haïnh.                           understanding bring about right concentration. Chaùnh Hoïc Nöõ: Sikhaimana (p)—Siksamana                     Thus, right understanding, which is the main (skt)—Female novice—See Thöùc Xoa Ma Na.                      spring in the Eightfold Noble Path, causes Chaùnh Kieán: Sammaditthi (p)—Samyagdrsti                     other factors of the co-ordinate system to (skt)—Right understanding—Right view.                         move in proper relation. (I) Toång quan veà “Chaùnh Kieán”—An overview (II) Nghóa cuûa Chaùnh Kieán—The meanings of of Right Understanding (correct or perfect               Right Understanding: Chaùnh kieán laø hieåu view): Chaùnh kieán laø hieåu ñuùng theo “Töù            ñuùng theo “Töù Dieäu Ñeá.” Chaùnh kieán cuõng coù Dieäu Ñeá.” Chaùnh kieán cuõng coù nghóa laø nhìn        nghóa laø nhìn thaáy ñöôïc baûn taùnh cuûa Phaùp thaáy ñöôïc baûn taùnh cuûa Phaùp Thaân Phaät.           Thaân Phaät. Chaùnh kieán noùi ñeán thaùi ñoä cuûa Chaùnh kieán noùi ñeán thaùi ñoä cuûa chính mình veà     chính mình veà söï vaät, caùi nhìn cuûa mình baèng söï vaät, caùi nhìn cuûa mình baèng tinh thaàn vaø yù    tinh thaàn vaø yù kieán cuûa chính mình, chöù khoâng kieán cuûa chính mình, chöù khoâng phaûi laø thöù        phaûi laø thöù maø mình nhìn thaáy baèng maét maø mình nhìn thaáy baèng maét thöôøng. Chaùnh           thöôøng. Hieåu ñöôïc boán söï thaät cao quí. Söï kieán laø phaàn quan troïng nhaát trong Baùt Thaùnh      hieåu bieát naày laø trí tueä cao caû nhaát nhìn thaáy Ñaïo, vì baûy yeáu toá coøn laïi ñeàu do chaùnh kieán    söï thaät toái haäu, nghóa laø thaáy söï vaät ñuùng laø daãn daét. Chaùnh kieán ñoan chaéc vieäc duy trì         nhö theá. Ñaây laø giai ñoaïn ñaàu tieân trong Baùt ñöôïc chaùnh tö duy vaø saép xeáp caùc yù töôûng; khi    Thaùnh ñaïo. Chaùnh kieán laø nhaän thaáy moät caùch nhöõng tö duy vaø yù töôûng trôû neân trong saùng vaø    khaùch quan ngay thaúng; thaáy theá naøo thì ghi thieän laønh thì lôøi noùi vaø haønh ñoäng cuûa chuùng   ñuùng theá aáy, khoâng bò thaønh kieán hoaëc tình ta cuõng seõ chaân chaùnh. Chính nhôø coù chaùnh         caûm aûnh höôûng maø laøm cho söï nhaän xeùt bò sai kieán maø ngöôøi ta boû ñöôïc nhöõng coá gaéng laøm      leäch; bieát phaân bieät caùi thaät caùi giaû; nhaän thöùc toån haïi vaø khoâng coù lôïi, ñoàng thôøi giuùp tu taäp ñaïo lyù chaân chaùnh ñeå tieán tôùi tu haønh giaûi chaùnh tinh taán ñeå hoã trôï cho söï phaùt trieån       thoaùt. Trong Phaät Giaùo, chaùnh kieán laø söï hieåu chaùnh nieäm. Chaùnh tinh taán vaø chaùnh nieäm coù      bieát veà khoå hay tính chaát baát toaïi nguyeän cuûa chaùnh kieán höôùng daãn seõ ñem laïi chaùnh ñònh.       moïi hieän höõu duyeân sanh, hieåu bieát veà nhaân Nhö vaäy, chaùnh kieán ñöôïc xem laø nhaân toá           sanh khoå, veà söï dieät khoå vaø con ñöôøng daãn chính trong Baùt Thaùnh Ñaïo, noù thuùc ñaåy caù c       ñeán söï dieät khoå—Right view refers to yeáu toá khaùc vaän haønh nhaèm giuùp ñöa ñeán moái      understanding of the “Four Holy Truths.” It töông quan hoaøn chænh—Right view refers to              also can refer to insight into the nature of the understanding of the “Four Holy Truths.” It              Dharma Body of the Buddha. Right view also can refer to insight into the nature of the         refers to your manner of regarding something, Dharma Body of the Buddha. Right view                    your mental outlook and your opinions, not to refers to your manner of regarding something,            what you view with your eyes. Right your mental outlook and your opinions, not to            understanding, right views, or knowledge of

the four noble truth. This understanding is the            Chaùnh Kieán laø moät trong hai phaàn hoïc cuûa Trí highest wisdom which sees the Ultimate                     Tueä (phaàn hoïc khaùc laø Chaùnh Tö Duy). Chaùnh Reality. That is to say to see things as they              kieán laø thaáy ñuùng baûn chaát, hieåu bieát chaân lyù are. The understanding the four noble truths,              thaät söï cuûa moïi söï, khoâng phaûi nhìn thaáy the first of the eightfold noble path. Right               chuùng coù veû nhö theá. Theo quan ñieåm Phaät understanding or right view is viewing things              giaùo, chaùnh kieán coù nghóa laø tueä giaùc, laø söï objectively; seeing them and reporting them                hieåu bieát thaâm saâu, hay nhìn thaáy ñöôïc maët exactly as they are without being influenced               döôùi cuûa söï vieäc qua laêng kính cuûa Töù Dieäu by prejudice or emotion. Right view helps                  Ñeá, lyù nhaân duyeân, voâ thöôøng, voâ ngaõ, vaân differentiate the true from the false, and                 vaân. Chuùng ta coù theå töï mình ñaït ñöôïc chaùnh determines the true religious path for                     kieán hay hieåu bieát chaân lyù do ngöôøi khaùc chæ attaining liberation. In Buddhism, right                   baøy. Tieán trình ñaït ñöôïc chaùnh kieán phaûi theo understanding means the understanding of                   thöù töï, tröôùc nhaát laø quan saùt khaùc quan nhöõng suffering or the unsatisfactory nature of all              vieäc quanh ta, keá thöù xem xeùt yù nghóa cuûa phenomenal existence, its arising, its                     chuùng. Nghóa laø nghieân cöùu, xem xeùt, vaø kieåm cessation and the path leading to its cessation.           tra, vaø cuoái cuøng laø ñaït ñöôïc chaùnh kieán qua (III) Phaân loaïi Chaùnh Kieán—Categories of Right               thieàn ñònh. Vaøo thôøi ñieåm naøy thì hai loaïi hieåu Understanding—Theo Tieán Só K. Sri.                        bieát, töï mình hay thoâng qua ngöôøi khaùc, trôû Dhammananda trong Nhöõng Haït Ngoïc Trí                    neân khoâng theå phaân bieät ñöôïc. Noùi toùm laïi, Tueä Phaät Giaùo, coù hai loaïi Chaùnh Kieán—              tieán trình ñaït ñöôïc chaùnh kieán nhö sau: quan According to Dr. K. Sri. Dhammananda in the                saùt vaø nghieân cöùu, khaûo saùt moät caùch coù trí Gems of Buddhism Wisdom, there are two                     tueä nhöõng ñieàu mình ñaõ quan saùt vaø nghieân sorts of understanding:                                    cöùu, vaø cuoái cuøng laø taäp trung tö töôûng ñeå tö 1) Phaøm Kieán: Kieán thöùc veà moät söï tích luõy cuûa          duy veà caùi maø mình ñaõ khaûo saùt. Noùi toùm laïi, trí nhôù—an accumulated of memory, an                      chaùnh kieán coù nghóa laø söï hieåu bieát veà töù dieäu intellectual grasping of a subject according to            ñeá: khoå ñeá vaø taäp ñeá hay nhöõng nguyeân nhaân certain given data.                                        khieán keùo daøi doøng luaân hoài sanh töû, dieät ñeá 2) Thaùnh Kieán: Hieåu bieát thaät vaø saâu xa, hay              vaø ñaïo ñeá hay con ñöôøng ñöa ñeán chaám döùt thaâm nhaäp, nghóa laø nhìn söï vaät ñuùng baûn chaát      khoå ñau vaø giaûi thoaùt hoaøn toaøn—Right cuûa noù, chöù khoâng theo teân hay nhaõn hieäu beà        Understanding or Right View is one of the ngoaøi. Söï thaâm nhaäp naày chæ xaõy ra khi taâm ta       two trainings in Wisdom (the other training is ñaõ goät röõa heát nhöõng baát tònh vaø ñaõ hoaøn toaøn    Right Thought). Right understanding can be phaùt trieån qua thieàn ñònh—Real deep                     said to mean seeing things as they really are, understanding, a penetration or an intellectual            or understanding the real truth about things, seeing a thing in its true nature, without name            rather than simply seeing them as they appear and external label. This penetration is                    to be. According to Buddhist point of view, it possible only when the mind is free from all               means insight, penetrative understanding, or impurities and is fully developed through                  seeing beneath the surface of things, etc., meditation.                                                under the lens of the Four Noble Truths, (IV) Qua chaùnh kieán vaø chaùnh tö duy chuùng ta                Interdependent origination, impermanence, ñoaïn tröø tham, saân, si—Through Right                    impersonality,          and     so     forth.    Right understanding and right thought we eliminate               understanding can be acquired by ourselves or greed, anger and ignorance: The mind                       by acquiring the truths that are shown by supported by wisdom will bring forth the                   others. The process of acquiring right Right Understanding which help us wholly                   understanding must follow the following and entirely free from the intoxication of                 order: first we must observe objectively the sense desire (kama), from becoming (bhava),                facts which we are presented, then consider wrong views (ditthi) and ignorance (avijja):               their significance. It is to say first to study and

then to consider and examine them, and                      see its causes, and put an end to them right at finally attaining right understanding through               the very moment, rather dealing with their contemplation. At this point, the two types of              effects later on. understanding, either by ourselves or through 2) Chaùnh kieán laø trí tueä nhö thaät baûn chaát cuûa theá others,      become         indistinguishable.          To  gian. Muoán ñöôïc vaäy, chuùng ta caàn phaûi coù söï summarize, the process of acquiring right                   thaáu thò roõ raøng veà Töù Thaùnh Ñeá. Ñoù laø Khoå understanding are as follows: to observe and                ñeá, Taäp ñeá, Dieät ñeá vaø Ñaïo ñeá. Ñoái vôùi ngöôøi to study, to examine intellectually what we                 coù chaùnh kieán, khoù coù theå coù caùi nhìn meâ môø have observed and studied, to contemplate                   veà moïi hieän töôïng (chö phaùp), vì ngöôøi aáy ñaõ what we have examined. In short, Right                      voâ nhieãm vôùi moïi baát tònh vaø ñaõ ñaït ñeán baát Understanding means the understanding of                    ñoäng taâm giaûi thoaùt (Akuppa ceto vimutti). the four noble truths: the truths of suffering              Chaùnh kieán coù nghóa laø hieåu bieát caùc phaùp and its causes perpetuate cyclic existence, the             nhö chuùng thaät söï laø chöù khoâng nhö chuùng truths of cessation and the path are the way to             döôøng nhö laø. Ñieàu quan troïng laø phaûi nhaän liberation.                                                 thöùc ñöôïc raèng chaùnh kieán trong ñaïo Phaät coù (V) Chaùnh       kieán      vaø       Tueä       hoïc—Right     moät yù nghóa ñaëc bieät khaùc haún vôùi nhöõng gì Understanding and the training of Wisdom:                   thöôøng ñöôïc moïi ngöôøi gaùn cho. Trong Phaät 1) Ngöôøi tu theo Phaät neân phaùt trieån chaùnh kieán          giaùo, Chaùnh kieán laø soi chieáu tueä giaùc treân baèng caùch nhìn moïi vaät döôùi aùnh saùng cuûa voâ        naêm thuû uaån vaø hieåu ñöôïc baûn chaát thaät cuûa thöôøng, khoå vaø voâ ngaõ seõ chaám döùt ñöôïc             noù, ñieàu naày coù nghóa laø phaûi hieåu ñöôïc chính luyeán aùi vaø meâ laàm. Khoâng luyeán aùi khoâng coù       thaân taâm con ngöôøi. Ñoù laø tröïc nghieäm, töï nghóa laø gheùt boû. Gheùt boû thöù gì maø chuùng ta        quan saùt thaân taâm cuûa chính mình. Chaùnh kieán ñaõ coù vaø öa thích tröôùc ñaây chæ laø söï gheùt boû      laø söï hieåu bieát veà khoå hay tính chaát baát toaïi taïm thôøi, vì söï luyeán aùi laïi seõ trôû veà vôùi chuùng nguyeän cuûa moïi hieän höõu duyeân sanh, hieåu ta. Muïc ñích cuûa haønh giaû khoâng phaûi laø ñi           bieát veà nhaân sanh khoå, veà söï dieät khoå vaø con tìm söï khoaùi laïc, maø laø ñi tìm söï bình an. Bình       ñöôøng ñöa ñeán söï dieät khoå. Chaùnh kieán raát an naèm ngay trong moãi chuùng ta, söï bình an              quan troïng trong Baùt Chaùnh Ñaïo, vì baûy phaàn ñöôïc tìm thaáy cuøng choã giao ñoäng vôùi khoå             coøn laïi ñeàu do chaùnh kieán höôùng daãn. Chaùnh ñau. Khoâng theå naøo tìm thaáy söï bình an trong           kieán ñoan chaéc raèng caùc tö duy chaân chaùnh ñaõ röøng saâu nuùi thaúm. Bình an cuõng khoâng theå            ñöôïc duy trì vaø nhieäm vuï cuûa noù laø saép xeáp laïi ñöôïc ban phaùt bôûi ngöôøi khaùc. Haønh giaû tu            caùc yù nieäm; khi nhöõng tö duy vaø yù nieäm naày thieàn ñònh laø ñeå theo doõi ñau khoå, thaáy               ñaõ trôû neân trong saùng vaø thieän laønh thì lôøi noùi nguyeân nhaân cuûa noù vaø chaám döùt noù ngay baây         vaø haønh ñoäng cuûa chuùng ta cuõng seõ chaân giôø hôn laø ñöông ñaàu vôùi keát quaû cuûa noù veà         chaùnh nhö vaäy. Laïi nöõa, chính nhôø coù chaùnh sau naày—Buddhist practitioners should                      kieán maø ngöôøi ta töø boû ñöôïc nhöõng tinh taán coù develop right understanding by seeing                       haïi hay baát lôïi, ñoàng thôøi tu taäp chaùnh tinh taán impermanence, suffering, and not-self in                    hoã trôï cho söï phaùt trieån chaùnh nieäm. Chaùnh everything, which leads to detachment and                   tinh taán vaø chaùnh nieäm coù chaùnh kieán höôùng loss infatuation. Detachment is not aversion.               daãn seõ ñem laïi chaùnh ñònh. Nhö vaäy chaùnh An aversion to something we once liked is                   kieán ñöôïc xem laø ñoäng löïc chính trong Phaät temporary, and the craving for it will return.              giaùo, thuùc ñaåy caùc phaàn khaùc trong Baùt Chaùnh Practitioners do not seek for a life of pleasure,           Ñaïo vaän haønh trong moïi söï töông quan hoaøn but to find peace. Peace is within oneself, to              chænh. Coù hai ñieàu kieän caàn thieát ñeå ñöa tôùi be found in the same place as agitation and                 chaùnh kieán; do nghe ngöôøi khaùc, nghóa laø suffering. It is not found in a forest or on a              nghe chaùnh phaùp (saddhamma) töø nôi ngöôøi hilltop, nor is it given by a teacher.                      khaùc; vaø do nhö lyù taùc yù. Ñieàu kieän thöù nhaát Practitioners meditate to investigate suffering,            thuoäc veà beân ngoaøi, nghóa laø nhöõng gì chuùng ta thu thaäp ñöôïc töø beân ngoaøi; trong khi ñieàu

kieän thöù hai naèm ôû beân trong, ñoù laø nhöõng gì            Nhôø chaùnh kieán maø ngöôøi ta thaáy ñöôïc taùc chuùng ta tu taäp, hay nhöõng gì ôû trong taâm cuûa             ñoäng nhaân quaû, söï sanh vaø söï dieät cuûa caùc chuùng ta. Nhöõng gì chuùng ta nghe taïo thaønh                 phaùp höõu vi. Thaät taùnh cuûa chö phaùp chæ coù thöùc aên cho tö duy vaø höôùng daãn chuùng ta                  theå naém baét theo caùch ñoù, chôù khoâng phaûi do trong vieäc thaønh hình nhöõng quan ñieåm rieâng                nieàm tin muø quaùng, taø kieán, söï suy dieãn hay cuûa mình. Do vaäy, nghe laø ñieàu raát caàn thieát,            ngay caû baèng trieát lyù tröøu töôïng maø chuùng ta nhöng chæ ñoái vôùi nhöõng gì lieân quan ñeán                   coù theå hieåu ñöôïc söï thaät cuûa chö phaùp. Theo chaùnh kieán, vaø neân traùnh taát caû nhöõng lôøi noùi         Kinh Taêng Chi Boä, Ñöùc Phaät daïy: “Phaùp naày baát thieän cuûa ngöôøi khaùc, vì noù laøm caûn trôû tö         daønh cho ngöôøi coù trí chöù khoâng phaûi cho duy chaân chính. Ñieàu kieän thöù hai laø taùc lyù              ngöôøi voâ trí.” Trong caùc kinh ñieån, Ñöùc Phaät nhö yù, khoù tu taäp hôn, vì noù ñoøi hoûi phaûi coù söï        luoân giaûi thích caùc phaùp haønh vaø caùc phöông tænh giaùc thöôøng xuyeân treân nhöõng ñoái töôïng              tieän ñeå ñaït ñeán trí tueä vaø traùnh nhöõng taø kieán chuùng ta gaëp trong cuoäc soáng haèng ngaøy. Taùc              hö voïng. Chaùnh kieán thaám nhuaàn toaøn boä giaùo lyù nhö yù thöôøng ñöôïc duøng trong caùc baøi phaùp            phaùp, lan toûa ñeán moïi phöông dieän cuûa giaùo coù yù nghóa raát quan troïng, vì noù coù theå laøm             phaùp, vaø taùc ñoäng nhö yeáu toá chaùnh cuûa phaät cho chuùng ta thaáy ñöôïc caùc phaùp moät caùch saâu            giaùo. Do thieáu chaùnh kieán maø phaøm phu bò xa hôn. Töø “Yoniso” coù nghóa laø baèng ñöôøng                 troùi buoäc vaøo baûn chaát thaät cuûa cuoäc ñôøi, vaø ruoät, thay vì chæ treân beà maët noâng caïn. Do ñoù,           khoâng thaáy ñöôïc söï thaät phoå quaùt cuûa cuoäc dieãn ñaït theo loái aån duï, thì ñoù laø söï chuù yù trieät    soáng laø khoå, thaäm chí hoï coøn khoâng muoán ñeå hay söï chuù yù hôïp lyù. Hai ñieàu kieän nghe vaø          hieåu nhöõng söï thaät naày, theá nhöng laïi voäi keát taùc yù nhö lyù phoái hôïp vôùi nhau seõ giuùp cho              aùn giaùo phaùp nhaø Phaät veà Töù Dieäu Ñeá laø bi vieäc phaùt trieån chaùnh kieán. Ngöôøi taàm caàu               quan yeám theá. Coù leõ ñaây cuõng laø ñieàu töï chaân lyù seõ khoâng thoûa maõn vôùi kieán thöùc beà            nhieân, vì ñoái vôùi nhöõng ngöôøi coøn maõi meâ maët, vôùi caùi giaû töôûng hôøi hôït beân ngoaøi cuûa          trong nhöõng laïc thuù traàn gian, nhöõng ngöôøi luùc chö phaùp, maø muoán tìm toøi saâu hôn ñeå thaáy                naøo cuõng muoán thoûa maõn caùc giaùc quan vaø nhöõng gì naèm ngoaøi taàm thaáy cuûa maét thöôøng.             chaùn gheùt khoå, thì ngay caû yù nieäm veà khoå naày Ñoù laø loaïi nghieân cöùu ñöôïc Ñöùc Phaät khuyeán             cuõng ñaõ laøm cho hoï böïc boäi vaø xoay löng laïi khích, vì noù daãn ñeán chaùnh kieán. Ngöôøi coù                vôùi noù. Tuy nhieân, hoï khoâng nhaän ra raèng cho ñaàu oùc phaân tích tuyeân boá moät ñieàu gì sau khi            duø hoï coù leân aùn caùi yù nieäm veà khoå naày, vaø cho ñaõ phaân tích chuùng thaønh nhöõng tính chaát khaùc            duø hoï coù trung thaønh vôùi chuû nghóa lôïi ích caù nhau, ñöôïc saép ñaët laïi theo heä thoáng, laøm cho            nhaân, vaø laïc quan veà caùc phaùp, hoï vaãn bò ñeø moïi vieäc trôû neân roõ raøng deã hieåu, ngöôøi aáy            beïp bôûi tính chaát baát toaïi nguyeän coá höõu cuûa khoâng bao giôø tuyeân boá moät ñieàu gì khi chuùng             cuoäc ñôøi—Right Understanding, in the coøn nguyeân theå, maø seõ phaân tích chuùng theo               ultimate sense, is to understand life as it nhöõng neùt ñaëc thuø sao cho söï thaät cheá ñònh vaø           really is. For this, one needs a clear söï thaät tuyeät ñoái coù theå ñöôïc hieåu roõ raøng            comprehension of the Four Noble Truths, khoâng bò laãn loän. Ñöùc Phaät laø moät baäc toaøn             namely: the Truth of Suffering or giaùc, moät nhaø phaân tích ñaõ ñaït ñeán trình ñoä             Unsatisfactoriness, the Arising of Suffering, tuyeät luaân. Cuõng nhö moät nhaø khoa hoïc phaân               the Cessation of Suffering, and the Path tích con ngöôøi thaønh caùc moâ vaø caùc moâ thaønh             leading to the Cessation of Suffering. Right caùc teá baøo. Ñöùc phaät cuõng phaân tích caùc phaùp           understanding means to understand things as höõu vi thaønh nhöõng yeáu toá cô baûn, cho ñeán khi            they really are and not as they appear to be. It ñaõ phaân tích thaønh nhöõng phaùp cuøng toät,                  is important to realize that right understanding khoâng coøn coù theå phaân tích ñöôïc nöõa. Ñöùc                in Buddhism has a special meaning which Phaät baùc boû loái phaân tích noâng caïn, khoâng taùc          differs from that popularly attributed to it. In yù nhö lyù, coù khuynh höôùng laøm cho con ngöôøi               Buddhism, right understanding is the trôû neân ñaàn ñoän vaø ngaên trôû vieäc nghieân cöùu           application of insight to the five aggregates of tìm toøi vaøo baûn chaát thaät söï cuûa chö phaùp.              clinging, and understanding their true nature,

that is understanding oneself. It is self-           ‘radical’ or ‘reasoned attention’. These two examination and self-observation. Right              conditions, learning and systematic attention, understanding is the understanding of                together help to develop right understanding. suffering or the unsatisfactory nature of all        One who seeks truth is not satisfied with phenomenal existence, its arising, its               surface knowledge, with the mere external cessation, and the path leading to its               appearance of things, but wants to dig deep cessation. Right understanding is of the             and see what is beyond the reach of naked highest important in the Eightfold Noble Path,       eye. That is the sort of search encouraged in for the remaining seven factors of the path are      Buddhism, for it leads to right understanding. guided by it. It ensures that right thoughts are     The man of analysis states a thing after held and it co-operates ideas; when as a result      resolving it into its various qualities, which he thoughts and ideas become clear and                  puts in proper order, making everything plain. wholesome, man’s speech and action are also          He does not state things unitarily, looking at brought into proper relation. Moreover, it is        them as a whole, but divides them up through right understanding that one gives up        according to their outstanding features so that harmful or profitless effort and cultivates right    the conventional and the highest truth can be effort which aids the development of right           understood unmixed. The Buddha was mindfulness.      Right    effort and right          discriminative and analytical to the highest mindfulness guided by right understanding            degree. As a scientist resolves a limb into bring about right concentration. Thus, right         tissues and the tissues into cells, the Buddha understanding, which is the main spring in           analyzed all component and conditioned Buddhism, causes the other limbs of the co-          things into their fundamental elements, right ordinate system to move in proper relation.          down to their ultimates, and condemned There are two conditions that are conducive          shallow thinking, unsystematic attention, to right understanding: Hearing from others,         which tends to make man muddle-headed and that is hearing the Correct Law (Saddhamma),         hinders the investigation of the true nature of from others (Paratoghosa), and systematic            things. It is through right understanding that attention or wise attention (Yoniso-                 one sees cause and effect, the arising and manasikara). The first condition is external,        ceasing of all conditioned things. The truth of that is, what we get from outside, while the         the Dhamma can be only grasped in that way, second is internal, what we cultivate                and not through blind belief, wrong view, (manasikara literally means doing-in-the-            speculation or even by abstract philosophy. mind). What we hear gives us food for                According to the Anguttara Nikaya, the thought and guides us in forming our own             Buddha says: “This Dhamma is for the wise views. It is, therefore, necessary to listen, but    and not for the unwise.” The Nikaya also only to that which is conducive to right             explains the ways and means of attaining understanding and to avoid all the harmful           wisdom by stages and avoiding false views. and unwholesome utterances of others which           Right understanding permeates the entire prevent straight thinking. The second                teaching, pervades every part and aspect of condition, systematic attention, is more             the Dhamma and functions as the key-note of difficult to cultivate, because it entails           Buddhism. Due to lack of right understanding, constant awareness of the things that one            the ordinary man is blind to the true nature of meets with in everyday life. The word                life and fails to see the universal fact of life, ‘Yoniso-manasikara’ which is often used in           suffering or unsatisfactoriness. He does not the discourses is most important, for it enables     even try to grasp these facts, but hastily one to see things deeply. ‘Yoniso’ literally         considers the doctrine as pessimism. It is means by-way-of-womb instead of only on              natural perhaps, for beings engrossed in the surface. Metaphorically, therefore, it is        mundane pleasures, beings who crave more

and more for gratification of the senses and             Boä ñöôïc thaønh laäp, trong ñoù Chaùnh Löôïng Boä laø hate pain, to resent the very idea of suffering          boä thöù ba—One of the 18 sects of early Hinayana. and turn their back on it. They do not,                  The school of correct measures, or correct however, realize that even as they condemn               evaluation. Three hundred years after the the idea of suffering and adhere to their own            Buddha’s nirvana it is said that from the convenient and optimistic view of things, they           Vatsiputriyah school four divisions were formed, are still being oppressed by the ever recurring          of which this was the third. unsatisfactory nature of life.                           Chaùnh Löu Boà Taùt: Amoghadarsana (skt)— Chaùnh Kieán Hôïp Theá: Mundane right                         Amoghadarsin (skt)—Baát Khoâng Nhaõn Boà Taùt— understanding—Chaùnh kieán hôïp theá nghóa laø söï            See Baát Khoâng Kieán Boà Taùt. hieåu bieát cuûa haøng phaøm nhaân veà nghieäp vaø quaû       Chaùnh Lyù: Naya (skt)—Nyaya (skt)—Na Da— cuûa nghieäp. Vì theá, chaùnh kieán hôïp theá coù nghóa laø   Phöông phaùp ñuùng (ñaïo lyù chaân chính)—Good söï hieåu bieát hôïp vôùi Töù Thaùnh Ñeá. Goïi laø chaùnh     way—Right method—Right principle. kieán hôïp theá vì söï hieåu bieát naày chöa thoaùt khoûi     Chaùnh Lyù Luaän: Naya-sastra (skt)—Luaän veà caùc laäu hoaëc (caáu ueá). Chaùnh kieán hôïp theá coù theå   phöông phaùp ñuùng (ñaïo lyù chaân chính)—Treatise goïi laø “tuyø giaùc trí.”—Mundane right                      on good way (right method, right principle). understanding means an ordinary worldling’s                   Chaùnh Lyù Nhaát Trích Luaän: Nyayabindu (skt)— knowledge of the efficacy of moral causation or of            Teân cuûa moät boä luaän thuoäc phaùi Chaùnh Lyù—Name actions and their results. Therefore, mundane right           of a commentary of the Naiyayika. understanding means the knowledge that accords                Chaùnh Lyù Phaùi: Naiyayika (skt)—Ninhu (skt)— with the Four Noble Truths. This is called                    Phaùi theo phöông phaùp ñuùng, ñöôïc saùng laäp vaøo mundane because the understanding is not yet                  khoaûng theá kyû thöù nhaát, coù nhieàu ñieåm töông ñoàng free from taints. This may be called “knowing                 vôùi phaùi Thaéng Luaän—Right method sect, founded accordingly.”                                                 in the first century, there are a lot of similar views Chaùnh Kieán Sieâu Theá: Supramundane right                   with the Vaisesika-Sastra Sect—See Thaéng Luaän understanding.                                                Toâng. Chaùnh Kieán Thieàn Ñònh: Jhana samma ditthi                  Chaùnh Lyù Trích Luaän: See Chaùnh Lyù Nhaát Trích (p)—Right        understanding        in    stages      of    Luaän. meditation—Chaùnh kieán trong caùc taàng thieàn. Ñaây         Chaùnh Maïng: Samma-ajiva (p)—Samyag-ajiva laø söï hieåu bieát thaät vaø saâu xa, hay thaâm nhaäp,       (skt)—Correct Livelihood or perfect Livelihood. nghóa laø nhìn söï vaät ñuùng baûn chaát cuûa noù, chöù       (I) Nghóa cuûa Chaùnh Maïng—The meanings of khoâng theo teân hay nhaõn hieäu beà ngoaøi. Söï thaâm             “Right livelihood”: nhaäp naày chæ xaõy ra khi taâm ta ñaõ goät röûa heát         1) Chaùnh maïng coù nghóa laø sinh soáng chaân chính nhöõng baát tònh vaø ñaõ hoaøn toaøn phaùt trieån qua              vaø löông thieän; khoâng laøm giaøu treân moà hoâi thieàn ñònh—This is a real deep understanding, a                   nöôùc maét cuûa ngöôøi khaùc; khoâng ñoái xöû teä baïc penetration or an intellectual seeing a thing in its               vôùi ngöôøi khaùc; khoâng soáng baùm vaøo ngöôøi true nature, without name and external label. This                 khaùc; khoâng meâ tín dò ñoan; khoâng soáng baèng penetration is possible only when the mind is free                 mieäng löôõi moái laùi ñeå kieám lôïi. Chaùnh maïng from all impurities and is fully developed through                 coøn coù nghóa laø möu sinh ñuùng laø traùnh nhöõng meditation.                                                        ngheà gaây phöông haïi cho nhöõng chuùng sanh Chaùnh Kî: The day of decease.                                     khaùc nhö ñoà teå, ñi saên, buoân baùn vuõ khí, buoân Chaùnh Löôïng Boä: Sammatiya or Sammitiya                          baùn xì ke ma tuùy, v.v. Möu sinh ñuùng coøn coù (skt)—Sa        Ma       Ñeá—School        of      Correct         nghóa laø choái boû moïi loái soáng taø vaïy—Right Evaluation—School of Correct Measure—Moät                          livelihood means to lead a decent and honest trong 18 boä cuûa tröôøng phaùi Tieåu Thöøa. Phaùp cuûa            life. We must keep from exploiting or phaùi boä naày laø chaùnh löôïng hay ñuùng y vôùi Phaät            mistreating others or sponging on them. Do phaùp nguyeân thuûy khoâng sai leäch. Ba traêm naêm                not be superstitious; do not act as a go- sau ngaøy Phaät nhaäp nieát baøn thì boán phaùi Ñoäc Töû           between to take profit. Correct occupation

also means avoid professions that are harmful                   should live by profession which is blameless to sentient beings such as the five immoral                     and free from harm to oneself and others. occupations (slaughterer, hunter, dealer in                5) Chaùnh maïng laø cuoäc soáng ñuùng ñaén cuûa haøng weaponry, or narcotics, ect). Perfect                           tu só laø khaát thöïc. Laøm vieäc hay laøm thöông livelihood also means rejecting all wrong                       maïi laø taø meänh—The right livelihood for a living.                                                         monk is to beg for food. To work for a living 2) Chaùnh maïng coù nghóa laø möu sinh ôû möùc                     or to do worldly business is an improper life. khoâng vi phaïm nhöõng giaù trò ñaïo ñöùc caên baûn.       (II) Ñöùc Phaät daïy veà Chaùnh Maïng—The Buddha Chaùnh maïng laø söï môû roäng cuûa luaät veà chaùnh            taught about the “Right Livelihood”: Ñöùc Phaät nghieäp ñoái vôùi sinh keá trong xaõ hoäi. Chaùnh               daïy: “Coù naêm loaïi sinh keá maø ngöôøi Phaät töû maïng laø söï môû roäng veà luaät cuûa chaùnh nghieäp           khoâng neân laøm laø buoân baùn suùc vaät ñeå laøm ñoái vôùi sinh keá cuûa Phaät töû trong xaõ hoäi.               thòt, buoân baùn noâ leä, buoân baùn vuõ khí, ñoäc Chaùnh maïng coøn coù nghóa laø taïo ra cuûa caûi taøi          döôïc, vaø caùc chaát say nhö ma tuùy vaø röôïu. saûn baèng nhöõng phöông caùch thích ñaùng. Phaät               Naêm loaïi ngheà nghieäp naøy ngöôøi Phaät töû töû thuaàn thaønh khoâng neân nhuùng tay tham gia               khoâng neân laøm vì chuùng goùp phaàn laøm cho xaõ vaøo loaïi haønh ñoäng hay lôøi noùi toån haïi ñeå möu          hoäi baêng hoaïi vaø vi phaïm nguyeân taéc toân sinh, hoaëc giaû xuùi giuïc khieán ngöôøi khaùc laøm            troïng söï soáng vaø phuùc lôïi cuûa ngöôøi khaùc.” vaø noùi nhö vaäy—Right livelihood means                        Ngöôïc laïi, ngöôøi Phaät töû neân soáng baèng nhöõng earning a living in a way that does not violate                 ngheà nghieäp löông thieän, khoâng laøm haïi mình basic moral values. Right livelihood is an                      haïi ngöôøi—The Buddha taught: “There are extension of the rules of right action to our                   five kinds of livelihood that are discouraged roles as breadwinners in society. Right                         for Buddhists: trading in animals for food Livelihood also means that to earn a living in                  (selling animals for slaughter), slaves (dealing an appropriate way. Devout Buddhists should                     in slaves), arms (selling arms and lethal not engage in any of the physical or verbal                     weapons), poisons, and intoxicants (drugs and negative actions to earn a living, nor should                   alcohol, selling intoxicating and/or poisonous we cause others to do so.                                       drinks). These five are not recommended 3) Chaùnh maïng laø khí giôùi cuûa Boà Taùt, vì xa rôøi            because they contribute to the destroy of taát caû taø maïng. Chö Boà Taùt an truï nôi phaùp              society and violate the values of respect for naày thôøi coù theå dieät tröø nhöõng phieàn naõo, kieát        life and for the welfare of others.” Right söû ñaõ chöùa nhoùm töø laâu cuûa taát caû chuùng               Livelihood is an extension of the rules of right sanh—Right livelihood is a weapon of                            action to our roles as breadwinners in society. enlightening beings, leading away from all                      In the contrary, Buddhists should live by an wrong livelihood. Enlightening Beings who                       honest profession that is free from harm to abide by these can annihilate the afflictions,                  self and others. bondage, and compulsion accumulated by all                 Chaùnh Maïng Taêng: See Chaùnh Maïng Thöïc. sentient beings in the long night of                       Chaùnh Maïng Thöïc: Chaùnh Maïng Taêng—Ngöôøi ignorance—See Möôøi Khí Giôùi Cuûa Chö Ñaïi                xuaát gia phaûi laáy vieäc khaát thöïc maø nuoâi xaùc thaân Boà Taùt.                                                  maø tu haønh—The right kind of monk’s livelihood 4) Chaùnh maïng laø töø boû nhöõng loái laøm aên sinh         by mendicancy. soáng taø vaïy, ñem laïi söï tai haïi, khoå ñau cho        Chaùnh Meänh: See Chaùnh Maïng. mình vaø cho ngöôøi khaùc. Ngöôøi Phaät töû neân           Chaùnh Meänh Sa Moân: Vò Taêng chæ soáng baèng sinh soáng baèng nhöõng ngheà ñöôïc xem laø                phöông caùch khaát thöïc—Monk who makes his khoâng bò khieån traùch, khoâng laøm haïi ñeán baûn        living by mendicancy (right livelihood for a thaân vaø ngöôøi khaùc—Right livelihood is                 monk). abandoning wrong ways of living which bring                Chaùnh Minh: Kinh luaän tröïc tieáp trình baøy toâng harm and suffering to others. A Buddhist                   chæ cô baûn—Sutras and sastras directly show the school's fundamental thesis or ideas.

Chaùnh Moân: Main gate.                                    (II) Chaùnh nghieäp vaø giôùi hoïc—Right action and Chaùnh Nghieäp: Samma-kammanta (p)—Samyak-                      trainings in ethics: Chaùnh Nghieäp laø moät trong karmanta (skt)—Correct or Right Deed or Action                  ba phaùp tu hoïc cao thöôïng veà Giôùi Hoïc (hai (conduct)—Perfect conduct means getting rid of                  phaùp khaùc laø Chaùnh Ngöõ vaø Chaùnh Maïng). all improper action—To dwell in purity.                         Nhö vaäy chaùnh nghieäp bao haøm toân troïng ñôøi (I) Nghóa cuûa Chaùnh Nghieäp—The meaning of                    soáng, toân troïng taøi saûn vaø toân troïng quan heä caù Right Action: Haønh ñoäng ñuùng, traùnh laøm vieäc         nhaân. Toân troïng ñôøi soáng laø khoâng gieát haïi vaø aùc, thanh tònh thaân laø giai ñoaïn thöù tö trong         khoâng baûo ngöôøi khaùc gieát haïi, toân troïng taøi Baùt Thaùnh Ñaïo. Chaùnh nghieäp laø haønh ñoäng           saûn laø khoâng troäm caép vaø khoâng baûo ngöôøi chaân chaùnh, ñuùng vôùi leõ phaûi, coù ích lôïi           khaùc troäm caép, toân troïng nhöõng quan heä caù chung. Luoân luoân haønh ñoäng trong söï toân              nhaân laø traùnh taø daâm. Chaùnh Nghieäp laø haønh troïng haïnh phuùc chung; toân troïng löông taâm           ñoäng chaân chaùnh khieán cho chuùng ta coù theå ngheà nghieäp cuûa mình; khoâng laøm toån haïi ñeán        traùnh ñöôïc ba vieäc laøm toån haïi veà thaân (saùt quyeàn lôïi, ngheà nghieäp, ñòa vò, danh döï, vaø          sanh, troäm caép vaø taø daâm). Chaùnh Nghieäp daïy tính maïng cuûa ngöôøi khaùc; giöõ gìn thaân khaåu yù      cho chuùng ta yù thöùc ñöôïc nhöõng tai haïi maø baèng caùch luoân tu taäp möôøi nghieäp laønh vaø          chuùng ta gaây ra cho ngöôøi khaùc. Thay vì laøm nhoå döùt möôøi nghieäp döõ. Chaùnh nghieäp coøn coù       nhöõng ñieàu maø tröôùc maét chuùng ta caûm thaáy nghóa laø traùnh nhöõng haønh ñoäng taø vaïy, soáng        öa thích thì chuùng ta laïi quan taâm ñeán tha thanh khieát, khoâng laøm gì toån haïi ñeán tha            nhaân. Moät khi coù Chaùnh Nghieäp thì dó nhieân nhaân, khoâng troäm caép, khoâng taø daâm —Right           töï ñoäng caùc moái quan heä cuûa chuùng ta vôùi moïi action, avoiding all wrong, purity of body, the            ngöôøi seõ ñöôïc toát ñeïp hôn vaø moïi ngöôøi seõ fourth of the eightfold noble path. Right action           caûm thaáy haïnh phuùc hôn khi cuøng soáng vôùi involves action beneficial to both others and              chuùng ta. Chaùnh Nghieäp cuõng bao goàm vieäc ra ourselves. We must always act for the                      tay giuùp ñôõ ngöôøi khaùc nhö phuï giuùp ngöôøi happiness of the community, conforming to                  giaø caû, cöùu trôï thieân tai baõo luït, hay cöùu giuùp our sense of duty, without any ulterior motive             ngöôøi ñang laâm naïn, vaân vaân—Right action is for damaging others’ interests, occupations,               one of the three higher trainings in Ethics positions, honors, or lives. We must also keep             (two other trainings are Right Speech and strict control of our "“action, speech, and                Right Livelihood). Right action implies mind," carrying out ten meritorious actions                respect for life, respect for property, and and avoiding ten evil ones. Right action also              respect for personal relationships. Respect for means to abstain from injuring living beings,              life means not to kill or tell others to kill from stealing and from unlawful sexual                     living beings, respect for property means not intercourse. Perfect conduct also means                    to steal or tell others to steal, respect for avoidance of actions that conflict with moral              personal relationships means to avoid sexual discipline.                                                misconduct (avoid adultery). Right action (A) Khoâng neân laøm (Neân traùnh): Ngöôøi Phaät töû            means acting properly. Right action can help khoâng saùt sanh, khoâng troäm caép, vaø khoâng taø        us avoid creating the three destructive actions daâm—Not to do or avoid: A Buddhist should                 of the body (killing, stealing and unwise abstain from taking life, abstain from taking              sexual behavior). Right action teaches us to what is not given, and abstain from carnal                 be aware of the effects of our actions on indulgence or illicit sexual indulgence.                   others. Once we possess Right Action, instead (B) Ngöôøi Phaät töû neân luoân trau doài töø bi, chæ laáy      of doing whatever pleases us at the moment, khi ñöôïc cho, vaø soáng ñôøi thanh tònh vaø trong         we’ll be considerate of others, and of course, saïch—Should always cultivate compassion,                  automatically our relationships will improve take only things that are given, and live a pure           and others will be happier in our company. and chaste life.                                           Right Action also includes giving old people a hand in their house work, helping storm and

flood victims, and rescuing people from                         that are pleasant, gentle, meaningful and danger, and so on.                                              useful. Speak at the right time and place. If Chaùnh Nguyeän: Vappa (p)—Vaspa (skt)—Baspa                          not necessary, or if one cannot say something (skt)—Baø sa ba—Moät trong naêm ñeä töû ñaàu tieân                   useful, the Buddha advised people to keep cuûa Ñöùc Phaät, ñöôïc ngöôøi ta coi nhö laø Ngaøi Ñaïi              silent. This is a noble silence. Ca Dieáp—One of the first five diciples of the                 (II) Chaùnh ngöõ bao goàm—Right Speech includes: Buddha, Dasabala-Kasyapa, identified with Maha-                1) Khoâng noùi doái, ñoàng thôøi phaûi luoân luoân noùi Kasyapa.                                                             söï thaät—Abstain from falsehood and always Chaùnh Nguyeät: Thaùng gieâng—The first month.                       speak the truth. Chaùnh Ngöõ: Samma-vaca (p)—Samyak-vaca                        2) Khoâng noùi lôøi ly giaùn gaây söï baát hoøa vaø chia (skt)—Correct or perfect Speech—Noùi ñuùng laø                       reõ, ñoàng thôøi phaûi noùi nhöõng lôøi naøo ñöa ñeán giai ñoaïn thöù ba trong Baùt Thaùnh ñaïo—Right                      söï hoøa hôïp vaø ñoaøn keát—Abstain from tale- speech, the third of the eightfold noble path.                       bearing which brings about discord and (I) Nghóa cuûa Chaùnh ngöõ—The meanings of                           disharmony, and to speak words that are Right speech: Chaùnh ngöõ laø noùi lôøi thaønh thaät            conducive to concord and harmony. vaø saùng suoát, noùi hôïp lyù, noùi khoâng thieân vò,    3) Khoâng noùi nhöõng lôøi thoâ aùc, coäc caèn, thay vaøo noùi thaúng chöù khoâng noùi xeùo hay xuyeân taïc,              ñoù phaûi noùi nhöõng lôøi töø aùi, teá nhò—Abstain noùi lôøi thaän troïng vaø hoøa nhaõ; noùi lôøi khoâng          from harsh and abusive speech, and instead to toån haïi vaø coù lôïi ích chung. Noùi ñuùng laø khoâng         speak kind and refined words. noùi doái, khoâng ba hoa, taùn gaãu hay deøm pha.         4) Khoâng noùi nhöõng lôøi voâ ích, ngoài leâ ñoâi maùch, Noùi ñuùng laø khoâng noùi xaáu phæ baùng vu khoáng             thay vaøo ñoù phaûi noùi nhöõng lôøi coù yù nghóa vaø vaø noùi naêng coù theå mang laïi saân haän, thuø oaùn,         khoâng bò baäc trí khieån traùch—Abstain from chia reõ vaø baát hoøa giöõa caù nhaân vaø caùc ñoaøn           idle chatter, vain talk or gossip and instead to theå. Khoâng noùi doái, khoâng laïm duïng nhaøn                 speak words which are meaningful and ñaøm hyù luaän, khoâng noùi lôøi coäc caèn thoâ loã,            blameless. thieáu leã ñoä, hieåm ñoäc vaø nhöõng lôøi sæ nhuïc,      (III) Chaùnh ngöõ vaø Giôùi hoïc—Right Speech and khoâng noùi lôøi böøa baõi. Ngöôïc laïi, Noùi ñieàu             the training of ethics: Chaùnh Ngöõ laø moät trong chaân thaät, noùi baèng lôøi dòu daøng thaân höõu vaø           ba phaàn cuûa Giôùi Hoïc (hai phaàn khaùc laø nhaân ñöùc, vaø duøng lôøi vui veû lòch söï, coù yù             Chaùnh Nghieäp vaø Chaùnh Maïng). Lôøi noùi coù nghóa vaø coù lôïi ích. Noùi ñuùng luùc ñuùng choã.             theå laøm aûnh höôûng ñeán haøng trieäu ngöôøi. Neáu khoâng caàn noùi, hay khoâng noùi ñöôïc ñieàu              Ngöôøi ta noùi raèng moät lôøi noùi thoâ baïo coù theå lôïi ích, thì Ñöùc Phaät khuyeân chuùng ta neân giöõ            laøm toån thöông hôn vuõ khí, trong khi moät lôøi im laëng, vì ñaây laø söï im laëng cao thöôïng—                 noùi nheï nhaøng coù theå thay ñoåi caû traùi tim vaø Right speech implies sincere, sound,                            taâm hoàn cuûa moät phaïm nhaân böôùng bænh nhaát. impartial, direct, not distorting, cautious,                    Vì vaäy chaùnh ngöõ trong Phaät giaùo bao haøm söï affable, harmless, useful words and                             toân troïng chaân lyù vaø phuùc lôïi cuûa ngöôøi khaùc. discourses. Avoidance of lying, slander and                     Chaùnh Ngöõ baét ñaàu vôùi vieäc traùnh xa boán loaïi gossip (false and idle talk), or abstaining from                lôøi noùi gaây toån haïi: noùi doái, noùi lôøi ly giaùn, noùi lying, tale-bearing, harsh words, and foolish                   lôøi thoâ aùc vaø noùi chuyeän phuø phieám. Chaúng babble. Abstaining from backbiting slander                      nhöõng vaäy, Phaät töû thuaàn thaønh neân luoân coá and talk that may bring about hatred, enmity,                   gaéng duøng lôøi noùi nhö theá naøo cho ngöôøi khaùc disunity and disharmony among individuals or                    ñöôïc vui veû. Thay vì truùt ñi söï giaän döõ vaø böïc groups of people. Abstaining from lying,                        doïc leân ngöôøi khaùc, Phaät töû thuaàn thaønh neân abstaining from abuse and idle talk,                            nghó ñeán nhöõng caùch höõu hieäu ñeå truyeàn ñaït abstaining from harsh, rude, impolite,                          nhöõng nhu caàu vaø caûm xuùc cuûa chuùng ta. malicious language, abstaining from careless                    Ngoaøi ra, Chaùnh Ngöõ coøn laø noùi lôøi khen ngôïi words. On the contrary, utilize words that are                  nhöõng thaønh töïu cuûa ngöôøi khaùc moät caùch soft, friendly and benevolent, utilize words                    chaân tình, hay an uûi ngöôøi ñang buoàn khoå, hay

giaûng Phaùp cho ngöôøi. Lôøi noùi laø moät coâng cuï     Chaùnh Ngöõ Maõ Sö: Asvajit (skt)—A Thaáp Phaï coù coâng naêng aûnh höôûng maïnh meõ leân ngöôøi         Phaït Ña—A Thaáp Baø Thò—A Thaáp Baø Thò Ña— khaùc, neáu chuùng ta bieát duøng lôøi noùi moät caùch    Maõ Thaéng—See A Thuyeát Thò. khoân ngoan thì seõ coù raát nhieàu ngöôøi ñöôïc lôïi     Chaùnh Nhaân: Immediate cause—Direct cause— laïc. Lôøi noùi coù theå laøm aûnh höôûng ñeán haøng      Caän Nhaân—Correct cause (Buddha nature of all trieäu ngöôøi. Ngöôøi ta noùi raèng moät lôøi noùi thoâ   beings). Main cause—True cause, as compared to baïo coù theå laøm toån thöông hôn vuõ khí, trong         a contributory cause—Nhaân chính, so vôùi nhaân khi moät lôøi noùi nheï nhaøng coù theå thay ñoåi caû     phuï. traùi tim vaø taâm hoàn cuûa moät phaïm nhaân böôùng      Chaùnh Nhaân Phaät Taùnh: The Buddha-nature or bænh nhaát. Vì vaäy chaùnh ngöõ trong Phaät giaùo         Bhutatathata. The direct cause of attaining the bao haøm söï toân troïng chaân lyù vaø phuùc lôïi cuûa    perfect Buddha-nature. ngöôøi khaùc, nghóa laø traùnh noùi doái, traùnh noùi     Chaùnh Nhaãn: The right patience—Khaû naêng nhaãn xaáu hay vu khoáng, traùnh noùi lôøi hung döõ, vaø        nhuïc vaø duøng chaùnh tín ñeå trieät tieâu si meâ vaø ñi traùnh noùi chuyeän voâ ích—Correct or Right              ñeán chöùng ngoä Trung Ñaïo (nhöõng baäc trong möôøi Speech or Perfect Speech is one of the three              ñòa hay nhöõng ñöùc tính cuûa moät vò Phaät hay Boà higher trainings in Ethics (two other trainings           Taùt)—The ability to bear patience and to use right are Right Action and Right Livelihood).                   faith to eliminate all illusion in order to realize the Speech can influence millions of people. It is            Middle Path (those who are in the ten stages or said that a harsh word can wound more deeply              characteristics of a Buddha, i.e. Bodhisattvas). than a weapon, whereas a gentle word can                  Chaùnh Nhöït: The day of a funeral. change the heart and mind of even the most                Chaùnh Nieäm: Sati (p)—Smrtindriya (skt)— hardened criminal. Therefore, right speech                Sammasati (p)—Samyaksmrti (skt)—Correct implies respect for truth and respect for the             thinking—Mindfulness—Memory—Correct (Right well being of others. Right speech begins with            or Perfect) Remembrance or Mindfulness—Right avoiding four destructive actions of speech:              mindfulness. lying, divisive words, harsh words and idle               (I) Toång quan veà "Chaùnh Nieäm"—An overview talk. Not only that, devout Buddhists should                    of Mindfulness: Coù moät maãu ñaøm thoaïi ngaén always try to communicate in a way pleasing                     nguûi veà "Chaùnh Nieäm" giöõa ñöùc Phaät vaø moät to others. Rather than venting our anger or                     trieát gia ñöông thôøi. Trieát gia noùi: "Toâi thöôøng frustration onto another, devout Buddhists                      nghe noùi raèngñaïo Phaät laø moät hoïc thuyeát giaùc should think about effective ways to                            ngoä. Vaäy phöông phaùp cuûa Ngaøi laø gì? Caùch communicate our needs and feelings to them.                     tu taäp haèng ngaøy cuûa Ngaøi goàm coù nhöõng gì?" Besides, Right Speech also means to                             Ñöùc Phaät ñaùp: "Chuùng toâi ñi, chuùng toâi aên, sincerely make an effort to notice and                          chuùng toâi taém röûa, vaø chuùng toâi ngoài xuoáng." comment upon others’ good qualities and                         Trieát gia noùi: "Nhö vaäy coù gì laø ñaëc bieät? Taát achievements, or to console people in time of                   caû moïi ngöôøi ai cuõng ñi, aên, taém röûa vaø ngoài grief, or to teach people Dharma. Speech is a                   xuoáng..." Ñöùc Phaät ñaùp laïi: "Thöa ngaøi, khi powerful tool to influence others and if we                     chuùng toâi ñi, chuùng toâi yù thöùc raèng chuùng toâi use it wisely, many people will benefit.                        ñi. Khi chuùng toâi aên, chuùng toâi yù thöùc raèng Speech can influence millions of people. It is                  chuùng toâi aên... Noùi chung, khi ñi, khi aên, khi said that a harsh word can wound more deeply                    taém röûa hoaëc khi ngoài xuoáng, nhöõng ngöôøi than a weapon, whereas a gentle word can                        khaùc khoâng yù thöùc veà ñieàu mình ñang laøm." change the heart and mind of even the most                      Trong ñaïo Phaät, chaùnh nieäm laø ñieàu chuû yeáu. hardened criminal. Therefore, right speech                      Chaùnh nieäm laø nguoàn naêng löôïng toûa aùnh implies respect for truth and respect for the                   saùng xuoáng treân moïi vaät vaø moïi hoaït ñoäng, well being of others. It is to say right speech                 taïo ra söùc maïnh ñònh löïc vaø ñöa chuùng ta ñeán means the avoidance of lying, backbiting or                     caùi taâm saâu thaúm trong chuùng ta, ñeán bôø giaùc slander, harsh speech and idle talk.                            ngoä. Noùi toùm laïi, trong ñaïo Phaät, chaùnh nieäm

laø traïng thaùi taâm ñuùng trong ñoù haønh giaû ñöôïc   ngoaøi—Right mindfulness means to give heed höôùng ñuùng vaø gaëp gôõ vôùi traïng thaùi taâm cuûa    to good deed for our own benefit and that of ñöùc Phaät. Chaùnh nieäm laø coäi nguoàn cuûa taát caû   others. Right mindfulness also means moïi tu taäp Phaät giaùo—There's a short                 remembrance including old mistakes to repent conversation about "Mindfulness" between                 of and deep gratitude towards parents, the Buddha and a philosopher of his time. The            country, humankind, and Buddhist Triple philosopher said, "I have heard that Buddhism            Gems. Right mindfulness also means the is a doctrine of enlightenment. What is your             reflection on the present and future events or method? What do you practice everyday?"                  situations. We must meditate upon human The Buddha said, "We walk, we eat, we wash               sufferings that are caused by ignorance and ourselves, we sit down." The philosopher said,           decide to work for alleviating them, "What is so special about that? Everyone                 irrespective of possible difficulties and walks, eats, washes, sits down..." The Buddha            boredom. Correct Memory which retains the said, "Sir, when we walk, we are aware that              true      and excludes the false—Dwell in we are walking; when we eat, we are aware                contemplation of corporeality. Be mindful that we are eating... When others walk, eat,             and putting away worldly greed and grief. wash, or sit down, they are generally not                Correct mindfulness also means ongoing aware of what they are doing." In Buddhism,              mindfulness of body, feelings, thinking, and mindfulness is the key. Mindfulness is the               objects of thought. energy that sheds light on all things and all (III) Chaùnh Nieäm Vaø Moâi Tröôøng—Mindfulness actitivites,      producing        the    power      of  and Environment: Theo Thieàn sö Thích Nhaát concentration, bringing forth deep insight and           Haïnh, khi neùm moät caùi voû chuoái vaøo thuøng awakening. In short, in Buddhism, correct                raùc, vaø neáu coù chaùnh nieäm, chuùng ta bieá t raèng state of mind in which one is properly directed          caùi voû chuoái seõ bieán thaønh phaân uû vaø vaøi to and united with the state of mind of the              thaùng sau, seõ taùi sinh döôùi daïng moät traùi caø Buddha. Mindfulness is at the base of all                chua hay moät laù caûi rau dieáp. Nhöng khi Buddhist practice.                                       chuùng ta neùm moät tuùi nhöïa vaøo thuøng raùc, yù (II) Nghóa cuûa "Chaùnh Nieäm"—The meanings of                thöù cho chuùng ta bieát raèng seõ khoâng nhanh Mindfulness: Chaùnh nieäm laø nhôù ñeán nhöõng           choùng bieán thaønh quaû caø chua hay rau xaù laùch. ñieàu hay leõ phaûi, nhöõng ñieàu lôïi laïc cho mình     Vaøi loaïi raùc caàn ñeán boán hoaëc naêm traêm naêm vaø cho ngöôøi. Chaùnh nieäm coøn coù nghóa laø öùc      sau môùi phaân huûy. Chaát thaûi haïch nhaân caàn nieäm hay nghó nhôù tôùi caûnh quaù khöù, nhôù ñeán      ñeán hai traêm naêm chuïc ngaøn naêm môùi maát ñi loãi laàm cuõ ñeå söûa ñoåi, nhôù aân cha meï thaày baïn tính laøm haïi vaø quay veà vôùi ñaát. Soáng tænh ñeå baùo ñaùp, nhôù aân toå quoác ñeå phuïng söï baûo    giaùc giaây phuùt hieän taïi, toaøn taâm toaøn yù vôùi veä; nhôù aân chuùng sanh ñeå giuùp ñôû traû ñeàn; nhôù  hieän taïi giuùp chuùng ta khoâng laøm nhöõng vieäc aân Phaät Phaùp Taêng ñeå tinh taán tu haønh. Chaùnh     phaù hoaïi töông lai. Ñoù laø caùch cuï theå nhaát ñeå nieäm coøn coù nghóa laø quaùn nieäm hay quaùn saùt      laøm ñieàu gì ñoù coù tính xaây döïng cho töông caûnh hieän taïi vaø töôûng töôïng caûnh töông lai.      lai—According to Zen Master Thich Nhat Chuùng ta neân quaùn töôûng ñeán caûnh ñôøi ñau          Hanh, when we throw a banana peel into the khoå, beänh taät, meâ môø cuûa chuùng sanh maø           garbage, if we are mindful, we know that the khuyeán tu; töôûng nieäm laøm nhöõng ñieàu lôïi ích      peel will become compost and be reborn as a chung, khoâng thoái lui, khoâng e ngaïi khoù khaên       tomato or a lettuce salad in just afew months. nhoïc nhaèn. Chaùnh nieäm coøn coù nghóa laø chuù        But when we throw a plastic bag into the taâm ñuùng laø töôûng ñeán söï thaät vaø choái boû taø   garbage, thanks to our awareness, we know vaïy. Luùc naøo cuõng tænh taùo deïp boû tham lam        that a plastic bag will not become a tomato or vaø buoàn khoå cuûa theá tuïc. Chaùnh nieäm coøn coù     a salad very quickly. Some kinds of garbage nghóa laø luùc naøo cuõng tænh giaùc veà thaân theå,     need four or five hundred years to caûm xuùc, tö töôûng cuõng nhö nhöõng ñoái taùc beân     decompose. Nuclear waste needs a quarter of

a million years before it stops being harmful          vaø chaùnh maïng. Chaùnh nieäm laø moät yeáu toá toái and returns to the soil. Living in the present         caàn thieát cho nhöõng haønh ñoäng cuûa chuùng ta moment in an awakened way, looking after               trong ñôøi soáng haèng ngaøy cuõng nhö cho taâm the present moment with all our heart, we will         linh—According to Theravada Buddhism, not do things which destroy the future. That is        mindfulness is considered as the strongest the most concrete way to do what is                    strand for it plays an important role in the constructive for the future.                           acquisition of both calm and insight. (IV) Chaùnh nieäm theo Phaät giaùo Nguyeân Thuûy—           Mindfulness is a certain function of the mind, Right mindfulness according to the Theravada           and therefore , a mental factor. Without this Buddhism: Theo Phaät giaùo Nguyeân Thuûy,              all important factor of mindfulness one cannot nieäm ñöôïc xem nhö laø moät sôïi daây maïnh meõ       cognize sense-objects, one cannot be fully vì noù giöõ moät vai troø quan troïng trong caû hai    aware of one’s behavior. It is call right loaïi thieàn ñònh laø tònh truù vaø bieät quaùn. Nieäm mindfulness because it avoids misdirected laø moät cô naêng naøo ñoù cuûa taâm vaø vì vaäy, noù  attention, and prevents the mind from paying laø moät yeáu toá cuûa taâm hay moät taâm sôû. Khoâng  attention to things unwholesome, and guides coù nieäm, moät taâm sôû toái quan troïng, chuùng ta   its possessor on the right path to purity and khoâng coù khaû naêng nhaän ra baát cöù thöù gì,       freedom. Right mindfulness sharpens the khoâng theå hay bieát ñaày ñuû caùc taùc phong cuûa    power of observation, and assists right chính mình. Ñöôïc goïi laø chaùnh nieäm, vì noù        thinking and right understanding. Orderly vöøa traùnh chuù taâm sai laïc, maø cuõng vöøa traùnh  thinking and reflection is conditioned by cho taâm ñeå yù vaøo nhöõng ñieàu baát thieän, vaø     man’s right mindfulness. In the Satipatthana ñaøng khaùc noù höôùng daãn taâm cuûa haønh giaû       and Anapanasati sutras, the Buddha states treân con ñöôøng chaân chaùnh, trong saïch vaø giaûi   clearly how a meditator becomes aware of his thoaùt moïi phieàn tröôïc. Chaùnh nieäm laøm beùn      thoughts, mindfully watching and observing nhaïy khaû naêng quan saùt cuûa haønh giaû, vaø hoã    each and every one of them, be they good or trôï chaùnh tö duy vaø chaùnh kieán. Hieåu bieát vaø   evil, salutary or otherwise. The sutras warn us suy tö ñöôïc coù traät töï cuõng nhôø chaùnh nieäm.    against negligence and day-dreaming and Trong hai kinh Nieäm Xöù vaø Nhaäp Töùc Xuaát          urges us to be mentally alert and watchful. As Töùc Nieäm, Ñöùc Phaät daïy roõ raøng laøm caùch       a matter of fact, the earnest student will note naøo moät haønh giaû coù theå hay bieát luoàng tö      that the very reading of the discourse, at töôûng cuûa mình, tænh giaùc theo doõi, ghi nhaän      times, makes him watchful, earnest and vaø quan saùt töøng yù nghó cuûa chính mình, töø toát  serious-minded. It goes without saying that cuõng nhö xaáu. Caû hai baøi kinh ñeàu caûnh giaùc     right mindfulness is a quality that no sensible chuùng ta khoâng neân xao laõng vaø mô moäng,          man would treat with contempt. Thus, it is cuõng nhö thuùc hoái chuùng ta neân luoân canh         truly essential to cultivate mindfulness in this chöøng vaø luoân giöõ taâm chaùnh nieäm. Kyø thaät,    confused age when so many people suffer moät haønh giaû chuyeân caàn tu nieäm seõ ghi nhaän    from mental imbalance. Right mindfulness is raèng chính nhôø söï kieän ñoïc laïi kinh ñieån seõ    an instrumental not only in bringing laøm cho chuùng ta tænh giaùc hôn, quyeát taâm         concentration calm, but in promoting right hôn, vaø thaän troïng chuù nieäm nhieàu hôn. Khoûi     understanding and right living. It is an noùi ai trong chuùng ta cuõng bieát raèng chaùnh       essential factor in all our actions both worldly nieäm laø moät ñöùc ñoä maø khoâng ai coù theå xem     and spiritual. thöôøng ñöôïc. Nhö vaäy vieäc tu taäp chaùnh nieäm (V) Chaùnh nieäm vaø Thieàn ñònh—Right thaät laø thieát yeáu trong thôøi buoåi hoãn taïp maø  Mindfulness and Meditation: chuùng ta ñang soáng ñaây trong khi raát nhieàu 1) Chaùnh Nieäm laø moät trong ba phaàn hoïc cuûa ngöôøi phaûi gaùnh chòu khoå ñau vì taâm trí maát      Thieàn Ñònh (hai phaàn hoïc khaùc laø Chaùnh Tinh thaêng baèng. Chaùnh nieäm laø moät phöông tieän       Taán vaø Chaùnh Ñònh). Chaùnh Nieäm laø yù thöùc, mang laïi tònh truï, laøm thaêng tieán chaùnh kieán    hay söï chuù yù, nhö vaäy chaùnh nieäm laø traùnh söï

xao laõng hay tình traïng taâm trí vaån ñuïc. Trong     (cittanupassana),         and     mental       objects vieäc tu taäp Phaät phaùp, chaùnh nieäm giöõ vai troø   (dhammanapassana). moät sôïi daây cöông kieåm soaùt taâm cuûa chuùng ta 3) Vôùi haønh giaû tu thieàn, chaùnh nieäm laø nhôù vì taâm chuùng ta khoâng bao giôø taäp trung hay        ñuùng nghó ñuùng laø giai ñoaïn thöù baûy trong Baùt ñöùng yeân moät choã. Ñöùc Phaät daïy: “Tu taäp         Thaùnh ñaïo. Nhìn vaøo hay quaùn vaøo thaân taâm chaùnh nieäm laø tu taäp chuù taâm vaøo thaân, chuù     ñeå luoân tænh thöùc. Chaùnh nieäm coù nghóa laø lìa taâm vaøo caûm nghó, chuù taâm vaøo thöùc, vaø chuù     moïi phaân bieät maø nieäm thöïc tính cuûa chö taâm vaøo ñoái töôïng cuûa taâm.” Noùi toùm laïi,       phaùp. Theo Baùt Chaùnh Ñaïo, chaùnh nieäm laø chaùnh nieäm laø kieåm soaùt thaân vaø taâm vaø bieát   “Nhaát Taâm.” Nôi thaân tænh thöùc baèng caùch chuùng ta ñang laøm gì vaøo moïi luùc. Chaùnh           thöïc taäp taäp trung vaøo hôi thôû. Nôi caûm thoï Nieäm laø moät yeáu toá taâm thöùc quan troïng coù      tænh thöùc baèng caùch quaùn saùt söï ñeán ñi trong ta chöùc naêng laøm cho chuùng ta nhôù tôùi nhöõng gì      cuûa taát caû moïi hình thöùc cuûa caûm thoï, vui, coù lôïi laïc. Chaùnh nieäm giöõ moät vai troø quan     buoàn, trung tính. Nôi nhöõng hoaït ñoäng cuûa troïng trong thieàn ñònh, thí duï Chaùnh Nieäm coù      taâm tænh thöùc baèng caùch xem coi taâm ta coù theå giuùp chuùng ta laøm tan ñi nhöõng tö töôûng       chöùa chaáp duïc voïng, saân haän, löøa doái, xao roän ròp xoân xao trong taâm thöùc, vaø cuoái cuøng     laõng, hay taäp trung. Nôi vaïn phaùp tænh thöùc giuùp chuùng ta coù ñuû naêng löïc ñaït ñöôïc söï nhaát baèng caùch quaùn saùt baûn chaát voâ thöôøng cuû a taâm treân hôi thôû—Right Mindfulness is one of         chuùng töø sanh truï dò dieät ñeå taän dieät chaáp the three trainings in meditation (two others           tröôùc vaø luyeán aùi. Chaùnh nieäm laø yeáu toá giaùc are Right Effort and Right Concentration).              ngoä thöù nhaát. “Sati” laø thuaät ngöõ töông ñöông Mindfulness is awareness or attention, and as           gaàn nhaát trong ngoân ngöõ Nam Phaïn duøng ñeå such it means avoiding a distracted or cloudly          chæ vaø dòch ra cho töø “Chaùnh nieäm.” Tuy state of mind. In the practice of the Dharma,           nhieân, chaùnh nieäm phaûi ñöôïc hieåu vôùi nghóa right mindfulness plays as a kind of rein upon          tích cöïc hôn. Chaùnh nieäm phaûi ñöôïc hieåu laø our minds for our minds are never                       taâm tieán ñeán vaø bao phuû hoaøn toaøn ñoái töôïng, concentrated or still. The Buddha taught: “The          xuyeân thaáu vaøo trong ñoái töôïng khoâng thieáu practice of mindfulness means mindfulness of            phaàn naøo. Chaùnh nieäm coù theå ñöôïc hieåu roõ the      body,      mindfulness      of     feelings,   baèng caùch khaûo saùt ba khía caïnh laø ñaëc taùnh, mindfulness         of     consciousness,          and  chöùc naêng vaø söï theå hieän. Trong Phaät giaùo mindfulness of objects of the mind.” In short,          chaùnh nieäm laø luoân tænh thöùc veà taát caû moïi right mindfulness means to watch our body               sinh hoaït, töø vaät chaát ñeán tinh thaàn. Haønh giaû and mind and to know what we are doing at               giöõ taâm chaùnh nieäm laø vò aáy hieåu bieát roõ raøng all times. Right Mindfulness is an important            veà nhöõng hoaït ñoäng cuûa cô theå mình vaø luoân mental factor that enables us to remember               tænh thöùc veà nhöõng uy nghi: khi ñi, ñöùng, ngoài and keep our attention on what is beneficial.           hay naèm. Taát caû nhöõng hoaït ñoäng cuûa cô theå Right Mindfulness plays an important role in            haønh giaû ñeàu laøm vôùi caùi taâm tænh thöùc. Khi ñi meditation, i.e., Right mindfulness can help us         tôùi ñi lui, khi nhìn tôùi hoaëc nhìn moät beân, haønh clear the flurry of thoughts from our minds,            giaû chuù taâm hay bieát roõ raøng; khi co tay co and eventually, we’ll be able to concentrate            chaân hay khi duoãi tay duoãi chaân haønh giaû luoân single-pointedly on our breath.                         laøm trong chaùnh nieäm; khi maëc quaàn aùo, khi 2) Chaùnh nieäm laø phaùt khôûi nieäm hay gaùn söï chuù    aên, uoáng, nhai, vaân vaân, haønh giaû phaûi luoân taâm vaøo thaân haønh nieäm (caùc hoaït ñoäng cuûa      chuù taâm hay bieát roõ raøng; khi ñi, ñöùng, ngoài, thaân), thoï nieäm, taâm haønh nieäm (caùc hoaït        naèm, haønh giaû phaûi luoân giöõ chaùnh nieäm; khi ñoäng cuûa taâm), vaø nieäm phaùp (caùc hoaït ñoäng     noùi cuõng nhö khi khoâng noùi haønh giaû phaûi luoân cuûa phaùp)—Right mindfulness is the                    hay bieát roõ raøng—For Zen practitioners, right application or arousing of attention in                 remembrance or the seventh of the eightfold activities of the body            (kayanupassana),      noble path means remembering correctly and feelings or sensations, activities of the mind          thinking       correctly.     The      looking       or

contemplating on the body and the spirit in        4) Theo Thieàn sö Thích Nhaát Haïnh trong quyeån such a way as to remain ardent, self-                   'Chìa Khoùa Tu Thieàn': "Chaùnh nieäm giuùp possessed and mindful. Right remembrance                chuùng ta taäp trung chuù yù vaø bieát ñöôïc chuùng ta means looking on the body and spirit in such a          ñang laøm gì. Thoâng thöôøng chuùng ta laø tuø way as to remain ardent, self-possessed and             nhaân cuûa xaõ hoäi. Naêng löïc cuûa chuùng ta bò mindful, having overcome both hankering and             phaân taùn choã naøy choã kia. Thaân vaø taâm chuùng dejection. According to the eightfold noble             ta khoâng haøi hoøa. Ñeå baét ñaàu yù thöùc ñöôïc ñieàu path, right mindfulness means the one-                  chuùng ta ñang laøm, ñang noùi vaø ñang suy nghó pointedness of the mind. Be attentive to the            laø baét ñaàu cöôõng laïi söï xaâm laán cuûa ngoaïi activities of the body with the practice of             caûnh vaø nhöõng nhaän thöùc sai laàm cuûa chuùng concentration on breathing. Be aware of all             ta. Khi ngoïn ñeøn yù thöùc ñöôïc ñoát leân, toaøn theå forms of feelings and sensations, pleasant,             con ngöôøi chuùng ta saùng böøng leân. Chuùng ta unpleasant, and neutral, by contemplating               tìm laïi ñöôïc loøng töï tin, boùng toái cuûa aûo töôûng their appearance and disappearance within               khoâng coøn nhaán chìm chuùng ta, vaø chuùng ta coù oneself. Be aware whether one’s mind is                 theå taäp trung ñeán möùc cao nhaát. Chuùng ta röûa lustful, hatred, deluded, distracted or                 tay, maëc y phuïc, laøm nhöõng coâng vieäc haèng concentrated. Contemplate the impermanence              ngaøy gioáng nhö tröôùc ñaây, nhöng baây giôø, of all things from arise, stay, change and              chuùng ta yù thöùc ñöôïc veà haønh ñoäng, lôøi noùi vaø decay to eliminate attachment. Mindfulness is           tö töôûng cuûa mình."—According to Zen the first factor of enlightenment. The nearest          Master Thich Nhat Hanh in The Zen Keys: equivalent term in Pali for “mindfulness” is            "Mindfulness helps us focus our attention on “Sati.” Mindfulness has come to be the                  and know what we are doing. Usually we are accepted translation of “sati” into English.            a prisoner of society. Our energies are However, this word has a kind of passive                dispersed here and there. Our body and our connotation which can be misleading.                    mind are not in harmony. To begin to be “Mindfulness” must be dynamic and                       aware of what we are doing, saying, and confrontative. Mindfulness should leap onto             thinking is to begin to resist the invasion by the object, covering           it completely,           our surroundings and by all of our wrong penetrating into it, not missing any part of it.        perceptions. When the lamp of awareness is Mindfulness can be well understood by                   lit, our whole being is lit up. Self-confidence examining its three aspects of characteristics,         is re-established, the shadows of illusion no function and manifestation. In Buddhism,                longer overwhelm us, and our concentration mindfulness means being aware of all                    develops to its fullest. We wash our hands, activities, both physical and mental. A                 dress, perform everyday actions as before, but meditator who is mindful of his bodily                  now we are aware of our actions, words, and activities becomes aware of his postures:               thoughts." when walking, standing, sitting or lying down.     Chaùnh Nieäm Löïc: Löïc chaùnh nieäm vaø chaùnh All his bodily activities he does with             quaùn—Power of right mindfulness and right mindfulness. In walking to and from, in            contemplation. looking ahead and in looking aside, he applies     Chaùnh Nieäm Phaùp Tuùc: Phaùp ñaïo ñi vaøo chaùnh mindfulness; in bending and stretching he          nieäm, moät trong boán phaùp tuùc theo Kinh Phuùng applies mindfulness; in wearing clothes, in        Tuïng trong Tröôøng Boä Kinh—Way of Dhamma eating, drinking, chewing, etc. he applies         with right mindfulness, one of the four ways of mindfulness; in walking, standing, sitting,        Dhamma according to the Sangiti Sutta in the lying down, he applies mindfulness; in             Long Discourses of the Buddha. keeping awake, speaking, and being silent, he      Chaùnh Nieäm Vaø Tænh Giaùc: Sati ca applies mindfulness.                               sampajananan ca (p)—Mindfulness and clear awareness (clarity of awareness).

Chaùnh Nieäm Vaø Tænh Thöùc: Mindfulness and                  caùc nghi leã khaùc. Trong moãi Thieàn ñöôøng ñeàu coù awareness—See Chaùnh Nieäm, and Tænh Thöùc.                   hai cöûa: cöûa tröôùc vaø cöûa sau. Trong haàu heát caùc Chaùnh Nieäm Tyø Kheo: Mindful monk—Monk                      thieàn ñöôøng ôû Nhaät Baûn, thöôøng thöôøng beân treân who is mindful—Vò Tyø Kheo chaùnh nieäm, ñaày ñuû             cöûa tröôùc coù haøng chöõ "Chaùnh Phaùp Nhaõn Ñöôøng." toái thöôïng nieäm vaø tænh giaùc, nhôù ñeán vaø ghi nhôù     Theo Thieàn sö D.T. Suzuki trong quyeån "Söï Huaán nhöõng ñieàu noùi vaø laøm töø laâu—Here a monk who           Luyeän cuûa moät Thieàn Taêng Phaät Giaùo," bôûi vì is mindful, with a great capacity for clear recalling         thieàn ñöôøng coù chuû yù laø khai môû Phaùp nhaõn cuûa things done and said long ago.                                nhöõng ngöôøi ôû trong ñoù, ñeå baèng vaøo Phaùp nhaõn Chaùnh Phaùp: Saddharma (skt)—Saddhamma                       hoï coù theå nhìn thaáy nhöõng bí maät cuûa ñôøi soáng vaø (p)—Chaùnh Phaùp Thoï—Buddha dharma—Buddha                    theá gian. Laïi coù treo moät taám baûng vuoâng baèng goã dharma—Correct Doctrine of the Buddha—The                     ñöôïc söû duïng trong nhieàu muïc ñích khaùc nhau: ñeå Law         correctness—Right            teaching—Right       goïi Taêng chuùng ñi aên, nghe giaûng, laøm vieäc, vaân dharma—Right method—The period of correct                     vaân, hay ñeå hoï bieát giôø thieàn ñònh ñaõ baét ñaàu hay Dharma—Chaùnh Phaùp coøn laø phöông phaùp ñuùng,              chaám döùt. Treân taám baûng coù ghi haøng chöõ: thöôøng ñöôïc duøng ñeå chæ Baùt Chaùnh Ñaïo—Correct                   "Sanh töû laø chuyeän ñaïi söï; (right or true) doctrine of the Buddha also means                       Cuoäc soáng voâ thöôøng laøm sao! the right method, is often used as a name for the                       Phaûi tieác töøng giaây phuùt, Noble Eightfold Path.                                                   Thôøi giôø khoâng ñôïi ai." Chaùnh Phaùp Cöï: AÙnh ñuoác chaân lyù hay Phaät              Phía sau thieàn ñöôøng coù thôø Boà Taùt Vaên Thuø Sö Giaùo—The torch of the truth or Buddhism.                     Lôïi, vò Boà Taùt töôïng tröng cho trí hueä Baùt Nhaõ. Chaùnh Phaùp Hoa Kinh: Cheng-Fa-Hua-Ching—                    Môû Phaùp nhaõn coù nghóa laø ñaït ñöôïc loaïi trí hueä 10 quyeån dòch cuûa boä kinh Phaùp Hoa ñöôïc dòch bôûi        naøy, vaø Boà Taùt Vaên Thuø xöùng ñaùng ñöôïc thôø trong ngaøi Truùc Phaùp Hoä ñôøi Taán vaøo khoaûng naêm 286         thieàn ñöôøng. Trong khi ñoù, cöûa sau cuûa thieàn sau Taây Lòch, hieän nay vaãn coøn (ñaïi ñeå cuõng gioáng     ñöôøng ñöôïc Taêng chuùng duøng cho nhöõng muïc ñích nhö baûn dòch cuûa ngaøi Cöu Ma La Thaäp sau                  rieâng nhö taåy röûa, laøm vieäc vaët vaõnh, vaân vaân. naày)—The earliest translation of the Lotus Sutra             Giaøy deùp ñöôïc xeáp ñaët raát thöù töï. Tuy chuùng ñeàu in 10 books by Dharmaraksa in around 286 A.D.,                laø nhöõng chuyeän giaû n dò nhaát, nhöng ñöôïc gìn giöõ still in existence.                                           raát kyõ caøng; vaø khi moät Thieàn Taêng côûi giaøy ra ñeå Chaùnh Phaùp Höng Thònh: The True Dharma is                   ñi vaøo thieàn ñöôøng, hoï caån thaän khoâng ñeå loän still flourished.                                             loän—In large temples, meditation hall is a Chaùnh Phaùp Kieàu: Thuaät ngöõ chæ Phaät phaùp nhö           separate structure, where only meditation is moät caùi caàu cho pheùp moïi ngöôøi vöôït qua doøng          practiced without any other ceremonies. In each soâng sanh töû—A term for Buddhism, which is                  Zen hall (Zendo or meditation hall) has two main compared to a bridge that permits human beings to             entrances: the front and the back. In most cross the river of life and death.                            Japanese Zendos, usually there is a tablet at the Chaùnh Phaùp Luaân: Phaät phaùp—Buddha-dharma.                top of the front entrance that reads "The Hall of Chaùnh Phaùp Minh Nhö Lai: Vò Nhö Lai hieåu                   the Eye of the Right Dharma." According to Zen töôøng taän chaùnh phaùp. Danh hieäu Phaät maø Ñöùc           master Daisetz Teitaro Suzuki in "The Training of Quaùn Theá AÂm ñaõ ñaéc thaønh trong quaù khöù —The           the Zen Buddhist Monk," because the hall is Tathagata who clearly understands the true law,               intended for opening the Dharma-eye of the i.e. Kuan-Yin, who attained Buddhahood in the                 occupants who with it can see into the secrets of past.                                                         life and the world. There is also a square board of Chaùnh Phaùp Nhaõn: The Right Dharma Eye—                     wood which is used for various purposes: to call Right or true experience of reality.                          the monks to meals, lectures, services, etc., or to tell them that the meditation hour has begun or Chaùnh Phaùp Nhaõn Ñöôøng: The Hall of the Eye ended. On the board there are several lines which of the Right Dharma (Shobogen Do)—Taïi caùc read: chuøa lôùn, thöôøng Thieàn Ñöôøng laø moät kieán truùc "Birth and death is a great event; bieät laäp chæ ñeå thöïc haønh toïa thieàn, chöù khoâng coù

How transient is life!                                thì coù meâ hoaëc vaø giaùc ngoä, coù trau doài tu taäp, Every minute is to be grudged,                        coù sanh, coù töû, coù chö Phaät, coù chuùng sanh Time waits for nobody."                               muoân loaøi. Khi muoân söï khoâng laø caùi ngaõ, The shrine behind the half-opened door contains                 khoâng coù meâ hoaëc vaø giaùc ngoä, khoâng coù trau generally the image of Manjusri Bodhisattva, who                doài tu taäp, khoâng coù sanh, khoâng coù töû, khoâng represents wisdom. The opening of the Dharma-                   coù chö Phaät, vaø khoâng coù chuùng sanh muoân eye means acquiring this wisdom, and the                        loaøi. Bôûi vì Phaät Ñaïo töø nguyeân thuûy khôûi Bodhisattva is the fit object of worship in the                 sanh töø söï phong phuù vaø söï thieáu thoán, nhö theá Meditation Hall. The rear door is used by monks                 môùi coù meâ hoaëc vaø giaùc ngoä, coù trau doài tu for their private purposes such as washing, going               taäp, coù sanh, coù töû, coù chö Phaät, coù chuùng sanh on errands, etc. Observe those foot-gears in                    muoân loaøi. Hôn nöõa, daàu laø nhö theá, hoa vaãn perfect order. They are the simplest kind, but very             rôi ruïng khi chuùng ta luyeán chaáp vaøo chuùng, well taken care of; and when the monks leave                    vaø caùc loaøi coû daïi vaãn sanh soâi naåy nôû cho them at the door to enter into the Hall, they see to            daàu chuùng ta coù gheùt boû chuùng. Ngöôøi ñaõ ñaït it that they are not scattered about in confusion—              ñeán giaùc ngoä coù theå saùnh ñöôïc vôùi aùnh traêng See Thieàn Ñöôøng.                                              chieáu xuoáng nöôùc. Vaàng traêng khoâng öôùt, maët Chaùnh Phaùp Nhaõn Taïng:                                       nöôùc khoâng vôõ. Söùc saùng cuûa traêng maõnh lieät, 1) Correct Law Eye-Treasury—Treasury of the                     nhöng traêng vaãn naèm yeân trong vuõng nöôùc eye of the true dharma—Ñaây laø moät trong                 nhoû, troïn veïn moät vaàng traêng, troïn veïn baàu taùm nguyeân taéc caên baûn, cuûa tröïc giaùc hay          trôøi naèm yeân trong moät gioït söông treân ngoïn lieân heä tröïc tieáp vôùi taâm linh cuûa tröôøng phaùi    coû, naèm yeân trong moät gioït nöôùc li ti. Söï Thieàn Toâng—Correct Law Eye-Treasury.                     chöùng ñaïo maø khoâng gaây toån thöông cuõng This is one of the eight fundamental                       gioáng nhö aùnh traêng khoâng xuyeân thuûng nöôùc. principles, intuitional or relating to direct              Ngöôøi khoâng ngaên trôû giaùc ngoä cuõn g gioáng mental vision of the Zen School—See Baùt                   nhö gioït söông khoâng ngaên trôû aùnh traêng giöõa Caâu Nghóa.                                                baàu trôøi."—The right Dharma eye treasury or 2) Shobo-genzo (jap)—The right Dharma eye                       'Treasure Chamber of the Eye of True treasury—Something that contains and                       Dharma'. Something that contains and preserves the right experience of reality—                 preserves the right experience of reality, the Dieäu Phaùp Trí Taïng—Kho Taøng Kieán Thöùc                principal work of the great Japanese Zen Dieäu Phaùp—Treasury of Knowledge of the                   master Dogen Zenji; it is considered the most True Dharma—Chaùnh Phaùp Nhaõn Taïng hay                   profound work in all of Zen literature and the 'Con maét cuûa kho baùu Chaùnh Phaùp'. Boä söu             most outstanding work of religious literature taäp nhöõng chaâm ngoân vaø nhöõng lôøi thuyeát            of Japan. A collection of sayings and giaûng cuûa ñaïi thieàn sö Ñaïo Nguyeân, ñöôïc ñeä         instructions of the great Japanese Zen master töû cuûa oâng laø thieàn sö Hoaøi Trang ghi laïi.          Dogen Zenji as recorded by his student Ejo Chaùnh Phaùp Nhaõn Taïng laø moät taùc phaåm               (1198-1280). "Shobo-genzo" is a major work chính cuûa thieàn sö Ñaïo Nguyeân, ñöôïc coi nhö           of Dogen Master (1200-1253), a voluminous laø moät trong nhöõng vaên baûn saâu saéc nhaát cuûa       treatise that discusses all aspects of Buddhist toaøn boä vaên hoïc thieàn vaø taùc phaåm xuaát saéc       life and practice, from meditation to details nhaát cuûa toân giaùo noùi chung. Moät taùc phaåm          concerning personal hygiene. In Shobogenzo, cuûa Thieàn sö Ñaïo Nguyeân (1200-1253), ñaây              Zen Master Dogen taught: "When all things laø moät boä luaän nhieàu taäp baøn luaän veà moïi khía    are Buddha-teachings, then there is delusion caïnh trong ñôøi soáng Phaät giaùo vaø söï tu taäp, töø    and enlightenment, there is cultivation of thieàn taäp ñeán chi tieát veà veä sinh caù nhaân.         practice, there is birth, there is death, there Trong quyeån Chaùnh Phaùp Nhaõn Taïng, Thieàn              are Buddhas, there are sentient beings. When sö Ñaïo Nguyeân Hy Huyeàn (1200-1253) daïy:                myriad things are all not self, there is no "Khi taát caû moïi söï vieäc ñeàu laø Phaät phaùp, roài    delusion, no enlightenment, no Buddhas, no

sentient beings, no birth, no death. Because               Chaùnh Só: 1) Baäc thöùc giaû chôn chaùnh: Correct the Buddha Way originally sprang forth from                scholar; 2) Boà Taùt: Bodhisattva. abundance and paucity, there is birth and                  Chaùnh Taïp Nhò Haïnh: Two kinds of practices: death, delusion and enlightenment, sentient                Right and sundry practices—Chaùnh haïnh laø haønh beings and Buddhas. Moreover, though this is               ñoäng ñuùng. Chaùnh haïnh nôi thaân laø moät trong so, flowers fall when we cling to them, and                nhöõng cöûa ngoõ quan troïng ñi vaøo ñaïi giaùc, vì nhôø weeds only grow when we dislike them.                      ñoù maø tam nghieäp haèng thanh tònh. Taïp haïnh coù People's attaining enlightenment is like the               nghóa laø ngöôøi thaáy ai tu phaùp moân gì cuõng baét moonreflected in water. The moon does not                  chöôùc theo caû, thay ñoåi lieàn lieàn. Nay tu Tònh Ñoä, get wet, the water isn't broken. Though it is a            mai tu Thieàn, moát tuïng kinh. Nay tuïng kinh naày, vast expansive light, it rests in a little bit of          mai tuïng kinh khaùc, vaân vaân—Right conduct of water, even the whole moon, the whole sky,                 the actions of the body is one of the most rests in a dewdrop on the grass, rests in even a           important entrances to the great enlightenment; single droplet of water. That enlightenment                for with it, the three kinds of behavior are pure. does not shatter people is like the moon not               Combining practices also referred to as “Mixed piercing the water. People's not obstructing               Cultivation.” This refers to cultivators who mimic enlightenment is like the drop of dew not                  others’ practices depending on who is practicing obstructing the moon in the sky."                          what at the time. Thus, they are constantly mixing Chaùnh Phaùp Nhöït Oai Löïc: Energy of the Sun of               and changing their practices by practicing Truth.                                                          Pureland one day, Zen the next, and then another Chaùnh Phaùp Nieäm Xöù: Base of mindfulness or                  day chanting one Sutra, only to switch to a foundation of mindfulness on the correct dharma.                different Sutra the next day, etc. Chaùnh Phaùp Nieäm Xöù Kinh: Saddharma-                         Chaùnh Taâm: Taâm caên baûn vaø chaân chaùnh—True smrtyupasthana-sutra (skt)—Sutra on the base of                 and Fundamental Mind—Duø bò bao nhieâu oâ nhieãm mindfulness on correct dharmas.                                 che laáp, chaùnh taâm vaãn coøn ñoù, nhö maët traêng vaãn Chaùnh Phaùp Taïng: Phaùp Giôùi Taïng—The source                coøn ñoù duø bò maây che laáp—The essence of one’s or treasury of all right laws and virtues—Treasury              nature. No matter how much defilement covered, of all right laws.                                              this mind is still there just like the moon is often Chaùnh Phaùp Thoï: See Chaùnh Phaùp.                            hidden behind clouds. Chaùnh Phaùp Thôøi: Right Dharma—Period of                      Chaùnh Taâm Haønh Xöù: Ñieàu kieän trong ñoù söï vaän orthodoxy and vigour—See Chaùnh Töôïng Maït.                    haønh cuûa taâm vöõng chaéc vaø hoøa hôïp vôùi ñoái Chaùnh Phaùp Y: 1) Phaät laø choã töïa cuûa Chaùnh              töôïng—The condition when the motions of the Phaùp: He, the Buddha, on whom the truth                        mind are steadied and harmonized with the object. depends; 2) Danh hieäu cuûa Phaät: A term for a                 Chaùnh Taâm Thieàn Sö (1836-1906): Teân cuûa moät Buddha.                                                         vò Thieàn sö Vieät Nam vaøo theá kyû thöù XIX, ñôøi thöù Chaùnh Phuï: Primary and secondary.                             40 toâng Laâm Teá, queâ ôû Long An, Nam Vieät — Chaùnh Quaû: 1) Chaùnh baùo (chuùng sanh do nôi                 Name of a Vietnamese Zen master in the nghieäp löïc ñôøi tröôùc ñaõ taïo maø chieâu caûm quaû baùo     nineteenth century, of the fortieth Lin-chi lineage. thaân ñoù. Thaân laø moät söï ñeàn traû, laø quaû baùo chaùnh   He came from Long An, South Vietnam. cuûa chuùng sanh, neân goïi thaân laø chaùnh baùo): Direct      Chaùnh Taâm Truï: Choã truù cuûa söï chaùnh taâm. reward, body or person; 2) Heä quaû tröïc tieáp, toát           Dung maïo vaø taâm töôùng nhö Phaät, goïi laø chính hay xaáu laø do bôûi keát quaû cuûa tieàn nghieäp: One’s        taâm truï—Abode of correct mind. With a physical direct reward, good or bad, depends on or results               appearance like that of a Buddha and a mind that from former karma.                                              is the same as well, they are said to be dwelling in Chaùnh Quan: Söï quan saùt ñuùng ñaén—Correct                   the rectification of the mind. The whole mind observation.                                                    becoming Buddha-like or dwelling of the Chaùnh Quaùn: Söï thieàn ñònh ñuùng ñaén—Correct                rectification of the mind. meditation.                                                     Chaùnh Taän Giaùc: See Chaùnh Bieán Tri.

Chaùnh Thaønh (1873-1949): Teân cuûa moät vò danh                 Hoïc Nhaäp Moân", thaät ra, Thieàn khoâng hoaøn Taêng Vieät Nam vaøo theá kyû thöù XX, ñôøi thöù 36               toaøn phuû ñònh, cuõng khoâng baét buoäc trong loøng toâng Laâm Teá—Name of a Vietnamese Zen master                    khoâng coù ñieàu gì caû, phaûng phaát laø hö voâ in the twentieth century, of the thirty-sixth Lin-chi             thuaàn tuùy vì ñieàu ñoù seõ töï gieát maát trí hueä. lineage.                                                          Trong Thieàn coù moät loaïi khaúng ñònh töï ngaõ Chaùnh Thoï: Caûm thoï ñuùng veà ñoái töôïng trong khi            naøo ñoù, nhöng ñoù laø söï töï do tuyeät ñoái, khoâng thieàn quaùn—Correct sensation of the object                      coù baát cöù moät giôùi haïn naøo, cuõng khoâng theå contemplated—See Ñaúng Chí.                                       thaûo luaän veà noù thoâng qua phöông phaùp tröøu Chaùnh Thoï Laõo Nhaân Thieàn Sö: Zen master                      töôïng. Thieàn laø thöïc töôùng cuûa sinh meänh, noù Shoju Rojin—See Chaùnh Thoï Laõo OÂng Thieàn Sö.                  khoâng phaûi laø taûng ñaù hay hö voâ khoâng coù Chaùnh Thoï Laõo OÂng Thieàn Sö (1642-1721):                      sinh meänh. Muïc ñích cuûa vieäc tu Thieàn laø phaûi Shoju Rojin (jap)—Teân cuûa moät vò thieàn sö trong               tieáp xuùc vôùi thöïc töôùng traøn ñaày söùc soáng naøy, Phaät giaùo Nhaät Baûn, vaøo cuoái theá kyû thöù XVII,            noùi tröïc tieáp hôn chính laø naém baét noù ngay ñaàu theá kyû thöù XVIII. Thieàn sö Chaùnh Thoï Laõo              trong nhöõng haønh ñoäng ñi, ñöùng, naèm, ngoài — OÂng, coøn goïi laø Ñaïo Caûnh (Ñaïo Kính Hueä Ñoan),             While still a young monk, Hakuin eagerly thuoäc Thieàn phaùi Laâm Teá, ñeä töû vaø ngöôøi noái phaùp       bent on the monastery of Zen, had an cuûa Voâ Nan Thieàn Sö; vaø laø thaày cuûa thieàn sö              interview with Zen master Shoju Rojin. Baïch AÅn Hueä Haïc. Ngaøi laøm du Taêng ñi khaép                 Hakuin thought that he fully comprehended nöôùc Nhaät, theo hoïc vôùi nhieàu baäc thaày Thieàn              Zen and was proud of his attainment, and this khaùc nhau. Ngaøi laø taùc giaû cuûa boä “Goùp Nhaët Caùt         interview with Shoju Rojin was in fact Ñaù,” moät taùc phaåm raát phoå thoâng, taä p hôïp nhöõng         intended to be a demonstration of his own caâu chuyeän vaø truyeàn thuyeát ñaày chaát haøi höôùc maø        high understanding. Shoju Rojin asked Hakuin caùc thaày Thieàn thöôøng duøng khi thuyeát giaûng tö             how much he knew of Zen. Hakuin answered töôûng cuûa mình—Name of a Japanese Zen master                    disgustingly, "If there is anything I can lay my in the late seventeenth century and early                         hand on, I will get it all out of me." So saying, eighteenth century. Zen master Shoju Rojin, also                  he acted as if he were going to vomit. Shoju called Dokyo Etan, belonged to the Japanese Lin-                  Rojin took firm hold of Hakuin's nose and Chi school, a disciple and dharma successor of                    said: "What is this? Have I not after all Bu'nan Shido; and the master of Hakuin Zenji. He                  touched it?" Zen practitioners should think it wandered through Japan and trained under                          over on Hakuin's interview with Zen master masters of various Zen schools. He is the author of               Shoju Rojin and try to find out for yourselves the Collection of Sand and Stone, a popular                       what is that something which is so realistically anthology of frequently humorous Buddhist stories                 demonstrated by Shoju Rojin. According to and legends, which Zen masters are fond of                        Zen master D.T. Suzuki in "An Introduction quoting in their teaching.                                        To Zen Buddhism," Zen is not all negation,  Khi Baïch AÅn ñeán tham kieán Thieàn sö Chaùnh                  leaving the mind all blank as if it were pure Thoï Laõo OÂng, töï khoe mình ñaõ ngoä ñaïo, muoán           nothing; for that would be intellectual suicide. ñöôïc Chaùnh Thoï aán khaû. Chaùnh Thoï hoûi Baïch           There is in Zen something self-assertive, AÅn ñaõ ngoä Thieàn nhieàu hay ít? Baïch AÅn ñaùp:           which, however, being free and absolute, "Neáu coù baát cöù vaät gì coù theå baøy ra treân tay,       knows no limitations and refuses to be toâi seõ oùi heát ra roài." Theá laø Baïch AÅn laøm haønh    handled in abstraction. Zen is a live fact, it is ñoäng noân oùi ra. Chaùnh Thoï keùo muõi Baïc h AÅn,         not like an inorganic rock or like an empty hoûi: "Ñaây laø caùi gì? Chaúng phaûi ta ñaõ naém            space. To come into contact with this living ñöôïc noù roài sao?" Haønh giaû haõy suy nghó veà            fact, directly speaking, to take hold of it in maãu ñoái thoaïi naøy cuøng Baïch AÅn ñeå töï mình           every phase of life such as walking, standing, phaùt hieän ra vieäc tieáp cô soáng ñoäng nhö theá           lying down and sitting, is the aim of all Zen cuûa Chaùnh Thoï laø muoán noùi caùi gì. Theo                discipline. Thieàn sö D.T. Suzuki trong taùc phaåm "Thieàn

   Moät laàn khaùc, vaøo moät buoåi chieàu heø, Baïch          voã vai oâng, noùi: "Ñöôïc roài ñoù, ñöôïc roài ñoù." AÅn ñeán trình choã sôû ngoä cuûa mình cho Laõo             Ñoù laø caùch maø ngöôøi xöa duøng ñeå bieán moät OÂng, luùc aáy ñang hoùng gioù tröôùc maùi hieân.           thieàn sinh bình thöôøng thaønh moät Toå Sö Thieàn Laõo OÂng baûo: "Troø nhaûm!" Baïch AÅn laëp laïi           vó ñaïi. Caùc thieàn sö thöôøng duøng nhöõng thuû trong moät tieáng cöôøi gaèn hôi mai mæa: "Troø             ñoaïn haàu nhö quaù taøn nhaãn. Tuy nhieân, trong nhaûm!" Laõo OÂng beøn naém laáy ngöôøi hoïc troø,          nhöõng tröôøng hôïp naøy, loøng tin phaûi tuyeät ñoái ñaùnh ñaù lung tung, roài xoâ ra ngoaøi maùi hieân.         ñaët ôû chaân lyù Thieàn, vaø ôû söï trieät ngoä cuûa Ñang muøa möa, Baïch AÅn teù xuoáng vuõng sình.             thaày. Thieáu loøng tin aáy töùc laø thieáu luoân loøng Laùt sau tænh laïi, Baïch AÅn laïi vaøo laïy thaày, vaø     tin ôû khaû naêng töï tri töï giaùc cuûa chính mình. laàn nöõa bò thaày maéng: "Ñoà suùc sinh ôû hang            Hôn theá nöõa, haønh giaû tu Thieàn neân luoân nhôù ñoäng." Hoâm sau, Baïch AÅn nghó raèng thaày                raèng trong söï tu taäp Thieàn, söùc noäi quaùn chieáu mình khoâng hieåu noåi kieán giaûi cao thaâm tuyeät         dieäu phaûi ñi ñoâi vôùi ñöùc ñoä khieâm haï saâu daøy dieäu cuûa mình, neân nhaát quyeát baèng moïi caùch         vaø moät caùi taâm nhaãn nhuïc cao ñoä —Another phaûi laøm cho ra leõ. Vöøa gaëp cô hoäi, oâng vaøo         time, in one summer evening when Hakuin ngay phöông tröôïng, vaø ñem heát bieän taøi ra             presented his view to the old master, Shoju, tranh luaän vôùi thaày, laàn naøy nhaát ñònh khoâng         who was cooling himself on the veranda, nhöôøng moät taác ñaát naøo. Laõo OÂng noåi côn             Shoju said, "Stuff and nonsense." Hakuin thònh noä, chuïp laáy Baïch AÅn, giaùng cho maáy            echoed, loudly and rather satirically, "Stuff baït tai, roài xoâ ra khoûi cöûa. Baïch AÅn rôi töø gaùc    and nonsense!" Thereupon Shoju seized him, cao xuoáng chaân böùc töôøng ñaù, naèm meâ man              struck him several times, and finally pushed baát tænh. Laõo OÂng doøm xuoáng oâng Taêng baát            him off the veranda. It was soon after the haïnh, cöôøi ha haû. Tieáng cöôøi ñaùnh thöùc Baïch         rainy weather, and poor Hakuin rolled in the AÅn tænh côn cheát giaác; oâng raùng leo leân, moà          mud and water. Having recovered himself hoâi ñaàm ñìa. Nhöng Laõo OÂng vaãn chöa chòu               after a while, he came up and reverentially buoâng tha, vaø nhö tröôùc, laïi maéng: "Ñoà suùc           bowed to the teacher, who then remarked sinh ôû hang ñoäng!" Trong côn tuyeät voïng,                again, "O you, denizen of the dark cavern!" Baïch AÅn tính boû thaày ra ñi. Ngaøy noï, treân            Another day Hakuin thought that the master ñöôøng khaát thöïc, oâng döøng böôùc tröôùc nhaø moät       did not know how deep his knowledge of Zen baø laõo, baø khoâng cho côm, oâng cöù ñöùng yeân           was and decided to have a settlement with tröôùc cöûa nhö khoâng bieát gì ñeán söï töø khöôùc         him anyhow. As soon as the time came cuûa baø. Taâm thaàn oâng ñang taäp trung cao ñoä           Hakuin entered the master's room and vaøo caâu hoûi laøm baän taâm oâng nhaát maáy luùc          exhausted all his ingenuity in contest with gaàn ñaây. Baø laõo noåi giaän, töôûng oâng khoâng          Shoju, making his mind up not to give way an ñeám xæa gì ñeán lôøi baø noùi, vaø coá xin cho kyø         inch of ground this time. Shoju was furious, ñöôïc môùi nghe. Saün caây choåi lôùn caàm treân tay,       and finally taking hold of Hakuin gave him baø ñaäp vaøo ñaàu oâng, baûo phaûi cuùt ñi ngay.           several slaps and let him go over the porch Caây choåi ñaäp naëng quaù laøm xeäp caùi noùn töø lö       again. Hakuin fell several feet at the foot of cuûa oâng, coøn oâng thì ngaõ xuoáng ñaát xæu. Giaây        the the stone wall, where he remained for a laâu oâng tænh daäy, vaø oâ kìa, döôùi maét oâng, taát      while almost senseless. The master looked caû hieän ra saùng roõ, thoâng suoát. Tai naïn tình côø     down and heartily laughed at the poor fellow. hoát nhieân môû maét oâng tröôùc chaân lyù Thieàn, maø      This brought Hakuin back to consciousness. töø tröôùc bò hoaøn toaøn khuaát laáp ôû oâng. OÂng         He came up again all in perspiration. Shoju, möøng rôõ khoâng keå sieát, voäi trôû veà trong taâm        however, did not release him yet and traïng phaán khích cöïc ñoä. Chöa ñaët chaân ñeán           stigmatized him as ever with, "O you, denizen cöûa ngoaøi thì Laõo OÂng ñaõ nhaän ra, ñöa tay ra          of the dark cavern!" Hakuin grew desperate daáu, vaø noùi: "Böõa nay ñem tin vui gì veà ñaây?          and thought of leaving the old master Vaøo ñaây mau, leï ñi!" Baïch AÅn thuaät laïi söï           altogether. When one day he was going about vieäc vöøa qua trong ngaøy. Laõo OÂng nheï nhaøng           begging in the village, a certain accident

made him all of a sudden open his mental eye          Right effort, zeal or progress, the sixth of the to the truth of Zen, which until this time            eightfold noble path. completely shut off from him. His joy knew            (I) Nghóa cuûa Chaùnh tinh taán—The meanings of no bounds and came back in a most exalted                  “Right effort”: Chaùnh tinh taán coù nghóa laø state of mind. Before he crossed the front                 chuyeân caàn sieâng naêng laøm lôïi mình vaø lôïi gate, the master recognized him and                        ngöôøi; khoâng laøm nhöõng vieäc baát chính nhö beckoned to him, saying "What good news                    saùt haïi, gian xaûo, ñaøng ñieám, côø baïc, aùc ñoäc have you brought home today? Come right in,                vaø bæ oåi, vaân vaân; ngöôïc laïi phaûi chuù taâm laøm quick, quick!" Hakuin told Shoju all about                 nhöõng vieäc laønh, taïo phöôùc nghieäp. Chaùnh tin what he had been through that day. The                     taán coøn coù nghóa laø noã löïc ñuùng coù nghóa laø coá master tenderly stroked him on the back and                gaéng khoâng cho phaùt khôûi nhöõng ñieàu taø vaïy, said, "You have it now, you have it now."                  coá gaéng vöôït qua nhöõng taø vaïy ñang maéc That's the way the ancients turn an ordinary               phaûi, coá gaéng laøm naåy nôû nhöõng ñieàu thieän student to a great Zen patriarch. Zen masters              laønh chöa naåy nôû, coá gaéng phaùt huy nhöõng always resort to methods seemingly inhuman.                ñieàu thieän laønh ñaõ phaùt khôûi. Chaùnh tinh taán In these cases, however, there must be                     coøn coù nghóa laø vun boài thieän nghieäp cuøng luùc absolutely faith in the truth of Zen and in the            nhoå boû aùc nghieäp—Right effort means we master's perfect understanding of it. The lack             must be always hard-working, helpful to of this faith will also mean the same in one's             others and ourselves. Do not kill, cheat, or own spiritual possibilities. Furthermore, Zen              lead a wanton, gamble life. On the contrary, practitioners should always remember that in               always try to perform good deeds for having the study of Zen the power of an illuminating              good karma. Correct (Right or Perfect) Zeal insight must go hand in hand with a deep                   or Effort or Energy also means to try to avoid sense of humility and meekness of mind.                    the arising of evil, demeritorious things have Chaùnh Thuï: Samapatti (skt & p)—Attainment of                   not yet arisen. Try to overcome the evil, an enjoying stage of meditation—Chöùng ñaéc—                     demeritorious things that have already arisen. See Ñaúng Chí.                                                   At the same time, try to produce meritorious Chaùnh Thöøa Phöông Tieän Thöøa: Chaùnh thöøa laø                things that have not yet arisen and try to duøng phaùp moân cöùu caùnh ñeå hoùa ñoä chuùng sanh.            maintain the meritorious things that have Trong khi phöông tieän thöøa laø duøng phöông phaùp              already arisen and not let them disappear, but tieän duïng tuøy theo hay thích hôïp vôùi söï thuï nhaän         to bring them to growth, to maturity and to the cuûa chuùng sanh; caùch tieän lôïi vôùi hoaøn caûnh vaø          full perfection of development. Right effort ñieàu kieän—The correct vehicle uses the ultimate                also means cultivation of what is karmically dharma door to save beings, i.e., methods of                     wholesome and avoidance of what is meditation. While upaya-yana means using tacts                   karmically unwholesome. or skills or expedient ways in teaching according           (II) Nhieäm vuï cuûa chaùnh tin taán laø ñeå caûnh giaùc to receptivity; ways that are convenient to the                  vaø chaën ñöùng nhöõng tö duy khoâng laønh maïnh, place or situation and suited to the conditions.                 ñoàng thôøi tu taäp, thuùc ñaåy, duy trì nhöõng tö Chaùnh Tín: Right belief—Cöûa ngoõ ñaàu tieân ñi                 duy thieän vaø trong saùng ñang sanh trong taâm vaøo ñaïi giaùc, vì nhôø ñoù maø taâm ta luoân kieân ñònh        haønh giaû—The function of the right effort is to khoâng thoái chuyeån—The first entrance to the great             be vigilant and check all unhealthy thoughts, enlightenment; for with it, the steadfast mind is                and to cultivate, promote and maintain not broken.                                                      wholesome and pure thoughts arising in a Chaùnh Tín Nieäm Phaät Keä: Hymns on True Faith                  man’s mind. in Nembutsu—Baøi tuïng veà Nieäm Phaät Chaân Thaät          1) Ñeå ngaên ngöøa nhöõng tö duy aùc, baát thieän chöa Tín (nieàm tin chaân thaät cho ngöôøi nieäm Phaät).              sanh, khoâng cho chuùng khôûi sanh trong taâm Chaùnh Tinh Taán: Samma-vayama (p)—Coá gaéng                     haønh giaû—To prevent the arising of evil and ñuùng laø giai ñoaïn thöù saùu trong Baùt Thaùnh ñaïo—

unwholesome thoughts that have not yet                    both. Now if we allow such thoughts to rise arisen in a man’s mind.                                   repeatedly, it is a bad sign, for when an 2) Ñoaïn tröø nhöõng tö duy aùc ñaõ sanh—To                     unhealthy thought is allowed to recur again discard such evil thoughts already arisen.                and again, it tends to become a habit. It is, 3) Laøm cho sanh khôûi vaø phaùt trieån nhöõng tö duy           therefore, essential to make a real effort to thieän chöa sanh—To produce and develop                   keep unwholesome thoughts away from us. wholesome thoughts not yet arisen.                        Until we succeed in stopping them to rise in 4) Thuùc ñaåy vaø duy trì nhöõng tö duy thieän ñaõ              our mind, unhealthy thoughts will always be sanh caøng theâm taêng tröôûng—To promote and             taking possession of our mind. It is not only maintain the good thoughts already present.               during the time of meditation that we need to (III) Phaùt trieån Chaùnh tinh taán—Development of              cultivate our right effort. Right effort should “Right effort”: Khi tu taäp chaùnh tinh taán chuùng       be cultivated always whenever possible. In all ta caàn phaûi thöïc haønh vôùi nhöõng tö duy cuûa         our speech, actions and behavior, in our daily chuùng ta. Neáu suy xeùt chuùng ta seõ thaáy raèng        life, we need right effort to perform our duties nhöõng tö duy naày khoâng phaûi luùc naøo cuõng laø       wholeheartedly and successfully. If we lack thieän laønh trong saùng. Ñoâi khi chuùng chæ laø         right effort and give in to sloth and indolence, nhöõng tö duy baát thieän vaø ngu xuaån, maëc duø         we can not proceed with our cultivation. khoâng phaûi luùc naøo chuùng ta cuõng boäc loä (IV) Chaùnh tinh taán trong thieàn ñònh—Right effort chuùng thaønh lôøi noùi hay haønh ñoäng. Nhö vaäy,        in Zen: Chaùnh Tinh Taán laø moät trong ba phaàn neáu chuùng ta cöù ñeå cho nhöõng tö duy naày khôûi       hoïc cuûa Thieàn Ñònh (hai phaàn hoïc khaùc laø leân, ñoù laø moät daáu hieäu khoâng toát, vì khi moät    Chaùnh Nieäm vaø Chaùnh Ñònh). Theo Phaät giaùo, tö duy khoâng thieän laønh ñöôïc pheùp taùi dieãn         chaùnh tinh taán laø trau doài moät thaùi ñoä töï tin nhieàu laàn, noù seõ thaønh thoùi quen. Vì theá, ñieàu    cuûa taâm, chuù yù vaø tænh thöùc: Chaùnh tinh taán laø thieát yeáu laø phaûi noã löïc khoâng ñeå cho nhöõng      söï noã löïc trau doài thaùi ñoä töï tin ñoái vôùi coâng tö duy baát thieän naày tôùi gaàn, vì cho ñeán khi        vieäc hay ñaûm nhaän vaø theo ñuoåi nhieäm vuï naøo chuùng ta thaønh coâng trong vieäc cheá ngöï         baèng nghò löïc vaø yù chí thi haønh nhieäm vuï aáy chuùng, nhöõng tö duy baát thieän naày vaãn seõ xaâm      cho ñeán cuøng. Ñeå tieán boä treân con ñöôøng ñaïo, chieám taâm chuùng ta. Khoâng phaûi chæ trong             chuùng ta caàn phaûi noã löïc trong vieäc tu taäp theo nhöõng giôø haønh thieàn chuùng ta môùi ñeå yù ñeán       Chaùnh Phaùp. Nhôø nhieät taâm tinh caàn chuùng ta tính chaát voâ cuøng quan troïng cuûa chaùnh tinh         coù theå laøm cho nhöõng haønh ñoäng quaáy aùc oâ taán. Chaùnh tinh taán caàn phaûi ñöôïc thöôøng           nhieãm maø mình ñaõ laøm tröôùc ñaây trôû neân xuyeân tu taäp baát cöù khi naøo vaø baát cöù ôû ñaâu coù thanh tònh, ñoàng thôøi ngaên ngöøa nhöõng haønh theå ñöôïc. Trong moïi lôøi noùi cuûa chuùng ta, moïi     ñoäng naøy phaùt sinh trong töông lai. Laïi nöõa, haønh ñoäng cuûa chuùng ta vaø caùch cö xöû cuûa          tinh caàn raát caàn thieát ñeå duy trì ñöùc haïnh maø chuùng ta trong ñôøi soáng haèng ngaøy, chuùng ta         chuùng ta ñaõ tu taäp, cuõng nhö xaây döïng nhöõng caàn chaùnh tinh taán ñeå thöïc hieän nhöõng boån         ñöùc haïnh môùi trong töông lai—Right effort is phaän cuûa chuùng ta moät caùch toaøn haûo. Neáu          one of the three trainings in meditation (two chuùng ta thieáu chaùnh tinh taán hay ñöùc tính           other trainings are Right Mindfulness and nhieät taâm tinh caàn naày, chuùng ta coù theå bò         Right Concentration). Right effort means nhöõng traïng thaùi hoân traàm vaø löôøi bieáng khuaát    cultivating a confident attitude toward our phuïc, thì chaéc chaén khoâng theå naøo chuùng ta coù     undertakings, taking up and pursuing our task theå tieán trieån vieäc tu taäp ñöôïc—When                with energy and a will to carry them through developing right effort we must be sincere                to the end. In Buddhism, right effort means about our thoughts. If we analyze them we                 cultivating a confident attitude of mind, being will find that our thoughts are not always good           attentive and aware. To progress on the path, and wholesome. At times they are                          we need to put our energy into Dharma unwholesome and foolish, though we may not                practice. With enthusiastic effort, we can always express them in words and actions or               purify negative actions already done to

prevent doing new ones in the future. In                 Nibbana. According to Zen Master D. T. Suzuki in addition, effort also is necessary to maintain           The Studies In The Lankavatara Sutra, this is one the virtuous states we’ve already generated,             of the five categories of forms. Corrective as well as to induce new ones in the future.             wisdom, which correct the deficiencies of errors of Chaùnh Tính Ly Sinh: According to Abhidharma-                  the ordinary mental discrimination. Right kosa, the life of holiness apart or distinguished              Knowledge consists in rightly comprehending the from the life of common unenlightened people—                  nature of Names and Appearances as predicating See Thaùnh Tính Ly Sinh.                                       or determining each other. It consists in seeing Chaùnh Tri Kieán: Holy wisdom—Supreme                          mind as not agitated by external objects, in not knowledge—Wisdom of Buddha—Söï hieåu bieát toái                being carried away by dualism such as nihilism thöôïng hay trí hueä Phaät hieåu bieát vaïn höõu vaø           and eternalism, and in not faling the state of phöông caùch cöùu ñoä—The perfect understanding                Sravakahood and Pratyekabuddhahood as well as of omniscience regarding the laws of universal                 into the position of the philosopher. salvation. The Buddha-wisdom of knowing                        Chaùnh Trí Mai Thoï Truyeàn (1905-1973): Teân everything or method of salvation.                             cuûa moät vò cö só hoïc giaû Phaät giaùo Vieät Nam vaøo Chaùnh Tri Nhi Truï: Giöõ laáy chaùnh tri—Abiding              theá kyû XX. OÂng laø moät trong nhöõng ngöôøi ñaàu tieân in correct wisdom.                                             ñöôïc môøi veà giaûng daïy taïi Vieän Ñaïi Hoïc Vaïn Chaùnh Trí: Samma-nana (p)—Samyagjnana                         Haïnh vaøo naêm 1964—Name of a Vietnamese (skt)—Trí hueä chaân chaùnh—Correct knowledge—                 Buddhist scholar in the twentieth century. He was Correct insight—Correct vision through wisdom—                 one of the first scholars who was invited to teach Right knowledge—Right wisdom—Trí cuûa caùc                     at Vaïn Haïnh University in 1964. baäc Hieàn Thaùnh hay söï nhìn thaáy baèng trí tueä, moät      Chaùnh Trôï Nhò Nghieäp: Hai nghieäp chaùnh trôï— trong nguõ phaùp. Chaùnh trí laø trí thaáy caùc phaùp nhö      Chaùnh nghieäp laø haønh ñoäng ñuùng, traùnh laøm vieäc chuùng thaät söï laø, thaáy tính chaát voâ thöôøng, khoå vaø   aùc, thanh tònh thaân laø giai ñoaïn thöù tö trong Baùt voâ ngaõ cuûa chö phaùp höõu vi. Nhôø bieát caùc phaùp         Thaùnh Ñaïo. Trôï nghieäp laø tuïng kinh hoä nieäm giuùp nhö chuùng thaät söï laø nhö vaäy, nhaän chaân ñöôïc thöïc     ngöôøi quaù coá vaõng sanh Tònh Ñoä—Two kinds of chaát cuûa nguû uaån chaáp thuû, haønh giaû coù theå chöùng    action: Correct or right deed or sction (conduct) nghieäm haïnh phuùc cuûa Nieát Baøn. Theo Thieàn Sö            and auxiliary karma. Right action, avoiding all D. T. Suzuki trong Nghieân Cöùu Kinh Laêng Giaø,               wrong, purity of body, the fourth of the eightfold ñaây laø moät trong naêm phaùp töôùng. Trí hueä chaân          noble path. While auxiliary karma bases on chaùnh thaáy roõ nhöõng loãi laàm cuûa söï phaân bieät cuûa    reciting a sutra to help a death person to reach the phaøm phu. Chaùnh trí bao goàm hieåu ñuùng baûn chaát          Pure Land. cuûa Danh vaø Töôùng nhö laø söï xaùc nhaän vaø quyeát         Chaùnh Trung: See Chính Trung. ñònh laãn nhau. Chaùnh trí laø ôû choã nhìn thaáy caùi taâm    Chaùnh Trung Lai: Giai ñoaïn thöù ba laø ngoâi vò khoâng bò dao ñoäng bôûi caùc ñoái töôïng beân ngoaøi, ôû      trong aáy khoâng coøn yù thöùc veà thaân hay taâm. Caû hai choã khoâng bò mang ñi xa bôûi nhò bieân nhö ñoaïn             ñaõ ñöôïc xaû boû hoaøn toaøn. Ñaây laø naêm caáp baäc dieät hay thöôøng haèng, vaø ôû choã khoâng bò rôi vaøo        chöùng ngoä do Ñoäng Sôn Löông Giôùi thieát laäp. traïng thaùi cuûa Thanh Vaên hay Duyeân Giaùc, hay             Gioáng nhö 10 baøi keä chaên traâu, ñaây laø caùc möùc ñoä luaän ñieäu cuûa caùc trieát gia—Sage-like or saint-like       khaùc nhau veà söï thaønh töïu trong nhaø Thieàn—The knowledge, one of the five Dharmas. True                       third grade is a level of realization wherein no wisdom or insight is wisdom that sees all things as            awareness of body or mind remains; both “drop they really are. Wisdom that views things as they              away” completely. Like the Ten Osherding are implies, and sees the transient, unsatisfactory            Verses, these are five different levels or degrees and no-self-nature of all conditioned and                      of Zen realization formulated by Zen master component things. Owing to the comprehending                   Tung-Shan-Liang-Chieh—See Ñoäng Sôn Nguõ Vò. things as they really are, and realizing the true              Chaùnh Trung Thieân: Sho-Chu-Hen (jap)—Moät nature of the five aggregates of clinging,                     trong naêm caáp baäc chöùng ngoä do Ñoäng Sôn Löông practitioner will be able to experience the bliss of           Giôùi thieát laäp. Gioáng nhö 10 baøi keä chaên traâu, ñaây

laø caùc möùc ñoä khaùc nhau veà söï thaønh töïu trong nhaø      suffering, the root of all wicked acts; Thieàn. Giai ñoaïn trong ñoù söï nhaän thöùc veà theá giôùi      therefore, we must look for a way to get rid of hieän töôïng ngöï trò, nhöng noù ñöôïc nhaän thöùc nhö           suffering for us and for others. A mind free laø chieàu kích cuûa ngaõ tuyeät ñoái—The first level of         from sensual lust, ill-will and cruelty. Right the five different levels or degrees of Zen                      thought means resolve in favour of realization formulated by Zen master Tung-Shan-                  renunciation, goodwill and nonharming of Liang-Chieh. The stage in which realization of the               sentient beings. Right thought and intent, the world of phenomena is dominant, but it is                        second of the eightfold noble path. Right perceived as a dimension of the absolute self—                   aspiration towards renunciation, benevolence See Ñoäng Sôn Nguõ Vò.                                           and kindness. Chaùnh Truyeàn: Handed down from authentic 2) Tö duy chaân chaùnh laø nhöõng tö duy coù lieân source—From genuine tradition.                                   quan ñeán söï xuaát ly (Nekkhamma-samkappa), Chaùnh Tröïc: 1) Thaúng Thaén: Correct and straight;             tö duy voâ saân hay töø aùi (Avyapada- 2) Nhöùt Thöøa Thieân Thai: The One Vehicle                      samkappa). Nhöõng tö duy naày caàn ñöôïc tu taäp teaching of the T’ien-T’ai.                                      vaø môû roäng ñeán muoân loaøi chuùng sanh baát keå Chaùnh Tröïc Taâm: Cittajjukata (p)—Moät caùi taâm               chuûng toäc, giai caáp, doøng doõi hay tín ngöôõng, chaùnh tröïc—Rectitude of consciousness.                         vì chuùng bao truøm moïi loaøi coù hôi thôû, khoâng Chaùnh Tröïc Taâm Sôû: Kayujjukata (p)—Taâm Sôû                  coù nhöõng giôùi haïn quy ñònh—Right thoughts Chaùnh Tröïc—Rectitude of mental body.                           includes thoughts of renunciation, good will, Chaùnh Tröïc Xaû Phöông Tieän: Con ñöôøng thaúng                 and of compassion, or non-harm. These loaïi boû taát caû moïi phöông tieän—The straight way            thoughts are to be cultivated and extended which has cast aside expediency.                                 towards all living beings regardless of race, Chaùnh Tö Duy: Samma-sankappa (p)—                               caste, clan, or creed. As they embrace all that Samyaksamkalpa (skt)—Sho-Shi-I (jap)—Correct                     breathes there are no compromising or Right Thought or Perfect Resolve.                             limitations. (I) Nghóa cuûa Chaùnh tö duy—The meanings of                (II) Chaùnh tö duy vaø Tueä hoïc—Right Thought and Right thought:                                             the  training in Wisdom: Chaùnh Tö Duy laø moät 1) Chaùnh tö duy laø suy nghó ñuùng vôùi leõ phaûi, coù          trong hai phaàn hoïc cuûa trí tueä (phaàn khaùc laø lôïi cho mình, vaø coù lôïi cho ngöôøi khaùc. Suy          Chaùnh Kieán). Chaùnh tö duy coù nghóa laø traùnh nghó nhöõng haønh vi laàm loãi, nhöõng taâm nieäm          luyeán aùi vaø saân haän. Theo Phaät giaùo, nguoàn xaáu xa caàn phaûi caûi söûa. Suy nghó giôùi ñònh          goác cuûa khoå ñau vaø phieàn naõo laø voâ minh, tueä ñeå tu taäp giaûi thoaùt. Suy xeùt voâ minh laø       luyeán aùi vaø saân haän. Trong khi chaùnh kieán nguyeân nhaân cuûa moïi söï ñau khoå, laø nguoàn           loaïi boû voâ mình thì chaùnh tö duy loaïi boû luyeán goác cuûa moïi toäi aùc; suy nghó tìm phöông phaùp         aùi vaø saân haän; vì vaäy chaùnh kieán vaø chaùnh tö ñuùng ñeå tu haønh giaûi thoaùt cho mình vaø cho           duy cuøng nhau loaïi boû nguyeân nhaân cuûa khoå ngöôøi. Nghó ñuùng laø yù nghó töø boû moïi duïc           ñau vaø phieàn naõo. Ñeå loaïi boû luyeán aùi vaø voïng tham saân si. Nghó ñuùng laø luoân nghó veà          tham lam, chuùng ta phaûi trau doài buoâng boû, loøng khoan dung vaø nhaân töø vôùi moïi loaøi. Suy        trong khi muoán loaïi boû saân haän vaø giaän döõ nghó ñuùng laø giai ñoaïn thöù nhì trong Baùt              chuùng ta phaûi trau doài loøng yeâu thöông vaø bi Thaùnh ñaïo. Suy nghó ñuùng veà cuoäc soáng xuaát          maãn. Buoâng boû phaùt trieån baèng caùch suy gaãm gia, töø bi lôïi chuùng—Right thought means that           veà baûn chaát baát toaïi nguyeän cuûa ñôøi soáng, ñaëc our reflection must be consistent with                     bieät laø baûn chaát baát toaïi cuûa laïc thuù giaùc quan. common sense, useful both to others and                    Laïc thuù giaùc quan cuõng gioáng nhö nöôùc maën, ourselves. We must strive to correct our                   caøng uoáng caøng khaùt. Do hieåu bieát baûn chaát faults, or change our wicked opinions. While               baát toaïi cuûa cuoäc soáng, vaø coâng nhaän nhöõng meditating on the noble formula of “Precept,               haäu quaû khoâng ñöôïc öa thích cuûa laïc thuù giaùc Concentration, and Wisdom,” we must realize                quan, chuùng ta coù theå trau doài söï buoâng boû vaø that ‘ignorance’ is the main cause of                      khoâng luyeán chaáp moät caùch deã daøng. Chuùng ta

coù theå phaùt trieån loøng yeâu thöông vaø bi maãn            desire life and happiness. Understanding this, do coâng nhaän söï bình ñaúng thieát yeáu ôû chuùng            we should not place ourselves above others or sanh moïi loaøi. Gioáng nhö con ngöôøi, taát caû               regard ourselves any differently from the way chuùng sanh ñeàu sôï cheát vaø run raåy tröôùc hình            we regard others. Right thought means the phaït. Hieåu thaáu ñieàu naøy chuùng ta khoâng neân            thoughts of non-attachment, benevolence and gieát haïi hay laøm cho chuùng sanh khaùc bò gieát             non-harmfulness. On a deeper level, Right haïi. Cuõng gioáng nhö con ngöôøi, taát caû chuùng             Thought refers to the mind that subtly sanh ñeàu muoán soáng vaø haïnh phuùc. Hieåu thaáu             analyzes Emptiness, thus leading us to ñieàu naøy, chuùng ta khoâng neân töï cho mình cao             perceive it directly. hôn ngöôøi khaùc hay ñaùnh giaù mình khaùc vôùi           Chaùnh Töôïng Maït: Ba thôøi kyø chính cuûa Phaät caùch maø chuùng ta ñaùnh giaù ngöôøi khaùc. Chaùnh       giaùo laø thôøi Chaùnh Phaùp, Töôïng Phaùp, vaø Maït Tö Duy coù nghóa laø nhöõng tö duy khoâng coá             Phaùp—Three main periods of Buddhism, the real chaáp, töø aùi vaø baát toån haïi. ÔÛ möùc ñoä cao hôn,   or correct, the formal or semblance, and the final Chaùnh Tö Duy chæ cho loaïi taâm thöùc coù khaû           or termination—See Chaùnh Phaùp, Töôïng Phaùp, naêng giuùp chuùng ta phaân tích khoâng tính moät         and Maït Phaùp. caùch vi teá, ñeå nhaän bieát ñöôïc tính khoâng moät      Chaùnh ÖÙng: Söï caûm öùng linh nghieäm cuûa chö caùch tröïc tieáp—Right Thought is one of the             Phaät vaø chö Thaùnh—The influence of Buddha; the two trainings in Wisdom (the other training is            response of the Buddhas, or saints. Right View or Right Understanding). Right                 Chay:       Uposatha       (skt)—Fasting        feasts— thought or right thinking means avoiding                  Vegetarian—See Trai. attachment and aversion. According to                     Chay Tònh: Uposatha (skt)—Fasting feasts— Buddhism, the causes of suffering and                     Vegetarian—See Trai. afflictions are said to be ignorance,                     Chaïy Theo Danh Lôïi Hö AÛo: To chase after attachment, and aversion. When right                      dream-like and empty fame and fortune. understanding removes ignorance, right                    Chaúng Boû Taâm Meán Thích Thieän Tri Thöùc : thought removes attachment and aversion;                  Never give up friendships with wise people— therefore, right understanding and right                  Chaúng boû taâm meán thích taát caû thieän tri thöùc; ñaây thought remove the causes of suffering. To                laø moät trong möôøi luaät nghi cuûa chö Ñaïi Boà Taùt. remove attachment and greed we must                       Chö Boà Taùt an truï trong phaùp naày thôøi ñöôïc luaät cultivate renunciation, while to remove                   nghi ñaïi trí voâ thöôïng—Should never give up their aversion and anger we must cultivate love                 friendship with wise people. This is one of the ten and compassion. Renunciation is developed                 kinds of rules of behavior of great enlightening by contemplating the unsatisfactory nature of             beings. Enlightening beings who abide by these existence, especially the unsatisfactory nature           can attain the supreme discipline of                great of pleasures of the senses, for pleasures of the          knowledge—See Möôøi Luaät Nghi Cuûa Chö Ñaïi sens are likened to salt water, the more we               Boà Taùt. drink, the more we feel thirsty. Through                  Chaúng Phaûi Gioù Ñoäng, Chaúng Phaûi Phöôùn understanding the unsatisfactory nature of                Ñoäng: It is not the wind moving, neither the flag existence and recognizing the undesirable                 moving—Luïc toå Hueä Naêng ñaõ khaúng ñònh vôùi caùc consequences of pleasures of the senses, we               vò sö ñang caûi coï tröôùc tu vieän Phaùp Taâm raèng: can easily cultivate renunciation and                     “Chaúng phaûi phöôùn ñoäng, cuõng chaúng phaûi gioù detachment. To develop love and compassion                ñoäng, maø laø taâm cuûa maáy oâng ñoäng.”—Several through recognizing the essential equality of             monks was arguing back and forth about the flag all living beings. Like human beings, all other           and the wind without reaching the truth in front of beings fear death and tremble at the idea of              the Fa Hsin monastery in Kuang Chou. The sixth punishment. Understanding this, we should                 patriarch, Hui-Neng, said to them: “It is not the not kill other beings or cause them to be                 wind moving, neither the flag moving. It is your killed. Like human beings, all other beings

own minds that are moving."—See Phi Phong Phi                       ngöôøi coøn khoù hôn theá aáy nöõa)—A needle eye; it Phan.                                                               is as difficult to be reborn as a man as it is to Chaúng Sôï Nghieäp Sôùm Khôûi, Chæ Sôï Chaäm Giaùc                  thread a needle on earth by throwing the thread at Ngoä Maø Thoâi: Not to fear an early development                    it from the sky. of karma, fear only a slow awakening.                               Chaâm Mao Quyû: Moät trong chín loaøi quyû—One Chaép Tay: Hapchang (kor)—To join one’s hands                       of the nine classes of pretas—See Cöûu Quyû. together—Join one's palms together.                                 Chaâm Ngoân: Maxim—Precept. Chaép Tay Vaùi Chaøo: Adara (skt)—Salute with                       Chaâm Phong: See Chaâm Giôùi. folded hands and palms together.                                    Chaám Döùt: To put an end—To close—To Chaâm: Suci (skt)—Caây kim—A needle.                                conclude—To end—To finish—To bring to an Chaâm Bieám: Ironical.                                              end. Chaâm Chuøy: Laáy kim nhoïn ñaâm vaøo traùn, aùm chæ                Chaám        Döùt     Luaân      Hoài:     Cessation       of thuû thuaät maø moät soá thieàn sö söû duïng nhaèm traéc            transmigration. nghieäm söï laõnh hoäi thieàn cuûa ñeä töû—To pin the               Chaám Döùt Moïi Troùi Buoäc Cuûa Kieát Söû: To stop forehead with a sharp needle. The term implies                      one’s propensities and habits. expedient tricks that some masters utilize to test                  Chaám Döùt Toàn Taïi: Cease to exist. their disciples' comprehension of Zen.                              Chaåm: Theá naøo—How?—What? Chaâm Giôùi: Haït caûi vaø muõi kim, ví vôùi vieäc thò              Chaåm Sinh: Laøm theá naøo ñöôïc sinh ra?—How hieän cuûa Ñöùc Phaät coøn hieám hôn vieäc haït caûi bay            born?—How did it arise? töø khoâng trung maø rôùt vaøo ngay loå kim—Needle                  Chaân: 1) Chaân dung: A portrait; 2) Chaân thöïc: and mustard seed; the appearance of Buddha is as                    Tattva (skt)—True, real, truth, reality; 3) Traïng rare as hitting the point of a needle on earth by a                 thaùi thöïc: Tattvata (skt)—Real state. mustard seed thrown from the sky.                                   Chaân AÛnh: AÛnh töôïng chaân dung, bao goàm tranh Chaâm Giôùi Töông Ñaàu: Haït caûi neùm ra ngay vaøo                 veõ chaân dung, hình aûnh hay töôïng goã —The ñaàu muõi kim, ví vôùi vieäc thaày troø nhaân duyeân kheá           reflection of the truth, i.e. a portrait, photograph, hôïp thaät ñaëc bieät hieám coù, cuõng gioáng nhö vieäc haït        image, etc. caûi töø khoâng trung maø rôùt vaøo ngay loå kim vaäy —             Chaân Ba Tî: Ngöôøi thaät söï coù ñuû caùi loã muõi, duï To throw a mustard seed to hit the point of a                       cho baäc ñaïi tröôïng phu thaät söï trieät ngoä —A person needle. The term means suitable conditions and                      who really has a complete nose, i.e., a great circumstances of the meeting between a master                       gentleman or a great noble-minded man who and a disciple is as rare as hitting the point of a                 really has an absolutely complete enlightenment. needle on earth by a mustard seed thrown from                       Chaân Baø La Moân: Brahmas (skt)—See Phaïm the sky.                                                            Thieân. Chaâm Khaåu Quyû: Moät trong chín loaïi quyû, laø loaïi             Chaân Bæ Löôïng: Söï suy luaän vöõng chaéc—Valid quyû coù mieäng nhoû nhö caây kim, khoâng aên uoáng gì              inference. ñöôïc—One of the nine classes of pretas, needle-                    Chaân Boá Thí: Söï boá thí chaân chaùnh—Correct mouth ghosts, with mouth so small that they                         donation—Taïi Nhaät Baûn, ngaøy ñoù Hei-zayemon laø cannot satisfy their hunger or thirst—See Ngaï                      moät ñaïi phuù gia suoát ñôøi soáng cuoäc soáng ñöùc haïnh Quyû, and Cöûu Quyû.                                                maø caùc vò thaùnh coå ñöùc ngôïi khen. OÂng luoân söû Chaâm Khoång: Loå kim, yù noùi taùi sanh laøm ngöôøi                duïng taøi saûn cuûa mình laøm phöôùc, töø thieän vaø phuùc coøn khoù hôn chuyeän moät sôïi chæ töø treân khoâng bay            lôïi xaõ hoäi. Nhieàu treû sô sinh trong caùc gia ñình xoû vaøo ngay loå kim döôùi ñaát (theo Phaùp Uyeån                  ngheøo ñöôïc oâng cöùu giuùp. OÂng cuõng laø ngöôøi ñaõ Chaâu Laâm, quyeån 31, “Neáu nhö coù moät ngöôøi                    taøi trôï cho raát nhieàu coâng trình baét caàu boài loä giuùp ñöùng treân ñænh nuùi Tu Di keùo ra moät sôïi daây cöïc             cho daân chuùng trong vuøng ñi laïi tieän lôïi. Tröôùc khi nhoû, moät ngöôøi ñöùng döôùi chaân nuùi tay caàm caây              qua ñôøi, oâng ñaõ laäp di chuùc yeâu caàu tieáp tuïc söû kim ñoùn laáy ñaàu daây, ôû löng chöøng gioù loác, gioù             duïng taøi saûn cuûa mình vaøo muïc ñích nhaân ñaïo. YÙ xoaùy laïi noåi leân döõ doäi vaøo sôïi daây, sôïi daây thaät laø   nguyeän naøy ñaõ ñöôïc con chaùu oâng traân troïng vaø khoù chui vaøo ñöôïc ñuùng loå kim. Laøm ñöôïc thaân                nghieâm chænh thöïc hieän. Vaøo luùc sinh thôøi, moät

ngaøy noï coù moät vò sö Phaät giaùo nghe noùi veà loøng         groups of Hi-Yuan’s categories of Buddhist haøo hieäp cuûa oâng neân ñaõ ñeán nhaø oâng ñeå quyeân          schools. goùp tieàn xaây döïng coång chuøa. Nghe xong lôøi oâng           Chaân Daõ Chính Thuaän (1892-1962): Teân cuûa moät phaùt leân cöôøi vaø noùi: "Toâi giuùp ngöôøi vì khoâng          vò hoïc giaû Phaät giaùo Nhaät Baûn vaøo theá kyû XX. muoán nhìn thaáy hoï khoå sôû. Nhöng moät ngoâi chuøa            OÂng chuû tröông môû roäng vieäc tu taäp nieäm Phaät — khoâng coù coång thì coù gì goïi laø khoán khoå ñeå toâi phaûi   Name of a Japanese Buddhist scholar in the giuùp?" Phaät töû chaân thuaàn neân hieåu moät caùch roõ         twentieth century. He supported in spreading the raøng veà chaân boá thí—In Japan, once there was a               cultivation of Buddha Recitation. wealthy man, Hei-zayemon by name, who strove                     Chaân Dò Thuïc: Satya-parinata (skt)—True to realize in his life the virtues commended by                  maturation of effect—See Dò Thuïc. ancient sages. An earnest and studious man, Hei-                 Chaân Dieãn Thieàn Sö (1621-1677): Zen master zayemon used to spend liberally of his wealth in                 Jen-Yuan—Teân cuûa moät vò Thieàn sö Trung Hoa ôû acts of benevolence, charity, and welfare. Many                  Giang Toâ, Thieàn phaùi Laâm Teá vaøo thôøi nhaø infants of impoverished families were rescued by                 Minh—Name of a Chinese Zen master in Jiang his intervention, and he personally financed the                 Ssu Province, of the Lin-chi lineage, in the Ming construction of numerous bridges and roads in his                dynasty (1368-1644). province for the convenience of the people. When                 Chaân Dieän Muïc: Horai-no-nemoku (jap)—Baûn he died, Hei-zayemon stipulated in his will that his             Lai Dieän Muïc—Initial form—Original form— bequest should be used to continue relief work                   Former state of things—Original face or Buddha- through the generations, and this was honored by                 nature. his children and grandchildren. One day, they say,               Chaân Dieäu: Chaân thöïc vi dieäu—The mysterious there appeared at the door of Hei-zayemon a                      reality; reality in its profundity. certain Buddhist friar. It seems that this clergyman             Chaân Ñaø La Ni Haøo Töôùng AÁn: Daáu aán ñaø la ni had heard of the wealthy man's selfless                          cuûa töôùc loâng traéng giöõa hai chaân maøy cuûa Phaät, benevolence, unusual among the rich of his time,                 moät trong 32 töôùng haûo—Dharani seal of white and had come to ask him for money to build a                     hair between Buddha’s eyebrows, one of the temple gate. The philanthropist laughed in the                   thirty-two signs of a Buddha. friar's face and said, "I help people because I                  Chaân Ñaø Ma Ni AÁn: See Chaân Ñaø La Ni Haøo cannot bear to see them suffer. What's so bad                    Töôùng AÁn. about a temple without a gate?" Sincere Buddhists                Chaân Ñaø Ma Ni Haøo Töôùng AÁn: Cintamani (skt should understand clearly about correct donation.                & p)—Chaán Ña Maït Ni—Ma Ni. Chaân Caûnh: Caûnh giôùi cuûa chaân lyù—The region               1) AÁn ngoïc öôùc cuûa nhaø hieàn giaû: The seal of of truth or reality.                                                  philosopher’s stone, granting all one’s wishes. Chaân       Chaùnh       Yeáu       Taäp:    Saddharma-          2) AÁn ngoïc nhö yù—The seal of fabulous gem samparigraha-sastra (skt)—Nhieáp Chaùnh Phaùp                         (jewel of the thought)—The seal of Luaän—Treatise on the collected correct dharmas.                      philosopher’s stone—The seal of sacred Chaân Chính: Legitimate.                                              gem—The seal of wish-fulfilling jewel—AÁn Chaân Chính Phaùt Taâm: Hotsu-bodaishin (jap)—                        “Ngoïc öôùc nhö nguyeän” hay aán ngoïc Ma Ni Develop Bodhicitta—See Phaùt Taâm Boà Ñeà.                            baûo chaâu hay Nhö YÙ baûo chaâu, hay ngoïc öôùc Chaân Chöùng: Baèng chöùng cuûa söï giaùc ngoä—Real                   nguyeän. evidence, proof or assurance, or realization of                  Chaân Ñan: Chaân Ñaùn—Thaàn Ñan—Thaàn Ñaùn— truth. The knowledge, concept, or idea which                     Traàn Ñan—Moät töø ngöõ coå cuûa AÁn Ñoä duøng ñeå goïi corresponds to reality.                                          Trung Quoác—An ancient Indian term for China. Chaân Cuï Phaàn Maõn Giaùo: Boà Taùt hieåu roõ caû hai           Chaân Ñaïo: Con ñöôøng cuûa chaân lyù—The Truth, “tuøy duyeân” vaø “baát bieán”. Ñaây laø Moät trong Uyeån        the true way; reality. Coâng Töù Giaùo—The school of fully developed                    Chaân Ñaïo Voâ Theå: Chaân Phaùp Voâ Töôùng— Chaân Bodhisattvas, who know both the phenomenal and                   Phaät Voâ Hình—Chaân lyù döùt tuyeät moïi hình the noumenal bhutatathata. This is one of the four

töôùng—Absolute truth as having no differentiated              competent adept, you get to the one reality ideas nor appearances.                                         naturally, without wasting any effort. Chaân Ñaït La Ñaïi Töôùng: Kinnara (skt)—Chaân                 Chaân Ñaúng Löu: Respective consequences—Haäu Trì La Thaàn—Moät trong möôøi hai vò thaàn lieân heä           quaû theo sau haønh ñoäng thieän, baát thieän hay trung vôùi ñöùc Phaät Döôïc Sö—One of the the twelve                 tính—The certain consequences that follow on a spirits connected with the Master of Healing                   good, evil or neutral kind of nature respectively. Buddha.                                                        Chaân Ñeá: Paramartha-satya (skt)—Ñeä nhaát nghóa Chaân Ñaéc Thöïc Töôùng: To really attain the one              ñeá—Thaéng ñeá—The Buddha law—The correct Reality—Theo Bích Nham Luïc, khi baïn tu hoïc vaø              dogma or averment of the enlightened— tham vaán, khoâng coù nhieàu ñieàu khieán baïn phaûi baän      Fundamental                meaning—Reality—Ultimate taâm. Caùc moái baän taâm naûy sinh vì baïn thaáy beân         truth—Categories of reality in contrast with ngoaøi vaãn coù nuùi, soâng vaø ñaïi ñòa hieän höõu; beân      ordinary categories (tuïc ñeá) —Giaùo phaùp giaùc ngoä trong baïn nhaän thöùc ñöôïc raèng vieäc thaáy, nghe,          toái thöôïng cuûa Phaät hay caùi thöïc khoâng hö voïng caûm xuùc, vaø hieåu bieát vaãn hieän höõu; beân treân, baïn   voán coù, ñoái laïi vôùi theá ñeá (tuïc ñeá) cuûa phaøm phu, thaáy coù nhieàu vò Phaät khaû caàu; vaø beân döôùi, baïn      haïng chæ bieát hình töôùng beân ngoaøi chöù khoâng phaûi thaáy coù nhieàu chuùng sanh coù theå cöùu ñoä. Baïn phaûi     laø chaân lyù—The asseveration or categories of khaïc heát nhöõng thöù aáy ra ngoaøi ngay laäp töùc: sau       reality. Truth in reality, opposite of ordinary or ñoù, daàu baïn ñi, ñöùng, ngoài, hay naèm, hai möôi boán       worldly truth (Theá ñeá) or ordinary categories; they giôø moät ngaøy, baïn seõ ñuùt keát moïi thöù thaønh moät      are those of the sage, or man of insight, in contrast khoái. Luùc ñoù, daàu baïn coù ñöùng treân choùp moät sôïi     with those of the common man, who knows only loâng, noù cuõng bao la nhö vuõ truï; cho daàu baïn ôû         appearance and not reality. trong moät noài nöôùc soâi hay trong loø than hoàng thì        Chaân Ñeá Ba La Maät: Sacca-paramita (skt)— cuõng chæ gioáng nhö baïn ñang ôû trong moät daõy ñaát         Perfection of Truthfulness. thanh bình vaø haïnh phuùc; daàu cho baïn coù giöõa moät       Chaân Ñeá Ñaêng: Paramattha-dipani (p)—Lamp of môù chaâu baùu, ngoïc ngaø cuõng gioáng nhö baïn ñang          the Ultimate truth—Moät trong nhöõng boä luaän noåi soáng trong moät tuùp leàu tranh thoâi. Vì vaäy neáu baïn      tieáng do ngaøi Phaùp Hoä vieát vaøo theá kyû thöù naêm— laø moät Phaät töû coù naêng löïc, baïn seõ ñaït ñeán thöïc    One of the famous commentaries written by töôùng moät caùch töï nhieân, maø khoâng caàn phí phaïm        Dhammapala in the fifth century. theâm baát cöù noã löïc naøo nöõa—According to The             Chaân Ñeá Khuoâng: Paramattha-manjusa (p)—Moät Blue Cliff Record, whenever you study and ask                  boä luaän veà Thanh Tònh Ñaïo, ñöôïc vieát bôûi ngaøi questions, there aren't so many things to be                   Phaùp Hoä vaøo theá kyû thöù naêm—A commentary to concerned with. Concerns arise because outside                 the Visuddhimagga, written by Dhammapala in you perceive that mountains and rivers and the                 the fifth century. great earth exist; within you perceive that seeing,            Chaân Ñeá Phieán Dieän: The one-sided higher hearing, feeling, and knowing exist; above you                 truth—Theo Ngaøi Long Thoï Boà Taùt trong Trung see that there are various Buddhas that can be                 Quaùn Luaän, thì Nhò Ñeá Trung Ñaïo ñöôïc baèng sought; and below you see that there are sentient              “Naêm Huyeàn Nghóa”. Chaân ñeá phieán dieän chaáp beings who can be saved. You must simply spit                  vaøo thuyeát baát dieät cuûa theá giôùi hieän töôïng, moät them all out at once: afterwards, whether walking,             trong naêm huyeàn nghóa—According to Nagarjuna standing, sitting, or lying down, twenty-four hours            Bodhisattva in the Madhyamika Sastra, the a day, you fuse everything into one. Then, though              Middle Path of the Twofold Truth is expounded by you're on the tip of a hair, it's as broad as the              the “five terms.” The one-sided higher truth universe; though you dwell in a boiling caudron or             adheres to the theory of the non-production and in furnace embers, it's like being in the land of              non-extinction of the phenomenal world, one of peace and happiness; though you dwell amidst                   the five terms. gems and jewels in profusion, it's like being in a             Chaân Ñeá Tam Taïng (513-569): Paramartha thatched hut. For this kind of thing, if you are a             (skt)—Gunarata, or Kulanatha (skt)—Shintai- Sanzo (jap)—Ba La Maït Ñaø—Caâu Na La Ñaø—

Chaân Ñeá Tam Taïng laø moät nhaø sö, nhaø dòch thuaät       moät trong naêm huyeàn nghóa—According to noåi tieáng, töø vuøng Taây AÁn. Vaøo naêm 548, Chaân Ñeá    Nagarjuna Bodhisattva in the Madhyamika Sastra, ñaõ mang theo moät soá lôùn kinh Phaät ñeán Trung            the Middle Path of the Twofold Truth is Hoa baèng ñöôøng bieån (ñeán Nam Kinh). Theo                 expounded by the “five terms.” In the middle path mong öôùc cuûa nhaø vua, trong khoaûng thôøi gian ñoù        of the higher truth, one sees there is neither ñeán naêm 557, oâng ñaõ dòch 70 taùc phaåm. Ngöôøi ta        contemporary production nor contemporary noùi oâng cuõng coù vieát treân 40 taùc phaåm khoaûng 200    extinction, one of the five terms—See Nguõ Truøng quyeån. Ñoái töôïng chính cuûa oâng laø truyeàn baù hoïc     Huyeàn Nghóa. thuyeát A Tyø Ñaït Ma Caâu Xaù vaø Nhieáp Ñaïi Thöøa         Chaân Ñeá Tuïc Ñeá: The twofold truth, the higher Luaän. Hoaït ñoäng vaên hoïc cuûa oâng hình nhö ñaõ gaây     truth and the worldly truth. aûnh höôûng lôùn trong taâm hoàn Trung Hoa thôøi baáy        1) Chaân Ñeá: Higher truth—Chaân lyù tuyeät ñoái— giôø; ñieàu naày ñöôïc minh chöùng vôùi nhieàu ñoà ñeä            The higher truth—See Chaân Ñeá. xuaát saéc döôùi tröôùng. Chaân Ñeá thieát laäp Caâu Xaù     2) Tuïc Ñeá: Worldly truth—Chaân lyù cuûa theá giôùi Toâng vaø hoaït ñoäng cuûa oâng chæ coù theå so saùnh             hieän töôïng—The phenomenal truth—See Tuïc ñöôïc vôùi Cöu Ma La Thaäp ôû theá heä tröôùc vaø                 Ñeá. Huyeàn Trang ôû theá heä sau oâng maø thoâi. Sau ñoù         Chaân Ñoä: True Recompensed Land—See Baùo oâng bò buoäc phaûi ñi lang thang nhieàu nôi do nhöõng       Ñoä. bieán ñoäng chaùnh trò ôû Trung Hoa. OÂng soáng nhöõng       Chaân Ñoäc: Ñoïc tuïng moät boä kinh suoát töø ñaàu ñeán naêm cuoái ñôøi trong aån daät. Naêm 569 oâng thò tòch,      cuoái khoùa leã—To recite just one sutra from the thoï baûy möôi moát tuoåi—Paramartha was a famous            beginning to the end of the session. translator, a monk from Ujjayini, western India. In          Chaân Ñöùc Baát Khoâng Toâng: Toâng phaùi tin raèng 548 A.D., Paramartha carried with him a large                maëc duø chaân nhö khoâng coù ñònh töôùng, nhöng vaãn collection of Buddhist texts and travelled to China          coù voâ soá aân ñöùc maø töø ñoù bieåu loä taát caû caù c phaùp by the sea route (arrived in Naking). In                     taát ñònh vaø sai bieät. Giaùo thuyeát naày ñöôïc Ñaïi accordance with the desire of the emperor, from              Thöøa Chung Giaùo vaø Ñaïi Thöøa Khôûi Tín Luaän that time to 557, he translated seventy texts. He is         thöøa nhaän—The attribute of Thusness not empty also said to have written more than forty works,             or ‘void.’ Thusness , though it is without any altogether amounting to two hundred Chinese                  determinate character, is possessed with volumes. His chiefly object was to propagate the             innumerable potentialities from which all doctrine of Abhidharma-kosa and the Mahyana-                 determinate ot differentiated dharmas are samparigraha. His literary and religious activity            manifested. This tenet is admitted in the final seems to have greatly influenced the Chinese                 doctrine of Mahayana (the T’ien-T’ai School) and mind of the time as is testified by the fact that he         in the Awakening of Faith. had many able pupils under him. Paramartha                   Chaân Ñöôøng: Hall for Patriarchs’ images— founded the realistic Kosa School and his                    Trueness Hall. activities can be compared only with Kumarajiva              Chaân Giaù Trò: True value. who came before him and Hsuan-Tsang who came                 Chaân Giaû: True and false—Real and unreal— after him. Thereafter he was compelled to wander             Chaân nguïy—Chaùnh taø—Chaân Voïng—Taát caû chö from place to place on account of political                  phaùp ñeàu coù hai tính chaân vaø voïng. Phaùp tuøy theo upheavals in China. The last years of his life were          tònh duyeân tam hoïc (Phaät Phaùp) thì goïi laø chaân, spent in solitude and retirement and he died in 569          phaùp tuøy theo nhieãm duyeân voâ minh (khoâng giaùc A.D. at the age of seventy-one.                              ngoä) maø khôûi leân thì goïi laø voïng. Chaân nhö chaân Chaân Ñeá Trung Ñaïo: The middle path of the                 thöïc (baát sinh baát dieät) thì goïi laø chaân phaùp, Caùc higher truth—Theo Ngaøi Long Thoï Boà Taùt trong             phaùp do nhaân duyeân sinh ra thì goïi laø hieän töôïng Trung Quaùn Luaän, thì Nhò Ñeá Trung Ñaïo ñöôïc              hay laø voïng phaùp—All things have two baèng “Naêm Huyeàn Nghóa”. Trong Trung Ñaïo                  characteristics: true and false, or real and unreal. Chaân Ñeá, ngöôøi ta thaáy raèng giaû baát sinh giaû baát    That which arises in Buddha-truth, meditation and dieät hay thaáy raèng khoâng coù giaû sinh hay giaû dieät,   wisdom is true, influences of unenlightenment is

untrue. The essential bhutatathata is the real,                realized. Bernard Glassman and Rick Fields wrote phenomena as the unreal.                                       in Instruction to the Cook: "People who cling to Chaân Giaû Nhò Moân: True and provisional doors—               the experience of spirituality are said to have 'the Chaân Moân, cöûa ngoû chaân chaùnh ñi vaøo chaân lyù cuûa      stink of enlightenment.' It's necessary to come hieän thöïc; vaø giaû moân bao goàm taát caû nhöõng lôøi       back and work in the world." According to Zen phaùp taïm thôøi ñeå cöùu ñoä chuùng sanh—The true             Master Philip Kapleau in Awakening to Zen, those door is the gateway of truth or reality, and                   truly enlightened do not boast of their provisional door includes all provisional teachings            enlightenment. Just as a truly generous person for saving beings.                                             doesn't say, "I'm a generous guy, you know," so Chaân Giaùc: Chen-chueh (chi)—Söï toaøn giaùc chaân            one who has integrated into life what she or he chính, nhö nieát baøn toaøn thieän cuûa Phaät—The true         has realized in awakening will not wear and complete enlightenment, i.e. the perfect                   enlightenment as a badge and shield. The fully nirvana of Buddha, the perception of ultimate                  awakened are modest and self-effacing. While truth.                                                         they do not hide their light under a bushel basket, Chaân Giaùc Ngoä: Chen-chueh-wu (chi)—To be                    as the saying goes, at the same time they are not truly enlightened—Chaân giaùc ngoä laø söï toaøn giaùc         pushy or aggressively self-assertive. They know chaân chính, nhö nieát baøn toaøn thieän cuûa Phaät.           that in truth there's nowhere to go; they are there Haønh giaû tu Thieàn neân luoân nhôù raèng chaân giaùc         already. Those who are fully awakened do not ngoä khoâng gì khaùc hôn laø toaøn trieät chính baûn theå      hate either themselves or others since they know cuûa töï ngaõ. Bernard Glassman and Rick Fields vieát          that the all-embracing, nothing-lacking Essential trong quyeån 'Truø Phoøng Giaùo Chæ': "Nhöõng ngöôøi           Nature is common to all; thus they see others as mieät maøi ñi tìm kinh nghieäm taâm linh ñöôïc xem             fundamentally no different from themselves... nhö laø nhöõng ngöôøi chæ coù 'phaàn thoái tha cuûa giaùc      What is it really like to be enlightened? There's ngoä.' Hoï caàn quay veà vaø chuyeân taâm laøm vieäc           one certain way to find out: wake up yourself! trong coõi theá gian naøy." Theo Thieàn sö Philip              Chaân Giaûi Thoaùt: Söï giaûi thoaùt thaät söï laø söï thoaùt Kapleau trong quyeån 'Giaùc Ngoä Thieàn', nhöõng baäc          khoûi moïi chöôùng ngaïi cuûa duïc voïng phieàn naõo ñeå chaân giaùc khoâng laáy laøm kieâu haõnh veà söï giaùc ngoä    ñaït tôùi Nieát Baøn cuûa Phaät (döùt boû troùi buoäc goïi laø cuûa mình, cuõng gioáng nhö moät ngöôøi thaät taâm haøo        giaûi, an nhieân töï taïi goïi laø thoaùt). Nieát baøn cuûa hieäp khoâng bao giôø noùi: "Toâi laø ngöôøi haøo hieäp,       Phaät coù ñaày ñuû phaùp thaân, baùt nhaõ vaø giaûi thoaùt, caùc baïn ñeàu bieát ñoù." Vì vaäy moät ngöôøi ñaõ bieát       maø khoâng thieáu vaéng ñaïi bi maãn chuùng—Release ñem nhöõng ñieàu mình chöùng ñöôïc qua giaùc ngoä              from all the hindrances of passions and afflictions hoøa vaøo cuoäc soáng aét khoâng ñem ñieàu ñoù ra phoâ         to attain the Buddha’s nirvana, which is not a tröông. Baäc toaøn giaùc khieâm toán vaø kheùp mình kín        permanent state of absence from the needs of the ñaùo. Hoï khoâng che daáu phaåm chaát cuûa mình vì             living, but is spiritual, omniscient, and liberating. khieâm toán, ñoàng thôøi hoï khoâng töï ñeà cao, huøng hoå     Chaân Giaùo: töï khaúng ñònh mình. Hoï thaät bieát raèng khoâng coøn        1) Saddhamma (p)—Saddharma (skt)—True phaûi ñi ñaâu nöõa, vì hoï ñaõ ñeán nôi roài. Nhöõng baäc            vehicle—Chaân giaùo hay Chaùnh Phaùp laø giaùo toaøn giaùc khoâng gheùt mình, cuõng khoâng gheùt                    lyù chaân chaùnh, laø lôøi daïy cuûa Phaät, laø phöông ngöôøi, vì hoï bieát raèng chaân baûn taùnh vieân hôïp,              phaùp ñuùng, thöôøng ñöôïc duøng ñeå chæ Baùt toaøn haûo voán dó coù trong taát caû moïi ngöôøi; nhö theá,         Chaùnh Ñaïo. Trong Phaät giaùo Ñaïi Thöøa, hoï thaáy ngöôøi khaùc cô baûn khoâng khaùc gì hoï. Giaùc            Chaùnh Phaùp thöôøng duøng ñeå chæ nhöõng kinh ngoä thaät söï nhö theá naøo? Coù moät caùch chaéc chaén             Phaùp Hoa vaø Hoa Nghieâm. Trong khi Phaùp ñeå hieåu ra: haõy töï mình ñaùnh thöùc mình daäy!—                  phöông tieän goàm nhöõng lôøi daïy thöïc tieån The true and complete enlightenment, i.e. the                        khaùc—True teaching or right doctrine means perfect nirvana of Buddha, the perception of                         true teaching, the Buddha’s teachings, the ultimate truth. Zen practitioners should always                      right method which is often used as for the remember that the true enlightenment is nothing                      Noble Eightfold Path. In Mahayana, true but the nature of one’s own selfbeing fully                          teachings primarily refer to those of the Lotus

and Avatamsaka Sutras. While Expedient                   the mind. Right concentration or abstraction so teachings include all other practical teachings.         that becomes vacant and receptive. In this state, 2) (1237-1319): Master Jen-Jiao—Teân cuûa moät                the mind is fixed and undisturbed. This is the last vò Taêng Nhaät Baûn, thuoäc Thôøi Toâng (Thôøi           link of the Eightfold Path. Toâng ñöôïc Nhaát Bieán khai saùng vaøo naêm             Chaân Höõu Taùnh: Parinispanna-laksana (skt)— 1276)—Name of a Japanese monk, of the                    Character of Ultimate Reality—True existence— Shih School in Japan (was founded in 1276 by             Theo Duy Thöùc Toâng, ñaây laø moät trong ba loaïi I-Bien (1238-1289).                                      hieän höõu cuûa moïi vaät. Chaân höõu taùnh coøn ñöôïc goïi Chaân Haønh: See Thò Chaân Haønh Giaû.                        laø “Vieân Thaønh Thaät Taùnh.” Nhöõng höõu theå chaân Chaân Haïnh Phuùc: Advaitananda (skt)—                        thaät, nghóa laø phi höõu trong yù nghóa cao nhaát cuûa Mahamangala (skt)—Bliss of knowledge of the                   danh töø naày, xa lìa taát caû töôùng khoâng thaät vaø giaû absolute—Real happiness—True happiness.                       taïm hay voâ töôùng. Söï thöïc, caùi naày khoâng phaûi laø Chaân Hieän Löôïng: Söï nhaän thöùc chính xaùc vaø            phi höõu maø laø hieän höõu sieâu vieät. Taùnh naày coøn vöõng        chaéc—Accurate            perception—Valid       ñöôïc goïi laø “Baûn Theå cuûa taát caû” vaø chæ coù nhöõng cognition—Valid perception.                                   ngöôøi coù trí tueä sieâu vieät môùi thaáu hieåu noù ñöôïc. Chaân Hình: Thaân chaân thaät voâ töôùng cuûa Phaät—          Taùnh naày tieâu bieåu nhöõng gì coøn soùt laïi sau khi hai Body of ultimate truth—The true body—Buddha                   taùnh tröôùc ñaõ bò loaïi boû—According to the Mind- as absolute.                                                  Only School, this is one of the three kinds of Chaân Hoùa:                                                   existence for everything. True existence, also 1) Cöùu ñoä ngöôøi baèng chaân lyù giaûi thoaùt—To            called “Character of Ultimate Reality.” Those of convert people by using teaching of the Truth.           true existence, that is to say, non-existent in the 2) Giaùo thuyeát cuûa Chaân Toâng: The teaching of            highest sense of the word, bereft of all false and the True Sect or Shingon.                                temporary nature (alaksana). This is, in truth, not Chaân Hoùa Nhò Thaân: Chaân thaân laø phaùp thaân vaø         non-existence but transcendental existence. This baùo thaân; vaø hoùa thaân laø öùng thaân—The true body       is also called the “Substratum of all” and can be is the dharmakaya and sambhogakaya, and the                   known only by a person of supreme knowledge. It transformation body is the nirmanakaya.                       represents merely the remainder after the Chaân Hueä (1434-1512): Master Jen-Hui—Teân                   elimination of the first two—See Tam Höõu. cuûa moät vò Taêng Nhaät Baûn, thuoäc Chaân Toâng             Chaân Hyû: Kalaruci (skt)—Kararuci (skt)—See (Chaân Toâng hay Tònh Ñoä Toâng cuûa ngaøi Chaân              Cöông Löông Laâu Chí. Loan saùng laäp taïi Nhaät Baûn vaøo naêm 1224)—              Chaân Khaû Thieàn Sö (1543-1603): Zen master Name of a Japanese monk, of the Shin School in                Jen-K'o—Teân cuûa moät vò Thieàn sö Trung Hoa vaøo Japan (the True Sect, or Shin Sect of Japan,                  thôøi nhaø Minh—Name of a Chinese Zen master in founded by Shinran in 1224 A.D.).                             the Ming dynasty (1368-1644). Chaân Hueä Tòch Tónh Phaùp Thaân: Nirvanic                    Chaân Khoâng: dharma-body of true wisdom—Thuaät ngöõ ñöôïc                  1) Shinku                (jap)—Emptiness—Wonderful ngaøi Theá Thaân duøng trong baøi thuyeát veà Tònh Ñoä              existence—Chaân khoâng khoâng coù nghóa laø ñeå dieãn taû chaân lyù toái thöôïng maø moïi söï thò hieän         troáng roãng, maø coù nghóa laø caùi khoâng maø röïc rôõ cuûa Phaät A Di Ñaø, cuûa cöïc laïc quoác ñoä vaø          khoâng phaûi laø khoâng; chaân khoâng laøm khôûi leân cuûa chö Boà Taùt ñi vaøo trong ñoù ñeàu hieån hieän—               dieäu höõu. Ngöôøi ta noùi chaân khoâng laø Nieát The term used by Vasubandhu in his discourse on                     Baøn cuûa Tieåu Thöøa (chaân khoâng töùc nieát baø n the Pure Land to describe the ultimate reality into                 dieät ñeá, chaúng phaûi giaû neân goïi laø chaân, lìa boû which all the glorious manifestations of Amitabha,                  haønh töôùng neân goïi laø khoâng)—True his Pure Land and Bodhisattvas enter.                               emptiness is not empty; it gives rise to Chaân Höu Chi Xöù: Thuaät ngöõ Thieàn aùm chæ choã                  wonderful existence. Wonderful existence ngöng nghæ cuûa taâm. Taâm coá ñònh vaø khoâng bò                   does not exists; it does not obstruct True khuaáy roái. Giai ñoaïn cuoái cuøng trong Baùt Thaùnh               Emptiness. From the void which seemingly Ñaïo—In Zen, the term means the resting place of                    contains nothing, absolutely everything

descends. The absolute void, completely               contrasted with phenomenon. However, true vacuity, said to be the nirvana of the                mark stands for true form, true nature, Buddha Hinayana.                                             nature always unchanging. True mark of all 2) (855-937) Master Jen-K'ung—Teân cuûa moät vò             phenomena is like space; always existing but danh Taêng Trieàu Tieân vaøo khoaûng giöõa nhöõng     really empty; although empty, really existing. theá kyû thöù IX vaø thöù X—Name of a famous 2) Khi nhìn ra khoaûng khoâng tröôùc maët, chuùng ta Korean monk between the ninth and tenth               cho raèng noù laø troáng khoâng, nhöng kyø thaät centuries.                                            trong ñoù coù khoâng khí vaø voâ soá buïi traàn. Ngaøy 3) (1204-1268): Master Jen-K'ung—Teân cuûa moät             nay ngöôøi ta tìm thaáy trong khoaûng khoâng aáy vò Taêng Nhaät Baûn, thuoäc Tam Luaän Toâng           nhöõng chaát khaùc nhö döôõng khí, ñaïm khí, vaø (Vaøo theá kyû thöù baûy, Hueä Quaùn, ngöôøi Cao      coù theå coù voâ soá vi khuaån nöõa. Hôn theá nöõa, Ly, ñoà ñeä cuûa Caùt Taïng, sang Nhaät naêm 625      caùc nhaø vaät lyù ñaõ tìm thaáy caùc tia vuõ truï, tia vaø giaûng giaùo lyù Tam Luaän taïi chuøa Nguyeân     soùng aâm thanh vaø nhieàu thöù khaùc maø chæ coù Höng ôû Naïi Löông. Ñaây laø söï truyeàn thöøa        caùc khoa hoïc gia môùi hieåu noåi. Ñieàu naøy cho Tam Luaän toâng ñaàu tieân taïi Nhaät Baûn)—          chuùng ta thaáy khoaûng chaân khoâng naøy dieäu Name of a Japanese monk, of the San Lun               höõu. Ñieàu naøy coøn cho chuùng ta thaáy khoaûng School in Japan (In the seventh century A.D.,         khoâng gian naøy khoâng phaûi laø troáng khoâng— Chi-Tsang’s Korean pupil, Hui-Kuan from               When we look at the open space right in front Kauli, a state in Korea, came to Japan in 625         of us, we say it’s empty space, but in fact, it and taught the Madhyamika doctrine at the             has air and numerous particles of dust in it. monastery Gwangoji in Nara. This is the first         Nowadays people find in it other substance transmission of Madhyamika to Japan).                 such as oxygen, nitrogen, and possibly Chaân Khoâng Baát Khoâng: Moïi hieän töôïng vaät            numerous bacteria. Furthermore, physicists chaát ñeàu khoâng coù thaät. Caùi gì laø theá giôùi hieän   have found cosmic rays, radio rays and many töôïng thì caùi ñoù laø Khoâng, caùi gì Khoâng thì caùi ñoù other things which only scientists can laø theá giôùi hieän töôïng—All physical phenomena          understand. This will tell us that the true void are unreal. What is the phenomenal world that is            is the mysteriously existing. This means that emptiness, what is emptiness that is the                    this this open space is far from empty. phenomenal world—See Saéc Töùc Thò Khoâng, 3) Chaúng phaûi hieän höõu maø cuõng chaúng phaûi Khoâng Töùc Thò Saéc.                                       khoâng hieän höõu: Futan-ku (jap)—Neither Chaân Khoâng Dieäu Höõu: True void is wonderful             existence nor nonexistence (the true nature or existence—The true void is the mysteriously                 Buddha-nature)—Baûn taùnh thaät cuûa caùc hieän existing—Truly void, or immaterial yet                      töôïng chaúng phaûi 'toàn taïi' hay 'khoâng toàn taïi', transcendentally existing—True emptiness—                   maø laø caû hai cuøng moät luùc, hoaëc khoâng phaûi laø Wonderful existence.                                        caùi naøo heát trong hai thöù ñoù, tuøy thuoäc vaøo 1) Taùnh coù nghóa laø tinh thaàn hay tinh yeáu; daáu       quan ñieåm cuûa mình. Löôùt qua Taâm kinh, hieäu coù nghóa laø töôùng. Taùnh vaø töôùng ñoái     baèng moät coâng thöùc ngaén Thieàn nhaán maïnh söï nghòch nhau, gioáng nhö tinh thaàn ñoái choïi vôùi    khoâng phaân bieät caùi tuyeät ñoái vaø töông ñoái, hieän töôïng. Tuy nhieân, thaät töôùng thaät taùnh    moät söï ñoàng nhaát vöôït khoûi moïi caùch hieåu hay Phaät taùnh thöôøng haèng khoâng thay ñoåi.       bieát theo lyù luaän vaø duy lyù: "Saéc töùc laø khoâng, Thaät taùnh cuûa theá giôùi hieän töôïng laø chaân    khoâng töùc laø saéc." Thaät vaäy, söï toång hôïp hình khoâng, thöôøng höõu maø hö voâ; tuy hö voâ nhöng     thöùc vaø hö khoâng khoâng theå hieåu ñöôïc baèng lyù thöôøng höõu (caùi khoâng chaúng phaûi laø khoâng,    luaän duy lyù; noù baát khaû tö nghì, vaø chæ coù theå caùi höõu chaúng phaûi laø höõu maø phaøm phu suy     nghieäm ñaïi giaùc saâu xa môùi cho pheùp chuùng ta nghó)—Nature means noumenon or essence;               hieåu ñöôïc noù—The true nature of all mark mean characteristics, forms or                   phenomena is neither existence nor physiognomy. Marks and nature are                     nonexistence, but rather both and yet neither, contrasted, in the same way noumenon is               depending on the viewpoint from which

phenomena are regarded. A glimpse of the                   maõi vôùi thaùi hö. OÂng coù bao giôø thaáy coù thöù gì laøm non-distinctiveness of relative and absolute,              trôû ngaïi thaùi hö ñöôïc chaêng? Tuy khoâng bò vaät trôû which transcends all logical or conceptual                 ngaïi, noù cuõng chaúng ngaên ngaïi caùc vaät ñi laï i trong comprehension, is provided by a short formula              noù (caùi Chaân khoâng Dieäu trí cuõng vaäy, sinh töû from the Heart Sutra: "Form is nothing other               phaøm thaùnh chaúng nhieãm tröôùc noù ñöôïc chuùt naøo; than emptiness, emptiness is nothing other                 tuy chaúng bò nhieãm tröôùc, nhöng noù cuõng chaúng than form." As a matter of fact, the unity of              ngaïi sinh töû phaøm thaùnh ñi laïi trong noù)"—The form and emptiness is not something that can               wisdom the knows clearly that nature means be reached by reasoning and thinking; it is                noumenon or essence; mark mean characteristics, inconceivable, and it can only be experienced              forms or physiognomy. Marks and nature are in profound enlightenment.                                 contrasted, in the same way noumenon is Chaân Khoâng Dieäu Trí: The true, void marvellous                contrasted with phenomenon. True mark of all wisdom—Trí thaáy roõ raèng taùnh coù nghóa laø tinh              phenomena is like space; always existing but thaàn hay tinh yeáu; daáu hieäu coù nghóa laø töôùng.            really empty; although empty, really existing. Taùnh vaø töôùng ñoái nghòch nhau, gioáng nhö tinh               When we look at the open space right in front of thaàn ñoái choïi vôùi hieän töôïng. Thaät taùnh cuûa theá        us, we say it’s empty space, but in fact, it has air giôùi hieän töôïng laø chaân khoâng, thöôøng höõu maø hö         and numerous particles of dust in it. Nowadays voâ; tuy hö voâ nhöng thöôøng höõu (caùi khoâng chaúng           people find in it other substance such as oxygen, phaûi laø khoâng, caùi höõu chaúng phaûi laø höõu maø phaøm      nitrogen, and possibly numerous bacteria. phu suy nghó). Khi nhìn ra khoaûng khoâng tröôùc                 Furthermore, physicists have found cosmic rays, maët, chuùng ta cho raèng noù laø troáng khoâng, nhöng           radio rays and many other things which only kyø thaät trong ñoù coù khoâng khí vaø voâ soá buïi traàn.       scientists can understand. This will tell us that the Ngaøy nay ngöôøi ta tìm thaáy trong khoaûng khoâng               true void is the mysteriously existing. This means aáy nhöõng chaát khaùc nhö döôõng khí, ñaïm khí, vaø coù         that this this open space is far from empty. In a theå coù voâ soá vi khuaån nöõa. Hôn theá nöõa, caùc nhaø        letter to respond to his disciple Tseng T'ien-yu, vaät lyù ñaõ tìm thaáy caùc tia vuõ truï, tia soùng aâm thanh    Zen master Hsu-yun wrote: "The one who vaø nhieàu thöù khaùc maø chæ coù caùc khoa hoïc gia môùi        distinguishes, judges, and makes decisions is hieåu noåi. Ñieàu naøy cho chuùng ta thaáy khoaûng chaân         sentient consciousness. This is the one who khoâng naøy dieäu höõu. Ñieàu naøy coøn cho chuùng ta            forever wanders in Samsara. Not being aware that thaáy khoaûng khoâng gian naøy khoâng phaûi laø troáng           this sentient consciousness is a dangerous pitfall, khoâng. Trong moät böùc thô traû lôøi cuûa Thieàn sö Hö          many Zen students nowadays cling to it and deem Vaân göûi cho Taêng Thieân Du, ngaøi ñaõ noùi: "Ngöôøi           it to be the Tao. They rise and fall like a piece of naøo duøng tình thöùc ñeå phaân bieät, phaùn ñoaùn vaø           driftwood in the sea. But if you can abruptly put quyeát ñònh, ngöôøi ñoù seõ traàm luaân troâi noåi trong         everything down, stripped of all thought and coõi ta baø vôùi caùi tình thöùc naøy. Khoâng yù thöùc ñöôïc     deliberation, suddenly you feel as if you had veà caùi tình thöùc naøy laø caùi haàm baãy nguy hieåm,          stumbled over a stone and stepped upon your own nhieàu Thieàn giaû ngaøy nay baùm víu vaøo noù maø cho           nose. Instantaneously you realize that this sentient laø Ñaïo. Hoï khôûi leân vaø chìm xuoáng gioáng nhö moät         consciousness is the true, void, marvellous mieáng vaùn troâi giaït giöõa bieån khôi. Neáu nhö oâng          wisdom itself. No other wisdom than this can be thình lình gaït boû ñöôïc moïi thöù, tuoät boû caû tö töôûng     obtained. This is like a man, in his confusion, vaø söï giaûi thoaùt, hoát nhieân oâng thaáy mình nhö trôït      mistakenly regarding the east as the west. But chaân daãm leân treân muõi mình. Ngay töùc khaéc luùc ñoù        when he awakens, he realizes that the west is the oâng nhaän ra raèng caùi tình thöùc ñoù töï noù laø caùi Chaân   east. There is no other east to be found. This true, khoâng dieäu trí, chöù khoâng coøn thöù gì khaùc nöõa ñeå        void, marvellous wisdom lives on eternally like maø ñaït ñöôïc. Nhö moät ngöôøi trong côn meâ loaïn              space. Have you ever seen anything that can xem ñoâng laø taây, kòp ñeán khi tænh nhaän ra raèng taây        impede space? Though it is not impeded by cuõng chính laø ñoâng, chaúng coøn coù ñoâng naøo khaùc          anything, neither does it hinder anything from ñeå tìm. Caùi Chaân khoâng Dieäu trí naøy cuøng soáng            moving on in its embrace."

Chaân Khoâng Giaùo: Khoâng Ñaïo—Path of                        taâm cuûa moät vò thaày ñaõ chöùng ñaéc. Chæ coù ngöôøi Emptiness.                                                     naøo khoâng coøn luyeán chaáp vaøo keát quaû cuûa haønh Chaân Khoâng Quaùn: Chaân khoâng quaùn laø phaùp               ñoäng môùi coù theå haønh xöû caùch naøy, vaø ngöôøi ta noùi quaùn Lyù phaùp giôùi. Ñaây laø caùch nhìn Phaùp Giôùi         voâ vi bieåu thò nhö laø söï hoaøn toaøn töï do cuûa haønh nhö laø söï hieån hieän cuûa nhaát taâm (ekacitta) hay         ñoäng thích öùng khoâng ngaên ngaïi tröôùc moïi hoaøn moät baûn theå cô baûn (ekadhatu). Ñaây laø theá giôùi theå    caûnh. Voâ vi laø phaùp xa lìa nhaân duyeân taïo taùc hay taùnh noùi veà caùc phaùp saéc vaø taâm cuûa chuùng sanh       khoâng coøn chòu aûnh höôûng cuûa nhaân duyeân. Haønh tuy coù sai khaùc nhöng cuøng chung moät theå taùnh.           giaû tu thieàn neân luoân nhôù raèng ‘voâ vi’ laø phaùp Ñaây laø theá giôùi cuûa lyù taéc. Noù ñöôïc Tam Luaän         thöôøng haèng, khoâng thay ñoåi, vöôït thôøi gian vaø Toâng vaø Phaùp Töôùng Toâng chuû xöôùng, daïy raèng lyù       sieâu vieät. Nieát Baøn vaø hö khoâng ñöôïc xem nhö laø taùch rôøi vôùi söï—Contemplation of emptiness or              Voâ Vi Phaùp. Noùi toùm laïi, voâ vi laø söï taïo taùc khoâng meditation on Emptiness is the idea of looking at              coù nhaân duyeân. Phaùp khoâng nhôø haønh ñoäng cuûa the Dharmadhatu as a manifestation of one spirit               thaân khaåu yù. Baát cöù phaùp naøo khoâng sanh, khoâng (ekacitta) or one elementary substance                         dieät, khoâng truï vaø khoâng bieán ñoåi ñích thöïc laø (ekadhatu). This is the noumenal realm, or                     phaùp voâ vi.” Ngaøi ñaõ toùm löôïc phaùp ngöõ luïc cuûa noumenal world. The Dharma Realm of                            mình qua nhöõng vaàn keä sau ñaây: Noumena, or the realm of principles. This is the                          “Dieäu baûn hö voâ minh töï khoa, world of principle or theorical world. It is                                Hoøa phong xuy khôûi bieán ta baø. represented by the Sam-Lun and Dharmalaksana                                Nhaân nhaân töï thöùc voâ vi laïc, Schools which teach that principle is separate                              Nhöôïc ñaéc voâ vi thuûy thò gia.” from facts—See Khoâng Quaùn.                                              (Dieäu baûn theânh thang roõ töï baøy, Chaân Khoâng Sinh Dieät: Vacuum Polarization—                              Gioù hoøa thoåi daäy bieán ta baø. Truøng truøng duyeân khôûi—Caùi naày coù thì caùi kia                      Ngöôøi ngöôøi nhaän ñöôïc voâ vi laïc, coù, caùi naày dieät thì caùi kia dieät.                                   Neáu ñöôïc voâ vi môùi laø nhaø). Chaân Khoâng Thieàn Sö: Zen Master Chaân Khoâng                A Vietnamese Zen master from Phuø Ñoång, Tieân (1045-1100)—Thieàn sö Vieät Nam, queâ ôû Phuø                  Du, North Vietnam. He left home at the age of 20. Ñoång, Tieân Du, Baéc Vieät. Naêm 20 tuoåi sö xuaát gia        First, he went to Tónh Löï Temple on Mount Ñoâng taïi chuøa Tónh Löï treân nuùi Ñoâng Cöùu. Ngaøi laø phaùp     Cöùu to stay there to practice meditation. He was töû ñôøi thöù 16 doøng Thieàn Tyø Ni Ña Löu Chi. Veà           the dharma heir of the sixteenth generation of the sau, ngaøi dôøi ñeán nuùi Töø Sôn vaø truï taïi ñaây vaøi      Vinitaruci Zen Sect. Later, he moved to Mount Töø naêm. Vua Lyù Nhaân Toâng göûi chieáu chæ trieäu hoài          Sôn and stayed there for several years. King Lyù ngaøi veà trieàu ñình thuyeát phaùp. Sö vaøo trong Ñaïi        Nhaân Toâng sent an Imperial Order to summon him noäi vaø thuyeát kinh Phaùp Hoa laøm thöùc tænh nhieàu         to the capital to preach Buddha Dharma to the ngöôøi. Sau ñoù sö veà truï taïi chuøa Chuùc Thaùnh treân      royal family. He went to the Great Citadel to nuùi Phaû Laïi. Moät ngaøy noï coù vò sö tôùi hoûi: “Theá      preach the Lotus sutra to awaken many people. naøo laø dieäu ñaïo?” Sö ñaùp: “Haõy ngoä ñi roài seõ          Later, he stayed at Chuùc Thaùnh Temple on Mount bieát!” Khi veà giaø, sö trôû veà queâ höông truøng tu         Phaû Laïi. One day, a monk came to ask him: “What chuøa Baûo Caûm vaø truï taïi ñaây tieáp tuïc hoaèng hoùa      is the wonderful way?” He replied: “When you Phaät giaùo cho ñeán khi thò tòch vaøo naêm 1100, thoï         obtain enlightenment, you will know it by 55 tuoåi. Ngaøi thöôøng daïy ñeä töû: “Voâ vi coù nghóa        yourself.” When he was old, he returned to his ñen laø ‘khoâng gaéng söùc,’ hay ‘khoâng göôïng eùp,’          home district to rebuild Baûo Caûm Temple and hay ‘khoâng mieãn cöôõng taïo taùc.’ Noù khoâng aùm chæ        stayed there to revive and expand Buddhism until söï baát ñoäng hay löôøi bieáng. Haønh giaû tu Thieàn chæ      he passed away in 1100, at the age of 55. He khoâng neân gaéng söùc vì nhöõng vieäc khoâng chaân            always taught his disciples: “‘Non-doing’ means thaät, laøm cho chuùng ta hoùa muø ñeán noãi khoâng thaáy      ‘non-striving’ or ‘not making.’ It does not imply ñöôïc töï taùnh. Ñaây laø moät khaùi nieäm cuûa Thieàn veà     inaction or mere idling. We are merely to cease haønh ñoäng töùc thôøi, chöù khoâng coù vaán ñeà chuaån bò     striving for the unreal things which blind us to our tröôùc, thuaät ngöõ naøy ñöôïc xem nhö laø söï dieãn taû veà   true self. This is a Zen notion of acting

spontaneously, without premeditation, considered          cho vaøng roøng maát maøu—Pure gold loses color, to be an expression of the mind of an awakened            i.e., an enlightened practitioner has the power to master. Only a person who is unattached to the            cause pure gold to lose its color. result of actions is able to act in this way, and it is   Chaân Kim Töôïng: 1) Moät pho töôïng baèng vaøng characterized as perfect freedom of action that           roøng: An image of pure gold; 2) Thaân Phaät: The responds without hesitation to circumstances.             body of the Buddha. ‘Non-action’ means anything that is not subject to        Chaân Kinh: True sutras—Thöïc Kinh—Thöïc kinh cause, condition or dependence. Practitioners             ñoái laïi vôùi quyeàn kinh (theo Kinh Trung A Haøm: should always remember that ‘non-action’                  “Con ngöôøi coi luyeán aùi laø moùn aên, luyeán aùi coi voâ dharmas are out of time, eternal, inactive,               minh laø moùn aên, voâ minh coi nguõ caùi laø moùn aên, unchanging, and supra-mundane. Nirvana and                baát tín coi aùc phaùp laø moùn aên, bieån caû coi soâng lôùn space are considered to be unconditioned                  laø moùn aên, soâng lôùn coi soâng nhoû laø moùn aên, khe dharmas. In short, unconditioned dharmas are              suoái, ao ñaàm coi gioït möa laø moùn aên)—As things that are not being produced or non-                contrasted to the relative or temporary sutras, a causative. Whatever dharmas lack production,              term of the Lotus school. cessation,       abiding,     and      change       are   Chaân Loan: Shinran (jap)—Thaân Loan (1173- ‘unconditioned.’” He summarized his teachings in          1262)—The founder of Jodoshinshu—Toå sö phaùi the following verses:                                     Chaân Toâng ôû Nhaät. “Wonderful originally,                               Chaân Lyù: Sacca (p)—Satya (skt)—Sutyata (skt)— the emptiness manifests itself visibly.            Truth—Suchness—True emptiness— The true A peaceful wind blows and creates                  principle—The principle of truth—The absolute all the universe.                                  apart from phenomena—Chaân lyù laø leõ töï nhieân, Should all human beings know                       khoâng choái caõi ñöôïc. Chaân lyù chính laø nguyeân the bliss of non-action,                           nhaân dieät tröø khoå ñau. Trong Phaät Giaùo Ñaïi Thöøa, For attaining the non-action is being              chaân lyù ñöôïc noùi trong Kinh Lieân Hoa vaø Hoa in real home.”                                     Nghieâm. Theo Tam Phaùp Ñoä Luaän, chaân lyù coù Chaân Kieán: Dris-tattva (skt)—True perceiving.           nghóa thöïc höõu, chaân, baát hö vaø nhö thò; ñoù goïi laø Chaân Kieán Ñaïo: Giaùc ngoä ñöôïc caùi lyù chaân nhö     chaân lyù. Trong Töù A Haøm Moä Sao Giaûi coù chöùa voâ phaân bieät—The realization of reality in the         ñöïng moät ñoaïn ngaén veà tam ñeá: "Chaân lyù goàm coù absolute as whole and undivided.                          nghóa cuûa theá gian höõu töôùng vaø nghóa ñeä nhaát. Chaân Kim: Vaøng roøng—Pure gold.                         Kinh noùi: 'Chaân lyù theá tuïc, chaân lyù cuûa hình töôùng, Chaân Kim Phoá: Tieäm baùn vaøng roøng, yù khen ngôïi     vaø chaân lyù toái thöôïng'"—True teachings. The truth thieàn phong quyù nhö vaøng roøng. Theo Truyeàn           is the destructive cause of pain. In Mahayana, true Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån XIV, trong moät böùc thö, Thieàn       teachings primarily refer to those of Lotus and sö Döôïc Sôn Duy Nghieãm noùi: "Thaïch Ñaàu laø           Avatamsaka Sutras. Expedient teachings include Chaân Kim Phoá, coøn Giang Taây laø tieäm baùn taïp       all other teachings. According to the Treatise on hoùa"—Pure gold shop, i.e., Zen manner or Zen             liberation in three parts, truth means that which is style is as precious as pure gold. According to The       actually existent, real, not nothingness and Records of the Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-          Thusness; therefore, it is called "truth." The Teng-Lu), Volume XIV, in a letter, Zen master             Summary of the four Agamas (Ssu EÂ Han Mu Yueh-Shan-Wei-Yen (745-828 or 750-834) wrote:             Ch'ao Chieh) contains a short reference to three "Shih-tou is a Pure gold shop, while Jiang-Hsi Ma-        truths: "Truth includes that of mundane plurality, tsu is a Sundry goods store."                             that which has marks, and that of supreme Chaân Kim Sôn: 1) Moät traùi nuùi baèng vaøng roøng: A    meaning. A Sutra says 'The truth of mundane moutain of pure gold; 2) Thaân Phaät: Buddha’s            plurality, the truth of marks, and the truth of body.                                                     supreme meaning'." Chaân Kim Thaát Saéc: Vaøng roøng maát maøu, yù noùi      Chaân Lyù Baùt Nhaõ: The Prajna-Truth—Sau thôøi ngöôøi tu thieàn ngoä ñaïo coù söùc maïnh coù theå laøm   Luïc Toå Hueä Naêng, Thieàn daàn daàn ñaõ trôû thaønh

moät "Ngheä thuaät," moät ngheä thuaät ñoäc nhaát ñeå          thoaùt ra. Hai hình aûnh naøy mieâu taû moät caùch linh truyeàn Chaân lyù Baùt Nhaõ, nhö taát caû nhöõng ngheä         ñoäng caùi baûn tính eo heïp, böng bít vaø chaáp tröôùc thuaät vó ñaïi, töø choái khoâng chòu theo moät hình           cuûa taâm trí con ngöôøi. Vôùi tính chaát haïn heïp vaø thöùc, khuoân maãu, hay heä thoáng nhaát ñònh naøo             böng bít ñaùng thöông naøy baét reã saâu xa trong loái trong vieäc bieåu hieän. Thaùi ñoä phoùng khoaùng ñaëc         suy töôûng cuûa con ngöôøi, khoâng laï gì caùi Chaân lyù bieät naøy phaùt sinh ra nhöõng caùch bieåu thò quaù           Baùt Nhaõ töï do vaø bao haøm taát caû trôû neân moät chieác khích vaø ñoâi khi "hoang daïi" ñoù cuûa Thieàn, goùp          boùng maõi maõi treo lô löûng trong söï coá naém baét cuûa phaàn lôùn lao cho tính phöùc taïp vaø khoù hieåu cuûa         con ngöôøi—After the period of the Sixth Patriarch vaán ñeà. Haønh giaû tu Thieàn neân luoân nhôù raèng           Hui-neâng (638-713), Zen gradually became an Chaân lyù Baùt Nhaõ cöùu caùnh maø Thieàn coá gaéng            "Art", a unique art for transmitting the Prajna- chuyeån taûi khoâng theå naøo coù theå laø moät caùi gì heïp   Truth, refusing, as all great arts do, to follow any hoøi, höõu haïn hoaëc chuyeân bieät; noù phaûi laø moät caùi   set form, pattern, or system in expressing itself. gì bao la, ñaïi ñoàng vaø voâ haïn, haøm chöùa taát caû vaø    This exceptionally liberal attitude gave birth to bao truøm taát caû; khoâng theå ñònh nghóa vaø meänh           those radical and sometimes "wild' Zen danh ñöôïc. Ñoù laø lyù do taïi sao Chaân lyù Baùt Nhaõ        expressions, which also contribute so greatly to cöùu caùnh Thieàn laø khoâng theå ñònh nghóa cuõng             the complexity and incomprehensibility of the khoâng theå laõnh hoäi ñöôïc baèng phaøm trí. Caùi baûn        subject. Zen practitioners should always chaát khoâng theå ñònh nghóa vaø khoâng theå laõnh hoäi        remember that the ultimate Prajna-Truth that Zen naøy cuûa Chaân lyù Thieàn ñöôïc giaûi minh raát roõ raøng     tries to convey cannot be a thing that is narrow, trong nhöõng coâng aùn theo sau ñaây. Theo Kinh                finite, or exclusive; it must be something vast, Phaùp Baûo Ñaøn, chöông baûy, Nam Nhaïc Hoaøi                  universal, and infinite; all-inclusive and all- Nhöôïng ñeán Taøo Kheâ tham vaán Luïc Toå Hueä                 embracing; defying definition and designation. Naêng. Toå hoûi: “ÔÛ ñaâu ñeán?” Sö thöa: “ÔÛ Tung Sôn         That's why the ultimate Prajna-Truth cannot be ñeán.” Toå hoûi: “Maø vaät gì ñeán?” Sö thöa: “Noùi in         defined and grasped by ordinary intellect. This tuoàng moät vaät töùc khoâng truùng.” Toå hoûi: “Laïi coù      indefinable and ungraspable nature of Zen-truth is theå tu chöùng chaêng?” Sö thöa: “Tu chöùng töùc               well illustrated in the following koans. According chaúng khoâng, nhieãm oâ töùc chaúng ñöôïc.” Toå noùi:         to the Flatform Sutra, Chapter Seven, Nan-Yueh “Chính caùi khoâng nhieãm oâ naày laø choã hoä nieäm cuûa      came to Tsao-Xi to study with Hui-Neng. Hui- chö Phaät, ngöôøi ñaõ nhö theá, ta cuõng nhö theá. Toå         Neng said to Nan-Yueh: “Where did you come Baùt Nhaõ Ña La ôû Taây Thieân coù lôøi saám raèng:            from?” Nan-Yueh said: “From Mount Song.” Hui- ‘Döôùi chaân ngöôi seõ xuaát hieän NHAÁT MAÕ CAÂU              Neng said: “What is it that thus come?” Nan-Yueh (con ngöïa tô) ñaïp cheát ngöôøi trong thieân haï. ÖÙng        couldn’t answer. After eight years, Nan-Yueh taïi taâm ngöôi chaúng caàn noùi sôùm.’” Vaø ñaây laø moät     suddenly attained enlightenment. He informed the coâng aùn khaùc: Phoù Ñaïi Só noùi trong baøi keä noåi         Sixth Patriarch of this, saying: “I have an tieáng cuûa ngaøi:                                             understanding.” The Sixth Patriarch said: “What is "Khoâng thuû baû xöø ñaàu;                          it?” Nan-Yueh said: “To say it’s a thing misses the Boä haønh kî thuûy ngöu;                          mark.” The Sixth Patriarch said: “Then can it be Nhaân tuøng kieàu thöôïng quaù.                   made evident or not?” Nan-Yueh said: “I don’t say Kieàu löu thuûy baát löu."                        it can’t be made evident, but it can’t be defiled.” (Tay khoâng, caàm caùn mai;                        The Sixth Patriarch said: “Just this that is Ñi boä, löng traâu ngoài;                         undefiled is what is upheld and sustained all Ngöôøi ñi qua treân caàu.                         Buddhas. You are thus. I am also thus. Caàu troâi nöôùc chaúng troâi!)                   “Prajnadhara has foretold that from beneath your Thaät vaäy, theo Chang Chen-Chi trong quyeån                   feet will come a horse which will trample to "Thieàn Ñaïo Tu Taäp," ngay chöõ "ñònh nghóa" khieán           death everyone in the world. Bear this in mind but chuùng ta lieân töôûng ñeán moät ngoùn tay chæ vaøo moät       don’t soon repeat it.” And here is another koan: Fu ñoái töôïng ñaëc thuø, vaø chöõ "laõnh hoäi," gôïi yù moät     Ta Shih said in his famous stanza: baøn tay caàm chaéc moät caùi gì khoâng ñeå cho noù                 "Empty-handed I go,

but a spade is in my hand;                              which was immediately followed a blow and this: I walk on my feet,                                      "Impossible it is to fix nails onto vacuity of space." yet I am riding on the back of a bull;                  Zen practitioners should always remember that When I pass over the bridge,                            the ultimate truth that Zen tries to convey cannot The bridge, but not the water, flows!"                  be a thing that is narrow, finite, or exclusive; it As a matter of fact, according to Chang Chen-Chi               must be something vast, universal, and infinite; in the "Practice of Zen (p.17)," the very word                 all-inclusive and all-embracing; defying definition "defining" suggests a finger pointing to a                     and designation. That's why the ultimate truth particular object, and the word "grasping", a hand             cannot be defined and grasped by ordinary holding something tightly and not letting it go.               intellect. These two pictures vividly portray the narrow,                 Chaân Lyù Nhaát Ñeá: One truth—Caùi taïm goïi laø tight, and clinging nature of the human mind. With             chaân lyù coù voâ löôïng traïng thaùi khaùc nhau. Coù khi this deplorable limitation and tightness deeply                noù ñöôïc goïi laø nhaát ñeá: chaân lyù nhö ñöôïc hieåu bôûi rooted in the human way of thinking, no wonder                 ngöôøi khoâng coøn voïng nieäm. Chæ coù moät chaân lyù the free and all-inclusive Prajna-Truth becomes an             bôûi vì khoâng coù caùi thöù hai—That which is evasive shadow forever eluding one's graps.                    conventionally called truth has innumerable Chaân Lyù Cöùu Caùnh: Parayana (skt)—Ultimate                  varieties. At times one truth is established: reality truth—Chaân lyù toái thöôïng thöøa—Moät vò Taêng ñeán          as perceived by one who has no delusions. There gaëp Thieàn sö Laâm Teá vaø hoûi: "Chaân lyù cöùu caùnh        is only one truth because there is no second. cuûa ñaïo Phaät laø gì?" Laâm Teá lieàn quaùt leân! Vò         Chaân Lyù Nhò Ñeá: Two truths—Caùi taïm goïi laø Taêng leã baùi. Thieàn sö Laâm Teá noùi moät caùch chaâm       chaân lyù coù voâ löôïng traïng thaùi khaùc nhau. Coù khi bieám: "Vò sö huynh ñaùng kính naøy coù theå giöõ vöõng        noù ñöôïc goïi laø nhò ñeá: theá tuïc ñeá vaø thaéng nghóa laäp tröôøng trong tranh bieän." Vò Taêng hoûi: "Thaày         ñeá—That which is conventionally called truth has chôi aâm ñieäu gì vaäy? vaø Thaày thuoäc tröôøng phaùi         innumerable varieties. At times two truths are naøo?" Laâm Teá noùi: "Khi laõo Taêng ôû nôi cuûa Hoaøng       established: worldly truth and the truth of supreme Baù, laõo Taêng hoûi Thaày moät caâu hoûi ba laàn vaø caû ba   meaning. laàn laõo Taêng ñeàu bò thaày ñaùnh." Vò Taêng chaàn chöø.     Chaân Lyù Quy Öôùc: Sammuti-sacca (p)— Thaáy theá Thieàn sö Laâm Teá beøn quaùt leân roài laäp töùc   Samvr(i)ti-Satya (skt)—Tuïc Ñeá—Conventional ñaùnh vaø noùi: "Khoâng theå naøo ñaët moùng tay vaøo hö       truth—Mundane truth—Ordinary truth—Relative khoâng ñöôïc." Haønh giaû tu Thieàn neân luoân nhôù raèng      truth—Superficial truth, or ordinary ideas of Chaân lyù Cöùu Caùnh cöùu caùnh maø Thieàn coá gaéng           things—Worldly truth—Tuïc ñeá chæ söï vaät chæ ñuùng chuyeån taûi khoâng theå naøo coù theå laø moät caùi gì heïp   treân möùc ñoä hieåu bieát bình thöôøng vaø thöïc taïi cuûa hoøi, höõu haïn hoaëc chuyeân bieät; noù phaûi laø moät caùi   caùc hieän töôïng—Conventional truths refer to gì bao la, ñaïi ñoàng vaø voâ haïn, haøm chöùa taát caû vaø    things that are true on the level of ordinary bao truøm taát caû; khoâng theå ñònh nghóa vaø meänh           perceptions and phenomenal reality. danh ñöôïc. Ñoù laø lyù do taïi sao Chaân lyù cöùu caùnh       Chaân Lyù Tam Chuûng: Three kinds of truth— Thieàn laø khoâng theå ñònh nghóa cuõng khoâng theå            Trong Tam Phaùp Ñoä Luaän coù moät ñoaïn vaên noùi laõnh hoäi ñöôïc baèng phaøm trí—A monk came to                raèng: "Coù ba loaïi chaân lyù: chaân lyù ña nguyeân, chaân see Zen master Lin-chi and asked: "What is the                 lyù saéc töôùng, vaø chaân lyù ñeä nhaát." Trong Töù A ultimate truth of Buddhism?" The master gave a                 Haøm Moä Sao Giaûi coù chöùa ñöïng moät ñoaïn ngaén "kwatz!" The monk bowed. The master said                       veà tam ñeá: "Chaân lyù goàm coù nghóa cuûa theá gian sarcastically: "The venerable brother can hold his             höõu töôùng vaø nghóa ñeä nhaát. Kinh noùi: 'Chaân lyù theá point in controversy." The monk asked: "Whose                  tuïc, chaân lyù cuûa hình töôùng, vaø chaân lyù toái tune do you play? and to what school do you                    thöôïng'." Moãi thöù trong ba chaân lyù naøy ñöôïc giaûi belong?" The master said, "When I was at Huang-                laøm ba phaàn. Ñaúng ñeá ñöôïc giaûi thích nhö coõi theá po, I asked him a question three times and was                 tuïc, gia ñình vaø giaùo duïc. Choã naøy töông hôïp vôùi struck by him three times." The monk hesitated.                hieän höõu giaû taïm trong ñôøi soáng haèng ngaøy, vaø söï Thereupon, the master gave him another "kwatz!"                chaáp nhaän caùi nhìn töông ñoái hôïp lyù. Thöù nhì laø

chaân lyù cuûa saéc töôùng goàm ba phaàn thuoäc Töù Dieäu     innumerable varieties. At times three truths are Ñeá: khoå, taäp vaø ñaïo. Ñaây goïi laø chaân lyù cuûa hình   established: the truth of marks, the truth of words, töôùng vì noùi ñeán vieäc quaùn chieáu hình töôùng hoaëc      and the truth of activity. söï thöïc, vöôït luaân hoài sanh töû, chöùng ngoä khoå ñeá,   Chaân Lyù Thieàn: The truth of Zen—Haønh giaû tu taäp ñeá vaø ñaïo ñeá. Phaàn thöù tö cuûa Töù Dieäu Ñeá laø   Thieàn neân luoân nhôù raèng Thieàn khoâng phaûi laø caùi dieät ñeá, ñöôïc giaûi thích laø voâ töôùng, vì vaäy khoâng   gì phöùc taïp, hoaëc laø moät söï nghieân cöùu ñoøi hoûi naèm trong phaïm vi töôùng maïo. Chaân lyù ñeä nhaát          giaùc quan coù söï tröøu töôïng cao nhaát. Chaân lyù vaø nghóa goàm coù ba phaàn: tònh thaân, tònh khaåu vaø tònh      söùc maïnh cuûa Thieàn chính laø söï ñôn giaûn, tröïc tieáp yù. Thaân chæ cho nhöõng hoaït ñoäng sinh vaät lyù, khaåu     vaø thöïc tieãn. Tyû nhö, khi baïn gaëp moät ngöôøi, chæ chæ cho lôøi noùi vaø yù chæ cho töï töôûng. Nhö vaäy         ñôn giaûn chaøo vaø hoûi "hoâm nay anh coù khoeû thanh tònh taát caû ba maët naøy laø ñeä nhaát nghóa—In       khoâng?" Ngöôøi aáy seõ noùi "Toâi khoûe, caùm ôn anh." the Treatise on liberation in three parts contains a          Ñaây chính laø Thieàn. Hay khi baïn gaëp moät ngöôøi commentary, sayings: "There are three types of                baïn, lieàn môøi ngöôøi aáy uoáng moät taùch traø, ñaây truth: the truth of plurality, the truth of marks, and        cuõng traøn ñaày yù Thieàn. Hay khi baïn ñoùi buïng, lieàn the truth of supreme meaning." The Summary of                 tìm caùi gì ñoù ñeå aên, töùc laø baïn ñang haønh Thieàn the four Agamas (Ssu EÂ Han Mu Ch'ao Chieh)                   moät caùch troïn veïn. Khoâng coøn thöù gì khaùc töï nhieân contains a short reference to three truths: "Truth            hôn nhö theá ñöôïc; ñieàu duy nhaát chuùng ta phaûi laøm includes that of mundane plurality, that which has            laø môû maét ra ñeå thaáy ñöôïc yù nghóa tieàm taøng cuûa marks, and that of supreme meaning. A Sutra says              vaïn höõu. Tuy nhieân, haønh giaû tu Thieàn phaûi luoân 'The truth of mundane plurality, the truth of marks,          caån troïng veà vaán ñeà naøy. Thieàn khoâng theå vaø and the truth of supreme meaning'." These three               khoâng bao giôø ñöôïc laãn loän vôùi chuû nghóa töï nhieân truths are each explained in three parts. First, the          hay söï buoâng thaû khoâng boù buoäc naøo, nghóa laø con truth of plurality is explained as the realm of the           ngöôøi buoâng troâi theo taäp khí töï nhieân maø khoâng mundane, the family, and the education. This                  ñaët nghi vaán veà giaù trò vaø nguoàn goác cuûa söï vieäc. corresponds to the conventional world of everyday             Coù söï khaùc bieät lôùn giöõa haønh vi cuûa ñoäng vaät vaø existence and the acceptance                      of the      cuûa con ngöôøi, haønh vi cuûa ñoäng vaät thì thieáu haún commonsensical view of reality. Second, the truth             ñaïo ñöùc tröïc giaùc vaø söï hieåu bieát veà toân giaùo. of marks consists of three parts of the Four Noble            Ñoäng vaät khoâng bieát gì veà chuyeän töï coá gaéng caûi Truths: suffering, the cause of suffering, and the            thieän hoaøn caûnh hay tieán boä treân ñöôøng ñi ñeán ñöùc Path. This is called the "truth of marks" because it          haïnh cao hôn. Theo Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån VI, refers to contemplating the marks or                          moät hoâm Thaïch Cuûng Hueä Taïng ñang laøm vieäc characteristics of reality, the transiency of samaric         trong nhaø beáp, Thieàn sö Maõ Toå Ñaïo Nhaát, thaày existence, and realizing the truth of suffering, the          cuûa Thaïch Cuûng, ñeán hoûi oâng ñang laøm caùi gì vaäy. cause of suffering, and the way to liberation. The            Thaïch Cuûng traû lôøi: "Chaên traâu." Thaày hoûi: "Chaên fourth Noble Truth, that of the extinction of                 nhö theá naøo?" Thaïch Cuûng ñaùp: "Moãi khi traâu ñi suffering, is explained as having no marks, and               leäch daàu chæ moät laàn, con lieàn keùo muõi traâu laïi." therefore does not correspond to the realm of                 Maõ Toå noùi: "OÂng ñuùng laø keû chaên traâu." Theo marks. Third, the truth of supreme meaning also               Thieàn sö D.T. Suzuki trong quyeån "Thieàn Hoïc has three parts: it consists of the complete                  Nhaäp Moân," ñaây khoâng phaûi laø chuû nghóa töï nhieân, cessation of action, words, and thoughts. Action              maø ñaây laø duïng coâng tu taäp. Ñaây chính laø chaân lyù corresponds to physical activity, words to verbal             Thieàn—Zen          practitioners      should     always activity, and thoughts to mental activity. Thus the           remember that Zen is not a very complicated cessation of all activity is the realm of supreme             affair, or a study requiring the highest faculty of truth.                                                        abstraction and speculation. The truth and power Chaân Lyù Tam Ñeá: Three truths—Caùi taïm goïi laø            of Zen consists in its very simplicity, directness, chaân lyù coù voâ löôïng traïng thaùi khaùc nhau. Coù khi     and utmost practicalness. For instance, when you noù ñöôïc goïi laø Tam ñeá: töôùng ñeá, ngöõ ñeá vaø haønh    see another person, just simply say hello, good ñeá—That which is conventionally called truth has             morning, and ask "how are you today?" That

person will say "I am fine, thanh you." This is Zen.              cause of ignorance, and the truth of extinction of Or, when you see a friend, you invite that friend to              ignorance, and the truth of of Path. have a cup of tea, this, again, is full of Zen. Or,               Chaân Lyù Töï Minh: Obvious truth—Self-evident when you are hungry, you find something to eat,                   truth. you have been acting Zen to its fullest extent.                   Chaân Lyù Töông Ñoái: Kun sop (tib)—Relative Nothing could be more natural; the one thing                      truth. needful is just to open your eye to the latent                    Chaân Lyù Töông Ñoái-Chaân Lyù Tuyeät Ñoái: (concealed or hidden) significance of it all.                     Relative truth-Absolute truth—Theo chaân lyù töông However, Zen practitioners should always be                       ñoái thì taát caû caùc söï vaät ñeàu hieän höõu, nhöng trong careful on this matter. Zen cannot and can never                  chaân lyù tuyeät ñoái thì khoâng coù gì hieän höõu caû; be confused with naturalism or libertinism, which                 trong chaân lyù tuyeät ñoái, ngöôøi ta thaáy raèng taát caû means to follow one's natural bent without                        caùc söï vaät ñeàu khoâng coù töï tính, nhöng trong chaân questioning its origin and value. There is a great                lyù töông ñoái coù moät söï nhaän thöùc choã naøo khoâng difference between human action and that of the                   coù töï tính—According to relative truth all things animals, which are lacking in moral intuition and                 exist, but in absolute truth nothing is; in absolute religious consciousness. The animals do not know                  truth one sees that all things are devoid of self- anything about exerting themselves in order to                    nature; however, in relative truth, a perception improve their conditions or to progress in the way                where there is no self-nature. to higher virtues. According to the Records of the                Chaân Minh: 1) Trí tueä baùt nhaõ hay trí hueä cuûa söï Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu),                        giaùc ngoä chaân lyù ñoái laïi vôùi hình töôùng beân ngoaøi: Volume VI, one day Shih-kung was working in the                   The truth wisdom: Buddha-illumination, true kitchen when Zen master Ma-tsu Tao-i, his                         knowledge or enlightenment (in regard to reality master, came in and asked what he was doing. "I                   in contrast with appearance); 2) See Chaùnh Trí. am herding the cow," said Shih-kung. The master                   Chaân Moân: The gateway of truth or reality. asked, "How do you attend her?" Shih-kung                         Chaân Naêng Laäp: Phöông phaùp cuûa nhaân minh replied, "If she goes out of the path even once, I                luaän, coù ñaày ñuû chính nhaân vaø chính duï ñeå thaønh pull her back straightway by the nose; not a                      laäp toân phaùp goïi laø naêng laäp—A proposition in moment's delay is allowed." Said the master, "You                 logic that can be established, or postulated. truly know how to take care of her." According to                 Chaân Naêng Phaù: Invalid proposition—Coù theå phaù Zen master Daisetz Teitaro Suzuki in "An                          boû ñi ñöôïc; ñaây laø moät trong taùm phaùp moân hay Introduction To Zen Buddhism," this is not                        taùm lyù luaän khoân ngoan trong lyù luaän Phaät giaùo — naturalism. Here is an effort to do the right thing.              This is one of the eight kinds of syllogisms in This is the truth of Zen.                                         Buddhist logic—See Baùt Moân. Chaân Lyù Thieàn Sö: Teân cuûa moät vò Thieàn sö Vieät            Chaân Ngaõ: Mahatman (skt)—Parmatman (skt)— Nam vaøo theá kyû thöù XVII, thuoäc Thieàn phaùi Truùc            Intrinsic essence—Transcendental ego—True Laâm, queâ ôû Hueá, Trung Vieät—Name of a                         selfness—See Chaân Ngaõ Dieän. Vietnamese Zen master in the seventeenth                          Chaân Ngaõ Dieän: Boä maët thaät cuûa Chaân Ngaõ—The century, of the Ch'u-Lin Sect. He came from Hue,                  real face of our real self—Chaân ngaõ hay Nieát Baøn Central Vietnam.                                                  ngaõ cuûa chö Phaät, töùc laø caùi ngaõ sieâu vieät, ñoái laïi Chaân Lyù Tuyeät Ñoái: Söï thaät tuyeät ñoái—Absolute             vôùi voïng ngaõ cuûa phaøm phu. Caùi ngaõ maø ngoaïi truth.                                                            ñaïo cho laø thöïc, Phaät giaùo thì cho laø giaû ngaõ. Chaân Lyù Töù Ñeá: Four truths—Caùi taïm goïi laø chaân           Trong quyeån Coát Loõi Thieàn, Thieàn sö Laâm Teá noùi: lyù coù voâ löôïng traïng thaùi khaùc nhau. Coù khi noù           "Neáu baïn muoán töï do, haõy coá nhaän ra chaân ngaõ ñöôïc goïi laø töù ñeá: khoå ñeá, taäp ñeá, dieät ñeá, vaø ñaïo   cuûa baïn, noù khoâng coù hình töôùng, khoâng coù ngoaïi ñeá—That which is conventionally called truth has                 dieän, khoâng goác reã, khoâng caên baûn, khoâng nôi truù innumerable varieties. At times four truths are                   nguï, nhöng noù vaãn soáng ñoäng vaø beành boàng. Noù established: the truth of ignorance, the truth of                 deã daøng ñaùp öùng vôùi nhöõng thay ñoåi, nhöng chöùc naêng cuûa noù khoâng theå ñöôïc xaùc ñònh. Vì vaäy, khi

baïn tìm noù baïn seõ xa caùch noù; khi baïn ñuoåi theo        2) Ñeä Nhò Toå: Ngaøi Kim Cang Taùt Ñoûa Boà noù, baïn seõ caøng quay löng laïi vôùi noù."—The real              Taùt—The second patriarch, The imaginary or nirvana ego, the transcendental ego, as                          Bodhisattva Vajrasattva. contrasted with the illusory or temporal ego. The              3) Ñeä Tam Toå: Ngaøi Long Thoï Boà Taùt —The ego as considered real by non-Buddhists. In Zen                     third patriarch, Nagarjuna Bodhisattva. Essence, Zen Master Linji said, "If you want to be             4) Ñeä Töù Toå: Ngaøi Long Trí Boà Taùt —The fourth free, get to know your real self. It has no form, no                patriarch, Dragon-wisdom Bodhisattva. appearance, no root, no basis, no abode, but is                5) Ñeä Nguõ Toå: Ngaøi Kim Cang Trí Taïng Boà lively and buoyant. It responds with versatile                      Taùt—The       fifth     patriarch,     Vajramati facility, but its function cannot be located.                       Bodhisattva. Therefore when you look for it you become                      6) Ñeä Luïc Toå: Ngaøi Baát Khoâng Tam Taïng Boà further from it, when you seek it you turn away                     Taùt—The sixth patriarch, Amoghavajra from it all the more."                                              Bodhisattva. Chaân Ngoân: Dharani (skt)—Chen-yen (chi)—                     7) Ñeä Thaát Toå: Ngaøi Hueä Quaû—The seventh Sacred formula—Maïn Ñaùt La—Maïn Ñoà La—Ñaø                         patriarch, Hui-Kuo. La Ni Chuù Minh—Thaàn Chuù—Chaân ngoân laø ngöõ                8) Ñeä Baùt Toå: Ngaøi Khoâng Haûi (Nhaät Baûn)— maät trong tam maät cuûa Ñöùc Nhö Lai, chæ rieâng                   The eighth patriarch, K’ung-Hai (Japan). thuyeát phaùp cuûa phaùp thaân Phaät (coøn goïi laø bí maät    Chaân Ngoân Baùt Toå Töông Thöøa: See Chaân Ngoân hieäu, maät ngoân, maät ngöõ, chuù minh). Chaân Ngoân laø      Baùt Toå. tieáng dòch töø Phaïn ngöõ “Mantra,” coù nghóa laø             Chaân Ngoân Bí Maät: Nhaát ngöõ bí maät cuûa Nhö “chuù” ñöôïc duøng trong Phaät Giaùo Maät Toâng.               Lai, moät trong tam maät cuûa Ñöùc Phaät (baûn taùnh bí Truyeàn thoáng naøy ñöôïc ngaøi Thieän Voâ UÙy truyeàn         maät cuûa chuù vaø ñaø la ni)—The mystic nature of sang Trung Hoa vaøo theá kyû thöù taùm vaø coù moät thôøi      the mantras and dharanis; one of three esoteric gian ngaén raát phoå caäp döôùi thôøi nhaø Ñöôøng, nhöng       things of the Buddha. veà sau naøy bò taøn luïn khoâng coøn laø moät tröôøng phaùi   Chaân Ngoân Chæ Quaùn: Shingon-Shikan-no-Gyo rieâng bieät ôû Trung Hoa nöõa. Tuy nhieân, noù ñöôïc          (jap)—The use of a mantra is characteristic of the Kukai truyeàn sang Nhaät Baûn vaø vaãn coøn tieáp tuïc         esoteric Buddhism of the Shingon Sect. mang teân Chaân Ngoân Toâng cho ñeán ngaøy hoâm                Chaân Ngoân Chuû: Ñöùc Phaät Tyø Loâ Giaù Na laø vò nay—Precept, true words, right discourse, words                giaùo chuû cuûa Chaân Ngoân—Vairocana Buddha is of truth, or the words of Tathagata, Buddha-truth.             the Lord of the True Words. One of the three mystic things of the Tathagata.               Chaân Ngoân Giaùo: See Chaân Ngoân Thöøa. “True Words” or "Chen-Yen" is a translation of                 Chaân Ngoân Nhò Thöøa: Mantrayana (skt). the Sanskrit term “Mantra,” which refers to the                1) Maät Chuù Thöøa: The True World, or Mantra spells used in tantric Buddhism. The tradition was                  Vehicle. brought to China by Subhakarasimha (Shan-Wu-                   2) Thaàn Thoâng Thöøa: Thöøa theo giaùo phaùp chaân Wei) during the eighth century and enjoyed a brief                  ngoân maø ñeán ñaát Phaät moät caùch nhanh choùng: period of relative popularity during the T’ang                      The supernatural vehicle, because of dynasty, but later died out as a separate tradition                 immediate attainment of the Buddha-land in China. It was, however, brought to Japan by                      through tantric methods. Kukai (774-835), where it continues today as the               Chaân Ngoân Thöøa: Mantrayana (skt)—See Chaân Shingon school.                                                Ngoân Toâng. Chaân Ngoân Baùt Toå: Eight patriarchs of the True             Chaân Ngoân Toâng: Mantrayana (skt)—Tch'en- Word Sect.                                                     Yen-Tsung (chi)—The True Word Sect—Chaân 1) Ñeä Nhaát Toå Giaùo Chuû Bí Maät Ñaïi Nhaät Nhö             Ngoân Toâng laø teân goïi chung cho Phaät giaùo Maät Lai: The first patriarch, the Mantra Lord,                toâng ñöôïc duøng ñeå chæ caùc hình thöùc Phaät giaùo veà Vairocana Buddha.                                         sau naày taïi AÁn Ñoä, nhö toâng Chaân Ngoân (Mantrayana), Kim Cang thöøa (Vajrayana), hay Caâu Sinh Khôûi thöøa (Sahajayana). Ngöôøi saùng laäp

ra Maät Toâng taïi Trung Quoác laø ngaøi Thieän Voâ UÙy       trí khaùc—The mantra wisdom which surpasses all (see Thieän Voâ UÙy) vaøo khoaûng naêm 720 sau Taây           other wisdom. Lòch. Du Giaø coù nghóa laø ‘ñònh trí,’ vaø cuõng mang        Chaân Ngoân Vöông Toân: Töø toân xöng Ñöùc Phaät yù nghóa ‘chöùa ñöïng nhöõng maät thuyeát.’ Toâng phaùi       Tyø Loâ Giaù Na, vò giaùo chuû cuûa Chaân Ngoân —The naày daïy cho Phaät töû nhöõng söï haønh trì bí hieåm         honorable title of Vairocana Buddha, the Lord of trong vieäc tu taäp ñaïo Phaät. Toâng phaùi naày coù moät     the True Words. thôøi kyø phoàn thònh ñeán noãi ñoàng hoùa caû Baùt Nhaõ      Chaân Nguïy: True and false. toâng vaø Töù Luaän toâng. Tuy nhieân, trong taát caû caùc    Chaân Nguyeân: Thieàn sö Chaân Nguyeân (1647- xu höôùng cuûa Phaät giaùo thì giaùo lyù Maät toâng cho       1726)—Zen Master Chaân Nguyeân—Moät nhaø sö ñeán ngaøy nay vaãn coøn bò xem thöôøng vaø ngoä nhaän.       noåi tieáng Vieät Nam, queâ ôû Haûi Döông. Thuôû nhoû Caùc pheùp tu luyeän Maät toâng (tantras) bò nhieàu           ngaøi raát thoâng minh. Ngaøi xuaát gia naêm 16 tuoåi. ngöôøi keát toäi, baét nguoàn chuû yeáu töø nhöõng truyeàn    Naêm 19 tuoåi ngaøi ñeán chuøa Hoa Yeân vaø trôû thaønh thoáng AÁn Ñoä giaùo suy ñoài vaø nhöõng vieäc laøm baát      ñeä töû cuûa Thieàn sö Tueä Nguyeät vôùi phaùp hieäu laø chính maø caùc truyeàn thoáng naày gaây ra trong ñaùm         Tueä Ñaêng. Khi thaày thò tòch, ngaøi trôû thaønh du ngöôøi ngu doát. Thaønh kieán choáng laïi moïi caùi gì        Taêng khaát só, thöïc haønh haïnh tu khoå haïnh. Sau ñoù thuoäc veà Maät toâng nhö theá maïnh meõ ñeán noãi ngay       ngaøi truï laïi taïi chuøa Coâ Tieân ñeå hoaèng döông Phaät caû caùc hoïc giaû cuõng töø boû khoâng muoán dính daùng      phaùp. Ngaøy noï, ngaøi vieáng chuøa Vónh Phuùc gaëp vaø gì ñeán noù, keát quaû laø moïi söï nghieân cöùu voâ tö veà   trôû thaønh ñeä töû cuûa Thieàn sö Minh Löông. Ngaøi thò giaùo phaùi naày ñaõ bò gaùc boû suoát moät thôøi gian        tòch naêm 1726. Ngaøi thöôøng nhaéc nhôû haønh giaû: daøi—The general name of Tantric Buddhism is                  “Kieán Taùnh Thaønh Phaät hay laø nhìn thaáy ñöôïc given to the later aspects of Buddhism in India,              Phaät taùnh hay nhìn thaáy baûn taùnh thaät cuûa chính i.e., esoteric, mantra, or esoteric school, or the            mình. Caùi taùnh aáy ôû Thaùnh hay ôû phaøm ñeàu gioáng Tantra School. It is also called the True Word sect           nhau, nhöng vì bò voâ minh che laáp neân môùi coù ñaây (Chaân Ngoân toâng—Mantrayana), or the secret                 phaøm kia Thaùnh. Moät khi böùc maøn voâ minh bò trieät teachings, the Vajrayana, or the Sahajayana. The              tieâu thì muoân ñieàu taïo hoùa ñeàu ñoàng nhau vôùi caùi founder of the Esoteric school in China was                   taùnh aáy. Cuõng nhö vaäy, caùc oâng khoâng theå thaáy Subhakara (Shan-Wu-Wei) around 720 A.D.                       maët traêng döôùi maët soâng vì maët nöôùc bò khuaáy Yoga means ‘to concentrate the mind,’ and also                ñoäng; tuy nhieân, moät khi soâng nöôùc laéng trong thì means ‘containing the secret doctrines.’ This sect,           aùnh traêng aáy seõ hieän hieän ra ngay nôi maët nöôùc. which taught the magic observances in Buddhist                Veà maët töø nghóa, ‘kieán taùnh’ vaø ‘ngoä’ coù cuøng moät practices. At one time, this school was so                    yù nghóa vaø chuùng thöôøng ñöôïc duøng laãn loän vôùi prosperous that the prajna school and the Four                nhau. Tuy nhieân khi noùi veà söï giaùc ngoä cuûa Phaät Madhyamika Treatises school were absorbed in it.              vaø chö toå, ngöôøi ta thöôøng duøng chöõ ‘ngoä’ hôn laø However, among all the aspects of Buddhism, its               “kieán taùnh” vì ngoä aùm chæ moät kinh nghieäm saâu Tantric teachings have until now been the most                hôn. Ñaây laø moät caâu noùi thoâng duïng trong nhaø neglected and misunderstood. The Tantras against              Thieàn. Ñaây laø moät trong taùm nguyeân taéc caên baûn, which accusations have been hurled originated                 cuûa tröïc giaùc hay lieân heä tröïc tieáp vôùi taâm linh cuûa mostly from the decadent forms of late Hindu                  tröôøng phaùi Thieàn Toâng. Haønh giaû neân nhôù, ñöøng tradition and the malpractices which they gave                caàu Phaät baèng saéc töôùng hay aâm thanh, vì nhöõng rise to among the ignorant. The prejudice, which              thöù naày khoâng phaûi laø Phaät. Nhöõng ai mong caàu in this way grew against everything Tantric, was              Phaät baèng saéc töôùng aâm thanh laø ñang theo taø ñaïo. so strong that even scholars refused to have                  Phaät chính laø söï giaùc ngoä Boà Ñeà vaø con ñöôøng taàm anything to do with it, and consequently any                  Phaät phaûi laø söï chöùng ngoä ñaïo quaû Boà Ñeà. Vôùi nhaø impartial investigation or research was neglected             Thieàn, coù taùm nguyeân taéc caên baûn, cuûa tröïc giaùc for a long time.                                              hay lieân heä tröïc tieáp vôùi taâm linh cuûa haønh giaû. Chaân Ngoân Toâng Baùt Toå: Eight patriarchs of the           Thöù nhaát laø Chaùnh Phaùp Nhaõn Taïng. Thöù nhì laø True Word Sect—See Chaân Ngoân Baùt Toå.                      Nieát Baøn Dieäu Taâm. Ñaây laø caùi taâm vi dieäu vaø Chaân Ngoân Trí: Chaân ngoân trí vöôït treân moïi thöù        thaâm saâu khoâng theå nghó baøn, noù vöôït ra ngoaøi söï

suy nghó cuûa con ngöôøi. Caùi taâm naày khoâng coøn              ngay ñaây, ñoái dieän hieän duøng, tuøy cô thu buoâng, vöôùng maéc bôûi coù khoâng, trong ñoù taát caû nhöõng aûo        ñoái ñaõi thöa hoûi, chaúng phaûi taùnh thì laø gì? Caùi gì töôûng taø vaïy ñeàu bò loaïi boû. Theo Thieân Thai Bieät         thöa hoûi ñaây? Noùi naêng ñoù laø caùi gì? Caùi gì hay Giaùo, thì ñaây chæ giôùi haïn vaøo taâm Phaät, trong khi         bieát hoûi? Tuy nhieân, caùc oâng neân nhôù raèng ngay Thieân Thai Vieân Giaùo laïi cho raèng ñaây laø taâm cuûa         khi caùc oâng thaáy noù, caùc oâng cuõng khoâng coù lôøi ngay caû nhöõng ngöôøi chöa giaùc ngoä. Thöù ba laø               naøo ñeå noùi ñöôïc veà noù ñaâu! Haønh giaû chaân thuaàn Thöïc Töôùng Voâ Töôùng. Thöù tö laø Vi Dieäu Phaùp               phaûi thaáy nhö vaäy ñeå nhaát cöû nhaát ñoäng töø ñi, Moân. Thöù naêm laø Baát Laäp Vaên Töï. Thöù saùu laø             ñöùng, naèm, ngoài luùc naøo cuõng phaûi cheá phuïc mình Giaùo Ngoaïi Bieät Truyeàn. Thöù baûy laø Tröïc Chæ               theo ñuùng leã nghóa cuûa moät ngöôøi con Phaät. Haønh Nhaân Taâm. Thöù taùm laø Kieán Taùnh Thaønh Phaät.”              giaû cuõng neân luoân nhôù raèng chæ vì taâm nieäm khoâng Döôùi ñaây laø moät trong nhöõng baøi keä thieàn noåi             chuyeân nhaát, yù chí khoâng kieân coá, cöù tuøy theo tieáng veà ‘Kieán Taùnh’ cuûa ngaøi:                              duyeân caûnh maø xoay chuyeån ñeå roài bò caûnh giôùi “Nhaát ñieåm hö voâ theå boån khoâng,                       daãn daét gaây toäi taïo nghieäp. Chuùng ta queân maát Vaïn ban taïo hoùa giaù cô ñoàng.                          muïc ñích tu haønh cuûa chuùng ta laø tu ñeå thaønh Phaät, Bao la theá giôùi caøn khoân ngoaïi,                       thaønh Boà Taùt, hay thaønh baát cöù quaû vò Thaùnh naøo Traïm tòch haøn quang saùt haûi trung.                     trong Töù Thaùnh. Thay vaøo ñoù, chuùng ta chæ bieát Taïi Thaùnh baát taêng phaøm maïc giaûm,                   taïo ra ñòa nguïc, ngaï quyû hay suùc sanh maø thoâi. Phöông vieân tuøy khí nhaäm dung thoâng.                   Phaät hay ma ñeàu do moät nieäm sai bieät maø ra. Phaät Thuûy tröøng nguyeät hieän thieân giang aùn,               thì coù taâm töø, ma thì coù taâm tranh thaéng baát thieän. Saéc aùnh hoa khai ñaïi ñòa ñoàng.”                        Toaøn theå theá giôùi naày chæ laø söï saùng taïo cuûa taâm, (Moät ñieåm roãng rang theå voán khoâng,                    maït na vaø yù thöùc; raèng theá giôùi ñöôïc sinh taïo do Muoân ñieàu taïo hoùa aáy cô ñoàng.                        phaân bieät sai laàm bôûi caùi taâm cuûa chính mình; raèng Bao la theá giôùi ngoaøi trôøi ñaát,                       khoâng coù nhöõng töôùng traïng hay daáu hieäu naøo cuûa Laëng aùnh haøn quang coõi coõi trong.                     moät theá giôùi beân ngoaøi maø trong ñoù nguyeân lyù ña ÔÛ Thaùnh chaúng theâm phaøm chaúng bôùt,                  phöùc ñieàu ñoäng; vaø cuoái cuøng raèng ba coõi chæ laø Vuoâng troøn tuøy moùn maëc dung thoâng.                   caùi taâm cuûa chính mình. Cuoái cuøng, haønh giaû neân Nghìn soâng nöôùc laéng traêng in boùng,                   luoân nhôù raèng ‘vaïn phaùp chæ laø moät taâm naøy.’ Ñöùc Hoa nôû khaép nôi röïc saéc hoàng).                        Phaät noùi Nieát Baøn laø söï chaám döùt tham, saân, si. Ngaøi thöôøng nhaán maïnh ñeán caùi ‘taâm naøy’: “Heát            Caùc oâng phaûi thaáy cho ñöôïc caùi chaân taùnh naøy, vì thaûy chö phaùp ñeàu ôû beân trong caùi taâm, khoâng coù          neáu caùc oâng khoâng hieåu ñöôïc söï vaän haønh cuûa phaùp naøo ôû ngoaøi taâm (taâm coù nghóa laø nhoùm khôûi         taâm, caùc oâng khoâng theå naøo daäp taét löûa tham, saân, leân caùc phaùp; thöùc coù nghóa laø phaân bieät caùc phaùp).     si ñöôïc.” Döôùi ñaây laø moät trong nhöõng baøi keä Chæ moät taâm naày maø coù ñuû ñaày boán coõi. Töø Luïc           Thieàn noåi tieáng cuûa ngaøi veà ‘Ñeøn Taâm’: Phaøm Töù Thaùnh ñeàu do taâm naày taïo ra. Caùi taâm coù               “Nhaát ñieåm taâm ñaêng Phaät nhaõn sinh, theå taïo ra thieân ñöôøng, taïo ra ñòa nguïc. Taâm laøm                 Töông truyeàn töù muïc coá phaân minh. mình thaønh Phaät, thì cuõng chính taâm naày laøm mình                   Lieân phöông tuïc dieäm quang voâ taän, thaønh ngaï quyû, suùc sanh, hay ñòa nguïc, Boà Taùt,                    Phoå phoù Thieàn laâm thoï höõu tình.” Duyeân Giaùc hay Thanh Vaên. Vì moïi thöù ñeàu do                       (Moät ngoïn ñeøn taâm maét Phaät sinh, taâm taïo, neân moïi thöù ñeàu chæ ôû nôi taâm naày. Neáu                Truyeàn nhau boán maét ngoù phaân minh. taâm muoán thaønh Phaät thì Phaät Phaùp Giôùi laø quyeán                 Ngoïn ñeøn maõi noái saùng voâ taän, thuoäc cuûa mình. Caùc phaùp giôùi khaùc laïi cuõng nhö                  Trao gôûi Thieàn laâm daïy höõu tình). vaäy. Khi caùc oâng hoûi toâi, töùc ñoù laø taâm caùc oâng.       Thaät vaäy, ñeøn taâm laø söï saùng suoát beân trong hay Khi toâi ñaùp laïi caùc oâng, töùc ñoù laø taâm toâi. Neáu caùc   söï thoâng minh. Trong Taâm Ñòa Quaùn Kinh, Ñöùc oâng khoâng coù taâm, nhaân ñaâu maø bieát hoûi? Neáu noùi        Phaät daïy: “Trong Phaät phaùp, laáy taâm laøm chuû. Taát toâi khoâng coù taâm, thì nhaân ñaâu maø toâi bieát ñaùp laïi     caû caùc phaùp ñeàu do taâm sanh.” Taâm taïo ra chö caùc oâng? Chính ngay caùc oâng hoûi toâi, töùc laø taâm          Phaät, taâm taïo thieân ñöôøng, taâm taïo ñòa nguïc. Taâm caùc oâng. Taâm naøy töø voâ thæ cho ñeán nay, moïi haønh         laø ñoäng löïc chính laøm cho ta sung söôùng hay ñau ñoäng, taïo taùc, ôû trong taát caû caùc thôøi, cuõng nhö         khoå, vui hay buoàn, traàm luaân hay giaûi thoaùt. Theo

kinh nghieäm nhaø thieàn, thì taâm laø toaøn boä tænh           toaøn thöùc tænh, phaûi luoân nôi thaân tænh thöùc baè ng thöùc, noùi caùch khaùc laéng nghe khi nghe laø tænh            caùch thöïc taäp taäp trung vaøo hôi thôû; nôi caûm thoï thöùc. Taâm bao goàm traïng thaùi tính thoaùng qua luoân        tænh thöùc baèng caùch quaùn saùt söï ñeán ñi trong ta cuûa luoân troãi leân roài maát ñi nhanh nhö tia chôùp. “Vì          taát caû moïi hình thöùc cuûa caûm thoï, vui, buoàn, trung sinh ra ñeå thaønh nguoàn cuûa noù vaø cheát ñi ñeå trôû        tính; nôi nhöõng hoaït ñoäng cuûa taâm tænh thöùc baèng thaønh loái vaøo cuûa noù, noù beàn vöõng traøn treà nhö con    caùch xem coi taâm ta coù chöùa chaáp duïc voïng, saân soâng nhaän nöôùc töø caùc suoái nguoàn boài theâm vaøo         haän, löøa doái, xao laõng, hay taäp trung; nôi vaïn phaùp doøng chaûy cuûa noù.” Moãi thöùc nhaát thôøi cuûa doøng        tænh thöùc baèng caùch quaùn saùt baûn chaát voâ thöôøng ñôøi khoâng ngöøng thay ñoåi, khi cheát ñi thì truyeàn laïi     cuûa chuùng töø sanh truï dò dieät ñeå taän dieät chaáp tröôùc cho thöùc keá thöøa toaøn boä naêng löôïng cuûa noù, taát caû   vaø luyeán aùi. Haõy nhìn vaøo taâm cuûa chính mình ñeå nhöõng caûm töôûng ñaõ ghi khoâng bao giôø phai nhaït.          tænh thöùc vôùi baát cöù voïng nieäm naøo aäp ñeán, vaø Cho neân moãi thöùc môùi goàm coù tieàm löïc cuûa thöùc         ñöøng tieáp tuïc lang thang vôùi chuùng nöõa. Taát caû caùc cuõ vaø nhöõng ñieàu môùi. Taát caû nhöõõng caûm nghó           oâng haõy soáng vôùi söï chöùng ngoä naày caû ngaøy laãn khoâng phai nhaït ñöôïc ghi vaøo caùi taâm khoâng               ñeâm; vaäy laø caùc oâng ñang soáng vôùi ‘chaân thöôøng ngöøng thay ñoåi, vaø taát caû ñöôïc truyeàn thöøa töø ñôøi     kieán vaø chaùnh bieán tri’ vaäy.” Döôùi ñaây laø moät naày sang ñôøi kia baát chaáp söï phaân huûy vaät chaát         trong nhöõng baøi keä thieàn noåi tieáng cuûa ngaøi: taïm thôøi nôi thaân. Vì theá cho neân söï nhôù laïi nhöõng           “Hieån haùch phaân minh thaäp nhò thì, laàn sanh hay nhöõng bieán coá trong quaù khöù trôû                     Thöû chi töï taùnh nhaäm thi vi. thaønh moät khaû naêng coù theå xaõy ra. Taâm laø con dao               Luïc caên vaän duïng chaân thöôøng kieán, hai löôõi, coù theå xöû duïng cho caû thieän laãn aùc. Moät             Vaïn phaùp tung hoaønh chaùnh bieán tri.” tö töôûng noåi leân töø moät caùi taâm voâ hình coù theå cöùu          (Baøy hieän roõ raøng ñöôïc suoát ngaøy, hay phaù hoaïi caû theá giôùi. Moät tö töôûng nhö vaäy coù              Ñaây laø töï taùnh maëc phoâ baøy. theå laøm taêng tröôûng hay giaûm ñi daân cö cuûa moät                  Chaân thöôøng öùng duïng saùu caên thaáy, nöôùc. Taâm taïo Thieân ñaøng vaø ñòa nguïc cho chính                   Muoân phaùp doïc ngang giaùc ngoä ngay). mình. Tuy nhieân, vôùi thieàn baïn coù theå huaán luyeän        A Vietnamese famous monk from Haûi Döông. cho taâm bình tónh vaø thoaùt khoûi nhöõng xaùo troän           When he was young, he was very intelligent. He beân trong hay beân ngoaøi. AÙp duïng taäp trung tænh           left home and became a monk at the age of 16. thöùc vôùi nhöõng hoãn loaïn beân trong vaø maâu thuaãn         When he was 19, he went to Hoa Yeân Temple to tinh thaàn, quan saùt hay chuù taâm ñeán taát caû nhöõng        meet Zen Master Tueä Nguyeät and became his traïng thaùi thay ñoåi cuûa taâm. Khi taâm ñöôïc phaùt          disciple with the Dharma name Tueä Ñaêng. After trieån ñuùng caùch, noù seõ mang laïi nieàm vui vaø haïnh       his master passed away, he became a wandering phuùc nhaát. Neáu taâm bò xao laõng noù seõ mang laïi           monk who practised ascetics. Later, he stayed at cho baïn trôû ngaïi vaø khoù khaên khoâng theå keå xieát.       Coâ Tieân Temple to expand the Buddha Dharma. Taâm kyõ luaät raát maïnh meõ vaø höõu hieäu. Ngöôøi trí        One day he visited Vónh Phuùc Temple, there he huaán luyeän taâm hoï nhö ngöôøi ta huaán luyeän ngöïa          met and became the disciple of Zen Master Minh vaäy. Vì theá baïn neân quan saùt taâm mình. Ngaøi              Löông with the Dharma name Chaân Nguyeân. He thöôøng nhaéc nhôû ñeä töû: “Moät ngöôøi giaùc ngoä baûn        passed away in 1726, at the age of 80. He always taùnh thaät söï cuûa vaïn höõu laø giaùc ngoä caùi hö khoâng    reminded practitioners: “Seeing one’s own nature hieän taïi. Caùi hö khoâng maø ngöôøi ta thaáy ñöôïc            and becoming a Buddha or to behold the Buddha- trong khoaûnh khaéc aáy khoâng phaûi laø hö voâ, maø laø        nature within oneself or to see into one’s own caùi khoâng theå naém baét ñöôïc, khoâng theå hieåu ñöôïc       nature. That nature is the same for both the baèng caûm giaùc hay tö duy vì noù voâ haïn vaø vöôït ra        enlightened and the unenlightened, but because of ngoaøi söï toàn taïi vaø khoâng toàn taïi. Caùi hö khoâng       the coverage of ignorance that causes here ñöôïc giaùc ngoä khoâng phaûi laø moät ñoái töôïng cho          ordinary people and there the saints. Once the chuû theå suy gaãm, maø chuû theå phaûi hoøa tan trong ñoù      curtain of ignorance is eliminated, all things will môùi hieåu ñöôïc noù. Trong Phaät giaùo thaät, ngoaøi theå      be the same with that same nature. Similarly, you nghieäm ñaïi giaùc ra, khoâng coù Phaät giaùo. Tuy              cannot see the moon in the rivers because the nhieân, moät ngöôøi ñaõ ñaït tôùi ñaïi giaùc, hay hoaøn         water is so disturbed; however, once the water

becomes still, the moon will immediately appears        of desire, hatred and illusion. You all must see this in the water. Semantically ‘Beholding the               true nature, because if you don’t, you can never Buddha-nature’ and ‘Enlightenment’ have                 extinguish the fire of desire, hatred and illusion.” virtually the same meaning and are often used           Below is one of his famous Zen poems on ‘Seeing interchangeably. In describing the enlightenment        the Nature’: of the Buddha and the patriarchs, however, it is          “It is originally an empty spot in nature, often used the word ‘Enlightenment’ rather than            All things would have the same “Beholding the Buddha-nature.” The term                    nature of emptiness. ‘enlightenment’ implies a deeper experience. This          Beyond the sky and earth, is a common saying of the Ch’an (Zen) or Intuitive         so vast is the universe, School. Through it one sees one’s own nature and           The cold light is so serene though becomes a Buddha. This is one of the eight                 it is shinning through countless worlds. fundamental principles, intuitional or relating to         It neither increases at the enlightened, direct mental vision of the Zen School. Zen                nor does it decrease at the unenlightened, practitioners should not seek a Buddha by his form         It appears square or round in or his sound because neither the form nor the              receptacles at ease. sound is the real Buddha. Those who seek Buddha            When the water is still, by form and sound are on the wrong path. The true          the moon appears in thousands of rivers, Buddha is Enlightenment and the true way to                As the flower blossoms , know Buddha is to realize Enlightenment. For Zen           the whole universe glows in red.” Schools, there are eight fundamental intuitional        He always emphasized on this ‘mind’: “All things principles that relate to direct mental vision of       are inside the mind, nothing exists apart from practitioners. First, the Correct Law Eye-Treasury      mind. This single mind encompasses the four or Treasury of the eye of the true dharma. Second,      kinds of lands in their totality. From the Six Nirvana of Wonderful and Profound Mind or the           Common Dharma Realms to the Four Dharma subtle mind of nirvana. This is the wonderful and       Realms of the Sages are not beyond the present profound mind or heart which is beyond human            thought in the Mind. The mind can create the thought. The mind which clings to neither to            heavens as well as the hells. The mind can nothingness nor to actuality. The mind in which all     achieve Buddhahood, but it can also turn into a erronuous imaginings have been removed.                 hungry ghost or an animal, or fall into the hells. It According to to the Differentiated Teaching of the      can be a Bodhisattva, a Pratyekabuddha, or a T’ien-T’ai school, limited this to the mind of the      Sravaka. Since everything is made from the mind, Buddha, while the Perfect teaching universalized        nothing goes beyond the mind. If we want to it to include the unenlightened heart of all men.       create Buddhas in our minds, we become part of Third, reality is nullity or true marks are no marks.   the retinue of the Dharma Realm of the Buddhas. Fourth, the Door of Abhidharma or the extremely         The other Dharma Realms are the same way. subtle dharma gate. Fifth, it is not relying on         However, remember even when you see it, you books, or not established on words or no                still have no words to say about it! Devout establishment of words and letters. Sixth, it is a      practitioners should always see this and pay special transmission outside the teachings or the       attention to all daily activities from walking, distinct transmission outside of the teachings.         standing, lying down, or sitting... We must Seventh, it points directly to the human mind or        regulate ourselves in accord with propriety of a directly pointing to the mind of man. Eighth,           true Buddhist. When you ask me, that is the through it one sees one’s own nature and becomes        manifestation of your mind. When I reply you, that a Buddha or seeing the nature is the attainment of      is the manifestation of my mind. If you have no Buddhahood.        Finally,     practitioners  should   mind, how can you know to ask me? If I have no remember that all phenomena are just the one            mind, how can I know to reply you? Your mind is mind. The Buddha says Nirvana is the extinction         manifesting right at the time you are asking me.

Since the beginningless time, this mind has              it persistently flows on like a river receiving from manifested in all your actions all the time. This        the tributary streams of sense constant accretions mind is manifesting in accordance with                   to its flood.” Each momentary consciousness of circumstances. It is manifesting while you are           this everchanging lifestream, on passing away, facing me, talking and asking me. This mind is the       transmits its whole energy, all the indelibly true nature. What is asking here? What is talking        recorded impressions, to its successor. Every fresh here? What is having the ability to put a question       consciousness      therefore    consists    of    the here? Practitioners should also remember that we         potentialities of its predecessors and something create more and more karmas and commit more              more. As all impressions are indelibly recorded in and more sins because we are not concentrated            this everchanging palimpsest-like mind, and as all and determined. We get dragged into situations           potentialities are transmitted from life to life, until we forget what we want to do. We forget our        irrespective of temporary physical disintegrations, goal is to cultivate to become a Buddha, a               reminiscence of past births or past incidents Bodhisattva, or any of the four kinds of the sages.      become a possibility. Mind is like a double-edged Instead, we only know how to create hells, hungry        weapon that can equally be used either for good ghosts, and animals, etc. Thus, Buddhas and              or evil. One single thought that arises in this demons are only a single thought apart. Buddhas          invisible mind can even save or destroy the world. are kind and compassionate, while demons are             One such thought can either populate or always competitive with unwholesome thoughts.            depopulate a whole country. It is mind that creates The whole triple world is no more than the               one’s paradise and one’s hell. However, with creation of the citta, manas, and mano-vijnana,          meditation, you can train the mind to keep calm that it is brought forth by falsely discriminating       and be free from disturbances either from within one’s own mind, that there are no signs of an            or outside. Apply concentrated awareness to the external world where the principle of multiplicity       internal confusions and mental conflicts, and rules, and finally that the triple world is just one’s   observe or pay attention to all the changing states own mind.” Below is one of his famous Zen                of your mind. When the mind is properly poems on the ‘lamp of mind’:                             developed, it brings happiness and bliss. If the “From the lamp of mind,                           mind is neglected, it runs you into endless troubles the Buddha’s eyes manifest,                      and difficulties. The disciplined mind is strong and And the four eyes gaping                         effective, while the wavering mind is weak and clearly pass on the way.                         ineffective. The wise train their minds as Keep the transmission of the lamp                thoroughly as a horse-trainer train their horses. He shinning endlessly,                              always reminded his disciples: “A person awakens And empower the Zen rangers                      the true nature of the all things means he awakens to teach human beings.”                          to a nowness of emptiness. The emptiness As a matter of fact, the lamp of the mind is the         experienced here here is no nihilistic emptiness; inner ligh or intelligence. In Contemplation of the      rather it is something unperceivable, unthinkable, Mind Sutra, the Buddha taught: “All my tenets are        unfeelable for it is endless and beyond existence based on the mind that is the source of all              and nonexistence. Emptiness is no object that dharmas." The mind has brought about the                 could be experienced by a subject, a subject itself Buddhas, the Heaven, or the Hell. It is the main         must dissolve in it (the emptiness) to attain a true driving force that makes us happy or sorrowful,          enlightenment. In real Buddhism, without this cheerful or sad, liberated or doomed. From the           experience, there would be no Buddhism. standpoint of Zen experience, “mind” means total         However, a being who has attained perfect awareness. In other words, just listening when           complete enlightenment, or a fully awakened one, hearing. It consists of fleeting mental states which     should always be attentive to the activities of the constantly arise and perish with lightning rapidity.     body with the practice of concentration on “With birth for its source and death for its mouth,      breathing; be aware of all forms of feelings and

sensations, pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral, by         “baát bieán” maø chaúng ñöôïc “tuøy duyeân.” Ñaây laø contemplating         their       appearance       and    Moät trong Uyeån Coâng Töù Giaùo—The school of the disappearance within oneself; be aware whether            novitiate Bodhisattvas who know only the one’s mind is lustful, hatred, deluded, distracted or     noumenal bhutatathata. This is one of the four concentrated; and contemplate the impermanence            groups of Hi-Yuan’s categories of Buddhist of all things from arise, stay, change and decay to       schools—See Töù Giaùo. eliminate attachment. Let watch your mind in              Chaân Nhieân (804-891): Shinnen (jap)—Teân cuûa order to be mindful of any coming false thoughts,         moät vò danh Taêng Nhaät Baûn vaøo theá kyû thöù IX. Sö and not continue to wander with them anymore.             laø moät trong nhöõng ñeä töû xuaát saéc nhaát cuûa Sö You all should live with this realization all day         Chaân Nhaõ—Name of a Japanese master of the and night; it is to say you are living with ‘seeing       Shingon Sect in the ninth century. He was one of the true eternity and complete enlightenment.’”           the outstanding disciples of master Shinga. Below is one of his famous Zen poems:                     Chaân Nhö: Bhutatathata or Tathata (skt)—Chen- “Appearing clearly all day and night,               ju (chi)—Shinnyo (jap)—De-kho-na-nyi (tib)—Töï The self nature manifests comfortably.             Taùnh Thanh Tònh Taâm—Phaät Tính—Phaùp Thaân— Seeing the true eternity applying through the      Nhö Lai Taïng—Thöïc Töôùng—Phaùp Giôùi—Phaùp six senses,                                         Tính—Vieân Thaønh Thöïc Tính—Real—Reality— You will move horizontally and vertically          Suchness—True              Suchness—According            to Among all phenomena with complete                   reality—Natural purity—Töø Phaïn ngöõ chæ “thöïc enlightenment.”                                     taùnh” vaø thöôøng ñöôïc xem nhö töông ñöông vôùi Chaân Nguyeân Thieàn Sö: See Chaân Nguyeân.               chöõ “taùnh khoâng” (sunyata),              “phaùp thaân” Chaân Ngöõ: Lôøi thuyeát lyù chaân nhö nhöùt thöïc hay    (dharma-kaya). Noù khoâng thay ñoåi, khoâng lay lôøi noùi cuûa Nhö Lai laø chaân thaät vaø ñuùng maõi —   chuyeån, vaø vöôït ra ngoaøi nhaän thöùc suy nghó. Chaân True words, especially as expressing the truth of         nhö laø chaân taùnh hay thöïc töôùng, hay hieän thöïc the bhutatathata; the words of Tathagata are true         ngöôïc vôùi neùt beân ngoaøi cuûa theá giôùi hieän töôïng. and consistent.                                           Chaân nhö (Bhutatathata) laø baát bieán vaø vónh haèng, Chaân Nhaõ (801-879): Shinga (jap)—Teân cuûa moät         coøn hình thöùc vaø nhöõng neùt beân ngoaøi thì luùc naøo vò danh Taêng Nhaät Baûn cuûa toâng Chaân Ngoân vaøo      cuõng sinh ra, thay ñoåi vaø bieán maát. Chaân lyù töï theá kyû thöù IX. Sö laø em trai cuûa Sö Khoâng Haûi —    nhieân, khoâng phaûi do con ngöôøi taïo ra; chaân nhö Name of a Japanese master of the Shingon Sect in          hay baûn taùnh thaät thöôøng haèng nôi vaïn höõu, thanh the ninth century. He was the younger brother of          tònh vaø khoâng thay ñoåi, nhö bieån ñoái nghòch laïi vôùi master Kukai.                                             soùng (baûn chaát coá höõu cuûa nöôùc laø phaúng laëng vaø Chaân Nhaân: Shinnin (jap)—Zhen-ren (chi)—1)              thanh tònh chöù khoâng daäp doàn nhö soùng). Theo Nguyeân nhaân chaân thöïc: The true cause, reality as     Trung Quaùn Luaän, chaân nhö laø chaân lyù, nhöng noù causes; 2) Ngöôøi chöùng ñaéc chaân lyù: The one who      phi nhaân caùch. Ñeå hieån hieän, noù caàn coù moät moâi embodies the truth; 3) A La Haùn: An Arhat; 4)            giôùi. Nhö Lai chính laø moâi giôùi cuûa noù. Nhö Lai laø Phaät: A Buddha.                                          tröïc ngoä veà thöïc taïi. Ngaøi laø Thöïc Taïi ñöôïc nhaâ n Chaân Nhaát Phaàn Baùn Giaùo: Chæ Thanh Vaên vaø          caùch hoùa. Ñoàng thôøi Ngaøi coøn coù caû hai loaïi tính Duyeân Giaùc, chæ chöùng ñöôïc moät phaàn söï (hieän      chaát cuûa Tuyeät Ñoái vaø hieän töôïng. Ngaøi ñoàng nhaát töôïng) chaân nhö hay moät phaàn cuûa “tuøy duyeân baát   vôùi Chaân Nhö, nhöng ñöôïc theå hieän trong hình bieán cuûa chaân nhö.” Ñaây laø Moät trong Uyeån Coâng    daïng cuûa moät con ngöôøi. Ñaây laø lyù do taïi sao Chaân Töù Giaùo—The school of sravakas and pratyeka-            Nhö cuõng coøn ñöôïc goïi laø Nhö Lai Taïng—Tathata buddhas who know only the phenomenal                      is a Sanskrit term that refers to the “final nature of bhutatathata. This is one of the four groups of Hi-       reality,” and is commonly equated with such terms Yuan’s categories of Buddhist schools—See Töù             as “emptiness” (sunyata), and “truth body” Giaùo.                                                    (dharma-kaya). Suchness; central notion in the Chaân Nhaát Phaàn Maõn Giaùo: Boà Taùt sô taâm chæ        Mahayana Buddhism, referring to the Absolute, chöùng ñöôïc moät phaàn lyù chaân nhö hay moät phaàn      the true nature of all things. Tathata is also

explained as “Immutable” or “Immovable” or                     Taùt—Chaùnh Löu Boà Taùt—See Baát Khoâng Kieán “Permanent.” It is beyond all concepts and                     Boà Taùt. distinctions. Bhutatathata, the suchness of                    Chaân Nhö Nhöùt Thöïc: Chaân nhö laø chaân lyù duy existence, the reality as opposed to the                       nhaát—Bhutatathata the only reality, the one appearance        of     the   phenomenal            world.    bhutatathata reality. Bhutatathata is immutable and eternal, whereas                 Chaân Nhö Noäi Huaân: Höông thôm töø beân trong forms and appearances arise, change and pass                   hay aûnh höôûng cuûa chaân nhö (phaùp taùnh cuûa chaân away. Bhutatathata means permanent reality                     nhö laø söï caûm hoùa töø beân trong trong. Chaân nhö laø underlying all phenomena, pure and unchanged,                  töï taùnh thanh tònh taâm maø ai ai cuõng ñeàu coù, laø such as the sea in contrast with the waves.                    phaùp thaân cuûa chö Phaät. Phaùp thaân naày coù khaû According to Madhyamaka Philosophy, Tathata is                 naêng tröø boû voïng taâm ôû beân trong. Coøn beân ngoaøi the Truth, but it is impersonal. In order to reveal            thì nhôø hai baùo thaân vaø hoùa thaân cuûa chö Phaät ñeå itself, it requires a medium. Tathagata is that                laïi giuùp ñôû huaân taäp. Nhôø ñoù maø chuùng sanh daàn medium. Tathagata is the epiphany of Reality. He               daàn phaùt taâm Boà Ñeà, chaùn coõi theá tuïc vaø caàu thaønh is Reality personalized. Tathagata is an                       Phaät)—The internal perfuming or influence of the amphibious being partaking both of the Absolute                bhutatathata, or Buddha-spirituality. and phenomena. He is identical with Tathata, but               Chaân Nhö Phaùp Thaân: Body of true suchness— embodied in a human form. That is why Tathata is               1) Baát Khoâng Chaân Nhö coù ñaày ñuû phaùp coâng ñöùc also      called     the     womb       of      Tathagata      voâ löôïng: Not-void, or phenomenal bhutatathata (Tathagatagarbha).                                             has limitless virtue; 2) Caùi theå cuûa phaùp thaân, chaân Chaân Nhö Chi Nguyeät: Traêng chaân nhö, yù noùi               thöïc nhö thöôøng: The absolute as dharmakaya or vieäc theå ngoä chaân nhö maø thoaùt khoûi nhöõng meâ          spiritual body, all embracing. hoaëc cuõng gioáng nhö vaàng traêng chieáu saùng phaù          Chaân Nhö Quaùn: Shinnyo-Kan (jap)—Quaùn tan söï taêm toái—The moon of the bhutatathata. The            chieáu kyõ löôõng chaân nhö—Crutinize thusness. term implies the comprehension of the true                     Chaân Nhö Quoác Ñoä: Land of naturalness—YÙ noùi suchness is like the moon's shining the bright light           coõi Tònh Ñoä cuûa ñöùc Phaät A Di Ñaø, nôi hoøa ñieäu to exclude the darkness.                                       vôùi chaân nhö moät caùch hoaøn haûo —Refers to Chaân Nhö Duyeân Khôûi: Conditioned essence—                   Amitabha's Pure Land, which is perfectly in Conditioned substance—Conditioned thusness—                    accord with the ultimate reality, or true suchness. The conditioned Bhutatathata or relative                       Chaân Nhö Tam Muoäi: Meditation of suchness— condition—Ever-changing essence or substance—                  The true thusness samadhi—Thieàn ñònh quaùn lyù Chaân nhö bò aûnh höôûng bôûi ngoaïi caûnh, ñieàu kieän        chaân nhö voâ töôùng, trong ñoù moïi hieän töôïng ñeàu thanh tònh hay baát tònh, taïo ra chö phaùp—The                taän dieät vaø chaân nhö hieån loä. Traïng thaùi tam muoäi absolute in its causative or relative condition—               trong ñoù gheùt, thöông, chaáp nhaän, choái boû ñeàu bò The Bhutatathata influenced by environment, or                 deïp boû, vaø trong ñoù taâm ñaït tôùi traïng thaùi baát pure and impure conditions, produces all things—               phaân, ñeå truï vaøo tòch tónh. Tam muoäi thöïc chöùng See Tuøy Duyeân Chaân Nhö.                                     raèng baûn taùnh cuûa chö Phaät baát dò—The Chaân Nhö Haûi: Ocean of the bhutatathata—Taùnh                meditation in which all phenomena are eliminated haûi (bieån chaân nhö)—Lyù taùnh cuûa chaân nhö saâu           and the Bhutatathata or absolute is realized. A roäng nhö bieån caû, bao truøm taát caû, ñoù laø caûnh giôùi   state of samadhi in which hate and love, accepting cuûa phaùp thaân Nhö Lai. Phaùp tính chaân nhö coù ñaày        and rejecting are repressed, and in which the ñuû voâ löôïng coâng ñöùc tính—The all-containing,             mind reaches an undivided state, being anchored immaterial nature of the Dharma, or immaterial                 in calm and quiet. A samadhi for realizing that the nature of the Dharmakaya is limitless.                         nature of all Buddhas is the same. Chaân Nhö Huaân Taäp: The inter-perfuming of                   Chaân Nhö Thaân: Body of true suchness—See bhutatathata—See Huaân Taäp.                                   Chaân Nhö Phaùp Thaân. Chaân Nhö Kim Cang Boà Taùt: Amoghadarsana                     Chaân Nhö Thieàn: See Chaân Nhö Tam Muoäi. (skt)—Amoghadarsin (skt)—Baát Khoâng Nhaõn Boà                 Chaân Nhö Thöùc: See Nhö Lai Taïng.

Chaân Nhö Thöïc Nghóa Kieán: Yathabhutartha-                  Ñeà. Caùch phaùt taâm Boà Ñeà chaân thaät laø moät trong sthanadarsanam (skt)—Caùch nhìn veà thöïc tính cuûa           boán caùch phaùt taâm ñuùng ñaén cho ngöôøi tu Phaät. theá giôùi—View of the true nature of the world.              Moãi nieäm ñeàu treân vì caàu Phaät ñaïo, döôùi vì ñoä Chaân Nhö Thöïc Taïi: Bhutatathata (skt)—                     chuùng sanh, nhìn ñöôøng Boà Ñeà daøi xa maø khoâng Suchness of existence—Chaân lyù chaân thaät (thöïc            khieáp, thaáy loaøi höõu tình khoù ñoä nhöng chaúng sôøn. töôùng hay chaân nhö cuûa söï hieän höõu).                    Taâm beàn vöõng nhö leân nuùi quyeát ñeán ñænh, nhö leo Chaân Nhö Thöïc Töôùng: Essential characteristic              thaùp quyeát ñeán choùt. Nhöõng baäc naày, nieäm nieäm of the bhutatathata—Chaân lyù laø chaân nhö töø caùi          treân caàu Phaät daïo, taâm taâm döôùi ñoä chuùng sanh. nhìn cuûa khoâng; trong khi thaät töôùng laø chaân nhö        Nghe thaønh Phaät duø laâu xa chaúng sôï, chaúng lui. töø caùi nhìn cuûa hieän töôïng. Chaân nhö vaø thöïc          Phaùt taâm nhö theá goïi laø CHAÂN—One of the eight töôùng laø ñoàng theå, nhöng teân goïi khaùc nhau. Ñoái       ways of developing the Bodhi Mind. True way of vôùi nghóa nhaát nhö cuûa khoâng ñeá thì goïi laø chaâ n      developing the Bodhi Mind is is one of the four nhö; coøn ñoái vôùi nghóa dieäu höõu cuûa giaû ñeá thì goïi   improper ways of cultivation for Buddhists. laø thöïc töôùng—Reality is bhutatathata from the             Aiming with each thought to seek Buddhahood point of view of the void; while essential                    “above” and save sentient beings “below,” characteristic is bhutatathata from the point of              without fearing the long, arduous Bodhi path or view of phenomena. The essential characteristic               being discouraged by sentient beings who are or mark (laksana) of the Bhutatathata, i.e. reality.          difficult to save, with a mind as firm as the resolve The bhutatathata from the point of view of the                to ascend a mountain to its peak. These cultivators void, attributeless absolute; the real-nature is              who, thought after thought, above pray for bhutatathata from the point of view of phenomena.             Buddhahood; mind after mind, below rescue Chaân Nhö Tín: Faith in bhutatathata—Tín caên                 sentient beings; hearing to become Buddha will Baûn—Tin lyù Chaân Nhö laø thaày cuûa chö Phaät—              take forever, do not become fearful and wish to Faith in bhutatathata (chaân nhö) as the teacher of           regress. Such development of the Bodhi Mind is all Buddhas.                                                  called “true.”—See Taùm Caùch Phaùt Taâm Boà Ñeà. Chaân Nhö Tuøy Duyeân: Tuøy duyeân chaân nhö laø              Chaân Phaùt Minh Taùnh: Tinh thaàn chaân ñaïi giaùc tuøy theo nhieãm duyeân voâ minh maø sinh ra voïng            hay giôùi luaät cuûa taâm trong vieäc phaùt trieån tinh phaùp, hay chaân nhö aûnh höôûng bôûi ngoaïi caûnh,           thaàn Phaät taùnh caên baûn—The spirit of true tònh hay baát tònh, maø sanh ra vaïn phaùp —The               enlightenment (the discipline of the mind for the conditioned Bhutatathata or relative condition—               development of the fundamental spiritual or The Bhutatathata influenced by environment, or                Buddha-nature. pure and impure conditions, produces all things—              Chaân Phaùp Voâ Töôùng: Chaân lyù döùt tuyeät moïi See Chaân Nhö Duyeân Khôûi.                                   hình töôùng—Absolute truth as having no Chaân Nhö Töôùng Hoài Höôùng: Transference of                 differentiated ideas nor appearances. the appearance of True Suchness.                              Chaân Phaùt Minh Taùnh: Spirit of true Chaân Nhö Voâ Vi: Tathata (skt)—True suchness—                enlightenment—Tinh thaàn chaân ñaïi giaùc hay giôùi Unconditioned True Suchness—See Saùu Phaùp Voâ                luaät cuûa taâm trong vieäc phaùt trieån tinh thaàn Phaät Vi Trong Duy Thöùc Hoïc.                                      taùnh caên baûn—The discipline of the mind for the Chaân Phaùp: Real dharma—Chaân phaùp voâ töôùng,              development of the fundamental spiritual or the ñoái laïi vôùi hieän töôïng ñöôïc coi nhö nhöõng kieán laäp   Buddha-nature. taïm thôøi—The real or absolute dharma without                Chaân Phaät: 1) Baùo thaân Phaät, ñoái laïi vôùi hoùa thaân attritbutes, in contrast to phenomena which are               Phaät: The sambhogakaya or reward body (the regarded as momentary constructs.                             unreality of the ego or phenomena), in contrast Chaân Phaùp Giôùi: Phaùp giôùi cuûa chaân lyù, döùt tuyeät    with the nirmanakaya, or manifested body; 2) hö voïng—The region of reality apart from the                 Phaùp Thaân Phaät (voâ töôùng): The Dharmakaya; 3) temporal and unreal.                                          Ñöùc Phaät töï nhieân chaân thöïc nôi mình (Kinh Phaùp Chaân Phaùt Boà Ñeà Taâm: True way of developing              Baûo Ñaøn noùi: “Taâm ta töï coù Phaät.”): The real the Bodhi Mind—Moät trong taùm caùch phaùt taâm Boà           Buddha in self; 4) Baûn taùnh thanh tònh nôi mình

(Kinh Phaùp Baûo Ñaøn: “Baûn taùnh töï nôi mình voán                  thuoäc Thôøi Toâng (Thôøi Toâng ñöôïc Nhaát Bieán thanh tònh.”): The natural purity in self.                            khai saùng vaøo naêm 1276)—Name of a Chaân Phaät Töû: Theo Thieân Thai Bieät Giaùo, chaân                  Japanese master of the Shih Sect in the Phaät töû laø Boà Taùt sô ñòa (ñaõ chöùng ñaéc chaân nhö              fourteenth century (Shih Sect was founded in ngaõ phaùp nhò khoâng)—According to the                               1276 by I-Bien (1238-1289). Diiferentiated Teaching of the T’ien-T’ai Sect, a               Chaân Saùm Hoái: Real repentance—Serious true Buddha son is the one who has attained the                 repentance—Toäi voán khoâng töôùng, do bôûi aûo first stage of bodhisattvahood, where he knows                  töôûng laàm meâ trong taâm maø gaây ra. Khi taâm saïch, thoroughly the unreality of theego and                          toäi cuõng heát. Khi caû taâm laãn toäi ñeàu khoâng, ñoù laø phenomena.                                                      chaân saùm hoái—Sins are empty, but created by Chaân Phaät Voâ Hình: Chaân Phaùp Voâ Töôùng—                   illusions and thoughts from a deluded mind. If the Chaân lyù döùt tuyeät moïi hình töôùng—Absolute truth           minds are purified, sins become vacant. When as having no differentiated ideas nor appearances.              both minds and sins are empty, then, it’s a real Chaân Phong Ñoä Thöôïc: OÁng thuït löûa cuûa thôï reøn,         repentance. yù chæ thuû thuaät maõnh lieät cuûa thieàn sö ñeå reøn luyeän   Chaân Saéc: Dharmakaya (skt)—Dieäu Saéc trong ñoà ñeä, cuõng nhö ngöôøi thôï reøn duøng oáng thuït löûa       Nhö Lai Taïng, töùc laø caùi dieäu saéc chaân khoâng ñeå reøn thanh saét laøm thaønh moät duïng cuï höõu             (theo Kinh Laêng nghieâm, trong Nhö Lai Taïng caùi duïng—A fire blow-pipe of a blacksmith. The term                tính saéc töï nhieân thanh tònh khaép trong phaùp means fierce expedient methods that some Zen                    giôùi)—The mystic or subtle form of bhutatathata masters utilize to train disciples, just as a                   (chaân nhö—absolute). The form of the void or blacksmith utilzes his fire blow-pipe to forge a                immaterial. piece of iron into a valuable tool.                             Chaân Taøi: Real talent. Chaân Phoå Hieàn: A true P’u-Hsien or                           Chaân Taùnh: Tatbhava, Bhutabhava, or Vastu samanatabhadra, a living incarnation of P’u-Hsien.              (skt)—Original nature. Chaân Phuï: Cha ruoät, trong Phaät giaùo, töø naøy aùm          1) Theå taùnh chaân thaät: True nature or true chæ ñöùc Phaät Thích Ca Maâu Ni—The real father,                      being—The root or essence of all things— in Buddhism, the term implies Sakyamuni Buddha.                       Chaân nhö hay tinh yeáu cuûa vaïn phaùp. Chaân Quaù: Caûnh giôùi ñaïi trieät ngoä. Tröôùc khi ñaït       2) Coøn goïi laø Chaân taùnh hay Phaät taùnh. Giaùc ñeán caûnh giôùi naày, haønh giaû phaûi vöôït qua giai                taùnh laø taùnh giaùc ngoä saún coù ôû moãi ngöôøi, hieåu ñoaïn höõu hoïc voâ hoïc. Trong Töù Thaùnh Tieåu Thöøa,               roõ ñeå döùt boû moïi thöù meâ muoäi giaû doái. Trong ba quaû ñaàu laø höõu hoïc (nghóa laø nhöõng ai ñaéc ba               Lieân Taâm Thaäp Tam Toå, Ñaïi Sö Haønh Saùch quaû Tu Ñaø Höôøn, Tö Ñaø Haøm, vaø A Na Haøm vaãn                    ñaõ khaúng ñònh: “Taâm, Phaät, vaø Chuùng sanh coøn phaûi hoïc ñaïo tu haønh), coøn quaû thöù tö laø A La            khoâng sai khaùc. Chuùng sanh laø Phaät chöa Haùn, vöôït ra ngoaøi höõu hoïc—The realm of                          thaønh; A Di Ñaø laø Phaät ñaõ thaønh. Giaùc taùnh absolutely great enlightenment. Before reaching                       ñoàng moät chôù khoâng hai. Chuùng sanh tuy ñieân this realm, practitioner must surpass the learning                    ñaûo meâ laàm, song Giaùc Taùnh chöa töøng maát; and beyond learning stage. In Hinayana those in                       chuùng sanh tuy nhieàu kieáp luaân hoài, song Giaùc the first three stages of training as arhats, the                     Taùnh chöa töøng ñoäng. Chính theá maø Ñaïi Sö fourth and last stage being those beyond the need                     daïy raèng moät nieäm hoài quang thì ñoàng veà nôi of further teaching or study.                                         baûn ñaéc.”: Also called True Nature or Buddha Chaân Quaùn:                                                          Nature. The enlightened mind free from all 1) Meditation on the truth (Khoâng quaùn)—                            illusion. The mind as the agent of knowledge, Khoâng quaùn hay quaùn veà lyù chaân ñeá maø ñoaïn               or enlightenment. In the Thirteen Patriarchs tröø kieán hoaëc vaø tö hoaëc—Meditation on the                  of Pureland Buddhism, the Tenth Patriarch reality of the void, or infinite, in order to be                 Ching-She confirmed: “Mind, Buddha, and rid of illusion in views and thoughts.                           Sentient Beings, all three are not any 2) (1269-1341): Shinkuan (jap)—Teân cuûa moät vò                      different. Sentient beings are Buddhas yet to danh Taêng Nhaät Baûn vaøo theá kyû thöù XIV,                    be attained, while Amitabha is Buddha who

has attained. Enlightened Nature is one and                    manifesting his true nature, no matter what not two. Even though we are delusional,                        that person is doing. It is that simple. As a blind, and ignorant, but even so our                           human being, you cannot do anything but Enlightened Nature has never been disturbed.                   manifest your true nature.'' Thus, once seeing the light, all will return to           4) See Chaân Nhö. the inherent enlightenment nature.”                       Chaân Taùnh Söï Vaät: Vastu-dharma (skt)—The 3) Chaân nhö Phaät tính hay taâm theå thanh tònh             true nature of things—Suchness of all dharmas— trong saùng nôi moãi ngöôøi (khoâng hö voïng laø          Theo nhaø Thieàn, chaân taùnh ôû khaép nôi. Chaân Taùnh chaân, khoâng bieán ñoåi laø tính). Dennis Genpo          bao quanh moïi vaät. Chaân Taùnh ôû beân trong, chaân Merzel vieát trong quyeån 'Con Maét Khoâng Bao            taùnh ôû beân ngoaøi. Chuùng sinh sanh ra giöõa loøng Giôø Nguû': "Chaân taùnh cuûa taát caû moïi vaät vaãn     chaân taùnh. Hôn nöõa, cuoäc soáng cuûa chuùng ta vaø caùi ñöôïc phaùt loä moät caùch lieân tuïc. Khi con choù       chaân taùnh naøy khoâng bao giôø coù theå taùch rôøi. Chaân suûa hay teø ra ñaát, aáy laø noù phaùt loä caùi chaân    Taùnh luoân ôû beân chuùng ta baát keå laø chuùng ta ôû ñaâu taùnh cuûa noù. Con choù phaùt loä taùnh choù cuûa noù,   (daàu laø leân coõi trôøi hay xuoáng coõi ñòa nguïc)— gioáng nhö caây gaäy quaúng xuoáng ñaát phaùt loä         According to Zen, the true nature of things is taùnh gaäy cuûa noù. Taát caû nhöõng gì toàn taïi treân   everywhere. It surrounds everything. It's inside ñôøi chung qui ñeàu phaùt loä chaân taùnh cuûa mình.      and outside of things. We were born with this true Chuùng ta khoâng bao giôø nhìn moät caùi caây vaø         nature and will pass away with it. What's more, noùi: 'Caây naøy khoâng toaøn thieän, noù khoâng phaùt    our lives and this true nature can never be loä chaân taùnh cuûa noù.' Chuùng ta chæ töï nhìn         separated. It is forever with us no matter where mình hay nhìn ngöôøi khaùc vaø noùi: 'Chuùng ta           we go (heavens or hells). khoâng phaùt loä chaân taùnh cuûa mình.' Taïi sao         Chaân Taùnh Thieàn: Baûn chaát thaät cuûa Thieàn— chuùng ta noùi nhö vaäy? Bôûi vì khi noùi veà con         True nature of Zen—See Baùt Caâu Nghóa. ngöôøi, chuùng ta coù yù nieäm veà tính thaùnh thieän,      "Giaùo ngoaïi bieät truyeàn, veà söï hoaøn haûo cuûa con ngöôøi. Vaø chuùng ta            Baát laäp vaên töï, khoâng hieåu raèng con ngöôøi, trong moïi vieäc y            Tröïc chæ nhaân taâm, laøm, ñeàu phaùt loä chaân taùnh cuûa mình. Ñôn              Kieán taùnh thaønh Phaät." giaûn theá thoâi. Laø con ngöôøi, baïn khoâng theå          "A special transmission outside the scriptures; laøm gì khaùc hôn laø phaùt loä chaân taùnh cuûa             No dependence upon words and letters; baïn."—The true nature; the fundamental                      Direct pointing at the mind of men; nature of each individual, i.e. the Budha-                   Seeing into one’s nature and the attainment of nature. Dennis Genpo Merzel wrote in The                     Buddhahood." Eye Never Sleeps: "The true nature of all                 Chaân Taùnh Yeáu Taäp Naïn Ngöõ Thích: Tattva- things is continuously manifesting. When a                Samgraha-panjika (skt)—Nhieáp Chaân Thaät Luaän dog barks or pees on the ground, that dog's               Thích—Interpretation of the Treatise on Holding true nature is in realization. The dog is                 the Truth. manifesting dog nature, just as a stick lying on          Chaân Taùnh Yeáu Taäp Tuïng: Tattva-Samgraha- the ground manifests its stick nature. All                karika (skt)—Nhieáp Chaân Thaät Luaän—Name of a things are always manifesting their true                  work of commentary on Holding the Truth— nature. We never look out at a tree and say,              Treatise on Holding the Truth. 'That tree is imperfect, that tree is not                 Chaân Taâm: Nhö Lai Taïng Taâm—True mind— manifesting its true nature.' We only look at             True nature—The original, simple, pure, natural ourselves and other human beings and say,                 mind of all creatures—The Buddha-mind (taâm 'We are not manifesting our true nature.' Why             Phaät)—The mind of the Buddha—Buddha nature do we say that? Because when it comes to                  (Phaät taùnh)—Womb of the Tathagata (Nhö Lai humans, we have an idea of what it is to be               taïng)—Dharma realm (phaùp giôùi)—Dharma saintlike, to be a perfect human being. We                nature (phaùp taùnh)—True mark (Thaät töôùng)— don't realize that each human being is always             Nirvana (Nieát baøn)—Dharma body (Phaùp thaân)—

True mind (chôn taâm)—Alaya consciousness of                   to do so, we would be wrong about the the Tathagata (A Laïi Da thöùc)—Prajan (Baùt                   manifestations of the ocean and fail to understand nhaõ)—Original face (Baûn lai dieän muïc)—Self-                truly what the ocean is. Therefore, when we nature (töï taùnh)—True nature (baûn taùnh)—True               abandon phenomena, noumenon cannot stand by emptiness (chaân khoâng)—Chaân taâm laø moät thöïc             itself; when we reject marks, essence cannot theå chung goàm hai phaàn höõu vi vaø voâ vi. Theo Ñaïi        remain stable. In the Diamond Sutra, the Buddha Thöøa Khôûi Tín Luaän, chaân taâm coù hai phaàn: taùnh         stated: “Who sees Me by form, who seeks Me in vaø töôùng. Phaàn Taùnh goïi laø chaân nhö moân, phaàn         sound, perverted are his footsteps upon the way, Töôùng goïi laø sanh dieät moân. Chaân nhö khoâng rôøi         for he cannot perceive the Tathagatha.” However, sanh dieät, sanh dieät töùc laø chaân nhö. Bôûi theá Maõ       the Buddha immediately told Subhuti: “Subhuti, Minh Boà Taùt goïi phaàn chaân nhö laø taïng Nhö thaät         do not think the opposite either that when the khoâng, phaàn sanh dieät laø taïng nhö thaät baát khoâng.      Tathagatha attained Supreme Enlightenment it Caû hai ñoàng chung moät theå taùnh nhö thaät. Ví nhö          was not by means of his possession of the thirty- maët bieån to roäng, khoâng theå chæ chaáp nhaän phaàn         two marks of physical excellence. Do not think nöôùc maø boû ñi phaàn soùng boït; vì chaáp nhö theá töùc      that. Should you think that, then when you begin ñaõ sai laïc vôùi hieän töôïng cuûa bieån, maø cuõng chaúng    the practice of seeking to attain supreme bieát bieån laø gì? Cho neân boû söï töùc lyù khoâng thaønh,   enlightenment you would think that all systems of baùc töôùng thì taùnh khoâng ñöùng vöõng. Theo Kinh            phenomena and all conceptions about phenomena Kim Cang, Ñöùc Phaät baûo: “Keû naøo duøng saéc töôùng         are to be cut off and rejected, thus falling into aâm thanh thaáy vaø tìm caàu ta, laø keû haønh taø ñaïo.”      nihilism. Do not think that. And why? Because Nhöng lieàn theo ñoù Ngaøi laïi baûo: “Tu Boà Ñeà! OÂng        when a disciple practices seeking to attain ñöøng nghó raèng Nhö Lai khoâng duøng töôùng cuï tuùc          supreme enlightenment, he should neither grasp ñaéc quaû A Naäu Ña La Tam Mieäu Tam Boà Ñeà. Tu               after such arbitrary conceptions of phenomena nor Boà Ñeà! Neáu oâng suy nghó phaùt taâm A Naäu Ña La            reject them. First, the Buddha taught that we Tam Mieäu Tam Boà Ñeà laø noùi caùc phaùp ñoaïn dieät.         should not follow sounds, forms and marks in Ñöøng nghó nhö theá! Taïi sao? Vì phaùt taâm A Naäu            seeking the Way. But right after that, He Ña La Tam Mieäu Tam Boà Ñeà, ñoái vôùi caùc phaùp              reminded that at the same time, we should not khoâng noùi töôùng ñoaïn dieät.” Tröôùc tieân Ñöùc Phaät       abandon sounds, forms and marks, nor should we daïy ñöøng theo aâm thanh saéc töôùng maø tìm ñaïo,            destroy all dharmas. Thus we can see that the nhöng lieàn sau ñoù Ngaøi laïi nhaéc nhôû ‘cuõng ñöøng         Way belongs neither to forms, nor to emptiness. rôøi boû aâm thanh saéc töôùng hoaë c dieät heát caùc phaùp    Clinging to either aspect is misguided. ñeå phaùt taâm caàu ñaïo. Nhö theá ta thaáy ñaïo chaúng        Chaân Taâm Quaùn: Phaùp quaùn duøng chaân taâm laøm thuoäc veà saéc, maø cuõng chaúng thuoäc veà khoâng. Tìm       ñoái töôïng—The method of contemplation that chaáp moät beân laø sai laàm—True mind is a common             takes true mind (true nature or the original, true state encompassing both the conditioned and               simple, pure, natural mind of all creatures or the the unconditioned.” According to the Treatise on               Buddha-mind) as its object of contemplation. the Awakening of Faith, the true mind has two                  Chaân Taâm Roäng Lôùn: Broad and spacious true aspects: essence and marks. The aspect of essence              mind. is called the door of True Thusness, the aspect of             Chaân Taâm Saùng Choùi Vaø Toûa Khaép: The true marks is called the door of Birth and Death. True              mind is all-extensive and all-illuminating. Thusness is inseparable from Birth and Death.                  Chaân Taâm Vi Dieäu Saùng Choùi: The wonderful, Birth and Death are True Thusness. This is why                 bright true mind. Patriarch Asvaghosha called True Thusness the                  Chaân Teá: "truth-like Emptiness Treasury" and”Birth and                  1) The region of reality, ultimate truth—See Death the “truth-like Non-Emptiness treasury.”                      Chaân Thöïc. True Thusness and Birth and Death have the same                2) (800-860): Shinzei (jap)—Khai toå toâng Thieân truth-like nature. For instance, the great ocean, we                Thai Nhaät Baûn—Founder of the Japanese cannot accept sea water but not waves. If we were                   Tendai.

Chaân Thanh:                                                 Chaân Thaät Ñaïo Tam Muoäi Trí Quang: Söï thaønh 1) (1537-1593): Zen master Jen-Ch'ing—Teân                   ñaït tam muoäi cuûa hoï ñaày ñuû aùnh saùng cuûa trí tueä cuûa moät vò danh Taêng Trung Hoa vaøo theá kyû         xuaát phaùt töø böôùc ñi treân con ñöôøng chaân chaùnh— XVI, döôùi thôøi nhaø Minh—Name of a Chinese            Their attainment of the Samadhi is full of the light famous monk in the sixteenth century, during            of knowledge which is derived from walking the the Ming dynasty (1368-1644).                           path of righteousness. 2) (1588-1674): Master Jen-Ch'ing—Teân cuûa                  Chaân Thaät Giaùc Ngoä: True enlightenment—Teân moät vò Taêng Nhaät Baûn, thuoäc Tònh Ñoä Toâng—        cuûa chöông thöù tö trong taäp 'Giaùo-Haïnh-Tín- Name of a Japanese monk, of the Pure Land               Chöùng' cuûa ngaøi Thaân Loan—Name of the fourth Sect.                                                   chapter of the Kyogyoshinsho ('Teaching, Chaân Thanh Nhaõn Töôùng: Maét xanh bieác—Eyes               Practice, Faith, and Enlightenment'), written by deep (violet) blue, one of the thirty-two auspicious         Hsin-Luan. marks—See Tam Thaäp Nhò Haûo Töôùng.                         Chaân Thaät Haïnh: Conduct of true actuality— Chaân Thaønh: Devout—Sincerity.                              Haïnh tu haønh theo chaân lyù cuûa Ñöùc Phaät. Haïnh theå Chaân Thaønh Caàu Ñaïo: To be faithfully wishing             hieän trong taát caû moïi söï vaät tính thanh tònh vaø chaân for the Dharma.                                              thaät, moät trong möôøi haïnh cuûa chö Boà Taùt—The Samvritikaya (skt)—ÖÙng thaân, caùi thaân maø Ñöùc           practice of truth or the conduct of manifesting in Phaät mang nhaèm vì lôïi ích cuûa chuùng sanh—The            all things the pure, final and true reality, one of body assumed by the Buddha for the benefit of all            the ten lines of actions of a Bodhisattva—See beings.                                                      Thaäp Haïnh Boà Taùt. Chaân Thaïnh (1443-1495): Shinzei (jap)—Khai toå             Chaân Thaät Nghóa: The real meaning of things. phaùi Chaân Thaïnh thuoäc toâng Thieân Thai Nhaät            Chaân Thaät Nhaân Theå: Initial form—Original Baûn—Founder of the Shin-zei sect of the                     form—Former state of things—Thuaät ngöõ Thieàn Japanese Tendai.                                             aùm chæ ngöôøi chöùng ngoä Thieàn thì baát cöù ôû ñaâu vaø Chaân Thaân: Paramarthakaya (skt).                           baát cöù nôi naøo cuõng hoaøn toaøn soáng vôùi Baûn Lai 1) Phaùp taùnh phaùp thaân: Dharmakaya (skt)—                Dieän Muïc cuûa chính mình—The Zen term that Thaân cuûa Phaät ñaõ chöùng lyù theå phaùp taùnh—       indicates that an enlightened person always lives Dharma-Nature or dharmakaya.                            with his own Original face or Buddha-nature in 2) Thaân chaân thaät cuûa Phaät: Samvritikaya (skt)—         anywhere and at anytime. Body of ultimate truth—The true body—                   Chaân Thaät Nhö Lai: Mulatathagata (skt)—Phaùp Buddha as absolute.                                     Thaân—Real Tathagata—Dharmakaya. Chaân Thaân Quaùn: Phaùp quaùn töôûng thaáy toû roõ          Chaân Thaät Nhö Teá: See Chaân Thöïc. chôn thaân maø Ñöùc Phaät A Di Ñaø ñaõ thò hieän nôi         Chaân Thaät Quy Maïng Taâm: True entrusting coõi Cöïc Laïc. Ñaây laø phaùp quaùn thöù chín trong 16      mind—True entrusting heart—Mind with faith of phaùp quaùn—Visualization of the Reward body of              the other-power—Taâm tin töôûng nôi tha löïc. Amitabha Buddha, i.e. the form in which he                   Chaân Thaät Tam Baûo: See Hoùa Töôùng Tam Baûo appears in the Pure Land. This is the ninth of the           and Nguõ Giaùo. sixteen kinds of contemplations—See Thaäp Luïc               Chaân Thaät Taùnh Trí: Wisdom of nature of Quaùn.                                                       phenomena—Wisdom of the true nature of reality, Chaân Thaät: Sattya (skt)—The real—Honest—                   not as it appears to individuals in samsara. Frank—Reality—Sincere—Truth.                                 Chaân Thaät Taêng: True monks—Chaân thaät Taêng Chaân Thaät Baùo Ñoä: Thoï Duïng Ñoä, quoác ñoä cuûa         bao goàm nhöõng baäc Thaùnh nhaân coøn ôû baäc höõu baùo thaân Nhö Lai—The realm of Sambhogakaya.                hoïc, vaø nhöõng baäc ñaõ hoaøn thaønh tu taäp (khoâng Chaân Thaät Bieän Taøi: Bieän taøi chôn thaät nôi taát caû   coøn phaûi hoïc nöõa)—True monks include sages caùc phaùp—Intellectual power of truthfully                  who are still in the stage of discipline (Sekho explaining all things.                                       puggalo (p), and the non-learner (Asekho puggalo Chaân Thaät Cöùu Caùnh Giaûi Thoaùt: True end of             (p)—See Töù Chuûng Taêng (4). salvation.

Chaân Thaät Taâm: True nature of the mind—Taâm                khaùc gì nguõ thoâng cuûa ngoaïi ñaïo? Neáu khoâng laøm chuùng sanh taùnh thöôøng roãng laëng nhö chaân nhö           ra töôùng maø thaáy thì laø voâ vi, leõ ra khoâng thaáy (baûn chaát thaät cuûa taâm)—Our mind is by nature            chöù?’ Baïch Theá Toân! Luùc aáy con nín laëng. Caùc vò that of the bhutatathata.                                     Phaïm Thieân nghe oâng Duy Ma Caät noùi lôøi aáy roài Chaân Thaät Teá: Region of reality—See Chaân                  ñaëng choã chöa töøng coù, lieàn laøm leã hoûi oâng raèng: Phaùp Giôùi.                                                  “Baïch ngaøi ôû trong ñôøi ai laø ngöôøi coù chôn thieâ n Chaân       Thaät    Thaân:      Sabbavakaya          (p)—    nhaõn?” Tröôûng giaû Duy Ma Caät ñaùp: ‘Coù Phaät Theá Svabbavikaya (skt)—Dharmakaya (skt)—Body of                   Toân ñöôïc chôn Thieân nhaõn, thöôøng ôû tam muoäi, dharma—Dharma-Body—See Phaùp Thaân.                           thaáy suoát caùc coõi Phaät khoâng coù hai töôùng.’ Khi aáy Chaân Thaät Theå: Baûn Lai Dieän Muïc—Initial                 Nghieâm Tònh Phaïm Vöông cuøng quyeán thuoäc naêm form—Original form—Former state of things—                    traêm Phaïm Vöông ñeàu phaùt taâm Voâ thöôïng Chaùnh Original face or Buddha-nature.                               ñaúng Chaùnh giaùc, ñaûnh leã döôùi chaân oâng Duy Ma Chaân Thaät Thieän: Goodness of true actuality—               Caät roài boãng nhieân bieán maát. Vì theá, con khoâng See Thaéng Nghóa Thieän.                                      kham laõnh ñeán thaêm beänh oâng.”—According to Chaân Thaät Thuyeát: Giaûi thích chaân thaät vaø chính        the Vimalakirti Sutra, Chapter Three, the Buddha xaùc—Accurately explain.                                      said to Aniruddha: “You call on Vimalakirti to Chaân Thaät Vi Dieäu Phaùp: Real, exquisite                   inquire after his health on my behalf.” Aniruddha Dharma.                                                       said: “World Honoured One, I am not qualified to Chaân Thaâu Baát Baùc Kim: Thau khoâng ñoåi ñöôïc             call on him and inquired after his health. For once vaøng, duï cho thoâng minh vaø ngu ñoän coù giaù trò          when I was walking about while meditating to khaùc nhau—Brass cannot be exchanged for gold,                prevent sleepiness, a Brahma called, ‘The i.e., intelligence and stupidity have different               Gloriously Pure’, together with an entourage of values.                                                       ten thousand devas sent off rays of light, came to Chaân Theå: Embodiment of truth—Fundamental                   my place, bowed their heads to salute me and of religion—Ñaïo theå hay söï theå hieän cuûa chaân lyù.      asked: ‘How far does your deva eye see?’ I Chaân theå hay chaân nhö laø neàn cuûa ñaïo, nhö töï taâm     replied: ‘Virtuous one, I see the land of thanh tònh. Ñöùc Phaät laø vò theå hieän chaân lyù—The        Sakyamuni Buddha in the great chiliocosm like an embodiment of truth, the fundament of religion,               amala fruit held in my hand.’ Vimalakirti i.e. the natural heart or mind, the pure nature, the          (suddenly) came and said: ‘Hey, Aniruddha, when universal mind, the bhutatathata. A Buddha is one             your deva eye sees, does it see form or who embodies the truth.                                       formlessness? If it sees form, you are no better Chaân Thieân Nhaõn: Real deva eye—Theo kinh                   than those heretics who have won five Duy Ma Caät, chöông ba, Ñöùc Phaät baûo A Na Luaät:           supernatural powers. If you see formlessness, “OÂng ñi ñeán thaêm beänh oâng Duy Ma Caät duøm ta.”          your deva eye is non-active (wu wei) and should A Na Luaät baïch Phaät: “Baïch Theá Toân! Con khoâng          be unseeing.’ “World Honoured One, I kept kham laõnh ñeán thaêm beänh oâng ta. Vì sao? Nhôù laïi        silent. And the devas praised Vimalakirti for what luùc tröôùc con ñi kinh haønh ôû moät choã noï, khi aáy coù   they had not heard before, They then paid vò Phaïm Vöông teân Nghieâm Tònh, cuøng vôùi moät             reverence and asked him: ‘Is there anyone in this muoân Phaïm Vöông khaùc, phoùng aùnh saùng trong              world who has realized the real deva eye?” saïch röïc rôõ ñeán choã con cuùi ñaàu leã vaø hoûi, ‘Thöa    Vimalakirti replied: ‘There is the Buddha who ngaøi A Na Luaät! Thieân nhaõn cuûa ngaøi thaáy xa            has realized the real deva eye; He is always in the ñöôïc bao nhieâu?’ Con lieàn ñaùp, ‘Nhôn giaû, toâi thaáy     state of samadhi and sees all Buddha lands coõi Tam thieân Ñaïi thieân Theá giôùi cuûa Phaät Thích       without (giving rise to) the duality (of subjective Ca Maâu Ni ñaây nhö thaáy traùi Am ma laëc trong baøn         eye and objective form).’ At that time, Brahma tay vaäy.’ Luùc ñoù oâng Duy Ma Caät ñeán noùi vôùi con,      and five hundred of his relatives developed the ‘Thöa ngaøi A Na Luaät! Thieân nhaõn cuûa ngaøi thaáy         anuttara-samyak-sambodhi mind; they bowed ñoù laøm ra töôùng maø thaáy hay laø khoâng laøm ra           their heads at Vimalakirti’s feet and suddenly töôùng maø thaáy? Neáu nhö laøm ra töôùng maø thaáy thì

disappeared. This is why I am not qualified to call                 thöùc): According to the Awakening of Faith, on him to inquire after his health.”                                the real knowledge is a knowledge which is Chaân Thieàn: Tathagata’s pure Dhyana—Ñaây laø                      free from illusion, the sixth vijnana—See Baùt phaùp thieàn thöù tö trong boán phaùp Thieàn. Theo                  Thöùc (6). Kinh Laêng Giaø, coù boán loaïi thieàn ñònh: quaùn saùt       Chaân Thöïc: Tattva (skt)—1) Chaân tính vaø thaønh nghóa thieàn (thieàn ñònh nhaèm quaùn saùt yù nghóa),         thöïc (lìa boû meâ tình, döùt heát hö voïng): Truth, ngu phu haønh thieàn (thieàn ñònh do phaøm phu thöïc          reality; 2) Ñieàu gì thöïc söï xaõy ra: What has haønh), nhö nhö thöïc phaùp thieàn (thieàn ñònh döïa          actually been or happened; 3) Söï kieän: Fact; 4) Söï vaøo nhö nhö), vaø Chaân Thieàn hay Nhö Lai thieàn            vieäc thöïc teá: Matter of fact; 5) Söï vieäc xaõy ra: An (thieàn ñònh tính thuaàn cuûa Nhö Lai)—This is the            actual occurrence; 6) Thöïc taïi: Reality; 7) Traïng fourth method in four kinds of dhyana. According              thaùi coù thaät cuûa söï kieän hay tröôøng hôïp: The real to the Lankavatara Sutra, there are four kinds of             state of a case or circumstance. dhyana: dhyana that surveys the meanings,                     Chaân Thöïc Höõu: Truly real existence—Chaân dhyana practiced by the ignorant, dhyana                      thöïc höõu chæ cho Nhö Lai taïng nhö duyeân khôûi, vaø depending on suchness, and the Tathagata’s pure               bao goàm caû hai thöù luaân hoài vaø Nieát baøn. Nhö vaäy, Dhyana—See Töù Chuûng Thieàn Ñònh.                            ñaây laø caùi nhìn ñuùng veà theá giôùi hieän töôïng cuûa Chaân Thieän Myõ: The truth—The good—The                      Duyeân khôûi—This refers to the Tathagatha-garbha beautiful.                                                    as conditioned co-arising and includes both Chaân Thuùc Ca Baûo: Kimsuka (skt)—Red                        samsara and nirvana. Thus reality is identical with pearls—Xích ngoïc.                                            this phenomenal world of pratityasamutpada Chaân Thuùc Ca Thuï: Kimshuka (skt)—Moät loaïi                correctly perceived. caây goác mieàn baéc AÁn Ñoä, cho ra boâng ñoû thaät          Chaân Thöïc Lyù Moân: Tuøy theo baûn yù cuûa chö Phaät ñeïp—Butea frondosa, a kind of tree originated                vaø chö Boà Taùt maø laøm saùng toû thöïc nghóa— from north India, that bears beautiful red                    Teaching of the truth revealed by the Buddhas and blossoms.                                                     Bodhisatvas. Chaân Thuyeân: Nhöõng baøi luaän giaûi veà chaân lyù—         Chaân Thöïc Minh: Söï chieáu saùng cuûa Phaät trí hay Commentaries or treatises on relaity.                         Baùt Nhaõ—The Truth-wisdom, or Buddha- Chaân Thuyeát: Lôøi thuyeát giaûng hay giaùo phaùp cuûa       illumination, i.e. prajna. Ñöùc Nhö Lai—True speech or teaching—The                      Chaân Thöïc Teá: Chaân nhö—The region of reality, teaching or preaching of the Buddha.                          the bhutatathata. Chaân Thöøa: The true teaching or doctrine—The                Chaân Thöïc Trí: Tattvajnana (skt)—Knowledge true vehicle—Mantra Vehicle—Chaân Ngoân                       of absolute truth. Thöøa—See Chaân Ngoân Toâng.                                  1) Trí hieåu bieát veà chaân lyù tuyeät ñoái, ñoái laïi vôùi Chaân Thöùc: Tathagata-garbha (skt).                                phöông tieän trí: Knowledge of absolute truth, 1) Nhö Lai taïng, töï tính thanh tònh khoâng ueá                    which is contrasted to knowledge of means nhieãm, hay thöùc A Laïi Da, hay thöùc thöù taùm:              (wisdom or knowledge that uses skillful The Tathagata-garbha—The eighth or                             means to save others) or Upayajnana. alaya—The original or fundamental unsullied              2) Bieát baûn theå chaân thöïc hay bieát hoaøn toaøn: To consciousness of mind                                          know the true nature or to know thoroughly. 2) Chaân Thöùc hay trí hueä Phaät, taâm vöôït thoaùt          3) Trí chaân thaät: Trí Baùt Nhaõ—Wisdom or khoûi luaân hoài sanh töû, laø moät trong ba thöùc             Knowledge of absolute (ultimate) truth. ñöôïc noùi ñeán trong Kinh Laêng Giaø: Buddha-           4) Voâ Trí: Knowledge of the no-thing, i.e. of the wisdom, innocent mind in all which is                          immaterial or absolute. independent of birth and death, one of the               5) Thaùnh Trí—Sage wisdom, or wisdom of the three states of mind or consciousness                          sage: Trí duyeân theo chaân nhö thöïc töôùng. mentioned in the Lankavatara Sutra.                            Chaân trí laø trí thaáy söï vaät nhö thöïc —Intuitive 3) Theo Khôûi Tín Luaän, chaân thöùc laø taâm thöùc lìa             wisdom means knowledge of things as they boû voïng nieäm, laø tònh taâm hay thöùc thöù saùu (yù         are.

6) Trí hieåu bieát veà chaân lyù tuyeät ñoái, ngöôïc laïi     Suøng Sôn Haïnh Nguyeän: 'Trong luùc toâi ngoài toïa vôùi phöông tieän trí. Chaân trí coù khaû naêng phaân   thieàn, tieáng oàn cöù theo quaáy nhieãu toâi. Toâi phaûi tích vaø phaân loaïi vaïn phaùp theo thöïc tính cuûa    laøm sao?' Ñaïi sö hoûi: 'Taám thaûm naøy maøu gì?' chuùng: Knowledge of absolute truth which is            'Maøu xanh.' 'Noù im laëng hay oàn aøo?' 'Im laëng.' 'Caùi contrasted to skilful knowledge. True                   gì buoäc noù im laëng?' Ngöôøi thieàn sinh nhuùn vai. knowledge has the ability to analyze and                Thieàn sö Suøng Sôn Haïnh Nguyeän noùi: 'Chính baïn classify things according to their real                 ñaáy. Chính yù nghó cuûa baïn taïo ra tieáng oàn vaø söï im properties.                                             laëng. Neáu baïn nghó ñieàu gì ñoù laø oàn, noù seõ oàn. Neáu Chaân Thöïc Töôùng: Ñaëc taùnh chaân thaät—True               baïn nghó ñieàu gì ñoù laø yeân laëng, noù seõ yeân laëng. characteristics.                                              Tieáng oàn khoâng phaûi laø tieáng oàn. Im laëng khoâng Chaân Thöôøng: Phaùp chaân thöïc thöôøng truï maø Ñöùc        phaûi laø im laëng. Söï yeân laëng ñích thöïc khoâng phaûi Nhö Lai sôû ñaéc—True and eternal; the eternal                laø im laëng maø cuõng khoâng phaûi laø oàn aøo. Neáu baïn reality of Buddha-truth.                                      nghe tieáng oàn cuûa xe coä ñi laïi vôùi moät caùi taâm Chaân Thöôøng Löu Truù: Troâi giaït trong caûnh giôùi         thanh tònh, khoâng vöôùng moät töï nieäm naøo, tieáng oàn Chaân Thöôøng. Moät vò Taêng hoûi: "Laøm theá naøo ñeå        khoâng coøn laø tieáng oàn, noù laø chính noù. Tieáng oàn vaø lieãu sanh giaø, thoaùt beänh töû?" Linh Vaân noùi: "Nuùi     im laëng ñoái nghòch nhau. Chaùnh giaùc chæ laø nhö xanh treân caên baûn laø chaúng bao giôø ñoäng; coøn maây     theá.' Im laëng moät laùt, Ñoaïn Thieàn sö Suøng Sôn thì cöù beành boàng troâi noåi maõi." (chaân taùnh thöôøng    Haïnh Nguyeän tieáp tuïc noùi: 'Ñoái laäp vôùi maøu xanh haèng baát bieán, coøn sanh laõo beänh töû laø tuaàn hoaøn    laø gì?' Thieàn sinh ñaùp: 'Toâi khoâng bieát.' Thieàn sö bieán thieân trong caûnh giôùi chaân thöôøng löu truù hay     Suøng Sôn Haïnh Nguyeän noùi: 'Maøu xanh laø maøu nhö maây troâi noåi vaäy)—Floating back and forth in          xanh. Maøu traéng laø maøu traéng. Ñoù laø chaân lyù.'"— the eternal realm. A monk asked, "How can one                 True quiet is neither quiet nor noisy. Stephen escape from birth, old age, sickness, and death?"             Mitchell wrote in 'Dropping Ashes on the Buddha': Ling-yun said, "The green mountain is                         "One day a student at the Cambridge Zen Center fundamentally unmoving, but the floating clouds               said to Seung Sahn Soen-sa, 'I am disturbed by pass back and forth."                                         noise when I sit Zen. What can I do about this?' eternal.                                                      Soen-sa said, 'What color is this rug?' 'Blue.' 'Is it Chaân Tòch:                                                   quiet or nosiy?' 'Quiet.' 'Who makes it quiet?' The 1) Nieát baøn cuûa Ñöùc Phaät, ñoái laïi vôùi nieát baøn      student shrugged his shoulders. Soen-sa said, 'You cuûa haøng nhò thöøa—The true Buddha-nirvana            do. Noisy and quiet are made by your thinking. If as contrasted with that of the Hinayana.                you think something is noisy, it is noisy. Noisy is 2) (886-927)—Teân cuûa moät vò danh Taêng Nhaät               not noisy, quiet is not quiet. True quiet is neither Baûn cuûa toâng Chaân Ngoân vaøo theá kyû thöù IX—      quiet nor noisy. If you listen to the traffic with a Name of a Japanese master of the Shingon                clear mind. Without any concepts, it is not noisy, it Sect in the ninth century.                              is only what it is. Noisy and quiet are opposites. 3) Tuøng Duyeät Ñaâu Suaát Thieàn Sö: Tosotsu                 The absolute is only like this.' There were a few Juetsu      (jap)—Tou-shuai          Ts'ung-yueh—       moments of silence. Then Soen-sa said, 'What is Doushuai Congyue—See Ñaâu Suaát Tuøng                   the opposite of blue?' The student said, 'I don't Duyeät Thieàn Sö.                                       know.' Soen-sa said, 'Blue is blue. White is white. Chaân Tính: See Chaân Taùnh.                                  This is the truth.'" Chaân Tính Nhò Thaân: Phaùp thaân vaø Hoùa thaân—             Chaân Tónh Vaên Thieàn Sö: Zen master Cheân The Dharmakaya and Nirmanakaya.                               Ching Wen—Teân cuûa moät vò Thieàn sö Trung Hoa Chaân Tình: Sincere sentiment.                                ñôøi nhaø Toáng. Moät hoâm, Sö hoûi moät vò Taêng: "OÂng Chaân Tónh Laëng: True quietness—Söï yeân laëng               töø ñaâu ñeán?" Vò Taêng noùi: "Töø Ñaïi Döông." Chaân ñích thöïc khoâng phaûi laø im laëng maø cuõng khoâng         Tónh Vaên noùi: "Muøa haï roài oâng an cö ôû ñaâu?" Vò phaûi laø oàn aøo. Stephen Mitchell vieát trong quyeån        Taêng noùi: "Ñaïi Qui." Chaân Tónh Vaên noùi: "Queâ 'Tro Rôi Treân Thaân Phaät': "Moät hoâm, moät thieàn          quaùn oâng ôû ñaâu?" Vò Taêng noùi: "Höông Vieân Phuû." sinh ôû trung taâm Thieàn Cambridge hoûi Thieàn sö            Ñöa tay ra, Chaân Tónh Vaên noùi: "Taïi sao tay ta laïi

gioáng nhö tay Phaät nhö vaäy kìa?" Vò Taêng khoâng           Chaân Tònh Khaéc Vaân Thieàn Sö (1025-1102): bieát phaæ laøm sao. Chaân Tónh Vaên noùi: "Naõy giôø         Zen master Chen-ching K'o-wen (Zhenjing caùc caâu traû lôøi cuûa oâng môùi deã daøng vaø töï nhieân   Kewen)—See Khaéc Vaân Chaân Tònh Thieàn Sö. moät caùch tuyeät vôøi, baây giôø oâng caûm thaáy nhöõng      Chaân Toâng: Chen-tsung (chi)—Shinshu (jap)— chöôùng ngaïi gì khi laõo Taêng hoûi oâng veà vieäc tay ta    True sect. gioáng tay Phaät?" Vò Taêng noùi: "Con khoâng laõnh           1) Ñieàu maø caùc tín ñoà duøng ñeå goïi toâng maø mình hoäi ñöôïc vaán ñeà." Chaân Tónh Vaên noùi: "Taát caû ñeàu         toân theo. Toâng chæ laøm saùng toû caùi thöïc lyù cuûa heát söùc roõ raøng cho oâng, chaúng coù gì ñaëc bieät ñeå         chaân nhö phaùp töôùng—The true sect or oâng laõnh hoäi caû." Nghe Thieàn sö Chaân Tónh Vaên               teaching, a term applied by each sect to its pheâ phaùn nhö theá, vò Taêng laäp töùc gaït boû ñöôïc             own teaching. The teaching which makes nhöõng chöôùng ngaïi—Name of a Zen master in the                   clear the truth of the butatathata. Sung dynasty. One day, Cheân Ching Wen asked a                2) Chaân Toâng hay Tònh Ñoä Toâng cuûa ngaøi Chaân monk, "Where do you come from?" The monk                           Loan saùng laäp taïi Nhaät Baûn vaøo naêm 1224. said, "From Ta-yang." Cheân Ching Wen said,                        Toâng phaùi naøy toân Phaät A Di Ñaø laø vò Toân "Where did you pass your last summer sojourn?"                     Chuû cuûa toâng phaùi. Tín ñoà xem Coõi Tònh Ñoä The monk said, "Ta-k'uei." Cheân Ching Wen said,                   cuûa Ngaøi laø coõi nguyeän vaõng sanh cuûa tín ñoà. "Where is your native place?" The monk said,                       Ñaëc bieät laø toâng phaùi naøy khoâng ñoøi hoûi Taêng "Hsing-yuan Fu." Extending his hand now, Cheân                     Ni soáng ñoäc thaân—The True Sect, or Shin Ching Wen said, "How is it that my hand is so                      Sect of Japan, founded by Shinran in 1224 much like the Buddha hand?" The monk did not                       A.D., known as the Hongwanji sect. This sect know how to take it. Sai the master: "So far your                  considers Amida is the especial object of answers have been splendidly natural and easy;                     trust. The followers hope or wish to be reborn and what obstructions do you feel now that I ask                   in his Pure Land. Specifically, celibacy of about my hand ressembling the Buddha's?" The                       priests is not required. monk said, "I fail to perceive the point." Cheân              Chaân Toâng Ñaïi Sö: Zhen-zong-da-shi (chi)— Ching Wen said, "All is perfectly open to you, and            Kataku-Jin'e (jap)—Shinshu Daishi (jap)—Zen there is nothing special for you to perceive." Thus           master He-Ze-Shen-Hui—See Thaàn Hoäi Haø Traïch commented on, the monk at once had his                        Thieàn Sö. obstructions removed.                                         Chaân Traïng: True aspect. Chaân Tònh: Giaùo phaùp chaân thöïc vaø thanh tònh            Chaân Tri: Tattva-jna (skt)—Bieát baûn theå chaân cuûa Ñaïi Thöøa, ñoái laïi vôùi haøng nhò thöøa —The true     thöïc hay bieát hoaøn toaøn—To know the true nature and pure teaching of the Mahayana, in contrast to             or to know thoroughly. the Hinayana.                                                 Chaân Trí: Tattva-jnana or Viveka (skt)—Caên Baûn Chaân Tònh Boà Ñeà Taâm: Baûn chaát cuûa taâm Boà ñeà         Trí—Voâ phaân bieät trí—Chính theå trí—Nhö Lyù hay taâm vò tha laø taâm luoân mong ñaït ñöôïc giaùc          Trí—True         knowledge—Intuitive           wisdom— ngoä cho mình, ñoàng thôøi cuõng ñaït ñöôïc giaùc ngoä        Knowledge of truth. cho ngöôøi neân luoân luoân chaân tònh—The nature of          1) Trí chaân thaät: Trí Baùt Nhaõ—Wisdom or Bodhi Mind or the altruistic mind of enlightenment                 Knowledge of absolute (ultimate) truth. or a mind which wishes to achieve attainment of               2) Voâ Trí: Knowledge of the no-thing, i.e. of the enlightenment for self, spontaneously achieve                      immaterial or absolute. enlightenment for all other sentient beings, is               3) Thaùnh Trí: Trí duyeân theo chaân nhö thöïc always true and pure.                                              töôùng—Sage wisdom, or wisdom of the sage. Chaân Tònh Ñaïi Phaùp: Giaùo phaùp Ñaïi Thöøa luoân           4) Chaân trí laø trí thaáy söï vaät nhö thöïc —Intuitive luoân chaân thöïc vaø thanh tònh—The teaching of the               wisdom means knowledge of things as they Mahayana is always true and pure.                                  are. Chaân Tònh Giaùo: True and pure teaching—See                  5) Trí hieåu bieát veà chaân lyù tuyeät ñoái, ngöôïc laïi Chaân Tònh.                                                        vôùi phöông tieän trí. Chaân trí coù khaû naêng phaân tích vaø phaân loaïi vaïn phaùp theo thöïc tính cuûa

chuùng: Knowledge of absolute truth which is            He was one of the most outstanding disciples of contrasted to skilful knowledge. True                   Zen master Ming-Hsing, a Chinese Zen master knowledge has the ability to analyze and                who came to Vietnam with his master to spread classify things according to their real                 the Lin-Chi's Zen teachings. properties.                                             Chaân Töû: Ngöôøi theo Ñaïi Thöøa—True sons, or Chaân Trì La Thaàn: Kinnara (skt)—See Chaân Ñaït              Mahayanists—Con cuûa baäc Nhö Lai Chaân Chaùnh, La Ñaïi Töôùng.                                               hay haønh giaû chaân thöïc sanh ra töø mieäng Phaät, Chaân Truù: Teân cuûa moät vò Thieàn sö Vieät Nam             theo giaùo lyù cuûa Ñöùc Phaät, y vaøo chaùnh phaùp maø vaøo theá kyû thöù XVII, ñôøi thöù 36 toâng Laâm Teá. Sö      sinh ra—A son of the True One, i.e. Tathagata; a laø ñeä töû cuûa Thieàn sö Minh Haønh—Name of a               Buddha-son, one who embodies Buddha’s Vietnamese Zen master in the seventeenth                      teaching. century, of the thirty-sixth lineage of Lin-chi sect.         Chaân Töôùng: The reality. He was one of the most outstanding disciples of               Chaân Töôùng AÁn: Daáu aán cuûa chaân töôùng—The Zen master Ming-Hsing.                                        seal of reality—Seal of one true mark. Chaân Truyeàn: Orthodox.                                      Chaân Töôïng: Real image. Chaân Tu: Devout person—True cultivation                      Chaân Tyû Löôïng: Correct inference—Söï suy luaän (Practice)—Tröôùc nhôø duyeân tu, sau khi sanh                ñuùng ñaén. trong ñôøi roài thì chaân tu—Actual manifestation             Chaân Vaên: Vaên nghóa cuûa chaân lyù hay vaên nghóa here in this life.                                            maø chö Phaät vaø chö Boà Taùt thuyeát giaûng—The Chaân Tuïc: Chaân giaû—1) Teân khaùc cuûa “Söï Lyù”           writings of truth, those giving the words of the (söï lyù do nhaân duyeân sinh ra goïi laø “tuïc,” lyù taùnh   Buddha or Bodhisattvas. baát sinh baát dieät goïi laø “chaân”): Truth and             Chaân Vieân Giaùc: True and complete convention, the true view and the ordinary; 2)                enlightenment—Tröïc giaùc veà chaân lyù toái haäu hay Chaân lyù vaø hình töôùng beân ngoaøi (chaân laø khoâng       Nieát Baøn toaøn haûo cuûa Ñöùc Phaät—The perception hay tuyeät ñoái, tuïc laø giaû hay töông ñoái): Reality       of ultimate truth or the perfect Nirvana of the and appearance.                                               Buddha. Chaân Tuïc Nhò Ñeá: Satya-dvaya (skt)—Hai loaïi               Chaân Voïng: Taát caû chö phaùp ñeàu coù hai tính chaân chaân lyù chaân ñeán vaø tuïc ñeá—Two Truths (two             vaø voïng—All things have two characteristics: true forms of statement) of ultimate truth and mundane             and false, or real and unreal. truth—See Nhò Ñeá.                                            1) Phaùp tuøy theo tònh duyeân tam hoïc (Phaät Phaùp) Chaân Tuïc Trung Tam Ñeá: Tam ñeá "Khoâng Giaû                      thì goïi laø chaân, phaùp tuøy theo nhieãm duyeân voâ Trung" döïa treân trieát lyù cuûa ngaøi Long Thoï, ngöôøi           minh (khoâng giaùc ngoä) maø khôûi leân thì goïi laø ñaõ soáng ôû Ñoâng Nam AÁn Ñoä vaøo theá kyû thöù hai—              voïng: That which arises in Buddha-truth, Three prongs the identical void, identical                          meditation and wisdom is true, influences of temporary and identical middle, established by the                  unenlightenment is untrue. T’ien-T’ai sect. The system of threefold                      2) Chaân nhö chaân thöïc (baát sinh baát dieät) thì goïi observation is based on the philosophy of                           laø chaân phaùp, Caùc phaùp do nhaân duyeân sinh ra Nagarjuna, who lived in south-eastern India about                   thì goïi laø hieän töôïng hay laø voïng phaùp: The the second century A.D.—See Khoâng Giaû Trung                       essential bhutatathata is the real, phenomena and Tam Ñeá Thieân Thai.                                            as the unreal. Chaân Tueä: Teân cuûa moät vò Thieàn sö Vieät Nam             Chaân Voïng Nhò Taâm: Chaân taâm vaø voïng taâm — vaøo theá kyû thöù XVII, ñôøi thöù 36 toâng Laâm Teá, queâ    The true and false minds—Theo Kinh Phaùp Hoa, ôû Haø Baéc, Baéc Vieät. Sö laø ñeä töû cuûa Thieàn sö        coù hai taâm: Thöù nhaát laø Chaân Taâm hay chaân nhö Minh Haønh, ngöôøi ñaõ cuøng thaày mình (Thieàn sö            taâm. Chôn taâm laø Nhö Lai Taïng Taâm saún coù cuûa Chuyeát Chuyeát) sang Vieät Nam ñeå truyeàn baù giaùo         chuùng sanh hay laø taâm Phaät. Thöù nhì laø Voïng Taâm lyù thieàn cuûa toâng Laâm Teá—Name of a                      tieâu bieåu bôûi taùm thöùc. Voïng taâm laø taâm khôûi nieäm Vietnamese Zen master in the seventeenth                      phaân bieät sinh ra heát thaûy moïi caûnh giôùi— century, of the thirty-sixth lineage of Lin-chi sect.         According to the Lotus Sutra, there are two kinds

of mind. First, The true bhutatathata mind defined             Chaán Hoa (1908-1947): Zen master Jen-Hua— as the ninth Amalavijnana. The orginal, simple,                Teân cuûa moät danh Taêng Trung Hoa vaøo theá kyû thöù pure, natural mind of all creatures or the Buddha-             XX—Name of a Chinese famous monk in the mind. Second, the false or illusion mind as                    twentieth century. represented by the eight vijnanas. The illusion-               Chaán Höng: To develop—To prosper. mind results in complexity and confusion.                      Chaán Laõng Thieàn Sö: Chen-Lang (chi)—Zen Chaân Voïng Quaùn Caûnh: Hai phaùp quaùn cuûa toâng            master Chen-Lang—Teân cuûa moät Thieàn sö Trung Thieân Thai: ñoái töôïng quaùn chieáu laø chaân taâm, vaø      Quoác, soáng vaøo khoaûng cuoái theá kyû thöù taùm, ñaàu ñoái töôïng quaùn chieáu laø voïng taâm —Two methods           theá kyû thöù chín. OÂng laø moät trong nhöõng ñeä töû xuaát of contemplation of the T'ien-T'ai school: first, the          saéc cuûa Thieàn sö Thaïch Ñaàu Hy Thieân. Moät hoâm object of contemplation is the true mind, and                  Chaán Laõng hoûi Thaïch Ñaàu: “YÙ Toå Taây ñeán laø gì?” second, the object of contemplation is the illusion-           Thaïch Ñaàu noùi: “Hoûi caây coät kia.” Chaán Laõng noùi: mind—See Chaân Taâm Quaùn and Voïng Taâm Quaùn.                “Thöa, Chaán Laõng naày khoâng hieåu.” Thaïch Ñaàu Chaân Voâ: Chaân ñeá trung ñaïo laø nôi khoâng coù sanh        noùi: “Ta cuõng chaû hieåu.” Nhöng chính lôøi ñaùp naày dieät höõu voâ—The middle path of the higher truth             khieán Chaán Laõng toû ngoä—Chinese Zen master, where there is neither contemporary production                 lived in the end of the eighth and the beginning of nor contemporary extinction; neither existence nor             the ninth century. He was one of the most famous non-existence.                                                 disciples of Zen master Shih-T'o’-Hshis'ien. One Chaân Voâ Laäu Trí: Trí chaân thöïc voâ laäu hay voâ laäu      day Chen-Lang asked Shih-T’ou: “What is the trí cuûa Phaät vaø Boà Taùt ñoái laïi vôùi voâ laäu trí cuûa   idea of the First Patriarch’s coming from the haøng nhò thöøa (haøng nhò thöøa khoâng döùt boû phaùp         West?” Shih-T’ou replied: “Asked the post over chaáp, khoâng lìa boû sôû tri chöôùng)—The true                there.” Chen-Lang said: “I do not understand, sir.” knowledge of the Mahayana in its concepts of                   Shih-T’ou replied: “I, too fail to understand.” mental reality, in contrast with Hinayana concepts             However, this lighted up Lang’s ignorance, which of material relaity.                                           in turn became illuminated. Chaân Yeát Thanh Lieãu: Shingetsu Shoryo (jap)—                Chaán Linh: Rung chuoâng—To shake or ring a Xing-Liao-Zhen-Yieh—See Chôn Yeát Thanh Lieãu                  bell. Thieàn Sö.                                                     Chaán Nhöùt Thieát Haûi Loâi AÂm: Sound Emitted by Chaán: Chaán ñoäng—To shake—To thunder—To                      Ocean of All Universes. tremble—To rouse.                                              Chaán Nhöùt Thieát Phaùp Giôùi AÂm: Voice Chaán Chænh: To reorganize.                                    Pervading. Chaán Ña Maït Ni: Cintamani (skt & p): Chaán Ña                Chaán Vieät: Civara (skt)—AÙo nguû hay tuùi nguû—A Maït Ni—Ma Ni—Fabulous gem—Jewel of the                        garment, an article for sleeping on or in. thought—The philosopher’s stone—Sacred gem—                    Chaáp: Wish-fulfilling jewel—Ngoïc öôùc cuûa nhaø hieàn giaû.         1) Chaáp tröôùc: Laggati (p)—Lagati (skt)—Baùm Töø Phaïn ngöõ "Cintamani" coù nghóa laø “Ngoïc öôùc                 chaët vaøo, vöôùng maéc, cho raèng ngaõ vaø vaïn nhö nguyeän.” Ngoïc Ma Ni baûo chaâu hay Nhö YÙ                      höõu coù thaät—Tenet—To cling—To adhere— baûo chaâu, hay ngoïc öôùc nguyeän—The                               To stick or attach one’s self to—Holding philosopher’s stone, granting all one’s wishes.                      (grasping, clinging, attaching) on the belief of "Cintamani" is a Sanskrit term for “Wish-fulfilling                  the reality of ego and things. jewel.”                                                        2) Naém baét: To seize—To hold—To maintain. Chaán Ñaùn: Cina (skt)—Coøn goïi laø Chaân Ñaùn, hay           Chaáp Baûo Cöï Boà Taùt: The Bodhisattva Holding Thaàn Ñaùn, teân goïi nöôùc Trung Hoa vaøo thôøi coå AÁn       the Precious Torch. Ñoä (nôi maët trôøi moïc)—Name of China in ancient             Chaáp Chaët: Abhinivesamdhi or lelya (skt)—Close India (the place where the sun rises).                         attachment—Coá chaáp chaët. Trong Kinh Laêng Giaø, Chaán Ñòa: Laøm rung ñoäng maët ñaát—To shake the              Ñöùc Phaät daïy Mahamati: “Naøy Mahamati, coù voâ earth.                                                         soá löôïng caùc hình thöùc chaáp chaët vaøo theá giôùi Chaán Ñoäng: To shake—To move—To agitate.                      baèng caùch coi töøng chöõ trong kinh vaên töông öùng

ñuùng ñaén vôùi yù nghóa.”—Clinging or adhering                originated in ancient India. By bringing the ten very closely. In the Lankavatara Sutra, the                    fingers together. We symbolically make all ten Buddha reminded Mahamati: “Oh Mahamati,                        Dharma realms become one and are reminded of there are innumerable signs of close attachments               the Buddha nature within every being. By folding to the world by taking letters as exactly                      the palms, we show respect to and concentrate our corresponding to meaning.”                                     minds and our hearts upon the teachings of the Chaáp Chaân Lyù Heä Phöôïc: Chaáp ñaây laø chaân lyù—          Buddha. The bodily knot of adherence to dogmatic                       Chaáp Coù: Astika (skt)—Keû chaáp laø vuõ truï coù thaät. assertion of truth.                                            Phaät phaûn baùc caû hai phaùi chaáp coù vaø chaáp Chaáp Chæ Vi Nguyeät: Chaáp Ngoùn Tay Laøm                     khoâng—Realist—Who maintains the universe to Traêng—To mistake the finger pointing to the                   be real—The Buddha condemn both realists and moon for the moon itself—Trong töø ngöõ “Ngoùn                 non-realists—To cling to actuality (existence). tay chæ traêng,” giaùo phaùp cuûa Ñöùc Phaät ñöôïc ví          Chaáp Coù Chaáp Khoâng: Moät vaøi tröôøng phaùi cho nhö laø “ngoùn tay chæ leân traêng,” chuùng sanh phaûi         raèng thaø chaáp coù nhö nuùi Tu Di, coøn hôn laø chaáp bieát giaùo phaùp chæ laø phöông tieän ñeå tu haønh ñaït       khoâng nhö moät vi traàn.” Chaáp coù chaáp khoâng chæ ñöôïc giaùc ngoä chöù khoâng phaûi laø chaân lyù. Maët         xaûy ra khi chuùng ta chöa thaáu ñaùo chaân lyù nhaø traêng chæ cho chaân lyù hay söï giaùc ngoä. Ngöôøi tu         Phaät. Tuy nhieân, moät khi ñaõ thaáu trieät giaùo phaùp Phaät luoân neân voâ cuøng caån troïng, chôù neân laàm         nhaø Phaät, chuùng ta seõ khoâng chaáp vaøo beân naøo “ngoùn tay chæ traêng” hay phöông tieän tu haønh vôùi          caû—Clinging to existence or (clinging) to “traêng” hay muïc ñích toái thöôïng laø söï giaùc ngoä vaø     emptiness (non-existence). Some sects believe giaûi thoaùt—The teachings of the Buddha or the                that “It is better to be attached to existence, Dharma is only a finger pointing at the direction              though the attachment may be as big as Mount where living beings can reach enlightenment                    Sumeru, than to be atached to emptines, though (moon). The Dharma is only an expedient, which                 the attachment may be as small as a grain of should never be taken for the truth. The truth is              dust.” Clinging to existence or emptiness arises the Enlightenment. The moon stands for truth,                  only when we lack thorough understanding of the reality, or enlightenment. Buddhist practitioners              Buddha’s teachings. However, once we should always be very cautious, never mistake the              thoroughly understand the Buddha’s teachings, we teaching or the pointing finger for the moon or the            will not be attached to any extreme. goal of enlightenment and liberation.                          Chaáp Dieäc Höõu Dieäc Khoâng: Chaáp coù caû hai— Chaáp Chính: To assume power.                                  Attachment to both existence and non-existence. Chaáp Chöôùng: Chaáp vaøo töï kyû vaø chö phaùp, vaø           Chaáp Dieäu: Graha (skt)—The planets, nine or haäu quaû laø chöôùng ngaïi trong tieán trình ñi vaøo Nieát    seven—See Cöûu Dieäu, and Thaát Dieäu. baøn—The holding on to the reality of self and                 Chaáp Ñoaïn Kieán: See Ñoaïn Kieán Chaáp. things and the consequent hindrance to entrance                Chaáp Höõu: Chaáp coù—Cho raèng vaïn vaät laø coù into nirvana.                                                  thaät—Attachment to existence—To cling to the Chaáp Chöôûng: Greet by folding palms—Loái chaøo               idea that things are real. baèng caùch chaáp baøn tay laïi vôùi nhau—Chaáp hai            Chaáp Khoâng: Non-realist—To cling to emptiness baøn tay laïi trong moät tö theá bieát ôn ñeå chaøo ngöôøi     (non-existence)—To carry the term “Emptiness.” khaùc laø loái chaøo thaät uy nghi, baét nguoàn töø AÁn Ñoä.   Chaáp Khoâng Coù Khoâng Khoâng: Clinging to Baèng caùch chaép 10 ngoùn tay laïi vôùi nhau. Chuùng          neither existence nor non-existence. ta laøm daáu hieäu tieâu bieåu cho 10 phaùp giôùi laïi laøm    Chaáp Kieán: Lagna-samkhyam (skt)—Baùm chaët moät vaø nhaéc nhôû veà Phaät taùnh saün coù trong moãi        vaøo kieán giaûi cuûa mình hay giöõ laáy kieán giaûi chaáp chuùng ta. Baèng caùch chaáp hai baøn tay laïi vôùi nhau,      neâ töø taâm mình, khoâng daùm xa lìa neân sinh ra söï chuùng ta toû baøy söï toân kính vaø taäp trung taâm trí       laàm laïc muø quaùng veà taát caû moïi voïng kieán — cuûa chuùng ta vaøo giaùo phaùp cuûa Ñöùc Phaät—               Adhering or clinging to one’s interpretation— Folding palms is a graceful gesture to greet other             Views obstinately held, with consequent delusion, people is a dignified way of greeting which                    bigoted.

Chaáp Kim Cang: Channa-dorje (tib)—Vajrapani-                   founded on self as it is, only by chance does any bodhisattva (skt)—Bí Maät Chuû Boà Taùt—See Kim                 real good. We do some good, but by accident." Cang Thuû Boà Taùt.                                             Chaáp Ngaõ Tính: Chaáp vaøo caùi baûn tính cuûa caùi Chaáp Kim Cang Boà Taùt: See Chaáp Kim Cang.                    ‘toâi’—Attachment to the nature of a self. Chaáp Kim Cang Thaàn: Vajrapani-vajradhara                      Chaáp Nhaän Cô Baûn: Fundamental recognition. (skt)—See Kim Cang Thaàn.                                       Chaáp Nhaän Söï Chæ Trích: Accept the criticism of Chaáp Laïc: See Tröôùc Laïc.                                    others. Chaáp Lyù Boû Söï: Grasping at theory and                       Chaáp Nhaän Trôû Ngaïi: Take the troubles. neglecting practice.                                            Chaáp Nhaát Ngöõ Ngoân Boä: Sarvastivadah (skt)— Chaáp Ngaõ: Lagna-atman (skt)—Baùm chaët vaøo caùi              See Thuyeát Nhöùt Thieát Höõu Boä. Ta—Egoism—Ego-grasping (Clinging to the                         Chaáp Nhieãm: Taint interrelated to attachment— “I”)—Trong Töù Dieäu Ñeá, Phaät daïy raèng chaáp ngaõ           See Chaáp Töông Öng Nhieãm. laø nguyeân nhaân caên baûn cuûa khoå ñau; töø chaáp            Chaáp Phaùp: Lagna-dharma (skt)—1) Baùm chaët tröôùc sanh ra buoàn khoå; töø buoàn khoå sanh ra sôï seät.     vaøo giôùi luaät: To comply with the law; 2) Baùm Ai hoaøn toaøn thoaùt khoûi chaáp tröôùc, keû ñoù khoâng        chaët vaøo giaùo lyù: To cling to the dharma. coøn buoàn khoå vaø raát ít lo aâu. Neáu baïn khoâng coøn       Chaáp Phaùp Laøm Leõ Soáng Khieán Cho Caøng Meâ chaáp tröôùc, dó nhieân laø baïn ñaõ giaûi thoaùt. Vieän chuû   Laàm: To cling to the dharma and consider it as a Taøo Ñoäng Abora ñaõ vieát trong quyeån 'Hang Coïp':            reason of life would make one more stupid. "Chuùng ta thöôøng nghe nhieàu ngöôøi noùi veà hy sinh,         Chaáp Phaùp Töï Tính: Chaáp vaøo baûn chaát cuûa hieän queân mình, phuïc vuï tha nhaân, nhöng vì taát caû ñeàu         töôïng—Attachment to the own-nature of ñaët treân caên baûn cuûa chaáp ngaõ, nhöõ ng ngöôøi ñoù        phenomena. troâng chôø sôùm höôûng ñöôïc keát quaû baùo ñeàn. Nhö          Chaáp Phaát Bính: Caàm phaát traàn, bieåu thò cho theá ñoù laø moät ñieàu thieän xaáu xa, baát tònh, tuy raèng    quyeàn uy cuûa vò truï trì. Vò truï trì töï vieän phaûi vöøa vaãn coù theå goïi ñoù laø ñieàu thieän... Chöøng naøo maø      coù khaû naêng vì chuùng thuyeát phaùp, maø cuõng vöøa coù caùi chaáp ngaõ chöa dieät, trong luùc traùi tim meâ hoaëc      khaû naêng thöû nghieäm ngöôøi khaùc—To hold a vôùi caùi 'Toâi' chöa döùt ñöôïc, ñieàu thieän chæ laø aûo      duster, i.e., showing authority of an abbot. An töôûng vaø caùi aùc cuõng vaäy. Khi aûo töôûng vaãn coøn        abbot of a temple must have the ability to preach chöa deïp boû, hoïa chaêng chæ nhôø may maén maø caùi           and to test other people's abilities. goïi laø 'ñieàu thieän', voán döïa treân caùi ngaõ, coù theå    Chaáp Phi Höõu Phi Khoâng: Chaáp khoâng coù caû laøm ñöôïc ñieàu gì ñoù thaät söï toát. Chuùng ta laøm ñöôïc    hai—Attachment to neither existence nor non- chuùt ít ñieàu thieän nhöng chæ do tình côø dong ruoåi          existence. maø thoâi."—In the Four Noble Truth, Sakyamuni                  Chaáp Phong Thaàn: AÙt Neã La Thaàn—Truyeàn Buddha taught that “attachment to self” is the root             Thoáng Thaàn—Tradition Spirit. cause of suffering. From attachment springs grief;              Chaáp Sö Töû Quoác: Simhala (skt)—Tieáng Phaïn laø from grief springs fear. For him who is wholly free             Sim Ha La, phieân aâm laø Taêng Giaø La, dòch nghóa from attachment, there is no grief and much less                laø Chaáp Sö Töû nay laø nöôùc Tích Lan—Ceylon. fear. If you don’t have attachments, naturally you              Chaáp Söï: 1) Kieåm soaùt: To manage, to control; 2) are liberated. According to Soto Zen Abbot Abora                Ngöôøi troâng nom vieäc cuûa chuùng Taêng trong töï in The Tiger's Cave: "People these days talk about              vieän: A manager of all affairs in a monastery. sacrifice, about self-denial, about service, but as it          Chaáp Taùc: Samu (jap)—Work in a monastery— is all based on attachment to self, quite soon they             Chaáp taùc trong töï vieän (söï laøm vieäc trong töï vieän are expecting to see some result. So it is a mean               hay Thieàn vieän)—See Lao Taùc Thieàn. impure good, though good it may be called... Until Chaáp Taøng: Alaya-vijnana (skt)—A Lôïi Da—A attachment to self at the center melts. while the Leâ Da—A Laït Da—See A Laïi Da Thöùc. heart deluded by an I is not completely negated, Chaáp Taâm: Attachment to the activities of the good itself is an illusion and evil also. While the mind or the mind which clings to things as real— illusion remains unbroken, the so-called good, Taâm chaáp vaøo moïi thöù hay chaáp raèng vaïn höõu laø

thaät. Charlotte Joko Beck vieát trong quyeån 'Thieàn          But we never lose an attachment by saying it has Trong Ñôøi Soáng Haèng Ngaøy': Thay vì loaïi boû, quaù         to go. Only as we gain awareness of its true nature trình tu taäp nhaém vaøo choã nhìn thaáy baûn chaát cuûa       does it quietly and imperceptibly wither away; caùi maø chuùng ta tham aùi. Chuùng ta coù theå raát giaøu     like a sandcastle with waves rolling over, it just nhöng khoâng coù chaáp taâm vôùi caùi giaøu, hay chuùng        smoothes out and finally, where is it? What was ta coù theå khoâng coù gì maø laïi chaáp vaøo choã khoâng      it?" coù gì aáy. Thöôøng thöôøng, neáu chuùng ta nhìn thaáy         Chaáp Theo Truyeàn Thoáng Trì Tuïng Coå Truyeàn: baûn chaát cuûa caùi chaáp, chuùng ta coù khuynh höôùng        To attach to the traditional way of recitation and giaûm bôùt sôû höõu, nhöng ñieàu naøy khoâng caàn thieát.      worship. Phaàn lôùn caùc coâng phu tu taäp vöôùng maéc trong            Chaáp Thoï: Thu nhieáp vaø thoï trì nhöõng gì ñaõ ñöôïc nhöõng chuyeän khoâng ra gì naøy cuûa ngoaïi caûnh hay         truyeàn trao—Impressions, ideas grasped and held. cuûa taâm mình. "Taâm toâi neân tónh laëng." Caùi taâm         Chaáp Thuû: Upadana (p & skt)—Appropriating to cuûa chuùng ta chaúng ñaùng keå, ñieàu quan troïng laø         one’s self—Attachment—Grasping—Grasping at thaùi ñoä xaû chaáp ñoái vôùi nhöõng hoaït ñoäng cuûa taâm.    or clinging to exixtence—Laying hold of—Chaáp Vaø nhöõng caûm xuùc cuûa chuùng ta voâ haïi tröø phi          thuû—Taâm tham aùi dính chaët vaøo ñoái töôïng khoâng chuùng cheá ngöï chuùng ta; nghóa laø neáu chuùng ta quaù      buoâng rôøi—Thuû laø maéc xích thöù chín trong Thaäp tham chaáp vaøo chuùng, vaø luùc ñoù chuùng seõ gaây neân      nhò nhôn duyeân), laø söï raøng buoäc vaøo söï toàn taïi. söï khoâng hoøa hôïp cho moïi ngöôøi. Vaán ñeà quan            Moïi raøng buoäc ñaõ troùi chaët con ngöôøi vaøo söï toàn troïng nhaát trong tu taäp laø thaáy raèng chuùng ta coù       taïi vaø daãn daét ngöôøi aáy ñi töø söï taùi sanh naày ñeán chaáp taâm. Khi chuùng ta kieân trì vaø nhaãn naïi toïa        söï taùi sanh khaùc. Nhöõng ñoái töôïng raøng buoäc laø thieàn, chuùng ta baét ñaàu bieát raèng chuùng ta chaúng laø   nguõ uaån. Neáu caên cöù vaøo thaäp nhò nhaân duyeân thì gì ngoaøi söï chaáp tröôùc caû: chæ laø nhöõng chaáp thuû      ham muoán khieán chuùng sanh tìm buïng meï vaø töø ñoù chi phoái cuoäc soáng cuûa chuùng ta. Chuùng ta khoâng         daãn tôùi moät cuoäc luaân hoài môùi. Theo Ñöùc Phaät, bao giôø xaû ñöôïc moät chaáp tröôùc chæ baèng keâu noù        giaùc ngoä khoâng gì khaùc hôn laø caét ñöùt taát caû moïi ñi. Chæ khi naøo chuùng ta ñaït ñöôïc yù thöùc veà baûn        chaáp tröôùc. Chuùng ta coù theå chaáp tröôùc vaøo con chaát thöïc cuûa noù, moät caùch nheï nhaøng, kín ñaùo,        ngöôøi, vaøo söï vaät, vaøo nhöõng traïng thaùi maø chuùng chuùng seõ töï bieán ñi; gioáng nhö moät toøa laâu ñaøi        ta chöùng nghieäm, vaøo nhöõng suy nghó cuûa chính baèng caùt bò nhöõng ñôït soùng phuû traøn vaø san baèng,      mình, hay nhöõng yù ñònh töø tröôùc cuûa chính mình— vaø cuoái cuøng, chuùng ta seõ töï hoûi: Noù ñaâu roài? Noù    Clinging to existence, the ninth link in the Chain ñaõ töøng laø caùi gì nhæ?—Charlotte Joko Beck wrote           of Causation. The act of taking for one’s self. All in Everyday Zen: "The process of practice is to                attachments that create bonds that beings to see through, not to eliminate, anything to which               existence and drive them from rebirth to rebirth. we are attached. We could have great financial                 The objects of attachment are constituted by the wealth and be unattached to it, or we might have               five skandhas. According to the Chain of nothing and be very attached to having nothing.                Causation or Chain of Conditioned Arising, Usually, if we have seen through the nature of                 craving or attachment causes consciousness to attachment, we will tend to have fewer                         take possession in a womb and thus instigates the possessions, but not necessarily. Most practice                arising of a new existence. According to the gets caught in this area of fiddling with our                  Buddha, becoming enlightened is nothing other environment or our mind. 'My mind should be                    than cutting off all attachments. We can become quiet.' Our mind doesn't matter; what matters is               attached to either people, things, experiential nonattachment to the activities of the mind. And               states, our own thoughts, or preconceptions. our emotions are harmless unless they dominate                 Chaáp Thuû Baûn Ngaõ: Chaáp coù caùi “Ta” hay chaáp us; that is, if we are attched to them, then they              thuû baûn ngaõ laø coäi reã cuûa moïi taâm tai haïi—Self- create disharmony for everyone. The first problem              grasping—Self-grasping is the root of all harmful in practice is to see that we are attached. As we do           minds. consistent, patient zazen we begin to know that we             Chaáp Thuû Giaû Danh Taâm: Attachment to the are nothing but attachment: they rule our lives.               temporary name.

Chaáp Thuû Khoâng Taâm: Attachment to the Void               our efforts to escape, the more mayhem is created itself—See Phaùp Taâm Chaáp.                                 within phenomenal life, from war between nations Chaáp Thuû Phaùp Taâm: Attachment to all                     down to personal arguments between individuals, elements.                                                    to arguments within ourselves; all such problems Chaáp Thuû Töôùng: Ñoái vôùi caûnh khoå laïc chaúng          arise because we separate ourselves from our bieát ñoù laø hö huyeãn laïi sanh nieàm chaáp thuû. Thoâ     experience. The discomfort and pain are not the töôùng thöù ba trong saùu thoâ töôùng ñöôïc ñeà caäp trong   cause of our problems; the cause is that we don't Ñaïi Thöøa Khôûi Tín Luaän, nhôù maõi nhöõng vui             know what to do about them.—See Luïc Thoâ nhöõng buoàn coi nhö chuùng laø thaät chöù khoâng phaûi      Töôùng. laø aûo voïng. Khi moïi chuyeän ñeàu laøm cho chuùng ta      Chaáp Thuaän: To grant—To approve. vui thích, chuùng ta coá naém chaët laáy nieàm vui.          Chaáp Thöïc Tö Töôûng: Clinging thinking—Tö Trong luùc baùm chaët laáy laïc thuù, chuùng ta huûy hoaïi   töôûng coù tính caùch ñieân ñaûo laø moät loái suy töôûng noù. Tuy nhieân, khi chuùng ta toïa Thieàn, vaø thaät söï    khaùc cuûa con ngöôøi. Ñaây laø ñieåm quan troïng nhaát, tónh laëng, söï khoù chòu vaø caûm giaùc ñau ñôùn ñöa        phaùc thaûo caùi xu höôùng baåm sinh cuûa taâm thöùc chuùng ta trôû veà vôùi khoaûnh khaéc hieän taïi. Toïa       nhaân loaïi chaáp tröôùc caùi phöông dieän "höõu" hay Thieàn laøm cho chuùng ta thaáy roõ hôn laø noù laøm naûy    "töï tính" hieån nhieân cuûa vaïn phaùp; noù cuõng haøm yù sinh yù muoán troán chaïy hay taåu thoaùt. Nhöng khi         raèng tö töôûng nhaân loaïi luoân luoân coù tính caùch chuùng ta ngoài ñuùng theá, khoâng coøn caàn phaûi ñi ñaâu   "cöùng nhaét" vaø "coá ñònh". Taâm thöùc cuûa nhaân loaïi nöõa. Chuùng ta coù khuynh höôùng khoâng chòu hoïc           hieám khi hoaëc chaúng bao giôø thöøa nhaän caùi tröø phi chuùng ta caûm nhaän ñöôïc söï khoù chòu.           phöông dieän "khoâng", voâ töôùng vaø voâ töï tính cuûa Chuùng ta caøng khoâng yù thöùc veà söï khoù chòu vaø veà    vaïn phaùp. "Chaáp tröôùc" ôû ñaây coù nghóa laø baùm víu nhöõng coá gaéng ñaøo thoaùt cuûa chuùng ta, caøng coù       chaët vaøo maët "höõu" cuûa taát caû caùc phaùp, coi chuùng nhieàu söï hoãn loaïn ñöôïc taïo ra trong theá giôùi hieän   nhö laø thaät höõu vaø coù ñònh töôûng, nhö theå laø caùc töôïng, töø chieán tranh giöõa caùc nöôùc vôùi nhau, cho     phaùp ñeàu coù töï tính. Noùi toùm laïi, söï chaáp tröôùc cuûa ñeán söï tranh caõi giöõa caùc caù nhaân, hoaëc ngay giöõa   nhaân loaïi baûn tính noù voán chuyeâ n ñoaùn, coá ñònh, chính chuùng ta; taát caû nhöõng vaán ñeà nhö vaäy khôûi     vaø chuyeân nhaát, vì theá hoaøn toaøn töông phaûn vôùi leân bôûi vì chuùng ta töï taùch rôøi ra khoûi söï traûi     giaùo lyù Tính khoâng vaø Toaøn Theå cuûa Phaät giaùo. nghieäm cuûa chính mình. Caûm giaùc khoù chòu vaø noãi       Taát caû tö töôûng nhaân loaïi baét nguoàn töø hay phaùt ñau ñôùn khoâng phaûi laø nguyeân nhaân cuûa nhöõng          sinh bôûi caùi quan nieäm "thöïc höõu" caên baûn, maø vaán ñeà cuûa chuùng ta; nguyeân nhaân naèm ôû choã          voán laø voõ ñoaùn, böôùng bænh vaø coá ñònh. Neáu chuùng chuùng ta khoâng bieát laøm gì vôùi nhöõng caûm giaùc        ta nhaäp vaøo taän coát tuûy cuûa quan nieäm "thöïc höõu" khoù chòu vaø noãi ñau ñôùn aáy—Attachment or                naøy, chuùng ta caûm giaùc noù nhö chæ laø moät söï "chaáp clinging arising from consciouness of pain or                thöïc" khoång loà, thaâm caên coá ñeá. nghieân cöùu veà pleasure, or retention of memories of past joys              "chaáp tröôùc" cuûa nhaân loaïi laø moät chuû ñeà coát yeáu and sorrows as if they were reality and not                  trong Phaät giaùo; aûnh höôûng vó ñaïi cuûa noù phaûn aûnh illusions. The third of the six coarser stages in The        moät caùch thöïc tieãn trong toân giaùo, trieát lyù, taâm lyù, Awakening of Faith, retention of memories of past            vaên hoïc vaø ngheä thuaät Phaät giaùo trong moïi laõnh joys and sorrows as if they were realities and not           vöïc cuûa tö töôûng Phaät giaùo. Söï nhaán maïnh vieäc illusions. When things are pleasant, we try to hold          nghieân cöùu caùi chuû ñeà then choát vaø coù yù nghóa naøy on to the pleasantness. In trying to cling to                laø moät trong nhöõng ñaëc tính noåi baät ñaõ phaân bieät pleasure, we destroy it. When we are sitting in              giaùo lyù Phaät giaùo vôùi giaùo lyù cuûa caùc toân giaùo vaø meditation and are truly still, however, the                 trieát hoïc khaùc—Clinging thinking is another discomfort and pain draw us back to the present.             human way of thinking. This is the most important Sitting in meditation makes more obvious our                 point of all which delineates the innate tendency desire to escape or evade. When we are sitting in            of the human mind to cling to the apparently meditation well, there's no place to go. We tend             "existent" or "substantial" aspect of things; it also not to learn that unless we're uncomfortable. The            implies that human thoughts are always of a more unconscious we are of our discomfort and                "rigid" or "fixed" nature. The human mind seldom

or never recognizes the void insubstantial, and                  compelling men to reincarnate in one of the six "indefinite" aspect of things. "Clinging" here                   realms. Buddhists believe that Nihilism is false means the tight grasping of the "existent" facet of              because it is based on incomplete understanding all objects which are then regarded as real and                  of reality. Eternalism is also wrong, because definitive, as if they were in possession of their               Buddhists cannot accept that there is anything own self-natures. In short, human clinging is by                 either in this world or any other world that is nature arbitrary definitive and exclusive, and so is             eternal or unchangeable. diametrically opposed to the Buddhist teaching of                Chaáp Tình: Duïc voïng ngu xuaãn chaáp tröôùc vaøo Voidness and the Whole. All human thoughts are                   nhöõng caùi khoâng thaät—The foolish passion of derived from or produced by the fundamental idea                 clinging to the unreal. of "is-ness", which is essentially arbitrary,                    Chaáp Traùch: To take the responsibility. stubborn, and fixed. If we pierce into the very core             Chaáp Tri Thöùc: A ñaø na thöùc—The eighth of this idea of "is-ness", we sense it as being                  category of consciousness—See A Laïi Da Thöùc. nothing but a deep-rooted, colossal "chinging".                  Chaáp Trì: Dharana (skt)—Lagna-graha (skt)— The study of human "chinging" is a vital subject in              Hold on to—Giöõ vaøo hay naém vaøo khoâng lay Buddhism; its great influence is reflected in                    chuyeån. Giöõ chaët vaøo nghieäp, daàu toát hay xaáu. Buddhist religion, philosophy, psychology,                       Ñaây laø teân khaùc cuûa A Laïi Da thöùc—To hold literature, and art in practically all fields of                 firmly or to insist firmly on anything. Holding Buddhist thought. The emphasis on the study of                   together the karma, good or evil. It is another this crucial and significant subject is one of the               name for Alaya-vijnana. outstanding features that have distinguished the                 Chaáp Trì Thöùc: Adana-vijnana (skt)—Chaáp trì teaching of Buddhism from that of other religions                thöùc giöõ laáy taát caû caùc nhaân thieän aùc vaø giöõ cho and philosophies.                                                thaân theå cuûa höõu tình chuùng luoân luaân löu trong Chaáp Thöôøng Kieán: Attachment on Eternalism—                   luaân hoài sanh töû. Tieáng Phaïn laø A Ñaø Na Thöùc, Thuyeát naày tin raèng tröôùc khi laø ngöôøi, con ngöôøi         theo nghóa lyù Ñaïi Thöøa cuûa Phaùp Töôùng toâng, A khoâng coù hieän höõu, roài ñöôïc taïo neân, con ngöôøi          Laïi Da Thöùc coøn coù teân laø A Ñaø Na Thöùc—It ñöôïc sanh vaøo ñôøi do yù chí cuûa moät vò thaàn linh.          holds together, or is the seed of another rebirth, or Ngöôøi aáy soáng ñôøi mình, roài tuøy theo nhöõng gì             phenomena, the causal nexus. According to the mình tin töôûng hay nhöõng haønh ñoäng cuûa mình                 Mahayana Dharmalaksana School, Adana-vijnana trong ñôøi, seõ ñöôïc veà vónh vieãn treân coõi thieân ñaøng     is another name for Alaya-vijnana—See A Laïi Da hoaëc bò ñaøy vónh vieãn nôi ñòa nguïc. Thuyeát naày             Thöùc. khoâng ñuùng vôùi luaät “Luaân Hoài” cuûa ñaïo Phaät.            Chaáp Tröôùc: Abhinivesa or graha (skt)—To Theo giaùo lyù nhaø Phaät thì chuùng sanh laên loän trong        grasp, hold, or cling to anything—Dính maéc vaøo tö luaân hoài sanh töû, voøng luaân hoài xoay chuyeån               töôûng cho raèng vaïn höõu laø thöïc (dính chaéc vaøo söï chuùng sanh trong luïc ñaïo. Phaät töû khoâng tin nôi            vaät maø khoâng rôøi lìa. Moãi phaùp ñeàu coù nhieàu nghóa ñoaïn dieät, vì ñoaïn dieät caên cöù treân söï hieåu bieát       töông ñoái, neáu chaáp chaët vaøo moät nghóa, chaúng khoâng toaøn haûo veà chaân nhö thöïc taùnh; maø cuõng           bieát dung hoøa, chaúng bieát tuøy nghi, chaáp tröôùc nhö khoâng tin nôi thöôøng haèng vì Phaät töû khoâng tin theá        vaäy chæ laø töï haïn heïp laáy mình maø thoâi). Theo giôùi naày hay theá giôùi naøo khaùc laïi coù söï tröôøng cöûu   Truyeän Tieàn Thaân Ñöùc Phaät, coù moät caâu chuyeän khoâng thay ñoåi—This theory believes in                         veà ngöôøi ñaùnh baãy vaø con khæ. Ngöôøi ñaùnh baãy baét eternalism, believes that man was created by the                 con khæ baèng caùch naøo? Anh ta laáy moät traùi döøa vaø will of some Deity. He will live his life and act                khoeùt moät loå nhoû. Roài anh ta ñeå vaøi haït ñaäu phoäng according to his beliefs in order to return to                   beân trong vaø beân ngoaøi traùi döøa. Chaúng bao laâu, Heaven or to be condemned forever in Hell. This                  moät con khæ seõ ñeán vaø aên caùc haït ñaäu phoäng treân theory does not conform to the Buddhist law of                   maët ñaát. Roài noù seõ ñaët tay vaøo traùi döøa ñeå vôùi tôùi causality. In Buddhist view, men are tied to the                 nhöõng haït ñaäu beân trong. Vieäc naém caùc haït ñaäu cycle of birth and death, the cycle of                           phoäng beân trong traùi döøa seõ laøm cho tay noù lôùn reincarnation. This cycle turns around and around,               hôn, vì vaäy noù khoâng theå loâi tay ra khoûi loå hoång.

Noù la khoùc vaø noåi giaän, nhöng khoâng chòu buoâng          Chaát Ña: Citta (skt)—Coøn goïi laø Chaát Ña Da, boû caùc haït ñaäu ñeå ruùt tay ra. Cuoái cuøng, ngöôøi ñaët   Chaát Ñeá—Taâm hay caùi taâm suy nghó hieåu bieát— baãy ñeán vaø baét noù. Chuùng ta cuõng gioáng nhö con         The heart considered as the seat of intellect—The khæ treân. Chuùng ta muoán thoaùt khoå nhöng khoâng            thinking—The reflection mind. chòu buoâng boû caùc duïc voïng. Theo caùch naøy chuùng        Chaát Ña Da: Citta (skt)—See Chaát Ña. ta vaãn bò maéc keït maõi trong voøng luaân hoài sanh töû      Chaát Ña La: Citra (skt)—1) Taïp Saéc, maøu pha chæ vì söï THAM LUYEÁN cuûa chính mình—To                      chöù khoâng phaûi maøu nguyeân thuûy: Not to a cling to things as real. To grasp, hold, or cling to           primary colour, the variegated of mixed colour; 2) anything. A tendency for settling down in the                  Teân cuûa moät vì sao: Name of a star. mind. According to the Buddha Birth Story, there               Chaát Ñaùt La Baø Noâ: Citrabhanu (skt)—Chaát Ñaùt is a story about the Trapper and the Monkey. How               La Baø Nu—See Hoûa Bieän. does a trapper catch a monkey? He takes a                      Chaát Ñeá: Citta (skt)—See Chaát Ña. coconut and makes a small hole in it. He then puts             Chaát Ñeå: Caitya (skt)—Choàng chaát leân—To some peanuts inside and outside the coconut.                   assemble—To pile up. Before long, a monkey will come and eat the                    Chaát Lyù Nhaõ Ñeá: Trijati (skt)—Tijati (p)—Tam peanuts on the ground. Then he will put his hand               Sinh—Three generations (Past, present, and in the coconut to reach the peanuts inside. Holding            coming). the peanuts makes his hand bigger, so now he                   Chaát Tính: Substance. cannot pull it out through the hole. He cries and              Chaát Tröïc: Substantial and straight—Honestly— gets angry, but will not open his hand and let the             Firmly—Straight without disemblance. peanuts go. Finally, the trapper comes and catches             Chaâu: 1) Baûo chaâu Mani: Mani (skt)—A pearl, a him. We are like the monkey. We want to be free                bead; 2) Chaân lyù Phaät phaùp: The Buddha-truth; 3) from suffering, but we will not let go our desires.            Luïc ñòa: Continent. In this way we remain caught in Samsara because Chaâu Baûo: Ratanam (p)—Precious things. of our own ATTACHMENTS. Chaâu Baùu: Ratanam (p)—Precious things Chaáp Tröôïng Döôïc Xoa: Vajrapani-vajradhara (stones). (skt)—Chaáp Kim Cang Thaàn—See Kim Cang Chaâu Bieán: Universal—Everywhere—On every Thaàn. side. Chaáp Töông Öng Nhieãm: The stage of faith of Chaâu Bieán Du Laõm Thaàn: Traveling Everywhere Bodhisattvas—See Chaáp Töông Öng Nhieãm Taâm. Watching Deity (Spirit). Chaáp Töông Öng Nhieãm Taâm: Chaáp nhieãm cho Chaâu Bieán Phaùp Giôùi: The universal raèng caùi “döôøng nhö” laø caùi “thaät.” Ñaây laø giai dharmadhatu—The universe as an expression of ñoaïn cuoái cuûa Bích Chi Phaät Ñòa (Thanh Vaên vaø the dharmakaya—The universe. Duyeân Giaùc) hay Tín Truï Ñòa cuûa Boà Taùt. Ñaây laø Chaâu Chöû: Moät baõi caùt bieät laäp, yù noùi taùch bieät moät trong saùu thöù nhieãm taâm trong Khôûi Tín vôùi theá giôùi beân ngoaøi hay caét ñöùt phieàn naõo, ñoàng Luaän—The taint interrelated to attachment, or nghóa vôùi Nieát Baøn—An island, i.e. cut off, holding the seeming for the real. This is the final separated, a synonym for nirvana. stage of sravakas and pratyeka-buddha or the Chaâu Ñaø: See Chaâu Lôïi Baøn Ñaø Giaø. stage of faith of bodhisattvas. This is one of the six Chaâu Ñaûnh Vöông Boà Taùt: Maha-kutaradja mental taints of the Awakening of Faith—See Luïc (skt)—Mani-kutaraja           (skt)—Name           of      a Nhieãm Taâm. Bodhisattva. Chaáp Töôùng: Lagna-laksana (skt)—Baùm chaët vaøo Chaâu Haønh Baát Ngaïi Thaàn: Traveling hình töôùng cuûa chö phaùp—To attach to forms or to Everywhere Unhindered Deity (Spirit). cling to the characteristics of dharmas. Chaâu Hoaèng: See Chaâu Hoaèng Ñaïi Sö. Chaáp Töôùng Xaû: Xaû boû chaáp töôùng—Riddance Chaâu Hoaèng Ñaïi Sö (1535-1615): Chou-Hung— of the clinging of form. Chaâu Hoaèng Ñaïi Sö laø vò Toå thöù taùm cuûa Tònh Ñoä Chaáp Voâ: Chaáp khoâng—Attachment to non- Trung Quoác. Ngaøi töï laø Phaät Tueä, hieäu Lieân Trì. existence.

Ngöôøi hoï Traàm ñôøi nhaø Minh, queâ ôû quaän Nhaân            virtues and merits of practicing Buddha Hoøa tænh Haøng Chaâu. Naêm 17 tuoåi ngaøi ñaõ ñöôïc            Recitation are unfathomable.” After hearing boå nhaäm laøm chöùc Giaùo Thoï, noåi tieáng laø ngöôøi         this, he was greatly touched. From that time, hoïc haïnh kieâm toaøn—Chou-Hung was the Eighth                 he often paid attention to the Pureland Patriarch of Chinese Pureland Buddhism. His                     Dharma Door. Moreover, he also wrote these self-given name was Buddha’s Wisdom and his                     four words “Life and Death is a Great Matter” Dharma name was Lien-Chih. He was a son of the                  and pinned them on the walls, table, Traàm family of the Nhaân Hoøa District, Heng-Chou              headboard, etc, in order to remind himself. Province. He lived during the Ming Dynasty.                     When he turned thirty, he was ordained and When he turned seventeen, he was already                        became a Bhiksu. After completing the appointed as a teacher and was renowned for                     ceremony, he traveled abroad to learn the being a complete person having both virtues and                 Buddha-Dharma from well-known, highly talents.                                                        respected and virtuous Buddhist Masters.  Laùng gieàng cuûa ngaøi coù moät baø laõo, moãi ngaøy         Eventually, he came to learn Buddhism with nieäm Phaät vaøi ba ngaøn caâu, laáy laøm thöôøng          Zen Master Tieáu Nham Nguyeät Taâm to khoùa. Nhaân luùc raûnh roãi ngaøi sang chôi, thaáy        examine and investigate fully the meanings theá môùi hoûi duyeân côù, thì baø laõo ñaùp raèng:        behind the question “Who Is Buddha?” One “OÂng nhaø cuûa toâi luùc sanh tieàn chuyeân lo            day, while walking and pondering deeply, he nieäm Phaät, ñeán khi saép cheát, khoâng ñau beänh         suddenly awakened and immediately chi caû maø traùi laïi coøn vui veû voøng tay caùo bieät   composed this poem: moïi ngöôøi roài môùi qua ñôøi. Do ñoù neân toâi bieát      “Twenty years with one persisting doubt, coâng ñöùc nieäm Phaät khoâng theå nghó baøn.”                Beyond three thousand miles encounters Ngaøi nghe xong raát laáy laøm caûm ñoäng. Töø ñoù            a star. luoân ñeå yù ñeán phaùp moân Tònh Ñoä, ngaøi laïi coøn        Light incense throws away all illusions, vieát theâm boán chöõ “Soáng Cheát Vieäc Lôùn” daùn           Devil, Buddha who’s better is just a futile vaøo nôi vaùch ñaàu naèm ñeå töï raên nhaéc. Naêm 30          discussion.” tuoåi ngaøi xuaát gia. Sau khi xuaát gia xong, ngaøi      Luùc Sö ñang soaïn boä saùch taùn tuïng möôøi coâng ñi du phöông tham hoïc ñaïo phaùp nôi caùc baäc            ñöùc cuûa ngöôøi xuaát gia thì coù moät vò Taêng cao Taêng. Cuoái cuøng ngaøi ñeán hoïc ñaïo vôùi           thuoäc haøng cuoàng nhieät, ñaày töï phuï, ñeán noùi: Ngaøi Tieáu Nham Nguyeät Taâm Thieàn Sö. Ngaøi             "Vieát laùch laøm quaùi gì trong khi Thieàn khoâng tham cöùu caâu “Nieäm Phaät Laø Ai.” Moät hoâm             coù maûy may gì ñaùng hoaëc khoâng ñaùng taùn ñang ñi vaø tham cöùu, boãng ngaøi chôït tænh ngoä,        tuïng heát." Sö ñaùp: "Nguõ uaån dieäu vuõ, töù ñaïi lieàn laøm baøi keä raèng:                                 döông oai, sao oâng khoâng noùi coù toäi?" Vò “Hai chuïc naêm qua vieäc ñaùng nghi,                 Taêng caõi laïi: "Nhöng töù ñaïi voán khoâng, nguõ Ngoaøi ba ngaøn daäm gaëp sao kyø.                  uaån chaúng thaät." Chaâu Hoaèng ñaùnh vaøo maët vò Ñoát höông, lieäng kích döôøng nhö moäng,           Taêng noùi: "Toaøn laø haïng sa moân chaáp vaên töï Ma, Phaät tranh suoâng: Thò laãn phi.”              chöa bieát theá naøo laø caùi thöïc; ñaùp laïi ta thöû One of his neighbors was an elderly woman                  xem naøo?" Nhöng vò Taêng khoâng ñaùp gì, boû ra who practiced Buddha Recitation, reciting up               ñi, trong loøng ñaày oaùn haän. Sö mæm cöôøi noùi: to several thousand times a day as her daily               "Sao khoâng chuøi veát baån treân maët ñi?" Haønh ritual. Seeing this, he asked the woman for a              giaû tu Thieàn neân luoân nhôù raèng trong söï tu taäp reason, and he was told: “When my husband                  Thieàn, söùc noäi quaùn chieáu dieäu phaûi ñi ñoâi vôùi was alive he practiced Buddha Recitation                   ñöùc ñoä khieâm haï saâu daøy vaø moät caùi taâm nhaãn regularly; when nearing death, he was not                  nhuïc cao ñoä—When he was writing a book on sick or anything; in contrast, he seemed happy             the ten admirable deeds of a monk, one of and at peace as he placed his palms together               those high-spirited, self-assertive fellows to bid a final farewell to everyone before                 came to him, saying, "What is the use of passing away. For this reason, I know the                  writing such a book when in Zen there is not

even an atom of thing to be called admirable             looked down upon. But the Buddha treated him or not?" Chou-Hung answered, "The five                   just the same as others. The Buddha taught him: aggregates are entangling, and the four                  “When you sweep the floor or dust off the dirt elements grow rampant, and how can you say               from the Bhiksu’s robes, remember to recite at the there are no evils?" The monk still insisted,            same time these six words: “I wipe dust, I clear "The four elements are ultimately all empty              filth.” Finally, Ksudrapanthaka remembered the and the five aggregates have no reality                  six words of “I wipe dust, I clear filth.” With the whatever." Chou-Hung, giving the monk a                  passage of time, he was very accomplished in his slap on his face, said, "So many are mere                practice. From these six words, he realized that learned ones; you are not the real thing yet;            the dirt and filth in his mind should be wiped clean give me another answer." But the monk made               with mahaprajna or transcendental wisdom. He no answer and went off filled with angry                 was thus awakened to the ultimate Truth. feelings. Chou-Hung smilingly said, "There,              Chaâu Lôïi Da: Caula (skt)—Culya or Cola (skt)— why don't you wipe the dirt off your own                 Theo Eitel trong Trung Anh Phaät Hoïc Töø Ñieån, face?" Zen practitioners should always                   Chaâu Lôïi Da laø moät vöông quoác coå, naèm veà phía remember that in the study of Zen the power              ñoâng baéc khu Madras, nôi ñöôïc moâ taû laø vaøo of an illuminating insight must go hand in               khoaûng naêm 640 sau Taây Lòch haõy coøn daõ man, cö hand with a deep sense of humility and                   daân ôû ñaây luùc aáy quyeát lieät choáng laïi ñaïo Phaät — meekness of mind.                                        According to Eitel in The Dictionary of Chinese- Chaâu Keá Boà Taùt: Mani-cuda (skt)—Topknot                   English Buddhist Terms, Caula is an ancient Bodhisattva—A Bodhisattva with a topknot left on              kingdom in the northeast corner of the present the head.                                                     Madras presidency, described in 640 A.D. as a Chaâu Leä: Tears.                                             scarcely cultivated country with semi-savage and Chaâu Lôïi Baøn Ñaø Daø: See Chaâu Lôïi Baøn Ñaø Giaø.        anti-Buddhistic inhabitants. Chaâu Lôïi Baøn Ñaø Giaø: Ksudrapanthaka (skt)—               Chaâu Lî Baøn Ñaø Giaø: See Chaâu Lôïi Baøn Ñaø Giaø. Udapanthaka           (skt)—Sudapanthaka           (skt)—     Chaâu Lî Baøn Ñaëc Ca: See Chaâu Lôïi Baøn Ñaø Sudhipanthaka (skt)—Panthaka (skt)—Ban Thaùc                  Giaø. Ca—Baùn Ca—Baøn Ñaø Giaø—Baøn Ñaëc—Chuù Ñoà                   Chaâu Lî Baøn Ñaëc Na: See Chaâu Lôïi Baøn Ñaø Baùn Thaùc Ca—Ngöôøi ñöôïc sanh ra beân veä ñöôøng,           Giaø. moät trong nhöõng ñaïi ñeä töû cuûa Phaät. Ñaây laø teân      Chaâu Ma Ni: Mani (skt)—Ngoïc Ma Ni. cuûa vò La Haùn thöù 16 trong 16 vò La Haùn ñöôïc ñöùc        Chaâu Ngoïc: See Chaâu baûo. Phaät cöû ñi hoaèng phaùp ôû haûi ngoaïi. Vaøo thôøi Ñöùc     Chaâu Phaát Baø Ñeà: Pubba-videha (p)— Phaät coøn taïi theá, coù moät Tyø kheo teân laø Chaâu lôïi   Purvavideha (skt)—Eastern continent—Ñoâng Baøn Ñaø Giaø, laø moät thanh nieân trì ñoän, ai cuõng        Thaéng Thaàn Chaâu—Phaät Baø Ñeà—Phaät Baø Tyø Ñeà xem thöôøng anh ta, nhöng Ñöùc Phaät vaãn xem anh             Ha—Thaàn Chaâu. ta nhö moïi ngöôøi. Phaät daïy anh ta: “Khi ngöôi caàm        Chaâu Taùp Trang Nghieâm Coâng Ñöùc Phaät: Full- choåi queùt nhaø hoaëc giaët giuõ aùo quaàn cuûa caùc Tyø     Lap-Adornment-Merit-Virtue Buddha. kheo, vöøa laøm vieäc, vöøa ñoïc nieäm saùu chöõ :Ta          Chaâu Thôùi Töï: Chau Thoi Temple—Teân cuûa moät queùt doïn, ta phaåy buïi.” Roát cuoäc Chaâu Lôïi Baøn Ñaø    ngoâi chuøa coå noåi tieáng (coøn goïi chuøa Nuùi Chaâu Giaø nhôù ñöôïc saùu chöõ “Ta queùt doïn, ta phaåy buïi,”     Thôùi), toïa laïc treân moät ngoïn ñoài cao 85 meùt treân laâu ngaøy coâng phu chín muoài, anh ta nhôø theá tænh        nuùi Chaâu Thôùi, thuoäc aáp Chaâu Thôùi, xaõ Bình An, ngoä ñöôïc buïi baëm trong loøng phaûi duøng trí tueä doïn    huyeän Thuaän An, tænh Phöôùc Long, Nam Vieät saïch, boãng nhieân anh ñöôïc khai ngoä—One who               Nam—Name of a famous ancient pagoda located was born on the road, one of the great disciples of           on the slope of the hill of 85 meters high and 208 Sakyamuni Buddha. This is name of the sixteenth               stairs, in Chaâu Thôùi hamlet, Bình An village, of the sixteen arhats. At the time of the Buddha,             Thuaän An district, Phöôùc Long province, South there was a Bhiksu named Ksudrapanthaka who                   Vietnam. was originally a very stupid youth whom others

Chaàu Phaät: To pass away—To go to the Pure                  Cheá Giaùo: Giaûng veà giôùi phaùp cho haøng xuaát Land to meet Amitabha Buddha.                                gia—The Buddha’s teaching on discipline, Cheá: Keàm cheá—To restrain—To govern--                      especially for monks and nuns—See Cheá Giôùi. Regulations.                                                 Cheá Giôùi: Yama (skt)—Samyama or Samnnama Cheá       Caûm:      Pratyahara       (skt)—Individual      (p)—Cheá giaùo—Kieåm soaùt—Thu thuùc—Keàm absorption or withdrawal—Withdrawal of senses,               cheá—Control—Self-control—Self-restraint—Caùc this is the first of the stages of the completion            ñieàu giôùi luaät do Phaät quy ñònh ñoái vôùi caùc haøng phase of practice—Ñaây laø giai ñoaïn ñaàu cuûa thôøi        ñeä töû (Ñaïo Phaät laáy giôùi luaät trong Tyø Ni Taïng kyø thöïc taäp hoaøn maõn.                                   laøm giaùo lyù ñeå haïn cheá hay ngaên chaën toäi loãi sai Cheá Daâm: To restrain venereal desire.                      traùi)—The restraints or rules, i.e. of the Vinaya. Cheá Duïc: To restrain one’s desire                          Cheá Giôùi Moân: See Cheá Giôùi and Cheá Moân. Cheá Ña: Caitya (skt)—See Thaùp.                             Cheá Moân: Ñöùc Phaät cheá ra giôùi luaät moân nhaèm Cheá Ña Hoài Xöù: Cetiya (p)—Caitya (skt)—                   giuùp moïi ngöôøi tu haønh giaûi thoaùt, ñoái laïi vôùi hoùa Pagoda—Stupa—Cheá ña (thaùp moä)—See Thaùp.                  moân—The way or method of discipline, contrasted Cheá Ña Sôn Boä: Caityasaila (skt)—Cetiyavada                with the door of teaching of enlightenment, both (p)—Cityavadin (skt)—Jetiyasailah (skt)—Chi Ñeà              methods used by the Buddha. Gia Boä—Chæ Ñeå Khaû Boä—Tröôøng phaùi cuûa nhöõng           Cheá Ngöï: To dominate—To subdue. ngöôøi treân nuùi Chæ Ñaùt, moät toâng phaùi cuûa Thöôïng    Cheá Ngöï Tham Lam-Saân Haän-Ñoá Kî: Refrain Toïa Boä, moät trong hai möôi boä phaùi Tieåu Thöøa, do      from greed, anger, and jealousy—Ñeå cheá ngöï Tyø Kheo Ñaïi Thieân saùng laäp, goàm nhöõng nhaø tu         nhöõng tö duy tham lam, saân haän vaø ganh tî vaø khoå haïnh cö nguï trong caùc laêng moä hay hang             nhöõng tö duy khaùc maø con ngöôøi phaûi chòu, chuùng hoùc—School of the dwellers on Mount Jeta or                 ta caàn phaûi coù nghò löïc, sieâng naêng tinh taán vaø tænh school of Jetrvana, a subdivision of Sthavirah.              giaùc. Khi thoaùt khoûi nhöõng vöôùng baän cuûa cuoäc Caitya-saila, described as one of the twenty sects           soáng phoá thò hoaëc nhöõng lo toan vöôùng baän khaùc of the Hinayana, founded by Bhikkhu Mahadeva,                cuûa cuoäc ñôøi, chuùng ta khoâng ñeán noãi bò quyeán ruõ comprised of ascetic dwellers among tombs or in              ñeå ñaùnh maát mình, nhöng khi hoøa nhaäp vaøo nhòp caves.                                                       soáng xaõ hoäi, ñoù laø luùc maø chuùng ta caàn phaûi tinh Cheá Ña Vaên Boä: See Cheá Ña Sôn Boä.                       taán ñeå chaën ñöùng nhöõng sai soùt, laàm laãn cuûa mình. Cheá Ñaùt La: Caitra (skt)—Teân moät ngoâi sao xuaát         Thieàn ñònh laø söï trôï löïc lôùn lao giuùp chuùng ta ñieàm hieän vaøo ñeâm traêng troøn thaùng gieâng (thaùng gieâng    tónh khi ñoái dieän vôùi nhöõng tö duy xaáu naày—To cuûa AÁn Ñoä cuõng ñöôïc goïi laø thaùng Cheá Ñaùt La). ÔÛ   refrain from greed, anger, jealousy, and other evil Trung Quoác vaø Vieät Nam nhaèm töø 16 thaùng gieâng         thoughts to which people are subject, we need ñeán 15 thaùng hai, khoaûng thaùng ba vaø thaùng tö          strength of mind, strenuous effort and vigilance. döông lòch—The spring month in which the full                When we are free from the city life, from nagging moon is in this constellation. In China and                  preoccupation with daily life, we are not tempted Vietnam, it is the first month of spring from the            to lose control; but when we enter in the real 16th of the first moon to the 15th of the second             society, it becomes an effort to check these moon (between the months of March and April).                troubles. Meditation will contribute an immense Cheá Ñeå: Caitya (skt)—Cheá Theå—1) Thaùp Phaät:             help to enable us to face all this with calm. Temple or stupa where the Buddha’s relics are                Cheá Phuïc: 1) Keàm cheá, caâu thuùc, hay kieåm soaùt: stored; 2) Coät côø chaùnh: The main flagstaff on a          Samvunati (p)—To subdue, to restrain, to control; pagoda.                                                      2) Söï cheá phuïc: Samvaro (skt)—Restraint. Cheá Ñeå Baïn Theã: Caitya-vandana (skt)—Cheá Ñeå            Cheá Phuïc Chö Caên: Indiyasamvaro (p)— Baïn Ñaïn Na—Toân kính thaùp thôø hay hình                   Restraint of the senses. töôïng Phaät—To pay reverence to, or worship a               Cheá Thính Nhò Giaùo: Hai giaùo phaùp cheá giaùo vaø stupa, image, etc.                                           thính giaùo. Cheá giaùo giaûng veà giôùi phaùp cho haøng xuaát gia; coøn thính giaùo laø cho nhöõng ai nghe vaø phuïng haønh Phaät phaùp—Two doctrines of

discipline and hearing. Discipline doctrine is the                hôn. Moät khi chuùng ta coù khaû naêng chieâm nghieäm Buddha’s teaching on discipline, especially for                   veà söï cheát laø caùi maø chuùng ta khoâng theå naøo traùnh monks and nuns; while to hear the Buddha’s                        khoûi thì taát caû nhöõng thöù nhoû nhaët trong ñôøi soáng doctrine is for those who hear and obey the                       haèng ngaøy boãng trôû neân voâ nghóa so vôùi ñoaïn Buddha’s doctrine.                                                ñöôøng coøn laïi cuûa kieáp soáng maø chuùng ta ñang ñi. Cheá Toäi: Coøn goïi laø Giaø toäi. Töï tính khoâng phaûi laø     Chính Ñöùc Phaät ñaõ töøng daïy: “Khoâng coù yù thöùc aùc nhö uoáng röôïu, nhöng bò Ñöùc Phaät caám vì lôïi             naøo cao hôn vieäc yù thöùc ñöôïc tính caùch voâ thöôøng ích cho nhöõng giôùi khaùc—Offenses which not                     cuûa kieáp soáng. Vì yù thöùc ñöôïc nhö vaäy seõ giuùp wrong in itself, i.e. taking alcohol, but forbidden               chuùng ta hieåu roõ raèng luùc meänh chung, doøng taâm by the Buddha for the sake of the other                           thöùc vaø nhöõng daáu aán nghieäp löïc maø chuùng ta ñaõ commandments.                                                     gieo taïo seõ ñöa chuùng ta ñi ñeán nhöõng kieáp soáng Cheá Tra Ca Ñoàng Töû: Cetaka (skt)—Duta                          môùi. Hieåu nhö vaäy seõ giuùp chuùng ta hieåu raèng neáu (skt)—Ceti (skt)—Duti (skt)—Phieán Ñeå Ca Ñoàng                   trong kieáp soáng naøy chuùng ta coù nhöõng haønh ñoäng Töû—Celestial messenger—Thieân söù giaû.                          gaây toån haïi cho ngöôøi khaùc vôùi ñoäng cô xaáu thì Cheá Y: Tam y cuûa chö Taêng vaø nguõ y cuûa chö Ni               nhöõng daáu aán ñen toái cuûa nhöõng haønh ñoäng ñoù seõ do Phaät ñònh cheá vaø baét buoäc phaûi maëc —                    ñeo baùm theo doøng chaûy taâm thöùc cuûa chuùng ta. Regulation of three robes for monks and five for                  Phaät töû thuaàn thaønh neân luoân nhôù raèng caùi cheát nuns, which must be worn.                                         chaéc chaén laø caøng luùc caøng ñeán gaàn vôùi taát caû moïi Cheát: Gata (skt)—Dead—Deceased—To die—To                         ngöôøi, duø baäc vua quan hay daân giaû, duø giaøu hay expire—Gone or departed—To pass way—Theo                          ngheøo, duø sang hay heøn, vaân vaân. Chuùng ta ai roài Phaät giaùo, Cheát laø luùc A-Laïi-Da thöùc lìa thaân, chôù       cuõng seõ cheát chöù khoâng ai soáng maõi ñöôïc vôùi ñònh khoâng phaûi laø luùc maø tim ngöøng ñaäp hay oùc ngöng           luaät voâ thöôøng. Khoâng coù nôi naøo cho chuùng ta laøm vieäc. Cheát laø söï tan raõ caû theå xaùc vaø tinh thaàn.   ñeán ñeå traùnh ñöôïc caùi cheát. Tuoåi thoï cuûa chuùng ta Quaù trình taùch lìa coù theå xaûy ra nhieàu giôø, nhieàu         khoâng theå keùo daøi ñöôïc vaø moãi luùc qua ñi laø maïng ngaøy, nhö caùi cheát töï nhieân do giaø beänh; hoaëc xaûy        soáng chuùng ta caøng ngaén laïi. Khi töû thaàn ñeán ra ñoät ngoät do töû naïn. Nhöng ôû caû hai tröôøng hôïp,         chuùng ta khoâng theå naøo kyø keøo bôùt moät theâm hai caùi cheát ñeàu coù nhöõng böôùc tieán nhöùt ñònh. Thaân          ñeå chuùng ta coù thôøi giôø chuyeån hoùa taâm thöùc cuûa xaùc khoâng phaûi ñoät ngoät maát ngay khaû naêng duy             mình ñaâu—According to Buddhism, Death is the trì taâm thöùc, maø noù maát töø töø, moãi ñaïi nhö ñaát,         moment when the alaya consciousness leaves the nöôùc, löûa, gioù... tuaàn töï maát khaû naêng naâng ñôõ thaân    body, not when the heart has stopped or brain xaùc. Phaät töû tin töôûng raèng duø thaân xaùc cheát ñi          waves can no longer be detected. Death is the nhöng taâm thöùc vaãn tieáp tuïc cuoäc haønh trình cuûa           separation of mind and matter (body). This noù, do ñoù maø coù taùi sanh. Theo nhöõng quan nieäm             separation may take place over several hours or cuûa caùc toân giaùo khaùc ôû Trung Hoa, cheát laø söï tan        days, as is generally the case in a death from raõ giöõa phaàn thaân theå vaø caùc phaàn khaùc cuûa noù,         natural causes, or it may happen rather more caùc cô quan nhaän thöùc ñöôïc gaït boû. Nhöõng cô quan           suddenly, as in an accident. But in either case naøy rôøi boû hình haøi vaø kieán thöùc. Luùc aáy ngöôøi ta       there are certain definite stages in the dying trôû thaønh ñoàng nhaát vôùi caùi ñaïi ñoàng. Caùi cheát seõ      process. The body does not lose its ability to ñeán vôùi moïi ngöôøi moät caùch töï nhieân. Tuy nhieân,          maintain consciousness all at once, but does so haàu heát moïi ngöôøi ñeàu caûm thaáy lo sôï suy tö veà           gradually with each element of the body, earth, caùi cheát. Ngöôøi ta sôï raèng neáu hoï noùi veà töû thaàn thì   water, fire, and air, losing its supportive ability in töû thaàn seõ ñeán gaàn vôùi hoï hôn. Ñoù laø moät yù töôûng      turn. Buddhists believe that though the body dies, sai laàm. Kyø thaät baûn chaát thaät cuûa kieáp soáng laø voâ     the consciousness lives on; thus there exists thöôøng vaø caùi cheát khoâng mieãn tröø moät ai. Theo            rebirth. According to other religious concepts in quy luaät töï nhieân, cheát laø moät trong boán tieán trình       ancient China, death is the dissolution of the body cuûa luaät voâ thöôøng, vaø khoâng theå traùnh khoûi, thì         and its other parts, where perceptive organs are khi nghó töôûng hay chieâm nghieäm veà söï cheát seõ              discarded. These organs left the material form and khieán cho ñôøi soáng cuûa chuùng ta coù yù nghóa toát            bidding farewell to the knowledge. At that time,

one becomes one with the great pervader. Death           Chi Cöông Löông Tieáp: Kalasivi (skt)—Teân cuûa naturally comes to everyone. However, most               moät vò Taêng AÁn Ñoä, ñeán Trung Hoa dòch kinh ñieån people feel uncomfortable thinking about death.          vaøo khoaûng naêm 255-256 sau taây lòch—Name of People fear that if they talk about death, death is      an Indian monk who came to China to translate coming closer. That’s a mistaken idea. In fact, by       sutras around 255-256 A.D. very nature our lives are impermanent, and death         Chi Dieäu: Master Chi-Miao—Teân cuûa moät danh is inevitable. By natural law, death id one of the       Taêng ngöôøi Taây Vöïc, sang Trung Quoác vaøo thôøi four steps of the Law of Impermanence. Thus,             Ñoâng Haùn (206 B.C.-220 A.D.). Vaøo naêm 185, Sö death is an irrevocable result of living, it’s good to   ñeán thaønh Laïc Döông vaø löu laïi ñaây ít laâu ñeå dòch think about it to make our lives more meaningful.        hôn möôøi boä kinh—Name of an Indian famous Once we fully recognize that we will inevitably          monk who came to China during the Eastern Han die, all the petty concerns that worry us in our         Dynasty. In 185, he came to Luo-Yang, and stayed daily life become insignificant compared to the          there for some time to translate more that ten sets importance of following the path before our lives        of sutras. end. The Buddha taught: “There is no greater             Chi Duïng: To divide or to distribute for use. realization than awareness of the impermanence           Chi Ñaøm Thöôïc: Teân cuûa moät danh Taêng ngöôøi of our lives. Such realization will help us              Trung Quoác vaøo thôøi Ñoâng Taán (317-420)—Name understand that at the time of death, our                of a Chinese famous monk who lived in the mindstreams and the imprints of the actions we           Eastern Chin Dynasty. have created go on to future lives. Such                 Chi Ñaïo Caên: Teân cuûa moät danh Taêng ngöôøi realization will also help us understand clearly         Trung Quoác vaøo thôøi Ñoâng Taán (317-420)—Name that if we spend oue precious human lives acting         of a Chinese famous monk who lived in the harmfully with bad motivations, the imprints of          Eastern Chin Dynasty. those actions will come with us. Devout Buddhists        Chi Ñaïo Laâm: Teân cuûa moät danh Taêng Trung should always remember that death definitely             Hoa vaøo theá kyû thöù IV. Sö chuû tröông giaûi thích comes to everyone, whether we are kings or               caâu "saéc töùc thò khoâng" dieãn taû chaân taùnh (thöïc mandarins, rich or poor, noble or ignoble. There is      töôùng) maø khoâng laøm hö hoaïi caùi höõu giaû danh— nowhere we can go to avoid death. Our lifespans          Name of a Chinese famous monk in the fourth can’t be extended and with every passing                 century. He supported the interpretation of the moment, they’re becoming shorter and shorter.            phrase "form as it is, is empty" as describing true When our lifespans run out, we can’t bargain for         reality    without     destroying      existence       as more time in order to transform our minds.               conventional designation. Cheát Chæ Laø Söï Hao Moøn Sinh Lyù Cuûa Cô Theå:        Chi Ñeá Phuø Ñoà: Caitya (skt)—Thaùp laø nôi ñeå thôø Death is only a physiological erosion of the human       phöôïng—A stupa, or a place or object of worship. body.                                                    Chi Ñeà: Caitya (skt)—Chi Ñeá—Chi Tröng—Cheá Cheát Chæ Laø Söï Xa Lìa Giöõa Taâm Vaø Thaân:           Ña—Cheá Ñeå Da—Nôi ñeå xaù lôïi, kinh saùch hay Death is only a separation of mind and matter.           hình töôïng cuûa Phaät. Coù taùm Chi Ñeà noåi tieáng töø Chi: 1) Caønh: Branch; 2) Loaïi caây thôm: A             xöa—A tumulus, a mausoleum; a place where the felicitous plant, sesamum; 3) Loaøi quyû nuùi troâng     relics of Buddha were collected, hence a place gioáng nhö coïp: A mountain demon resembling a           where his sutras or images are placed. Eight tiger; 4) Môõ: Fat, lard.                                famous Caityas formerly existed. Chi Caâu La Saám: Lokaraksa (skt)—Theá Hoä—Ca            1) Vöôøn Laâm Tyø Ni: See Lumbini. Saám—Name of an Indian monk.                             2) Boà Ñeà Ñaïo Traøng: See Buddha-Gaya. Chi Chuaån: ÖÙng phoù vôùi vieäc baát ngôø—To cope       3) Thaønh Ba La naïi: Varanasi (skt)—See with—To cope with a contingence.                              Benares. Chi Cöông Löông Laâu: Chih-Chiang-Liang-Lou              4) Vöôøn Kyø Thoï Caáp Coâ Ñoäc: Jetavana (skt)— (chi)—Name of a monk.                                         See Kyø Thoï Caáp Coâ Ñoäc Vieân. 5) Soâng Ni Lieân Thieàn: See Kanyakubja.

6) Thaønh Vöông Xaù: See Rajagriha.                            Chi Löôïng: Teân cuûa moät danh Taêng ngöôøi Trung 7) Thaønh Xaù Veä: See Vaisali.                                Quoác vaøo thôøi Tam Quoác: Ngoâ, Nguïy vaø Sôû (220- 8) Ta La Song Thoï ôû Caâu Thi Na: Sala Grove in               280). Sö laø moät trong nhöõng ñeä töû xuaát saéc nhaát Kusinagara.                                               cuûa Chi Laâu Ca Saám, vaø laø thaày cuûa Chi Khieâm — Chi Ñeà Gia Boä: See Chi Ñeà Sôn Boä.                          Name of a Chinese famous monk who lived in the Chi Ñeà Sôn Boä: Caityasailah (skt)—Jetavaniyah                San-Kuo Dynasties (Wu, Wei, and Shu). He was (skt)—See Cheá Ña Sôn Boä.                                     one of the most outstanding disciples of master Chi Ñoä: The various articles required for worship.            Chih-Lou-Chia-Ch’an (Lokakshin (skt), and was Chi Ñoän (314-366): Teân cuûa moät danh Taêng ngöôøi           the master of Chih-Ch’ien. Trung Quoác, queâ ôû tænh Haø Nam. Sö thöôøng hay              Chi Maït Hoaëc: Branch and twig illusion—Chi chu du khaép nôi giaûng kinh Duy Ma cho moïi                   Maït Voâ Minh hay nghieäp töôùng, kieän töôùng, caûnh ngöôøi—Name of a Chinese famous monk who                       giôùi töôùng döïa vaøo caên baûn voâ minh maø daáy leân, came from He-Nan Province, China. He always                    ñoái laïi vôùi caên baûn voâ minh (chuùng sanh khoâng ñaït traveled all over to lecture the Vimalakirti Sutra.            lyù nhaát phaùp giôùi boãng nhieân vi ñoäng voïng Chi Ñöông: 1) Gaùnh vaùc: To shoulder a                        nieäm)—Ignorance in detail or branch and twig responsibility, to take on a responsibility; 2) ÖÙng           illusion, in contrast with root or radical ignorance phoù: To cope with.                                            (caên baûn voâ minh), i.e. original ignorance out of Chi Haø: ÖÙng phoù vôùi vieäc baát ngôø—To cope                which arises karma, false views and realms of with—To cope with a contingence.                               illusion which are the “branch and twig” condition Chi Höông: Nhang laøm töø nhöõng caønh caây, moät              or unenlightenment in detail or result. trong ba loaïi nhang—One of the three kinds of                 Chi Maït Phaùp Luaân: The branch wheel is all incense, incense made of branches of tree.                     Hinayana and Mahayana texts—Chi maït Phaùp Chi Khieâm: Chi Khieâm laø teân cuûa moät vò sa moân           Luaân laø caùc kinh ñieån Tieåu vaø Ñaïi Thöøa. xöù Nguyeät Chi, ñeán Laïc Döông vaøo cuoái ñôøi nhaø          Chi Maït Voâ Minh: See Chi Maït Hoaëc. Haùn, sö ngöôøi cao, maûnh khaûnh, da ngaâm ñen, maét          Chi Maãn Ñoä: Teân cuûa moät danh Taêng ngöôøi naâu, uyeân baùc vaø khoân ngoan. Trong khoaûng thôøi          Trung Quoác vaøo thôøi Taán (265-420)—Name of a gian töø naêm 222 ñeán naêm 235, Sö ñaàu tö heát moïi          Chinese famous monk who lived in the Chin noã löïc dòch thuaät raát nhieàu boä kinh, trong soá ñoù coù   Dynasty. boä Duy Ma Caät laø chính yeáu —Chih-Ch’ien, name              Chi Mi: Evil spirits—Loaøi quyû ôû vuøng ñaàm laày, coù of a Yueh-Chih monk who said to have come to                   ñaàu heo mình ngöôøi—A demon of marshes having Loyang at the end of the Han dynasty and under                 the head of a pig and body of a man. the Wei; tall, dark, emaciated, with light brown               Chi Na: Cina (skt)—Tieáng ngöôøi ngoaïi quoác goïi eyes, very learned and wise. During the period of              nöôùc hay ngöôøi Trung Quoác—The name by which time from 222 to 235, he invested all his efforts to           China or Chinese is referred to. translate many different sutras, among them the                Chi Na Ñeà Baø Cuø Haèng La: Cina Deva Gotra Vimalakirit Sutra was the major one.                           (skt)—Haùn Thieân Chuûng—The “solar deva” of Chi Khieån: ÖÙng phoù vôùi vieäc baát ngôø—To cope             Han descent, first king of Khavandha, born to a with—To cope with a contingence.                               princess of the Han dynasty on her way as a bride Chi Lang: Teân goïi xöa kia cuûa caùc vò Taêng, ngöôøi         elect to Persia, the parentage being attributed to ta noùi teân naày baét nguoàn töø “Tam Chi” thôøi nhaø         the solar deva. Nguïy laø Chi Khieâm, Chi Saùm vaø Chi Löôïng—                 Chi Nghó: ÖÙng phoù vôùi vieäc baát ngôø—To cope Chih-Lang, formerly a polite term for a monk, said             with—To cope with a contingence. to have arisen from the fame of the three chih of              Chi Ngoâ: 1) Coá gaéng: To endeavour, to strive, to the Wei dynasty, Chih-Ch’ien, Chih Ch’an and                   do one's utmost, to make every effort; 2) ÖÙng phoù: Chih Liang.                                                    To cope with. Chi Laâu Ca Saám: Lokakshin (skt)—Chih-Lou-                    Chi Phaùp Ñoä: Teân cuûa moät danh Taêng ngöôøi Chia-Ch’an—See Chi Saám.                                       Trung Quoác vaøo thôøi Taây Taán (265-316)—Name

of a Chinese famous monk who lived in the                   ascetic in a period without a Buddha, as a Western Chin Dynasty.                                       pratyeka-buddha. He attains his enlightenment Chi Phaùp Laõnh: Teân cuûa moät danh Taêng ngöôøi           alone, independently, of a teacher, and with the Trung Quoác vaøo thôøi Ñoâng Taán (317-420). Naêm           object of attaining nirvana and his own salvation 392, Sö cuøng Phaùp Tònh sang Taây Vöïc caàu phaùp,         rather than that of others, as is the object of a gaëp ngaøi Phaät Ñaø Da Xaù treân ñöôøng trôû veà Trung     Bodhisattva. Hoa. Naêm 408, Sö cuøng ñeä töû laø Hueä Bieän tham         Chi Phaät Ñòa: Bích Chi Phaät Ñòa—The stage of dö cuoäc phieân dòch boä Töù Phaàn Luaät do ngaøi Phaät     Pratyeka-buddha. Ñaø Da Xaù chuû trì—Name of a Chinese famous                Chi Phong (1901-?): Teân cuûa moät danh Taêng monk who lived in the Eastern Chin Dynasty. In              ngöôøi Trung Quoác vaøo theá kyû XX. OÂng chuyeân 392, he accompanied Fa-Tsing to travel to India to          nghieân cöùu veà Duy Thöùc, Thieân Thai vaø Luaät seek Dharma. Later, on the way back to China he             Toâng—Name of a Chinese famous monk in the met Buddhayasas. In 408, he and his disciple Hui-           twentieth century. He particularly studied theories Pien participated in the translation of Four-               of the Mind-Only, T'ien-T'ai and Vinaya Schools. division Vinaya of the Dharmagupta school, which            Chi Phoái: To direct—To control. was chaired by master Buddhayasas.                          Chi Saùm: Lokakshin (skt)—See Chi Saám. Chi Phaït La: Civara (skt)—Chaán Vieät—Trí                  Chi Saám: Lokakshin (skt)—Chih-Lou-Chia- Phöôïc La—Quaàn aùo cuûa ngöôøi khaát só—A                  Ch’an—Chi Saám hay Chi Loâ Ca Saám, moät vò sa mendicant’s garment—AÙo nguû hay tuùi nguû hay “y           moân xöù Nguyeät Chi, ñeán Laïc Döông, Trung Quoác aùo cuûa töï vieän.” Loaïi y maø caùc vò sö maëc—A          vaøo khoaûng naêm 147 sau Taây Lòch ñeå laøm coâng garment, an article for sleeping on or in.                  vieäc dòch thuaät cho ñeán naêm 186 sau Taây Lòch— “Monastic robes” or the robes worn by Buddhist              Chih-Ch’an or Chih-Lou-Chia-Ch’an, a sramana monks.                                                      who came to China from Yueh-Chih around 147 Chi Phaàn: Svayava (skt)—Moät trong thaäp luïc ñeá          AD and worked at translations till 186 AD at (möôøi saùu chaân lyù)—One of the sixteen truths.           Loyang. Chi Phaät: Bích Chi Phaät laø ngöôøi thaáu hieåu möôøi      Chi Thi Luaân: Teân cuûa moät vò sa moân xöù Nhuïc hai nhaân duyeân, vaø do ñoù ñaït ñöôïc trí hueä. Baäc      Chi. Naêm 373, Sö ñeán Löông Chaâu dòch boä kinh naày ñaõ ñaït ñöôïc Bích Chi Ñòa. Ñaây laø nhöõng baäc      Thuû Laêng Nghieâm vaø boä Nhö Huyeãn Tam Muoäi tu haønh tìm caàu giaùc ngoä cho chính mình, ñöôïc          Kinh—Chih-Shi-Lun, came from Ru-Chih. In 373, ñònh nghóa trong Kinh Phaùp Hoa laø nhöõng vò tinh          he came to Liang-chou to translate the chuyeân haønh trì, thích nôi vaéng veû yeân tónh, tu        Shuramgama Sutra and the Mayopamasamadhi haønh vieân maõn maø khoâng coù thaày baïn daïy baûo,       (Meditation on the unreality of all things). moät mình töï nhieân giaùc ngoä, chöù khoâng cöùu ñoä tha   Chi Thieän (1152-1235): Teân cuûa moät vò Thieàn sö nhaân nhö muïc ñích cuûa caùc vò Boà Taùt (quaùn saùt       toâng Laâm Teá Trung Quoác vaøo thôøi Toáng (960- hoa bay laù ruïng vaø 12 nhaân duyeân maø ñaït ñeán giaùc   1279)—Name of a Chinese Lin-chi Zen master ngoä). Caùc nhaø Thieân Thai thì cho raèng “Chi Phaät”      who lived in the Sung Dynasty. hay “Ñoäc Giaùc” laø loaïi ngoä ñaïo khi ñôøi khoâng coù    Chi Uyeån: Teân cuûa Ngaøi Nguyeân Chieáu taïi Töï Phaät, töï mình giaùc ngoä, khoâng nhôø thaày baïn, vaø     vieän Linh Chi thuoäc thaønh phoá Haøng Chaâu— cuõng khoâng cöùu ñoä ai—Pratyeka-buddha who                Name for Yuan-Chao of Ling-Chi Monastey in understands the twelve nidanas, or chain of                 Hang-Chou—See Nguyeân Chieáu. causation, and so attains to complete wisdom. His           Chí: 1) Döï ñoaùn: To predict, to forecast, to stage of attainment is Pratyeka-buddha stage. One           foresee; 2) Ghi nhôù (chí ñaéc): To record, to who seeks enlightenment for himself, defined in             remember; 3) YÙ chí, taâm chí: Will, resolve. the Lotus sutra as a believer who is diligent and           Chí An (1664-1729): Master Chi-An—Teân cuûa zealous in seeking wisdom, loves loneliness and             moät vò danh Taêng Trieàu Tieân vaøo theá kyû thöù XVII. seclusion, and understands deeply the nidanas. It           Sö vieát moät quyeån saùch nhan ñeà "Thieàn Moân Nguõ is a stage above Sravaka and is known as the                Toâng"—Name of a famous Korean monk in the middle vehicle. T’ien-T’ai distinguishes as an

seventeenth century. He wrote a book titled "The                ngöôøi chuùng ta, khoâng loaïi tröø moät ai. Khi maây Five Ch’an schools".                                            keùo ñeán thì sao? Maây muø mòt. Khi möa ñoå xuoáng Chí Baøn: Teân cuûa moät danh Taêng Trung Quoác vaøo            thì sao? Söï öôùt aùt. Nhö Thieàn sö Vaân Moân ñaõ coù thôøi Nam Toáng (1127-1279)—Name of a famous                    moät caâu noùi heát söùc ñôn giaûn: "Nhaät nhaät thò haûo Chinese monk who lived in the South Sung                        nhaät (moãi ngaøy ñeàu laø moät ngaøy toát laønh)." Chæ khi Dynasty.                                                        naøo chuùng ta ñeå cho caùi taâm phaân bieät chi phoái, thì Chí Caàn Linh Vaân Thieàn Sö: Reiun (jap)—Reiun                 luùc ñoù chuùng ta môùi gaëp phaûi raéc roái. Traùnh thöông Shigon (jap)—Ling-yun Chih-ch'in—Ling-yun                       traùnh gheùt; theá laø moïi chuyeän ñeàu roõ raøng minh Zhiqin—See Linh Vaân Chí Caàn Thieàn Sö.                        baïch. Haønh giaû tu thieàn ngaøy nay hoûi ñaïo neân luoân Chí Coâng: 1) Coâng minh: Very just; 2) Teân cuûa               nhôù raèng chaúng ôû trong choïn löïa laø töï ñònh mình moät vò Taêng noåi tieáng ngöôøi Trung Quoác: Name of           trong minh baïch vaäy. Haønh giaû tu Thieàn neân luoân a famous Chinese monk.                                          nhôù raèng con ñöôøng Ñaïo hoaøn haûo khoâng khoù; chæ Chí Ñaïi: Very big.                                             caàn taâm thöùc cuûa chuùng ta khoâng duïng taâm phaân Chí Ñaïo Thieàn Sö: Zen Master Chih-Tao—See                     bieät. Khi chuùng ta vöôït leân treân caùi yeâu, caùi gheùt, Trí Ñaïo Quaûng Chaâu Thieàn Sö.                                taát caû seõ saùng toû nhö ban ngaøy. Ñöøng theo ñuoåi Chí Ñaïo Quaûng Chaâu Thieàn Sö: Zen Master                     hoaøn caûnh beân ngoaøi, vaø cuõng ñöøng giam mình Chih-Tao—See Trí Ñaïo Quaûng Chaâu Thieàn Sö.                   trong caùi hö voâ beân trong. Haõy nhaäp vaøo trong caùi Chí Ñaïo Voâ Nan: Shodo-Munan (jap).                            nhaát töôùng cuûa vaïn höõu vaø moïi raøo caûn seõ bieán 1) To arrive at the truth is without difficulty; just           maát. Ngay khi chuùng ta coù caùi taâm taâm hay sai, avoid picking and choosing—See Chí Ñaïo Voâ               chuùng ta seõ bò hoang mang vaø ñaùnh maát caùi chaân Nan, Duy Hieàm Giaûn Traïch.                              taâm cuûa mình. Caùi hai töø caùi moät maø ra, nhöng 2) Shido-Munan (jap)—Teân cuûa moät thieàn sö                   cuõng ñöøng chaáp thuû vaøo caùi moät. Quaùn chieáu vaïn Nhaät Baûn: Name of a Japanese Zen master—                phaùp moät caùch bình ñaúng, chuùng ta seõ coù theå quay See Voâ Quy Thieàn Sö.                                    veà vôùi baûn theå. Loaïi boû taát caû caùc ñieàu kieän, chuùng Chí Ñaïo Voâ Nan, Duy Hieàm Giaûn Traïch: The                   ta seõ vöôït leân treân moïi phaân bieät. Moät laø voâ soá vaø Ultimate Path is Without Difficulty—Chí Ñaïo Voâ                voâ soá laø moät. Neáu chuùng ta coù theå hieå u bieát ñieàu Nan laø chuû ñeà cuûa thí duï thöù nhì trong Bích Nham          naøy, chuùng ta seõ ñöôïc giaûi thoaùt khoûi moïi moái lo Luïc. Trieäu Chaâu xuaát hieän trong caùc thí duï 2, 9,         aâu. Taâm chaân thaønh laø tuyeät ñoái. Tuyeät ñoái laø taâm 30, 41, 45, 52, 57, 58, 64, 80, vaø 96 cuûa Bích Nham           chaân thaønh. Caét ñöùt con ñöôøng daãn tôùi ngoân ngöõ, Luïc. Chuùng ta hieåu veà taâm cuûa ngaøi nhieàu hôn qua        chuùng ta seõ vöôït leân treân quaù khöù, hieän taïi vaø vò nhöõng coâng aùn naày hôn laø qua nhöõng döõ kieän lòch         lai."—The Ultimate Path is Without Difficulty is söû veà cuoäc ñôøi cuûa ngaøi. ÔÛ ñaây, trong Bích Nham         the second example in the Pi-Yen-Lu. Chao-Chou Luïc 2, noùi veà "Chí ñaïo khoâng khoù, chæ traùnh löïa         appears in examples 2, 9, 30, 41, 45, 52, 57, 58, traùnh choïn." Moät hoâm, coù moät vò Taêng ñeán thaêm          64, 80, and 96 of the Pi-Yen-Lu. We learn more Trieäu Chaâu vaø ñoïc baøi keä noåi tieáng cuûa Tam Toå         about the mind of Chao-chou from these koans Taêng Xaùn: "Ñaïo khoâng khoù, chæ caàn khoâng löïa             than from all historical data concerning his life and choïn vaø chaáp thuû." Vaø roài vò Taêng laïi hoûi Trieäu       significance. Here, for instance, is example 2 of Chaâu: "Khoâng löïa choïn, khoâng chaáp thuû, ñieàu ñoù         the Pi-Yen-Lu, regarding "The Ultimate Path is nghóa gì?" Trieäu Chaâu ñaùp: "Khaép cuøng trôøi vaø            Without Difficult; just avoid picking and ñaát, chæ coù ta laø toân quí nhaát." Moãi ngöôøi chuùng ta     choosing." Once a monk came to Chao-chou, and ñeàu cao quí nhaát giöõa trôøi vaø ñaát. Ngay töø thôøi         quoted a famous saying by Sosan, the Third khôûi thuûy ñaõ khoâng coù nhò nguyeân. Ñieàu naøy vöôït        Patriarch: "The Great Way has no difficulties, just leân treân caâu hoûi: "Phaûi hay khoâng phaûi." Vò Taêng        avoid choice and attachment." And then he asked ñaõ ñaët caâu hoûi ñoù cho Trieäu Chaâu vaãn coøn bò troùi      Chao-chou, "What are non-choice and non- buoäc trong quan ñieåm töông ñaõi: löïa choïn vaø chaáp         attachment?" Chao-chou answered, "Throughout thuû hoaëc khoâng löïa choïn vaø khoâng chaáp thuû. Maët        heaven and earth, I alone am the noblest." Each trôøi choùi loïi, maët traêng saùng rôõ, möa rôi. Maët trôøi,   one of us alone is the noblest one throughout maët traêng chieáu saùng, möa rôi, taát caû dieãn ra treân      heaven and earth. From the beginning there is

nothing dualistic. It is beyond asking "Is it or isn't   Name of a famous Chinese Vinayana monk who it?" The monk who was asking Chao-chou this              lived in the Yuan Dynasty. question was still caught in a relative point of         Chí Khai (1911-1981): Teân cuûa moät danh Taêng view: choice and attachment or non-choice and            Trung Quoác vaøo theá kyû thöù XX—Name of a non-attachment. The sun shines, the moon shines,         famous Chinese monk in the twentieth century. the rain rains. They shine and rain on all of us.        Chí Khieâm (1145-1229): Master Chi-Ch’ien— They do not exclude anyone. When clouds come,            Teân cuûa moät vò danh Taêng Trieàu Tieân vaøo theá kyû what? Cloudiness. When rains come? Raininess.            thöù XII—Name of a famous Korean monk in the As Zen Master Ummon (864-949) said with                  twelfth century. stunning simplicity, "Every day is a good day." It       Chí Khoan (566-643): Teân cuûa moät danh Taêng is when our discriminating minds interfere that we       Trung Quoác vaøo thôøi nhaø Ñöôøng (618-907)— have trouble. Just don't love and hate, and you will     Name of a famous Chinese monk who lived in the be lucid and clear. People these days who practice       T'ang Dynasty. meditation and ask about the Path should always          Chí Löïc: Will. remember that if they do not remain within               Chí Lyù Nhaõ Ñeå: Trijati (skt)—Ba giai ñoaïn cuûa picking and choosing, then they settle themselves        sanh laø quaù khöù, hieän taïi, vaø vò lai—Three stages down within clarity. Zen practitioners should            of birth, past, present, and future. always remember that the perfect Way is not              Chí Minh Thieàn Sö: Zen master Chi-Ming—Teân difficult; just do not make discriminations in our       cuûa moät Thieàn sö Trung Quoác—Name of a mind. If we are beyond love and hate, all is as          Chinese Zen master. clear as the broad daylight. Do not pursue the           Chí Ngoân (?-1048): Teân cuûa moät Thieàn Taêng outer conditions nor dwell in the inner void. Rest       Trung Quoác vaøo thôøi nhaø Toáng (960-1279)— ourself in oneness with things and all barriers will     Name of a Chinese Zen monk who lived in the disappear. As soon as we have a mind of right and        Sung Dynasty. wrong, we will become confused and lose our true         Chí Ngung Vaân Caùi Thieàn Sö: Thieàn Sö Vaân Caùi mind. The two come from one, but there must be           Chí Ngung—Zen master Yun-Kai-Chih-Yung— no attachment to the one, either. Equally                See Vaân Caùi Chí Ngung Thieàn Sö. contemplating all things, we will be able to return      Chí Nguyeân: Teân cuûa moät Thieàn Taêng Trung to nature. Eliminating all conditions, we are            Quoác vaøo thôøi nhaø Ñöôøng (618-907)—Name of a beyond all discrimination. One is the many and           Chinese Zen monk who lived in the T'ang the many are one. If we are able to know this, we        Dynasty. can be free from all worries. The sincere mind is        Chí Nguyeân Vaân Caùi Thieàn Sö: Zen master absolute; the absolute is the sincere mind. Cutting      Chih-Yung Yun-Kai—See Vaân Caùi Chí Ngung off the path of language, we will be beyond the          Thieàn Sö. past, present, and future." Chí Nguyeän: Will—Desire. Chí Ñöùc (1235-1322): Teân cuûa moät danh Taêng Chí Nguyeän Ñoä Tha: Altruistic determination. Trung Quoác vaøo thôøi Nguyeân (1280-1368)—Name Chí Nieäm (535-608): Teân cuûa moät danh Taêng of a famous Chinese monk who lived in the Yuan Trung Quoác vaøo thôøi nhaø Tuøy (581-618)—Name Dynasty. of a famous Chinese monk who lived in the Sui Chí Ñöùc Tyø Kheo: Jnanagupta (skt)—Xaø Na Quaät Dynasty. Ña Tyø Kheo—See Xaø Na Quaät Ña. Chí Phaûi: Quite right. Chí Giaùo Löôïng: Chính Giaùo Löôïng—Nhöõng lyù Chí Phan Nam Thieàn: Nan-ch'an Ch'i-fan—See luaän vaø chöùng cöù cuï theå trong Thaùnh ñieån—The Nam Thieàn Chí Phan Thieàn Sö. argument or evidence of authority in logic, i.e. Chí Phuøng Thieàn Sö: Ch'i-feng—Moät hoâm, Chí that of the sacred books. Phuøng thöôïng ñöôøng, roài ngoài im laëng treân thieàn Chí Haïnh: Good behavior. saøng hoài laâu. Sau ñoù Sö noùi: "Ñaïi chuùng xem kìa!" Chí Hoàng: Teân cuûa moät danh Taêng Trung Quoác, Noùi xong Sö böôùc xuoáng toøa. Ñaïi chuùng nghó raèng thuoäc Luaät toâng, vaøo thôøi Nguyeân (1280-1368)—

thaày seõ khoâng noùi theâm gì khaùc nöõa neân nhaát teà        Chí Taâm Tín Laïc Nguyeän: Vow of sincere mind ruùt lui. Sö quôû: "Xem ra, maáy oâng ai cuõng nhö ai.          and joyful faith—Nguyeän thöù 18 trong 48 lôøi Chaúng coù laáy moät ngöôøi coù trí hueä. Khi thaáy ta môû      nguyeän cuûa ñöùc Phaät A Di Ñaø—The eighteenth of mieäng ra, ai naáy keùo ñeán tìm lôøi, cho raèng ñoù laø        the forty-eight vows of Amitabha Buddha. chaân lyù toái thöôïng. Thaät ñaùng thöông, chaúng moät         Chí Thaønh: Very sincere. ai hieåu caùi gì laø caùi gì caû. Chöøng naøo maø maáy oâng     Chí Thaønh Caùt Chaâu Thieàn Sö: Zen master vaãn cöù nhö theá naøy, thì ñaây quaû laø moät tai öông         Chih-sheng Chi-chou—See Trí Thaønh Caùt Chaâu cho nhaø Thieàn vaäy!" Thieàn sö Chí Phuøng soáng vaøo          Thieàn Sö. khoaûng cuoái nhaø Ñöôøng ñaàu nhaø Toáng. Luùc ñoù             Chí Thaønh Nhö Thaàn: Ngöôøi chí thaønh thì chaúng thieân höôùng phaùt trieån cuûa giaùo phaùp Thieàn toâng        khaùc gì thaàn thaùnh—The man possesses of laàn hoài thay theá caùc toâng phaùi khaùc ôû Trung Hoa.        complete sincerity is like a god. Nghóa laø thaùi ñoä Thieàn ñoái vôùi truyeàn thoáng, vaø        Chí Thaønh Taâm: Perfect sincerity. trieát lyù ñaïo Phaät, coù khuynh höôùng coi nheï vieäc         Chí Thaønh Thieàn Sö: Zen master Chih-sheng— hoïc hoûi theo thöù lôùp cuûa noù, lô laø kinh ñieån vaø caùc   OÂng laø moät trong nhöõng hoïc troø cuûa Ñaïi Sö Thaàn thöù sieâu hình trong kinh. Vaø vaøo thôøi ñoù, vieäc giöõ      Tuù—Zen master Chih-sheng was one of the im laëng khoâng noùi moät lôøi trong moät thôøi khi             disciples of Great Master Shen-Hsiu—See Trí thöôïng ñöôøng cuõng laø moät phöông caùch ñöôïc                Thaønh Caùt Chaâu Thieàn Sö. nhieàu thieàn sö öa thích duøng ñeå daïy chuùng—One             Chí Thieän: Ñieàu thieän cao toät—Extremely day, Ch'i-feng entered the hall, then sat quietly in            wholesome—Supreme goodness. his pulpit for some time. Then said, "O monks,                  Chí Thieàng (1861-1933): Teân cuûa moät danh Taêng look, look!" After speaking these words, he came                Vieät Nam, ñôøi thöù 39 doøng Laâm Teá—Name of a down from the seat. The monks thought he was                    famous Vietnamese monk, of the thirty-ninth not going to say anything else, so they began to                lineage of Lin-chi sect. retire all at once. He then scolded them: "As I                 Chí Thoâng Thieàn Sö: Zen Master Chih-T’ung observe, you are all of one pattern; not one of you             —See Trí Thoâng Thoï Chaâu Thieàn Sö. has sagacity enough to see things properly. You                 Chí Toân: Supreme. have come here to see me open my mouth, and, Chí Toân Ca: Bhagavad-gita (skt)—The Lord’s taking hold of my words, imagine they are Song—A complete treatise on spiritual ultimate truths. It is a pity that you all fail to know development along the lines of Karma Yoga, the what's what. As long as you remain like this, what way of Right Action. a calamity for Zen Buddhism!" Zen master Ch'i- Chí Trieät Giang Taây Thieàn Sö: Zen Master feng, who lived between late T'ang and early Chih-Ch’e Chiang Hsi—Teân cuûa moät vò Thieàn sö Sung when the trend of development of Zen Trung Hoa. Hieän nay chuùng ta coù nhieàu taøi lieäu chi teaching gradually superseded the other Buddhist tieát veà Thieàn Sö Chí Trieät nhö trong Truyeàn Ñaêng schools in China. It is to say, Zen attitude towards Luïc, quyeån V, vaø Kinh Phaùp Baûo Ñaøn; tuy nhieân, Buddhist lore and philosophy tended to slight its coù moät soá chi tieát lyù thuù veà vò Thieàn sö naøy trong study in an orderly manner, to neglect the sutras Kinh Phaùp Baûo Ñaøn. Theo Kinh Phaùp Baûo Ñaøn, and what metaphysics there is in them. And during chöông taùm, Taêng Chí Trieät, queâ ôû Giang Taây, hoï that period of time, the keeping quiet in silence Tröông teân Haønh Xöông, thuôû nhoû laø moät hieäp for some time in the pulpit was a favorite method khaùch. Vì lyù do naøy maø ngöôøi ñöông thôøi luoân goïi that many masters used to instruct their disciples. oâng laø Haønh Xöông—Zen Master Chih-Ch’e, Chí Phöôùc: Teân cuûa moät danh Taêng kieâm hoïc giaû name of a Chinese Zen master. We do have a lot Phaät giaùo Trung Quoác vaøo thôøi nhaø Lieâu (907- of detailed documents on this Zen Master, i.e, the 1124)—Name of a famous Chinese monk and Records of the Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan- Buddhist scholar who lived in the Liao Dynasty. Teng-Lu), Volume V, and the Flatform Sutra; Chí Taâm Ñaûnh Leã: Respectful Homage.                          however, there is some interesting information on Chí Taâm Höôùng: See Nam Moâ.                                   him in Flatform Sutra. According to the Flatform Chí Taâm Nieäm Phaät: Whole-hearted recitation.                 Sutra, Chapter Eight, Bhikshu Chih-Ch’e, a native

of Chiang Hsi, had the family name Chang and the                 Xöông thöa: “Hoïc nhôn thöùc löôïng caïn toái, cuùi personal name Hsing-Ch’ang. For this reason,                     mong Hoøa Thöôïng löôïng theo maø töø bi khai contemporary people always called him "Hsing-                    thò.”—When the schools split into the Ch’ang". As a youth, he was an itinerant warrior.                Northern and Southern, although the two  Töø khi chia ra hai toâng Nam Baéc, hai vò Toâng               leaders had lost the notion of self and other, chuû tuy queân bæ ngaõ, nhöng ñoà chuùng tranh               the disciples stirred up love and hate. The nhau khôûi yeâu gheùt. Khi aáy ñeä töû cuûa Baéc             disciples of the Northern School secretly set Toâng töï laäp Ngaøi Thaàn Tuù laøm Toå thöù saùu, maø       up Shen-Hsiu as the Sixth Patriarch. Fearing kî vì Luïc Toå ñöôïc truyeàn y, moïi ngöôøi ñeàu             that the country would hear of the nghe neân môùi daïy Haønh Xöông ñeán aùm saùt                transmission of the robe, they hired Hsing- Luïc Toå. Toå taâm thoâng döï bieát vieäc aáy neâ n lieàn    Ch’ang to assassinate the Master. But the ñeå möôøi laïng vaøng ôû döôùi toøa. Khi aáy ban             Master had the power of knowing the ñeâm Haønh Xöông vaøo trong thaát Toå, toan                  thoughts of others. He knew of this matter in muoán haïi Toå, Toå ñöa coå cho cheùm, Haønh                 advance and set ten ounces of gold in his Xöông lieàn höôi kieám ba laàn, thaûy ñeàu khoâng            chair. That night, Hsing-Ch’ang entered his thöông toån. Toå baûo: “Kieám chaùnh chaúng taø,             room intending to kill him. The Master kieám taø chaúng chaùnh, chæ nôï vaøng cuûa oâng.”           stretched out his neck. Hsing-Ch’ang swung Haønh Xöông hoaûng hoát teù xæu, giaây laâu môùi             the blade three times but could not harm him. tænh, caàu xin saùm hoái, lieàn nguyeän xuaát gia.           The Master said, “A straight sword is not bent, Toå lieàn cho vaøng baûo: “OÂng haõy ñi, e ñoà               a bent sword is not straight, I merely owe you chuùng trôû laïi haïi oâng, moät ngaøy khaùc oâng coù        gold, I do not owe you life.” Hsing-Ch’ang theå thay hình ñoåi daïng maø trôû laïi, toâi seõ nhaän      fell to the ground in fright. After a while he oâng.” Haønh Xöông vaâng lôøi daïy, giöõa ñeâm               came to and begged for mercy, repenting of troán ñi, sau theo Taêng xuaát gia, thoï giôùi cuï           his error and vowing to leave home. The tuùc, tinh caàn tu haønh. Moät hoâm oâng nhôù laïi lôøi      Master gave him the gold and said, “Go. I Toå, töø xa ñeán leã ra maét Toå. Toå baûo: “Toâi nhôù       fear that my followers will come and take oâng ñaõ laâu, sao oâng ñeán muoän vaäy?” Haønh              revenge. Change your appearance and return Xöông thöa: “Tröôùc nhôø ôn Hoøa Thöôïng xaù                 another day and I will accept you.” Hsing toäi, ngaøy nay tuy xuaát gia khoå haïnh, troïn khoù         Ch’ang received his orders and disappeared ñeàn ñaùp aân ñöùc, ñaâu mong truyeàn phaùp ñoä              into the night. Later, he left home under sanh ö? Ñeä töû thöôøng xem kinh Nieát Baøn,                 another Bhikshu, received complete precepts chöa hieåu nghóa thöôøng vaø voâ thöôøng, cuùi xin           and was vigorous in practice. One day, Hoøa Thöôïng töø bi chæ daïy.” Toå baûo: “Voâ                remembering the Master’s words, he made thöôøng töùc laø Phaät taùnh, höõu thöôøng töùc laø taâm     the long journey to have an audience. The phaân bieät taát caû phaùp thieän aùc vaäy.” Haønh           Master said, “I have thought of you for a long Xöông thöa raèng: “Hoøa Thöôïng noùi phaùp raát              time. What took you so long?” He replied, traùi vôùi vaên kinh.” Toå baûo: “Ta ñöôïc truyeàn           “The High Master once favored me by taâm aán cuûa Phaät, ñaâu daùm traùi vôùi kinh Phaät.”       pardoning my crime. Although I have left Haønh Xöông thöa: “Kinh noùi Phaät taùnh laø                 home and although I practice austerities, I thöôøng, Hoøa Thöôïng laïi noùi laø voâ thöôøng, caùc        shall never be able to repay his kindness. May phaùp thieän aùc cho ñeán taâm Boà Ñeà ñeàu laø voâ          I try to repay you by transmitting the Dharma thöôøng maø Hoøa Thöôïng laïi noùi laø höõu thöôøng,         and taking living beings across? Your disciple ñaây töùc laø traùi nhau, khieán cho hoïc nhôn caøng         often studies the Mahaparinirvana Sutra, but theâm nghi ngôø.” Toå noùi: “Kinh Nieát Baøn thuôû           he has not yet understood the principles of xöa toâi coù nghe Ni Voâ Taän Taïng ñoïc moät laàn           permanence and impermanence. I beg the lieàn vì baø giaûng noùi, khoâng coù moät chöõ, moät         High Master to be compassionate and explain nghóa naøo khoâng hieäp vôùi vaên kinh, cho ñeán vì          them for me.”           The      Master said, oâng noùi cuõng troïn khoâng coù hai thuyeát.” Haønh         “Impermanence is just the Buddha nature and

permanence is just the mind discriminating                 Therefore, I explain it as impermanent. That good and evil dharmas.” Hsing-Ch’ang                       is exactly what the Buddha explained as the replied, “High Master, your explanation                    meaning of true permanence. Furthermore, if contradicts the Sutra text!” The Master said,              all dharmas were permanent, all things would “I transmit the Buddha’s mind-seal. How                    have a self-nature subject to birth and death could I dare to contradict the Buddhas’                    and the true permanent nature would not Sutras?” Hsing-Ch’ang replied, “The Sutra                  pervade all places. Therefore, I explain it as says that the Buddha nature is permanent and               impermanent. That is exactly what the the High Master has just said that it is                   Buddha explained as the meaning of the true impermanent; it says that good and evil                    permanence. It was for the sake of common dharmas, reaching even to the Bodhi Mind,                  people and those who belong to other are impermanent and the High Master has just               religions who cling to deviant views of said that they are permanent. This                         permanence, and for all those who follow the contradiction has merely intensified your                  two-vehicle way, mistaking permanence for student’s doubt and delusion.” The Master                  impermanence           formulating       the     eight said, “Formerly, I heard Bhikshuni Wu Chin                 perverted views, that the Buddha in the Tsang recite the Nirvana Sutra. When I                     ultimate Nirvana teaching destroyed their commented on it, there was not one word or                 prejudiced views. He explained true principle which did not accord with the sutra              permanence, true bliss, true selfhood and true text. My explanation to you now is not                     purity. You now contradict this meaning by different.” Hsing-Ch’ang replied, “Your                    relying on the words, taking annihilation to be student’s capacity for understanding is                    impermanence and fixing on a lifeless superficial. Will the High Master please                   permanence. In this way you misinterpret the explain further?”                                          last, subtle, complete and wonderful words of    Nhôn ñoù Toå baûo: “OÂng bieát chaêng, Phaät taùnh         the Buddha. Even if you read it a thousand neáu thöôøng laïi noùi gì laø caùc phaùp thieän aùc, cho   times, what benefit could you derive from it?” ñeán cuøng kieáp khoâng coù moät ngöôøi phaùt taâm        Haønh Xöông boãng nhieân ñaïi ngoä, lieàn noùi keä Boà Ñeà, neân toâi noùi laø voâ thöôøng, maø chính laø     raèng: ñaïo chôn thöôøng cuûa Phaät noùi. Laïi taát caû phaùp           “Vì giöõ taâm voâ thöôøng, neáu laø voâ thöôøng, töùc laø moãi vaät ñeàu coù töï             Phaät noùi coù taùnh thöôøng, taùnh, dung thoï sanh töû maø taùnh chôn thöôøng                  Khoâng bieát ñöôïc phöông tieän, coù choã baát bieán, neân toâi noùi thöôøng chính laø             Nhö ao xuaân moø gaïch, Phaät noùi nghóa chaân voâ thöôøng. Phaät xöa vì                  Nay toâi chaúng thi coâng, phaøm phu ngoaïi ñaïo chaáp taø thöôøng, coøn caùc                Maø Phaät taùnh hieän tieàn, haøng nhò thöøa thöôøng maø chaáp laø voâ thöôøng,                Khoâng phaûi thaày trao cho, coäng thaønh taùm thöù ñieân ñaûo, neân trong giaùo                 Toâi cuõng khoâng sôû ñaéc.” lyù lieãu nghóa kinh Nieát Baøn phaù thieân kieán kia      Hsing-Ch’ang suddenly achieved the great maø hieån baøy chôn thöôøng, chôn laïc, chôn ngaõ,         enlightenment and spoke this verse: chôn tònh. Nay oâng y theo lôøi noùi maø traùi vôùi        “To those who hold impermanence in mind nghóa, duøng ñoaïn dieät voâ thöôøng vaø xaùc ñònh           The Buddha speaks of the permanent nature; caùi töû thöôøng maø laàm hieåu lôøi noùi maàu nhieäm        Not knowing expedients is like vieân dieäu toái haäu cuûa Phaät, duø coù xem moät           Picking up pebbles from a spring pond. ngaøn bieán kinh thì coù lôïi ích gì?”—Then the              But now without an effort Master said, “Don’t you understand? If the                   The Buddha nature manifests; Buddha nature were permanent, what use                       The Master did not transmit it, would there be in speaking of good and evil                  And I did not obtain a thing.” dharmas? To the end of an aeon not one                    Toå baûo: “Nay oâng môùi trieät vaäy, neân ñaët teân person would produce the Bodhi Mind.                       oâng laø Chí Trieät.” Chí Trieät leã taï maø lui—The

Master said, “Now you understand! You                     Samatha ñöôïc vöôït qua trong 9 giai ñoaïn tinh should be called Chih-Ch’e (breadth of                    thaàn, saùu söùc maïnh vaø boán hoaït ñoäng taâm understanding).” Chih-Ch’e thanked the                    thaàn—Samatha is a method of training the Master, bowed and withdrew.                               mind to develop concentration. Samatha Chí Trieät Thieàn Sö: Bhikshu Chih-Ch’e—See                    meditation is concerned with producing a one- Chí Trieät Giang Taây Thieàn Sö.                               pointed mind. Samatha is one of the two main Chí Tuyeàn Vaân Phong Thieàn Sö: See Vaân Phong                methods of meditation, which is defined as Chí Tuyeàn Thieàn Sö.                                          silencing, or putting to rest the active mind, or Chí Vieân Hoàng Chaâu Thieàn Sö: Zen master Ji-                let the mind fixed on one place, or in one yuan Hung-chou—Thieàn sö Chí Vieân, moät Thieàn                position. It differs from “contemplation” sö Trung Hoa vaøo thôøi nhaø Toáng, ngöôøi ñaõ noåi            which observes, examines, etc. Samatha deals tieáng vôùi coâng aùn quaû haïnh thoái —Zen master Ji-         with getting rid of distractions, rather than yuan was from China during the Sung dynasty                    contemplation. When our physical body is at (960-1279). He was famous with the koan of a                   rest, it is called “samatha”; when the mind is rotten apricot.                                                seeing clearly, it is called “contemplation.” Chí Vieãn (768-844): Zen master Ji-yuan—Teân                   One of the seven names for meditation. cuûa moät Thieàn sö Trung Hoa vaøo thôøi nhaø                  Samatha also means quieting, ceasing, Ñöôøng—Ji-yuan, name of a Chinese Zen master                   tranquility or serenity comes from the during the T'ang dynasty (618-907).                            literature of Yogachara school and were put Chí Yeáu: Most important.                                      into practice in Tibet as a unified system of Chæ: Samatha (skt & p)—Calming.                                meditation. One-pointedness of mind, one of (I) Toång quan veà “Chæ”—An overview of                        the      mental       factors      in   wholesome “Samatha”: Tieáng Phaïn Tam Ma Ñòa coù nghóa              consciousness; however, samatha (tranquility laø traïng thaùi taâm vaéng laëng, laø moät phöông        of mind) rather in the negative sense of phaùp huaán luyeän taâm taäp trung tö töôûng.             withdrawal. Vipassana is a more positive Thieàn Tam Ma Ñòa lieân quan tôùi vieäc gom               achievement (the quietude achieved) through taâm vaøo moät ñieåm (see Nhaát Ñieåm Truï).              the practice of dhyana, to cause subjugation Thieàn Chæ laø moät trong hai phöông phaùp chính          or cessation of troubles.             The various cuûa Thieàn, noù ñöôïc ñònh nghóa baèng laéng dòu         obstacles   that encounter     the  development    of hay laøm cho caùi taâm sinh ñoäng nghæ ngôi, hay          shamatha     are overcome      through  nine   stages laøm cho taâm gaén vaøo moät choã, moät vò trí naøo       of mind, six powers and four mental activities. ñoù. Thieàn chæ lo vieäc deïp boû voïng, hôn laø (II) Nghóa cuûa “Chæ”—The meanings of quaùn chieáu. Khi thaân theå chuùng ta nghæ ngôi          “Samatha”: thì chuùng ta goïi ñoù laø “chæ”; khi taâm chuùng ta   1) Yeân laëng hay yeân tænh: Samatha (skt)— quaùn chieáu ñeå thaáy roõ vaán ñeà thì chuùng ta goïi    Quiet—Tranquility—Calm—Absence                     of ñoù laø “quaùn.” Moät trong baûy teân goïi cuûa thieàn    passion—Cessation—Moä         t   trong  baû y   ñònh ñònh (thu nhieáp taâm vaøo moät duyeân, xa lìa moïi       nghóa cuûa Thieàn Ñònh, ñöôïc dieãn taû nhö laø taùn loaïn; trong caùc caûnh nhieãm tònh maø taâm         Xa-Ma-Tha hay Tam Ma Ñòa, coù nghóa laø deïp khoâng voïng duyeân). Tam Ma Ñòa coøn laø söï             yeâ n taâm loaïn ñoäng, hay laø ñeå cho taâm yeân yeân tænh laâu daøi cuûa tinh thaàn ñöôïc thöïc taäp      ñònh,  döøng ôû moät choã. Taâm ñònh chæ ö nhöùt xöù, trong tröôøng phaùi Yogachara vaø baây giôø ñöôïc         khaùc vôùi “quaùn” laø xaùc nghieäm baèng chöùng caùc sö Taây Taïng thöïc taäp nhö moät heä thoáng         cöù. Chæ laø deïp boû caùc voïng nieäm, coøn quaùn thieàn ñònh toång theå. Söï nhaát taâm, moät trong        duøng ñeå chöùng nghieäm chaân lyù: One of the yeáu toá tinh thaàn trong thieän thöùc. Tuy nhieân,       seven definitions of dhyana described as Samatha haøm nghóa ruùt lui thuï ñoäng trong khi          samatha or samadhi; it is defined as silencing, Vipassana (minh saùt) haøm nghóa thöïc hieän tích         or putting to rest the active mind, or auto- cöïc qua thieàn taäp, laøm ngöng baët nhöõng trôû         hypnosis. The mind is centered or the mind ngaïi. Nhöõng trôû ngaïi trong khi phaùt trieån           steadily fixed on one place, or in one position.

It differs from “contemplation” which                      to be preferable. It is attained when the mind observes, examines, sifts evidence. Samadhi                is able to remain upon its object one- or samatha has to do with getting rid of                   pointedly, spontaneously and without effort, distraction for moral ends; it is abstraction,             and for as long a period of time as one wishes, rather than contemplation.                                 without being disturbed by laxity or 2) Khi caùc cô quan trong ngöôøi nghæ ngôi laø chæ,           excitement. There are said to be six ñoái laïi vôùi “quaùn” laø taâm trí nhìn thaáu suoát roõ   prerequisites for achieving calming. They are raøng. Chæ laø moät traïng thaùi thieàn ñònh bieåu         staying in an agreeable place, having few tröng söï nhaát taâm (hay taâm tuï vaøo nhaát ñieåm)       desires, knowing satisfaction, not having treân moät vaät theå. Moät trong baûy ñònh nghóa           many activities, pure ethics, and thoroughly cuûa Thieàn Ñònh, ñöôïc dieãn taû nhö laø Xa-Ma-           abandoning thoughts. It is generally Tha hay Tam Ma Ñòa, coù nghóa laø deïp yeân                considered to be a prerequisite for attainment taâm loaïn ñoäng, hay laø ñeå cho taâm yeân ñònh,          of “higher insight” or "Prajna". döøng ôû moät choã. Taâm ñònh chæ ö nhöùt xöù, khaùc (III) Chín giai ñoaïn tinh thaàn—Nine stages of vôùi “quaùn” laø xaùc nghieäm baèng chöùng cöù. Chæ        mind—Nhöõng khaùi nieäm cuûa chín giai ñoaïn laø deïp boû caùc voïng nieäm, coøn quaùn duø ng ñeå       tinh thaàn naøy ñeán töø caùc vaên baûn cuûa tröôøng chöùng nghieäm chaân lyù. Veà maët lyù thuyeát maø         phaùi Du Giaø vaø ñöôïc thöïc haønh taïi Taây Taïng noùi, baát cöù vaät theå naøo cuõng coù theå ñöôïc duøng   nhö moät heä thoáng thieàn ñònh hôïp nhaát. Chín laøm ñieåm taäp trung, duø vaäy nhöõng vaät theå nhö       giai ñoaïn naøy laø: Höôùng tinh thaàn vaøo moät ñoái thaân Phaät vaãn ñöôïc ngöôøi ta öa thích duøng laøm       töôïng thieàn ñònh, cuûng coá tinh thaàn, luoân luoân ñieåm taäp trung hôn. Chæ ñöôïc thaønh ñaït khi            thay ñoåi söï chuù taâm, giôùi haïn söï chuù taâm vaøo taâm coù khaû naêng truï yeân moät choã treân vaät theå    ñoái töôïng thieàn ñònh, laøm cho tinh thaàn thuaàn moät caùch töï nhieân khoâng caàn phaûi noã löïc, vaø      thuïc, laøm cho tinh thaàn yeân tónh, hoaøn thieän söï coù khaû naêng truï taïi ñoù trong thôøi gian ngöôøi ñoù   yeân tónh, taäp trung tinh thaàn vaøo moät ñieåm, vaø muoán maø khoâng bò phoùng daät hay taùn loaïn             tam ma ñòa—The concepts of these nine quaáy raày. Ngöôøi ta noùi coù saùu ñieàu tieân quyeát     stages come from the literature of the tröôùc khi thaønh ñaït ñöôïc “Chæ”, truï nôi thích         Yogacara school and were put into practice in hôïp, thieåu duïc, tri tuùc, khoâng coù nhieàu sinh        Tibet as a unified system of meditation. These hoaït, tònh giôùi vaø phaûi hoaøn toaøn ruõ boû moïi       nine stages are: Directedness of mind toward voïng nieäm. Chæ laø ñieàu caàn coù tröôùc khi ñaït        the object of meditation, stabilization of the ñöôïc trí hueä “Baùt Nhaõ”—Physical organism is            mind, continuous renewal of attention, at rest, in contrast with contemplation is when            confinement to the object of meditation, the mind is seeing clearly. Calming is a                   taming of the mind, calming the mind, refined meditative state characterized by a one-                   calm, the mind collected into oneness, and pointedness of mind (cittaikagrata) on an                  samadhi. internal meditative object. One of the seven (IV) Saùu söùc maïnh: Nghe hoïc thuyeát, suy nghó, söùc definitions of dhyana described as samatha or              chuù taäm, hieåu roõ, taäp trung naêng löôïng, vaø töï samadhi; it is defined as silencing, or putting            tin töï nhieân—Six powers: Hearing the to rest the active mind, or auto-hypnosis. The             teaching, reflection, power of attention, clear mind is centered or the mind steadily fixed on             comprehension, concenrated energy, and one place, or in one position. It differs from             natural confidence. “contemplation” which observes, examines, (V) Boán hoaït ñoäng taâm thaàn: Ñaët lieân heä giöõa tinh sifts evidence. Samadhi or samatha has to do               thaàn vaø ñoái töôïng, Ñaët lieân heä giöõa tinh thaàn with getting rid of distraction for moral ends;            vaø ñoái töôïng, phuïc hoài söï chuù taâm, chuù taâm it is abstraction, rather than contemplation.              lieân tuïc vaø thanh thaûn khoâng coá gaéng—Four Theoretically, any object may serve as the                 mental activities: Connecting the mind to the focus of concentration, though virtuous                    object,      re-establishment       of      attention, objects such as the body of a Buddha are said

uninterrupted       attention,     and      dwelling     Vöïc, hay baéc AÁn Ñoä, ngöôøi ñaõ dòch 23 quyeån kinh effortlessly.                                            sang Hoa ngöõ vaøo ñôøi Taán (coù leõ laø Kinh Boà Taùt Chæ AÙc Haønh Thieän: Ngöøng moïi aùc nghieäp vaø tu           Thaäp Truï)—Also called “Friend of Song,” a noted caùc nghieäp laønh—To stop evil or wickedness, and             monk from western China, or north India, who in to cultivate all the wholesome deeds.                          the fourth century, translated 23 works into Chæ AÙc Moân: See Chæ Trì.                                     Chinese (perhaps The sutra of Bodhisattva’s Ten Chæ AÙc Tu Thieän: Caét ñöùt moïi aùc nghieäp vaø tu           Grounds). caùc nghieäp laønh—To cut off evil or wickedness,              Chæ Ñaïo: To lead—To guide. and to cultivate all the wholesome deeds.                      Chæ Ñaùt: Jetavaniyah or Jetiyasailah (skt)— Chæ AÁn: Kyù teân baèng caùch in daáu tay caùi—To sign         Tröôøng phaùi cuûa nhöõng ngöôøi treân nuùi Chæ Ñaùt, by a thumb-mark; a sign.                                       moät toâng phaùi cuûa Thöôïng Toïa Boä—School of the Chæ Bao Baát Truï Hoûa: Tuùi giaáy khoâng bao ñöôïc            dwellers on Mount Jeta or school of Jetrvana, a löûa, yù noùi bí maät theá naøo cuõng bò loä —Paper bags       subdivision of Sthavirah. cannot wrap a fire, i.e., secrets cannot be kept               Chæ Ñaéc Nhaát Quyeát: Ñaønh phaûi duøng moät caùi forever.                                                       choát cöûa, duï cho söï chöùng ñaéc chæ coù moät nöûa maø Chæ Baûo: To advise—To teach—To direct.                        thoâi—To be satisfied (contened) with just one Chæ Beänh: Chæ voïng töùc chaân (tòch nieäm ñeå caàu           door bolt, i.e., an incomplete realization. vieân giaùc laø chæ beänh, vì vieân giaùc chaúng phaûi do      Chæ Ñaàu Höõu Nhaõn: Ngoùn tay coù maét, duï cho söï chæ nieäm maø ñöôïc), moät trong boán beänh ñöôïc noùi         khai thò Phaät phaùp roõ raøng cho chuùng sanh, ñeå töø ñeán trong Kinh Vieân Giaùc—Cessation of all                   ñoù hoï coù theå theo böôùc, hoïc hoûi vaø thoâng hieåu mental operation, one of the four mistaken ways                chaân lyù, cuõng nhö phaân bieät roõ raøng thò phi— of seeking perfection, mentioned in The Complete               Fingers have eyes, i.e., a clear introduction and Enlightenment Sutra.                                           opening the Buddhas’ views and knowledge to Chæ Can Chaâm Chuøy: Ngoùn tay, coät phöôùn, caây              sentient beings; so they can follow, learn, kim, kieàn chuøy, vaân vaân, laø nhöõng phöông phaùp           understand thoroughly the truths, and clearly maø baäc thaày söû duïng khi tieáp hoùa ñeä töû. Caùc thieàn   distinguish right from wrong. sö thöôøng ñaùnh baèng gaäy hay ñöa ra moät tieáng heùt        Chæ Ñeå Khaû Boä: See Chi Ñeà Sôn Boä. thaät to nhaèm khaùm nghieäm trình ñoä laõnh hoäi cuûa         Chæ Ñoâng Chæ Taây: Noùi loøng voøng—To beat ñeä töû—Finger, banner (Pataka), needle, and                   about the bush. copper instrument, etc., are the Masters' methods              Chæ Ñoâng Hoaïch Taây: See Chæ Ñoâng Taùc Taây. in welcoming and transforming disciples. Zen                   Chæ Ñoâng Taùc Taây: Laàm cho höôùng ñoâng laø masters usually strike with a staff or give an                 höôùng taây, duï cho söï hieåu laàm chaân lyù—To extremely loud cry to test                       disciples'    mistake the east with the west, i.e., a comprehensive levels.                                          misunderstanding of the truth. Chæ Chuù: Chæ trích—To criticize.                              Chæ Ñöôøng: To point out the way. Chæ Daãn: To show—To explain.                                  Chæ Haønh Nhò Thieän: Chæ laø döøng laïi moïi aùc Chæ Dieäp: Palm-leaves.                                        nghieäp; vaø haønh laø thöïc haønh hay tu taäp theo toâ n Chæ Doanh Ñaéc Nhaõn Tình Daõ Laïc Ñòa: Chæ coøn               giaùo—To cut off evil or wickedness and to ñoâi maét coøn laïi cuõng bò muø, duï cho chaúng hieåu         practice of religious life are two wholesome Phaät phaùp, laàm giaûng Phaät phaùp maø bò quaû baùo          deeds. ruïng loâng maøy, raâu ria, muõi vaø muø maét—The only         Chæ Hoaøn: See Chæ Xuyeán. things left are blind eyes, i.e., preaching with               Chæ Hung Ñieåm Laëc: Ñoäng taùc cao ngaïo phaùch wrong views will receive the results of losing all             loái—An arrogant and haughty action. beards, eyebrows, nose, and blind eyes—See                     Chæ Höùa Laõo Hoà Tri, Baát Höùa Laõo Hoà Hoäi: Chæ Thuùy Nham Mi Mao.                                             cho laõo Hoà (Boà Ñeà Ñaït Ma) bieát, chöù khoâng cho Chæ Ña: See Chaát Ña.                                          laõo Hoà hieåu, duï cho ngay caû toå Boà Ñeà Ñaït Ma Chæ Ña Maät: Gitamitra (skt)—Kyø Ña Maät—Ca                    cuõng khoâng duøng theá trí ñeå hieåu nghóa lyù vaø choã Höõu—Kyø Maät Ña—Vò Taêng noåi tieáng ngöôøi Taây              cöùu caùnh nhaø thieàn—Only to inform Bodhidharma,

but not to let him understand, i.e., even the                 Chæ Nam: Söï höôùng daãn—Guidance. patriarch Bodhidharma cannot use the mundane                  Chæ Nguyeät: Ngoùn tay chæ traêng, hay tay chæ thoû wisdom to understand the meanings and aim of                  treân traêng (ngoùn tay tieâu bieåu cho kinh ñieån, vaø Zen.                                                          traêng tieâu bieåu cho chaân lyù)—To point a finger at Chæ Keá: Suy löôøng phaân bieät—To have thought or            the moon, or to indicate the hare in the moon (the idea and to discriminate.                                     finger represents the sutras, the moon represents Chæ Khoâng Thieàn Sö (1289-1363): Dhyana-                     their truth (doctrines). bhadra (skt)—Teân cuûa thieàn sö AÁn Ñoä vaøo theá kyû        Chæ Nguyeät Hueä AÁn Thieàn Sö: Shigetsu Hein XIV—Name of an Indian Zen master in the                       Zenji (jap)—Teân cuûa moät Thieàn sö Nhaät Baûn— fourteen century.                                             Name of a Japanese Zen master. Chæ Lôïi: Master Chi-li—Teân cuûa moät vò danh                Chæ Nhö: 1) Chaúng haïn nhö: For example, for Taêng Nhaät Baûn chuyeân veà ñieâu khaéc töôïng Phaät —       instance; 2) Theá thì: Then. Name of a famous Japanese monk who was a                      Chæ Phaïm: Negative in not doing good or professional sculptor of statues of Buddha.                   preventing good or sin omission—Chaúng chòu tu Chæ Man: Angulimalya (skt)—See Öông Quaät Ma                  haønh ñeå traùnh caùc aùc nghieäp. Thuï ñoäng trong La.                                                           nhöõng vieäc thieän laønh nhö khoâng boá thí laø “chæ Chæ Man Kinh: Angulimala-Sutra (skt)—See                      phaïm”, trong khi phaïm toäi baèng haønh ñoäng (hay Öông Quaät Ma La Kinh.                                        phaïm nhöõng giôùi maø mình ñaõ thuï) nhö saùt sanh, Chæ Moân: Meditation by concentrating the mind—               troäm caép, vaân vaân thì goïi laø “taùc phaïm.” Töï kieåm Chæ Moân hay phaùp moân "Taäp Trung Taâm YÙ" hay              baèng caùch giöõ giôùi hay ngöøng laøm nhöõng vieäc taø taäp trung vaøo chæ quaùn ñeå laéng taâm tónh laëng (ñaõ      vaïy—Ceasing to do wrong, while transgression sin quaùn soå töùc vaø tuøy töùc, haønh giaû phaûi coá gaéng tu   by action, active sin, or positive in doing evil such taäp chæ quaùn). Ngöøng caû soå töùc vaø tuøy töùc ñeå taäp   as killing, stealing, etc. Self-control in keeping the trung vaøo taâm yù. Trong giai ñoaïn naøy haønh giaû          commandments or prohibitions relating to deeds phaûi hoaøn toaøn khoâng bieát ñeán hôi thôû vaø "döøng"      and words. taâm mình laïi treân ñaàu muõi. Baáy giôø haønh giaû seõ      Chæ Phuùc Thaân: Quan heä baèng caùch höùa hoân khi caûm thaáy heát söùc thanh thaûn vaø oån ñònh, roài ít laâu   hai ñöùc nhoû trai vaø gaùi haõy coøn trong thai meï — sau ñoù caû thaân laãn taâm nhö tan bieán vaøo hö voâ. Ñoù    Related by the betrothal of son and daughter still laø traïng thaùi "Thieàn Ñònh", moät traïng thaùi hoaøn       in the womb. toaøn ñình chæ. Khi ñaït ñöôïc traïng thaùi naøy, haønh       Chæ Phöông Laäp Töôùng: Chæ veà höôùng Taây, coõi giaû phaûi luoân töï nhaéc nhôû raèng, maëc daàu kinh         Tònh Ñoä cuûa Ñöùc Phaät A Di Ñaø; truï taâm vaøo caûnh nghieäm "Thieàn Ñònh" laø tuyeät vôøi, nhöng theo lôøi        giôùi cuûa Ñöùc Phaät A Di Ñaø ñeå caàu giaûi thoaùt—To caûnh caùo cuûa ñöùc Phaät, mình khoâng ñöôïc chaáp           point to the west, the location of the Pure Land, tröôùc hay laàn löõa trong traïng thaùi ñoù—Stopping          and set up in the mind the presence of Amitabha both counting and following the breathing and                 Buddha; to hold this idea, and to trust in Amitabha, starting concentrating the mind. In this stage, the           and thus attain salvation. The mystics regard this practitioner should completely ignore the breath              as a mental experience, while the ordinary and stop his mind on the tip of the nose. He will             believer regards it as an objective reality. now feel extremely tranquil and steady, and soon              Chæ Quan: Noùn giaáy, duøng ñeå ñoát cuùng ngöôøi both his body and mind will seem to have                      cheát—Paper hats, burnt as offerings to the dead. vanished into nothingness. This is the stage of               Chæ Quaùn: Chih-kuan (chi)—Shikan (jap)— "Dhyana", a stage of perfect cessation. When it               Samatha-vipasyana (skt)—Xa Ma Tha Bì Baùt (Baø) has been reached, the practitioner should remind              Xaù      Na—Quieting          and      reflecting—Quiet, himself that, although the experience of "Dhyana"             tranquility and absence of passion—Chæ coù nghóa is wonderful, one should not, as Buddha has                   laø ñình chæ, quaùn laø quaùn ñaït. Nhö vaäy chæ quaùn laø admonished, cling to it or linger in it.                      ñình chæ voïng nieäm ñeå quaùn ñaït chaân lyù . Khi taâm Chæ Nan: Nöôùc Trung Quoác—China—See Chi                      yeân tónh thì goïi laø chæ; khi taâm thaáy roõ caùi gì ñoù thì Na.                                                           goïi laø quaùn—Ceasing and reflecting—A

meditational technique to calm the mind to a state                translation of the Sanskrit terms “Samatha” of tranquility and concentration. When the                        and “Vipasyana.” The former refers to physical organism is at rest it is called samadhi;                stabilizing meditation designed to develop the when the mind is seeing clearly it is called                      ability to maintain focus on one’s meditative contemplation.                                                    object, and the latter refers to analytical 1) Khi cô theå ngöøng nghæ laø “Chæ”. Khi taâm ñang               meditation in which one directly perceives the nhìn thaáy moät caùch roõ raøng laø “Quaùn”. Ñaây laø         emptiness (sunyata) of the object, and by cöûa thöù ba trong "Luïc Dieäu Phaùp Moân" Trong              extension all phenomena. This practice is giai ñoaïn naøy haønh giaû phaûi hoaøn toaøn queân ñi         particularly important in the T’ien-T’ai hôi thôû vaø ñình chæ taâm mình treân ñaàu muõi.              school, which was systematized by Chih-I, Baáy giôø haønh giaû caûm thaáy thanh thaûn vaø oån           who wrote one of the most influential ñònh toät ñoä, roài chaúng bao laâu sau ñoù caû thaân         meditation manuals of Chinese Buddhism, the vaø taâm cuûa haønh giaû hình nhö tan bieán vaøo hö           Great Calming and Insight (Ma Ha Chæ Quaùn), voâ. Ñoù laø traïng thaùi "Thieàn Ñònh", moät traïng          in which he outlined a path of practice that thaùi ñình chæ hoaøn toaøn. Khi ñaït ñöôïc traïng             begins with cultivation of morality and leads thaùi naøy, haønh giaû phaûi töï nhaéc mình raèng,            to perceiving all phenomena directly as empty maëc daàu kinh nghieäm "Thieàn Ñònh" laø tuyeät               of inherent existence. dieäu, nhö ñöùc Phaät ñaõ caûnh baùo, nhöng mình         3) Thomas Cleary vieát trong quyeån 'Döøng Laïi khoâng ñöôïc chaáp tröôùc hay laàn löõa trong ñoù —           Vaø Thaáy': "'Chæ' vaø 'Quaùn' hay 'Döøng laïi' vaø When the physical organism is at rest it is                   'Thaáy' laø hai maët aâm vaø döông cuûa Thieàn ñònh called “Stop” or “Halt.” When the mind is                     Phaät giaùo, hai nöûa boå sung nhau cuûa moät toång seeing clearly it is called “Contemplation.”                  theå hôïp nhaát. YÙ nghóa caên baûn cuûa 'Chæ' vaø This is the third door in the "Six Wondrous                   'Quaùn', ñoâi khi ñöôïc dieãn taû moät caùch uy nghi Entrances to Enlightenment". In this stage the                laø 'ñình chæ' vaø 'quaùn töôûng', laø 'döøng meâ hoaëc' practitioner should completely ignore the                     vaø 'thaáy chaân lyù.' Taát caû nhöõng Thieàn ñònh breath and stop his mind on the tip of the                    Phaät giaùo, taát caû nhöõng nguyeân taéc tu taäp Phaät nose. He will now feel extremely tranquil and                 giaùo ñeàu coù theå ñöôïc phaân loaïi vaø toå chöùc lieân steady, and soon both his body and mind will                  heä tôùi caùc töø ngöõ 'chæ', 'quaùn' vaø söï hôïp nhaát seem to have vanished into nothingness. This                  giöõa chæ vaø quaùn."—Thomas Cleary wrote in is the stage of "Dhyana", a stage of perfect                  'Stopping and Seeing': "'Stopping' and 'seeing' cessation. When it has been reached, the                      are the yin and yang of Buddhist meditation, practitioner should remind himself that,                      complementary twin halves of a unified although the experience of "Dhyana" is                        whole. The fundamental meaning of 'stopping wonderful, he should not, as Buddha has                       and seeing,' sometimes more solemnly called admonished, cling to it or linger in it.                      cessation and contemplation, is stopping 2) “Chæ” gaùn cho thieàn oån ñònh nhaèm phaùt trieån              delussion and seeing truth. All Buddhist khaû naêng duy trì taäp trung vaøo moät ñoái töôïng,          meditations, and indeed all Buddhist coøn “Quaùn” gaùn cho Thieàn phaân tích trong ñoù             principles and practice, can be categorized haønh giaû tröïc nhaän taùnh khoâng cuûa ñoái töôïng,         and organized in terms of stopping, seeing, vaø baèng caùch môû roäng söï tröïc nhaän naøy ñeán           and the integration of stopping and seeing." moïi hieän töôïng. Söï tu taäp naøy ñaëc bieät quan      Chæ Quaùn Baát Nhò: Samatha and contemplation troïng trong toâng Thieân Thai, ñöôïc Trí Giaû heä       are not two—Chæ coù nghóa laø ñình chæ, quaùn laø thoáng hoùa, chính oâng ñaõ vieát nhöõng saùch chæ       quaùn ñaït. Khi taâm yeân tónh thì goïi laø chæ; trong khi nam coù aûnh höôûng trong Phaät Giaùo Trung              taâm thaáy roõ caùi gì ñoù thì goïi laø quaùn. Nhö vaäy chæ Hoa, nhö boä Ma Ha Chæ Quaùn, trong ñoù oâng             quaùn khoâng hai, vì chuùng cuøng laøm vieäc vôùi nhau vaïch ra con ñöôøng tu taäp baét ñaàu baèng tu giôùi     vôùi muïc ñích laø ñình chæ voïng nieäm ñeå quaùn ñaït vaø daãn ñeán tröïc nhaän taùnh khoâng trong söï hieän   chaân lyù—Quieting and reflecting are not two höõu cuûa moïi hieän töôïng—A Chinese                    (ceasing and reflecting are not two). Quiet means

tranquility and absence of passion. In other words,              töôûng vì khoâng coù ngöôøi suy töôûng. Thay vaøo ñoù, samatha is a meditational technique to calm the                  haønh giaû tu Thieàn chính laø nhöõng yù töôûng lôûn vôûn mind to a state of tranquility and concentration.                aáy. Khoâng coù tieáng chim hoùt vì khoâng coù khaùi When the physical organism is at rest it is called               nieäm chim hoùt. Thay vaøo ñoù, haønh giaû laø nhöõng samadhi; while when the mind is seeing clearly it                aâm thanh ñoù. Cuõng vaäy, haønh giaû tu Thieàn laø is called contemplation. Thus, Samatha and                       nhöõng gioït möa, tieáng saám vaø tia chôùp. Chæ caàn contemplation are not two, because they work                     ngoài xuoáng laø caû vuõ truï lieàn hieån baøy ra tröôùc together to cease deluded thoughts and to attain                 maét—Meditation without any object, without the truth.                                                       counting; nor focusing on breathing, nor koans. A Chæ Quaùn Ñaû Toïa: Shikan-taza (jap)— 'Nothing                  form of the practice of zazen in which there are no but precisely sitting'—Chæ quaùn ñaû toïa laø loaïi              more supportive techniques. According to Dogen thieàn khoâng coù ñoái töôïng, khoâng ñeám, khoâng taäp          Zenji, 'nothing but precisely sitting', i.e., resting in trung vaøo hôi thôû, cuõng khoâng coù coâng aùn thoaïi           a state of brightly alert attention that is free of ñaàu. Hình thöùc thieàn boû qua moïi ñieåm töïa beân             thoughts, directed to no object, and attached to no ngoaøi khi thieàn ñònh. Theo thieàn sö Ñaïo Nguyeân,             particular content is the highest or purest form of chæ quaùn ñaû toïa, traïng thaùi chuù yù beàn vöõng, linh        zazen, zazen as it was practiced by all the hoaït vaø thoaùt khoûi moïi yù nghó, khoâng coá ñònh vaøo        Buddhas of the past. According to Senior Zen moät ñoái töôïng naøo, cuõng khoâng baùm laáy moät noäi          master Philip Kapleau in the Three Pilars of Zen, dung naøo, laø hình thöùc thuaàn khieát nhaát vaø cao            Zen master Hakuun Ryoko Yasutani, one of the nhaát cuûa toïa thieàn tónh taâm; ñoù laø caùch toïa thieàn      most outstanding Zen masters in our modern time, tónh taâm ñöôïc taát caû chö Phaät trong quaù khöù thöïc         says in his Introductory Lectures on Zen Training, haønh. Trong Ba Truï Thieàn cuûa laõo sö Philip                  "Shikantaza is the mind of some body facing Kapleau, thieàn sö Baïch Vaân An Coác, moät trong                death. Let us imagine that you are engaged in a nhöõng thieàn sö noåi tieáng trong thôøi caän ñaïi, vieát        duel of swordsmanship of the kind that used to trong 'Nhöõng Lôøi Khuyeân Nhaäp Moân veà Thöïc                  take place in ancient Japan. As you face your Haønh Thieàn' raèng: "Chæ Quaùn Ñaû Toïa laø moät traïng         opponent you are unceasingly watchful, set, thaùi thöùc tænh vaø taäp trung, coù theå so saùnh vôùi traïng   ready. Were you to relax your vigilance even thaùi moät ngöôøi ñuïng phaûi caùi cheát. Haõy töôûng            momentarily, you would be cut down instantly. A töôïng raèng baïn ñaõ tham gia moät traän ñaáu kieám,            crowd gathers to see you fight. Since you are not gioáng nhö nhöõng ngöôøi luyeän taäp ôû nöôùc Nhaät              blind you see them from the corner of your eye, ngaøy xöa. Neáu söï tænh taùo cuûa baïn yeáu ñi, duø chæ         and since you are not deaf you hear them. But not laø moät giaây, baïn coù theå cheát. Ñaùm ñoâng taäp trung       for an instant is your mind captured by these laïi ñeå xem traän ñaáu. Vì khoâng phaûi laø muø, baïn           impressions." In short, 'nothing but precisely nhìn thaáy khaùn giaû baèng khoùe maét, nhöng khoâng             sitting' means intense sitting, where there is moät khoaûnh khaéc naøo tinh thaàn cuûa baïn ñöôïc pheù p        unshakeable conviction that sitting meditation xao laõng vì nhöõng aán töôïng caûm giaùc aáy." Toùm laïi,       (zazen) is the actualization, and there is nothing chæ quaùn ñaû toïa laø chæ ngoài vaø ngoài chöù khoâng coù       else to gain. At the root, this frame of thought gì ñeå ñaït ñöôïc. Taän goác reã cuûa thieàn, khung tö           clearly realizes that there is not a struggle töôûng veà chæ quaùn ñaû toïa nhaän thöùc roõ raøng raèng        involved in the attainment of satori. In short, khoâng coù söï coá gaéng naøo quan heä ñeán chöùng ñaéc          shikan-taza is a form of Zen that emphasizes on ñaïi ngoä. Noùi toùm laïi, chæ quaùn ñaû toïa laø hình thöùc     quieting and reflecting in sitting meditation toïa thieàn maø khoâng quaùn thoaïi ñaàu. Ñaây laø loaïi         without using a koan. This is the form of Zen most thieàn ñöôïc nhaán maïnh nhieàu nhaát trong phaùi Taøo           emphasized in the Soto school in Japan. Zen Ñoäng ôû Nhaät Baûn. Haønh giaû tu Thieàn neân luoân nhôù        practitioners should always remember that "Just raèng coù leõ "Chæ quaùn ñaû toïa" laø coâng phu khoù khaên      sitting" is perhaps the most difficult thing to do in nhaát trong tu taäp Thieàn ñònh. Haønh giaû nhaát ñònh           cultivation (Zen practice). For in order to just sit, phaûi queân chính mình thì môùi coù theå "Chæ quaùn ñaû          Zen practitioners have to forget te self. In "Just- toïa" ñöôïc. Trong "Chæ quaùn ñaû toïa," khoâng coù yù           sitting," there are no thoughts because there is no

thinker. Instead, Zen practitioners are the thoughts         qua chuû tröông hieän thöïc, chaáp nhaän thöïc theå that come up. There are no bird songs because                cuûa thöïc taïi khaùch quan, nhaän thaáy taùnh there are no concepts of bird songs. Instead, Zen            khoâng cuûa vaïn phaùp, vaø söï thieáu vaéng moät practitioners are those sounds. In the same way              chuû teå. Nhö Trí Khaûi noùi: "Taát caû caùc phaùp töø Zen practitioners are the rain-drops, are the                nhaân duyeân sinh. Söï vaät töø duyeân khôûi laø thunder and the lightning. In sitting, the whole             khoâng vaø khoâng coù chuû teå... Vì haønh giaû bieát universe is revealed and manifested.                         do duyeân khôûi, hoäi tuï giaû taïm, aûo hoùa, vaø taùnh Chæ Quaùn Ñaïi YÙ: General idea of Samatha and               khoâng cuûa vaïn phaùp, ñaây goïi laø theå. Nhöõng aûo contemplation—Immediate and whole dhyana—                    töôûng thuoäc khaùi nieäm ñeán choã taän cuøng khi Töùc thì vaø toaøn dieän, nghóa laø tröôùc vaø sau khoâng    chöùng ngoä taùnh khoâng, neân Khoâng laø taùnh cuûa khaùc, truï tö töôûng vaøo choã khoâng coù gì töï hieän      chaân lyù. Vì vaäy maø goïi laø 'theå chaân chæ'."— höõu, maø hieän höõu do nhaân töø tröôùc—Immediate           This cessation is the step of advancing beyond and whole, such as dwelling on the thought that              "naive realism," wherein one accepts the nothing exists of itself, but from a preceding               substantial existence of objective reality, to cause—See Ma Ha Chæ Quaùn.                                   realizing the emptiness of all things and the Chæ Quaùn Hoøa Thöôïng: Ñaïo hieäu cuûa Sö Ñaïo              lack of any substantive Being. As Chih-I says: Thuùy ñôøi Ñöôøng—A name for the T’ang monk                  "All dharma arise through conditions. Things Tao-Sui.                                                     which arise through conditions co-arising are Chæ Quaùn Huyeàn Vaên: See Ma Ha Chæ Quaùn.                  empty and without self-Being... Since one Chæ Quaùn Luaän: See Ma Ha Chæ Quaùn.                        knows           the     conditioned        co-arising, Chæ Quaùn Nghieäp: Moân hoïc Chæ Quaùn—Studies               conventional             confluence,            illusory of Samatha and contemplation.                                transformation,      and empty  nature   of  all things, Chæ Quaùn Tam Chuûng: Three types of                         this is called their essence. Conceptualized contemplation and samatha—Theo toâng Thieân                  delusions come to an end upon realizing Thai, tam quaùn thöïc söï chæ cho caû hai "tam chæ" vaø      emptiness; therefore emptiness is the nature "tam quaùn". Söï phaùt trieån khaùi nieäm naøy cuûa          of true reality. Therefore this is called Thieân Thai Trí Khaûi Ñaïi Sö ñöôïc trình baøy moät          'cessation as insight into the essence of true caùch yeáu löôïc trong phaåm ñaàu noùi veà yù nghóa cuûa     reality'." chæ vaø quaùn trong taùc phaåm Ma Ha Chæ Quaùn.           2) Phöông Tieän Tuøy Duyeân Chæ: Cessation as Trong ñoù Trí Khaûi luaän veà ba loaïi chæ: theå chaân       insight    into Expedient Conditions—Ñieàu naøy chæ, phöông tieän tuøy duyeân chæ, vaø töùc nhò bieân        chæ  cho    tö töôûng quaùn chieáu thöïc taïi laø söï giaû phaân bieät chæ—According to the T’ien-T’ai sect,            höõu cuûa vaïn phaùp ñeán töø nhaân duyeân. Trí threefold contemplation actually refers to both              Khaûi goïi ñoù laø "khoâng phi khoâng". Taùnh threefold cessation and threefold contemplation.             khoâng cuûa vaïn höõu khoâng coù nghóa raèng T'ien-T'ai Great Master Chih-I's mature                      chaúng coù gì caû. Söï coù maët giaû taïm cuûa vaïn development of this concept is succinctly                    phaùp nhö nhöõng thöïc taïi töông nhaäp laø chaân presented in an early section of the Mo Ho Chih              thöïc. Trí Khaûi noùi: "Nhò thöøa chæ nhaän laáy Kuan where he discusses the meaning of chih-                 Khoâng nhö theå taùnh cuûa chaân lyù , vì theá neân kuan. In that chapter Chih I discusses three kinds           khoâng thaáy caàn phaûi nhìn vaøo 'phöông tieän tuøy of skillful cessation: cessation as insight into the         duyeân chæ.' Chö Boà Taùt hieåu giaû höõu, vaø ñöa true essence of reality as empty of substantial              vaøo choã thöïc haønh. Chö vò bieát raèng khoâng Being; cessation as insight into reality as                  chaúng phaûi laø khoâng, vì vaäy maø ñöôïc goïi laø expedient conventional existence which arises                'phöông tieän'. Haønh giaû phaân bieät vaø choïn through conditions; and cessation as putting an end          thuoác trò ñöôïc beänh, vì vaäy maø ñöôïc goïi laø to both extremes of discriminatory conceptual                'tuøy duyeân'. Taâm an truï ñoái vôùi theá tuïc ñeá neân categories.                                                  goïi laø 'chæ'."—This refers to the contemplation 1) Theå Chaân Chæ: Cessation as insight into the             of an insight into reality as the conventional true essence of reality—Ñaây laø böôùc ñi vöôït         existence of all things which arise through

conditioned co-arising, which Chih-I calls "the                   simultaneously empty of substantial Being non-emptiness of emptiness". The emptiness                        and conventionally existent. As Chih-I says: of all things does not mean nothingness. Their                    "To think that samsara flows and moves and conventional existence as interdependent                          that nirvana is a constant and inactive entities is real. As Chih-I says: "Those of the                   maintenance of an awakened state is a one- two vehicles accept only emptiness as the                         sided view of practice and activity, and does essence of true reality, so they do not                           not correspond to the Middle Path. Noe, if one consider as necessary the cessation of                            knows that the mundane is not mundane, then expediency or insight into reality as                             the extreme view of the mundane is put to conventional          existence.          Bodhisattvas            rest, and if one realizes the non-mundane or understand conventional existence and should                      nature of conventional existence, then the put it into practice. They know that emptiness                    extreme view of emptiness is put to rest. This is not empty, not nothingness, therefore this is                  is called 'cessation as an end to both called      an      'expedient        means'.       One           extremes'." discriminates and chooses medicine in                        Chæ Quaùn Taâm Ñònh Nhöùt Xöù: Quaùn töôûng baèng accordance with the disease, therefore it is                 caùch ngöøng suy töôûng hay loaïi boû nhöõng loaïn ñoäng called 'in accordance with conditions'. The                  töø ñoù taâm coù theå ñònh tænh vaøo moät nôi hay moät vò mind is at rest with regard to the mundane                   trí. Coù ba caùch quaùn: Ñònh vaøo moät ñieåm coá ñònh truth, therefore it is called 'cessation'."                  nhö muõi hay ruùn; ngöøng moïi suy töôûng khi chuùng 3) Töùc Nhò Bieân Phaân Bieät Chæ: Cessation as an              môùi khôûi daäy; vaø ñònh vaøo taùnh khoâng cuûa vaïn end to both discriminatory extremes—Ñieàu                    höõu—Contemplation by stop thinking or getting naøy chæ cho tö töôûng quaùn chieáu taùnh ñoàng              rid of distraction so that the mind can be steadily nhaát cuûa caû hai "cöïc ñoan" Khoâng vaø Giaû. Söï          fixed on one place or in one position. There are phaân chia vaø chaáp tröôùc moät caùch phieán dieän          three methods of attaining such abstraction: To fix vaøo Khoâng hoaëc vaøo Giaû ñeàu sai laàm. Haønh             the mind on the nose or navel; to stop every giaû phaûi nhaän thaáy raèng caû hai thöù Khoâng vaø         thought as it just arises; and to dwell on the Giaû, neáu hieåu ñuùng, chæ cho cuøng moät thöïc taïi,       thought that nothing exists of itself, but from a vaø thöïc taïi ñoù thieáu töï taùnh vaø ñoàng thôøi coù      preceeding cause. maët moät caùch giaû taïm. Trí Khaûi noùi: "Neáu cho         Chæ Quaùn Thaäp Ñònh: Chæ Quaùn Thaäp Quaùn hay raèng luaân hoài thì noåi troâi vaø Nieát Baøn laø moät      möôøi quaùn cuûa chæ quaùn (möôøi caûnh sôû ñoái cuûa chæ vò theá thöôøng tòch cuûa giaùc ngoä, thì ñaây laø caùi      quaùn) cuûa toâng phaùi Thieân Thai: AÁm Giôùi Nhaäp thaáy phieán dieän cuûa vieäc tu haønh, khoâng thuaän        bao goàm nguõ aám, thaäp baùt giôùi vaø thaäp nhò nhaäp; hôïp vôùi Trung Ñaïo. Chính vaøo luùc naøy, neáu             Duïc Voïng vaø Phieàn Naõo; Beänh Hoaïn; Nghieäp haønh giaû thaáy ñöôïc raèng theá tuïc khoâng haún laø       Chöôùng; Ma Söï; Thieàn Ñònh; Taø Kieán; Taêng theá tuïc, thì caùi thaáy cöïu ñoan veà theá tuïc seõ        Thöôïng Maïn; Nhò Thöøa; vaø Boà Taùt—The T’ien- chaám döùt; neáu haønh giaû thaáy ñöôïc raèng phi            T’ai’s ten fields of meditation or concentration: theá tuïc hay taùnh laø giaû höõu, thì caùi thaáy veà cöïc   Aggregates (Spheres or Entrances) which include ñoan veà Khoâng seõ chaám döùt. Ñaây goïi laø 'töùc          the five Aggregates, eighteen Spheres (Astadasa- nhò bieân phaân bieät chæ'."—This refers to the              dhatavah (skt), and the twelve entrances contemplation of an insight into the                         (Dvadasayatanani (skt); Passion and delusion; synonymous nature of both "extremes" of                      Sickness; Karma Forms; Mara-deeds; Dhyana; emptiness and conventional existence. A                      Wrong theories; Arrogance; the two vehicles; and discriminatory and one-sided attachment to                   Bodhisattvahood. either concept of emptiness or conventional                  Chæ Quaùn Thaäp Quaùn: See Chæ Quaùn Thaäp Ñònh. existence is mistaken. One must realize that                 Chæ Quaùn Toâng: Moät teân khaùc cuûa Toâng Thieân both       "emptiness"        and       "conventional        Thai vì toâng naày laáy chæ quaùn haønh laøm goác, muïc existence," if correctly understood, refer to                ñích chính laø ñònh taâm baèng nhöõng phöông phaùp the same thing, and that reality is                          ñaëc bieät ñeå thaáu trieät chaân lyù vaø loaïi tröø phieàn

naõo—Another name for the T’ien-T’ai Sect                  Self-control in keeping the commandments or because its chief object being concentration of the        prohibitions relating to deeds and words—Ceasing mind by special methods for the purpose of clear           to do wrong. insight into truth, and to be rid of illusion.             Chæ Trì AÙc Phaïm: Ceasing to do evils. Chæ Quaùn Xaû:                                             Chæ Trì Giôùi: Stopping offences by keeping 1) Chæ quaùn ñeàu xaû ñeå chæ truï nôi phaùp giôùi bình    commandments—See Chæ Trì. ñaúng—Indifference to or abandonment to               Chæ Trì Moân: See Chæ Trì. both “stop” and “contemplation”, such as to           Chæ Trì Taùc Phaïm: Ñoái vôùi caùc aùc phaùp (saùt, ñaïo, rise above both into the universal.                   daâm, voïng) thì ñình chæ. Töï thaân traùnh laøm caùc 2) Chæ-Quaùn-Xaû laø ba pheùp tu thieàn ñònh trong         vieäc aùc vaø giuùp tha nhaân traùnh laøm caùc vieäc aùc— Phaät giaùo: Three methods of Buddhist                Stopping offences, ceasing to do evil, preventing cultivation or practice.                              others from doing wrong. a) Chæ: Samatha or samadhi (skt)—See Chæ (2)               Chæ Trì Taùc Trì: Cease to do wrong and do what (3) (4).                                              is right—Chæ trì baèng caùch giöõ giôùi (chaám döùt laøm b) Quaùn: Vipasyana (skt)—See Quaùn.                       vieäc sai traùi). Taùc trì hay laøm vieäc gì ñuùng ñaén c) Xaû: Upeksa (skt)—See Xaû.                              baèng caùch leã baùi hay soáng ñôøi phaïm haïnh—Cease Chæ Quaûn Ñaû Toïa: Chæ moät möïc ngoài thieàn—            to do wrong by keeping the precepts. Do what is Stubbornly stick to sitting meditation—See Maëc            right by worshipping or living in accordance with Chieáu Thieàn.                                             the monastic life. Chæ Quy: The purport, aim, or objective—See                Chæ Töùc: Chih shi (chi)—Stopping the breath— Toân Chæ.                                                  Moät trong nhöõng ñaëc tính caên baûn cuûa "Ñònh" laø Chæ Quy Tònh Ñoä: The way back to the Pure                 "Chæ töùc". Khoâng coù söï hoaøn toaøn ñình chæ cuûa hôi Land.                                                      thôû, doøng chaûy cuûa tö töôûng seõ chaúng bao giôø Chæ Thaúng Taâm Ngöôøi: See Tröïc Chæ Nhaân Taâm.          ngöøng söï chuyeån ñoäng baát tuyeät cuûa noù. Moät soá Chæ Thò Caù Chi Töï: Chaúng qua laø gioáng nhö chöõ        thuaät ngöõ ñöôïc duøng cho "Ñònh", moät trong nhöõng chi. Thieàn sö Ñoäng Sôn Löông Giôùi thò chuùng raèng      thuaät ngöõ naøy laø "Chæ Töùc", chæ ra moät caùch khoâng moät ñaïi taïng giaùo chaúng qua laø gioáng nhö chöõ chi   sai laïc raèng "Ñònh" laø moät traïng thaùi lieân heä vôùi maø thoâi—It is only similar to a zigzag word. Zen         ñieàu kieän naøy. Nguyeân nhaân cuûa hieän töôïng thoâng master        Tung-Shan-Lieng-Chieh           preached:    thöôøng vaø töï nhieân cuûa "Ñònh" ñöôïc giaûi thích moät "Teachings in the tripitaka are similar to a zigzag        caùch minh baïch bôûi Maät Toâng trong lyù thuyeát veà word"                                                      "Nguyeân Taéc Taâm Khí Baát Nhò", theo ñoù moãi tö Chæ Thieân: To point to heaven.                            töôûng caù nhaân trôû neân bôûi moät söï chuyeån ñoäng ñaëc Chæ Thoá: See Chæ Nguyeät.                                 bieät cuûa hôi thôû. Neáu hôi thôû ñöôïc traán tónh hay Chæ Tieàn: Tieàn giaáy, ñoát ñeå cuùng ngöôøi cheát theo   ngöng nghæ, thì taâm laïi cuõng nhö vaäy, vaø ngöôïc laïi . taäp tuïc cuûa moät soá daân toäc ôû AÙ Chaâu—Paper        Tuy nhieân, ñoái vôùi haønh giaû tu Thieàn ôû nhöõng trình money, burnt as offerings to the dead, as custom           ñoä trung bình, nhaát laø nhöõng ngöôøi taïi gia, "Chæ of some peoples in Aisa.                                   Töùc" ôû ñaây coù nghóa laø thôû ñeàu vaø meàm maïi, Chæ Tieát: Anguli-parvan (skt)—1) Ñôn vò ño löôøng         nhöng luoân taäp trung vaøo taâm hay laø ngöng thôû töông ñöông vôùi 1/24 caùnh tay: Hasta (skt)—A             moät chuùt baèng caùch töï kieåm soaùt ñeå mang taâm veà measure, the 24th part of a forearm; 2) Loùng tay:         tónh laëng—One of the basic characteristics of Finger-joint.                                              Samadhi is the stoppage of breath. Without a Chæ Tænh: Thôøi gian yeân laëng hoaëc toïa thieàn—         complete cessation of breathing, the progressive Time of tranquility or time of sitting meditation.         thought-flow will never cease its perpetual Chæ Tònh: Dvangulakappa (p)—Tranquility and                motion. A number of different terms have been purity.                                                    used to designate Samadhi, one of them being Chæ Trì: Prohibiting from evil—Restrain from               "stopping the breath" (Chih shi), which evil—Töï kieåm baèng caùch giöõ giôùi hay ngöøng laøm      unmistakably points to the fact that Samadhi is a nhöõng vieäc taø vaïy hay traùnh laøm nhöõng vieäc aùc—    state related to this condition. The reason for this

common and very natural phenomenon of                         theå nghieäm cuûa Thieàn ñeå kieán laäp traät töï môùi cho Samadhi is clearly expounded by Tantrism in its               söï vaät thì ñaây laø moät söï laät ñoå caàn thieát. Vì vaäy, theory of the "Principle of the Identicalness of              vieäc Thieàn sö Baïch AÅn ñoøi hoûi ôû haøng ñeä töû hình Mind and Breathing (prana)," according to which               nhö khoâng ñöôïc töï nhieân, maø cuõng khoâng hôïp lyù. every individual thought is brought into play by a            Haønh giaû tu Thieàn neân luoân nhôù raèng "tieáng voã particular "Breathing-in-action." If the breathing is         cuûa moät baøn tay" thuoäc veà aâm thanh, laø caùi gì ñoù pacified or halted, so is the mind, and vice versa.           coù lieân quan ñeán thính giaùc. Khi Thieàn sö Baïch AÅn However, for Zen practitioners of average levels,             ñöa moät baøn tay leân, ngaøi coù muoán caùc ñeä töû cuûa especially laypeople, "Chih shi" here means to                ngaøi voã moät baøn tay hay khoâng? Chaéc chaén laø stay breathing steadily and softly, but focus on the          khoâng. Ngaøi chæ muoán duøng muïc ñích toái haäu cuûa concentration of the mind (or stop breathing for a            coâng aùn naøy ñeå khai môû ngoâi nhaø bí maät cuûa taâm short while by self-control to bring the mind to              maø thoâi, ñeå töø ñoù nhöõng ai tinh chuyeân haønh trì coù rest).                                                        theå nhìn thaáy beân trong laø caû moät kho baùu voâ taän. Chæ Töùc Thaéng Xöù: Place of victory in gaining              Thính giaùc khoâng coù lieân quan vôùi yù nghóa voán coù tranquility.                                                  cuûa coâng aùn nhö moät vò Thieàn sö noùi: "coâng aùn chæ Chæ Töôûng Ñònh: Jada-samadhi (skt)—Thieàn ñònh               laø phöông tieän maø khi ñaït ñöôïc muïc ñích thì lieàn ngöng moïi tö duy—Thought suspended mediation.                phaûi vöùt boû," laø "ngoùn tay chæ traêng." Coâng aùn chæ Chæ Xuyeán: Nhaãn tay, ñoâi khi ñöôïc laøm baèng coû,         caàn toång hôïp hay sieâu vieät baát cöù thöù gì maø baïn Maät giaùo hay duøng trong nghi leã—Finger-ring;              choïn, nhò nguyeân luaän thuoäc tính caûm quan. Chöøng sometime made of grass used in ceremonies by                  naøo maø taâm mình chöa ñöôïc töï do ñeå nhaän bieát aâm the esoteric sect.                                            thanh cuûa moät baøn tay, chöøng ñoù taâm thöùc coøn bò Chæ Y: Quaàn aùo baèng giaáy, ñoát cuùng ngöôøi cheát —       giôùi haïn vaø chia caét chính noù. Luùc ñoù thay vì naém Paper clothes, burnt as offerings to the dead.                baét ñöôïc chieác chìa khoùa cuûa nhöõng bí aån cuûa söï Chích: 1) Caùi: A, an (caùi baøn: a table); 2) Chaâm          saùng taïo, thì taâm thöùc laïi bò choân vuøi moät caùch voâ chích: To sting.                                              voïng trong tính töông ñoái cuûa söï vaät, vaø, chính vì Chích Gia Hoäi: Moät buoåi leã cuûa Thieàn Toâng veà          vaäy maø noù chæ naèm treân beà maët cuûa söï vaät maø thoâi. muøa ñoâng, trong leã naày ngöôøi ta aên reã sen              Cho ñeán khi naøo taâm thöùc thoaùt ra khoûi nhöõng troùi nöôùng—A Zen School winter festival at which                  buoäc thì ñoù laø luùc noù môùi coù theå quaùn chieáu toaøn roasted lily roots were eaten.                                boä vuõ truï moät caùch thoûa thích. AÂm thanh cuûa moät Chích Lyù Taây Qui: Truyeàn thuyeát Sô Toå Boà Ñeà            baøn tay thaät söï ñi ñeán nhöõng taàng trôøi cao nhaát Ñaït Ma quaûy chieác giaøy veà Taây Thieân—The                cuõng nhö nôi taän cuøng ñòa nguïc, ngay caû baøn lai legendary of Bodhidharma's carrying of one shoe               dieän muïc cuûa moät ai ñoù cuõng nhìn khaép tam thieân back to India—See Boà Ñeà Ñaït Ma.                            theá giôùi thaäm chí ñeán thôøi ñieåm taän cuøng cuûa thôøi Chích Thuû: The clap of just one hand—Tieáng Voã              gian. Theo Thieàn sö Linh Moäc Tuaán Long trong Cuûa Moät Baøn Tay—Baïch AÅn chaúng nhöõng laø moät           quyeån Thieàn Taâm, Sô Taâm, chuùng ta noùi "Nghe thieàn sö xuaát chuùng, maø oâng coøn laø moät nhaø hoïa só   thaáy tieáng voã cuûa moät baøn tay." Thöôøng thì phaûi ñaïi taøi, moät ngöôøi vieát chöõ Haùn nhö roàng bay          hai baøn tay môùi voã neân tieáng, vaø chuùng ta nghó phöôïng muùa, vaø moät nhaø ñieâu khaéc. Sekishu hay          raèng chæ voã moät baøn tay khoâng theå phaùt ra aâm “tieáng voã cuûa moät baøn tay laø caùi gì?” Ñaây laø moät    thanh. Nhöng thaät ra, moät baøn tay ñaõ laø aâm thanh. coâng aùn noåi tieáng do oâng thieát laäp. Thieàn sö Baïch    Daàu baïn khoâng nghe thaáy, aâm thanh vaãn coù. Neáu AÅn töøng ñöa leân moät baøn tay, muoán haøng ñeä töû         baïn voã hai tay, baïn coù theå nghe aâm thanh. Nhöng nghe thöû aâm thanh cuûa tieáng voã cuûa moät baøn tay        neáu aâm thanh ñaõ khoâng coù tröôùc khi baïn voã tay, naøy. Thoâng thöôøng thì phaûi coù hai baøn hai tay voã       baïn khoâng theå naøo taïo ra aâm thanh ñoù. Tröôùc khi vaøo nhau môùi vang ra aâm thanh, do ñoù, chæ moät            baïn taïo ra aâm thanh, noù ñaõ coù ñoù. Vì aâm thanh ñaõ baøn tay seõ khoâng vang ra aâm thanh ñöôïc. Tuy              coù, baïn coù theå taïo ra noù vaø nghe thaáy. AÂm thanh nhieân, Thieàn sö Baïch AÅ n muoán laät ñoå nhöõng kinh       coù khaép nôi. Neáu baïn luyeän taäp, baïn seõ coù aâm nghieäm cuûa cuoäc soáng thöôøng ngaøy voán laáy khoa         thanh. Ñöøng coá gaéng laéng nghe. Neáu baïn khoâng hoïc hay lyù luaän laøm neàn taûng. Neáu muoán laáy söï       laéng nghe, aâm thanh vaãn coù khaép nôi. Vì baïn coá

nghe, ñoâi khi coù aâm thanh, ñoâi khi khoâng coù aâm           known koan by a Japanese master. Zen master thanh. Baïn hieåu chöù? Daàu baïn khoâng laøm gì heát,          Hakuin used to raise one of his hands and demand baïn vaãn coù phaåm chaát cuûa toïa thieàn. Nhöng neáu          of his disciples to hear the sound of the clap of just baïn coá tìm noù, coá thaáy ñöôïc phaåm chaát cuûa noù, baïn    this one hand. Ordinarily a sound is heard only seõ khoâng coù ñöôïc phaåm chaát. Baïn soáng trong theá         when two hands are clapped, and in that sense no giôùi naøy nhö moät caù theå, nhöng tröôùc khi mang             possible sound can come from one hand alone. hình haøi con ngöôøi, baïn ñaõ coù roài, luoân coù roài.        Zen master Hakuin wants, however, to strike at Chuùng ta luoân coù tröôùc roài. Baïn hieåu chöù? Baïn          the root of our everyday experience, which is nghó raèng tröôùc khi ra ñôøi, baïn khoâng toàn taïi.           constructed on a so-called scientific or logical Nhöng laøm sao baïn coù theå xuaát hieän trong theá giôùi       basis. This fundamental overthrowing is necessary naøy khi maø baïn khoâng coù? Chính vì baïn ñaõ coù saün,       in order to build up a new order of things on the baïn môùi coù theå xuaát hieän trong theá giôùi naøy. Theo      basis of Zen experience. Hence this apparently Thieàn sö D.T. Suzuki trong quyeån "Thieàn Hoïc                 most unnatural and therefore illogical demand by Nhaäp Moân," khi Thieàn sö Baïch AÅn ñöa moät baøn              Hakuin on his pupils. Zen practitioners should tay leân, ngaøi muoán cho chuùng ta bieát laø chuùng ta         always remember that "the clap of just this one khoâng theå naøo duøng phöông phaùp lyù luaän ñeå giaûi         hand" is about "the sound," something that appeals ñaùp ñieàu naøy ñöôïc. Ngay luùc ñoù, baïn bieát ñöôïc          to the sense of hearing. When Zen master Hakuin luoàng suy nghó cuûa baïn ñoät nhieân bò caét ñöùt. Baïn        puts out one hand, does he want his disciples clap caûm thaáy do döï, hoaøi nghi vaø böïc töùc, khoâng bieát       with just one hand? Surely not. He just wants to laøm sao ñoät phaù ñöôïc böùc töôøng töôûng chöøng nhö          use the ultimate purport of this koan to open up khoâng theå naøo xuyeân qua ñöôïc. Khi ñaït ñeán ñænh           the secret chamber of the mind, where the ñieåm naøy, toaøn boä nhaân caùch, yù chí noäi taïi vaø baûn    devotees can find numberless treasures stored. taùnh saâu thaúm nhaát cuûa baïn nhaát ñònh phaûi bò phaù       The sense of hearing has nothing to do with the saäp heát, nieäm nieäm ñeàu khoâng nghó tôùi caùi ngaõ hay      essential meaning of the koan; as the Zen master caùi voâ ngaõ, khoâng ñaây maø cuõng khoâng kia, tieán          says, the koan is only a piece of brick used to thaúng khoâng ngöøng, phaù vôõ böùc töôøng saét cuûa coâng      knock at the gate, an index-finger pointing at the aùn. Vieäc naøy neùm toaøn toång theå cuûa baïn vaøo caùi       moon. It is only intended to synthesize or coâng aùn ñeå roài baát thaàn môû ra laõnh vöïc chöa töøng      transcend whichever expression you may choose, bieát cuûa taâm linh. Veà phöông dieän trí tueä maø noùi        the dualism of the sense. So long as the mind is thì ñaây laø söï vöôït qua giôùi haïn cuûa lyù luaän nhò        not free to perceive a sound produced by one nguyeân, nhöng ñoàng thôøi noù cuõng laø söï taùi sinh, söï     hand, it is limited and is divided against itself. tænh ngoä caûm quan noäi taïi, khieán cho chuùng ta thaáy       Instead of grasping the key to the secrets of ñöôïc dieäu duïng chaân thaät cuûa chö phaùp. Vì theá maø       creation, the mind is hopelessly buried in the laàn ñaàu tieân yù nghóa cuûa coâng aùn boãng trôû neân roõ     relativity of things, and, therefore, in their raøng, vaø cuøng moät caùch nhö vaäy, ngöôøi uoáng nöôùc        superficiality. Until the mind is free from the thì aám laïnh töï bieát. Maét vaãn thaáy, tai vaãn nghe laø     fetters, the time never comes for it to view the ñieàu chaéc chaén, nhöng vôùi troïn veïn caû caùi taâm tænh     whole world with any amount of satisfaction. The ngoä. Khoâng nghi ngôø ñaây laø moät hoaït ñoäng tri            sound of one hand as a matter of fact reaches the giaùc, nhöng laø loaïi tri giaùc ôû taàng cao nhaát. Giaù trò   highest heaven as well as the lowest hell, just as tu Thieàn chính laø ôû choã naøy, noù laøm cho chuùng ta        one's original face looks over the entire field of tin chaéc raèng ñích thöïc coù moät thöù toàn taïi vöôït haún   creation even to the end of time. According to Zen hoaït ñoäng tö duy. Vaø vôùi coâng aùn "Tieáng voã cuûa         Master Shunryu Suzuki in Zen Mind, Beginner's moät baøn tay," Baïch AÅn vaø Luïc Toå cuøng daét tay           Mind, we say, "To hear the sound of one hand nhau ñöùng treân cuøng moät dieãn ñaøn Thieàn—Not               clapping." Usually the sound of clapping is made only was Hakuin an outstanding master, he was a                 with two hands, and we think that clapping with highly accomplished painter with great talents,                 one hand makes no sound at all. But actually, one calligrapher, and sculptor. Sekishu, or “What is the            hand is sound. Even though you do not hear it, sound of one hand?” which he devised, is the best               there is sound. If you clap with two hands, you can

hear the sound. But if sound did not already exist       conviction that there is something indeed going before you clapped, you could not make the               beyond mere intellection. And with the koan of sound. Before you make it there is sound. Because        "the clap of just one hand", Hakuin and the Sixth there is sound, you can make it, and you can hear        Patriarch stand on the same platform of Zen with it. Sound is everywhere. If you just practice it,        the hands mutually joined. there is sound. Do not try to listen to it. If you do    Chích Thuû Chi Thanh: The clap of just one not listen to it, the sound is all over. because you     hand—Tieáng Voã Cuûa Moät Baøn Tay—See Chích try to hear it, sometimes there is sound, and            Thuû. sometimes there is no sound. Do you understand?          Chieác Beø: Kaula (skt)—A ferryboat—Raft—Moät Even though you do not do anything, you have the         ngöôøi ñang troán chaïy khoûi tay boïn cöôùp ñi ñeán gaëp quality of zazen always. But if you try to find it, if   phaûi moät khoaûng nöôùc bao la tröôùc maët. Ngöôøi aáy you try to see the quality, you have no quality.         bieát raèng bôø beân naøy nguy hieåm vaø bôø beân kia an You are living in this world as one individual, but      toaøn. Tuy nhieân, khoâng coù taøu thuyeàn gì ñeå ñi ñeán before you take the form of a human being, you           bôø beân kia. Neân ngöôøi aáy nhanh nheïn gom goùp are already there, always there. We are always           nhaùnh laù laøm moät chieác beø, vaø vôùi chieác beø, ngöôøi here. Do you understand? You think before you            aáy ñaõ qua bôø beân kia moät caùch an toaøn. Chaùnh were born you were not here. But how is it               Ñaïo ñöôïc daïy bôûi Ñöùc Phaät cuõng gioáng nhö chieác possible for you to appear in this world, when           beø. Noù coù coâng naêng ñöa chuùng ta töø beán bôø khoå there is no you? Because you are already there,          ñau phieàn naõo ñeán bæ ngaïn voâ öu. Trong Phaät giaùo you can appear in this world. According to Zen           Ñaïi Thöøa, giaùo phaùp gioáng nhö chieác beø; khi cöùu master D.T. Suzuki in "An Introduction To Zen            caùnh bæ ngaïn ñaõ ñeán, thì beø cuõng phaûi boû laïi sau Buddhism", when Zen master Hakuin puts out one           löng. Giaùo phaùp khoâng phaûi laø cöùu caùnh maø chæ laø hand, Zen master Hakuin wants to let us know that        phöông tieän thoâi. Theo Kinh AÅn duï Con Raén, Ñöùc we cannot use logical way to get around it. At that      Phaät daïy: “Giaùo phaùp cuûa ta nhö chieác beø ñeå vöôït time, you feel as if your march of thought had           qua chöù khoâng phaûi ñeå naém giöõ.”—A man who been suddenly cut short. You hesitate, you doubt,        was escaping from a group of bandits came to a you are troubled and agitated, not knowing how to        vast stretch of water that was in his way. He knew break through the wall which seems altogether            that this side of the shore was dangerous and the impassable. When this climax is reached, your            other side was safe. However, there was no boat whole personality, your inmost will, your deepest        going to the other shore, nor was there any bridge nature, determined to bring the situation to an          for crossing over. So he quickly gather wood, issue, throws itself with no thought of self or no-      branches and leaves to make a raft, and with the self, of this or that, directly and unreservedly         help of the raft, he crossed over safely to the other against the iron wall of the koan. This throwing         shore. The Noble Eightfold Path taught by the your entire being against the koan unexpectedly          Buddha is like the raft. It would take us from the opens up a hitherto unknown region of the mind.          suffering of this shore to the other shore of no Intellectually, this is the transcending of the limits   suffering. In Mahayana Buddhism, the teaching is of logical dualism, but at the same time it is a         likened a raft; when the goal, the other shore, is regeneration, the awakening of an inner sense            reached, then the raft is left behind. The form of which enables one to look into the actual working        teaching is not final dogma but an expedient of things. For the first time the meaning of the         method. According to the Discourse on the Water koan becomes clear, and in the same way that one         Snake’s Parable, the Buddha taught: “My teaching knows that ice is cold and freezing. The eye sees,       is like a raft for crossing over, not for carrying.” the ear hears, to be sure, but it is the mind as a       Chieác Beø Phaùp: Raft of Dharma—See Phaùp whole that has enlightenment (satori); it is an act      Phieät. of perception, no doubt, but it is a perception of       Chieâm: 1) Chieác ñeäm: Thatch, mat; 2) Chieâm the highest order. Here lies the value of the Zen        ngöôõng: To look up to, to adore, to revere; 3) Tieân discipline, as it gives birth to the unshakable

ñoaùn: Guess, to estimate; 4) Söï tieân ñoaùn hay baùo      Chieâm Phong: Hy voïng coù gioù chaân lyù Phaät phaùp tröôùc: Divine, prognosticate.                              thoåi ñeán ñeå cöùu ñoä—To hope for the wind of Chieâm Ba: Campa or Campaka (skt)—See Chieâm                Buddha truth or aid. Baëc Ca.                                                    Chieâm Saùt: Moät caùch thanh loïc thaùnh thieän trong Chieâm Ba La Quaät: Hang ñoäng nôi coù nhieàu caây          Maät giaùo baèng caùch trì maãu töï “a” trong Phaïn Chieâm Ba—A cave where grown a lot of campa-                ngöõ—A method of divination in the esoteric trees.                                                      school by means of the sanskrit letter “a.” Chieâm Ba Quoác: Campaka (skt)—Nöôùc Chieâm                 Chieâm Thuù Naõ: Tchansuna (skt)—Thuû ñoâ coå cuûa Ba ôû mieàn Trung AÁn Ñoä, beân bôø soâng Haèng (xöù coù    vöông quoác Vrji, moät vöông quoác coå naèm veà phía nhieàu caây Chieâm Ba hay Moäc Lan, neân laáy teân aáy      Baéc AÁn Ñoä vaø phía Ñoâng Nam xöù Neù-Pal—An maø ñaët cho xöù), laø moät nöôùc ôû mieàn trung AÁn Ñoä,   ancient capital of Vrji, an ancient kingdom north maø theo Eitel trong Trung Anh Phaät Hoïc Töø Ñieån,        of the Ganges and southeast of Nepal. baây giôø laø Bhagalpur hay vuøng phuï caän phía treân      Chieâm Töôùng Kieát Hung: Xem boùi töôùng noùi Punjab ñöôïc thaønh laäp bôûi daân Chieâm Ba—A              ñieàu laønh döõ cuûa ngöôøi ñeå caàu lôïi döôõng— kingdom and city od Campa in the central India,             Perform divination and fortune telling. along the riverbank of the Ganges, according to             Chieâm Y: Öôùc löôïng giaù trò sôû höõu cuûa moät vò Eitel in The Dictionary of Chinese-English                  Taêng ñaõ thò tòch vaø phaân phaùt cho nhöõng vò Taêng Buddhist Terms, the modern Bhagalpur or a place             khaùc—To estimate the value of a deceased in its vicinity, founded by Campa, a district in the        monk’s personal possessions and to distribute upper Punjab.                                               them to the other monks. Chieâm Baø La: Jambhala or Jambhira (skt)—                  Chieân Ñaø La: Candala (skt)—Tchandala (skt)— Chieâm Boä La—Teân cuûa moät loaøi caây gioáng nhö          Chuyeân ngheà laøm thòt. Giai caáp thaáp nhaát trong xaõ caây chanh (hoa vaøng vaø coù muøi thôm toûa ngaùt)—        hoäi AÁn Ñoä, döôùi caû boán giai caáp chính thöùc, goàm Name of a tree similar to the citron tree.                  nhöõng daân chaøy, toäi nhaân vaø nhöõng tay maõi voõ, Chieâm Baùi: To adore.                                      vaân vaân—A butcher or other low occupations. The Chieâm Bao: Dream.                                          lowest class in the Indian caste system, beneath Chieâm Baëc Ca: Campa or Campaka (skt)—                     even the lowest of the four formal castes. Its Chieâm Ba Ca—Chieâm Baø—Chieâm Baùc—Chieâm                  members are fishermen, jailers, slughterers, etc. Baùc Ca—Chieâm Baëc—Kim Saéc Hoa hay Moäc                   Chieân Ñaø Lî: Candala (skt)—See Chieân Ñaø La. Lan, teân cuûa moät loaïi boâng thôm maøu vaøng, höông      Chieân Ñaø Vieät Quoác Vöông Kinh: Cadrapati- thôm cuûa noù lan toûa raát xa—A yellow fragrant            sutra (skt)—Name of a sutra. flower. Its fragrance spreading very far.                   Chieân Ñaøn: Candana (skt)—Goã Chieân ñaøn Chieâm Baëc Hoa: See Chieâm Baëc Ca.                        traéng—White sandalwood. Chieâm Baëc Thuï: Campa or Campaka (skt)—                   Chieân Ñaøn Höông Bích Chi Phaät: Candana- Chieâm Ba Ca—See Chieâm Baëc Ca.                            gandha-pratyeka-buddha (skt)—Teân cuûa moät vò Chieâm Beänh: Xem beänh hay khaùm beänh—To                  Phaät trong Thai taïng maïn ñaø la—Name of a examine a sick person medically.                            Tathagata in the Garbhamandala. Chieâm Boä: Jambudvipa (skt)—See Nam Thieäm                 Chieân Ñaøn Höông Phaät: Tamalabhadra (skt)— Boä Chaâu.                                                  Ña Ma La Baït Chieân Ñaøn Höông Phaät— Chieâm Boä La: Jambhira (skt)—See Chieâm Baø La.            Chandana-fragrance Buddha. Chieâm Dieâm: Jambudvipa—See Dieâm Phuø Ñeà.                Chieân Ñaøn Laâm Thaàn: Sandalwood Forest Deity Chieâm Maït La: Camara (skt)—Teân cuûa vaøi loaïi           (Spirit). caây ôû AÁn Ñoä—Name of several plants in India.            Chieân Ñaøn Thoï Quang Thaàn: Sandlewood Tree Chieâm Nghieäm: To experiment.                              Light Deity (Spirit). Chieâm Ngöôõng: See Chieâm (2).                             Chieân Ñaøn Thuï Nhó: Loaïi naám moïc treân thaân caây chieân ñaøn—Sandalwood fungus. Chieân Ñaàu La: See Chieân Ñoå La Ñaïi Töôùng.

Chieân Ñoå La: See Chieân Ñoå La Ñaïi Töôùng.                  elder Sariputra subdued a group of Brahman Chieân Ñoå La Ñaïi Töôùng: Catura(skt)—Moät trong              heretics at the debate, another group of Brahman möôøi hai vò thaàn lieân heä vôùi ñöùc Phaät Döôïc Sö—         heretics were dissatisfied with the flourishing of One of the the twelve spirits connected with the               Budhism. They planned an evil scheme and Master of Healing Buddha.                                      assembled at Sravasti to discuss a secret plot to Chieân Nieäm Thò Hieän: Quaùn Tha Taâm—Quaùn saùt              trap the Buddha. They bought off a woman by the taâm tính cuûa chuùng sanh, khoâng coù moät söï naøo ôû        name of Cinca to act as a Buddhist follower. One ngoaøi taâm caû—Contemplation of the mind of other             early morning, while everyone was in session at beings, there is nothing outside of the mind.                  Jetavana Vihara, worshipping the Buddha, Cinca Chieân Truï La: See Chieân Ñoå La Ñaïi Töôùng.                 walked out from the inner room. People heard her Chieán: War—Hostilities—Battle.                                saying to herself: “I spent the night at the vihara.” Chieán Ñaït La: Candra (skt)—Chieán Naïi La.                   Her move aroused the suspicion of the assembly. 1) Maët Traêng: The moon.                                      Eight months later, Cinca with a bulging belly as 2) Nguyeät Thaàn: The moon deity.                              in pregnancy, again appeared at the vihara’s 3) Teân cuûa moät vò laõnh ñaïo moät phaùi ngoaïi ñaïo:        lecture hall. When the Buddha was about to Name of a heretical leader.                              deliver a talk, she suddenly stood up, pointing her Chieán Ñaït La Baùt Laït Baø: Candraprabha (skt)—              finger to her belly, she accused the Buddha, and Teân cuûa Phaät Thích Ca trong tieàn kieáp khi Ngaøi           demanded the Buddha to accommodate her and coøn laø moät vò quoác vöông, caét ñaàu boá thí—               her unborn baby. For a moment, there was an Moonlight, name of Sakyamuni when a king in a                  uproar from the assembly. People began to discuss former incarnation, who cut off his head as a gift             this incident. The Buddha made no move and to others.                                                     simply sat where he sat in a meditative position. Chieán Giaø Ma Na: Cinca-manvika (skt)—Chieán                  Just at that moment, the sound of a bang was Giaø laø ngöôøi ñaøn baø vu caùo Phaät veà baøo thai giaû      heard, and a small wooden basin fell off Cinca’s trong buïng cuûa baø ta. Theo truyeàn thuyeát Phaät            body. It was now clear that she had faked her giaùo, sau khi Xaù Lôïi Phaát ñaõ beõ gaõy bieän luaän cuûa    pregnancy, so she ran off desperately. moät nhoùm ngoaïi ñaïo Baø La Moân thì laïi coù nhoùm          Chieán Naïi La: See Chieán Ñaït La. khaùc khoâng haøi loøng khi thaáy Phaät giaùo ngaøy caøng      Chieán Thaéng Cuoái Cuøng: Final Triumph—Vaøo höng thònh. Hoï tuï taäp taïi thaønh Xaù Veä, aâm möu          ngaøy traêng troøn thaùng Naêm naêm 578 tröôùc Taây haõm haïi Phaät. Boïn hoï mua chuoäc moät ngöôøi ñaøn          lòch, Thaùi töû Taát Ñaït Ña thaønh ñaït Giaùc Ngoä Toái baø teân laø Chieán Giaø, giaû boä laøm moät tín ñoà Phaät     Thöôïng (Chaùnh Ñaúng Chaùnh Giaùc) baèng caùch giaùo. Moät buoåi saùng sôùm, trong khi moïi ngöôøi            hoaøn toaøn thaáu trieät Boán Chaân Lyù Cao Thöôïng (Töù ñang leã Phaät ôû tònh xaù Kyø Vieân thì Chieán Giaø töø       Dieäu Ñeá) vaø trôû thaønh Phaät. Ñaây laø chieán thaéng vó beân trong böôùc ra töï noùi: “Toái hoâm qua, toâi nguû laïi   ñaïi khoâng lay chuyeån, chieán thaéng cuoái cuøng —On tònh xaù.” Haønh ñoäng ñoù laøm khôi daäy loøng nghi           a full moon day of May in 578 B.C., Prince ngôø cuûa töù chuùng. Taùm thaùng sau, Chieán Giaø laïi        Siddhartha attained Supreme Enlightenment by xuaát hieän ôû giöõa tònh xaù, buïng noåi to leân nhö ñang     completely comprehending the Four Noble Truths mang baàu. Khi Ñöùc Phaät ñang thuyeát phaùp, Chieán           and became the Buddha. This is the greatest Giaø boãng nhieân ñöùng daäy, chæ vaøo buïng oaùn traùch       unshakable victory, the final victory. Phaät, yeâu caàu phaûi saép xeáp oån thoûa cho baø ta vaø      Chieán Thaéng Laâm: Röøng chieán thaéng: The grove ñöùa con trong buïng. Trong phuùt choác, loøng ngöôøi          of victory—Röøng Kyø Thoï Caáp Coâ Ñoäc: Jetavana roái loaïn, baøn taùn xoân xao. Ñöùc Phaät vaãn tónh toïa,     or Jetrvana. khoâng nhuùt nhít. Ñuùng luùc ñoù, boãng nghe “caïch”          Chieán Tranh: War—Ngöôøi Phaät töû neân luoân vaâng moät tieáng, moät caùi chaäu baèng goã côû nhoû töø treân      theo lôøi Phaät daïy, nhaát laø giôùi thöù nhaát laø “caám saùt mình coâ gaùi rôi xuoáng, thì ra, taát caû ñeàu laø nguïy      sanh.” Trong hôn 2.500 naêm lòch söû Phaät giaùo, coù taïo. Coâ gaùi chæ coøn caùch cuùp ñi nôi khaùc—The            vaøi cuoäc chieán tranh giöõa caùc nhaø sö hay giöõa caùc woman who falsely accused the Buddha about her                 nhaø sö vaø nhaø ñöông cuoäc. Tuy nhieân, söï xaâm laêng pregnancy. According to Buddhist legends, after                nhaân danh toân giaùo chöa töøng ñöôïc bieát ñeán trong

Phaät giaùo (moät quoác gia ñi xaâm laêng quoác gia khaùc    ñoåi thöông maõi ñaùng keå vôùi xöù Tích Lan— ñeå truyeàn baù moät toân giaùo chöa töøng xaûy ra trong     According to Eitel in The Dictionary of Chinese- caùc quoác gia theo Phaät giaùo). Trong quaù khöù, lyù do    English Buddhist Terms, Caritra was a port on the maø caùc vò sö chieán tranh vôùi nhau hay chieán tranh       south-east frontier of Uda (Orissa) whence a vôùi chính quyeàn chuû yeáu vì tieàn baïc vaø quyeàn löïc    considerable trade was carried on with Ceylon. chöù khoâng phaûi ñeå truyeàn baù Phaät giaùo. Cuõng cuøng   Chieát Lö: Ñaùm saäy bò chaët gaãy maø ngöôøi ta noùi nhöõng lyù do aáy vôùi nhöõng cuoäc chieán tranh giöõa       Toå Boà Ñeà Ñaït Ma ñaõ duøng ñeå vöôït soâng Döông caùc nhaø sö vaø chính quyeàn taïi Nhaät. Taïi Tích Lan,     Töû töø Nam Kinh—The snapped-off reed on which döôùi trieàu vua Dutthagamani ñaõ ñaùnh laïi trieàu ñaïi     Bodhidharma is said to have crossed the Yangtsze Damilas cuûa Tamils vì hoï laø nhöõng keû xaâm laêng         from Nanking. Tích Lan thôøi ñoù, chöù vua Dutthagamani chöa bao           Chieát Ma Ñaø Na: Calmadana (skt)—Nieát Maït— giôø chuû tröông chieán tranh xaâm chieám luïc ñòa AÁn       Theo Eitel trong Trung Anh Phaät Hoïc Töø Ñieån, Ñoä ñeå truyeàn baù Phaät giaùo. Ñöùc Phaät daïy chuùng ta   Chieát Ma Ñaø Na laø teân cuûa moät vöông quoác coå khoâng saùt sanh, chöù Ñöùc Phaät chöa töøng baûo chuùng     naèm veà phía ñoâng nam sa maïc Gobi—According ta ñöøng ñaùnh laïi keû thuø ñeå baûo veä toå quoác —        to Eitel in The Dictionary of Chinese-English Buddhists should always follow the teachings of              Buddhist Terms, Calmadana is an ancient the Buddha, especially the first precept of                  kingdom and city at the south-east borders of the “prohibiting killing.” In more than 2,500 years of           desert of Gobi. Buddhist history, there were some cases of                   Chieát Phuïc Nhieáp Thoï: Khuaát phuïc keû aùc, thaâu fighting between monks, or fighting with civil               nhieáp ngöôøi thieän (hai cöûa chính cuûa ñaïo Phaät. authorities in Tibet and Japan However, invasion             Khuaát phuïc laø cöûa Trí Hueä, coøn thaâu nhieáp laø cöûa in the name of religion is unknown in Buddhism               Töø Bi)—To subdue the evil and receive the good. (one country invades other countries to spread a             Chieát Saøng Hoäi: OÂng Hoäi Giöôøng Gaõy—Thieàn religion never happens in any Buddhist countries).           Taêng Nhö Hoäi vaøo thôøi nhaø Ñöôøng, ngöôøi ñöôïc In the past, reasons for monks in Tibet fought with          coâng chuùng ngöôõng moä, neân ñeán ñoâng trong Taêng other monks and with civil authorities were mainly           ñöôøng ñeán noãi laàn naøo cuõng nhö laàn naáy thieàn concerned with money and power, not with the                 saøng cuõng ñeàu bò gaõy, neân thôøi aáy goïi oâng laø Chieát propagation of Buddhism. The same reasons for                Saøng Hoäi—Zen monk Ru Hui in the T'ang the fighting among monks and civil authorities in            Dynasty, who was admired by the public. They Japan. In Sri Lanka, king Dutthagamani launched              always flocked into the temple to receive his battles to fight against Damilas dynasty of the              instructions, and each and every time they came, Tamils who tried to invade Ceyland at the time,              his meditation bed collapsed. Thus, he received king Dutthagamani never put forward any bettles              the name of "Broken bed Hui". with the intention of invasion of the continent of           Chieát Thaïch: Phaù thaïch hay ñaäp vôõ ñaù. Moät India for the spreading of Buddhism. The Buddha              trong boán thí duï veà Ba La Di—A broken stone, i.e. teaches us not to kill, but he never teaches us not          irreparable. to fight against enemies to protect our country.             Chieát Töï: Graphology. Chieán Tranh Toân Giaùo: Religious war.                      Chieâu Caûm: To attract. Chieát: Beû gaõy—Gaáp laïi—To break—To fold.                 Chieâu Ñaõi: To entertain. Chieát Caâu Ca: Cakoka (skt)—Xöù Karghalik thuoäc            Chieâu Ñeà Töù Phöông: Caturdisa (skt)—Thuoäc veà vuøng Turkestan—Karghalik in Turkestan.                      boán phöông—Belonging to the four directions. Chieát Ñoaïn: Laøm vôõ ra—To break off.                      Chieâu Ñoã La: Catura (skt)—Chieân Ñoå La Ñaïi Chieát Hôïp: Keát quaû—Result.                               Töôùng—One of the twelve spirits connected with Chieát Khaáu: To discount.                                   the Master of Healing. Chieát Lôïi Ñaûn La: Caritra (skt)—Phaùt Haïnh               Chieâu Ñöôøng: Ñieän thôø caùc vò Toå sö—The Thaønh—Theo Eitel trong Trung Anh Phaät Hoïc Töø             patriarchs' hall—Patriarchal altar. Ñieån, Chieát Lôïi Ñaûn La laø moät caûng naèm veà phía      Chieâu Hoàn: To call up a spirit. ñoâng nam bieân giôùi Uda, nôi coù nhöõng cuoäc trao

Chieâu Nhö (1246-1312): Zen master Chao-Ru—                    the head phrase "Who is the one who recites the Thieàn sö Chieâu Nhö, teân cuûa moät Thieàn sö toâng           name of Buddha?" Zen practitioners must observe Laâm Teá Trung Hoa trong tænh Giang Taây, vaøo theá            and look into the very idea of "Who?", to kyû thöù XIII—Chao-Ru, name of a Chinese Lin-                  penetrate into the state before the thought ever chi Zen master in the thirteenth century.                      arises, and see what this state look like. If we, Zen Chieâu Thieàn Töï: Chieu-Thien Temple—Teân cuûa                practitioners, have any doubt for the head-phrase, moät ngoâi chuøa coå toïa laïc trong laøng Yeân Laõng,         we should investigate the place of doubt. To phöôøng Laùng Thöôïng, quaän Ñoáng Ña, caùch trung             observe to see from whence the very thought of taâm thaønh phoá Haø Noäi khoaûng 4 daäm veà phía              "Who" comes, to see what it looks like, and subtly taây—Name of a temple, located in Yeân Laõng                   and gently to penetrate into it. village, Laùng Thöôïng quarter, Ñoáng Ña district,             Chieáu Ñöôøng: Shodo (jap)—The Illumination about 4 miles west of Hanoi.                                   Hall—Chieáu ñöôøng phaân caùch Thieàn ñöôøng vaø Chieáu: Chieáu saùng—To shine—To illuminate—                   phoøng röûa maët. Haønh lang giöõa cöûa sau cuûa Taêng Illustrious.                                                   ñöôøng vaø choã röûa tay. Haàu heát caùc thieàn vieän duøng Chieáu Coá: Observe and Look something—See                     haønh lang naày laøm choã thöïc taäp thieàn cho thieàn Chieáu Coá Thoaïi Ñaàu.                                        taêng. Moät vò Taêng cao tuoåi haï coù theå söû duïng Chieáu Coá Thoaïi Ñaàu: Observe and Look into the              Chieáu Ñöôøng ñeå chæ daïy nhöõng vò Taêng khaùc trong head-phrase (hua-tou)—Haønh giaû tu Thieàn phaûi               khi vò Vieän chuû ñang baän—This hall directly hieåu roõ tham thoaïi ñaàu nhö theá naøo. Ñöøng coá ñem        separates the Zazen Hall and the washroom. A caâu thoaïi ñaàu maø nieäm ñi nieäm laïi. Tu taäp thoaïi       passage-way between the back door of the Monk ñaàu khoâng phaûi laø chuyeän ñem caâu thoaïi ñaàu maø         Hall and the hand-washing basin. Most Zen laëp ñi laëp laïi. Tham thoaïi ñaàu laø nhìn thaáu vaøo hay    monasteries use this passage for practicing taäp trung vaøo noù. Noù coù nghóa laø xuyeân thaáu vaø        meditation. A senior monk would use this area for quan saùt. Thuaät ngöõ "Chieáu Coá Thoaïi Ñaàu" coù            instructing other monks while the master of the nghóa laø ñeå taâm thaåm thaáu xuyeân qua caâu thoaïi          temple was otherwise occupied. ñaàu. Taâm cuûa chuùng ta quen höôùng ngoaïi caàu              Chieáu Haïnh Tieân: Immortals with Illuminating hình. Baây giôø tham thoaïi ñaàu laø quay ngöôïc caùi          Conduct—Rsi with Illuminating Conduct—Coù thoùi quen höôùng ra ngoaøi naøy ñeå höôùng trôû veà beân      ngöôøi tu pheùp taäp trung tö töôûng, luyeän maõi cho trong. Thí duï nhö caâu thoaïi ñaàu "Ai laø keû nieäm          ñeán khi thaønh hoaøn haûo, goïi laø Chieáu Haïnh Tieân— Phaät?" Haønh giaû tu Thieàn phaûi quan saùt vaø nhìn          Some beings with unflagging resolution make vaøo ngay yù töôûng cuûa chöõ "Ai?", thaåm thaáu xuyeân        themselves strong through the use of thought- qua traïng thaùi tröôùc khi tö töôûng khôûi leân, vaø xem      process. When they have perfected thought and coi traïng thaùi naøy nhö theá naøo. Neáu chuùng ta, haønh     memory, they are known as Immortals with giaû tu Thieàn, ñoái vôùi caâu thoaïi ñaàu coù ñieàu gì nghi   Illuminating Conduct. ngôø, thì phaûi truy cöùu caùi choã nghi ñoù. Xeùt xem         Chieáu Huyeàn Töï: Vaøo theá kyû thöù naêm sau Taây caâu noùi aáy roát cuoäc laø töø ñaâu tôùi, vaø noù nhö theá   Lòch, nhaø Ñöôøng ñaët ra Chieáu Huyeàn Töï daønh cho naøo, quan saùt kyõ löôõng, vaø vi teá maø nheï nhaøng         Ni chuùng—The bureau for nuns in the fifth thaåm thaáu xuyeân qua noù—Zen practitioners should            century A.D. understand how to practice the head-phrase (hua-               Chieáu Khoan (1761-1830): Teân cuûa moät Thieàn tou). Do not try to recite repeatedly the sentence             Taêng thuoäc toâng Laâm Teá cuûa Vieät Nam vaøo theá kyû itself! This "head phrase" (hua-tou) practice is not           thöù XIX—Name of a Vietnamese Lin-chi Zen a matter of reciting. It is to look into or to                 monk in the nineteenth century. concentrate on it. It is to look into penetratingly            Chieáu Kieán: Soi göông, bò caám trong ñaïo Phaät, and to observe. The term "Observe and look into                ngoaïi tröø nhöõng lyù do ñaëc bieät—To reflect—To the head phrase." Our minds are used to going                  look at oneself in a mirror, forbidden to monks outside and sensing the things in the outer world.             except for special reasons. Now to observe and look into the head phrase is to             Chieáu Phaùp Luaân: Ba möôi naêm giaûng daïy kinh reverse this habit and to look inside. For example,            Baùt Nhaõ cuûa Ñöùc Phaät Ba möôi naêm giaûng daïy

kinh Baùt Nhaõ cuûa Ñöùc Phaät Illuminating or                     phaïm haïnh truù baát thôøi baát tieát thöù saùu laø ngöôøi aáy explaining the law-wheel. The thirty years                         bò sanh vaøo choã bieân ñòa, giöõa caùc loaøi moïi rôï voâ teaching of the Prajna (Baùt Nhaõ) or Wisdom                       trí, nhöõng choã maø caùc haøng Tyø Kheo, Tyø Kheo Ni, Sutras.                                                            Nam cö só, Nöõ cö só khoâng coù ñaát ñöùng. Thöù baûy laø Chieáu Phaát: Vò sö quaûn lyù trong töï vieän—The                  phaïm haïnh truù baát thôøi baát tieát thöù baûy laø ngöôøi aáy manager of affairs in a monastery.                                 sanh vaøo coõi trung taâm, nhöng laïi theo taø kieán ñieân Chieáu Tòch: Luminous and quiescent—Dieäu duïng                    ñaûo: “Khoâng coù boá thí, khoâng coù cuùng döôøng, chaân nhö chieáu roïi thanh tònh khaép möôøi phöông                khoâng coù cuùng teá, khoâng coù quaû baùo caùc haønh vi cuûa Phaät hay chaân nhö—The shining mystic purity                 thieän aùc, khoâng coù ñôøi naøy, khoâng coù ñôøi sau, of Buddha, or the bhutatathata.                                    khoâng coù meï, khoâng coù cha, khoâng coù caùc loaøi hoùa Chieáu Tòch Hueä: Ñaúng Giaùc Hueä—Trí tueä cuûa                   sanh, khoâng coù caùc vò Sa Moân, Baø La Moân ñaõ aùnh saùng vaø söï tòch tónh, coøn goïi laø Tòch Chieáu            chöùng ñaït chôn chaùnh, ñaõ töï mình chöùng tri, chöùng Hueä, hay trí hueä cuûa Boà taùt ôû Ñaúng Giaùc Vò ñaõ             ngoä theá giôùi naày vôùi theá giôùi sau vaø tuyeân thuyeát. quaùn trieät thöïc taùnh vaø thöïc töôùng cuûa Nieát Baøn —        Thöù taùm laø phaïm haïnh truù baát thôøi baát tieát thöù taùm Wisdom of illumination and quiescence, also                        laø ngöôøi aáy ñöôïc sanh vaøo nöôùc trung taâm, nhöng called the wisdom of understanding of Nirvana.                     aùc hueä, ngu si, ñieác, ngoïng, khoâng bieát nghóa lyù Buddha-wisdom which comprehends nirvana                            ñöôïc kheùo noùi hay vuïng noùi. Thöù chín laø phaïm reality and its functioning.                                       haïnh truù baát thôøi baát tieát thöù chín laø ngöôøi aáy ñöôïc Chieáu Y (1605-1673): Zen master Chao-Yi—Teân                      sanh vaøo nöôùc trung taâm, coù trí tueä, khoâng ngu si, cuûa moät Thieàn sö Trung Hoa vaøo theá kyû thöù                   khoâng ñieác, khoâng ngoïng, bieát nghóa lyù ñöôïc kheùo XVII—Chao-Yi, name of a Chinese Zen master                         noùi hay vuïng noùi, nhöng laïi khoâng coù Nhö Lai xuaát in the seventeenth century.                                        hieän—According to the Sangiti Sutta in the Long Chim Ca Laêng Taàn Giaø: Kalavinka bird—An                         Discourses of the Buddha, there are nine Indian cuckoo.                                                     unfortunate, inappropriate times for leading the Chim Seû: Kalandaka (skt)—Sparrow.                                 holy life. A Tathagata has been born in the world, Chim Xaù Lôïi: Chim haïc (baïch haïc)—Egret.                       Arahant, fully-enlightened Buddha, and the Chìm Ñaém: Sunk—Immersed.                                          Dhamma is taught which leads to calm and perfect Chìm Ñaém Trong Voâ Minh: To sleep in Mogha                        nirvana, which leads to enlightenment as taught by (moha) or ignorance.                                               the Well-farer, and this person is born in the Chín Baát Thôøi Baát Tieát Daãn Ñeán Ñôøi Soáng                    following realms: The first unfortunate, inappropriate time is that that person is born in a Phaïm Haïnh: Akkhana-asamaya-brahmacariya- hell-state. The second unfortunate, inappropriate vasaya (p)—Nine unfortunate, inappropriate times time is that that person is born among the animals. for leading the holy life—Theo Kinh Phuùng Tuïng The third unfortunate, inappropriate time is that trong Tröôøng Boä Kinh, coù chín thöù baát thôøi baát tieát that person is born among the petas. The fourth daãn ñeán ñôøi soáng phaïm haïnh. Nhö Lai xuaát hieän ôû unfortunate, inappropriate time is that that person ñôøi, baäc A La Haùn, Chaùnh Ñaúng Giaùc, Phaùp ñöôïc is born among the asuras. The fifth unfortunate, thuyeát giaûng, ñöa ñeán an tònh, höôùng ñeán Nieát inappropriate time is that that person is born in a Baøn, tieán tôùi giaùc ngoä, ñöôïc Thieän Theä khai thò, long-lived group of devas. The sixth unfortunate, maø ngöôøi aáy laïi sanh vaøo nhöõng coõi sau ñaây: Thöù inappropriate time is that that person is born in the nhaát laø phaïm haïnh truù, baát thôøi baát tieát thöù nhaát laø border regionsamong foolish barbarians where ngöôøi aáy sanh vaøo ñòa nguïc. Thöù nhì laø phaïm haïnh there is no access for monks and nuns, or male or truù baát thôøi baát tieát thöù nhì laø ngöôøi aáy bò sanh vaøo female followers. The seventh unfortunate, coõi baøng sanh. Thöù ba laø phaïm haïnh truù thöù ba baát inappropriate time is that that person is born in the thôøi baát tieát laø ngöôøi aáy bò sanh vaøo coõi ngaï quyû. middle country, but he has wrong views and Thöù tö laø phaïm haïnh truù baát thôøi baát tieát thöù tö laø distorted vision, thinking: “There is no giving, ngöôøi aáy bò sanh vaøo coõi A-Tu-La. Thöù naêm laø offering, or sacrificing, there is no fruit or result of phaïm haïnh truù baát thôøi baát tieát thöù naêm laø ngöôøi good or bad deeds; there is not this world and the aáy ñöôïc sanh vaøo coõi trôøi tröôøng thoï. Thöù saùu laø

next world; there are no parents and there is no              Brahma. Third, beings are alike in body and spontaneous rebirth; there are no ascetics and                different in perception such as Light-sound Brahmins in the world who, having attained to the             heavens (Abhasvara). Fourth, beings alike in body highest and realised for themselves the highest               and alike in perception such as Heavens of pure knowledge about this world and the next.” The                 dwelling. Fifth, the realm of unconscious beings eighth unfortunate, inappropriate time is that that           such as heavens of no-thought. Sixth, beings who person is born in the middle country but lacks                have attained the Sphere of Infinite Space. wisdom and is stupid, or is deaf and dumb and                 Seventh, beings who have attained to the Sphere cannot tell whether something has been well said              of Infinite Consciousness. Eighth, beings who or ill-said. The ninth unfortunate, inappropriate             have attained to the Sphere of No-Thingness. time is that that person is born in the middle                Ninth, beings who have attained to the Sphere of country and is intelligent, not stupid, and not deaf          Neither-Perception-Nor-Non-Perception. and dumb and well able to tell whether something              Chín Coõi: Cöûu Giôùi—Nine realms—See Cöûu Ñòa. has been well said or ill said, but no Tathagata              Chín Coâng Ñöùc Haïnh: Nine elements of virtue— has arisen.                                                   See Cöûu Coâng Ñöùc Haïnh. Chín Böôùc An Taâm: Semnegu (tib)—Nine steps                  Chín Loaïi Nghieäp: Nine kinds of karma—See for setting the mind in meditation—Coù chín böôùc             Cöûu Nghieäp. ñeå an taâm cho haønh giaû: chuù taâm, chuù taâm moät         Chín Oai Nghi: Nine ways of showing respect in caùch lieân tuïc; chuù taâm giaùn ñoaïn, ñieàu phuïc taâm,    India—See Cöûu Nghi. an tònh taâm, hoaøn toaøn an tònh, nhaát taâm töøng           Chín Söï Ñieàu Phuïc Xung Ñoät: Aghata- phaàn, hoaøn toaøn nhaát taâm, vaø hoaøn toaøn ñieàm          pativinaya (p)—Theo Kinh Phuùng Tuïng trong tænh—There are nine steps for setting the mind in             Tröôøng Boä Kinh, coù chín söï ñieàu phuïc xung ñoät meditation: attentive mind, continuously attentive            baèng caùch nghó raèng: “Coù lôïi ích gì maø nghó raèng mind, intermittently attentive, taming the mind,              moät ngöôøi ñaõ laøm haïi, ñang laøm haïi, vaø seõ laøm haïi pacifying the mind, complete pacification, partial            mình, haïi ngöôøi mình thöông, hoaëc haïi ngöôøi mình single-mindedness, complete single-mindedness,                gheùt.”—According to the Sangiti Sutta in the Long and complete composure.                                       Discourses of the Buddha, there are nine ways of Chín Choã An Truù Cuûa Loaøi Höõu Tình: Theo                  overcoming malice by thinking “There is no use to Kinh Phuùng Tuïng trong Tröôøng Boä Kinh, coù chín            think that a person has harmed, is harming, or will choã an truù cho loaøi höõu tình: Thöù nhaát laø loaøi höõu   harm either you, someone you love, or someone tình coù thaân sai bieät,töôûng sai bieät nhö loaøi ngöôøi    you hate.”—See Chín Xung Ñoät Söï. vaø moät soá chö Thieân. Thöù nhì laø loaøi höõu tình coù     Chín Ñieàu Laàm Loãi: Nine faults—See Cöûu Quaù. thaân sai bieät, töôûng ñoàng nhaát nhö Phaïm chuùng          Chín Thöù Ñeä Dieät: Anupubha-nirodha (p)—See Thieân khi môùi taùi sanh. Thöù ba laø loaøi höõu tình coù    Cöûu Thöù Ñeä Dieät. thaân ñoàng nhaát, töôûng sai bieät nhö Quang AÂm             Chín Thöù Ñeä Truù: See Cöûu Thöù Ñeä Truù. Thieân. Thöù tö laø loaøi höõu tình coù thaân ñoàng nhaát,    Chín Xung Ñoät Söï: Aghata-vatthuni (p)—Theo töôûng ñoàng nhaát nhö Tònh Cö Thieân. Thöù naêm laø          Kinh Phuùng Tuïng trong Tröôøng Boä Kinh, coù chín loaøi höõu tình khoâng coù töôûng, khoâng coù thoï nhö        söï xung ñoät khôûi leân bôûi tö töôûng. Thöù nhaát laø chö Voâ Töôûng Thieân. Thöù saùu laø loaøi höõu tình ñaõ      ngöôøi aáy ñaõ laøm haïi toâi. Thöù nhì laø ngöôøi aáy ñang chöùng ñöôïc (ôû coõi) Khoâng Voâ Bieân Xöù. Thöù baûy laø    laøm haïi toâi. Thöù ba laø ngöôøi aáy seõ laøm haïi toâi. Thöù loaøi höõu tình ñaõ chöùng ñöôïc (ôû coõi) Thöùc Voâ Bieân    tö laø ngöôøi aáy ñaõ laøm haïi ngöôøi toâi thöông meán. Xöù. Thöù taùm laø loaøi höõu tình ñaõ chöùng (ôû coõi) Voâ   Thöù naêm laø ngöôøi aáy ñang laøm haïi ngöôøi toâi Sôû Höõu Xöù. Thöù chín laø loaøi höõu tình ñaõ chöùng (ôû    thöông meán. Thöù saùu laø ngöôøi aáy seõ laøm haïi ngöôøi coõi) Phi Töôûng Phi Phi Töôûng Xöù—Nine abodes               toâi thöông meán. Thöù baûy laø ngöôøi aáy ñaõ laøm haïi of beings: First, beings different in body and                ngöôøi toâi khoâng thöông khoâng thích. Thöù taùm laø different in perception such as human beings,                 ngöôøi aáy ñang laøm haïi ngöôøi toâi khoâng thöông some devas and hells. Second, beings different in             khoâng thích. Thöù chín laø ngöôøi aáy seõ laøm haïi ngöôøi body and alike in perception such as new-rebirth              toâi khoâng thöông meán—According to the Sangiti

Sutta in the Long Discourses of the Buddha, there          mind becomes vacant and receptive, the eighth of are nine causes of malice which are stirred up by          the eightfold noble truth—Right concentration. the thought: First, he has done me an injury.              Chính Ñònh Nghieäp: Chaùnh ñònh nghieäp— Second, he is doing me an injury. Third, he will do        Concentration upon the eighteenth vow of me an injury. Fourth, he has done an injury to             Amitabha and the Western Paradise, in repeating someone who is dear and pleasant to me. Fifth, he          the name of Amitabha. is doing an injury to someone and pleasant to me.          Chính Ñònh Vöông Kinh: Candra-dipa-samadhi Sixth, he will do an injury to someone who is dear         Sutra             (skt)—Samadhi-raja-candrapradipa- and pleasant to me. Seventh, he has done an                Sutra(skt)—Sutra on the king of concentration— injury to someone who is hateful and unpleasant            Tam Muoäi Vöông kinh—See Nguyeät Ñaêng Tam to me. Eighth, he is doing an injury to someone            Muoäi Kinh. who is hateful and unpleasant to me. Ninth, he             Chính Ñöôøng: Phöông Tröôïng Taåm Ñöôøng— will do an injury to someone who is hateful and            Phoøng nguû cuûa phöông tröôïng, möôøi maõ vuoâng, unpleasant to me.                                          nguyeân thuûy ñöôïc duøng trong caùc Thieàn vieän chæ Chinh: Caùi chieâng—Loaïi naõo baït nhoû duøng ñeå         kích côõ lyù töôûng cho khu vöïc toïa chuû —Abbot's ñaùnh trong nghi thöùc leã laïc—A small gong struck        dormitory “fangzhang,” or ‘ten feet square,’ is a during the worship, or service.                            term used primarily in Zen monasteries and refers Chinh Coå: Chieâng troáng, nhaïc khí duøng trong nghi      to the ideal size of the abbot’s quarters. thöùc leã laïc Phaät giaùo—Cymbals, or small gongs         Chính        Giaùc:      Sambodhi      (skt)—Correct and drums.                                                 awakening—Right realization—See Chaùnh Giaùc. Chinh Phuïc: To conquer—To subdue.                         Chính Giaùc Hoa: Hoa sen nôi coõi Tònh Ñoä, ngöôøi Chính AÙn Baøng Ñeà: Cô Phaùp bieán hoùa hay caùch         ta noùi hoa ñöôïc sinh ra töø söï chính giaùc cuûa ñöùc thöùc khaùm phaù vaø chuyeån hoùa caên cô ngöôøi hoïc      Phaät A Di Ñaø—The lotus flower in the Pure Land; cuûa moät baäc thaày—A master's methods of                 it is said that the flower is born from mitabha discovering and transforming disciples in                  Buddha's Samyak sambodhi. accordance with their capabilities.                        Chính Giaùo: The orthodox religion. Chính AÁn: Zen master Chen-Yin—Teân cuûa moät              Chính Giaùo Luaân: Power of teaching—Chính danh Taêng toâng Laâm Teá Trung Quoác vaøo thôøi nhaø      giaùo luaân—See Giaùo Thaønh Luaân. Nguyeân (1280-1368)—Name of a famous Chinese               Chính Giaùo Löôïng: See Thaùnh Giaùo Löôïng. Zen monk of the Lin-chi sect, who lived in the             Chính Haønh Ñòa: Giai ñoaïn tu haønh ñuùng—Stage Yuan Dynasty.                                              of correct practice. Chính Baùo: Chaùnh baùo—The direct retribution of          Chính Haïnh: Right behavior—Haønh ñoäng ñuùng. the individual’s previous existence, such as being         Chính Haïnh Chaân Nhö: Samyak-Praptipatti- born as a man.                                             tathata (skt)—Right behavior of Suchness. Chính Caên: Thaéng nghóa caên—Khaû naêng söû duïng         Chính Höõu (1258-1352): Zen master Chen-Yu— caùc caên ñeå nhaän thöùc roõ veà chaân lyù, chöù khoâng   Teân cuûa moät danh Taêng toâng Laâm Teá Trung Quoác phaûi laø sôû kieán phaøm phu—The power or ability         vaøo cuoái thôøi nhaø Nguyeân (1280-1368)—Name of which uses the sense organs to discern the truth.          a famous Chinese Zen monk of the Lin-chi sect, Chính Chuyeân: Virtuous.                                   who lived in the end of the Yuan Dynasty. Chính Cô: Right basis—Right foundation—Caên                Chính Kieán: Right views. baûn chính ñaùng.                                          Chính Laäp Thuû Ma Taát Töôùng: Khi ñöùng hai tay Chính Danh: True name.                                     daøi quaù ñaàu goái—Hand reaching below the knees, Chính Ñaïi: Straightforward—Upright.                       long graceful hands which reach below the knees, Chính Ñaïi Quang Minh: Upright and clear.                  one of the thirty-two auspicious marks—See Tam Chính Ñaïo: The right way—The correct path—                Thaäp Nhò Haûo Töôùng. The correct way—The true doctrine.                         Chính Leänh Ñöông Haønh: Ñaïo cuûa Phaät Toå löu Chính Ñònh: Chaùnh ñònh—Samyaksamadhi—                     haønh töø ñôøi naày qua ñôøi khaùc—Buddhism of Right abstraction or concentration, so that the

Sakyamuni Buddha has been handed down from                  with a contributory cause (Duyeân nhaân); 2) Phaät generation to generation.                                   taùnh cuûa moïi chuùng sanh: Correct or direct cause Chính Leänh Toaøn Ñeà: Thieàn phong chaân chaùnh            (Buddha nature of all beings). mang saéc thaùi chính thoáng neâu ra toaøn boä vaán ñeà     Chính Nhaãn: See Chaùnh Nhaãn. tröïc chæ nhaân taâm sieâu vieät ngoân cuù nghóa lyù —The   Chính Nieäm: Ñang naûy ra yù nieäm—Realization of real Zen manner of the main line of succession              a thought. brings up everything in the issue of pointing               Chính Phaùp Luaân: Buddha Dharma(skt)— directly to the human mind which is beyond words            Buddha-dhamma (p)—The correct wheel of law— and meanings.                                               The teaching of the Buddha—Phaät phaùp—Buddha Chính Löôïng Boä: Sammatiya or Sammitiya                    Teachings, or Law of Buddhist—The Buddha law (skt)—Sa        Ma      Ñeá—School          of    Correct   preached by the Buddha—Chính Phaùp Luaân coù Evaluation—School of Correct Measure—See                    nghóa laø “Giaùo phaùp cuûa Ñöùc Phaät” hay “Nhöõng Chaùnh Löôïng Boä.                                          giaùo phaùp ñöôïc Phaät giaûng daïy, maø thöïc haønh theo Chính Lyù: See Chaùnh Lyù.                                  ñoù seõ daãn ñeán giaùc ngoä.”—The correct wheel of Chính Maïng: Chaùnh maïng—Samyagajiva (skt)—                dharma means “Doctrine of the Buddha” or 1) Traùnh nhöõng ngheà caám ñoaùn (trong kinh Phaät):       “methods of cultivation taught by the Buddha Right livelihood or right life, the fifth of the            leading beings to enlightenment.” eightfold noble truth, abstaining from any of the           Chính Phaùp Nhaõn Taïng: See Chaùnh Phaùp Nhaõn forbidden modes of living; 2) Phöông caùch chính            Taïng. thoáng ñeå sinh soáng cuûa moät vò Tyø Kheo laø khaát       Chính Saùch Soáng Chung Hoøa Bình: Peaceful thöïc: Begging or seeking alms, was the orthodox            coexistence policy. way of obtaining a living; 3) See Chaùnh Maïng.             Chính Só: Correct scholar—Bodhisattva. Chính Nguyeät: Thaùng ñaàu naêm aâm lòch—The first          Chính Taø: True and false. month of the year (lunar calendar).                         Chính Taâm: 1) Söï ngay thaúng: Straightness, Chính Ngöng (1191-1274): Zen master Chen-                   straighforwardness; 2) Laøm cho taâm ngay thaúng: Yung—Teân cuûa moät danh TaêngTrung Quoác vaøo              To regulate the mind. thôøi nhaø Nam Toáng (1127-1279)—Name of a                  Chính Taâm Tu Thaân: To rectify one's mind and famous Chinese Zen monk, who lived in the South             improve oneself. Sung Dynasty.                                               Chính Theå Trí: Caên boån trí—Voâ phaân bieät trí— Chính Nham:                                                 Chaân trí—See Nhö Lyù Trí. 1) (1597-1670): Zen master Chen-Yen—Teân cuûa               Chính Thoáng: Orthodox. moät danh Taêng Trung Quoác vaøo cuoái thôøi nhaø     Chính Thuï: Samapatti (skt & p)—Chöùng ñaéc— Minh (1368-1644)—Name of a famous                     Tam Ma Ñòa—Thieàn Chöùng—See Ñaúng Chí. Chinese Zen monk, who lived in the end of             Chính Toâng: Orthodox. the Ming Dynasty.                                     Chính Tri Kieán: See Chaùnh Tri Kieán. 2) Zen master Chen-Yen—Teân cuûa moät danh                  Chính Trò: Politics—Söï khaùc bieät giöõa chính trò Taêng toâng Laâm Teá Trung Quoác vaøo thôøi nhaø      vaø toân giaùo laø caên baûn cuûa toân giaùo laø giôùi luaät, Thanh (1644-1912)—Name of a famous                    thanh tònh vaø nieàm tin; trong khi caên baûn cuûa chính Chinese Zen monk, who lived in the Ch'ing             trò laø quyeàn löïc—The differences between politics Dynasty.                                              and religions are the bases of religion are Chính Nhaõn: Nhaát Chích Nhaõn—Ñaûnh Moân                   morality, purity and faith; while the basis of Nhaõn—Hoaït Nhaõn—Minh Nhaõn—Maét trí hueä—A                politics is power. wisdom eye—The right Dharma eye treasury—                   Chính Trung: 1) Giöõa Tröa: Midday; 2) Ngay Something that contains and preserves the right             Chính Giöõa: Exactly middle, eaxactly in the experience of reality.                                      middle. Chính Nhaân: 1) Nhaân chính sinh ra phaùp, so vôùi          Chính       Tröïc:      Right—Righteous—Rightful— duyeân nhaân laø nhöõng nhaân phuï chæ trôï löïc cho        Upright. nhaân chính: The true or direct cause, as compared

Chính Tröøng (1274-1339): Teân cuûa moät danh                 Tònh ñoä. Taâm ñöøng laøm nhöõng chuyeän sieåm khuùc, Taêng toâng Laâm Teá Trung Quoác vaøo thôøi nhaø              mieäng noùi tröïc, mieäng noùi nhaát haïnh tam muoäi maø Nguyeân        (1280-1368)—Name of a famous                   khoâng haønh tröïc taâm, coøn haønh tröïc taâm, ñoái vôùi Chinese Zen monk, who lived in the Yuan                       taát caû caùc phaùp chôù coù chaáp tröôùc. Ngöôøi meâ chaáp Dynasty.                                                      phaùp töôùng, chaáp nhaát haïnh tam muoäi, chæ noùi ngoài Chính Töôïng Maït: Ba thôøi kyø giaùo phaùp cuûa Ñöùc         khoâng ñoäng, taâm voïng khoâng khôûi töùc laø nhaát haïnh Phaät—The three periods of the Buddha’s doctrine:             tam muoäi, ngöôøi khôûi hieåu theá naày töùc laø ñoàng vôùi 1) Chaùnh Phaùp: The Proper Dharma Age—See                    voâ tình, trôû laïi laø nhôn duyeân chöôùng ñaïo.” Naày Chaùnh Phaùp.                                           thieän tri thöùc! Ñaïo phaûi thoâng löu, do ñaâu trôû laïi 2) Töôïng Phaùp: The Dharma Semblance Age—                    ngöng treä, taâm khoâng truï nôi phaùp, ñaïo töùc laø See Töôïng Phaùp.                                       thoâng löu. Taâm neáu truï phaùp goïi laø töï phöôïc, neáu 3) Maït Phaùp: The Dharma Ending Age—See                      noùi thöôøng ngoài khoâng ñoäng, aáy chæ nhö Ngaøi Xaù Maït Phaùp.                                             Lôïi Phaát ngoài yeân trong röøng laïi bò Ngaøi Duy Ma Chính Vaên: Baûn vaên goác—Original text.                     Caät quôû traùch. Naày thieän tri thöùc! Laïi coù ngöôøi daïy Chính Vò: Quaû vò chöùng ngoä, trong ñoù khoâng coøn          ngoài khaùn taâm quaùn tònh, khoâng ñoäng khoâng khôûi, phieàn naõo, cuõng goïi laø chöùng quaû nieát baøn Thanh      töø ñaây maø laäp coâng khoùa, ngöôøi meâ khoâng hieåu Vaên—The stage of attainment, or reward in which              lieàn chaáp thaønh ra ñieân cuoàng, nhöõng ngöôøi nhö there are no more afflictions. This is also called            theá naày thaät laø ñoâng, daïy nhau nhö theá, neân bieát the nirvana of Sravakas.                                      ñoù laø laàm lôùn.”—According to the Platform Sutra Chính Xaùc: Accurate—Exact.                                   of the Sixth Patriarch’s Dharma Treasure, the Chính Y Kinh: Kinh ñieån chính maø caùc toâng phaùi           Sixth Patriarch, Hui-Neng, taught: “Good döïa vaøo vaø coi laø kinh ñieån caên baûn—The sutras         Knowing Advisors, the Way must penetrate and on which any sect relies.                                     flow. How can it be impeded? If the mind does not Cho Pheùp: To permit—To allow—To authorize—                   dwell in dharmas, the way will penetrate and flow. To empower—To enable—To let.                                  The mind that dwells in dharmas is in self- Choáng Baùng: To resist—To oppose.                            bondage. To say that sitting unmoving is correct is Chôn An (1880-?): Teân cuûa moät vò cö só Phaät giaùo         to be like Sariputra who sat quietly in the forest noåi tieáng cuûa Vieät Nam vaøo theá kyû thöù XIX. OÂng       but was scolded by Vimalakirti. Good Knowing töøng laøm tuaàn vuõ tænh Phan Thieát. Naêm 1958, oâng        Advisors, there are those who teach people to sit thoï giôùi Boà Taùt taïi Giôùi Ñaøn Phaät Hoïc Vieän Nha      looking at the mind and contemplating stillness, Trang, luùc ñoù oâng ñaõ 74 tuoåi —Name of a famous           without moving or arising. They claimed that it Vietnamese layperson in the nineteenth century.               has merit. Confused men, not understanding, He was a province chief in Phan Thiet, Central                easily become attached and go insane. There are Vietnam. In 1958, he received the Bodhisattva                 many such people. Therefore, you should know Precepts at Nha Trang Buddhist Institute, at the              that teaching of this kind is a greater error.” age of 74.                                                    Chôn Ngoân: See Chaân Ngoân. Chôn Ñeá: Paramartha-satya (skt)—Ultimate                     Chôn Ngoân Thöøa: See Chaân Ngoân Thöøa. truth—See Chaân Ñeá.                                          Chôn Ngoân Toâng: See Chaân Ngoân Toâng. Chôn Hyû: Kalaruci (skt)—Kararuci (skt)—See                   Chôn Nhö Nghóa: Chôn nhö nghóa, vì taát caû Nhö Cöông Löông Laâu Chí.                                         Lai thuaän nhaäp. Ñaây laø moät trong möôøi nghóa cuûa Chôn Lieân Ñaø: Mucilinda or Mahamucilinda                    chö Ñaïi Boà Taùt (theo Kinh Hoa Nghieâm, Phaåm (skt)—See Muïc Chi Laân Ñaø.                                  38), chö Boà taùt an truï trong phaùp naày thôøi ñöôïc Chôn Lyù Ñaïo: Path of truth—Con ñöôøng cuûa chôn             nhöùt thieát trí voâ thöôïng nghóa—Principle of true lyù—Ñaïo phaûi thoâng löu—Theo Kinh Phaùp Baûo                Thusness, as all who realize Thusness enter it. Ñaøn, Luïc Toå Hueä Naêng daïy: “Naày thieän tri thöùc!       This one of the ten kinds of principle of Great Nhaát haïnh tam muoäi laø ñoái vôùi taát caû choã, ñi ñöùng   Enlightening Beings. Enlightening Beings who naèm ngoài thöôøng haønh moät tröïc taâm aáy vaäy.” Kinh      abide by these can attain the supreme principle of Tònh Danh noùi: “Tröïc taâm laø ñaïo traøng, tröïc taâm laø

omniscience—See Möôøi Nghóa Cuûa Chö Ñaïi Boà                 Xia stopped him and said: “You are disturbed Taùt.                                                         now. Go!” Chôn Taâm: Buddha-mind—True mind—True                        Veà sau naøy, Sö haønh cöôùc du phöông ñeán moät nature—Nhö Lai Taïng Taâm saún coù cuûa chuùng                vuøng maø baây giôø thuoäc tænh Sôn Taây vaø vieáng sanh—The orginal, simple, pure, natural mind of               chuøa Thieáu Laâm. Roài moät hoâm sö leân ngoïn all creatures.                                                Baùt-Vu, nôi coù thaûo am cuûa Nhò Toå, vaø trong Chôn Thieät Haïnh: Practice of truth.                         khi thaêm vieáng nôi naøy, Sö boãng nhieân kheá Chôn Tònh Thieàn Sö: True Stillness Zen                       ngoä. Treân ñöôøng sö trôû veà gaëp Ñôn Haø, thì Master—See Tuøng Duyeät Thieàn Sö.                            Ñôn Haø ñaõ bieát, taùt oâng moät caùi vaø noùi: “Ñaõ Chôn Tu Giaû Tu: Genuine and Sham                             noùi laø oâng seõ chaïy veà ñaây noùi cho ta bieát maø.” cultivation—Laøm theá naøo bieän bieät ñöôïc chôn tu          Sö leã baùi roài lui ra. Hoâm sau, Ñôn Haø thöôïng vaø giaû tu?—How can we tell the genuine from the             ñöôøng noùi keä: sham cultivator?                                                       “Nhaät soi coâ phong bieác, Chôn Yeát Thanh Lieãu Thieàn Sö (1089-1151):                           Nguyeät ñeán nöôùc trong khe, Shingetsu Shoryo (jap)—Cheân-hsieh Ch'ing-liao—                        Toå sö huyeàn dieäu quyeát, Zhenxie Qingliao—Hieän nay chuùng ta khoâng coù                        Chôù höôùng taát loøng an.” nhieàu taøi lieäu chi tieát veà Thieàn sö ; tuy nhieân, coù   Noùi xong Ñôn Haø lieàn xuoá ng toøa. moät vaøi chi tieát lyù thuù veà vò Thieàn sö naøy trong      Thanh Lieãu beøn tieán ñeán tröôùc toøa thöa: Nguõ Ñaêng Hoäi Nguyeân: Thieàn sö Chôn Yeát Thanh            “Ngaøy nay ñaêng toøa laïi chaúng löøa ñöôïc con.” Lieãu sanh naêm 1089 taïi vuøng An Tröôøng, nay               Ñôn Haø hoûi: “Ngöôi thöû nhaéc laïi ngaøy nay ta thuoäc tænh Töù Xuyeân. Sö xuaát gia naêm möôøi moät          ñaêng toøa xem?” Sö im laëng giaây laâu. Ñôn Haø tuoåi, ñeán naêm möôøi taùm tuoåi sö thi ñaäu Kinh Phaùp      baûo: “Seõ noùi oâng khaép ñaát.” Sö lieàn ñi ra— Hoa. Sau ñoù sö tieáp tuïc ñi ñeán Thaønh Ñoâ tieáp tuïc      Later, Chen-hsieh went traveling to an area of hoïc taäp kinh ñieån. Veà sau, oâng tieáp tuïc vaân du ñeå    modern Shanxi Province and visited Shaolin tham vaán vôùi nhieàu vò thaày noåi tieáng khaùc nhau.        Temple. He then went to nearby Boyu Peak, OÂng laø ñeä töû vaø laø ngöôøi noái phaùp cuûa thieàn sö     the site of the Second Ancestor's hut, and, Ñôn Haø Töû Thuaàn—We do not have detailed                    while visiting that site, he suddenly documents on this Zen Master; however, there is               experienced enlightenment. Upon returning to some interesting information on him in The                    see Tan-Xia, his teacher immediately knew Wudeng Huiyuan: Chen-hsieh Ch'ing-liao was                    what had transpired. Before Tan-Xia could born in 1089 in Anchang, in the area of modern Si-            speak, Tan-Xia slapped him saying: “You Chuan province. He left home at the age of eleven             were going to tell me what you know!” He and passed his scriptural examinations on the                 bowed and retreated. The next day, Tan-Xia Lotus Sutra at the age of eighteen. He then                   entered the hall and said to the monks this traveled to Cheng-Tu, where he continued his                  verse: scriptural study. Later, he set off traveling and                “The sun shines on a solitary green peak, visited various famous teachers. He was a disciple                The moon reflects in the cold creek and dharma successor of Zen master Dan-Xia-Zhi-                   water. Chun.                                                             The sublime mystery of the ancestors,  Moät laàn treân ñöôøng vaân du, sö gaëp thieàn sö               Is not found in the small mind.” Ñôn Haø. Ñôn Haø hoûi sö: “Theá naøo laø chính          Tan-Xia then got down from the seat. Xing- mình tröôùc khoâng kieáp?” Sö suy nghó ñeå traû         Liao came forward and said: “A talk like the lôøi, thì Ñôn Haø ñaõ chaän laïi baûo: “Ngöôi coøn      one you gave today won’t deceive me again.” oàn aøo theá sao, haõy ñi ñi!”—One time on the          Tan-Xia said: “Then explain it to me and we way of traveling, he met Tan-Xia. Tan-Xia               will see if you understand.” Xing-Liao was asked him: “What is the self before the empty           silent. Tan-Xia said: “I will say you caught a eon?” When Xing-Liao began to answer, Tan-              glimpse of it.” Xing-Liao then went out.

   Veà sau naøy, Sö ôû Chuøa Tröôøng Loâ, taïi ñaây Sö        monks, saying, "Climbing to an isolated laøm thò giaû cho vò truï trì laø Sö Toå Chieáu. Ít laâu   mountain top, crossing a one-boarded bridge, sau Toå Chieáu beänh naëng, neân ñeà cöû Sö leân           rushing about like this is how people these thay chöùc truï trì. Sö laøm truï trì ôû Tröôøng Loâ       days travel to places high and low. But if cho ñeán nhöõng naêm xaõ hoäi baát oån vì söï suy          they've really penetrated it, then without suïp cuûa trieàu Baéc Toáng (vaøo khoaûng naêm             leaving their room their body pervades the ten 1127). Sau ñoù Sö tieáp tuïc du phöông ñeán moät           directions. Not entering any gate, they are soá nôi, bao goàm nhöõng vuøng Tuyeát Phong ôû             always in their room. But if someone doesn't Phuùc Kieán vaø Caûnh Sôn ôû Haøng Chaâu. Hoaøng           understand this, then when he feels a draught thaùi haäu Töø Ninh ra leänh xaây moät ngoâi töï vieän     he goes and hauls a big load of firewood." ñeå vinh danh toå tieân cuûa baø. Trong buoåi leã         Sö thöôïng ñöôøng thò chuùng: "Nhìn khaép moïi khai maïc, Sö thuyeát giaûng: "Laõo Taêng ôû choã          nôi khoâng theå tìm ñöôïc noù. Chæ coù moät nôi maø tieân sö, nhôø bò taùt moät caùi maø taát caû so saùnh     maáy oâng khoâng theå luïc laïo ñöôïc, vaø ñoù laø nôi ñeàu döùt baët. Tìm choã môû mieäng khoâng theå            maø maáy oâng coù ñöôïc noù. Ñoù laø nôi naøo vaäy?" ñöôïc. Coù phaûi nhö nhöõng keû lanh noùi maø caïn         Sau moät luùc laâu im laëng, Sö noùi: "Thaân theå côït nhö chuùng thaáy ngaøy nay ñaâu? Neáu khoâng,         cuûa teân troäm ñaõ bò phôi baøy."—Chen-hsieh thì cöù ñeå cho hoï mang haøm saét chòu roi da, roài       entered the hall and addressed the monks, xem moãi ngöôøi hoï coù theå noùi ñöôïc gì"—Later,         saying, "Looking everywhere it can't be Chen-hsieh resided at Changlu Temple where                 found. There's just one place you can't search, he served as attendant to the abbot, a monk                and there it is attained. What place is that?" named Zuzhao. Zuzhao subsequently became                   After a long pause, Chen-hsieh said, "The gravely ill and retired from his position,                 thief's body is already exposed." naming Chen-hsieh as his successor. Chen-                 Sö noùi: "Coù ai chaúng bò nhieãm bôûi Huyeàn Sa hsieh served as abbot of Changlu until the                 hay khoâng? Ngay khi maáy oâng nhuùng veát years of social unrest accompanying the                    nhieãm naøy trong boán bieån, maáy oâng cuõng downfall of the Northern Song dynasty                      chaúng bao giôø röûa saïch ñöôïc noù ñaâu."—Chen- (around 1127). He then continued to travel to              hsieh said, "Is there anyone who hasn't been a series of places, including Snow Peak in                 stained by Hsuan-sha? Even if you dip this Fujian and Mt. Jing in Hangzhou. The                       stain in the four seas, you won't be able to dowager empress, Zi Ning, ordered the                      wash it out." construction of a temple to honor her                     Coù vò Taêng hoûi: “Chö Phaät ba ñôøi nhaèm trong ancestors. At the opening ceremony Chen-                   ñoáng löûa xoay baùnh xe ñaïi phaùp, laïi quaû thöïc hsieh lectured to the assembled crowd,                     ñaáy chaêng?”Thanh Lieãu baûo: “Ta laïi nghi saying, "My previous teacher slapped me and                ñaáy.” Vò Taêng baûo: “Hoøa Thöôïng vì sao laïi all of my cleverness vanished. I was unable to             nghi?” Sö ñaùp: “Hoa ñoàng thôm ñaày ñaát, chim open my mouth to speak. Was that like all of               röøng chaúng bieát xuaân.” Vò Taêng thöa: “Chaúng these fast-talking but shallow fellows we see              rôi phong theå laïi nhaän chuyeån thaân hay today? If not, then let them take the iron bit in          khoâng?” Sö ñaùp: “Choã ñi ngöôøi ñaù chaúng ñoàng their mouths and suffer the whip, then let's               coâng.”—A monk asked Chen-hsieh: “All the see what each of them can say."                            Buddhas in the three worlds have turned the    Moät hoâm, Sö thöôïng ñöôøng daïy chuùng: "Treân           great wheel of Dharma into the flames. Has ñænh coâ phong, qua caàu ñoäc moäc, ñi thaúng theá         this ceased or not?” Chen-hsieh laughed out aáy, vaãn laø choã chaân cao chaân thaáp cuûa thôøi        loud and said: “I have doubts about it.” The nhaân. Neáu hoäi ñöôïc trieät ñeå ñaâu caàn ra khoûi       monk said: “Master, why do you have doubts cöûa maø thaâu khaép möôøi phöông, chöa vaøo cöûa          about this?” Chen-hsieh said: “The fragrance maø thöôøng ôû trong thaát. Neáu kia chöa nhö theá,        of wild flowers fills the road. The secluded nhôn trôøi maùt böûa moät ñoáng cuûi."—One day,            bird does not know it’s spring.” A monk Chen-hsieh entered the hall and addressed the              asked: “Without letting go of wind and color,

is it still possible to pivot oneself or not?”               hsieh said: “Really, it’s a shame to waste a Chen-hsieh said: “Where the stone person                     pot of noodles!” walks, there is no other activity.”                     Thieàn sö Thanh Lieãu thò tòch naêm 1151, ngaøi    Coù moät vò Taêng hoûi: "Caùi gì laø caùi töï ngaõ           ñöôïc vua ban danh hieäu “Ngoä Khoâng Thieàn tröôùc khoâng kieáp?" Sö ñaùp: "Moät con ngöïa               Sö.”—Chen-hsieh died in 1151. He received traéng ñi vaøo ñaùm hoa vaø coû (lau saäy)."—A               the posthumous name “Zen Master monk asked, "What is the self before the                     Enlightened Emptiness.” empty eon?" Chen-hsieh said, "A white horse            Chôït Tænh: To awake. enters the flowers and reeds."                         Chôït Tænh Giaác Mô Xuaân: To awake from the    Moät vò Taêng hoûi: "Taát caû chö Phaät trong tam      worldly dream. giôùi ñaõ chuyeån Ñaïi Phaùp Luaân vaøo löûa. Vieäc    Chu: 1) Voøng quanh: Around; 2) Xung quanh: On naøy ñaõ döùt hay chöa vaäy?" Sö beøn cöôøi lôùn vaø   every side; 3) Chu toaøn: Complete. noùi: "Laõo Taêng nghi vieäc naøy quaù." Vò Taêng      Chu Bang Ñaïo (1898-?): Teân cuûa moät vò cö só noùi: "Thaày, taïi sao laïi nghi veà vieäc naøy?" Sö   Phaät giaùo noåi tieáng ngöôøi Trung Quoác vaøo thôøi nhaø noùi: "Höông thôm hoa daïi toûa ngaùt caû ñöôøng.      Thanh (1644-1912). Naêm 1949, sau khi sang Ñaøi Theá maø moät con chim soáng caùch bieät laïi          Loan, oâng trôû thaønh Chuû Bieân cuûa chöông trình chaúng bieát laø xuaân ñaõ ñeán."—A monk asked         Phaät hoïc trong "Trung Quoác Ñaïi Ñieån" cuûa Vieän Chen-hsieh, "All the Buddhas in the three              Phaät Hoïc Trung Hoa—Name of a famous Chinese worlds have turned the great wheel of                  layperson in the Ch'ing Dynasty. After he went to Dharma into the flames. Has this ceased or             Taiwan in 1949, he became a Chief Editor for a not?" Chen-hsieh laughed out loud and said,            project of the Chinese Buddhist Institute named "I have doubts about it." The monk said,               "Chinese Great Scripture". "Master, why do you have doubts about this?"           Chu Bieán: Khaép moïi nôi—Universal— Chen-hsieh said, "The wild flowers' fragrance          Everywhere—On every side. fills the road. The secluded bird does not             Chu Bieán Phaùp Giôùi: Choán sôû taïi cuûa phaùp goïi laø know it's spring."                                     phaùp giôùi; vì phaùp voâ taän neân phaùp giôùi voâ bieân.    Moät vò Taêng hoûi: "Khoâng buoâng gioù vaø saéc,      Coâng ñöùc cuûa phaùp thaân roäng khaép caû phaùp giôùi vaãn coøn coù theå töï xoay hay khoâng?" Sö noùi:      voâ     bieân—The         universe;     the     universal "Nôi ngöôøi ñaù kinh haønh, khoâng coù baát kyø sinh   dharmadhatu; the universe as an expression of the hoaït naøo khaùc nöõa."—A monk asked,                  dharmakaya. "Without letting go of wind and color, is it still     Chu Caûnh Truï: Teân cuûa moät vò cö só Phaät giaùo possible to pivot oneself or not?" Chen-hsieh          noåi tieáng ngöôøi Trung Quoác vaøo theá kyû XX. Naêm said, "Where the stone person walks, there's           1949, sau khi sang Ñaøi Loan, oâng saùng laäp nhaø in no other activity."                                    chuyeân in saùch Phaät giaùo ñeå phoå bieán vôùi giaù thaáp    Moät hoâm sö vaøo nhaø truø xem laøm buùn, chôït       vaø coù luùc phoå bieán mieãn phí—Name of a famous thuøng thoâng luûng ñaùy. Taêng chuùng la hoaûng:      Chinese layperson in the twentieth century. After “Uoång laém!” Sö baûo: “Thuøng thoâng luûng ñaùy       he went to Taiwan in 1949, he established a töï neân vui möøng, vì sao laïi phieàn naõo?” Taêng    printing house to print Buddhist books for low chuùng thöa: “Hoøa Thöôïng thì ñöôïc.” Sö noùi:        price and some for free distribution. “Quaû thöïc ñaùng tieác moät thuøng buùn.”—One         Chu Caáp: To supply one’s family. day Chen-hsieh went into the kitchen and saw           Chu Du: To travel. a pot of boiling noodles. Suddenly, the bottom         Chu Ñaø: Ksudra (skt)—See Chaâu Lôïi Baøn Ñaø fell out of the pot. The monks there were              Giaø. crestfallen, saying: “Oh, what a waste!” Chu Ñaïo La: Cuda (skt)—See Chu La Phaùt. Chen-hsieh said: “An overturned bucket is a Chu Kieàu Nhaát Trai (1909-?): Teân cuûa moät vò joy. Why are you disturbed?” the monks said: hoïc giaû noåi tieáng cuûa Phaät giaùo Nhaät Baûn vaøo theá “The master can take delight in it.” Chen- kyû XX. Vaøo naêm 1932, oâng toát nghieäp khoa Phaät giaùo hoïc taïi tröôøng ñaïi hoïc Otani vaø trôû thaønh

giaûng sö khoa naøy taïi tröôøng ñaïi hoïc Kyoto. OÂng      dictionary titled "Dharmalaksana Dictionary" vieát raát nhieàu saùch veà Phaät giaùo Nguyeân Thuûy—      which explained terms of the Fa-Hsiang-tsung. Name of a famous Japanese Buddhist scholar in               Chu Phæ: Teân cuûa moät vò cö só Phaät giaùo noåi tieáng the twentieth century. In 1932, he graduated                ngöôøi Trung Quoác vaøo theá kyû XX. Naêm 1949, sau Buddhology at Otani University, and became a                khi sang Ñaøi Loan, oâng saùng laäp Vieän Cöùu Teá Boà professor of Buddhology of Kyoto University. He             Ñeà taïi Ñaøi Trung. OÂng cuõng phaùt haønh moät trong wrote a lot of books on Theravadan Buddhism.                nhöõng nguyeät san Phaät giaùo noåi tieáng nhaát treân theá Chu Kî: Kyû nieäm ngaøy gioã thöù nhaát cuûa ngöôøi         giôùi, ñoù laø Nguyeät san Boà Ñeà Thuï—Name of a quaù vaõng—The first anniversary of a death.                famous Chinese layperson in the twentieth Chu Kî Trai: Leã cuùng côm trong buoåi gioã—The             century. After he went to Taiwan in 1949, he anniversary masses in an anniversary of a death.            established Tai-Chung Bodhi Relief Institute. He Chu La: Cuda (skt)—See Chu La Phaùt.                        also published one of the famous Buddhist Chu La Phaùt: Cuda (skt)—Chu Ñaïo La—Tieåu                  magazines in the world, the monthly Bodhi-Tree Keá—Chu La—Baäc Sa Di khi nhaäp ñaïo treân ñaàu             magazine. vaãn coøn ñeå moät choûm toùc con, sau ñoù thaày seõ caét   Chu Só Haønh (203-282): Teân cuûa moät danh Taêng boû ñeå chöùng toû quyeát taâm tu haønh theo Phaät cuûa     Trung Quoác döôùi trieàu nguïy thôøi Tam Quoác (220- ngöôøi aáy—A topknot left on the head of an                 265). Sö laø vò Taêng ñaàu tieân cuûa Trung Hoa ñi ordinand when he receives the commandments;                 sang Taây Vöïc caàu phaùp vaø thænh kinh. Naêm 257, the locks are later taken off by his teacher as a           Sö thuyeát giaûng kinh "Ñaïo Haønh Baùt Nhaõ" ôû Laïc sign of his complete devotion.                              Döông. Naêm 260, Sö ñeán nöôùc Vu Ñieàn thænh boä Chu Lyù (1591-1647): Teân cuûa moät danh Taêng toâng        Phoùng Quang Baùt Nhaõ—Name of a famous Laâm Teá Trung Quoác vaøo cuoái thôøi nhaø Minh             Chinese Zen monk, who lived in the Wei dynasty (1368-1644)—Name of a famous Chinese Lin-chi                during the San-Kuo. He was the first Chinese Zen monk, who lived in the end of the Ming                  monk who traveled to India to seek the Dharma Dynasty.                                                    and to bring some sutras back to China. In 257, he Chu Moäng Nhan (1656-1739): Teân cuûa moät vò cö            lectured the "Practice the Buddha-truth of the só Phaät giaùo noåi tieáng ngöôøi Trung Quoác vaøo thôøi    Prajna" in Lo-Yang. In 260, he came to Yu-Tien to nhaø Thanh (1644-1912). OÂng vieát raát nhieàu saùch        obtain the Heart of Maha Prajan Paramita Sutra veà Phaät giaùo Tònh Ñoä—Name of a famous                   (Mahaprajna-paramita sutra (skt). Chinese layperson in the Ch'ing dynasty. He wrote           Chu Thuùc Ca (1899-1970): Teân cuûa moät vò cö só a lot of books on Pure Land Buddhism.                       Phaät giaùo noåi tieáng ngöôøi Trung Quoác vaøo theá kyû Chu Na: Cunda (skt)—See Thuaàn Ñaø.                         XX. Naêm 1933, oâng trôû thaønh giaûng sö tröôøng ñaïi Chu Ngung: Teân cuûa moät vò cö só Phaät giaùo noåi         hoïc Baéc Kinh veà moân trieát hoïc Duy Thöùc. Naêm tieáng ngöôøi Trung Quoác vaøo thôøi nhaø Toáng (960-       1953, oâng laø moät trong nhöõng saùng laäp vieân ñaàu 1279). OÂng ñöôïc vua Toáng Minh Ñeá trieäu vaøo            tieân cuûa Hieäp Hoäi Phaät Giaùo Trung Quoác ñeà cung ñeå thuyeát giaûng cho hoaøng gia. Trong nhieàu        xöôùng xuaát baûn taïp chí Hieän Ñaïi Phaät Giaùo ôû Baéc cô hoäi oâng ñaõ giuùp thay ñoåi haønh vi cuûa nhaø vua—    Kinh—Name of a famous Chinese layperson in Name of a famous Chinese layperson in the Sung              the twentieth century. In 1933, he became a dynasty. At the time, King Sung-Ming-Ti                     professor at Bei-Jing University to teach the summoned him to the royal palace to lecture for             philosophy of the Mind-Only. In 1953, he was one the royal family. On many occasions, he helped              of the first members of the Chinese Buddhist changing the king's behaviors.                              Association who initiated to publish the Modern Chu Phí Hoaøng: Teân cuûa moät vò cö só Phaät giaùo         Bei-Jing Buddhist Magazine. noåi tieáng ngöôøi Trung Quoác vaøo thôøi nhaø Thanh        Chu        Toaøn:      Tana      (skt)—Hoaøn         taát— (1644-1912). Naêm 1937, oâng soaïn boä Phaùp Töôùng         Accomplishment—Perfect—Complete. Töø Ñieån—Name of a famous Chinese layperson                Chu Trieàu: Chou Dynasty (China). in the Ch'ing dynasty. In 1937, he composed a               Chu Trình Cuoäc Soáng: Life cycle—Theo Phaät giaùo, chu trình cuoäc soáng cuûa moät chuùng sanh baét

ñaàu khi thaàn thöùc ñi vaøo thai meï, ñaây laø luùc thoï    penalties for failure; 5) Maät chuù duøng trong Du- thai, hay luùc baét ñaàu cuoäc soáng cuûa moät sinh vaät     Giaø: Mystical, or magical formulae employed in khaùc—According to Buddhism, the life cycle of a             Yoga; 6) Trong Laït Ma Giaùo, chuù goàm nhöõng chöõ sentient being begins when the consciousness                 Taây Taïng vieát chung vôùi Phaïn ngöõ: In Lamaism enters the womb, and traditionally this has been             dharani consist of sets of Tibetan words connected considered the moment of conception, another life            with Sanskrit syllables. cycle begins.                                                Chuù Am: Teân cuûa moät vò Taêng ngöôøi Trung Quoác Chu Trung Ñöùc (1906-?): Teân cuûa moät vò cö só             vaøo thôøi nhaø Thanh (1644-1912). Sö noåi tieáng veà Phaät giaùo noåi tieáng ngöôøi Trung Quoác vaøo theá kyû     vieäc khaéc kinh treân tre—Name of a famous XX. OÂng ngöôøi tænh Hoà Baéc. OÂng vieát raát nhieàu        Chinese monk in the Ch'ing dynasty. He was saùch Phaät giaùo, trong soá ñoù boä "Phaät Hoïc Nghieân     famous for his engraving sutras on bamboo sticks. Cöùu" laø moät trong nhöõng quyeån saùch noåi tieán g        Chuù Caùt Töôøng Thieân Nöõ: Good Goddess nhaát—Name of a famous Chinese layperson in the              Mantra. twentieth century. He was from Hu-bei Province.              Chuù Chuaån Ñeà: Cunde (Jwun Ti) Dharani— He wrote a lot of Buddhist books, among which                Mantra—One of the Great Compassion Mantras— the "Studies of Buddhism" is one of the very                 Thousand-armed Avalokitesvara Mantra. famous books.                                                Chuù Coâng Ñöùc Baûo Sôn: Meritorious Virtue Chu Tuyeân Ñöùc (1899-?): Teân cuûa moät vò cö só            Jewelled Mountain Spirit Mantra. Phaät giaùo noåi tieáng ngöôøi Trung Quoác vaøo theá kyû     Chuù Döôïc Sö Quaùn Ñaûnh Chôn Ngoân: Medicine XX. Naêm 1949, sau khi sang Ñaøi Loan, oâng phaùt            Master’s True Words For Anointing The Crown. haønh moät trong nhöõng nguyeät san Phaät giaùo noåi         Chuù Ñaïi Bi: Great Compassion Mantra. tieáng nhaát treân theá giôùi, ñoù laø Nguyeät san Hueä      Chuù Ñoà Baùn Thaùc Ca: Udapanthaka (skt)— Cöï—Name of a famous Chinese layperson in the                Sudapanthaka (skt)—Chaâu Lôïi Baøn Ñaø Giaø—Teân twentieth century. After he went to Taiwan in                cuûa vò La Haùn thöù 16 trong 16 vò La Haùn ñöôïc ñöùc 1949, he published one of the famous Buddhist                Phaät cöû ñi hoaèng phaùp ôû haûi ngoaïi—Name of the magazines in the world, the monthly Wisdom                   sixteenth of the sixteen arhats. Torch magazine.                                              Chuù Giaûi: Commentary—Explanation and Chu Töôøng: Kyû nieäm leã Phaät Ñaûn—The                     interpretation of sutras. anniversary of Buddha’s birthday.                            Chuù Nguyeän: Incantation-vow—Xöôùng phaùp ngöõ Chu Töôøng Quang (1919-1963): Teân cuûa moät vò              caàu nguyeän cho thí chuû, hoaëc vong linh ngöôøi quaù cö só Phaät giaùo noåi tieáng ngöôøi Trung Quoác vaøo        coá, ñaëc bieät trong ngaøy cuùng thaát toå trong ngaøy theá kyû XX. OÂng ngöôøi tænh Trieát Giang. OÂng sang        cuùng caùc vong linh—Vows, prayers or formulas AÁn Ñoä ñeå hoaøn taát vieäc nghieân cöùu Phaät giaùo cuûa   uttered in behalf of donors, or of the dead; mình vaø trôû thaønh giaûng sö ôû tröôøng ñaïi hoïc          especially at the All Souls Day’s offering to the Allahabad. OÂng vieát raát nhieàu saùch Phaät giaùo,         seven generations of ancestors. Every word and trong soá ñoù boä "Trung Quoác Thieàn Toâng Phaùt            deed of a bodhisattva should be a dharani. Trieån Söû" laø moät trong nhöõng quyeån saùch noåi tieáng   Chuù Nguyeän Sö: Invoker. nhaát—Name of a famous Chinese layperson in the              Chuù Nhö YÙ Baûo Luaân Vöông Ñaø La Ni: As- twentieth century. He was from Je-Jiang Province.            You-Will Jewel Wheel King Dharani Mantra. He came to India to complete his Buddhist studies            Chuù Quan AÂm Linh Caûm Chôn Ngoân: Kuan and became a professor at Allahabad University.              Yin’s Efficacious Response True Words Mantra. He wrote a lot of Buddhist books, among which                Chuù Saùt: Gieát baèng caùch nguyeàn ruûa—Killing the "Chinese Zen History of Development" is one              through curse. of the very famous books.                                    Chuù Taïng: Moät trong boán taïng kinh, toaøn boä töø Chuù: Dharani (skt)—1) Thaàn Chuù: Mantra,                   ñieån cuûa Ñaø La Ni—One of the four pitakas, the incantation, spell; 2) Lôøi giaûi thích: Explain, or         thesaurus of dharanis. open up the meaning; 3) Lôøi theà: Oath; 4) Lôøi             Chuù Taâm: Nhöõng ñieàu coát yeáu cuûa lôøi chuù —The nguyeàn (seõ bò phaït khi thaát baïi): A vow with            heart of a spell—To pay attention to—A vow.

Chuù Taâm Caûnh Giaùc: Theo Kinh Höõu trong                  Chuù Thuaät: Mantapadam (p)—Sorcery—The Trung Boä Kinh, Ñöùc Phaät ñaõ daïy veà ‘Chuù taâm           sorcerer’s arts. caûnh giaùc’ nhö sau—According to the Sekha Sutta            Chuù Thö: Chuù Khôûi Töû—Chuù Thi Quyû—Pheùp UÙy in the Middle Length Discourses of the Buddha,               Ñaø La—Nieäm chuù khieán cho töû thi nhö coù quyû the Buddha confirmed his noble disciples on                  nhaäp ñöùng daäy, coù theå sai ñi baùo thuø hay khieán devotion to wakefulness as follows:                          cheát ngöôøi khaùc—An incantation for raising the 1) Ban ngaøy trong khi ñi kinh haønh vaø trong khi           vetala or corpse-demons to cause the death of ñang ngoài, goät saïch taâm trí khoûi caùc chöôùng      another person. ngaïi phaùp: During the day, while walking              Chuù Tieâu Tai Caùt Töôøng: Disaster Eradicating back and forth and sitting, a noble disciple            Auspicious Spirit Mantra. purifies his mind of obstructive states.                Chuù Tieåu: A Buddhist novice. 2) Ban ñeâm trong canh moät, trong khi ñi kinh               Chuù Vaõng Sanh: Rebirth Dharani Mantra. haønh vaø trong khi ñang ngoài, goät saïch taâm trí     Chuù Vaõng Sanh Tònh Ñoä: Spirit Mantra For khoûi caùc chöôùng ngaïi phaùp: In the first watch      Rebirth In The Pure Land. of the night, while back and forth and sitting,         Chuù YÙ: Attention—To pay attention to. he purifies his mind of obstructive states.             Chuû: 1) Chuû: Chief; 2) Chuùa: Master, Lord; 3) 3) Ban ñeâm trong canh giöõa, vò naày naèm xuoáng            Laøm chuû: To control; 4) Moät loaïi höôu, maø boä phía hoâng phaûi, nhö daùng naèm con sö töû, chaân      loâng ñuoâi ñöôïc ngöôøi ñôøi duøng laøm roi, nhöng gaùc treân chaân vôùi nhau, chaùnh nieäm tænh giaùc,    Taêng Ni bò caám khoâng ñöôïc duøng: A greta deer, höôùng nieäm ñeán luùc ngoài daäy laïi: In the          whose tail is used as a fly-whi, but the use of middle watch of the night he lies down on the           which is forbidden to monks and nuns; 5) Moät right side in the lion’s pose with one foot             trong nhöõng danh hieäu cuûa ñöùc Phaät: Nata (skt)— overlapping the other, mindful and fully                One of the epithets of the Buddha. aware, after noting in his mind the time for            Chuû Baïn: Chief and attendant—Principal and rising.                                                 secondary. 4) Ban ñeâm trong canh cuoái, khi ñaõ thöùc daäy,            Chuû Baïn Vieân Minh Cuï Ñöùc Moân: The theory of trong khi ñi kinh haønh vaø trong khi ñang ngoài,       co-relation—See Ñoàng Thôøi Cuï Tuùc Töông Öng goät saïch taâm trí khoûi caùc chöôùng ngaïi phaùp:     Moân. After rising, in the third watch of the night,          Chuû Bính Taïi Thuû: Caàm caùn trong tay, chæ cho while walking back and forth and sitting, he            vieäc naém ñöôïc troïng taâm cuûa söï vieäc —To keep a purifies his mind of obstructive states.                handle in hands, i.e., grasping the most important 5) Trong Phaät giaùo, chuù taâm hay söï tænh thöùc coù       point of the issue (matter). nghóa laø thöïc hieän söï tænh thöùc trong moïi hoaït Chuû Daï Thaàn: Vasantavayanti (skt)—1) Baø San ñoäng. Ñaây laø söï tænh thöùc toaøn thieän, yù noùi Baø Dieãn Ñeå: See Xuaân Hoøa Thaàn; 2) Teân cuûa vò chaùnh nieäm hay yeáu toá thöù baûy trong Baùt thieän tri thöùc thöù 32 trong soá 53 vò thieän tri thöùc maø Thaùnh Ñaïo: In Buddhism, "attention" or Thieän Taøi Ñoàng töû ñaõ tham cöùu treân ñöôøng taàm "mindfulness" refers to mindfulness of all caàu giaùc ngoä—Name of the thirty-second good- mental and physical activities. This is the knowing advisors among the fifty-three advisors perfect mindfulness, i.e., the seventh element whom Sudhana tried to consult on his way of of the eightfold noble path. seeking enlightenment. Chuù Thaùnh Voâ Löôïng Thoï Quyeát Ñònh Quang Chuû Ñeá: Sacca (p)—Satya (skt)—The true Minh Vöông Ñaø La Ni: The Resolute Light King                principle—Truth—See Chaân Lyù. Dharani Of Holy Limitless Life Mantra. Chuû Khaùch: Host and guest. Chuù Thaát Phaät Dieät Toäi Chôn Ngoân: The True Chuû Khaùn Chuû: Phong thaùi töông hôïp giöõa ngöôøi Words Of Seven Buddhas For Eradicating hoïc ñaõ ngoä thieàn vôùi moät vò thieàn sö ñaõ ñaéc ñaïo— Offenses Mantra. Compatible manners of both an awakened Chuù Thuû Laêng Nghieâm: See Shurangama                      disciple and a master who has attained the Way. Mantra.

Chuû Khaùn Khaùch: Phong thaùi khoâng töông hôïp              chi nhaùnh cuûa töï vieän lôùn ñeå tieáp khaùch—The giöõa moät vò thieàn sö ñaõ ñaéc ñaïo vôùi moät ngöôøi hoïc   chief monastery, in contrast with the guest hill, or troø si meâ baát ngoä—Incompatible manners of a               branch monastery—See Khaùch Sôn. master who has attained the Way and an ignorant               Chuû Sôn Kî AÙn Sôn, Chuû Sôn Cao AÙn Sôn Ñeâ disciple.                                                     Khaùch Sôn: Nuùi chuùa côõi nuùi maâm, nuùi chuùa cao Chuû Khaûo: Head examiner.                                    nuùi maâm thaáp, duï cho söï phaân bieät caùc söï khaùc Chuû Kieán: One's own views.                                  bieät—The main hill rides the guest hill; the main Chuû Leã: Ngöôøi chuû toïa buoåi leã—One who                  hill is high and the guest hill is low, i.e., presides a ceremony.                                          discrimination of distinctions. Chuû Ngaõ: Egoism.                                            Chuû Söï: Viharasvamin (skt)—1) Vò giaùm ñoác hay Chuû Nghóa Baát Dieät: Eternalism.                            Kieåm soaùt: Cotroller, Director; 2) Boán chöùc chuû söï Chuû Nghóa Bi Quan: Pessimism.                                trong töï vieän (Giaùm Töï, Duy Na, Ñieån Toïa, Tröïc Chuû Nghóa Caù Nhaân: Abhimana (skt)—                         Tueá): The four heads of affairs in a monastery. Individualism—See Taêng Thöôïng Maïn.                         Chuû Taùn: Vò chuû leã trong caùc nghi thöùc phaùp Chuû Nghóa Caáp Tieán: Radicalism.                            hoäi—One who presides a ceremony. Chuû Nghóa Chaân Lyù Tuyeät Ñoái Baát Khaû Tri:               Chuû Taân: Chuû vaø khaùch—Host and guest. Anissaravada (p)—Agnosticism—The doctrine of                  Chuû Taân Ñoàng Taùnh Khoâng: Host and guest are agnostics that claims that human mind cannot                  both empty—Thieàn sö Thích Nhaát Haïnh ñaõ vieát know whether there is a God or an ultimate cause,             trong quyeån 'Traùi Tim Hieåu Bieát': Trong truyeàn or anything beyond material phenomena.                        thoáng cuûa toâi, moãi laàn toâi chaép tay leã Phaät, toâi ñeàu Chuû Nghóa Khoaùi Laïc: Epicurism—Ngöôøi thích                ñoïc baøi keä ngaén naøy: cuoäc soáng xa xæ vaø duïc laïc—A person who is fond               "Ngöôøi ñaûnh leã vaø baøy toû loøng toân kính, of luxury and sensuous pleasures.                                   Vaø ngöôøi nhaän leã vaø söï toân kình, Chuû Nghóa Khoå Haïnh: Asceticism.                                  Caû hai ñeàu taùnh khoâng, Chuû Nghóa Laïc Quan: Optimism.                                     Vì vaäy, söï ñoàng caûm laø toaøn haûo." Chuû Nghóa Truyeàn Thoáng Baèng Lôøi: Oral                    Zen Master Thich Nhat Hanh wrote in the Heart lineage—See Toå Truyeàn Phaùi.                                of Understanding: In my tradition, every time I Chuû Nghóa Vaät Chaát: Materialism.                           join my palms together to make a deep bow to the Chuû Nhaân Coâng: See Chuû Nhaân OÂng.                        Buddha, I chant this short verse: "The one who bows and pays respect, Chuû Nhaân OÂng: OÂng chuû, duï cho Phaät taùnh saün coù And the one who receives the bow trong moïi ngöôøi—The host (boss), i.e., an innate and the respect; Buddha-nature in everyone. Both of us are empty. Chuû Phaùp: Truï trì—An abbot. That is why the communion is perfect." Chuû Phöông Thaàn: Nhöõng vò thaàn kieåm soaùt taùm Maëc daàu caû chuû vaø khaùch ñoàng taùnh khoâng, tuy höôùng—The spirits controlling the eight nhieân, coù nhöõng moái quan heä giöõa chuû vaø khaùch directions. do thieàn sö Ñoäng Sôn Löông Giôùi laäp ra ñeå hieån Chuû Quan: Boû ngöôøi chaúng boû caûnh, moät trong baøy lyù huyeàn dieäu cuûa Phaät phaùp —Although both boán caùch caân nhaéc trong giaùo töôùng cuûa toâng Laâm host and guest are both empty, there are Teá—Subjective, one of the four aspects of Lin-Chi relationships between subjective and objective, school—See Laâm Teá Töù Kieán. which are displayed by Zen master Tung-Shan- Chuû Quan-Khaùch Quan: Nhìn chuû quan hay Lieng-Chieh to reveal the wonderful theories of khaùch quan theo Phaät giaùo—Subjective or Buddhism—See Ñoäng Sôn Taân Chuû Cuù. Objective View in Buddhism—See Khaùch Quan Chuû Teá Sö: Intoner—Leader of the chanting. Vaø Chuû Quan. Chuû Teå: 1) Chuùa teå: Lord, master, the lord of the Chuû Sôn: Töï vieän lôùn, ñoái laïi vôùi töï vieän nhoû hay universe, God; 2) Ngöï trò: To dominate, to control; 3) Taâm hoàn (beân trong): The lord within.

Chuû Thaønh Töïu: Perfect lord—Laáy chöõ “Phaät”                to the Records of the Transmission of the Lamp chæ roõ vò chuû thuyeát phaùp laøm chuû thaønh töïu, moät       (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), Volume XII, one day, a monk trong saùu loaïi thaønh töïu, thöôøng môû ñaàu caùc             asked Zen master Lin-chi, "What does it mean to kinh—“The Buddha” implies the perfect lord or                   snatch away the object, but save the person?" Lin- master, one of the six perfections found in the                 chi answered, "The king's commands are opening phrase of each sutra.                                   sanctioned by the nation, the general, free from Chuû Theå Ñoái Töôïng Baát Nhò: Ninkyo-funi                     smoke and dust, has gone abroad." (jap)—Con ngöôøi vaø hieän töôïng (chuû theå vaø ñoái           Chuû Tröông Phoùng Daät: Libertinism—Khoâng töôïng) khoâng hai. Töø ngöõ döïa vaøo söï theå nghieäm         chòu gheùp mình vaøo ñaïo haïnh, luaân lyù. Ñaây laø moät caên baûn cuûa thieàn veà söï khoâng phaân bieät giöõa chuû     trong möôøi laàm laïc maø thieàn giaû coù theå bò rôi theå (con ngöôøi) vaø ñoái töôïng (hieän töôïng). YÙ töôûng     vaøo—Libertinism, in which there is no regulation sai laàm naày, theo ñoù chuû theå suy nghó taùch khoûi          of conduct, moral or otherwise. This is one of the theá giôùi hieän töôïng, naèm beân ngoaøi yù nghó cuûa          ten wrong ways into which the Yogin may fall. mình, laø moät daáu hieäu muø quaùng maø Thieàn tìm             Chuû Tröông Tröôøng Trai: Vegetarianism—Giaùo caùch khaéc phuïc—'Person-phenomenon not two';                  thuyeát nhaø Phaät luoân nhaán maïnh ñeán töù voâ löôïng an expression pointing to the fundamental Zen                   taâm, ñaïi töø, ñai bi, ñaïi hyû vaø ñaïi xaû. Ngöôøi Phaät töû realization of the nondistinctness of subject                   coi thaân maïng laø thieâng lieâng neân khoâng saùt haïi (person) and object (phenomenon). The erroneous                 baát cöù chuùng sanh naøo. Vaø chính vì theá maø ña view of being separated as an experiencing                      phaàn Phaät töû tu theo Ñaïi thöøa ñeàu phaùt nguyeän aên subject from an experienced phenomenal world                    chay—Buddhist doctrine always emphasizes on 'out there', is an expression of delusion that Zen              the four sublime states of boundless loving- training is intended to overcome.                               kindness, boundless compassion, boundless joy Chuû Theå Naêng Tri: The subjective knowing—                    and boundless equanimity. Buddhists hold life to See Kieán Phaàn.                                                be sacred. They do not, therefore, kill or harm any Chuû Thuû: Giaùm Töï—The abbot of a monastery.                  sentient beings. And thus, most of Mahayana Chuû Toïa: To preside.                                          Buddhist vows to be vegetarians. Chuû Trung Chuû: Khi tieáp hoùa ngöôøi hoïc, vò thaày           Chuû Vó: See Phaát Traàn. ñöùng ôû vò trí cuûa mình, khoâng caâu neä nhöõng               Chuû Vò: Vò Taêng hay Ni truï trì moät töï vieän: phöông phaùp thoâng thöôøng, giuùp cho ngöôøi hoïc trôû         Abbot—Abbess—A monk or nun who is head of a veà töï kyû boån phaän söï, nghóa laø töï mình phaûi laø oâng   monastery (convent). chuû cuûa chính mình. Luùc naøo caùc baäc thaày naày            Chuû Xöôùng: To put forward. cuõng khuyeán taán ngöôøi hoïc neân quay veà tìm Phaät          Chuû YÙ: Main idea—Chief purpose. taùnh ngay chính mình, chöù ñöøng chaïy ñoâng chaïy             Chuùa Baûn Sô: See Chuùa Boån Sô. taây tìm kieám beân ngoaøi—When leading and                     Chuùa Boån Sô: Adinatha (skt)—Primal creator. transforming disciples, masters utilize whatever                Chuùa Taïo Vaät: See Chuùng Sanh Chuû. methods to help their diciples to return to their               Chuøa Quaùn Bieån Laëng: Reflection on a Calm original Buddha-nature. These masters always                    Sea Temple—Moät trong nhöõng ngoâi chuøa chính encourage their disciples to turn back into                     taïi Trieàu Tieân, ñöôïc caùc nhaø sö Sunyong vaø themselves to find the Buddha-nature, not going                 Yijong saùng laäp vaøo naêm 803. Chuøa toïa laïc treân east and west to find it from outside.                          nuùi Kaya-san mieàn Nam tænh Kyongsang vaø noåi Chuû Trung Taân: Khaùch trong chuû—Khaùch Quan                  tieáng nhôø boä Kinh Ñieån Ñaïi Haøn ñaõ ñöôïc khaéc hay ñoaït caûnh chaúng ñoaït nhaân. Theo Truyeàn                treân goã ñöôïc löu tröõ taïi ñaây. Vieäc laøm naøy ñöôïc Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån XII, moät hoâm, coù moät vò Taêng            vua Kojong taøi trôï. Muïc ñích ñöôïc noùi ñeán cuûa laïi hoûi Thieàn sö Laâm Teá: "Theá naøo laø ñoaït caûnh        vieäc naøy laø taïo phöôùc baûo veä quoác gia, nhöng mæa chaúng ñoaït nhaân?" Sö ñaùp: "Leänh vua ñaõ haønh              mai thay nhu caàu cho moät taïng kinh môùi khôûi leân khaép thieân haï, töôùng quaân ngoaøi aûi döùt khoùi            nhö laø haäu quaû cuûa vieäc Moâng Coå xaâm laêng Trieàu buïi."—Objective or snatch away the object, but                 Tieân, neân trong thôøi gian ñoù taïng kinh ñöôïc khaéc save (do not snatch away) the person. According                 treân goã tröôùc ñaây bò huûy dieät—One of Korea’s

major temples, founded in 803 by the monks                        faculties (sight,hear, smell, taste, touch, mind), 6 Sunyong and Yijong. It is located on Kaya-san                     elements (form, sound, scent, flavor, bodily Mount in Southern Kyongsang province and is                       sensation, and all other elements in general), and best known for the Korean canon on 81,340                         6 consciousnesses (sight, hearing, smell, taste, carved wood blocks housed in one of its buildings.                touch, and mind). These were commissioned by King Kojong (1213-                     Chuaån Ñeà Boà Taùt: Moät hình thöùc cuûa Ñöùc Quaùn 1259). The stated purpose of the project was to                   AÂm hay quyeán thuoäc cuûa ngaøi—A form of Kuan- generate merit that would protect the nation, but                 Yin, or Kuan-Yin’s retinue. ironically the need for a new canon arose as a                    Chuaån Ñeà Phaät Maãu: Theo huyeàn thoaïi Trung result of a Mongol invasion, during which an                      Hoa, Chuaån Ñeà gioáng nhö Ma Lyù Chi hay Thieân earlier set of wood blocks was destroyed. Their                   Haäu. Baø ñöôïc tieâu bieåu bôûi nhöõng hình töôïng ba carving, which took sixteen years to complete,                    maét möôøi taùm tay—In China identified with was finished in 1252. Haeinsa is one of Korea’s                   Marici, Queen of Heaven. She is represented with “Three Jewels Temples,” and represents the                        three eyes and eighteen arms. Dharma (the others are Tongdosa, representing                     Chuaån Ñeà Quaùn AÂm: See Chuaån Ñeà Boà Taùt. the Buddha, and Songgwangsa, representing the                     Chuaån Ñeà Quaùn AÂm Boà Taùt: Ñaïi Chuaån Ñeà— Samgha). It was founded as the seat of the                        Moät hình thöùc khaùc cuûa Ñöùc Quaùn AÂm. Coù moät Hwaom (Chin. Hua-Yen) tradition in Korea, and                     loaïi chuù Ñaø La Ni baét ñaàu vôùi teân Chuaån Ñeà— its name derives from a meditative state called the               Maha-cundi, a form of Kuan Yin. There are “Haein” (calm sea) samadhi that is mentioned in                   dharanis beginning with the name of Cundi. the Avatamsaka Sutra.                                             Chuaån        Ñònh:     Parikamma-samadhi        (p)— Chuaån: 1) Ñuùng: Correct; 2) Chính xaùc: Exact; 3)               Preparatory concentration. Pheâ chuaån, chuaån thuaän: To grant, to permit, to               Chuaån Höùa: To Allow—To grant. acknowledge; 4) Tieâu chuaån: Standard.                           Chuaån Nhaän: To accept, to agree, to confirm. Chuaån Chi Quaùn AÂm: Cundi (skt)—See Chuaån                      Chuaån Xaùc: Accurate—Certain. Ñeà Phaät Maãu.                                                   Chuùc: 1) Caên daën: To tell (speak of the dead), to Chuaån Ñaø: See Thuaàn Ñaø.                                       order, to bid; 2) Chaùo: Rice-noodle (soup), Chuaån Ñeà: Candi or Cundi (skt)—Cundi                            congee, gruel. Bodhisattva—Theo huyeàn thoaïi Baø La Moân thì                    Chuùc Höông: Ñoát höông—To burn incense. Chuaån Ñeà laø moät hình thöùc cuûa Durga hay Parvati,            Chuùc Luïy: Daën doø (veà vieäc hoaèng trì Chaùnh vôï cuûa Thaàn Siva. Theo huyeàn thoaïi Trung Hoa,                Phaùp)—To entrust to—To lay responsibility upon. Chuaån Ñeà gioáng nhö Ma Lyù Chi hay Thieân Haäu.                 Chuùc Möøng: To congratulate. Baø ñöôïc tieâu bieåu bôûi nhöõng hình töôïng ba maét             Chuùc Ngoân: Will. möôøi taùm tay. Moät hình thöùc cuûa Ñöùc Quaùn AÂm               Chuùc Phaïn Chuû Nhaân: Vò Taêng coù traùch nhieäm lo hay quyeán thuoäc cuûa ngaøi. Theo truyeàn thuyeát                vieäc côm chaùo trong töï vieän—A monk who is Phaät giaùo, Ngaøi laø hoùa thaân cuûa Quaùn AÂm Ma Ha            responsible for rice and gruel in a monastery. Boà Ñeà Taùt Ñoûa. Vò Boà taùt coù 18 tay tieâu bieåu cho Chuùc Phaïn Taêng: Moät vò Taêng chæ bieát coù côm vaø luïc caên (maét, tai, muõi, löôõi, thaân, yù), luïc ñaïi (saéc, chaùo, yù noùi voâ duïng—A rice-gruel monk, or gruel thinh, höông, vò, xuùc, phaùp), vaø luïc thöùc (nhaõn, nhó, and rice monk, i.e. useless. tyû, thieät, thaân, yù)—In Brahmanic mythology a Chuùc Phaùt: Teihatsu (jap)—Mundaka (skt)— vindictive form of Durga, or Parvati, wife of Siva. Mundana (skt)—Shave (v) one’s hair—To shave "Chuaån Ñeà" in China identified with Marici, one’s head—Shaving—See Theá Phaùt. Queen of Heaven. She is represented with three Chuùc Phoù: Truyeàn trao truyeàn thoáng ñaïo phaùp eyes and eighteen arms. A form of Kuan-Yin, or giaùc ngoä trong nhaø thieàn—To hand down the Kuan-Yin’s retinue: According to Buddhists tradition of the way and method to attain legends, Cundi is a transformation body of the enlightenment in Zen. Avalokitesvara Maha-Bodhisattva. This Maha Chuùc Phuùc: To wish happiness. Bodhisattva has 18 arms which symbolizes 6

Chuùc Phuùc Sanh Nhaät: To invoke blessing on              1) Tyø Kheo hay Tyø Kheo Ni, tröôùc khi thænh someone’s birthday.                                              tieáng chuoâng, neân thôû ba hôi trong tænh thöùc Chuùc Thaùnh: Chuùc phuùc trong ngaøy sinh nhöït cuûa            vaø tuïng keä thænh chuoâng—A Bhiksu or hoaøng ñeá—To invoke blessings on the emperor’s                  Bhiksuni, before inviting the sound of the bell, birthday.                                                        should breathe in and out mindfully three Chuùc Thoï: To wish a long life.                                 times and recite the gatha for inviting the bell. Chuùc Tuïng: To compliment—To congratulate—                2) Tyø Kheo vaø Tyø Kheo Ni, khi nghe tieáng To invoke, either to bless or curse—To praise.                   chuoâng, neân ngöøng taát caû moïi suy nghó, noùi Chung: 1) Cheát: Death; 2) Coâng coäng: Common;                  naêng, sinh hoaït, ñeå thöïc taäp thôû trong chaùnh 3) Chuoâng: Ghanta (skt)—A bell; 4) Keát thuùc hay               nieäm—A Bhiksu or Bhiksuni, upon hearing chung cuoäc: End termination, final.                             the sound of the bell, should stop all thinking, Chung Caùc: Gaùc chuoâng (trong caùc töï vieän)—Bell             speech, and other movements, in order to house—Bell pavilion.                                             practice mindful breathing. Chung Coå: Chuoâng vaø troáng—Bell and drum.               3) Nghe tieáng chuoâng lieàn maëc aùo An Ñaø Hoäi, Chung Cuoäc: Final—End—Ending.                                   thí duï thöù 16 cuûa Voâ Moân Quan: Putting on Chung Ñaàu: Vò taêng chòu traùch nhieäm ñaùnh                    Seven-piece Robe at the Sound of the Bell, chuoâng trong caùc nghi leã trong töï vieän—A monk               example 16 of the Wu-Men-Kuan—See who is responsible to strike the bell in ceremonies              Chung Thanh Thaát Ñieàu. in a monastery.                                            Chung Thanh Thaát Ñieàu: Nghe tieáng chuoâng lieàn Chung Giaùo: Giai ñoaïn thöù ba trong nguõ giaùo Hoa       maëc aùo An Ñaø Hoäi, thí duï thöù 16 cuûa Voâ Moân Nghieâm—The third in the category of the Hua-              Quan—Putting on Seven-piece Robe at the Sound Yen School—See Nguõ Giaùo (A) (3).                         of the Bell, example 16 of the Wu-Men-Kuan— Chung Haï: Heát giai ñoaïn an cö kieát haï—The end         Ngaøy noï Vaân Moân noùi: "Theá giôùi roäng lôùn nhö (conclusion) of summer retreat.                            vaäy, sao nghe chuoâng laïi maëc aùo thaát ñieàu?" Tuy Vaân Moân laø ngöôøi bieát xöû duïng nhöõng lôøi daïy sinh Chung Laàu: Gaùc chuoâng—Bell-tower. ñoäng cuûa caùc thaày xöa, nhöng oâng toû ra raát ngôø Chung Nam Sôn: Mount Chung Nan—1) Ngoïn vöïc nhöõng töø ngöõ ñöôïc vieát ra, nhöõng töø naày deã nuùi Chung Nam ôû Sôn Taây: Chung-Nan Shan, a ñoïc nhöng khoâng phaûi luùc naøo ngöôøi ta cuõng hieåu mountain in Shan-Si; 2) Töôùc hieäu cuûa ngaøi Ñoå ñöôïc yù nghóa saâu saéc cuûa chuùng. Vì theá oâng caám Thuaän, sô toå toâng Hoa Nghieâm beân Trung Quoác: A khoâng cho ñeä töû vieát laïi nhöõng lôøi cuûa mình. Chính posthumous name for Tu-Shun, founder of the nhôø moät moân ñoà ñaõ baát chaáp söï caám ñoaùn, ghi laïi Hua-Yen or Avatamsaka School in China. nhöõng lôøi oâng daïy treân moät chieác aùo daøi baèng giaáy Chung Nhaãn: Shonin (jap)—Teân cuûa moät vò Taêng khi döï caùc buoåi giaûng , maø nhieàu chaâm ngoân vaø lôøi Nhaät Baûn—Name of a Japanese monk. giaûi thích baát huû cuûa ñaïi sö môùi coøn laïi ñeán ngaøy Chung Quy Ö Khoâng: Taát caû vaïn höõu cuoái cuøng nay. Theo Voâ Moân Hueä Khai trong Voâ Moân Quan, roài cuõng trôû veà daïng khoâng—All things in the end haønh giaû tu thieàn neân luoân nhôù raèng trong tham return to the Void. thieàn hoïc ñaïo, kî nhaát laø vieäc theo tieáng ñuoåi Chung Söùc: To join (unite) one’s efforts. maøu. Daàu cho nghe tieáng maø ngoä ñaïo, thaáy saéc maø Chung Thaïch Baøn (1904-?): Teân cuûa moät vò cö só saùng taâm, cuõng laø chuyeän thöôøng. Phaûi bieát raèng Phaät giaùo noåi tieáng ngöôøi Trung Quoác vaøo theá kyû ngöôøi tu thieàn phaûi côõi tieáng, ñaïp maøu, ñaâu ñaâu XX—Name of a famous Chinese layperson in the cuõng roõ, chi chi cuõng hay. Tuy vaäy, haõy thaønh thaät twentieth century. vôùi chính mình thöû hoûi xem tieáng ñeán beân tai hay Chung Thanh: Sound of the bell—AÂm thanh cuûa tai qua beân tieáng? Khi baïn ñaõ ñaït ñeán choã caû im tieáng chuoâng—Ñaây laø moät trong nhöõng uy nghi laãn tieáng ñeàu queân thì theá naøo? Choã naày neáu tai quan troïng nhaát trong söï tu taäp cuûa chö Taêng Ni— maø nghe aét khoù hieåu ñöôïc, coøn laáy maét maø nghe This is one of the most important fine manners of thì môùi ñöôïc—One day, Yun-men said, "See how monks’ and nuns’ cultivation: vast and wide the world is! Why do you put on your seven-piece robe at the sound of the bell?"

Yun-Men, who made such skillful use himself of               group of Buddhist followers that includes monks, the words of the ancient masters, was at the same            nuns, and laypeople. time very mistrustful of the written word, which             Chuùng Dò: Vaisvantara (skt)—Teân khaùc cuûa Thaùi could all too easily be understood literally but not         töû Taát Ñaït Ña Coà Ñaøm—Another name of Prince really grasped. Thus he forbade his students to              Siddhattha Gotama. write his sayings down. Owing to one of his                  Chuùng Dieäu Chi Moân: Taát caû leõ huyeàn dieäu— followers, who attended his discourses wearing a             The gateway to all mysteries—See Tri Chi Nhaát paper robe on which he took notes in spite of the            Töï Chuùng Dieäu Chi Moân. ban, that many of the imperishable sayings and               Chuùng Dieäu Cung Ñieän Thaàn: Palaces of explanations of the great Ch’an master have been             Wonders Deity (Spirit). preserved. According to Wu Men Hui-Kai in the                Chuùng Dieäu Toái Thaéng Quang Thieân Vöông: Wu-Men-Kuan, Zen practitioners should always                 Supreme Light of Myriad Subtleties—Moät trong remember that in training the Way, don't be                  möôøi Hoùa Laïc Thieân Vöông—See Hoùa Laïc Thieân victimized by sounds; don't follow up on forms.              Vöông. You may have realization on hearing a sound or               Chuùng Dieäu Trang Nghieâm AÂm Vöông: King of enlightenment on seeing a form, that's natural. But          Mahoraga of Sound Adorned by Myriad don't you know that true Zen practitioners can ride          Subtleties—Moät trong möôøi Ma Haàu La Giaø sounds and veil forms? They see all and sundry               Vöông. clearly; they handle each and every thing deftly.            Chuùng Duyeân: Shu-En (jap)—Nhöõng hoaøn Perhaps you are such a person. Howver, let's be              caûnh—Circumstances. honest with ourselves, does the sound come to the            Chuùng Döôõng: Sanghapala (skt)—Shanghapala ear, or does the ear go to the sound? And if you             (skt)—Teân cuûa moät vò sö AÁn Ñoä—Name of an have transcended sound and silence, what do you              Indian monk. say at such a point? If you listen with your ear, it is      Chuùng Ñaïo: Con ñöôøng cöùu khoå hay Tam Thöøa— hard to understand. If you hear with your eye, you           The way of all—Vehicle of salvation, or the three are intimate at last.                                        yana. Chung Thaân: Throughout one’s life.                          Chuùng Ñoà: Caû taäp theå ñoà chuùng, goàm caû Taêng Ni Chung Thôøi Thöùc: YÙ thöùc luùc laâm chung—Death-           vaø taïi gia—The whole body of followers, consciousness.                                               including the monks, the nuns and lay followers. Chung Voâ Ngoân Thuyeát: Troïn khoâng moät lôøi ñeå          Chuùng Ñoàng Phaän: Nikaya-sabhaga (skt)— thuyeát. Haønh giaû tu thieàn neân luoân nhôù raèng:         Generic Similarity—Cuøng moät choã thuù höôùng "Thieàn laø baát laäp vaên töï, giaùo ngoaò bieät truyeàn;   cuøng moät quaû baùo—Being in the same abode to tröïc chæ nhaân taâm, kieán taùnh thaønh Phaät"—Not a        get the same effect. word to preach. Zen practitioners should always              Chuùng Haø: Sanghanandi (skt)—See Taêng Giaø remember that: "Zen is not established by words,             Nan Ñeà. it is a special transmission outside the teachings. It       Chuùng         Hieàn:      Sanghabhadra           (skt)— directly points to the human mind, and through it            Shanghabhadra (skt)—Taêng Giaø Baït Ñaø La—Sö one sees one’s own nature and becomes a                      Chuùng Hieàn, moät danh Taêng cuûa toâng Taùt Baø Ña, Buddha."                                                     laø taùc giaû cuûa nhöõng boä luaän noåi tieáng cuûa Phaät Chuùng: Samgha (skt)—Assembly—Theo Phaät                     giaùo (Thuaän Chính Lyù Luaän vaø Hieån Toâng giaùo thì chuùng laø moät taäp hôïp cuûa taát caû Taêng      Luaän)—A learned priest of Cashmere, a follower chuùng hay ít nhaát laø ba vò Taêng hay Tam Taêng.           of the Sarvastivadah school, the author of many Chuùng Phaät giaùo coøn coù nghóa laø moät nhoùm Phaät       philosophical works. giaùo ñoà bao goàm Taêng, Ni, vaø ngöôøi taïi gia—           Chuùng Hieän: Sanghabhuti (skt)—Shanghabhuti According to the Buddhist rules, an assembly of              (skt)—Taêng Giaø Baït Tröøng—Teân cuûa moät vò sö monk is an assembly of all monks or a company of             AÁn Ñoä vaøo theá kyû thöù tö—Name of an Indian at least three monks. Buddhist Parisa also means a           monk in the fourth century.

Chuùng Hieäp Ñòa Nguïc: Sanghata (skt)—                      sanh—All the miseries of existence—The Shanghata (skt)—Narakanitaya (p)—Chuùng hôïp                 sufferings of all beings. ñòa nguïc, nôi giam giöõ taát caû moïi loaøi chuùng sanh     Chuùng Lieâu: Samgharama (skt)—Shuryo (jap)— aùc ñoäc. Ñaây laø moät trong taùm ñòa nguïc noùng lôùn.     Phoøng cuûa chö Taêng Ni trong töï vieän—A Ñòa nguïc nôi phaïm nhaân caáu xeù laãn nhau thaønh          monastery—A nunnery—Common Quarters— moät khoái giöõa hai nuùi roài cuøng rôùt xuoáng vöïc vôùi   Monks’ Dormitories. nhau—A hell where all kinds of evil beings were              Chuùng Ngoä Tu Ngung: Cheng-Wu-Hsiu-Yung— put in. This is one of the eight great hot hells. The        Name of a monk. hell in which all are squeezed into a mass                   Chuùng Sanh: Sattva or Bahujanya (skt)—Satta- between two mountains falling together.                      sacetano        (p)—Sattva-sacetana           (skt)—Shujo Chuùng Hoïc: Sata-saiksa (p)—See Chuùng Hoïc                 (jap)—Living beings—Conscious beings—Living Giôùi.                                                       creatures—All the living—Sentient beings—All Chuùng Hoïc Giôùi: Sata-saiksa (p)—Moät traêm trong          who are born—Töø “Chuùng sanh” noùi ñeán taát caû soá hai traêm naêm chuïc giôùi Tyø Kheo—One hundred          nhöõng vaät coù ñôøi soáng. Moãi sinh vaät ñeán vôùi coõi of the two hundred-fifty precepts for monks—See              ñôøi naøy laø keát quaû cuûa nhieàu nguyeân nhaân vaø ñieàu Cuï Tuùc Giôùi Tyø Kheo.                                     kieän khaùc nhau. Nhöõng sinh vaät nhoû nhaát nhö con Chuùng Hoïc Phaùp: Shaiksha-dharma (skt)—                    kieán hay con muoãi, hay ngay caû nhöõng kyù sinh Sekhiya-dhamma (p)—Saiksa-dharma (skt)—Baù                   truøng thaät nhoû, ñeàu laø nhöõng chuùng sanh. Moãi chuùng hoïc phaùp—100 giôùi nhoû caàn phaûi hoïc cho         chuùng sanh laø söï keát hôïp cuûa nhöõng thaønh toá, coù bieát. Theo Ñöùc Toân Sö Minh Ñaêng Quang trong              theå phaân bieät thaønh naêm phaàn: saéc, thoï, töôûng, Luaät Nghi Khaát Só, Thöùc Xoa Ca La Ni laø moät             haønh, thöùc. Do ñoù, chuùng sanh naày khoâng khaùc vôùi traêm giôùi caàn hoïc trong sinh hoaït haèng ngaøy cuûa      chuùng sanh khaùc, vaø con ngöôøi bình thöôøng khoâng Ni chuùng trong caùc tònh xaù —One hundred very              khaùc vôùi caùc baäc Thaùnh nhaân. Nhöng do baûn chaát minor standards, which are easily broken but                 vaø hình theå cuûa naêm yeáu toá toàn taïi trong töøng caù which should be borne in mind for one’s self-                theå ñöôïc thaønh laäp, neân chuùng sanh naày coù khaùc development. According to Most Honorable                     vôùi chuùng sanh khaùc, con ngöôøi bình thöôøng coù Master Minh Ñaêng Quang in the Rules for                     khaùc vôùi caùc baäc Thaùnh. Söï keát hôïp naêm uaån naày Mendicant Bhiksunis, Sikkka-karaniya includes                laø keát quaû cuûa nghieäp vaø thay ñoåi töøng saùt na, one hundred rules of conduct which are connected             nghóa laø chuyeån hoùa, thaønh toá môùi thay cho thaønh with daily activities of nuns in monasteries.                toá cuõ ñaõ tan raõ hoaëc bieán maát. Naêm uaån ñöôïc keát Chuùng Hôïp Ñòa Nguïc: Sanghata (skt)—See                    hôïp seõ thaønh moät höõu tình töø voâ thuûy, höõu tình aáy Chuùng Hieäp Ñòa Nguïc.                                      ñaõ taïo nghieäp vôùi söï chaáp thuû ñònh kieán cuûa caùi Chuùng Hoä: Sangharaksa (skt)—Taêng Giaø La                  ngaõ vaø ngaõ sôû. Söï hieåu bieát cuûa vò aáy bò boùp meùo Saùt—Vò sö AÁn Ñoä vaøo theá kyû thöù nhaát—An Indian        hoaëc che môø bôûi voâ minh, neân khoâng thaáy ñöôïc monk in the first century.                                   chaân lyù cuûa töøng saùt na keát hôïp vaø tan raõ cuûa töøng Chuùng Hoäi: Chuùng Taêng—An assembly of all the             thaønh phaàn trong naêm uaån. Maët khaùc, vò aáy bò chi monks.                                                       phoái bôûi baûn chaát voâ thöôøng cuûa chuùng. Moät ngöôøi Chuùng Höông: Caùc loaïi höông khaùc nhau—                   thöùc tænh vôùi söï hieåu bieát vôùi phöông phaùp tu taäp Various odors.                                               cuûa Ñöùc Phaät seõ giaùc ngoä ñöôïc baûn chaát cuûa chö Chuùng Höông Quoác Ñoä: 1) Coõi cuûa ñuû caùc loaøi          phaùp, nghóa laø moät höõu tình chæ do naêm uaån keát höông: Land of all fragrances; 2) Quoác ñoä cuûa             hôïp laïi vaø khoâng coù moät thöïc theå thöôøng haèng taát caû höông thôm treân coõi Tònh Ñoä: The country         hoaëc baát bieán naøo goïi laø linh hoàn caû —The term of all fragrance in the Pure Land.                           “Living beings” refer to all creatures that possess Chuùng Höïu: Vò hoä phaùp—Protector or benefactor            life-force. Each individual living being comes into of Buddhism.                                                 being as the result of a variety of different causes Chuùng Khaûi: Sanghavarman (skt)—See Taêng Giaø              and conditions. The smallest living beings as ants, Baït Ma.                                                     mosquitoes, or even the most tiniest parasites are Chuùng Khoå: Taát caû nhöõng khoå ñau cuûa chuùng            living beings. Every being is a combination of five

elements: rupa, vedana, sanna, sankhara, and                 taát caû chuùng sanh, thöông meán nhö con, neân chuùng vinnana. Hence, one being is not essentially                 sanh beänh, Boà Taùt cuõng beänh; chuùng sanh laønh, Boà different from another, an ordinary man is not               Taùt cuõng laønh.” Vaên Thuø Sö Lôïi laïi hoûi: “Beänh aáy different from a perfect saint. But is the nature and        nhôn ñaâu maø sanh?” Duy Ma Caät traû lôøi: “Boà Taùt proportion of each of the five constituents existing         coù beänh laø do loøng ñaïi bi.” Vaên Thuø Sö Lôïi hoûi: in an individual be taken into account, then one             “Cö só! Nhaø naày vì sao troáng khoâng vaø khoâng coù being is different from another, an ordinary man is          thò giaû?” Duy Ma Caät ñaùp: “Coõi nöôùc cuûa chö Phaät different from a perfect saint. The combination of           cuõng ñeàu khoâng.” Vaên Thuø hoûi: “Laáy gì laøm elements is the outcome of Karma and is                      khoâng?” Duy Ma Caät ñaùp: “Laáy khoâng laøm happening every moment, implying that the                    khoâng.” Vaên Thuø hoûi: “Ñaõ khoâng, caàn gì phaûi disintegration of elements always precedes it. The           khoâng?” Duy Ma Caät ñaùp: “Vì khoâng phaân bieät, elements in a combined state pass as an                      neân khoâng.” Vaên Thuø hoûi: “Coù theå phaân bieät ñöôïc individual, and from time immemorial he works                ö?” Duy Ma Caät ñaùp: “Phaân bieät cuõng khoâng.” under misconception of a self and of things                  Vaên Thuø hoûi: “Khoâng, phaûi tìm nôi ñaâu?” Duy Ma relating to a self. His vision being distorted or            Caät ñaùp: “Phaûi tìm trong saùu möôi hai moùn kieán obscured by ignorance of the truth he can not                chaáp.” Vaên Thuø hoûi: “Saùu möôi hai moùn kieán chaáp perceive the momentary combination and                       phaûi tìm nôi ñaâu?” Duy Ma Caät ñaùp: “Phaûi tìm disintegration of elements. On the other hand, he            trong caùc phaùp giaûi thoaùt cuûa chö Phaät.” Vaên Thuø is subject to an inclination for them. A perfect man         hoûi: “Phaùp giaûi thoaùt cuûa chö Phaät phaûi tìm nôi with his vision cleared by the Buddhist practices            ñaâu?” Duy Ma Caät ñaùp: “Phaûi tìm nôi taâm haïnh and culture realizes the real state of empirical             cuûa chuùng sanh.” Duy Ma Caät tieáp lôøi: “Ngaøi laïi things that an individual consists of the five               hoûi vì sao khoâng thò giaû? Taát caû chuùng ma vaø caùc elements and does not possess a permanent and                ngoaïi ñaïo ñeàu laø thò giaû cuûa toâi. Vì sao? Vì caùc ma unchanging entity called soul.                               öa sanh töû, maø Boà Taùt ôû nôi sanh töû khoâng boû. Coøn Chuùng Sanh Baát Khaû Ñaéc: Sentient beings are              ngoaïi ñaïo öa caùc kieán chaáp, maø Boà Taùt ôû nôi caùc ungraspable.                                                 kieán chaáp khoâng ñoäng.” Vaên Thuø hoûi: “Beänh cuûa Chuùng Sanh Baát Khaû Tö Nghì: Inconceivable                 cö só töôùng traïng theá naøo?” Duy Ma Caät ñaùp: sentient beings—Lôøi Phaät daïy veà hoaøn caûnh cuûa         “Beänh cuûa toâi khoâng hình, khoâng töôùng, khoâng theå chuùng sanh laø baát khaû tö nghì—The Buddha's               thaáy ñöôïc.” Vaên Thuø hoûi: “Beänh aáy hieäp vôùi thaân teaching about living beings’ circumstances is               hay hieäp vôùi taâm?” Duy Ma Caät ñaùp: “Khoâng phaûi beyond human conception.                                     hieäp vôùi thaân, vì thaân töôùng voán lìa; cuõng khoâng Chuùng Sanh Beänh Neân Boà Taùt Beänh: All living            phaûi hieäp vôùi taâm, vì taâm nhö huyeãn.” Vaên Thuø beings are subject to illness, I am ill as well—             hoûi: “Ñòa ñaïi, thuûy ñaïi, phong ñaïi, hoûa ñaïi, trong Theo kinh Duy Ma Caät, chöông naêm, khi ngaøi Vaên           boán ñaïi beänh oâng veà ñaïi naøo?” Duy Ma Caät ñaùp: Thuø Sö Lôïi ñeán thaêm Duy Ma Caät, ngaøi hoûi: “Cö         “Beänh aáy khoâng phaûi ñòa ñaïi, cuõng khoâng lìa ñòa só beänh coù chòu noåi ñöôïc khoâng? Ñieàu trò coù bôùt      ñaïi; thuûy, hoûa, phong ñaïi cuõng nhö theá. Nhöng khoâng? Beänh khoâng ñeán noãi taêng ö? Theá Toân aân        beänh cuûa chuùng sanh laø töø nôi töù ñaïi maø khôûi, vì caàn hoûi thaêm chi xieát. Beänh Cö só nhôn ñaâu maø         chuùng sanh beänh neân toâi coù beänh.” Ñoaïn Vaên Thuø sanh, sanh ñaõ bao laâu, phaûi theá naøo môùi maïnh          hoûi tieáp: “Phaøm Boà Taùt an uûi Boà Taùt coù beänh nhö ñöôïc?” Duy Ma Caät ñaùp: “Töø nôi si maø coù aùi, beänh     theá naøo?” Duy Ma Caät ñaùp: “Noùi thaân voâ thöôøng, toâi sanh. Vì taát caû chuùng sanh beänh, neân toâi beänh.   nhöng khoâng bao giôø nhaøm chaùn thaân naày. Noùi Neáu taát caû chuùng sanh khoâng beänh, thì beänh toâi       thaân coù khoå, nhöng khoâng bao giôø noùi veà söï vui ôû laønh. Vì sao? Boà Taùt vì chuùng sanh maø vaøo ñöôøng       Nieát Baøn. Noùi thaân voâ ngaõ maø khuyeân daïy daét dìu sanh töû, heã coù sanh thôøi coù beänh, neáu chuùng sanh     chuùng sanh. Noùi thaân khoâng tòch, chöù khoâng noùi laø khoûi beänh thì Boà Taùt khoâng coù beänh. Ví nhö oâng       roát raùo tòch dieät. Noùi aên naên toäi tröôùc, chöù khoâng tröôûng giaû chæ coù moät ngöôøi con, heã ngöôøi con         noùi vaøo nôi quaù khöù. Laáy beänh mình maø thöông beänh, thì cha meï cuõng beänh; neáu beänh cuûa con          beänh ngöôøi. Phaûi bieát caùi khoå voâ soá kieáp tröôùc, laønh, cha meï cuõng laønh. Boà Taùt cuõng theá! Ñoái vôùi   phaûi nghó ñeán söï lôïi ích cho taát caû chuùng sanh, nhôù

ñeán vieäc laøm phöôùc, töôûng ñeán söï soáng trong saïch,   replied: “It should be sought in the minds of all chôù neân sanh taâm buoàn raàu, phaûi thöôøng khôûi loøng    living beings.” He continued: “The virtuous one tinh taán, nguyeän seõ laøm vò y vöông ñieàu trò taát caû    has also asked why I have no servants; well, all beänh cuûa chuùng sanh. Boà Taùt phaûi an uûi Boà Taùt coù   demons and heretics are my servants. Why? beänh nhö theá ñeå cho ñöôïc hoan hyû.”—According            Because demons like (the state of) birth and death to the Vimalakirti Sutra, Chapter Five, when                 which the Bodhisattva does not reject, whereas Manjusri arrived to visit Vimalakirti, he asked:             heretics delight in false views in the midst of “Venerable Upasaka, is your illness bearable?                which the Bodhisattva remains unmoved.” Will it get worse with the wrong treatment? The              Manjusri asked: “What form does the Venerable World Honoured One sends me to inquire after                 Upasaka’s illness take?” Vimalakirti replied: “My your health, and is anxious to have good news of             illness is formless and invisible.” Manjusri asked: you. Venerable Upasaka, where does your illness              “Is it an illness of the body or of the mind?” come from; how long since it arose, and how will             Vimalakirti replied: “It is not an illness of the it come to an end?” Vimalakirti replied: “Stupidity          body, for it is beyond body and it is not that of the leads to love, which is the origin of my illness.            mind, for the mind is like an illusion.” Manjusri Because all living beings are subject to illness, I          asked: “Of the four elements, earth, water, fire am ill as well. When all living beings are no                and air, which one is ill?” Vimalakirti replied: “It longer ill, my illness will come to an end. Why? A           is not an illness of the element of earth but it is not Bodhisattva, because of (his vow to save) living             beyond it; it is the same with the other elements of beings, enters the realm of birth and death which            water, fire and air. Since the illnesses of all living is subject to illness; if they are all cured, the            beings originate from the four elements which Bodhisattva will no longer be ill. For instance,             cause them to suffer, I am ill too.” Manjusri then when the only son of an elder falls ill, so do his           asked: “What should a Bodhisattva say when parents, and when he recovers his health, so do              comforting another Bodhisattva who falls ill?” they. Likewise, a Bodhisattva loves all living               Vimalakirti replied: “He should speak of the beings as if they were his sons; so when they fall           impermanence of the body but never of the ill, the Bodhisattva is also ill, and when they              abhorrence and relinquishment of the body. He recover, he is no longer ill.” Manjusri asked:               should speak of the suffering body but never of “What is the cause of a Bodhisattva’s illness?”              the joy in nirvana.          He should speak of Vimalakirti replied: “A Bodhisattva’s illness                egolessness in the body while teaching and comes from (his) great compassion.” Manjusri                 guiding all living beings (in spite of the fact that asked: “Why is the Venerable Upasaka’s house                 they are fundamentally non-existent in the empty and without servants?” Vimalakirti replied:            absolute state). He should speak of the voidness of “All Buddha lands are also void.” Manjusri asked:            the body but should never cling to the ultimate “What is the Buddha land void of?”Vimalakirti                nirvana. He should speak of repentance of past replied: “It is void of voidness.” Manjusri asked:           sins but should avoid slipping into the past. “Why should voidness be void?” Vimalakirti                   Because of his own illness he should take pity on replied: “Voidness is void in the absence of                 all those who are sick. Knowing that he has discrimination.” Manjusri asked: “Can voidness be            suffered during countless past aeons, he should subject to discrimination?” Vimalakirti replied:             think of the welfare of all living beings. He should “All discrimination is also void.” Manjusri asked:           think of his past practice of good virtues to uphold “Where can voidness be sought?” Vimalakirti                  (his determination for) right livelihood. Instead of replied: “It should be sought in the sixty-two false         worrying about troubles (klesa) he should give rise views.” Manjusri asked: “Where should the sixty-             to zeal and devotion (in his practice of the two false views be sought?” Vimalakirti replied:             Dharma). He should act like a king physician to “They should be sought in the liberation of all              cure others’ illnesses. Thus, a Bodhisattva should Buddhas.” Manjusri asked: “Where should the                  comfort another sick Bodhisattva to make him liberation of all Buddhas be sought?” Vimalakirti            happy.”

Chuùng Sanh Bình Ñaúng: Sattvasamata (skt)—                     intrinsically Buddhas." We are all right to begin Sameness of all beings—Söï ñoàng nhaát cuûa moïi                with. So when called, just answer. If you cannot thöïc theå—Trong Phaät giaùo Ñaïi Thöøa, chö Boà taùt           answer, that, too, is okay. Regardless of whether öùng xöû ñoàng caûm vì coù moät nieàm tin chaéc chaén           you answer or not, you are this fundamentally, raèng moïi vaät ñoàng theå, nghóa laø khoâng coù söï khaùc      originally enlightened ground. We practice on this bieät naøo giöõa chuùng sanh moïi loaøi—In Mahayana             ground of original enlightenment because that is Buddhism, Bodhisattvas behave compassionately                   our life. We do not need to look for anything else because they firmly believe that there is no                    because everything is already right here. This life distinction between all sentient beings.                        itself, your life itself, is the valley that has no Chuùng Sanh Boån Lai Thò Phaät: All sentient                    echo. When you look for something else, you are beings are intrinsically Buddhas—Trong "Baïch AÅn               putting another head on top of your own. How do Toïa Thieàn Ca," Thieàn sö Baïch AÅn Hueä Haïc noùi:            we appreciate the life that we have? "Chuùng sanh boån lai thò Phaät." Moãi caù nhaân thaät ra       Unfortunately, we often experience this life as if it töø khôûi thuûy ñeàu khoâng coù vaán ñeà. Vì theá, coù          were a roller coaster, spinning around in the six ngöôøi goïi baïn thì baïn traû lôøi. Neáu baïn khoâng traû      realms. Sometimes you feel marvelous. The next lôøi, cuõng khoâng sao. Daàu baïn coù traû lôøi hay khoâng      day, you hit bottom. You go from heaven to hell caên baûn vaø nguyeân lai baïn ñeàu ôû trong tình traïng        and all kinds of spheres in between from day to khai ngoä. Chuùng ta ñang tu taäp trong tình traïng             day, maybe even in one day. What are you doing baûn lai khai ngoä vì ñoù voán laø cuoäc soáng cuûa mình.       with this life? You wonder, "Am I really the same Chuùng ta khoâng caàn phaûi tìm caùi gì khaùc nöõa vì           as the Buddhas?" Many of you respond, "Hardly." moïi thöù ñaõ coù saún ôû ñaây. Töï cuoäc ñôøi naøy, cuoäc      So what will you do? This is a very common ñôøi cuûa baïn chính laø thung luõng khoâng coù tieáng          dilemma. That is why if we just rely on one voïng. Khi baïn tìm caùi gì khaùc, töùc laø baïn ñang ñaët      perspective, such as "We are all okay, be just as moät caùi ñaàu khaùc leân treân caùi ñaàu saún coù cuûa         you are." we fall into a trap. It sounds good, but mình. Laøm caùch naøo ñeå bieát traân quí cuoäc soáng maø       unfortunately, not all of us can live like that. chuùng ta ñang coù? Baát haïnh thay, chuùng ta thöôøng          Something is not quite right. We, Zen kinh nghieäm cuoäc ñôøi naøy nhö theå noù laø moät coå xe       practitioners, must examine who we are and truly chaïy treân maây, tôùi lui xoay vaàn trong luïc ñaïo. Coù       see what this life is, what is the very nature of khi baïn caûm thaáy cuoäc ñôøi laø tuyeät vôøi, coù khi baïn    existence. This is a very natural inquiry—See laïi rôi xuoáng vöïc thaúm. Moãi ngaøy, thaäm chí chæ noäi      Baïch AÅn Thieàn Toïa Tuïng. trong moät ngaøy thoâi, baïn ñaõ töø treân trôøi rôi xuoáng     Chuùng Sanh Boån Taùnh: Boån taùnh hay chaân nhö ñòa nguïc, vaø taát caû moïi caûnh giôùi khaùc. Baïn phaûi      phaùp taùnh cuûa chuùng sanh (Chaân Nhö Phaùp Taùnh laøm gì ñaây vôùi cuoäc ñôøi naøy? Baïn töï hoûi: "Toâi thaät   coù 2 nghóa baát bieán vaø tuøy duyeân)—The original söï coù phaûi laø Phaät khoâng?" Raát nhieàu ngöôøi ñeàu        nature of all the living, i.e. the bhutatathata in its traû lôøi "Hieám khi laém." Vaäy thì baïn phaûi laøm gì         phenomenal aspect. ñaây? Ñoù laø moät hoaøn caûnh khoù khaên thoâng thöôøng.       Chuùng Sanh Caûnh: See Chuùng Sanh Giôùi. Ñoù cuõng laø lyù do taïi sao neáu chuùng ta chæ döïa vaøo      Chuùng Sanh Caên: 1) Caên goác cuûa chuùng sanh: moät thöù quan ñieåm, cho raèng "Chuùng toâi ñeàu toát,         The root or nature of all beings; 2) Khaû naêng cuûa chæ caàn anh laøm toát phaàn anh", laø chuùng ta seõ rôi        chuùng sanh: Capacity of sentient beings. vaøo baãy ngay. Quan ñieåm naøy nghe qua cuõng toát,            Chuùng Sanh Caáu: Stain of sentient beings— nhöng baát haïnh ôû choã khoâng phaûi moãi caù nhaân ñeå        Nhöõng caáu ueá bình thöôøng cuûa chuùng sanh khôûi coù theå soáng gioáng nhö tình traïng aáy. Vaãn coøn thöù       sanh bôûi taø kieán veà söï hieän höõu thaät cuûa caùi ngaõ — gì ñoù khoâng ñuùng. Chuùng ta, nhöõng haønh giaû tu            The common defilements of all beings by the false Thieàn, phaûi phaûi xem xeùt coi mình laø ai vaø thaät söï      views that the ego has real existence. mình muoán thaáy gì trong cuoäc soáng naøy, vaø ngay            Chuùng Sanh Chaáp: Attachment to sentient caùi baûn chaát cuûa söï sinh toàn laø caùi gì. Söï tìm kieám   beinghood—Chaáp veà caùi ‘toâi’ cuûa mình. naøy raát ñoãi töï nhieân—In the "Song of Meditation,"          Chuùng Sanh Chuû: Pajapati (p)—Ba Xaø Ba Ñeà— Hakuin Zenji says, "All sentient beings are                     Sanh Chuû—Name of a deity—Teân cuûa moät vò trôøi.

Chuùng Sanh Coù Trí Tueä: A wisdom-being                        rôøi—Unimpeded function of power relating to Chuùng Sanh Duyeân Töø: Compassion based on                     sentient beings, teaching and taming them without awareness of the suffering of sentient beings—                  abandoning them—See Möôøi Löïc Voâ Ngaïi Duïng. Loøng töø bi döïa treân söï bieát caùi khoå cuûa chuùng         Chuùng Sanh Ma Quyû Ñoäc Ñòa: The evil and sanh.                                                           cruel living creatures. Chuùng Sanh Ñaúng: Rank of sentient beings—Baäc                 Chuùng Sanh Nghieäp Naëng Taâm Taïp: Sentient chuùng sanh.                                                    beings bear heavy karma and their minds are Chuùng Sanh Ñieân Ñaûo: Upside-down state of                    deluded. living beings—See Nhò Chuûng Ñieân Ñaûo.                        Chuùng Sanh Nhaãn: Nhaãn naïi caùc söï naõo haïi cuûa Chuùng Sanh Ñoäc: Sattvakasaya (skt)—Giai ñoaïn                 chuùng sanh, nhö caêm thuø hay lôïi duïng. Nhaãn nhuïc thöù tö trong naêm giai ñoaïn huûy dieät nôi maø moïi           vôùi taát caû moïi chuùng sanh trong moïi tình huoáng— sinh vaät ñeàu ñaàn ñoän vaø baát tònh—The fourth of            Patience of human assaults and insults, i.e., the five periods of decay, when all creatures are               hatred, or abuse. Patience towards all living stupid and unclean.                                             beings under all circumstances. Chuùng Sanh Ñöôøng: Thuûy Luïc Ñöôøng—All                       Chuùng Sanh Quaùn: Contemplation on living Beings Hall.                                                    beings—See Quaùn Chuùng Sanh. Chuùng Sanh Giôùi: Sattaloka (p)—Caûnh giôùi cuûa               Chuùng Sanh Sai Bieät Thaân Ñaïi Tam Muoäi: The taát caû chuùng sanh, ñoái laïi vôùi caûnh giôùi cuûa Phaät —   Great Concentration of Differentiated Bodies of The realm of all the living, in contrast with the               Sentient Beings. Buddha-realm (Phaät giôùi).                                     Chuùng Sanh Tam Chuûng Caên Taùnh: Sentient Chuùng Sanh Haûi: Bieån chuùng sanh—Ocean of                    beings’ three kinds of nature—Theo Phaät giaùo Ñaïi sentient beings—Soá löôïng chuùng sanh raát nhieàu,             Thöøa, ñöùc Phaät ban boá nhöõng giaùo phaùp khaùc ví nhö löôïng nöôùc bieån—The ocean of sentient                 nhau, nhöng choã cuøng toät thì gioáng nhau, kheá hôïp beings, great in number.                                        caên cô ngöôøi nghe, gioáng nhö moat vò löông y tuøy Chuùng Sanh Höõu Tình: Conscious beings.                        theo beänh maø cho thuoác. Noùi caùch khaùc, chö Phaät Chuùng Sanh Kieân Cöôøng: Recalcitrant                          kheá hôïp vôùi ba loaïi caên cô cuûa thính chuùng maø (stronghearted—steadfast) sentient beings.                      thuyeát giaûng ba loaïi giaùo phaùp nhaát nghóa. Vôùi caùc Chuùng Sanh Kieán: False concept of human                       chuùng sinh haï caên, chö Phaät thuyeát Khoâng, Khoå vaø beings—View of sentient beinghood—Voïng kieán                   Voâ Thöôøng. Nhöõng chuùng sinh naøy khi nghe raèng coá chaáp thöïc höõu cuûa chuùng sanh, hay khaùi nieäm          taát caû caùc phaùp ñeàu voâ thöôøng vaø khoå, lieàn thaám cho raèng chuùng sanh coù thaät höõu, chöù khoâng phaûi         thía maø xa lìa, döùt ñöôïc tham duïc ñeå ñeán choã giaûi do nguõ uaån taïo thaønh (cho raèng chuùng sanh khoâng          thoaùt. Vôùi nhöõng chuùng sinh trung caên, chö Phaät laäp thaønh bôûi nguõ uaån). Taø kieán cho raèng thaân töù      thuyeát raèng vaïn phaùp voâ ngaõ, yeân oån, tónh laëng, vaø ñaïi do nguõ uaån hôïp thaønh maø cho laø thöïc, laø            laø Nieát Baøn. Khi nhöõng chuùng sanh naøy nghe raèng thöôøng truï coá ñònh—The concept that all beings               vaïn phaùp laø voâ ngaõ vaø chính laø Nieát Baøn an laïc vaø have reality and the five skandhas as not the                   tónh laëng, hoï döùt ñöôïc tham duïc, chöùng giaûi thoaùt. constituents of the livings (holding to the idea of             Vôùi nhöõng chuùng sanh thöôïng caên, chö Phaät thuyeát the five skandhas as not the constituents of the                raèng vaïn phaùp töï nguyeân lai khoâng sinh dieät, roát living). False view that every man has a                        raùo Khoâng, vaø laø Nieát Baøn. Vì vaäy, trong moät permanent lord within. Wrong view on the                        nghóa, tuøy theo taâm ngaên ngaïi cuûa chuùng sinh maø existence of a permanent ego. The erroneous                     coù söï cao thaáp khaùc nhau—According to the doctrine that the ego or self composed of the                   Mahayana Buddhism, the Buddha offers different, temporary five skandhas, is a reality and                       yet ultimately the same, teachings to people permanent.                                                      according to their capacity to understand, as a Chuùng Sanh Löïc Trì: Support by the power of                   physician prescribes different medicine to various sentient beings.                                                patients according to their illness. In other words, Chuùng Sanh Löïc Voâ Ngaïi Duïng: Chuùng sanh löïc              the Buddhas, accommodating to what living beings voâ ngaïi duïng, vì giaùo hoùa ñieàu phuïc chaúng boû           understand, explain three classes of doctrine

within the one meaning (ekartha). For beings with              nature and enlightenment of all living beings is the dull faculties they declare emptiness, suffering,              same. Outside the mind there is no other thing; and impermanence. These beings, having heard                   mind, Buddha, and all the living, these three are that all dharmas are impermanent and suffering,                not different. There is no differentiating among become profoundly detached, succeed in cutting                 these three because all is mind. All are of the of craving, and attain liberation. For beings with             same order. This is an important doctrine of the medium faculties, they declare that everything is              Hua-Yen sutra. The T’ien-T’ai called “The without self, secure, quiescent, and in nirvana.               Mystery of the Three Things.” T’ien-T’ai Chih I When these beings hear that all dharmas are                    Great Master quotes the Avatamsaka Sutra that without self and consist of only nirvana, security,            "the mind, the Buddha, and sentient beings are not and quiescence, they cut of craving, and gain                  distinct," and emphasizes the unity of the three. liberation. For those with keen faculties, they                Chih I does not use this verse to support a mind- declare that all the dharmas from the very                     only idealism. He propses instead that the mind, or beginning are unarising, unceasing, utterly empty,             one's thoughts, is the most accessible of the three and like nirvana. Therefore, within the one                    dharmas, and thus should be the focus of one's meaning, according to the fetters and mental faults            contemplation and meditation. Since the Buddha, of beings, there are differences of profundities.              objects, other sentient beings, and so forth, are all Chuùng Sanh Taïo Nghieäp, Nghieäp Taïo Chuùng                  part of one reality, they are all included when one Sanh: Chuùng sanh taïo nghieäp, nghieäp taïo chuùng            concentrates on one simple thought. This is sanh, cöù theá maø chuùng sanh laên troâi trong luaân hoài     illustrated with another quote from the sanh töû—Sentient beings create karma, the effect              Avatamsaka Sutra: "If one disports one's mind in of karma will reflect back on sentient beings,                 the dharmadhatu as if in space, then one will know therefore, sentient beings continue to roll in the             the objective realm of all Buddhas." cycle of births and deaths.                                    Chuùng Sanh Thaân: Body of sentient beings (all Chuùng Sanh, Taâm, Phaät Thò Tam Voâ Sai Bieät:                the living). Ba loaïi sai bieät: taâm voâ sai bieät, Phaät voâ sai bieät,   Chuùng Sanh Theá Gian: World of beings—Moät vaø chuùng sanh voâ sai bieät. Ngoaøi taâm ra khoâng coù       trong ba theá gian maø Ñöùc Phaät ñaõ ñeà caäp ñeán gì nöõa; taâm, Phaät vaø chuùng sanh khoâng sai khaùc.         trong Kinh Hoa Nghieâm, töùc laø theá giôùi cuûa chuùng Ñaây laø moät giaùo thuyeát quan troïng trong Kinh Hoa         sanh töø ñòa nguïc leân ñeán Phaät. Taát caû chuùng sanh Nghieâm. Toâng Thieân Thai goïi ñaây laø Tam Phaùp             ñeàu coù theå ñöôïc chuyeån hoùa bôûi Phaät—One of the Dieäu. Thieân Thai trí Khaûi Ñaïi Sö daãn chöùng kinh          three worlds which the Buddha mentioned in The Hoa Nghieâm raèng "Taâm, Phaät vaø chuùng sanh voâ             Flower Adornment Sutra, the world of beings from sai bieät," vaø nhaán maïnh treân taùnh ñoàng nhaát cuûa caû   Hades to Buddha-land. All beings subject to ba thöïc taïi. Trí Khaûi khoâng duøng baøi keä naøy ñeå        transformation by Buddha. ñöa ra chuû thuyeát duy taâm. Thay vaøo ñoù, Ñaïi Sö           Chuùng Sanh Thöôøng Laáy Tam Ñoà AÙc Ñaïo Laøm nhaän ñònh raèng taâm hoaëc nieäm laø phaùp deã thaáy          Nhaø: Sentient beings usually take the three evil nhaát trong ba phaùp, vì vaäy haønh giaû neân chuyeân          paths as their homeland. chuù vaøo phöông phaùp quaùn vaø thieàn. Vì Phaät, caûnh       Chuùng Sanh Tính: Baûn chaát cuûa vaïn vaät höõu giôùi, chuùng sinh, vaân vaân... ñeàu laø moät phaùp giôùi,    tình—Nature of sentient beings. taát caû ñeàu goàm thaâu trong nhaát nieäm. Choã naøy          Chuùng Sanh Tröôïc: Sattvakasaya (skt)—Thôøi kyø cuõng ñöôïc daãn chöùng töø kinh Hoa Nghieäm: "Neáu            chuùng sanh daãy ñaày ngu si ueá tröôïc—Impurity of haønh giaû ñöa taâm vaøo phaùp giôùi nhö hö khoâng, thì        sentient beings, when all creatures are stupid and haønh giaû seõ thaáy bieát caûnh giôùi cuûa taát caû chö       unclean—See Nguõ Tröôïc. Phaät."—The three that are without essential                   Chuùng Sanh Töø Voâ Thæ Ñaõ Taïo Voâ Löôïng Toäi: difference (the three that are of the same nature):            From the immemorial time sentient beings have the nature of mind is the same in Buddhas, men,                committed countless transgressions. and all the living beings; the nature and                      Chuùng Sanh Töùc Phaät, Phieàn Naõo Töùc Boà Ñeà: enlightenment of all Buddhas is the same; and the              Ngoaøi chuùng sanh khoâng coù Phaät, ngoaøi phieàn naõo

khoâng coù Boà ñeà—Sentient beings are Buddhas,                gia giöõ moät vai troø quan troïng trong Phaät giaùo, vì afflictions are bodhi.                                         hoï hoä trì Taêng giaø. Hoï xaây döïng töï vieän. Hoï cuùng Chuùng Sanh Töôùng: Living beings appearance—                  döôøng thöïc phaåm, quaàn aùo, nôi nguû ngheâ vaø thuoác Taát caû chuùng sanh do chaáp ngaõ ñöa vaøo nguõ uaån          men cho chö Taêng Ni. Ñoåi laïi, chö Taêng Ni gaùnh maø sanh chuùng sanh töôùng—Mark of sentient                   vaùc Phaät söï vaø thuyeát giaùo Phaät phaùp cho coäng beings. All the living are produced by the                     ñoàng taïi gia. Baèng caùch naøy caû chö Taêng Ni vaø skandhas. The ego of all beings, that all beings               Phaät töû taïi gia ñeàu laøm lôïi ích cho nhau, hoï cuøng have an ego born of the five skandhas.                         nhau duy trì Phaät phaùp. Duø laø thaønh vieân cuûa Taêng Chuùng Sanh Töôûng: Taø kieán cho raèng chuùng sanh            giaø hay taïi gia, taát caû ñeàu laø Phaät töû vaø hoï neân coá laø thöïc höõu—The false notion that all beings have           gaéng heát söùc mình soáng moät ñôøi soáng phaïm haïnh reality.                                                       cao caû, neâu göông töø bi toát ñeán chuùng sanh muoân Chuùng Sanh Vaát Vaû Trong Cuoäc Soáng Haèng                   loaøi. Duø ñang laøm vieäc hay ñang thieàn ñònh, muïc Ngaøy: Sentient beings must toil and suffer day in             ñích laø laøm lôïi laïc cho tha nhaân vaø cho chính and day out to earn a living.                                  mình—The Buddhist Community consists of two Chuùng Sanh Voâ Ngaõ: Egolessness of sentient                  groups of people, the Sangha and the Laity. The beings—Selflessness of sentient beings—Chuùng                  word “Sangha” means “friendly community”. It sanh khoâng coù söï thöôøng haèng cuûa caùi ngaõ —             usually refers to the Buddhist monks and nuns. Sentient beings as without ego or permanent soul.              They live in monasteries. The laity includes Chuùng Sanh Voâ Ngaïi Duïng: Unimpeded function                Buddhist men and women who do not become relating to sentient beings.                                   monks and nuns. They usually live at home with Chuùng Sanh Voâ Sai Bieät: The nature and                      their families. The first step to becoming a enlightenment of all living beings is the same.                member of the Laity is to go for refuge in the Chuùng Sanh Voâ Thuûy Voâ Chung: Theå cuûa chuùng              Triple Gem (the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha). sanh laø phaùp thaân, maø phaùp thaân thì voâ thæ voâ          Then, they willingly observe the Five Precepts in chung—All beings as part of the dharmakaya                     their daily life. The laity plays an important role in (phaùp thaân), they have no beginning nor end.                 Buddhism, as they care for and support the Chuùng Sanh Y Töïa: The trust of the community.                Sangha. They build the temples and monasteries. Chuùng Saéc Do Taâm Khôûi: Sarvarupavabhasam-                  They give offerings of food, clothing, bedding and hiyada-cittampravartate (skt)—Taát caû saéc ñeàu do            medicine to the Sangha. In return, the Sangha taâm khôûi maø hieän ra—All forms arising from                 carries on the work of Buddhism and teaches the mind—When mind evolves, all forms are                          laity on the Dharma. In this way the Sangha and manifested.                                                    the laity benefit each other and together, they keep the Dharma alive. Whether one is a member Chuùng Ta: See Chuùng Mình. of the Sangha or the laity, they all are Buddhists Chuùng Ta Chaúng Bao Giôø Toaïi Nguyeän: We are and they should do their best to live an honest life, never completely satisfied. show compassion to all living beings and set a Chuùng Taïi Gia: The laity who observe the five good example. Even when they are working or commandments and eight commandments—Coäng meditating, it should be for the benefit of others as ñoàng Phaät giaùo bao goàm hai nhoùm, Taêng giaø vaø well as for themselves. Phaät töû taïi gia. Töø “Taêng giaø” coù nghóa laø “Coäng Chuùng Taêng: Samgha (skt)—Taát caû caùc vò Taêng ñoàng thaân höõu”. Töø naøy thöôøng ñöôïc duøng ñeå chæ trong töï vieän, hay moät taäp hôïp cuûa ít nhaát ba vò chö Taêng Ni. Hoï soáng trong caùc töï vieän. Phaät töû taïi Taêng—All the monks, as an assembly of at least gia bao goàm caû ngöôøi nam laãn ngöôøi nöõ, nhöõng three monks, in a monastery. ngöôøi Phaät töû nhöng khoâng trôû thaønh Taêng Ni. Hoï Chuùng Tha Thieän Nghieäp: Various other good thöôøng soáng taïi gia vôùi gia ñình. Böôùc ñaàu tieân ñeå acts—Coù boán loaïi thieän nghieäp khaùc: khoâng baøy toû trôû thaønh thaønh vieân cuûa coäng ñoàng taïi gia laø quy- thaùi ñoä baát thöôøng khi tu taäp nôi tòch tónh; tu taäp y Tam Baûo (Phaät, Phaùp, Taêng). Sau ñoù thoï trì nguõ phöông phaùp ñaéc nhaân taâm maø khoâng caàu baùo giôùi trong cuoäc soáng haèng ngaøy. Nhöõng ngöôøi taïi ñaùp; baûo veä chaùnh phaùp daàu phaûi hy sinh thaân

maïng cuûa chính mình; ñaët boà ñeà taâm leân treân taát   Chuùng Xuaát Gia: The monks—The clergy—Who caû moïi thieän nghieäp khaùc—There are four other         observe ten, 250 or 348 commandments. good acts: not to show an abnormal behavior                Chuùng Xöng: Samgayashas (skt)—Gia Da Ña when practicing in a quiet place; to practice              Xaù—Taêng Giaø Da Xa, vò toå thöù 18 taïi AÁn Ñoä — methods of winning people over without expecting           The eighteenth patriarch. any reward; to protect the Right Dharma even at            Chuûng: Vija or Bija (skt)—Gieo troàng: To plant, the sacrifice of one's life; to place the Bodhi-mind       to sow—Haït: Seed, germ, species—Yeáu toá: above any other good acts.                                 Element (Maha-bhata (p & skt). Chuùng Thanh: Caùc loaïi aâm thanh khaùc nhau—             Chuûng Caên Khí: See A Laïi Da Thöùc Tam Chuûng Various sounds.                                            Caûnh. Chuùng Thaùnh: Chö Thaùnh: All saints—Taát caû caùc        Chuûng Chuûng: Vicitratva or Vicitrata (skt)— baäc ñaõ chöùng ñöôïc chaân lyù nhaø Phaät: All who have   Nhieàu loaïi hay ña daïng—Multiplicity— realized the Buddha-truth.                                 Manifoldness—Multitudinousness. Chuùng Thaønh Töïu: Perfect assembly—Laáy caùc             Chuûng Chuûng Bieän Taøi Ñaø La Ni: Mental chöõ “Ñaïi Tyø Kheo Chuùng” laøm chuùng thaønh töïu—       command of various intellectual powers—Raát “With the great assembly of bhiksus” implies the           nhieàu loaïi Bieän Taøi Ñaø La Ni, vì dieãn noùi voâ bieân perfect assembly—See Luïc Thaønh Töïu.                     nhöõng Phaät phaùp—Mental command of various Chuùng Thieân: Sanghadeva (skt)—Taêng Giaø Ñeà             intellectual powers, as they expound boundless Baø—Teân cuûa moät vò sö AÁn Ñoä vaøo theá kyû thöù tö—    Buddha teachings. Name of an Indian monk in the fourth century.              Chuûng Chuûng Cung Ñieän Thaàn: Various Chuùng Tröôùng: Census of monks and nuns—Ñôøi              Mansions Deity (Spirit). nhaø Ñöôøng chö Taêng Ni phaûi ñaêng kyù ba naêm moät      Chuûng Chuûng Dieäm Nhaõn Thaàn: Eyes of laàn—The T’ang dynasty register, or census of              Various Flames Deity (Spirit). monks and nuns, supplied to the government                 Chuûng Chuûng Duyeân: Caùc loaïi duyeân khaùc every three years.                                         nhau—Various kinds of conditions. Chuùng Tuï Thôøi Y: Sanghati (p)—Samghati                  Chuûng Chuûng Giaûi Trí Löïc: Nanadhimukti-jnana (skt)—See Ñaïi Y.                                          (skt)—Nana-dhimutti-katanana (p)—Bieát roõ caù Chuùng Töø: Xöng hoâ ñoái vôùi taêng chuùng, duøng ñeå     tính cuûa chuùng sanh. goïi caùc oâng hay caùc vò—Term is used to address         Chuûng Chuûng Giôùi Trí Löïc: Nana-dhatu-jnana- between monks in a monastery, i.e., your dear              bala (skt)—Various kinds of power of the wisdom listeners, gentlemen, and so on.                           on different realms. Chuùng Töï Taïi Vöông: Lord of the Masses.                 Chuûng Chuûng Khoå: Caùc loaïi khoå khaùc nhau— Chuùng Tyø Kheo: Bhikkhu-samgha (p)—Bhiksu-                Various kinds suffering. sangha (skt)—The order of fully ordained monks.            Chuûng Chuûng Nhaân: Caùc loaïi nhaân khaùc nhau— Chuùng Tyø Kheo Ni: Bhikkhuni-samgha (p)—                  Various kinds of causes. Bhiksuni-sangha (skt)—The order of fully                   Chuûng Chuûng Nhaân Duyeân: Caùc loaïi nhaân vaø ordained nuns.                                             duyeân khaùc nhau—Various kinds of causes and Chuùng Vò: Caùc vò khaùc nhau—Various tastes.              conditions. Chuùng Vieân: Samgharama (skt)—Chuùng Lieâu: A             Chuûng Chuûng Saéc Theá Giôùi: Theá giôùi cuûa moïi monastery, a nunnery—Nhaø vöôøn coù raøo bao boïc:         loaøi—Various kinds of worlds—A world of every The surrounding park.                                      kind of thing. Chuùng Xa Uyeån: Caitrarathavana (skt)—Park of             Chuûng Chuûng Tính: Caùc loaïi tính khaùc nhau— chariots—Chuùng Xa Uyeån ôû veà phöông Ñoâng, moät         Various kinds of natures—Various natures. trong boán nôi vui thuù beân ngoaøi Thieän Kieán           Chuûng Chuûng Trang Nghieâm Vöông: King of Thaønh, thaønh phoá cuûa coõi trôøi Ñeá Thích—The park     Various Adornments. of chariots in the east, one of the four pleasure          Chuûng Chuûng Trì Sôn Vöông: See Tyø Ñaø Leâ grounds outside of Sudarsana, the heavenly city of         Sôn Vöông. Indra.

Chuûng Ñòa: Gotra-bhumi (skt)—See Taùnh Ñòa.                 Chuûng Toäc: Race. Chuûng Ñöùc: 1) Nhieàu loaïi coâng ñöùc: Various             Chuûng Toäc Thích Ca: Sakyans. kinds of virtues; 2) Teân cuûa moät vò Baø La Moân:          Chuûng Trí: Nhaát thieát chuûng trí cuûa Phaät, laø loaïi Sonadanda (p)—Name of a Brahman.                             chuûng trí bieát heát taát caû caùc loaïi phaùp— Chuûng Giaùc: Phaät chöùng nhaát thieát chuûng trí maø       Omniscience, knowledge of the seed or cause of ñaïi giaùc vieân maõn—The insight into all seeds or          all phenomena. causes, Buddha-knowledge, omniscience.                       Chuûng Töû: Bija (skt)—Seed—Germ—Haït gioáng Chuûng Hoïc Phaùp: Sekhiya-dhamma (p)— Saiksa-               cuûa taát caû hieän haønh phaùp höõu laäu vaø voâ laäu. A Laïi dharma (skt)—Shaiksha-dharma—See Chuùng Hoïc                 Da Thöùc laø nôi chöùa ñöïng chuûng töû cuûa taát caû moïi Phaùp.                                                       hieän töôïng. Maät giaùo cuõng coi moät vaøi maãu töï Chuûng Loaïi: Various kinds of things.                       Phaïn, ñaëc bieät laø chöõ “a,” ñöôïc coi nhö laø chuûng töû Chuûng Loaïi Caâu Sinh: Caùc loaïi ñoàng thôøi sanh          chöùa ñöïng löïc sieâu nhieân—The seed, or cause, of ra, ñoái laïi vôùi do huaân taäp maø coù—Various kinds       all phenomena. The content of alayavijnana as the of spontaneous and inborn things, as opposed to              seed of all phenomena. The esoterics also have acquire.                                                     certain Sanskrit letters, especially the first letter Chuûng Loaïi Caâu Sinh Voâ Sôû Taùc YÙ Sinh                  “a” as a seed or germ containing supernatural Thaân: Nikaya-sahaja-samskarakrya-manomaya-                  power. kaya (skt)—Caùc loaïi ñoàng thôøi sanh ra vôùi caùi taâm     Chuûng Töû Baát Tònh: Impure seed—Haït gioáng voâ taùc hay khoâng hoaït ñoäng (ñoái laïi vôùi do huaân     chaúng saïch (nghieäp nhaân phieàn naõo laø gioáng beân taäp maø coù)—Various kinds of spontaneous and               trong vaø theå xaùc cha meï laø gioáng beân ngoaøi ñeàu inborn things with an inactive mind (as opposed to           baát tònh). Thaân naày do nôi nghieäp daâm duïc, töø haït acquire).                                                    gioáng tham aùi maø sanh—Unclean parental seed. Chuûng Quaû: See Quaû.                                       This body is born from the karma of lust and Chuûng Taùnh: Gotra (skt)—Gotrastha (skt)—                   attachment. Chuûng laø haït gioáng, coù nghóa laø phaùt sinh naûy nôû.   Chuûng Töû Hieän Tieàn: Hieän haønh chuûng töû— Tính laø tính chaát khoâng thay ñoåi—Seed nature,            Active seed. germ nature; derivative or inherited nature.                 Chuûng Töû-Hoaøn Caûnh-Ñieàu Kieän: Seed- Chuûng Taùnh Ñòa: Gotra-bhumi (skt)—See Taùnh                Circumstances-Conditions—Ñaây laø ba yeáu toá raát Ñòa.                                                         quan troïng trong giaùo lyù Phaät giaùo. Theo Phaät Chuûng Thuïc Thoaùt: Theo thuyeát cuûa toâng Thieân          giaùo, khoâng coù nhaân aét khoâng coù quaû. Tuy nhieân, Thai—According to the T’ien-T’ai’s doctrine.                 duø coù nhaân maø thieáu hoaøn caûnh vaø ñieàu kieän cho 1) Chuûng: Chuùng sanh ban ñaàu coøn meâ muoäi,              quaû phaùt sanh, laïi cuõng khoâng coù quaû—These are nhôø söï thieän xaûo cuûa Phaät, maø gieo ñöôïc vaøo    three most important elements in Buddhist hoï chuûng töû Phaät: The seed of Buddha-truth          theories. According to Buddhist theories, without a implanted.                                              seed nothing would happen. However, even 2) Thuïc: Nhôø gaëp gôõ vaø duøng phöông tieän, maø          though there is a seed, if it is lacking of haït gioáng naày ñöôïc thaønh thuïc—Its ripening.       surrounding circumstances and conditions, there 3) Thoaùt: Chuûng töû ñaõ thaønh thuïc töùc laø giaûi        will not be any effect on that seed. thoaùt—Its liberation or harvest.                       Chuûng Töû Luïc Nghóa: Six characteristics of Chuûng Thöùc: Alayavijnana (skt)—See A Laïi Da               seeds—Saùu ñaëc tröng cuûa chuûng töû. Thöùc.                                                       Chuûng Töû Maïn Ñoà La: See Phaùp Maïn Ñaø La. Chuûng Tính: Gotra (skt)—Gotrastha (skt)—Seed                Chuûng Töû Nghieäp: Karmabija (skt)—Karma- nature—See Chuûng Taùnh.                                     seed—See Nghieäp Chuûng. Chuûng Tính Truï: The attainment of the Buddha-              Chuûng Töû Nhö Lai: Buddhahood—The seed of seed.                                                        Tathagata—See Chuûng Töû Phaät and Nhö Lai Chuûng Tính Vò: Giai ñoaïn tieàm naêng baåm sinh—            Chuûng. Stage of innate potentiality.                                Chuûng Töû Phaät: Chuûng töû Phaät hay Boà Taùt, neáu ñem gieo vaøo taâm thöùc con ngöôøi, seõ naåy maàm

Phaät hay giaùc ngoä—The seed of Buddhahood—                   Chuûng Töï: Bija-mantra (skt)—Seed Syllable— Bodhisattva seeds which sown in the heart of man,              Thöïc taïi toái thöôïng ñöôïc coâ ñoïng trong moät aâm produce the Buddha fruit or enlightenment.                     thanh bieåu töôïng. Chuûng Töû Phaät Phaùp: The seed of Buddha                     Chuoäc Loãi: To redeem a fault—To make up for teaching—Moät khi chuûng töû Phaät phaùp ñaõ ñöôïc             one’s faults—Atonement—Phaät giaùo khoâng nhaán gieo troàng trong taâm thì khoâng sôùm thôøi muoän noù         maïnh vaøo söï chuoäc loãi; maø moãi ngöôøi phaûi töï tu seõ troå quaû—When the seed of Buddha teaching is              haønh laáy ñeå giaûi thoaùt. Chuùng ta coù theåø giuùp ngöôøi sown in the heart , it will be ripen sooner or later.          baèng lôøi noùi hay haønh ñoäng, nhöng chuùng ta khoâng Chuûng Töû Phuïc Ñoaïn: Söï ñoaïn dieät baèng caùch            theå gaùnh vaùc haäu quaû gaây neân bôûi toäi loãi cuûa ngöôøi cheá ngöï caùc chuûng töû—Quelling elimination of              khaùc. Tuy nhieân, Phaät giaùo nhaán maïnh vaøo loøng töø seeds.                                                         bi cöùu ñoä chuùng sanh thoaùt khoå cuûa chö Boà Taùt— Chuûng Töû Sôû Sanh: Do chuûng töû cuûa a laïi da thöùc        Buddhism does not stress on atonement; each maø coù—Produced from seeds in the alaya                       person must work out his own salvation. We can consciousness.                                                 help others by thoughts, words, and deeds, but we Chuûng Töû Thieàn: Seed of Zen—Zen seed—Ngaøy                  cannot bear another’s results or take over noï, thieàn sö Shosan noùi veà moät thieàn sinh môùi ñeán:     consequences of another’s errors or misdeeds. "Anh ta seõ laø moät thieàn gia ñaày höùa heïn ñaây! Anh       However, Buddhism stresses on compassion of ta noùi raèng daàu coù tai hoïa gì ñi nöõa thì anh ta vaãn     Bodhisattvas which help other beings relieve muoán töø giaû coõi ñôøi naøy moät caùch bình thaûn nhö        sufferings. ñang daïo chôi quanh laøng vaäy!" Nghe theá, moät              Chuoãi: Rosary—String of beads for counting thieàn sinh trong nhoùm noùi: "Anh ta chæ nghó ñöôïc           prayers. ñeán theá thoâi, chöù chöa ñuû tö chaát ñeå haønh thieàn!"     Chuoãi Ngoïc: Keruva (skt)—Necklace of pearl— Sö Shosan noùi: "Daãu raèng chæ nghó ñöôïc ñeán theá           Necklace of diamond—Chuoãi Anh Laïc. thoâi, anh ta vaãn laø ngöôøi ñang mang trong mình             Chuoãi Nieäm Phaät: Pasakamala (skt)—See Chuoãi chuûng töû Thieàn toâng ñaáy!"—One day Zen master              Traøng Haït. Shosan said of a new coming Zen student, "So-                  Chuoãi Traøng Haït: String of beads—Moät daây and-so is a great practitioner, is he not? He says             chuoãi traøng haït gioáng nhö xuyeán ñeo coå, ñöôïc that no matter what kind of plague he may die                  duøng ñeå laàn trong luùc nieäm Phaät hay nieäm chuù from, he wants to die as calmly as if he were                  trong caùc tröôøng phaùi Phaät giaùo—A string of beads taking a walk in the neighborhood." One of the                 resembling a bracelet, used for counting during students in the group said, "He just thinks that               reciting a Buddha name or a mantra in various way; he's not the kind of man to do Zen practice."             sects of Buddhism. The master said, "Even if that is so, still he is a            Chuoâng: Ghanta (skt)—A bell—Coù raát nhieàu loaïi man with the seed of great Zen practice."                      chuoâng duøng cho nhieàu muïc ñích khaùc nhau trong Chuûng Töû Thöùc: Alaya-vijnana (skt)—Chuûng töû               töï vieän. Moãi ngaøy chuoâng ngaân vang ít nhaát boán cô baûn vì töø ñoù maø phaùt sanh ra moïi phaùp, moïi vaät;    naêm laàn. Buoåi saùng chuoâng baùo giôø cho chö Taêng gioáng nhö töø haït gioáng naày maø sanh ra caây coái hoa      thöùc daäy, vaøo khoaûng ba giôø röôõi, chuoâng ngaân quaû. Teân khaùc cuûa A Laïi Da Thöùc (vì giöõ gìn ñöôïc       buoåi chieàu ñeå baét ñaàu buoåi thieàn ñònh chieàu, vaø taát caû caùc haït gioáng theá gian, höõu laäu vaø voâ laäu,   buoåi toái ñeå tieáp tuïc tu taäp trong khi naèm, thöôøng laø neân ñöôïc goïi laø Chuûng Töû Thöùc)—Seeds mind,              vaøo khoaûng chín hay chín giôø röôõi. Theo Thieàn Sö because from it spring all individualities, or                 D.T. Suzuki trong quyeån "Söï Huaán Luyeän cuûa Moät particulars. Another name for Alaya-vijnana. The               Thieàn Taêng", tinh thaàn Phaät giaùo lieân heä maät thieát abode or seed-store of consciousness from which                vôùi ñaïi hoàng chung, neáu khoâng coù chuoâng chuùng ta all phenomena spring, producing and reproducing                khoâng theå nghó veà ñôøi soáng trong töï vieän. YÙ nghóa momentarily—See A Laïi Da Thöùc.                               cuûa chuoâng ñöôïc hieån loä moät caùch yù nghóa nhaát: Chuûng Töû Vónh Ñoaïn: Vónh vieãn tieâu tröø ñöôïc             khi ñeâm ñeán, maây laïnh hôn, khoâng khí hoaøn toaøn heát caùc chuûng töû—Permanent eliminaiton of                  tónh laëng, traêng non môø nhaït baét ñaàu loù daïng, chim seeds.                                                         muoâng ñaõ meät nhoaøi sau moät ngaøy lao ñoäng vaát

vaû, tìm veà toå nghæ ñeâm giöõa ñaùm caây trong nuùi, luùc   stick to a small octagonal wooden bell to cause (to aáy chuoâng baét ñaàu ngaân vang baùo hieäu sinh hoaït        order) the assembly to remain silent. buoåi chieàu. Khi khoái kim loaïi roãng kia ñöôïc ñaùnh       Chuøy Chaâm: Vôùi vò taêng naøo phaïm vieäc aùc moät vaøo bôûi moät thanh goã naëng, moät aâm thanh nheï           caùch nghieâm troïng thì duøng roi ñaùnh maø ñuoåi ñi. nhaøng, vang doäi, laøm laéng loøng ngöôøi ñöôïc phaùt        Ñaây laø hình phaït naëng nhaát trong nhaø thieàn—A ra, traøn ñaày vaø aâm voïng khaép caû thung luõng—           Zen monk who commits a gravest offense will be There are several kinds of bell used in the                   expelled by striking with a staff. This is the most monastery for different purposes. Usually it rings            serious offense in Zen. regularly at least four or five times a day; in the           Chuûy Ñoâ Loâ: Noùi nhieàu lôøi—Talkative. morning it reports the time for the monks to wake             Chuûy Thöôïng Gia Chuûy: Treân mieäng laïi gaén up, which is about half past three, and in the                theâm mieäng, chæ cho vieäc laøm dö thöøa voâ ích—To evening to start their evening meditation, and at             add more mouths to the mouth, i.e., an night to keep up their exercise in a reclining                unnecessary and wasteful work. position, which is about nine or half past nine.              Chuyeân: Chæ moät—Solely. According to Zen master D.T. Suzuki in "The                   Chuyeân Caàn: Industrious. Training of the Zen Buddhist Monk" (p.120), the               Chuyeân Caàn Löïc: Power of diligence—Naêng löïc spirit of Buddhism is most intimately connected               cuûa söï chuyeân caàn—Theo Laït Ma Khenchen with the big bell, apart from which we cannot                 Thrangu trong “Thöïc Haønh veà Thieàn Chæ vaø Thieàn think of the monastery life. The meaning of the               Quaùn”, naêng löïc cuûa söï chuyeân caàn taïo ra söï oån bell is revealed in a most significant way: when              ñònh tinh thaàn, ñoù laø taâm bình yeân hoaøn toaøn. Ñoái the dusk approaches, the clouds grows chillier, the           vôùi nhöõng chöôùng ngaïi heát söùc maïnh meõ, gioáng air is perfectly still, the pale and almost                   nhö taâm traïng khoâng vui, nuoái tieác hoaëc ngay caû indistinguishable new moon is about to set, and               söï kích ñoäng veà suy nghó nhöõng ñaëc tính toát cuûa the birds quite tired after a day's labour seek their         thieàn seõ khoâng loaïi boû ñöôïc chuùng ngay töùc khaéc. nests for the night among the mountain trees, then            Chuùng ta caàn phaûi coù naêng löïc chuyeân caàn ñeå loaïi the bell begins to ring its evening mission. As the           boû nhöõng chöôùng ngaïi maïnh meõ nhö söï chaáp thuû solid body of metal hollowed out is struck with a             kích ñoäng vaø voâ minh—According to Lama heavy piece of wood, a soft, resonant, soul-                  Khenchen Thrangu in “The Practice of Tranquility pacifying sound issues from it, which fills and               and Insight”, the power of diligence creates reverberates through the entire valley.                       mental stability, which is complete pacification. Chuoâng Caûnh Tænh Haønh Giaû: A ringing bell                 With very strong obstacles such as unhappiness, which is awakening cultivators.                               regret, or aggression, just thinking of good Chuoâng Gia Trì: Gong.                                        qualities of meditation will not eliminate them Chuoäng: To be fond of—To esteem—To like—                     right away. Instead, one needs the power of To love.                                                      diligence so that one can eliminate all strong Chuoäng Caùi Hoïc Qua Kinh Ñieån Maø Queân Ñi                 obstacles such as attachment, aggression, and Phaàn Thöïc Haønh: To prefer to make use of the               ignorance and creates the state of complete education or the study of Buddhist sutras and                 pacification. forget the practices.                                         Chuyeân Chính: Absolutism. Chuoäng Taùnh Queân Töôùng: To prefer nature                  Chuyeân Ñoïc Tuïng: Chuyeân Ñoïc Tuïng kinh while neglecting marks.                                       ñieån—Devotion in reciting or reading sutras. Chuoäng Töôùng Queân Taùnh: To prefer marks                   Chuyeân Leã: Devotion in worship. while neglecting nature.                                      Chuyeân Nhöùt: To devote to one thing. Chuøy: Kieàm chuøy: A heavy thrashing (khí cuï trong          Chuyeân Nhöùt Coâng Phu: Single-mindedly make loø reøn)—Kim nhoïn: A sharp needle—See Chaâm                 effort. Chuøy.                                                        Chuyeân Nieäm: To attend upon—To fix the Chuøy Chaâm: Duøng duøi goõ vaøo caùi buïc goã nhoû ñeå       thought on—To think of—To be drawn to— khieán ñaïi chuùng giöõ im laëng—To strike a wooden           Chuyeân nieäm hoàng danh Phaät hay chuyeân chuù

nieäm vaøo moät caûnh. Raøng buoäc yù nieäm theo moät        To concentrate on—To give all one’s attention höôùng nhaát ñònh, chaúng nghó gì khaùc, ñeâm ngaøy          to—With single mind—Whole-heartedly. thöôøng raøng buoäc nhaát nieäm, chôù nghó tôùi caûnh        Chuyeân Tín: Vaên thö chính thöùc cuûa töï vieän— duïc—Devotion in invocation of the name of                   Monastery official document. Amitabha Buddha or solely to invoke a certain                Chuyeân Tinh: Solely or purely. Buddha. Fix the mind on one thing, or fix the                Chuyeân Trì Danh Haïnh: Nhöõng vò chæ chuyeân thoughts on one thing, not thinking of desires.              nieäm Phaät, khoâng xen taïp moân naøo khaùc, thuoäc veà Chuyeân Nieäm Thò Hieän: Adesana-patiharia (p)—              caùc haønh giaû tu haïnh Thuaàn Tònh. Trong ñaây caùc Adesana-pratiharya (skt)—Khi haønh giaû chuyeân              vò caên cô cao thì theo Thaäp Luïc Quaùn, coøn ñaïi ña chuù nieäm vaøo caûnh giôùi cuûa moät ñöùc Phaät naøo ñoù    soá chæ chuyeân veà haïnh trì danh—The fourth thì ngaøi seõ thò hieän vì Ngaøi coù Tha Taâm Luaân—         category of cultivators comprises those who When practitioners solely attend upon (solely                practice Buddha Recitation diligently and invoke) a certain Buddha, that Buddha will appear            exclusively without cultivating other methods. to support them because He has the wheel of                  Within this group, those of high capacities practice knowing the other's mind.                                    the sixteen Meditations as taught in the Chuyeân Nieäm Tö Duy: To fix the thought on—To               Meditation Sutra, while the great majority only think of—To be drawn to—See Chuyeân Nieäm                    practice oral recitation of the Buddha's name. Chuyeân Quaùn: Devotion in meditation.                       Chuyeân Tu: Chief or sole duty—Focused Chuyeân Söù: Vò taêng chòu traùch nhieäm giaûi quyeát        practice—Sole or single-minded—Chuyeân tu laø caùc vaán ñeà beân ngoaøi töï vieän—A monk who is            choïn laáy moät phaùp moân duy nhaát naøo ñoù roài y theo responsible to solve external problems.                      phaùp moân aáy maø tu cho ñeán suoát ñôøi khoâng thay Chuyeân Taùn Thaùn Chö Phaät: Devotion in                    ñoåi; thí duï nhö choïn phaùp moân Tònh Ñoä thì suoát praising Buddhas.                                            ñôøi chæ chuyeân nieäm Phaät caàu vaõng sanh maø thoâi. Chuyeân Taïp Nhò Tu: Two kinds of practices:                 Neáu tu thieàn thì chæ chuù taâm vaøo thieàn quaùn maø Chief or sole duty (focused practice or sole or              thoâi, chöù khoâng neân nay tu phaùp moân naày, mai ñoåi single-minded)          and      Sundry          practices   phaùp moân khaùc—Focused practice is to selct a (miscellaneous or varied, aids thereto or                    single Dharma Door and then practice according adjunctive observances)—Chuyeân tu laø choïn laáy            to the teachings of that Dharma Door for the moät phaùp moân duy nhaát naøo ñoù roài y theo phaùp         remainder of the cultivator’s life without changing moân aáy maø tu cho ñeán suoát ñôøi khoâng thay ñoåi.        and mixing in other practices. For example, once a Taïp tu coù nghóa laø ngöôøi thaáy ai tu phaùp moân gì       person chooses to practice Pureland Buddhism, cuõng baét chöôùc theo caû, thay ñoåi lieàn lieàn. Nay tu    then for the entire life, he should always and often Tònh Ñoä, mai tu Thieàn, moát tuïng kinh. Nay tuïng          focus his energy into reciting the Buddha’s kinh naày, mai tuïng kinh khaùc, vaân vaân—Focused           virtuous name and pray to gain rebirth. If he or she practice is to selct a single Dharma Door and then           chooses to practice meditation, he or she should practice according to the teachings of that Dharma           always focus on meditation and contemplation. Door for the remainder of the cultivator’s life              Thus, the wrong thing to do is to practice one without changing and mixing in other practices.              Dharma Door one day and switch to another the Sundry practices mean combining practices, also              next. referred to as “Mixed Cultivation.” This refers to           Chuyeân Tu Voâ Giaùn: Uninterrupted cultivation— cultivators who mimic others’ practices depending            Theo thuyeát Chuyeân Tu Voâ Giaùn cuûa Trung Quoác on who is practicing what at the time. Thus, they            Tònh Ñoä Lieân Toâng Nhò Toå laø ngaøi Thieän Ñaïo Ñaïi are constantly mixing and changing their practices           Sö, Nhöùt Taâm Nieäm Phaät A Di Ñaø caàn phaûi hoäi ñuû by practicing Pureland one day, Zen the next, and            caùc ñieàu kieän sau ñaây: khoâng leã taïp nhaïp, khoâng then another day chanting one Sutra, only to                 xöng taïp hieäu, vaø khoâng töôûng taïp nieäm — switch to a different Sutra the next day, etc.               According to the “Uninterrupted Cultivation” Chuyeân Taâm: Chuyeân chuù taâm hay taäp trung tö            method of the the Second Patriarch of Chinese töôûng vaøo moät vaán ñeà gì—To apply oneself to—            Pureland Buddhism, the Great Venerable Master

Sen-Tao, in order for recitation to be considered a           Chuyeån Di Coâng Ñöùc: Parinama (skt)—Hoài “Singlemindedness on Buddha Recitation of                     Höôùng Coâng Ñöùc—Transference of merits. Amitabha Buddha,” it is necessary to have the                 Chuyeån Di Taâm Thöùc: Pravrttijnana (skt)—Thieàn following criteria: One must often prostrate to               ñònh taâm          truyeàn taâm —Transference            of Amitabha Buddha, and not prostrate in a random                consciousness meditation—Mind transference. or disorderly way, not recite in a random and                 Chuyeån Dieäu Phaùp Luaân: Tenmyohorin (jap)— disorderly way, and not think in a random and                 Turning the Wonderful Dharma-wheel—See disorderly way.                                               Chuyeån Phaùp Luaân. Chuyeån: Ten (jap)—1) Ñoåi: To change into; 2)                Chuyeån Ñaïi: Ñoïc löôùt qua moät quyeån kinh—To Thuyeân chuyeån: To transfer.                                 roll or unroll a scripture-roll—See Chuyeån Kinh Chuyeån Baûn Theå: Chuyeån töø baûn theå naøy sang            (2) and Chuyeån Ñaïi Baùt Nhaõ Kinh. baûn       theå      khaùc—Transubstantiate         (v)—      Chuyeån Ñaïi Baùt Nhaõ Kinh: Ñoïc löôùt qua 600 Transubstantiation (n)—Ngoaïi ñaïo cho raèng coù caùi         quyeån Kinh Ñaïi Baùt Nhaõ ñeå mong ñöôïc coâng ñöùc goïi laø “ñaáng toaøn naêng” coù theå chuyeån ñöôïc baûn      (chæ ñoïc nhöõng doøng ôû ñaàu, giöõa vaø cuoái kinh) To theå cuûa con ngöôøi töø baûn theå naøy sang baûn theå        turn over the leaves of the scan for acquiring khaùc—Externalists believe that there exists a so-            merit, the 600 books of the complete Prajna- called        “Almighty       Creator”      who        can    paramita. transubstantiate human beings.                                Chuyeån Ñaïo: Caûi sang ñaïo khaùc—Proselytizing. Chuyeån Baùnh Xe Phaùp: Turning The Wheel of                  Chuyeån Ñaïo (1872-1943): Teân cuûa moät vò Taêng the Dharma.                                                   ngöôøi Trung Quoác vaøo cuoái thôøi nhaø Thanh (1644- Chuyeån Baát Thoái Phaùp Luaân: Chö Phaät chuyeån             1912)—Name of a famous Chinese monk in the baát thoái Phaùp luaân, vì laøm cho chö Boà Taùt chaúng       end of the Ch'ing dynasty. thoái chuyeån—Turn the irreversible wheel of the              Chuyeån Ñoïc: Ten-doku (jap)—Read by Teaching and to cause the Enlightening Beings                 revolving—Taïi haàu heát caùc Thieàn vieän ôû Nhaät not to backslide.                                             Baûn, vaøo nhöõng cô hoäi ñaëc bieät naøo ñoù, Kinh Ñaïi Chuyeån Bieán: Parinama (skt)—Transform—                      Baùt Nhaõ saùu traêm quyeån cuõng ñöôïc ñoïc baèng Change—Evolve—Söï chuyeån bieán hay khoâng                    phöông phaùp "Chuyeån Ñoäc". Bôûi vì kinh quaù daøi, ngöøng thay ñoåi (nhaân duyeân sinh ra caùc phaùp,            khoâng theå naøo tuïng ñoïc heát trong moät khoaûng thôøi nhaân duyeân noái tieáp taùc ñoäng aûnh höôûng keát hôïp      gian nhaát ñònh. Saùu traêm quyeån kinh ñöôïc phaân vôùi nhau thaønh ra moïi söï vaät coù hình töôùng, coù teân   chia giöõa caùc Thieàn Taêng vaø moãi vò Taêng ñoïc hai goïi, coù ñaëc tính khaùc nhau, nhöng taát caû ñeàu phaûi     hoaëc ba trang cuûa phaàn môû ñaàu vaø phaàn cuoái cuûa traûi qua boán thôøi kyø sanh, truï, dò, dieät)—All the       moãi quyeån trong khi phaàn giöõa ñöôïc ñoïc baèng transformations are to be regarded as due to                  caùch laät qua toaøn quyeån vaøi laàn; do ñoù môùi coù erroneous discrimination.                                     thuaät ngöõ "Chuyeån Ñoäc". Moãi quyeån kinh goàm Chuyeån Bieán Voâ Thöôøng: Söï chuyeån bieán vaø voâ          moät tôø giaáy daøi vaø chaéc, ñöôïc gaáp laïi thaønh nhieàu thöôøng—Change and impermanence.                              trang, vaø khi caùc vò Taêng ñoïc baèng caùch "Chuyeån", Chuyeån Caùch Lan: Ñi voøng tam boä nhöùt baùi                kinh troâng gioáng nhö nhieàu mieáng vaûi maøu vaøng quanh Chuøa Trung Taâm Lhasa, ñeå caàu nguyeän                bay trong khoâng. Vaø ñaëc bieät bôûi vì chö Taêng ñoïc tieâu tai caùt töôøng—The circuit of the central Lhasa        tuïng vang vang, neân toaøn caûnh voâ cuøng soáng ñoäng. temple, made by prostrations every third step, to             Vieäc tuïng ñoïc kinh haøm chöùa ñaày nhöõng lôïi laïc get rid of evils or obtain blessing.                          taâm linh khoâng nhöõng cho nhöõng ngöôøi ñoïc maø caû Chuyeån Chieáu Theá Phaùp Luaân: Turn the world-              cho nhöõng ngöôøi ñöôïc hoài höôùng coâng ñöùc. illuminating wheel of Teaching, to cause all                  Thöôøng thì ba buoåi saùng sôùm ñaàu naêm ñöôïc daønh sentient beings to purify their vision of reality—            ñeå tieán haønh leã "Chuyeån Ñoäc" naøy trong taát caû caùc Chuyeån chieáu theá phaùp luaân, vì laøm cho taát caû         thieàn vieän ôû Nhaät, luùc aáy ngöôøi ta khoâng chæ thaønh chuùng sanh ñöôïc tònh phaùp nhaõn.                           khaån caàu nguyeän cho quoác thaùi daân an, maø coøn Chuyeån Cô: Tenki (jap)—Ñieåm chuyeån—A                       cho caû neàn hoøa bình cuûa theá giôùi—In most turning point.                                                Japanese Zen monasteries, on some special

occasions the Maha-prajna-paramita Sutras in six               duøng moät thöù kyû luaät noäi taïi ñeå chuyeån ñoåi taâm. hundred fascicules are read in the way known as                Trong cuoäc soáng haèng ngaøy, thöôøng thì con ngöôøi "Ten-doku" (Chuan-tu in Chinese). "Ten-doku"                   chuùng ta luoân kinh qua hai traïng thaùi ñoái nghòch means to read revolving (read by revolving). As                nhau (coù aûnh höôûng tröïc tieáp ñeán taâm con ngöôøi): the sutras are of such a bulk, they cannot be                  haïnh phuùc vaø khoå ñau. Duø chuùng ta khoâng muoán finished with a prescribed period. The six hundred             baøn luaän xa ñeå phaân bieät veà moät caùi thöùc trong volumes are divided among the monks and each                   tieåu ñeà naøy, ai trong chuùng ta cuõng phaûi thöøa nhaän monk reads two or three pages in the beginning                 raèng ngoaøi caùi cô theå hieån hieän chuùng ta coøn moät and at the end of each volume while the middle                 phaàn khaùc thoáng trò caû phaàn cô theå aáy. Ai trong part is read by turning over the entire volume for a           chuùng ta cuõng phaûi ñoàng yù raèng kinh nghieäm veà few times; hence the phrase "read by revolving."               khoå ñau vaø haïnh phuùc khoâng ñôn thuaàn xaûy ra nôi Each volume consisting of one long sheet of                    thaân theå chuùng ta, maø noù baét nguoàn töø moät choã strong paper is folded up to so many folios, and               tröøu töôïng beân trong maø ñaïo Phaät goïi noù laø “taâm”. when the monks read them "by revolving" the                    Theo ñaïo Phaät, nhöõng sinh hoaït tinh thaàn maïnh sutras look as if they were so many long narrow                meõ döôùi hình thöùc tình caûm vaø tö töôûng, maïnh meõ pieces of yellow cloth flying in the air. And                  ñeán noãi chuùng coù khaû naêng thoáng trò luoân caû kinh especially because they recite them at the top of              nghieäm veà theå xaùc. Ñaây laø ñieåm then choát trong their voices, the whole scene is quite a lively one.           ñaïo Phaät, vì töø quan ñieåm naøy chuùng ta môùi thöøa The reading of the sutras is full of spiritual                 nhaän raèng tu chính laø chuyeån hoùa taâm, vaø chuyeån benefits not onle for readers themselves but for all           hoùa taâm chính laø tu. Vaø töø chính quan ñieåm naøy to whom the merit is dedicated. Generally, the                 chuùng ta thöøa nhaän raèng chính traïng thaùi taâm, bao first three early mornings of the New Year are                 goàm thaùi ñoä, tö töôûng vaø tình caûm, ñoùng vai troø devoted to this ceremony at all the Zen                        quyeát ñònh cho nhöõng kinh nghieäm veà haïnh phuùc monasteries in Japan, when not only the welfare                vaø ñau khoå cuûa chuùng ta. Trong vaàn ñeà chuyeån of the nation but the peace of the entire world is             hoùa taâm, ngöôøi Phaät töû neân nhôù raèng khoâng coù moät most earnestly prayed for.                                     thöù kyû luaät naøo coù theå ñöôïc duøng ñeå eùp buoäc taâm Chuyeån Ñoäc: Ten-doku (jap)—Read by                           mình phaûi theo. Noù phaûi ñöôïc haønh söû treân caên revolving—See Chuyeån Ñoïc.                                    baûn töï nguyeän chaáp nhaän chuyeån hoùa. Tuy nhieân, Chuyeån Ñoåi: Paravrit (skt)—To change—To                      söï töï nguyeän chaáp nhaän naøy chæ xaûy ra sau khi exchange—To turn back.                                         chuùng ta ñaõ nhaän dieän vaø thaáy roõ thaùi ñoä, tö töôûng Chuyeån Giaùo: Thuyeát giaùo löu truyeàn töø ngöôøi            hoaëc tình caûm hay loái soáng naøo laø coù lôïi ích cho naày sang ngöôøi kia—To teach or preach through a              mình vaø cho ngöôøi. Vaø chæ coù con ñöôøng taâm linh deputy; to pass on the doctrine from one to                    maø mình quyeát ñònh theo ñuoåi môùi coù theå giuùp cho another.                                                       chuùng ta chuyeån hoùa taâm mình maø thoâi. Tuy Chuyeån Giaùo Dung Thoâng: Thôøi kyø thöù tö trong             nhieân, ñeå coù khaû naêng chuyeån hoùa taâm mình, naêm thôøi kyø ñöôïc toâng Thieân Thai ñeà caä p: thôøi Baùt   chuùng ta phaûi hieåu thaùi ñoä, tö töôûng vaø tình caûm Nhaõ keùo daøi 22 naêm—The fourth period in the                chuùng ta laøm vieäc nhö theá naøo. Chuùng ta phaûi hieåu five periods mentioned by the T'ien-T'ai Sect: the             roõ söï khaùc bieät giöõa thieän vaø baát thieän. Trong ñaïo Prajna period for twenty-two years—See Thieân                  Phaät, noùi khoâng phaûi laø tu, maø thöïc haønh baèng taát Thai Nguõ Thôøi Baùt Giaùo.                                    caû naêng löïc vaø söï thaønh khaån cuûa chính mình môùi Chuyeån Hoùa: Parinam (skt)—To alter—To be                     laø tu. Neáu chuùng ta noùi ñeå giaûm thieåu nhöõng naêng transformed into—Actively seeking to convert                   löïc baát thieän nhö tham, saân, si, maïn, nghi, taø kieán, others to one's beliefs.                                       saùt, ñaïo, daâm, voïng, chuùng ta phaûi coù taám loøng töø, Chuyeån Hoùa Noäi Taâm: Internal practice.                     bi, hyû, xaû, vaân vaân, thì ñoù chæ laø lôøi noùi troáng roãng. Chuyeån Hoùa Sanh: Sanh ra töø söï chuyeån hoùa—               Chæ noùi raèng ñaây laø thöù caàn cho moät caùi taâm thieän Birth by transformation.                                       laø chöa ñuû, hay chæ mong öôùc mình töø bi hôn, Chuyeån Hoùa Taâm: Transforming the mind—                      thöông yeâu hôn hay hyû xaû hôn thoâi cuõng chöa ñuû. Trong ñaïo Phaät, tu chæ laø chuyeån hoùa taâm, nghóa laø      Ngöôïc laïi, ngöôøi Phaät töû phaûi coá gaéng lieân tuïc ñeå

tu taäp nhöõng taùnh thieän beân trong mình. Chìa khoùa        differences       between        “wholesome”          and cuûa vieäc chuyeån hoùa taâm laø söï coá gaéng vaø thaønh      “unwholesome”. In Buddhism, speaking is in no khaån lieân tuïc. Ñeå coù theå böôùc leân con ñöôøng           way cultivating, cultivating means practicing with chuyeån hoùa taâm mình, ngöôøi Phaät töû khoâng coù söï        our own energy and sincerity. If we say in order to löïa choïn naøo khaùc hôn laø phaûi tu taäp giôùi luaät vaø    reduce greed, hatred, ignorance, pride, doubt, töï quaùn saùt laáy mình xem coi nhöõng thaùi ñoä, tö          wrong views, killing, stealing, lying, etc., we must töôûng vaø tình caûm phaùt khôûi ra sao trong taâm             have the mind of loving-kindness, compassion, mình. Nhöõng tu taäp naøy seõ cho chuùng ta trí tueä           joy, and renunciation. This is only an empty word. chaân thaät coù theå giuùp chuùng ta bieát roõ raøng phaûi     It is not enough to recognize that this is what is laøm caùi gì thieän vaø khoâng laøm caùi gì baát thieän. Ñoù   required to obtain a wholesome mind. It is not laø caùch chuyeån hoùa taâm chaân chính nhaát cuûa ngöôøi      enough simply to wish that we should have more Phaät töû—In Buddhism, cultivating is simply                   loving-kindness, more compassion, more joy or transforming the mind, it is to say that we use                more renunciation. On the contrary, Buddhists some kind of inner discipline to transform the                 must make an on going effort, again and again, to heart. In our daily life, we usually experience two            cultivate the positive aspects within us. The key contrary states of mind (that have direct bearing              for transforming the mind is a sustained effort and on human mind): happiness and suffering. Even                  sincerity. To be able to step on the way of though we don’t want to further discuss about the              transforming the mind, Buddhists have no other consciousness in this subtitle, we all recognize that          choice but observing the rules and contemplating besides our concrete body we still have another                the way to examine how attitudes, thoughts and part that dominates the body. We all agree that the            emotions arise in us through introspection. These experiences of suffering and happiness do not                  will give us the real wisdom that can help us originate or stem from the body itself, they                   understand clearly what we should do and what originate from an inner abstract place which                   we should not do with the wholesome and the Buddhism calls “mind”. According to Buddhism,                  unwholesome. This is the real way of transforming powerful mental experiences under the forms of                 of the mind of a Buddhist. thoughts and emotions are so strong that they have             Chuyeån        Hoùa      Taâm       Thöùc:       Thought the capability to dominate all physical levels of              transformation—Moät trong caùc phöông phaùp tu taäp experience. This is the key point in Buddhism, for             coù theå giuùp ngöôøi ta ñaït ñöôïc giaûi thoaùt hay giaùc from this point of view, we recognize that                     ngoä. Ñaây laø caùch giuùp chuùng ta soáng töøng giaây cultivating is transforming the mind, and                      töøng phuùt moät caùch vieân maõn, thí duï nhö khi transforming the mind means cultivating. And                   chuùng ta röûa cheùn dóa hay giaët quaàn aùo, chuùng ta from this very viewpoint, we agree that our state              coù theå taâm nieäm ‘Ta nguyeän giuùp cho moïi ngöôøi of mind, including our attitudes, thoughts and                 coù ñöôïc taâm thöùc thanh tònh, khoâng coøn nhöõng taâm emotions, plays a crucial role in our experiences              thaùi nhieãu loaïn u meâ.’—One of the methods of of happiness and suffering. In transforming the                cultivation that can help people achieve liberation mind, Buddhists should remember that there’s no                or enlightenment. This is a way to live each discipline can be used to force our mind. It must              moment to the fullest, for example, when we be done on the basis of voluntary acceptance.                  wash dishes or clothes, we think ‘may I help all However, this voluntary acceptance or voluntary                beings cleanse their minds of disturbing attitudes follow a spiritual discipline happens only after we            and obscurations.’ ourselves have recognized that certain attitudes,              Chuyeån Hoùa Tieàm Naêng Giaùc Ngoä: thoughts, emotions and ways of life are beneficial             Transformation of potential enlightenment. to us and to others. And the spiritual path is the             Chuyeån Hoïa Thaønh Phuùc: Turn misery into luck. only way that will help us transform our minds.                Chuyeån Hoaùn: To commute. However, to be able to transform our minds we                  Chuyeån Hoài: Trôû laïi: To return, to revolve—Taùi must understand the way our attitudes, thoughts                sanh: To be reborn. and emotion work. We must understand the                       Chuyeån Höôùng: To change (shift) one’s direction.

Chuyeån Höôùng Töø Thieàn Sang Tònh: To shift                    sö cuûa caû moät vöông quoác ñi voøng quanh nuùi haøng from Zen to the Pure Land method.                                tyû trieäu voøng, theo quan ñieåm cuûa baø laõo vaãn chæ Chuyeån Khai Ngoä Phaùp Luaân: Chuyeån khai ngoä                 laø moät nöûa Tam Taïng. Ngay caû khi taát caû nuùi, soâng phaùp luaân, vì coù theå laøm ñaïi voâ uùy sö töû hoáng—         vaø ñaïi ñòa vaø taát caû nhöõng gì laøm thaønh vuõ truï cuûa Turn the awakening wheel of the Teaching.                        voâ soá thöù naøy, goàm caû moãi coäi caây vaø moãi coïng coû, Chuyeån Khai Thò Nhaát Thieát Phaùp Luaân:                       ñoàng thôøi chuyeån thaønh Tam Taïng keå töø hoâm nay Chuyeån khai thò nhöùt thieát trí phaùp luaân, vì cuøng          cho ñeán ngaøy taän theá, thì theo quan ñieåm cuûa baø khaép taát caû tam theá—Turn the wheel of Teaching               laõo vaãn chæ laø moät nöûa Tam Taïng—In Zen revealing all knowledge; pervading all things in                 tradition, to revolve a scripture means to scan a all times.                                                       scripture by reading the beginning, midle, and end Chuyeån Kieáp: Transmigration.                                   of each chapter. According to the Records of the Chuyeån Kinh: To revolve a scripture—Trong                       Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), truyeàn thoáng nhaø Thieàn, thuaät ngöõ "chuyeån kinh"           Volume X, one day, an old lady once sent a coù nghóa laø chæ ñoïc coù maáy haøng ñaàu, maáy haøng           messenger with money to Chao-chou, requesting giöõa, maáy haøng cuoái cuûa moãi chöông. Theo                   him to "revolve" the whole Tripitaka. Chao-chou Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, quyeån X, moät hoâm coù moät baø             came down from his seat, and, walking around the laõo göûi moät ngöôøi ñöa tin ñeán Thieàn sö Trieäu Chaâu        chair once, said: "The revolving is finished." The Toøng Thaåm, yeâu caàu Sö "chuyeån" taát caû Tam                 messenger went back to the old lady and reported Taïng Kinh Ñieån. Trieäu Chaâu rôøi khoûi choã ngoài, ñi         the proceeding as it happened. The old lady said: voøng quanh gheá, noùi: "Chuyeån xong roài." Ngöôøi              "I asked him to 'revolve' the entire Tripitaka but ñöa tin trôû veà baùo caùo taát caû moïi vieäc cho baø laõo.     his 'revolving' covers only a half of the Tripitaka." Baø laõo noùi: "Ta yeâu caàu thaày 'chuyeån' toaøn theå          On this, Ta-hui, one of the great Zen masters Tam Taïng song thaày laïi 'chuyeån' coù phaân nöûa Tam           during the Sung dynasty, commented: "Some ask, Taïng maø thoâi." Veà vaán ñeà naøy, Thieàn sö Ñaïi Hueä         'What is the other half?' Others say, 'Make another Toâng Caûo, moät trong nhöõng ñaïi thieàn sö ñôøi nhaø           round'; or 'Snap your fingers'; still others say, Toáng, bình luaän raèng: "Coù ngöôøi hoûi: 'Moät nöûa kia        'Give a cough'; or 'Utter a kwatz!' or 'Clap the laø gì?', coù ngöôøi khaùc noùi: 'Laøm theâm moät voøng          hands!'" Ta-hui remained silent for a while and nöõa.' Hay 'Haõy buùng tay.' Coù ngöôøi laïi noùi: 'Ho           continued: "The beautiful pair of ducks, moät caùi ñi.' Hay 'Heùt leân!' hay 'Voã tay!' " Ñaïi Hueä       embroidered in the finest style, is there for you to nín laëng moät luùc roài noùi tieáp: "Ñoâi vòt ñeïp kia, theâu   see as much as you like; but take care not to moät caùch tinh xaûo nhaát, ñeå cho oâng tha hoà nhìn tuøy       deliver up the gold needle that did the work!" thích; nhöng maø haõy caån thaän, ñöøng coù giao traû            After these references, another Zen master gave chieác kim vaøng ñaõ laøm neân taùc phaåm." Sau nhöõng           his own ideas saying: "The old lady claims that trích daãn naøy, moät vò thieàn sö khaùc ñöa ra yù kieán         Chao-chou has only finished revolving a half of cuûa mình: "Baø laõo noùi raèng Trieäu Chaâu môùi                the Tripitaka. This is replacing the genuine by the chuyeån xong moät nöûa Tam Taïng. Ñaây laø loäng giaû            spurious. The only thing that was needed at the thaønh chaân. Ñieàu duy nhaát caàn noùi luùc ñoù laø nhö         time to say was this: 'Why not take the whole vaày: 'Taïi sao khoâng bao goàm taát caû söï theå ngay caû       thing in even before Chao-chou started to walk tröôùc khi Trieäu Chaâu baét ñaàu ñi quanh gheá?'" Theo          around the chair'?" According to Zen master D.T. Thieàn Sö D.T. Suzuki trong quyeån "Söï Huaán                    Suzuki in "The Training of the Zen Buddhist Luyeän cuûa Moät Thieàn Taêng", nhöõng ngöôøi noùi nhö           Monk" (p.79), those who make these remarks do vaäy khoâng bieát hoã theïn laø gì. Veà "moät nöûa kia",         not know what shame means. As regard "the other xin ñöøng bao giôø noùi nhö vaày: "Laøm moät voøng               half," do never make such a remark as this: "Make nöõa!" Ngay caû khi laøm haøng traêm ngaøn tyû voøng             another round!" Even when hundreds of thousands nöõa thì töø quan ñieåm cuûa baø laõo vaãn chæ laø moät nöûa     of kotis (equal to ten billion) of rounds are made, Tam Taïng. Ngay caû khi ñi voøng quanh nuùi Tu Di                they are, from the point of view of the old lady, no haøng tyû voøng, theo quan ñieåm cuûa baø laõo vaãn chæ          more than a half Tripitaka. Even when Mount laø moät nöûa Tam Taïng. Ngay caû khi caùc ñaïi thieàn           Sumeru is gone round for hundreds of thousands

of kotis of time, they are, from the point of view of           preaching—Toái Thaéng Kim Luaân Phaät Ñaûnh— the old lady, no more than a half Tripitaka. Even               See Toái Thaéng Phaät Ñaûnh. when the great Zen masters of the whole empire                  Chuyeån Meâ Khai Ngoä: Deïp boû meâ muoäi cuûa theá walk round the mountain for hundreds                     of     giôùi luaân hoài sanh töû ñeå böôùc vaøo giaùc ngoä nieát thousands of kotis of time, they are, from the point            baøn—To reject the illusion of the transmigrational of view of the old lady, no more than a half                    worlds and enter into nirvana enlightenment. Tripitaka. Even when all the mountains and rivers               Chuyeån Ngaïn (1882-1970): Teân cuûa moät vò Taêng and the great earth and everything that makes up                ngöôøi Trung Quoác vaøo theá kyû XX. Tröôùc theá chieán this universe of multiplicities, including every                laàn thöù hai, Sö ñeán Taân Gia Ba hoaèng phaùp vaø löu plant and every blade of grass, each endowed with               laïi ñaây cho ñeán heát ñôøi—Name of a famous a long broad tongue, unanimously revolve the                    Chinese monk in the twentieth century. Before the Tripitake from this day on to the end of time, they             World War II, he came to Singapore to spread the are, from the point of view of the old lady, no                 Buddha-dharma and stayed there for the rest of his more than a half Tripitaka.                                     life. Chuyeån Lôøi Noùi Ra Haønh Ñoäng: To translate all              Chuyeån Ngöõ: Turning words—Lôøi leõ saéc beùn maø one’s words into action.                                        baäc thaày tuøy nghi lôïi duïng cô hoäi nhaèm giuùp haønh Chuyeån Luaân: To turn the wheel—See Chuyeån                    giaû khai ngoä. Thí duï thöù 96 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Phaùp Luaân.                                                    Trieäu Chaâu daïy chuùng ba chuyeån ngöõ: Phaät vaøng Chuyeån Luaân Thaùnh Vöông: Bala-cakravartin                    khoâng qua ñöôïc loø ñuùc; Phaät caây khoâng qua ñöôïc (skt)—Tenrinsho-o (jap)—Wheel-Turning King—                     löûa; vaø Phaät ñaát khoâng qua ñöôïc nöôùc, Sau khi daïy Moät vò vua lyù töôûng trong huyeàn thoaïi AÁn Ñoä,             chuùng ba chuyeån nöõ naày Trieäu Chaâu laïi noùi: ngöôøi trò vì theá giôùi vôùi moät loaïi baùnh xe ñaëc bieät,   "Chôn Phaät ngoài trong thaát."—Sharp words that bay trong khoâng trung vaø nghieàn naùt keû thuø —The           masters use their discretion to make necessary ideal king in Indian legends, who rules the world               decision, and to take advantage of opportunities with a special kind of wheel that flies in the air              to help disciples become awakened. Chao Chou and destroys the enemies.                                       expressed three turning words to his community. Chuyeån Luaân Vi Sôn Vöông: See Chuyeån Luaân                   A gold Buddha does not pass through a furnace; a Thaùnh Vöông.                                                   wood Buddha does not pass through fire; a mud Chuyeån Luaân Vöông: Chakravartin (p)—                          Buddha does not pass through water. According to Cakravartin (skt)—Wheel Turner—Thaày cuûa caùc                  Yuan-Wu in the Pi-Yen-Lu, after Chao Chou had coã xe. Moät vò toái thöôïng maø caùc coã xe cuûa ngöôøi        spoken these three turning words, in the end he ñoù khoâng bao giôø gaëp trôû ngaïi. Coù boán loaïi: vaøng,     said, "The real Buddha sits within." baïc, ñoàng, saét. Veà sau Chakravartin ñöôïc duøng ñeå         Chuyeån Nhaát Thieát Phaùp Trí Taïng Phaùp Luaân: chæ moät vò Phaät coù hoïc thuyeát phoå bieán vaø mang          Turn the wheel of treasury of knowledge of all chaân lyù veà toaøn boä vuõ truï—Wheel ruler, the               truths; to cause to open the door of the treasury of wheels of his chariot roll unosbstructedly                      truth and remove the obstacle of obscurity— everywhere. In Buddhism, Wheel Turner means a                   Chuyeån nhöùt thieát phaùp trí taïng phaùp luaân, vì khai king or Sovereign ruler whose rule is unbounded,                cöûa phaùp taïng tröø aùm chöôùng. and also the wheels of his chariots (chariot                    Chuyeån Nöõ Thaønh Nam: Ñöôïc chuyeån hay töï wheels) can turn anywhere without obstruction                   chuyeån töø nöõ sang nam—To be transformed from, (roll everywhere without hindrance). There are                  or transform, a female into a male. four types of wheels, based on the quality and                  Chuyeån Nöõ Thaân Boà Taùt Kinh: Strivivarta- power: gold, silver, copper and iron. “Wheel                    vyakarana-sutra (skt)—Thuaän Quyeàn Phöông Tieän Turner” (Chakravartin) later became and epithet                 Kinh—Name of a sutra. for a buddha whose teaching is universal and                    Chuyeån Phaøm Thaønh Thaùnh: To transform whose truth is applicable to the entire cosmos.                 ordinary beings into sages. Chuyeån Luaân Vöông Phaät Ñaûnh: Vijaya (skt)— With golden wheel symbol of unexcelled power of

Chuyeån Phaïm Luaân: Chuyeån Phaùp Luaân. Tieáng             According to Buddhist tradition, this is the first Phaïn coù nghóa laø thanh tònh—To turn the noble or          discourse of Sakyamuni Buddha in Sarnath shortly pure wheel.                                                  after his enlightenment. The central themes of the Chuyeån Phaùp Hoa: Ten-Hokke (jap)—To read                   discourse are the “middle way” (madhyama- the Lotus Sutra and to realize the real Universe.            pratipad), which avoids the extremes of hedonism Chuyeån Phaùp Luaân: Dharma Cakra Pravartana                 and asceticism, and the four noble truths (arya- (skt)—To turn the wheel of the Dharma—Chuyeån                satya). baùnh xe Phaät Phaùp hay thuyeát Phaät Phaùp. Chuyeån        Chuyeån Phaùp Luaân Löïc: Dharma-cakra- Phaùp Luaân coù nghóa laø tuyeân thuyeát lyù töôûng cuûa     pravartana-bala (skt)—See Löïc Chuyeån Phaùp Phaät, hay theå hieän lyù töôûng cuûa Phaät trong theá       Luaân. gian, nghóa laø kieán laäp vöông quoác cuûa Chaùnh           Chuyeån Phaùp Luaân Nhaät: Ngaøy Ñöùc Phaät thuyeát Phaùp. Phaùp Luaân töôïng tröng cho giaùo lyù cuûa Ñöùc      phaùp laàn ñaàu trong vöôøn Loäc Uyeån laø ngaøy moàng Phaät. Taùm caây caêm cuûa baùnh xe töôïng tröng cho         taùm thaùng taùm—The day when the Buddha first Baùt Thaùnh Ñaïo. Ngaøy nay, Phaùp Luaân ñöôïc quoác         preached, in the Deer Park, i.e. the eighth day of teá duøng laøm bieåu töôïng cuûa ñaïo Phaät—To turn the      the eighth month. Dharma Cakra (wheel) of dharma. To turn or roll              Chuyeån Phaùp Luaân Töôùng: Moät trong taùm töôùng along the Law-wheel, i.e. to preach Buddha-truth,            thaønh ñaïo cuûa Ñöùc Phaät, noùi veà moät ñôøi thuyeát or to explain the religion of Buddha (Buddhist               phaùp cuûa Phaät töø khi thaønh ñaïo ñeán khi nhaäp preaching). Turning the Wheel of Truth means                 dieät—The sign of preaching, one of the eight signs ‘preaching the Buddha’s Ideal,’ or the ‘realization          that Sakyamuni was a Buddha—See Taùm Thôøi Kyø of the Buddha’s Ideal in the world,’ i.e., the               Trong Cuoäc Ñôøi Ñöùc Phaät. foundation of Kingdom of Truth. The Dharma                   Chuyeån Phaùp Luaân Voâ Ngaïi Thanh Tònh: Turn Wheel symbolizes the Buddha’s Teaching. The                  the unimpeded pure wheel of teaching. eight spokes of the wheel represent the Noble                Chuyeån Sanh: To transmigrate—Transmigration. Eight-fold Path. Nowadays, the Dharma Wheel is               Chuyeån Taïng: See Chuyeån Kinh. used internationally as the symbol of Buddhism.              Chuyeån Taùnh Haïnh: Nhôø coâng haïnh tu haønh maø Chuyeån Phaùp Luaân Boà Taùt:                                chuyeån phaøm thaønh Thaùnh—Bodhisattva’s 1) Kim cang Ba La Maät Boà Taùt—Vajra-paramita               transforming nature (powers of conversion or Bodhisattva         (Dharma         Wheel-Turning       salvation). Bodhisattva)—The preaching Bodhisattva.                 Chuyeån Taâm: Spiritual transformation—Maurine 2) Moät trong ba hình thöùc cuûa Phaät Tyø Loâ Giaù          Stuart vieát trong quyeån 'AÂm Thanh Vi Teá': Na—Vajra-paramita Bodhisattva, one of the               "Chuyeån ñoåi taâm linh laø moät töø ngöõ coù tính caùch three forms of Vairocana.                               phaùt ñoäng nhaäp cuoäc, nhöng ñoù laïi laø caùi maø Chuyeån Phaùp Luaân Kinh: Dhammacakka-sutta                  chuùng ta phaûi tham gia vaøo. Vaø seõ coù raát nhieàu (p)—Dhammachakkappavattana-sutta                   (p)—      khoù khaên. Seõ coù ñau ñôùn vaø meät moûi, ngôø vöïc vaø Dharma-cakra-pravartana-sutra             (skt)—Chuyeån      nghi vaán. Nhöng ñoù laø pheùp tu taäp vaän duïng caû Phaùp Luaân Kinh—Sutra on turning the wheel of               thaân vaø taâm cuøng moät luùc. Khoâng phaûi chæ ngoài the Dharma—Sutra on the Wheel of the                         xuoáng quaùn töôûng laø ñuû, nhöng phaûi giöõ moät yù Dhamma—Chuyeån Phaùp Luaân hay nhöõng baøi                   thöùc naêng ñoäng vaø caûm nhaän toaøn boä thaân xaùc. thuyeát phaùp taïi vöôøn Loäc Uyeån (neàn taûng cuûa         Chuùng ta ñöa hôi thôû ñi vaøo taát caû nhöõng nôi gaây vöông quoác ñaïo ñöùc). Theo truyeàn thoáng Phaät            ñau ñôùn, chöù khoâng phaûi chæ ôû nhöõng veát thöông giaùo, ñaây laø baøi phaùp ñaàu tieân cuûa Ñöùc Phaät taïi   theå xaùc maø caû nhöõng veát thöông cuûa cuoäc ñôøi. Hôi Sarnath ngay sau khi Ngaøi giaùc ngoä. Chuû ñeà cuûa         thôû chen vaøo moät caùch nheï nhaøng, aám aùp vaø coù baøi phaùp laø “trung ñaïo”, traùnh hai cöïc ñoan buoâng     taùnh caùch chöõa laønh. Tö theá toïa thieàn laø moät tö theá lung theo khoaùi laïc vaø khoå haïnh. Baøi phaùp cuõng       hoài phuïc, roäng môû vaø tænh thöùc; hôi thôû duøng ñeå noùi veà Töù Dieäu Ñeá—The setting in motion of the          hoài phuïc di chuyeån moät caùch töï khaép chaâu thaân Wheel of the Law, or sermons in the deer park (on            chuùng ta."—Maurine Stuart wrote in Subtle the foundation of the Kingdom of Righteousness).             Sound: "Spiritual transformation is a rather

ground-breaking phrase, but that is what we are                  Chuyeån Thöùc Ñaéc Trí: Chuyeån thöùc thaønh trí— engaged in. And hard work it is. There is pain and               Chuyeån thöùc ñaéc trí laø chuyeån phaøm thöùc trong theá weariness, there are many doubts and questions.                  giôùi luaân hoài sanh töû thaønh Phaät thöùc—The But this is a practice of body and mind coming                   transformation of consciousness means the together. It is not just sitting and thinking, but               knowledge which transmutes the common being dynamically aware, sensing with our entire                 knowledge of this transmigration-world into bodies. We let the breath go into all the places in              Buddha-knowledge. us that hurt, not just the physical wounds, but all              Chuyeån Thöùc Luaän: Luaän giaûi veà söï bieán chuyeån the wounds of our life. The breath enters tenderly,              cuûa taâm thöùc—Treatise on the transformation of warmly, healingly. Our zazen posture is a posture                consciousness. of healing. it is open and alert; the healing breath             Chuyeån Thöùc Thieàn: Phowa (tib)—Di chuyeån moves freely through us."                                        taâm thöùc—Moät caùch tu taäp cao trong Maät giaùo Chuyeån Thanh Tuïng: Vibhaktikarika (skt)—A                      nhaèm ñöa thöùc veà moät coõi thích hôïp luùc tòch dieät— form of Geya.                                                    Transference of consciousness meditation, an Chuyeån Thaân: Tenshin (jap)—Xoay mình, duï cho                  advanced tantric practice concerned with ejection söï ñoán ngoä töùc thì—To turn the body around, i.e.,            of consciousness at death to a favorable realm. enlightenment comes upon one abruptly and is a                   Chuyeån Töôùng: See Kieán Töôùng. momentary experience.                                            Chuyeån Vaät: Chuyeån hoùa vaïn vaät baèng löïc sieâu Chuyeån Thaân Nhaát Loä: Con ñöôøng taét chuyeån                 nhaân—To transform things, especially by meâ thaønh ngoä, chæ cho Thieàn toâng. Thieàn laø con            supernatural power. ñöôøng ngaén nhaát giuùp haønh giaû deïp boû meâ muoäi           Chuyeån Voâ Löôïng Phaùp Luaân: Chuyeån voâ löôïng cuûa theá giôùi luaân hoài sanh töû ñeå böôùc vaøo giaùc ngoä    phaùp luaân, vì laøm cho taát caû theá gian ñeàu bieát roõ — nieát baøn—A short cut from illusion to                          Turn the immeasurable wheel of the Teaching, to enlightenment, i.e., the Zen sect. Zen is the short              cause all worldlings to know. cut that helps practitioners reject the illusion of the          Chuyeån Voâ Ngaïi Phaùp Luaân: Chuyeån voâ ngaïi transmigrational worlds and enter into nirvana                   phaùp luaân, vì ñoàng vôùi hö khoâng—Turn the enlightenment.                                                   unobstructed wheel of the Teaching, being equal Chuyeån Thaân Thoå Khí: Thuaät ngöõ Thieàn bieåu thò             to space. söï töï do vaø giaûi thoaùt—This is a Zen term                   Chuyeån Voâ Tröôùc Phaùp Luaân: Chuyeån voâ tröôùc denoting freedom and liberation.                                 phaùp luaân, vì quaùn taát caû phaùp chaúng coù chaúng Chuyeån Theá: Trôû laïi kieáp naày—Return to this                khoâng—Turn the wheel of Teaching of non- life.                                                            attachment; see that all things are neither existent Chuyeån Thöùc: Pravrtti-vijnana (skt)—Nghieäp                    nor nonexistent. thöùc chuyeån laàn maø sanh ra naêng kieán hay töï thaáy         Chuyeån Y: Asrayaparavrtti (skt)—Paravrtti mình maø khôûi leân taùc duïng. Chuyeån thöùc coøn goïi          (skt)—Revolution           at       substratum—Sudden laø sanh khôûi thöùc, laø caùi thöùc trong khía caïnh naêng      change—Söï bieán ñoåi cuûa caùi goác hay söï ñoät bieán ñoäng cuûa noù, töùc laø ñang phaùt trieån noái keát vôùi caùc   chuyeån hoùa trong taâm thöùc, ñöa taâm thöùc töø traïng cô quan caûm giaùc hay caên. Chuyeån thöùc laø kieán             thaùi voâ minh sang tænh thöùc—Transformation of thöùc giuùp chuyeån phaøm thöùc trong theá giôùi luaân           the basis. Sudden change from ignorance to hoài sanh töû thaønh Phaät thöùc —The act of turning             awakening. towards the apparent object for its observation.                 Chuyeän Thieân Cung: Vimana-vatthu (p)—Thieân Also called arising or appearance, the vijnana in                Cung Söï Kinh—Kinh ghi laïi caùc truyeàn thuyeát— its dynamic aspect, i.e., as evolving in conjunction             Discourses on legends—Stories of the Mansion. with the sense-organs. Pravrtti-vijnana means the                Chuyeän Truyeàn Khaåu: Stories transmitted by knowledge which transmutes the common                            words (mouth). knowledge of this transmigration-world into                      Chuyeát Am Ñöùc Quang Thieàn Sö (1121-1203): Buddha-knowledge.                                                Teân cuûa moät vò Thieàn sö Trung Hoa, thuoäc toâng Laâm Teá, soáng vaøo thôøi nhaø Toáng (960-1279)—

Name of a Chinese Zen master of the Lin-chi                  doctrine of all Buddhas.” These four sentences are Sect, who lived during the Sung dynasty.                     said to include all the Buddha-teaching. Chuyeát Coâng Thieàn Sö: Zen master Chuyeát Coâng            Chö Ba La Maät: Sadparamita (skt)—Six (1590-1644)—Thieàn sö Trung Hoa, queâ ôû Tieäm               Paramitas—Six virtues of perfection—See Luïc Sôn, tænh Phöôùc Kieán, Trung Quoác. Ngaøi ñaõ toû ra        Ñoä Ba La Maät. thoâng minh luùc tuoåi haõy coøn raát nhoû. Thoaït ñaàu      Chö Boà Taùt Hoä Phaùp: The Dharma protector ngaøi theo hoïc thieàn vôùi Thieàn sö Tieäm Sôn. Veà         Bodhisattvas. sau, ngaøi theo hoïc vôùi Thieàn sö Taêng Ñaø Ñaø ôû         Chö Caên: Nguõ Caên—All roots, powers, organs, Nam Sôn vaø trôû thaønh phaùp töû ñôøi thöù 34 doøng         e.g—1) Tín, taán, nieäm, ñònh, tueä: Faith, energy, Thieàn Laâm Teá. Naêm 1633, ngaøi ñeán Thaêng Long,          memory, meditation, wisdom; 2) Maét, tai, muõi, Baéc Vieät. Ngaøi ñöôïc caû Chuùa Trònh vaø vua Leâ          luôõi, thaân: Eyes, ears, nose, tongue and body. Huyeàn Toâng kính troïng vaø toân suøng. Sau khi truøng      Chö Caên Haûi: Ocean of faculties. tu chuøa Ninh Phuùc, Chuùa Trònh môøi ngaøi veà truï trì     Chö Caên Myõ Dieäu Thaàn: Sublime Faculties taïi ñaây ñeå chaán höng vaø hoaèng hoùa Phaät giaùo cho     Deity (Spirit). ñeán khi ngaøi thò tòch naêm 1644—A Chinese Zen              Chö Caên Thöôøng Hyû Thaàn: All Senses Always master from Tieäm Sôn, Phöôù c Kieán, China. Since           Joyful Deity (Spirit). his young age, he was very intelligent. First, he            Chö Chaáp: Chín ngoâi sao—The nine studied Zen with Zen master Tieäm Sôn. Later, he             luminaries—See Cöûu Dieäu. studied with Zen master Taêng Ñaø Ñaø in Nam Sôn.            Chö Chuùng Sanh Voâ Naêng Ñoäng Löïc: Power He was the Dharma heir of the thirty-fourth                  that all living beings cannot shake—See Möôøi Löïc generation of the Lin-Chih Zen Sect. In 1633, he             Cuûa Chö Phaät. arrived at Thaêng Long, North Vietnam. He was                Chö Duyeân: Taát caû nhöõng ñieàu kieän phuï thuoäc respected and honored by both Lord Trònh and                 beân ngoaøi laøm aûnh höôûng ñeán cuoäc soáng—All the King Leâ Huyeàn Toâng. After rebuilding Ninh Phuùc           accessory conditions, or environmental causes Temple, Lord Trònh invited him to stay there to              which influence life. revive and expand Buddhism until he passed away              Chö Ñaïi Boà Taùt: The great Mahasattvas. in 1644.                                                     Chö Ñaïi Ñeä Töû: All great disciples. Chuyeát Sôn (1744-?): Teân cuûa moät vò cö só Phaät          Chö Haønh: Taát caû moïi söï thay ñoåi cuûa hieän töôïng; giaùo noåi tieáng cuûa Vieät Nam vaøo theá kyû thöù XVIII.   moïi haønh ñoäng (caùc phaùp höõu vi do nhaân duyeân Queâ oâng ôû Ninh Bình vaø oâng töøng laøm quan döôùi        sanh ra vaø löu chuyeån trong ba ñôøi)—All thôøi Chuùa Trònh—Name of a famous Vietnamese                phenomenal changes; all conduct or action. layperson in the eighteenth century. He came Chö Haønh Höõu Vi Kinh: Anityata-sutra (skt)— from Ninh Binh Province and he used to be a Sutra on conditioned phenomena. mandarin Under Trinh Lord. Chö Haønh Sinh: Söï sinh ra cuûa caùc nghieäp khaùc Chö: Heát thaûy—The diverse kinds—Many— nhau—Production of various karmic formations. All—Every. Chö Haønh Voâ Thöôøng: Anityah-sarva-samskarah Chö AÙc Maïc Taùc, Chuùng Thieän Phuïng Haønh, (skt)—Vaïn vaät thöôøng bieán chuyeån (Theo Kinh Töï Tònh Kyø YÙ, Thò Chö Phaät Giaùo: Shoaku-                Nieát Baøn: “Chö haønh voâ thöôøng laø phaùp sinh dieät.” makusa, Shuzen-bugyo, Jijo-go-i, Ze-shobutsu-kyo             Chö phaùp höõu vi luoân luaân chuyeån trong ba ñôøi goïi (jap)—“Khoâng laøm nhöõng vieäc aùc, chæ laøm nhöõng         laø chö haønh, vì chö haønh laø sinh dieät voâ thöôøng, laø vieäc laønh, giöõ taâm yù trong saïch, ñoù lôøi chö Phaät    khoå. Chöøng naøo dieät ñöôïc caû sinh dieät, töùc laø voâ daïy.” Bieån phaùp meânh moâng cuõng töø boán caâu keä       sinh voâ dieät, thì chöøng ñoù laø tòch dieät, laø nieát naày maø ra—In the Agama Sutra, the Buddha                   baøn.”)—Whatever is phenomenal is impermanent. taught: “Do not commit wrongs, devoutly practice Chö Haïnh Haûi: Bieån thöïc haønh—Ocean of all kinds of good, purify the mind, that’s practices—Soá löôïng phaùp thöïc haønh raát nhieàu, ví Buddhism” or “To do no evil, to do only good, to nhö löôïng nöôùc bieån—The ocean of practices, purify the will, these can be interpreted as the great in number.

Chö Hieàn: Shoken (jap)—Wise ones—Ladies and                Chö Nhaân Tuùc Taùc Toâng: See Tuùc Taùc Ngoaïi gentlemen (a term of respect used when                      Ñaïo. addressing an assembly).                                    Chö Phaùp: Sarvadharma or Sarvabhava (skt)— Chö Höõu: Taát caû nhöõng gì hieän höõu (ñeàu do quaû       Shoho (jap)—Vaïn phaùp hay taát caû söï lyù cuûa söï baùo coù nhaân coù quaû cuûa chuùng sanh)—All that          vaät—All things; every dharma, law, thing, method. exists; all beings.                                         Chö        Phaùp      Baát     Sinh:      Anutpadam- Chö Höõu Tình Sinh Töû Trí Löïc: Thieân Nhaõn Trí           sarvadharmanam (skt)—All thing has no-birth. Löïc—Vôùi thieân nhaõn, Ñöùc Nhö Lai thaáy söï sinh töû     Chö Phaùp Bình Ñaúng, Voâ Höõu Cao Haï: Vaïn cuûa caùc höõu tình theo nghieäp cuûa hoï—With his          phaùp ñeàu nhö nhau, chöù khoâng coù phaùp naøo cao divine eye, a Tathagata sees other beings’ passing          hay phaùp naøo thaáp caû—All dharmas are even and away and arising according to their deeds.                  balanced, without high and low. Chö Kieán: Taát caû moïi taø kieán (goàm 62 taø kieán)—     Chö Phaùp Do Nhaân Duyeân Maø Sanh: All All the diverse views; all heterodox opinions               phenomena (dharmas) are arised (born) of causes (sixty-two in number).                                      and conditions. Chö Kinh Taäp Yeáu: Sutra-samuccaya (skt)—Moät              Chö Phaùp Ñaûn Danh Toâng: Popular truth—Toâng trong nhöõng taùc phaåm cuûa ngaøi Tòch Thieân, ñöôïc       phaùi tin raèng taát caû caùc phaùp ñeàu chæ laø nhöõng vieát vaøo nhöõng theá kyû thöù baûy hay thöù taùm. Ngaøi   danh töø, khoâng coù tính thöïc taïi, Nhaát Thuyeát Boä Tòch Thieân coøn noåi tieáng veà hai taùc phaåm vieát veà   thöøa nhaän giaùo thuyeát naày—All dharmas as Boà Taùt Haïnh—Name of one of the works                     nominal or mere names (akhyati matra or nama of Shantideva, a great Indian monk who lived in             matra). All elements are simply names and of no the seventh and eighth centuries. He was famous             reality, as admitted by the Ekottiya School. for his two works on the conduct of a Bodhisattva.          Chö Phaùp Giai Khoâng: Sarva-dharma-sunyata Chö Laäu: Asava (p)—Asrava (skt)—Shoro                      (skt)—Shoho-Kaiku (jap)—All things are empty— (jap)—See Laäu Hoaëc.                                       Heát thaûy chö phaùp ñeàu khoâng coù thöïc tính, chuùng Chö Long Löïc: Löïc cuûa caùc roàng laø baát khaû tö        do nhaân duyeân maø sanh ra. Giaùo thuyeát veà nghì—Power of dragons is inconceivable.                     “khoâng” naøy nhieàu tröôøng phaùi Phaät giaùo giaûi Chö Long Thaàn Hoä Phaùp: The Dragon Deity,                 thích khaùc nhau—All things and phenomena are Dharma protector.                                           totally empty. All things are produced by causes Chö Minh: Taát caû ñeàu môø mòt voâ minh—All                and accessory conditions have no reality, a darkness, i.e. all ignorance.                               doctrine differently interpreted in different schools Chö Nghieäp Voâ Thöôøng: Impermanence of all                of Buddhism—See Nhaát Thieát Phaùp Khoâng. karmas—Nhöõng nghieäp coù theå chuyeån hoùa ñöôïc           Chö Phaùp Haûi: Ocean of truths—Chö phaùp raát qua tu taäp—Karmas that can be changed through              nhieàu, ví nhö löôïng nöôùc bieån—The ocean of cultivation.                                                truths, great in number. Chö Nguyeän Haûi: Ocean of vows—Chö nguyeän                 Chö Phaùp Khoâng: See Chö Phaùp Giai Khoâng. raát nhieàu, ví nhö löôïng nöôùc bieån hay roäng lôùn nhö   Chö Phaùp Nguõ Vò: The five orders of things—See ñaïi döông—The ocean of vows, great in number               Nguõ Vò. or as vast as an ocean.                                     Chö Phaùp Thöïc Töôùng: Tattvasya-laksana Chö Nhaøn Baát Nhaøn:                                       (skt)—Chaân nhö phaùp tính, thöïc teá. Töø cuõng ñöôïc 1) Chö Nhaøn: Chuùng sanh trong coõi trôøi ngöôøi           duøng ñeå ñònh nghóa taùnh khoâng, nieát baøn, vaân khoâng gaëp chöôùng ngaïi hay hoaïn naïn—All in       vaân—The reality of all things, or all things in their happy conditions of metempsychosis, i.e.              real aspect, i.e. the reality beneath all things, the human beings and devas.                               Bhutatathata, or Dharmakaya, or Ultimate. The 2) Baát Nhaøn: Chuùng sanh ñoïa vaøo choán hoaïn            term also connotes “sunya,” “nirvana,” etc. naïn nhö ñòa nguïc, suùc sanh, ngaï quyû, goïi laø    Chö Phaùp Tòch Dieät Töôùng:Thöïc töôùng cuûa chö baát nhaøn—All in unhappy conditions of               phaùp döùt tuyeät moïi ngoân ngöõ vaø taâm haønh—All metempsychosis, i.e. hells, animals, hungry           things in their nirvana aspects, instructable. ghosts, etc.

Chö Phaùp Tính: Dharmanam-dharmata (skt)—                       It is the world of perfect harmony. This one of the Nature of phenomena—That which constitute the                   ten basic principles (Ten Mysterious Gates) of reason of things—Thöù taïo neân lyù do cuûa caùc söï vaät       Hua-yen, by means of which the Hua Yen (baûn chaát cuûa caùc hieän töôïng).                            philosophy of totality is expounded and to Chö Phaùp Töông Töùc Töï Taïi Moân: Freedom                     elucidate the possibility of the realm of Fact and from ultimate disctinctions—Theory of freedom—                  fact world perfectly harmonized.” Noùi veà töï do, nghóa laø vöôït ngoaøi nhöõng sai bieät kyø    Chö Phaùp Vò Ñaéc Töï Taïi Chöôùng: Non- cuøng, trong ñoù taát caû caùc phaùp ñeàu hoã töông ñoàng       attainment of complete mastery. nhaát. Ñaây laø söï ñoàng nhaát phoå bieán cuûa vaïn höõu.      Chö Phaùp Voâ Ngaõ: Dharma-nairatmya (skt)— Thöïc ra, hoã töông ñoàng nhaát laø töï tieâu huûy. Khi         Egolessness of phenomena—Selflessness of ñoàng nhaát ta vôùi keû khaùc, ta coù theå hoøa hôïp vôùi keû   phenomena—Moïi phaùp ñeàu khoâng coù thöïc ngaõ, taát khaùc. Töï tieâu huûy vaø töï ñoàng hoùa vôùi caùi khaùc taïo   caû ñeàu phaûi leä thuoäc vaøo luaät nhaân quaû —Nothing thaønh moät ñoàng nhaát hoùa toång hôïp. Ñaây laø lyù           has an ego, or is independent of the law of thuyeát hay thöïc haønh ñaëc bieät cuûa Ñaïi Thöøa, aùp         causation—See Phaùp Voâ Ngaõ. duïng cho baát cöù lyù thuyeát hay thöïc haønh naøo. Hai        Chö Phaùp Voâ Thöôøng: Impermanence of all lyù thuyeát ñoái nghòch hay nhöõng söï kieän khoù dung          dharmas. hôïp thöôøng ñöôïc keát laïi thaønh moät. Thoâng thöôøng        Chö Phaùp Voâ Thöôøng, Voâ Ngaõ Vaø Khoâng Thöïc: do phöông phaùp naøy maø ngöôøi ta ñi ñeán moät giaûi           All things are impermanent, non-self and unreal. phaùp eâm ñeïp cho moät vaán ñeà. Do keát quaû cuûa söï         Chö Phaùp Voâ Töôùng: Chö phaùp khoâng coù hình hoã töông nhieáp nhaäp vaø hoã töông hoøa hôïp, chuùng          töôùng thöôøng haèng nhaát ñònh—All things have no ta coù khaùi nieäm “Moät trong taát caû, taát caû trong moät.   permanent and fixed appearance, form, or sign. Moät ôû ñaøng sau taát caû, taát caû ôû ñaøng sau moät. Lôùn    Chö Phaät Gia: Nhaø cuûa chö Phaät, nhö Tònh Ñoä— vaø nhoû, cao hay thaáp, cuõng vaän chuyeån nhòp nhaøng         The home of all Buddhas, i.e. the Pure Land. vôùi nhau. Ngay caû nhöõng ñoùng goùp khieâm nhöôøng            Chö Phaät Haûi: Ocean of Buddhas. nhöùt vaøo coâng cuoäc hoøa ñieäu, cuõng khoâng ai coù theå     Chö Phaät Hieän Tieàn Tam Muoäi: Samadhi of taùch khoûi hay bieät laäp moät mình ñöôïc. Ñaây laø moät       Being in the Presence of All Buddhas—Tam muoäi trong möôøi nguyeân taéc caên baûn cuûa Hoa Nghieâm,            trong ñoù haønh giaû ñöùng maët ñoái maët vôùi chö Phaät; nhôø ñoù maø trieát lyù toång theå cuûa Hoa Nghieâm ñöôïc       loaïi tam muoäi naày ñöôïc thöïc haønh roäng raõi ôû AÁn giaûng giaûi vaø thuyeát minh khaû tính cuûa theá giôùi         Ñoä, Trung Hoa vaø Nhaät Baûn nhö phöông caùch “Söï Söï Voâ Ngaïi Phaùp Giôùi”—The theory of                   quaùn Phaät A Di Ñaø—The samadhi in which one freedom, i.e., freedom from ultimate disctinctions,             stands face to face with all Buddhas; this samadhi in which all elements are mutually identified. It is            has been widely practiced in India, China and a universal identification of all beings. Mutual                Japan as a method of visualizing Amitabha. identification is, in fact, self-negation. Identifying          Chö Phaät Keát Taäp Kinh: Buddha-Sangiti (skt)— oneself with another, one can synthesize with                   Sutra on collection of the Buddha-teachings— another. Negating oneself and identifying oneself               Kinh Keát Taäp Phaät Ñieån. with another constitute synthetical identification.             Chö Phaät Maãu Boà Taùt: Meï cuûa chö Phaät—The This is a peculiar theory or practice of Mahayana.              mother of all Buddhas. It is applied to any theory and practice. Two                   Chö Phaät Möôøi Phöông: The Buddhas of ten opposed theories or incompatible facts are often                directions—Chö Phaät möôøi phöông hieän leân töôùng identified. Often a happy solution of a question is             löôõi roäng daøi ñeå khen ngôïi Phaät Thích Ca— arrived at by the use of this method. As the result             Buddhas in the ten directions displayed vast and of mutual penetration and mutual identification.                long tongues to praise Sakyamuni Buddha. We have the concept “One in All, All in One. One                Chö Phaät Nhö Lai: Tathagata (skt)—Ones who behind All, All behind One.” The great and small,               have arrived in the state of reality. the high or low, moving harmoniously together. Chö Phaät Taâm Ñaø La Ni Kinh: Buddha-hrdaya- Even the humblest partaking of the work in peace, dharani (skt)—Sutra on all Buddhas' dharani. no one stands separately or independently alone.

Chö Phaät Taâm Kinh: See Chö Phaät Taâm Ñaø La                gioáng nhö nöôùc laø chaân nhö sanh ra soùng bieån laø Ni Kinh.                                                      caùc phaùp, neân goïi laø thöùc haûi). Chö Phaät Taäp Hoäi Ñaø La Ni Kinh: Sarva-                    Chö Taâm Taâm Sôû: Toaøn boä taâm vaø yù—All minds buddhangavati-dharani (skt)—Nhaát Thieát Chö                  and mental factors. Phaät Taäp Hoäi Ñaø La Ni Kinh—Teân khaùc cuûa kinh           Chö Teá: Nhöõng thöù chöôùng teá che ñaäy maát saùu Ba Phaùp Hoa—Another name of the Lotus Sutra.                    La Maät hay tònh taâm—Sins that smother the six Chö Phaät Thöôøng Truï Taâm: Taâm thöôøng truï maø            paramitas or the pure mind—See Luïc Teá. chö Phaät chöùng ñaéc, lieân heä vôùi loaïi trí hueä thaä m   Chö Thaùnh Chuùng: All the assembly of holy thaâm voâ löôïng—The permanent mind that                      ones. Buddhas realize, which associates with the                    Chö Thích Phaùp Vöông: 1) Phaùp Vöông cuûa boä profound and unfathomable wisdom.                             toäc Thích Ca: The dharma-king of all the Sakyas; Chö Phaät Trí Hueä Thaäm Thaâm Voâ Löôïng: Trí                2) Danh hieäu cuûa Phaät Thích Ca Maâu Ni: A title of hueä cuûa chö Phaät laø thaäm thaâm voâ löôïng—The            Sakyamuni Buddha. wisdom of the Buddhas is profound and                         Chö Thieân: Deva (skt)—Caùc loaïi Thieân (Nhöït unfathomable.                                                 Thieân, Nguyeät Thieân, Vi Ñaø Thieân, Luïc Duïc Chö Phaät Xöng Döông Nguyeän: See Boán Möôi                   Thieân, Töù Thieàn Thieân, Töù Khoâng Xöù Thieân, vaân Taùm Lôøi Nguyeän Cuûa Ñöùc Phaät A Di Ñaø (17).              vaân)—All the devas or gods. Chö Phaät Xöng Taùn Ích: Hieän Theá Lôïi Ích—Lôïi             Chö Thieân Ñoïa Xöù: Isipatana (p)—Rsipatana ích ñöôïc chö Phaät khen ngôïi trong cuoäc soáng hieän        (skt)—Ñòa danh noåi tieáng cuûa khu Loäc Uyeån— taïi—Benefits from Buddhas' praise in the present             Site of the famous Deer Park. life.                                                         Chö Thieân Nguõ Suy Töôùng: Five marks of decay Chö Phaät Xöng Taùn Nguyeän: Nguyeän möôøi                    of devas—See Nguõ Suy. phöông ñeàu ñöôïc chö Phaät khen ngôïi—See Boán               Chö Thoâng: See Thaàn Thoâng. Möôi Taùm Lôøi Nguyeän Cuûa Ñöùc Phaät A Di Ñaø               Chö Thuù: Chuùng sanh trong caùc coõi trôøi, ngöôøi, (17).                                                         ñòa nguïc, ngaï quyû, suùc sanh—All paths or Chö Phöông: Chö thieàn taêng ôû caùc nôi: Zen                 destinies of sentient existence, i.e. devas, men, monks from everywhere—Caùc thieàn vieän: Zen                  beings in purgatory, pretas, and animals. monasteries.                                                  Chö Thuyeát: All the speak. Chö Saùt Haûi: Ocean of lands—Soá löôïng quoác ñoä            Chö Thöôïng Thieän Nhaân: All have the highest raát nhieàu, ví nhö löôïng nöôùc bieån—The ocean of           level Bodhisattvas—See Thöôïng Thieän Boà Taùt. lands, great in number.                                       Chö Tieân: Taát caû nhöõng vò aån só tu tieân. Töø naày Chö Saéc: Taát caû caùc loaïi vaät—All kinds of things.       cuõng duøng ñeå chæ Baø La Moân—All the hermits, Chö Saéc Nhaøn Nhaân: Ngöôøi raûnh rang khoâng giöõ           mystics, rsi. A term also applied to the Brahmans. chöùc vuï gì trong töï vieän, aùm chæ ngöôøi voâ duïng—A      Chö Toân: All the honoured ones. person who has no position (keeps no post) in a               Chö Toâng: Taát caû nhöõng toâng phaùi trong Phaät monastery. In Zen, the term implies a person good             giaùo—All the sects in Buddhism. for nothing, or a useless person.                             Chö Traàn: Naêm traàn saéc, thanh, höông, vò vaø xuùc Chö Sinh: Caùc loaïi sinh—Way of birth.                       (laøm nhieãm oâ chaân tính)—All the atoms, or active Chö Soá: Taát caû moïi vaät hay moïi hieän töôïng—All         principle of form, sound, smell, taste, touch. the variety of things, all phenomena.                         Chö Tröôùc: Taát caû moïi chaáp tröôùc—All Chö Taêng: All the monks.                                     atachments—Phaøm phu chaáp tröôùc vaøo sinh töû. A Chö Taâm: Toaøn boä taâm thöùc—All minds.                     La Haùn (nhò thöøa) chaáp tröôùc vaøo nieát baøn. Boà Taùt Chö Taâm Haûi: Ocean of mind—Thöùc Haûi—The                   chaáp tröôùc vaøo söï chöùng ñaéc vaø cöùu ñoä cuûa bhutatathata as the store of all mind—Bieån cuûa              mình—The ordinary man is attached to life. The taïng thöùc. Goïi chaân nhö laø Nhö Lai taïng cuûa taïng      Arhat is attached to the nirvana. The bodhisattva thöùc (chaân nhö tuøy duyeân maø sinh ra caùc phaùp           to his realization and saving work.

Chö Töôùng: Caùc söï vaät hình töôùng khaùc nhau—             In Zen, the way of let go of anger is to enter the All the differentiating characteristics of things.            anger, become the anger rather than separate from Chö Uaån: Naêm uaån (saéc, thoï, töôûng, haønh, thöùc)—       it. Zen practitioners should always remember that All the skandhas.                                             if you even hold on to the notion of having to let Chöû: Naáu—To cook—To boil.                                   go of it, you are still stuck. Chöû Baù Tö (1909-?): Teân cuûa moät vò cö só Phaät           Chöa Döùt Nieäm Ñôøi: Have not yet severed giaùo noåi tieáng ngöôøi Trung Quoác vaøo theá kyû XX.        worldly thoughts. OÂng vieát toång coäng 64 boä saùch. Naêm 1981, oâng          Chöa Leân Bôø Ñaõ Voäi Phaù Beø: Prematurely xuaát baûn vaøi boä goàm: Trung Quoác Phaät Hoïc Söû          destroying the boat before stepping onto the shore. Luaän, Trung Quoác Thieàn Toâng Söû Thoaïi, vaø Thieàn        Chöa Ngoä Ñaïo: Have not yet attained or Toâng Döõ Thieàn Hoïc—Name of a famous Chinese                awakened the way. layperson in the twentieth century. He wrote a                Chöa Tinh Töôøng Veà Thieàn: Not well-versed in total of 64 books. In 1981, he published several              the Zen method. books: Chinese Treatise on History of                         Chöa Tinh Töôøng Veà Tònh Ñoä: Not well-versed Buddhology, Chinese History of Antics in Zen                  in the Pure Land method. Schools, and Zen Schools and Zen Studies.                     Chöùc Chuùng: Saéc Chuùng—See Saéc Uaån. Chöû Sa: Naáu caùt laøm côm—Boiling sand for rice             Chöùc Ñieàn Ñaéc Naêng (1860-1911): Master Che- (food).                                                       Tien—Teân cuûa moät vò danh Taêng Nhaät Baûn cuûa Chöû Vaân (1919-1986): Teân cuûa moät vò Taêng ngöôøi         toâng Chaân Ngoân vaøo theá kyû thöù XIX. Sö nghieân Trung Quoác vaøo theá kyû XX—Name of a famous                 cöùu hoïc thuyeát Duy Thöùc Toâng. Sö vieát raát nhieàu Chinese monk in the twentieth century.                        saùch Phaät giaùo. Naêm 1899 sö baét ñaàu soaïn boä Phaät Chöõ Nghóa: Letters and meanings—Literary                     Hoïc Ñaïi Töø Ñieån vaø hoaøn taát vaøo naêm sö thò tòch knowledge.                                                    (1911)—Name of a Japanese master of the Chöa Buoâng Xaû: Not yet letting go—Trong ñôøi                Shingon Sect in the nineteenth century. He studied soáng haèng ngaøy, chuùng ta nghó veà buoâng xaû nhö          theories of school of consciousness (Vijnanavada theå neùm boû ñi moïi thöù, chaám döùt moái quan heä, xoùa    (skt). He wrote a lot of Buddhist books. In 1899, boû baát cöù ñieàu gì ñang laøm phieàn chuùng ta. Nhöng       he started to compose and the Great Buddhist nhö theá chaúng khaùc naøo chuùng ta chæ keùo nhöõng          Dictionary and completed in the year he passed ngoùn tay ra khoûi caùi baãy. Chuùng ta, nhöõng phaøm         away (1911). nhaân buoâng xaû baèng caùch xoùa boû söï phaân caùch         Chöùc Naêng: Vyapana (skt)—Function. giöõa chuùng ta vaø ñieàu chuùng ta muoán buoâng xaû.         Chöng Sa: Naáu caùt—To cook sand—See Chöng Coù phaûi chuùng ta buoâng boû côn giaän chæ baèng caùch      Sa Taùc Phaïn. chaøo giaû bieät noù hay boû ñi? Dó nhieân laø khoâng phaûi   Chöng Sa Taùc Phaïn: Naáu caùt laøm côm, laø chuyeän nhö vaäy! Caùch ñoù khoâng coù hieäu quaû. Trong              khoâng theå naøo xaõy ra ñöôïc (trong Kinh Laêng Thieàn, caùch ñeå buoâng boû côn giaän laø ñi vaøo côn        Nghieâm, Ñöùc Phaät ñaõ nhaén nhuû ngaøi A Nan raèng: giaän, trôû thaønh côn giaän thay vì taùch rôøi khoûi noù.    “Neáu nhö oâng khoâng caét ñöùt söï daâm duïc maø tu Haønh giaû tu Thieàn neân luoân nhôù raèng neá u baïn         thieàn ñònh thì chaúng khaùc naøo naáu caùt maø muoán thaäm chí baùm laáy yù töôûng veà vieäc phaûi buoâng xaû,     thaønh côm, laøm gì coù chuyeän naáy! Traûi qua traêm laø baïn vaãn coøn bò vöôùng maéc—In our daily life,          nghìn kieáp, noù vaãn laø caùt noùng, bôûi caùi goác cuûa noù we think of letting go as doing something:                    khoâng phaûi laø côm, neân vaãn chæ laø caùt ñoù maø throwing things away, ending a relationship,                  thoâi)—Cooking sand for food, which is impossible. getting rid of whatever's bothering us. But that              Chöùng: Adhigama (skt)—Chính trí voâ laäu kheá hôïp works no better than just pulling our fingers in              vôùi chaân lyù sôû duyeân goïi laø chöùng. Chöùng bao haøm order to extricate them from the trap. We,                    ñoái töôïng ngoaøi taâm maø giaùc quan ta kinh nghieäm ordinary people, let go by eliminating the                    ñöôïc hay nhaän ra roõ raøng söï kieän ñoù nhö sôø sôø separation between us and what we wish to let go              tröôùc maét. Laøm cho thaáy roõ raøng tröôùc maét. Hieån of. Do we let go of anger by just saying good-bye             nhieân hay söï nhaän thöùc roõ raøng—To make visibly or going away? Of course not! That does not work.             present before the eyes. Evident or realization.

Chöùng Baát Hoaøn Quaû: Fully attain the status of            nghieäp chöôùng trong quaù khöù vaø hieän taïi laø khoâng. non-returner.                                                 Nhöng ngöôøi chöa giaùc ngoä thì phaûi taùi sanh ñeå traû Chöùng Baát Lai Quaû: Fully attain the status of              nôï tröôùc. Moät thí duï khaùc trong Chöùng Ñaïo Ca: once-returner.                                                      “Ma ni chaâu nhaân baát thöùc Chöùng Baát Thoái: Never receding from the                          Nhö Lai taøng lyù thaân thaâu ñaéc realization attained.                                               Luïc ban thaàn duïng khoâng baát khoâng Chöùng Boà Ñeà Toái Thöôïng: Realization of                         Nhaát thoûa vieân quang saéc phi saéc.” ultimate Enlightenment.                                             (Ngoïc ma-ni, ngöôøi chaúng bieát Chöùng Caûnh: Caûnh giôùi maø chö Phaät chöùng                      Nhö Lai kho aáy thaâu troïn heát ñöôïc—Lyù Chaân Nhö phaùp taùnh—The domain or                       Saùu ban thaàn duïng khoâng chaúng khoâng state of absolute enlightenment.                                    Moät ñieåm vieân quang saéc chaúng saéc). Chöùng Chaân Ñeá: To be perfectly aware of the                Song of Realization, a popular Zen writing, essence of true reason.                                       written by Yung-Chia-Hsuan-Chueh, one of the Chöùng Chuyeån: Evidential turn of the law-                   famous disciples of the Sixth Patriarch Hui-Neng wheel—Ñöùc Phaät duøng chöùng chuyeån ñeå giaûng              in the eighth century. In his “Song of trong vöôøn Loäc Uyeån veà vöôït thoaùt ñau khoå, moät        Enlightenment” Zen master Hsuan-Chiao said: trong ba loaïi chuyeån Phaùp luaân cuûa Ñöùc Phaät—                      “When truly understood, The Buddha preached in the Deer park on                                   all karmic obstructions, overcoming suffering, one of the three turns of the                       in their essence, are empty, law-wheel.                                                                When there is no realization, Chöùng Côù: Proof—Evidence.                                               All debts must be paid.” Chöùng Daãn: To quote—To cite.                                To the enlightened mind, past and present karmic Chöùng Döï Löu Quaû: Fully attain the status of               effects are non-existent, but if the practitioner has stream-winner.                                                not got enlightened, he must be reborn to pay his debts. Another example in the "Song of Chöùng Ñaïi Boà Ñeà: To experience, to attain to, or Realization": to prove perfect enlightenment. “You have a mani jewel, but you don’t know, Chöùng Ñaïo: Magga-sacchikaranam (p)— That Tathagata store can gather everything. Realization of the way—Religious experience— The six magical powers seem to be nothing, 1) Chöùng nghieäm toân giaùo hay thöïc chöùng con but not really void. ñöôøng chaân lyù cuûa chö Phaät: Religious experience The round, bright ball has a form, or having attained the way (of mystic experience) but it is formless.” or to witness to the truth; 2) Chöùng ñöôïc ñaïo hay Chöùng Ñaïo Ca Chuù: Saùch chuù thích quyeån Chöùng chöùng nghieäm toân giaùo hay söï laõnh hoäi roõ raøng hay Ñaïo Ca—Interpretation of the Song of nhaän ra roõ raøng veà ñaïo: Actualize the Enlightenment. wayUnderstanding clearly or realizing the Path. Chöùng Ñaïo Keä: Doha (skt)—Gatha or verse of Chöùng Ñaïo Ca: Shodoka (jap)—A song of Realization. Enlightenment—Baøi Chöùng Ñaïo Ca laø moät baøi vieát veà thieàn raát ñöôïc phoå bieán, ñöôïc Thieàn sö       Chöùng Ñaïo Quaû: Maggaphala-sacchikaranam Trung Quoác Huyeàn Giaùc Vónh Gia, moät trong                 (p)—Realizing the Paths and Fruitions. nhöõng ñeä töû xuaát saéc cuûa Luïc Toå Hueä Naêng vaøo       Chöùng Ñaïo Quaû Boà Ñeà: Obtain perfect ñôøi nhaø Ñöôøng, vaøo theá kyû thöù VIII. Trong “Chöùng      enlightenment—Ñaây laø moät trong taùm loaïi thaéng Ñaïo Ca” Thieàn Sö Huyeàn Giaùc ñaõ daïy:                     phaùp. Nhöõng ai thoï trì baùt trai giôùi seõ ñöôïc taùm “Lieãu töùc nghieäp chöôùng baûn lai khoâng              loaïi coâng ñöùc thuø thaéng—This is one of the eight Vò lieãu öng tu hoaøn tuùc traùi.”                     surpassing things. Those who keep the first eight (Khi toû roõ roài thì nghieäp chöôùng hoùa thaønh        commandments receive eight kinds of reward. khoâng, chöa toû roõ nôï xöa ñaønh trang traûi).        Chöùng Ñaéc: Adhisambodha (skt)—Thöïc chöùng Lieãu töùc laø lieãu ngoä, ngöôøi lieãu ngoä roài thì thaáy   nôi töï thaân (laáy chaùnh trí chöùng ngoä chaân lyù)— Attained—To realize—To attain truth by personal

experience—See Chöùng.                                        Chöùng Kieán: To behold—To witness—To Chöùng Ñaéc Nhaát Thieát Luaän Trí: Chöùng ñaéc heát          testify—Caùi nhìn thaät söï hoaøn toaøn thaáy ñöôïc chaân thaûy caùc phaùp—Realize full comprehension of all            nhö—Fully actualized view of reality. theories.                                                     Chöùng Kieán Caûnh Sanh, Giaø, Bònh, Cheát : Chöùng Ñaéc Nhò Ñaïo: Hai caùch chöùng ñaéc: Chöùng           Witnessed the misfortunes of birth, old age, ngoä baèng caùch tu taäp giaùo phaùp vaø chöùng ngoä baèng    disease and death. caùch tu taäp thieàn ñònh—Two ways of realization:            Chöùng Kim Cang Thaân Realization of the Realization by teaching and              Realization by       diamond embodiment. experience.                                                   Chöùng Lieân (1893-1967): Teân cuûa moät vò Taêng Chöùng Ñaéc Thaéng Nghóa Ñeá: Y moân hieån thaät              ngöôøi Trung Quoác vaøo theá kyû XX. Vaøo naêm 1925, ñeá—Postulates on the void or the immaterial.                 Sö trôû thaønh phaùp töû ñôøi thöù 47 doøng thieàn Nam Chöùng Ñaéc Theá Tuïc Ñeá: Phöông Tieän An Laäp               Nhaïc Hoaøi Nhöôïng—Name of a famous Chinese Ñeá—Abstract postulates (the four Noble Truths).              monk in the twentieth century. In 1925, he became Chöùng Ñaéc Trí Tueä Baùt Nhaõ: Ñaït ñöôïc trí tueä           the dharma heir of the forty-seventh lineage of the vöôït sang meù beân kia—Realization of Prajna-                Nan-yueh Huai-jang Zen branch. paramita—Realization of supreme wisdom.                       Chöùng Minh: To prove clearly—To have the Chöùng Ñeä Nhaát Ñeá Phaùp: Chöùng phaùp ñeä nhöùt            clear witness within. ñeá—Realize the foremost truth.                               Chöùng Nghieäm: Anubhuti (skt)—To verify— Chöùng Ñònh Luïc: Record of Attainment of                     Experimental evidence—Söï hieåu bieát khoâng do Samadhi—Ngöõ luïc veà söï chöùng ngoä bí maät veà A           kyù öùc, nhö söï hieåu bieát töø tri giaùc, caûm thoï, vaø caûm Di Ñaø Tam Muoäi cuûa sö Phaùp Nhieân trong khoaûng           giaùc, vaân vaân—Knowledge derived from any thôøi gian töø naêm 1198 ñeán 1206. Ngöôøi ta tin raèng       sources but memory, i.e., knowledge from chính sö Phaùp Nhieân ñaõ vieát boä 'Chöùng Ñònh Luïc'        perception, from feelings, from sensing, etc. nhöng giöõ bí maät; ñeán khi oâng thò tòch thì ñeä töû cuûa   Chöùng Kim Cang Thaân: Realization of the oâng laø Genchi ñaõ cho xuaát baûn—A record of                diamond embodiment. Honen's mysterious experience of Amitabha                     Chöùng        Nghieäm        Taâm         Linh:      Spiritual Samadhi during the period of 1198 to 1206. It is              Experience—Taâm nghieäm—Lôøi tuyeân boá noåi believed that Honen himself wrote this but kept it            tieáng cuûa Ñöùc Phaät “Soáng laø khoå”, ta chôù neân coi secret; after his death Genchi published this.                ñoù nhö laø moät thoâng ñieäp chaùn ñôøi. Noùi soáng laø Chöùng Ñöùc: Chöùng ñöùc hay chöùng ñöôïc thaàn löïc          khoå nhaèm vaøo thöïc traïng; trong cuoäc taâm nghieäm, baèng caùch tu taäp Töù Dieäu Ñeá, 12 Nhaân Duyeân vaø        ai trong chuùng ta cuõng ñeàu phaûi ñöùng leân töø thöïc Luïc Ñoä, cho caû Tieåu laãn Ñaïi Thöøa—Attainment of         traïng aáy. Vaø taâm nghieäm laø gì neáu khoâng laø thöïc virtue, or spiritual power, through the four                  nghieäm caùi khoå aáy? Ai khoâng khoå khoâng theå naøo dogmas, twelve nidanas and six paramitas, in both             vöôït leân ñöôïc. Ai coù ñaïo taâm ñeàu phaûi khoå noãi Hinayana and Mahayana.                                        khoå cuûa theá gian. Ngaøi Duy Ma Caät noùi, Phaät beänh Chöùng Ñöôïc Trí Tueä: To attain wisdom.                      vì taát caû chuùng sanh beänh. Khi taät beänh vaây ta töù Chöùng Giaùc: Chöùng ngoä ñöôïc chaân lyù ñaïo Phaät :        phía, neáu laø ngöôøi coù ñaïo taâm, laøm sao maø ta khoûi To prove and perceive, to know by experience—                 beänh theo? Phaät laø ñaáng Ñaïi Bi neân taâm cuûa Ngaøi Söï tænh thöùc ñaõ ñöôïc nhaän ra: Actualized                 luoân nhòp theo chuùng sanh, daàu höõu tình hay voâ awakening.                                                    tình—The noted Buddhist declaration that life is Chöùng Kheá: Shokai (jap)—Kinh nghieäm gioáng                 pain or suffering, must not be understood as a nhö traïng thaùi cuûa Phaät—To experience the same            message of pessimism. That life is pain is a plain state as the Buddha.                                          statement of fact, and all our spiritual experience Chöùng Khoâng (1177-1247): Teân cuûa moät vò                  starts from this fact. In fact, the so-called “spiritual danh Taêng Nhaät Baûn cuûa phaùi Taây Sôn, Tònh Ñoä           experience” is no more than the experience of toâng vaøo theá kyû thöù XIII—Name of a Japanese              pain raised above mere sensation. Those who master of the Hsi-shan branch of Japanese Pure                cannot feel pain can never go beyond themselves. Land Sect in the thirteenth century.                          All religious-minded people are sufferers of life-

pain. The Buddha says that Vimalakirti is sick                   vöùt raùc. Thieàn laø cuoäc soáng, cuoäc soáng cuûa chuùng because all sentient beings are sick. When we are                ta. Ñoù laø ñaït ñeán chöùng ngoä raèng moïi hieän töôïng surrounded by sickness on all sides, how can we,                 khoâng laø gì caû, maø laø nhöõng bieåu hieän cuûa chính if spiritually disposed, be free from being sick?                toâi. Vaø caùi 'chính toâi' aáy laø bieåu hieän troïn veïn cuûa The heart of the Compassionate One always beats                  moïi vaät. Ñoù laø moät cuoäc soáng voâ haïn ñònh. Coù with those of his fellow-beings, sentient and non-               nhieàu aån duï khaùc nhau cho moât cuoäc soáng nhö theá. sentient.                                                        Nhöng aån duï maø toâi cho laø höõu duïng nhaát vaø yù Chöùng Ngoä: Sakshatkara-sambhodhana (skt)—                      nghóa nhaát ñeán töø nhaø beáp. Caùc Thieàn sö goïi cuoäc Shogo (jap)—Attainment—The experience of                         soáng ñaày ñuû vaø troïn veïn, khoâng giöõ laïi ñieàu gì enlightenment—Duøng chaùnh trí ñeå chöùng thöïc                  baèng töø ngöõ 'böõa aên toái thöôïng.' Vaø ngöôøi soáng hieåu bieát chaân lyù (söï chöùng ngoä khoâng do trao            cuoäc soáng nhö theá, ngöôøi bieát saép xeáp, bieát naáu truyeàn maø haønh giaû phaûi töï chöùng laáy)—Mystic             nöôùng, bieát traân quí, bieát doïn leân böõa aên toái insight, conviction by thinking, realization, to                 thöôïng nhö theá, ñöôïc goïi laø ngöôøi ñaàu beáp prove and ponder.                                                Thieàn—Bernard Glassman and Rick Fields wrote Chöùng Ngoä Boà Ñeà: True way to know Buddha—                    in Instructions to the Cook: "At its deepest, most Thaät söï thaáy Phaät—Thaáy phaùp hay chöùng ngoä Boà            basic level, Zen, or any other spiritual path, for Ñeà laø thaät söï thaáy Phaät—The true way to know               that matter, is much more than a list of what we Buddha is to realize Enlightenment.                              can get from it. In fact, Zen is the realization of Chöùng Ngoä Ca: Doha (skt)—Gur (tib)—Songs of                    the oneness of life in all its aspects. It's not just the the mahasiddhas—Songs of masters with perfect                    pure or 'spiritual' part of life: it's the whole thing. abilities.                                                       It's flowers, mountains, rivers, streams, and the Chöùng Ngoä Chaân Lyù: The realization of correct                inner city and homeless children on Forty-second views—See Kieán Ñeá.                                             Street. It's the empty sky and the cloudy sky and Chöùng Ngoä Laø Keát Quaû Cuûa Thieàn Ñònh:                      the smoggy sky, too. It's the pigeon flying in the Enlightened as the result of insight.                            empty sky, the pigeon shitting in the empty sky, Chöùng Ngoä Nieát Baøn: Nibbana-sacchikiriya (p)—                and walking through the pigeon droppings on the Sacchikarana (skt)—Realization of Nibbana—                       sidewalk. It's the rose growing in the garden, the Realization of Nirvana.                                          cut rose shinning in the vase in the living room, Chöùng Ngoä Nhaát Töôùng: The realization of the                 the garbage where we throw away the rose, and oneness of life in all its aspects—Bernard                       the compost where we throw away the garbage. Glassman and Rick Fields vieát trong quyeån Truø                 Zen is life, our life. It's coming to the realization Phoøng Chæ Daãn: "Treân caên baûn thaâm saâu nhaát,              that all things are nothing but expressions of Thieàn, hoaëc taát caû moïi ñaïo giaùo khaùc, khoâng phaûi       myself. And myself is nothing but the full chæ laø moät baûng lieät keâ nhöõng gì chuùng ta coù theå coù    expression of all things. It's a life without limits. ñöôïc töø Thieàn. Thaät ra, Thieàn laø söï chöùng ngoä tính      There are many different metaphors for such a nhaát töôùng cuûa cuoäc soáng qua taát caû caùc khía caïnh.      life. But the one that I have found the most useful, Khoâng phaûi chæ laø cuoäc soáng thuaàn khieát hay taâm          and the most meaningful, comes from the kitchen. linh: noù laø toång theå cuûa söï vaät. AÁy laø hoa, laø nuùi,   Zen masters call a life that is lived fully and soâng, suoái, vaø khu noäi thaønh cuøng nhöõng ñöùa treû         completely, with nothing held back, 'the supreme voâ gia cö treân Phoá 42. AÁy laø baàu trôøi quang ñaõng,        meal.' And a person who lives such a life, a person baàu trôøi phuû ñaày maây muø, baàu trôøi môø söông khoùi.       who knows how to plan, cook, appreciate, serve, AÁy laø chuù boà caâu bay giöõa baàu trôøi quang ñaõng,          and offer the supreme meal of life, is called a Zen chuù boà caâu æa baäy giöõa baàu trôøi quang ñaõng, vaø          cook." böôùc ñi ngang qua phaân chim boà caâu treân vóa heø.            Chöùng Ngoä Thieàn: Realization of Zen. AÁy laø nuï hoa hoàng moïc giöõa vöôøn, aáy laø nuï hoa          Chöùng Ngoân: Chöùng tích—Testimony—Chöùng hoàng ñaõ caét, raïng rôõ caém trong chieác bình trong           minh—Lôøi chöùng—Thanh minh—Evidence. phoøng khaùch. AÁy laø thuøng raùc, nôi chuùng ta vöøa           Chöùng Nhaân: Witness. vöùt nuï hoàng taøn uùa, vaø laø ñoáng phaân uû nôi ngöôøi ta    Chöùng Nhaän: To certify—To attest.

Chöùng Nhaäp: 1) Laáy chaùnh trí nhö thöïc chöùng              daàn trôû neân thaønh thaïo vôùi loái ñeám naøy, taát caû ñöôïc chaân lyù: Experiential entry into Buddha-               voïng töôûng seõ bò tröø khöû, vaø tieán trình ñeám töø moät truth; 2) Phaàn Chöùng: Partial, as in Hinayana and            ñeán möôøi seõ ñöôïc hoaøn thaønh khoâng giaùn ñoaïn. early Mahayana; 3) Toaøn Chöùng (vieân maõn):                  Hôi thôû cuûa haønh giaû luùc ñoù seõ trôû neân raát vi teá, Complete, as in the perfect school of Mahayana.                nheï nhaøng vaø thuaàn thuïc. Luùc ñoù söï caàn thieát cuûa Chöùng Nhaäp Sinh: Realization of life in                      vieäc ñeám hôi thôû giaûm bôùt, ñeán noãi noù trôû thaønh Buddhahood.                                                    gaùnh naëng cho haønh giaû. Kinh nghieäm naøy ñöôïc Chöùng Phaùp: Sakkhi-dhammam (p)—Chöùng ñöôïc                  goïi laø "Chöùng Soå Töùc". Khi haønh giaû ñaõ ñaït ñeán ñaïo quaû nieát baøn: Realization of dharmas,                  trình ñoä naøy, haønh giaû chaám döùt pheùp soå töùc vaø realization of experiential proof of the dharma in             tieán ñeán giai ñoaïn "Tuøy Töùc"—There are many bodhi or nirvana—Chöùng trong lôøi nguyeän thöù 11             methods of contemplation, but the method of cuûa Phaät A Di Ñaø: Realization or proof of the               contemplation by counting the breathing is the eleventh of Amitabha’s vows.                                   easiest way to practice. A meditation of counting Chöùng Phaùt Taâm: The realization or proof of or              breathings to eliminate scattering thoughts. union with bodhi—Chöùng phaùt taâm laø moät trong              Through repeated practice one will gradually ba thöù phaùt taâm. Hai thöù kia laø tín thaønh töïu phaùt     become well-versed in this counting exercise, all taâm vaø giaûi haønh phaùt taâm—The realization or             distracting thoughts will be eliminated, and the proof of or union with bodhi is one of the three               process of counting from one to ten will be vows of the awakening of faith. The other two                  completed without interruption. The breathing will cows include to perfect bodhi of faith and to                  then become very subtle, light, and tamed. Now understand and carry into practice this wisdom.                the need for counting the breath diminishes, Chöùng Phaät: Sho-Butsu (jap)—Experiencing                     counting has even become a burden to the Buddha or realizing Buddha.                                    practitioner. This experience is called "Realizing Chöùng Phaät Trí: Buddha-Jnana (skt)—                          the counting of breath". When the practitioner has Realization of Buddha-knowledge—Ñaây laø moät                  reached this level, he stops and proceeds to the trong möôøi lyù do lieân heä ñeán ñôøi soáng khieán haønh      next level knwon as "Following the Breath."—See giaû mong caàu giaùc ngoä. Theo Kinh Hoa Nghieâm,              Luïc Dieäu Moân. vaán ñeà öôùc voïng giaùc ngoä toái thöôïng caàn thieát cho    Chöùng Thaønh: Chöùng minh giaûng giaûi roõ raøng haønh giaû—For the realization of Buddha-                      nhöõng ñieàu ñaõ noùi laø ñuùng vôùi chaân lyù—Make knowledge. This is one of ten reasons related to               perfect sense in one’s explanation of a matter and our daily life which lead practitioners desire for             prove that it is in accordance with the truth. enlightenment. According to the Avatamsaka                     Chöùng Thaønh Ñaïo Lyù: Giaûng giaûi roõ raøng ñaïo Sutra, the desire for supreme enlightenment is so              lyù—Make perfect sense in one’s explanation of a necessary for practitioners.                                   matter. Chöùng Quaû: Quaû chöùng ñöôïc trong töøng giai ñoaïn          Chöùng Thaâm Tueä: Nhöõng ngöôøi töï mình hieåu khaùc nhau (Tieåu Thöøa chöùng töù Thaùnh quaû, Ñaïi           ñöôïc trí naêng saâu saéc. Ñaây laø moät trong ba loaïi Thöøa Boà Taùt chöùng Thaäp Ñòa, Phaät chöùng Phaät            ngöôøi coù theå böôùc theo neûo Ñaïi Thöøa —Those who quaû chaùnh trí voâ laäu)—The fruits or rewards of the         realize the most profound wisdom or Prajna. This various stages of attainment.                                  is one of the three types of beings who can tread Chöùng Saéc Manh: Chöùng loaïn saéc—                           the path of the Mahayana. Achromatopsy.                                                  Chöùng Thaät: To prove—To certify. Chöùng Sô Ñòa Boà Taùt (Hoan hyû Ñòa): To attain               Chöùng Thoâng Tueä: Chöùng ñöôïc trí tueä thaáu the first Bodhisattva stage of extreme joy.                    suoát—Actualize the penetrating insight. Chöùng Soå Töùc: To realize the counting of                    Chöùng Thö: Certificate—Diploma. breath—Coù nhieàu phöông phaùp quaùn, nhöng quaùn              Chöùng Tích: Testimony. soå töùc laø deã thöïc haønh nhaát. Soå töùc laø pheùp quaùn   Chöùng Tín Töï: Thoâng töï baét ñaàu baèng caâu “Toâi ñeám hôi thôû ñeå loaïi tröø nhöõng taïp nieäm. Baèng          nghe nhö vaày.”—The ordinary opening phrase of caùch tu taäp laëp ñi laëp laïi nhö vaäy, haønh giaû daàn      a sutra, “Thus I have heard.”

Chöùng         Tri:      Adhigamavabodha             (skt)—      toaøn lieân tuïc. Luùc ñoù haønh giaû caûm thaáy khoâng khí Realization—Haønh giaû khoâng neân laàm laãn lieãu tri           maø mình hít vaøo lan toûa khaép chaâu thaân, ñeán ngay Thieàn baèng moät thaùi ñoä tri thöùc vôùi söï chöùng tri        caû ñaàu sôïi loâng cuõng coù; vaø taâm mình trôû neân raát tröïc tieáp chaân lyù Thieàn. Lieãu tri moät vieäc khoâng coù    yeân bình vaø thanh tònh. Kinh nghieäm naøy ñöôïc goïi nghóa laø chöùng tri vieäc ñoù. Chöùng tri thieàn laø tröïc      laø "Chöùng Tuøy Töùc." Khi haønh giaû ñaït ñeán ñieåm tieáp kinh nghieäm thieàn khi chuùng ta phaûi vöùt boû           naøy thì "Tuøy Töùc" cuõng trôû thaønh moät gaùnh naëng heát taát caû nhöõng gì ñaõ thaâu hoaïch ñöôïc baèng tri         maø haønh giaû caàn phaûi buoâng boû noù nhö ñaõ buoâng thöùc khaùi nieäm. Hieåu ñöôïc caùi vò kyø dieäu cuûa moät       boû soá töùc vaäy, ñeå tieán leân giai ñoaïn keá tieáp laø "chæ taùch traø xanh khoâng phaûi laø ñaõ thöïc söï neám caùi vò      quaùn"—Contemplation by following of breathings ñoù. Caùi hieåu bieát naøy so vôùi vieäc hieåu Thieàn thì        to eliminate scattering thoughts. Through repeated caùi hieåu Thieàn coù phaàn tröïc tieáp hôn laø giaùn tieáp,     practice one will gradually become well-versed in laäp töùc hôn laø tröøu töôïng, vaø sieâu vieät hôn laø nhò      this following of breath exercise, all distracting nguyeân. Lieãu tri thuoäc phaïm vi cuûa 'tæ löôïng caûnh         thoughts will be eliminated. The breathing will giôùi'; trong khi chöùng tri thuoäc phaïm vi cuûa 'hieän         then become very subtle, light, and tamed. In this löôïng caûnh giôùi'—Zen practitioners should not fail            stage, the practitioner's mind merges itself with his to distinguish between 'to understand' and 'to                   breathing, following it in and out with ease and in realize'. To understand a thing does not mean to                 perfect continuity. He will now feel that the air he realize it. To realize Zen means to experience                   takes in spreads throughout his entire body, even Zen directly, while practitioners must abandon all               reaching the tip of every hair; and his mind will that they have acquired by way of conceptual                     become very calm and serene. This experience is knowledge. To understand the wonnderful taste of                 called "Realizing the Following of Breath". When a cup of green tea is not to have actually                       the practitioner reaches this point, "Following of experienced that taste. This understanding is                    Breath" also becomes a burden, and he should comparable to understanding Zen as being direct                  then abandon it as he did the counting and proceed rather than indirect, immediate rather than                      to the next level of "Stopping Practice"—See Luïc abstract, and transcendental rather than dualistic.              Dieäu Moân. 'To understand' belongs to the domain of 'indirect               Chöùng Töï Chöùng Phaàn: Rewitnessing of self- measurement', while 'to realize' belongs to the                  witness or the reassuring portion—Theo Giaùo Sö domain of 'direct discernment'.                                  Junjiro Takakusu trong Cöông Yeáu Trieát Hoïc Phaät Chöùng         Trí:      Adhigamavabodha             (skt)—      Giaùo, trong Phaùp Töôùng Toâng, ñaây laø moät trong Experiential knowledge—Ñaõ chöùng ñöôïc trí hueä.                boán phaàn cuûa moãi thöùc vôùi baûn chaát lieân ñôùi. Chöùng trí voâ laäu cuûa Boà Taùt ôû ngoâi sô ñòa ngoä lyù       Chöùng töï chöùng phaàn hoaøn thaønh taùc duïng cuûa taâm trung ñaïo chaân thöïc—Actualized wisdom.                        thöùc—According to Prof. Junjiro Takakusu in Realization or attainment of truth by the                        “The Essentials of Buddhist Philosophy,” the bodhisattva in the first stage.                                  Dharmalaksana School, this is one of the four Chöùng Trí Sôû Haïnh: Pratyatma-gatigocharam                     functional divisions of interdependent nature of (skt)—Conduct of realization of wisdom.                          each of the consciousness. The rewitnessing of Chöùng Truù Manh: Chöùng muø veà ban ngaøy—Day-                  self-witness or the reassuring portion: The blindness.                                                       rewitnessing of the self-witness completes the Chöùng Tuøy Töùc: To realize the following of                    mental faculty. breath—Tuøy töùc quaùn laø pheùp quaùn theo doõi hôi             Chöôùc Ca Baø La: Cakravala (skt)—Hai voøng nuùi thôû ñeå loaïi tröø nhöõng taïp nieäm. Baèng caùch tu taäp       ñoàng taâm taïo neân chu vi cuûa theá giôùi—The double laëp ñi laëp laïi nhö vaäy, haønh giaû daàn daàn trôû neân       concentric circles of mountains forming the thaønh thaïo vôùi caùch theo doõi naøy, taát caû voïng           periphery of a world—See Thieát Vi Sôn. töôûng seõ bò tröø khöû. Hôi thôû cuûa haønh giaû luùc ñoù seõ   Chöôùc Ca La Baø Ca Ñieåu: Cakravaka (skt)—Teân trôû neân raát vi teá, nheï nhaøng vaø thuaàn thuïc. Trong       cuûa moät loaøi chim uyeân (ñoâi uyeân öông, con troáng giai ñoaïn naøy, taâm haønh giaû hoøa vaøo vôùi hôi thôû,        goïi laø uyeân, con maùi goïi laø öông)—Name of a nöông theo noù ra vaøo moät caùch deã daõi vaø hoaøn             kind of bird (drake of mandarin duck).

Chöôùc Ca La Sôn Vöông: Cakravala-raja (skt)—               "Regarding the mind-ground teaching that has Luaân Vi Sôn Vöông—King of the double                       been passed down from the ancestral teachers, is concentric circles of mountains.                            the mind they speak of the true mind, the deluded Chöôùc Nhieân: Thöïc söï—Actually—As a matter of            mind, or neither the true nor the deluded mind? fact—Indeed—In fact—Really.                                 And is it the mind that stands outside the teaching Chöông: A chapter—A section—Essay—                          of the Three Vehicle?" Zhangjing said, "Do you Document.                                                   see the emptiness before the eyes?" The monk Chöông An (561-632): Teân cuûa moät vò Taêng                said, "I believe that knowledge is always before ngöôøi Trung Quoác vaøo thôøi nhaø Tuøy (581-618)—          the eyes. People don't see this for themselves." Name of a famous Chinese monk in the Sui                    Zhangjing said, "Don't you see form?" The monk dynasty.                                                    said, "What is your meaning, Master?" Zhangjing Chöông Bænh Laân (1868-1936): Teân cuûa moät hoïc           raised his hand and poked the air three times, giaû Phaät giaùo noåi tieáng ngöôøi Trung Quoác vaøo theá   saying, "What am I doing when I do this?" The he kyû XIX. OÂng vieát toång coäng raát nhieàu saùch Phaät     said, "You'll understand in the future." giaùo. OÂng ñaõ xuaát baûn vaøi boä goàm: Duyeân Khôûi      Chöông Kính Hoaøi Huy Thieàn Sö (756-815): Tính Khoâng, Voâ Thaàn Luaän, Nhaân Voâ Ngaõ Luaän,         Shokei-Eki (jap)—Chang-ching Huai-hui (Wade- Töù Hoaëc Luaän, vaø Ñaïi Thöøa Phaät Giaùo Duyeân          Giles Chinese)—Zhangjing Huai-hui (Pinyin Khôûi Luaän—Name of a famous Chinese Buddhist               Chinese)—Teân cuûa moät ñeä töû vaø truyeàn nhaân noái scholar in the nineteenth century. He wrote a lot           phaùp cuûa ngaøi Maõ Toå Ñaïo Nhaát. Teân oâng xuaát of Buddhist books. From 1900 to 1936, he                    hieän trong thí duï thöù 31 cuûa Bích Nham Luïc. Coù published several books: The Nature Void of the             raát ít chi tieát veà cuoäc ñôøi cuûa Thieàn sö Chöông Environmental Cause of All Phenomena,                       Kính Hoaøi Huy; tuy nhieân, coù moät vaøi chi tieát nhoû Commentary on Atheism, Commentary on                        veà vò Thieàn sö naøy trong boä Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, Pudgalanairatmya (Egolessness of Person),                   quyeån VII: Thieàn sö Chöông Kính goác ngöôøi Commentary on Four Kinds of Delusion, and                   Tuyeàn Chaâu, baây giôø laø vuøng Phuùc Chaâu thuoäc Commentary            on      Mahayana        Buddhism      tænh Phuùc Kieán—Name of a student and dharma Environmental Cause of All Phenomena.                       successor of Ma-Tsu-Tao-I. We encounter his Chöông Kheâ Sôn Thieàn Sö: Zen master Chang of              name in example 31 of the Pi-Yen-Lu (the Blue Hsi-shan—See Kheâ Sôn Chöông Thieàn Sö.                     Cliff Record). Few other details about Zhangjing's Chöông Kính Baát Khoâng: The koan of Zen                    life are available in the classical records; master Zhangjing who poked the air—Coâng aùn                however, there is some brief information on him Thieàn sö Chöông Kính Hoaøi Huy ñöa tay leân choït          in the Records of the Transmission of the Lamp vaøo hö khoâng—Theo Truyeàn Ñaêng Luïc, Quyeån              (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu), Volume VII: Zen master VII, moät hoâm, coù moät vò Taêng hoûi Thieàn sö            Zhangjing came from Quanzhou, near modern Chöông Kính: "Toå sö truyeàn phaùp moân taâm ñòa, aáy       Fuzhou in Fujian Province. laø taâm chaân nhö, taâm voïng töôûng, taâm khoâng chaân,    Moät hoâm, Thieàn sö Chöông Kính thöôï ng khoâng voïng, hay laø taâm bieät laäp ngoaøi Tam Thöøa            ñöôøng thò chuùng: "Chí lyù queân lôøi, thôøi nhaân Giaùo?" Chöông Kính ñaùp: "OÂng coù thaáy hö khoâng               khoâng bieát, coá hoïc laáy nhöõng ñieàu voâ boå maø tröôùc maét khoâng?" Vò Taêng ñaùp: "Con tin laø taïi             cho laø coù coâng ñöùc. Hoï khoâng thöïc chöùng raèng tröôùc maét. Ngöôøi ta khoâng töï thaáy ñoù thoâi."               töï taùnh voán khoâng traàn caûnh. Noù laø phaùp moân Chöông Kính noùi: "Khoâng phaûi oâng thaáy töôùng ñoù             giaûi thoaùt vi dieäu. Kieán giaùc (giaùm giaùc) ngoä sao?" Vò Taêng noùi: "Coøn Hoøa Thöôïng thì theá                  khoâng nhieãm khoâng tònh, nhöng saùng rôõ nhö naøo?" Chöông Kính ñöa tay leân choït vaøo hö khoâng              theá, chöa töøng pheá boû. Töø bao ñôøi ñeán nay ba laàn, vaø noùi: "Laõo Taêng ñang laøm caùi gì ñaây khi         chaúng heà thay ñoåi. Gioáng nhö maët nhaät, gaàn laøm nhö vaày?" Roài Chöông Kính noùi: "Sau naøy taát             xa gì ñeàu chieáu saùng; tuy cuøng laãn loän vôùi voâ oâng seõ hoäi thoâi."—According to the Records of the             soá hình boùng vaø saéc töôùng, noù luoân giöõ mình Transmission of the Lamp (Ch’uan-Teng-Lu),                        taùch bieät vôùi söï hieän höõu höõu vi. Noù nhö ngoïn Volume VII, a monk asked Zen master Zhangjing,                    ñuoác linh dieäu, chaúng caàn phaûi tinh luyeän, noù

hieän höõu khoâng caàn giaûng giaûi, vaø sieâu vieät         "What speech that was. Seldom does one traàn töôùng. Nhöng ngöôøi ta naën maét vaø voïng            encounter such an adept!" khôûi hoa ñoám treân khoâng, töï mình lao nhoïc         Coù moät vò Taêng treû vöøa môùi ñi haønh cöôùc trôû trong voâ soá kieáp. Chæ khi naøo töï mình soi laïi          veà. Chöông Kính hoûi: "OÂng ñaõ rôøi xa nôi ñaây beân trong, nôi khoâng coù ngöôøi khaùc, thì chöøng          bao laâu roài?" Vò Taêng ñaùp: "Con rôøi Hoøa ñoù môùi khoâng laøm khuy toån thaät töôùng."—One            Thöôïng chöøng taùm naêm roài." Chöông Kính day, Zen master Zhangjing entered the hall                   hoûi: "Vaäy chöù baáy laâu nay oâng laøm ñöôïc and addressed the congregation, saying, "The                 nhöõng gì?" Vò Taêng veõ moät voøng troøn döôùi true way is not reached without abandoning                   ñaát. Chöông Kính hoûi: "Chæ coù vaäy aø? Coøn gì words. These days, people don't understand                   khaùc nöõa khoâng?" Vò Taêng boâi maát voøng troøn this. They diligently study useless things and               vaø leã baùi Sö. Chöông Kính noùi: "Khoâng phaûi! regard such activity as meritorious. They don't              Khoâng phaûi!"—A young adept returned from realize that self-nature is fundamentally                    a pilgrimage. Zhangjing asked him, "How unblemished. It is a sublime gate of                         long ago did you leave here?" The monk said, liberation. The mirror of awakening is neither               "I left you about eight years ago." Zhangjing tainted nor pure, but is like a brilliant light,             said, "What have you been doing?" The monk unceasing and undiminished. Through bygone                   drew a circle on the ground. Zhangjing said, eons down to the present time it is unchanged.               "Just this? Nothing else?" The monk erased It is like the sun, shining near or far, and                 the circle and bowed. Zhangjing said, "No! though appearing in countless shades and                     No!" forms, it remains apart from conditioned               Chöông Phuïc: Maëc ñuùng theo quy luaät—Code existence. The spiritual light is ethereal and         or regulation dress. luminous, without need of refinement,                  Chöông Sôù: Commentary—Lôøi chuù giaûi. existing without explanation, and beyond               Chöôùng: Kincanam or Palibhodho (p)—Varana or objects or form. But people press on their             Avarana               (skt)—Concealing—Hindrance— eyeballs and conjure up fantastic empty                Hiding—Impediment—Interruption—Mental illusions, belaboring themselves for numerous          blindness—Obstacle—Obstruction—Screen and eons. If only they would shine the light               obstruction—Theo Phaät giaùo Ñaïi Thöøa, "chöôùng" inward, where there is no 'other' person, cease        (avarana) laø moät trong hai yeáu toá laøm u meâ hay all activity, and not forsake true emptiness."         chöôùng ngaïi chuùng sanh cöù quanh quaån trong voøng    Moät vò Taêng hoûi: "Taâm phaùp ñeàu queân, chæ yù     luaân hoài sanh töû. Trong hai thöù chöôùng keå döôùi qui veà ñaâu?" Chöông Kính noùi: "Ngöôøi ñaát          ñaây thì phieàn naõo chöôùng deã bò ñoaïn dieät hôn sôû Dónh khoâng oâ nhieãm. Theá oâng vaùc buùa chi cho     tri chöôùng, vì yù muoán soáng vaø nhöõng thuùc ñaåy vò meät xaùc." Vò Taêng noùi: "Thænh Thaày ñöøng noùi     kyû laø caùi cuoái cuøng maø ngöôøi ta coù theå ñieàu phuïc lôøi töông phaûn." Chöông Kính noùi: "Ñaây naøo        hoaøn toaøn. Caùc baäc A La Haùn coù khaû naêng ñoaïn coù phaûi laø caâu töông phaûn." Veà sau naøy cuõng    dieät phieàn naõo chöôùng vaø ñaït ñöôïc höõu dö Nieát vò Taêng ñoù ñem vieäc naøy keå cho Ñoäng Sôn          Baøn, chæ coù chö Phaät vaø chö Boà Taùt môùi coù khaû nghe. Ñoäng Sôn noùi: "Thaät laø moät kieåu noùi. Ít   naêng phaù vôõ sôû tri chöôùng qua ñoán ngoä veà khoâng khi naøo haønh giaû gaëp ñöôïc moät ngöôøi kyø taøi    taùnh nôi vaïn höõu maø thoâi. Trong thieàn, chöôùng laø nhö vaäy!"—A monk asked Zen master                     moät trong saùu ñoái töôïng thieàn quaùn. Baèng thieàn Zhangjing, "Please point out the place where           quaùn chuùng ta coù theå vöôït qua moïi aûo töôûng duïc mind and Dharma are both gone." Zhangjing              voïng—According to Mahayana Buddhism, said, "People of Ying don't perspire. You              Avarana is one of the two factors which cause a belabor yourself carrying an ax." The monk             being to remain unenlightened and enmeshed said, "Please, Master, don't speak contrarily."        (hindered) in the cycle of birth and death. Among Zhangjing said, "This is not a contrary                the two below mentioned hindrances of cognitive phrase." Later the same monk brought up this           and intellectual, the latter is easier to destroy than conversation to Dongshan. Dongshan said,               the former, for the will to live or the egoistic

impulses are the last thing a man can bring under              Ganesa; a demon with a man’s body and complete control. Arahan is capable of eliminating             elephant’s head, which places obstacles in the the hindrance of passions and attain an Incomplete             way. Nirvana, but only Buddhas and Bodhisattvas are                 Chöôùng Ngaïi Vaät: Hindrance—Barrier— able to break through a direct realization of the              Barricade—Obstacle—Blockade. emptiness of all phenomena and attain a                        Chöôùng Ngaïi Y: Nhöõng thaønh phaàn gaây caûn trôû— Complete Nirvana. In Zen, hindrance (resistance)               Impedimentary constituents. is one of the six subjects in meditation. By                   Chöôùng Nghieäp: Upapilaka-kamma (p)—Nghieäp meditations on the distasteful and the delight,                gaây neân trôû ngaïi—Suppressive karma. delusions and passions may be overcome.                        Chöôùng Phaùp: Antarayikadharma (skt)—Tình Chöôùng Chuûng Töû: Haït gioáng cuûa chöôùng ngaïi—            traïng chöôùng ngaïi treân con ñöôøng ñaït ñeán Nieát Seeds of the hindrance.                                        Baøn—Obstructing condition of the passage to Chöôùng Duyeân Ma Khaûo: Demonic testing                       Nirvana. conditions—Baäc trí löïc chaúng nhöõng khoâng ngaïi            Chöôùng Taän Giaûi Thoaùt: Salvation through the chöôùng duyeân ma khaûo, maø coøn möôïn chöôùng                complete removal of the obstruction of illusion— duyeân ma khaûo ñeå tieán tu—Practitioners who                 Giaûi thoaùt ñaït ñöôïc baèng caùch loaïi boû hoaøn toaøn possess wisdom are not only unafraid of demonic                chöôùng ngaïi cuûa phieàn naõo—Deliverance testing conditions or obstacles, but they use these            acquired by the ending of all hindrances. impediments to achieve progress in cultivation.                Chöôùng Theå: Baûn chaát cuûa caùc chöôùng ngaïi— Chöôùng Ñaïo Voâ Sôû UÙy: Fearlessness of                      Essence of hindrances. expounding all obstructions to liberation—See                  Chöôùng Trì: Khaéc phuïc caùc trôû ngaïi ñoái vôùi söï Thuyeát Chöôùng Ñaïo Voâ Sôû UÙy.                              giaùc     ngoä—Subdue          the   obstructions     to Chöôùng Ñaïo Voâ Sôû UÙy Thuyeát: See Thuyeát                  enlightenment. Chöôùng Ñaïo Voâ Sôû UÙy.                                      Chöôùng Töôùng: Ñaëc tính cuûa caùc chöôùng ngaïi— Chöôùng Maét: Unpleasant to the eyes—                          Characteristics of the obstacles. Unpleasant to see.                                             Chöôûng: Loøng baøn tay: A palm—Caàm: To grasp, Chöôùng Naïn: Obstacles and hardship—Obstacles                 to control. and difficulties.                                              Chöôûng Quaû: Quaû Yeâm Ma La (quaû xoaøi) trong Chöôùng Ngaïi: Vinataka (skt)—Duy Ñeå Nan—                     tay, ñeå ví vôùi vaät deã nhìn thaáy—As a mango in the Kieàn Döõ—Obstacles—Baát cöù thöù gì laøm trôû ngaïi           hand, compared to something which is easy to see. (söï giaùc ngoä). Chöôùng ngaïi (söï troùi buoäc bôûi phieàn   Chöôûng Traân Luaän: Mahayana-tanaratna-sastra naõo goàm coù tham, saân, hoân traàm thuøy mieân, traïo        (skt)—See Ñaïi Thöøa Chöôûng Traân Luaän. cöû vaø nghi hoaëc). Trong Phaät giaùo, chöôùng ngaïi laø      Chöôûng Trung Luaän: Talantaraka-sastra (skt)— nhöõng tham duïc hay meâ môø laøm trôû ngaïi söï giaùc         Teân moät boä luaän ñöôïc vieát bôûi ngaøi Traàn Na— ngoä. Chöôùng ngaïi maø baát cöù Phaät töû naøo cuõng ñeàu     Name of a work of commentary, written by phaûi vöôït qua—Screen and obstructions, i.e                   Dignaga. anything that hinders. In Buddhism, hindrances mean the passions or any delusions which hinder enlightenment. Hindrances that any Buddhist must overcome before achieving enlightenment. Chöôùng Ngaïi Taïp Nhieãm: Chöôùng ngaïi vaø taïp nhieãm—Obstruction and affliction. Chöôùng Ngaïi Thaàn: Vinayaka (skt)—Tyø Na Daï Ca Thieân—Thöôøng Tuøy Ma—Hindrance-At-All- Time Spirit—Hindrance Spirit—Chöôùng Ngaïi Thaàn hay Thöôøng Tuøy Ma, mình ngöôøi muõi voi, laø loaïi aùc quyû thaàn thöôøng gaây ra trôû ngaïi hay tai naïn cho con ngöôøi—A hinderer, the elephant god or
